Both JCPenney and American Apparel have undergone significant transformations recently, facing substantial challenges within the highly competitive clothing retail industry. Understanding and diagnosing the underlying factors driving organizational change is critical, and the 7-S Framework provides a comprehensive tool to analyze these dynamics. This framework considers seven interconnected elements—Structure, Strategy, Systems, Style, Staff, Skills, and Superordinate Goals—that collectively influence organizational effectiveness and the success of change initiatives. Applying this model helps identify obstacles and potential catalysts for positive transformation in each organization, addressing resistance and aligning internal factors with strategic objectives.
The structure of JCPenney is characterized by its extensive hierarchy and longstanding presence in retail, making change complex and costly, especially after recent downsizing efforts targeting high-level management. In contrast, American Apparel operates with a more streamlined, vertically integrated model, which simplifies its structural adjustments. The strategy of JCPenney has historically focused on broad-based discount retailing, but recent attempts to reposition the brand under former CEO Ron Johnson's leadership aimed at store renovations and eliminating traditional promotions. Meanwhile, American Apparel's strategy emphasizes appealing to young adults through provocative advertising and a commitment to manufacturing domestically, emphasizing social responsibility and ethical standards.
Regarding systems, JCPenney has undergone extensive changes, including layoffs, training, and cultural shifts aimed at attracting a younger demographic. American Apparel’s systems, however, have remained relatively consistent, maintaining their focus on employee wages, diversity, and creative branding, which supports their market positioning. Style-wise, JCPenney’s efforts to modernize advertising to appeal to youth have had mixed results, balancing traditional customer bases with newer, younger audiences. American Apparel has continued with its distinctive aesthetic, even marketing to older demographics with diverse models, thus diversifying its appeal without significant stylistic overhaul.
The staff at JCPenney has experienced high turnover due to leadership changes and strategic shifts, leading to instability. Conversely, American Apparel retains a core team, though recent controversies involving the CEO and board could influence staff performance and morale. Skills within both organizations predominantly involve retail operations, marketing, and design, which have not required extensive upgrading; however, operational efficiency and digital marketing skills are areas ripe for development
At the core of both companies lies their Superordinate Goals—their overarching vision and purpose. JCPenney's vision has been challenged by repeated strategic failures and a return to previous models, leading to confusion and disillusionment among stakeholders. American Apparel’s vision centers on American manufacturing and youthful branding, though leadership instability risks diluting this focus. Both organizations face significant questions regarding their long-term direction, with their commitment to core values and competitive positioning at stake.
The SWOT analyses reveal key strengths such as JCPenney's extensive experience and retail presence, and American Apparel's distinctive brand and manufacturing ethics. However, weaknesses include brand credibility issues for JCPenney and leadership controversies for American Apparel. Opportunities for growth involve online sales expansion, new markets, and strategic alliances, whereas threats primarily stem from intense competition, changing consumer preferences, and potential leadership instability.
Change management efforts at JCPenney have involved significant initiatives, including store redesigns, marketing overhauls, and executive restructuring. The repeated leadership changes and strategic missteps have rendered the organization cautious. Future resistance may emerge from fear of further failure, stakeholder skepticism, and the desire to preserve existing customer bases. It is advisable for JCPenney to adopt a conservative approach, emphasizing operational stability and targeted growth, avoiding drastic changes until economic conditions improve.
American Apparel’s recent changes include leadership upheaval, international expansion, and revenue growth via online and wholesale channels. Continued stability depends on resolving internal governance issues, particularly regarding the CEO’s controversial role. Resistance may come from the existing leadership and stakeholders wary of further upheaval. Keeping Dov Charney involved as a consultant might preserve creative integrity but should be carefully managed to mitigate risks.
In conclusion, the 7-S Framework demonstrates that both JCPenney and American Apparel are at critical junctures, necessitating aligned efforts across structural, strategic, and cultural domains to foster successful transformation. Despite their differences, both companies share common challenges—leadership stability, brand perception, and adapting to market trends. By addressing internal discrepancies and harnessing opportunities judiciously, they can navigate the turbulent retail landscape and emerge resilient, although sustaining change will require overcoming internal resistance rooted in leadership and stakeholder
References
American Apparel. (2014). Vertical integration. Retrieved August 3, 2014, from https://www.americanapparel.com
Berfield, S. (2013). J.C. Penney Rehires Myron Ullman to Clean Up Ron Johnson's Mess. Bloomberg Businessweek. Retrieved August 3, 2014, from https://www.bloomberg.com
Casey, N. (2008). American Apparel Bares All. Wall Street Journal. Retrieved August 3, 2014, from https://www.wsj.com
Covert, J. (2014). American Apparel lender demands $10M loan payment after CEO’s exit. New York Post. Retrieved July 17, 2014, from https://nypost.com
Graham, E. (2014). Former JCPenney CEO Ron Johnson Tried To Resign Three Times. Racked. Retrieved August 3, 2014, from https://www.racked.com
Palmer, I. (2008). Managing Organizational Change (2nd ed.). McGraw-Hill Learning Solutions.
Michele, S. (2014). JC Penney, Your "Tagline" Is Inside Out. Huffington Post. Retrieved February 19, 2014, from https://www.huffingtonpost.com
Reuters. (2014). Investigation Finds Dov Charney Misused American Apparel Funds. Retrieved June 21, 2014, from https://www.reuters.com
Talley, K. (2012). Wall Street Journal Online. In J.C. Penney Trims Headquarters Staff. Retrieved April 5, 2012, from https://www.wsj.com
Ullman, M. (2014). Leadership strategies in retail. Journal of Retailing, 90(2), 150-165.