Skip to main content

Innovations in Tiered Legal Services Task Force Final Report and Recommendations

Page 1

Innovations in Tiered Legal Services Task Force Final Report and Recommendations

SE PTEM B ER 2 02 6


Maryland’s legal service providers are only able to meet approximately 20 percent of the needs of legal-aid-eligible Marylanders.

20% i


Executive Summary Maryland is experiencing a civil access-to-justice crisis. In 2023, Maryland’s Affordable Law Task Force found that approximately 40 percent of all Maryland households cannot afford basic necessities, much less afford to hire an attorney at market rate, yet only a quarter of this population are financially eligible for free legal aid. Due to a dearth of funding and resources, Maryland’s legal service providers are only able to meet approximately 20 percent of the needs of legal-aid-eligible Marylanders. Consequently, every year, hundreds of thousands of Marylanders confronting civil legal problems face a complex and unfamiliar legal system alone. Some lose their homes, custody of their children, access to life-saving public benefits, or forgo protection from domestic violence. To help ensure low-income and modest-means Marylanders get the civil legal help they need, the Affordable Law Task Force urged exploration of emerging national innovations, including modernization of unauthorized practice of law (UPL) rules to enable new tiers of allied legal professionals and legal technology tools. In answer to this charge, and at the behest of Chief Justice Matthew J. Fader of the Supreme Court of Maryland, the Maryland Judiciary, the Maryland State Bar Association, and the Maryland Access to Justice Commission teamed up in September 2024 to form the Innovations in Tiered Legal Services Task Force (hereinafter “Innovations Task Force”). Its charge was to conduct in-depth studies of civil legal service tiers, evaluate their applicability in the context of Maryland’s unique unmet civil legal needs, and develop formal recommendations for Maryland. This Report and the formal recommendations it puts forth are the culminating deliverables of the Innovations Task Force. Section I of this Report sets forth a statement of the problem the Innovations Task Force set out to solve, citing data and research illustrating the scope and gravity of the state’s access-to-justice crisis and noting where Maryland falls short of meeting global and national civil justice standards. Section II of this Report describes the Task Force’s structure and process. Section III summarizes the findings of the Task Force’s audit of existing use of allied legal professionals in Maryland, and describes the emerging national movement in UPL reform and tiered legal services. Section IV sets forth the Task Force’s formal recommendations and underlying reasoning, including how the Task Force addressed

40% OF ALL MARYLAND HOUSEHOLDS

cannot afford basic necessities, much less afford to hire an attorney at market rate.

stakeholder input. And, section V of this Report briefly lays out next steps for authorizing and implementing the recommendations. After conducting extensive research, studying other states’ programs and approaches, consulting a wide array of state and national experts, and incorporating input from a broad range of Maryland stakeholders, the Innovations Task Force recommends to the Supreme Court of Maryland as follows:

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

ii


EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

RECOMMENDATION 1: ESTABLISH A

COMMUNITY JUSTICE WORKER TIER The Maryland Judiciary should implement a UPL rule change establishing a Community Justice Worker Tier, through which individuals can apply for authorization to provide direct, civil legal services, in areas of civil law practice in which there is deep, unmet need. The purpose of this tier is to provide low-income Marylanders—with a household income at or below 125 percent of the federal poverty line—free legal help in areas currently underserved by attorneys. Community justice workers should be required to complete statewide training that includes the National Community Justice Worker Core Training Curriculum and specialized training in each area of Maryland law for which they will provide services, as well as an annual, post-certification update training. They should also be required to abide by the Maryland Rules of Professional Conduct applicable to licensed attorneys. Community justice workers will not engage in independent practice; they are required to be employed by or volunteer for a formally recognized, community-based host organization, provide services strictly through that organization, and receive oversight from a Maryland-licensed attorney. Upon successfully completing all requisite training, a community justice worker is authorized to perform, under attorney oversight, all levels of legal assistance (except presentation of complex evidence to the court and complex litigation) in the area(s) of law in which they are certified.

RECOMMENDATION 2: ESTABLISH A

LEGAL PRACTITIONER TIER The Maryland Judiciary should implement a UPL rule change establishing a Legal Practitioner Tier, through which individuals can apply for a license authorizing them to provide direct, civil legal services in certain high-need areas of civil practice, currently underserved by attorneys. The purpose of this Tier is to provide affordable legal help primarily to Maryland’s asset limited, income constrained, iii

employed (or “ALICE”) households—households that do not qualify for free legal aid but also cannot afford to hire an attorney at market rate. The judiciary should designate the high-need and underserved areas of civil law in which legal practitioners are authorized to practice. Legal practitioners should be required to meet robust educational and/or experiential requirements, pass an examination and a character and fitness assessment, and comply with many of the same ethical and regulatory obligations as attorneys. A licensed legal practitioner is authorized to perform the same functions as an attorney, but strictly within the designated civil law practice area(s) in which they are certified. After completing 1,000 hours of practice under direct attorney supervision, legal practitioners may practice independently, subject only to additional prerequisites for those who wish to perform in-court representation.

RECOMMENDATION 3: ESTABLISH A

LEGAL TECHNOLOGY TIER The Maryland Judiciary should implement a UPL rule change establishing a Legal Technology Tier, through which owners of legal technology tools—including AI-powered tools—can apply for a UPL exemption to provide legal services directly to self-represented civil litigants. Maryland’s Legal Technology Tier should initially be limited to a single practice area: criminal records expungement. After the proposed program is implemented, evaluated, and any needed adjustments or improvements are made, the Maryland Supreme Court should then consider expanding the Tier by phasing in authorization of additional high-needs practice areas and case types. Legal technology tool owners should be required to register their tools before commencing operations in Maryland. To qualify for registration, owners should be required to demonstrate how their tool will advance access to justice and meet or exceed a minimum required threshold when tested against relevant public benchmark datasets for consumers’ protection. Legal technology tool owners should be required to regularly test and validate the accuracy and reliability of their tools and services, maintain robust data security protocols to protect user privacy, and prominently and clearly disclose that the service provided by the tool is


not conducted by an attorney. The Legal Technology Tier is intended to leverage other legal service tiers by addressing cases and matters that are amenable to machine help, freeing up human legal helpers to assist other litigants with cases and matters that are not appropriate for business-to-consumer legal tools. Legal technology tool owners should be required to incorporate mechanisms that screen for matters unsuitable for resolution through the tool and notify consumers when human intervention may be necessary and they should seek legal assistance through a different legal service tier.

RECOMMENDATION 4: ADHERE TO

GUIDING PRINCIPLES The Innovations Task Force proposes a set of fundamental Guiding Principles to inform all three proposed legal service tiers. For example, the proposed new tiers should be designed and implemented in strict alignment with their primary

purpose: helping close Maryland’s access-tojustice gap. The introduction of new legal service tiers should not create a stratified legal system where people from low-income or modest-means households receive less effective legal help than those who are able to afford to hire an attorney. Legal assistance and representation should be high quality, accurate, and consistent across all tiers of Maryland’s civil legal system. Consumer protections and community engagement should be directly embedded into service design and delivery. Legal services should be designed and delivered in a manner that ensures all individuals have equitable access to assistance of equivalent quality, regardless of a person’s race, color, ethnicity, national origin, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, religion, disability, age, or other protected or immutable characteristic. The tiers should be accessible to rural and remote Marylanders, limited- and non-English speakers and pre-literate persons, deaf/hard-of-hearing and blind/ sight-impaired persons, persons with disabilities, and other historically disadvantaged, marginalized, and underserved Maryland populations.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

iv


EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

RECOMMENDATION 5:

RECOMMENDATION 6:

ADOPT AN

CONTINUE TO

The Innovations Task Force recommends that an Implementation Committee form in continued partnership with the Maryland Judiciary, the Maryland State Bar Association, and the Maryland Access to Justice Commission. The Implementation Committee should simultaneously roll out all three proposed new legal service tiers, each of which is designed to serve a distinct target population of selfrepresented Marylanders with current, unmet civil legal needs, none of whom should be left without immediate help. To increase the likelihood that these recommendations are fully and successfully implemented, the Innovations Task Force recommends grounding in an implementation science approach – a systemic, deliberate, and research-based process for building conditions where sustainable change is possible. The Innovations Task Force recommends a collaborative governance structure that includes an Office of Legal Services Innovation (“Innovation Office”) housed in the Maryland Judiciary and three, semi-autonomous advisory boards – a Community Justice Worker Advisory Board, a Legal Practitioner Advisory Board, and a Legal Technology Advisory Board – to administer the respective tiers. The Innovation Office should oversee the state government’s role and serve as a central hub for data collection, analysis, and reporting across all tiers, proposed and existing. The Innovations Task Force recommends the governing bodies pursue collaborative resource-pooling and structured resource allocation to seamlessly integrate all of Maryland’s new and existing tiers, leverage limited resources, effectively distribute the costs and benefits of the new tiers widely to minimize the burden and maximize benefits, and reinvest resulting cost savings and costs averted into proven civil access-to-justice strategies.

The proposed new legal service tiers should neither disturb or supplant Maryland’s existing allied legal professionals nor foreclose future innovation. The tiers are intended to complement and leverage the state’s current and future corpus of access-to-justice resources and initiatives. The Innovations Task Force recommends that Maryland:

IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY AND GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE

v

SUPPORT EXISTING TIERS AND PROMOTE INNOVATION

•

Strengthen statewide civil justice data and decision-making practices across all tiers of Maryland’s civil legal system;

•

Increase appropriations for the full spectrum of authorized legal service providers;

•

Continuously pursue appropriate new federal and private funding streams;

•

Regularly evaluate and continuously improve all Maryland legal service tiers;

•

Embed robust community engagement models and practices; and,

•

Continue to explore and adopt innovative approaches to provide legal services to unrepresented Marylanders while balancing consumer protection concerns.

In order to support the Judicial Rules changes necessary to authorize and implement the above recommendations, the Innovations Task Force offers the Supreme Court of Maryland, in the appendices to this Report, proposed regulatory language that includes Terms and Definitions, Guiding Principles, a Community Justice Worker Tier, a Legal Practitioner Tier, and a Legal Technology Tier.


State supreme courts are leading an emerging UPL reform movement to narrow the justice gap by authorizing new kinds of civil legal help.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

vi


Every year, hundreds of thousands of Marylanders confronting civil legal problems face a complex and unfamiliar legal system alone. Some lose their homes, custody of their children, access to life-saving public benefits, or forgo protection from domestic violence.

vii


Contents I. The Problem

1

A. Maryland Falls Short of International Norms and U.S. Standards

1

B. Cost and Complexity Impede Access

4

C. Lawyers Alone Cannot Bridge the Gap

5

D. Deprivation of Legal Help Has Severe Social Consequences

6

II. The Process

7

III. The Solution

10

A. Modernize Unauthorized Practice of Law Rules

10

B. Authorize New Legal Service Tiers

13

1. Allied Legal Professionals

13

a. Current Use of Allied Legal Professionals in Maryland

15

b. Other States’ Use of Allied Legal Professionals

17

i. Community Justice Workers

17

ii. Legal Practitioners

24

2. Legal Technology Tools

27

IV. The Recommendations

37

Recommendation 1: Establish a Community Justice Worker Tier

27

Recommendation 2: Establish a Legal Practitioner Tier

43

Recommendation 3: Establish a Legal Technology Tier

49

Recommendation 4: Adhere to Guiding Principles Across Tiers

57

Recommendation 5: Adopt an Implementation Strategy and Governance Structure

58

Recommendation 6: Continue To Support Existing Tiers and Promote Innovation

60

V. Next Steps

64

Appendix A: Innovations in Tiered Legal Services Task Force

65

Appendix B: Acknowledgments

66

Appendix C: Terms and Definitions

67

Appendix D: Guiding Principles

69

Appendix E: Proposed Regulatory Language for Community Justice Worker Tier

72

Appendix F: Proposed Regulatory Language for Legal Practitioner Tier

74

Appendix G: Proposed Regulatory Language for Legal Technology Tier

85

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

viii


THE PROBLEM

I. The Problem A. MARYLAND FALLS SHORT OF INTERNATIONAL NORMS AND U.S. STANDARDS The current crisis in civil access to justice is not unique to Maryland; it is a problem of global proportion. According to the World Justice Project, approximately 1.4 billion people worldwide have unmet civil or administrative justice needs despite living in societies with functioning justice systems.2 United Nations (UN) Sustainable Development Goal 16 urges states to “[promote] peaceful and inclusive societies, [provide] access to justice for all and [build] effective, accountable and inclusive institutions at all levels.”3 The UN asserts that “[p]eople everywhere should be free of fear from all forms of violence and feel safe as they go about their lives whatever their ethnicity, faith or sexual orientation,” and posits that “[e]qual access to justice is essential for protecting the rights of individuals, resolving disputes, and ensuring that vulnerable populations are not marginalized or mistreated.”4 The World Justice Project’s 2025 Rule of Law Index (ROLI) ranks the United States’ civil justice system 37th out of 143 countries, overall, far below other high-prosperity, industrialized nations.5 Worse still, ROLI ranks the U.S. 112th out of 143 countries when considering whether people can access and afford civil justice, placing us dead last in our region and income ranks. When considering whether civil justice is free of discrimination, ROLI ranks the U.S. 118th of 143, placing us 30th of 31 countries in our region and 49th of 51 countries in our income rank.6 In the U.S., the consequences of this access-to-justice crisis fall most heavily on Americans who are lower-income, women, multiracial, black, and/or rural residents.7 The American Bar Association (ABA) asserts that all individuals should be guaranteed a right to legal counsel in civil matters (a concept called “Civil Gideon”) where physical liberty is at stake and in matters related to “basic human need,” including shelter, sustenance, safety, health, and child custody. While all defendants facing charges in Maryland’s 1

“Despite sustained efforts to expand

public access to legal services, significant unmet needs persist . . . [m]ost people living in poverty, and the majority of moderate-income individuals, do not receive the legal help they need.”10 –ABA Commission on the Future of Legal Services

criminal courts are entitled to an attorney, Maryland has recognized the need for counsel in only a very limited number of civil proceedings11 involving the potential for deprivation of housing (eviction defense cases), deprivation of parental rights (Children in Need of Assistance (“CINA”) and Termination of Parental Rights (“TPR”) cases12), deprivation of


World Justice Project Rule of Law Index®.8

World Justice Project Rule of Law Index®.9

“The United States’ crisis of access to civil justice is so well documented at this point that its facts require little rehearsal. Whichever measure of the lack of access to justice one chooses as a standard, the crisis has only deepened, at the same time that the number of American lawyers has grown . . . More civil justice problems go unserved and unresolved than ever.1” –Matthew Burnett and Rebecca L. Sandefur

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

2


THE PROBLEM

“A person facing a legal issue has access to justice when they have timely and affordable access to the amount and type of legal help required for a fair outcome based on the merits of the case. At the conclusion of the proceeding, the person can walk away believing that the legal system treated them fairly, even if the outcome was not in their favor.”16 –Bob Glaves, Executive Director, Chicago Bar Foundation

liberty (civil contempt and involuntary commitment cases13), and in special education cases14. In a joint resolution, the Conference of Chief Justices and the Conference of State Court Administrators call upon states to aspire to meet a “goal of 100 percent access to effective assistance for essential civil legal needs.”15 According to the Legal Services Corporation (LSC), 74 percent of low-income households in the United States experienced at least one civil legal problem in 2022; 39 percent experienced five or more, and 20 percent experienced ten or more.17 LSC reports that low-income U.S. households did not get any or enough legal help for 92 percent of the problems that have had a substantial impact on them.18 Because Maryland currently does not publicly report data on self-represented litigants (“SRLs”)19 in civil cases, it is difficult to determine exactly how many individuals are without counsel in civil proceedings. Extrapolating from LSC’s national data, and based on an analysis of State Fiscal Year (SFY) 2024 court data, the Maryland Access to Justice Commission estimates that at least one party went without legal representation in 761,691 civil court cases.20 In SFY-2024, Marylanders faced eviction (311,989), foreclosure (52,973), and bankruptcy (7,873) legal proceedings alone.21 These are just a few of Maryland’s high-needs law-practice areas rife with SRLs. Hundreds of thousands more civil cases never even get filed with courts because people who cannot access legal assistance choose not to engage with the legal system to solve their civil legal problems.22 Lincoln Caplan, in an article in The American Scholar, says “Most people with an urgent need don’t realize they can seek recourse in the law, so 3

they don’t even try.”23 Rebecca L. Sandefur echoes Caplan, positing that many people confronting life problems with civil justice implications don’t turn to the law simply because they do not think their issues are legal or have a legal solution.24 Many Marylanders face similar challenges when appearing in administrative proceedings before government agencies without the benefit of counsel.25


[T]he middle class…faces distinct challenges. They make too much money to qualify for free legal aid, but generally can’t afford the services of lawyers and firms serving the corporate and higher-income market. As a result, many face legal problems with little to no protection at all.33 Complicated and unfamiliar laws, forms, processes, proceedings, and legal lexicon can make it extremely difficult for SRLs to understand and pursue their civil legal rights. These complexities are often exacerbated for persons who are preliterate, do not speak or understand English, are deaf/hard-of-hearing or blind/ visually impaired, lack reliable Wi-Fi access, or live in remote and rural areas far from legal resources and without effective public transportation.

B. COST AND COMPLEXITY IMPEDE ACCESS Nearly 40 percent of Marylanders cannot afford to hire an attorney at market rate to help them solve their civil legal problems. According to the United Way, 10 percent of Maryland households fall below the Federal Poverty Level (FPL)27 and another 29 percent fall below the ALICE threshold (Asset Limited, Income Constrained, Employed).28 Combining FPL and ALICE, approximately 934,715 Maryland households fall below the ALICE Threshold,29 meaning they cannot afford to meet their household’s basic needs and certainly cannot afford to pay market rates for legal representation. According to the widely-used legal software company CLIO, Maryland lawyers charged, on average, $362 per hour in 2025, higher even than the national average rate of $349.30

“A legal system that the average person cannot understand or use effectively fails to satisfy the fundamental principle of equality under the law. The social contract underpinning representative democracies rests on a conception of fairness in which like cases are decided alike.”26 –L. Karl Branting

Maryland’s civil legal aid organizations, whose charge is serving low-income Marylanders (households at or below 125 percent of FPL), are chronically underfunded. Maryland Legal Services Corporation – the state’s largest funder of civil legal aid – reports that its 47 nonprofit grantees closed more than 73,000 cases benefiting 159,147 people in Fiscal Year 2025, meeting only a small fraction of Maryland’s civil legal needs.31 And, Marylanders in ALICE households, whose income typically exceeds the eligibility threshold for free legal aid, currently have little recourse but to represent themselves in civil legal proceedings.32 According to the Institute for the Advancement of the American Legal System (IAALs): INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

4


C. LAWYERS ALONE CANNOT BRIDGE THE GAP Studies consistently show that having professional legal help improves outcomes, helps ensure fairness in the justice system, and yields a high return on investment (ROI).35 Most lay people facing a civil legal problem could benefit from some form of legal help. That help could range from understanding if they are eligible for a legal remedy and identifying the correct court or agency, correctly filling out and filing the right legal forms, and gathering the necessary evidence and documentation to support their case, to receiving legal advice or having someone represent them in court. Although Maryland has a relatively high number of resident, active attorneys, those attorneys are out of reach for many Marylanders.36 According to the U.S. Department of Justice, many rural counties – where residents are more likely to have household incomes below the FPL – have fewer than one attorney per 1,000 residents, and non-metropolitan areas are served by just 1.6 legal aid lawyers for every 100,000 residents.37 Many 5

“Appropriate and affordable legal help is out of reach for many people in the United States. It is clear that attorneys alone are not the answer, and further that subsidized legal services cannot come close to meeting the present need.”34 –Institute for the Advancement of the American Legal System

American attorneys have shifted their legal practice from serving individual clients to serving organizational clients.38 The dearth of lawyers is even more acute in the less lucrative law practice areas where most of Maryland’s civil legal needs lie. The Maryland Access to Justice Commission estimates that approximately


“Without representation, people lose custody of their children. They are evicted from their homes. Their assets or wages are seized. They are deported. Their lives are disrupted with significant financial and emotional impact.”43 –Ralph Baxter

500 of the 42,000 attorneys authorized to practice law in Maryland are civil legal aid attorneys.39 In short, Maryland’s demand for affordable and pro bono attorneys and free legal aid vastly exceeds available supply. Maryland’s Unauthorized Practice of Law (UPL) Rule41 restricts law practice to licensed attorneys (with some narrowly-tailored exceptions42). By strictly limiting the kinds of legal helpers available, and thereby stifling the supply, Maryland’s UPL Rules are preventing low-income and modest-means Marylanders from getting the civil legal help they want and need. Even as Maryland strives to expand the right to counsel in civil proceedings to align with national standards, it must also undertake parallel UPL reform to address the scale of the civil access-to-justice crisis.

D. DEPRIVATION OF LEGAL HELP HAS SEVERE SOCIAL CONSEQUENCES

legal problems—such as exposure to violence and abuse, housing instability, wrongful termination or employment discrimination, barriers to accessing public benefits, and consumer debt and harm—triggers severe social stressors. Those social stressors directly correspond with a well-established list of critical risk factors for criminal and juvenile offending.46 Criminal and juvenile justice system involvement, in turn, triggers collateral consequences that cannot be resolved without civil legal help, spiraling people deeper into a negative cycle. In all of these ways, lack of access to civil legal help exacerbates disparities and inequities for people of color, immigrants, limited- and non-English speakers, people with disabilities, LGBTQ+ persons, and other members of historically marginalized and underserved communities.47 Collectively, these harms, disparities, and inequities undermine public trust and confidence in Maryland’s civil justice system and erode respect for the rule of law.

Forcing people to navigate complex laws and systems without legal help leads to poor legal and life outcomes with devastating consequences for individuals, families, and entire communities. According to Lincoln Caplan (citing Rebecca Sandefur): “People who are poor or struggling for money and economic stability…and who lack help in addressing legal problems, often suffer shattering consequences. They lose their homes, their jobs, custody of their children, or access to insurance, benefits, or pensions. They default on financial obligations and forfeit legal rights. They encounter problems with their health and aren’t properly nourished.”44 Deprivation of a meaningful day in court or access to vital government programs and services deprives people of their fundamental human rights to food, shelter, employment, education, health, freedom from violence, and much more.45 Inability to resolve civil INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

6


THE PROCESS

II. The Process In 2021, the Maryland State Bar Association and the Maryland Access to Justice Commission partnered to launch the Affordable Law Task Force. Its purpose was to analyze the civil legal needs of modest-means Marylanders, and survey the national landscape for best practices and innovations to meet those needs. In its 2023 Report, Confronting the Access to Justice Crisis of Modest Means Marylanders, the Affordable Law Task Force found a significant civil access-to-justice gap and urged continued exploration of innovative solutions, including modernization of Maryland’s unauthorized practice of law rule to enable allied legal professionals (authorized nonlawyer legal helpers) and legal technologies to provide civil legal help to self-represented Marylanders.48 In answer to this charge and at the behest of Chief Justice Fader of the Supreme Court of Maryland, the Maryland Judiciary, the Maryland State Bar Association (MSBA), and the Maryland Access to Justice Commission (A2JC) teamed up in September 2024 to launch the Innovations in Tiered Legal Services Task Force (hereinafter “Innovations Task Force”). The Innovations Task Force is composed of a diverse, cross-sector, interdisciplinary group of leaders, each of whom bring extensive expertise on different aspects of the problem. Its charge was to conduct in-depth studies of the three distinct legal service tiers recommended for further study by the Affordable Law Task Force, evaluate the tiers’ applicability in the context of Maryland’s unique unmet civil legal needs, and develop formal recommendations for Maryland. The Innovations Task Force began by conducting a statewide audit to catalogue, for the first time, how allied legal professionals are already being utilized in Maryland and whether they are proving effective. This research culminated in a report titled, “2025 Audit on the Current Use of Allied Legal Professionals in Maryland” (hereinafter “Audit Report”).49 Its purpose was twofold: (1) to ensure that Task Force Members understood and learned from existing allied legal professionals’ scope of work and impact on consumers and the legal profession, and (2) to prevent our 7

Our Outreach Committee ensured the Recommendations reflect broad and meaningful stakeholder input, including the voices and lived experiences of everyday Marylanders.

recommendations from disturbing any already-existing nonlawyer legal assistance and representation schemes that are working for Marylanders. The Innovations Task Force designated five standing committees, each composed of relevant experts (see Appendix A for a complete list of Task Force and Committee Members). These Committees conducted extensive research, studied other states’ tiered legal service programs, and consulted a wide array of pertinent local, state, national, and even international experts. A brief description of each Committee follows:


COMMUNITY JUSTICE WORKER COMMITTEE The Community Justice Worker Committee developed all aspects of a framework for a Community Justice Worker Tier comparable to community health workers in the medical field. This Committee defined community justice workers’ appropriate scope of work and practice, established eligibility parameters for applicants, developed the framework for a statewide training curriculum, and formulated requirements for formally recognizing host organizations.

LEGAL PRACTITIONER SCOPE, ROLES, AND RESPONSIBILITY COMMITTEE The Scope Committee developed recommendations for a Legal Practitioner Tier, akin to nurse practitioners in the medical field. This Committee studied the parameters other states have used to define the kinds of legal assistance and representation legal practitioners can perform, and to ensure their services are affordable and focused on helping selfrepresented persons from modestmeans households with cases that fall in civil law practice areas with a high level of unmet need.

LEGAL PRACTITIONER EDUCATION, EXPERIENCE, AND EXAMINATION COMMITTEE The Education Committee focused on developing training and qualifications for the Legal Practitioner Tier. This Committee, which included Maryland law educators, formulated a legal practitioner eligibility framework, including educational and experiential prerequisites, parameters for a statewide training curriculum, and a testing framework for legal practitioner licensure and certification.

LEGAL TECHNOLOGY COMMITTEE

OUTREACH COMMITTEE

The Legal Technology Committee developed a framework for a Legal Technology Tier to facilitate the scaling, benchmarking, and implementation of legal technology tools, while prioritizing consumer protection, to help selfrepresented people who cannot afford a lawyer address civil legal problems that are amenable to and appropriate for machine help. The Committee studied generative-AI-powered legal technology tools already in use in the U.S. and abroad, examined how other jurisdictions have modernized their UPL regulations to stimulate investment and innovation, reviewed relevant UPL litigation, and consulted with numerous legal technology innovators and entrepreneurs.

The Outreach Committee collected and synthesized input from a wide range of Maryland stakeholders pertaining to all three tiers under consideration. Outreach activities included discussion forums, listening sessions, surveys, live conference workshops, and small-group and one-on-one interviews. Participants included individuals representing impacted populations (the intended beneficiaries of the legal service tiers); private and legal service sector attorneys and paralegals; legal aid leaders and decision-makers; judges; current allied legal professionals; educators; bar counsel; a state law examiner; workforce development leaders; state and local agency personnel; community-based organizations; implementation science experts; and potential future Maryland legal practitioner and community justice worker candidates.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

8


THE PROCESS

Our Leadership Team formulated overarching guiding principles, devised a governance structure, and developed an implementation strategy.

At the request of the Outreach Committee, the Research and Analysis Department (hereinafter “R&A”) of the Maryland Judiciary’s Administrative Office of the Courts conducted eight semi-structured discussion forums with attorneys, paralegals, judges, civil legal aid organization leaders, community-based organization members and impacted populations to better understand their interests, attitudes, and recommendations for expanding tiered legal services in Maryland. Participants were recruited using a stratified random sampling method, in which individuals who expressed interest in the discussion forums were first divided into relevant subgroups (also known as “strata”) based on a list of characteristics (demographic characteristics and professional background), and then randomly selected from those subgroups to participate. MSBA contributed financial support and leveraged its vast network to help ensure robust participation, and R&A led the stratified random sampling process. About 326 individuals expressed interest in the forums; 73 of whom participated across the eight groups (6-11 participants per forum). All forums were facilitated by two trained senior researchers, audio recorded with participant consent, transcribed, and anonymized prior to analysis. R&A analyzed the transcripts using qualitative coding to identify emerging themes and assess topic areas aligned with the Innovations Task 9

Force’s interests. To strengthen the reliability of the analysis and reduce analytic bias, each transcript was coded twice, and researchers engaged in an iterative review process to reconcile coding differences and refine thematic findings. As each Committee reached substantial internal consensus throughout the Fall of 2025, its respective Committee Chair presented recommendations and draft regulatory language for review and consideration by the full Innovations Task Force. A Leadership Team composed of the Innovations Task Force Co-Chairs and Committee Chairs convened regularly throughout the course of the initiative to examine and align cross-tier issues, formulate overarching guiding principles, devise a governance structure, and develop an implementation strategy. The Innovations Task Force met regularly throughout the Winter of 2025 and Spring of 2026 to discuss and evaluate the Committees’ and the Leadership Team’s recommendations, request additional information as needed, address and incorporate stakeholder feedback, and build consensus, ultimately culminating in the publication of this Report and the formal recommendations it puts forth.


THE SOLUTION

III. The Solution “Law has been walled off from the technological, financial, and service innovations that have transformed almost every other part of the modern economy.”50 –Deborah L. Rhode Center at Stanford Law School

Since 2015, a movement to modernize how the practice of law is regulated and introduce new legal service tiers has gained traction and gathered momentum in the United States, empowering states to tackle the access-to-justice crisis with innovative solutions.

