Skip to main content

Shop & Stroll / Home Port (CM, December 2026

Page 1

P O H S & L L O R T S CLEVELAND MAGAZINE

Pa ge

36

Ph ot og ra ph ed DANIEL LOZ ADA

by

&

Wri tt en by

MARK OPREA

LY D I A KOSZEGI

&

CHRISTINA RUFO

DECEMBER 2026 36 C L E V E L A N D 1 2 . 2 6

CLEVELANDMAGAZINE.COM

36

PHOTO CREDIT

THESE 21 LOCAL, INDEPENDENT G ROCE RY S TO R E S WI LL M AKE YO U F A L L I N L O V E W I T H YO U R SHOPPING LIST AGAIN.

PHOTO CREDIT

F O R G E T I N S TA C A R T A N D C U R B S I D E P I C K U P, B I G B O X E S A N D N A M E B R A N D S .

CHUPPA’S MARKET PLACE 5640 Pearl Road, Parma, 440-885-5000, chuppasmarketplace.com


Alesci’s of Shoregate WILLOWICK

A family-owned staple since 1972, Alesci’s offers a taste of Italy with deli favorites, homemade pastas, pizzas and a selection of imported specialties. “We’re known for our imported products, mainly imported prosciutto from Italy and Canada,” says manager Greg Herbert. Daily dinner specials, ranging from chicken Parmesan to lasagna, give customers something different to look forward to with each visit. 29730 Lakeshore Blvd., Willowick, 440-585-1112, alescisshoregate.com

Is anyone not busy?

Asian Town Center A S I ATOW N

Housed in a historic industrial building, this sprawling, 115,000-squarefoot shopping complex brings together an eclectic mix of Asian grocery stores, restaurants and

The word dominates small talk. Holidays. Kids. Work. Chores. Busy. Busy. Busy. Yet, we have more conveniences than ever. Grocery shopping is a special occasion for my toddlers. It’s just easier to lock them in their car-seat straitjackets and snatch the grub curbside. When desperate, my wife and I, dressed in PJs, slyly snag our delivery bags without the neighbor seeing. We’re not alone: 15% of shoppers admit to ordering their groceries online while only 74% visit a store weekly, a record low, according to a Gallup poll. We grew up in the carts. Every week, up and down the aisles of Heinen’s. Quick runs. Fullfledged trips. Sneaking slices of turkey from the pre-weighed bag. Begging for the sugary cereal (and receiving an emphatic no). Baseball pants. Church clothes. It didn't matter. After all, there was nothing in the house, Mom said. Before you’d reorder last week’s list with a digital poke, grocery shopping was an art. Our folks evaluated the ingredients and compared prices. They bumped into neighbors and asked for recipes. The deli clerk pointed out what was fresh. This month, we set out to rediscover that art by filling a cart with items from local grocery stores that warm our winter hearts. You’ll find shelves of Ohio-made maple syrup, hot sauces, craft beer and salamis that put our food culture on display and imported items that will expand your culinary mind — or help you find a familiar bite of a faraway home. No matter what you’re looking for, you can find it in these aisles. – DILLON STEWART

coming back. "We invented chicken paprikash soup,” claims operations manager Lisa Chuppa. With a staff that is passionate about food and fresh products, this Parma staple makes picking up a homemade meal quick and easy. 5640 Pearl Road, Parma, 440-885-5000, chuppasmarketplace.com

Constantino’s Market DOWNTOWN

Chuppa's Market Place PA R M A

Homemade comfort food is at the heart of this family-operated market. Along with a stock of produce, baked goods and deli meats, shoppers stop for the fresh soups, sandwiches and other ready-to-eat meals. The signature chicken paprikash soup, made daily, is what keeps them

Founder Costas Mavromichalis took a gamble when he opened his market in 2005. As Downtown Cleveland has grown, however, the store on the ground floor of the Bingham Building has woven itself into the fabric of our city center. With fresh produce, prepared foods, grab-and-go meals, wine, beer and everyday essentials, the European-style neighborhood market’s tagline says it all: “We don’t have everything, but we have what you need.” 1278 W. Ninth St., Cleveland, 216-344-0501, constantinosmarket2.com

$539

HOT BREAD & BUTTER PICKLES

H O M E M A D E S E A S A LT P I TA C H I P S

MARK OPREA

$3 99

DANIEL LOZADA

38 C L E V E L A N D 1 2 . 2 6

specialty shops. Browse imported Chinese herbs, specialty teas and traditional ingredients at Asia Plaza Herbal Shop, peruse the many gift and trinket shops or stop by Asia Food Co. for fresh produce, hardto-find ingredients and an extensive selection of international snacks and frozen foods. With aisles worth exploring, there’s something for adventurous home cooks and those looking for a convenient bite alike. 3820 Superior Ave. E., Cleveland, 216-621-1681, asiatowncleveland.org

