Skip to main content

solutions manual for Strategic Management and Business Policy Globalization, Innovation and Sustaina

Page 1

Case 1 The Wallace Group, Inc. I.

CASE ABSTRACT Harold Wallace, founder, serves as Chairman and President of the Wallace Group. He owns 45 percent of the outstanding stock. The company consists of three operating groups: Electronics, Plastics, and Chemicals, which generate sales of $70 million. Mr. Wallace continues direct operational control over the Electronics Group. Several years ago, Wallace and the Board embarked on a strategy of diversification into plastics and chemicals in order to decrease the company’s dependence on defenserelated business. Presently, the morale within The Wallace Group has deteriorated to the point where some of the employee stockholders made an attempt to force Wallace’s resignation. As a result of this crisis, Wallace has hired Frances Rampar, a management consultant, to conduct a management survey into the problems facing The Wallace Group. Her task is to develop a series of priorities for Wallace’s consideration. Decision Date: No Date

II.

Sales: Net Income:

$70,000,000 $ 1,760,000

CASE ISSUES AND SUBJECTS Corporate Governance Diversification Stages of Corporate Development Vertical Integration Transfer Pricing Sub optimization

Morale and Culture Organizational Structure Top Management Responsibilities Modes of Strategy Formulation Distinctive Competence Entrepreneurship

III. STEPS COVERED IN STRATEGIC DECISION-MAKING PROCESS (See Figure 1.5 on pages 20 and 21)

Review MBO & Mission

2

3

4

5A

5B

6

7

8

X

O

O

X

O

O

X

X

O

X

O=Emphasized in Case IV. CASE OBJECTIVES

Strategic Alternatives

Strategic Factors

1B

Strategic Posture

1A

Performance

Internal Factors

Evaluation & Control

External Factors

Strategy Implementation

Corporate Governance

Strategy Formulation

X=Covered in Case


Case 1 The Wallace Group 1. To acquaint the students with a CEO’s management of a company that leads to conflict and power struggles among managers. To deal with an issue in corporate governance: Why hasn’t the board of directors become involved in this issue? 2. To have the student act as a consultant. As such, the student should develop a list of the most important problem(s) facing The Wallace Group, and specific action plans to deal with each specific problem. 3. To discuss how to convey potentially negative information to the person who hired you, especially if that person is the principal cause of this negative information. 4. To review the corporation diversification plan from an area of expertise (electronics) into areas (plastics and chemicals), where it has no distinctive competence. V. SUGGESTED CLASSROOM APPROACHES TO THE CASE 1. Dr. Laurence J. Stybel, the case author, suggests two possible ways of handling this case. A. The first option involves students individually formulating a response to the following questions: •

What is the most important problem facing The Wallace Group?

•

Develop a specific action plan to deal with these problems.

This option typically involves one and a half to two hours for class discussion. B. The second option would be to bring in a guest who would take the role of Harold Wallace. A retired president would be ideal for this kind of exercise. Under this format, students are divided into consulting teams and are given the following instructions: •

Attached is some information about The Wallace Group, Inc. This information includes data regarding corporate operations and operating problems, as perceived by various managers of the company.

•

Your consulting team should review this material. The team will then meet to analyze critical issues facing The Wallace Group and to identify solutions that The Wallace Group management could either take alone or with consulting assistance from your firm.

•

On (date) your team will have an opportunity to meet with Mr. Harold Wallace to discuss your diagnosis and action plans. These plans should be as specific as possible, as they may lead to a consulting assignment for your group. In calculating costs associated with your participation in the plan, you propose, assume a professional fee of $100 per day plus out-of-pocket expenses for food, travel, hotel, graphics, etc.

•

Each team will present its findings to Mr. Wallace separately. 1-2 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 1 The Wallace Group You will have thirty minutes for the presentation, plus fifteen minutes for Mr. Wallace to question the team. At the conclusion of the presentations, Mr. Wallace will determine which team, if any, would be awarded the consulting contract. In addition to the substantive learning objectives discussed earlier, the second option would achieve the following additional objectives: 1. To have students learn to develop formal oral presentations, 2. To determine a proper approach in conveying potentially negatively charged information to someone perceived as a superior, and 3. To cost out a consulting project based on specific action plans developed by students. It is most effective to go through this option in one evening lasting three to four hours, rather than to space it over two to three classes. Special note from the case author Regardless of the option selected, the key element of this case is that the acquisition strategy of The Wallace Group has been disastrous in producing the following problems: A. The acquisition strategy has moved The Wallace Group away from its area of distinctive competence in electronics into areas where it does not have distinctive competence. In a small firm such as The Wallace Group, this has resulted in a tendency to not effectively utilize scarce technical personnel. It also contributes to the lack of morale on the part of employees because the firm does not have a clear mission. B. The acquisition strategy has locked the electronics group into using the plastics group as its major supplier, thus increasing costs for one group and making them less competitive. Presumably, the Plastics Group is also locked into using the Chemicals Group and is faced with a similar situation. C. A complex MIS apparatus has been constructed by central office to collect data from three very different operational groups. In addition, the central office appears “staff heavy” for such a small firm. This analysis is based on an examination of the organization chart. D. Problems resulting from being heavily dependent on defense-related contracts have not been solved. Mr. Wallace was once heard to have remarked, “We’ll get organized tomorrow. But we’ve got to deal with today’s needs today.” This all too common approach to management must be challenged by the students. This company desperately needs an organized approach to strategic planning which involves both the commitment of Mr. Wallace and the involvement of key employees within the company. 1-3 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 1 The Wallace Group Designing such a process would not be easy. But the case does seem to indicate that this is the most pressing need faced by The Wallace Group. 1. We have used it as a written paper. The students find the case somewhat difficult to handle because of Mr. Wallace’s direct involvement in the company’s problems. VI. DISCUSSION QUESTIONS 1. What is (are) the most important problem(s) facing The Wallace Group? 2. What recommendation(s) would you (as a consultant) make to Mr. Wallace, and in what order of priorities? 3. How do you educate a Stage I manager (entrepreneur) to become a Stage II or III professional manager? What impact does this problem have on this case? 4. How do you handle the transfer pricing problems involved in the backward integration? The acquisition of the plastic company has locked the Electronics Group into using its plastic products at a higher cost. 5. If Mr. Wallace is found to be one of the major problems, should he be addressed directly or indirectly? 6. Has the Wallace Group’s diversification strategy been effective? If yes, please explain. If no, please explain. *Reprinted by permission of the case author. VII. CASE AUTHOR’S TEACHING NOTE by Laurence J. Stybel* Presented earlier in Section V“, “Suggested Classroom Approaches to the Case.” VIII. STUDENT STRATEGIC AUDIT/STUDENT PAPER I. INTERNAL ENVIRONMENT A. Tremendous dissatisfaction among management and employees. This resulted from Wallace’s failure to delegate to subordinates and a lack of clear strategies or long-term plans, goals, or objectives. B. Lethargy and lack of direction on top management’s part. II. EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT A. Favorable market niche in electronics. Longstanding reputation of reliable government contracts. Potential for increased sales due to administration’s commitment to a strong military with the latest technology. B. Auto industry on an upward trend with high sales volume suggests solid future sales. III. STRENGTHS 1-4 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 1 The Wallace Group

A. The company is able to supply many of its own component parts and raw materials because it is well-integrated. B. Solid performance from the plastics and electronics divisions in the past. The Electronics Group has a good track record in developing and manufacturing countermeasure equipment. C. Public corporation provides the firm with flexibility to attract equity capital versus long- or short-term debt. IV. PROBLEM ANALYSIS A. Heavy dependence on government contracts could put the corporation in financial difficulty if further sales diversification cannot be found. B. Poor organizational design creates a span of control problems and results in poor operations. Specific job responsibilities need to be defined at the management level. C. The corporate policy of transfer pricing needs to be addressed in terms of product cost and profit margin. D. Stage I management in Stage III Corporation. E. Unprofitable chemical division needs new management or it needs to be analyzed for sale to someone else. V. RECOMMENDATIONS AND IMPLEMENTATION COSTS A. Develop new organization chart and clearly, define job responsibilities. Let management manage! Mr. Wallace needs to stop trying to run the firm himself. COST: $3,000 B. Diversify product mix and customer base to hedge against loss of large customers. See Mr. Williams. COST: $30 to $50,000 C. Change management of chemical division or sell off based on cost/ or analysis to corporation. COST: Money is needed to buy Mr. Luskic’s 5 percent and $45,000 to attract a good manager from another firm. D. Change management style. Mr. Wallace has got to let his managers manage. At the same time, he must develop long-term strategies and goals that will help the corporation grow. E. Clarify transfer pricing policy. Make sure that all managers understand that it is a team effort. The overall profitability of the corporation is what is important. This policy needs to be weighed in terms of overall profitability to corporation and not individual departments. 1-5 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 1 The Wallace Group

IX.

EFAS, IFAS, AND SFAS EXHIBITS Were inappropriate for this case.

X.

FINANCIAL ANALYSIS Was inappropriate for this case.

