Skip to main content

I by IMD magazine - The sustainability transformation issue

Page 1

#11 Sept-Nov 2023

DID FRIEDMAN WIN? NEW RULES ON TALENT

THE RISE OF THE CSO

CLOSING THE SKILLS GAP

TRIPLE BOTTOM LINE REIMAGINED

20 CHF

SUSTAINABILITY TRANSFORMATION A CLEAR VISION FOR A PROSPEROUS FUTURE

ENGAGE OR DIVEST? LEADING SYSTEMS CHANGE

NAVIGATING ESG RULES ibyimd.org


Forge your path to a sustainable future IMD’s Leading Sustainable Business Transformation program empowers you to bridge the knowing-doing gap in spearheading sustainable business changes, while finding renewed purpose. Learn in action Tackle your unique sustainability challenge, crafting a concrete roadmap for successful transformation, ready to action back in your organization. Build your sustainability foundations Explore technology, business model, and organizational implications of embedding sustainability company-wide. Discover best practices Dive into ESG and sustainability best practices, risks and opportunities, deriving insights from top-ranked sustainability enterprises.

Take the next step imd.org/lsbt


[ Foreword ]

We all have a stake in the future, so let’s use it wisely

T

ransforming organizations to become more sustainable is perhaps the defining leadership challenge of our time. The need for change is now urgent, from both a climate and a social perspective. This transformation is a deeply complex and unique task for every business and industry. At IMD, we are fortunate to have the opportunity to learn from and support a diverse range of leaders and organizations as they navigate their way through it. This edition of I by IMD draws on these experiences, as well as deep insights from external experts, to explore the key factors of the sustainable business transformation challenge – from regulation and business models to purpose and talent.

Illustration: Jörn Kaspuhl

Temasek head Dilhan Pillay observes, in our regular CEO Dialogue feature, that stewarding today’s assets for the benefit of those not yet born requires a serious consideration of difficult trade-offs that must be made right away. So, how do we guide our organizations past the fog of challenged planetary boundaries and social inequity toward a state of being sustainable, inclusive, and prosperous? “The future may already be here, but at times it can be damned hard to find,” observes John Elkington, the creator of the triple-bottom-line concept, calling on business to take things a step further toward regeneration.

sponsibilities that CSOs need to shoulder to pilot and orchestrate the transformation journey. Sam Gill and Jan van der Kaaij highlight the new role that boards must play in this journey as well as the threat of the ESG reporting trap – when a company spends more resources on reporting than it does on actually changing the game. Michael Skapinker despairs that neither of the two investment strategies to bring fossil fuel companies to a heel has been particularly effective: divestment equates abdication to more callous investors, and remaining invested in order to drive change requires superhuman patience. He asks: “Could there be a third way?” As always, our issue brims with sparkling insights from our regular columnists. Jerry Davis notes that corporations and their employees were much more rooted in a local context when Milton Friedman famously pronounced that companies had no other welfare obligations than to churn out profits for shareholders. Given that most contemporary corporations are “rootless cosmopolitans”, reading Jerry’s column makes me wonder: if Friedman were to be around today, would he make the same pronouncement? And Shelley Zalis provides a timely reminder of the rising importance of certification and access to training to plug the global tech skills gap.

In our framing article, Jean-François Manzoni, President of IMD, and Julia Binder offer a compelling strategic and organizational framework that organizations can deploy to kickstart their transformation. Knut Haanaes and Bryony Jansen-van Tuyll present the “future back” tool that encourages leaders to imagine that a desirable future state for their organizations has already been achieved in order to work out the necessary steps back from there. Sudhanshu Sarronwala argues that sustainability transformations are likely to work only when companies embed an externally oriented and holistic purpose of “doing the right things”.

We hope you enjoy reading this edition of I by IMD, and that the articles we present here resonate with you by offering relatable, relevant insights and clear, actionable impact as you seek to lead and transform your organizations. Dive in! ■

Natalia Olynec traces the evolution and explosion in popularity of the Chief Sustainability Officer (CSO) role, outlining the re-

Anand Narasimhan, Dean of Research Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 1


[ CONTENTS ] 04 [ In good company ]

Milton Friedman’s “profits above all” was the doctrine of the 1970s. While the look of big business in the US has evolved beyond recognition, the motivations seem little changed, argues Jerry Davis.

43

#11 Sept-Nov 2023

THE RISE OF THE CSO

DID FRIEDMAN WIN? NEW RULES ON TALENT

[ Sustainability transformation ]

CLOSING THE SKILLS GAP

TRIPLE BOTTOM LINE REIMAGINED

20 CHF

SUSTAINABILITY TRANSFORMATION A CLEAR VISION FOR A PROSPEROUS FUTURE

ENGAGE OR DIVEST? LEADING SYSTEMS CHANGE

NAVIGATING ESG RULES ibyimd.org

11_IMD_2023_Edition_11_Sept-Nov_2023_COVER_Final_PROOF.indd 19

04.09.23 12:34

Our 39-page in-depth report offers up-to-the-minute analysis and guidance on the best way of delivering a successful sustainable business transformation.

07 Jean-François Manzoni and Julia Binder set out a clear vision for sustainable business transformation that not only includes environmental sustainability but also social and economic inclusion. 14 The fast-paced developments in

global ESG regulations are transforming the position of the board of directors from one based on engagement to one requiring true commitment, write Sam Gill and

Jan van der Kaaij.

18 The Church of England has moved

away from engagement and sold its fossil fuel shares, but to whose benefit? Michael Skapinker explores the arguments.

21 Focusing on a company’s triple

bottom line has yielded mixed results. Sudhanshu Sarronwala offers advice on how all businesses can “do the right thing”. 2 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

24 John Elkington created the concept of the triple bottom line. Now he is an advocate of the 3Rs: responsibility, resilience, and regeneration.

28 Using the “Future Back” tool can set

your organization on the path to a successful sustainable business transformation. Knut Haanaes and Bryony Jansen-van Tuyll explain how it works.

32 More than 300 sustainability standards

and eco-labels have been established. A new legal framework is needed to cut through the jungle, argue Jonathan Normand and Fabio Monnet of B Lab Switzerland.

58 39 The I reader: IMD professors recommend five books to help you navigate the complexities of sustainable business transformation.

40 Amanda Williams and Knut Haanaes

talk to systems-change leaders to explore how organizations can collaborate across sectors and supply chains to keep within Earth’s limits.

43 Chief sustainability officers are becoming more senior and cross-functional. They need the ability and skills to address ESG issues across the spectrum. Suitable candidates are rare and a “talent war” is raging, writes Natalia Olynec.

36 CEO dialogue: CEO of Singapore’s

global investment giant Temasek, Dilhan Pillay, discusses the importance of a carbon tax with Jean-François Manzoni and explains how his company is working to ensure ‘every generation prospers’.

28


46 [ The human touch ]

Policymakers and business can raise “techquity” in the global labor market by improving access to digital skills training, writes Shelley Zalis.

47 [ I quote ]

Be inspired by some pearls of wisdom taken from a book of quotations compiled by IMD’s Dominique Turpin.

48 [ Finance ]

36 73

Measuring economic profits rather than accounting profits is a far more reliable indicator of a company’s performance, argue Simon Evenett and Felix Reitz. And value-creating firms are well-equipped to help fund sustainability.

Illustration: Jörn Kaspuhl ; Photos: Yasunobu Tamari, Wikipedia, Pinterest, Infarm, Temasek, Egon Zehnder

46

67

56 [ In the mind's eye ]

The COVID-19 pandemic altered the art of leadership. George Kohlrieser suggests seven changes that are worth making permanent.

58 [ Team spirit ]

Mayuka Yamazaki explains how working as a team on

21 67 [ Human resources ]

ikebana, the Japanese art of flower arrangement, can help us to become better leaders.

Job roles are continuously evolving, leaving many talent management practices in the dust. Tania Lennon and Mikolaj Jan Piskorski suggest new rules to upgrade your talent strategy.

63 [ Future investing ]

70 [ In my view ]

Executives need to be equipped with the tools to take a more integrated approach to impact and business. The impact economy offers alternatives and inspiration, write Vanina

Farber, Patrick Reichert, and Shih-Han Huang.

Technology may lead to a more efficient process, but it’s not the best option if it worsens the customer experience. Sometimes going back to the whiteboard is better, writes Bali Padda.

73 [ The forecaster ]

Coca-Cola has been forced to diversify to cater for rapidly changing tastes. We can all learn from the company’s agility and adaptability, writes Howard Yu.

76 [ Preview ]

Join us in December when I by IMD will focus on the increasingly important role of the impact economy. Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 3


[ In good company ]

Friedman and the case against social responsibility: did he win after all? Profits before all was the doctrine espoused in the 1970s, and while the look of big business in America has evolved beyond recognition, the motivations seem little changed, argues Jerry Davis

Opponents of ESG and those who decry corporate social responsibility almost inevitably harken back to an article published a half-century ago by Nobel prize-winning economist Milton Friedman in the New York Times Sunday Magazine. The headline gives away the punchline: “A Friedman doctrine – The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits.” In the decades since it appeared, this short piece has become one of the most widely assigned articles in business schools, often paired with a reading on stakeholder capitalism on the obligatory ethics day. As a piece of writing, it is a slippery work of sophistry full of hidden premises and hairpin turns. But its impact on the discourse cannot be denied, even as the world of business has been fundamentally transformed in ways that render its arguments in favor of unbridled capitalism and against corporate do-gooding sketchier. The Friedman doctrine in brief

Friedman’s argument runs as follows: only a person can have a responsibility, not “business”. Corporate executives, as people, are responsible to the corporation’s owners to make as much money for them as pos4 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

sible – executives are agents acting on behalf of the shareholder-principals who employ them, and shareholders love profits. If executives engage in do-gooding that reduces returns to shareholders (say, by cutting pollution more than is required by law), they are illegitimately imposing additional taxes on their employers and spending the income from those taxes at their own discretion. Taxing and spending are the functions of elected government, not unelected businesspeople, and allocating resources through politics rather than markets is socialism. Moreover, business executives have no particular expertise in pursuing goals beyond profit, and if they try their shareholders will probably fire them. Do-gooding is permissible when it ultimately contributes to profits – say, supporting amenities in the community that make it easier to attract and retain talented employees, or to reduce pilferage and sabotage. But these actions are only justified if they contribute to the corporation’s self-interest. The article closes with a flourish on the proper place of markets and politics in making societal choices. Markets involve voluntary cooperation for mutual benefit with unanimous consent. Politics requires conformity to decisions handed down by “a church, or a dictator, or a majority,” enforced by “the iron fist of government bureaucrats”. The choice for businesspeople was clear: maximize profits and avoid “social responsibility”, or be a hapless tool of socialism on the road to serfdom. Friedman left out a couple of steps in his fevered dash. In particular, the moral case for maximizing profits may not be entirely intuitive, so here’s what he might have said. Profit represents the difference between what it costs to create a good or service and how much customers are willing

Illustration: Jörn Kaspuhl

C

an businesses do well by doing good? Should they? This question has eluded resolution for generations and is now taken up by Republican presidential candidates in the US from Ron DeSantis to Mike Pence, who are campaigning against ESG investing and what they see as the sinister threat of “corporate wokeism”. One candidate, pharma investor Vivek Ramaswamy, has even published an anti-ESG screed titled Woke Inc. and launched a family of anti-ESG exchange traded funds, evidently to prove that you can still do well by not doing good.


to pay for it. If customers voluntarily buy something, they must value it at least as much as they paid for it (unless there was deception involved – and Friedman believes businesses shouldn’t deceive). Participants in the enterprise are all volunteers: workers, suppliers, and lenders agree to a fixed price for their contribution, and shareholders get whatever is left, that is, the profit. In this unanimous and voluntary cooperative venture, profit is both a motivator and a measure of the good that the venture has done for its voluntary customers. The greater the profit, the greater the social benefit. QED: business is off the hook for doing good if it does not yield a profit, because profit is good in itself. The context: an economy dominated by ‘Big Business’

The year 1970, when Friedman’s article was published, was arguably the high-water mark for “Big Business” in America. Unscathed by the Second World War, American industry had experienced astonishing growth and become an export powerhouse over the prior generation. Its biggest enterprises kept getting bigger: 25 corporations employed the equivalent of 10% of the US workforce. Big companies paid better than small firms and provided pathways for upward mobility for their

‘Unlikely as it may have seemed, Nixon presided over one of the greatest expansions of corporate regulation in American history’ career employees, growing a prosperous middle class. Moreover, in contrast to Europe, where governments provided health care and old-age income security for their citizens, these responsibilities fell to business. American corporations were like miniature welfare states, and it was no surprise that they were called on to exercise “social responsibility”. Many of them had annual revenues that surpassed all but the largest economies’ GDPs. Consider the 10 biggest American corporations in 1970. Many were vertically integrated manufacturers operating large-scale facilities in the heartland. As Peter Drucker, one of the founders of modern management thinking, had pointed out a generation earlier, Ford’s River Rouge plant (where both my grandfathers worked as welders) was a microcosm of industrial society, employing tens of thousands of people for their entire adult lives in a massive and intricately coordinated enterprise. It is no wonder corporations came to be “imagined communities” on the same plane as states and were expected to be responsive to the popular will. To create and sustain such an enterprise required collaboration among workers, suppliers, investors, and communities – a vast array of diverse interests all brought into harmony by market exchange, according to the Friedman dogma. To impose additional responsibilities on this fragile achievement was beyond the pale, and it was Friedman’s mission to put a stop to it.

TEN LARGEST US CORPORATIONS BY REVENUES, 1970 COMPANY

EMPLOYEES

HEADQUARTERS STATE

General Motors AT&T Exxon (Standard Oil of NJ) Ford Motor Sears Roebuck General Electric IBM Mobil Chrysler ITT

696 773 143 432 359 397 269 76 228 392

Michigan New York New York Michigan Illinois New York New York New York Michigan New York

(thousands)

TEN LARGEST US CORPORATIONS BY REVENUES, 2022 COMPANY

EMPLOYEES

HEADQUARTERS STATE

Walmart Amazon ExxonMobil Apple UnitedHealth Group CVS Health Alphabet McKesson AmerisourceBergen Berkshire Hathaway

2,100 1,541 62 164 400 300 190 51 44 383

Arkansas Washington Texas California Minnesota Rhode Island California Texas Pennsylvania Nebraska

(thousands)

Social responsibility from above

And yet before the ink was dry on Friedman’s article, the “iron fist of government bureaucrats” was about to pummel Big Business into socially responsible submission – thanks to Richard Nixon. Unlikely as it may have seemed, Nixon presided over one of the greatest expansions of corporate regulation in American history. In December 1970, the Environmental Protection Agency was launched to define and enforce environmental standards – taking specific aim at auto emissions and factory pollution. Later that month, Nixon signed the Occupational Safety and Health Act, creating another regulatory agency to make workplaces safer. The Consumer Product Safety Commission was launched in 1972 “to protect the American public from dangerous and deadly products”. And the Equal Employment Opportunity Act of 1972 gave the EEOC litigation authority to take on discriminatory employment practices in order to make the workplace more equitable for women and people of color. Big Business was suddenly drowning in requirements to meet environmental, social, and governance standards. » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 5


[ In good company ]

How does this square with the case against voluntary social responsibility? Friedman had stipulated at the start of his article that the business executive’s responsibility was “to make as much money as possible while conforming to the basic rules of the society, both those embodied in law and those embodied in ethical custom”. But what if those laws started to feel too restrictive or costly for businesses in their socially responsible pursuit of optimizing profit for their shareholders? Friedman had made clear his disdain for having to conform to the will of a “church, or a dictator, or a majority”. By the end of the piece, his doctrine had lost

‘Hilfiger is no more American than teenagers who wear Polo shirts, Hilfiger pants, and Timberland shoes are citizens of Ralph Lauren’ an important constraint: “There is one and only one social responsibility of business – to use its resources and engage in activities designed to increase its profits so long as it stays within the rules of the game, which is to say engages in open and free competition without deception or fraud.” Abracadabra: law and ethical custom had dropped out of the equation and all that was left was the pursuit of profit without deception. As in a Dostoevsky novel, all is permitted. And business is awfully clever when it comes to navigating its way out of unwanted constraints. ‘Law and custom’ as a choice

National laws may have seemed like a lamentable constraint when Friedman was writing, but over the subsequent years law became more of a choice for business. Corporations have grown skilled at optimizing where they incorporate, the nominal jurisdiction where their wares are sold, the legal home for their intellectual property, where they declare their profits, and where they source their labor (if anywhere). For business, the law is simply an operating system, to be chosen the same way as accounting systems or server software. Delaware, Bermuda, Liberia – all are simply competing vendors courting their corporate customers. And as the vertically integrated behemoths of the past gave way to the “Nikefied” virtual enterprise of the present, the choices have exploded. As Financial Times commentator Martin Wolf memorably put it (with a nod to Stalin), today’s corporations are “rootless cosmopolitans”. In my 2009 book Managed by the Markets, I described the all-American fashion brand Tommy Hilfiger: the company was “headquartered in Hong Kong, incorporated in the British Virgin Islands, held its annual meeting in Barbados, listed its shares on the New York Stock Exchange, and contracted manufacturing to vendors in Mexico and East Asia. (There is also a person named Tommy Hilfiger, who lives on Long Island.) Hilfiger is no more American than teenagers who wear Polo shirts, Hilfiger pants, and Timberland shoes are citizens of Ralph Lauren.” When Accenture went public in 2001, it was incorporated in Bermuda, where it joined a gaggle of crypto-American insurance companies. In 2009, proposed tax changes from the Obama administration encour6 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

aged the consultancy to re-incorporate in Ireland, where it was joined by Medtronic, Johnson Controls, and several pharmaceutical companies. It is unclear how many of Accenture’s 721,000 employees consider Ireland home. Judging from the pharmaceutical and software profits booked in Ireland, it must be both the sickest and the most tech-savvy country on the planet. Six of America’s biggest pharma companies recorded 90% of their profits overseas in 2022, despite the fact that the majority of their sales were in the US. And in 2020, a Microsoft subsidiary in Ireland reported profits of $315 billion – equal to three-quarters of Ireland’s GDP – despite the entity having no actual employees. And then there is e-Estonia, a virtual jurisdiction where one can gain virtual citizenship for online businesses and draw on incorporation, banking, and payment systems – all without leaving the comfort of one’s laptop, wherever it happens to be. It turns out that “law and custom” cannot slow down a company convinced of its duty to maximize profits. If you don’t like the law and custom where you are, it’s easy to relocate to a more congenial jurisdiction. Big Business today

The biggest American businesses today bear little resemblance to the industrial giants that dominated the economy when Friedman wrote. Today’s enterprises are dispersed both geographically and organizationally. The 1970 cohort’s headquarters were concentrated in New York, Detroit, and Chicago – today’s group is scattered across the country. And while the Rouge plant employed 100,000 people, Apple’s retail stores average perhaps 100 staff each; a Walmart supercenter might have 350 workers, and an Amazon warehouse between 1,000 to 1,500. In contrast to the high wages and career-long employment of the 1970 group, retail work today is notable for its low pay and high turnover, with Amazon’s hourly workforce reportedly experiencing an astounding 150% annual turnover rate. Today’s big enterprises are rarely the enveloping, community-defining institutions from Friedman’s time, and they retain only the faintest attachment to specific physical places (or tax or legal authorities). In fact, they defy attachment to any particular community to which they might owe some kind of social responsibility. Perhaps Friedman won after all. ■

Jerry Davis is the Gilbert and Ruth Whitaker Professor of Business Administration and Professor of Sociology at the University of Michigan’s Ross School of Business. He has published widely on management, sociology, and finance. His latest book is Taming Corporate Power in the 21st Century (Cambridge University Press, 2022), part of the Cambridge Elements Series on Reinventing Capitalism.


[ Sustainability transformation ]

A clear vision for sustainable business transformation Sustainable business contributes to the success of all its stakeholders and helps the next generation to enjoy a prosperous future. But, as Jean-François Manzoni and Julia Binder explain, this includes not only environmental sustainability but also social and economic inclusion. Over the following 39 pages, our experts examine how to achieve these ambitious goals.

W Photo: Daniel Lerman via Unsplash

e live in extraordinary times. Over the last few decades, the globalized world economy has generated huge amounts of wealth and helped to lift hundreds of millions of people out of deep poverty. Advances in health care have raised life expectancy in almost all countries in the world, access to knowledge has increased dramatically, and the world of work has become more inclusive.

Despite the prosperity and progress of recent times, the world urgently needs to transition to a more sustainable economic model. Among many signs thereof, the last eight years have been the warmest on record. And July 2023 was the hottest month ever recorded by a wide margin – a grim reminder that climate change is already disrupting life around the world. The scientific consensus is unequivocal: greenhouse gas emissions are harming our way of life, and there is an urgent need to reduce them. » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 7


[ Sustainability transformation ]

Sadly, the climate crisis is not the only major challenge. We are also headed for crises involving water scarcity and decreasing biodiversity. Beyond the environment, we observe significant civil unrest all over the world, powered by individuals and communities who do not believe that their governments and “the system” are operating in their best interests. Trust in leaders and corporations is decreasing, too, and anxiety about the future is rising. At IMD, our purpose is to develop leaders and organizations that contribute to a more prosperous, sustainable, and inclusive world. In this article, we will often use the word “sustainable” in a holistic sense, including environmental sustainability but also going beyond to refer to a form of stewardship. Hereafter, a “sustainable business” contributes to the success of all its stakeholders and helps the next generation achieve its goals and enjoy a prosperous future. This includes not only environmental sustainability but also social and economic inclusion. In simple terms, we want to help leaders and organizations to do well (financially) by doing good (for the world). We are very fortunate to have been able to study and work with organizations that started earlier than most on their sustainability transition. Studying the trajectories of these pioneers, we have realized that their transformations have some things in common, including that they always involved significant changes on both the strategic and the organizational fronts. In the rest of this article, we present a conceptual framework that identifies some of the key decisions that leaders and organizations must make to guide their organizations in a more prosperous, sustainable, and inclusive direction. Four reasons sustainability has taken on a new urgency

For quite some time, our discussions with boards and top management teams tended to include a lot of time and energy spent explaining why sustainability-related threats and opportunities were much broader and more important than mere “corporate social responsibility”. Top teams thought of sustainability as a cost and an imposition, and they often tried to minimize their spending on it. Nowadays, conversations no longer revolve around “why?”; they are much more centered around “how – and how fast – to manage the sustainable transformation?” This evolution stems from four interdependent and complementary transitions: First, regulators are and will increasingly be penalizing companies that degrade the environment. Carbon prices are in place in many parts of the world, and the US, long a laggard on climate policy, has finally passed major legislation in the form of the Inflation Reduction Act. It focuses more on carrots (subsidies) than sticks (taxes), but the outcome is the same: companies involved in decarbonization are being given a considerable advantage relative to those reliant on fossil fuels. And the pressure from regulators goes beyond climate: In 2021, the European Union announced the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) that 8 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

will significantly increase the amount of sustainability reporting that companies are required to do. At the same time, it provides incentives for companies to engage in sustainable investments and innovation through the “European Green Deal”. Second, employees and customers increasingly demand environmental and/or social performance from the companies they work for and buy from. Executives we’ve spoken with have joked that they can’t believe they complained about the “war for talent” 10 years ago since hiring has grown even tougher since. The people they hope to hire want to work for an organization they believe in, and that includes a genuine, demonstrable commitment to sustainability and inclusion. The same holds true for customers, spanning both B2C and B2B sectors. This is particularly evident in the case of B2B firms selling to large corporations. Notably, 60% of Fortune 500 companies have set climate-related goals – some of them very ambitious – and they are explicitly communicating to their suppliers that the continuation of their business relationships hinges on active support in meeting these sustainability goals. Third, companies increasingly face communal and social pressure to act. And, in the age of social media, they ignore these pressures at their peril. Poor social and environmental practices can trigger a backlash from activists and community groups. For instance, consider a corporation that fails to address workplace harassment issues raised by the #MeToo movement. This neglect may result in a public outcry with the movement's advocates using social media to amplify their concerns, organize protests, and call for boycotts. These actions can significantly damage the company's public image and brand reputation. Within the company, employees may become disheartened, impacting workplace dynamics and

‘At an inflection point, you have to challenge the assumptions that made you successful, but which may not be valid for the future’ Jim Hagemann Snabe, Chair of Siemens and Maersk

productivity. Furthermore, customers may opt to avoid the company's products or services in solidarity, potentially leading to financial losses. In today's interconnected world, these issues can quickly draw the attention of regulatory authorities and legal entities, opening the door to further legal actions. Fourth, investors increasingly demand sustainability and have made it a common part of the due diligence process. In 2020, 73% of investors conducted structured and formal reviews of ESG, according to a study from EY, up from 32% just two years earlier. Another telling example: in our “CEO Dialogue” series, Temasek’s CEO Dilhan Pillay explained that sustainability is a core pillar of the investment firm’s strategy and that he is pressing portfolio companies to develop their own forward-looking strategies around it (see Page 36).


“I think if you're a long-term investor, you look at what the value of a portfolio is going to be, not in terms of a three, five, 10-year timeframe, but even 15, 20 years,” he said. “And if you look at all the events that would impact the portfolio over that timeframe, you cannot ignore the impact of climate change on the value of your portfolio.” This pressure from investors is increasingly common and not limited to climate. Pillay says his firm takes a “stewardship” approach, emphasizing that “we are here to ensure that future generations benefit from what we do today”. Changing strategy

The two central questions in strategy are “where to play” and “how to win”. Sustainability transformations often require new answers to both. The companies we have studied and worked with often make major changes to their portfolios through investments, divestitures, and innovation. Royal DSM is an unlikely candidate to top the Dow Jones Sustainability Index. The company was formed by the Dutch government in 1902 to mine the country’s coal reserves, which it did for the first half of the last century (DSM stands for Dutch State Mines). In 1965, the government closed the coal mines and DSM had to reinvent itself by focusing on its growing chemicals business. But by the turn of the century, DSM was struggling. Its growth had stagnated, it was being rocked by volatile oil prices (a key input into its chemical business), and the tide was turning toward antipollution regulations that could seriously affect its operations. Once again, business as usual was not looking like a good bet. DSM was forced to come up with a new strategy. DSM’s new CEO, Feike Sijbesma, wasted no time in responding. Following his appointment in 2007, he reoriented the company toward life sciences, sold the more carbon-intensive petrochemicals business for $2 billion, and used the funds generated to make 25 acquisitions over the ensuing decade. Ten years into DSM’s journey, the Dow Jones Sustainability Index ranked DSM number one in the chemicals industry. DSM’s transformation was notable, in part, because the chemicals sector is invariably environmentally intensive. But as its evolution shows, even hard-to-abate sectors like chemicals are undergoing a shift toward more sustainable strategies.

Photo: E.Crooÿ ©Solvay

Many, if not most, companies face some version of this dilemma, though it is sometimes less acute. Some of their lines of business are unsustainable and/or carbon-intensive; others are much less so but may be more nascent. The challenge is to forge a new answer to the question of “where to play”, in real time, while finding a way to fund and manage the transition. In 1970, BCG’s Bruce Henderson introduced the “growth share matrix” to advise companies on where they should focus their portfolios. Market share was on one axis, growth prospects on the other. The prevailing belief was that low-growth, high-market-share businesses could fund investment into ventures with superior growth potential. However, in the contemporary business landscape, a transformative shift is underway as companies increasingly recognize that they must go beyond growth share considerations and incorporate sustainability factors into their strategic equations.