CHUPPA’S MARKET PLACE

$4 55

HONEY ROASTED PEANUT BUTTER

CLEVELANDMAGAZINE.COM

39


Fairfax Market FAIRFA X

When Fairfax Market opened in 2024, it brought a full-service grocery store back to the neighborhood for the first time in decades. The 40,000-squarefoot market pairs everyday essentials with more than 2,000 locally made products, spotlighting Cleveland businesses alongside a cafe, sushi bar, bakery and floral department. Beyond groceries, the market serves as a community gathering place, hosting local makers markets, cooking demonstrations and events. 2190 E. 105th St., Cleveland, 216-628-7301, fairfaxmarket.com

Giant Panda Supermarket & Cafe

Gingham Market

MENTOR

Attached to the cooking school Gatherings Kitchen, Gingham Market is an artisanal gourmet shop offering daily lunch specials, platters, deli items, fresh produce, baked goods and more. Its wide selection of graband-go meals makes it easy to bring something delicious home. With an ever-changing rotation of seasonal goods and cooking classes, Gingham Market is a destination for anyone with a passion for food. 17000 Madison Ave., Lakewood, 216-228-2285, ginghammarket.com

Whether you’re grabbing persimmon to cook your favorite dish, craving some carbonara-flavored chips, or snagging a boba tea and hot bao bun for lunch, this Mentor Avenue stop is full of Korean delights. Opened in May by 22-year-old, first-generation Vietnamese immigrant Lynn Nguyen, the shop is an outgrowth of her food stall, Cafe Panda, at nearby Great Lakes Mall. The market's cafe counter handles the boba, buns and more. 7770 Mentor Ave., Mentor, facebook.com

$14 99

LAKE ROAD MARKET

LAKEWOOD

DICKY T’S SPICE RUB

$1599

C H O C O L AT E C OV E R E D PRETZELS

Gust Gallucci’s Italian Foods MIDTOWN

GUST GALLUCCI’S ITALIAN FOODS I TA L I A N H E R B BREAD DIPPER

$1599 $6 99

GALLUCCI'S PEPPERONI BREAD

This Italian grocer has served the Midtown neighborhood for more than a century. It’s a one-stop shop for Gallucci’s homemade oils, seasonings, sauces, soups, breads, pastas, cheeses, cookies and meats, plus reputable national brands. Beyond its Italian offerings, the market is known for Hungarian specialties and an extensive olive counter. Browse the hot bar for ready-toeat pastas, wings, subs, salads and more. 6610 Euclid Ave., Cleveland, 216-881-0045, tasteitaly.com

$6 29

Heinen’s

40 C L E V E L A N D 1 2 . 2 6

MARK OPREA

Ever since Joe Heinen opened his Shaker Heights butcher shop in 1929, Heinen’s has been a staple of Northeast Ohio's diet. Now run by third- and fourth-generation owners, its 23 locations feature hundreds of regional brands such as Cleveland Kitchen, Black Cap Hot Sauce and Market Garden beer, as well as Ohiogrown produce and meat. Knowledgable clerks guide important decisions, like finding the freshest loaf in the bakery or ensuring you don't burn the halibut this time. The service-driven experience doesn’t end after you leave the checkout line, though; employees will help take your groceries out to your car for you. Various locations, heinens.com

MARK OPREA

VA R I O U S LO C AT I O N S

SPICY PICKLE SALSA

Lake Road Market

Lucky’s Market

Miles Farmers Market

ROCKY RIVER

VA R I O U S LO C AT I O N S

SOLON

Be it with locally sourced produce or imported European specialties, Lake Road Market has been serving shoppers since 1989. Now in its third generation of family ownership, the market features eye-catching product displays and indoor seating. Partnering with local vendors, the market offers fresh produce, meats prepared by its in-house butcher and imported Italian pastas, oils and cheeses. “We have such great relationships with the farmers and all the local people, the local vendors,” says owner Marta Rego. After shopping, settle in at the outdoor picnic tables for a bite. “It is very rewarding to be a part of the Rocky River community; many of our customers have become more like family and friends,” Rego adds. 20267 Lake Road, Rocky River, 440331-9326, lakeroadmarket.com

