Skip to main content

DANSIC21 - Case Competition Handbook

Page 1

CIRCULAR CONSUMPTION


│

CIRCULAR CONSUMPTION

DANSIC

About DANSIC Founded in 2011, DANSIC is a not-for-profit professional organization, run by student volunteers and recent graduates, constituted by both ambitious Danish and international students with a diverse academic and cultural background. Our aim is to contribute to a society that is socially, environmentally and economically sustainable. As Denmark’s largest platform for social innovation, we combine our different talents with a multidisciplinary approach to tackle several societal issues; the aim being to create a society that is environmentally, economically and socially sustainable.

To implement this vision, we organize and host an annual event which promotes the building of partnerships between students, national and international institutions (including businesses and NGOs), encouraging them to work together to tackle societal challenges.

26

1

10

team members

yearly event

years of activity


DANSIC21 CIRCULAR CHALLENGE

|

MAY 2021

Our Sponsors

The Tuborg Foundation The Tuborg Foundation has a socially beneficial objective: that of supporting associations and projects that bring people together in new ways and build bridges between civil society and industry. Since 1931, it has sustained a diverse range of initiatives across Denmark within the areas of music, culture, sport, education and industry. With volunteering as its focus, the Tuborg Foundation is proud to sustain initiatives with the objective of making society more sustainable and environmentally sound.

Copenhagen University The University of Copenhagen sees student-driven organizations as central to strengthening innovation and entrepreneurship. Therefore, it is important for KU to support activities in which students can put their knowledge into practice and engage with the surrounding community. This can, for example, be by solving challenges in society, and by working on applying knowledge from university to the development of society.


DANSIC21 CIRCULAR CHALLENGE

|

MAY 2021

Table of Contents 2. Introduction 5. Plastics 7. Food & Agriculture 9. Textile & Fashion 11. The challenge 12. Solution Structure 13. Judging criteria 14. Resources

1


│

CIRCULAR CONSUMPTION

DANSIC

Introduction to a Circular Economy The circular economy champions 1) a regenerative system where 2) waste and pollution are designed out, keeping products and materials in use, as opposed to the linear take-makedispose model. Companies who implement the circular economy concentrate on rethinking products and services using principles based on durability, renewability, reuse, repair, replacement, upgrades, refurbishment and reduced material use. However, a full circular transition calls for creative innovation in systems design and rigorous collaboration across and within value-chains, plus among multiple stakeholders. Designing both business models and value chains based on a circular economy will create a system reliable on renewable sources and materials. It decreases the level of dependency on natural resources, while increasing social and environmental benefits.

THE CIRCULAR ECONOMY WAY THE

OF

IS

A

NEW

LOOKING

AT

RELATIONSHIPS

BETWEEN

MARKETS,

STAKEHOLDERS

AND

NATURAL RESOURCES

IT

LEVERAGES

INNOVATIVE

NEW BUSINESS MODELS DISRUPTIVE

AND

TECHNOLOGIES

TO TRANSFORM THE LINEAR ECONOMIC MODEL

In light of this, the DANSIC21 Circular Challenge invites young and curious students and/or recent graduates to challenge the traditional system by bringing forth solutions to business challenges adoption of CE in business.

BENEFITS AND STATUS OF CIRCULARITY 48 %

USD 700 MILLION

THE PERCENTAGE OF

ANNUAL MATERIAL

ECONOMY IS ONLY

COST SAVINGS IN THE FAST-MOVING REDUCTION IN CO2 BY

CONSUMER GOODS INDUSTRY

2030

Source:

Ellen MacArthur Foundation

│

CIRCULARITY GAP MATERIALS CYCLED BACK INTO THE

8.7% OF MATERIALS

The 2021 Circularity Gap Report.