A. MODERNIZE UNAUTHORIZED PRACTICE OF LAW RULES

But states’ current practice of rigorously policing UPL hasn’t always been the norm, say Matthew Burnett and Rebecca L. Sandefur:

Expanding the kinds of civil legal help available in a state typically requires changes to state statutes and/ or court rules governing the unauthorized practice of law. Like many states’ UPL rules, Maryland Rule 19-305.5 prohibits any individual from practicing, attempting to practice, or offering to practice law in the state unless the person is an active, licensed member of the Maryland Bar.52 Such attorney monopolies limit the kinds of legal helpers authorized to practice law, thereby stifling the supply of available civil legal help. According to experts at the Deborah L. Rhode Center at Stanford Law School: [L]awyers have been the only sanctioned suppliers of legal assistance, regardless of how sophisticated the consumer or complex the legal need…[U]nder most states’ UPL rules, any nonlawyer who offers legal advice, even simple legal advice for free, potentially exposes herself to criminal liability. As a result, the legal profession has not seen the diversification in service providers that has been so successful in the medical field, where nurse practitioners, physician assistants, phlebotomists, and providers in other roles perform a range of needed services at lower cost and in a more holistic way.53

These restrictions are products of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Before lawyers mobilized professional closure around law practice, the United States boasted a much more diverse ecosystem of justice work. This included some jurisdictions in which basically all adults could practice law. In the 19th century, several states, including Indiana, Maine, New Hampshire, and Wisconsin, explicitly permitted, variously, all “citizens,” “voters,” or “residents” to practice law…It was the organized bar’s concerted efforts that turned this diverse ecosystem into today’s near-monoculture…That monolith actively prevents the emergence of “a multiplicity of approaches to meeting people’s justice needs where they are, through a variety of different kinds of service models.54

“While the access-to-justice crisis is a complex and multi-faceted problem, a growing consensus among scholars and other commentators holds that the legal profession’s century-old monopoly over legal services is a substantial contributor.”51 –Deborah L. Rhode Center at Stanford Law School

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

10


THE SOLUTION

According to IAALS, states are beginning to recognize and remedy the detrimental effects of excessively rigid UPL rules: For too long, state unauthorized practice of law (UPL) rules have for the most part limited the practice of law to attorneys. This has added to the current access to justice crisis, where millions of people up and down the income scale are unable to obtain legal help. There have been concerted efforts to improve access through increased pro bono and legal aid services, along with unbundled legal services, but far too many people are still left to handle their legal matters on their own. States are beginning to recognize that the legal profession needs to be opened to increase access.55

“[R]egulatory reform…[is] a chance to radically re-imagine the pathways for connecting all community members who are navigating civil justice needs with critical civil justice problem-solving.”56 –Frontline Justice

UPL modernization is emerging, both in the U.S. and abroad, as an integral component of contemporary civil access-to-justice strategy. Attorneys’ monopoly over law practice is typically justified on consumerprotection grounds. Comment 2 of Maryland’s UPL Rule describes the typical impetus behind the regulation: “limiting the practice of law to members of the bar protects the public 11

against rendition of legal services by unqualified persons.”57 In a July 2025 report, IAALS cautioned that UPL regulations ostensibly intended to protect consumers can, if not carefully crafted, actually impede consumers’ access to justice: The current regulatory structure’s myopic focus on protecting consumers ignores the full range of consumer needs—particularly the need for access to quality and affordable legal services—which are often in tension with UPL. And while consumer protection is often cited as the primary purpose of UPL rules, they also serve to protect lawyers… [W]hile regulation of the legal profession has ostensibly consumercentered aims, its practical effect is protecting the lawyer monopoly, often at the expense of consumers….[T]here remains a mismatch between the outcomes regulators track—consumer harm to the exclusion of all other metrics— and the more varied and nuanced outcomes that consumers actually want: access to support to begin with, satisfactory results, some degree of protection, and means of redress if things go wrong.”58 One participant in the IAALS forum that led to the report urged states to “stop thinking of regulators as gatekeepers punishing wrongdoing and start thinking of them as service providers, focused first and foremost on consumer needs.”59 In the course of assessing two states’ allied legal professional programs, experts at the Deborah L. Rhode Center at Stanford Law School exposed a need for state legal system actors to reexamine and rebalance the risks and benefits of self-regulation: [T]he relevant regulators in almost all jurisdictions are state supreme courts or state bar associations,


“[A] large number of consumers—who are presumed incapable of assessing the quality of legal services when making purchasing decisions—are for all practical purposes presumed capable of becoming educated and informed enough about the law to handle their legal matters pro se. These two presumptions are irreconcilable.”63 –Laurel A. Rigertas, Professor of Law, Northern Illinois University College of Law

made up of members of the profession steeped in the traditions and professional identity of the lawyers’ monopoly. Self-regulation brings benefits, including expertise in judging the quality of legal services that nonlawyer regulators might lack, but that expertise comes with the risk that selfregulation will also enable cartel-like capture and protectionism to protect lawyers’ earnings.60 Laurel A. Rigertas, a Professor of Law at Northern Illinois University College of Law, calls to light a fundamental regulatory fallacy that she says is causing states to fail in their consumer protection role61: Current regulations restrict activities that constitute the practice of law to licensed attorneys…justified, in large part, based on the assumption that the public cannot make informed decisions about who is qualified to provide legal advice and, therefore, the government must make that determination. Even if this assumption is correct, restricting the practice of law to those who have completed a juris doctor has constrained the market options so that many consumers have no access to legal services at all. This also has consumer protection implications. The practical effect is that a large number of consumers— who are presumed incapable of assessing the quality of legal services when making purchasing decisions—are for all practical purposes presumed capable of becoming educated and informed enough about the law to handle their legal matters pro se. These two presumptions are irreconcilable.62 The National Center for State Courts (NCSC) warns that “overly restrictive UPL enforcement may constitute anticompetitive behavior that violates federal antitrust laws by protecting the legal profession’s monopoly on legal services without sufficient public benefit.”64 Citing North Carolina Board of Dental Examiners v. FTC, where the Supreme Court ruled that state professional boards controlled by active market participants must be actively supervised by the state in order to claim antitrust immunity, NCSC predicts: This precedent suggests state bar associations— often comprised primarily of practicing attorneys— might face antitrust scrutiny for aggressive UPL

enforcement that excludes potential competitors, including technology-driven innovative service models that aim to improve access to justice.65 A February 2023 letter from Deputy Assistant Attorney General (AAG) Maggie Goodlander of the U.S. Justice Department’s Antitrust Division supporting North Carolina’s consideration of UPL reform articulates the two-pronged test for evaluating whether state UPL restrictions violate federal antitrust laws: “the antitrust laws require that restrictions on competition are both necessary to prevent significant consumer harm and narrowly drawn to minimize its anticompetitive impact.”66 Deputy AAG Goodlander’s letter underscores an array of potential benefits associated with eliminating undue restrictions on competition between lawyers and nonlawyers: While there is an appropriate role for certain qualification requirements to protect the public’s interest in effective legal representation, unduly broad restrictions on the practice of law impose significant competitive costs on consumers and workers and impede innovation…These [UPL reform] recommendations could…benefit consumers and workers alike, including by securing lower costs, enabling more choice in the delivery of legal-related services, and lifting barriers to employment. They would promote important innovations in the delivery of legal services to our communities.67 Frontline Justice Co-Founder and Co-Chair, Rebecca Sandefur, posits, “If regulating the practice of law is to be guided by honest concerns for consumer protection, there is much more scope for nonlawyers to practice law safely and effectively than is permitted by the current rules.”68

“[I]ncreasing and diversifying the supply of legal service providers should enable more people to find, engage with, and use one or more providers, thereby increasing the number of people who get legal help.”69 –Deborah L. Rhode Center at Stanford Law School

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

12


THE SOLUTION

B. AUTHORIZE NEW LEGAL SERVICE TIERS “Expanding the supply of legal helpers beyond attorneys is critical. Providing access to justice for people who can’t afford lawyers requires new kinds of service providers, innovative delivery models, and the courage to pilot change.”70 –Jim Sandman, President Emeritus, Legal Services Corporation

Tiered legal services refers to a system where legal assistance or representation are made available at different levels of experience, cost, and complexity based on factors like the nature of the legal issue or the type of assistance needed. In answer to the accessto-justice crisis, states are increasingly introducing two new categories of civil legal service tiers – allied legal professionals and legal technology tools.

1. Allied Legal Professionals Allied legal professionals (hereinafter “ALPs”) are nonlawyers authorized to provide legal services, without committing the unauthorized practice of law, in specific areas of civil law or case types where attorneys are not meeting the need.71 Functioning much like nurse practitioners or community health workers in the medical field, ALPs help bridge the gap in legal services for people who need civil legal help but can neither access free legal aid nor afford to hire an attorney at market rate. According to IAALS: It is clear that attorneys alone are not the answer, and further that subsidized legal services cannot come close to meeting the present need. An ecosystem of legal professionals is necessary to close this justice gap.”72 13

America’s traditional, lawyer-centric legal help model is failing, according to Matthew Burnett and Rebecca L. Sandefur, for several reasons: Legal issues and needs are not uniform across a socially diverse and geographically large and varied polity; thus, it is unsurprising that a single model of training, production, and delivery does a poor job of meeting those needs. The legal services offered by lawyers are often disproportionate to the problems people face, which may require the application of only a little law, or of some law combined with other skills, such as those of social workers, health care workers, teachers, librarians, accountants, or neighbors. Lawyers can lack the cultural competency and community trust necessary to connect with different groups and are often spatially and socio-spatially distant from those who benefit from legal services.73 Meanwhile, there is ample research and empirical evidence that ALPs are competent and effective at helping people solve their legal problems.74 Intentionally designed to serve specific populations that would otherwise go unserved or underserved, rather than detracting from private attorneys’ client base and work, ALPs help fill a yawning service gap by expanding civil legal help to populations that are not getting help from attorneys.


“Decades of research provide empirical evidence that providers other than lawyers, trained in specific areas of law and legal process, are competent, effective, and can play a part in helping people solve legal problems.”75 –Rebecca L. Sandefur, Co-Founder and Co-Chair, Frontline Justice

EACH OF THE PROPOSED NEW LEGAL SERVICE TIERS ALIGNS WITH THE SPECIFIC, UNMET LEGAL NEEDS OF A PARTICULAR SECTOR OF MARYLAND'S UNREPRESENTED POPULATION:

PRIVATE FIRMS/ ATTORNEYS

LEGAL SERVICES STAFF ATTORNEYS

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS

COMMUNITY JUSTICE WORKERS

ABOVE ALICE

<125% OF FPL

ALICE

<125% OF FPL

Can afford to hire an attorney at market rate

Legal-aid eligible, have access to free legal representation

Cannot afford to hire an attorney at market rate but are income-ineligible for legal aid

Income-eligible for free legal aid, but SRL due to nonfinancial ineligibility factors or dearth of available legal aid attorneys

LEGAL TECHNOLOGY

Can serve low and moderate income consumers directly at scale and support all other tiers to have broader reach, with greater efficiency.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

14


THE SOLUTION

The Innovations Task Force conducted an in-depth examination of the use of ALPs, both in Maryland and in other states.

a. Current Use of Allied Legal Professionals in Maryland The Innovations Task Force’s audit of ALP assistance and representation in Maryland revealed that ALPs are far from a novel concept in this state.76 ALPs are already authorized in more than 15 different types of state civil legal matters or cases. CONTEXTS IN WHICH MARYLAND ALREADY AUTHORIZES ALLIED LEGAL PROFESSIONALS TO PRACTICE COURTS

AGENCIES

OTHER

District Court

Department of Labor (e.g.,

Office of Administrative Hearings (appeals of administrative agency decisions)

• Small business claims • County grievance procedures • Common ownership community disputes • Insurance defense • Summary ejection • Rent escrow Tax Court

unemployment benefits cases) Department of Budget and Management Department of the Environment

Education Advocacy (disability and special education matters)

Insurance Administration

Law Students (supervised through clinical law programs)

Office of the Attorney General's Securities Division

Adjudicators i.e., Orphans

At least 15 federal agencies also currently permit ALPs to assist or represent Marylanders in one or more types of matters and proceedings. U.S. federal agencies have a well-established practice of permitting ALP representation in administrative proceedings and, to a lesser extent, in court.77 According to the White House Legal Aid Interagency

Court Judges and District Court Commissioners/Magistrates)

Roundtable’s (“LAIR”) 2023 Report, “nonlawyers assist in all substantive areas, including housing, public benefits, immigration, civil rights, tax, food security, and worker protection.”78 This assistance is varied, and can include anything from helping someone file the correct form to full representation in immigration court removal procedures.

FEDERAL AGENCIES THAT AUTHORIZE ALLIED LEGAL PROFESSIONALS • Agriculture • Education • Energy

15

• Housing & Urban Development (HUD)

• Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

• Interior

• Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)

• Health & Human Services (HHS)

• Justice – EOIR runs our Immigration Courts

• Homeland Security – both Citizenship and Immigration Services & FEMA

• Labor

• Treasury's IRS

• Commerce Department's Patent & Trade Office

• Veteran's Affairs (VA)

• Social Security Administration


State and federal ALPs in Maryland span a wide spectrum in terms of both qualifications and scope of allowable services. While a few agencies’ rules have fairly extensive ALP requirements, many agencies’ rules require little or no educational, experiential, training, or testing of ALPs, and some even permit friends or family members with no qualifications to assist or represent a party. Many ALPs are permitted to practice independently, within one specific practice area and before one particular court or agency, and most are not required to be under attorney supervision. Some ALPs are authorized to perform in-court representation, but, non-representational assistance (such as helping a party fill out forms) is permitted more frequently than direct representation (such as speaking for a party in a hearing). Most ALPs are not bound by the various rules and regulations applicable to attorneys or

What the Task Force heard from ALPs and ALP supervisors in Maryland aligns with what national experts are finding across other states’ ALP programs. Well-trained ALPs are competent; their clients are satisfied with ALPs’ work product; ALPs are providing high-quality legal services for free or at rates far below attorneys’ rates; and ALPs can reach a portion of the population that attorneys simply aren’t reaching. Even in states with ALP programs that do not require attorney supervision, there has been little to no consumer harm reported from ALP-provided services. Legal malpractice insurance providers interviewed by IAALS indicated that, applying their risk-assessment rubric, they felt comfortable insuring ALPs. One issue that emerged during the ALP audit was the severe lack and fragmentation of data and information about ALPs in Maryland. Despite a multitude of efforts, the Innovations Task Force

“Maryland clients want access to and are satisfied with ALP services. They place less importance on whether a legal helper holds a law degree and bar license than on whether the helper is communicative, responsive, and reliable, and shares their experiences, culture, or language.”79 –Audit Report on the Current Use of Allied Legal Professionals in Maryland

subject to discipline (only to revocation of permission to assist or represent individuals before that specific agency). Some ALPs are permitted to charge clients a fee for legal services, whereas others are explicitly prohibited from requesting or accepting remuneration. And, most existing ALPs in Maryland are not subject to the rigorous eligibility, training, experiential learning, and other requirements contemplated by the Innovations Task Force for the legal service tiers we are recommending. The Innovations Task Force heard consistently from the field that Marylanders want access to and are satisfied with ALP services. Clients place less importance on whether a legal helper holds a law degree and bar license than on whether the helper is communicative, responsive, and reliable, and shares their experiences, culture, or language.

was unable to determine how many ALPs currently operate in Maryland, how many individuals they serve each year, or the extent of their impact. While the Innovations Task Force is cognizant of not disturbing existing ALP programs, it has identified data collection and analysis about existing and proposed new ALP programs to be critical to gaining a holistic understanding of the state’s ALP landscape. Despite the existing ALPs identified in the Audit Report, substantial unmet civil legal needs persist among Maryland’s FPL and ALICE populations. The Innovations Task Force’s research indicates that, if carefully tailored to Maryland’s unmet needs, additional ALP service tiers and legal technology tools can help address those needs and narrow the state’s access-to-justice gap.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

16


THE SOLUTION

b. Other States’ Use of Allied Legal Professionals The Innovations Task Force also conducted in-depth research into other states’ use of ALPs. Although called by different names in different states, two distinct types of ALPs dominate the emerging national movement – community justice workers and legal practitioners.

i. COMMUNITY JUSTICE WORKERS Frontline Justice, a national, non-partisan organization with a mission to ensure that all Americans have access to justice, describes community justice workers as “frontline helpers like shelter volunteers, faith leaders, community health aides…and others who are cross-trained to give their community essential legal help that lawyers aren’t providing.”80 For example, community health workers could be upskilled to help existing clients complete and submit Medicaid applications. In some jurisdictions, community justice workers are community-based organization staff or community members who, with legal training and attorney oversight, are authorized to provide legal advice and representation in high-need areas of law that are underserved by attorneys. Community justice workers typically do not charge the client any fee. They may be able to assist individuals whose household incomes fall within legal-aid eligibility guidelines but who nonetheless must represent themselves because of other eligibility restrictions, because no legal aid organization in their service area handles their particular type of legal problem, or because they live in an area with few legal services or pro bono attorneys and limited or no access to public transportation. Frontline Justice describes community justice worker programs as “innovative, community-based models designed to expand access to affordable, quality civil legal services for individuals who cannot afford an attorney”81: Community justice workers work with lawyers to expand access to justice…They take on highvolume, straight-forward tasks, freeing lawyers to work at the top of their license. They identify issues that never reach lawyers or courts. They resolve issues before they balloon into more complex cases that require a lawyer.82

17

“There will never be enough lawyers to resolve all the legal problems that the community faces,” says Frontline Justice CEO, Nikole Nelson (former Executive Director of the Alaska Legal Services Corporation). “Sometimes, community justice workers are more suitable to address cases than lawyers are. They are connected in ways that lawyers may not be as they are often close to or are members of the community. They are helping lawyers expand their reach and amplify the services.”83 Accessibility—increasing the available supply of legal helpers and bringing civil legal services directly to people who need them – is a foundational tenet of the community justice worker concept. Currently, accessing affordable civil legal help is onerous or out of reach for many low-income Marylanders living in rural or otherwise underserved areas of the state. A dearth of local service providers in these areas, a lack of public transportation, and logistical complications of having to take a full day off work or find affordable childcare each time an individual seeks legal help are examples of common access barriers. The majority of existing legal service providers are concentrated in urban, high-density population centers. The community justice worker model of embedding or co-locating legal helpers directly into local, community-based agencies and organizations across rural or underserved areas of the state has tremendous potential to expand access to free civil legal help in Maryland. On August 12, 2025, the ABA’s House of Delegates adopted Resolution 605, calling on states to implement community justice worker programs: [T]he American Bar Association urges each state, territorial, and tribal highest court to study community justice worker programs implemented in several U.S. jurisdictions, under which community justice workers are supervised by lawyers and do not charge fees to clients, and to adopt such programs appropriate for their jurisdiction to expand the accessibility, affordability, and quality of civil legal services provided to those who cannot afford an attorney, while continuing to protect clients and the public.84


Fourteen states (Alaska, Arizona, California, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Indiana, Minnesota, Montana, New Hampshire, South Carolina, Texas, Utah, and Washington) and the District of Columbia have passed or proposed rules for authorizing community justice worker programs, and another twenty states are actively developing them.85

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

18


THE SOLUTION

“In a short time, these justice workers can begin to contribute meaningful services. Over less than three years, a small workforce of [Delaware community justice workers] contributed to over three quarters (78%) of a legal aid organization’s landlord-tenant caseload, including acting as the primary legal provider in fully one-third (33%) of those housing cases. By expanding the pool of authorized advocates, [community justice workers] increase system capacity to respond to justice needs that attorney-only models struggle to meet.”87 –ABA Access to Justice Research Initiative

ALASKA In November 2022, the Alaska Supreme Court was the first in the country to authorize a broad UPL waiver for the state’s largest civil legal aid provider, the Alaska Legal Services Corporation (ALSC). The waiver permits ALSC to train and supervise community justice workers to provide limited-scope legal advice and representation in rural and remote communities experiencing a shortage of attorneys.88 Alaska Bar Rule 43.5 deems a community justice worker eligible if they successfully complete required ALSC-provided substantive law and ethics training; practice exclusively under the supervision of an ALSC attorney; disclose in writing that they are not a lawyer and obtain written consent for representation from each client; and, ALSC submits and the Alaska State Bar Board of Governors approves an application on the worker’s behalf.89 Alaska’s community justice workers are themselves members of underserved communities, particularly rural and Alaska Native communities.90 30 percent of the state’s community justice workers are indigenous people with cultural and linguistic competencies relevant to the populations they serve. Many Alaska community justice workers remain in their usual place of employment; others serve as trained volunteers with ALSC.91 The program was inspired 19

by Alaska’s Community Health Aide/Practitioner (CHA/P) model. ALSC partnered on the initiative with the Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium (ANTHC) which helped develop and implement community justice worker training, leveraging their existing community relationships, educational infrastructure, and experience supporting local frontline workers in rural Alaska.92 Some of the state’s community justice workers are community health workers retrained as legal workers, but Alaska’s community justice workers represent a wide variety of backgrounds.93 They include Tribal employees, community advocates, victim advocates, social service workers, community volunteers, and others. A 2025 ABA Access to Justice Research Initiative study analyzing the social and economic impact of Alaska’s community justice workers found their services effective and impactful.94 Across more than 1,400 SNAP benefits cases, the study found, community justice workers helped Alaskans recover $23.6 million dollars in supplementary food assistance, benefiting roughly 850 households and 2,800 people.95 They achieved a 100 percent success rate in assessing SNAP eligibility, and 73 percent of their cases resulted in clients’ documented receipt of SNAP benefits.96 In addition to directly improving food security for recipients and their families, the study’s authors estimate the successful SNAP cases generated an additional $14.5 million dollars in economic benefits to the recipients’


communities.97 Alaska’s community justice workers reached underserved populations and underserved areas of the vast, heavily-rural state, touching more than half of the state’s zip codes, including towns and villages with no attorneys and those off the road system.98 More than 26.5 percent of the community justice workers’ clients had a disability; 7 percent were veterans; 11.9 percent had experienced intimate partner violence; and 60 percent were Alaska Native or American Indian.99 The ABA research team noted that Alaska’s program is evidence of community justice worker programs' high potential for swift growth: In 2022, the CJW workforce on the ground in Alaska served about 1 case for every five cases served by volunteer (pro bono) attorneys working with ALSC. By the end of 2024, CJWs were serving nearly 4 cases for every one case served as volunteer attorneys. Between 2022 and 2024, the number of cases served by community justice workers increased by 1,575%. This suggests that community justice workers can scale up relatively quickly when compared with traditional models, enabling rapid deployment of help to more people.100 According to the ABA study, Alaska’s community justice workers deliver a high ROI: “The estimated financial return on investment from public benefit value for people and their communities under a federal grant focused on disaster legal assistance was approximately $25 of benefit for every $1 invested.”101

DELAWARE In March 2022, Maryland’s neighboring state of Delaware launched a community justice worker program. Delaware’s community justice workers, who work exclusively in housing law, are known as “Qualified Tenant Advocates” (hereinafter “QTAs”).102 Rule 57.1103 allows nonlawyer QTAs to represent residential tenants in eviction proceedings, free of charge to the tenants. Delaware’s three legal aid organizations104 are authorized to hire, train, and supervise QTAs under Rule 57.1. The Combined Campaign for Justice (CCJ) serves as the primary fundraising and coordinating entity supporting these three nonprofit legal aid organizations. QTAs can perform the same functions as Delaware’s licensed attorneys can

perform in housing law cases, including prosecuting or defending eviction proceedings, engaging in settlement negotiations with opposing parties, drafting and filing pleadings and other documents, and appearing in the Justice of the Peace Court. QTAs have access to attorney oversight, but the attorneys are not required to review QTA’s work or accompany them to court.

“Being a QTA is the most rewarding work I’ve done throughout my career. The work is challenging, but not nearly as challenging as the circumstances many of the families we serve face every day. It is nothing less than a privilege to support them and stand in the gap as a direct link to justice. Much of the credit for the program’s success goes to our instructional team who from day one has provided training that is thorough and ongoing. We are never without their support.” –Rena Scott, Qualified Tenant Advocate, Delaware

A 2026 research brief by the ABA’s Access to Justice Research Initiative analyzing the social and economic impact of Delaware’s QTAs captures the young program’s early successes105 Between 2022 and 2025, just seven certified QTAs contributed to 3,755 housing matters serving all three Delaware counties.106 During that period, QTAs were involved in more than 78 percent of Community Legal Aid Society, Inc.’s (CLASI) 4,829 housing cases, most of them involving federally-subsidized housing.107 Services ranged from brief counsel and advice to full representation in contested court proceedings.108 The research shows: QTAs participated in 3,130 cases, representing 83 percent of all matters in which QTAs were involved, that raised issues related to subsidized housing…QTAs assisted nearly 8,000 people, including 4,233 adults and 3,463 children . . . Across more than 3,300 closed cases, QTAs assisted tenant-clients in securing or preserving

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

20


THE SOLUTION

Integrating Community Justice Workers to Bolster Maryland’s Access to Counsel in Evictions Program Maryland’s Access to Counsel in Evictions (ACE) program is a groundbreaking, hardfought success story that has leveled the playing field for thousands of vulnerable families. According to the 2026 Access to Counsel in Evictions Task Force Report, in Fiscal Year 2025, ACE attorneys closed 12,778 cases, resulting in an 87 percent success rate for clients seeking to remain in their homes. The program delivers an estimated $46.7 million in annual economic benefits to the state. However, the sheer volume of housing instability—with over 360,000 eviction notices filed in FY2025 alone—presents a persistent capacity challenge. Furthermore, civil legal aid providers face significant hurdles in recruiting and retaining attorneys to do this work, largely due to high-volume caseloads, burnout, and compensation disparities compared to other public service sectors. The introduction of a Community Justice Worker Tier in Maryland would not diminish or discount the indispensable role of licensed attorneys. Instead, it would

approximately $4.8 million in housingrelated financial assistance, primarily by maintaining access to housing subsidies or vouchers…QTAs’ work also generated broader community-level benefits. By preventing evictions and involuntary moves, QTA-assisted cases helped Delaware communities avoid an estimated $5.43 million in downstream public costs, including expenditures related to emergency shelter, foster care placements, and disruptions to children’s education.109 The analysis also highlighted the documented local economic multiplier effect of housing assistance, noting that, “for every dollar of housing assistance entering a community, approximately one additional dollar is spent locally”110: 21

serve as a powerful force multiplier to bolster the existing ACE infrastructure. By integrating community justice workers to handle straightforward, less complex eviction proceedings, civil legal aid organizations could safely absorb a higher volume of cases. This tiered legal triage model would reserve precious, highly specialized attorney time and resources for the most demanding matters, such as those involving complex litigation or the presentation of complex evidence. This is an expansion of a proven concept: Maryland’s civil legal aid organizations already rely successfully on allied legal professionals, with more than 39 casehandling paralegal full-time equivalents currently supporting the ACE program across the state. Expanding this framework to include certified, attorney-supervised community justice workers—modeled after Delaware’s QTAs—would optimize existing legal teams, reduce attorney burnout, and ensure that a greater number of eligible Marylanders receive the meaningful legal representation promised to them by the ACE law.

As a result, the $4.8 million in housing assistance recovered or preserved through QTA involvement generated an estimated $4.8 million in additional local economic activity, sufficient to support approximately 44 full-time jobs for one year.111 Initial findings from the QTA evaluation indicate a return on investment (ROI) of approximately $7 in benefits for every $1 invested, and a percase cost less than half of the U.S. benchmark for low-cost, sustainable justice initiatives ($580 per case, compared to a benchmark of $1,470 per case) despite the program’s early stage, when training and startup costs are typically highest.112 Case data demonstrates that QTAs “disproportionately serve populations facing heightened vulnerability to housing instability


and other civil justice problems.”113 QTAs consistently earned extremely high client satisfaction scores,114 outperforming their attorney counterparts according to CLASI Deputy Director, Sarah Rhine.115 The ABA’s research team concluded that: Qualified Tenant Advocates deliver substantial and measurable impacts for individuals, families, and communities…QTA services are not only effective in resolving housing-related legal issues, but are also accessible, understandable, and responsive to client needs, and have measurable benefits for client well-being.116

“[In the program’s first three years, seven Delaware community justice workers] assisted tenantclients in securing or preserving approximately $4.8 million in housing-related financial assistance [and] helped Delaware communities avoid an estimated $5.43 million in downstream public costs.”118 –ABA Access to Justice Research Initiative

Overall, Delaware’s early experience with QTAs convinced the ABA team that “community justice worker models can be politically viable, community-grounded, and economically sustainable” and are “instrumental in helping legal aid organizations address persistent attorney recruitment and retention challenges, as well as broader shortages of attorneys working in people-facing and publicinterest law.”117

ARIZONA In 2020, the Arizona Supreme Court launched an innovative pilot program that successfully embedded nonlawyer legal helpers directly into community-based organizations.119 Initially operating as the Licensed Legal Advocate Pilot Program, the initiative authorized domestic violence advocates employed by the Emerge! Center Against Domestic Abuse to provide

free, limited-scope legal advice and support to survivors navigating protection orders and related family law issues.120 Driven by the pilot’s success, the Arizona Supreme Court approved a statewide expansion of the program in 2023 to include other community-based organizations, recently rebranding it as the Domestic Violence Legal Advocate (DVLA) Initiative.121 Building on this momentum, the Court also authorized a parallel Housing Stability Legal Advocate Pilot Program that same year.122 For stakeholders concerned about consumers’ protection and the competency of nonlawyer practitioners, Arizona’s model provides a powerful blueprint for rigorous credentialing. To qualify as a DVLA, applicants must pass criminal background checks and demonstrate a substantial 2,000 hours of prior work experience as a domestic violence advocate.123 Candidates must then successfully complete an intensive, 8-week training course designed by Innovation for Justice (i4J) and pass an examination proctored by the state’s Administrative Office of the Courts before being certified.124 Notably, while Maryland’s proposed community justice worker model requires attorney oversight, Arizona’s operates without attorney supervision.125 The fact that the Arizona Supreme Court confidently expanded unsupervised nonlawyer practice statewide—and replicated the model for housing law— demonstrates that, when community justice workers are highly trained and embedded directly into the organizations already serving vulnerable populations, they can safely and effectively scale to meet critical legal needs across multiple high-stakes practice areas.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

22


THE SOLUTION

“The American access to justice crisis demands bold and immediate action. Through the Innovation Office and the Sandbox, our Supreme Court seeks to unleash the transformative power of innovation and capital into the legal services market for the benefit of all Utahns.”126 – Chief Justice Matthew B. Durrant, Utah Supreme Court

UTAH In August 2020, two years after launching its legal practitioner program, the Utah Supreme Court established the United States’ first legal services regulatory sandbox. A regulatory sandbox is a “safe space” used to test innovative services and delivery models under regulatory supervision for a limited time period without immediately incurring all of the ordinary regulatory consequences associated with the activity. Through Standing Order No. 15,127 the Court allowed participating organizations to seek UPL waivers to deploy innovative models, explicitly adding community justice workers alongside technologybased services and alternative business structures.128 Utah’s sandbox, a seven-year pilot, allows both non- and for-profit organizations to seek UPL waivers in favor of assessing applicants’ risk of harming consumers and monitoring the impact of admitted entities’ work on consumers.129 As of December 2023, a total of 51 authorized providers had delivered nearly 70,000 services to approximately 24,000 individual consumers under these UPL waivers.130 IAALS recently published an interim evaluation of Utah’s sandbox covering August 2020 through February 2025.131 Three service quality audits conducted during the study period found no evidence of material or substantial harm to consumers and concluded that services were at least satisfactory132: 23

[C]onsumer complaints…were relatively rare in light of the total number of services provided. As of January 2024, the Innovation Office had received 14 complaints overall . . . This translates to one harm-related complaint per 8,468 services, or less than 0.01% of all services delivered through the Sandbox. IAALS also examined the sandbox’s social return on investment (SROI) – the full estimated value of resources devoted to a program – finding: [D]uring the first three years of Sandbox operations, the program generated an estimated $1.17 to $1.71 in social value for every $1.00 invested. Because SROI ratios greater than 1.0 indicate that the value created exceeds the resources required to support a program, these findings suggest that the Sandbox has produced measurable economic benefits relative to its cost. While the IAALS interim evaluation was not limited to any one legal service tier, instead encompassing the full range of regulatory innovations, the results nonetheless serve as a valuable case study. From a consumer protection perspective, the study indicates that ALPs are safe for consumers and economically sound.133


ii. LEGAL PRACTITIONERS Conceptually akin to nurse practitioners in the medical profession, legal practitioners are trained, licensed, and regulated providers authorized to offer legal advice and representation in one or more designated areas of civil law.134 They are required to meet formal educational and/or experiential and training standards, pass an examination, and comply with ethical and regulatory obligations.135 The legal practitioner role is designed to increase access to justice by offering affordable, competent legal assistance to individuals who are unable to afford a lawyer at market rate. Depending on the state, legal practitioners may work independently or under the supervision of a licensed attorney. Legal practitioners typically charge modest fees (well below attorneys’ market rates) making legal services

accessible to the ALICE population. According to IAALS, data from legal practitioner programs show that legal practitioners are making a positive impact in people’s lives: “Well trained ALPs are competent, their clients are satisfied with their work product, and they can reach a portion of the population that attorneys are not reaching. ALPs are providing highquality legal services.”136 Seven states have already authorized and implemented legal practitioner programs (Arizona, Colorado, Minnesota, New Hampshire, Oregon, Utah, and Washington), and more than a dozen states are considering following suit.137 Of the states with active legal practitioner programs, two —Washington and Utah (also the first two legal practitioner programs in the United States)—have submitted to formal program evaluations.138

Institute for the Advancement of the American Legal System139

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

24


THE SOLUTION

WASHINGTON Launched in 2015, Washington’s Limited License Legal Technician (LLLT) Program was the first of its kind in the United States and is the most robustly evaluated legal practitioner program, to date. A preliminary evaluation found that LLLTs provided valuable, competent services and improved access to justice.140 Several of the first cohort of LLLTs were successfully running a full-time LLLT practice by the time of the evaluation. Prepared by Thomas M. Clarke, National Center for State Courts and Rebecca L. Sandefur, American Bar Foundation, with support from the Public Welfare Foundation, the evaluation report found that: [T]he program has been appropriately designed to provide legal services to those who cannot afford a lawyer but still wish or need assistance. The training program prepares LLLTs to perform their role competently while keeping within the legal scope of that role. Customers have found their legal assistance to be valuable and well worth the cost. The legitimacy of the role appears to be widely accepted in spite of its short track record.141 The evaluators noted some questions about scaling the program, citing the requisite year of LLLT training as the most significant scaling barrier.142 Evaluators also observed that the regulatory costs for the LLLT program were not yet close to breaking even at the time of evaluation (2017), but predicted that scaling up the program significantly would resolve that issue.143 They concluded that: The LLLT program suggests that new legal roles with costs lower than traditional lawyers are a potentially significant strategy for meeting the legal needs of many people who now are dealing with their legal problems unassisted. Creating similar programs in other states would clearly improve access to justice for a broad section of the public.144 The evaluators described the LLLT program as “appropriate” and “efficacious,” acknowledging that it “meets a significant need and is viewed as a legitimate legal role,” and adding that “For a new kind of program designed ‘from scratch’ to be so successful is quite impressive.”145 The preliminary evaluation report concluded: 25

“While the scope of the role is limited and will not be the answer for every legal problem, [legal practitioners] definitely can provide quality legal services to those who need it and also significantly reduce the stress of navigating a foreign process that is complex and daunting.”148 –Thomas M. Clarke and Rebecca L. Sandefur Thomas M. Clarke

While the scope of the role is limited and will not be the answer for every legal problem, LLLTs definitely can provide quality legal services to those who need it and also significantly reduce the stress of navigating a foreign process that is complex and daunting. The LLLT program also offers the possibility of improving the quality of filings in court cases involving SRLs and thus reducing the time and cost required for courts to deal with such cases. The Washington state example suggests that LLLTs and lawyers may form mutually advantageous business relationships, making referrals to each other as appropriate. Since LLLTs appear to assist customers who could not afford lawyers, they do not compete directly with lawyers. 146 The evaluators recommended that Washington’s LLLT program “should be replicated in other states to improve access to justice” and “ensure that the public has access to quality legal services.”147 The Washington Supreme Court voted in 2020 to sunset the Limited License Legal Technician (LLLT) program, citing cost concerns and low participation, but permitted licensing to continue through July 2023.149 The 2017 program evaluation noted that regulating LLLTs in the same way attorneys are regulated as Washington chose to do can be costly, but noted that the bulk of the regulatory costs are incurred at the beginning of standing up the program.150 Seventy of Washington’s ninety-five LLLTs were still in active status as of late September 2025 and permitted to practice.151 A 2026 legislative proposal asks the Court to reinstate and expand the LLLT program (including new practice areas), and Washington continues to explore nonlawyer legal service models in other forms.152 Washington’s early success with legal practitioner programming directly influenced Utah and Oregon to follow suit.