1-6 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


TEACHING NOTE

Case 2 CrossFit at the Crossroads Case Overview1 This case describes the brief history and meteoric rise of CrossFit from its founding in 2000 through mid-2016. The case opens with Greg Glassman, the founder, reflecting on the company’s past performance in terms of the CrossFit Games and then moves into information about the company in general. CrossFit’s philosophy has proven to be popular with those associated with the military and police, as well as with younger women and mothers; and has generated excellent customer satisfaction. The individual store ‘Boxes’ have also proven to be workable venues for the philosophy and products. The number of boxes and members have been growing rapidly. However, CrossFit faces tough competition in the growing and maturing fitness industry. Competition from other private and public companies is intense, and shows no sign of letting up. In fact, there is plenty of evidence that new entrants and larger firms are attempting to increase their presence in this market as vigorously as is CrossFit. The case also details the heavy criticism coming from industry analysts saying that CrossFit is a fad and a cult. Glassman and CrossFit have decided to embrace the criticisms and turn them into opportunities. Glassman has become a very visible spokesperson for the company philosophy as a result of the critics. He has used controversy to draw attention to himself and the stores. Teaching Objectives This case is intended to be used in an introductory strategic management course. It is probably best suited for undergraduates but could be used with other cases or analysis at the graduate level. It contains good examples of corporate growth strategy and examples pertaining to the decision of how to enter and grow a new business, and it presents the logic of business model development in an industry with which most students can identify. A major aspect of the case has to do with the company’s extremely strong culture. The culture helps differentiate the company from industry competitors, but perhaps the greatest asset of the culture comes from its effects on customers who identify very strongly with the company. The concept of a ‘Third Place’ and providing the opportunity for customers to find associations with those of like mind cannot be overstated. The extremely powerful customer orientation at

1This note was prepared by Andrew Callaghan and Charles B. Shrader for the purpose of aiding instructors with the case titled:

CrossFit, Inc.: The Fitness Industry’s Fastest Growing Brand

1


CrossFit has led to the criticism of it becoming a cult. Given this, the case could easily be the focal point for class discussions about the concept of corporate culture. This could also be used as a competitive strategy case in which students are asked to compare or defend alternative strategies for differentiation and competitive positioning. In terms of business-level or competitive strategy, the case is an excellent example of how to differentiate and define a strategic target. There is information in the case regarding the business models of industry competitors and relative performance information. Students could be asked to compare the business models of the leading fitness companies and analyze the models in terms of both economic viability and sustainability. The case is also a good integration case and can be assigned to groups for strategic audits and overall SWOT and environmental assessment. There are other fitness industry cases in the market- for example Harvard publishes a case about Arcadia Fitness (of London 2015) that is fairly recent, and there are existing cases dealing with Bally Fitness which now has sold most of its gyms to LA Fitness. Groups could be assigned an industry analysis of the world fitness industry as well as individual market segments. Students tend to find the fitness topic interesting and will have no difficulty finding materials written about the various competing companies mentioned in the case. Many will be familiar with CrossFit Games and the brand name. Plus, the case is well suited for current events and continual updating. Students should be able to find information about fitness industry competitors and CrossFit can easily be compared with the products and services of other firms. Finally, there have been many news stories about the controversial nature of the CrossFit Philosophy, about Glassman’s leader style, and about the cult following CrossFit seems to engender. There is plenty of information in the case about criticisms and there are plenty of interviews and stories about both Glassman and CrossFit in the news media. This makes the case a good candidate for general discussion about corporate social responsibility and ethics. This case provides the instructor a chance to pursue any of the following content objectives: 1. To illustrate the decision to enter an industry. •

Completing an industry analysis

2. To demonstrate the challenges of developing and growing a new business. •

Determining new ways to promote a product

•

Identifying marketing channels- the use of social media in business

•

Defining a selection process for the affiliates

•

Identifying an image of the product and the best way to portray that image

3. To illustrate the dynamics created by strong industry competitors. •

Identifying competition – directly and indirectly

•

Determining tactics to contend 2


•

Identifying a strong core competency and/or method of differentiation

4. To illustrate the importance of business concept innovation in the development of competitive strategy.

5. To illustrate horizontal integration and related diversification. 6. To illustrate executive leadership and corporate culture

Assignment Questions 1. Describe Glassman’s management style. Is he a good leader? Why or why not? 2. Identify CrossFit’s competitors. Give reasons as to why or why not CrossFit will be able to compete with these competitors. 3. Can CrossFit continue successfully competing against larger publicly traded firms? What are the advantages of the CrossFit business model? 4. How should Glassman continue to innovate and grow in a difficult market segment? What are they doing that will make them successful? What are they doing that could make them fail? What should they do differently? 5. How should CrossFit address the many business challenges and ethical criticism facing the company? 6. Is the fitness industry attractive? What forces are key in determining profitability? Does CrossFit have a good position? 7. What is the core competency at CrossFit? What main skills or advantages does it possess? 8. Describe the culture at CrossFit. Is CrossFit a cult? What are the costs and benefits of such a strong culture? 9. If the CrossFit Games were eliminated, would CrossFit be a viable business based solely on the physical fitness aspect?

Analysis 1. Describe Glassman’s management style. Is he a good leader? Why or why not? Glassman is charismatic and irreverent. He is also very self-confident, courageous, and confrontational. He personifies the ‘free will’ philosophy discussed in the case. As such, he exemplifies many of the leadership traits of the entrepreneurial mind-set. His confident air lends 3


to the brand image he is trying build in the company- that of being individually strong and independent. His attitude certainly works in terms of attracting members to CrossFit. On the other hand, this style has its detractors. He comes off as brash and authoritarian to some degree. He certainly is not humble and does not appear to approach what most would call authentic leadership. Instructors could ask students to assess Glassman in these terms above. Does his charisma outweigh the lack of humility? Does he need to have an attitude to make CrossFit work? In general, Glassman provides a good example of how an individual leader provides strategic leadership in determining the firm’s strategic direction (Chapter on Strategic Leadership). He has been effective in terms of determining direction (boxes and games) and building a strong culture. Students might be challenged to suggest ways Glassman might emphasize ethical practices and build the firm’s resource portfolio. Glassman has also done a good job of exploiting and maintaining core competencies, and has built a business on a business philosophy that is distinguishable from others in the industry. By emphasizing games and a comprehensive fitness philosophy he has built into his workforce the knowledge and skills to run the business. This in turn has created a large amount of human and social capital. CrossFit even extends its human capital into its customer base through the strong culture. 2. Identify CrossFit’s competitors. Give reasons as to why or why not CrossFit will be able to compete with these other industry competitors. The major industry-wide competitors are briefly described in the case. The main ones are probably Gold’s Gym and the 24-hour fitness centers. Gold’s Gym has a well-defined business model and a strong core competency (skill centered on weight training), and it has a strong corporate image. Anytime Fitness and 24-Hour Fitness appear to be attempting to appeal to a very wide-ranging customer base. CrossFit also seems to have a well-defined strategic position in the industry, truly intense and complete full body fitness, and it is using games and image to create attention for the business. Cross fit appears to portray the differentiation strategy and is now pursuing a large target market. Students could be asked to identify the differentiating factors of CrossFit’s strategy and whether or not the factors are sustainable. The strong culture is clearly sustainable and the games seem to facilitate growth. The intense individual fitness model, however, seems to be something that could easily be duplicated by other businesses or by other (substitute) technologies. Students will be able to get financial information on publicly traded firms such as Planet Fitness. A comparison of what is in the case with Planet Fitness will give an idea of how unique CrossFit’s business model really is. It will also give an indication of position and opportunity for growth. There is a decent amount of industry description in the case that could lead to a Five Forces analysis as well.

4


3. Can CrossFit continue successfully competing against larger publicly-traded firms? What are the advantages of the CrossFit business model? This is an industry that is growing and experiencing some shakeout. It seems likely that there will be some consolidation in the industry both in terms of fitness centers and in terms of fitness programs. Because CrossFit is privately held, it is difficult to compare financials. Nevertheless, being private also provides CrossFit with the flexibility to withstand short-term market fluctuations and to move quickly into new market opportunities. 4. How should Glassman continue to innovate and grow in a difficult market segment? What are they doing that will make them successful? What are CrossFit’s strengths and Weaknesses? What are they doing that could make them fail? What should they do differently? A simple SWOT analysis of CrossFit might result in something such as: • • • •

Strengths = strong culture, clear business model, energetic and charismatic leadership Weaknesses = easily copied value-adding practices, simplistic/myopic world view, lack of diversification Opportunities = industry growth and general interest in fitness, games, franchising Threats = criticism of culture and leader style, large heavily-resourced competitors

SO strategies then would be to grow and leverage the brand. WT strategies, although difficult to realize, would be to tone down the culture and look for alliances in the industry. 5. How should CrossFit address the many business challenges and ethical criticism facing the company? CrossFit probably has never considered any form of stakeholder analysis. Moreover, they may not feel that they need to. They always seem to be preaching to the converted. They seem to view their product and philosophy much in the same way, as do other companies that have cultlike customer followings such as Harley-Davidson. The sense in companies like CrossFit and Harley is that if you are truly interested in the concept (fitness or motorcycle riding) you will naturally seek out the ‘real’ value provider. Customers who are seeking true fitness (or whatever) will natural gravitate to our company. On the other hand, CrossFit has a big opportunity to create a special brand. The current ethical criticism is probably not too potentially damaging to the company in that is it based on the idea that CrossFit is simply too much/over the top. This could be countered by top 5


management doing a series of informational videos touting the virtues of extreme fitness from a virtue ethics point of view. They could try some public relations and could do a better job of telling their story instead of letting others tell it for them. As is, much of the public information about CrossFit comes from news shows that put CrossFit in a questionable light. The company could counteract this with a positive ad campaign of their own. 6. Is the fitness industry attractive? What forces are key in determining profitability? Does CrossFit have a good position? • • • •

•

Industry Rivalry = the industry is growing which tends to reduce rivalry, but there are well-resourced rivals and local fitness centers seem to be viable Power of Suppliers = suppliers of gym equipment and fitness programming do not seem powerful, and CrossFit is less dependent on equipment than others in the industry Power of Buyers = buyers are plentiful and there are many options and switching costs are low Substitutes = home fitness, online or TV/Video fitness, total body workout machines, other general health and wellness programs- there is currently no substitute of critical importance but there many options Threat of new entrants= there do not seem to be significant cost or access barriers. There is the possibility of companies such as Nike and Reebok entering in terms of sponsoring and then perhaps owning some of the businesses. CrossFit has a clear differentiated model that has claimed a growing niche. The industry overall does not have many barriers as indicated in the case- but that might change in the near future with the advent of company wellness program contracts with branded firms.

On balance, the industry appears to be reasonably attractive in terms of entry barriers, rivalry, and supplier power. Buyers or customers have numerous options right now and there appear to be many (but not significant) alternative to fitness centers. 7. What is the core competency at CrossFit? What main skills or advantages does it possess? CrossFit’s main set of skills centers on high intensity training (HIT). Beyond that is the ability to create a sense of community- a culture. CrossFit’s culture is probably the most sustainable advantage. Using the criteria for building core competencies: • •

Are the capabilities valuable? Both the HIT skills and culture are valuable. Are the capabilities rare? The HIT are probably not rare. Cultures are unique and therefore, rare.

