Virginia Taxation

Purchasing software? Document, document, document

Software can be exempt from sales tax in Virginia, but taxpayers must have the correct language in contracts to qualify.

Terry Barrett, CPA Software is a routine purchase for most businesses. Fortunately, Virginia (and some other states) provide an exemption from the retail sales and use tax for certain types of software. This can be a muchappreciated cost-saver, whether you are implementing a costly new enterprise resource planning system or just getting started with Quickbooks. However, unwary taxpayers may find themselves denied an exemption due to documentation issues.

SOFTWARE EXEMPTION DEFINITIONS

Exempt software falls into two general categories: custom computer programs and prewritten software delivered electronically (or in other than tangible format). Custom programs are generally defined as those that are specifically designed and developed only for one customer. Virginia law goes further in its distinction between prewritten and custom software by including within the definition of “custom programs” the statements “[t]he combining of two or more prewritten programs does not constitute a custom computer program. A prewritten program that is modified to any degree remains a prewritten program and does not become custom.” Thus, custom programs meeting the above criteria typically are not purchased by most businesses.

On the other hand, virtually every business purchases some form of prewritten or canned software. “Prewritten software” is defined by Virginia law for sales tax purposes as ”that which is prepared, held or

existing for general or repeated sale or lease, including a computer program developed for in-house use and subsequently sold or leased to unrelated third parties.” This includes your everyday, offthe-shelf prewritten software.

While few software vendors today sell software (prewritten, custom or otherwise) in tangible format — on CDs or “tapes” or another tangible medium — if the software is sold in tangible format it is subject to Virginia’s sales tax. Therefore, software purchased at stores like OfficeMax, Best Buy or from a valueadded reseller in CD format is subject to the tax— clearly something tangible is received by the purchaser. In addition, prewritten software that is preloaded on hardware prior to the delivery to the customer is also taxable since the software is transferred on something tangible.

Software delivered electronically, downloaded with a “key” or code or loaded by the seller onto a business’s computers is not taxable in Virginia. Virginia law specifically provides an exemption from the tax, in part, for “services not involving an exchange of tangible personal property which provide access to or use of the Internet and any other related electronic communication service, including software, data, content and other information services delivered electronically via the Internet.” Similarly, software as a service (SaaS), where users remotely access software on a vendor’s or third party’s server and do not receive anything tangible in the process, is not taxable. This sounds relatively straightforward: tangible equals taxable; electronic equals exempt.

DOCUMENTATION IS KEY

A problem, however, may arise in documenting the electronic delivery/remote access of the software. State auditors are quick to deny an exemption and assess tax if sufficient documentation is not provided. The Virginia Department of Taxation’s minimum documentation requirements for confirming the electronically delivery of software products is set forth in Public u

Experience benefi ts that reward you

Because Virginia Society of Certifi ed Public Accountants has partnered with Nationwide, you can save with exclusive discounts on Nationwide auto insurance. Add Accident Forgiveness and/or Vanishing Deductible, and you can save even more.

Contact me today to see how I can save you money on your insurance.

Ronnie Shriner shriner@nationwide.com 2571 Homeview Dr Richmond VA 23294 Ronnie Shriner Insurance Agency Inc Phone: (877) 683-3364

Nationwide may make a fi nancial contribution to this organization in return for the opportunity to market products and services to its members or customers. Products Underwritten by Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company and A liated Companies. Nationwide Lloyds and Nationwide Property & Casualty Companies (in TX). Home O ce: Columbus, OH 43215. Subject to underwriting guidelines, review, and approval. *Vanishing Deductible is an optional feature. Annual credits subject to eligibility requirements. Max. credit: $500. Details and availability vary by state. Products and discounts not available to all persons in all states. Nationwide, Nationwide Insurance, the Nationwide framemark, On Your Side and Vanishing Deductible are service marks of Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company. © 2016 Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company AFO-0915AO (03/16)

Document (P.D.) 05-44 (April 4, 2005). P.D. 05-44 provides that “at a minimum a sales invoice, contract or other sales agreement must expressly certify the electronic delivery of the software and that no tangible medium for that software has been furnished to the customer.” [Emphasis added.]

While this policy was clarified years ago, many software sellers still do not specify on their invoice, contract or sales agreement that the software is delivered electronically AND that no tangible property is delivered. Contractual language may state that the software may be provided electronically or in tangible format at the customer’s request, however, this permissive language is not sufficient to render the sale of software exempt. There must be a definitive statement that the software is delivered electronically and no tangible medium is provided. Most buyers believe that the mere fact that the software was delivered electronically (because that’s how everyone does it) renders the software exempt. That’s not the case.