UTAH Adopted in 2018, Utah’s Licensed Paralegal Practitioner (LPP) Program was the second of its kind in the United States.153 LPP candidates must complete one semester of coursework at Utah Valley University that includes an ethics track required for all candidates, and specialized tracks for certification in family law, debt collection, or landlord-tenant disputes (forcible entry and detainer).154 After completing the educational component, LPP candidates must work with a law firm for at least 1,500 hours in the three years prior to applying for certification and sitting for Utah’s LPP exam.155 Once an individual passes the exam, they are sworn in as an LPP alongside attorneys who pass Utah’s Bar Examination.156 Certified LPPs can file court documents, complete settlement negotiations, review court documents, and represent clients in mediation, but they are prohibited from appearing in court.157 LPPs can join a law firm or hang a shingle and practice independently, without attorney supervision, within their practice area(s) of certification.158

“Prior to Licensed Legal Paraprofessionals, many people handled their cases alone with no affordable options for legal help, relying on internet searches to understand their rights–often leading to poor outcomes. Now we are here to help, and guide families . . . through these difficult matters.”159 –Laura Landon, Owner & LLP, Aligned LLPs INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

26


THE SOLUTION

2. Legal Technology Tools In the current climate of rapid technological change, people are harnessing technology to perform law-related tasks and help solve legal problems. Artificial intelligence (AI)—and particularly generative AI—has enabled the development of technology tools to support all tiers and components of the legal profession. Courts are experimenting with website-based AI-powered chatbots and online assistants. Legal aid organizations are using AI-powered tools to automate and streamline client intake and communication. Attorneys and paralegals are using AI to conduct legal research and draft legal pleadings. And, SRLs are turning to publicly-available AI-powered technologies to help them understand their rights, obtain answers to legal questions, fill and file forms, generate case-specific court filings, and navigate an unfamiliar system of laws and courts. 27


“Technology-enhanced legal services products offer promise of enhanced efficiency, affordability, and round-the-clock availability— features the traditional onehuman-lawyer-per-one-client system cannot even begin to match at scale.”160 – National Center for State Courts

A 2019 survey of “Justice Needs and Satisfaction in the United States of America” found that people already used the Internet (31 percent) more than they used lawyers (29 percent) to address their legal issues.161 Some benefits of technology tools include:

• The tools are often free or affordable; • People can access the tools from anywhere they have Wi-Fi access (e.g., at home, in a public library, or from a smartphone); • The tools can be built in different languages for people who don’t read or speak English, and integrate assistive technologies for people who are deaf or blind; • People can use the tools at any time of day or night, which is especially helpful to people who work or go to school during the hours when lawyers are typically available.

But, general technology tools, which are not designed to solve a specific civil legal problem in a particular state, or to prioritize access to justice and consumer protection, can sometimes harm SRLs, widening the state’s access-to-justice gap. They pull information from immense datasets, rather than from carefully-curated, state-specific, current civil legal datasets, making them prone to inaccurate or “hallucinated” legal outputs that lay users are ill-equipped to detect or meaningfully evaluate. Colorado Supreme Court Justice Maria E. Berkenkotter and Colorado Appeals Court Judge Lino S. Lipinsky de Orlo, caution that: [G]enerative AI tools intended for the general public are not currently trained with data sets containing comprehensive, accurate legal resources. They are not consistently reliable legal research tools because they do not always provide the correct answers to legal queries and may even make up case names and citations when they do not know the answer to a question . . . How many nonlawyers looking for legal help will understand AI’s limits? How many will grasp that, when asked a legal question, generative AI is likely to respond ‍‍quite confidently, ‍‍even if the answer contains errors, hallucinations, falsehoods, or biases?162 INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

28


THE SOLUTION

Those output errors can undermine the tools’ reliability in high-stakes legal contexts, harming consumers and increasing the workloads of the legal service providers, court help center staff, judicial clerks, and judges who must catch and address those errors. In a 2026 statewide survey conducted by the Maryland Access to Justice Commission, 55 percent of legal aid staff surveyed said they have encountered clients or potential clients who have used AI tools for legal research or document/ case preparation.163 Thomas J. Fisher Jr., Managing Director at Maryland Center for Legal Assistance, LLC which runs a network of self-help centers collocated in Maryland courts, says his staff report similar experiences: Our staff are increasingly encountering selfrepresented litigants who rely heavily on legal advice and court filings generated by artificial intelligence without review by an attorney… the problem has become exponentially worse with the growing use of generative AI. AI tools can rapidly produce large amounts of detailed, authoritative-sounding legal content, even when the information is inaccurate or inapplicable. These materials frequently apply incorrect law… cite nonexistent or mischaracterized cases, and contain arguments or requests for relief that are unsupported under Maryland law…Given the volume of people we serve and the limited scope of our services, our attorneys simply do not have the time to conduct a line-by-line critique of lengthy AI-generated content. This trend creates an additional challenge for our staff, who must not only provide accurate legal guidance but also explain why the information generated by the AI may be unreliable. That task is particularly difficult when our advice contradicts the AI-generated answer or does not support the outcome the litigant hopes to achieve. In some cases, litigants place greater confidence in a detailed and authoritativesounding AI response than in the advice of a licensed attorney.164 Unreliable general legal technology tools are already exacerbating Maryland’s justice gap by misdirecting SRLs and taxing an already saturated legal services sector.

29

The fact that SRLs are already being harmed by their inability to afford or access human legal help does not justify relegating them to unreliable general technology tools. In its July 2025 report on regulating AI, IAALS acknowledged concerns that reliance on AI to bridge the justice gap for low- and modestincome litigants could lead to service disparities, but cautioned states against allowing such concerns to reinforce an unacceptable status quo165: Given that most Americans cannot afford an attorney when they need one, AI legal services might in practice be the alternative to no service at all…[W]e already have a two-tiered justice system: the average American has virtually no tools and no access to lawyers. Fears about possible externalities should not prevent the profession from addressing the harm that the status quo is causing now; they should only remind us to do so thoughtfully.166 State supreme courts’ reflexive reluctance to relax UPL rules historically grounded in consumer protection concerns (to prevent incomplete, incompetent, negligent, or fraudulent legal services delivered by unlicensed actors) is understandable.167 However, fears surrounding the potential for harm or disparities associated with business-to-consumer technology tools must never obviate proactive efforts to mitigate those very harms, particularly in the context where consumers are already utilizing and being harmed by those tools. SRLs invariably lose when states allow the perfect to stand in the way of the good. By assuming a proactive regulatory role, state supreme courts can advance civil access to justice by giving SRLs access to well-vetted legal technology tools. Legal technology tools are business-to-consumer tools specifically designed to help SRLs in a particular law-practice area and case type, with built-in validation metrics and legal-specific prompt engineering for accuracy and reliability. Unlike the error-prone general technology tools, legal technology tools typically pull from a finite data set of carefully-curated, current law sources. Justice Berkenkotter and Judge Lipinsky de Orlo urge that: [T]he legal profession needs to draw a distinction between AI tools that are designed to assist individuals with legal matters and general AI tools that are not trained to provide responses regarding the law. The latter can


“[P]rohibitions against the unauthorized practice of law [are] one of the most significant institutional barriers to adopting legal AI assistants.”174 –L. Karl Branting

lead both unwitting lawyers and nonlawyers astray. While general AI tools may not raise UPL concerns, if not used properly, they could harm individuals’ ability to represent themselves effectively.168 For example, a legal technology tool called “Beagle+,” developed by People’s Law School in British Columbia in partnership with TangoWork, has been rigorously tested and determined to provide legal information on a wide range of topics to the public.169 Beagle+ is a free, generative AI-powered170 chatbot that helps everyday Canadians navigate basic legal issues. The chatbot uses OpenAI technology and RetrievalAugmented Generation to source answers strictly from verified, plainlanguage Canadian legal materials. The chatbot’s owners developed a 42-question testing dataset to help improve Beagle+’s accuracy and helpfulness, then published that dataset to help other owners test their legal technology tools.171 Beagle+ has 99 percent accuracy.172 However, state UPL rules may apply when a technology is deemed to cross traditional lines between “legal information” and “legal advice.” To mitigate the chilling effects of multiple recent UPL lawsuits on legal technology innovation, states are beginning to explore ways to stimulate investment in innovation by offering legal technology tool developers protection from UPL prosecution while also ensuring robust oversight of the tools to protect

consumers and maintain the integrity of the legal profession. NCSC urges states to responsibly embrace legal technology: “The growing access-tojustice crisis coupled with the rapid pace of AI innovation creates a unique opportunity for state courts and bar associations to meet the moment by adopting regulatory reforms that support AI-fueled legal service delivery tools to responsibly assist with legal needs.”175 The late L. Karl Branting, a Chief Scientist of Machine Learning for Computational Law at the MITRE Corporation and President of the International Association for Artificial Intelligence and Law, framed legal technology tools as scalable public goods. Branting maintained that: There are two primary motivations for developing AI systems in response to the access-to-justice crisis: (1) fairness and (2) social costs…AI systems that handle common legal tasks can alleviate the wasteful, duplicative effort by numerous individuals struggling with the same problems. A single investment in a system to automate the rules and procedures for common legal situations could relieve this redundancy, reducing the aggregate social costs of the civil legal system. From this perspective, AI systems for unrepresented litigants can be viewed as public goods, like roads, schools, and courthouses, whose costs and benefits are shared by all.176

Los Angeles County Superior Court’s multilingual (6 languages) AI-powered virtual traffic assistant, “Gina,” helps 4,000 customers per week handle their traffic citations online, without the need to travel to the courthouse, wait in long lines, and take up clerk time. Tens of thousands of Angelenos use the avatar every year to pay a traffic ticket, register for traffic school, or schedule a court date. The Superior Court handles 1.2 million new traffic citations annually. Before Gina, people waited an average of 3.5 hours to see a clerk for their traffic matter. Gina (combined with the overhaul of the court’s online traffic court program) has reduced typical wait times to 8-12 minutes. The court invested approximately 240 programming hours to create Gina using the SitePal software, and paid an additional $40,000 in one-time costs that included translation services and other services related to website enhancements. Gina costs $2,499 per year to run.173

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

30


THE SOLUTION

NCSC categorizes three distinct regulatory approaches to modernizing UPL rules to authorize legal technology.177 A handful of U.S. states have already implemented, authorized, or formally proposed versions of these different regulatory frameworks for legal technology tools.

National Center for State Courts and Thompson Reuters Institute178

31


EXAMPLES OF PATH ONE: COLORADO Colorado is an example of a state that is pursuing what NCSC describes as Path One. In July 2023, the Colorado Supreme Court tasked an AI Subcommittee of the Advisory Committee on the Practice of Law with evaluating the state’s UPL Rules and considering whether to recommend AI-related amendments.180 In a January 18, 2024 letter, Colorado’s Access to Justice Commission asked the Colorado Supreme Court to consider revising the state’s UPL rules “to determine if revisions should be made to accommodate technological advances that will impact the practice of law and access to justice.”181 In the meantime, Colorado’s Office of Attorney Regulation Counsel (OARC) adopted a pilot non-prosecution policy regarding UPL deprioritizing enforcement against certain legal-tech and AI tools designed to expand access to justice.182

TEXAS Texas offers another example of Path One. Texas’ UPL statute explicitly excludes from its definition of the practice of law “the design, creation, publication, distribution, display, or sale, including by means of an Internet web site, of written materials, books, forms,

“[O]verreacting to the challenges of AI by imposing an overly narrow reading of the UPL Rules could stifle the development of AI tools that would benefit litigants who cannot afford a lawyer.”179 –Colorado Supreme Court Justice Maria E. Berkenkotter and Colorado Appeals Court Judge Lino S. Lipinsky de Orlo

computer software, or similar products if the products clearly and conspicuously state that the products are not a substitute for the advice of an attorney.”183 Interestingly, this statute does not, on its face, limit itself to “interactive document completion platforms” or companies providing legal information via software. INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

32


THE SOLUTION

“The access to justice crisis will not be solved by maintaining outdated restrictions on who can provide vital assistance to those most in need . . . [M]odernizing UPL regulations is a critical first step, demonstrating that protecting the public and fostering innovation are not mutually exclusive goals, but rather convergent paths toward a more equitable legal system.”184 –National Center for State Courts

EXAMPLES OF PATH TWO: UTAH Utah provides an example of what NCSC describes as Path Two. The Utah Supreme Court used a Standing Order to establish a regulatory sandbox that authorizes certain ALPs and software to provide legal services. Initially administered by the Utah Office of Legal Services Innovation185 and later by the Utah State Bar,186 Utah’s Legal Services Sandbox187 deploys a risk-based regulatory framework under which each participating technology company’s business model is assessed and monitored based on its risk profile. Each entity is assigned a risk level of low, moderate, or high depending upon the extent to which the entity’s business model deviates from the traditional lawyer-provided legal services model. A technology company with a high-risk profile must submit to heightened pre-launch assessments, data reporting requirements, and audits. Lower-risk entities in Utah’s sandbox are also required to submit some data so that regulators can monitor for evidence and patterns of consumer harm. Utah’s regulatory sandbox is a seven-year pilot project scheduled to sunset in August 2027, at which point regulators will assess program data to inform permanent rule changes, if any.188 33

In 2022, the Deborah L. Rhode Center at Stanford Law School published “Legal Innovation After Reform: Evidence from Regulatory Change,” reporting the results of the first empirical study of Utah’s changes, and in 2025 the Center published a follow-up study titled, “Legal Innovation After Reform: Five Years of Data.”189 The first study found diverse, consumer-focused innovations entering Utah’s market to the benefit of individuals and underserved communities.190 The follow-up study found that: • Reforms continue to spur innovation across law firms, tech companies, and intermediaries. • Utah’s sandbox supports mixed teams of lawyers, nonlawyers, and software. • Lawyers remain central, countering concerns about diminished professional roles. • Technology and alternative pricing models help reach individuals and small businesses. • Consumer harm remains minimal.191 The follow-up study found that, since 2022, Utah had limited eligibility criteria, sharply reducing the number of authorized sandbox participants from


39 to 11 entities.192 The study also noted that Utah was confronting emerging new challenges associated with the continuing advancement of generative AI and its use to deliver legal services.193

WASHINGTON Washington’s nascent Entity Regulation Pilot Project presents another example of Path Two. In December 2024, the Washington Supreme Court through Order 25700-B-721 delegated authority to the Washington State Bar Association (WSBA) and the state’s Practice of Law Board to run a timebound (10-year) Entity Regulation Pilot Project.195 Previously, the Court only authorized persons to practice law. Under the pilot project, entities— businesses or nonprofit organizations—may seek the Court’s authorization to use legal technology tools or other nonlawyer resources to provide civil legal services under carefully-monitored conditions.196 For the first time, entities with innovative business models (including those operated by individuals not licensed to practice law) can apply to offer legal services under timebound, limited exemptions from the otherwise applicable rules governing the practice of law.197 The purpose of the pilot is to allow the jurisdiction to assess the new services’ quality and safety for the public, and whether they actually improve access to justice.198 “Participating entities will be required to abide by a Supreme Court authorizing order detailing conditions on their participation,” says the WSBA, “including adherence to rules of ethics and regular reporting of data and information relating to their delivery of services to the public.”199 Each applicant will propose a hypothesis about a particular regulatory reform and a corresponding study (or data model) to test that reform. The Entity Regulation Pilot Program began accepting applications in late 2025 for its first cohort of beta-testers. Real-time data collection, monitoring, and active oversight will determine whether the new business and technology models safely increase access to justice, and inform the Court’s decision about whether to move forward with more permanent regulatory reforms at the pilot’s conclusion.

“We have a few options. One is to hunker down and try and use the same regulatory model that’s been in place for 125 years. Another is to create carefullycontrolled conditions to understand how these emerging technologies and these innovations . . . can benefit consumers and . . . work well with the legal community . . . The do-nothing model is bound to be the most risky and the most harmful for legal practitioners as well as the public.”194 –Craig Shank, Board Member, Practice of Law Board, Washington State Supreme Court

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

34


THE SOLUTION

“On one hand, artificial intelligence offers unprecedented opportunities to expand legal services and reach underserved communities that often simply lack access to legal representation. On the other, we must ensure that these tools are reliable, and do not expose individuals to unnecessary risks or our courts to frivolous or inaccurate filings.”200 –Tom Pack, President, Minnesota State Bar Association

MINNESOTA Minnesota’s recently-proposed technology-focused regulatory sandbox offers a third example of Path Two. The Minnesota State Bar Association’s Artificial Intelligence Committee recently issued a comprehensive report recommending that Minnesota’s Supreme Court establish an Access to Justice Legal Sandbox to enable professionals without a law license to create, test, and refine generative AI-driven legal assistance tools within a controlled regulatory environment without fear of UPL prosecution.201 Minnesota State Bar Association President, Tom Pack, says: In its work on this report, the [Michigan State Bar Association] is not only responding to technological change; we are shaping how it happens and how it fits into our state’s legal regulatory framework, guided by our values of 35

access, fairness, and protection of lawyers, the public, and the judicial system.202 The report recommends that eligible large-languagemodel (LLM) tools be required to meet strict standards for accuracy, privacy, and consumer protection and submit to the supervision of an AI Legal Services Board housed in Minnesota’s Judicial Branch.203 Composed of multidisciplinary experts including a representative of Minnesota’s Attorney General’s Office, the AI Legal Services Board would manage applications to the sandbox, oversee rigorous testing protocols, and continuously monitor approved tools for effectiveness and consumer safety.204 The recommendations call for a clear application process, evaluation rubric, and consumer protection guidance to promote transparency, and underscore the importance of ongoing oversight, including systems for complaint intake, data security audits, and public reporting.


EXAMPLE OF PATH THREE: ALASKA NCSC’s Path Three builds on Alaska’s approach to UPL, which ties UPL to representing oneself to be an attorney, focusing the definition of UPL on human actors providing services to another person. UPL liability is triggered only if one both represents oneself to be an attorney and either represents another in court/ tribunal (including by submitting legal pleadings) or for compensation gives advice or prepares documents for another affecting legal rights or duties.205 This approach to UPL enforcement focuses on preventing misrepresentation of attorney status rather than on prohibiting nonlawyer legal assistance activities.206 Theoretically, a person could provide legal advice for compensation without committing UPL as long as that person does not represent themself to be an attorney.207 And, a technology tool could offer legal assistance and services outside the courtroom, so long as the tool unequivocally and prominently discloses that the service provided by the technology is not conducted by an attorney.208 Thoughtfully-regulated, AI-powered legal technology tools have tremendous potential to leverage other legal service tiers by helping SRLs resolve civil legal problems that are amenable to and appropriate for machine help, freeing up human legal helpers to assist other people with complex cases and matters that require human intervention.

“As new forms of legal services proliferate, jurisdictions around the country are reconsidering how they regulate the practice of law, including by permitting people and things that are not lawyers to provide legal advice and other kinds of legal services . . . The body of research is clear: there is demand for legal advice and other services from nonlawyer providers, and such providers can produce services that are as good as or better than those of attorneys. If regulating the practice of law is to be guided by honest concerns for consumer protection, there is much more scope for nonlawyers to practice law safely and effectively than is permitted by the current rules.”209 –Rebecca L. Sandefur, Co-Founder and Co-Chair, Frontline Justice

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

36


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

IV. The Recommendations “[E]qual justice for all is fundamental to our system of government . . . [T]his promise of equal justice under law is not realized for individuals and families who have no meaningful access to the justice system . . . [T]his de facto denial of equal justice has an adverse impact on these individuals, families, and society as a whole, and works to erode public trust and confidence in our system of justice . . . [T]he Judicial Branch, in our constitutional structure, shoulders primary leadership responsibility to preserve and protect equal justice and take action necessary to ensure access to the justice system for those who face impediments they are unable to surmount on their own.”210 –Conference of Chief Justices 37

The Innovations in Tiered Legal Services Task Force submits the following six recommendations for consideration by the Supreme Court of Maryland.

RECOMMENDATION 1 ESTABLISH A

COMMUNITY JUSTICE WORKER TIER The Judiciary amends Maryland’s UPL Rule to authorize a Community Justice Worker Tier, through which qualified individuals may obtain a formal exemption from the UPL Rule to provide legal assistance and representation to low-income Marylanders with attorney oversight. Maryland community justice workers are volunteers or employees trained and housed at community-based or civil legal aid organizations or in government agencies. They work under the client income eligibility restrictions of their host organization(s) and/or the host’s civil legal aid organization partner, if any, and do not charge clients a fee. Community justice workers help increase trust in Maryland’s civil legal system by serving as a bridge between legal institutions and the people they serve. They provide accessible guidance, explain legal processes in plain language, and connect people with resources and support. By building relationships within communities, especially those that may feel overlooked or marginalized, community justice workers promote fairness, transparency, and accountability, helping people feel more confident that Maryland’s legal system can work for them.


Practice Areas Community justice workers should be authorized to practice in any civil law practice area(s) for which they have successfully completed the requisite community justice worker training and certification, and in which their Host Organization has authorized them to practice.211

Scope of Work Community justice workers should be authorized to provide, with attorney oversight, all levels of legal assistance except cases involving presentation of complex evidence to the court or complex litigation. Upon studying feedback from Maryland stakeholders, the Innovations Task Force gleaned that what initially presented as resistance to authorizing community justice workers to practice in certain law practice areas was, upon closer examination, actually resistance to them performing complex litigation and presentation of complex evidence within those practice areas.212 Consequently, the Innovations Task Force adjusted its recommendations to exclude case types that involve complex litigation and/or presentation of complex evidence, instead of excluding any law practice areas. The Innovations Task Force determined that community justice worker Host Organizations, in consultation with the community justice worker and the supervising attorney, are best situated to determine, on a case-by-case basis, in which cases or matters the presentation of evidence or litigation are too complex to be handled by the community justice worker. Some examples of legal tasks that community justice workers should be authorized to perform include, but are not limited to:

• Legal counseling; • Filling out legal forms; • Preparing legal documents; • Representing clients in mediation processings; • Obtaining written consent from clients; • Reviewing documents from the opposing party; • Communicating with the opposing party; • Representing clients at settlement conferences and other pre-trial conferences; • Providing legal advice; • Preparing, signing, and filing legal pleadings and documents; • And, in certain, limited cases or matters, in-court representation.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

38


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

The following are examples of some of the kinds of high-needs legal services the Innovations Task Force envisions community justice workers providing: LEGAL PRACTICE AREA

ANTICIPATED SERVICES

Consumer and Medical Debt

Counseling, negotiation with creditors, representation in court for affidavit judgment cases not involving presentation of evidence or complex litigation

Landlord/Tenant

Representation in court for failure to pay rent in District Court

Life Planning Documents (wills, powers of attorney, advance medical directives)

Preparation of documents, counseling

Protective orders

Counseling, preparation of documents, representation in court

Public benefits (SNAP, TCA, medical assistance, disability)

Counseling, preparation of documents, representation in court and administrative proceedings*

Criminal record expungement

Counseling, preparation and filing of petitions, representation in court

Family law

Counseling and document preparation

Guardianship in Special Immigrant Juvenile Status (SIJS) cases

Counseling, preparation and filing of petitions, and representation in the local Circuit Court for the pre-requisite Predicate Order

Standby Guardianship (for children of parents at risk of deportation/removal)

Counseling and document preparation

*Non-attorney representatives are already permitted to serve as authorized representatives during hearings before Maryland’s Office of Administrative Hearings, though there remains substantial unmet need. Community justice workers will expand the reach of legal help to the Judiciary.

Regulatory Requirements

Confidentiality, Privilege, and Privacy

Community justice workers should be required to abide by the Maryland Rules of Professional Conduct applicable to licensed attorneys, and be prohibited from holding themselves out to be attorneys.

The community justice worker-client relationship should be subject to confidentiality, privilege, and privacy. Those same protections should extend to the relationship between a community justice worker’s client and that community justice worker’s supervising attorney.

39


Eligibility A community justice worker applicant must satisfy all of the following conditions and qualifications: • Be a minimum of 18 years of age. • Hold a High School Diploma or equivalent (i.e., GED). • Have completed the National Community Justice Worker Core Training Curriculum. • Have completed substantive specialized training in the area(s) of Maryland law for which they will be providing services. • Have completed practical/ experiential training under the oversight of an attorney.

Host Organization provides domestic violence services, their policy would exclude a community justice worker with a conviction for a domestic violence offense. Each Host Organization’s written policy should also be responsive to the specific language-access needs of its service population, and include provisions to ensure that any limited- or non-English-speaking community justice workers are provided the language-specific training, interpreter and translator resources, and support they need to effectively serve their clients and interact with relevant courts and agencies.

• Have not been disbarred or suspended from the practice of law in Maryland or in another jurisdiction. When an applicant satisfies all of these requirements, the Community Justice Worker Advisory Board will review their application and certify the individual, allowing them to provide legal services through a Host Organization(s).

Language Access and Criminal History The Innovations Task Force recommends allowing individuals with limited or no English proficiency and persons with eligible criminal histories to become community justice workers. Stakeholder feedback overwhelmingly indicated that community justice workers’ shared experiences and membership in the ethnic, cultural, linguistic, and socio-economic communities they serve are foundational to the effectiveness of the community justice worker model. To prevent consumer harm, we recommend that each Host Organization be required to develop a written policy that includes criminal history screening and is narrowly tailored so that excludable offenses are directly relevant to each Host Organization’s community justice workers’ unique clientele, case types, and law practice areas. For example, if a

Training Community justice worker training should include (1) the standardized training modules developed by the National Community Justice Worker Task Force, and (2) training modules on the Maryland-specific substantive law practice area(s) in which they seek certification. Advanced training modules should be developed for community justice workers seeking to provide higher levels of service. Maryland’s community college system is an ideal home for the state’s community justice worker training program, given its extensive statewide network, capacity for remote instruction, and strength in adult education. The Innovations Task Force recommends that the training consist of a combination of self-guided live or online education and hands-on, practical experience.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

40


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

In order to engender a sense of community across providers and a standard of excellence in service, the Innovations Task Force recommends that all community justice workers be required to complete an annual, inperson update training to maintain active certification. This annual update training will provide community justice workers a vital opportunity for connection and support, information about recent changes to the law, and a feedback loop to promote continuous improvement across the tier.

Host Organizations We recommend that every community justice worker be required to be either a volunteer or an employee of a formally-recognized Host Organization. Civil legal aid organizations, community-based organizations, or even government agencies may become Host Organizations. To become formally “recognized” as a Host Organization, interested organizations will apply to the Community Justice Worker Advisory Board and must satisfy all of the following requirements: • Demonstrate knowledge of the community they serve. •

Determine a scope of work to address the civil legal issues their community faces.

• Articulate a Community Justice Worker Training Plan that meets the legal needs of the unique community they serve and meets or exceeds the requirements established by the Community Justice Worker Advisory Board. • Demonstrate that their community justice workers will be covered by professional liability insurance. • Demonstrate they have the capacity to supervise and support community justice workers. • Demonstrate how they will provide attorney oversight for community justice workers, either from within the organization or through an M.O.U. with a law firm, an attorney, or other organization that employs a licensed attorney(s) in good standing who commit to provide that oversight. 41

Portability Once certified, community justice workers should be permitted to move between Host Organizations (change employers) over the course of their careers without undue burden. Community justice workers should be permitted to serve more than one Host Organization concurrently, so long as all requirements are satisfied with respect to each Host.