6


• •

Are the capabilities costly-to-imitate? Again HIT would not be costly to imitate but the culture would be extremely difficult to imitate. Are the capabilities non-substitutable? There are numerous substitutes for the method of obtaining fitness.

Given this, the main advantage of CrossFit is the culture- the thing for which it is criticized. The HIT skills are much less sustainable.

8. Describe the culture at CrossFit. Is CrossFit a cult? What are the costs and benefits of such a strong culture? Glassman is the purveyor of culture. He portrays and communicates the basic fitness values well. The CrossFit Journal is also a good mechanism for the communication of values and beliefs. The Games also contribute to the culture and enhance the core values. Members such as Christmas Abbot exemplify the culture and embody the fitness philosophy. The entire case is an argument for company culture. The fact they are criticized for being a cult testifies to the strong company set of values. The values are basic overall fitness, whole body fitness, primitive and basic training, core and muscle and endurance work together, and straightforward no-nonsense fitness and training. CrossFit’s strong culture is an example of how corporate culture can substitute for strategy. The culture nurtures the brand. It creates value in terms of differentiating the product or service. It has been the force behind the growth of the company. The case mentions the sociological impact of the culture and the creation of a sense of belonging. CrossFit’s culture does this better or more profoundly than most other companies do. 9. If the CrossFit Games were eliminated, would CrossFit be a viable business based solely on the physical fitness aspect? As noted above, even though the business model is clear and valuable, it is not particularly complicated and could be easily duplicated or copied. CrossFit needs to maintain the Games and the cultural mystique in order to continue to be a gathering place and place of belonging for customers. 10. How has CrossFit performed through the COVD Pandemic into 2023? Since the case was written in 2018, CrossFit has grown to 14,000 gyms spanning 155 countries in 2023 (source: https://www.crossfit.com/about-crossfit-affiliates). The company continues to differentiate and the business model continues to be relevant. Over the years, methods or points of differentiation include have included: • WODs and varied workouts 7


• • • • • • • •

Box gyms – can cater to local demographic o Affiliates/communities determine how to run their own boxes Intensity of workouts Whole life/fitness approach/general fitness Newsletter/journal/blogs Games Company privately owned The Community/Culture Reebok and ESPN alliances

8


CASE 3 Everyone Does It I. CASE ABSTRACT When Jim Willis, Marketing VP learns that the launch date for the company’s new satellite will be late by at least a year, he is told by the company’s president to continue using the earlier published date for the launch. When Jim protests that the use of an incorrect date to market contracts was unethical, he is told that spacecraft are never launched on time and that it is common industry practice to list unrealistic launch dates. If a realistic date was used, no one would contract with the company. Decision Date: No Date

FY Sales: Unknown FY Net Income: Unknown

II. CASE SUBJECTS AND ISSUES Electronic Satellite Imaging Aerospace Industry Practice Code of Ethics Role Conflict Marketing Strategy Competitive Tactics

Ethics Decision-Making Moral Relativism Policies & Procedures Evaluations & Control Stakeholders Corporate Culture

III. STEPS COVERED IN STRATEGIC DECISION-MAKING PROCESS (See Figure 1.5 on pages 22 and 23)

3

4

X

O

X

O=Emphasized in Case

IV.

Strategic Factors

Internal Factors

External Factors

Corporate Governance

2

5A

Strategic Alternatives

1B

Review Objectives & Mission

1A

Strategic Posture

Performance

Strategy Formulation

5B

6

Strategy Implementation

Evaluation & Control

7

8

X

O

X=Covered in Case

CASE OBJECTIVES 3-1 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


CASE 3 Everyone Does It

1. To provide students with an understanding of the internal factors which cause managers to be placed in ethically compromising positions. 2. To evaluate and determine an ethically responsible course of action for ISI. 3. To offer students an opportunity to identify and evaluate possible positive and negative ramifications of the course of action that they have selected. 4. To illustrate the concept of moral relativism in making ethically questionable decisions. 5. To illustrate Kohlberg’s levels of moral development. 6. To provide students an opportunity to discuss the value of a code of ethics in a business organization. 7. To provide a vehicle to apply the three basic approaches to ethical behavior: utilitarian, individual rights, and justice approach, plus Kant’s two categorical imperatives. V. SUGGESTED CLASSROOM APPROACHES TO THE CASE 1. Assign this case along with Chapter Three: Ethics and Social Responsibility in Strategic Management. Students should be able to identify and apply relevant concepts from Section 3.2, Ethical Decision Making, to the situation described in this case. 2. Treat the case as a role-play and assign students to play the roles of Fred Ballard, Jim Willis, a venture capitalist, and a customer. Ask each person to make a case for his or her point of view. The class can then comment on what should be done. 3. Ask the class how this case might illustrate the concepts of moral relativism and Kohlberg’s levels of moral development. Which level of moral development seemed to fit Jim Willis and his boss, Fred Ballard? 4. Ask the students if a code of conduct would have resolved Jim Willis’ dilemma. This is an opportunity to discuss the value of a code of ethics and the sorts of things that such a code would include. Split the class into four groups. Have each group discuss how a particular approach to ethical behavior could be used to resolve Jim Willis’s dilemma: utilitarian, individual rights, justice, and Kant’s categorical imperatives. After each group discusses the case, ask each one to show how that concept would have resolved the ethical problem. Be prepared for disagreements VI. DISCUSSION QUESTIONS 1.

What are sources of the factors, which created the ethical dilemma?

2.

Is it ever appropriate to withhold negative information from the client? 3-2 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


CASE 3 Everyone Does It

3.

What should ISI do?

4.

What is meant by the term, “industry practice”? Is this an example of moral relativism?

5.

In what level of moral development is Jim Willis? And his boss, Fred Ballard?

6.

Would a code of ethics have prevented or resolved this ethical dilemma? What should be in a code of ethics? What if ISI had a Code of Ethics which stated that proprietary information could not be disclosed to anyone outside the company and allowed no exceptions?

7.

What would the utilitarian approach to ethical behavior say about full disclosure vs. withholding? Individual rights approach? Justice approach? Kant’s categorical imperatives?

VII. CASE AUTHOR’S TEACHING NOTE by Steven Cox and Shawana P. Johnson * (The Case Abstract, the first three Case Objective, the first three Discussion Questions, and second Suggested Classroom Approach were written by the case authors) ______________ *Reprinted and adapted by permission of the case authors. The type of situation discussed in the case is unfortunately not uncommon. Sales people are routinely asked to withhold information concerning shipping delays, production delays, possible labor unrest, product quality issues, and other customer relevant information. One of the greatest threats to a sales person’s personal integrity and long-term relationship with clients is pressure from within their own company to withhold relevant information. The fear of losing contracts, income, and job status often cause members of a firm to act outside of integrity. Recent cases like Enron/Arthur Anderson (R. Berebeirn, “Executive Action, the Enron Ethics Breakdown,” The Conference Board, No. 15, February 2002) have brought to the forefront how pressure to succeed can influence decision-makers and subordinates alike into unethical decisions. 1. What are sources of the factors, which have created the ethical dilemma? There are several internal and external forces at work here. • Internal forces included: 1. Jim Willis’ boss, Frank Ballard, has given Jim a specific instruction not to disclose the information. 2. The company did not permit the disclosure of company proprietary information without prior approval. 3. The financial health of the company could be jeopardized. 4. Jim Willis’s personal financial well-being could be jeopardized. • External forces included: 1. Jim Willis’ boss, Frank Ballard, has given Jim a specific instruction not to disclose the information. 3-3 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


CASE 3 Everyone Does It 2. The company did not permit the disclosure of company proprietary information without prior approval. 3. The financial health of the company could be jeopardized. 4. Jim Willis’ personal financial well-being could be jeopardized. 2. Is it ever appropriate to withhold negative information from the client? The answer is: it depends on the situation. Potential problems with production, delivery, and maintenance arise all the time. 3. What should ISI do? VIII. EFAS, IFAS, AND SFAS EXHIBITS Were inappropriate for this case.

IX. FINANCIAL ANALYSIS Was inappropriate for this case.

3-4 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 4 The Audit I. CASE ABSTRACT This case deals with personal value conflicts within the context of established organizational practices, which run counter to stated policy. The case involves conflicts between professional and possibly personal values on the one hand and peer pressures to conform to the other. “The Audit” is set in a national CPA firm. Sue, a newly hired auditor, has been sent out on an audit where she discovers that the client has been treating payments to a large number of its workers as “independent contractors.” This practice saves the client the payroll taxes that would otherwise be due. In Sue’s professional judgment, this may be improper and should be further investigated to see if it should be noted in the audit report. A conversation with her immediate supervisor gives her no help. Coworkers put pressure on Sue to drop the matter. If she goes over the head of the partner in charge of the audit, she will get them all in trouble as they have ignored the practice in prior years’ audits. They said that while they realized that it was probably wrong, they were sure their supervisor wanted them to ignore it again this year. They encourage her to be a “team player.” Clearly, Sue faces a dilemma. If she drops the issue she will be violating her professional code of ethics. On the other hand, if she continues with the matter, she may well jeopardize her future with the firm. Decision Date:

No Date

II. CASE ISSUES AND SUBJECTS CPA Firm Personal Values versus Group Norms Role Conflict Policies and Procedures Whistle Blowing

Ethics and Moral Relativism Corporate Culture Decision Making Evaluation and Control Code of Ethics

4-1 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 4 The Audit III. STEPS COVERED IN STRATEGIC DECISION-MAKING PROCESS (See Figure 1.5 on pages 20 and 21)

1A

1B

2

3

4

O

O

5A

5B

Strategy Implementation

Evaluation & Control

7

8

X

O

Strategic Alternatives

Review MBO & Mission

Strategic Factors

Internal Factors

External Factors

Corporate Governance

Strategic Posture

Performance

Strategy Formulation

6

O =Emphasized in Case

X=Covered in Case

IV. CASE OBJECTIVES 1. To help students identify personal value conflicts that occur in the work setting where the individual may be forced to choose between professional standards (or personal values) and group norms. 2. To introduce the idea that small concessions to peer pressure may lead to larger concessions later on. 3. To introduce the counterpoint that the act of disagreeing with one’s supervisors may also lead to unanticipated consequences. 4. To focus on the ethical dilemma posed by a violation, which is relatively minor, but which still appears to the central figure in the case to be a violation of professional standards. 5. Overall, to provide a vehicle for discussing the relationship between personal values, group norms, and codes of ethics. V. SUGGESTED CLASSROOM APPROACHES TO THE CASE 1. This is an excellent value case for open class discussion. • We suggest that you request each student to write out their specific solution to the employee’s dilemma. You can go back to the student’s individual solution after the class discussion. 2. This is an excellent in-class exam case focusing on ethics in decision making. 3. This is an excellent case for role-playing followed by questioning by the students. 4. This case can be placed anywhere on the course where you want to discuss ethics or value-oriented issues. 4-2 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 4 The Audit

VI. DISCUSSION QUESTIONS 1. What would you do in this situation if you were Sue? 2. Should Sue go over the head of the partner in charge of the audit to upper management? What are the pros and cons of such a decision? •

Would this help or hinder her career at the CPA firm?

