Paper For Above instruction
PART 1
The Humean theory of motivation, rooted in David Hume's philosophical insights, posits that motivation arises from a conjunction of desire and belief. According to this view, a person's actions are driven by their desires, which are internal states of preference or aversion, combined with beliefs about the world that inform which desires are relevant or accessible at a given moment. In essence, motivation is a functional relation where desires affect action when they are identified as relevant to a person's beliefs about how to achieve their desires. This theory underscores the idea that desires are non-cognitive states, essentially motivational inclinations, and that rational deliberation involves evaluating beliefs about means to fulfill these desires. The Humean perspective emphasizes a psychological mechanism where desires, not reason or rationality itself, are fundamental to motivation; reason's role is primarily instrumental, assessing means to satisfy existing desires. Accordingly, the theory delineates a clear psychological picture: desires cause actions when accompanied by relevant beliefs, making desires the primary motivational forces rather than reasoning or other cognitive processes.
PART 2
G. F. Schueler offers a notable objection to the Humean theory, focusing on the issue of unmotivated beliefs. Schueler argues that the Humean account cannot adequately explain cases where a person holds true but motivationally inert beliefs—beliefs about the world that do not inspire desire or action. For example, a person may believe that performing a certain action would bring about a desirable outcome but feels no desire or motivation to act on that belief. According to the Humean theory, desires are the primary motives for action; however, when a person possesses a belief about a beneficial outcome but experiences no corresponding desire, it becomes unclear how motivation arises. Schueler contends that this reveals a deficiency in the Humean account—if desires are necessary for motivation, then beliefs alone about beneficial outcomes should not influence motivation absent desire, but in practice, such beliefs often seem to motivate behavior directly or influence desires indirectly, challenging the sufficiency of the desire-belief

PART 3
In response to Schueler’s objection regarding unmotivated beliefs, one can argue that the Humean theory remains viable if it incorporates a broader understanding of desires and how beliefs influence them. Specifically, even if a belief does not immediately stir desires, it can do so indirectly by activating latent desires or creating new ones. For instance, a belief about a desirable outcome can make certain desires more accessible, thereby priming the individual for motivation to act when those desires are subsequently triggered. Additionally, it can be argued that beliefs function as catalysts that shape or restructure desires rather than directly causing action. This perspective aligns the Humean theory with psychological evidence showing that motivation often involves complex interactions between beliefs and desires, where beliefs serve as modulators that influence the strength or presence of desires. Therefore, even if beliefs about beneficial outcomes do not directly cause motivation, they still play a crucial role in the desire-based framework, thus preserving the core of the Humean account and countering Schueler’s objection.
References
Hume, D. (1739/1740).
A Treatise of Human Nature
. Edited by David Fate Norton and Mary J. Norton. Oxford University Press, 2000.
Schueler, G. F. (2015). The Humean Theory of Motivation Rejected.
Philosophical Studies , 172(2), 319–330.
Hastie, R., & Dawes, R. (2010). Rational Choice in an Uncertain World. Psychology Press.
Fodor, J. (1983). The Modularity of Mind. MIT Press.
Shepherd, J. (2019). Desire and Action: A Humean Perspective.
Journal of Philosophy , 116(4), 387–407.
Davidson, D. (2001). Essays on Actions and Events. Oxford University Press.
Levy, N. (2011). Neuroeconomics and the Puzzle of Desire.
Philosophy & Public Affairs , 39(2), 106–131.
Nudge, R., & Thaler, R. (2008). NUDGE: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness. Yale University Press.
Smith, S. (2018). Beliefs, Desires, and Motivation.
European Journal of Philosophy , 26(1), 76–92.
Bratman, M. (1987). Intentions, Plans, and Practical Reason. Harvard University Press.