│

TRANSITIONING TOWARDS A CIRCULAR ECONOMY

can unlock global GDP growth of $4.5 trillion by 2030

World Business Council for Sustainable Development

2


DANSIC21 CIRCULAR CHALLENGE

|

MAY 2021

3 Circular Economy Mechanisms CLOSING RESOURCE LOOPS

SLOWING RESOURCE LOOPS

Prevent waste from being generated by substituting virgin materials and new products by secondary raw materials (i.e. from recycled waste) and second-hand, repaired or remanufactured products.

Slow down consumption and demand for virgin materials by extending the life of existing goods through more durable product design (i.e. products that are designed for being long-lasting, easy to repair and recycle, and that can at the end of their life-cycle be broken down into components, which can be used again in production chains).

NARROWING RESOURCE FLOWS

Competitive advantages

Increase resource efficiency by decreasing the total amount of resources used per unit of output, making better economic use of existing resources and assets, developing and diffusing new production technologies, or shifting consumption behaviour away from material intensive goods and services. To note that narrowing a resource flow does not per se imply circularity in the form of loops.

By re-designing business models, production processes and products, circular businesses can significantly reduce their material, energy and waste management costs, resulting in higher yields and competitive advantages.

Economic incentives Transitioning to a circular economy can unlock global GDP growth of $4.5 trillion by 2030 and will enhance the resilience of global economies.

APPLYING CIRCULAR ECONOMY STRATEGIES AREAS

PLASTICS, ELIMINATE EMISSIONS OF

CO2

AND

–

E

FIVE KEY

FOOD)

ALMOST

EQUIVALENT EMISSIONS

JUST

ALUMINIUM,

FROM

GOODS

OF

IN

(CEMENT,

HALF

THE

TO

2050

OF

THE

PRODUCTION

9.3 BILLION IN

STEEL,

COULD

–

TONNES

WHICH

CUTTING

IS

CURRENT

FROM ALL TRANSPORT TO ZERO

3


CIRCULAR CONSUMPTION

│

DANSIC

C.E. in a nutshell

Source: Ellen MacArthur Foundation, Circular Economy Systems Diagram (2019)

This comprehensive visualization of the circular economy has been put together by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation and sums up the various resource loops and strategies. The blue side represents non-finite materials - therefore, the best way to design the products made from those materials is to keep the materials circulating in small loops. All strategy have to be done before recycling. The blue side represents the technical part of the economy. The green side is the renewable side (all materials that can rejuvenate) and the circular system is designed in a way in which natural capital can be circulated.

4


DANSIC21 CIRCULAR CHALLENGE

|

MAY 2021

Plastics A study in 2017 showed that the world has produced 8.3 billion tons of plastic, and 80% of it has ended up in landfills, in the ocean, in the gut of animals and everywhere in our environment. While a lot of focus has gone into promoting recycling, the amount of plastic recycled is still less than 10%. One angle into the plastic problem is to look at the infrastructure of it. 40% of all plastic will be discarded after a single use with half of it taking up to 1000 years to disintegrate. Scientists have estimated that with the current rate of production and pollution of plastic, the plastic in the oceans will outweigh the total weight of all fish. The problem with plastic itself can be divided into many different categories, each as important as the other. We will take a dive into the problems with plastic packaging material. Annually, 78 million tons of plastic packaging material is produced. Out of the 78 million tons produced, ≈ 11 million tons (14%) is collected and recycled. The rest will (1) be used as means for energy recovery, (2) end up as land fields and (3) be leaked out of our collection system. The infrastructure of plastic packaging material is a classic linear application and thus also has economic consequences. The fact that only 14% is recycled results in an annual loss of USD 80-120 billion in material value. Check out this visualization from the Ellen MacArthur Foundation to understand better the material flows of plastic and how can we achieve a circular economy.