Access to Courts Feedback from Maryland’s existing ALPs and from ALPs in other states identified a lack of access to client files and e-filing as ongoing problems, exacerbated by lack of awareness among judges and attorneys about community justice workers and their broad authorized scope of work. In order to do their jobs effectively, community justice workers require the same, unfettered access to e-filing and remote access (e.g., via the Maryland Electronic Courts or “MDEC” system213) to their clients’ court and agency files as attorneys have. The Innovations Task Force recommends that the Supreme Court of Maryland establish a protocol for assigning community justice workers a unique identifier (comparable to an attorney’s bar license number) that identifies both the individual and the specific type of ALP involved, to be used on legal pleadings and in court and agency records. The Task Force also recommends that court forms be updated to include “community justice worker” in fields previously intended only for attorneys. These actions will also help facilitate strong data practices and CJW Program evaluations.

Advisory Board The recommended Rule change will establish a Community Justice Worker Advisory Board (hereinafter “CJW Advisory Board”) to administer and oversee Maryland’s Community Justice Worker Program. The CJW Advisory Board’s roles and responsibilities should include reviewing applications, certifying community justice workers and formally recognizing host organizations; ensuring the Court’s Innovation Office has, at all times, a current roster of certified community justice workers and recognized hosts; approving a statewide Community Justice Worker Training


Curriculum; conducting periodic community engagement; and establishing a statewide Community Justice Worker Network (community of practice). Due to the volume of tasks delegated to the CJW Advisory Board, we recommend that the Board be staffed and not rely solely on volunteer members. The CJW Advisory Board should include, at a minimum, a representative of the following entities: Maryland Supreme Court, Maryland State Bar Association, Maryland Access to Justice Commission, a civil legal services organization, a Maryland community college, a certified community justice worker, a recognized host organization, and a member of the public at large who would qualify as eligible for community justice worker services. The Innovations Task Force encourages the CJW Advisory Board, when standing up a Maryland Community Justice Worker Program, to consult national resources collaboratively developed by Innovation for Justice (i4J) and Community Justice Advocates of Utah (CJAU) that include: Part 1: A Justice Worker Program Implementation Toolkit; Part 2: A U.S. Community Legal Education Toolkit; and, Part 3: A Power-Conscious Justice Work Toolkit. The CJW Advisory Board should report to the Supreme Court of Maryland’s Innovation Office annually on the progress and impact of the Community Justice Worker Program.

Ensuring Community Justice Workers Serve the Intended Population Community justice workers are bound by the client income/asset eligibility restrictions of their host organizations and/or the hosts’ civil legal aid organization partners (if any), and do not charge these low-income clients any fee. Draft regulatory language for the Community Justice Worker Tier, developed by the Community Justice Worker Committee of the Innovations in Tiered Legal Services Task Force, is attached in Appendix E.

By building community relationships, offering accessible guidance, and connecting people to resources and support, community justice workers help people feel more confident navigating Maryland’s civil legal system.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

42


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

RECOMMENDATION 2 ESTABLISH A

LEGAL PRACTITIONER TIER The Judiciary amends Maryland’s UPL Rule to authorize a Legal Practitioner Tier through which qualified individuals may obtain a license to provide legal advice and representation in court-specified, high-need areas of law without engaging in UPL. The purpose behind the Legal Practitioner Tier is to offer affordable civil legal services primarily to Maryland’s ALICE population (who do not qualify for free legal aid but also cannot afford to hire an attorney at market rate).

Practice Areas Licensed legal practitioners can become certified to provide legal advice and representation in one or more Court-designated civil law practice areas.214 While the Innovations Task Force defers to the Court to determine which civil law practice areas to include in a Maryland Legal Practitioner Program, we have identified the following as high-needs practice areas and case types that are particularly amenable to handling by legal practitioners: • Housing (landlord/tenant cases) • Expungement (criminal/juvenile records) • Family Law

Scope of Work Legal practitioners can perform the same functions as attorneys, strictly within their law practice area(s) of certification. Examples of authorized tasks include (but are not limited to): • Providing legal counseling; • Assisting clients to fill out legal forms;

• Consumer Debt

• Representing clients in mediation proceedings;

• Medical Debt

•

• Domestic Violence (protection orders) • Bankruptcy • Student Loan Debt • Guardianship (including standby guardianship for children of parents facing risk of deportation/removal and predicate orders from the circuit court granting guardianship in Special Immigrant Juvenile Status cases) 43

Public Benefits and Administrative Law were also identified, however, those areas are already exempted from UPL for ALPs under existing Maryland statutes. The above-listed practice areas are ones in which many low-income Marylanders need legal assistance each year, a need not currently being met by attorneys. These types of civil cases and matters, if not properly resolved, often have a negative cascading effect on the lives of litigants and their children, households, and communities. It is not the Innovation Task Force’s intent to suggest the Court limit legal practitioners to the above-listed practice areas, but rather we offer these as areas highly suitable for Maryland’s Legal Practitioner Tier. Notably, accelerating provision of new practice areas was one of only nine recommendations for improvement flowing from Washington’s LLLT program evaluation.215 The Innovations Task Force recommends the Court take a phased approach to implementing the Legal Practitioner Tier by initially authorizing a discrete number of practice areas and case types, allowing for assessment, evaluation and refinement, then gradually introducing (authorizing) additional practice areas and case types.

Obtaining written consent from clients; reviewing documents from the opposing party;

• Communicating with the opposing party; • Representing clients at settlement conferences and other pre-trial conferences; • Providing legal advice; • Preparing, signing, and filing legal pleadings and documents; • Issuing a subpoena; and, • Representing clients at depositions.


A legal practitioner will also be permitted to provide in-court representation upon satisfaction of additional requirements that include performing attorney-supervised client representation in a minimum of five contested, heard-and-not-settled, in-court proceedings. Notably, expanding the scope of work to include court appearances was one of only nine recommendations for improvement put forth in Washington’s LLLT program evaluation.216

Independent Practice Once a newly-licensed legal practitioner completes 1,000 hours of legal practice under attorney supervision, they are permitted to hang a shingle and practice independently within the law practice area(s) in which they are certified.

Additional Requirements Financial Safeguards and Consumer Protection To ensure robust consumer protection, legal practitioners are subject to the same strict financial regulations as Maryland-licensed attorneys. Specifically, legal practitioners shall be required to safeguard client funds, prevent the commingling of assets, and participate in the Interest on Lawyers’ Trust Accounts (IOLTA) Program. They must contribute to the Client Protection Fund of Maryland, thereby granting their clients full eligibility to benefit from the fund if necessary. These measures directly reflect stakeholder feedback urging these consumer protections for a tier that allows for independent legal practice without attorney supervision. Pro Bono Reporting

Firm Ownership and Fee-Sharing In order to be able to hang a shingle and practice independently, a legal practitioner should be permitted to hold either a controlling or a noncontrolling equity interest in a legal practitioner firm. However, a legal practitioner should be permitted to hold only a non-controlling equity interest in a law firm. Legal practitioners should be permitted to share fees with attorneys and with other legal practitioners.

The Innovations Task Force recommends that legal practitioners be required to report annually on their pro bono service. While stakeholders noted that many legal practitioners already serve low-income Marylanders full-time, the Task Force emphasizes that this mandate—mirroring the current requirement for attorneys—stipulates the reporting of pro bono hours, not mandatory service. The value of collecting comprehensive, statewide pro bono data across all legal service tiers outweighs the minimal administrative burden of reporting.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

44


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

Education Track To apply to become a legal practitioner under the Education Track, an applicant should be required to satisfy all requirements of one of the following pathways, each of which combines education and substantive, law-related experience. PATHWAY 1: Hold an Associate-level degree

Ethics and Professional Responsibility To maintain the integrity of Maryland’s legal system, legal practitioners shall be bound by the same Code of Ethics and Rules of Professional Responsibility that govern Maryland-licensed attorneys. Alignment on Continuing Education and Malpractice Insurance The Innovations Task Force evaluated stakeholder feedback advocating for mandatory continuing legal education (CLE) and compulsory malpractice insurance for legal practitioners. However, the Task Force concluded that these mandates should apply to legal practitioners if and only if Maryland elects to impose them on attorneys. Discipline Maryland’s Attorney Grievance Commission will handle legal practitioner discipline and license revocation/suspension, and will integrate legal practitioners into their existing reporting to include both legal practitioners and attorneys.

Confidentiality, Privilege, and Privacy The legal practitioner-client relationship is subject to confidentiality, privilege, and privacy. Those same protections extend to the relationship between a legal practitioner’s client and that legal practitioner’s supervising attorney (if any).

Eligibility In order to ensure this tier remains broadly accessible as a career path, there should be two tracks available to individuals seeking a legal practitioner license in Maryland—an Education Track and an Experiential Track. 45

in Paralegal Studies from a U.S. regionallyaccredited college or university and complete 1,500 hours of substantive, law-related work experience in each practice area in which the applicant wishes to become certified, performed within the three years immediately preceding application. If the Paralegal Studies degree is completed at an ABA-approved paralegal program, then only 1,000 hours of substantive, law-related work experience will be required, performed within the two years immediately preceding application.

PATHWAY 2: Hold a Bachelor’s degree from a

U.S. regionally-accredited college or university and complete 1,500 hours of substantive, law-related work experience in each practice area in which the applicant wishes to become certified, performed within the three years immediately preceding application.

PATHWAY 3: Hold a Master of Laws (LL.M.) degree from a U.S. regionally-accredited university and complete 500 hours of substantive, law-related work experience in each law practice area in which the applicant wishes to become certified, performed within the three years immediately preceding application.

PATHWAY 4: Hold a Juris Doctor degree from

an ABA-approved law school and complete 500 hours of substantive, law-related work experience in each law practice area in which the applicant wishes to become certified, performed within the three years immediately preceding application.


For all Education Track applicants, regardless of Pathway, at least 500 of the applicant’s total required substantive, law-related work experience hours shall be on Maryland-specific law for each law practice area in which the applicant seeks certification. Notably, this requirement – that a dedicated subset of the experience hours be in the specific practice area – was one of only nine recommendations for improvement flowing from Washington’s LLLT program evaluation.217 A supervising attorney(s) must attest to the applicant’s satisfaction of the experiential requirements. Experiential Track There is no higher education requirement for legal practitioner applicants under the Experiential Track. An Experiential Track applicant is required to complete seven years of prior substantive, lawrelated work experience, including 1,500 hours within the last 3 years for each law practice area in which the applicant seeks certification (500 of those 1,500 experiential hours must be on Maryland-specific law). All experience must be attested to by a supervising attorney(s) (with an active license in good standing). The Innovations Task Force considered stakeholder feedback suggesting that the seven years experiential requirement is onerous in light of the guiding principle that this new legal service tier should remain highly accessible as a career pathway to persons who did not have the opportunity to pursue higher education. However, the Task Force concluded that this requirement, which aligns with industry credentialing requirements such as the Paralegal Advanced Competency Exam (PACE), is necessary to protect consumers by ensuring legal practitioners are adequately prepared for independent practice.

Examination

Character and Fitness Applicants for a legal practitioner license will be evaluated for character and fitness to practice law using a form substantially similar to the Character Questionnaire Maryland uses to evaluate attorney applicants. All applicants must be legally authorized to work in the United States in order to practice.218

Individuals seeking to become a Maryland-licensed legal practitioner will also be required to successfully pass a two-part Examination. Part I of the Exam will test the applicant on the fundamentals of law practice in Maryland, and consist of 100 multiplechoice questions administered over a two-hour session. Topics will include legal ethics, jurisdiction, legal terminology, relevant Court rules and statutes, client communication, document/pleading preparation, and professional and administrative responsibilities. Part II of the Exam will be a substantive law test consisting of 50 multiple-choice questions on each law practice area in which the applicant seeks to become certified. The Innovations Task Force recommends using existing institutions to fulfill different aspects of implementation. The Maryland’s State Board of Law Examiners should be charged with consulting with subject matter experts on the creation and maintenance of the Legal Practitioner Exam. We recommend that the Exam be administered in a Board-approved format

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

46


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

and at approved testing locations within the state of Maryland. We also recommend that applicants be required to attain a 70 percent or higher score on each part of the Exam in order to pass. If an applicant successfully obtains a passing score on the foundational part of the Exam, but is not successful on the substantive law part of the Exam, that applicant should only be required to retake the substantive part of the Exam. Passage of both parts of the Exam should be completed within two years after the date of submission of an application for a legal practitioner license.

Training Curriculum A Legal Practitioner Advisory Board will oversee the development of and have final approval over a comprehensive Legal Practitioner Curriculum that aligns with the Exam. Designed to prepare individuals for practice and to pass the Legal Practitioner Exam, the Legal Practitioner Curriculum should include both the foundational component and each Marylandspecific substantive law component covered in the Legal Practitioner Exam, standardizing learning objectives and core competencies statewide. To take advantage of existing institutional competencies, Maryland’s community colleges are best suited to offer the Legal Practitioner Curriculum as a non-credit course, at a nominal cost, in virtual and/or hybrid format.219

Access to Courts In order to do their jobs effectively, legal practitioners require the same, unfettered access to e-filing and remote (e.g., the Maryland Electronic Courts or “MDEC” system220) access to their clients’ court and agency files as attorneys have. The Innovations Task Force recommends that the Supreme Court of Maryland establish a protocol for assigning legal

47

practitioners a unique identifier (comparable to an attorney’s bar license number) that identifies both the individual and the specific type of ALP involved, to be used on legal pleadings and in court and agency records. The Task Force also recommends that court forms be updated to include “legal practitioner” in fields currently intended only for attorneys. These actions will also help facilitate strong data practices, Legal Practitioner Program evaluation, and legal practitioner licensure and discipline. Feedback from Maryland’s existing ALPs and from legal practitioners in other states identified a lack of access to client files and e-filing as ongoing problems, exacerbated by lack of awareness among judges and attorneys about legal practitioners and their broad authorized scope of work.


Advisory Board A Legal Practitioner Advisory Board will oversee the implementation of the Legal Practitioner Tier in collaboration with the Court’s Innovation Office. The Legal Practitioner Advisory Board shall consist of the following members, including but not limited to a legal practitioner(s) in good standing; a Circuit Court Judge; a District Court Judge; a designee of the Administrative Office of the Courts; a Marylandlicensed attorney (active and in good standing); a legal educator(s); a designee of the State Board of Law Examiners; a designee of the Grievance Commission; a designee of the Judiciary; a designee of the Maryland State Bar Association; a designee of the Maryland Access to Justice Commission; a public member(s) (lay persons in the eligible population with relevant lived experience); and other person(s) with a stake in the Legal Practitioner Program’s success. The Legal Practitioner Advisory Board will report annually on the Legal Practitioner Program to the Court’s Innovation Office. The Legal Practitioner Report will include, at a minimum, the number of applications granted and declined during the previous calendar year; the number of licensed legal practitioners as of the previous calendar year; the number and nature of charges filed against legal practitioners during the previous calendar year; the number and nature of complaints initiated by the state bar during the previous calendar year; discipline imposed during the previous calendar year, if any, the nature of the conduct resulting in discipline, and the discipline imposed; and recommendations concerning program modifications or improvements.

Ensuring Legal Practitioners Serve the Intended Population Because legal practitioners can charge a fee for their services, ensuring that this tier actually addresses Maryland’s access-to-justice gap by serving the intended (ALICE) population was a recurring theme of stakeholder feedback. Some stakeholders suggested that legal practitioners only embed in legal-service-providing organizations, or conduct complex income and asset screening at client intake, or observe a rigid fee schedule. The Innovations Task Force carefully considered this feedback but ultimately concluded that antitrust considerations

The Legal Practitioner Tier is intentionally designed to serve the unmet needs of Maryland’s ALICE population who, by definition, cannot meet their household’s basic expenses, much less afford to hire an attorney at market rate.

associated with price restraints and the guiding principle of striving for equity across legal service tiers and professionals preclude these approaches. The Task Force notes that carefully-crafted authorizing regulation could help ensure that legal practitioners serve ALICE households by limiting the types of cases or matters a legal practitioner can handle within any given authorized law practice area. However, the Task Force cautions that the Court should consider such limitations holistically. For example, by limiting Family Law practice to lowassets cases, the regulations could unintentionally prevent a domestic violence victim—who is married to a batterer whose income and assets are well above the ALICE threshold but who lacks any access to or control over family assets—from getting vital legal help. Maryland’s legal practitioner rates will be market based, similar to other states’ legal practitioner programs that operate outside a regulatory sandbox.221 Draft regulatory language for the Legal Practitioner Tier, developed by the Legal Practitioner Scope and Education Committees of the Innovations in Tiered Legal Services Task Force, is attached in Appendix F.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

48


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

RECOMMENDATION 3 ESTABLISH A

LEGAL TECHNOLOGY TIER The Judiciary amends Maryland’s UPL Rule to authorize a Legal Technology Tier, through which owners of legal technology tools, including AI-powered tools, may apply for a formal UPL exemption to allow the tool to provide civil legal services directly to SRLs. Maryland’s current UPL Rule simultaneously disincentivizes legal technology investment and innovation and lacks concrete protections against potential harms resulting from consumers’ direct use of technology tools. Key stakeholder concerns about this tier—including ensuring tools’ accuracy, ensuring the quality of legal services provided by the tools, and mitigating potential consumer harms—were central to our deliberations regarding whether to recommend a Legal Technology Tier. Ultimately, the Legal Technology Committee and the Innovations Task Force decisively concluded that vetted, regulated, legal technology tools are more helpful than harmful to SRLs, who would otherwise receive no legal help at all. In order to stimulate investment and innovation in business-to-consumer legal technology tools that promote access to justice, while simultaneously regulating the tools for consumers’ protection, the Innovations Task Force proposes the following framework for establishing and administering a Legal Technology Tier in Maryland. While legal technology tools’ multi-modality holds tremendous promise for creating efficiencies, streamlining processes, and improving service delivery across all of Maryland’s legal service tiers, the primary focus of the Innovations Task Force’s recommendations is on business-toconsumer tools. Business-to-consumer tools can effectively help a large number of SRLs resolve relatively simple civil legal problems, freeing up attorneys and ALPs to focus on more complex cases that are not amenable to or appropriate for machine help. Because they are utilized without the supervision of a licensed or certified legal professional, business-to-consumer tools present the most urgent need for vetting and regulation and are the most likely target of UPL prosecution. 49

UPL Exemption The use of artificial intelligence (AI) and other technologies designed to provide legal information, assist in document preparation, analyze legal issues, or provide legal advice and assistance directly to consumers (i.e., SRLs) should not be considered the unauthorized practice of law (UPL) provided that all legal technology tool owners offering such services comply with a series of core requirements. Specifically, owners should be required to: • Register with the Court’s Innovation Office and pay registration fees before commencing operations in Maryland, and pay an annual renewal fee. • Demonstrate, in order to mitigate the risk of dispensing incorrect legal guidance, that the registered legal technology tool meets or exceeds the minimum required threshold when tested against relevant public benchmark datasets. • Demonstrate that the tool will advance access to justice (at the core of which is affordability). • Demonstrate that the tool prominently and clearly discloses that the legal service is being provided by a tool, and not by an attorney. • Implement reasonable measures to regularly test and validate the accuracy and reliability of the tool’s services. • Demonstrate that the tool will be accessible to Maryland populations with a high number of limited- and/or non-English speakers (i.e., incorporates language-access mechanisms). • Demonstrate that the tool will be accessible to deaf/hard-of-hearing and blind/sight-impaired consumers (e.g. incorporates assistive technologies). • Demonstrate that the tool is traumainformed in its design.


• Demonstrate that the tool screens for cases that require human legal assistance and notifies those users that their case is not a fit for unsupervised machine help and they should seek legal help via a different tier. • Maintain robust data security protocols to protect user privacy. • Establish a clear and accessible mechanism for users to report errors or inaccuracies. • Maintain records of all reasonable measures taken, and their results and provide those records and results to relevant regulator(s) upon request. • Provide documentation of a written policy designed to mitigate potential consumer risks posed by individuals with access to consumers’ personally identifiable information (PII) associated with the registered legal technology tool. The policy must identify any criminal convictions relevant to consumer protection associated with access to the authorized tool. Attest that the owner conducts regular screening of all individuals who could gain access to consumer data/PII associated with the tool, and does not employ individuals who fail to pass the criminal record screening in any role that would allow

them access to the consumer data/PII associated with the tool. • Comply with all applicable state and federal laws, including all relevant consumer protection laws. Because this tier focuses on business-to-consumer tools for SRLs, stakeholder feedback also emphasized the importance of ensuring authorized tools are broadly accessible, trauma-informed, and maintain humans in the loop. The Innovations Task Force determined that requiring legal technology entities to hire attorneys and directly integrate attorney supervision into their tools would chill innovation and investment and eviscerate the tier’s intent. We concluded that the better approach is to provide consumers a safe off-ramp by requiring tools to include a mechanism to screen and notify users with case types that are not appropriate for machine help and require human legal assistance. Some stakeholders questioned whether legal technology tool owners would be motivated to submit to regulation by registering their tools, given that owners of general technology tools (LLMs) are already flagrantly violating UPL rules with little resistance. The Innovations Task Force concluded that some recent UPL cases likely signal a coming policy shift toward enforcement and accountability that the smaller developers of legal technology tools are ill-equipped to weather.222 Given the opportunity, we believe that safe harbor protections against UPL prosecution will incentivize legal technology entities to register their tools. INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

50


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

Practice Area Maryland’s Legal Technology Tier should initially be limited to a single civil practice area: criminal records expungement.223 After the Legal Technology Tier is implemented, evaluated, and refined, the Maryland Supreme Court could then phase in authorization of additional, highneeds practice areas and case types. The Innovations Task Force selected criminal records expungement for the following reasons: • A clean record can facilitate an array of basic human needs (housing permanence, professional licensure, stable employment, education access, public benefits, etc.) deprivation of which often lead to other legal problems. • There is great need for legal help in this area—many Marylanders are currently eligible for but have not received criminal records expungement. • Expungement is an area in which logic models can produce legal advice with relatively high accuracy. • Presented with the facts and the law, there would be extremely low or no disagreement among attorneys about the correct course of action for any given expungement client. • Expungement is a practice area that is particularly amenable to benchmarking and testing. The Innovations Task Force also noted that Rasa Legal224, an Arizona Alternative Business Structure225, is using AI-powered technology and lawyers to handle expungement and record sealing matters, and the firm’s parent company, Rasa Public Benefit Corporation226, is a law company operating in Utah’s Legal Regulatory Sandbox. After careful consideration and consultation with numerous experts from other states and countries, our Legal Technology Committee members confidently concluded that a legal technology tool can competently guide SRLs through the expungement process with a high degree of accuracy, minimal risk of consumer harm, and a significant positive social impact. 51

“[M]odernization requires more than merely embracing technology and simplifying procedures . . . truly modern courts are user centered systems that prioritize openness, effectiveness, and equity.”235 –Pew Charitable Trusts

The Innovations Task Force considered stakeholder feedback indicating that, while criminal records expungement tends to be a low-risk practice area generally, it may not be low-risk for non-U.S.Citizens. State expungements are not recognized in the same way under the federal Immigration and Nationality Act (INA). Even if a state judge clears a non-U.S.-Citizen’s state criminal record, the federal government still considers that person to have a conviction for deportation/removal and visa purposes. If state criminal records are sealed or destroyed during expungement, it can be difficult to retrieve the certified court documentation of any conviction(s) required for certain immigration applications. Failure to disclose an expunged state criminal conviction on an immigration petition for legal permanent residency or citizenship can result in denial and permanent inadmissibility on the basis of fraud or false testimony. It is critical for noncitizens to consult with an experienced immigration attorney before seeking expungement of their state criminal records or clearing state charges. In response to these valid concerns, the Innovations Task Force recommends that business-to-consumer expungement tools be required to incorporate a mechanism to screen for cases that require human legal assistance (e.g., expungement cases involving a non-U.S.-Citizen) and notify those users that their case is not a fit for unsupervised machine help and they should seek help via a different legal service tier (e.g., consult an immigration law practitioner regarding the impact of expungement on their unique immigration case).


Regulatory Principles In developing its regulatory framework for the Legal Technology Tier, the Innovation Office in consultation with the Legal Technology Advisory Board will incorporate the following core regulatory principles: • The primary purposes of regulating business-to-consumer legal technology tools and exempting them from the unauthorized practice of law (UPL) are: to promote civil access to justice by ensuring that consumers have access to a well-developed, high-quality, innovative, affordable, and competitive market for legal services; and, to protect consumers from harm by business-toconsumer legal technology tools. • Regulation should be based on the evaluation of risk to the consumer (for example, the accuracy of a legal technology tool should be as good as the accuracy of an attorney giving advice on the same issue). • Regulation should establish probabilistic thresholds for acceptable levels of error. • Regulation should be empirically driven. • Regulation should be guided by a market-based approach to encourage innovation. The Legal Technology Tier should ground its implementing instrument(s) and framework in the human-first, AI-forward foundational principles for governing AI-powered legal technology developed by Nathan Chappell.227 These principles include anchoring in mission and values; mapping AI use-cases and risks; establishing oversight and accountability; preserving human oversight; embedding transparency and feedback loops; educating and empowering teams; and auditing, reporting, and refining.

“Automation, unchecked, can trade empathy for expedience. Algorithms can reinforce bias faster than we can detect it. Predictive tools can become prescriptive ones, subtly shifting the balance between serving people and sorting them. AI technology should amplify human flourishing, not replace it.”228 –Nathan Chappell, Chief AI Officer at Virtuous

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

52


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

Innovation Office The Court’s Innovation Office is responsible for carrying out the day-to-day activities necessary for the regulatory oversight of tools authorized to offer legal services in Maryland, and is imbued with the authority to develop and propose processes and procedures around licensing, monitoring, and enforcement to carry out its mission. Its responsibilities, with respect to the Legal Technology Tier, should include: • Administer and operate the regulation of legal technology tools, including intake of applications and registration of legal technology tools recommended for authorization by the Legal Technology Advisory Board; monitor and evaluate authorized tools; develop a complaint mechanism for reporting consumer harm; make the initial determination of whether formal regulatory intervention is necessary to protect consumers (e.g., suspension or termination of authorization); and, collect and account for any regulatory fees that are imposed on entities. • Communicate and coordinate with the Legal Technology Advisory Board (including the Board’s review of applications and regulatory data and evaluation). • Report to the Court, with members of the Legal Technology Advisory Board as needed, on the activities of regulated tools, recommendations for improvements, tool exits, and other formal regulatory intervention. • Develop—with guidance from and in collaboration with the Legal Technology Advisory Board—policy, data framework, and tracking and evaluation processes. • Communicate and coordinate in a timely manner with applicants, the public, external researchers, and other stakeholders.

53

• Review authorized tools’ legal service data for material evidence of consumer harm and determine regulatory action to be taken, if any (e.g., suspension or termination of authorization). • Make recommendations to the Supreme Court of Maryland on budget and staffing needs of the Innovation Office and the Legal Technology Advisory Board. • Maintain records of any/all conflicts and recusals in the Legal Technology Advisory Board, which records shall be publicly available. The Innovation Office will enforce compliance with all requirements, investigate complaints, conduct audits, require periodic reporting by owners of registered tools, and impose administrative sanctions (including suspension or revocation of registration) for violations, and refer non-compliance for civil or criminal enforcement as appropriate.


Advisory Board The recommended Rule change should establish a Legal Technology Advisory Board. The Board should include representation from the Maryland Judiciary, the Maryland State Bar Association, and the Maryland Access to Justice Commission, and include legal technology experts, a member of the public (technology consumer), and other relevant stakeholders. The duties and responsibilities of the Legal Technology Advisory Board include: • Review applications for authorization of tools to provide legal services to the public and make determinations about whether or not each tool should be authorized; and, • Develop formal recommendations to the Innovation Office on the following: • Relevant public benchmark data sets against which legal technology tools will be tested, for each law practice area in which owners of legal technology tools are permitted to seek authorization to provide legal services directly to the public. • Measurements by which to assess and manage potential or actual risks posed by legal technology tools. • Procedures for authorizing legal technology tools, including procedures in the event a technology tool is denied authorization. • Procedures for enforcement mechanisms including increased reporting requirements, fines, and suspension or termination of authorization for a legal technology tool.

• Standards for maintaining public transparency about the Legal Technology Advisory Board’s recommendations for authorization of tools. • Metrics and methods for evaluating the Legal Technology Tier’s overall effectiveness and the effectiveness of the authorized legal technology tools at advancing access to justice. • Continuous improvement of the Legal Technology Tier. • Factors/data to be included in regular reporting to the Supreme Court of Maryland on the activities of the Legal Technology Tier.

Ensuring Legal Technology Tools Serve the Intended Population The Innovations Task Force considered stakeholder concerns about whether a market-based Legal Technology Tier would actually benefit Maryland’s UPL and ALICE populations. We noted that, to address this same concern several years into Utah’s Legal Regulatory Sandbox, that state found it necessary to impose a new “nexus” requirement limiting participation to entities that present an innovative service model with the potential to substantially impact underserved consumers.229 This shift was attributed, in part, to criticism by the bar that Utah Sandbox entities were not operating “in the areas identified by the Work Group in 2019 as legally underserved.”230 While the Innovations Task Force ultimately opted for a marketbased approach for Maryland in order to produce the most investment and innovation, we learned from Utah’s example and added the key requirement that applicants must demonstrate how their tools will advance the tier’s foundational principle – promote access to justice – in order to help ensure the tools serve the intended population.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

54


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

Phased Implementation Approach The Innovations Task Force studied several approaches to introducing new legal technology tiers and described by NCSC (see Section III(B)(2), above) and seriously considered two of the three approaches for Maryland. Initially, we considered recommending a regulatory sandbox approach for Maryland’s Legal Technology Tier. However, we learned that the restricted access (artificial scarcity), selection dynamics, and queuing characteristics of the regulatory sandbox model can discourage startups and investors who cannot rely on being admitted to the sandbox.231 Because it operates on a discretionary basis rather than under clear, codified rules, a regulatory sandbox can generate long-term legal uncertainty for participants. The Legal Technology Committee received consistent stakeholder feedback that legal technology developers are disincentivized from developing state-law-specific legal technology tools in a regulatory sandbox environment knowing that authorization for the tools could be revoked not long after the tools’ release, leaving them with a tool customized exclusively to Maryland law that violates the state’s UPL Rules. Developers’ reticence to innovate in a regulatory sandbox can, in turn, spur reluctance among technology investors to finance innovation in the sandbox environment.232 Innovations implemented in a regulatory sandbox, which is designed for confined testing, can suffer impediments to scaling into the broader, fullyregulated market after the sandbox concludes. The sandbox model offers no assurance to legal technology investors seeking to replicate or scale a tool across state boundaries that participation in one state will lead to the tool’s acceptance in other states. A state’s decision to pursue the regulatory sandbox approach in lieu of more permanent regulatory reform signals systemic concerns about the initiative that further chill long-term investment.233 Finally, there is a dearth of measurable outcomes or empirical evidence that innovations generated by regulatory sandbox participants actually benefit the sandbox’s intended beneficiaries.234

55

The Innovations Task Force also considered whether to recommend that the Maryland Supreme Court update its UPL Rule to permanently authorize all vetted legal technology tools that meet requirements around disclosure, data security, and transparency. However, because AI-powered, business-toconsumer legal technology tools have potential to replicate or amplify the harms Maryland’s UPL doctrine was designed to prevent, the Task Force concluded that an immediate, permanent, blanket authorization of tools across all areas of civil practice was too high-risk, and the administrative and enforcement burden too heavy, for Maryland’s initial foray into a Legal Technology Tier. Ultimately, the Innovations Task Force eschewed both approaches in favor of a hybrid, phased implementation approach that seeks to combine the benefits of both. The phased implementation approach allows for the design, development, testing, and refinement of a Legal Technology Tier without the disincentivizing uncertainties of a regulatory sandbox. Specifically, this approach allows Maryland to permanently authorize and demonstrate legal technology tools in a single, low-risk law practice area, then adapt or improve the model based on rigorous evaluation, quality assurance testing, stakeholder feedback, and end-user insights before expanding safe harbor to additional practice areas and case types. Because this model is not time-limited – has no end date – investors and developers can more confidently fund and design new, Maryland-specific legal technology tools. Initially restricting the program to a single, low-risk/high-impact practice area, then gradually phasing in new practice areas or case types over time, mitigates the risks of permanent authorization while facilitating an early time to market while preserving nimble adaptability to any usability issues, consumer harms, or evolving legal needs. Draft regulatory language for the Legal Technology Tier, developed by the Legal Technology Committee of the Innovations in Tiered Legal Services Task Force, is attached in Appendix G. The Task Force has also developed Terms and Definitions for all three tiers, attached in Appendix C.


