Timeshare in Hospitality industry (In this report “timeshare
The coursework is an individual academic essay that provides a conceptual debate on the activities that influence the development of the resort or spa industry. Select a topic of your choice based on the module content, such as resort definition, resort ownership, services marketing (people, physical evidence, or process), resort strategic management, resort sustainability, spa, or wellness. Research the topic and find an argument presenting two contrasting perspectives. Analyze, assess, compare, and contrast these perspectives, then give your opinion and justify it. Link the contrasting perspectives to relevant theories supporting your opinion. Do not merely describe the perspectives but critically assess their influence on the development of resorts and spas.
The essay should have a logical flow, including an introduction, main body, and conclusion, with minimal headings. The topic selected is: Timeshare in the Hospitality Industry, focusing solely on ownership-based timeshare and system-based timeshare. The argument is whether ownership-based timeshare or system-based timeshare is more suitable for Sanya, China.
Paper For Above instruction
Introduction
Timeshare arrangements have become integral to the hospitality industry, especially in upscale resort destinations worldwide. As a model of shared ownership or usage, timeshares have evolved to include various formats that cater to different consumer preferences and operational efficiencies. This essay critically examines two primary types: ownership-based timeshare (OBT) and system-based timeshare (SBT), exploring their suitability for the popular resort destination, Sanya, China. The core debate is whether the traditional ownership model or the modern system-based approach aligns better with Sanya’s tourism dynamics and market environment. The analysis will incorporate theoretical perspectives from resort management and consumer behavior, assessing how these formats influence development strategies, customer satisfaction, and sustainable growth within Sanya’s resort industry.
Ownership-Based Timeshare (OBT): Background and Application in Sanya
Ownership-based timeshare involves consumers purchasing a deeded right to a specific property or interval, typically for a fixed period each year. This model grants the buyer long-term ownership rights, often accompanied by the ability to exchange or rent the unit. The concept emerged prominently in the
1960s and has been prevalent in traditional resort markets due to the promise of ownership security and investment potential (Casey & Chamberlain, 2018).
Sanya, a rapidly developing tourist hub in Hainan Province, has experienced significant growth in upscale resorts, many of which adopt ownership-based timeshare schemes to attract high-net-worth individuals and domestic buyers. Case studies demonstrate that in Sanya, ownership timeshares have been marketed as investment opportunities, leveraging the region’s attractiveness as a luxury destination. Resorts such as Atlantis Sanya and other high-end developments incorporate deeded timeshare units, offering owners a sense of permanence and exclusivity, bolstered by the region’s natural beauty and tourism infrastructure (Li & Zhang, 2020).
Theoretically, ownership timeshare aligns with resort strategic management principles emphasizing customer loyalty, long-term asset utilization, and transferability. However, in Sanya’s context, its success has been tempered by regional market maturity, regulatory challenges, and shifting consumer preferences towards more flexible arrangements (Wang & Lee, 2021).
System-Based Timeshare (SBT): Background and Application in Sanya
System-based timeshare, often referred to as points-based or club membership models, emphasizes usage rights without long-term ownership. Participants purchase a system of points that can be exchanged across multiple resorts and locations, offering greater flexibility and access to a broad array of properties and durations (Gursoy & Chi, 2018).
In Sanya, the rise of system-based timeshare is linked to the region’s increasing focus on flexible, innovation-driven tourism products. Resorts such as Hilton Hainan and other international chains offer points-based arrangements that appeal to younger, globally mobile tourists seeking adjustable vacation periods and diverse experiences. The flexibility, lower entry costs, and lack of property management obligations have contributed to the popularity of SBT models in Sanya’s evolving market (Zhang & Chen, 2019).
From a theoretical standpoint, SBT aligns with service-dominant logic and consumer sovereignty theories, emphasizing customized value and user participation. It also supports resort branding and network strategies, enabling resorts to build loyalty and market presence across multiple locations while reducing investment risk (Vargo & Lusch, 2008).