‘Keep one eye on the microscope and the other on the telescope’ Ilham Kadri, Solvay CEO

For example, Solvay, a leading material science company, employs a specialized matrix designed explicitly for a strategic sustainability assessment, aptly named the Sustainable Portfolio Management Guide. This matrix utilizes two primary axes: one quantitatively evaluates a product's environmental impact during its manufacturing, known as “operations vulnerability”, while the other qualitatively assesses the product's social and environmental merits and challenges, viewed through the lens of customers and other stakeholders, referred to as “market alignment”. Adding a dynamic dimension to the grid, sales volume is visually represented through color gradients. Products on this matrix are categorized as “solutions” when they exhibit low operational environmental footprint and high market alignment, while “challenges” encompass products that perform poorly in either measure. Within each business unit, a designated “correspondent”, typically the marketing strategy manager, oversees the assessment of their respective business line on the matrix. It's worth noting that this tool extends beyond mere greenhouse gas emissions measurement, encompassing a broad spectrum of sustainability factors, from water efficiency to raw material usage and potential exposure to toxic substances. The primary objective of such a tool is not to provide definitive solutions but to initiate thoughtful discussions. Solvay leverages this matrix not only for evaluating its existing products and business lines but also as a foundation for decision-making concerning product development and potential mergers and acquisitions. A similar approach is to plot businesses on a 2x2 grid where one axis represents their sustainability and the other their financial performance. Once that mapping is complete, a company can strategically utilize financially successful yet “less sustainable” businesses to fund investment in more sustainable businesses, ultimately aiming for both sustainability and financial profitability. That’s what DSM did when it sold its petrochemical business to fund its shift toward life sciences and less carbon-intensive approaches to chemicals. In some cases, like DSM, this transition may entail divestiture. In other cases, as in the original growth share matrix concept, declining businesses can generate cash. However, it's crucial to note that this approach carries certain risks, as such declining businesses may negatively impact employee and customer perceptions of the company's portfolio. Of course, sustainability strategy extends beyond M&A activities. Many companies adjust their portfolios through internal innovation, as DSM did with its “Project Clean Cow”, » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 9


[ Sustainability transformation ]

ACCELERATING YOUR ORGANIZATION´S TRANSITION TO A MORE SUSTAINABLE & INCLUSIVE MODEL

STRATEGIC DOMAIN − WHERE TO PLAY AND HOW TO WIN? PORTFOLIO OF BUSINESSES

Buy

• •

Sell

resource allocation

INNOVATION

Business model

Develop

Alone vs. partnering System leadership - Industry cooperation - Across the value chain

•

CAPTURING VALUE

Products & services

Help customers change behavior

Stakeholder management / working with "adversaries"

Right positioning

EVOLVING CONTEXT − HOW IS THE WORLD CHANGING? • Forthcoming regulations, laws, and financial incentives • The world of finance • Workforce/talent expectations and pressures • B2B customer and B2C customer expectations and pressures • Community/societal pressures

ORGANIZATIONAL DOMAIN

Re-shaping employee behavior & ultimately organizational culture in a more innovative, agile, diverse, and inclusive direction

Courageous decisions Long-term perspective

TOP TEAM INDIVIDUAL & COLLECTIVE BEHAVIOR

PROCESSES

LEADERSHIP BEHAVIOR THROUGH THE RANKS

of e EMPLOYEE BEHAVIOR

STRUCTURE

(incl. position of ESG staff)

INFORMATION & TECHNOLOGY

n o u gh

people COMMON WAY OF THINKING/ CULTURE OF THE ORGANIZATION

for lo

ng enou gh EMPLOYEE CAPABILITIES

hiring/firing/training

KPIs AND INCENTIVES • • • Professor Jean-François Manzoni, 2023

10 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Pricing

EMPLOYER VALUE PROPOSITION

Purpose & strategy Diversity & inclusion Way we work


a decade-plus research and development project. That project culminated in Bovaer, a feed additive that effectively reduces methane emissions from dairy cows by 30% and from beef cattle by 45%. New product development of this sort requires companies to foster innovation and agility, which in turn may require major shifts to an organization’s capabilities. Plenty more could be said about sustainability and strategy, but two strategic skill sets and one big question bear mentioning: Pricing. Sustainable products and services can create new value for customers and for the world, but sustainability strategies can only lead to favorable financial returns if the organization manages to capture a sufficient fraction of the value that they are creating. This requires organizations to learn to price products and services differently, to learn to build a narrative for their customers that makes the – often higher – pricing acceptable to key stakeholders, and oftentimes also to escalate discussions beyond procurement departments. For instance, consider a

‘Everything was in place … except that our customers, investors, and employees didn’t believe in our story.’ Matti Lievonen, CEO of Neste

shipping company that faced difficulties convincing its client’s procurement department to accept a significant price increase associated with the use of more renewable fuels. Upon closer examination, they realized that while the fuel-induced price increase was non-trivial, the ultimate impact translated to a mere 10 cents per pair of sneakers. This seemingly modest increase was deemed acceptable by the client’s CEO, who recognized its value in reducing the sneakers’ carbon footprint.

Infographic: Theresa Schwietzer

Partnering and cooperating. In the pursuit of sustainability, strategic decisions often extend beyond individual organizations and spill into collaborative efforts among competitors. We have observed instances where industry rivals chose to set aside competition to instead collaborate on some aspects of the value chain or business model to collectively drive substantial reductions in their industry’s environmental footprint. For example, Suntory succeeded at convincing Japanese beverage companies to standardize some packaging to enhance recycling efforts. Furthermore, even in fiercely competitive sectors, such as the automotive industry, competitors like Volvo and Daimler recognized the potential benefits of cooperation and established a groundbreaking fuel-cell joint venture in 2021. Yet, deciding where to embrace collaboration amid competition remains a complex question. How fast can you (afford to) go? When you’re right about something 20 years ahead of time, you’re essentially wrong for the first 19 years! Transforming toward a more sustainable and inclusive model often involves challenging considerations. How fast to exit businesses that will “very likely soon” face growing headwinds? How much to invest into new

lines of activities that “undoubtedly will” be very successful someday, but when? Management teams and boards ought to aim to be ahead of the curve to be ready to catch the wave when the wave hits. But being ahead of the curve for very long can be an extremely uncomfortable situation. One of the organizations we studied, Finnish power company Wärtsilä, illustrates this tension well. Its two business units focus on the energy and marine sectors, two carbon-intensive sectors that hold particular relevance for the European Union’s 2019 goal of carbon neutrality by 2050. On the positive side, Wärtsilä has been developing products that can improve their users’ footprint significantly. On the other, the long-lasting nature of the assets in these sectors is encouraging clients to “wait and see” before committing to one future technology. While Wärtsilä's investments in more carbon-efficient products will inevitably lead to long-term success as technological uncertainties diminish, it also must navigate the transitional period, necessitating challenging decisions for its top management team in the meantime. Cato Espero, a sales director at Wärtsilä, clearly laid out the challenge in an IMD case study we are writing on the company: “You have to make money now, but you also have to look at the future. When you are on the stock exchange, like Wärtsilä, you have to focus on ‘next week’. This is the continuous battle we are facing: make money now and at the same time progress towards our goals.” Making strategy come alive by reshaping employee behavior and organizational culture

For many of the companies we work with, the organizational transformation required to become more “sustainable” is proving as challenging as, and sometimes even more challenging than, the strategic change. Such was the feeling of Jean-Pascal Tricoire, the CEO of energy management company Schneider Electric, when in 2013 he tapped one of his most successful line managers to become the company’s CHRO. “We’re doing well on the hardware side,” said Tricoire. (And indeed they were: through a series of divestments, acquisitions, and investments to grow key activities, Schneider was successfully building a very different portfolio of products and services.) “But we also need to transform on the software (people) side.” Why must the organization change as well? Because the key strategic decisions we evoked above must a) then be translated into a large number of smaller decisions taken throughout the organization by a large number of individuals, and b) employees throughout the organization must be willing and able to produce the behaviors required by the strategy. “At an inflection point you have to challenge the assumptions that made you successful, but which may not be valid for the future,” said Jim Hagemann Snabe, then chair of Siemens and A P Moller Maersk. In particular, he explained that both companies had identified innovation as a key strategic lever and were increasingly focused on improving the speed at which they could innovate, i.e., on developing new capabilities support- » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 11


[ Sustainability transformation ]

ing the deployment of their new strategy. There is no one perfect playbook for managing organizational change. However, we have found that sustainability pioneers all made important decisions and investments in the following six areas:

Structure. Transforming the organization in a more sustainable direction “requires somebody to take on the role of conductor, the orchestrator across the organization,” says Judith Wiese, Chief People & Sustainability Officer at Siemens. At the core of this framework sits the CSO, a novel addition to the C-suite hierarchy, entrusted with orchestrating sustainability endeavors. Wiese's perspective underscores the essential nature of this position. To maximize its impact, the CSO should sit within the upper echelons of leadership – whether as part of the executive committee or the managing board. That sends a resounding message about the organization's dedication to sustainability and its elevated status. This placement not only signifies a commitment to sustainability but also underscores its alignment with the broader corporate strategy. It highlights that sustainability isn't a peripheral endeavor but a pivotal component tightly interwoven with the organization's overarching vision. Beyond the importance of the CSO’s positioning, important decisions must be made regarding where “CSR-related” roles and responsibilities get distributed. How much gets done centrally at headquarters? How much gets distributed to the various business units? Where should key capabilities be positioned? 12 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Ice hockey star Wayne Gretzky said he succeeded because he was skating to where the puck was going to be and not where it was

KPIs and incentives. When trying to change how an organization operates, don’t hope for “A” while rewarding “B”. Changing behavior often requires changing key performance indicators (KPIs) and even employees’ incentives. At DSM, Sijbesma tied half of his 300 most senior executives’ compensation to sustainability goals. The new incentives took three years to enact, but as soon as they were in place, the company’s sustainability metrics began seeing marked improvement. Schneider Electric followed a similar path, developing and regularly updating a sophisticated set of “sustainability and inclusion” metrics that became integrated into executives’ variable compensation and later on a company-wide bonus scheme. Of course, bad KPIs can be gamed, and sustainability is no different. Schneider spent years developing and evolving its own “Sustainability Impact” index, tailored to its engineering-centric culture. By the time executives were compensated based on it, the KPIs had been refined and so were harder to game. Information and tech. For employees to produce the behaviors that are required to successfully deploy the new strategy, employees need to have access to information that will enable them to make effective decisions. Over the last few years, many companies have found that they need to invest in new sources of data, both internal and external, that allow them to track progress toward their sustainability goals and to communicate them to investors, regulators, and other stakeholders. This can often require new hires and technical teams that specialize in tracking and managing ESG data for the organization. Wiese, of Siemens, emphasizes that digitalization and sustainability naturally fit together because

Photo: Britannica

Leadership. In all of the cases we studied, the transformation of the organization toward a more sustainable and inclusive model required a strong vision and persistence at the top. This is not to say that having a visionary and courageous CEO and top management team is sufficient – it is not. But it does seem to have been a necessary condition. We have already mentioned CEOs like Ilham Kadri (Solvay), Jean-Pascal Tricoire (Schneider Electric), and Feike Sijbesma (DSM, where he was succeeded by the duo of Geraldine Matchett and Dimitri de Vreeze). Another such leader is Matti Lievonen, who between 2008 and 2018 led the transformation of Neste Oil – as it was called back then – into a renewable fuel powerhouse and stock market darling Neste. Early on, the going was quite tough for Lievonen, who later joked that for a while he was “the most hated man in Finland”. “Everything was in place,” he said of the company’s transformation. “Except that our customers, investors, and employees didn’t believe in our story.” Lievonen’s tenure ended on a very positive note, but getting there required considerable courage and persistence on his part. It also required building around him a strong management team, willing and able to face the headwinds and disappointments that invariably appear along the way. Building such a strong team requires a powerful sense of shared purpose and direction. It may also involve separating from a few individuals who will be unwilling and/or unable to contribute to the transformation. As Sijbesma put it: “When transforming, you need to realize that the whole top of an organization rose through the ranks because they had expertise in that part of the portfolio (i.e., chemicals), which was core. That does not mean they will work well in the new portfolio.”


“they both leverage data”. Even beyond reporting, sustainability products and services often require new IT capabilities, for example energy monitoring or building automation.

cycle and can be lifted by tailwinds. The difficulty lies in winning when things are not going your way – in making things happen that would not have otherwise happened.

Employee capabilities. Employees fail to produce desired behaviors for a range of reasons; often, these reasons pertain to employees being provided with the wrong incentives and/or information – problems that are often related to structural problems and/or bad examples from top management. But another cause of employees failing to produce desired behaviors is simply that they do not know how to produce these behaviors under real-life-conditions – a capability problem.

But if Ghoshal was alive today, he would complement this first sentence by adding that leaders are also paid to make happen things that leave the system – the organizational, the ecological, and the social systems – stronger than they found it. Leaders are stewards of the organizations they lead, and we are all stewards of the world we are borrowing from our children. A good steward leaves the system in a better state than they found it. As of now, the generation leading governments and organizations is not exactly excelling on this front. We are continuing to create economic wealth, but we are doing so in a way that is increasingly unsustainable socially and ecologically.

In our experience, pioneers all made considerable investments into developing their employees’ capabilities at scale. This investment always includes three streams of effort: hiring new competencies and/or mindsets, shedding some old competencies and mindsets, and training everybody else in a set of values and behaviors carefully selected to support the new strategy. Too many organizations underestimate the importance of substantial investments in helping develop individual and organizational capabilities. Pioneers all understood this point and designed and deployed several waves of capability-building interventions. Changing behavior or changing culture. Few academics are as closely associated with the notion of leadership and culture than John Kotter, who wrote several articles and books explaining to managers how to go about changing their organization’s culture. For many years, Kotter’s and others’ view was that since the biggest impediment to creating change in a group was culture, it would make great sense to tackle culture first. Once the culture had shifted, the change effort would become much easier to effect. This focus on changing culture first is misguided, because as Kotter came to realize: “Culture is not something that you manipulate easily … you can’t grab it. Culture changes only after you have successfully altered people’s actions for a period of time.” Culture comes down to a common way of thinking that drives a common way of acting. And paradoxically, human beings act their way into new mindsets and values much more than they think their way into new actions. This is somewhat paradoxical, but it is not exactly new; more than two thousand years ago, Aristotle observed that “(human beings) do not act rightly because we have virtue or excellence, but we rather have those because we have acted rightly. (Human beings) acquire a particular quality by consistently acting in a particular way.” Hence, smart top teams focus on identifying the behaviors that they need to observe throughout their organizations, and then put in place a set of levers (discussed above) that will shape the behavior of enough employees for long enough, thus ensuring that enough individuals gradually internalize the desired behaviors. Behavior change comes first, culture change is the result of a job well done over a long enough period of time. The microscope and the telescope

The late Sumantra Ghoshal liked to say: “Leaders are not paid to preside over the inevitable. They are paid to make happen what otherwise wouldn’t happen.” That is very true. Anyone can ride a positive economic

Wayne Gretzky, arguably the greatest ice hockey player ever, once said he succeeded because he was skating to where the puck was going to be, instead of where the puck was. We at IMD believe that smart organizations, too, must skate to where the puck is going to be. They must prepare their organization to excel in a world that will increasingly force organizations to internalize the social and environmental cost of their actions. To do so, they must work on their strategy and on their organization. The graphic on Page 10 summarizes our current understanding of some of the key domains that we have seen successful innovators tackle. The specific decisions that each company made were always context-specific and hence changed across companies and contexts, but decisions had to be made on the dimensions that we discussed above. We believe that this framework highlights some of the areas that your organization will have to tackle to accelerate its transition toward a more prosperous, sustainable, and inclusive model. This is not an easy undertaking. It requires organizations to be performing at the same time as they are transforming. That requires leaders to keep “one eye on the microscope [and] one eye on the telescope,” as Kadri puts it, where the microscope provides a granular view of current activities and capabilities, and the telescope helps to start picturing the future. A more sustainable and inclusive, and yet prosperous model for business is possible. Making it a reality requires clear vision, bold leadership, and transformational management. ■ Jean-François Manzoni is President of IMD, where he also serves as Nestlé Chaired Professor of Leadership and Organizational Development. His research, teaching, and consulting activities are focused on leadership, the development of high-performance organizations, and corporate governance. Julia Binder is Professor of Sustainable Innovation and Business Transformation at IMD. As Director of IMD’s Center for Sustainable and Inclusive Business, she aims to help leaders find innovative solutions to some of the biggest challenges of our time. She was named on the 2022 Thinkers50 Radar list of management thinkers to watch in the coming year.

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 13


[ Sustainability transformation ]

Chicken or pig? New ESG rules require true board commitment There is a well-known metaphor in business that illustrates levels of buy-in: imagine a chicken and a pig discussing a bacon and egg sandwich – the chicken is engaged, but the pig is committed! A similar change in buy-in level applies to the fast-changing role of ESG in the boardroom, argue Sam Gill and Jan van der Kaaij

A

t the end of July, the European Commission took an essential step by adopting the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) in pursuit of a sustainable economy. These new ESRS standards, which are strategically aligned with the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) and the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI), aim to ensure a high degree of coherence in global sustainability reporting. However, it should be noted that there are still some differences between the different regimes, such as the ESRS definition of materiality including the concept of “double materiality”, i.e., not just the impact of the company on the climate but the impact of the climate on the company. With this gradual move towards greater alignment, companies can avoid having to report to multiple reporting regimes, reducing the reporting burden. In addition, the new ESRS standards are facilitating global com14 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Using the latest techniques, ASML is aiming to increase the energy efficiency of its lithography

parability, leading to comprehensive reporting on ESG issues. This not only reinforces the EU's commitment to sustainability but also paves the way for a unified global framework for meaningful corporate disclosure. This helps companies escape the “reporting trap” (i.e., spending much of their available ESG resources on reporting instead of performance enhancement). For instance, companies face fewer requirements to report differently in different jurisdictions. The alignment also makes life easier for investors as they seek to compare peer companies reporting under different ESG regimes. The fast-paced developments in global ESG regulations and frameworks are quickly transforming the position of the board of directors from one based on engagement to one requiring true commitment because, under the new rules, directors are becoming full stakeholders in a company´s ESG performance. Clearly, the changing regulatory landscape


produce computer chips – all major chipmakers use ASML’s technology. Regarded as a sustainability role model in its sector, ASML has a very low ESG risk score from Morningstar/Sustainalytics of 9.6 (indicating “negligible risk”), placing the company in first place out of 328 peers in the semiconductor industry. The company also features in the S&P Global Sustainability Yearbook 2023, scoring 83 out of a possible 100. ASML´s approach hinges on a solid ESG governance structure, wellequipped board members, and the inclusion of supply chain and innovation in pursuit of its “net zero” targets. As part of its sustainability program, ASML developed a clear climate action strategy that has a stratified approach to achieving net zero greenhouse gas emissions (see chart on Page 17).

‘All Singapore-listed companies are required to provide climate reports as a part of their sustainability reporting on a “comply or explain” basis.’ More than 98% of ASML´s CO2 emissions are sourced from its supply chain and product use (what are referred to as “scope 3” emissions). Consequently, for its climate action strategy to deliver on its promise, ASML is working to embed its net zero commitments in its product development and supply chain activities, for instance, by aiming to increase the energy efficiency of its lithography solutions. For each of the emission categories, key driver trees have been identified that ASML should work on to achieve its objectives.

Let’s look at two positive examples in practice: one from the semiconductor industry and another from the experience of the Singapore stock exchange in the adoption of disclosure standards.

To reinforce its ESG governance, in April 2023, ASML´s supervisory board decided to establish an ESG committee that focuses on ESG and sustainability in recognition of their importance both to the company and its business. The responsibilities of this committee include assisting the supervisory board in carrying out its governance and oversight responsibilities with regard to ESG matters. Some important agenda topics for the board include the company’s ESG strategy, the integration of ESG in the company, as well as ESG sustainability performance and progress against its objectives. The prominent position of this committee underpins ASML’s climate ambitions at the highest level, not just in its operations – increasing its chances of a successful transformation.

How ASML is making ‘net zero’ work

TCFD alignment at the Singapore Stock Exchange

solutions and is working to embed net zero commitments in its product development

Photo: ASML

requires reinforcement on an organizational level. So, what changes are needed within the realm of ESG to future-proof companies on their climate-related disclosures?

ASML is an innovation leader in the semiconductor industry with total net sales of €21.2bn ($23bn) in 2022. Netherlands-based ASML, one of the biggest firms in its sector, provides chipmakers around the world with hardware, software, and services. As a matter of fact, it is one of the most important players in the semiconductor supply chain, with an almost exclusive position on the machines that chipmakers need to

The Taskforce on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) was founded in 2015 to develop a global standard for consistent climate-related financial risk disclosure to enable companies to report on their potential climate impact. The standard requires companies to analyze risks and opportunities through the lens of different global warming scenarios, alongside embedding good corporate climate governance practices. » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 15


[ Sustainability transformation ]

Regarding governance, the TCFD standard recommends the disclosure of two elements that require commitment from senior management: a) A description of the board’s oversight of climate-related risks and opportunities. b) A description of the management’s role in assessing and managing those risks and opportunities. Even though the number of companies signing up to the TCFD standards has quickly risen over the past five years, the actual disclosures from those companies illustrate that the category of governance is lagging compared to that of metrics and targets (see chart below). From that data, it could be concluded that some companies are still setting climate-related targets without a matching level of disclosure for governance. Given the urgency of climate change, it may come as no surprise that regulatory bodies worldwide are seeking to strengthen the commit-

ment and accountability of companies in their ESG reporting. The list of countries that have implemented TCFD-aligned disclosure requirements – or are working on it – includes the UK, Brazil, Switzerland, and the EU. Indeed, the new ISSB S1 General Requirements for Disclosure of Sustainability-related Financial Information and S2 Climate-related Disclosure, which are designed to represent an international benchmark, are aligned with the TCFD. In late 2021, the Singaporean Stock Exchange (SGX) published a directive for listed companies regarding sustainability disclosures, as recommended by the TCFD. According to the SGX, all Singapore-listed companies are required to provide climate reports as a part of their sustainability reporting on a “comply or explain” basis. Under that premise, companies can comply with the regulation or explain why they have decided not to do so. This directive has resulted in industryspecific mandatory climate reporting for SGX-listed companies in the financial, energy, agriculture, food, and forest sectors starting in

TCFD-aligned disclosures for fiscal years 2017 and 2021 RECOMMENDED DISCLOSURE

GOVERNANCE

a) Board oversight

25

b) Management´s role

18

a) Risks and opportunities

35

b) Impact on organization

29

c) Resilience of strategy

14

a) Risk ID and assessment processes

25

b) Risk management processes

26

c) Integration into overall risk management

32

a) Climate-related metrics

23

b) Scope 1, 2, 3 GHG emissions

26

c) Climate-related targets

30

STRATEGY

RISK MANAGEMENT

METRICS AND TARGETS

LEGEND:

FY 2017

FY 2021

PT. CHANGE

PERCENT OF COMPANIES DISCLOSING 5%

30%

5%

23% 27% 19%

2%

48%

16% 9%

34%

8%

34%

6%

38% 25%

48%

18%

44%

16% 0%

20%

TCFD-aligned disclosures comparing FY2017 and 2021. Source: Taskforce on Climate-related Financial Disclosures

16 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

62%

46% 40%

60%

80%

100%

Infographic: Theresa Schwietzer

RECOMMENDATION


ASML's climate action strategy TYPE OF EMISSION

NET ZERO BY ...

SCOPE 1

2

3

2025

Own operations

X

Business travel and commuting

X

2030

Supply chain Product use

the 2023 financial year. The transportation, materials, and buildings industries are set to follow in 2024. Following the increased focus of the SGX on the disclosure of climate reports, all directors of Singapore-listed companies must attend one of eight pre-selected ESG sustainability training courses. The companies involved were required to provide confirmation that their directors have attended this training in their first sustainability report for the 2022 financial year. What can we learn from these examples?

From our experiences experiences over the past five years, it has become evident that merely following recent recommendations and standards should not be top of the ESG checklist for companies. Successful ESG programs can only deliver value to stakeholders if they have a strong and diverse commitment from both the C-suite and the board of directors. With many more companies yet to realize the full potential of the TCFD disclosure standards, the experiences from first movers are worth learning from. Based on these examples, we suggest the following three practical steps for companies looking to successfully navigate the new landscape: 1. Formalize sustainability governance from shopfloor to boardroom. A formal sustainability governance process creates clarity for roles and responsibilities and helps to embed the notion that the company's ESG performance is not just the responsibility of the sustainability department. At board level, topics (and responsibilities) should be broadly shared and not limited to a dedicated ESG committee of members with an “affinity” for the subject. As seen in the example of ASML, its ESG committee actively assists the supervisory board in carrying out its governance and oversight responsibilities regarding ESG matters. 2. Make sure board members are properly equipped. To obtain a commitment from boards on ESG objectives, involve and engage them early on in ESG risk assessments such as double materiality and TCFD processes. This can be done through workshops or interviews to ensure the im-

X

2040

X

‘ASML´s approach hinges on a solid ESG governance structure, well-equipped board members, and the inclusion of supply chain and innovation in pursuit of its “net zero” targets’

pact of climate scenarios and materiality on the company’s strategy are taken into account. In case regulatory bodies do not provide appropriate education – as offered by the SGX – companies should ensure that the C-suite and board directors are suitably trained in ESG ratings, metrics, and performance. This is a must to establish a broader base of ownership. 3. Do not rely on incremental innovation alone to achieve net zero targets. To reach the targets set out in most net zero plans, fundamental innovation is required on a product level and in collaboration within the value chain. In the case of ASML, this covers more than 98% of ASML´s CO2 emissions. To bring these emissions down to zero, value chain partnerships are a must – initially, to disclose scope 3 emissions but, more importantly, to jointly reduce emissions to zero before 2040. With sustainability factors rapidly becoming an integral part of corporate reporting and strategy, companies that want to achieve ESG leadership must realize that their board members need to be fully committed, not just involved. When struggling with the difference between the two, just remember the chicken and the pig. ■

Sam Gill is SLR Consulting’s Director of Climate Resilience, working with companies and institutional investors seeking to better understand the risks and opportunities associated with climate change. Amongst other projects, this includes working with the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development in providing technical assistance to its partner financial institutions to improve their corporate climate governance and achieve alignment with the goals of the Paris Agreement. Jan van der Kaaij is co-director of IMD´s Winning Sustainability Strategies program and the lead for ESG Strategic Advisory Services in Europe at SLR Consulting. As an ESG veteran of 20 years, his work includes developing sustainability strategies for corporate clients and investors as well as improving sustainability programs based on ESG rating performance with senior management.

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 17


[ Sustainability transformation ]

‘Some progress has been made, but not nearly enough’: Justin Welby, the Archbishop of Canterbury, on energy companies failing to keep their climate change promises

The Church of England has moved away from engagement and sold its fossil fuel shares, but to whose benefit? The shares have most likely been bought by investors who care little about climate change. One pension fund’s pioneering approach may provide a better alternative, argues Michael Skapinker 18 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

T

he Church of England has long been an advocate of engaging with companies, urging them to set and meet climate goals in line with the 2015 Paris Agreement, which aims to limit global temperature increases to less than two degrees Celsius, and preferably 1.5 degrees, compared with pre-industrial levels. The Church, which manages a 10-billion-pound endowment and a 3.2-billion-pound pension fund, is a co-founder of Climate Action 100+, a group of 700 global investors who engage with 166 companies across 32 markets. Yet the Church of England’s patience is not boundless. In June, it announced it was selling its holdings in a group of energy majors, includ-

Photo: Chris Ratcliffe/Getty Images

Should you put your faith in engagement or divestment? Praise be, there is a third way


ing Shell, BP, Exxon Mobil, and TotalEnergies. The Church concluded that these corporations had failed to keep their climate change promises. Justin Welby, the Archbishop of Canterbury, head of the Church of England, and himself a former oil executive, said: “Some progress has been made, but not nearly enough.”

And what if divesting from them results in lower returns? That could be a problem for those funds with a fiduciary duty to their members or investors. Will pension fund members really accept smaller pensions just because they are more ethically managed? Don’t their fund trustees have an obligation to avoid those lower returns?

After a northern hemisphere summer scarred by record heat waves, raging fires in Europe and North Africa, and floods from New York State to China, the need to take a stand has never seemed more urgent. For many investors, engagement is no longer enough. In 2020, under pressure from student protests and hunger strikes, the University of Cambridge pledged to sell its fossil fuel holdings over the next decade. The next year, Harvard University announced that it would make no direct investments in fossil fuel companies and would run down its holdings in funds that did so.

This is where supporters of divestment deploy their second argument – that any higher returns from fossil fuel activities are illusory – and that action to counter climate change will inevitably lead to a fall in oil and gas use. Fossil fuels will become “stranded assets” as the companies extracting them lose their “social right to operate”. Their value will decline to worthlessness. This argument suffered a blow when Russia’s war on Ukraine, beginning in February 2022, led to a disruption in energy supplies, a spike in prices – and bumper profits for the oil companies. But second-quarter results this year showed the profits of oil majors such as Exxon, Chevron, Shell, and BP falling after the worst of the Ukraine war price shock passed, leading to a boost for the “stranded assets” claim.

Yet there are prominent voices who say that, if you really want to wean the world off fossil fuels, divesting your shares in energy companies is the wrong way to do it – because for every seller of equities there is a buyer whose intentions may be less benign than yours. The new shareholders may not push fossil fuel companies as hard to set and achieve climate goals. They may be happy for the companies to expand their fossil fuel exploration and production and to bother less about investment in renewables. In which case, what have the divestors achieved? Nothing, Bill Gates told the Financial Times in 2019. “Divestment, to date, probably has reduced about zero tonnes of emissions,” he said. Chris James, the founder of Engine No. 1, took a similar line during a discussion at the COP 26 climate conference in Glasgow in 2021. Engine No. 1, an activist hedge fund that was pushing Exxon to take climate change more seriously, managed to elect three representatives to the company’s board that year. Engagement was better than divestment, James told a COP 26 panel, adding: “No problem has ever been resolved by running away.” The case for withdrawal

So why does divestment still attract support? There are at least four reasons. The first is that people do not want to be associated with an industry that is doing so much damage to the planet. “Not in our name,” they say. Luigi Zingales, a professor at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business, calls this the “deontological stand” – deontology being the theory of moral obligation. People do not want their money, or their institution’s money, to support a nefarious activity. This stance drives much of the growth in ethical and ESG funds. People feel deeply uncomfortable about earning profits from tobacco, gambling, and pornography – or coal, oil, and gas. But some critics of the deontological stand argue that fossil fuels are different. Most of us accept that we have to cut their use, and sharply, but we will still need them while the transition happens. Our economies would shut down if we simply stopped using fossil fuels. And if we catch planes or turn on lights that are still powered, albeit to a happily reducing extent, by fossil fuels, isn’t it hypocritical to say we won’t invest in them?

‘If we catch planes or turn on lights that are still powered, albeit to a happily reducing extent, by fossil fuels, isn’t it hypocritical to say we won’t invest in them?’