3. What role does the group (co-workers) impact on Sue’s choice? The case authors provided eleven excellent discussion questions and answers in the following Section VII, “Case Authors’ Teaching Note: Discussion Questions and Answers.” VII. CASE AUTHORS’ TEACHING NOTE by John Kilpatrick, Gamewell Gantt, and George Johnson* A. Teaching Objectives These were listed in Section IV, “Case Objectives.” B. Discussion Questions and Answers 1. What are the responsibilities or obligations that the main characters in the case owe to themselves? This is the issue of personal integrity and the duty one owes to oneself. Students will inevitably be faced with pressures to bend their standards or to agree with and cooperate with policies and practices, which they find offensive all in the name of job security or promotion. In the words of the short story, how far are you willing to go with this; “kiss, kiss, grovel, grovel?” 2. What are the responsibilities or obligations that the main characters in the case owe to the organization? In our experience at this point, questions of loyalty to the organization inevitably come up. It is possible to introduce the notion that “loyalty” is a two-way street and requires a certain level of trust, integrity, and reciprocity. The issue of organizational culture also should be introduced. Organizations can either encourage, from the top down, the moral “high road,” or discourage compliance with company policies and community or professional standards. This may be done either through the tacit approval of actions that generate revenues but do not place the organization in jeopardy, or by actively encouraging disregard for those same standards. It may be argued that an organization gets the moral climate it deserves. The student should be encouraged to identify the stress which occurs between the respect for organizational values and the need to get along with peers or to advance one’s own career. *Reprinted by permission of the case authors. 3. What are the responsibilities or obligations that the main 4-3 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 4 The Audit characters in the case owe to their profession? One of the distinguishing characteristics of professionals is the tendency to identify more with their chosen profession than with any particular organization. Another is the importance of upholding the reputation and integrity of the profession by adhering to standards and practices that other members of the profession have concluded are appropriate and important. In “The Audit,” questions of potential conflicts between company policy and practice, and professional standards are all evident. How does a profession maintain its integrity and reputation with its clients and the general public if members are not willing to make difficult choices? The accounting profession is regulated by state licensing boards and state statutes. Each state has its own code of Ethics, which is largely patterned upon the code of ethics of the profession’s national association of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (the “AICPA”). Excerpts from relevant sections of the state of Idaho’s Code of Ethics for certified public accountants appear below: Rule 202—Auditing Standards. A licensee shall not permit his name to be associated with financial statements in such a manner as to imply that he is acting as an independent public accountant unless he has complied with the applicable generally accepted auditing standards. Statements on Auditing Procedure issued by the Institute’s Auditing Standards Executive Committee are, for purposes of this rule, considered to be interpretations of the generally accepted auditing standards, and departures from such statements (or other standards considered by the board to be applicable in the circumstances) must be justified by those who do not follow them. Rule 103—Accounting Principles. A licensee shall not express an opinion that financial statements are presented in conformity with generally accepted accounting principles if such financial statements contain any departure from such accounting principles which has a material effect on the financial statements taken as a whole, unless the licensee can demonstrate that by reason of unusual circumstances the financial statements would otherwise have been misleading. Rule 301—Confidential Client Information. A licensee shall not without the consent of his client disclose any confidential information pertaining to his client obtained in the course of performing professional services. An accountant who violates the ’profession’’s code of ethics can be subject to a number of possible sanctions including (1) public and/or private reprimands, (2) license suspension, (3) license revocation, or (4) potential civil liability to the client and to third parties for damages in appropriate cases. In “The Audit,” Sue faces the likelihood of immediate adverse repercussions on the job if she continues to call objections to the client’s practice. She also faces the possibility of even more severe adverse professional consequences if she fails to object and if she is later accused of violating the ’profession’s code of 4-4 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 4 The Audit ethics in having failed to pursue the matter further. Indeed, an auditor who has reason to suspect improper accounting practices has an obligation to further investigate the questionable practice. Failure to do so could result in a violation of generally accepted auditing standards as well as the presentation of financial statements that are not in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. This case is particularly difficult because Sue’s supervisors and the partner in charge of the audit seem to be encouraging her to violate the ’profession’s code of ethics and professional standards in order to retain the client. 4. What are the responsibilities or obligations that the main characters in the case owe to their peers? Most students will be able to identify with the peer pressures that are being exerted, or are anticipated, in the case. In our experience, many students will underestimate the consequences of attempting to change departmental practice or of disagreeing with one’s supervisor or of going further and engaging in some form of “whistle blowing.” (For a discussion, see Near and Micelli, “Retaliation against whistleblowers: predictors and effects” in the Journal of Applied Psychology (February 1986): 137-146.) 5. What are the responsibilities or obligations that the main characters in the case owe to the business community? Edward T. Hall, a cultural anthropologist who has written a number of books dealing with the practices of subcultures, suggests that employees operate in three cultures: the broad community culture, the business culture of the United States or region, or another country, and that of the specific firm in which the individual works (E. T. Hall, The Silent Language, Doubleday-Anchor, 1973). The question opens the door to a discussion of a number of “rules” of the U.S. business culture and, by way of comparison, those predominating in other cultures. It also leads to questions of the type of business community—”What are the rules of the game?”—which the individual student would like to see. To what extent does this type of business community require that individuals exercise some degree of “moral restraint?” 6. What are the responsibilities that the main characters in the case owe to the broader community? This issue allows the issues identified above to be extended to the local, regional, national, and global communities. While it may be counter-productive to try to get too much mileage out of cases that are fairly narrowly focused, the students can be encouraged to recognize that none of the dilemmas exist in a vacuum. This should be particularly appropriate at the community level. What kind of community do they wish to live in, and in what ways is that issue dependent on the choices of individuals? To what extent are the choices of individuals swamped by policies and practices of major institutions, including those of business? At some point, everything is connected to everything, as the ecologists are inclined to point out. 7. What are the implications for the individual of each of the options? Discussion of this issue can be useful in getting the students to 4-5 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 4 The Audit really think through the significance and likely outcomes of the various choices. Students with work experience will probably keep the discussion from becoming too naive. Our experience has been that students are eager to explore the ramifications of moral and to some, political choices. 8. How does an organization ensure that the policies, which it develops, will be followed by organization members? This, of course, is an issue for which there is no short or easy answer. Research suggests that a number of characteristics and practices are critical if organization members are going to commit to organizational values. Among these are the full support of top management, recognition and support for compliance, censure for failure to comply, willingness to not reward behavior strictly on the basis of bottom-line performance, and effective communication of policies and the reasons for them. 9. What impact does an organization’s reward system have on member’s decisions when confronted by ethical dilemmas? Specifically, what are the implications of asking for “ethical conduct” while rewarding solely on the basis of narrowly defined (short-term) performance goals? This is simply an extension of the “reward structure” question raised above. The students in colleges of business will have thoroughly absorbed the manager’s responsibility for profitability. However, they may not have been challenged to consider the tradeoffs and conflicts, which sometimes evolve from the pursuit of single or narrowly defined goals. 10. How does a group leader balance between the need to work with his or her group and the need to provide strong leadership? Management and organization behavior classes focus attention on the task or people dimensions, and on the balance between being liked and being effective. This question addresses the ethical dimensions of those conflicts: At what point does the group leader make an issue of a breach of company policy? 11. What is the role of trust in these matters? What are the costs and benefits of using “administrative controls” versus trusting employees to act in good faith? It can be argued that the tendency in many American firms has been to rely on administrative controls: the greater the perceived level of “misbehavior” the more tightly bureaucratic and rule oriented the firm becomes. This line of argument suggests that frequently “misbehavior” is a symptom of some other underlying problem, which is only exacerbated by increasing autocratic or unilaterally designed and imposed controls. At the other end of the spectrum are firms, which focus on developing an atmosphere of trust which, ideally, leads to a lessened need for administrative controls. The goal is to have the employees “internalize” and identify with the objectives of the organization. This, of course, presupposes a high level of integrity on the part of top management in particular. Most firms, and perhaps the values and management style of most managers, lie somewhere in between these two extremes. This question confronts the students with some of the practical managerial issues, which confront managers in attempting to set the ethical tone for the firm. 4-6 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 4 The Audit