VIRGINIA FOLLOWS THE LETTER OF THE LAW

Over the years, taxpayers have appealed tax assessments on software due to failure of the vendor’s contracts to meet the minimum documentation requirements, and quite frequently have been denied relief by the Tax Commissioner. Most recently, in P.D. 18-111 (June 8, 2018), in an appeal of the assessment of tax on electronically received software, the taxpayer provided copies of the vendor's quote, the purchase order, the sales invoice and correspondence from the vendor for the transaction at issue. The vendor’s correspondence referenced the purchase order number for the contested transaction and stated that the software and related maintenance were delivered electronically and were not physically delivered to the taxpayer.

The Tax Commissioner, however, responded that Virginia law requires that “[a]ny assessment of a tax by the Department shall be deemed prima facie correct” and the burden was on the taxpayer to prove the assessment was erroneous. He denied the exemption for the transaction. The Commissioner maintained that although the taxpayer had provided correspondence from the vendor that referenced the purchase order number for the contested transaction, that fact alone was insufficient evidence that electronic delivery was the only method available for delivery of the software.

The Tax Commissioner further maintained that because the taxpayer did not provide any of the types of documentation, i.e., a sales invoice, contract or sales agreement, which contained the required certification language discussed in P.D. 05-44, no exemption was allowed. It was also noted in the letter that the vendor’s sales invoice listed a “ship to” address and stated that the delivery method was “ground,” which indicated the possibility that the software and maintenance agreement may have been delivered by a tangible medium.

In P.D. 11-70 (5/11/11), there was a similar situation in which a taxpayer contested an audit assessment on the purchase of software and provided email correspondence from the software vendor stating that there was no delivery of software via tangible media. The Tax Commissioner ruled that the vendor’s email correspondence alone was not sufficient evidence to support the removal of the purchase from the taxpayer’s audit.

The takeaways from the recent Tax Commissioner rulings are:

1. In order to qualify for the exemption from the tax, the documentation requirements of P.D. 05-44 should be met.

Namely, the sales invoices or a contract/sales agreement for the purchase of electronically delivered software should state that the software is delivered electronically and no tangible medium is provided to the customer.

Further, the invoices should not reference “ship to” addresses or physical delivery modes.

2. If the documentation provided in connection with a purchase of software does not clearly state the above, it is recommended the buyer reach out to the vendor to seek a revised invoice, contract or sales agreement that does.

3. If a software buyer cannot obtain such documentation, consider self-assessing and reporting use tax directly to

TAX; if audited, TAX likely will assess the tax, interest and possibly penalties.

This issue frequently arises in audits and because a recent appeal letter was on point, odds are the issue is receiving renewed attention by auditors. If you have purchased any software recently, you may want to review the invoices/contracts to see if they meet the documentation tests — and if not, take action. n

Terry Barrett, CPA, is a tax senior manager at Keiter in Glen Allen. She focuses on state and local tax consulting, with a special interest in and emphasis on sales and use tax in the multistate arena.

tbarrett@keitercpa.com connect.vscpa.com/TerryBarrett (804) 273-6254 keitercpa.com

WE’RE LOOKING FOR A FEW CPA STARS!

Nominate yourself or an outstanding colleague for a VSCPA Distinguished CPA Award by Friday, Dec. 7.

The VSCPA has added two new awards this year, and it only takes a few minutes to nominate a colleague! Award nominations can be made in the following categories:

Impact Award

Recognizes a VSCPA member who has made a recent contribution to the advancement of the profession by showing a commitment to one or more of the following: innovation, learning, advocacy or student activities.

Top 5 Members Under 35 Award

Recognizes a young CPA member (35 or younger as of April 30, 2019) who has shown excellence in one or more of the following: professional achievement, VSCPA or local VSCPA chapter accomplishment, community contribution or dedication to the CPA profession.

Outstanding Member Award

Recognizes a VSCPA member who has provided outstanding service to the profession through participation in VSCPA activities, civic engagement and charitable activities that further a positive image of accounting and the CPA profession.

Advancing Diversity & Inclusion Award

Recognizes a VSCPA member who champions diversity and inclusion in the field of accounting by doing one or more of the following:

• Plans and implements organizational initiatives to help ensure a diverse, inclusive workplace environment

• Champions policies and programs aimed at improving diversity in the profession

• Demonstrates leadership and commitment to raising awareness of diversity principles

• Serves as a role model for current and future CPAs through mentorship, coaching or other types of volunteer work in the community

READY TO NOMINATE?

Visit vscpa.com/Awards or email Student & Member Engagement Specialist at Lauren Simonetti at lsimonetti@vscpa.com by Friday, Dec. 7.