The divestment campaign’s third argument is that engagement doesn’t work. The New York Times in May quoted Mark Kramer, a senior lecturer at Harvard Business School, as saying that, despite Engine No. 1 getting its supporters on to the company’s board, “Exxon has continued to invest aggressively in expanding its oil and gas production”. Danielle Fugere, president and chief counsel of investor advocacy group As You Sow, said that Engine No. 1 “has not made a discernible difference in the way Exxon is addressing climate change”. The argument here is that by engaging with Exxon, Engine No. 1 is simply providing the company with cover: yes, its environmentally responsible directors sit on the board, but Exxon carries on doing exactly what it wants. Engine No. 1 attempted to counter this criticism, pointing The New York Times to Exxon’s investments in carbon capture, hydrogen, and lithium mining, and saying that none of these were happening before the election of the Engine No. 1-backed directors. The Church of England has effectively endorsed this third divestment argument – by selling its fossil fuel shares, it has appeared to accept that its engagement with the energy giants has not worked. This brings us back to Bill Gates’s point: by divesting, how have you made things better? You have merely sold your shares to investors who care less about climate change than you do. » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 19


[ Sustainability transformation ]

The fourth argument in favor of divestment – and one frequently used – is that it worked in the case of South Africa. Just as sanctions helped to bring down apartheid, this argument goes, so divestment will force the fossil fuel companies into a change of course. This begs the question: did sanctions really help to bring down apartheid? It is understandable that many people think that they did – the two most illustrious opponents of apartheid, Nelson Mandela and Desmond Tutu, said so. Also, sanctions were imposed and apartheid ended. Isn’t it obvious that the one caused the other? But correlation is not causation. A solid body of academic research suggests that sanctions were a marginal reason for apartheid’s downfall. This contrarian research is usefully summarized in a 1999 article in The American Economic Review by Philip Levy, then at Yale University. Drawing on writers such as Patti Waldmeir, the FT’s South African correspondent during the fall of apartheid, Levy says there is little evidence that sanctions substantially damaged South Africa’s economic performance. Far from wilting in the heat of trade sanctions, South Africa’s export volumes rose. The white South African business community often benefited from divestment. When foreign corporations withdrew from the country, local businesspeople could buy their South African subsidiaries at knock-down prices – and then conclude licensing deals with the departed parent companies.

‘Rather than selling shares in companies that don’t live up to climate pledges, Lothian does not lend to them’ If sanctions didn’t end apartheid, what did? Levy and Waldmeir have pointed to three factors. First, local opposition, strikes, and demonstrations were making South Africa increasingly ungovernable, adding to pressure for change. Second, apartheid’s restrictions on black workers doing skilled jobs were acting as a brake on the country’s development and attracting increasing opposition from local business leaders. Third, the Soviet Union collapsed. This deprived the African National Congress, the main opposition movement, of its key backer and made it more amenable to a negotiated settlement with the apartheid regime. In turn, the apartheid government, deprived of one of its most persistent arguments against change – that it was a Communist plot – realized, under pressure from business leaders, that the ANC was open to compromises that left whites with significant economic power.

Scotland, has a different approach. Lothian describes its strategy, broadly, as “engage our equity and deny our debt”. Rather than selling shares in companies that don’t live up to climate pledges, Lothian does not lend to them. That is, it does not subscribe to new corporate bond issues. And, in a slight deviation from “engage our equity”, it doesn’t participate in rights issues or new issues of shares. Lothian explains its position by saying that “buying or selling existing listed equities (shares) does not affect the capital position of the company (it receives no cash), whereas subscribing to new bond or equity issuance does – it usually receives cash to invest”. This does not mean that Lothian is soft on companies that depart from Paris Agreement goals – to which it is strongly committed. If companies do not adhere to climate targets, Lothian denies them financing, whether through bonds or new equity, potentially also increasing the long-term cost of taking on any new debt and reducing income from any new share issuance. Crucially, it does not divest its existing shareholdings – using its presence as a shareholder to push for setting and meeting net zero goals. “We expect our approach to be a more effective means of achieving necessary change – a real reduction in greenhouse gas emissions – than divestment,” Lothian says. Lothian’s strategy offers one possible way through the engagementversus-divestment dispute. It answers the criticism that divesting merely brings in shareholders with a less environmentally committed outlook. It also deals with the reality that share sales in the secondary market don’t much bother quoted companies; they don’t raise any new money for the company. Some argue that selling shares at a reduced price raises the companies’ cost of capital but, as Stuart Kirk, who had to leave his role as head of responsible investing at HSBC’s asset management division when he criticized the ESG movement, has said: no one has satisfactorily explained how this increase in the cost of capital works. Lothian instead punishes environmentally delinquent companies when they try to raise new money, which has a real and measurable impact. And, in the meantime, as engaged shareholders, Lothian can put pressure on those companies to do better. That the Lothian approach hasn’t been more widely adopted is perhaps because it is not widely known. Or possibly that, in our polarized world, it is insufficiently strident to satisfy either side. Which is a pity – because the climate crisis, becoming more evident by the day, requires some joined-up – and grown-up – investor thinking. ■

A third way? Engage with equity, not debt

So, what can environmentally concerned investors do if they find the four arguments in favor of divestment unconvincing? Is there an alternative to simply walking away, as the Church of England has done? The Lothian Pension Fund, which manages the local government pension scheme for Edinburgh and the surrounding area of south-east 20 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Michael Skapinker is a Financial Times contributing editor, a member of the I by IMD editorial advisory board, and the author of Inside the Leaders’ Club: How Top Companies Deal with Pressing Business Issues.


[ Sustainability transformation ]

Still on the right track, the triple bottom line has renewed purpose Focusing on a company’s ecological and social impact as well as its economic performance has yielded mixed results. However, there is increasing evidence that even legacy companies are now making positive strides. Sudhanshu Sarronwala offers advice on how all businesses can ‘do the right thing’

It’s nearly 30 years since John Elkington first posed the concept of the “triple bottom line” (TBL) in his milestone book Cannibals with Forks. Moving beyond shareholder and financial value alone, Elkington postulated that success in this century would be determined by companies that look at three bottom lines – the economic, the ecological, and the social. In short, he was de facto signaling the end of the Friedman era that focused purely on financial shareholder value and not stakeholder implications. Almost a quarter of the way into the century, the results for the TBL are decidedly mixed – as determined by the creator himself, who called for a rethink of the concept five years ago because he felt it had been reduced to an accounting tool rather than a genuine lever for change. While the concept has given rise to a variety of reporting methods (SROI, integrated reporting, and ESG, to name a few), the plethora of standards and measurements has created enough “wiggle room” for inaction from companies. The adoption of the concept has been positive, but the consultant-led corporate interpretation, adoption, and realization of it have not always been so. Reporting standards can be adhered to strictly and companies can thereby get a green/clean chit, but that is not necessarily a true reflection of the impact of their activities. This is why some fossil fuel companies get a better environmental rating than the world’s largest EV manufacturer. At face value, it may seem that the concept is riddled with problems or has had its time. But I would argue that it is just getting started. The idea of this being a seismic shift in the way companies conduct their business, incorporate the stakeholder universe into their orbit, and evaluate their performance has clearly been ignited. The calling out of companies for their lack of environmental responsibility or exposing human rights issues in their supply chains as well as holding directors responsible for governance issues are a direct product of this orientation. Major stock markets and shareholders demand the above transparency and reporting, and consumers actively seek this information and reward or punish a company’s brands accordingly. In effect, business as a whole has moved up on the responsibility spectrum to create a new normal and this, in turn, has led to the concept of corporate purpose being reimagined. For many years, and even to this day, defining purpose for some companies has been about simply articulating its vision and bringing it together with the skills and passion of the workforce – what the firm is good at, its economic output, and the need it has fulfilled. Purpose and ‘doing things right’

Since the TBL discussion started, purpose has undergone a metamorphosis. No longer is it about a company “building the best x” or “providing the toughest y”. Increasingly, purpose encapsulates the social and environmental intent of the company – its raison d’être, built into its business model. Let’s illustrate this for clarity. A call center committed to hiring convicts and ex-convicts as staff is executing its business (call center services) » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 21


[ Sustainability transformation ]

to address a need (no question there) while impacting society in a positive way by providing opportunities for rehabilitation. Or take indoor farming as another example: greenhouses and vertical farming (a sector I have been associated with) are designed to grow crops with a significantly lighter tread on the natural resources of the planet in terms of land, water, and pesticides. Both examples illustrate businesses that have been designed from scratch with a clear purpose that is built deep into their business model so that, by simply operating, they impart a positive value to society or the environment. While it is undoubtedly easier for new businesses to be conceived in this way, it is far more complex for legacy businesses to reflect the same in their model simply because they were set up well before this thinking came about. But this doesn’t prevent legacy companies from transforming their approach to help the environment or society in the course of conducting their business. To be clear, we are not talking about the CSR type of activities where, for example, companies continue to pollute a river or lake at an operating level and build children’s parks elsewhere in the name of corporate citizenship. Such blatant greenwashing tactics are clearly unacceptable. A glance through the listed purpose statements of Fortune 500 companies shows that the trend toward redefining corporate purpose is being embraced and experimented with by more and more companies, whether or not it is leading to a positive impact. However, it is apparent on scanning these mission statements that an overwhelming majority still have an internal orientation (for example, “Real food that matters for life’s moments”; “Achieve superior shareholder returns”; “Powering global investments to help our clients succeed”) versus an external one that impacts the environment, societies, or communities (for example, “To celebrate and liberate the diversity of your beauty”; “Working together for a healthier world”). Clearly, we still have some way to go, alongside the recognition that not all legacy companies will be able to adhere to this paradigm – though there are other ways for them to make a positive impact as we will explore later in this article. Furthermore, there is an argument that there are inherent dangers in companies trying to define purpose for individual brands and taking the concept too far when it may not be necessary – especially when the overarching corporate purpose is not clearly articulated. For those new and legacy businesses that are embedding a TBL-inspired purpose, how does it influence their activities beyond those bold words on the first page of the annual report? I like to think of them as existing in two categories concerned with the idea of doing the “right thing”: new businesses that are set up with purpose built into their model, are, commendably, “doing things right”. Legacy companies that have redefined their purpose and are undergoing a transformation in their business operation to benefit the environment and society, in my view, are “doing the right thing”. 22 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Vertical farming is designed to grow crops with a significantly lighter tread on the planet’s natural resources. The company Infarm, for example, is growing salad indoors

Both are necessary for the simple reason that legacy companies are responsible for a significant majority of the output in global goods and services, and their “doing the right thing” has a massive impact on society and the environment. Over time, hopefully, there will also be enough purpose-born companies that are “doing things right” to begin with that will help define the new normal. The example of the redefinition of the tech sector led by Google, Meta, and now Microsoft and Apple with respect to investing in renewable energy and carbon removal technologies in the operation of their energy-intensive data centers is a powerful statement for the new and the old and all things “right”. Bravo!

‘The journey to a sustainable future belongs at the highest level of the company as well as at the deepest operational level’ A resultant development in this journey has been the birth and exponential growth of the B Corp movement. B Corp Certification seeks to recognize companies that are a “force for good” – very much along the lines of “doing things right” or “doing the right thing”. A critical aspect is the consideration and active engagement of stakeholders to the point of enshrining a commitment to them in the articles of the company in question. In the next avatar of the movement, it is proposed that the human and workers' rights aspects will be strengthened so as to ensure that the social aspect is as robust as the environmental one. At present, while there are only around 6,000 B Corp certified companies, there are more than 200,000 that have used the open-source B


This starts at the top: a core aspect of successful sustainable business transformation is for the board and leadership to actively enable and encourage courageous decisions. This involves looking at critical decisions through a multi-lens of ESG and not just the financials. This is easier said than done, but if not facilitated at the top, it will almost always fall by the wayside, leaving the financial lens to dominate decision-making processes. Looking beyond your company to systemic change

A stark reality that companies and their key executives must recognize is that, no matter how good their company becomes in the sustainability space, systemic change in any industry can only come about if multiple key players move in a common direction with aligned standards to “tip” the sector into systemic sustainability. Environmental, social, and governance impact at scale can only truly be felt when industry players gather around a table and discuss pre-competitive issues with a view to creating systemic change.

Impact Assessment tool to measure their company's effectiveness on the environmental, social, and governance front. (Full disclosure, I am an Affiliate B Leader.) Next, we will move into how decision-makers can translate the new concept of corporate purpose and the idea of “doing things right” into a business context by embedding transformation in their organizations and building alliances with all stakeholders. Priming your organization for holistic transformation

Photo: www.infarm.com

The journey to a sustainable future – environmental, social, and governance – belongs at the highest level of the company as well as at the deepest operational level. If it doesn’t pervade throughout the organization, it will be short-lived or, at best, dependent on the one person driving it. Encouraging organizational readiness is, therefore, essential for sustainability to reside and thrive in the DNA of the operational entity so that it becomes a true way of doing business. The sustainability team should exist to help collaborate with and guide teams and decision-makers, but the targets and the intent must belong to the divisions that want to shine throughout the company for their sustainable methods and stakeholder engagement. This is not a simple process and involves the various divisions co-creating an agenda with the sustainability team. It involves answering tough questions about the various aspects of sourcing, production, operations, and supply chain to create a joint list of actions that need to be taken over a defined timeline and that can be seen in the context of the entire company. Triaging the various recommendations is a delicate exercise involving leadership, division heads, and sustainability experts and requires a corporate culture that sparks courageous actions.

This could involve human rights issues for supply-chain-heavy organizations, sourcing issues for production companies, and carbon measurement issues for carbon-intensive industries. Unless industries tip in this way and systemic changes are created, sustainability efforts – while noteworthy for a single company – can be reduced to an internal achievement or worse, just bragging rights. Hence, for systemic change, there is a crucial need to look at the broader concept of impact in the sustainability space: of recognizing the absolute and critical need for engaging stakeholders and bringing the various actors, competitors, and value-chain members to the table to thrash out the issues and agree on alignments in terms of sustainability standards, measurements, third-party verifications, and the resultant communications that benefit the industry as a whole, as much as it will help an individual player. Regardless of the resistance to and politicization of ESG in some quarters, a steadily increasing number of companies are defining their purpose through the lens of their desired individual impact on the environment and on society. Industries, on the other hand, can define impact at scale and bring about systemic change. Business transformation needs both aspects – a company's commitment internally and the sector’s commitment collectively and externally to make a difference and deliver the impact needed. ■

Sudhanshu Sarronwala is a commercially oriented C-suite professional and Affiliate B Leader with 30+ years of global experience in business, NGOs, startups and purpose-driven companies. He has demonstrated expertise in identifying shifting trends and creating new industries, establishing new businesses, and embedding sustainability in companies. Prior to his time with Infarm (Chief Impact Officer) and WWF International (Executive Director, Communications and Marketing) in Switzerland, Sarronwala was based in the Asia-Pacific across Hong Kong, Singapore, and India in the digital music and TV entertainment space.

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 23


[ Sustainability transformation ]

Responsibility, resilience, and regeneration … three Rs are the new triple bottom line What’s a regenerative business model? It starts with designing companies as if we mean to stay on this planet, writes John Elkington

Many adopt a defensive crouch, as we have seen with the vicious pushback against BlackRock – the world’s largest asset manager – by US oildrunk states such as Texas, Louisiana, and Florida. For example, champions of the old order claim that BlackRock CEO Larry Fink has swallowed the “woke” Kool-Aid whereas it could easily be argued that the opposite is true.

If you’ve ever tried to promote a change agenda, you’ll know the problem: it’s often easier to flag what won’t fit with your desired new order than to pull up examples of tomorrow’s solutions already operating successfully in today’s world. The future may already be here, but at times it can be damned hard to find.

Indeed, it’s possible to see Fink as somewhat conservative because he has simply been arguing the business case for ESG strategies, combining environmental, social, and governance goals, rather than promoting the necessary – and radical – disruption of markets and capitalism.

Worse, if the changes you want to see in the world demand a true paradigm shift, you can pretty much guarantee that today’s market incentives are actively suppressing the necessary thinking, behaviors, and – crucially – business models. Incumbents almost always try to crush insurgents. But ignore any emerging need for long enough and you ensure that when change does come, it does so in a destructive rush. That’s one reason why companies like Ford are beginning to split apart, in their case forming separate businesses offering cars powered, on the one hand, by incumbent internal combustion engines and, on the other, insurgent electric vehicles. There are no guarantees that either Ford business will succeed, but you can bet your bottom dollar that, ultimately, the market reflexes of a fossils-fuels-only company would have steered the company onto the wrong side of history – and parked it there. Similar trends now drive change in sectors as varied as chemicals, energy, food, and finance (including insurance – with severe convective storms held responsible for 70% of insured losses in the first half of 2023). Common sense would suggest early action to ward off such threats, but cognitive dissonance ensures that those trapped inside the old, expiring paradigm often just dig in their heels. Many become increasingly unhinged from reality, terrified, or angered by the emerging threats to their vested interests and “strandable” assets. They see the challenges not simply as a threat to their bottom lines, but to their sense of identity. 24 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

The nature and scale of the paradigm shift now underway was underscored for me on the very day I started drafting this article. Reading obituaries, as I do most mornings, I came across one for James Watt – someone I recall going down in political flames 40 years ago. A combative US interior secretary serving President Ronald Reagan, Watt was once asked whether he felt a responsibility to future generations as he fought to open up wilderness areas to development. His reply? “I do not know how many future generations we can count on before the Lord returns.” Clearly, he was a political accident waiting to happen. Ultimately, he was forced out of office after publicly declaring that the panel reviewing his controversial coal-leasing proposals had “every kind of mix you can have. I have a black, I have a woman, two Jews, and a cripple”. And there you had it: the unmasking of an old order on the verge of radical, disruptive change. Watt worked for a boss whose own thinking was perhaps best indicated by his infamous remark: “Once you’ve seen one tree, you’ve seen them all.” Over time, such views have come to seem Palaeolithic, but these people weren’t stupid: they, too, spoke from a worldview which they saw as undiluted common sense. Until it wasn’t. Coming out

At the time, (un)common sense suggested that such people were degenerators. They were perfectly comfortable with degrading natural and even social capital if it turned them a tidy profit. Perhaps the simplest indicator of the impact has been Earth Overshoot Day. In 1971, it was declared to be on 25 December, whereas by 2023 it had tumbled to


How carbon ‘ranchers’ could help prevent environmental disaster

2 August. The implication: when the tracking started, our global needs could be met with the renewable resources of one planet, whereas today the ratio stands at 1.7 planets. Sustainable that is not. Degeneration it is, and on a planetary scale. So, who today are the regenerators and what sort of business models are they promoting and evolving? Google “regeneration” and you will find people like Janine Benyus of Biomimicry 3.8, John Fullerton of The Capital Institute, Damon Gameau of Regenerating Australia, Paul Hawken of Regeneration.org, Laura Storm of The Regenerators, and Daniel Wahl, among many other things a Volans Fellow. But mainstream media attention to date has focused on major companies “coming out” with their regenerative ambitions.

The fires that recently swept Maui killed more than 100 people, with many more unaccounted for. The economic losses have been initially calculated to exceed $6 billion. It is one more illustration of what happens when degeneration trumps regeneration. Wetlands that were once a key feature around the worst-affected area, Lahaina, were destroyed as industries such as whaling and sugar cane plantations grew and colonists imported new invasive grasses, posing much greater fire hazards. Solutions must include new business models incorporating regeneration – economic, social and, crucially, environmental. One key means of stabilizing the climate, boosting soil fertility, and increasing biodiversity on farms would be to use soil carbon capture and storage (SCCS) technologies that are evolving rapidly. In a study for Shell, Carbon Nation and Arizona State University explored a spectrum of potential business models. While the approach would depend on carbon offsets, and on an oil company notorious for changing its mind, it does underscore the multi-dimensional nature of regenerative solutions. In headlines, all the CO2 emitted from each gallon of fuel sold would be stored in the soil, verified by a third party, and purchased by the company from “soil carbon ranchers” enrolled in a special program. Ranchers would receive short-term cash to help them to reduce the risks of implementing changes in ranching operations in the form of a pre-purchase of carbon storage credits (say 10% of the estimated five-year total), plus the right of first refusal on any additional credits. An online big data community would enable best practice exchange between carbon ranchers, the relevant corporations and institutions, and government agencies. Watch this space.

Among notable companies which have already declared their commitment to regeneration have been Danone North America, General Mills, Interface, Walmart, and perhaps the longest-running advocate, Patagonia. The latter has gone so far as to hand over ownership of the company to Earth itself, by proxy.

‘Champions of the old order claim that BlackRock CEO Larry Fink has swallowed the “woke” Kool-Aid whereas it could easily be argued that the opposite is true’ As the company’s leadership explained in 2022: “Effective immediately, the Chouinard family has transferred all ownership to two new entities: Patagonia Purpose Trust and the Holdfast Collective. Most significantly, every dollar that is not reinvested back into Patagonia will be distributed as dividends to protect the planet.” Or to put it more succinctly, “Earth is now our only shareholder”. Clearly, if that’s your ownership structure, it should be much easier to deliver against the sustainability, circular economy, and regeneration agendas. Few business leaders will go this far, but a growing number will try to reboot their business models. So, what might these look like as we move through the remainder of the 2020s and into the 2030s? There is no shortage of people claiming to have the answer, but clarity and coherence are hard to come by as a market feeding frenzy boils around the still-emerging concept of the “regenerative economy”. The regenerative mindset has spread quickly. Some companies now even talk of a “triple regeneration”, linking their ambitions to new variants of the triple bottom line, a concept for reimagining business models that I proposed in 1994 and later described in my book Cannibals With Forks. So, for example, instead of my “people, planet, and profit” (or “prosperity”) formulations, we hear talk of “people, places, and planet”. In the UK, healthcare insurer BUPA is one emerging champion of regeneration. Julia Giannini, its Head of Environment and Climate Action, » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 25


[ Sustainability transformation ]

put it this way: “Regenerative business is quite a new term, but it’s gaining more traction since the pandemic. Instead of doing less bad by reducing our impact on the environment, it’s about looking at how we can do ‘more good’ and understanding the interconnections between nature and health.”

To get a better idea of what that might involve, consider another long-standing sustainability pioneer, the carpet maker Interface. As part of its “Climate Take Back” mission, aiming to reverse global heating, Interface piloted a fascinating “Factory as a Forest” project in Australia. The idea was that such a plant would provide positive ecosystem services – such as clean air and energy, potable water, carbon sequestration, and nutrient cycling – services that the local ecosystem it replaces would otherwise have provided. Next, Interface partnered with Biomimicry 3.8 to make its US factory outside Atlanta, Georgia, function more like a high-performing ecosystem.

What does this mean in practice? Well, BUPA has launched “Mission Regenerate”, designed to help restore the health of our planet through community-based programs that focus on regenerating the clinical environment and through “participating in partnerships to bring our clinical expertise to drive health benefits through the conservation of natural ecosystems”.

By 2018, Interface had made all its products carbon neutral. Next, it raised the bar considerably, launching the world’s first carbon-negative carpet tiles, designed to sequester more carbon than they create from “cradle to gate” – from raw material extraction through manufacturing – without the use of carbon offsets. Big consultancies are spotting the opportunity and making their plays. Take EY, which notes: “We’ve seen the rise of positive approaches in recent years – climate-positive, nature-pos-

None of this is particularly new. Properly understood, the sustainability agenda has always included regeneration, but that element has been increasingly sidetracked by concepts like corporate social responsibility, shared value, and ESG. All useful as far as they go, but rarely embracing true regeneration.

Linear mindsets and business models

Fossil fuel dependence

Shareholder primacy

TRANSITION

B Corp movement

Money = political power Inequality of wealth, income and opportunity

PREVALENCE

ESG investing goes mainstream Product and business model innovation Technologies enable greater transparency and accountability New technologies enable a better use of finite resources

Integration of human and machine intelligence

Political parties that champion sustainability issues do well

GDP growth is the goal

FUTURE

Externalities are properly priced

No fossil fuels

Attention spans get shorter and shorter More localized production and consumption patterns

New accounting frameworks and disclosure rules for extra-financials

Governments (eg, Scotland, New Zealand) start to prioritize well-being

Equal access to resources, education, health and capital

Waste has been designed out of value cycles rather than supply chains

Industries and countries run up against environmental limits Society is polarized and atomized

Retreat from globalization

Individuals within society have sense of purpose, opportunity and community

Social and enviromental regeneration, not economic growth, recognized as the goal

Social campaigning (eg, XR, climate strikes) triggers shift in social values

TIME

How horizons are changing

All three horizons in the diagram are present at any point in time, though their relative momentum and dominance change. Businesses that have been perfectly happy operating in a degenerative world of linear mindsets and models, fossil fuel dependence, and shareholder primacy now find

26 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

themselves facing what some call a polycrisis, or even permacrisis, as the resilience of systems we have all taken for granted starts to wobble. The critical question that boards and C-suites face is whether to batten down the hatches and hope to ride out the storm, or whether to set a new course

– even change the nature of the vessel they sail in. In the process, business models evolve to deliver net zero emissions, circularity, the relocalization of many parts of the economy, and the proper pricing of economic externalities that were once dumped on people and planet.

Infographic: Theresa Schwietzer, Source: Bill Sharpe adapted Volans

NOW


itive, and net-positive business – to address our interlinked natural and social challenges. At the same time, there is growing recognition that efforts to restrain climate change and halt biodiversity loss will not be successful unless we address them together as part of a broader holistic approach.” Regeneration, EY insists, “is a concept that addresses challenges comprehensively and provides CEOs and business leaders with a new framework for creating and protecting long-term value”. Moving beyond neutrality and zero-based frameworks, “regenerative approaches aim for complete systems changes that address the root causes of global challenges”. When we launched our business advisory firm and think tank Volans back in 2008, in the teeth of the ongoing financial implosion, we argued the need for system change – so, yes, it’s good to see some elements of the system change agenda embraced even by full-throttle capitalists. But, caveat emptor: this is the same EY where “hundreds” of auditors were recently discovered to have cheated on their ethics exams. True regeneration, it hardly needs saying, demands sustained commitment, ambition, and integrity even when it flies in the face of current business sense – as it often will. One interesting shift over the past decade has been the accelerating expansion of earlier discussions of the business case for change, from “Tell us why we should change!” to growing interest in evolving new business models: “How can we create new forms of value and be rewarded for them?” The business models catwalk

When Volans surveyed emerging breakthrough business models back in 2016, we argued that “the entire sustainability industry must undergo a radical reinvention, involving defragmentation and re-capitalization, if it is to tackle its current weaknesses, including intense siloing, internal competition, and a Babel-like confusion of terminologies”. We spotlighted 60 business models that combined elements of the social, lean, integrated value, and circular economies, all with an eye to exponential – not just incremental – replication and scaling. At the time, there wasn’t much research work being carried out on regenerative business models, but leading business schools are now showing greater interest. Recently, I keynoted the eighth International Conference on New Business Models, a series of events encouraging debate about and research into sustainable business models. Researchers from Maastricht University, for example, are exploring the differences between sustainable, circular, and regenerative business models. Jan Konietzko and his colleagues carried out a major literature review, organizing six focus groups, and concluded that “regenerative business models focus on planetary health and societal well-being. They create and deliver value at multiple stakeholder levels including nature, societies, customers, suppliers and partners, shareholders and investors, and employees – through activities promoting regenerative leadership, co-creative partnerships with nature, and justice and fairness”.

They continued: “Capturing value through multi-capital accounting, they aim for a net-positive impact across all stakeholder levels. Regenerative business models share some design approaches with sustainable and circular models but differ in their main goals and systemic perspectives.” As we concluded in our own Tomorrow’s Capitalism Inquiry, and in our 2020 book Green Swans, the “people, planet, and prosperity” framing still works in many areas but it must be seen in the context of an ongoing and accelerating shift from a “responsibility” framing to firstly a “resilience” framing and then on to a “regenerative” framing. The diagram on the facing page illustrates some of the underlying dynamics in this space as the sustainability agenda begins to go mainstream. As the failings of the current economic order are signaled by growing problems with the resilience of critical systems, so the need for truly regenerative strategies and business models will grow exponentially. Current corporate responsibility and ESG strategies are necessary conditions for progress, but they have failed to ward off the system resilience challenges now compromising our economies, societies, and biosphere. To solve these challenges, we need to regenerate all these systems, more or less simultaneously. Imagine, as an example, how the business model of a bank or insurance firm might evolve as it moves through the three stages. In the first domain, responsible practice might involve ensuring that vulnerable communities are red-lined or excluded. In the second, borrowers or those taking on insurance would be actively helped to make their operations more resilient. Then, in the third, tailored debt instruments and insurance cover would be developed and provided to regenerators to help them replicate and scale their solutions. The further we move toward the right-hand side of the diagram, the more business models must be designed and operated as if we intended to stay on this planet of ours. One thing is clear in all of this: the coming technological and industrial revolutions will drive existing businesses way beyond their comfort zones, forcing them to experiment in radically new ways. A key question now is whether business schools will continue to teach and support old-order solutions to tomorrow’s challenges, or whether they can shake off their own incumbent mindsets (and ranking and rating systems) to spur the evolution of the economic and business models that will define tomorrow’s regenerative economies. ■

John Elkington is Founder and Chief Pollinator at Volans and author of Green Swans: The Coming Boom in Regenerative Capitalism (Fast Company Press, 2020).