5


CIRCULAR CONSUMPTION

│

DANSIC

Plastics There are many different directions we can take to solve the problem. The Ellen Macarthur Foundation has given their take on a solution: Upstream Innovation. The application of Upstream innovation is divided into 3 strategies. (1) Elimination, (2) Reuse, (3) Material circulation. Elimination is presented as two approaches. (1) The direct elimination of packaging. That is the elimination of packaging that does not serve an essential function. (2) Innovative elimination of packaging. That is eliminating the essential packaging through an innovative idea. This could be to create a product that eliminates the need for plastic packaging.

Reuse gives life to five business models, each able to coexist with another. A couple of examples would be refill at home, Refill on the go, Return on the go, Return from home, Business to business packaging and reuse.

Material circulation is at its essence: to design the end use of packaging to be able to circulate in the economy through recycling or composting. Therefore, the end design of the packaging should be able to go through at least one of the following material circulation routes: Plastic recycling (or "downcycling"), plastic composting or substitution (changing the plastic packaging material to a non-plastic material that is already designed for recycling or composting). With this strategies in mind, plastic materials can be kept in smaller loops that prevent it from being recycled, which is a low-grade approach and last resort strategy for the circular economy Resources:

1. The Problems with Plastics | Public Health Post. Accessed May 19, 2021. 2. MacArthur DE. Rethinking the future of plastics Ellen MacArthur Found. Published online 2014:1-120. 3. Ellen MacArthur Foundation. Upstream Innovation. Published online 2020.

6


DANSIC21 CIRCULAR CHALLENGE

|

MAY 2021

Food Waste & Agriculture In the last few years, the way we produce and consume our food has changed tremendously. Technological advancements in production lines have made it possible to access almost any type of food, at any point in the day or year. Additionally, our busy lifestyles have become reliant on consuming on the go and often reckless food decisions and impulsive buying. With increased demand for food, larger population, resource inefficiency and high amount of industrially produced food - it is clear that our current food system is unsustainable. On average, we waste almost 30-40% of the food we produce at various points across the chain. In retrospect, one third of the food we produce is never eaten. In fact, if food waste was a country, it would be the third largest emitter of CO2, after China and the USA. What is more shocking is that a very big part of the wasted food is edible and could have been avoided. But it is not just food that gets wasted, it is the water, the energy and all the natural resources that took to produce it.

Source: Areas of implementation of circularity in the food system; Fassio F., Tecco N. Circular Economy For Food. Matter, energy and information in circulation, Ed.A Ambiente 2018)

7


CIRCULAR CONSUMPTION

│

DANSIC

Food Waste & Agriculture Although 42% of food waste happens in the household, a lot of the food discarded is surplus food that is misleadingly labeled as “best before” or food from retail services (e.g. restaurants). Food waste takes place in all parts of the supply chain, but the proportions differ according to geographical location. In developing nations, a considerable amount of the food is lost in the primary stage of the production due to improper storage, ineffective harvesting procedures and inefficient transportation. In fact, more than 40% of crops never see the shelf and some never pass the screening process. On the other hand, in developed nations most of the food is lost at the consumption stage. Therefore the question arises: how can we improve the way we consume and produce our food? The best and most preferable way is to avoid generating it in the first place through more efficient agricultural practices, storing and shortening the supply chain, from farm to fork. On the consumer side, we can avoid impulse shopping and purchasing excessively, buy less-than-perfect produce, and we can hoard less food in fridges. Producers can use regenerative agriculture, closing nutrients loops and utilizing waste, recovering energy and materials through e.g. vermicomposting and other practices as such. Here you can find are the most preferable strategies for food recovery, according to the EU Commission.