With five locations across Ohio, Lucky’s Market offers more than your typical grocery run, putting local farmers, makers and food producers in the spotlight. Alongside organic produce and everyday staples, shoppers can browse Ohio-made specialty goods, freshly prepared meals and an extensive selection of bulk foods. Bakery, butcher and seafood counters round out the offerings, while Lucky’s Sip ’n Stroll concept invites customers to enjoy a beer or glass of wine while browsing the aisles. The Ohio stores belong to the Saltzmans, the family behind Dave’s Markets, five generations of Cleveland grocers going back nearly a century to 33rd and Payne. 11620 Clifton Blvd., Cleveland, 216-651-9490; 7596 Fredle Drive, Concord, 440-290-6550, luckysmarketsohio.com

What began as a seasonal, open-air produce stand in 1971 has grown into a sprawling food destination known for its extensive selection of fresh foods and gourmet goods. Founded by Frank Cangemi, the market features locally sourced meats, hundreds of cheeses from around the world and an old-world deli with an assortment of specialties. The store's pride point, however, is the 200 people it employs. "We like to keep the counter fully staffed with people who know what they’re talking about,” says general manager Justin Golobek. An in-house bakery turns out fresh breads, pies and pastries daily, while Benny’s Bistro serves up its signature fried chicken, made with a special breading developed by Cangemi's team. 28560 Miles Road, Solon, 440-248-5222, milesfarmersmarket.com CLEVELANDMAGAZINE.COM

41


Murray Hill Market L I T T L E I T A LY

Inspired by the charm of oldfashioned grocery stores, this Little Italy market has offered affordable staples, fresh produce, beer, wine and prepared foods since 2010. Daily specials, including customer favorites like zucchini pancakes and eggplant, make it a convenient stop for college students and locals alike. “I don’t want to count anyone out. I want everybody to come in here,” says co-owner Michele Buckholtz. The market's nostalgic feel reflects the owners’ vision. 2072 Murray Hill Road, Cleveland, 216-791-1900, murrayhillmarket.net

Mustard Seed Market AKRON

The Nabers family has run this market, with a focus on natural and organic foods, since 1981. Buyers

here avoid products with chemicals, preservatives and artificial colors or flavorings. Order online for pickup and delivery. But if you are going to the store, the Highland Square location has a lively cafe, bar and patio, which hosts live music and overlooks the neighborhood. 885 Medina Road, Akron, 330-666-7333; 867 W. Market St., Akron, 330-434-7333, mustardseedmarket.com

Nature’s Oasis LAKEWOOD

This Lakewood market brings a healthy twist to the neighborhood, stocking locally sourced products, handmade goods, produce and wholesome snacks. Partnering with more than 250 Ohio businesses, the shop also features a spacious cafe serving handcrafted smoothies, locally roasted coffee, teas and freshmade meals. With plenty of seating and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s as much a hangout as it is a convenient

GIANT PANDA SUPERMARKET & CAFE

stop for everyday essentials. 15613 Detroit Ave., Lakewood, 216-505-5333, naturesoasisstores.com

Rego’s Neighborhood Market

Park to Shop Supermarket

For more than 25 years, Rego’s has served Strongsville with locally grown produce, a full-service deli and custom-cut meats. Beyond the everyday essentials, it’s the personal touch that keeps customers coming back. “We take pride in offering quality products, fresh foods and personal service that you don’t find at big chains,” says owner Courtney Rego. “We’re your neighborhood market and customers are treated like family.” 19600 W. 130th St., Strongsville, 440-878-9466, regosmarket.com

STRONGSVILLE

A S I ATOW N

One of Cleveland’s largest Asian supermarkets, Park to Shop offers plenty beyond the typical grocery run. Pick up freshly baked buns from the grab-and-go selection, browse the expansive produce and seafood sections or load up on noodles, sauces, spices and hot pot essentials. “I think what makes us stand out, especially at our Cleveland location, is that we’re Pan-Asian," says Jonny Chen, son of the owners. "We have different aisles dedicated to a variety of Asian cultures.” An extensive assortment of authentic cookware and kitchen utensils makes it a one-stop shop for stocking the kitchen. 1580 E. 30th St., Cleveland, 216781-3383, ptsmall.world

Founded by Italian immigrants in 1917, Rulli Brothers has spent more than a century supplying straightfrom-the-boot specialties and affordable groceries. Times have changed, but this store, still familyrun, honors its roots at the butcher shop, where cattle is cut in-house. “We were the first Italian market in the area," says Austintown general manager Joe Richards. "We still carry on that tradition." Today, the family operates three locations in Boardman, Austintown and McDonald. Various locations, rullibrothers.com