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 27


[ Sustainability transformation ]

Set an ambitious goal, then work backward to achieve it Using the ‘Future Back’ tool can set your organization on the path to a successful sustainable business transformation. Knut Haanaes and Bryony Jansen-van Tuyll outline three practical steps to achieve lasting results.

Project yourself into the future … much like the cast of the Sixties TV series ‘The Time Tunnel’

28 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

daily decisions and project their company into an aspirational future. From there, it asks business leaders to work back to the present and create a stairway to far-reaching change. The concept works equally well for a range of business priorities, from growth and innovation to cost and operational efficiency. Most companies have great processes and tools for short-term improvements, but few companies have good tools for the longer term. Thinking far into the future helps us free ourselves from what can and needs to happen today. It liberates us to think more creatively about our goals.

Photo: Pinterest

T

o design a strategy for a successful business transformation, imagine where ideally you want to be at a certain point in the future and then work out the steps needed to get there. This is the essence of the “Future Back” approach pioneered by Thomas Malnight, Professor Emeritus of Strategy and General Management at IMD. In our work, we see how the tool is particularly valuable for sustainability because many of the solutions to be leveraged might not yet exist, and it can help identify where innovation and collaboration may be needed. Future Back is a tool that encourages business leaders to temporarily disengage from the complications of


It gives us the space to set challenging and absolute goals rather than incremental ones. When we think from the present forward, we become linear and traditional, and we compromise on timing and targets. Future Back forces us to be ambitious and leaves no room for excuses. You are asked how you will reach your target, not whether you will achieve it. For every company, the imagined aspirational future will look different – it will depend on company and industry realities. From a sustainability perspective, drawing that ideal future picture requires understanding the varied needs of stakeholders. What is required to protect our environment? How can we support social equity and inclusion? What do our employees, or people in general, look for from their work? Here are examples of possible goals that could be set to kick-start action under a Future Back approach: • It’s 2030 and there is no more virgin plastic packaging. How did that happen? • It’s 2035 and our business has gone fully circular, taking back all our products to circle them back into the system. How did we get there? • It’s 2030 and the cocoa supply chain has managed to pay all employees family living wages. How did this come about? We have carried out these kinds of exercises with numerous executive teams, setting different goals depending on their industry and company. For interactions involving diverse participants, we have found that the following prompt can be a useful starting point for sustainability: “By 2030, we turned the corner on climate change. How did that happen?” Step 1: Imagining where you want to be in the future

It is best to do this as a group exercise with employees from different backgrounds and functions to enable diversity in opinions and ideas. However, it can be done individually to encourage more creative and ambitious thinking. • The first step in imagining an aspirational future is to set a date for how far ahead you would like to project. Ideally, it should be around 10 years away to ensure it is detached enough from the present to enable significant and innovative thinking. • From a sustainability perspective, determine what an ideal future would look like for your company. Where would you like your company to be providing a positive contribution? Think about the areas where your company is having a positive impact, for example, supporting communities or setting up recycling systems. Can that be strengthened even more? Think about where your company potentially has a negative impact – for example, emissions, water use, or low wages in the supply chain. Can any of those be turned around? Think about the strengths you have in your company. Could they contribute to solving local or global

8 steps to make

the ‘Future Back’ exercise a success

1. Introduce the concept of Future Back. Explain its benefits and how it differs from traditional planning.

2. Describe the exercise. Explain the purpose of the exercise, which is to encourage participants to think creatively and collaboratively about the future. 3. Form groups. Make sure the groups are diverse and that everyone has a chance to participate.

4. Provide framing. Put up templates in group rooms covering the key questions that will help them think through a roadmap.

5. Set the task. Instruct the groups to tell a story from the future that leads to a sustainability outcome. Encourage them to be specific and to think about the steps needed to achieve that outcome.

6. Allow time for discussion. Give groups time to discuss and develop a deliverable outcome. Encourage them to work collaboratively and be creative in their thinking. Groups work on posters that can be shared in plenary for discussion and learning. 7. Reconvene. Groups come back together and share their narratives, allowing everyone to learn from each other and understand the different approaches.

8. Summarize the discussion. Sum up the discussion around learnings, not solutions. Emphasize the importance of Future Back’s “ can do” mindset, where almost everything is possible if present realities do not constrain us.

issues that we collectively face? In an ideal world, where would you like your company to be leading in 10 or 15 years’ time? • Based on this analysis, set one ambitious objective to reach. Make the goal absolute and without compromise, like the examples above. As Paul Polman and Andrew Winston rightly note in their book Net Positive, if you set a target for 60% renewable energy, you are also saying that 40% will be energy that is probably polluting. Is that the goal you want to reach? A stretch goal will also push the team to think more creatively. • Choose a goal that excites the team and one that you would be proud to contribute to. If you are a construction company, how about imagining a future without waste going to landfills or burning? If you are a retail business, how about stores without plastic packaging or where customers are invited to return all the plastic packaging they use? If you are in shipping, how about a future with zero emissions? » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 29


[ Sustainability transformation ]

How ‘Future Back’ works in practice Future Back approaches have inspired sustainability initiatives across our interactions with program participants and corporate clients. We are seeing many companies shifting their strategy focus towards longer-term goals and acknowledging the need to improve their long-term planning toolkit. For example, one client, adept at short-term planning, sought ways to better prepare for shaping the future on more of a long-term basis, with Future Back thinking at its core. Other illustrations include the following: • A commodity company, aiming to lead in sustainable practices, found that by employing a Future Back approach, they could see potential in eco-friendly technologies, embracing renewable energy, land regeneration, and in engaging local communities. • A consumer goods company envisioned how to get to a circular economy future through packaging redesign, recycling collaborations, and sustainable consumption. • An engineering firm aspired to urban innovation, prompting investments in smart city technologies, cooperation with urban planners, and sustainable construction expertise. • A financial institution aspired to financial inclusion leadership via digital banking solutions by investing in digital infrastructure, community partnerships, and tailored financial products. Through these diverse examples we see how the Future Back approach empowers organizations to transcend limitations, stimulate innovation, and work towards ambitious, sustainable, and socially responsible long-term goals.

Step 2: Looking back – how did we get there?

Once the team has a good picture of the aspirational future, it is time to project yourselves into that future. Imagine we are in that future, and you have reached your goal. Now think about what happened that allowed you to achieve this. There are two routes to do this: Proactive: Think of the steps you took to get to the aspired future. Where did you invest? Which frameworks did you build? Which new business units did you create? Which products did you slash or add to your portfolio? How did you get all employees to contribute to reaching the goal? Think also about how your ecosystem supported you in reaching the destination. How did your suppliers contribute? Did you build new types of relationships with your customers? Was precompetitive collaboration required? Did you cross category lines to work with new types of organizations? Think also about the role that external parties played. Did government put up new regulations? 30 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Why Amazon innovators write press releases for products that don’t exist Ian McAllister, a former director at Amazon, has described in a blog post on Quora how the company uses a similar tool to Future Back to infuse innovation processes. Through the “Working Backward” approach, employees who have ideas for new products or services are asked to write a press release. In most companies, a press release is written when a product is ready to hit the markets. Amazon turns this around. In their press release, the employee must describe the problem they identified, explain how existing solutions aren’t good enough, and how this new solution would benefit customers. Written in a language that is both convincing and simple for customers to understand, the press release is then shared internally. This process forces the employee to focus and flesh out the idea on paper up-front, share, get feedback, and better evaluate whether the idea is worth pursuing. Spending time on this up-front process is more cost effective than diving straight into product development. At the same time, once the press release is approved, it helps teams stay focused on the final product rather than getting lost in adding features or functionalities.

Photo: www.beunpackaged.com

Can a global fast-moving goods company go totally packaging free by 2030? Innovative companies offering packaging free solutions, such as Unpackaged in the UK, show that alternatives are possible


and possible partners you could collaborate with. Deliberate whether there are ways that you could influence change at a political or societal level. What else could you do to make the change come about concretely? Consider whether your current business goals could be adapted or elaborated. And finally, is it possible to develop new KPIs to ensure objectives are clear and measurable? Our learning is that Future Back should take a long-term perspective but the focus in the discussion should go back to the first steps – on how we got started. We often add a question on players, for example, who were the main stakeholders, what was the role of business, or what role did our company play?

‘Future Back forces us to be ambitious and leaves no room for excuses. You are asked how you will reach your target, not whether you will achieve it’

The goal of the exercise is to be as ambitious and creative as possible in thinking of strategies for a better future. Some companies such as Amazon (see box) already excel at using the Future Back concept. But all organizations can use it to play a role in protecting our environment, supporting workers and communities, and safeguarding our shared future. The key is identifying the most relevant levers for your business and industry and setting demanding goals. ■

Can a real estate firm aim for their buildings to capture more CO2 than they release through energy use? This well-known apartment block in Milan might provide inspiration

This article is the final instalment in the IMD Sustainability Toolkit series. Scan the QR code to explore the full series.

Photo: Daryan Shamkhalivia Unsplash

Reactive: Think of shocks to the system that might have brought you to the aspired future and how this forced your company to react. For example, were there climate catastrophes that caused governments to shut down parts of the economy, like during the COVID-19 pandemic? Was there an incumbent that changed the rules of the game? Did a social or political crisis force the company to take a different route? How did the company react to the shock, bringing it to the desired system? A timeline can help lay out all the different actions and reactions that are part of the story of how you got to that desired future. Step 3: Planning a pathway to the future

Once you have a good picture of the aspirational future, it is time to return to the here and now. Consider which of the steps in the story you could make happen today. Think about products and service models you could develop, ways to leverage your resources differently from today,

Knut Haanaes is Professor of Strategy and Lundin Sustainability Chair at IMD. He is Program Co-Director of the Leading Sustainable Business Transformation program and the Driving Sustainability from the Boardroom program. Previously, Knut was a Dean of the Global Leadership Institute at the World Economic Forum, and a Senior Partner and Managing Director at the Boston Consulting Group, where he was Global Leader of the group’s Strategy Practice. Bryony Jansen-van Tuyll is a Senior Research Writer Sustainability at IMD. Previously, she worked as a management consultant, supporting companies in their growth strategies, before specializing in sustainable innovation. Bryony has founded and run non-profit organizations aimed at knowledge sharing around sustainable business, connecting with experts and entrepreneurs who are developing novel business models and systems.

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 31


[ Sustainability transformation ]

A new legal framework is needed to cut through the sustainability jungle With over 300 sustainability standards and labels available, it’s no wonder that so many companies get away with ‘greenwashing’. A new approach is needed to drive holistic and transparent change, write Jonathan Normand and Fabio Monnet of B Lab Switzerland

A

t a time when sustainability is increasingly demanded of businesses, the European commerce landscape stands at the precipice of significant transformation. A rising number of regulations and standards, a surge in sustainability labels, and the evolving expectations of stakeholders have set new and complex norms for companies of all sizes and sectors to navigate.

But how do we move beyond the buzzwords and noise and genuinely infuse sustainability into the core of business operations? For the foundation B Lab Switzerland, the answer is clear: we need to push back against green- and impact-washing, cut through the complexity of the label jungle, support rather than demonize companies in their sustainability quest, and be clear about what true sustainability entails. A new legal framework, drawing on the strengths of existing rules and voluntary certification processes, could build the necessary momentum for change. A call for more transparency and collaboration

In today's business world, companies need to show they are about more than just profits – they need to prove that they are environmentally and ethically responsible, too. Sadly, many companies make false claims or exaggerate their green efforts, so-called “greenwashing”. A study conducted by the European Commission and national consumer authorities indicates that "in 42% of cases, companies' green claims on their websites were exaggerated, false, or deceptive". Greenwashing is widespread, for instance, among fast-fashion brands. Using guidelines from the UK Competition and Markets Authority, research by the Changing Market Foundation in its 2021 “Synthetics Anonymous” report found 32 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

that 96% of sustainability claims by H&M, 89% of ASOS’s green claims, and 88% of Marks & Spencer’s claims fell short of the guidelines in some way. That's where sustainability labels come in. They help vouch for a company's true commitment to doing good. But with over 300 different sustainability labels out there, companies, investors, and consumers can struggle to figure out which labels really matter and what they mean. To improve the situation, B Lab Switzerland has appealed for greater transparency. We believe we must strive for a clearer, easily navigable system to validate the authenticity of corporate sustainability assertions and to boost consumer trust. This process will be complex, but it is necessary and will require learning on all sides. The B Lab and its B Corp certification process, for example, actively advocates for collaboration between different actors in the certification movement as a key component in standard development. We work with the Impact Management Project (IMP), a coalition that fosters global consensus on impact measurement and management. This collaborative endeavor is aimed at paving a clear, achievable path to sustainability for corporations and providing comprehensible guidance for consumers. Collaborative initiatives like these show us a way through what KPMG has called the “jungle” of sustainability labels and point towards a future where credible certification can regain the trust of consumers, investors, and business partners. Navigating the complexities of the business landscape calls for customers, investors, and corporations to grasp the full breadth of sustainability, spanning all environmental, social, and governance (ESG) dimensions. This purview extends beyond environmental stewardship to incorporate best-practice corporate governance, which demands ethical and transparent decision-making processes as well as social sustainability, promoting elements such as inclusive hiring practices and active support for local communities. As an illustration of how businesses can shine in one area of ESG but fail in another, a company might operate with a carbon-neutral footprint yet maintain questionable labor practices in its supply chain.


300+ eco-labels E

S

G

ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIAL GOVERNANCE ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIAL ENVIRONMENTAL GOVERNANCE SOCIAL GOVERNANCE ENVIRONMENTAL

25 industry sectors

199 countries

There are over 300 sustainability and eco-labels with varying scopes. While a few cover all aspects of ESG, most only cover one or perhaps two different elements. This can paint a confusing picture of a company’s true values and, in the worst cases, facilitate so-called greenwashing.

B Lab’s B Corp certification offers a more holistic approach and aims to balance profit, people, and the planet. For example, Fairphone, a B Corp-certified enterprise from the Netherlands, champions an ethical approach with its interchangeable phone parts, which not only reduces waste but also contributes significantly to worker rights and environmental sustainability.

‘We must strive for a clearer, easily navigable system to validate the authenticity of corporate sustainability assertions and to boost consumer trust’ Comprehensive certification frameworks such as B Corp, EcoVadis, and others grant clear insights into a company's overarching sustainability practices. Other product- or process-specific labels cater to distinct sustainability nuances or industry-specific concerns that might not be wholly captured by broader evaluations. Consider a coffee product bearing both Fair Trade and B Corp emblems. From such labeling, a consumer can be confident that, at a foundational level, the company conforms to stringent environmental and social benchmarks, painting a holistic picture of its ESG commitment (B Corp label), and that the coffee has been ethically sourced, accounting for fair compensation and sustainable farming practices (Fair Trade label). In essence, while all-encompassing certifications give an expansive perspective, specialized badges delve into the details, together delivering a rounded sustainability narrative. B Lab recognizes this balance, collaborating with niche sustainability standards such as Fair Trade. Such partnerships enrich its wide-ranging approach with precise, pointed standards, framing a detailed sustainability map for businesses. The challenges faced by SMEs

Source: KPMG

SOCIAL

GOVERNANCE

As Europe introduces new regulatory measures – notably the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) and the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) – big corporations, both in the EU and in closely aligned markets such as Switzerland, are gearing up for compliance. Given the interconnectedness of European markets and Switzerland's close trading ties with the EU, it is anticipated that Swiss corporations, too, will eventually need to fall into alignment. Although the directives primarily target larger entities, their indirect repercussions are expected to extend to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). SMEs, often viewed as the backbone of the Swiss economy, are at a critical juncture. While our experience shows that they are keen to embrace sustainable practices, they also grapple with the cost-intensive nature of non-financial reporting and complying with sustain- » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 33


[ Sustainability transformation ]

The Alliance for Sustainable Enterprises calls for Swiss law changes Nicole Bardet, Board Member and Responsible for Corporate Loans at Banque Alternative Switzerland: "For us, it would be very important to have a model for change and economic transformation. With the help of a legislative framework, we can be much stronger and can go much further."

Christophe Barman, Co-Founder Loyco, Co-president FSE and President Fédération Romande des Consommateurs: "We need a reference framework for what a sustainable business is. Today, we rely on private initiatives and our own judgment."

A manifesto for the recognition of sustainable enterprises The path to a sustainable economy lies in a synergistic combination of private labels, standards, and a new regulatory framework that offers clear, detailed, and fair guidance and rules for all actors, developed in collaboration with a diverse range of interests, from NGOs to small businesses. To ensure the specific needs and views of the Swiss corporate and voluntary community are integrated into any proposal for a new kind of legal framework in the Swiss parliament, B Lab Switzerland has developed a manifesto to engage private sectors, individuals, and civil society organizations. For full details, go to www.blab-switzerland.ch/manifesto.

What is the B Corp Certification?

B Lab Switzerland, as part of the B Lab global movement, supports companies in the B Corp Certification process and has also developed national engagement programs: The Swiss Triple Impact Program, which helps Swiss organizations – regardless of size and sector – to set a clear and tailored sustainability strategy, and the Swiss Boards for Agenda 2030, an alliance of Swiss CEOs and board members committed to sustainability.

To date, the certified Swiss B Corp community includes over 100 certified companies and, at a global level, more than 7,000 companies across 160 industries in 90 countries are certified B Corps. 150,000 firms also use the related B Impact Assessment tool, which evaluates how a company’s operations and business model impact workers, communities, the environment, and customers. The tool forms the basis of the B Corps certification process, with certified companies required to meet high standards of verified social and environmental performance, transparency, and accountability, from supply chain to employee benefits.

34 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

ability standards. Large corporations, with their vast resources and influential market positions, are setting the tone by demanding tangible proof of sustainability via non-financial reporting and high ESG scores. This trend puts SMEs in a precarious position. Without adequate support and foresight, SMEs could find themselves lagging, especially if these sustainability requirements solidify as industry norms. The situation is exacerbated by potential biases against SMEs in ESG ratings. Limited resources might hinder their ability to measure and present all the relevant information comprehensively, thereby impacting their ESG scores. This, in turn, affects their competitiveness in accessing sustainable finance, which is becoming an integral part of modern business financing strategies. Therefore, public decision-makers must acknowledge and address these challenges head-on, crafting policies that recognize and cater to the unique needs of SMEs. Furthermore, large corporations, with their comprehensive reporting, emissions reduction, and production standards, often extend these expectations to their supply chain partners. SMEs, if unprepared or unsupported, might find it challenging to meet these standards. Failure to do so risks them becoming side-lined, as larger corporations have the leverage to shift to other suppliers that fit the bill. Meeting the demands set by these corporations requires significant resources and time, which is often a luxury SMEs cannot afford, especially when juggling operational costs and employee welfare. The role of regulatory frameworks in enhancing sustainability

While private labels and standards are critical in driving the sustainability agenda, their scope often falls short of creating universally impactful change, as they are either not sufficiently known or recognized by consumers, investors, and businesses or do not encompass all ESG dimensions. Recognizing this gap, B Lab Switzerland is championing the introduction of a comprehensive Swiss legal framework. This proposed regulatory structure aims to not only fill the void left by private labels but also to extend support to SMEs. This legal framework would equip SMEs with the necessary guidance to navigate any more stringent ESG requirements demanded by larger corporations in light of new EU regulations, thereby leveling the competitive playing field and facilitating more accessible financial resources. Moreover, this proposed framework isn't exclusive to SMEs. It provides a roadmap for larger corporations seeking proactive alignment with the forthcoming EU directives. Key organizations such as Swiss Leaders and Fédérations Suisse des Entreprises have already voiced their support for the initiative. Through a comparative law study conducted by Professor Giulia Neri-Castracane at the University of Geneva, and in partnership with experts including Professor Jean-Luc Chenaux, Professor Henry Peter, and Dr Michael Mosimann, B Lab Switzerland has gleaned crucial insights about Switzerland’s readiness for the pending changes in regulation across Europe. The study highlights that unlike some of its European counterparts


Global regulatory best practices and learnings for Switzerland The US, UK, Italy, France, and Spain have instituted legal frameworks that acknowledge businesses (“benefit corporations”) integrating social and environmental goals alongside their profit objectives. A parallel model is currently being proposed in Switzerland. B Lab and the Alliance for Sustainable Enterprises argue that it will deliver clarity to Swiss citizens, consumers, financial operators, and the nation at large. By doing so, it would further bolster Switzerland’s reputation as a hub for business and innovation. The primary characteristics and mandates of these existing frameworks include: 1. Directors' empowerment: These jurisdictions empower directors of benefit corporations with greater security and flexibility, enabling them to balance a wide range of stakeholder interests without facing criticism or legal challenges. 2. Soft governance: Benefit corporations are encouraged to enshrine sustainability principles in their statutes, ensuring that these values persist, even through changes in company ownership.

3. Third-party assessments: Benefit corporations undergo third-party evaluations, offering a consistent and impartial assessment of their dedication to societal and environmental goals. 4. Mandatory reporting: Benefit corporations are required to produce annual reports. This mandate includes SMEs, which might not usually fall under standard non-financial reporting obligations. 5. Rapid adoption: The uptake of the benefit corporation model in these countries has surpassed that of private certifications, highlighting its practical appeal. Building on this foundation, B Lab’s proposed legal framework for Switzerland aims to enhance and adapt the model with the following elements: 1. Shift in reporting: Reporting for benefit corporations will evolve from "public benefit reporting" to a more standardized non-financial format, aligning Swiss benefit legal framework reporting with European reporting standards.

– including France, Italy, and Spain – Switzerland lacks a concrete legislative framework to guide companies in their pursuit of ESG objectives. This finding underscores the pressing need for a holistic framework to support the fair adoption of corporate sustainability in Switzerland and sets the stage for further discourse on this pivotal issue. Wherever such legislation has been instituted, the quantity of companies electing to qualify under this category significantly surpasses the number adhering to private labels. For instance, in Italy, following the introduction in 2015 of specific legislation inspired by similar laws in the US, more than 3,000 companies have been granted “Società Benefit” status – an official label for for-profit organizations that deliver more than one public benefit and operates responsibly and sustainably, according to definitions laid out in the legislation. This underscores the compelling influence of regulatory frameworks in encouraging and enabling companies to adopt sustainable practices. There is a growing realization within the Swiss business community of the need for this kind of framework in Switzerland. The Alliance for Sustainable Enterprises – a B Lab-coordinated Swiss consortium calling

2. Due diligence integration: Inspired by the EU's CSDDD, elements of due diligence will be incorporated, ensuring that Swiss benefit corporations not only report on sustainability but also take proactive measures. 3. Support for SMEs: A significant focus will be on offering technical and, potentially, financial support to SMEs transitioning to benefit corporation status. This support is designed to ensure that Swiss SMEs maintain competitiveness relative to their European peers. 4. Third-party assessment refinement: The criteria and design for the Swiss model's third-party assessments are under active development, with contributions from experts and stakeholders. B Lab has identified nine primary focus areas for companies considering this new legal status and aiming for a holistic approach to sustainability: purpose and governance, ethical and anti-corruption practices, human rights, climate management, environmental management, equal opportunities, fair wages, health and well-being, and community engagement.

for new legislation – now counts more than 200 companies and leadership organizations among its ranks. We hope that more businesses will partake in this transformative movement as we advocate for a competitive approach that synchronizes with the challenges of innovation and the legal recognition necessities of all Swiss enterprises. ■

Jonathan Normand is leader of B Lab Switzerland, which he founded in 2017. An expert in societal innovation and governance, he participated in the launch of B Lab in Europe in 2014. He also designed the Swiss Triple Impact engagement program and is co-initiator of the Swiss Board for Agenda 2030. He contributes to academic publications and research for an inclusive, circular, and regenerative economy. Fabio Monnet is a postgraduate student at the University of Geneva. At B Lab Switzerland, he is researching the implications for businesses of EU regulations covering sustainability issues.

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 35


[ CEO dialogue ]

Dilhan Pillay, CEO of Singapore’s global investment giant Temasek, discusses with Jean-François Manzoni the importance of an internal carbon price and how his company is working to ensure ‘every generation prospers’ without sacrificing profits 36 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

T

he year 2022 was a turbulent one for financial markets, with rampant inflation and the resulting rate hikes by central bankers leading to the worst stock market performance since the 2008 global financial crisis. Against this volatile backdrop, Temasek, a global investment company, is doubling down on its mission to build a resilient and forward-looking portfolio with sustainability at its core. Founded in 1974 to own and manage businesses and assets previously held by the Singapore government following the city-state's independ-

Photo: Temasek

The net-zero portfolio ‘isn’t like a light switch that’s on or off ... it’s a journey, but you have to start somewhere’


ence from Malaysia, Temasek has grown from a portfolio of 35 Singaporean-based companies with a book value of 354 million Singapore dollars ($261m) to a global investment house worth 382 billion Singapore dollars (as of 31 March 2023). Ranked among the top 10 investors in the world (according to the Global SWF 2022 GSR scorecard), with average annual returns of 14% since 1974, 6% over the past decade, and 9% over the past 20 years, Temasek owns holdings as diverse as China’s second-largest lender China Construction Bank, German pharmaceutical group Bayer, and Singapore Airlines, and employs 950 people globally. Pillay joined Temasek in 2010 from the law firm WongPartnership with a plan to stay for three years. Thirteen years later he’s still there − not because he was promised a job, but because he became increasingly convinced that pursuing Temasek’s mission to secure prosperity for future generations was more important than what he had left behind.

Dilhan Pillay

ID

• Joined Temasek in 2010, and held various leadership roles before becoming CEO, including Head of Temasek's Investment, Portfolio Management, and Enterprise Development Groups. He has also led various market teams including Singapore, and the Americas.

• A member of the Future Economy Council, an initiative by the

Singaporean government to oversee future skills and innovation efforts to prepare for potential technological or economic disruptions and opportunities.

• Sits on the Financial Centre Advisory Panel of the Monetary Authority of Singapore and the boards of the National Research Foundation (NRF) and Enterprise Singapore.

• Board Director at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, a US-based global economic think tank.

‘It’s not just about making financial returns – which are very important – but it’s also about how we uplift communities’ In October 2021, he ascended to the CEO role just as the investment firm grappled with the economic fallout from the pandemic and rising global trade tensions. Yet this has only emboldened Pillay to double down on Temasek’s mission to help its portfolio companies transition towards a net-zero future. Sustainability at the core

Even before taking over Temasek’s helm, Pillay was involved in shaping the investment firm’s 2030 strategy that identified six key issues that pose current and future challenges and opportunities, among them persistent inflation, geopolitical tensions, and climate change. This strategy is supported by four pillars, one of which involves putting sustainability at the core. It aims to slash the net carbon emissions of its portfolio to half of 2010 levels by 2030 and achieve net zero portfolio emissions by 2050. While this is undoubtedly the right thing to do for future generations who will have to deal with the “existential problem” of climate change, Pillay champions the approach and believes it makes good financial sense. “If you're a long-term investor, you look at what the value of the portfolio is going to be, not in terms of a three, five, or 10-year timeframe, but even 15 to 20 years,” he said. “And if you look at all the events that would impact the portfolio over that timeframe, you cannot ignore the impact of climate change.” Pillay admits that reaching some of Temasek’s goals will be a tall order for some of its investments, which include a container shipping company, an airline, and a port business. But he believes setting out a clear and credible vision for how to get there will be rewarded by investors.

• Formerly Managing Partner of WongPartnership LLP, one of the largest

law firms in Singapore with clients around the world. Practiced law for over 20 years in the areas of mergers and acquisitions, corporate governance, and general corporate law.

• Graduated from the National University of Singapore with a law degree and obtained a Master's from the University of Cambridge.

“It’s not like a light switch that’s on or off, it’s a journey. But you have to start somewhere,” he said. “You come up with a plan for that journey, figure out how you’re going to transition your business, transform your business, when you’re going to put capital to work for that transformation, and start doing it now because then the long-term value will be ascribed to you by other investors and we will get the benefit too.” He cites the example of Sembcorp Industries, a power utilities company that hived off its division that developed offshore oil rigs in 2020, to focus on green energy. The new CEO committed to quadrupling its renewables capacity to 10 gigawatts by 2025 – a target he had almost hit by the end of 2022 – and generating 70% of its profit from green investments in the same period. “The share price has gone up three-and-a-half times. Not because of us – we haven’t bought a single share – but because a new group of investors have embraced that transitional model and is now basically valuing him on his execution capabilities of the vision he has set forward for the company,” explained Pillay. Internal incentives to decarbonize

Temasek has taken some bold action to ensure its portfolio is fit for the future, including imposing an internal carbon price of US$50 per tonne » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 37


[ CEO dialogue ]

of CO2 to better assess the resiliency of companies in their transition journeys, and prepare for a world in which regulators might force firms to price in the cost of their actions.

Sustainable business transformation has thrown up a confusing array of organizations, regulations, and protocols. Here’s a quick guide to some of the most important:

The firm expects to raise its internal carbon price progressively to $100 per tonne of CO2 by the end of the decade. One of its existing portfolio companies, the national carrier Singapore Airlines, is in the process of renewing its entire fleet with planes that are up to 30% more fuel efficient. “Now why is that important? Well, because Singapore Airlines emitted 19.6 million tonnes of CO2 equivalent back in 2019, pre-pandemic. And if they go up at that level to $100 per tonne [of CO2 emitted], you’re going to be looking at a bill of almost $2 billion,” said Pillay. “That’s not feasible. So, you’ve got to do things today to reduce that full impact in the future.”