Source: Brief on food waste in the European Union, European Commission Joint Research Centre, 2020 Resources: Why is one-third of the food wasted worldwide How cutting food waste can help the climate Commitment: Reduce food waste in supply chains Foodwaste: preventing a multibillion dollar problem

8


DANSIC21 CIRCULAR CHALLENGE

|

MAY 2021

Textiles & Fashion Clothes are a fundamental part of our daily lives. All people on earth interact daily with clothing - it gives us comfort and security, but at the same time it enables us to express ourselves as individuals. The clothing industry is globally one of the largest industries in existence and is also considered to be the second largest source of industrial pollution surpassed only by the oil and coal industry. A prominent example of how large and significant the clothing industry is that in 2015 it emitted more than 1.2 billion tons of CO2, which in comparison is more than both the aerospace industry and maritime transport combined. In addition to the massive emission of CO2, the clothing industry is also linked to unhealthy working conditions, water pollution and pollution due to landfill.

Source: Euromonitor International Apparel & Footwear 2016 Edition (volume sales trends 2005-2015); World Bank, World development indicators - GD (2007)

9


CIRCULAR CONSUMPTION

│

DANSIC

Textiles & Fashion A study by McKinsey shows that in 2014, more than 100 billion items of clothing were produced, and that there has been a doubling since the year 2000. In addition, it also appears that the time that the consumer uses the clothes before they dispose of them has been halved compared to 15 years ago. It has even been estimated that clothing, produced in the fast fashion industry, is typically disposed of within a year. This has contributed to a use-and-throwaway culture, which is precisely characterized by clothing that is only used a few times before it is discarded. The study from McKinsey predicts that if the clothing industry continues in the same way as today, in 2025 we will see a 77% increase in CO2 emissions, compared to the level in 2015. Where does this leave us? How can we create a new circular fashion industry? The problem with today’s textile system is the massive waste of materials and the underutilization of clothes, the dangerous chemicals, low recycling rate and a burdening carbon footprint ( 4% of global annual CO2 emissions comes from fashion industry which is more than Germany, France and UK combined ). Below you can find an overview of strategies for a more circular business model in the fashion industry:

Source: Book - “Vores tøj - Verdens ressourcer: Tekstilindustriens kompleksitet og fremtid” by Esben Licht & Markus Hatting Resources: Circular Fibers Initiative (2017). A new textiles economy: Redesigning fashion’s future. Ellen MacArthur Foundation Remy, N., Speelman, E., & Swartz, S. (2016). Style that ’ s sustainable : A new fast-fashion formula. 1–6.

10


DANSIC21 CIRCULAR CHALLENGE

|

MAY 2021

The Challenge

CASE PROPOSITION REDESIGN, REINVENT OR CREATE A NEW PRODUCT OR SERVICE THAT CAN AID OR ADVANCE CIRCULAR CONSUMPTION. (You

can

choose

to

work

with

a

product,

service

or

process)

In your ideation process you can use these guiding questions: Within the theme of your choosing, how can you incorporate business initiatives that are aligned with Circular Economy? Within the theme of your choosing, how can you tackle their waste issues in relation to a business model? How can we design a consumer centred strategy that reduces waste and improves the circularity within one of the three industrial themes? How can these industries create circular systems from supplier to end consumer to close the loop? How can digitalization and/or technology underpin a circular model for businesses within one of these industries: textile, plastic or food?

CONSIDERED BUT NOT LIMITED TO THESE INDUSTRIES

Plastics

Textile

Food

11


CIRCULAR CONSUMPTION

│

DANSIC

The Solution GUIDELINES FOR THE STRUCTURE When structuring your solution, consider, but do not limit yourself to, the following guidelines:

Opening pitch ( 1 slide ) Your target market ( 1 slide ): identify and shortly explain the context and its challenges Identify the problem ( 1-2 slides ): State and explain the issue that you are going to address Identify the solution ( 2 slides ): State your solution, explain how is your solution challenging the status quo/the problem. Highlight the circular strategies are used Implementation of solution ( max. 3 slides ): Think about feasibility and implementation, you can provide a timeline for implementation and consider some costs aspects of your idea or solution. A complete cost breakdown is not necessary but it should be touched upon. Remember that it has to be realistic, not accurate. Consider competitive environment and substitutes if needed. Risk Analysis ( 1 slide ): Identify the key risks and the factors that would stop you from implementing the solution Conclusion ( 1 slide ): Sum up your main points

12


DANSIC21 CIRCULAR CHALLENGE

|

MAY 2021

Your solution will be assessed, on a scale of 1 to 10, based on:

CONTECT AND ADHERENCE TO THEME: 01

airetirC gnigduJ

02

03

04

05

06

07

Was the team’s presentation relevant to the case?