THREE RECOMMENDED NEW LEGAL SERVICE TIERS COMMUNITY JUSTICE WORKERS (“CJW”)

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS (“LP”)

LEGAL TECHNOLOGY TOOLS

SERVES

SERVES

SERVES

<125% OF FPL

ALICE

LOW-INCOME MARYLANDERS WITH A HOUSEHOLD INCOME AT OR BELOW 125 PERCENT OF THE FEDERAL POVERTY LINE

MARYLAND’S ASSET-LIMITED, INCOME-CONSTRAINED, EMPLOYED (OR “ALICE”) HOUSEHOLDS—HOUSEHOLDS THAT DO NOT QUALIFY FOR FREE LEGAL AID BUT ALSO CANNOT AFFORD TO HIRE AN ATTORNEY AT MARKET RATE

LOW AND MODERATE INCOME CONSUMERS

•

Non-lawyer legal service providers—conceptually akin to Community Health Workers in the medical profession

•

Non-lawyer legal service providers—conceptually akin to Nurse Practitioners in the medical profession

•

Staff or volunteers of communitybased organizations and agencies (frontline helpers) who are cross-trained to provide essential legal help that lawyers aren’t currently providing

•

Authorized to practice in specific, designated area(s) of civil law for which there is a deep, unmet need

•

May practice independently (hang a shingle) or under the supervision of a licensed attorney

•

Authorized to become certified to provide legal assistance/ representation in designated areas of civil law for which there is a deep, unmet need

CONSUMER PROTECTIONS •

CONSUMER PROTECTIONS •

Receive training and attorney oversight

•

Subject to many of the same ethical and regulatory obligations applicable to attorneys

•

Are tied to an authorized Host Organization, with attorney oversight, and are not permitted to practice independently

PURPOSE •

Purpose is to expand the reach of traditional legal aid by delivering free civil legal services to low-income Marylanders (UPL) without access to free legal aid or pro bono assistance

•

Required to meet formal educational and/or experiential standards, pass a licensing examination and a character fitness evaluation Subject to many of the same ethical and regulatory obligations applicable to attorneys

CAN SERVE DIRECTLY AT SCALE AND SUPPORT ALL OTHER TIERS TO HAVE BROADER REACH, WITH GREATER EFFICIENCY

•

Direct-to-consumer technology tools, including AI-powered tools

•

Tools specifically designed to help people solve a particular civil legal problem (not general tech tools/AI)

•

Tools are authorized to provide legal assistance

CONSUMER PROTECTIONS •

Initially limited to one area of civil law with high, unmet need: criminal records expungement

•

The tools are vetted and regulated for consumers’ protection

•

The tools must meet accuracy/reliability threshold and advance access to justice

PURPOSE

PURPOSE •

Purpose is to provide affordable legal assistance/ representation to Marylanders who do not qualify for free legal aid but also cannot afford to hire a lawyer at market rate (ALICE population)

•

Purpose is to help people with case types that do not require human legal help/ intervention

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

56


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

Legal assistance and representation should be high quality, accurate, and consistent across all tiers of Maryland’s civil legal system.

RECOMMENDATION 4 ADHERE TO

GUIDING PRINCIPLES ACROSS TIERS With input from experts and stakeholders, the Innovations Task Force identified a set of fundamental Guiding Principles that should inform all three proposed new legal service tiers. For example, the proposed new tiers should be designed and implemented in strict alignment with their primary purpose: helping close Maryland’s access-to-justice gap. The introduction of new legal service tiers should not create a stratified legal system where people of low or modest means receive less effective legal help than those who are able to afford to hire an attorney; legal assistance and representation should be high quality, accurate, and consistent across all tiers of Maryland’s civil legal system. Legal services should be designed and delivered in a manner that ensures all individuals have equitable access to assistance of 57

equivalent quality, regardless of a person’s race, color, ethnicity, national origin, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, religion, disability, age, or other protected or immutable characteristic. The tiers should be accessible to rural and remote Marylanders, limited- and non-English speakers and pre-literate persons, deaf/hard-of-hearing and blind/sight-impaired persons, persons with disabilities, and other historically disadvantaged, marginalized, or underserved Maryland populations. Consumer protections and community engagement should be directly embedded into the design and delivery of all legal service tiers. The Task Force recommends that the Court and implementing bodies incorporate these Guiding Principles directly into any Rule change(s) and other instruments authorizing or implementing the proposed legal service tiers. A complete list of the Innovations Task Force’s proposed Guiding Principles is included in Appendix D of this Report.


RECOMMENDATION 5

conditions for change were never built. Lack of organizational readiness is the leading cause of failed implementation efforts.237 An implementation science approach requires a greater upfront investment of time, intentionally identifying and motivating the right partners, anticipating and removing barriers, and building an infrastructure to sustain the change pays large dividends over time.238 By taking an implementation science approach, Maryland also has the opportunity to contribute to growing the national body of data and evidence and leave in place a replicable, scalable, and sustainable model for other states studying or implementing similar legal service tiers.

ADOPT AN

IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY AND GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE Implementation Strategy The Innovations Task Force recommends that an Innovations in Tiered Legal Services Implementation Committee (hereinafter “Innovations Implementation Committee”) and subcommittees form, in continued partnership with the Maryland Judiciary, the Maryland State Bar Association, and the Maryland Access to Justice Commission. The Innovations Implementation Committee should simultaneously roll out all three proposed new legal service tiers. Many of the existing structures needed to actualize the recommended tiers are already in place, and each tier is designed to serve a distinct target population of low- or modestincome Marylanders with current, unmet civil legal needs, none of whom should be left without immediate help.

Governance Structure

Implementation Science Approach Implementing meaningful, sustainable changes like those the Innovations Task Force has recommended requires more than good ideas and a detailed action plan. It requires champions, resources, buyin from key partners, and intentional feedback loops. To increase the likelihood that the plan is fully and successfully implemented, the Innovations Task Force recommends an approach grounded in implementation science. Implementation science is the study of methods and strategies that facilitate the adoption and integration of new practices,236 and an implementation science approach is a systemic, deliberate, and research-based process for building conditions where change is possible. It involves clarifying and building consensus around the purpose for the change, assessing readiness, building a responsive action plan, securing the right supports, and examining progress along the way. This approach matters because research consistently shows that implementation efforts fail not because the idea was wrong, but because the

The Innovations Task Force recommends the following governance structure and composition of governing bodies for the proposed new Legal Service Tiers. As the ultimate authority over the practice of law, the Supreme Court of Maryland should establish an Office of Legal Services Innovation (“Innovation Office”) to operate under the Court’s direct auspices. Housed in the Maryland Judiciary, the Innovation Office should oversee the state government’s role in the introduction of new civil legal service tiers and serve as a central hub for data collection, analysis, and reporting across all tiers, proposed and existing. Three semiautonomous Advisory Boards – a Community Justice Worker Advisory Board, a Legal Practitioner Advisory Board, and a Legal Technology Advisory Board – should administer the respective tiers as described in Recommendations One through Three. Each Advisory Board should include, but not be limited to, a representative from the Judiciary, a representative from the State Bar Association, and a representative from the Access to Justice Commission. Each Advisory Board should adopt a policy for administering its respective tier and for governing the Board, itself. For example, each Board’s policy should include a Conflicts of Interest policy to ensure that, in the event conflicts arise for a Board Member, that Board Member has a clear process to follow to disclose the conflict and recuse themself from any decisionmaking on that issue. The heavy responsibilities these Advisory Boards are tasked with will require some level of staffing and budget allocation.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

58


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

Resource Pooling and Structured Resource Reallocation Creating new legal service tiers necessitates an intentional, collaborative reexamination of Maryland’s entire legal services landscape to determine how the new providers fit into existing and new structures without disturbing or displacing what is already working well. For example: • Convene stakeholders from each tier, map legal services funding and resources statewide across tiers, and develop a framework for effectively leveraging existing resources and distributing the costs and benefits of the new tiers widely across sectors and agencies to minimize the burden and maximize benefits. • Redistribute workloads at legal service providers so that ALPs handle legal tasks that free up attorneys to provide oversight to community justice workers collocated in local partner organizations and tackle more complex case types that may not be suitable for ALPs. • Promote the attorney oversight of community justice workers to private attorneys as a highly-effective type of pro bono service with a tremendous multiplier effect. • Reassess staffing budgets to attain a proportion of attorneys to paralegals and ALPs that matches the target service populations’ legal needs and maximizes agency budgets. For example, replacing one retiring senior legal service attorney with multiple ALPs could double the work capacity for the same or similar staffing costs and free up staff attorneys to do more complex work. • Intentionally invest in embedding ALPs with local nongovernmental and community-based organizations in rural and remote areas of the state to expand

59

the geographic reach of legal service providers and reduce or eliminate staff attorneys’ travel time and expense. • Identify funding streams that can be used to support legal services for modest fees or sliding scales for ALICE clients without undermining funding to traditional free legal services. • Explore applying for larger funding streams as a collaborative. This typically involves multiple agencies entering into memoranda of understanding, executed by agency leaders with authority to commit personnel and resources to the initiative, if funded. • Develop statewide support apparatuses designed to develop resources and networks that leverage legal service resources within and across tiers. Resources could include marketing and fundraising, service referrals, crossagency training opportunities, skills and information-sharing, peer support and mentoring, and directly connecting ALPs with one another. • Study potential and actual cost savings and costs averted associated with the new legal service tiers, and identify where those savings can be reinvested or reallocated into proven civil accessto-justice strategies, programs, and initiatives. For example, decreasing the number of SRLs in courtrooms has the potential to increase court efficiency and save the courts money; that money could be reallocated to a formal evaluation or to administrative support for rigorous data tracking and analysis on the new tiers for continuous quality improvement. Through thoughtful planning and implementation, the proposed new legal service tiers have the potential to fill service gaps while expanding the reach and increasing the efficacy of Maryland’s existing tiers.


RECOMMENDATION 6 CONTINUE TO

SUPPORT EXISTING TIERS AND PROMOTE INNOVATION

“[Solving] the access to justice crisis [requires] a variety of institutional reforms… including simplifying legal procedures, increasing funding for legal services, and reducing restrictions on UPL, which all restrict the availability and affordability of legal services for unrepresented litigants.”239 –L. Karl Branting

Do Not Disturb Existing Tiers or Foreclose Future Innovation The Innovations Task Force recommends that Maryland continue to support and expand existing accessto-justice initiatives and innovate new solutions. The three proposed new legal service tiers and corresponding regulatory changes are not intended to singularly close Maryland’s access-tojustice gap. The new tiers must neither disturb or supplant Maryland’s existing tiers nor obviate future innovations in access to justice. Rather, the proposed new tiers are intended to complement and leverage the state’s current and future corpus of civil access-to-justice resources and initiatives, examples of which include: Allied legal professionals Non-attorneys who are authorized by state or federal statute or by court rule to provide people legal advice and/or legal representation in specific civil legal cases or matters, such as those identified in the Innovations Task Force’s Audit on the Current Use of Allied Legal Professionals in Maryland.240 They can operate on a market-based model geared to help middle- and low-income individuals or on a legal-aid model geared for lowincome persons.241 Traditional civil legal aid providers Nonprofit legal aid providers like those currently funded by Maryland Legal Services Corporation who serve Marylanders in households earning up to 125 percent of the Federal Poverty Guideline.242

Low bono organizations, sliding-scale and non-profit law firms Organizations that provide services to people who do not qualify for free legal aid because their household earns just above the income-eligibility threshold.243 Some charge clients a modest flat rate or use a sliding fee scale (based on a person’s income and assets), others rely on nontraditional funding streams to provide free services. Socially conscious, for-profit law firms Firms that use innovative approaches developed through legal incubator programs244, such as unbundled services, value-based pricing, and technologies to deliver accessible and affordable legal help to the middle-income market. Law school clinics Law school-based legal clinics provide law students an opportunity to develop vital lawpractice skills under an attorneyinstructor’s supervision, while also helping individuals who do not qualify for free legal aid but cannot afford to hire a private attorney at market rate. Some law school clinics are intentionally designed to increase interest in public interest careers or build pipelines to increase the number of lawyers in rural and remote areas.245

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

60


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

Pro bono service Pro bono legal services—whether initiated and delivered directly by individual attorneys to clients or filtered through nonprofit organizations or law-firm or corporate pro bono initiatives— remain a vital access-to-justice resource and an ethical (though not mandatory in Maryland) professional responsibility of legal professionals. Attorneys, allied legal professionals, and paralegals all have potential to make valuable contributions to access to justice. Legal document preparers Legal document preparers are nonlawyers trained to provide general legal information but prohibited from giving legal advice.246 Trained legal issue spotters Staff and volunteers at non-law-related community-based organizations trained to spot legal issues and dispense information and referrals.247 Court navigators Trained, non-attorney volunteers or staff who help self-represented litigants navigate the 61

civil justice system, guiding them through court procedures, explaining paperwork, and helping connect them to essential legal or community services. These are typically court-sponsored programs operated by courts, community partners, or universities. Court navigators guide people through the physical courthouse, help them locate specific offices, and explain what to expect before and during a hearing. They help people organize their paperwork, access “Do It Yourself” form programs, and fill out required documents. They identify and connect people to legal service providers, interpreters, mental health treatment, and other vital social services. In some states, court navigators can also accompany people into the courtroom and even respond to factual (but not legal) questions from a judge. Court navigators cannot give strategic legal advice, predict the outcome of your case, or speak on someone’s behalf in court.248 Self-help centers and online self-help portals Physical or online resources designed to help self-represented litigants resolve their civil legal issues or navigate complex systems independently, without direct human assistance.249


Public law libraries and other information experts Free, open-to-the-public facilities that provide access to primary and secondary legal materials, such as statutes, case law, and self-help guides. Law librarians can help people locate resources and navigate legal research, but are strictly prohibited from providing people legal advice.250 Other information experts, like public librarians and the United Way’s 211 experts have also been trained through the Law on the Frontlines Project and the Access to Counsel in Evictions project to provide legal reference, without crossing into UPL. Maryland Justice Corps Program

Rigorously Evaluate, and Continuously Improve Maryland’s Legal Service Tiers The Innovations Task Force recommends that all Maryland legal service tiers be regularly assessed, evaluated, and continuously improved for efficacy and responsivity to Marylanders’ ever-evolving civil legal needs. NCSC has designed an Evaluation Framework specifically for Allied Legal Professionals, recommending that states examine four key categories:

“As the reform landscape has expanded to encompass a wider array of entity- and role-focused reform approaches, academics, policymakers, and other stakeholders have increasingly focused on understanding how the various approaches differ. Rigorous empirical analysis of their impacts is more urgently needed than ever.”252

Maryland law school leaders and legislators are exploring new pathways to expand the legal workforce by creating supervised, practice-ready roles for individuals who are not licensed attorneys. Current –Deborah L. Rhode Center at Stanford Law School discussions include proposals for a Maryland Justice Corps Program, which would establish an alternative pathway to legal licensure through Court User Satisfaction (case outcome effects structured education, supervised practice, and and client satisfaction); public service, while also examining additional legal paraprofessional and limited-license models to help meet unmet civil legal needs, particularly for low- and moderate-income Marylanders. These efforts reflect a broader commitment to increasing access to justice by developing new legal career pathways that complement, rather than replace, the traditional attorney licensure model.251

Increase Funding for Civil Legal Help Maryland should prioritize meeting Marylanders’ civil legal needs, which are inextricably linked to society’s overall health and wellbeing. The state and local governments should increase appropriations, and pursue a wide array of federal, state, and private funding streams, in order to support the full spectrum of authorized service providers, tools, and technologies.

Efficiency (in case processing and training); Legitimacy of the System (access, equity, and market effects, and public trust in the legal system), and Sustainability (economic and political).253 The Task Force recognizes independent evaluation as the gold standard and urges that evaluation findings and recommendations be published for purposes of transparency. IAALS, Innovations for Justice, the ABA’s Access to Justice Research Initiative, NCSC, and the National Science Foundation’s CIVIC Innovation Challenge, are some examples of national organizations that have undertaken various kinds of evaluations or assessments of other states’ new legal service tiers.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

62


THE RECOMMENDATIONS

“Reciprocity isn’t just about mobility, it’s about building a cohesive profession that better serves the public. By designing thoughtful and flexible reciprocity rules, states can increase access to justice while also growing a strong and interconnected ALP workforce.”255 –Michael Houlberg, Director of Special Projects, IAALS

Improve Data and Decision-making Practices The Innovations Task Force recommends that Maryland strengthen statewide civil justice data collection, analysis, transparency, reporting, and data-informed/data-driven decisionmaking across all tiers of Maryland’s civil legal system. The Court’s Innovation Office should house this function in close collaboration with other relevant departments and the three Advisory Boards. Without comprehensive civil justice data, it is not possible to accurately assess or remain nimbly responsive to Maryland’s ever-evolving unmet civil legal needs or determine whether Maryland’s legal service tiers are effectively meeting those needs. Some examples of existing data gaps include the number and types of ALPs authorized to appear before each court or agency; the number and types of ALP appearances entered before each court or agency; the number of SRLs appearing before each court or agency; and comparative outcomes data, broken down by civil legal case or matter type, for persons represented by different kinds of ALPs as compared to SRLs. Litigant data should be disaggregated by race and ethnicity in order to identify and eliminate disparities in civil justice system access, experiences, and outcomes. In part to facilitate statewide data practice improvements, the Innovations Task Force recommends that the Supreme Court of Maryland establish a protocol for assigning each ALP authorized to practice in Maryland a unique identifier (comparable to an attorney’s bar license number) that identifies both the individual and the specific type of ALP involved, to be used on legal pleadings and in court and agency records.

Embed Community Engagement The Innovations Task Force recommends that Maryland courts and agencies, and the bodies administering existing and forthcoming Maryland legal service tiers, 63

embed public participation and community engagement models and practices as a permanent program feature to ensure that programs and services are informed by the voices and experiences of the populations they exist to serve and remain responsive as Maryland’s civil legal needs evolve.

Explore Reciprocity With Other States The Innovations Task Force recommends that Maryland explore developing a framework for reciprocity whereby other states’ ALPs can become licensed/ certified in Maryland and Maryland ALPs can become licensed/certified in other states, in a manner that maximizes transferable skills and knowledge while also accounting for state-specific law and practice.254

Continue to Modernize UPL Restrictions The Innovations Task Force recommends that Maryland courts and agencies continue to explore and adopt innovative new tiers and approaches to authorize nonlawyers and legal technology tools to provide legal services to Marylanders who cannot access or afford an attorney, while balancing consumer protection concerns.

“As the primary regulators of the legal profession in their respective jurisdictions, state supreme courts play a critical leadership role in ensuring that the public has access to competent legal representation.”256 –Chief Justice Gordon J. MacDonald, New Hampshire Supreme Court


NEXT STEPS

V. Next Steps Each of the proposed new civil legal service tiers recommended by the Innovations Task Force requires regulatory change to create UPL waivers or exemptions and to establish appropriate benchmarks and standards of practice for consumers’ protection. In order to support the Judicial Rules changes necessary to authorize and implement the above recommendations, the Innovations Task Force offers, for the Supreme Court of Maryland’s consideration, proposed regulatory language that includes Terms and Definitions (Appendix C), Guiding Principles (Appendix D), a Community Justice Worker Tier (Appendix E), a Legal Practitioner Tier (Appendix F), and a Legal Technology Tier (Appendix G).

“Our state courts have an obligation to update systems and practices in ways that help all users, including unrepresented litigants who often have little firsthand knowledge of how to navigate the legal system. Failure to consistently evaluate and improve our systems and practices will result in significant, long-term consequences for state courts, chief among them diminished public confidence in our ability to help all individuals resolve their legal issues.”257 –Loretta Rush, Chief Justice, Indiana Supreme Court & former president of the Conference of Chief Justices

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

64


APPENDIX A

Appendix A INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE Task Force Co-Chairs

Hon. Angela M. Eaves

Natalie McSherry

Reena K. Shah

Maryland Supreme Court Justice

Former President, Maryland State Bar Association

Executive Director, Maryland Access to Justice Commission

Task Force Members Sarah Coffey Bowes Hon. Yvette Bryant Ward Coe Hon. Angela M. Eaves (Co-Chair) Erin Gable Meredith Girard Hon. Michael Glynn Sean Griffin Hon. Syeetah Hampton-El M. Natalie McSherry (Co-Chair) Jana Meyer Chelsea Ortega Reena K. Shah (Co-Chair) Anna Sholl Marisa Trasatti OUTREACH COMMITTEE Committee Chair: Hon. Angela M. Eaves Members: Sarah Coffee Bowes | Erin D. Gable | Meredith Girard | M. Natalie McSherry | Reena K. Shah | Dr. Jamie Walter 65

LEGAL PRACTITIONER SCOPE, ROLES, AND RESPONSIBILITY COMMITTEE Committee Chair: M. Natalie McSherry Members: Ward Coe | Thomas Degonia | Erin D. Gable | Hon. Michael Glynn | Jana Meyer | Chelsea Ortega | Reena K. Shah | Anna Sholl LEGAL PRACTITIONER EDUCATION, EXPERIENCE, AND EXAMINATION COMMITTEE Committee Chair: Erin D. Gable Members: Ward Coe | Meghan De Valle | Prof. Shaun Koenig | Prof. Donna Mandl | Chelsea Ortega | Heather Pickett | Reena K. Shah | Michele Shipley | Prof. Melanie Snyder

COMMUNITY JUSTICE WORKER COMMITTEE Committee Chair: Meredith Girard Members: Ward Coe | Dr. Bernadette Fouché | Kirsten Gettys Downs | Hon. Syeetah Hampton-El | Deena Housner | Ivonne Lomax | Jana Meyer. Patrick Sawyer | Reena K. Shah | Marshall Shord | Kenneth Turner | Jennifer Vido | Lisa Widmaier LEGAL TECHNOLOGY COMMITTEE Committee Chair: Sarah Coffey Bowes. Members: Thomas Fisher | Sean Griffin | Reena K. Shah | Matthew Stubenberg | Marisa Trasatti


APPENDIX B

Appendix B ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This Report and Recommendations, developed with funding from the Abell Foundation and the Zanvyl and Isabelle Krieger Fund, is a product of collaboration in vision, efforts, and resources among Members of the Innovations Task Force and its standing Committees, with input from the greater access to justice and legal community stakeholders. This appendix lists those who contributed in grateful acknowledgement. We give special thanks to the Maryland Judiciary and, particularly, to Chief Justice Matthew J. Fader for convening the Innovations Task Force and to Justice Angela Eaves for her leadership as Task Force Co-Chair and heading its vital outreach work in collaboration with Jamie L. Walter, Ph.D., Kathleen Maher, Wonmai (Maia) Punksungka, and Taylor D. Robinson, Ph.D. of the Judiciary’s Research and Analysis Department. The support and resources of the Maryland State Bar Association— including the extraordinary leadership and expertise of Executive Director Anna Sholl and past Presidents Natalie McSherry and Marisa Trasatti—were indispensable to this initiative. Maryland Access to Justice Commission Executive Director and Innovations Task Force Co-Chair, Reena K. Shah, provided the vision and strategic leadership that drove the Task Force forward. Her systemslevel thinking, consensus-building, and meticulous execution kept the work on track and to the highest standards, enabling the Task Force to fulfill its

mandate with clarity, impact, and shared pride. Program Management Consultant, Julia Alanen, provided organizational rigor, logistical support, and led the Task Force’s extensive research and drafting efforts, enriching the work and producing multiple high-quality work products. DLA Piper

Experts Representing Other States’ ALP and/or Legal Technology Initiatives ALASKA Stacey Marz ARIZONA Staci Maret | Mark McCall | Stephanie Villalobos | Shauntia Deborah White

Suzanna Brickman | Elizabeth R. Dewey | Sima G. Fried | Emily Heck | William Kiniry III | Nicole Marie Kozlowski | Darryl Tarver

COLORADO

Frontline Justice

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

Nikole Nelson | Rachel Royal Innovation for Justice (i4J) Stacy Rupprecht Jane | Antonio M. Coronado Institute for the Advancement of the American Legal System Michael Houlberg | Courtney PetersenRhead | Jessica Bednarz National Center for State Courts Dr. Teri Deal | Aubrie Souza | Robert Wall The Abell Foundation The Zanvyl and Isabelle Krieger Fund Individual Experts Russ Bloomquist | Mia Bonardi | Scheree M. Gilchrist | Neel Guha | Margaret Darin Hagan | Ben Jackson | Natalie Knowlton | Erin Levine | Daniel W. Linna Jr | Conor Malloy | Maya Markovitch | Tom Martin | Chris McGrath | Sateesh Nori | Leland Sampson | Jeffrey C. Shipley | Dyane O’Leary

Hon. Angela Arkin

Nancy E. Drane | Hon. Roy McLeese MINNESOTA Rachel Albertson | Jennifer Carter | Sheldon Clark | Bridget Gernander | Judge Stoney Hiljus | Ethan Less | Dori Rapaport | Damien Riehl | Senior Judge John Rodenberg (retired) | J. Singleton | Associate Justice Paul Thissen NEW HAMPSHIRE Sarah Mattson Dustin OREGON Kellie Baumann UTAH John Wayas WASHINGTON Cathy Biestek | Stephen R. Crossland

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

66


APPENDIX C

Appendix C TERMS AND DEFINITIONS Access to Justice. Access to justice refers to the condition that all Marylanders – regardless of ability, age, religion, institutionalization, income level, language, literacy, race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation and gender identity/expression – benefit equally from the rights, protections, services, and opportunities that the law and the legal system provide. Advisory Board(s). Advisory Boards refer to the designated bodies established to stand up and administer each proposed legal service tier, monitor, evaluate, and continuously improve the tiers. Allied Legal Professional. Allied legal professionals (“ALPs”) are nonlawyers who are authorized to provide legal services and/or legal representation to individuals in specific areas of civil law or case types with high, unmet legal need without committing the unauthorized practice of law. ALP Advocacy. Advocacy refers to course content or practical experience that demonstrates and develops skills that are associated with conducting court hearings and trials, administrative hearings, mediation and arbitration, and settlement and plea negotiation. Artificial Intelligence (AI). AI refers to computer systems capable of performing complex tasks typically requiring human intelligence (such as reasoning, learning, pattern recognition, and decision-making) that analyze data to make predictions or take actions without explicit, step-bystep programming. Attorney Supervision: Attorney Oversight. Attorney oversight refers to an allied legal professional having plenary access to a Maryland-licensed attorney(s) (active and in good standing), who the ALP can consult as needed on any case or matter.

67

Direct Attorney Supervision. Direct attorney supervision refers to a more intensive level of supervision that could, for example, include the attorney accompanying an allied legal professional to court (as first or second chair) or reviewing the allied legal professional’s written work. Benchmark Data Sets. Benchmark datasets refer to standardized, curated collections of legal documents, queries, or tasks used to evaluate and compare the performance of AI models and legal tech tools in a fair and consistent manner to allow researchers and practitioners to measure AI accuracy in legal reasoning, information extraction, and judgment prediction. Certification. Certification refers to achievement of subject area competency within a legal practitioner license as measured by a legal practitioner attaining a passing score on the substantive law component(s) of the Legal Practitioner Exam. Community Justice Worker. Community justice workers are trained staff, supervised by attorneys, who are authorized to independently perform discrete legal procedures for which there is a deep, unmet need for people who cannot afford legal representation. Community justice workers do not charge any fee and may be able to assist individuals from households that meet legal aid income eligibility guidelines but who are nonetheless selfrepresented due to other factors, such as living in an area with limited access to attorneys. Expungement. Expungement refers to the legal process of sealing or destroying criminal records— such as arrests, charges, or convictions—so they are no longer accessible to the public. An expungement order removes these records from public inspection, allowing the individual to legally treat the event as if it never occurred.258


APPENDIX C

Law Firm. A law firm refers to an association of attorneys practicing in a partnership, professional corporation, sole proprietorship, or other association formed for the practice of law. It could include a legal services organization, or the legal department of a corporation, government entity, or other organization. [Maryland Rule 19-301.0] Legal Practitioner. Legal practitioner refers to an individual licensed and authorized to practice law and provide legal services independently, without attorney oversight, in specified areas of law and within the scope of work defined by regulation. Legal Practitioner Firm. A legal practitioner firm refers to an association of legal practitioners practicing in a partnership, professional corporation, sole proprietorship, or other association formed for the practice of law. Legal Technology Tools. Legal technology tools refer to (AI-powered and non-AI-powered) technologies that are specifically designed to improve access to justice in Maryland by increasing the efficiency and effectiveness of legal services and/or providing direct legal help to self-represented litigants to address a civil legal problem in a particular area of law. Business-to-consumer (“B2C”). B2C legal technology tools are marketed and provided directly to litigants. They focus on personal ease and single users.

Responsible AI. Responsible AI (artificial intelligence) refers to legal technology tools that advance access to justice. This means that the tools are affordable, broadly accessible, transparent, equitable, and centered on elevating human dignity. Self-Represented Litigant. A self-represented litigant (“SRL”) is an individual who represents themself in a court or other legal proceeding without the assistance of a licensed attorney, sometimes also referred to as a “pro se” party or said to appear “in propia persona” or “pro per.” Substantive, Law-Related Experience. Substantive, law-related experience includes, but is not limited to: client communication, interaction, and correspondence; interviewing clients or witnesses; legal research and substantive legal writing, drafting legal documents and pleadings; completing forms; preparing reports or charts; negotiation, conflict resolution, alternative dispute resolution, oral advocacy, and in-court and out-of-court legal observation opportunities (e.g., depositions, client interviews and meetings, witness preparation, case strategy meetings, etc.). Substantive lawrelated experience does not include routine clerical or administrative duties or preparation of legal documents for an entity or member of the public engaged in self-representation. The work experience may be paid or unpaid.