$4 48

CARBONARA HOT CHICKEN TURTLE CHIPS

42 C L E V E L A N D 1 2 . 2 6

I N S TA N T B U B B L E TEA KIT

MARK OPREA

$14 48

MARK OPREA

$6

MOJO HONEY BEES PURE R AW HONEY

VA R I O U S LO C AT I O N S

WICKLIFFE

STIR-FRY CHEESY RAMEN

$13 99

Rulli Brothers Italian Markets and Grocery Stores

Sweetberry Market

89

SWEETBERRY MARKET

With an ever-changing weekly menu of prepared foods, Sweetberry Market offers more. Produce is a major focus, with selections sourced from local auctions featuring Amishgrown fruits and vegetables. “Really, part of our success here is we try to make our shops feel like an oldschool neighborhood market,” says general manager Ryan Wilson. From the welcoming atmosphere to the attention given to sourcing its products, the storefront aims to make grocery shopping an experience rather than a chore. 30022 Euclid Ave., Wickliffe, 440-569-1042, facebook.com

YA YA’ S T A B L E - S I D E CAESAR DRESSING

$699

Taste of Europe

Tink Holl

LAKEWOOD

A S I ATOW N

The Old World is alive in Lakewood, where the shelves run deep with imports you won’t find at a chain. A West Lakewood staple, the store from owner and Alabania-native Dafina Bedini offers many a taste of Eastern Europe, with a diverse selection of meat, cheese, snacks and beverages from countries like Hungary, Croatia, Ukraine, Russia and more. Catering options and weekly housemade specials include dishes like goulash, stuffed peppers and Weiner schnitzel. 15512 Madison Ave., Lakewood, 216-521-9530, facebook.com

Tucked inside Asiatown’s Man Kam Plaza, this longtime supermarket is a destination for fresh produce, specialty seafood, roasted meats and hard-to-find Asian ingredients. Among its regular shoppers is Sora chef Eric Hess, who turns to Tink Holl for its extensive spice selection. “You can get more fresh spices there than anything from any other purveyors,” says Hess, who particularly appreciates the variety of whole spices available to grind himself. 1735 E. 36th St., Cleveland, 216-881-6996, facebook.com CLEVELANDMAGAZINE.COM

43


CLEVELAND MAGAZINE

Pa ge

44

E M O H T R O P Wri tte n by

DIL

MEG

Ph ot og ra ph ed by USE ANN GALEHO

T LO N S T E WA R

PHOTO CREDIT

44 C L E V E L A N D 1 2 . 2 6

PHOTO CREDIT

TOM MCINT YRE, THE OWNER AND FISHMONGER BEHIND K AT E ' S F I S H , H A S B E C O M E AN AMBASSADOR FOR THE 11 4 -Y E A R - O L D M A R K E T ’ S NEXT ER A AS IT UNDERGOES A H I S T O R I C T R A N S F O R M AT I O N .

DECEMBER 2026 CLEVELANDMAGAZINE.COM

45


few dozen people snake into an empty, tiled hallway in the northeast corner of the West Side Market. Saturday mornings are always busy, especially as the weather warms, but likely no stand has seen a line this long in decades. Like hypebeasts waiting for a sneaker drop, they’re all hungry for, but not guaranteed, a lobster roll from Kate’s Fish. About halfway through the line, diners pass Kate’s Fish owner Tom McIntyre at a stainless steel worktable. He is focused, working quickly and diligently, but he doesn’t shoo anyone away, however tempting that might be with 80 pounds of lobster to prepare. At his first lobster roll pop-up, McIntyre underestimated demand and ran out by midday. Smarter this time, he tripled that order — but still sold out before the day was over. Few fishmongers outside of Seattle’s Pike Place Market are used to the kind of attention that McIntyre is getting. He has, unexpectedly, blown up on social media, where his videos earn hundreds of thousands, sometimes even millions, of views. Some of his viewers are shoppers, eager to hear about whatever's fresh, but increasingly, they are voyeurs of the life of a fishmonger, watching him travel, receive fish and host oyster bar events. Many of them don't even live in Cleveland. The attention has turned Kate’s Fish — and with it, the West Side Market — into a destination for seafood lovers, who make pilgrimages to see the man with a simple catchphrase: “OK, folks.” When I approach him in line to reacquaint myself, McIntyre throws down his knife and pulls off his glove to shake my hand. “When are you going to do a story on Kate’s Fish?” he asks. I remind him of a five-year-old interview request, to which he didn’t respond. He furiously searches his email for proof. When he finds it, he abandons his station and whisks me away for an impromptu tour of the ongoing West Side Market renovations. “Let’s just do it now,” he says with a laugh. McIntyre is more than a foodie's favorite follow; the outspoken fishmonger is a symbol of the past and future 46 C L E V E L A N D 1 2 . 2 6

