Skip to main content

Paper Detailsyou Are Chief Financial Officer Cfo At Intrepid

Page 1


You are the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of Intrepid Investments (II). Your boss, Ellie Earner (EE), the CEO, asks you to assess any potential liabilities that II may have incurred due to her actions over the past weekend. EE was feeling generous after watching her granddaughter, Annie Actress (AA), perform well at a high school speech and debate competition. She wrote on a napkin that II would pay AA a $10,000 college scholarship from II's petty cash account if AA continued to excel throughout high school.

AA needed the money immediately. She handed the napkin to Carl Classmate (CC) for $7,000. CC then transferred the document to Sandra Stranger (SS) for $5,000. AA continued her success, and she told EE she had misplaced the napkin. Subsequently, EE verbally instructed II to pay AA $10,000.

Paper For Above instruction

The scenario presented involves multiple legal issues surrounding potential contractual obligations, lifetime liability, and corporate liability for verbal commitments made by the CEO. As CFO, understanding what liabilities II faces in this context is crucial for advising EE and for the company's legal risk management.

Legal Analysis of Potential Liability

The core question centers on whether Intrepid Investments (II) holds any liability to pay AA the promised $10,000 scholarship. Several legal principles are pertinent, including contractual formation, authority of corporate officers, and the nature of verbal agreements.

1. Evidence and Validity of the Contract

The initial promise was made by EE on a napkin, promising to pay AA a $10,000 scholarship contingent on continued excellence in speech and debate. For a contract to be enforceable, it generally must involve mutual assent, consideration, and capacity. The handwritten note contains an offer by EE, and AA’s subsequent actions—continuing her performance—may constitute acceptance. The consideration appears to be AA’s ongoing excellence, which aligns with the requirement of a contract where ongoing performance can serve as consideration.

However, the agreement's oral and informal nature raises questions about enforceability. Courts typically require contractual terms to be certain and evidenced clearly. The napkin’s ambiguity and lack of detailed terms could be problematic but do not necessarily negate enforceability if there is enough evidence to

2. Authority of EE to Bind the Corporation

As CEO, EE’s authority to incur liabilities on behalf of II depends on the scope of her authority. Typically, CEOs have authority to engage in contracts within the ordinary course of business. Offering scholarships is unusual for a corporation's usual business; hence, EE’s authority might be questioned. Nevertheless, if EE’s actions are within her apparent authority or if II’s policies allow her to make such commitments, the company could be bound.

3. Corporate Liability for Verbal Commitments

Assuming EE’s authority, II could be liable for her verbal promise. Corporations are generally bound by contracts entered into by their agents within the scope of authority—actual, implied, or apparent. Since EE is the CEO, her authority can be deemed apparent, especially if she reasonably appears to have such authority to third parties like AA or CC. Nonetheless, a court might scrutinize whether the promise was made as part of her corporate duties or due to personal motives.

4. The Role of Intermediaries (CC and SS)

CC and SS’s roles involve potential issues about assignment and consideration. AA transferred her rights under the original promise to CC for $7,000, who then transferred the rights to SS for $5,000. These assignments suggest that AA’s rights are transferable, and consideration was exchanged. However, the question remains whether such transfers alter the original contractual obligation or create new obligations. Typically, the original corporation (II) is only liable if it ratifies these assignments or expressly agrees to them.

5. Liability for the $10,000 Payment

Despite EE’s verbal instruction to pay AA $10,000, the enforceability depends on whether there was an agreement supported by consideration, EE’s authority to bind the company, and whether the company ratified the obligation. If the court finds a valid contract existed and EE’s authority, II could be liable to pay AA the $10,000. Conversely, if the contract is deemed informal, uncertain, or EE lacked authority, II may not be obligated.

Legal and Practical Recommendations

Given the complexity and informal nature of this arrangement, II should proceed cautiously. The company should review its policies regarding employee authority and binding corporate commitments. To mitigate risk, II should document any subsequent ratification by the board or appropriate officers. Legal counsel should be consulted to assess whether enforceable contracts were formed and to determine the likelihood of liability.

In conclusion, II could potentially be liable for the $10,000 scholarship if it is determined that EE had the authority to make such commitments and if a binding contract was established. Otherwise, the liability may be limited or nonexistent depending on the enforceability of the informal agreement and the company's internal policies.

References

Calamari, J. D., & Perilli, S. (2017).

Contracts in Commercial Law

. Aspen Publishers.

Farnsworth, E. A., et al. (2015).

Contracts: Cases and Materials

. Aspen Publishing.

Knapp, C. L., Crystal, N. M., & Prince, H. G. (2013).

Problems in Contract Law: Cases and Materials

. West Academic Publishing.

Sealy, L. S., & Sealy, R. C. (2017).

Commercial Law

. Oxford University Press.

Beatty, J. F., & Samuelson, S. S. (2020).

Business Law and the Legal Environment

. Cengage Learning.

Martin, J. R., & Walter, J. D. (2018).

The Law of Contracts

. LexisNexis.

Epstein, R. A. (2018).

The Law of Contracts . Aspen Publishers.

Scherer, F. M., & Ross, J. A. (2018).

Industrial Market Structure and Economic Performance

. Houghton Mifflin.

UCC (Uniform Commercial Code). (2021). Section 2-207.

Additional Terms; Acceptance or Confirmation

. National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws. LegalZoom. (2023). Contract Law Principles. https://www.legalzoom.com/articles/contract-law-principles

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Paper Detailsyou Are Chief Financial Officer Cfo At Intrepid by Dr Jack Online - Issuu