Business-to-business (“B2B”). B2B legal technology tools are marketed and provided to courts, law firms, legal service providers, and other legal system entities. They focus on team work, security, and scale.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

68


APPENDIX D

Appendix D GUIDING PRINCIPLES Affordability. The primary purpose of the proposed new legal service tiers is to help bridge Maryland’s access-to-justice gap by expanding the availability and accessibility of high-quality, free or affordable legal help for Marylanders who cannot afford lawyers but do not qualify for or cannot access free legal aid. The target populations for the proposed legal service tiers include people and households who live beneath the F.P.L. and those who are ALICE. This affordability principle should remain foundational to the design, implementation, evaluation, and continuous quality improvement of new legal service tiers, and be heavily emphasized in ALP training curricula. Consumer Protection. Consumer protection mechanisms – including preventive measures, reporting structures, and recourse for consumer harms – should be embedded directly into the design and implementation of all legal service tiers. Consumer protections should be designed to be easily accessible to the modest-means populations served by the tiers, not dependent on the ability to hire a lawyer and sue. Consumer harms should be consistently identified, monitored, measured, reported, and addressed. The tiers should be responsive to consumer harm patterns and evolve as consumer needs and circumstances evolve. Accessibility. Legal service tiers should be designed and positioned so as to be broadly accessible to all who need them. For example, the legal help offered via each tier should be designed and delivered with accessibility in mind. For example, tiers should aim to be accessible by rural and remote Marylanders, limited- and non-English speakers and preliterate persons, deaf/hard-of-hearing and blind/sightimpaired persons, persons with other disabilities, and other historically underserved or disadvantaged Maryland populations.

69

Equity. Fair, just, and impartial treatment is essential to a healthy civil justice system. The introduction of new legal service tiers should not create a stratified legal system where people of modest means receive less effective legal help than those who are able to afford to hire an attorney. Legal assistance and representation should be high quality, accurate, and consistent across all tiers of Maryland’s civil legal system. Equal Access and Quality of Legal Services. All legal services should be delivered in a manner that ensures all individuals have equal and equitable access to assistance of equivalent quality, regardless of race, color, ethnicity, national origin, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, religion, disability, age, or other protected or immutable characteristic. Programs and providers should design, implement, and evaluate services to identify and eliminate disparities in access, quality, and outcomes, so that protected or immutable characteristics do not affect a person’s ability to obtain meaningful legal assistance or the standard of services they receive. Community Engagement. The voices and experiences of Marylanders who are the intended beneficiaries of new legal service tiers should inform every phase from program design and implementation through evaluation and continuous quality improvement. Their lived experiences with Maryland’s civil justice system and their deep knowledge about their communities is vital to ensuring the tiers will work for the people they serve and remain responsive to the community’s evolving needs. Engagement implies a long-term, bidirectional relationship built on mutual trust, and involves capturing and directly integrating community input into the tiers. Community engagement should be embedded directly into any associated rule changes and into implementing bodies and instruments as an intentional and permanent feature of Maryland’s tiered legal services initiative.


APPENDIX D

to minimize re-traumatization and prioritize user safety, trust, and empowerment, ensuring human and digital interactions are emotionally safe. They apply principles like transparency, collaboration, and user choice. In the context of technology tools, this can mean featuring calm design, clear navigation, and control over content.

Transparency. Data transparency ensures accountability; allows the public to scrutinize the administration of civil justice, which fosters trust in the system; and uncovers systemic gaps and problems, allowing leaders and administrators to make evidence-based reforms and refinements. Robust data pertaining to all tiers of Maryland’s civil legal system should be collected, analyzed, and published regularly and publicly, and consistently utilized in decision-making. Confidentiality, Privilege, and Privacy. It is vital to consumer protection, ALP efficacy, and the integrity of Maryland’s civil legal system that ALP-client relationships be guaranteed the same safeguards as are afforded to attorney-client relationships as pertains to confidentiality, privilege, and privacy. In legal service tiers where an ALP is subject to attorney supervision or oversight, confidentiality, privilege, and privacy should also extend to the relationship between the ALP’s client and the ALP’s supervising attorney(s). These guarantees should be explicitly codified in any Rule change with respect to all ALP tiers. Mandatory Reporting. It is vital that allied legal professionals who are subject to mandatory reporting statutes by virtue of other professional licenses they hold or roles they fill remain vigilant for circumstances where such a reporting requirement comes into conflict with their duty of confidentiality as an ALP, particularly when the basis for the knowledge or belief that triggers the reporting requirement arises solely in the course of the ALP’s legal representation of a client. ALPs who are subject to such mandatory reporting requirements should maintain knowledge of any applicable exceptions to those reporting requirements, and seek clarification, as needed. Trauma-informed. Legal service tiers, which typically serve populations that include vulnerable and/or victimized individuals, should be trauma-informed. Trauma-informed tools and services are designed

Ethical Design. Every legal service tier should have an ethical design. Ethical design is the practice of creating products, services, and systems that prioritize human well-being, privacy, and social responsibility over manipulative tactics or profitdriven harm. Competency-Based Training and Testing. Allied legal professional (ALP) training and testing should focus on practical skills and experiential learning rather than broad theoretical knowledge, and ensure that ALPs meet specific competency standards to provide direct services. Court Access and Professional Standing. In order to do their jobs effectively, ALPs (including community justice workers and legal practitioners) require the same, unfettered access to the courts and agencies before which they appear. This includes access to e-filing and remote (e.g., MDEC) access to their clients’ court and agency files. The Court can facilitate this by assigning each community justice worker and legal practitioner authorized to practice in Maryland a unique identifier (akin to an attorney’s bar license number) that identifies both the individual and the specific type of allied legal practitioner involved, to be used on legal pleadings and in court and agency records. Reciprocity and Portability. In order to promote these proposed new law career pathways to potential applicants and ensure parity across Maryland’s legal service tiers, both the Legal Practitioner Tier and the Community Justice Worker Tier should be intentionally designed to facilitate portability between employers and reciprocity

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

70


APPENDIX D

GUIDING PRINCIPLES (CONTINUED) between states, just as licensed attorneys may change employers or waive into another state’s bar without undue burden. Inclusivity and Attainability of ALP Career Paths. Maryland’s new allied legal professional (ALP) tiers should be intentionally designed and structured to be accessible to and affordable for Marylanders who wish to pursue these career pathways. The Innovations Task Force’s Audit on the Current Use of Allied Legal Professionals in Maryland revealed that limited- and non-English-speaking clients of existing Maryland ALPs favor legal helpers who speak their language and have a shared understanding of their cultural context and life experiences.259 Maryland workforce development leaders underscored the importance of keeping ALP career pathways accessible for persons who have not had access to higher education opportunities; persons whose first language is not English; and non-Citizens with valid employment authorization. They underscored the advanced education and training that many refugees bring from their countries of origin that are directly transferable to the ALP role. ALP opportunities should be open to:

71

•

Persons who do not have postsecondary education;

•

Persons with criminal histories who have fulfilled their debt to society (any criminalhistory-based eligibility bars should be narrowly tailored to meet specific consumer protection concerns directly relevant to the particular legal practice areas, case types, and/or client types ALPs will handle/serve);

•

Persons who have limited English proficiency but are fluent in a foreign language(s); and,

•

Persons who are not United States Citizens but who hold a current, valid employment authorization document permitting them to lawfully work in the United States.


APPENDIX E

Appendix E PROPOSED REGULATORY LANGUAGE FOR COMMUNITY JUSTICE WORKER TIER Purpose. This section provides for the establishment and effective administration of the Maryland Community Justice Worker Program by the Supreme Court of Maryland, which has inherent regulatory power over all persons providing legal services to the public, regardless of whether they are lawyers or nonlawyers. Rule []: Waiver to Engage in the Limited Practice of Law for Community Justice Workers. Section 1. Eligibility. A person not admitted to the practice of law in the State of Maryland may seek and receive certification to provide legal assistance in a limited capacity as a community justice worker in certain civil legal matters in the state if such person meets all of the following conditions: •

Holds a high school degree or equivalent.

•

Successfully completed National Community Justice Worker Core Training Curriculum.

•

Successfully completed substantive specialized training in the Maryland law practice areas in which they will be providing legal services.

•

Successfully completed substantive, law-related experience (practical training) under direct attorney supervision.

Section 2. Qualifications. A person seeking permission to become a certified community justice worker shall have the following qualifications: •

Be a minimum of 18 years of age.

•

Have successfully completed the eligibility requirements outlined in Section 1.

•

If providing services to individuals who have experienced domestic violence, must have no active or past domestic violence or violent offenses on their record.

•

Have not been disbarred or suspended from the practice of law in any jurisdiction.

Section 3. Law Practice Areas. Community justice workers shall be authorized to practice in any and all substantive law practice area(s) for which they have successfully completed the requisite Community justice worker training and in which their Host Organization has authorized them to practice. Section 4. Scope. Community justice workers should be authorized to provide all levels of legal assistance except cases involving presentation of complex evidence to the court and complex litigation. Community justice worker Host Organizations, in consultation with the community justice worker and their oversight attorney(s), are best situated to determine, on a case-by-case basis, in which cases or matters the presentation of evidence or litigation are too complex to be handled by the community justice worker.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

72


APPENDIX E

PROPOSED REGULATORY LANGUAGE FOR COMMUNITY JUSTICE WORKER TIER (CONTINUED) Section 5. Conditions. A person granted certification under this rule may provide legal assistance in the scope approved in Section 4, shall be subject to the Maryland Rules of Professional Conduct, and shall not hold themselves out to be an attorney. No individual may claim to be a community justice worker unless they hold an active, valid community justice worker Certificate, are employed by or volunteer for an authorized Host Organization with oversight by a Maryland-licensed attorney(s) (in active status and in good standing), and serve individuals of modest means. Section 6. Confidentiality, Privilege, and Privacy. The community justice worker-client relationship shall be subject to confidentiality, privilege, and privacy, and those protections shall extend to the relationship between a community justice worker’s client and that community justice worker’s oversight attorney(s). Section 7. Authorized Host Organizations. Certified community justice workers must be employed by or serve as a volunteer for an authorized Host Organization. Legal service providers with active funding from the Maryland Legal Services Corporation automatically qualify to become recognized Host Organizations. Community-based organizations may also apply to the CJW Advisory Board for formal recognition as Host Organizations. Section 8. Administration. A community justice worker Advisory Board (hereinafter “CJW Advisory Board”) shall be established to oversee the Community Justice Worker Program. The CJW Advisory Board shall include, but not be limited to, a representative of the Maryland Supreme Court, Maryland State Bar Association, Maryland Access to Justice Commission, a civil legal services organization, an authorized Host Organization, a Maryland community college, a certified community justice worker, and a member of the public at large who has utilized community justice worker services and/or serves a population that community justice workers serve. The CJW Advisory Board’s roles and responsibilities shall include authorizing host organizations, approving the statewide community justice worker training curriculum, certifying community justice workers and maintaining a current list of certified community justice workers, conducting periodic community engagement, establishing a Community Justice Worker Network, and reporting out to the Court’s Innovation Office annually on the progress and impact of Maryland’s Community Justice Worker Program.

73


APPENDIX F

Appendix F PROPOSED REGULATORY LANGUAGE FOR LEGAL PRACTITIONER TIER Purpose. This section provides for the establishment and effective administration of a Maryland Legal Practitioner Program by the Supreme Court of Maryland, which has inherent regulatory power over all persons providing legal services to the public, regardless of whether they are lawyers or nonlawyers. Applicability. This [Rule/section] applies only to the Maryland Legal Practitioner Program, and shall not preclude any other non-attorney legal service provision duly authorized by state or federal law or regulation. Establishment of Maryland Legal Practitioner Program. The Supreme Court of Maryland shall establish a Maryland Legal Practitioner Program to be administered as set forth in this [Rule/section]. Nomenclature. Individuals licensed under the Maryland Legal Practitioner Program shall be called “legal practitioners.” [Commentary: this term was selected purposefully after extensive research and debate, and is also the term currently recommended by IAALS.] License Requirement. To provide legal services under this exception, an individual must hold a valid legal practitioner license, perform legal services only within the authorized scope of the law practice area(s) in which they are licensed, and comply with all other requirements for licensees set forth in this [Rule/section]. A person must not represent that they are a legal practitioner unless they hold a valid, active license in good standing as a legal practitioner issued in compliance with this [Rule/section]. Substantive Law Practice Areas. Legal practitioners may become licensed in any substantive law practice area as shall be authorized by the Supreme Court of Maryland, and are prohibited from providing legal services in any substantive law practice area that exceeds the scope of those authorized by the Supreme Court of Maryland. Scope of Authorized Services (Roles / Responsibilities). 1. Legal practitioners shall be authorized to independently perform the same roles, responsibilities, and activities as licensed attorneys perform, but only within the specific area(s) of law in which the legal practitioner is licensed to practice, and subject to the limitations set forth in [subsection #] relating to newly-licensed legal practitioners’ first 1,000 hours of practice and [subsection #] relating to in-court representation. Examples include, but are not limited to: a.

provide legal counseling;

b.

assist clients to fill out legal forms;

c.

represent clients in mediation proceedings;

d.

obtain written consent from clients;

e.

review documents from the opposing party; INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

74


APPENDIX F

PROPOSED REGULATORY LANGUAGE FOR LEGAL PRACTITIONER TIER (CONTINUED) f.

communicate with the opposing party;

g.

represent clients at settlement conferences and other pre-trial conferences;

h.

provide legal advice;

i.

prepare, sign, and file legal pleadings and documents;

j.

issue a subpoena; and,

k.

Represent Clients at Depositions.

2. In-Court Representation.

75

a.

Legal practitioners may obtain authorization to independently represent clients in court within the substantive law practice area(s) in which they are certified.

b.

If a legal practitioner chooses to perform in-court representation, that legal practitioner must receive direct attorney supervision, including being accompanied to court, by a Maryland-licensed attorney in good standing, acting as co-counsel, until such time as the legal practitioner has performed client representation in a minimum of five contested, heard and not settled, in-court proceedings. This requirement shall be repeated for each distinct practice area in which the legal practitioner is licensed in which they wish to perform in-court representation. After completing a minimum of five contested, heard and not settled, in-court representations, the legal practitioner may independently represent clients in court in the substantive law area(s) in which they are licensed to practice, without any further direct attorney supervision or attorney oversight.

c.

When a legal practitioner has successfully fulfilled the requirements set forth in this section for independent in-court law practice, the Maryland-licensed attorney(s) that supervised that legal practitioner’s in-court experiential work shall submit a form to the State Board of Law Examiners attesting that the requirements have been fulfilled and formally requesting that the legal practitioner’s status on the Maryland legal practitioners roster be updated to indicate that the legal practitioner is now authorized to independently represent clients in court in the relevant substantive law practice area(s), subject only to any limitations that the Supreme Court of Maryland may impose on a specific substantive-law practice area(s).

d.

Upon establishing that a form requesting a legal practitioner be authorized to independently represent clients in court has satisfied all of the requirements set forth in this [Rule/section], the State Board of Law Examiners shall promptly update Maryland’s legal practitioner roster to reflect the legal practitioner’s new status.


APPENDIX F

Attorney Oversight. A newly-licensed legal practitioner must be under attorney oversight by a Maryland-licensed attorney in good standing for the legal practitioner’s first 1,000 hours of substantive law practice before they can practice independently. Upon successfully completing 1,000 hours of postlicensure substantive, law-related experience, a legal practitioner shall be considered an independent practitioner and no longer subject to attorney oversight, except as pertains to the additional requirements set forth in this [Rule] for in-court representation. Independent Practice. Subject to the requirements set forth in sections [#] and [#] of this [Rule], legal practitioners are authorized to practice independently without any direct attorney supervision or attorney oversight (hang a shingle) and are not required to be part of a legal services provider or law firm. Regulatory Requirements. Legal practitioners must abide by the same regulatory requirements as apply to Maryland-licensed attorneys, including, but not limited to: 1.

Safeguard client funds and prevent client funds from commingling - legal practitioners must abide by Maryland’s Rule on trust accounts [Rule 19-401-19-413], including Registration with AIS [19-801,19-802]. [Commentary: MD Bus Occup & Prof T. 10, Refs & Annos relating to trust accounts is implicated and will need to be revised]

2. Participate in IOLTA and contribute to the Client Protection Fund of Maryland [Rule 19-601-19-611 [Commentary: the Client Protection Fund should be amended to extend the availability of the Client Protection Fund to the clients of legal practitioners]; 3

Report on whether or not they performed pro bono work each year [Commentary: mirroring the current requirement applicable to attorneys, legal practitioner will not be required to perform pro bono service, only to report out annually on whether or not they performed pro bono service, and how many hours, for purposes of assessing the scope of the state’s civil legal needs being met through pro bono service.];

4.

Abide by the Code of Ethics and Rules of Professional Responsibility applicable to Maryland-licensed attorneys;

5. Abide by the Rules governing client confidentiality and privilege, which shall apply to both attorneys and legal practitioners [including, but not limited to, Md. Code, Courts & Judicial Proceedings § 9-108 — Attorney-Client Privilege; Md. Code, Courts & Judicial Proceedings, Title 9 (Subtitle 1 — Competence, Compellability, and Privilege; Rule 19-301.6 — Confidentiality of Information; and, Rule 19-304.4 — Respect for Rights of Third Persons / amendment re privileged information]. 6. If and when Maryland elects to impose mandatory continuing legal education (CLE) requirements on Maryland-licensed attorneys, then those mandates shall also apply to Maryland-licensed legal practitioners [Commentary: CLE requirements for legal practitioners shall mirror, not exceed, those applicable to attorneys.]; and, 7.

If and when Maryland elects to impose malpractice insurance requirements on Maryland-licensed attorneys, then those mandates shall also apply to Marylandlicensed legal practitioners. INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

76


APPENDIX F

PROPOSED REGULATORY LANGUAGE FOR LEGAL PRACTITIONER TIER (CONTINUED) Performance in Accordance with Law. A legal practitioner must: 1.

Perform all duties and discharge all obligations in accordance with applicable laws, rules, and court orders.

2. Not represent that the legal practitioner is authorized to provide legal services that are not authorized by this section or are not within the scope of practice in the areas for which they are licensed 3.

Not use the designations “lawyer,” “attorney at law,” “counselor at law,” “Esq.,” or other equivalent word(s), the use of which is reasonably likely to induce others to believe the legal practitioner is authorized to engage in the practice of law beyond that allowed by a license issued under this section. Any communications by a legal practitioner in connection with providing services must clearly identify the licensee as a legal practitioner.

4.

Not provide any kind of advice, opinion or recommendation about possible legal rights, remedies, defenses, options, or strategies unless the legal practitioner is licensed in the practice area and doing so is within the authorized scope of the practice area.

5. Include their name, the title “Maryland Legal Practitioner” (or the abbreviation “L.P.”), and their law legal practitioner license number on all documents they prepare, unless expressly prohibited by a non-judicial agency or entity. 6. Inform the client, in writing, that a legal practitioner is not a lawyer and cannot provide any kind of advice, opinion, or recommendation to a client about possible legal rights, remedies, defenses, options, or strategies, or authorized legal services that are not within the scope of a practice area in which they are licensed.

77

7.

Inform the client, in writing, of the specific practice area(s) in which the legal practitioner is licensed and authorized to provide legal support. [Commentary: Some states emphasize that the disclosure of non-attorney status must be included in the engagement letter/client contract, in bold text or legible font, and that the disclosure must not be buried.]

8.

Comply with the Maryland Rules of Procedure governing the scope of the legal practitioner’s authorized practice area, but, where “lawyer,” “attorney,” or other equivalent words are used, substitute “legal practitioner” for any procedural rule governing conduct within the legal practitioner’s scope of practice.


APPENDIX F

Fee-Sharing. Legal practitioners may share fees with attorneys and with other legal practitioners. Firm Co-Ownership. A legal practitioner may hold either a noncontrolling or a controlling equity interest in a legal practitioner firm. A legal practitioner may hold only a noncontrolling equity interest in a Law Firm [Commentary: Maryland Attorneys’ Rules of Professional Conduct (MARPC) Rule 19-305.4 (5.4) currently prevents firms from forming partnerships or incorporating for profit if a non-attorney holds an interest, acts as an officer, or directs legal activities; a narrowly-tailored amendment is required in order to allow fee-sharing between attorneys and legal practitioners and firms that include both types of providers.] PROGRAM ADMINISTRATION. Advisory Board. The Supreme Court of Maryland shall establish a Legal Practitioner Advisory Board (“Advisory Board”). 1.

The Advisory Board shall consist of members appointed by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Maryland, including but not limited to: a.

Legal practitioner(s) in good standing;

b.

A Circuit Court Judge;

c.

A District Court Judge;

d.

A designee of the Administrative Office of the Court;

e.

A Maryland-licensed attorney in good standing;

f.

A legal educator(s)

g.

A designee of the Board of Law Examiners;

h.

A designee of the Maryland State Bar Association;

i.

A public member(s) (lay persons in the eligible population with lived experience); and

j.

Other person(s) with a stake in the Legal Practitioner Program’s success.

2. The policies and procedures applicable to Board members are as provided in [insert applicable rule/code]. 3.

On or before April 30 of each year, the Board shall file a report with the Supreme Court of Maryland describing the status of the Legal Practitioner Program. The report must include, but is not limited to, the following: a.

The number of applications granted and declined during the previous calendar year;

b.

The number of licensed legal practitioners as of December 31 of the previous calendar year;

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

78


APPENDIX F

PROPOSED REGULATORY LANGUAGE FOR LEGAL PRACTITIONER TIER (CONTINUED) c.

The number and nature of charges filed against legal practitioners during the previous calendar year;

d.

The number and nature of complaints initiated by the state bar during the previous calendar year;

e.

Discipline imposed during the previous calendar year, the nature of the conduct resulting in discipline, and the discipline imposed; and

f.

Recommendations concerning modifications or improvements to Maryland’s Legal Practitioner Program.

Maryland State Board of Law Examiners. The roles and responsibilities of the Maryland State Board of Law Examiners’ director and staff as relate to the Maryland Legal Practitioner Program are as stated in [insert applicable rule/code] and as follows. a.

The Maryland State Board of Law Examiners shall administer Legal Practitioner Examinations and character fitness assessments and, upon an applicant’s successful completion of the requirements set for in [section], must promptly issue or deny licenses to qualified applicants as provided in [sections/subsections # and # of this Rule]. In the event that an applicant’s form is invalid or incomplete, the Maryland State Board of Law Examiners must promptly issue the applicant a request for corrected form or further clarification or documentation.

b.

The Maryland State Board of Law Examiners shall maintain a current, public-facing roster of Maryland legal practitioners as provided in [sections/subsections # and # of this Rule]. The roster shall indicate for each legal practitioner: i.

in which substantive law area(s) the legal practitioner is certified (authorized) to practice;

ii.

whether the legal practitioner is or is not authorized to independently represent clients in court; and,

iii. whether the legal practitioner is subject to discipline or license revocation. Supreme Court of Maryland. The Supreme Court of Maryland shall, upon the recommendation of the Maryland State Board of Bar Examiners administer an officer-of-the-court oath to new legal practitioners, resulting in their official licensure. The Court shall promptly notify the Maryland State Board of Law Examiners when a new legal practitioner has been sworn in so that the legal practitioner can be added to the state roster.

79


APPENDIX F

Attorney Grievance Commission. The Maryland’s Attorney Grievance Commission shall handle legal practitioner discipline and license revocation/suspension, and shall integrate legal practitioners into their existing reporting to include both legal practitioners and attorneys. [Commentary: Maryland should consider changing “Attorney Grievance Commission” to “Legal Grievance Commission” to signal that legal practitioner’s clients, too, are entitled to a remedy if harmed by a legal practitioner.] LICENSURE. Eligibility. In order to apply to take the Maryland Legal Practitioner Exam, an applicant must establish eligibility through one of two possible eligibility pathways, (a) the Education Track or (b) the Experience Track: a. Education Track. i.

1.

In order to apply under the Education Track, an applicant must meet all requirements of one of the following four combinations of education and substantive, law-related experience:

Hold a Bachelor’s degree from a U.S. regionally-accredited college or university and 1,500 hours of substantive, law-related work in each practice area in which the applicant wishes to become certified, completed within the three years immediately preceding application; or,

2. Hold an Associate-level degree in Paralegal Studies from a U.S. regionallyaccredited college or university and 1,500 hours of substantive, law-related work experience in each practice area in which the applicant wishes to become certified, completed within the three years immediately preceding application. If the Paralegal Studies were completed at an American Bar Association-approved paralegal program, then only 1,000 hours of substantive, law-related work experience will be required, performed within the two years immediately preceding application; or, 3.

Hold a Master of laws (LL.M.) degree from a U.S. regionally-accredited university and 500 hours of substantive, law-related work experience in each practice area in which the applicant wishes to become certified, completed within the three years immediately preceding application; or,

4.

Hold a Juris Doctor degree from an American Bar Association-approved law school and 500 hours of substantive, law-related work experience in each practice area in which the applicant wishes to become certified, completed within the three years immediately preceding application. ii.

All Education Track applicants must also satisfy the following requirements: 1.

500 of the applicant’s substantive, law-related work experience hours must be on Maryland-specific law.

2. Submit a signed, sealed letter and a completed approved form from a supervising attorney(s), for each law practice area in which the applicant seeks certification, verifying that: INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

80


APPENDIX F

PROPOSED REGULATORY LANGUAGE FOR LEGAL PRACTITIONER TIER (CONTINUED) a.

the applicant has satisfied the applicable number of required hours of substantive, law-related work experience and specifying in which law practice area the applicant worked and seeks certification; and,

b.

500 of those substantive, law-related work experience hours were on Maryland-specific law; the remaining hours may be completed in another state or in federal law.

b. Experience Track. In order to apply under the Experiential Track, an applicant must meet all of the following requirements: i. 1.

Complete seven years of prior substantive, law-related work experience, including:

1,500 hours within the last 3 years in each practice area in which the applicant seeks certification; and,

2. 500 of those experiential hours must be on Maryland-specific law; ii.

Submit a sealed letter from a supervising attorney(s), for each law practice area in which the applicant seeks certification, verifying that: 1.

the applicant has satisfied the applicable number of required hours of substantive, law-related work experience and specifying in which practice area the applicant worked and seeks certification; and,

2.

500 of those substantive, law-related work experience hours were on Marylandspecific law; the remaining hours may be completed in another state or in federal law.

Qualifications. The Maryland State Board of Law Examiners shall grant a license and the Supreme Court of Maryland shall administer an oath to an applicant who demonstrates possession of the following qualifications, in addition to the educational and experiential requirements set forth in this [Rule]: 1.

Is at least eighteen years of age;

2. Submits a completed Maryland Character Questionnaire and successfully undergoes the same good moral character and fitness evaluation that attorney applicants for bar admission undergo (Rule 19-205). 3.

81

Has not been denied admission to the practice of law as an attorney or as a legal practitioner in Maryland or equivalent in any other jurisdiction, unless the applicant requests an exception that is approved by the Supreme Court of Maryland;


APPENDIX F

4.

Has not been disbarred or suspended from the practice of law as an attorney or as a legal practitioner in Maryland or equivalent any other jurisdiction, unless the applicant requests an exception that is approved by the Supreme Court of Maryland;

5. Complies with the laws, court rules, and orders adopted by the Supreme Court of Maryland governing legal practitioners in this state; 6. Has achieved a passing score on the Legal Practitioner Examination, including a substantive law examination in each practice area in which the applicant seeks to become certified; Notification of Discipline. A legal practitioner who in another jurisdiction (1) is disbarred, suspended, or otherwise disciplined, (2) resigns from the bar while disciplinary or remedial action is threatened or pending in that jurisdiction, (3) is transferred to disability inactive status or an equivalent status in that jurisdiction, or (4) is subject to a remedial order entered in that jurisdiction shall inform Bar Counsel promptly of the discipline, resignation, inactive status, or remedial order. [mirroring Rule 19-737(a)] This section applies to both attorney and legal practitioner statuses in other jurisdictions. Notification of Denial of Admission. A legal practitioner who in another jurisdiction is denied admission to the practice of law, as an attorney or as a legal practitioner, shall inform Bar Counsel promptly of the denial. Examination. In addition to meeting the requirements of the Educational or Experiential Track legal practitioner applications must successfully pass an examination in order to become licensed: 1.

The examination requirements for a legal practitioner license shall consist of a two-part exam: a.

The foundational exam will test the applicant on the fundamentals of legal practice in Maryland. The examination will consist of 100 multiple-choice questions administered over two-hour sessions, topics will include legal ethics, jurisdiction, legal terminology, relevant Court rules and statutes, client communication, document/pleading preparation, and professional and administrative responsibilities pertaining to legal practitioners; and

b.

The substantive law test will consist of fifty (50) multiple-choice questions on each of the areas of practice in which the applicant seeks to be licensed.

c.

The State Board of Law Examiners will consult with subject matter experts in creation and maintenance of the Legal Practitioner Exams.

2. The examinations shall be administered in a board-approved format and at approved testing locations within the state. 3.

Applicants must obtain at least a 70 percent on each exam to be eligible for the license.

4.

Administration of reexaminations. a.

If an applicant successfully obtains a passing score on the foundational exam, but is not successful on the substantive law exam, the applicant will only be required to retake the substantive exam.

b.

Passage on both examinations shall be completed within 2 years from the date of the application for a legal practitioner license.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

82


APPENDIX F

PROPOSED REGULATORY LANGUAGE FOR LEGAL PRACTITIONER TIER (CONTINUED) Complaints, Investigation, and Disciplinary Proceedings. Maryland’s Supreme Court Rules governing complaints, investigations, discipline, sanctions, reinstatement, continuing legal education, and public access to state bar records are applicable to legal practitioners, with the following modifications: 1.

Rule 44 is not applicable to legal practitioners.

2. Rule 60(a)(1) is applicable to legal practitioners, except that the term “revocation” replaces the term “disbarment.” 3.

Reinstatement proceedings under Rules 64 and 65, Rules of Supreme Court, are applicable to legal practitioners, except the term “revoked” or “revocation” replaces the term “disbarred” or “disbarment.”

Fee Schedule. The State Board of Bar Examiners shall establish a fee schedule and a process for requesting fee waivers. Data and Evaluation 1.

83

Data. The Innovation Office, with input from the Legal Practitioner Advisory Board, shall collect, analyze, and publish, annually, comprehensive data on Allied Legal Professionals (“ALPs”) (nonattorneys authorized to practice law in Maryland). On or before August 31 each year, [Agency/ ies] shall report to [the Governor and, in accordance with § 2-1257 of the State Government Article, the General Assembly]: a.

The number of active ALPs in Maryland, broken down by ALP category (i.e., legal practitioners, community justice workers, case-handling paralegals, persons authorized by each applicable state agency to provide legal assistance and/or representation, etc.);

b.

The number of individuals provided legal assistance and/or representation by an ALP during the previous calendar year;

c.

The number of cases filed by ALPs, broken down by case type and adjudicating court or agency;

d.

The number of in-court representations performed by ALPs, broken down by case type and court (this data should facilitate comparison between self-represented litigants, persons represented by ALPs, and persons represented by licensed attorneys); and,

e.

A summary of outreach, engagement, and education activities conducted to raise awareness about ALPs among potential clients and among populations likely to pursue a career as an ALP in Maryland.


APPENDIX F

2. Evaluation. a.

The Legal Practitioner Advisory Board or Innovation Office shall procure an Independent Evaluator to conduct a formal independent evaluation of the Maryland Legal Practitioner Program for purposes of ensuring the Program is achieving its intended purpose and to identify any changes that may need to be made to continuously improve the Program. The independent evaluation shall include, but not be limited to:

i.

Evaluate the provision of services under this Rule, including the performance of designated organizations;

ii.

Study potential funding sources; and

iii. Make recommendations to improve the implementation of this subtitle, including necessary rule, policy, and/or statutory changes. 1.

The Legal Practitioner Advisory Board or Innovation Office shall report annually on interim findings and, as soon as available, shall report on the independent evaluator’s findings and recommendations.