M C I N T Y R E N E V E R T H O U G H T a seafood market, especially one on the North Coast,

could attract a line of customers, until he saw one. In the mid 2000s, he was working at Plitt Seafood, a distributor in Chicago. One day around Christmas, he made a delivery to Supreme Lobster & Seafood. Despite the cold, a queue zig-zagged around the block. The image spawned a new idea of what his mom’s fish stand back home, Kate’s Fish, could be. “I stopped. I got out. I made sure I knew what I was seeing — people in line for a f---ing fish market,” he says. “In my head, I was like, whatever my mom’s doing at home, there could be money in it. There could be a future in it.” Kate’s Fish officially opened in 2001, but of course, the story starts earlier. Kate, McIntyre’s mom, met his dad at Penn State University’s corporate hospitality program in 1969, and they graduated a year later. His dad managed Lucarelli's Sweetwater Cafe in Playhouse Square, owned by longtime restaurateur Gary Lucarelli, then pivoted to become a lawyer. His mom continued to run corporate kitchens, including the one in the former BP Tower. In 1998, she went to work for Navillus Seafoods, a wholesaler at the West Side Market. When Navillus turned into Euro USA, it wanted out of retail. So, Kate purchased the equipment and the stand at the Market. She rebranded it as Kate's Fish. McIntyre, now 42, grew up in the Market. He enjoyed the atmosphere but showed little interest in the family business. On weekends, the Bay High School student would sleep in his mom’s car, then work a shift in the afternoon. After dropping out of college in 2004, he felt aimless. He took off to Chicago. The city was expensive, so he got a job doing the only thing he was (hardly) qualified to do. Plitt Seafood hired him as a receiving manager, based on his mom’s reputation alone. Every morning, 6 a.m. sharp, felt like a crash course in offloading trucks, managing inventory, grading tuna and busting ass. “I learned a hell of a lot out there: how to make it as a poor person in the big city, how to get up and go to work,” he says. “And I learned a lot about seafood.” Back at home, Kate’s Fish was on the brink. Over dinner, Kate told her son that she was $22,000 in debt. She needed to sell. “Don’t,” McIntyre urged her. “I’ll move home.” “You don’t want to do that,” she said. McIntyre did it anyway. “In my dad’s terms, I took over an insolvent company,” he says. “But I don’t see it that way. The company had a little bit of brand equity. She sold quality products, and people kept coming back. That is the foundation of business.” McIntyre moved home around 2007. He didn’t envision what Kate’s Fish has become today, a brand with a face, but his time at Plitt taught him who to call, what to buy and how to build credit, which the company severely lacked. In 2020, he bought the business from his mother. “I owe her everything in terms of my career. Now it feels like we’re at a point where it’s going to go like this,” he says, moving his hand in a J. T H E R E H A V E B E E N G O O D D A Y S and bad days at the West Side Market. A good

one? “That first $10,000 day,” a small milestone by today’s standards. A bad one? Jan. 23, 2021. It was a Saturday morning. The case at Kate’s Fish displayed whole red snapper, pink tuna fillets and jagged oysters neatly tucked in an icy bed. “It looked f---ing sick,” McIntyre says. “I had so much seafood to sell that

experience — and the revenue stream — hard to argue against. Nine million dollars still stands in the way, but when the North Arcade food hall does open in a few years, guests will line up for tastes and sips from 12 vendors. They'll grab a plate and head to the outdoor courtyard or the second-floor mezzanine, where former locker rooms will become public seating and event spaces. By then, the refrigerators will be back downstairs. Historically haunted by ghosts and rats, the infamous West Side Market basement is 29,500 square feet of construction and dirt right now. But by summer, it's first face-lift in decades will be complete, adding merchant amenities like walk-in coolers, a service elevator, a shared commercial kitchen, food processing stations and offices. The basement upgrade is so monumental that it accounts for nearly half of the project's budget. Infrastructure updates like these — new floor drains, HVAC, pressure sprayers and backup generators (to prevent losses from power outages) — aren't as eye-catching to consumers as late-night eats or historic preservation. But to business owners, they mean survival. McIntyre still has thoughts and the occasional grievance. He finds the Tuesday and Thursday closures outdated, a holdover from the days of the Central Market, which closed in 1988. And he really wants to know who is getting into the food hall. Videos of Tom McIntyre unboxing king mackeral (to the left) or prepping lobster rolls (bottom) have given Kate's Fish's business a boost. But when viewers visit the West Side Market stall in person, it's the quality of product that keeps them coming back.