“I believe that we are here to ensure that future generations benefit from what we do today. At the end of the day, it’s not just about making financial returns – which are very important – but it’s also about how we uplift communities,” he said. “We have a responsibility, with others, to create a better world for future generations.” ■

Standards. Adopted by the EU this year, the law requires all large companies and all listed companies (except listed micro-enterprises) to disclose information on the risks and opportunities arising from social and environmental issues, and on the impact of their activities on people and the environment.

ISSB The International Sustainability Standards

Information station

The internal carbon price also acts as an incentive to invest in carbon-negative businesses, which could include sequestration, green hydrogen, and carbon capture and storage. This fits with Temasek’s broader purpose − simplified in 2021 into the statement, “So every generation prospers” − which encapsulates its role as stewarding today’s assets for the benefit of current generations as well as those who have not yet been born.

ESRS European Sustainability Reporting

Board aims to develop standards for a global baseline of sustainability disclosures to aid investors in their decision-making and enable companies to provide comprehensive sustainability information to global capital markets.

GHP Scope 1-3 Greenhouse Gas Protocol

Corporate Standard classifies a company’s emissions into three categories. Scope 1: direct emissions from owned or controlled sources. Scope 2: indirect emissions from the generation of purchased energy. Scope 3: all indirect emissions that occur in the value chain of the reporting company (upstream and downstream).

GRI The standards set by the Global Reporting

Initiative represent global best practice for reporting publicly on a range of economic, environmental, and social impacts. Sustainability reporting based on the standards provides information about an organization’s positive or negative contributions to sustainable development.

TCFD The Taskforce on Climate-related Financial

Watch the full CEO Dialogue to hear more about Temasek’s evolving investment strategy, his view on China’s economic prospects, and how the investment firm has built centers of excellence in AI, blockchain, cyber, and digital transformation to add value to its portfolio companies. Jean-François Manzoni is President of IMD, where he also serves as Nestlé Chaired Professor of Leadership and Organizational Development. His research, teaching, and consulting activities are focused on leadership, the development of high-performance organizations, and corporate governance.

38 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Disclosures was created by the Financial Stability Board to develop recommendations on the types of information that companies should disclose to support investors, lenders, and insurance underwriters in appropriately assessing and pricing a specific set of risks related to climate change.

B Corp Certification is a designation that a

business is meeting high standards of verified performance, accountability, and transparency on factors from employee benefits and charitable giving to supply chain practices and input materials.


[ The I reader ]

Five reads to sustain and detain you IMD professors recommend books to help you think differently about the challenges posed by sustainable business transformation Radical Collaboration – Five essential skills to overcome defensiveness and build successful relationships James Tamm and Ronald J Luyet

Ask any leader who drives sustainability transformation if collaboration is important, you will get a sounding “yes”. Ask if collaboration is working well within his or her organization and with outside stakeholders, the answer will be much more pessimistic. Radical Collaboration is a “how to” guide for building effective collaboration in and outside the organization. Sustainability transformation is dependent on strong collaboration – not only within organizations but also with external stakeholders. Without it, building competitive advantages based on sustainability is impossible. Radical Collaboration is an important guide to taking collaboration seriously and putting it at the heart of the upskilling initiatives needed for sustainable business transformation. Florian Hoos, Professor of Sustainability and ESG Accounting

Saving Us: A Climate Scientist’s Case for Hope and Healing in a Divided World Katharine Hayhoe The “knowing-doing gap” is perhaps the most significant climate-related challenge we face today. The concept explains a situation where we have plenty of knowledge (through science and our own experiences) to assess the challenge, but still do not act forcefully enough. This can be applied to climate change: despite our increased knowledge, inaction is the real enemy. The book by Hayhoe, a reputable climate scientist known for her ability to communicate complex concepts, is among the most important on the subject so far. Her message is clear: it matters how we talk about climate change and who we talk to. There is always a way towards mutual understanding. She uses anecdotes – positive and negative – about bridging the knowing-doing gap, provides real-life examples of conversations, and reveals our dilemmas. Hopefully, Saving Us can help us to engage in better dialogue and more aligned action. Knut Haanaes, Professor of Strategy and Lundin Sustainability Chair

The Ministry for the Future Kim Stanley Robinson

How will our climate future unravel for business and society? Countless business and economics books have provided theories and recommendations, but they miss a novel’s ability to engage a reader’s imagination and emotions. The Ministry for the Future, published in 2020, does exactly that. It’s 2025 and the ministry has been set up under the auspices of the Paris Agreement with the purpose of acting on behalf of future generations of all living creatures. The ministry’s activities gather pace when a deadly heatwave hits India. The novel – which centers on the adventures of Mary Murphy, the leader of the Ministry, and Frank May, an American aid worker – provides thought-provoking commentary and hard scientific evidence on the effects of climate change. James Henderson, Professor of Strategic Management

Breaking Together: A Freedom-Loving Response to Collapse Jem Bendell

Is society already experiencing total system collapse? Renowned scholar Jem Bendell argues that the collapse of industrial consumer societies is well underway – framing it as a process rather than a single event. He invites us to reflect openly and honestly on the “deep adaptation” required to ensure future flourishing. The book’s first half explores seven types of collapse: economic, monetary, energy, biosphere, climate, food, and societal. The second focuses on seven “freedoms,” including the freedom to know, freedom from progress, and freedom from banking. The book offers a practical way to rid ourselves of self-destructive habits that abound in our consumption-led, fear-based society and choose instead to live in a more spiritual and sustainable place of universal love. Susan Goldsworthy, Affiliate Professor of Leadership, Communications, and Organizational Change

Privacy is Power: : Why and How You Should Take Back Control of Your Data Carissa Véliz

When we think about sustainability, we often consider the preservation of the planet and the biosphere (at least I do). While this is essential, we also need to think about preserving fundamental rights such as access to reliable and unbiased information, the freedom to form informed opinions, and the ability to choose and critically assess what we consume. Privacy is Power explores how personal privacy is evolving in the digital age, emphasizing the societal risks stemming from an increased use of digital tools and services in all spheres of our life. Posing challenging questions, Véliz provides readers with mental frameworks and practical tools to critically assess how their data is being used. She inspires readers to become "privacy active" citizens who can shape and co-create a more prosperous, free, and socially sustainable society. A must-read for all those aspiring to lead. José Parra-Moyano, Professor of Digital Strategy

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 39


[ Sustainability transformation ]

Leading systems change is tough. We asked the experts how to get it right Today’s urgent sustainability challenges need more than the efforts of individual companies. Amanda Williams and Knut Haanaes talked to systems-change leaders to explore how organizations can collaborate across sectors and supply chains to keep within planetary boundaries

Five key factors in leading effectively for systems change emerged from their collective experiences and approaches:

atural scientists propose that we have entered the Anthropocene, a new geological epoch created by the damaging impact of humans. Since the Industrial Revolution, our activities have been the main driver for Earth system changes and are responsible for pushing our use of resources beyond planetary boundaries. If collective industrial impacts have fundamentally altered the Earth's systems, then collective efforts are needed to ensure we do not go beyond sustainable limits. This calls for the transformation of entire sectors and all companies working along the same supply chain. For example, restoring biodiversity in a given geographical region will require every firm that depends on the natural resources in the area to change their practices. Also, reducing Greenhouse Gas Protocol Scope 3 emissions along the supply chain requires the cooperation of companies both up and downstream.

If we can change the underlying incentives or the root causes of the unsustainability of those broader systems and the way they work, then sectoral and value chain change will follow, White explained. For example, leading up to the 2015 COP21 climate negotiations in Paris, the World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBSCD) gathered the voice of business to demonstrate business solutions that could justify stronger climate policies and commitments. The resulting Paris Agreement has served as the foundation for ambitious climate action, such as the Science Based Targets initiative that provides companies with a framework to set long-term climate targets in line with the goal of keeping temperature change within 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels. A similar process for biodiversity is currently underway: Business for Nature is bringing the voice of business to the UN biodiversity conferences to advocate for stricter biodiversity reporting and disclosure requirements.

To tackle these challenges, specific roles designed to lead systems change are becoming more widespread. Leaders of systems change initiatives have a difficult task – they have to mobilize loosely coupled, diverse actors to solve broad long-term social or environmental issues without any formal control or power.

2. Communicate the vision clearly for all stakeholders

To better understand this emerging role and what it takes to drive change at this scale, we spoke to the following four leaders of systems change representing the private, public, nonprofit, and academic sectors: Christine Diamente of the sustainable business consultancy BSR, Rasmus Valanko of the We Mean Business Coalition (WMBC), Peter White, Professor of Practice, Business and Biodiversity at the University of Exeter in the UK, and Gail Whiteman, an executive director of Arctic Basecamp. 40 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

System leaders must begin their task by seeking to understand the complex social and ecological problems they are trying to solve. They base this initial analysis on science and research. All of our interviewees said starting with a holistic view of the problem based on the facts was key. White recommended focusing on the systems level – such as those covering energy or food – instead of the sector or value chain level. Many sectors are interconnected and are subsystems of (and depend upon) the larger systems in which they are embedded.

Beyond this analysis, there needs to be an effective, intermediary translator between science and the collective mass to drive change. The most important aspects of the holistic systems understanding need to be simplified and communicated to key stakeholders. Our experts said finding the right balance between simplicity and complexity could be challenging and required some iteration to get right. Valanko said: “The challenge you always have is how much do you simplify so that you're able to take decisions and communicate those to the people that you need to bring on the journey with you, versus how much complexity do you retain to ensure that you do actually go in the exact right direction? I think that's the piece where the actual word leadership

Photo: Alex Stephen Teuscher

N

1. Build a holistic view based on science


The panel of experts Christine Diamente | Managing Director of Business Transformation at BSR. Diamente leads BSR’s Business Transformation team, helping companies manage sustainability throughout their business and across their supply chains and to develop resilient business strategies. She has over 20 years of experience in leading brand, sustainability, public affairs, communications, and reputation management with multinational corporations at the executive leadership level. Her role includes overseeing corporate relations with external stakeholders, such as the World Economic Forum (WEF), the UN, European institutions, and investors. Rasmus Valanko | Managing Director of Systems Transformation at the We Mean Business Coalition (WMBC). At WMBC, a global nonprofit coalition, Valanko works to implement systemic change by working with companies and partner organizations on climate change. Before joining WMBC, he led the sustainability transformation of the chemical company Kemira, acting as Director for Corporate Sustainability. He has directed several business collaboration initiatives at the World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD) where he led the climate and energy program. His background includes climate change and strategy work at Royal Dutch Shell as well as multilateral environmental agreement negotiations with the government of Finland. Valanko has a wealth of knowledge on sustainability from the private, public, and NGO sectors. Peter White | Professor of Practice, Business and Biodiversity at the University of Exeter. White is a sustainability leader and biologist with experience leading organizations, research, policy work, and teaching in global corporations, international NGOs, and academia. For more than seven years, he was responsible for WBCSD’s work programs in climate and energy, food, land and water, cities, people, and the circular economy, redefining value, and sector projects in chemicals, forestry, cement, and tires. Previously, he led the sustainability approach for the world’s largest consumer goods company as Director for Global Sustainability, creating the company’s long-term vision and sustainability goals. Gail Whiteman | Executive Director at Arctic Basecamp, Professor of Sustainability at the University of Exeter Business School, and Professor-in-Residence at WBCSD. Whiteman is the Founder of Arctic Basecamp, a registered not-for-profit science outreach platform that brings a message to the WEF annual meeting at Davos on the global risk to the Arctic. In 2022, she launched an online Arctic Risk Platform (www.arcticrisk.org) to curate the latest scientific information on how the Arctic drives global risks for key target audiences, including businesses. Whiteman is a social science expert on how decision-makers make sense of systemic global risks from climate change and other environmental threats. Since 2012, she has been the Professor-in-Residence at the WBCSD and is actively involved in building science-based targets for collective business action.

comes in. Leadership isn't just about knowing where to go, it's about how many people you bring with you.” For example, in his work at Kemira, there were multiple different stakeholder perspectives that he could use as a lens to understand how the chemical industry would evolve across several countries over the next decades. Complex technological, economic, political, and environmental factors all needed to be taken into account. These factors complicate all sustainability-related leadership decisions. Valanko chose to focus on the consumer perspective and integrate climate change into strategy. This strategic direction paved the way for sustainability as a whole to be integrated into the core strategy.   Whiteman founded Arctic Basecamp because she felt there was a need to translate complex system dynamics based on natural science to decision-makers. “We needed to get a much more direct communication line between scientists – particularly natural scientists that knew about systemic global risks that would happen in the future – and those actors that had power that could make decisions to either adapt or mitigate to those risks,” she said. Arctic Basecamp curates scientific data, then translates and communicates it in a way that everyone can understand. It then designs data visualizations to share the information broadly in new ways. For example, the Arctic Sea Ice Meltometer lets users interactively explore how greenhouse gases across the globe are contributing to Arctic Sea ice melt. Through effective communication, the initial systems view forms the basis for a long-term shared, pliable, and broad vision that diverse stakeholders can get behind. “A key skill of systems leaders is being able to bring people together from very different viewpoints,” said Whiteman. 3. Intervene in the system through collaboration

The next step is to identify the levers of change or the concrete actions and solutions that will drive change on the ground. White said these levers were hindering business progress, and which, if altered, might help drive progress forward. All our experts said the initiative they were leading had a set of core competencies and resources that served as the foundation for the change lever. For example, WMBC specializes in creating “ambition loops” where evidence of business action provides confidence for policymakers to increase their own ambition. Meanwhile, Arctic Basecamp leverages science to change information flows and influence decision-makers. Each organization or initiative has its own unique role to play in systems transformation. Collaboration is key in this step because the systems change initiative may not have all the resources needed. Deciding which collaborations to engage in depends on what resources are already available and what resources need to be acquired through partnerships. All our » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 41


[ Sustainability transformation ]

interviewees expressed the need to collaborate with other systems-changing organizations. “Each organization will have a unique angle to help tackle today's challenges, and we do broadly collaborate by connecting those different angles for systemic change,” said Diamente. For example, WMBC is a coalition founded by seven non-profit organizations including BSR and WBCSD to deliver key climate initiatives aggregating business either behind demand side market signals or representing the voice of business at key international forums such as the G7, the G20, or the UN climate negotiations. 4. Consider the interconnected nature of the challenge ahead

When designing interventions, the interconnections between the issues need to be considered. “We know that these challenges are crossing together,” said Diamente. “For example, we no longer just talk about climate change – we also look at the nexus between climate and social factors such as the just transition or climate justice or the link to health equity, human rights, and climate change.”

‘Systemic change requires you to be comfortable with getting it wrong, and iterating until you get it right’ Rasmus Valanko

As Valanko explained: “Climate change can cause a drought that causes social unrest in the Middle East, which causes immigration, which then causes political upheaval in Europe.” Systems leaders need a broad scope and systems thinking to make sense of and account for those interconnections. He said his team also considered local political, economic, technological, and social factors when deciding on interventions. For example, the energy pathway for Brazil would be very different from that of Japan. These additional factors help determine the local possibilities and realistic options for systems interventions. 5. Experiment, assess, and readjust

Systems leaders can’t repeat what was done in the past because the actions of the past have created the social and ecological problems that we face today. Systems change requires doing things differently, continuous evaluations of the situation, and readjustments: it is a learning process. “If we don’t experiment and track it, we do exactly what we have done in the past, which was mostly incremental change,” said Whiteman. Some actions will fail, and there will be a need to unlearn things. Systems leaders will have to settle for less than perfection due to the complexity 42 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

and scale of the challenges they face. White said leaders should not wait for perfect “because if you wait for something to be perfect, you’ll never do anything in this area". There was “no perfect roadmap, especially in this age of continuous disruption”, said Diamente. “You need a roadmap that enables resilience and connects accountabilities across the organization all the way up to the board.” To help companies focus and prioritize what really matters in the age of disruption, she supports companies’ “double materiality” assessments that examine both enterprise value and the impact on society and the environment. “Every single thing I've worked on, I’ve never got it right the first time,” said Valanko. “It's about iteration. The key thing is to not fear getting it wrong. Systemic change requires you to be comfortable with getting it wrong, and iterating until you get it right.” For example, in his work at Royal Dutch Shell, it took several iterations to find the trigger and supporting analysis that could successfully convince the executive team to invest in electric mobility. Success can be measured in many different ways and means many different things. For example, organizational-level success might mean achieving important milestones or reaching a certain number of people with communication efforts. When defining success, White and Valanko both referred to reaching a tipping point where momentum starts to gather pace in the right direction. White said: “Are you still pushing water up the hill? Or do you have the right incentives in place so that the water is running down the hill in the right direction?” Valanko’s team judges the tipping point based on the number of companies that are aligned with science-based targets for climate action. The social and environmental challenges we face present a significant opportunity to lead in different ways. Without systems change efforts and bold leaders driving them, we risk falling short of important global targets such as the UN Sustainable Development Goals. We hope that these insights from our conversations with leaders for system change will help inspire others to change the world. ■ Amanda Williams is a research fellow at IMD. She was formally a senior researcher at ETH Zurich, a research fellow term research professor at Copenhagen Business School, and a Research Associate at the World Business Council for Sustainable Development where she worked on the SDG Compass, a guide for corporate action on the SDGs. Knut Haanaes is Professor of Strategy and Lundin Sustainability Chair at IMD. He is Program Co-Director of the Leading Sustainable Business Transformation program and the Driving Sustainability from the Boardroom program. Previously, Knut was a Dean of the Global Leadership Institute at the World Economic Forum, and a Senior Partner and Managing Director at the Boston Consulting Group, where he was Global Leader of the group’s Strategy Practice.


[ Sustainability transformation ]

Leading transformation isn't child’s play. Here are the skills your company needs CSOs are becoming more senior and cross-functional. They need the ability and skills to address ESG issues across the spectrum – from finance to sales, investor relations to procurement. Suitable candidates are rare and a ‘talent war’ is raging, writes Natalia Olynec

W

hen Mattel released its ‘Chief Sustainability Officer’ Barbie recycled plastic doll last year, it was clear the role of CSO had gone mainstream. Sustainability has emerged as a strategic imperative for firms, driving the search for talent to meet new ambitions and regulatory pressures. With it, there’s a significant transformation – and growing importance – of the role of the CSO, fueling demand for the professionalization of this expanding role. Why is the CSO in the spotlight? Growing global challenges, such as climate change, resource depletion, and social inequality have forced businesses to re-evaluate their risks, opportunities, and impact on the world. They are also struggling to stay on top of changing regulations, investor demands for transparency, and employees seeking careers with “purpose”. Consequently, there’s a growing war for talent as organizations seek executives with the knowledge and skills to navigate complex sustainability issues and drive sustainable business transformation. Finding senior executives with the necessary capabilities and attributes to fit this changing landscape is a challenge. Today, 183 US public companies have a CSO, up from 29 in 2011, according to the Weinreb Group, a sustainability executive search firm. The number of companies appointing their first CSO has also seen a dramatic increase over the past three years. More CSOs were hired in 2021 than in the previous five years combined, according to a global Strategy& study.

Photo: Egon Zehnder

In Europe, tightening regulations and demands for transparency are driving firms to embed sustainability in their organizational structures. In Germany, for example, 90% of DAX-listed firms have a CSO, the Strategy& study showed. More than half report directly to the CEO. All Swiss and Austrian listed companies have a CSO. In parallel, the remit of the CSO is changing. The title was first used in 2004. Traditionally, the CSO was responsible for implementing initiatives such as employee volunteer programs and waste reduction. The role mostly focused on NGO partnerships, corporate philanthropy, and developing a compelling narrative to mitigate reputational risks. In the

‘A CSO is now essentially another C-level executive looking to create business opportunities through sustainability’ Catherine Zhu

early days, CSOs were not involved in strategic conversations or direct communication with investors. However, as sustainability moves to the center of business strategy, the role is expanding. The CSO role has become much more strategic, taking responsibility for broader business transformation, explained Catherine Zhu, Global Head of Sustainability Practice at leadership advisory firm Egon Zehnder. Today, the CSO is part of, or works closely with, the C-suite to integrate material sustainability issues into every aspect of a firm’s operations, processes, and capital allocation. “They work on transforming the core business model,” she said, comparing the evolution of the CSO role to how the Chief Digital Officer emerged to transform businesses a decade ago. “Firms are seeking candidates for the role with an overall understanding of business processes, with expertise in supply chain, strategy, sales and marketing, and operations. A CSO is now essentially another C-level executive looking to create business opportunities through sustainability,” Zhu added. » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 43


[ Sustainability transformation ]

“The role takes on completely different sets of challenges depending on the industry and engages stakeholders throughout its ecosystem,” she said. “For example, the CSO of a mining company may set up a waste management business, while the CSO at a skincare company may build partnerships to introduce sustainable packaging through circular business models.”

integrating sustainable business practices into their work. Firms across industries need professionals who possess a deep understanding of sustainable value chains, energy efficiency, social impact, and stakeholder engagement. But that’s not enough. At the same time, they require indepth knowledge of the operations of the firm to tie sustainability to its core business strategy.

Consequently, their team sizes and budgets are increasing, and their position in the firm’s hierarchy is growing in importance, according to Weinreb.

Companies are, therefore, seeking talent with the skills and knowledge to address ESG issues for practically all functions, including finance, sales, investor relations, operations, and procurement. Changing regulations worldwide also require that sustainability, finance, legal, and strategy teams work more closely together.

This is especially evident in companies going through major business model transformations. Consider Neste, for example, which in about two decades transformed from an oil refiner to a leading producer of renewable fuels. “The biggest risk is inaction – you have to be part of those companies that move before you have to,” said Minna Aila, EVP of Sustainability and Corporate Affairs at Neste. “We are approaching planetary boundaries. If we want to be in business for the long term, we need to adapt and change.” CSO roles are becoming more senior and cross-functional, managing both internal and external critical stakeholders that may have competing interests. For example, this can include balancing the social and environmental consequences in what’s called a “just transition” to a greener economy where job losses can result from shifts to cleaner manufacturing or assessing human rights risks as firms mine for the raw materials needed to make batteries for electric vehicles. In particular, CSOs are increasingly being tasked with value creation and identifying what areas of focus will contribute both to society and profitability. As investors pay more attention to environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors, CSOs are collaborating with chief financial officers to engage investors and demonstrate the link between material sustainability issues and financial performance. CSOs also inform boards through stand-alone sustainability or ESG committees, which were unheard of a decade ago. Some report to the audit or finance committee, or even the full board, as new regulations increase pressure for the sound governance of non-financial corporate performance in addition to financial results. “For some board members, this is their first exposure to sustainability risks and opportunities, so the CEO and CSO arrange orientation sessions on changing business models and regulatory standards,” said Zhu. Traditional CSO backgrounds from NGOs or public affairs are often not up to these tasks, requiring a rethink of the capabilities needed for the role. To fill the gaps, many CSOs are adding experts to their teams in areas such as climate science, supply chain, ESG performance measurement, and reporting. Beyond the sustainability department, there are many corporate sustainability leaders who don’t have the CSO title but are responsible for 44 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

The European Union’s new Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) is the most far-reaching, requiring a double materiality approach, referring to reporting on both how ESG topics impact the bottom line and how the company has a wider environmental or social impact. This requires a substantial change in the firms’ measurement and reporting of impact. While on paper CSRD initially affects about 50,000 large or listed companies, it will also require detailed reporting for companies within their supply chains. In addition, the International Sustainability Standards Board has issued two new disclosure standards meant to serve as a global baseline with a broader geographical reach. To comply with CSRD, larger firms have the resources to set up cross-functional project teams, including colleagues from finance, legal, human resources, health and safety, strategy, internal control, IT, and risk management. Smaller firms, however, often struggle with leaner teams trying to manage the shift. Still, while the importance of sustainability has grown, there can be confusion around the scope of sustainability-related roles and the ideal organizational design. While more CSOs are being appointed and the topic is reaching the C-suite, the distribution of responsibilities across the organization can create competition for resources, miscommunication, and duplication. It is helpful to take note of reporting lines to better understand a firm’s commitment, maturity, and potential to succeed in its transformation. For example, 42% of CSOs or heads of sustainability report to the CEO, according to a Gartner survey of 175 executives. Additionally, 34% of heads of ESG report to the CEO. Those reporting lines can indicate to investors that the firm prioritizes sustainability, since the leader will be shaping core strategy. Reporting to a general council or to the communications lead indicates more of a compliance or reputation-building focus. To be sure, there isn’t one ideal model. The organizational structure depends on the maturity of the firm’s sustainability strategy and how embedded it is in the core business. Firms need to design a structure that harnesses the data and insights needed to develop an informed strategy and to create accountability. Thus, getting the talent equation right is essential.


Number of companies appointing their first CSO 50

40

30

Number of CSOs

20

10

0

2004

2022

The first CSO was appointed in 2004. The past three years have marked a dramatic increase in the number of companies appointing their first CSO.

Five factors for sustainability leadership

Regardless of what organizational structure is chosen, our research with sustainability leaders across industries highlights five skills and competencies that are sought by companies seeking to position themselves at the forefront of sustainability strategy.

Source: Weinreb Group

1. Define strategy. CSOs must define a comprehensive and forward-thinking strategy that goes beyond compliance by analyzing the company's environmental, social, and economic impacts – setting clear goals and establishing a roadmap to achieve these objectives. The CSO must align the sustainability strategy with overall business goals to ensure a holistic and integrated approach. This involves identifying potential risks and opportunities, developing sustainable business models, and incorporating ESG factors into investment decisions. By integrating sustainability into the core business strategy, companies can drive innovation, enhance brand reputation, and gain a competitive edge. 2. Bridge the knowing-doing gap. One of the critical roles of a CSO is to bridge the knowing-doing gap within the organization. They need to ensure that the sustainability strategy is effectively implemented throughout the company and translated into language that allows employees at all levels to understand their roles in contributing to the objectives. This requires effective communication, education, and the establishment of processes that embed sustainability principles into dayto-day operations. 3. Engage and influence stakeholders. Successful sustainability efforts rely heavily on collaboration and engagement with a diverse range of stakeholders, both internal and external. Rising societal demands and

regulatory risk mean major groups of stakeholders – including potential employees and investors – are paying attention. Losing focus means alienating one or more of these groups. CSOs must possess strong communication and relationship-building skills and tap into their passion to engage with employees, investors, customers, suppliers, communities, NGOs, and governmental entities. Internally, the CSO works to foster a culture of sustainability, creating awareness and driving behavioral change, and attracting and retaining talent seeking purpose. Externally, they engage with customers, suppliers, NGOs, and governments to establish collaborative networks and advocate for sustainable practices across the value chain. This requires resilience, as they often work through influence rather than authority, to foster shared understanding, support, and alignment. 4. Drive innovation. The ability to drive innovation amid ambiguity is crucial for CSOs to identify new and creative approaches to complex sustainability challenges. This entails staying informed about emerging technologies, industry best practices, and global trends that can enhance sustainability performance. The CSO needs to foster a culture of continuous improvement and open-mindedness to embrace innovative solutions and adapt to evolving demands. 5. Measure and demonstrate impact. Measuring and reporting the impact of sustainability initiatives is essential to demonstrate progress, transparency, and accountability. CSOs must have teams with expertise in data collection, analysis, and reporting to provide meaningful metrics to measure, monitor, and highlight the firm’s sustainability performance. This information enables stakeholders to assess the company's efforts and outcomes, driving better decision-making and reinforcing the organization's reputation and commitment to sustainability. A CSO who is empowered with the authority, resources, and support from the top can drive sustainable transformation throughout the organization. By embedding sustainability into their strategy, businesses can build resilience, mitigate risks, attract and retain employees, and foster innovation – ultimately creating value for both the company and society as a whole. By driving sustainable business strategies, engaging stakeholders, and demonstrating impact, CSOs are leading change. These skills are also in demand for more traditional functions that are being influenced by the shifting landscape towards greater transparency and accountability. With the right talent in place, organizations that prioritize and invest in sustainability will emerge as “future ready”. ■

Natalia Olynec is Chief Sustainability Officer at IMD, focusing on executive education, corporate advisory, research, and partnerships. Leveraging her diverse background spanning corporate, academic, and board roles in international contexts, she integrates sustainability strategy with financial acumen to steer capital towards a more sustainable and inclusive future.