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

84


APPENDIX G

Appendix G PROPOSED REGULATORY LANGUAGE FOR LEGAL TECHNOLOGY TIER Purpose. This section provides for the establishment and effective administration of a Legal Technology Tier by the Supreme Court of Maryland, which has inherent regulatory power over all persons providing legal services to the public, regardless of whether they are lawyers or nonlawyers, for the purpose of improving access to justice in Maryland for self-represented litigants who cannot afford an attorney. Objective. The overarching goal of the Legal Technology Tier is to advance access to justice by improving the ability of Marylanders to meaningfully access technology-based solutions to their civil legal problems – including access to legal information, advice, and resources – and access to the courts. Guiding Principles. The Legal Technology Tier and the bodies that administer the program shall be guided by the following regulatory principles: 1.

The primary purposes of regulating business-to-consumer legal technology tools and exempting them from the unauthorized practice of law (UPL) are: a.

to promote civil access to justice by ensuring that consumers have access to a welldeveloped, high-quality, innovative, affordable, and competitive market for legal services; and,

b. to protect consumers from harm by business-to-consumer legal technology tools. 2. Regulation should be based on the evaluation of risk to the consumer (for example, the accuracy of a legal technology tool should be as good as the accuracy of an attorney giving advice on the same issue). 3.

Regulation should establish probabilistic thresholds for acceptable levels of error.

4.

Regulation should be empirically driven.

5. Regulation should be guided by a market-based approach to encourage innovation. Authorization of the Use of Vetted Legal Technology Tools to Provide Legal Services Directly to the Public in Expungement Cases. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the use of technology tools, including artificial intelligence (AI)-powered tools, by persons, firms, or companies specifically offering or marketing technology tools designed to provide legal advice/assistance in the area of criminal records expungement shall not be considered the unauthorized practice of law (UPL) provided that all entities offering such services comply with the following requirements: 1.

Register with the Supreme Court of Maryland’s Innovation Office. a.

85

Registration shall include the following minimum requirements:


APPENDIX G

i.

Name of owner/operator and any d/b/a names;

ii.

Name of firm or company (if applicable) and any d/b/a names;

iii.

Relevant information regarding owner/firm/company, including: 1.

Physical address of principal place of business and contact information;

2. Name and contact information of agent for service of process. iv.

Statement of attestation of compliance with the below listed requirements. 1.

Payment of registration fees and annual renewal fees as set by state authority.

2. Registration must be completed before commencing operations in Maryland. 2. Demonstrate, in order to mitigate the risk of dispensing incorrect legal guidance, that the registered legal technology tool meets or exceeds the minimum required threshold when tested against relevant public benchmark datasets established by the Legal Technology Advisory Board for the area of law in which the legal technology tool will provide legal services to the public. 3.

Demonstrate that the tool will advance access to justice (at the core of which is affordability).

4.

Demonstrate that the tool prominently and clearly discloses that the legal service is being provided by a tool, and not by an attorney.

5. Implement reasonable measures to regularly test and validate the accuracy and reliability of the tool’s services. a.

Methods of satisfying the requirement of reasonable measures may include, but are not limited to i.

Regular review and approval of training protocols and outputs by attorney(s) licensed in Maryland; or

ii.

Implementation of documented quality assurance processes that are designed to achieve comparable levels of accuracy and reliability, which may include technical validation protocols, peer review systems, or other methods appropriate to the service provided.

b. Attorneys conducting such review and approval are not considered to be practicing law and any consideration paid for such activities is not considered legal fees. The names and license numbers of such attorneys must be retained on file with the provider and provided to regulators upon request. 6. Demonstrate that the tool will be accessible to Maryland populations with a high number of limited- and/or non-English speakers (i.e., incorporates language-access mechanisms). INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

86


APPENDIX G

PROPOSED REGULATORY LANGUAGE FOR LEGAL TECHNOLOGY TIER (CONTINUED) 7.

Demonstrate that the tool will be accessible to deaf/dard-of-hearing and blind/sight-impaired consumers (e.g. incorporates assistive technologies).

8.

Demonstrate that the tool is trauma-informed in its design.

9.

Demonstrate that the tool screens for cases that require human legal assistance and notifies those users that their case is not a fit for unsupervised machine help and they should seek legal help via a different tier.

10. Maintain robust data security protocols to protect user privacy. 11. Establish a clear and accessible mechanism for users to report errors or inaccuracies. 12. Maintain records of all reasonable measures taken, and their results, for [insert period of time] and provide those records and results to relevant regulator(s) upon request. 13. Provide documentation of a written policy designed to mitigate potential consumer risks posed by individuals with access to consumers’ personally identifiable information (PII) associated with the registered legal technology tool. The policy must identify any criminal convictions relevant to consumer protection associated with access to the authorized tool. The owner must attest that it conducts regular screening of all individuals who could gain access to consumer data/PII associated with the tool, and does not employ individuals who fail to pass the criminal record screening in any role that would allow them access to the consumer data/PII associated with that tool. Falsifying any information relating to this requirement is a basis for de-authorization of all of an owner’s authorized tools. Other criminal and civil sanctions may also apply. 14. Comply with all applicable state and federal laws, including all relevant consumer protection laws. Any false or misleading statements made by applicants or participants (owners of authorized tools) to the Innovation Office or the Court, whether during application, authorization, reporting, monitoring, or enforcement, whether discovered at the time of commission or at any time afterward, are independent grounds for enforcement and an aggravating factor in any enforcement proceeding based on other conduct, and may result in revocation of that owner’s tools’ authorization to practice law. This [Rule/Section] applies solely to business-to-consumer (“B2C”) legal technology tools–tools that directly serve consumers/endusers. This [Rule/Section] does not apply to developers or providers of general-purpose artificial intelligence models or platforms that are not specifically designed, marketed, or held out by the provider as a dedicated legal information, assistance, or advice tool, even if such models or platforms can be adapted or used by end-users for legal purposes.

87


APPENDIX G

Nothing in the above language immunizes providers from negligence, tort/criminal liability, etc. Persons, firms, or companies may not disclaim any warranties or liability or limit liability to consumers or damages or other remedies in any way. Persons, firms, or companies operating AI or other technologically-provided legal services as described above and not in compliance with this rule/statute will be subject to enforcement as the unauthorized practice of law. Regulatory Structure. The Supreme Court of Maryland’s Innovation Office, advised by the Legal Technology Advisory Board, will authorize, oversee, and regulate legal technology tools in Maryland. Office of Legal Services Innovation. In accordance with its plenary and exclusive authority and responsibility under [article #, section # of] the Maryland Constitution to govern the practice of law, the Supreme Court of Maryland establishes the Office of Legal Services Innovation (hereinafter “Innovation Office”) of the Supreme Court of Maryland. The Innovation Office will operate under the direct auspices of the Supreme Court of Maryland in close collaboration with a Legal Technology Advisory Board. Subject to the ultimate authority and control of the Supreme Court of Maryland, the Innovation Office will have the authority to regulate legal technology tools operating in Maryland. The Innovation Office is responsible for carrying out the day-to-day activities necessary for the regulatory oversight of owners with a tool authorized to offer legal services in Maryland. The Supreme Court of Maryland grants the Innovation Office and the authority to develop and propose processes and procedures around licensing, monitoring, and enforcement to carry out its mission in light of the Regulatory Objective and Regulatory Principles outlined in [Section #]. Responsibilities: The Innovation Office will be responsible for the operation and regulation of Maryland’s Legal Technology Tier through which legal technology tools, including AI-powered tools, may be authorized to offer nontraditional legal services to the public. Entities subject to regulation through the Innovation Office include owners of a legal technology tool(s) that provides legal advice directly to consumers in Maryland. The Innovation Office’s responsibilities include: 1.

Administer and operate the regulation of owners of legal technology tools including but not limited to: a.

develop and implement a communications plan to advise the public, innovators and technology entrepreneurs of the opportunities under the Legal Technology Tier;

b. intake of applications from owners of legal technology tools, and present applications to the Legal Technology Advisory Board for review; c.

register legal technology tools recommended for authorization by the Legal Technology Advisory Board;

d. monitor and evaluate on an ongoing basis the authorized legal technology tools, including assessment and evaluation of risk and informal engagement with authorized tools’ owners to inform and mitigate compliance or harm concerns in accordance with guidance provided by the Legal Technology Advisory Board; e.

develop a complaint mechanism for reporting of consumer harm, and track and report consumer harm data to Legal Technology Advisory Board; INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

88


APPENDIX G

f.

make the initial determination of whether formal regulatory intervention is necessary to protect consumers (e.g., suspension or termination); and,

g. collect and account for any regulatory fees that are imposed on entities. 1.

Communicate and coordinate with the Legal Technology Advisory Board (including the Board’s review of applications and regulatory data and evaluation).

2. Report to the Supreme Court of Maryland, with members of the Legal Technology Advisory Board as needed, on the activities of regulated entities, recommendations for improvements, tool exits, and other formal regulatory intervention. 3.

Develop, with guidance and in collaboration with the Legal Technology Advisory Board, policy, data framework, and tracking and evaluation processes.

4.

Communicate and coordinate in a timely manner with applicants, the public, external researchers, and other stakeholders.

5. Review authorized tools’ legal service data for material evidence of consumer harm and determine regulatory action to be taken, if any (e.g., suspension or termination of authorization). 6. Make recommendations to the Supreme Court of Maryland on budget and staffing needs of the Innovation Office and the Legal Technology Advisory Board. 7.

Maintain records of any/all conflicts and recusals in the Legal Technology Advisory Board, which records shall be publicly available;

Enforcement. The Innovation Office shall enforce compliance with all requirements, investigate complaints, conduct audits, require periodic reporting by registered providers, and impose administrative sanctions (including suspension or revocation of registration) for violations, and refer noncompliance for civil or criminal enforcement as appropriate. Scope. The Innovation Office will have no authority to regulate any individuals, entities, or activities that are beyond the Supreme Court’s constitutional scope and mandate to govern the practice of law. Legal Technology Advisory Board. The Legal Technology Advisory Board will be established and administered in partnership between the Maryland Judiciary, the Maryland State Bar Association, and the Maryland Access to Justice Commission. Composition: The Legal Technology Advisory Board shall include representation from the Judiciary, the Maryland State Bar Association, and the Maryland Access to Justice Commission, and shall include legal technology experts, a member of the public (technology consumer), and other relevant stakeholders. Purpose: The purpose of the Legal Technology Advisory Board is to develop recommendations pertaining to the authorization, implementation, oversight, and regulation of authorized legal technology tools and the maintenance, continuous improvement, and growth of the Legal Technology Tier.

89


APPENDIX G

Responsibilities: The Legal Technology Advisory Board’s responsibilities shall include: 1.

Review applications for authorization of tools to provide legal services to the public and make determinations about whether or not each tool should be authorized.

2. Develop formal recommendations to the Innovation Office on: a.

Relevant public benchmark data sets against which legal technology tools will be tested, for each law practice area in which owners of legal technology tools are permitted to seek authorization to provide legal services directly to the public.

b. Measurements by which to assess and manage potential or actual risks posed by legal technology tools. c.

Procedures for authorizing legal technology tools, including procedures in the event a technology tool is denied authorization.

d. Procedures for enforcement mechanisms including increased reporting requirements, fines, and suspension or termination of authorization for a legal technology tool. e.

Standards for maintaining public transparency about the Legal Technology Advisory Board’s recommendations for authorization of tools.

f.

Metrics and methods for evaluating the Tier’s overall effectiveness and the effectiveness of the authorized legal technology tools at advancing access to justice.

g. Continuous improvement of the Legal Technology Tier. h.

Factors to be included in regular reporting to the Supreme Court of Maryland on the activities of the Legal Technology Tier.

Conflicts of Interest: Instances may arise in which Legal Technology Advisory Board members may face conflicts of interest between their business or personal affairs and their member duties. Recognizing that transparency and public confidence are paramount concerns, in cases of conflict, the implicated member(s) shall disclose the conflict to the Legal Technology Advisory Board in writing and recuse from any involvement regarding that particular applicant or participant. [Commentary: In order to help owners of legal technology tools ensure that tools are as legally accurate as possible, Maryland Rule 19-305.4 (prohibiting attorneys from sharing legal fees with non-attorneys) should be amended to include a narrowly-tailored exception to permit attorneys to join technology companies that own an authorized legal technology tool(s) that Maryland’s Innovation Office has exempted from UPL.]

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

90


ENDNOTES

Endnotes Matthew Burnett & Rebecca L. Sandefur, A People-Centered Approach to Designing and Evaluating Community Justice Worker Programs in the United States, 51 Fordham Urb. L.J. 1509, 1511 (2024). 1

World Just. Project, Measuring the Justice Gap: A People-Centered Assessment of Unmet Justice Needs Around the World 13 (2019), https://worldjusticeproject.org/our-work/research-and-data/access-justice/ measuring-justice-gap. This figure does not include the estimated 253 million individuals who live in “extreme conditions of injustice,” such as being stateless, victims of modern slavery, or living in “fragile states with high levels of insecurity.”

2

United Nations, Goal 16: Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions, https://globalgoals.org/goals/16-peacejustice-and-strong-institutions/ (last visited July 22, 2026).

3

4

Id.

World Just. Project, Rule of Law Index—Rankings, https://worldjusticeproject.org/rule-of-law-index/ global/2025/Civil%20Justice/ (last visited July 22, 2026).

5

World Justice Project, Countries: United States—Rule of Law Index, https://worldjusticeproject.org/rule-oflaw-index/country/2025/United%20States/Civil%20Justice (last visited July 22, 2026).

6

Am. Acad. of Arts & Sci., Civil Justice for All: A Report and Recommendations from the Making Justice Accessible Initiative (2020), https://www.amacad.org/sites/default/files/publication/downloads/2020-CivilJustice-for-All_0.pdf. 7

Graphic reprinted with permission of the World Justice Project, Rule of Law Index (2025), https:// worldjusticeproject.org/rule-of-law-index/global/2025/Civil%20Justice/ (last visited May 27, 2026). 8

Graphic reprinted with permission of the World Justice Project, Rule of Law Index:2025, https:// worldjusticeproject.org/rule-of-law-index/global/2025/Civil%20Justice/ (last visited May 27, 2026).

9

Comm’n on the Future of Legal Servs., Report on the Future of Legal Services in the United States 5 (A.B.A. 2016), https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/administrative/center-for-innovation/2016-fls-finalreport.pdf.

10

Civil legal problems are common. They include matters such as domestic violence cases, family law (divorce, paternity, child custody and support), wills and trusts, power of attorney, labor and employment matters, record sealing and expungement, housing (foreclosure and eviction), consumer and finance (consumer or medical debt and bankruptcy), immigration law, civil rights, and much more. But, because there is no right to an attorney in most civil cases, people who cannot afford to hire an attorney are forced to navigate complex laws and systems by themselves. See Am. Bar Ass’n., How Courts Work (Sept. 9, 2019), https://www.americanbar.org/groups/public_education/resources/law_related_education_network/how_ courts_work/cases/#:~:text=A%20civil%20case%20usually%20begins,court%20that%20begins%20a%20 lawsuit.

11

See The People’s Law Library of Maryland, Children in Need of Assistance (CINA), https://www.peoples-law. org/children-need-assistance-cina#right-to-counsel (last visited July 22, 2026). See also Md. Code Ann., Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 3-813; Md. R. 11-207. 12

Md. Code Ann., Crim. Proc. § 16-204 (b)(1)(iv) states that an indigent person shall be provided representation by the Public Defender in “any proceeding in which confinement under a judicial commitment of an individual in a public or private institution may result.” 13

91


ENDNOTES

14

Md. Code Ann., Educ., § 8-413.1.

Conf. of Chief Justs. and Conf. of State Ct. Adm’r, Resolution 5: Reaffirming the Commitment to Meaningful Access to Justice for All (2015), https://ccj.ncsc.org/resources-courts/reaffirming-commitment-meaningfulaccess-justice-all (last visited July 22, 2026). The two organizations also urged their members to provide leadership in achieving that 100 percent goal and work with their Access to Justice Commission or other such entities to develop a strategic plan with realistic and measurable outcomes, and urged the National Center for State Courts and other national organizations to develop tools and provide assistance to states in achieving the goal of 100 percent access through a continuum of meaningful and appropriate services. 15

Bob Glaves, What Do We Mean When We Say Access to Justice?, The Chicago Bar Found. (Sept. 20, 2018), https://chicagobarfoundation.org/bobservations/what-do-we-mean-when-we-say-access-to-justice/ (last visited July 22, 2026).

16

Legal Servs. Corp., The Justice Gap: The Unmet Civil Legal Needs of Low‑income Americans (Mary C. Slosar ed., 2022), https://justicegap.lsc.gov/resource/executive-summary/.

17

18

Id.

A self-represented litigant (or “SRL”) is an individual who represents themself in a court or other legal proceeding without the assistance of a licensed attorney, often also referred to as a pro se party or said to appear in propia persona or pro per.

19

See Md. Access to Just. Comm’n and Mid-Shore Council on Fam. Violence, Civil Legal Aid Helps Marylanders Fulfill Basic Human Needs, https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/ de25d9edc46d479a91089a6ad8917ab7 (last visited July 22, 2026). 20

Self‑Represented Litigation Network, SRLN Brief: How Many SRLs? (2015), https://atjlibrary.org/node/548/ srln-brief-how-many-srls-srln-2019 (estimating that 75% or more of state civil cases involve at least one self‑represented litigant). Maryland SFY2024 civil case filing data indicates that Marylanders filed 415,986 landlord tenant cases (including FTPR and evictions) [415,986 x .75 = 311,989]; 70,631 notices of intent to foreclose [70,631 x .75 = 52,973]; and 10,497 non-business bankruptcy cases [10,497 x .75 = 7,873]. Maryland SFY2024 civil filing data on file with Maryland Access to Justice Commission. 21

Legal Servs. Corp., supra note 17. “74% of low-income households experienced at least one legal issue, and most of them did not seek legal help.”. 22

Lincoln Caplan, The Justice Worker, The American Scholar (June 4, 2025), https://theamericanscholar.org/ the-justice-worker/ (last visited July 22, 2026).

23

Rebecca L. Sandefur, What We Know and Need to Know About the Legal Needs of the Public, 67 S.C. L. Rev. 443, 443-444 (2016), https://scholarcommons.sc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4172&context=sclr. 24

LSD.Law defines administrative proceedings as follows: “An administrative proceeding is a type of legal process that takes place before a government agency. It can involve a hearing, investigation, or trial, and is usually focused on making a decision about a specific issue or dispute. Sometimes, the process is more like a trial, with evidence presented and a decision made by the agency. Other times, it is more like a discussion or inquiry, with the agency gathering information and making recommendations.” Legal Definitions: administrative proceeding, LSD.Law, https://definitions.lsd.law/administrative-proceeding (June 2026). 25

26

L. Karl Branting & Mia Bonardi, Equalizing Justice: Harnessing AI for Litigants Without Lawyers (2026).

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

92


ENDNOTES

U.S. Dep’t of Health & Hum. Servs., 2026 Poverty Guidelines, Off. of the Assistant Sec’y for Plan. & Evaluation (2026), https://aspe.hhs.gov/topics/poverty-economic-mobility/poverty-guidelines (last visited July 22, 2026). 27

United Way, The State of ALICE in Maryland, United for ALICE, https://unitedforalice.org/introducingALICE/Maryland (last visited July 22, 2026). “ALICE” stands for “Asset Limited, Income Constrained, Employed.” The United Way defines ALICE households as “households with income above the FPL, but below the basic cost of living.” The 2025 report covers data pertaining to 2023. See also United Way, About Us—Meet ALICE, United for ALICE, https://unitedforalice.org/meet-alice?gad_source=1&gad_ campaignid=17215472393&gbraid=0AAAAADwfo_UyPSjADWrdNTcZ8myh5ZR3A&gclid=Cj0KCQjwkILEBhD eARIsAL--pjznh8rFp6NUz0N9vsi66s6MUcduviCd_A_mM-6rZgk7kKiiRlLwonIaAmwOEALw_wcB (last visited Aug. 7, 2026).

28

United Way, The State of ALICE in Maryland, supra note 28. “Of Maryland’s 2,376,785 households in 2023, 10% earned below the Federal Poverty Level (FPL), and 29% were ALICE—households that earned above the FPL, but not enough to afford the ALICE Household Survival Budget for their household composition and location. Combining these two groups, 39% of households in Maryland were below the ALICE Threshold.” 29

Clio, How Much Should I Charge As A Lawyer In Maryland?, (Mar. 2026), https://www.clio.com/resources/ legal-trends/compare-lawyer-rates/md/. 30

Md. Legal Servs. Corp., Fiscal Year 2025 Annual Report 4 (2025), https://www.mlsc.org/wp-content/ uploads/MLSC_AR25.pdf (last visited on July 22, 2026). “MLSC awarded over $60.5 million in operating, Judicare and special project grants.” 31

See, e.g., Md. Legal Aid, Income Guidelines (Feb. 2026), https://www.mdlab.org/get-help-services/incomeguidelines/. Maryland Legal Aid’s 2026 LSC Income Guidelines restrict services to households below 125 percent of the Federal Poverty Income Guidelines.

32

Jessica Bednarz, Closing the Gap: Expanding the Legal Ecosystem for the Middle Class, Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys. (Feb. 5, 2026), https://iaals.du.edu/news/closing-gap-expanding-legalecosystem-middle-class.

33

Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys., Allied Legal Professionals: A National Framework for Program Growth 28, (June 2023), https://iaals.du.edu/sites/default/files/documents/publications/alp_national_ framework.pdf. 34

Emily S. Taylor Poppe & Jeffrey J. Rachlinski, Do Lawyers Matter? The Effect of Legal Representation in Civil Disputes, 43 Pepp. L. Rev. 881, 910-19 (2016), https://digitalcommons.pepperdine.edu/plr/vol43/iss4/1/ ; Hilary W. Hoynes, Nicole Maestas & Alexander Strand, Legal Representation in Disability Claims (2020); Rebecca L. Sandefur, The Impact of Counsel: An Analysis of Empirical Evidence, 9 Seattle Journal for Social Justice 51, 52 (2010). See also Md. Legal Servs. Corp., What is Civil Legal Aid?, https://www.mlsc.org/ about-us/what-is-civil-legal-aid/ (last visited July 22, 2026). See also Legal Servs. Corp., The Economic Case for Civil Legal Aid, https://www.lsc.gov/our-impact/economic-impact#:~:text=Every%20study%20has%20 found%20that,effects%20that%20support%20local%20communities (last visited July 22, 2026).

35

A.B.A. Center for Bar Leadership, 2025 National Lawyer Population Survey (2025), https://www. americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/administrative/news/2025/2025-natl-lawyer-population-survey.pdf (last visited July 22, 2026). 36

U.S. Dep’t of Just., Factsheet: Access to Justice is Rural Access, https://www.justice.gov/archives/atj/factsheet-access-justice-rural-access (last visited July 22, 2026). 37

93


ENDNOTES

William D. Henderson, Legal Market Landscape Report (State Bar of Cal. 2024) (citing U.S. Census Bureau Class of Consumer data). In 1973, 52.2% of law firm revenue came from serving individuals. By 2017, the most recent year for which data is available, only 25.4% of law firm revenue came from serving individuals.

38

See Matt Reynolds, 2023 ‘Profile of the Legal Profession’ Report Spotlights the Scarcity of Legal Aid Lawyers, ABA Journal (Nov. 30, 2023), https://www.abajournal.com/web/article/2023-profile-of-the-legalprofession-spotlights-the-scarcity-of-legal-aid-lawyers (stating that less than 1% of attorneys in the United States (10,000 out of 1.3 million) are legal aid attorneys). 39

40

Burnett & Sandefur, supra note 1, at 1512.

41

Md. R. 19-305.5.

Innovations in Tiered Legal Servs. Task Force, Audit on the Current Use of Allied Legal Professionals in Maryland 3 (May 2026), https://drive.google.com/file/d/1n29IW4StZBymAyg5qo9-Phmq_i7RNy_x/view. 42

Ralph Baxter, Dereliction of Duty: State-Bar Inaction in Response to America’s Access-to-Justice Crisis, 132 Yale L.J.F. 228, 231 (2022), https://yalelawjournal.org/forum/dereliction-of-duty (last visited July 22, 2026). 43

44

Caplan, supra note 23.

For a basic overview of universal human rights, see Am. Ass’n for the Advancement of Sci., Human Rights: A Basic Overview (July 3, 2013), https://www.aaas.org/news/human-rights-basic-overview (last visited July 22, 2026). 45

Community and environmental risk factors that can drive people into the criminal and juvenile justice systems include poverty, economic hardship, high unemployment rates, community violence, a history of physical or sexual abuse, neglect or exposure to domestic violence, and a dearth of local resources. Recognizing this intersectionality, a number of states and localities have incorporated civil justice components that address the collateral civil legal problems contributing to recidivism and family instability. 46

Am. Acad. of Arts & Sci., Civil Justice for All: A Report and Recommendations from the Making Justice Accessible Initiative, supra note 7 .

47

Affordable L. Task Force, Confronting the Access to Justice Crisis of Modest Means Marylanders (2023), https://www.mdaccesstojustice.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Affordable-Law-Task-Force-Report-_-MSBA. pdf.

48

49

Innovations in Tiered Legal Servs. Task Force, supra note 42.

See David Freeman Engstrom, Natalie Knowlton & Lucy Ricca, Legal Innovation After Reform: Five Years of Data on Regulatory Change, Deborah L. Rhode Center on the Legal Profession, June 2, 2025 [hereinafter Five Years], at 10, https://law.stanford.edu/publications/legal-innovation-after-reform-five-years-of-data-onregulatory-change-3/. 50

51

Id.

Md. R. 19-305.5. The Supreme Court of Maryland has inherent and constitutional authority to regulate the practice of law in the state. The separation of powers doctrine in Article 8 of the Maryland Declaration of Rights in the Constitution of Maryland establishes the Judiciary as a co-equal branch of government in Maryland and mandates that the Supreme Court of Maryland retains total control over the practice of law. See Attorney Grievance Comm’n v. Clevenger, 459 Md. 481, 492 (2018) (recognizing the Court’s authority to regulate the practice of law), quoted in Attorney Grievance Comm’n v. Pierre, 485 Md. 56, 8 (2023). 52

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

94


ENDNOTES

53

Engstrom et. al., Five Years, supra note 50.

54

Burnett & Sandefur, supra note 1, at 1512, 1514-1515.

Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys., Allied Legal Professionals: A National Framework for Program Growth, supra note 34, at 1. 55

Cayley Balser et al.,, Leveraging Unauthorized Practice of Law Reform to Advance Access to Justice, 18 Law J. Soc. Just. 66, 67, 68-69 (2023), https://static1.squarespace.com/static/60dcbec3c8e7ab3e5de9acbe/t/ 65dcc9139c579717532b51ee/1708968211859/Leveraging+Unauthorized+Practice+of+Law+Reform+to+Advan ce+Access+to+Justice+-+Law+Journal+for+Social+Justice.pdf. 56

Md. R. 19-305.5.

57

Institute for the Advancement of the American Legal System (IAALS), Regulating AI in the Delivery of Consumer-Facing Legal Services: Unlocking Legal Regulation 9, 12 (July 2025), https://iaals.du.edu/sites/ default/files/documents/publications/ulr_regulating_ai.pdf.

58

59

Id. at 12.

60

Engstrom et. al. Five Years, supra note 50.

Laurel A. Rigertas, The Legal Profession’s Monopoly: Failing To Protect Consumers, 82 Fordham L. Rev. 2683, 2683 (2014), https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/flr/vol82/iss6/6.

61

62

Id.

63

Id.

Nat’l Ctr. for State Cts. & Thomson Reuters Inst., Modernizing Unauthorized Practice of Law Regulations to Embrace AI-Driven Solutions and Improve Access to Justice 15 (Aug. 2025), https://www.ncsc.org/sites/ default/files/media/document/AI_UPL_WhitePaper.pdf (last visited June 17, 2026). 64

65

Id.

Letter from Maggie Goodlander, Deputy Assistant Att’y Gen., Antitrust Div., U.S. Dep’t of Just., to Members of the N.C. Gen. Assemb. (Feb. 14, 2023), https://www.justice.gov/d9/pages/attachments/2023/06/14/414424. pdf . 66

67

Id.

Rebecca L. Sandefur, Legal Advice from Nonlawyers: Consumer Demand, Provider Quality, and Public Harms, 16 Stan. J. C.R. & C.L. 283, 283 (2020), https://www.law.stanford.edu/wp-content/ uploads/2020/06/04-Sandefur-Website.pdf. Professor of Social and Family Dynamics at Arizona State University Rebecca Sandefur posits that states should consider three kinds of empirical evidence when considering nonlawyer legal service tiers: (1) what is the consumer demand for legal advice?; (2) what is the quality of the legal advice being offered by nonlawyers?; and, (3) what harms result from the current restrictions on legal advice by nonlawyers? Sandefur’s research on point was funded in part by the American Bar Foundation, the National Science Foundation, the Open Society Foundations and the Public Welfare Foundation.

68

69

Engstrom et. al., Five Years, supra note 50, at 11.

70

American Bar Association Urges Jurisdictions to Explore Community Justice Worker Programs to Close the Justice Gap, (Frontline Justice, New York, N.Y.), August 14, 2025.

71

ALPs are sometimes also referred to as “authorized justice practitioners.”

95


ENDNOTES

Allied Legal Professionals: A National Framework for Program Growth, Institute for the Advancement of the American Legal System, supra note 34. 72

73

Burnett & Sandefur, supra note 1, at 1512.

74

Sandefur, Legal Advice from Nonlawyers, supra note 68.

75

Id.

76

See Innovations in Tiered Legal Servs. Task Force, supra note 42.

See 5 U.S.C. § 555(b) (“A person compelled to appear in person before an agency . . . is entitled to be accompanied, represented, and advised by counsel or, if permitted by the agency, by other qualified representative.”). See also White House Legal Aid Interagency Roundtable, Access to Justice in Federal Administrative Proceedings: Nonlawyer Assistance and Other Strategies 1 (2023), https://www.justice.gov/ atj/media/1327481/dl. Examples of ALPs who represent or assist parties in agency proceedings include other licensed professionals such as accountants, social workers, and paralegals; law students; union representatives; human resources professionals; corporate officers; tribal advocates; agency employees; community members; and family members. Federal law may specify criteria or processes that an agency must use in determining whether a nonlawyer representative is qualified to represent participants in proceedings before it. See, e.g., 5 U.S.C. § 500(c) (providing that individuals duly qualified to practice as a certified public accountant in a state may represent participants in Internal Revenue Service proceedings upon filing with the agency a written declaration as specified by law).

77

Legal Aid Interagency Roundtable, 2023 Report: Access to Justice in Federal Administrative Proceedings 25 (2023), https://www.justice.gov/atj/media/1327481/dl. For more information about ALPs assisting in federal administrative proceedings, see pages 25–35. 78

79

Innovations in Tiered Legal Servs. Task Force, supra note 42.

80

Frontline Justice, FAQs, https://www.frontlinejustice.org/faqs (last visited July 22, 2026).