COURTESY TOM MCINT YRE

A

day. It was gonna be a slammer. I knew it.” Suddenly, the Market went dark. It was, “like, the 30th power outage in three years,” he says. There was no backup generator. Hundreds of pounds of tilapia or perch were at risk. Insurance payouts would never cover the lost revenue, if they even covered the lost product. McIntyre fought tears as he typed what would become his first viral social media post. @KatesFish will be leaving the @WestSideMarket at the end of this year if it is not turned over to a non-profit management structure. Today, something happened that was just another example of why the market is on a downward spiral that can’t be stopped. @CityofCleveland, wake up. The post spurred a firestorm. Other vendors, though equally fed up, lambasted McIntyre for airing their dirty laundry. But after two decades of inaction, the complaints inspired movement. Local media glommed onto the story. Customers sent well wishes. Meanwhile, Bibb’s run for mayor was heating up. The young politician put the West Side Market — and his plan to transition it to nonprofit management — at the center of his messaging. Bibb says that idea stemmed from conversations he had with McIntyre and fellow vendor Don Whitaker, the longtime owner of D.W. Whitaker Meats. “I really sensed their frustration,” Bibb recalls. “I had to win them over because they had been made promise after promise after promise, and all those promises were broken.” In 2024, Bibb made good on his promise by handing management over to the Cleveland Public Market Corp. The city of Cleveland retains ownership. That year, the nonprofit launched a fundraising campaign to raise $70 million for a historic renovation. In the North Arcade, formerly the Produce Arcade, McIntyre walks to the end of a long row of temporary refrigerators. He proudly points to his own and pulls a box from it. "This is the future food hall," he says. "We're very hopeful to get a stall." For decades, Market customers have craved more seating, more prepared foods and, maybe, a beer to wash it all down. Some skeptics feared and fought this kind of change, but counterparts like Cincinnati's Findlay Market make the

of the West Side Market. Before the social media explosion, McIntyre gained publicity in 2021 for speaking out about the need to save the Market. Over the next year, Justin Bibb made it a priority of his mayoral campaign. Today, the institution, which turns 115 next year, is under new management and in the midst of the largest capital improvement project in its history. Now, with the renovations underway, he’s turning more of his attention to what’s next. In 2027, he plans to open a seafood restaurant in Tremont. Social media success has inspired other ideas, too. Those ideas rarely a filter between his brain and mouth. An expanded retail operation? A TikTok cooking show spotlighting fellow vendors? A Kate’s Fish spot on Food Network? But even as the fishmonger enters open waters, the West Side Market remains his home port.

CLEVELANDMAGAZINE.COM

47


1946

McIntyre continues to act like he’s an unlikely influencer, but friends and co-workers beg to differ. Dean Buck, whose passion for seafood inspired him to moonlight at Kate’s Fish when he’s not conducting the Cleveland Philharmonic Orchestra, says, “He loves every minute of it.” “He’s good at it!” Buck adds. “He likes talking to people. He likes campaigning. He’s always the first one to jump up and do something that needs to be done or say something that needs to be said. And I’m glad because the Market’s a better place for it.”

Kate's seems like a shoo-in. It's now serving hot food daily and hosting pop-up events with other chefs. Cleveland Public Market Corp. says the selections will include “a breadth of different types of foods” that are “reflective of Cleveland’s culinary scene” and include “a mix of existing merchants as well as folks new to the Market.” “Tom is a really good example — and is representative of a good number of our merchants — who love the market but recognized things had to change and advocated for that change,” says executive director Rosemary Mudry. “Now, he’s representative of a whole group of merchants who are collectively upping their game.” After years of empty promises, vendors are seeing results. Small ones, like quicker repairs and well-coordinated construction. And big ones, with the opening of the fully renovated Produce Arcade this year. “I’m sipping the Kool-Aid now,” he says. “I’m all in.”

T H R O U G H T H E W I N D O W of Hoopples, the longtime dive bar on Columbus Road,

O N E D A Y L A S T Y E A R , McIntyre was on the phone dealing with some BS. A “f---ing

2026

WEST SIDE MARKET'S NEXT ERA Here's what you need to know about the historic $70 million renovation project. East Arcade: The new KeyBank Produce Arcade opened in January with climate control, improved utilities and a more spacious design. North Arcade: Twelve leasable spaces will eventually be filled by local food and beverage purveyors. Guests will eventually sit inside on the second-floor mezzanine and outside at the courtyard.