CREATIVITY AND ORIGINALITY

How creative and original was this team in their analysis and recommendation?

COHESIVENESS & CLARITY

Is there a clear cohesi veness throughout the hand-in and is the relevant information presented clearly?

INNOVATION

Did the team propose innovative solutions that go beyond current available sustainable initiatives?

JUSTIFICATION OF RECOMMENDATION

How well do they defend their solution? Do their quantitative and qualitative arguments have a strong support for their solution?

RECOMMENDATION PLAUSIBILITY The recommendation should be based on realistic solutions. How realistic is this team's recommendation?

CIRCULAR STRATEGIES Did the team use a high-value (reducing, redesigning) or low-value (recycling, recovering) circular strategies? How strong is the model? Does the team clearly present one or more circular economy strategies i n their solution? How well are they integrated?

13


CIRCULAR CONSUMPTION

│

DANSIC

Resources

GENERAL RESOURCES Circle Knowledge Hub: Browse Case Studies Explore Key Elements of the circular economy Ellen MacArthur Foundation: Learning Hub The circular Design Guide Business Case Studies

The circular Design OER Databaser

Circular Economy Practioner Guide: Strategies and examples World Business Council for Sustainable Development: 8 business cases for the circular economy Platform for Accelerating the Circular Economy (PACE): Action Agenda Circular Economy Practitioner Guide: Resources and Tools

Big Circles Studios: African Circularity Database

Circular Business with the Value Hill

The RSA: Case Study Database

Board of Innovation: Business Models that work in the Circular Economy

Circle Economy: The Key Elements of the Circular Economy

Circle Economy: Circular Product Design Framework

14


DANSIC21 CIRCULAR CHALLENGE

|

MAY 2021

Resources REPORTS

Towards the Circular Economy: Economic and business rationale for an accelerated transition The Circularity Gap Report 2021

Circular Economy case studies from Africa by Footprints Africa and ACEN

Realising opportunities of a circular business model

Upstream Innovation Guide and Case Study Database

UNEP: Sustainability and Circularity in the Textile Value Chain

OECD: Business Models for the Circular Economy

World Economic Forum: The New Plastics Economy Catalysing action

World Economic Forum & African Circular Economy Alliance: Five Big Bets for the Circular Economy in Africa

World Business Council for Sustainable Development & Accenture: CEO Guide to the Circular Economy

15


│

CIRCULAR CONSUMPTION

DANSIC

Resources

VIDEOS & TOOLS

Explaining the Circular Economy and How Society Can Re-think Progress | Animated Video Essay What If We Don’t Buy Products and We Buy Service? Circular Economy Explained | Animated Video Essay

The circular economy: A new way to design, make, and use things

This is a video about plastic pollution. Err..actually it’s about material circulation solutions.

This is a video about plastic pollution. Err..actually it’s about elimination solutions.

This is a Video About Packaging Solutions. Upstream Innovation Guide Upstream Innovation: Let's talk about solutions to plastic pollution! The Story of Stuff

European Circularity: Good practice, strategies & networks Closing the Loop: A Film documentary: Agro-food & Circular Economy

The Circular Toolbox: Circular Business Models for the Textile and Fashion industry

Accenture Strategy: Waste to Wealth

Case Writers: Adelina Laura Burlacu Valeria Esteban Diaz John Vinh Quang Tran Anna Lin

Special thanks to: Niklas Green

16


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
DANSIC21 - Case Competition Handbook by danishsocialinnovationclub - Issuu