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 45


[ The human touch ]

Raising ‘techquity’: closing the skills gap starts with sharing the possibilities Policymakers and business can increase equity and opportunity in the global labor market by improving access to digital skills training, writes Shelley Zalis

There isn’t a leader, employee, or student who is not in need of a skills refresher or enhancement. Being a digital expert is not “a one (degree) and done”, it’s a continual learning process. Just this summer, we saw the launch of Google Analytics 4, Threads, Twitter’s rebrand to X, and the phrase “generative AI” referenced in every other marketing campaign. This speed of business transformation will be harder to sustain and comprehend without a commitment from business leaders to focus on closing the skills gap. A seismic shift in hiring and retention should hone its focus on specific skillsets needed to perform the role. A degree alone cannot ensure that one is adept enough in all things, but a current certification in Google Ads, Google Analytics, and HubSpot certainly verifies that you are capable of digitally marketing a company’s goods or services. The skills gap also provides opportunities for those without traditional degrees to become masters of their own destinies by attaining certifications. The focus should no longer be on the letters that follow one’s name, or the degree hung on the wall – but the solutions one can bring 46 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

to the table. When you look at your workforce, upskilling and reskilling should be high priorities for retention and growth. Skills-focused hiring is a call to action for global businesses – an initiative I shared at the G20 Summit in New Delhi, India in September. This year’s theme is “One Earth, One Family, One Future”, which for me speaks to achieving gender equity. In July, G20 labor ministers pledged to address global skill gaps for sustainable and inclusive economic development – a commitment that fed into the summit, which brings together the leaders of the most influential economic powers to shape the future of the global economy. One way to fuel this skills initiative at a policy level is to raise “techquity”, making sure more citizens have access to digital learning through a computer or a mobile device with access to the internet. In many parts of the world, digital access is the difference between having a future and remaining stuck in a generational cycle of poverty. Future jobs are tech jobs, and many can be done remotely, providing economic empowerment to those who might have never thought it possible. In industry, global leaders such as German multinational software company SAP are already taking the lead to fill the skills gap and are providing their own certifications that guarantee jobs for those who complete them successfully. This must become the standard. We need more Fortune 500 companies to step up and model this for truly sustainable business transformation. With ready-made accessible platforms, they can share the opportunity, assess the individual, and teach the skills they need to fill their talent pipeline. Here are a few ways to get started:

Illustration: Jörn Kaspuhl

W

e’ve seen the stats: the global talent shortage could reach more than 85 million people by 2030. It will take 132 more years to close the gender gap. The average career is now expected to span 60 years. What does this all boil up to? We are at the “flipping point” – a time when collective, meaningful action meets the moment. This is where good intentions need to turn into intentional action.


[ I Quote ]

• Promote a culture of continuous learning Nurture your talent pool from within and incentivize upskilling and • Provide a clear path to opportunity by sharing potential outcomes What are the skills needed for specific roles, i.e., “You will be more likely to get hired for this if you are certified in this…” • Encourage employees to shadow those in different roles Certain positions will begin to lose importance and phase out, while other departments double. If programmatic is a potential fit for someone who has been in more traditional sales, give them the opportunity to try out different job responsibilities.

‘The pandemic reinforced what we already knew: you can learn from anywhere given the right resources’

• Share success stories Find ambassadors – those who are achieving this skills transition within your organization – to inspire existing colleagues and attract new ones. The pandemic reinforced what we already knew: you can learn from anywhere given the right resources. The disruption no one saw coming has had a silver lining that has made waves around the world, even in the most remote communities. Hone in on the skills needed and empower leaders, employees, and students to learn them and use them. Together, let’s change the equation and close the skills gap. ■

SOME WORDS ON SUSTAINABILITY uote TRANSFORMATION … WISE AND OTHERWISE

IQ

Give a man a fish and he’ll eat for a day; but teach a man to fish and he’ll destroy the ecosystem. American cartoonists Brant Parker and Johnny Hart (The New York Times, 2022)

Four laws of ecology: 1. Everything is connected to everything else; 2. Everything must go somewhere; 3. Nature knows best; 4. There is no such thing as a free lunch. Barry Commoner, American cellular biologist and politician (The Closing Circle,1971) (The New York Times, 2022)

It’s extremely hard – and rare – for an incumbent company to disrupt its own traditional industry, and at the same time absolutely necessary. Vanina Farber, economist and political scientist (A comment made at IPADE, Mexico, 2020)

Noise pollution is a relative thing. In a city it’s a jet plane taking off. In a monastery it’s a pen that scratches. Robert Orben, American writer and humorist (The Columbia Daily Tribune, 2008)

Marketing was the child of globalization. Marketing will be the parent of sustainability.

Frédéric Dalsace, French marketing scholar (Comment made at IMD, 2022)

If you want to understand opposition to climate action, follow the money. Paul Krugman, American economist and Nobel laureate (Watchtower Online Library, 2011)

Less bad does not equal good.

Jeffrey Hollender, American entrepreneur, author and activist (Interview on YouTube, 2010)

Shelley Zalis is a trailblazer for women in the workplace. She is an internationally renowned entrepreneur, a pioneer for online research, a sought-after speaker, a well-known thought leader, and a devoted mentor. As founder and CEO of The Female Quotient, Zalis is in the business of equality®. Together with a growing global community of more than a million conscious leaders, she is on a mission to change the equation and close the gender gap.

The best thing you can do with environmentalists is shoot them. These headbangers want to make air travel the preserve of the rich. They are luddites marching us back to the 18th century. If preserving the environment means stopping poor people flying so the rich can fly, then screw it. Michael O’Leary, Irish businessman, best known as the CEO of Ryanair (The Daily Telegraph, 2012)

The quotations are taken from The Essential Book of Business & Life Quotations compiled by Dominique Turpin, Professor Emeritus of Marketing Strategy at IMD.

Sept-Nov Sept-Nov2023 2023• •I Iby byIMD IMD 4747


[ Finance ]

Beware of false profits: how a firm’s true added value can benefit society Measuring economic profits rather than accounting profits is a far more reliable indicator of a company’s performance, argue Simon Evenett and Felix Reitz. And value-creating firms are well-equipped to help fund sustainability as well as making healthy returns for shareholders

N

ever afraid to provoke, when asked about doing good in 1980, Margaret Thatcher replied: “No one would remember the Good Samaritan if he’d only had good intentions – he had money as well.” This comment resonates today as societal demands on businesses grow and grow. Just how much surplus does capitalism create that could then be deployed for the benefit of its stakeholders? For example, how do those amounts compare to the costs of attaining net zero or implementing the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)? Despite capitalism existing for millennia, there aren’t widely used economy-wide measures of corporate value creation – how much surplus value businesses deliver in the course of their operations, once all their costs are deducted. For sure, there are macroeconomic aggregates but their link to firm performance is indirect, at best. We were determined to fill this major data gap with the “Crux of Capitalism” project – the first attempt to build a bottom-up measure of firm value creation for publicly listed companies in 21 of the world’s major or most successful economies. Those economies include the largest by GDP plus a range of successful smaller ones such as Switzerland. Fortunately, we could adapt “economic value added” measures of firm performance (operating profit less the cost of raising the firm's capital) to create a measure of a company’s economic profits, which offers a truer reflection of the value created or destroyed by a firm than its accounting profit (Stern Value Management, a management consulting firm, proposed economic value added as a measure to calculate the true economic profit of a company in the 1990s). In Econ 101 courses, students learn that the difference between economic profits and accounting

48 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

profits is that the former takes account of the income investors in a firm could have earned if the investors had deployed their capital elsewhere. Failure to factor in this “opportunity cost” artificially flatters the corporate performance of asset-heavy companies, in particular. As the goal is to quantify how much a firm’s current operations generate total revenues above its operational costs (including the opportunity costs of capital owned by the firm), other adjustments are needed too. Adding back in R&D expenses (a non-operational, voluntary expense) and deducting taxes tend to be the two biggest adjustments. Altogether, economic profit reveals how much value or surplus a firm has created in a given year. Against this, some might want to deduct the environmental or social damage inflicted by a firm. We didn’t do that because our goal was to learn the maximum amount of resources a firm has at its disposal to take on any challenge, including rectifying any damage it has caused. Economic profits aren’t assured, but when they happen public finances benefit

As the graph opposite illustrates for two household names, companies differ a lot in their levels of recorded economic profit, depending on the amount they invest in R&D, how much tax they pay, and what their cost of capital is in any given year. For example, pharma giant Roche’s economic profit exceeded its accounting profit in the 2022 financial year by some margin, largely due to a significant investment in R&D and its low cost of capital. In fact, Roche had just under $30bn to deploy on whatever commercial and other priorities its management decides upon. The economic profit of Mercedes Benz, however, fell below its accounting profits due to a lower R&D budget and a higher cost of capital. From the perspective of getting the most bang from a society’s resources, one disturbing finding is that some firms can report positive accounting profits while their economic profits are negative. That means a firm’s current operations cannot cover its full operational costs – in short, it destroys value. The graph on Page 50 shows that of the more than 17,000 firms we have data on in 2022, 3% of them have economic losses exceeding $100m. Now, a firm having economic losses for a year or two as it turns around may not be problematic, but hard questions should be directed toward the management of firms that sustain economic losses over many years. Reasons for underperformance differ. Some have lower productivity levels, worse records of operational efficiency, or have inherited high or rising cost


bases – all of which push firms into negative economic profit territory. These firms burn investors’ funds, which is economically inefficient because the capital invested into them could be employed in more productive ventures instead, leading to higher overall productivity growth. A total of 14% of employees and 22% of assets are invested in firms that made economic losses exceeding $100m in 2022. Taken together, last year a quarter of employees in our huge sample work for value-destroying firms and these firms deploy 30% of all corporate capital. The reason countries need competitive markets and effective bankruptcy laws is to induce management of these companies to shape up, hand the reins over to others, or release talent and capital to other value-creating sectors of the economy.

High economic profits needn’t come at the cost of lower ESG ratings

For those putting a premium on responsible business conduct, capitalism creating value doesn’t cut it if it comes at the expense of cherished environmental, social, and governance (ESG) goals. So, we examined the 500 firms with the largest revenues to see how economic profit (EP) performance related to ESG ratings recently and over time. We sourced ESG scores from Refinitiv Eikon, a financial market analysis tool, and compared them to economic profits as a share of total revenues (which effectively scales EP performance). For 2021, we plotted ESG scores against these economic profit margins for the 500 firms (see chart 1, page 52). To help interpret the plot, we added dotted lines for median ESG score and median economic profit performance. At first, the plot looks random but it turns out that the quadrant with above average EP and ESG performance contains 29% of firms, and the quadrant that has below average EP and ESG performance contains another 29% of firms. This finding means that any notion that there is an inherent trade-off between high ESG scores and strong EP performance can be discounted – there are plenty of firms firms where management has taken steps to deliver both. »

But looking at the graph from the perspective of successful value-creating firms (those making more $100m or more in 2022), we can see that these firms account for 59% of all employees, absorb 61% of corporate assets, and, critically, contribute 76% of all corporate taxes paid. Firms that generate lots of value also contribute the most to public finances – a finding that undercuts a lot of the critics of capitalism.

Accounting profit and economic profit, $m USD, 2022 Cost of Capital

Accounting profit 22,914

Roche Holding AG

Research & Development expense +17,329 Tax –8,316

WACC

Cost of capital –2,433

*

(Invested Capital – Excess Cash) 0,04927 * (58,722 – 9,340)

Economic profit 29,494

In Europe, most firms‘ accounting profits ex-

ceed their economic profits. In 2022, notable

exceptions were Leonardo SPA, ASML Holding NV, Ferrari NV, Koninklijke Philips NV.

Infographic: Marina Bräm | viz. bybraem

Cost of Capital WACC

*

(Invested Capital – Excess Cash) 0,04927 * (158,805 – 22,790)

Accounting profit 18,670

Mercedes Benz Group AG

Research & Development expense +8,180 Tax –6,839 Cost of capital –6,776 Economic profit 13,235

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 49


[ Finance ]

It’s time to revisit assumptions that investments in firms that deliver more on ESG don’t pay off financially. Maybe that applies in some noteworthy cases, but they are the exception, not the rule. But what about performance over time? Do firms that want to boost economic profits have to do so at the expense of their ESG scores? For the same 500 firms, chart 2 (Page 53) plots the change in ESG score against the change in economic profit margin from 2013 to 2021. It turns out that almost a quarter of firms are found in each quadrant of the chart. Some firms found ways to deliver better EP and better ESG performance. On average, ESG scores rose 12.9 points from 2013 to 2021, but average

Share of employment, assets and taxes paid by value-creating and value-destroying firms in 2022

–

Economic profit ($) ≥ 100m

+

0 ≤ Economic profit <100m –100m ≤ Economic profit < 0 Economic profit < –100m

Share of firms 3

40 %

44 %

12 %

Share of total employment 14 % 10 %

17 %

59 %

Share of total assets 22 %

8

9

61 %

Share of total taxes paid 11 % 6

8

76 %

The share of employment, assets, and taxes refers only to firms with economic profit data for 2022. For about 26% of these firms, no employment data was reported. For about 37% of these firms, no tax data was reported. The value of total taxes paid is in some cases negative (if reported income is negative).

50 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

EP margins barely moved. These findings don’t support a broad-brushed critique of capitalism, but they certainly beg questions about win-win formulas and why some firms felt they could buck pressures to improve ESG performance. Currently, capitalism can finance major societal priorities

Given the large debts many governments took on during the COVID-19 pandemic, their ability to finance the transition to net zero, attain the UN SDGs, and cope with the costs of aging populations is in doubt. Consequently, some look to the private sector as a pot of gold to finance these social imperatives. For their part, if their public statements are anything to go by, many corporate executives plead with governments for subsidies to accelerate the energy transition and digital transformation. So just how much money does the private sector have to spare after it has paid its operational costs in full? That’s where our aggregate economic profit measure comes in. Using current exchange rates in 2022 and summing across the 21 economies in the Crux of Capitalism project, we estimate that firms generated a total of $2.2 trillion in economic profit. When careful corrections are made for the fact that not every firm has reported its financial results, we reckon about $2.725 trillion of economic profit was made in these 21 economies. Is that a lot or a little? Graph 3 (Page 52) provides instructive comparisons. McKinsey & Company estimates that financing net zero worldwide requires an additional $3.5 trillion every year. If that’s right, then firms in these 21 economies have the resources alone to foot over 78% of that bill. For sure, that would wipe out R&D budgets, but this calculation provides context and, indirectly, highlights the trade-offs at stake. What of the SDGs that governments agreed in 2015 must be reached by 2030? The financing gaps calculated by a range of international organizations for ending hunger (SDG 2), achieving health goals (SDG 3), and assuring access to safe drinking water (SDG 6) amount to $525bn per annum. This amount is less than a fifth of the total economic profits created by the 21 economies examined here. Country-specific comparisons are possible too. The Federation of German Industries (BDI) and BCG estimate that the yearly cost of reaching climate change targets at $110bn. That’s a sixth less than the total estimate of German economic profit in 2022, $133bn. Here it is worth pointing out that many successful German firms don’t list on the stock market, so the overall economy-wide EP of all German firms will be significantly higher. If German businesses can continue to deliver 2022 levels of economic profit, then the resources are there in the private sector to attain climate targets without subsidies from Berlin. Care is needed here in drawing conclusions. First, economic profit acts as a reward for innovation, corporate improvements, and the like. Tax all of it away for any purpose, good or ill, and extrinsic incentives are blunted. Still, the point is that, at the moment, the corporate Samaritan has the money.


Accounting profits aren’t a reliable guide during crises

Overall inflation-adjusted economic profit compared to inflation-adjusted accounting profit, selected crisis years

Global financial crisis

Real accounting profit, in billion USD

Real economic profit, in billion USD

Another reason to focus on economic profits as a measure of corporate performance is that totals for accounting profits provide a misleading indicator of capitalism’s health during crises. For example, aggregate economic profits in our sample of 21 economies fell more than half between 2008 and 2009, when bank lending channels were frozen at the start of the global financial crisis. In contrast, enough companies were able to put a gloss on their performance and reported only small falls in their accounting profits (see graph).

2008 3,210 1,301 2009 2,726 0,607 2019 3,381 1,373

COVID-19 crisis

2020 2,921 1,327 2021 4,116 2,214 2022 4,278 1,907

Accounting profit is shown in billion $ and aggregated only for firms with economic profit data. Values are adjusted for inflation by using country-specific GDP deflators before aggregation. Data on countries’ GDP deflator was sourced from the World Bank’s World Development Indicators database. The base year used was 2015.

Infographics: Marina Bräm | viz. bybraem

Second, the recorded levels of total economic profits in 2021 and 2022 were around a third higher than in 2018 and 2019, the two years preceding the pandemic. The ongoing phase-out of COVID-19-related and more recent fiscal measures as well as moves towards interest rate normalization and the resulting rise in the cost of capital will reduce total levels of economic profits. All of this underpins why it is so important not just to track economic profit but also to design policies that enhance legitimate firm value creation. It is in no one’s interest if the corporate goose stops laying golden eggs. Future-proofing today’s value generators

Business plays a crucial role in addressing the problem of climate change. Firms create the technologies and infrastructure necessary to transition to a carbon-neutral economy, but they are also significant emitters of greenhouse gas (GHG). These emissions account for a considerable share of the global annual GHG budget and originate either from sources that a firm controls directly (what are referred to as Scope 1 emissions), or indirectly (Scope 2), for example, when purchased energy is used in the

The pattern was reversed in the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic: total economic profits barely changed from 2019 to 2020 as the cost of capital was pulled down by aggressive monetary policy easing. At the same time, accounting profits fell by more than 10% due to weak aggregate demand. Once the pandemic stimulus kicked in, the reported totals of accounting and economic profits jumped (in 2021) – but in 2022, the former was double the latter. The moral of this story: accounting profits aren’t a good proxy for how much value companies create. Thanks to the Crux of Capitalism project, managers, analysts, and shareholders can track the true capacity of capitalism to create value.

production process. Information on the CO2 footprint of firms can be combined with our economic profit data to identify which business models must change to align with the Paris Agreement. Of course, it is worth noting that the CO2 footprint alone does not indicate the capacity and the willingness of firms to green their production processes: financially weak firms have other priorities whereas highly profitable firms may not see an urge to change their business models. Our data suggests that there are three different groups of firms. Just 6% of firms realized economic losses over $100m in 2022, but collectively they account for 37% of CO2 emissions. This observation is consistent with the argument that financially distressed firms do not possess the means to invest in greener production processes because they first and foremost seek to stay in business. At the other end of the spectrum, 22% of firms realized more than $100m in economic profits and accounted for 44% of CO2 emissions. These firms can invest in new production processes, but so far they may have » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 51


[ Finance ]

Economic profits: a visual guide 1

Exx

The relationship between the EP and ESG scores of selected top 500 publicly listed firms, 2021. The top 500 firms shown in the chart are selected by total revenue in 2021 (firms with missing economic profit values were replaced by the firm with the next highest revenue). The x-axis quantifies the economic profit of companies while the y-axis depicts their ESG scores, sourced from Refinitiv Eikon. The ESG scores are based on publicly available company disclosures (e.g., annual reports, NGO websites, and corporate social responsibility reports) and range from 0 to 100 (with 0 being the lowest score and 100 being the highest). Europe includes Switzerland, Germany, Spain, France, the UK, Italy, Netherlands, and Sweden. North America includes Canada and the US. Asia includes China, India, Indonesia, Japan, South Korea, Malaysia, and Singapore. The Rest of the World includes Australia, Brazil, Russia, and South Africa.

+2

Chi Un

A ited

2,7

25

All figures are in billion USD

3

Available economic profit (2022)

nes

leu

ld Ho

bil

Co

Cor

p.

G

co len

re P

Ast

LC

raZ

Dis

C ney

Me

o.

er ati art unic Chm m Co

on

P

4

dia

n:

c s In

oc etr

hin

aC

o

Ltd

16

Ne

e

rc Me

ede

sB

tfli

P

20

c x In

eS

pA

G

Joh

a

Int

nso

el C

J n&

ohn

orp he

son

ld Ho

te roc

r&

Gam

n ion izo cat Ver muni Com Co ble

c s In

ing

Me

dia

n:

28

North America

AG

ro Mic

24

Econ

Europe

rou

1.1

12

Le

S SAP

G enz

Roc

8

orp

PLC

Val

0

rC nna

ca ene

m

sof

omi

Rest of the world

c pr

ofit

t Co

rp

100

73

32

Asia

90

.8

80

70

(in b

60

80

illio

n US

D)

50

84 88

8%

Refi

40 30

92 0

Sam

su

nit

SG iv E

sco

re

3

s nic ctro d Ele Co Lt g n

2 zon ma A

m .co

1 habet

Inc

Alp

00 Achieving universal access to safe drinking water, sanitation, and hygiene (SDG 6) would cost $114bn per year; ending hunger by 2030 would cost $40bn per year (SDG 2); achieving SDG (3) health targets would cost $371bn per year.

Additional yearly cost of net-zero transition

2

5 ,72

-81

52

Available economic profit (2022)

Total economic profit estimates are adjusted for missing values. Cost estimates on the global net-zero transition are taken from a McKinsey & Company report titled The net-zero transition: What it would cost, what it could bring? Estimates on the costs of universal access to safe drinking water are sourced from a UNESCO report titled The United Nations World Water Development Report 2021: Valuing Water. Estimates on access to nutritious food were sourced from a World Food Programme report titled We have the resources to

52 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

on

rp.

ing

y lwa Rai ion a t n Chi struc -4 Con

3,5 Global spending on physical assets in the net-zero transition would amount to about $275tn between 2021 and 2050, or $9.2tn per year on average, an annual increase of as much as $3.5tn from today.

irli

na

ro Pet

o

o nM

vr Che

%

Country example: Implementing climate protection measures requires Germany to make additional investments of about $950bn by 2030, or about $110bn per year– almost 2.5% of Germany‘s GDP.

-17

13

%

3 11

0

5

Reaching SDGs 2, 3 and 6

German economic profit (2022)

Yearly cost to reach climate targets

end hunger – no child should be allowed to starve. Estimates on the costs of access to quality healthcare are sourced from the World Health Organization, Cost of reaching global health targets by 2030. Cost estimates on the implementation of climate protection measures in Germany were sourced from the Climate Paths 2.0: A Program for Climate and Germany‘s Future Development, published by the Federation of German Industries (BDI) and the Boston Consulting Group (BCG).

Inc


B

olrist

My

Sq ers

ZH

old

uib

ing

Ast

raZ

bC

or sC

o North America

p

ca ene

A

PLC

ev mb

S.A

Europe

Asia

.

Boe

C ing

o DK

SH

ld Ho

ing

Kin

AG

der

Un

Rest of the world

rg Mo

ited

He

an

al

ro th G

en Reg

-0.

2

Inc

ero

up

nP

h

Inc

a arm

ceu

C

3

Me

2 -0.

Change in economic profit margin and ESG scores from 2013 to 2021 The x-axis shows the change in economic profit scaled by revenue between 2013 and 2021 (economic profit scaled by revenue in 2021 minus economic profit scaled by revenue in 2013). Similarly, the y-axis shows the change in ESG score between 2013 and 2021.

-0.

dia

n:

0.0

1

s line Air Inc d s e g it Un oldin H

1

VM

w

I are

nc.

CL

tica

ls

CO OS

Sh

CM

A

in ipp

OC

gH

old

up Gro

s ing

Lim

Co

Ltd

ited

0.0 0.1

Me

0.2

Econ

c o In p er C T Cor w p o & P C Cor ng tric are c lec amsu h E t S bu eal Chu et H Ten

omi

Tat

c pr

aS

te

ofit

(in b

dia

n:

12

0.3

illio

n US

0.4

D)

-20

0.5 -30 -40

td el L

PLC an s eric evice m D oA o l p r g c An rou Mi to G ced n n i a T Adv Rio

Economic profit ($) ≥ 100m 0 ≤ Economic profit < 100m – 100m ≤ Economic profit < 0

PJS

in CM

30

20

10

0

10

.9

Refi

ing

and

ta Me

nit

llur

SG iv E

gic

50

40

sco

60

re

al

Economic profit < – 100m

In percent, 2022

22

43

28

44

9 10

tu Sta

2,2

sq

uo

:

m Nu

01

ber

o

ms f fir

h wit

bo Car

Infographics: Marina Bräm | viz. bybraem

np

<0

ric

an

: ing

37

on

pric

e

+5

Me

b Car

diu

on

m

pr

3 20

icin

Share of emissions

4 Actual or forecasted company CO 2 emissions for the year 2022 based on Trucost Paris Alignment Data. Emission data for 10,600 firms was merged with corresponding firms in our dataset. For a total of 7,969 firms, emission and economic profit data was available for the year 2022. The number of firms in the economic profit segments may therefore deviate from the previous analysis in the graph on Page 50.

5

54

+1

39 +3

0

H g:

Car

6 Share of firms

EP

rb d ca

igh

bon

20

p

30

n rici

g: M

edi

b 46 Num 3,2 sted: ju

um

g /Hi

ffi er o

h2

rms

w

05

52

0

E ith

P<

0a

nd

bo car

np

rice

Ad

Trucost Carbon Earnings Risk Data provides carbon price risk premia for individual firms which reflect the impact on earnings today if firms had to pay a future price for their GHG emissions. We matched the carbon price risk premia for 7,176 individual firms with our data on economic profit generation to calculate how many firms would become value-destroying if they had to pay a future price for their GHG emissions and did not change their business models.

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 53

70


[ Finance ]

decided against it. One explanation is that carbon prices aren’t yet high enough to warrant reducing CO2 emissions or changing the business models from which these firms extract substantial value.

2. High 2030: The implementation of policies that are considered sufficient to reduce GHG emissions in line with the goal of limiting climate change to 2°C.

This leaves a third group of firms comprising more than two-thirds of those featured in our analysis, but only accounting for 19% of CO2 emissions. They realize small economic profits or losses, which makes them particularly vulnerable to external forces that could result in cost increases such as carbon pricing schemes. Firms with high-margin pressure invest in low-carbon technology if the costs of emitting an additional tonne of CO2 warrant the investment. For these firms, any adverse change in their cost structure matters a lot, because they are just on the brink of profitability.

3. 2050: The implementation of policies that are considered sufficient to reduce GHG emissions in line with the Paris Agreement.

The situation of the 503 firms destroying more than $100m in economic value deserves special consideration for two reasons. First, burning stakeholders’ resources will be unsustainable in the medium term. Second, it seems unlikely that these firms can mobilize enough funds to invest in green production processes. The CO2 emissions per firm in this group – 9.4m tCO2e (for comparison, the total emissions of North Macedonia amounted to 9.77m tCO2e in 2022) – are triple the size of firms in any other economic profit segment. In other words, these firms destroy financial value even though they largely externalize the environmental costs of production. If these firms’ license to operate is not to be called into question, then ways must be found to help them become greener and cleaner (accelerated depreciation could be one way to promote green investment). Chinese firms – notable examples include GD Power Development, China National Building, Xinjiang Tianshan Cement, China Petroleum & Chemical Corporation – account for 3.1bn tCO2e (65.3% of the 4,731bn tCO2e total), US firms for 0.4bn tCO2e (8.5%), Indian firms for 0.3bn tCO2e (6.7%), and Japanese firms for 0.3bn tCO2e (6.5%) of total emissions in this economic profit segment.

On their current trajectory with no change in business models, the number of value-destroying firms would increase by more than 1,000 (or by nearly 50%) if firms had to pay a future price for their emissions. If the 2050 carbon price was to be paid by firms today, 45% of all firms considered here would not generate economic profits. More than 500 firms would change from being value-generators to value-destroyers even if climate action was delayed beyond 2030. These findings clearly highlight the pressures for business model transformation. If firms had to pay 2050 carbon prices on each metric ton of GHG today, an additional 11 million employees and an additional $9 trillion in assets would be stranded in firms that no longer generate economic profits. Another $150bn in tax payments by these firms would be in jeopardy. These statistics highlight the need for businesses to upgrade their production processes sooner rather than later and for governments to carefully track the effects of future carbon price hikes on corporate performance. The investments needed to switch to green business models should not be underestimated and need to be financed somehow. No economic profit, no progress

Successful capitalist firms create value, which means they generate surpluses that can be deployed to a wide range of uses or that can be taxed and used to advance national and global well-being. Without the prospect of earning higher economic profits, managers and shareholders lose extrinsic motivation to take on challenging projects that can, directly or indirectly, have massive societal payoffs. Intention is not enough – just like the Good Samaritan, business must be able to fund societal improvements. ■

Are current business models viable with higher carbon prices?

To incentivize businesses to limit their emissions and transition towards cleaner, more sustainable practices, many governments have introduced carbon prices. Carbon prices are a market-based mechanism that assigns a monetary value to the emission of CO2 and other GHGs. Since carbon prices are an additional cost driver for companies, it is crucial for owners and investors to understand how potential increases in carbon prices will affect the economic profitability of their businesses. To assess how future carbon pricing schemes may affect the ability of firms to generate economic profits, in effect, we draw on research from the International Energy Agency and the International Renewable Energy Agency. Based on their insights, S&P Trucost derived carbon price risk premia which vary by sector, geography, year, and scenario and reflect the additional financial cost paid (per tonne of emissions) from the price that is currently paid. Three scenarios are considered: 1. Medium 2030: Policies will be implemented to reduce GHG emissions and limit climate change to 2°C in the long term but with action delayed in the short term. 54 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Simon J Evenett is Professor of International Trade and Economic Development at the University of St Gallen, Switzerland. Evenett holds economics degrees from the University of Cambridge and Yale University. He has taught at Oxford University and has been a Distinguished Visiting Professor at the Johns Hopkins University (twice) as well as a Visiting Professor at the Ross School of Business, University of Michigan three times. He specializes in the global business environment, geopolitics, and firm strategy. Felix Reitz is a PhD candidate in international affairs and political economy at the University of St Gallen, Switzerland, and holds a Master’s in international political economy from the London School of Economics and Political Science. Reitz focuses on fiscal policy, international taxation, and corporate strategy under uncertainty.


Can biology reverse disease and slow climate change? Science is unlocking big ideas in tiny places, like genes that can help stop disease and crop DNA that helps farmers fight climate change. It’s the Bio Revolution, one of the megatrends we’re investing in to help treat chronic human conditions, like a warming planet. To us, there’s nothing more valuable.