Remaining Funds: The Cleveland Public Market Corp. is working to close a $9 million funding gap. Chef Michael Symon has joined the final push for donations. 48 C L E V E L A N D 1 2 . 2 6

COURTESY WEST SIDE MARKET

Basement: The engine of the market, the 29,500-square-foot space is getting a total overhaul, with new coolers, processing space and a commercial kitchen.

health insurance company” was giving him the run-around on a family matter. “I was not in a good place,” he admits. As he paced beside the stand, a kid with his father eagerly waited to meet the guy he’d seen in so many TikTok videos. McIntyre brushed him off with a quick hi. His gut sank as he watched the kid walk away obviously dejected. “Dang, that interaction hit me so hard,” he remembers. “He was probably super stoked to meet me. And I wasn’t gracious. I didn’t give him the time of day. Ever since then, I’ve been very conscious of being like, ‘Hi, how you doing? Great to see you. Thanks for supporting us.’” Whether McIntyre likes it or not, the social media attention has turned the Kate’s Fish counter into a stage. Customers travel from the boundaries of the metro area and far beyond just to see the social media star in person. Viewers from as far as Iceland, Mexico or South America comment on his videos: I’ve never wanted to move to Cleveland until now. Followers repeat his catchphrase back to him. “It’s weird to be recognized at, like, Costco,” he says. “The other day I was at Ace Hardware, and this dude looked up, and he’s like, ‘You’re the dude from the videos!’ Like, it’s happening. But there’s a weight to it.” McIntyre launched his social media presence in earnest in 2024. Last year, he added LT Magnotto to a business development position, with a heavy focus on social media and marketing. Magnotto is well-known for his own companies, Guardian Cold Brew and Field Trip Merch; for his partnership in Martha on the Fly, the breakfast-lunch takeout spot in Tremont; for his guitar playing in hardcore band Above This Fire; and as an affable man-about-town. His planning, directing and editing support has helped McIntyre add polish and frequency — while also allowing him to focus on what he knows best. “I would give a lot of credit to LT for having a vision, recognizing that there was an interesting product here in Kate’s Fish and the West Side Market and helping deliver some of that messaging,” says Joe Nagle of the nearly 140-year-old, family-run Boston seafood wholesaler John Nagle Co. “Tom is a fish guy, and he has all his qualities that make him good at that, but I don’t think he saw this coming, this internet popularity and the algorithmic celebrity.” McIntyre and Magnotto have known each other for years, which means Magnotto is comfortable saying, “Hey, your energy sucked. Do it again.” That chemistry has produced results they can see at the counter. After a video goes viral, new customers come in asking for “the TikTok fish.” “I’ve seen success with Martha and stuff, but I’ve never seen instant success like this,” Magnotto says. “It wasn’t just customers or potential customers. It was, like, seafood fanatics.” McIntyre says the digital marketing efforts have blown sales projections out of the water. In 2025, revenue was up 9.5% over 2024. In 2026, it's up nearly 50%, and that's after accounting for price increases due to rising costs. Customer count is estimated to be up 32%, with nearly 60,000 sales expected for the year. “The footprint is the same, the business is the same, the service is the same, the product is the same,” McIntyre says. “Marketing is the only thing you can attribute it to.”

is one of the city’s great views, made greater by a 3 p.m. beer. From atop the bluff, we watch the Columbus Road Lift Bridge elevate itself to create room for a cargo ship, that periodic reminder of Cleveland’s roots. “If you ask me what’s coming in on Thursday,” McIntyre says, “I can tell you everything off my head.” “OK, do it,” I say. “Everything?” “Yeah.” “Seventy perch. 50 cat. 40 cod. 100-pound sword. 120-pound tuna. 70 pounds of halibut. Seven cases of salmon. All the whole fish are coming in: black bass, fluke, snapper, walleye, branzino, zebra, grouper. I don’t write down any of it. I don’t send emails with the order. It’s personal. I get on the phone, and I find out what the f--- is going on.” Earlier this morning, he and his daughters sat at the breakfast table and FaceTimed his tuna, shown off by his supplier, Nagle. After all, it’s the beginning of bluefin season off the coast of Nova Scotia, where the beasts sit as fat as 800 to 1,000 pounds. Once caught, it’s 10 hours or less to Nagle’s Boston warehouse and then overnight to the West Side Market. If McIntyre orders on Wednesday, the fish hits cases by Friday. “Tom’s a great fishmonger,” says Buck. “The selection and quality of whole fish we sell at Kate’s Fish, I think the closest place geographically you’d have to go is either Baltimore or New York City. Not even Chicago has anything close to the selection that Kate’s does.” Nagle is like the “godfather of my children,” says McIntyre. They’ve stayed at each other’s houses, traveled together and talked business for hours. McIntyre has similar relationships with suppliers across the country. A first-gen immigrant with a Cajun-Irish accent in Louisiana sells him red snappers and Gulf shrimp. A guy in Wheatley, Ontario, a fishing town 60 miles due northwest from the West Side Market, ships him walleye via Sandusky’s Lake Fish Co. “That’s why I’m good at this, because I create personal relationships,” McIntyre says, pounding the bar top for emphasis. (Don’t worry, this one’s seen worse.) “So if you send me something bad, you like me so much that you’re going to feel bad.” And he’ll make sure you know about it, Nagle says. Just a week before Nagle and I spoke, McIntyre texted in a group: Why did you send me tuna from Ecuador? Nagle replied, The best fish of the day came from Ecuador. He responded curtly, I don’t want fish from Ecuador. Three days later, he texted Nagle again: That was some of the best tuna I’ve seen all year. “That’s him. He’s hard on us,” says Nagle. “Some of the guys will be like, Geez, why is he freaking out so much? But I think that’s passion, that little bit of craziness.” On a recent tour of Nagle's facility, McIntyre surprised him by asking to say a few words to his staff. As they gathered around him, McIntyre spoke for a few minutes, offering sharp feedback but also noting the importance of their work. “He got a standing ovation,” Nagle says. “Social media is great, but he really believes if he didn’t have (the product), he wouldn’t have anything.” A F T E R A B E E R O R T W O at Hoopples, we cruise over to Tremont. McIntyre shoul-