C. General Discussion Short cases provide a number of advantages to an instructor. They can easily be slipped into a course when the instructor or students need a change, or when something planned does not work out. Since the text is only a page or two, students can be given time to read the case in class with minimal lost time. Also, at times it seems that students today struggle with a steady diet of business ethics “essays.” The use of short cases provides some relief and can be used on very short notice. Overall, we have found the interest level to be very high in discussing issues such as are found in this briefcase. The discussions tend to be lively and thought-provoking. Many students have indicated that these discussions have proven to be among the most stimulating and eyeopening of the semester. We have used “The Audit” for a number of pedagogical purposes. The case focuses very clearly on an example of the potential conflicts between group norms and personal and professional standards, of the type which the students will face as they begin their professional lives. The situation serves to highlight the importance of personal values, organizational culture and the responsibilities of management in ensuring an environment in which personal and professional standards are respected. The cases have been used in a variety of courses: sophomore level legal environment courses; junior or senior level management or organization behavior courses; business and society or business ethics; marketing and purchasing; and senior level accounting courses. These materials do not presuppose advanced work in philosophy or ethics. The intention, as noted above, is to present moral dilemmas which students will likely face, and to engage them in the exchange of ideas and the comparing of values and insights. In the process, it is hoped that students will better understand the nature of such value conflicts and the relationship and importance of their own values. For “The Audit,” the instructor should be aware of the auditing standards, which require the noting of certain practices in the audit report as well as some knowledge of the specific standards dealing with the accounting for “independent contractors.” A brief discussion of relevant auditing standards is included below for the instructor’s use. Under the accounting profession’s guidelines, independent accountants are required to opine as to whether or not they believe a client’s financial statements “fairly present” the financial position of the client at a given point in time. If the client in “The Audit” is improperly accounting for wages paid to some workers as payments to independent contractors when those workers are in fact common law employees, the result would be an understatement of the client’s payroll tax expenses and an understatement of liabilities for the potential back taxes, penalties, and interest. This is something that generally accepted auditing standards would require the accounting firm to call to the attention of management of the client and could require a “qualified opinion” (i.e. disclosure in the financial statements) if 4-7 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 4 The Audit management refused to modify its statements to reflect the correct expenses and liabilities involved. Moreover, under the profession’s guidelines, Sue, as a staff accountant, would have an obligation to document the disagreement with her supervisors as part of the working papers on the audit. Finally, the accounting profession’s code of ethics prohibits an accountant from disclosing confidential information to third parties. Therefore, under the guidelines of the profession, at least, Sue should not report the client’s practice to the state or federal government tax authorities. Not all of the above-specialized knowledge concerning the position of the accounting profession is necessary to use “The Audit” in nonaccounting classes. The information is included in this teaching note for use in upper-level accounting classes where students may have had some exposure to the profession’s guidelines. It is also included to provide background information for instructors who may wish to use the case in general management courses that typically include a broad cross-section of business majors. It should be emphasized, however, that the case is intended to illustrate the discovery of facts that might lead a reasonable auditor to take further action. The relevant question is whether or not Sue should continue to pursue the matter in light of the pressure from her peers and the partner in charge of the audit for her to “drop it.” VIII. STUDENT STRATEGIC AUDIT/STUDENT PAPER Sue is in a difficult position, one with far-reaching consequences. To make it worse, she is receiving a great deal of pressure to do nothing, and the others involved are presenting what seem to be quite a few arguments supporting their position. Several issues were raised to promote the “don’t make waves” position and to be a team player. Paul, the partner in charge of the audit, brought up the point that others in the industry of the company in question followed the same practice. He further encouraged no action by stating that to pursue the issue could mean the loss of the account and hinted of negative repercussions for Sue if this were to happen. Sue’s coworkers, Bill and Mike, echoed the sentiment by urging Sue to be a “team player.” They pointed out that it had been ignored in the past. If Sue were to follow through, her coworkers’ careers would be jeopardized. In addition, her relationship with her superiors would be so threatened, and it would possibly force her to leave the firm. The arguments for raising the issue were not many in the case itself (see Exhibit 1). The fact that the practice was wrong was confirmed. Despite evidence to the contrary, the firm endorses high ethical standards and highlighted the ethical responsibilities as a CPA. Also, Sue’s conscience would bother her if she were to do nothing. The support for this issue is far greater than those mentioned in the case. If the authorities were to discover the understating of taxes, the company could be fined as well as forced to pay back taxes. This would, in 4-8 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 4 The Audit all likelihood, be a material amount. The stockholders rely on an auditor’s clean opinion to ensure that there is not a material deviation. If she were to overlook this situation, Sue could possibly be expected to overlook the next one. It seems like once a person backs down, it is easier to do so again. As a CPA, this could have serious consequences for her career. As stated previously, Paul hinted at possible negative actions were Sue not to let the issue die. I question whether this is a type of firm one would want to work for anyway. To tailor an opinion because of the risk of losing a client is a very dangerous practice and a highly unethical one. It defeats the entire concept of an auditor’s independence. All these factors are very significant in making the decision, but the one which most moves me to recommend pursuing the issue is Sue’s feelings. If she does not feel comfortable with the situation, she should act on it. To deviate from one’s own standards could lead to a lifetime of regret. Because of this and the other reasons, Sue should follow through on this issue.

4-9 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


Case 4 The Audit EXHIBIT 1 PROS AND CONS OF PURSUING THE ISSUE Do Not Pursue Issue

-Better relationship with superiors. -Better relationship with co-workers. Pros

—Wouldn’t risk losing account. -Wouldn’t risk losing job. -Other professionals would follow same. .

Cons

-Firm’s members confirmed practice was not correct. -Potential liability. -Bothered conscience. -Firm members might expect her to overlook other issues in the future. -Would not act in a manner that the firm “preached.” -Once you back down it is easier to do it again.

Pursue Issue

- Impact on conscience. - Make a firm statement about her beliefs. - Act in manner firm preached. -Doubtful if you would want to stay with a firm that did not practice what they preach.

-Damage relationship with coworkers. -Damage her future -Might cause firm to lose an account. -Possible damage to coworkers’ careers. ’

IX. EFAS, IFAS, and SFAS EXHIBITS Were inappropriate for this case. X. FINANCIAL ANALYSIS Was inappropriate for this case.

4-10 © 2024 Pearson Education, Ltd.


IBS Center for Management Research

CLBS/1 73

Teaching Note:

Case 5 Best Buy’s Strategy to Beat the Pandemic Blues This teaching note was written by Koti Vinod Babu, under the direction of Namratha V Prasad, IBS Hyderabad.

Sankarapally Road, Hyderabad 501 203, Telangana, India or email: casehelpdesk@ibsindia.org

www.icmrindia.org


CLBS/1 73

Case 5 - Best Buy’s Strategy to Beat the Pandemic Blues TEACHING NOTE INTRODUCTION TO THE CASE The caselet “Best Buy’s Strategy to Beat the Pandemic Blues” discusses the various measures taken by US-based multinational consumer electronics retailer Best Buy Co., Inc. (Best Buy) to beat the business crisis that stemmed from the COVID-19 pandemic and the resultant lockdown restrictions in the US. Best Buy formulated a crisis management strategy and the case documents the various measures the company took to keep its stores up and running during an unprecedented crisis such as the pandemic. The case also mentions some of the human resource (HR) measures taken by Best Buy to keep up employee morale and encourage vaccination against COVID-19. The various measures taken by Corie Barry (Barry), the CEO of Best Buy, proved effective in keeping up the sales. Can Barry’s successfully crisis management strategy be an example to emulate in the retail industry?

LEARNING OBJECTIVES The case enables students to •

Manage the changes in the external environment

•

Understand the issues and challenges faced by companies during pandemics

•

Discuss the importance of crisis management and crisis communication

•

Create an effective crisis management plan

•

Analyze the significance of technology in pandemic preparedness and response.

•

Examine how a company’s digital focus helps it to overcome the challenges posed by the external business environment.

•

Recognize the role of human resources in devising an effective crisis management plan

TARGET AUDIENCE The case is intended for use in teaching the subjects “Business Continuity & Risk Management”, “Macroeconomics & Business Environment,” “Retail Management,” and “Strategic Management” in both graduate and post-graduate programs.

TEACHING APPROACH AND STRATEGY The students may be asked to study the pre-reading material before commencement of the case discussion. They can use the additional readings and references to get further information on and a thorough understanding of the issues involved. 1


Best Buy’s Strategy to Beat the Pandemic Blues

The moderator can start the class by asking the students about the global pandemic and the impact it has had on retail companies like Best Buy. The moderator can then extend the discussion to the basic issues related to the case such as the COVID-19 pandemic and its impact globally; the importance of crisis management; and the need to design suitable business strategies to handle unforeseen crises. The instructor can divide the entire class into groups to engage all the students. Each group could then be given several minutes to discuss how to answer a question related to the case. After the case has been discussed, the students can be asked to give their opinion on the measures that Best Buy has taken and other steps it could take to further handle the crisis. The moderator can take the discussion further with the help of the following questions:

QUESTIONS FOR DICSUSSION 1. Explain how retail companies in the US like Best Buy were affected by the COVID-19 pandemic and the subsequent state policy. What is a crisis management plan? What are the key leadership practices during the COVID pandemic, which is a crisis unlike any other? Discuss the measures taken by Barry to ensure that Best Buy effectively tackled the pandemic. 2. Discuss HR’s new role in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. What were the HR initiatives taken by Best Buy to keep up employee morale and deal with the crisis? How effective were Best Buy’s strategies to handle the crisis?

PROPOSED SESSION PLAN (60 MINUTES) Appropriate Time for Discussion Introduction

10 minutes

Question 1

20 minutes

Question 2

20 minutes

Conclusion

10 minutes

Total Session Time

60 Minutes

ANALYSIS 1. Explain how retail companies in the US like Best Buy were affected by the COVID-19 pandemic and the subsequent state policy. What is a crisis management plan? What are the key leadership practices during the COVID pandemic, which is a crisis unlike any other? Discuss the measures taken by Barry to ensure that Best Buy effectively tackled the pandemic. A. The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in an unprecedented disruption of business for retailers in the US. Retailers and brands faced various challenges around health and safety, supply chain, labor force, cash flow, consumer demand, and marketing. The major issues faced by the retailers in the US were: •

Change in Demand with Home Bound Consumers Most US consumers learned to cook at home while quarantined and they were expected to continue doing so, even after the pandemic. A large portion of the workforce shifted from working in an office to working from home. This scenario hiked the demand for various goods and services like electronics.