Comparative Analysis: Suitability of Ownership-Based vs System-Based Timeshare in Sanya
The debate centers on whether the traditional long-term, deeded ownership model or the flexible, points-based system serves Sanya's strategic and market needs better. Ownership timeshare appeals to consumers seeking security, investment potential, and a sense of belonging—attributes attractive to affluent Chinese nationals and overseas investors whom Sanya aims to attract (Wang et al., 2022). Its advantage lies in generational wealth transfer and tangible asset appreciation, fitting Sanya’s luxury branding.
Conversely, system-based timeshare offers significant advantages in terms of flexibility, lower upfront costs, and broader accessibility. These features attract younger tourists, family groups, and international visitors who prioritize experience diversity and convenience over ownership rights (Chen & Liu, 2021). Moreover, the ongoing global shift toward shared economy principles favors SBT models, aligning with Sanya’s ambition to position itself as an innovative and environmentally conscious destination.
The effectiveness of each model depends on regional policies, consumer behavior, and the development stage of Sanya’s resort industry. While ownership models support long-term asset development, their rigidity can limit adaptability in a dynamic market. In contrast, system-based models provide agility and scalability, supporting Sanya’s rapid tourism growth and diversification efforts.
Personal Opinion and Justification
Considering Sanya’s unique market characteristics—its rapid growth, diverse tourist demographics, and strategic emphasis on branding—system-based timeshare appears more suitable. The flexibility inherent in points or system models aligns with Sanya’s aspiration for innovative, experience-oriented tourism. It enables resorts to attract a broader client base, adapt quickly to market changes, and sustain infrastructural development without the heavy capital commitments associated with ownership schemes. Furthermore, SBT models foster a sustainable growth paradigm, emphasizing shared usage and resource efficiency, critical factors amid environmental concerns and land-use regulations prevalent in Sanya.
Empirical evidence suggests that Sanya’s younger and international tourists favor flexible, cost-effective timeshare arrangements, reinforcing the strategic priority for SBT models (Li et al., 2023). Additionally, the evolving regulatory landscape and increasing awareness of environmental sustainability further tilt the balance in favor of flexible, system-based approaches. Hence, for Sanya’s future development, systems-based timeshare holds the potential to sustain tourism growth while aligning with global trends
and local market needs.
Conclusion
Both ownership-based and system-based timeshare models present distinct benefits and challenges within the Sanya tourism context. Ownership models offer stability and long-term investment appeal but may limit adaptability in a fast-changing market. The system-based approach, with its flexibility, lower entry costs, and alignment with sustainable tourism principles, better supports Sanya’s current strategic objectives of diversification, innovation, and environmentally conscious growth. Therefore, embracing system-based timeshare appears more suitable for Sanya’s development trajectory, fostering resilient and inclusive tourism expansion while catering to diverse consumer preferences.
References
Casey, B., & Chamberlain, R. (2018). The evolution of timeshare ownership: Trends and implications. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Research, 42(4), 503-521.
Chen, Y., & Liu, Q. (2021). Consumer preferences and behavior in timeshare utilization: Evidence from Chinese hospitality markets. Tourism Management Perspectives, 39, 100844.
Gursoy, D., & Chi, C. G. (2018). The impact of participation in timeshare programs on customer loyalty: An integrated model. Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management, 27(3), 307-322.
Li, H., Zhang, L., & Chen, W. (2020). Luxury hospitality development in Sanya: The role of timeshare ownership in regional growth. Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research, 25(1), 22-36.
Li, X., Wang, Y., & Zhou, M. (2023). Digital transformation and consumer engagement in timeshare resorts in Sanya. Journal of Tourism Futures, 9(2), 145-162.
Vargo, S. L., & Lusch, R. F. (2008). Service-dominant logic: Continuing the evolution. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 36(1), 1-10.
Wang, J., & Lee, S. (2021). Regulatory impacts on timeshare development in Chinese tourism markets. International Journal of Tourism Policy, 11(4), 321-336.
Wang, Y., Huang, L., & Sun, Q. (2022). Market segmentation and preferences in Chinese luxury resort timeshares. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management, 50, 13-22.
Zhang, M., & Chen, Q. (2019). International hotel brands and innovative timeshare models in Sanya.
International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 31(9), 3607-3624.