Gain more insights that matter at

Bayer.com/megatrends


[ In the mind’s eye ]

The COVID pandemic changed the way we lead. Here are seven traits worth keeping By George Kohlrieser

What the CEO had failed to realize is that the pandemic has heralded a permanent shift in the way people want to be led. While several high-profile executives – among them Elon Musk, the Tesla CEO and owner of X (formerly Twitter) – have tried to revive an authoritarian style of leadership, this is unlikely to lead to results in the long term. Employees have become accustomed to a more compassionate and empathetic workplace. They want to be treated as people, not just workers, and those who don’t feel bonded to their team, or a sense of purpose, are more likely to cut ties. Drawing on my experience of working with hundreds of executives across different sectors, here are seven ways in which the art of leadership has evolved as a result of the pandemic – changes that I believe leaders should adopt as permanent traits, if they have not done so already: 1. Collaboration over command and control

While the hierarchical “command and control” management model where leaders made decisions and issued orders was already dead long before COVID, the pandemic well and truly hammered the nails into the coffin. 56 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

This was the case for a restaurant chain with over 4,000 franchises across the US. Prior to the pandemic, top management dictated everything – right down to how often the toilets should be cleaned in individual restaurants. Employees felt they were treated like children, morale was low, and business was in decline. When COVID hit, the situation worsened. To avoid bankruptcy, they hired a new CEO who implemented a different strategy – to give back power to the managers. Emboldened to make changes to the menu and introduce special offers based on their knowledge of the local area, managers achieved a turnaround within six months. In today’s uncertain economic environment, collaborative leadership that fosters innovation, creativity, and engagement, will ultimately lead to better results. 2. Leadership as a relationship

Musk may think it’s fine to issue demands with an iron fist, but people are fed up with being told what to do and view their work as solely transactional. This has led to a collapse in the traditional hierarchy between manager and employee. Instead, leadership is now viewed as a dynamic relationship between leaders and their followers. A great leader will build strong relationships based on trust, mutual respect, and effective communication to work with and influence others. They actively listen to their teams, solicit feedback, and create an inclusive environment where everyone feels valued and heard. 3. Focus on the experience of your customers AND employees

We often hear the phrase “the customer comes first.” Today’s leaders will recognize that the success of their organization depends on understanding and meeting the needs of both customers and employees. After all, if you have happier employees who find meaning and purpose in their

Illustration: Jörn Kaspuhl

B

efore the pandemic, Jane was a well-respected CFO at a pharmaceutical company who drove an hour each way to the office. When the COVID-19 crisis hit, Jane – like millions of others – was forced to work from home. A silver lining was the extra time she had to spend with her grandchildren. As restrictions eased, however, the CEO wanted her back in the building fulltime. She had forgotten how many hours the daily commute consumed and tried to negotiate for a couple of days a week at home. But he refused. So she quit. He was shocked.


roles, they are more likely to deliver exceptional customer experience. This involves ensuring your teams have the necessary support, resources, and development opportunities to thrive and do their best work. One leader who exemplifies this trait is Jørgen Vig Knudstorp, Member of the Board at LEGO A/S and Executive Chairman of LEGO Brand Group, who led the turnaround of the children’s play materials group when he was CEO. Knudstorp advocated a leadership style of “serious play” where he gave his leadership team huge amounts of autonomy and asked them to surprise him rather than just doing what they were told. He understood that to make the customer happy, the employee must come first. 4. Leading with meaning and purpose

The upheaval and grief caused by the pandemic triggered a great deal of reflection among today’s workers about how they spend their time. People want to feel they are both valued and creating value in their roles. Yet just 45% of people responding to a Gartner survey believed their organization saw them as a person. To overcome this, leaders should shift their focus simply from achieving goals to leading with meaning and purpose. By connecting the work of their teams to a larger vision and articulating a compelling purpose that resonates with the values of employees, they will increase motivation and employee retention. 5. Emotional intelligence

The pandemic put the mental health of millions under pressure and many people are still grieving, either for lost loved ones or lost opportunities. This has led to a state of heightened emotions that calls for leaders who can consider people’s feelings, and how this affects their behavior. At one financial firm, a manager started to worry about his star perform-

‘People want to feel they are both valued and creating value in their roles. Yet just 45% of people responding to a Gartner survey believed their organization saw them as a person’

psychological well-being. Leaders who prioritize psychological safety foster an environment where individuals feel comfortable taking risks, speaking up, and expressing their opinions without fear of negative consequences. One such leader is Jakob Stausholm, CEO of Rio Tinto, who, along with the executive committee, is building a culture at the mining group where employees are encouraged to say the truth with respect and put the “fish on the table” – an expression that means raising a difficult issue openly and dealing with important differences. 7. Leadership as a manifestation of your leadership story

In the past, we might have viewed leadership as a performance – you had to look the part and speak a certain way. Today, as we increasingly value diverse perspectives, leadership is no longer confined to a set of prescribed behaviors; it is a deeply personal expression of one's values, experiences, and aspirations. Leaders must embrace their unique leadership stories, sharing their authentic selves and inspiring others through their narratives. By embracing their individuality and vulnerability, leaders can establish genuine connections, inspire trust, and cultivate a culture of authenticity within their organizations. It may be tempting for leaders, especially those facing hard economic times, to advocate a tougher and more emotionless style of leadership. My response is that being a collaborative, purpose-driven, and emotionally intelligent leader doesn’t mean you coddle and rescue people. There are times when you will have to give tough feedback, and maybe even fire staff. The difference is that you can do this in a way that is both respectful and kind, where you treat employees as people and not just disposable objects. By embracing the value of building relationships, fostering psychological safety, and leveraging emotions to motivate teams, leaders will be able to adapt to the dynamic needs of organizations, inspiring employees to take the risks needed to drive sustainable growth in the face of ever-evolving challenges. ■

er, who seemed increasingly disengaged, leading to a drop in the quality of his work. The manager called a one-to-one meeting to discuss the problem. The employee admitted he was grieving for his mother who had died during COVID when he was unable to be with her to say goodbye. By being emotionally available and sensitive to the situation, the manager allowed the employee to gradually process his grief and return to the top of his game. 6. Psychological safety

Psychological safety, a concept popularized by Harvard leadership scholar Amy Edmondson, has gained recognition as an essential element in effective leadership, and one that is increasingly valued by workers. A 2023 Work in America Survey by the American Psychological Association found that 92% of workers said it was very (57%) or somewhat (35%) important to work for an organization that values their emotional and

George A. Kohlrieser is Distinguished Professor of Leadership and Organizational Behavior at IMD and Director of the High Performance Leadership Program.

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 57


[ Team spirit ]

Photo: xxxxxxxxxxxx

Translated into English as ikebana, the ancient Japanese art of flower arrangement can change the way we do business

58 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023


Working on ikebana as a team means relinquishing our desire to control, letting go of our ego, and existing in the present. Out of this process something beautiful can emerge, explains Mayuka Yamazaki

L

et flowers live. That’s the concept that lies at the heart of ikebana, the traditional art of Japanese flower arrangement. Every time you hold a flower in your hand, you think about how you can help it look as beautiful as possible and in harmony with the other flowers. “Think” may not be the right word, though. After years of practice, your body moves instinctively to cut the flower and place it in the vase, without even thinking. It is as if your body knows how to let the flower live before your head does. If your ego starts kicking in, thinking, “I want to create a great ikebana work”, it becomes about you, not the flowers, and you end up failing to let the flowers live. Ikebana is the art and practice of continuously letting go of your ego and being attuned to the voice of flowers.

Photo: Yasunobu Tamari

I have practiced ikebana for decades while working in management consulting and for a business school. Until very recently, ikebana was something very personal and private, something I just enjoyed doing in the small, closed ikebana community. But I started to observe that the nature of management studies and leadership education was changing, and there were more and more overlaps between what I had learned in ikebana and what was being researched and taught in business schools. What if I could bridge these two worlds, ikebana and business, and let them learn from each other? That’s why I founded IKERU in 2017 with the mission to bring the wisdom of ikebana to business and leadership education. For the past few years, through offering various ikebana programs, I have seen the positive impact that it can have on organizations and leaders.

ed to dedicate time to learn techniques and its philosophy. It was recorded that, in the 14th century, there were people known as “flower masters” who were widely recognized for their flower-arranging skills and were sometimes invited by powerful samurai lords and court nobles to arrange flowers on their estates. One of the oldest existing ikebana textbooks was published in the 16th century by a then well-known flower master who defined ikebana as the “art of letting the true nature of nature emerge in the vase” and illustrated how to put it into practice. Ikebana has survived as Japan has undergone a series of enormous social transformations: from a feudal medieval society where clans were constantly engaged in military conflicts to the unified, peaceful but strictly hierarchical pre-modern society in the 17th to 19th centuries; from the drastic Westernization and modernization of the late 19th and early 20th centuries to the recovery from the devastation of the Second World War and the emergence as a global economic power. Regardless of the era, the Japanese have practiced ikebana and deepened their relationship with it in their own way, leading to diverse definitions and principles. For example, different perspectives exist around the relationship between humanity and nature. Some believe that we understand the truth of nature and that ikebana is a way for us to express this truth. Others believe nature is perfectly beautiful as it is, and human intentions and interventions should be kept to the minimum. There are also different theories about how much individual creativity should be used. Some believe there is no room for individual creativity as ikebana is about practicing established balance formulas called kata until they are deeply ingrained, while others believe we should allow spontaneous and creative collaboration with the flowers. Among those who put greater importance on human creativity, some masters have tried to redefine ikebana as modern art – to the extent that they sometimes replace the flowers with artificial materials (called “avant-garde ikebana”).

So, what can ikebana teach today’s businesses? Why is it important for leaders to learn from this ancient practice?

There is, therefore, no single definition for what ikebana is – every definition should be respected and appreciated. But, for me, the philosophy of “letting flowers live” seems to lie at the heart of the art, cutting across many ikebana disciplines and making it distinct from the practice of flower arrangement in the West.

The origins of Ikebana and how it has evolved

Let flowers live

Gradually, arranging flowers evolved from a simple daily routine that anyone could do to a more sophisticated practice in which you need-

For us to let flowers live, we must exist with them, without having a preset vision of what we want to create. The stem’s curve might be the most »

Ikebana cannot be traced back to one moment or tradition in history. It is said that ikebana is inspired by both Buddhism and Shintoism, where the former arranges flowers and serves the Buddha statue and the latter sets up a specific tree branch to welcome the Divine. Also, in the old days, people enjoyed collecting flowers and arranging them in a vase, as documented in the Japanese essay Makura no Soshi, written around 1,000 years ago by a high-ranking court lady who served the empress: “A big blue-green precious vase was placed at the terrace and quite a few exquisite cherry-blossom branches were put in the vase. The cherry flowers were so in bloom that they were overflowing from the terrace.”

What do I mean by “letting flowers live”? Each flower is cut and placed in the vase in a way to make it look as authentically beautiful as possible. For that, we need to find the right angle, length, and location for each flower. Here, the definition of “right” becomes important. If we think of “right” as the flower being a perfect part of the work we are going to make, we are not letting the flower live – it is just being used to make what we want to make. Instead, we must try to see how the flower can become as beautiful as it can be. It must be placed in a way that creates harmony with the other flowers in the vase. By focusing on this, we are able to see the entire work emerge in a natural way.

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 59


[ Team spirit ]

charming part of the flower, but if we already have a plan in our head, the curve might not look right and we might cut the stem short to remove that curvature. Instead, if you can appreciate the flower as it is, you might see that it is unique and beautiful because of the stem’s curve, and you might find a way to let the curve shine within the entire work. This is letting flowers live: letting go of our desire to control, letting go of our ego, and existing in the present.

‘For us to let flowers live, we must exist with them, without having a pre-set vision of what we want to create’

Ikebana and business

I began studying ikebana when I was at college and continued to practice it as my weekend hobby after I embarked on my career in management consulting in the early 2000s. Ikebana was like an oasis for me during that sleep-deprived and over-stimulative phase of my career. On the weekend, through trying to let flowers live and letting go of my ego, I found tranquility and was able to return to my hyperactive job feeling deeply recharged. It never crossed my mind that ikebana would become my career or have anything to do with the business world. Ikebana was a beautiful practice I had to protect and keep away from my hectic work life. Things started to look different around 2010. I was working at Harvard Business School (HBS) as a researcher based in Japan. Having gone through deep self-reflection after the Great Recession and various discussions about the school’s future during its year-long centennial forums in 2008, HBS reached the conclusion that it should transform itself to keep fulfilling its mission, “Educate Leaders Who Make a Difference in the World”, over the next 100 years. The school came up with a guiding principle – “Knowing, Doing, Being” – and revised its two-year MBA curriculum based on that code. The school emphasized that “being”, which is to understand who you really are and what you believe in, would be like a compass for life – without it, one would get lost and might end up making a negative difference in the world. I was genuinely and pleasantly surprised by the fact that HBS, “a capital of capitalism”, officially announced that cultivating the mind was the most important thing for future leaders. For the first time in my life, I saw there was a possible connection between ikebana and business. I began to see a pattern forming: that mindfulness became an increasingly popular research topic in management studies as well as a practice

60 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Photos: Yasunobu Tamari (2)

Whenever possible, Mayuka Yamazaki collects wild flowers and grasses (second from top) to use in her ikebana workshops. Men and women of all ages collaborate to create something beautiful by learning to ‘let the flowers live’

This is why cultivating our minds is the most important part of ikebana. Skills and techniques are, of course, important but they can be naturally developed over time if you keep practicing. Other Japanese traditional arts such as the tea ceremony, calligraphy, martial arts, and archery also share this philosophy.


Workshop participants are always amazed to see the outcome of their work, as it is often far more beautiful and dynamic than their initial expectations

in the real business world as seen in, for example, Google’s Search Inside Yourself program. Research showed that mindfulness could boost employees’ productivity, creativity, and well-being and that it was also linked to leadership effectiveness. While the term mindfulness was used almost as a synonym of meditation, I thought ikebana could become another powerful mindfulness practice for business. If mindfulness

5 guiding

• Do not discuss or plan beforehand what your team

is going to create. Always just pay attention to what is emerging in front of you.

principles of ‘team ikebana’ • Let each team member focus on their own dialogue

with their flower. If you notice something, say it in a way not to disrupt their focus.

• Even if you do not agree with the flow the previous member created, accept it without judgment and play with that flow. Photo: Yasunobu Tamariri

• When it is not your turn, check the balance and flow of the whole work. • Once all members have finished their turns, look at the work as a team and see whether there are parts that should be fixed. If the team agrees about changing something, make sure that the member who arranged it in the first place fixes it.

is about existing and remaining in the present, ikebana is indeed the very practice of mindfulness: we cannot let flowers live without being “present” in the moment. Further, given the more creative and dynamic nature of ikebana, I realized it could become a mindfulness practice that might appeal to those, who like me, found difficulty with meditation. At the time, Ikebana was known for its tremendous, inherent wisdom but it was appreciated mainly in the realm of culture. What if I could bridge the gap between ikebana and business and let managers access opportunities to learn from the wisdom of the art of flower arranging? It might also help redefine and reinvigorate ikebana, which had faced the challenge of an aging and declining population of practitioners, for a whole new audience and generation. How ikebana in business works

So, in 2017, I left HBS, where I had worked for 10 fulfilling years, and founded IKERU with a mission to bring the wisdom of ikebana to business. “Ikeru” is a Japanese verb used in ikebana which implies that arranging flowers is about “letting flowers live”. I developed an ikebana workshop for corporate training, in which a team of three to four people would create one ikebana work, and began introducing the concept to companies. In the workshop, each member of the team is responsible for one type of flower and members take turns to arrange their flowers as if passing the baton in a relay race. » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 61


[ Team spirit ]

I have developed five guiding principles of team ikebana based on the traditional wisdom of ikebana (see box). The process can feel quite different from a typical team collaboration in a business setting where colleagues typically discuss and agree upon a goal, identify tasks to achieve it, assign a task to each member, and make sure that no one deviates from a given task. In this setting, the team knows where it is going and can measure where it is in relation to that goal. Individuals might also intervene while other members are still working on their tasks.

‘We work together because we can go to a place where we cannot go alone’ In the workshop, team ikebana participants are always amazed to see the outcome of their work, as it is often far more beautiful and dynamic than their initial expectations. They learn the power of respecting and trusting other members, accepting others’ perspectives (even if they initially disagreed), and appreciating what is emerging during the moment. Most importantly, the workshop reminds them of why we work together. We work together because we can go to a place where we cannot go alone. And working together means expanding how you see the world by accepting and internalizing how others see it. Participants also deepen their understanding of themselves. They might notice their hesitation to cut a flower because they are afraid that they will not be able to come back once the cut is made – a fear of making a mistake. They might feel irritated about not being able to intervene when another member is arranging a flower – a habit of impatience and micromanagement. They might be surprised to find that they actually enjoy ikebana, an art of creating something beautiful, using not their logical thinking capability but their artistic sensitivity. For the past few years, dozens of companies, business schools, and non-profit organizations have implemented the team ikebana workshop. I have received feedback that the experience has helped to change team dynamics and the quality of collaboration. Convinced that the wisdom of ikebana is relevant to business and can be a powerful tool to boost collaboration and leadership development, I have started to work with a mindfulness-based leadership development firm to create a longer-term global leadership program in which ikebana plays a central role. I have also worked with the HR team of the company where I serve on the board to integrate ikebana into its leadership development plan. Knowing that a one-time ikebana workshop can make such a profound impact, I am truly excited about what these longer programs can bring to business. Broader and deeper

While I have worked on bringing ikebana into the corporate setting, I have also offered ikebana lessons to individuals, designing sessions so 62 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Mayuka Yamazaki, who has a long history in business, founded IKERU in 2017 with the mission to bring the wisdom of ikebana to leadership education

participants can be fully immersed in the experience of letting flowers live, not distracted by the formalities and rules that have been prevalent in the traditional ikebana world. My IKERU community includes people as diverse as professionals, entrepreneurs, and artists in their 20s to 50s, both male and female – a stark contrast to the existing ikebana schools where the majority of practitioners are women over 60. If you are deeply in the flow of ikebana, you focus on letting each flower live and then realize later that the whole work emerges in front of you naturally and instinctively. You do not know where you are going while you are practicing it. The same thing has happened to IKERU. I don’t know where this movement is heading, but if I just keep trying to let each workshop, each lesson, every person I interact with “live”, I might see something emerge along the way that could be far more beautiful and powerful than I originally anticipated. This is probably true for my life in general. If I can apply the wisdom of ikebana not only to flower arranging or ikebana-related activities, but to every aspect of my life, I might be able to call it a good life. Until I can get closer to that state of mind, I will keep practicing ikebana, doing my best to let flowers and those around me live. ■ Mayuka Yamazaki is an ikebana artist and the founder of IKERU, an initiative to bring the wisdom of ikebana to business and leadership development. She also works as a Harvard Business Review Diamond Fellow and is an external director of three public companies, including Ryohin Keikaku (MUJI). Prior to that, Mayuka worked at Harvard Business School and McKinsey & Company.


[ Future investing ]

The pursuit of purpose: how the impact economy is delivering change There is a growing need to provide executives with the tools to take a more integrated approach to impact and business – and to change mindsets when it comes to financial decision-making. The impact economy offers alternatives and inspiration, write Vanina Farber, Patrick Reichert and Shih-Han Huang

F

irst introduced in 2007 as a niche investment strategy for enterprising philanthropists and foundations, the field of “impact investing” has since transitioned into a much broader movement: the “impact economy”. In a world confronted with numerous and overlapping crises, the impact economy provides a holistic framework for how we create, exchange, and distribute value.

The impact economy envisions a future where impact investing is not just an option for niche players in the investment landscape, but a norm for the economy. In this future, investors would unleash more capital for social good, and entrepreneurs would build more innovative and scalable businesses that simultaneously match market demand and meet societal needs. Consumers would vote with their wallets for social businesses while governments and public agencies create more sustainable policies from the top down.. Meanwhile, mainstream companies would look to accelerate fair, inclusive, and sustainable global value chains. At its core, the impact economy aims to account for positive and negative externalities (the full costs and benefits) in all productive activities, with net positive impacts pursued in business and rewarded through trade, investment, taxation, and labor. Given estimates from the Global Footprint Network that the global economy is currently consuming resources at 1.75 times the Earth’s carrying capacity, these shifts in mindset and behavior are both pertinent and pressing. To deliver on the promise of the impact economy, entrepreneurs, executives, investors, philanthropists, researchers, and other change agents are employing social innovations – in the form of new products, services, markets, models, and processes – to benefit society and address social and environmental needs more efficiently and effectively than current public policies and business activities. We will explore these themes in

greater depth in the December issue of I by IMD, which will focus on the impact economy, impact investing, and social innovation. Why now?

Around the world, the impact economy is emerging through a dynamic and organic interchange of ideas, missions, mechanisms, strategies, and alliances. References to the Green New Deal, impact investing, social entrepreneurship, the circular economy, purpose-led business, ethical consumption, and civic wealth creation all represent approaches that feed into a broad intent to integrate economic activity with improved social and environmental outcomes. This movement is emerging within a context of unprecedented and accelerating global change. Through just two data points – population growth and economic output – the scale and pace of recent human development is nothing less than an explosion by any geological or historical timescale, even calling for the introduction of a new geological epoch – the Anthropocene (i.e., the first time in history where humans have had a substantial impact on the planet). While these developments have created immeasurable gains for humanity, they have also created negative spillovers, unintended consequences, and systemic risks that now undermine prospects for progress, safety, and well-being. Discourse in public media indicates growing political polarization, economic volatility, and societal unrest with the status quo. For example, the 2022 Edelman Trust Barometer revealed that 52% of people (across 27 countries) believe that capitalism, as it exists today, is doing more harm than good, and 81% stated that CEOs should be personally visible when discussing what their business has done to benefit society. Whether it is ongoing conflict in the Middle East or Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, migrant crises in Asia and Europe, climate-induced natural disasters, longstanding social ills such as » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 63


[ Future investing ]

poverty, water scarcity, gender inequality, and famine, or the more recent COVID-19 pandemic, grand challenges remain stubbornly persistent despite technological, economic, and social progress. As a result, the prevailing paradigm of economic growth is being challenged. The interconnectedness of economic, social, and environmental systems calls for an end to the sole supremacy of economic indicators as a measure to human progress and well-being. Put simply, relying on GDP as a measure of human progress without considering a wider set of indicators is like running the world on a profit and loss statement without a balance sheet. We are, therefore, at an important inflection point in the evolution of social innovation’s ability to deliver the impact economy. While the field of social innovation has shown tremendous growth over the past dec-

‘Relying on GDP as a measure of human progress without considering a wider set of indicators is like running the world on a profit and loss statement without a balance sheet’

ade, many actors within the spectrum of capital are still sitting on the sidelines – interested in impact, but not yet allocating enough resources or investments. Much of the discussion over the past decade has focused on understanding and measuring impact, and rightfully so. But a key challenge that has not received its fair due in the conversation, in our view, is how impact is managed by social innovators. We believe now is

The key milestones 2007

The term “impact investing” is coined at a meeting hosted by the Rockefeller Foundation in Bellagio, Italy.

2007

First 82 companies obtain B Corp certification.

2009

a universal framework for addressing global challenges.

2015-2016

The Paris Agreement on climate change is adopted by 196 Parties at the UN Climate Change Conference (COP21).

2016

The Global Impact Investing Network (GIIN) is launched as an independent non-profit organization to promote and support the development of the impact investing industry.

The first Green Bond Principles are published by the International Capital Market Association (ICMA) to provide guidelines for issuing bonds that finance environmental projects.

2010

2017

2013

2017

The first Social Impact Bond (SIB) is launched in the UK to reduce reoffending rates among prisoners released from Peterborough prison. The first Global Impact Investing Rating System (GIIRS) ratings are issued to measure and compare the social and environmental performance of impact businesses and funds.

2015

The United Nations adopts the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, which includes 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) as

64 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

The first Gender Lens Investing Initiative is launched by the Criterion Institute, Women Effect, and USAID to increase the flow of capital to women and girls. The ICRC creates the world's first Humanitarian Impact Bond to help transform the way vital services for people with disabilities are financed in conflict-hit countries.

2019

Esther Duflo, Abhijit Banerjee, and Michael Kremer win the Nobel Prize in Economics for their experimental approach to alleviating global poverty, which has influenced many

impact investors and social entrepreneurs.

2019

Signed by 181 CEOs, the Business Roundtable redefined the purpose of a corporation, advocating for companies to move beyond the shareholder primacy model to lead their businesses to the benefit of all stakeholders – workers, customers, communities, suppliers, the environment, and shareholders.

2020

The European Union adopts the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR), which requires financial market participants to disclose information on how they integrate sustainability risks and impacts into their investment decisions and advice.

2021

The first Net Zero Asset Managers Initiative is launched by a group of 30 asset managers, representing over $9 trillion in assets under management. They commit to support the goal of net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 or earlier.

2022

Impact investing tops $1 trillion in assets under management, according to the GIIN annual survey.


the time for impact management to take center stage. Asset owners such as investors, banks, entrepreneurs, corporates, or family offices articulate and realize their impact objectives through impact management. That is, they identify what problems they want to solve, who they want to reach, where they want to invest, and what risks they want to take. Impact management requires asset owners to consider how they want to prototype, onboard, and create a pipeline of social innovation. How the impact economy is taking shape

One of the most interesting aspects of social innovation is the range of investment options available to actors throughout the impact economy. Innovative financial tools are emerging across the entire capital spectrum. As our illustration shows, between traditional investing and traditional philanthropy lie a myriad of alternative options to mobilize private capital for impact – from the reinvention of public contracting

arrangements to increased efficiency and crowd-in private investors to the creation of financial products available to retail banking customers. Social innovators are creating entirely new markets that can attract private capital at scale. Many philanthropists have moved beyond providing one-off grants to non-profit organizations and begun to focus on identifying and funding nascent social innovators. The socially beneficial goods and services created through social innovation – be they improved value chains, solar panels, seeds, or medicines – are, after all, the “purpose” of businesses. Philanthropic impact investors also understand that profit is a condition – and result – of achieving purpose. Understanding this is critical to the ability of impact investors to leverage their scarce capital with that of traditional market-rate investors. Philanthropic impact investing fills an important role in the lifecycle of »

TRADITIONAL INVESTING

RESPONSIBLE INVESTING

SUSTAINABLE INVESTING

BELOW MARKET RETURN

MARKET RETURN

THE IMPACT ECONOMY

'FINANCE-FIRST' IMPACT INVESTMENT

'IMPACT-FIRST' IMPACT INVESTMENT

BLENDED FINANCE

0% RETURN

PHILANTHROPIC IMPACT INVESTMENT

NEGATIVE RETURN

TRADITIONAL PHILANTHROPY

This chart shows the range of options available today, from traditional finance to philanthropy, depending on the risk appetite and goals of investors. Blended finance allows impact economy actors to “blend” different investment approaches and instruments to suit the needs of investors, stakeholders, social enterprises, and projects.

RESPONSIBLE INVESTING – for investors who

want to exclude options based on ESG criteria, while mitigating risk and receiving market returns.

SUSTAINABLE INVESTING – for investors who want

to focus on investments characterized by ESG practices that enhance returns.

'IMPACT-FIRST' IMPACT INVESTING – for those who

want to invest in the impact economy and are willing to accept higher risk and lower returns.

'PHILANTHROPIC' IMPACT INVESTING – for investors who are prepared to invest in areas of the impact economy where there is the risk of losing their investment.

TRADITIONAL INVESTING – for investors purely

'FINANCE-FIRST' IMPACT INVESTING – for people

TRADITIONAL PHILANTHROPY – for charities,

ESG practices.

receive market returns.

grants to projects that are focused solely on impact.

seeking financial returns with limited or no regard for

who want to invest in the impact economy and

foundations, and philanthropists who want to allocate

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 65


[ Future investing ]

social enterprises (organizations that pursue a social mission through commercial activities) by helping them overcome the pioneer gap and navigate the “death valley curve” – the perilous phase in enterprise development when negative cash flows from operations need to be funded.