2


Best Buy’s Strategy to Beat the Pandemic Blues

•

Consumers Switching to Digital Even before the COVID-19 pandemic, many product categories in the retail sector such as books, entertainment, and consumer electronics had been considerably disrupted by digital. Most importantly, grocery was still emerging in terms of a transition to digital. The COVID19 pandemic accelerated the transition to digital commerce. With consumers being asked to practice social distancing, e-commerce orders for groceries and other essentials had become a survival tool for an average American family. It was observed that many American families had tried digital grocery services for the first time during the pandemic.

•

Extra Cautious Consumers Consumers became more cautious about health than ever before. As no-touch deliveries became a new social norm, consumers turned less receptive to in-store shopping and more cautious while using public touch screens or keypads in stores. Thus, retailers had to develop no-touch customer experiences, with an emphasis on sanitation.

•

Altered Customer Experiences The online ordering experience became frustrating for many consumers due to the high demand for goods. Many customers found it hard to secure a delivery slot; product inventory was in constant fluctuation; and lead times were longer than usual.

•

Rising Delivery Costs Due to the high order picking and delivery costs, online orders were less profitable than traditional in-store purchases. On the other hand, it was likely that once the pandemic receded and delivery prices stabilized, households that had relied upon curbside pickup or home delivery during the pandemic would continue to use those services, thereby posing an emerging challenge to the existence of physical stores.

•

Long-term Financial Impact The economic effects of the pandemic were such that many retailers had a weak balance sheet loaded with debt. The economic climate for retailers was so uncertain that many companies withdrew their earnings and declined to provide estimates of their performance to investors. Crisis Management Plan A crisis management plan is a document that describes the processes that an organization should use to respond to a critical situation that could adversely affect its profitability, reputation, or ability to operate. These are used by business continuity, emergency management, crisis management, and damage assessment teams to prevent or minimize damages and provide guidelines for personnel, resources, and communications.1 Crisis management planning included preparation, process development, testing and training as shown in Figure I. Figure I: Crisis Management Planning •

Determine the crisis management team members.

•

Document the criteria for determining whether a crisis has occurred.

•

Establish monitoring systems and practices for early warning of possible crises. Contd…

1

Tobias Schroeder, “What It Is and How to Develop a Crisis Management Plan,” www.blog.softexpert. com, March 23, 2020. 3


Best Buy’s Strategy to Beat the Pandemic Blues Contd…

•

Specify the spokesperson in the event of a crisis.

•

Provide a list of the main emergency contacts.

•

Document who should be notified in the event of a crisis and how this notification should occur.

•

Identify a process for assessing the incident, its potential severity, and how it will affect the building and employees.

•

Identify procedures to respond to the crisis and define safe places where employees can go in an emergency.

•

Develop a strategy for posting and responding on social media.

•

Develop a process to test the effectiveness of the crisis management plan and update it on a regular basis.

Source: Tobias Schroeder, “What It Is and How to Develop a Crisis Management Plan,” www.blog.softexpert.com, March 23, 2020.

Key Leadership Practices during the COVID-19 Pandemic: The pandemic posed unperceived challenges for leaders in the retail business. It had the hallmarks of a “landscape scale” crisis – an unexpected event or sequence of events of enormous scale and overwhelming speed, resulting in a high degree of uncertainty that gives rise to disorientation, a feeling of lost control, and strong emotional disturbance. During a crisis, which is ruled by unfamiliarity and uncertainty, recognizing that their company faces a crisis is the first thing leaders must do. The leaders must then build a suitable response system for business continuity, wherein effective responses are largely improvised. At that time, a leader cannot use a predefined response plan, but should adopt behaviors and mind-sets that will prevent them from overreacting and help them look ahead. They could follow a strategy suggested in Figure II. Figure II: Key Leadership Practices during an Unprecedented Crisis •

To promote rapid problem solving and execution under high-stress, chaotic conditions, leaders can organize a network of teams. In many cases, the network of teams will include an integrated nerve center covering four domains: workforce protection, supply-chain stabilization, customer engagement, and financial stress analysis.2

•

The leaders should see to it that team members openly discuss ideas, questions, and concerns without fear of repercussions. This allows the network of teams to make sense of the situation, and how to handle it, through healthy debate.

•

The senior executives must empower the team members to control many aspects of the organization’s crisis response. This involves giving them the authority to make and implement decisions without having to gain approval.

•

The crisis management teams should frequently pause from crisis management, assessing the situation from multiple action points, anticipate what may happen next, and then act. Contd…

2

D’Auria and Aaron De Smet, “Leadership in a Crisis: Responding to the Coronavirus Outbreak and Future Challenges,” www.mckinsey.com, March 16, 2020. 4


Best Buy’s Strategy to Beat the Pandemic Blues Contd…

•

The pause-assess-anticipate-act cycle should be ongoing, for it helps leaders maintain a state of thoughtful calm and to avoid overreacting to new information as it comes in.

•

It is vital that leaders not only demonstrate empathy toward customers in the stressful pandemic situation, but open themselves to empathy from others and remain attentive to their own well-being.

•

Thoughtful, frequent communication shows that leaders are following the situation and adjusting their responses as they learn more. This helps them reassure stakeholders that they are dealing with the crisis. Communications should not stop once the crisis has passed. Offering an optimistic, realistic outlook can have a powerful effect on employees and other stakeholders, inspiring them to support the company’s recovery

Source: D’Auria and Aaron De Smet, “Leadership in a Crisis: Responding to the Coronavirus Outbreak and Future Challenges,” www.mckinsey.com, March 16, 2020.

Measures Taken by Barry to Ensure that Best Buy Effectively Tackled the Pandemic: Barry took several key decisions at different points during the pandemic that helped showcase Best Buy in a positive light and saved the business. The measures taken by Barry demonstrated that he had implemented them after constantly evaluating the situation at hand. At the Start of the Pandemic (March-May 2020) •

In March 2020, Barry voluntarily closed the company’s 1,000 stores across the US amidst the lockdown regulations in order to keep its employees and customers safe.

•

He did not know how long the stores would have to be kept closed, how much business Best Buy would lose to competitors, and whether it would be able to bounce back after that hit to its business.

•

He then converted some of its stores into curbside pickup points for shoppers. This made it possible for customers to order online at bestbuy.com and then pick them up at the stores, without getting out of their cars.

•

In addition, Best Buy’s stores served as fulfilment centers to ship online orders to customers’ homes. About 250 stores were specially designated to handle a higher volume of packages, though all stores shipped online orders.

Midst of the Pandemic (May 2020-Early 2021) •

With limitations on in-store shopping beginning to ease, Best Buy opened most of its stores for customers.

•

As consumers shifted to shopping online, Best Buy’s years of investments in that area helped it adapt to the changed scenario quickly.

•

There was a sea change in the way people worked or studied, prompting a surge in demand for various electronic items.

•

The increased foot traffic at Best Buy stores posed a contamination risk to both customers and employees. To curb the contamination risk, Best Buy framed a store policy (See Table I in the case).

•

Customers had to schedule appointments online if they wanted to visit the store. Best Buy prevented customers from informally entering the stores, checking the items on display, and touching them.

5


Best Buy’s Strategy to Beat the Pandemic Blues

End of the Pandemic (January 2021) •

Once the vaccines became widely available, Best Buy was like most other retail companies in the US that were busy framing strategies to safeguard their businesses from the pandemic by making sure that all their employees got vaccinated.

•

It launched an employee sweepstakes with more than US$ 100,000 in cash prizes to encourage its staff to get vaccinated against the COVID-19 virus and contribute to the allround efforts to beat the ongoing pandemic. While 20 winners were to be chosen from its field employees, one was to be selected from its corporate offices based in Richfield, US.

•

The company’s stance toward employee vaccinations was to leave the choice of vaccination entirely to the employees and not enforce it.

•

To further encourage and motivate employees, Best Buy announced a onetime bonus. All hourly employees, regardless of whether they were full-time, part-time, or occasional seasonal employees – received a Gratitude Bonus. While full-time hourly US employees received US$ 500, part-time US employees got US$ 200.

2. Discuss HR’s new role in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. What were the HR initiatives taken by Best Buy to keep up employee morale and deal with the crisis? How effective were Best Buy’s strategies to handle the crisis? A. The COVID-19 pandemic caused a massive disruption in lives and in business, and human resources (HR) was the key to supporting companies and implementing changes in the workplace. Organizations have to frame a forward-thinking HR strategy on how they deliver the best work experience to staff. Issues like employee support, leadership development, pay and benefits, and shifts and strategic partnerships across the organization are some of the most important ways HR can lead and partner with staff, and drive for the best results in their organizations as shown in Figure III. Figure III: HR’s New Role in Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic •

HR can facilitate discussions that help ensure the right amounts of reinvention, reproportioning, and re-prioritizing of business goals to adapt to shifting customer demands and markets in response to the crisis created by Covid-19.

•

HR has a key role to play in developing leaders, ensuring they are successful, and holding them accountable.

•

Leaders require new and enhanced skills in managing from a distance, motivating employees toward a vision in the midst of uncertainty, providing calm and clarity, aligning work among team members, and building community.

•

An organization’s success is based on having talent in the right roles at the right times, and HR is integral to this process. Managing talent through the pandemic requires fundamental shifts. This dynamic requires strategic redeployment, flexibility, reskilling, and tapping into the gig economy with speed and effectiveness.

•

Social capital is the goodwill, fellowship, linkages, and shared understanding that allow staff to work together most effectively. HR has a role to play in helping the organization build, maintain, and sustain social capital among employees.

•

Establishing mentorship programs and affiliation groups, developing teams and ensuring thorough onboarding are ways in which HR can make a difference. Contd…

6


Best Buy’s Strategy to Beat the Pandemic Blues Contd…

•

Engagement is tough to ensure when people are working from home, because it is the physical workplace that brings people together, contributes to their focus, and allows the creation of companionship. HR should see that they are motivated to work from home as they do in office.

•

HR should ensure diversity, equity, and inclusion. This includes educating the organization, understanding the realities of diverse experiences, and taking proactive steps to equalize the playing field.

•

HR can offer expanded support in everything from employee assistance programs to programs for mindfulness, exercise, nutrition, and financial counselling.

•

HR must support different options regarding where people work, when they work, and even the extent to which they are supported in their home offices with furniture solutions.