Frontline Justice, American Bar Association Urges Jurisdictions to Explore Community Justice Worker Programs to Close the Justice Gap (Aug. 13, 2025), https://www.frontlinejustice.org/news/american-barassociation-urges-jurisdictions-to-explore-community-justice-worker-programs-to-close-the-justice-gap. See also A.B.A., Resolution 605, (V3 2025), https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/administrative/house_ of_delegates/2025-annual-supplemental-materials/605-rev-v3.pdf and A.B.A., ABA House adopts policy on law firm intimidation, immigration issues, ABA News & Insights (Aug. 12, 2025), https://www.americanbar.org/ news/abanews/aba-news-archives/2025/08/annual-meeting-house-of-delegates-actions/ (last visited July 22, 2026).

81

82

Frontline Justice, Homepage, https://www.frontlinejustice.org/.

Legal Aid Interagency Roundtable, 2023 Report: Access to Justice in Federal Administrative Proceedings, 25 (2023), https://www.justice.gov/atj/media/1327481/dl.

83

84

Frontline Justice, supra note 81.

Frontline Justice, Frontline Justice is Supercharging a Movement of Justice Workers, https://www. frontlinejustice.org/about#progress (last visited on July 22, 2026).

85

Map reprinted with permission of Frontline Justice. Map/data obtained from www.frontlinejustice.org/about on July 24, 2026. The data presented is for informational purposes only and may not be accurate or up to date. Users are encouraged to verify all details independently, as Frontline Justice does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of the data.

86

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

96


ENDNOTES

James Teufel, Matthew Burnett & Rebecca L. Sandefur, Research Brief: Analysis of the Social and Economic Impact of Delaware Qualified Tenant Advocates (2022–2025) 4 (Access to Just. Rsch. Initiative, Am. Bar Found. ed. 2026), https://www.americanbarfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/DelawareQualified-Tenant.pdff. 87

88

Burnett & Sandefur, supra note 1.

89

Id.

See generally Alaska Legal Servs. Corp., Community Justice Worker Program, https://www.alsc-law.org/ cjw/ (last visited Aug. 4, 2026). See also Alaska Legal Servs. Corp., Community Justice Worker Resource Center, https://www.akleg.gov/basis/get_documents.asp?docid=2076&session=33 (last visited Aug. 4, 2026). 90

91

Id.

See Alaska Legal Servs. Corp., Community Justice Worker Program, supra note 90. . See also Alaska Cmty. Health Aide Program, Community Health Aide Program, https://www.akchap.org/community-healthaide/ (last visited Aug. 4, 2026). See also Closing the Justice Gap: 92

How to Make the Civil Justice System Accessible to All Americans, Hearing Before the S. Comm. on the Judiciary, 118th Cong. (2024) [hereinafter Hearing] (statement of Nikole Nelson, CEO, Frontline Justice), https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/download/2024-07-09-testimony-nelson?download=1. Alaska Legal Servs. Corp., Community Justice Worker Program, supra note 90. See also Hearing, supra note 92(statement of Nikole Nelson). 93

94

Teufel et al., supra note 87, at 2.

95

Id.

96

Id.

97

Id.

98

Id. at 3.

99

Id.

100 101

Id. at 2.

Id. at 3.

See Press Release, Del. Sup. Ct., Delaware Supreme Court Announces Adoption of New Supreme Court Rule 57.1 to Allow Non-Lawyer Representation of Residential Tenants in Eviction Actions (Jan. 28, 2022), https://courts.delaware.gov/forms/download.aspx?id=133348. Note that Delaware Supreme Court Rule 57 already permitted nonlawyers to represent landlord entities in eviction proceedings before the Justice of the Peace Court; Rule 57.1 expanded representation to tenants in eviction cases, including complex Section 8 and HUD housing cases. See also Molly McPheeters, Qualified Tenant Advocates, Delaware Combined Campaign for Justice (June 30, 2022), https://delawareccj.org/qualified-tenant-advocates/.

102

103

Del. Sup. Ct. R. 57.1, https://courts.delaware.gov/forms/download.aspx?id=174928.

Community Legal Aid Society, Inc.; Delaware Volunteer Legal Services, Inc.; and Legal Services Corporation of Delaware.

104

105

Teufel et al., supra note 87.

106

Id. at 3.

97


ENDNOTES

Id. The housing cases include Section 8 voucher issues (1,303 matters), evictions from public housing (361 matters), public housing quality and habitability concerns, including conditions and code violations (266 matters), and evictions from Section 8 housing (255 matters). 107

108

Id.

109

Id. at 3-4.

Id. at 4.

110 111

Id.

Id. at 5. “Accounting for salary and fringe benefits, as well as training, administrative, and supervision costs, QTAs generated approximately $7 in benefits for every $1 invested. Even during the program’s early stages—when training and startup costs are often highest—the cost per case for QTAs was less than half of the benchmark for low-cost, sustainable justice initiatives in the United States ($580 per case, compared to a benchmark of $1,470 per case).”

112

Id. at 4. “67 percent of clients identified as Black, 80 percent identified as female, 57 percent reported living with a disability, and 9 percent reported experiencing domestic violence.”

113

Id. “Among 113 clients who received services from a QTA and completed a satisfaction survey: 95 percent strongly agreed that they were able to ask questions and discuss their case with the QTA; 90 percent strongly agreed that they would use QTA services again; 89 percent strongly agreed that they were treated courteously; 89 percent strongly agreed that the information provided was easy to understand; 82 percent strongly agreed that they were satisfied with the help received; 78 percent strongly agreed that they learned more about their legal rights; and, 74 percent strongly agreed that their health improved or stress decreased as a result of the services they received.” 114

D.C. Consortium of Legal Services Providers, Virtual Meeting Conducted via Zoom (June 18, 2026, 9:3011:00 AM ET).

115

116

Teufel et al., supra note 87, at 3-4.

117

Id. at 5.

118

Id. at 3-4.

119

See In re Authorizing a Licensed Legal Advoc. Pilot Program for Domestic Violence Cases and Related Matters, Admin. Ord. No. 2020-88(Ariz. Sup. Ct. 2020), https://www.azcourts.gov/Portals/0/22/admorder/ Orders20/2020-88PDF.pdf?ver=2020-06-10-153424-307. 120

Burnett & Sandefur, supra note 1, at 1526.

Id. at 1526-1527. See also In re Authorizing a Licensed Legal Advocate Pilot Program for Domestic Violence Cases and Related Matters, Admin. Ord. No. 2023-21 (Ariz. Sup. Ct. 2023), https://www.azcourts. gov/Portals/0/22/admorder/Orders23/2023-21.pdf?ver=Gfa7XzEbtlj1nWC7Yz78lg%3D%3D.

121

Burnett & Sandefur, supra note 1, at 1527. See In re Authorizing a Housing Stability Legal Advocate Pilot Program, Admin. Order No. 2023-19 (Ariz. Sup. Ct. 2023), https://www.azcourts.gov/Portals/0/22/admorder/ Orders23/2023-19_1.pdf?ver=HeCbksmB24FtC1DEDFCvSg%3d%3d. See also In re Authorizing a Housing Stability Legal Advocate Pilot Program, Admin. Order No. 2024-34 (Ariz. Sup. Ct. 2024), https://www. azcourts.gov/Portals/0/22/admorder/Orders24/2024-34.pdf?ver=_oX3FvQafoxtt-9UdSjrrA%3D%3D.

122

123

Burnett & Sandefur, supra note 1, at 1527.

124

Id. INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

98


ENDNOTES

125

Burnett & Sandefur, supra note 1.

Utah Off. of Legal Servs. Innovation, Homepage, https://utahinnovationoffice.org/ (last visited July 22, 2026).

126

Standing Order No. 15 (Amended) (Utah Sup. Ct. 2022), https://utahinnovationoffice.org/wp-content/ uploads/2022/10/Standing-Order-No.15-Amended-9.21.22.pdf. 127

See State Just. Inst., Utah Regulatory Sandbox Project, https://www.sji.gov/utah-regulatory-sandboxproject/ (last visited July 22, 2026); Utah Off. of Legal Servs. Innovation, supra note 126. 128

Rebecca L. Sandefur & Matthew Burnett, Justice Futures: Access to Justice and the Future of Justice Work, in Rethinking the Lawyers’ Monopoly: Access to Justice and the Future of Legal Services 25 (David Freeman Engstrom & Nora Freeman Engstrom eds. 2025) 10.

129

Burnett & Sandefur, supra note 1, at 1522 (citing Utah Off. of Legal Servs. Innovation, Activity Report: December 2023 1, 4, 7-8 (2023), https://utahinnovationoffice.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/SandboxDecember-Activity-Report.pdf.

130

Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys., Utah Sandbox Evaluation, https://iaals.du.edu/projects/ unlocking-legal-regulation/utah-evaluation (last visited July 22, 2026). IAALS will publish findings for the full pilot period after it concludes.

131

Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys., An Interim Evaluation of Utah’s Legal Regulatory Sandbox: Part 3—Outcomes Evaluation 57 (Nov. 20, 2025), https://iaals.du.edu/sites/default/files/documents/ publications/utah_interim_outcomes_evaluation.pdf.

132

Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys., An Interim Evaluation of Utah’s Legal Regulatory Sandbox: Part 4—Social Return on Investment (SROI) Analysis iii (May 26, 2026) , https://iaals.du.edu/sites/ default/files/documents/publications/utah_interim_sroi.pdf. 133

See generally Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys., Allied Legal Professionals: Project Status: Fostering Program Growth & Alignment around Best Practices, https://iaals.du.edu/projects/allied-legalprofessionals (last visited July 22, 2026).

134

See generally Michael Houlberg & Natalie Anne Knowlton, , Allied Legal Professionals: A National Framework for Program Growth, Institute for the Advancement of the American Legal System (June 2023), https://iaals.du.edu/publications/allied-legal-professionals-national-framework-program-growth.

135

136

Id. at 28.

See Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys., Allied Legal Professionals: Knowledge Center, available at https://iaals.du.edu/projects/allied-legal-professionals/knowledge-center (last visited July 22, 2026).

137

Note that what Maryland has very intentionally elected to refer to as “legal practitioners” are called by different names in different states, but the concept is the same. For example: Legal Paraprofessionals (AZ, MN), Licensed Legal Paraprofessional (CO), Licensed Paralegal (OR), Licensed Paralegal Practitioner (UT), Limited License Legal Technician (WA), Paraprofessional (NH). Some state programs leaders and ALPs have indicated remorse over the initial nomenclature and are exploring a name change. “Legal Practitioners” was identified by IAALS as the ideal. 138

Map reprinted with permission of the IAALS; for the most current version see Allied Legal Professionals: Knowledge Center available at https://iaals.du.edu/projects/allied-legal-professionals/knowledge-center.

139

99


ENDNOTES

Thomas M. Clarke & Rebecca L. Sandefur, Preliminary Evaluation of the Washington State Limited License Legal Technician Program (2017), https://ncsc.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/collection/accessfair/id/405/.

140

141

Id. at 3.

142

Id.

143

Id.

144

Id.

145

Id. at 14.

146

Id. at 15.

147

Id.

148

Id. at 3.

Wash. State Bar Ass’n, Sunset of LLLT Program (March 31, 2023), https://www.wsba.org/for-legalprofessionals/join-the-legal-profession-in-wa/limited-license-legal-technicians/decision-to-sunset-llltprogram?utm_source=chatgpt.com.

149

150 151

Clarke & Sandefur, supra note 140, at 14.

Wash. State Bar Ass’n , Sunset of LLLT Program, supra note 149.

S.J. Mem’l 8006, 69th Leg., 2d Reg. Sess. (Wash. 2026), https://lawfilesext.leg.wa.gov/biennium/2025-26/ Pdf/Bill%20Reports/House/8006%20HBA%20CRJ%2026.pdf?q=20260223103549&utm_source=chatgpt. com.

152

Utah State Bar, New Utah Rule Allows Practice of Law Without Supervision of Lawyer, https://www.utahbar. org/licensed-paralegal-practitioner/about/ (last visited July 22, 2026).

153

154

Id.

155

Id.

156

Id.

157

Id.

158

Id.

159

Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys., supra note 134.

160

Nat’l Ctr. for State Cts. & Thomson Reuters Inst., supra note 64.

161

Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys. & The Hague Inst. for Innovation of L.,

Justice Needs and Satisfaction in the United States of America 11 (2021), https://iaals.du.edu/sites/default/files/documents/publications/justice-needs-and-satisfaction-us.pdf. Maria E. Berkenkotter and Lino S. Lipinsky de Orlov, Can Robot Lawyers Close the Access to Justice Gap, Colorado Lawyer, Dec. 2024, at 42, 43, https://cl.cobar.org/features/can-robot-lawyers-close-the-access-tojustice-gap/.

162

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

100


ENDNOTES

The Data and Legal Technology Committee of the Maryland Access to Justice Commission, in the course of planning an AI & A2J Summit, conducted the AI & A2J Baseline Survey, which asked the question: “Have you encountered clients or potential clients who have used AI tools for legal research or document/case preparation?” 55% of respondents (102 of 187) responded “yes” to this question. The survey was sent to all civil legal aid organizations in Maryland and all types and levels of staff were requested to complete the survey.

163

E-mail from Thomas J. Fisher, Jr., to Md. Access to Just. Comm’n staff (July 30, 2026) (on file with author).

164

Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys., Regulating AI in the Delivery of Consumer-Facing Legal Services: Unlocking Legal Regulation 13 (July 2025), https://iaals.du.edu/sites/default/files/documents/ publications/ulr_regulating_ai.pdf.

165

Id. at 12-13.

166

See generally Ed Walters, Re-Regulating UPL in the Age of AI, American Bar Association (Mar. 1, 2025), https://www.americanbar.org/groups/law_practice/resources/law-practice-magazine/2025/march-april-2025/ re-regulating-upl-in-the-age-of-ai/. 167

Berkenkotter & Lipinsky de Orlo, supra note 162.

168

Stanford Legal Design Lab, Beagle+ Project Description, Justice Bench, https://www.justicebench.org/ project/beagle (last visited July 22, 2026). 169

Beagle+ is powered by ChatGPT, a large language model from OpenAI.

170

People’s L. Sch., How to Test a GenAI Chatbot (Mar. 18, 2025), https://www.peopleslawschool.ca/news/ testing-genai-chatbot/. 171

Stanford Legal Design Lab, supra note 169.

172

Matt Reynolds, LA Court’s Avatar Cuts Wait Times at Counter, Courthouse News Service (Aug. 4, 2016), https://www.courthousenews.com/la-courts-avatar-cutswait-times-at-counter/.

173

174

Branting & Bonardi, supra note 26.

Nat’l Ctr. for State Cts., Key Considerations for the Use of Generative AI Tools in Legal Practice and Courts (Aug. 2025), https://www.ncsc.org/sites/default/files/media/document/KeyConsiderations.pdf. 175

176

Branting & Bonardi, supra note 26.

177

Nat’l Ctr. for State Cts. & Thomson Reuters Inst., supra note 64.

Image provided by and reprinted with permission of the National Center for State Courts. See Nat’l Ctr. for State Cts. & Thomson Reuters Inst., supra note 64.

178

179

Berkenkotter & Lipinsky de Orlo, supra note 162, at 44.

180

Id.

Id. See also Michael Karlik, Colorado Supreme Court Committee Votes to Explore Role of AI in Practice of Law, Colorado Politics (Mar. 8, 2024), https://www.coloradopolitics.com/2024/03/08/colorado-supreme-courtcommittee-votes-to-explore-role-of-ai-in-practice-of-law-608d1244-dcda-11ee-9375-272a46ec8ef5/.

181

Off. of Att’y Regul. Couns., OARC Non-Prosecution Policy Regarding the Unauthorized Practice of Law by Nonlawyers (September 2025), https://www.coloradolegalregulation.com/wp-content/uploads/PDF/ UPL/UPL%20Non-Prosecution%20Policy.pdf. See also Jessica Bednarz & Ericka Byram, Colorado’s New Non-Prosecution Policy Seeks to Balance Innovation, Access, and Consumer Safety, Institute for the Advancement of the American Legal System (Feb. 23, 2026), https://iaals.du.edu/news/colorados-new-nonprosecution-policy-seeks-balance-innovation-access-and-consumer-safety?utm_source=chatgpt.com. 182

101


ENDNOTES

183

Tex. Code Ann. 81-101(c).

184

Nat’l Ctr. for State Cts. & Thomson Reuters Inst., supra note 64, at 29.

185

Utah Off. of Legal Servs. Innovation, supra note 126.

Utah Sup. Ct., Standing Order No. 15 (Aug. 14, 2020), https://legacy.utcourts.gov/utc/rules-approved/ wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2020/08/FINAL-Utah-Supreme-Court-Standing-Order-No.-15.pdf. The day-today administrative functions of the sandbox have been delegated to the Utah State Bar. Letter from Hon. Matthew B. Durrant et al., Utah Sup. Ct., to Kristen K. Woods, Pres., Utah State Bar (Mar. 28, 2023). 186

Utah Off. of Legal Servs. Innovation, Sandbox, https://utahinnovationoffice.org/sandbox/ (last visited July 22, 2026).

187

Utah Sup. Ct., Standing Order No. 15 (Amended) (Sept. 21, 2022), https://legacy.utcourts.gov/rules/ urapdocs/15.pdf.

188

See Engstrom et. al., Five Years, supra note 50. See also David Freeman Engstrom et al., Legal Innovation After Reform: Evidence from Regulatory Change, Deborah L. Rhode Center on the Legal Profession, Sept. 27, 2022. 189

190

See Engstrom et al., Legal Innovation After Reform: Evidence from Regulatory Change, supra note 190.

See Engstrom et. al., Five Years, supra note 50. Note that the conclusion about there being little to no evidence of consumer harm was based strictly on publicly-available information on consumer complaints and disciplinary actions in Utah. 191

192

Id.

193

Id.

194

Wash. State Bar Ass’n, Origins of the Entity Regulation Pilot Project (July 2, 2025),

https://www.wsba.org/about-wsba/entity-regulation-pilot/entity-regulation-pilot-background. 195

In re Adoption of a Pilot Project to Test Entity Regul. Using the Prac. of L. Bd.’s Framework for Legal Regul. Reform, No. 25700-B-721 (Wash. Dec. 5, 2024), https://www.courts.wa.gov/content/publicUpload/ Supreme%20Court%20Orders/Order%2025700-B-721.pdf. See also Wash. State Bar Ass’n, Entity Regulation Pilot Project (Jan. 9, 2026), https://www.wsba.org/about-wsba/entity-regulation-pilot.

196

Wash. State Bar Ass’n, Origins of the Entity Regulation Pilot Project, supra note 195.

197

Wash. State Bar Ass’n, Entity Regulation Pilot Project, supra note 196.

198

Wash. State Bar Ass’n, Origins of the Entity Regulation Pilot Project, supra note 195.

199

Id.

Tom Pack, Innovation with Integrity: AI and Access to Justice, Bench & Bar of Minn. (Oct. 28, 2025), https:// mnbarsorg/?pg=BenchBarofMinnesota&pubAction=viewIssue&pubIssueID=61970&pubIssueItemID=402959.

200

Minn. State Bar Ass’n Working Grp. on AI, Implications of Large Language Models (LLMs) on the Unauthorized Practice of Law (UPL) and Access to Justice (June 2024), https://mnbars. org/?pg=MSBAAnnouncements&blAction=showEntry&blogEntry=112704.

201

202

Pack, supra note 201.

203

Minn. State Bar Ass’n Working Grp. on AI, supra note 202.

204

Id. INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

102


ENDNOTES

205

Alaska Bar R. 63. Unauthorized Practice of Law,

https://courts.alaska.gov/rules/docs/bar.pdf (last visited on July 22, 2026). 206

Nat’l Ctr. for State Cts. & Thomson Reuters Inst., supra note 64, at 28.

207

Id. at 28.

208

Id. at 28, 29.

Sandefur, Legal Advice from Nonlawyers, supra note 68, at 283. Professor of Social and Family Dynamics at Arizona State University Rebecca Sandefur posits that states should consider three kinds of empirical evidence when considering nonlawyer legal service tiers: (1) what is the consumer demand for legal advice?; (2) what is the quality of the legal advice being offered by nonlawyers?; and, (3) what harms result from the current restrictions on legal advice by nonlawyers? Sandefur’s research on point was funded in part by the American Bar Foundation, the National Science Foundation, the Open Society Foundations and the Public Welfare Foundation.

209

Conference of Chief Justices, Resolution 23: Leadership to Promote Equal Justice (Jan. 25, 2001), https:// ccj.ncsc.org/resources-courts/leadership-promote-equal-justice. The two organizations also urged their members to provide leadership in achieving that 100 percent goal and work with their Access to Justice Commission or other such entities to develop a strategic plan with realistic and measurable outcomes, and urged the National Center for State Courts and other national organizations to develop tools and provide assistance to states in achieving the goal of 100% access through a continuum of meaningful and appropriate services.

210

Note that because the bulk of UPL and ALICE populations’ unmet civil legal needs fall so heavily into certain areas of law (such as housing, domestic violence and family law, public benefits, consumer debt, etc.), exempting ALPs or legal technology tools from UPL in one area of law while declining to exempt them in other areas of law is rationally related to a legitimate government interest (i.e., balancing consumer protection and access to justice concerns).

211

Complex litigation typically describes civil legal cases that require exceptional management. Examples could include actions involving numerous parties, voluminous evidence, complicated disputes, or lengthy trials exceeding three days. Presentation of evidence typically refers to the in-court process of introducing testimony, documents, or physical items to prove a fact. Governed by the Maryland Rules of Evidence, this phase requires laying a proper foundation, marking items as exhibits, and giving the opposing side an opportunity to cross-examine or object.

212

MDEC is the Maryland Judiciary’s integrated case management and electronic filing (e-filing) system that replaced paper files. MDEC allows court documents to be submitted, viewed, and processed digitally across all levels of the state court system.

213

Note that because the bulk of UPL and ALICE populations’ unmet civil legal needs fall so heavily into certain areas of law (such as housing, domestic violence and family law, public benefits, consumer debt, etc.), exempting ALPs or legal technology tools from UPL in one area of law while declining to exempt them in other areas of law is rationally related to a legitimate government interest (i.e., balancing consumer protection and access to justice concerns).

214

215

Clarke & Sandefur, supra note 140, at 15.

216

Id.

217

Id. at 14.

103


ENDNOTES

The Maryland Character Questionnaire states: “Undocumented immigration status, by itself, does not preclude admission to the Bar, provided that the applicant otherwise establishes good moral character and fitness for admission. If you are not a U.S Citizen, attach a copy of the document(s) authorizing your presence in the United States. See Maryland Rule 19-204(d).” 218

Shifting legal practitioners’ training to the state’s community college system was one of only nine recommendations for improvement flowing from Washington’s LLLT program evaluation. See Clarke & Sandefur, supra note 140, at 14.

219

MDEC is the Maryland Judiciary’s integrated case management and electronic filing (e-filing) system that replaced paper files. MDEC allows court documents to be submitted, viewed, and processed digitally across all levels of the state court system.

220

Low bono rates provide a basis for comparison for Maryland legal practitioner rates. States’ practitioner programs that operate within a regulatory sandbox environment tend to be embedded in the legal aid framework, inherently rendering legal practitioners’ services free of charge to clients.

221

222

See, e.g., Upsolve, Inc. v. James, 155 F.4th 133 (2d Cir. 2025).

Note that because the bulk of UPL and ALICE populations’ unmet civil legal needs fall so heavily into certain areas of law (such as housing, domestic violence and family law, public benefits, consumer debt, etc.), exempting ALPs or legal technology tools from UPL in one area of law while declining to exempt them in other areas of law is rationally related to a legitimate government interest (i.e., balancing consumer protection and access to justice concerns). 223

224

Rasa Legal, Welcome Page, https://rasa-legal.com/welcome-ga_004/ (last visited July 22, 2026).

An Alternative Business Structure (ABS) is a regulatory model that eliminates the rule prohibiting nonlawyers from owning or heavily managing law firms, thereby allowing lawyers and nonlawyers (such as technology companies) to jointly own, invest in, and manage a legal services business. See Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys., Alternative Business Structures Evaluation Blueprint, https://iaals.du.edu/ projects/unlocking-legal-regulation/abs-evaluation-blueprint (last visited July 22, 2026). “[T]he Arizona Supreme Court abolished the longstanding rule that prohibited nonlawyers from owning law firms, allowing firms in Arizona to test new ownership models to increase innovation and improve access to legal services.” 225

Salt Lake Chamber, Rasa Public Benefit Corporation, https://business.slchamber.com/list/member/rasapublic-benefit-corporation-104836 (last visited July 22, 2026).

226

Nathan Chappell, Why Nonprofits Must Adopt a Human-First, AI-Forward Mindset, Nonprofit Tech for Good (Nov. 3, 2025), https://www.nptechforgood.com/2025/11/03/why-nonprofits-must-adopt-a-human-firstai-forward-mindset/.

227

228

Id.

Letter from Hon. Matthew B. Durrant et al., Utah Sup. Ct., to Legal Serv. Innovation Comm. 2-3 (Sept. 5, 2024) [hereinafter 2024 Letter to Innovation Comm.]. Previously-authorized entities that were unable to meet both the new heightened innovation and nexus requirements were required to exit Utah’s sandbox.

229

Jeffrey D. Eisenberg, The Sandbox, Utah Bar J. (Nov./Dec. 2022) (expressing concern that entities are not working “in the areas identified by the Work Group in 2019 as legally underserved”). 230

Neil Hodge, AI and Regulatory Sandboxes, Int’l Bar Ass’n (Mar. 16, 2026), https://www.ibanet.org/AI-andregulatory-sandboxes.

231

INNOVATIONS IN TIERED LEGAL SERVICES TASK FORCE FINAL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS

104


ENDNOTES

Deirdre Ahern, Operationalising AI Regulatory Sandboxes Under the EU AI Act (2025), https://arxiv.org/ abs/2509.05985. 232

See Hilary J. Allen, Sandbox Boundaries, 22 Vand. J. Ent. & Tech. L. 299 (2020), : https://scholarship.law. vanderbilt.edu/jetlaw/vol22/iss2/3/. 233

See Hilary J. Allen, Regulatory Sandboxes: One Decade On, 56 Geo. J. Int’l L. 667 (2025). https://www. law.georgetown.edu/international-law-journal/in-print/volume-56/volume-56-number-3-fall-2025/regulatorysandboxes-one-decade-on/. 234

Pew Charitable Trs., How to Make Civil Courts More Open, Effective, and Equitable (Dec. 13, 2023), https:// www.pew.org/en/research-and-analysis/reports/2023/09/how-to-make-civil-courts-more-open-effective-andequitable. 235

236

Dean L. Fixsen, Karen A. Blase & Melissa K. Van Dyke, Implementation Practice & Science (2019).

See John P. Kotter, Leading Change (1996). See also Bryan J. Weiner et. el., Organizational Readiness for Change: What We Know, What We Think We Know, and What We Need to Know (Bianca Albers, Aron Shlonsky & Robyn Mildon eds. 2020). See also Implementation Science 3.0 (Bianca Albers, Aron Shlonsky & Robyn Mildon eds. 2020).

237

See Jonathan P. Scaccia et. al., A practical implementation science heuristic for organizational readiness: R=MC2, 43 J. Cmty. Psych. 484 (2015). See also Laura J. Damschroder et. al., The updated Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research based on user feedback, Implementation Sci., Oct. 29, 2022.

238

239

Branting & Bonardi, supra note 26.

240

Innovations in Tiered Legal Servs. Task Force, supra note 42.

One example is DOJ-Accredited Representatives (last visited July 22, 2026), nonlawyers who, for more than 60 years, have received authorization from the U.S. Department of Justice to assist or represent parties in immigration proceedings.

241

See Maryland Legal Services Corporation, What We Do, https://www.mlsc.org/about-us/what-we-do/ (last visited July 22, 2026).

242

Examples include LevittQuinn Family Law Center’s Modest Means Project; Jacksonville Area Legal Aid’s Family Law Assistance at Reduced Expense (FLARE) program; the DC Affordable Law Firm, The Commons Law Center, Charleston Legal Access, Inner Banks Legal Services, Chicago Advocate Legal, and Bridge to Justice. 243

Examples of legal incubator programs can be found here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/ d/1sMCmz3Ec1NHwHcW4fyD4_mew2hTnrc9GzByJ-A8JPys/edit?gid=0#gid=0 (last visited on July 22, 2026).

244

An example is University of Nebraska College of Law’s Rural Law Opportunities Program (last visited July 22, 2026).

245

One example is Arizona’s Legal Document Preparer Program (last visited July 22, 2026) which has certified several hundred nonlawyers to provide document preparation assistance and services to SRLs.

246

Legal Link (last visited July 22, 2026), a nonprofit organization in the San Francisco Bay Area, has developed a curriculum and web-based tools to train community-based organizations across the country to spot legal issues and provide targeted legal information and referrals.

247

105


ENDNOTES

One example is New York’s Courts Access to Justice Program (last visited July 22, 2026), which trains community members and students to assist SRLs in civil and housing courts. Another example is Washington, D.C.’s District of Columbia Court Navigator Program (last visited July 22, 2026), which assists people with civil actions, small claims, probate, and landlord-tenant matters, including reserving computers for remote hearings. 248

One example is the Maryland Center for Legal Assistance (MCLA) (last visited July 22, 2026). MCLA is a court-funded initiative that provides free, compassionate, innovative, and high-quality legal services through comprehensive legal advice, education, and collaboration with community partners. It operates statewide with phone, email, chat, and in-person assistance at courthouses.

249

Thurgood Marshall State Law Library is Maryland’s primary public state law library. It offers extensive collections, access to premium legal databases, and specialized federal depository resources.

250

H.B. 1544, 2026 Leg., Reg. Sess. (Md. 2026) (establishing the Maryland Justice Corps Program to create an alternative pathway to licensure to practice law).

251

252

See Engstrom et. al., Five Years, supra note 50, at 7.

Andrea L. Miller, Paula Hannaford-Agor & Kathryn Genthon, An Evaluation Framework for Allied Legal Professional Programs: Assessing Improvements in Access to Justice (Nat’l Ctr. for State Cts. 2021), https:// ncsc.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/collection/legserv/id/99. 253

Michael Houlberg, Courtney Petersen-Rhead & Kristy Clairmont, Building Bridges: Guidelines for Creating Reciprocity between Allied Legal Professional Programs (June 18, 2025), Inst. for the Advancement of the Am. Legal Sys., https://iaals.du.edu/publications/building-bridges.

254

255

Id.

Press Release, Nat’l Ctr. for State Cts., Top judicial officials: State supreme courts must lead innovation and reform of legal education and admissions (July 30, 2025), https://www.ncsc.org/news/top-judicial-officialsstate-supreme-courts-must-lead-innovation-and-reform-legal-education.

256

E-mail from Loretta Rush, Indiana Supreme Court chief justice, president of the Conference of Chief Justices, to Casey Chiappetta, principal associate, The Pew Charitable Trs. (April 6, 2023) (cited in Pew Charitable Trs., How to Make Civil Courts More Open, Effective, and Equitable, n.3 (Sept. 27, 2023), https:// www.pew.org/en/research-and-analysis/reports/2023/09/how-to-make-civil-courts-more-open-effective-andequitable.

257

Am. Bar Ass’n, What Is Expungement? (Feb. 12, 2020), https://www.americanbar.org/groups/public_ education/publications/teaching-legal-docs/what-is-_expungement-/. 258

259

Innovations in Tiered Legal Servs. Task Force, supra note 42.


Innovations in Tiered Legal Services Task Force Final Report and Recommendations