‘Many firms have been sinking money into ineffective sustainability solutions for the better part of two decades’ Although philanthropic impact investing operates through an impact-first mentality, the creation of new markets also leads to attractive investment opportunities for investors with a finance-first mentality as they mature and scale. At the other end of the spectrum, financial products that bring environmental, social, and governance (ESG) considerations into investment decisions are also being created. Three popular strategies include: • Avoiding “bad” actors. Negative screening (exclusionary and normsbased screening): exclude companies or sectors from the investment universe based on ESG concerns. • Promoting “good” actors. Positive screening (sustainability-themed, best-in-class, ESG integration): integrate the financial implications of ESG factors into research and analysis – weight fund toward holdings with higher ESG quality.

development finance and philanthropic funds to mobilize private capital flows to emerging and frontier markets transactions – can speed up and de-risk this process and mobilize private capital at scale. Blended finance creates positive, win-win ecosystems among private firms, civil society actors, and government institutions, as the total costs and risks of investments are syndicated across different institutions. They play to the strengths of each type of actor: private companies realize entrepreneurial opportunities for impact value creation, civil society organizations monitor the social/environmental impact, while public actors step in to offer financial guarantees. Such ecosystems can lead to effective impact creation while enjoying high levels of trust by societies. Blended finance is still in the initial stages of experimentation, and it remains to be seen whether it can truly scale investments that will transform business models. However, the early signs are promising, particularly where organizations can identify and measure the externalities created in their value chains. Looking ahead

The world is rapidly becoming more complex and connected. How we think about the economy – productivity, value, markets, growth, and capital – requires an equally radical shift in mindset. It’s up to us to determine the future that we want. To this end, we believe the impact economy helps to frame much of the progressive developments already underway and identify the issues that can be addressed by change agents across the spectrum of capital. ■

• Engaging “bad” actors. Active ownership (engagement and proxy voting): identify ESG as a lever for value creation. Pursue improvements in a company's ESG performance by engaging with the board or management. Alongside investor demands, we believe societal demands will continue to put pressure on firms to develop sustainability strategies and, accordingly, encourage a process of business model transformation that can satisfy both owners and other stakeholders. This might be met in part through the scaling and mainstreaming of social enterprises. However, we also believe that corporate transformation will be a key piece of the puzzle. Firms that are able to successfully place purpose at the center of their strategy, along with committed leadership and the dedication of resources, have a leg up on the competition. Despite the potential gains of corporate transformation, many firms have been sinking money into ineffective sustainability solutions for the better part of two decades. Solutions based on mobilizing public relations and recognition awards appear unlikely to move the needle if they are not backed by fundamental changes within the business model. In our view, recent social innovations like blended finance – the strategic use of 66 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Vanina Farber is elea Professor of Social Innovation and Dean of the IMD EMBA program. She is an award-winning economist and political scientist who specializes in social innovation and the mobilization of private capital for impact investing. Patrick Reichert is a Term Research Professor at the IMD elea Center for Social Innovation. His research primarily focuses on how financial innovation can accelerate the speed, scale, and effectiveness of promising social innovations. Shih-Han Huang is a senior researcher and writer at the IMD elea Center for Social Innovation.


[ Human resources ]

Time to reboot the way you identify and develop ‘talent’

Job roles and careers have changed dramatically and are continuously evolving, leaving many talent management practices in the dust. Tania Lennon and Mikolaj Jan Piskorski offer three new rules to upgrade your talent strategy

M

ore than 25 years ago, a pioneering McKinsey study underlined the “war for talent” as a strategic challenge for companies. The study strengthened the focus on talent management as a discipline with greater emphasis on talent identification and succession planning. Yet even now, 80% of Chief Human Resources Officers (CHROs) say they lack the essential talent required to deliver their company’s strategy. Indeed, a quick survey of the literature conducted by the IMD Strategic Talent team in August suggests that no more than 15% of any organization is perceived as “talent” that should be invested in to support their progression towards bigger leadership roles. A great deal of effort in talent management is, therefore, expended in identifying these elusive high potential employees to manage their trajectory towards target leadership positions. However, there is limited published evidence for these numbers. With a global population of 7.8 billion and education rates higher than they have ever been, it seems counterintuitive to suggest that such a small percentage could be classified as “talent”.

Measuring talent through performance is easy on the running track but can prove elusive in business

Some researchers have been pushing back against what Yvonne Downs and Stephen Swailes at the University of Huddersfield have described as the “conceptualization of talent and talent management sustaining a narrative of scarcity and metaphor of war”. Aligned with changes in the world of work catalyzed by COVID-19 combined with a growing recognition that traditional approaches to talent management have not succeeded, there is a movement towards adopting more person-centric approaches to talent. This requires some fundamental alterations in the way we define and identify talent. We reviewed the literature on talent management to pinpoint three core shifts in the “rules of talent” that need to be rewritten to address the talent gap. These new rules will enable organizations to better capitalize on the talent available to them to deliver sustained success.

Rule 1

Old: Select talent for ‘fit’

The importance of hiring for “fit” is based on the idea that similarity between the organization and the individual employee impacts on performance. Person-organization fit has been linked to outcomes such as financial performance, job satisfaction, and turnover. Hiring for fit often focuses on the degree of congruence between the values of the individual and the organization. » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 67


[ Human resources ]

There is clear evidence that a perception of common values leads to greater trust and, therefore, more autonomy for employees. This trust facilitates social integration and cohesion and further strengthens the company culture. In turn, a strong culture drives faster execution, as there are fewer process losses when assumptions, perspectives, and values are shared across team members and functions. A strong culture has thus traditionally been perceived as a positive attribute for organizations, supporting continuity and consistency to preserve what is distinctive about the organization while also facilitating fast execution. The “attraction, selection, attrition” bias, where organizations and leaders tend to recruit people like themselves, results in increasing convergence in values and perspectives as tenure increases, creating a virtuous circle that constantly reinforces the existing culture. While a close-knit culture breeds trust and facilitates rapid execution, it can also anchor organizations to the status quo so that they inherently resist change. In a world characterized by complexity and dynamism, organizations need to counter this rigidity by extending the range of perspectives and values they integrate. Organizations that select talent with more diversity in values, perspectives, and backgrounds benefit from greater cognitive resources and breadth of experience, which enables teams to engage in more complex problem-solving and innovation. Being part of groups with diverse values and backgrounds is also good for employee well-being. In work environments where people feel able to be themselves and express different views, employees tend to experience less stress and are more engaged in their work. This further boosts performance. New: Hire for diverse perspectives and backgrounds

How can organizations get the best of both worlds? Organizations need to decide what is absolutely central to their culture – what Ed Schein called “pivotal values” – and where they can flex. Greater diversity in what are known as the peripheral values of the organization supports adaptive change and innovation. This combination can be called “extension fit”, because it maintains what is important while extending the breadth of perspectives and learning capacity of the organization. To make extension fit work in practice requires leaders with high levels of social sensitivity. Encouraging people to express different views while creating space for individuals to explore and understand diverse perspectives enables organizations to translate diversity into creative solutions. Without leader support, “diverse” individuals recruited into the organization can experience rejection and are likely to leave, which further amplifies the effect of the “attraction-selection-attrition" bias.

Rule 2

Old: Select talent against current job demands

Job descriptions continue to serve as vital tools to provide clarity about job expectations and outcomes. They enable role incumbents to understand how their position contributes to the strategy and define how success will be evaluated and measured. The practice of analyzing jobs to 68 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

What the experts say ‘One in 10 employees has a high level of talent, while two in ten are basic talent’

Gallup (2015). State of the American manager: Analytics and advice for leaders.

‘The percentage of high potential employees to total employees is between 3% and 5%’

Eva Boštjančič and Zala Slana (2018), University of Ljubljana, Slovenia

‘The top 10 to 15% of an organization are its high potential talent’

Michael Mankins (2017), Harvard Business Review

determine the knowledge, skills, and abilities (KSAs) required for a given role is grounded in scientific management: in the late 1800s, F W Taylor asserted that “workers were to be selected appropriately for each task” and “tasks and jobs should be rigorously defined based on appropriate study of the work”. In an era when human capital provided “resources” with an emphasis on stable, consistent, and practiced skills that could be measured and replicated through time-and-motion studies, this perspective on organizations as machines was essential to enable productivity and performance. However, work has changed significantly. The nature of jobs is constantly evolving, with automation and digitization prompting the disappearance of some roles and the emergence of others. For example, positions such as Chief Digital Officer have appeared in numbers only in the past seven years, with eight out of 10 CDOs the first in their organization to hold the role. In fact, it is estimated that 65% of organizational roles today will no longer exist in 15 years’ time. Further, by removing the more repetitive and mundane components of jobs, technology has enriched many roles so that they encompass greater strategic breadth and complexity. This enrichment results in increased requirements for both cognitive and emotional intelligence. Requirements for success within roles also change rapidly. For example, it is estimated that the life span of many skills in the digital space is about 18 months. This means that sustained success in roles is driven not by the possession of target skills and knowledge but rather the ability to rapidly acquire new skills and knowledge and constantly adapt to new challenges. Yet traditional succession plans continue to use existing role requirements to evaluate and develop talent pools. Too much rigor and focus on developing talent to fulfill current demands means that, by the time potential successors are nearing the target role, what is needed to succeed has dramatically shifted – or the role itself may have disappeared altogether.


New: Select for adaptive capacity

In the context of shifting role demands, how do you develop robust talent pools to ensure you have the leadership talent you need in the medium to long term? Firstly, an inclusive approach that helps individuals own, harness, and amplify their talents to create value for the organization in new ways is not only a good talent strategy but also drives innovation and fuels dynamic capabilities that can support sustained competitive advantage. Secondly, focusing development in the early- to mid-career stages on the development of the meta-competencies that comprise “situational judgment” – such as cognitive agility, emotional intelligence, and adaptive learning – can increase the capacity of future leaders to support the ongoing transformation of your business.

Rule 3

Old: Select talent using complementary sources

Meta-analyses have repeatedly shown that well-designed assessment processes can explain just under 40% of the variance in future job performance. This is typically achieved through a multi-method approach using a combination of tools targeted at the needs of the job. These include a measure of general mental ability, a structured interview focused on understanding current behaviors and skills and past experiences, a psychometric test focused on aspects of personality, and a work sample (role play, presentation, simulation, etc). Each component adds further explanatory power because it measures a different aspect of the person that informs the level of person-job fit – intelligence, personality, skills, and behaviors. By adding information from each source, assessments aim to judge how the individual is likely to perform. The better the fit between person and job, the better the performance, so ticking off different components of the job description provides a more rounded appraisal of the individual’s capabilities.

‘Just like financial services, the past performance of your employee is no guarantee of future performance’ However, this approach may inherently limit the predictive power of assessments so that they have been unable to break beyond the 40% barrier over the past 100 years. Firstly, as discussed above, skills can rapidly become obsolescent. There is an inverse relationship between the dynamism of the environment and the value of experience: just like financial services, the past performance of your employee is no guarantee of future performance. An individual may have honed a particular set of skills but if job requirements change (as is likely) these may no longer support their performance. Secondly, behaviors are context dependent. Behavioral choices are driven by a complex mix of situation, environment, individual, and situational judgment. So, the demonstration of target behaviors in one context

does not mean that the individual will make the same choices in a new role or organization that contains different processes, challenges, culture – and leaders. New: Select talent using dynamic interactional sources

Using robust data from a range of valid assessment tools continues to be the gold standard and the pathway to optimizing prediction. In addition, technology-driven assessment tools such as game-based and AI-enabled adaptive assessment tools are providing a wealth of data that can provide new insights into the underlying drivers of performance. Advances in data science enable us extract far more knowledge and understanding than previously possible. By understanding the interdependencies and interactions between different facets of individuals and how these contribute to performance, we can create more integrated and dynamic models of leadership performance with greater predictive power. Further, these models yield increasingly sophisticated insights about how we can harness and develop the talents of our people and support their success in role. The new talent mindset

Instead of a lean 15%, what if 50% of your organization was perceived as talent? Or 80%? What if you took a perspective that everyone in your organization was talent? The new talent mindset is inclusive, starting with the assumption that everyone has unique abilities. The key question is no longer, “Is this person ‘talent’?” but rather, “What is the nature of this person’s talent and how can we release, develop, amplify, and harness that talent to create value?” New models and technologies in the talent space make this possible. With the new talent mindset, the goal is no longer to chart a series of sequential moves to achieve a coveted destination role. Instead, the primary focus of talent management is to leverage precision insights to support learning and accelerated adaptation in the context of rapidly changing roles and organizations. The new talent mindset focuses on engaging and enabling the talent available within your organization more effectively, cutting through old rules that can anchor progression planning to the past rather than accelerate your future. ■

Tania Lennon leads the Strategic Talent team for IMD. She is an expert on future-ready talent development, including innovative assessment methods to maximize the impact of talent development on individual and organizational performance. Lennon is a “pracademic”, blending a strong research orientation with evidence-based practice in talent development and assessment. Mikolaj Jan Piskorski is Professor of Digital Strategy, Analytics and Innovation and Dean of IMD Asia and Oceania. He is an expert on digital strategy, platform strategy, and the process of digital business transformation. He works with companies in various industries across the globe to support them through digital transformation.

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 69


[ In my view ]

70 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023


Technology may lead to a more efficient process, but it’s not the best option if it worsens the customer experience – and without due regard to data cleansing the results can be catastrophic, warns Bali Padda

I

n the early years of this century, the UK national postal service centralized and automated its financial reporting systems for thousands of post offices around the country, typically run by small, independent business owners, known as sub-postmasters. The project, supplied by Fujitsu, was called Horizon. After the roll-out, many of the sub-postmasters began reporting bugs in the system, often registering a significant but incorrect shortfall in takings. The system frequently failed to compute sums accurately. Someone who trained sub-postmasters on the system reported years later that he had reported this systemic error to his bosses, but the flaws were not corrected. Some postmasters even made up the accounting discrepancy from their own funds. Instead of acknowledging the possibility of incorrect data, between 2000 and 2013, senior Post Office executives began criminal proceedings against over 700 blameless individuals, some of whom were sent to prison for “theft”. The criminal convictions are in the process of being overturned, and a public inquiry has been launched, but many lives have been ruined. It has been described as the most widespread miscarriage of justice in British history. Amid the understandable desire in the business world to maximize operational efficiency through automation, and to be data-led, there is not always the same priority applied to data cleansing as there is to project roll-out and delivery. Data is so readily available and so convenient to use that it requires discipline to ensure it is “clean” – that it states what it purports to state. Early in my tenure as Chief Operations Officer at LEGO, I and an American colleague devoted many hours to ensuring more visible and more accurate operational data so that we could better match supply to demand.

Photo: Shutterstock

Throughout my career in supply chain management, I have fought against an irrational bias in which strategy and the implementation of new technology carry greater kudos, and often higher salaries, than operations, logistics, and maintenance. The Horizon scandal is perhaps the most extreme example of this prejudice. Of course, more than 20 years on, digital technology has developed considerably since Horizon, but automation was nothing new in 2000. Robots had been building cars since the 1970s, and air traffic control was automated well before the turn of the century. While it could be argued that such an appalling error as had occurred in the Horizon

scandal could not happen with more sophisticated systems, one could equally well argue the opposite: that the very sophistication of newer systems may exacerbate the human tendency to have too much respect for the technology – to neglect data cleansing, fail to ensure checks and balances within managerial systems and, crucially, to lose sight of the over-riding purpose of serving the customer. An understandable excitement about the potential of new technology can result in the failure to engage sufficiently in scrutiny or due diligence. If we adopt the latest innovations without a critical eye and imbue them with special powers, we will fail to gain the best use of them. In large language models and other AI applications, for example, there are acknowledged problems of “model drift”, “data drift” and “concept drift” – models whose usefulness has decayed resulting either from such factors as a change in context or methods of obtaining data, inaccuracy, the incompleteness of relevant data, or the bias of designers. The need for continual updating and training is increasingly recognized as essential in the field of machine learning. What are your vital data points?

In my years as head of the supply chain at the toy company LEGO, I would place a strong emphasis on data cleansing and on being led by what I called the “vital few” points of operational data – the key indicators showing performance as experienced by retail customers and consumers, and whether operations were performing and/or delivering. It was essential to ensure the maximum flexibility and responsiveness to enable supply to match demand. Sometimes I would push back against a proposal from an engineer to automate a certain process because, with the technology available at the time, it would have locked us into a less flexible process. One result of this was that, on one occasion, a colleague expressed surprise when I advocated in favor of the automation of a process for

‘If we adopt the latest innovations without a critical eye and imbue them with special powers, we will fail to gain the best use of them’ molding machines so that waste could be removed by a robot arm and recycled back into production in the correct dose. He had assumed I was “anti-automation”. Perhaps I could have explained myself to my colleagues better earlier, but the point was: automation must serve the business, not the other way around. A useful distinction, I discovered, was between efficiency and effectiveness: a more efficient process that worsens the customer experience is not the option to take. In the context of an innovative toy company with its own factories and a high turnover in its portfolio of products, dealing with fluctuating and seasonal demand, the matching of supply to demand requires constant discipline, anchored around the “vital few” » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 71


[ In my view ]

data points and overseen by a multi-disciplinary team. The over-automation of the packing process could result in overly rigid processes in which we were packing the wrong things more quickly. Too much inventory is inefficient from a business point of view and has a negative environmental and brand impact. The efficiency of our molding processes, on the other hand, was continually enhanced through robotics.

‘The physical act of writing on the whiteboard serves to embed the importance of an action in the individual’s memory. It reinforces personal accountability too’ There are essential disciplines to observe when weighing up where to deploy data and the latest technology. The central one is to maintain an overall understanding of the entire value chain of the whole business. This is allied to working back from the customer’s needs. A multi-disciplinary approach, in which all relevant divisions are represented, is essential. The decision on which parts of an operation to automate, and how, should be a joint managerial decision, not one that is left to technology gurus alone. Once this is decided, then the tech experts can oversee the implementation. Visualize your operations as a team

An approach I introduced at LEGO – initially in our North American operations but eventually adopted globally – and used in other companies is that of the “visual factory”. This is anchored around a weekly operations briefing, which provides a concise yet full overview of the company’s operations, attended by all relevant personnel (and no one else!). The briefing starts on time, typically early morning, and only lasts for 30 minutes, or 40 minutes if there is a major issue to address.

data on a screen is that it is too easily absorbed and too quickly forgotten. And there can be way too much of it. Provided the data is accurate, upto-date, and supplied by the most modern systems available, then the “visual factory” harnesses the best of data-led intelligence and cognitive human engagement and facilitates collaboration. A business needs to find its own cadence, or rhythm, within which it ensures constant vigilance – therefore, such briefings may be more, or less, frequent than weekly in another sector. In the meetings themselves, this vigilance involves asking the “What if?” questions. You must ask yourselves continually: “What is the problem we are trying to solve here? How will automation help us?” Another important feature within the “visual factory” approach is the presence of everyone in the room (or on the video call) who affects the outcome. They should be given freedom of expression. This includes relatively new or junior individuals: it is not a hierarchical approach, but rather one that enables collaboration, honesty, and listening. Had this approach been adopted at the UK Post Office, it is likely reports by sub-postmasters of worrying bugs in the system would have been taken seriously and corrected before it was too late. That regrettable tale reminds us that automation and AI will not automatically improve operations, efficiency, or customer service. Yes, they can enhance, even transform, performance, but only when overseen by a well-trained, tuned-in, multi-disciplinary team with an informed and open-minded view of the whole value chain. The purpose of a business, after all, is to serve the customer, not to pursue technological change as an end in itself. ■

The “vital few” points of data (and nothing else!) are written up on a whiteboard. They are coded green for “on course”, and red for “attention/ action”. The kind of data used in this process may change over time – at LEGO, we would have a review every six months. Typically, data would cover areas such as customer service, complaints, progress against delivery, and business results as well as health and safety indicators. The physical act of writing on the whiteboard serves to embed the importance of an action in the individual’s memory. It reinforces personal accountability too. The individual responsible for an action must report back to the group the following week. The handwriting and whiteboard may sound like an archaic approach in the age of AI, but it is not. The data will, of course, be up-to-date and supplied by the latest systems, fed in by retailers as well as internal sources on real-time systems. The idea is to select the points that most directly affect performance and to be anchored around those. A problem with 72 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Bali Padda was Chief Operations Officer for LEGO from 2004-2016, later becoming the first non-Danish CEO of the company. He took a leading role in the rescue, turnaround, and revival of the business after it nearly went into liquidation in 2003-04. His book Deliver What You Promise, was published by Heligo Books in 2022 (Chinese translation 2023).


[ The forecaster ]

Coca-Cola's refreshed itself in the face of changing tastes ... and so can you

I

t’s impossible to execute the right strategy if there are no options. Surprises crop up no matter how carefully we plan. Who would have thought, for instance, that young people prefer moderation? That abstinence is the new cool? Old-fashioned hard drinkers might ask: “What’s the point of low or no-alcohol versions of spirits and wines?” But the vast majority of consumers aged 18 to 34 are the ones switching – driving double-digit growth in this category within the beverage industry in the US, Germany, and Spain. The challenge in all this, if you happen to be a traditional incumbent, is the unpredictability of the business environment. When something fundamentally surprising can take off, the old way of reacting simply doesn’t work. For one, running a business always requires planning capacity. Launching a new line of products takes not just money but the attention and time of your best marketing people to work on a campaign. Then, factories need to adjust with new recipes, and the procurement folks need to hunt down the right ingredients at reasonable prices and in sufficient quantities.

Unpredictability in the marketplace can quickly burst the bubble of any company not agile enough to adapt to change. Howard Yu and his team offer lessons from the soda pop giant’s successful mission to update and diversify its product range

All of this is obvious but serves to highlight that if any part of these complex and interrelated activities is not in lockstep and each is not optimized, the company can risk losing money. Either a hot product isn't manufactured in enough quantity and shipped where it's needed, or worse, a lot of products get stuck in warehouses, unwanted. In this scenario, even the CEO’s job might be at risk from investor pressure. Wall Street might think short term, but it has even less tolerance for perceived incompetence. But what’s the alternative? Doing nothing will only guarantee a longterm decline because bold upstarts are ready to catch the market trends. And thus the innovator’s perennial dilemma: damned if you do, damned if you don’t. Only the most exceptional manage to perform and transform at the same time. The question is: how?

Illustration: Jörn Kaspuhl

Future Readiness is a balanced scorecard

At IMD, we try to gauge a company’s readiness to operate in an inherently unpredictable business landscape. We seek to measure outcomes – that is, if a company is able to capitalize on new market opportunities in the form of product diversity, opening new geographical markets, or introducing new innovations without sinking the company » Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 73


[ The forecaster ]

into chaos and destroying the near-term profit pool. We look at which companies are able to scale up and invest in new capabilities and embrace entrepreneurship while simultaneously reducing the cost of production and administrative overheads (see chart on facing page).

told the audience: “It’s okay if your favorite drink is not red Coke.” People gasped. “Coke is not a one-product company anymore,” he continued. “If the culture is to pretend that Coke is everyone's favorite beverage, then there's a conflict between culture and strategy.”

In other words, we want to know how top-performing companies break out from the traditional trade-off. These are tall orders, but exceptional companies have much to teach us. Here are three key lessons:

Of course, a grand statement like that must be backed by consistent resource allocation, followed by execution to enable the new categories to flourish.

1. Name the problem

2. To grow fast, free up resources

The challenge is that carbonated soft drinks have a higher margin. Non-bubbly or still drinks are “harder to make”, at least for Coca-Cola, and they are currently made in smaller quantities. So, CEO James Quincey took a bottle of Dasani water to a town hall meeting in August 2015 and

‘Decisions made by AI in real time can unearth patterns in the value chain that simply escape the purview of the human mind’

If you are the Coca-Cola Company, it would be delusional to believe that selling sugary drinks, and doing so alone, could be a viable strategy in the long run. The obesity crisis, the rise of alternatives, and the ebb-andflow of consumer preferences due to social media demand that a company like Coca-Cola branches out into other product lines and makes them central to the organization. Often, the first step to progress is to name the problem as it is.

Quincey decided it was time to eliminate some 1,200 positions from its Atlanta headquarters and work more closely with independent bottlers. Under this asset-light model, Coke could then push its flagship brand with new varieties such as Orange Vanilla, Coke Energy, and Coke with Coffee. It reformulated its Diet Coke brand and launched Coke Zero while shutting down 1,300 products that showed no sign of potential.

Coke went on to acquire Fairlife (dairy drinks), Costa Coffee (cafes), BodyArmor (sport drinks), Mojo (kombucha), Tropico (fruit juice), and Made Group (smoothies), among others. To manage the new products and to increase the odds of their success, Coke could not rely on focus groups or home visits alone. Such consumer studies are valid, but there is now a need to analyze social media using AI to spot patterns and identify what’s likely to become popular and where. The next step is to combine such demand insights and use AI again to handle the procurement and sourcing, packaging, and logistics. Why? Because decisions made by AI in real time can unearth patterns in the value chain that simply escape the purview of the human mind. How else can you manage to sell 500 soft drinks in 200 countries involving some 80,000 employees worldwide like Coca-Cola? Which brings us to the third lesson about scaling up the digital backbone. 3. To create impact, scale up excellence

Changing times and changing tastes: an advert for Coca-Cola in the early 1900s

74 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

At the consumer goods conglomerate Procter & Gamble (P&G), as Joshi observed, the corporate center provides the centralized platform. Microsoft Azure and a centralized data lake are there to support business units

Photo: Wikipedia

It is tempting to praise an experimental mindset. But without the proper follow-up, nothing scales. Without scaling, there is a lack of standardized data and AI infrastructure, narrow data availability and capabilities, and the absence of mechanisms for sharing results and best practices. “Standardized processes and a shared data and analytics architecture are crucial,” my colleague Amit Joshi has argued in the MIT Sloan Management Review.


FUTURE READINESS INDICATOR 2023 - CONSUMER PACKAGE GOODS

around the world as they build their analytics and AI features on top. As a result, teams can extract data from this central system and further load it with internal and external data sources to build out specific solutions that correspond to the needs of different business units.

Infographic:Theresa Schwietzer

This federal system provides the headquarters with a bird’s-eye view. The center can identify situations where a particular local solution could have multiple applications across regions. Meanwhile, local units have the autonomy to incubate bottom-up ideas. It's P&G’s way of achieving autonomy and control simultaneously – allowing people to create local solutions, test them, deploy them, and have them quickly replicated elsewhere. That’s also how Coca-Cola and L’Oréal evaluate marketing campaigns across channels, platforms, formats, audiences, and messages. They measure their respective returns (ROI) across dozens of markets, identify the top performers, and then allocate resources. Audience modeling, a highly valuable use case for digital marketing, does not need to be rebuilt country by country. It should apply everywhere.

A can of Coke or a pack of eyeliner might look low-tech, but it’s not about what you sell – it’s about knowing what to create and how to engage consumers, and it’s about running a seamlessly efficient operation across channels, regions, and time periods. In the dance of change, only those who move with agility and grace can lead. ■ Discover how IMD has derived seven factors with 23 variables for our readiness indicator at www.imd.org/future-readiness-indicator/home/ our-research-methodology/ Jialu Shan, Alexandre Sonderegger, and Lawrence Tempel contributed to this article.

Howard Yu is LEGO® Professor of Management and Innovation at IMD, and the author of LEAP: How to Thrive in a World Where Everything Can Be Copied (PublicAffairs, June 2018). He is also director of IMD’s Center for Future Readiness.

Sept-Nov 2023 • I by IMD 75


[ PREVIEW ]

Scan the QR code to visit ibyimd.org

Maximum impact

Coming in December 2023 To secure a more sustainable and inclusive future, we need creative ideas and partnerships that reimagine the inner workings of the global economy. The “impact economy” has emerged as a space for corporations, entrepreneurs, investors, non-profits, and governments to co-create solutions to address society’s complex challenges. In the December issue of I by IMD, we explore how social innovation, new approaches to finance, and collaboration can change the way we do business – and the world. In the meantime, join us online daily at ibyimd.org, where you will find articles, videos, podcasts and learning exercises that will spark conversation and help you and your teams excel.

[ IMPRINT ] PUBLISHER

International Institute for Management Development Ch. de Bellerive 23, P.O. Box 915, CH-1001 Lausanne | Switzerland

76 I by IMD • Sept-Nov 2023

Cynthia Hansen Managing Director of the Innovation Foundation, empowered by the Adecco Group Prince Michael of Liechtenstein Founder and Chairman of Geopolitical Intelligence Services AG; Chairman of the European Centre of Austrian Economics Foundation in Vaduz; Member of STEP Ann-Marie Sevcsik​ Catalyst of social change through innovative partnerships Michael Skapinker Financial Times contributing editor Ian Charles Stewart Executive in Residence, IMD; Main Board Director Trustee International Institute for Sustainable Development; Co-Founder of WiReD Magazine Su-Mei Thompson CEO at Media Trust

EDITORIAL

Delia Fischer Matt Falloon Ken Toner ART DIRECTOR

Catharina De Gregorio PRINTING

IMD – Printshop

Send Letters to the Editor to: content@imd.org

Photo: Ali Abdul Rahman via Unsplash

EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD Anand Narasimhan (Chair) Professor of Global Leadership and Dean of Research Christine Batruch Sustainability Advisor, Lundin Group; President, Bohdan Hawrylyshyn Family Foundation Vincent Bieri Co-Founder Nexthink; Member of the Board of Advisors Trust Valley Jean-Philippe Bonardi Professor of Strategic Management and Dean at HEC Lausanne, University of Lausanne Stuart Crainer Thinkers50 Founder and author Michel Demaré Chairman of IMD; Chair of the Board at AstraZeneca Plc. and Nomoko AG; member of the supervisory boards at Vodafone Group Plc and Louis-Dreyfus Company International Holdings B.V.


Live. Learn. Play. It’s go time. Time to get yourself out of bed and get going, because the day belongs to those who claim it. It’s go time. Time to live, love, learn, teach, work and play on SA’s Bozza Network. It’s go time. Time to rewrite your story, stake your claim, or start that start-up. Time to slay, make your moves, and add your own unique flavour to the world. It’s go time. The time for waiting is over. The time for going is here.

*Based on MyBroadband 2020


21052 Dubai

21323 Grand Piano

10280 Flower Bouquet

LESS ACTION. M O R E S AT I S FA C T I O N . A D U LT S W E L C O M E

Experience LEGO ® Sets for Adults – rewarding and creatively challenging sets to suit all interests. LEGO.com/Adults

LEGO and the LEGO logo are trademarks of the LEGO Group. ©2021 The LEGO Group.