•

HR is also the keeper of employment, pay, and benefits systems. HR departments can ensure empathy and equitable processes when layoffs are unavoidable.

•

HR should address the compensation needs of all employees – including work share programs, commission-based plans, and more. The seamless administration of these processes with perfect quality is critical to employees’ financial health and employee trust.

•

As the pandemic has necessitated a new approach to the rules and practices that guide the organization, many organizations have had to establish regulations based on federal or state mandates and have had to formalize their approaches. HR must respond quickly to develop these with the broad input from stakeholders.

•

The HR role involves taking the lead in reimagining the organization, developing talent strategies, addressing wellbeing and work-life, administering HR systems, and facilitating re-entry to the office. These are all critical and uniquely skilled contributions HR can make.

Source: Tracy Brower, “HR’s Compelling New Role in Response to the Coronavirus,” www.forbes.com, June 7, 2020.

HR Initiatives Taken up by Best Buy to Keep up Employee Morale and Deal with the Crisis: •

Best Buy closed down its stores voluntarily to ensure the safety of its employees at the start of the pandemic.

•

It did not fire any employees. On the contrary, it provided job security to them by reassigning physical stores as curbside pickup points for shoppers and online order fulfilment centers.

•

When it re-opened its stores, it took its employees into confidence and framed a string of measures to ensure their safety.

•

Surveys and feedback from store managers and employees were done frequently to ensure that they were providing a safe experience for employees and customers.

•

After the launch of vaccines, it framed strategies to make sure that all its employees got vaccinated. It launched an employee sweepstakes with more than US$ 100,000 in cash prizes to encourage its staff to get vaccinated against the COVID-19 virus and contribute to the allround efforts to beat the ongoing pandemic.

7


Best Buy’s Strategy to Beat the Pandemic Blues

•

To keep up employee morale and as a token of gratitude to them for sticking with the retailer doing an unprecedented crisis, Best Buy announced a onetime bonus to its employees. All hourly employees, regardless of whether they were full-time, part-time, or occasional seasonal employees – received a Gratitude Bonus. While full-time hourly US employees received US$ 500, part-time US employees got US$ 200. The bonus was given to all hourly employees who were with the company as of February 15, 2021, regardless of whether they were staying with the company or leaving.

All of Best Buy’s efforts to handle the crisis seemed to work out. •

During the six weeks after Best Buy closed stores beginning in March 2020, it retained 81% of its sales compared with the same period in 2019.

•

Sales in May, June, and July of 2020 increased 5.8% over the sales in same period in 2019. Analysts had predicted that the sales increase would be at 2.3%, but Best Buy actually exceeded their expectations.

•

For the three months ended October 31, 2020, the company booked US$ 11.85 billion in sales, up 21% from the same period in 2019.

Suggested Readings and References: 1. Tracy Brower, “HR’s Compelling New Role in Response to the Coronavirus,” www.forbes.com, June 7, 2020. 2. Tobias Schroeder, “What It Is and How to Develop a Crisis Management Plan,” www.blog.softexpert.com, March 23, 2020. 3. Berman, Barry / Evans, Joel R. Pearson, “Retail Management – A strategic Approach,” (Prentice Hall, Ninth Edition). 4. Gilbert, David, “Retail Marketing Management,” (Pearson Education, Second Edition). 5. Edward Shapiro, “Macroeconomic Analysis,” (Harcourt Brace Jovanovich Inc.). 6. Roger E.A. Farmer, “Macroeconomics,” (Thomson).

8


IBS Center for Management Research

BSTR/6 19

Teaching Note:

Case 6 - Zoom’s Rise Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic This teaching note was written by Syeda Ikrama, under the direction of Syeda Maseeha Qumer, IBS Hyderabad.

www.icmrindia.org


BSTR/6 19

Case 6 - Zoom’s Rise Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic TEACHING NOTE ABSTRACT The case documents the meteoric rise of Zoom, a cloud-based conferencing tool, amidst the COVID-19 pandemic as work from home and social distancing became the new norm. Zoom was the most downloaded app globally with 37.8 billion downloads in Q2 2020. Founded in 2011 by Eric S. Yuan (Yuan), the tool allowed users to interact virtually with each other through audio, video, and chat. The case discusses the business model of Zoom and the reasons behind its success, including its ease of use as well as high-quality audio/video output. With lockdowns in place the world over in early 2020 and the risk of the virus spreading, remote working became a reality. It was during this period that Zoom really took off. Zoom’s features — ranging from user-friendly tools for sharing presentations to fun options such as “virtual backgrounds” — contributed to its widespread adoption as millions of people transitioned to working from home during the pandemic. Zoom offered customers the best experience in its video meetings. Across the world, Zoom also kept students learning and enabled friends and families to stay connected while practicing social distancing. Zoom, which started off as an enterprise solution, became a go-to service for remote education, exercise classes, church services, and happy hour celebrations. Also, many companies used it to conduct meetings and organize their work processes. Zoom’s total revenue for fiscal year 2020 grew 88% year-over-year to US$623 million. Despite its phenomenal success, Zoom came under scrutiny over its handling of privacy and security, including its failure to prevent uninvited guests from barging in on sessions. Other challenges included intense competition from deep pocketed rivals such as Microsoft, Google, and Cisco with their products Teams, Meet, and Webex, and building a large global channel partner network quickly, to continue growing its reach and market penetration. Going forward, the challenges before Yuan were to sustain Zoom’s success, convert free users into paying customers, fix its security problems, and restore customer trust.

LEARNING OBJECTIVES This case is designed to enable students to: •

Understand the business model of Zoom

•

Analyze the impact of COVID-19 on the video conferencing industry

•

Understand Zoom’s growth strategy during the pandemic and the reasons behind its success

•

Identify the challenges faced by Zoom in sustaining its position in the highly competitive video conferencing industry.

•

Examine the ways in which Yuan can overcome Zoom’s shortcomings.

This case is meant for students of graduate and undergraduate programs in Management as part of their Business Strategy/ Corporate Strategy curriculum. 1


Zoom’s Rise Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic

TEACHING APPROACH AND STRATEGY The case can be used to illustrate Zoom’s phenomenal growth during the COVID-19 pandemic. The instructor may initiate the discussion by giving an overview of the company and its business model. The participants can then proceed to discuss the global outbreak of COVID-19 and its impact on the video conferencing industry. The instructor can discuss the strategies adopted by Zoom during the pandemic and the reasons behind its success. He/she can conclude the session by discussing the challenges faced by Zoom and whether it can sustain its success in a post pandemic world. Some broad assignment questions are listed here: 1. Critically analyze the business model of Zoom 2. Discuss Zoom’s growth strategy amidst the COVID-19 pandemic. 3. Discuss the challenges faced by Zoom. What steps should Yuan take to overcome Zoom’s shortcomings and maintain its dominance in the global video conferencing industry?

SESSION PLAN Time Introduction

05 min

Discussion on Q1

20 min

Discussion on Q2

15 min

Discussion on Q3

15 min

Closing discussion

05 min

Total Expected Session Time

60 min

ANALYSIS 1. Critically analyze the business model of Zoom. A. Zoom is a remote video conferencing SAAS platform that allows users to virtually interact with each other using video, helping them maintain their workflow even when they are not available physically. Zoom has seen a spectacular rise in terms of user numbers as a result of the global COVID-19 pandemic. Earlier, it was known only within enterprises and businesses, but that has changed with the outbreak of the pandemic. The success of Zoom can be attributed partly to its simple yet effective business model. Zoom follows the freemium business model. The freemium business model is a model in which a product/service will be available free of cost and if users want to use additional features, then a premium amount has to be paid. In a nutshell, the freemium business model involves providing a basic version of a product or service for free, with the intention of persuading sufficient numbers of customers to pay for a more advanced version. Freemium models are usually used in the media, software, and web-application industries to attract more users initially and later convert them into premium customers. A freemium business model offers customers a free option for a service that has a reduced set of features compared to a premium and paid for offer (See TN Exhibit I and TN Exhibit II).

2


Zoom’s Rise Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic

TN Exhibit I:

Freemium Business Model

Source: https://www.garyfox.co/freemium-business-model/

TN Exhibit II:

Freemium Business Model: Advantages and Disadvantages Advantages • •

•

•

•

• • •

Disadvantages

It is easy to get a large user base when a product is offered for free. Businesses can easily acquire customers who promote the product to the prospects, and help the companies grow exponentially. “Free” holds a special appeal for customers and is inviting. Businesses with freemium offers attract many users when they are launched. There is a decreased customer acquisition cost. Since the users are already in the company’s ecosystem, it becomes easier to monetize them. The company does not have to spend on any ads or sales personnel as it can advertise premium features on the platform. Customer feedback can be easily collected based on the product features. It generates advertisement incomes and keeps freemium users engaged. It increases adoption rates besides boosting word of mouth publicity. 3

•

•

•

•

•

It is difficult to monetize. The biggest challenge in freemium is to find a way to make customers pay for the premium features Freemium users may not get totally converted to premium users, leading to difficulties in monetization. It drains resources with low ROI. The time, resources, and money needed to convert free users to paid ones can quickly deplete cash. A company may burn its cash reserves fast in supporting a large number of nonpaying customers. It is very challenging to strike a balance between freemium users and paid users. A company may want to make its freemium product engaging but not so good that people would never need to pay. On the other hand, a company may want to keep its freemium customers in the loop as long as possible because that increases the likelihood of their switching to premium.


Zoom’s Rise Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic

Advantages •

Disadvantages

Beta Testing. Having freemium users on • the platform allows the company to test new product features on them.

•

The operations are expensive. The company incurs heavy operational costs in the form of storage, marketing, or product development. These can be quite taxing on the company’s balance sheet as it has to invest heavily in these areas without seeing a financial return. The customer churn rate is high as some of the freemium customers may not want to pay for premium features.