ders open the sticky door of the former Polish Legion of American Veterans

Roosevelt Post 58. The building on Professor Avenue was built in 1910, two years before the Market opened. Back then, a sausage manufacturer occupied the space. Inside is a moment between past and future. The removal of drop ceilings exposed imposing U.S. Steel beams, looking fresh off the mill, that now line the ceiling. Beige, century-old tiles, which rested under wood paneling for decades, neatly cover the walls. “These tiles might be the same ones in the market,” says McIntyre. “How many tile makers would there have been back then?” The two-story building is the future home of Kate’s Fish’s first full-service restaurant. A 12-seat oyster bar will occupy space in the front of the restaurant, while twoand four-person booths and mid-tops will line the walls. A horseshoe booth in the center, which currently lives in McIntyre’s imagination, will be dubbed “the captain’s chair” and dedicated to his parents; his wife, Maddie, and his girls, Penny and Maeve. Upstairs will feature additional seating and an event space for parties and clambakes. The restaurant, as they often are, is a source of excitement and stress for McIntyre. Impatient, he hopes to open in the summer of 2027. He’s teamed up with hospitality vets Nick and Tony Cross of Happy Dog and Roseanna Safos of Little Rose Tavern. Brett Sawyer, who now lives in California but was formerly the chef of acclaimed restaurants like Good Company and The Plum, is an adviser. They are on the hunt for a chef. The names they’ve floated include some of Cleveland’s best. The goal is a “blue-collar seafood bar,” he says, “the opposite of Pier W or Blue Point Grille, though I love those places.” That might sound a bit like jumbo shrimp. After all, seafood inspires images of white tablecloths and big checks, at least in the minds of Clevelanders. McIntyre hopes to keep price points in the “high teens, 20s and low 30s” by focusing on oddball cuts and overlooked species. Dishes like the Kate’s Fish-supplied walleye cheeks from chef Vinnie Cimino’s Rosy exemplify the approach, and McIntyre wants it to be similarly James Beard caliber. Still, “lobster rolls will be king,” he says. “It's not really possible for anyone else to do this,” he says. “I have the supply chain. We'll pay less for better product than anyone can get from a wholesaler.” Even McIntyre doesn’t know how far he can take Kate’s Fish. On the cusp of rapid expansion, his days as simply a fishmonger, slicing fillets and ordering by memory, are over. The Market is entering a new era alongside Kate’s Fish. KeyBank’s name sits upon the Produce Arcade, and the Haslam family’s will appear on the forthcoming event space. The Market's future depends on serving the oncea-month suburbanites shopping for their Saturday meal, the tourists looking for a taste of Cleveland and the daily grocery-seeking locals. McIntyre is learning to serve a wider audience, too. Some come for their weekly fish order. Others come for a lobster roll or to meet the guy from TikTok. Soon, they’ll pull up a chair at his restaurant in Tremont. But he’s clear about where those new adventures begin. “My future, my life, my career, my family’s life — it’s all tied up in the West Side Market.” CLEVELANDMAGAZINE.COM

49


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Shop & Stroll / Home Port (CM, December 2026 by Dillon Stewart - Issuu