Zoom follows a freemium business model, wherein it provides free limited services initially to hook users and then turns them into paying subscribers in exchange for upgraded services. Revenue is generated through a premium version with added features to the standard free offering. The company earns most of its revenue by offering subscription plans with varying features. Subscription revenue is driven primarily by the number of paid hosts, as well as purchases of additional products including Zoom Rooms and Zoom Video Webinars. Customers can use Zoom’s Meetings and Chat product for free. This allows the users to host group meetings with up to 100 people for 40 minutes. If more advanced features or a greater capacity (in terms of users and time) are needed, premium plans have to be purchased. Zoom’s freemium model focuses on getting its free users to become paying customers, helping to increase the adoption rates as well as boost word of mouth publicity Zoom offers four subscription plans – Free, Pro, Business, and Enterprise – with limited features in each plan. Customers can host unlimited 1-to-1 meetings and access core features like HD Video/Voice, desktop sharing, recording, and whiteboarding under the basic Free plan. More advanced features such as prolonged meeting duration, reporting, custom personal meeting ID, company branding are available as the plan is upgraded (See Case Exhibit II). Zoom has been able to scale its revenues by leveraging on a free product in the B2C space. If a participant wants to host a meeting, they can subscribe to one of the paid plans or sign up for the free Basic plan. By attracting free hosts through their Basic plan, the company drives usage on its platform, and its free hosts then introduce and invite new participants to experience the benefits of Zoom. As the free hosts realize the benefits of the platform, they often subscribe to a paid plan to gain access to additional functionality. 2. Discuss Zoom’s growth amidst the COVID-19 pandemic. The pandemic has propelled Zoom to the forefront of global video collaboration in enterprises and households across the globe. It has triggered a new market disruption for Zoom that has enabled it to tap into a massive new consumer base across the globe that has never used video conferencing before. Ansoff Growth Strategy Matrix To portray growth strategies, Igor Ansoff (1957) presented a matrix that focused on a company’s present and potential products and markets. By considering ways to grow through existing and new products and in existing and new markets, there are four possible productmarket combinations (See TN Exhibit III). They are: •

Market Penetration

•

Market Development

•

Product Development •

Diversification 4


Zoom’s Rise Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic

TN Exhibit III:

The Ansoff Growth Matrix

Adapted from Furrer, O. (2016). Corporate level strategy: Theory and applications. Routledge.

Zoom pursued growth through Market Penetration, Market Development, and Product Development. Market Penetration: The first quadrant in the Ansoff matrix is market penetration. The firm seeks to achieve growth with existing products in its current market segments, aiming to increase its market share. This is often adopted as a strategy when the organization has an existing product with a known market and needs a growth strategy within that market. The Freemium model itself is a market penetration strategy which drives new customer acquisition. Zoom adopted a multipronged go-to-market strategy with optimal routes-tomarket, including direct sales representatives, online channel, resellers, and strategic partners. Zoom’s platform is designed to make it easy to host meetings. By attracting free hosts to use its platform, the company promotes usage that allows hosts and their meeting attendees to experience the difference in Zoom. Zoom’s customer base spans numerous industry categories, including education, entertainment/media, enterprise infrastructure, finance, government, health care, manufacturing, non-profit/not for profit and social impact, retail/consumer products, and software/internet. Market Development: The firm seeks growth by targeting its existing products at new market segments. This strategy is used when the firm targets a new market with existing products. Zoom entered new geographical markets, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic, as it offered its products to organizations and government agencies in several countries globally. It catered to the education industry, health sector, small enterprises sector, training and development industry, and also to the general public who used the Zoom app for informal meetings like parties, funeral services, prayers, and protests. 5


Zoom’s Rise Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic

It achieved accelerated international expansion. With users, offices, and data centers strategically located around the world, the company reached new customers globally (See Case Exhibit III). Product Development: The firm develops new products targeted at its existing market segments. Product development in the Ansoff matrix refers to firms which have a good market share in an existing market and therefore might need to introduce new products for expansion. Zoom developed a variety of products tailored toward private consumers as well as businesses. These included core products Zoom Meetings and Chat as well as Zoom Rooms and Workspaces. Zoom Meetings could be attended and held via a web browser, or desktop and mobile applications. The Chat worked as an extension to the Zoom Meetings where users could interact through a chat with each other, share files, or create groups. Zoom Rooms and Workspaces were used by large scale organizations to conduct virtual meetings. Reasons behind Zoom’s Success: Zoom established the right resources, processes, and profit formula to dominate the marketplace. It had the right product, core competencies, and business model to scale during the pandemic. Zoom’s success during the COVID-19 pandemic can be attributed to the following reasons: •

Zoom’s Free Plan: The free plan was almost fully-fledged, offering the same features as its competitors, but at no cost.

•

Ease of Use: Zoom focused on making its product user friendly with a series of iterative enhancements.

•

Product Features: Zoom worked on giving its users the best video and audio experience and built a product which had high precision and quality.

•

Simple user interface: Zoom’s user interface was simple and easy to use with features like audio/ video chat, record, screen share, virtual hand raise, polls, mute participants, and change virtual backgrounds.

•

Affordability: Zoom’s subscription plans were more affordable and palatable to both individuals and small/medium sized businesses.

•

Customer-centric approach: Zoom’s products were developed to provide the best customer experience and totally relied on customer satisfaction.

•

Visionary Leadership: Yuan built investors’ trust, boosted employee morale, collaborated with high end technology companies and satisfied customers.

•

Low Latency: Zoom’s videos tried to stay under 150 milliseconds – since it was after 150 milliseconds that a conversation started to feel unnatural – by optimizing the connection on per-device basis instead of focusing on the worst ones in the loop.

•

Multipronged go-to-market strategy: The company leveraged on its freemium to build a continuous flow of paying customers

•

Broad interoperability: One of the most important features of Zoom’s platform was its broad interoperability with a range of diverse devices, operating systems, and third-party applications. The Zoom app was accessible from the web and from devices running Windows, Mac OS, iOS, Android, and Linux.

•

Easy integration: Zoom also integrates with most apps that make scheduling, accessing files, generating leads, and collaborating effortlessly easy 6


Zoom’s Rise Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic

3. Discuss the challenges faced by Zoom. What steps should Yuan take to overcome Zoom’s shortcomings and maintain its dominance in the global video conferencing industry? A. Following are the challenges faced by Zoom: •

Security and privacy issues. These include Zoom bombings and data leakages.

•

A significant number of the so-called Zoom bombings – the practice of uninvited parties hijacking video conversations to disrupt the usual proceedings – were reported since the global quarantine began.

•

Privacy shortcomings. Zoom was accused of passing on data to third parties, including Facebook, without notifying the users. The iOS version of Zoom's app reportedly sent analytics to Facebook even for users who did not have a Facebook account, thus violating the privacy of its users.

•

Security measures were compromised in the past and could be compromised in the future. If Zoom’s security measures were compromised in the future, it could damage the company’s reputation, impair its sales, and harm business. In addition, Zoom’s products and services might be perceived as not being secure. This perception might result in customers and hosts curtailing or ceasing their use of its products, thereby incurring significant liabilities for the company and harming its business

•

Intense competition in the video conferencing industry where deep pocketed rivals like Microsoft, Google, Cisco, and others were coming up with the same product features and pricing.

•

Product performance. Health experts and cyber psychologists pointed out potential inefficiencies in Zoom calls as they lacked an element of personal and eye contact and led to Zoom fatigue.

•

Managing growing customer base. The steep rise in the number of users during the pandemic strained the company, forcing it to invest more on expanding capacity to meet the needs of new users, many of whom were not paying customers. Moreover, it faced a difficult task in managing 17 data centers on a cloud-based platform with different regions, time zones, and employees working in stay-at-home work settings

•

Increased costs as it was unclear how many of Zoom’s free users would turn into subscribers.

•

While Zoom had been focusing on building strong technology partnerships, it had yet to lay out a robust distribution strategy for its channel partner program. The company primarily relied on direct sales and needed to build a large global channel partner network quickly, to continue growing its reach and market penetration. The strategic situation of Zoom can be analyzed using the SWOT analysis (See TN Exhibit IV): The SWOT analysis is a strategic framework used to study the internal and external environment of a business by identifying its strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. TN Exhibit IV: Zoom: SWOT Analysis Strengths: • Video-first cloud architecture • Freemium strategy • Reliable, high-quality communications • Viral demand driven by individual users • Best user interface

Weaknesses: • Security issues • Data privacy concerns • Zoom fatigue & health issues • End-to-end encryption not supported Contd…

7


Zoom’s Rise Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic Contd…

• • • • • • •

Cost effective subscription plans High video quality Low video latency Easy to use Growing base of happy customers Multipronged go-to-market strategy Unique technology and infrastructure enabling best-in-class reliability, scalability, and performance.

Opportunities: Threats: • Expand international market. With the • Competition from Microsoft, Webex, new norm of physical distancing and GoToMeeting (See Case Exhibit X). work-from-home, the demand for video • Competitors offering similar products at communication services is gaining same prices. momentum. • Security flaws • The COVID-19 pandemic has created • Compliance with applicable the opportunity for rapid growth for international laws and regulations, Zoom. As the pandemic persists including laws and regulations with globally, Zoom is positioned to record respect to privacy, telecommunications more growth in the number of users and requirements, data protection, consumer meetings held on the app. protection • According to Global Market Insights, the video conferencing market was projected to grow from US$14 billion in 2019 to US$50 billion by 2026. Going forward, Yuan can take the following steps to overcome Zoom’s shortcomings: • To maintain revenue growth, post the pandemic, Yuan should focus on expanding the Zoom ecosystem, progressing with technological innovations, and providing the best in class customer service in order to yield future growth •

The IT Security Administrators of the company should implement stringent policies to tackle security and privacy issues

•

Zoom can diversify into new product verticals using virtual reality and augmented reality

•

It can grow its partnership ecosystem and collaborate with high end technology startups to develop innovative products

•

Yuan should track the competitive strategies adopted by Zoom’s competitors and also keep an eye on their direction of scaling up

•

Zoom should take customer feedback to update the product features and functionality and maintain its growth momentum.

•

It should think about how to convert free users into paying customers: o

Unless new, attractive, and useful premium features offer users incredible value as they engage with the product, they may not have the incentive to ever upgrade to a paid plan over their freemium solution.

8


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook