2001
25TH
ANNIVERARY
EDITION THE
COLUMBIA POLITICAL REVIEW MAGAZINE
2026
Columbia Political Review
AN EDITOR’S NOTE
2026 EDITOR-IN-CHIEF,
SOUMYA KAMADA Dear Reader,
This year marks the Columbia Political Review’s 25th anniversary. Over the past 25 years, we have published over 1,000 articles, distributed more than 50 editions of print magazines, and have had upwards of 5,000 writers and editors pass through our publication’s community. All the while, political writing has consistently pushed its partakers to grapple with our role in history and to do the moment justice. It has become CPR’s guiding purpose to meet the political momeant by offering something new to ongoing conversations. The publication today stands as an unwavering record of student opinions and analysis, effectively serving as an archive of the last 25 years. Chronicling these opinions of just about every political affair has never been easy and has faced attacks from outright suppression to self-censorship, within and beyond Columbia University’s gates. Engaging in ongoing discourse has, thus, always required the sensitivity of understanding our place in the conversation. Moreover, it requires the stubborn insistence to articulate opinions that go against the grain and to continue speaking when speech itself is chilled. In the pages that follow, our staff members, current and former, reckon with the political moments of their time at CPR. In 2005, Paul Sonne, then a writer and later Editor-in-Chief, discussed Iran’s desire for nuclear weapons and the United States’s possible responses. Editor-in-chief, 2021, Alex Siegal stresses the significance of the COVID-19 pandemic and the January 6th insurrection as
reminders of how important it is to continuously build a culture of deliberative political thought. 2025-2026 Columnist Yunus Akdal seeks to analyze current political ideals in contrast to the French Revolution’s ambitions in defining social freedoms and public virtue. Editor-in-chief, 2024, Alan Chen reflects on how the ongoing project of CPR is the amalgamation of many students’ desire to turn their ideas into reality in seemingly such little time. CPR’s enduring persistence to think deliberately, write honestly, and serve as a record of student opinions throughout the past 25 years is a feat worth celebrating. While it is entirely impossible, and surely futile, to predict what will happen over the next 25 years, I am certain that CPR will continue to meet every political moment with conviction. With that, it is my deepest honor to present the Columbia Political Review’s 25th Anniversary Special Edition Magazine.
With conviction,
Soumya Kamada Editor-in-Chief
Table of Contents
EDITORIAL BOARD
Editor-in-Chief Soumya Kamada Publisher Shreya Karnik Chief of Staff Arvin Kim Director of Print Annika Aumentado Director of Publicity Vivian Hnin Zar Ni Director of Engagement Katherine Buckman Illustrator Shay Baer
2 3 6 7 9 10 13 14 17 20 26
Managing Editors Ashley Park Ava DiGiuseppe Camilo Choi Braden Mendiburu Claire Thornhill Liane Bdair Priya Shah Josh Cohen, Column Roma Tivare, Policy 360 Rohan Sarma, Interviews Oscar Uhalde, Submissions Marcello Maturi, Virtual
Anniversary Edition Contributors Aditya Sharma Alan Chen Alex Siegal Benjamin Levitan Constance Boozer Geetika Rudra Ishaan Barrett Mark Hay
Matthew Zipf Parini Rao Paul Sonne Rachel Barkin Sajaa Ahmed Sophia Lander Taylor Thompson Yunus Akdal
TABLE OF CONTENTS AN EDITOR’S NOTE: CONSTANCE BOOZER WHO IS THE PEOPLE?......................................................................YUNUS AKDAL AN EDITOR’S NOTE: MATTHEW ZIPF THE PHILOSOPHER-POLITICIAN ........................................SOPHIA LANDER AN EDITOR’S NOTE: ALAN CHEN BUBBA’S PLAYBOOK ..................................................................TAYLOR THOMPSON AN EDITOR’S NOTE: ALEX SIEGAL IRAN ON THE BRINK ............................................................................PAUL SONNE “FAILURE WILL BE DEVASTATING”....................................ADITYA SHARMA LEFT HANGING ...............................................................................BENJAMIN LEVITAN AN INTERVIEW WITH: SAJAA AHMED, ISHAAN BARRETT, & RACHEL BARKIN ...................................................................................PARINI RAO 1
Columbia Political Review
AN CONSTANCE BOOZER EDITOR’S NOTE A LETTER FROM 2012 EDITOR-IN-CHIEF,
“Still, thou art blest, compar’d wi’ me! The present only toucheth thee” - TO A MOUSE, BY ROBERY BURNS
I
t’s remarkable that human beings can reflect on the past, be grounded in the present, and ponder what the future might be – and one day at a time along the way within the split of a second toggle across time to take the long view of history while also make sure to complete that frog to-do item each day. And when contemplating anniversaries, notions of nostos and algos are almost unavoidable, partly as Robert Burns notes elsewhere in the poem “[i]n proving foresight may be vain” and partly because the Odyssey is yet again in the zeitgeist. Regardless of whether you are focused on the past v. present v. future: 25 years, which also is 1.25 scores as well as 788,923,800 seconds, is cause for CPRevelry. Congratulations!!!!!! My time at the Columbia Political Review truly is one of my most treasured and formative experiences while I was at Columbia, and I am deeply fortunate and grateful to each and every member of the masthead staff and contributing writers for making CPR such a rewarding experience. So much of college and life really is the people you meet along the way! And to me, it’s almost a magical experience when people utilize their unique talents as they work together to build something larger than themselves — the most apt description I can think of is Rumi’s: “When you do things from your soul, you feel a river moving in you, a joy.” I hope CPR continues to be a source of joy for 25, 50, 100, and beyond more years from today! And in thinking through why exactly CPR holds such special meaning to me compared to other extracurriculars, these virtues, values, ideals, character shapers, and life lessons jump to mind:
1. When you discover and follow your mission-driven north stars while also are aligned and grounded in your values, your personality day after day will guide you toward work that animates, excites, fascinates, and sustains your heart and mind – and when you’re lucky, flow states and waking up excited each morning are omnipresent. 2. CPR’s deadline-driven and word-count-constrained magazine fostered persistent, precise project management along with goal-driven adaptability (oh the places you’ll go after overcoming a layout weekend crisis or two!) and its expansive approach to political thought nurtured creativity, wit, and courageous networking (spanning from punny titles and impressive artwork to cold pitching and then interviewing public figures). 3. CPR as a multi-partisan organization: via web columns and magazine pieces, CPR has been a forum where people with all points of view and political identities could express their opinions, spark and foster discourse and dialogue, and encourage greater empathy for another human being’s point of view. As the cycles of time continue in this fleeting world, thank you so much CPR for being a bedrock in my life and the lives of others. Onwards!
2
25th Anniversary Edition
WHAT IS THE PEOPLE?
International Article from the Archive
OCTOBER 1, 2025 BY YUNUS AKDAL
an article from the archive
T
he way we do politics today is not how it has always been. Far from it. I think we know of this on an intuitive level; the strongest argument that compels one to go to the ballot today is that one party is “the lesser of two evils.” We know that the window of policy difference between the Democrats and Republicans in the United States is claustrophobically narrow, and that there is no room for revolutionary politics in Congress, nor amongst the people. And yet, we are continuously confronted in our history classes with the Age of Revolutions, which envisioned something far greater than our political imagination and capacity today. We know that there was once a time when parliaments grappled openly with the very nature of our freedom, the foundational rights of individuals, and the meaning of social existence. We know, then, that at the dawn of the 19th century, politics was alive, and that by the beginning of the 21st century, it was dead. Something must have intervened that replaced all the philosophers with bureaucrats, idealists with public servants. There are many ways of reading into this problem. In the limited space of this column, I want to give you a brief glimpse of what a living political body looks like through the eyes of history. So take a deep breath, don your sans-culottes, and fasten
your tricolour cockades. We are off to France, 1789. Few moments illustrate the philosophical dimension of politics in the French Revolution more powerfully than Abbé Sieyès’ response to Jacques Necker, the finance minister under Louis XVI. Necker had sought guidance from political writers on how to organize the king’s advisory body, the Estates General, and instead of addressing Necker’s question, which limited the question of the Estates General to purely administrative matters, Sieyès reframed the issue, asking instead: “What is the Third Estate?” In this existential question alone, we find the first political expression of a society demanding a self-identity. Sieyès’ reply— “Everything”—was not rhetoric, but the opening move in a radical reconceptualization of the meaning of politics. It is in the first part of his pamphlet that Sieyès translated the abstract idea of social freedom (first articulated by Rousseau as the “general will”) into concrete political forms. For Sieyès, the Third Estate, in contrast to the First Estate, composed of the clergy, and the Second Estate of the nobility, was alone the living embodiment of society itself. He argued that this estate, composed of peasants, laborers, artisans, merchants, professionals, and intellectuals, was responsible for all the essential func-
3
Columbia Political Review
tions of society. It produced agricultural and industrial goods, sustained its trade networks, staffed and provisioned its military, and carried out the specialized work of doctors, lawyers, educators, and philosophers. So really, “everything.” The conclusion follows logically: if the Third Estate does everything necessary for society’s survival and flourishing, in other words, the social rights over that society, then it must also be entitled to the political rights over that society: power to constitute itself, become itself, and control itself. Philosophy, to Sieyès, was inseparable from language and the spirit of politics. This understanding was not unique to him, as it set the tone for what followed. The history of the French Revolution is marked by a succession of these dynamic moments. I should mention Mirabeau’s response at the royal session of the National Assembly on 23 June, 1789, to the king’s envoy, who had come to deliver the order to dissolve the Assembly: “Tell those who send you that we are here by the will of the people and will leave only by the force of bayonets!” Another fan favourite was when Desmoulins, responding to the dismissal of the popular finance minister by Louis XVI, climbed onto
4
25th Anniversary Edition
a table at the café Foy, drew a pistol, and lit the fuse: “To arms, to arms!” Saint-Just’s intense 1792 speech on the fate of the King similarly encapsulates the revolutionary fever, when in one of the many thunderous crescendos, he declared, “No man can reign innocently!” Moments like these reveal a kind of political conviction that feels almost unimaginable today. Perhaps nowhere is this contrast more profoundly expressed than in Robespierre’s 1794 speech, “On the Principles of Political Morality.” “What is the end of our revolution? The tranquil enjoyment of liberty and equality; the reign of that eternal justice, the laws of which are graven, not on marble or stone, but in the hearts of men, even in the heart of the slave who has forgotten them, and in that of the tyrant who disowns them.” Robespierre, perhaps the most devout abolitionist of his time, is not here referring to the plight of the enslaved in France’s colonial holdings. Rather, he addresses a more insidious form of servitude, the political oppression of oneself from within oneself, echoing what Rousseau described in The Social Contract as the condition of “vile slaves” who “grin
in mockery at the name of liberty.” Robespierre speaks about the citizenry, having once glimpsed the horizon of emancipation, has retreated into cynicism and complacency. Thus, he speaks to us, people who have abandoned the transformative ideals that once animated politics. We, who in our vague political imagination can no longer conceive of human nature as contingent and society as an entity with limitless potential. Robespierre’s political morality hinged on precisely this point: that the human subject is not fixed, but formed through collective life and civic virtue. His vision was anthropological transformation. Laws, he claimed, must awaken “generous passions” in the hearts of the people and not simply pose as fragments of language. This was the ethical foundation of the Republic: a society grounded in shared public virtue. You get the point. These pivotal moments, moments that highlight the eclectic personalities who led the republic, moments of energy and zeal, and of philosophic inquiry, were all fundamental, not only to the politics of France during the 1789 Revolution, but also to the rights and freedoms we cherish today. It was only because they were politicians as philosophers and not as statesmen that
Article from the Archive
they discovered the social demand for freedom and pursued it without conviction. Our understanding of political rights is much less ambitious today. That ambition, the belief that politics could reforge the human condition, seems unintelligible. The most radical and “transformative” political decision we have seen in the past 10 years of American politics could possibly be Trump’s international tariffs. That, regrettably, is the horizon of our political moment. It is no wonder, then, that in a place like Columbia, a policy school, above all, the deeper questions of sovereignty and freedom barely register. We let the NYU kids wander about that. This is why, when CPR published an op-ed titled “The ‘Radical Left’ Needs to Start Playing Dirty,” encouraging the Democrats to use anti-democratic weapons such as filibustering and gerrymandering more assertively,
and simultaneously rendering them effectively indifferent from the Republicans, I was not surprised at all. Although CPR advertised this article as a “provocative argument,” I really thought the opposite. Telling politicians to abandon their principles in order to win in office is truly a timeless strategy, but it leans more on the milquetoast side of the spectrum. This reading of politics as public policy, whereby voters are consumers demanding public goods, is the political compass reading of politics. It is not provocative one bit. It appears to me that the most provocative and radical stance one can take today is to unapologetically advocate for what one believes to be true. This is the difference between the politics of 1789 and 2025. Perhaps this is what best explains populist movements and the politicians who emerge from them, such as the likes of Trump. The social de-
mand for politics is inevitable. The people will always want to actively be part of a whole and express their demand for freedom. The people will always want to be led. We cannot pretend otherwise and declare that “politics should be boring,” that it is just a matter of policy. The unfortunate reality is that the further we run away from 1789, the more our politics will reflect an uglier side of that epoch, precisely that which materialises in Trump. Then, the “radical left,” if such a thing still exists, should grab these cat theorist Democrats and cosplay Republicans by the collar and tell them that they do not, and will not in their current state, represent our political and social desire for freedom. When asked the question “what is the most cost-effective model for healthcare?” we should respond with a question of our own, as did Sieyès: “what is the People?”
5
Columbia Political Review
AN MATTHEW ZIPF EDITOR’S NOTE A LETTER FROM 2017 EDITOR-IN-CHIEF,
“Since the First World War, Americans have been leading a double life, and our history has moved on two rivers, one visible, the other underground; there has been the history of politics, which is concrete, factual, practical, and unbelievably dull if not for the consequences of the actions of some of these men; and there is a subterranean river of untapped, ferocious, lonely and romantic desires, that concentration of ecstasy and violence which is the dream life of a nation.” - NORMAN MAILER
T
hose lines were published in 1960. They struck me as vital and necessary in 2016, when I was in college. They seem dead to me now. I wonder whether they say anything to the magazine’s new cohort. I thought, ten years ago, that it was a writer’s particular job—and so he or she must have the particular gift—to sense the movements of the underground and not be taken in by the merely visible. But such a historical division, which may have been nothing more than one of Mailer’s parlor-trick lines, seems far from the American reality now. I hesitate to say anything more in such a short forum. The past ten years have involved massive changes in American life. Writing about those changes would require a measure of certainty and insight that I have not yet achieved. But I find it a useful exercise to look back at quotations
6
25th Anniversary Edition
that I found relevant in college and that, working like milestones, can now help us see how we have drifted, advanced, or strayed. One quotation will always apply. In the Review’s summer 2017 editorial, I copied the opening question from Emerson’s essay “Experience”: “Where do we find ourselves?” There are fast, polemical answers to that question. But I think that serious political writing begins by recognizing how difficult it is to provide, with any real insight and accuracy, the basic facts of where we are, how we got here, and what paths remain.
Article from the Archive
an article from the archive
THE PHILOSPHERAN ANALYSIS OF THE POLITICIAN: FUTURE OF DEMOCRACY NOVEMBER 11, 2021 BY SOPHIA LANDER
T
he relationship between the political and the philosophical has always held a murky place in the minds of thinkers and leaders. While philosophy has played a role in politics since the time of Plato and Aristotle, the term “political philosophy” didn’t arise until the late 1800s. Originally derived from the study of social philosophy, political philosophy as a discipline focuses on the “philosophical reflection on how best to arrange our collective life—our political institutions and our social practices, such as our economic system and our pattern of family life.” Political philosophy is interested in asking the bigger questions of politics: is this institution consistent with our state’s moral objective? What does it mean
to a free citizen that possesses a right to justice in our state? The particular realm in which political philosophy lies is even harder to establish than its definition. Even more so, the notion of “the politician” has never been explicitly intertwined with that of “the philosopher” in the same way that the disciplines of politics and philosophy have been united. Perhaps the closest that history has come to a “philosopher-politician” was Confucius in the sixth century— but even then, Confucius only briefly held public office. Plenty of scholars like Max Weber, Niccolo Machiavelli, Plato, and Aristotle have theorized about a “philosopher-politician” with a unique set of skills to both present the right answers in politics and ask
the right questions in philosophy. However, this kind of leader has yet to show their face in modern politics. With the deterioration of political systems, institutions, and structures around the world, it is high time that society encourages the development of the “philosopher-politician” mindset and establishes an electoral mindset that stimulates intellectualism, not populism. The first thing, then, is to establish what can be said about the modern politician. While it should be noted that not every politician can be described the same way, there is a general attitude and charisma that seems to attract the modern electorate—a recipe for a successful candidate. In the 1930s, Max Weber described
7
Columbia Political Review
this kind of politician as one ruled by bureaucracy. The modern politician to Weber, then, is simultaneously a product of bureaucracy and an active figure in maintaining said bureaucracy to promote their own agenda— namely, reelection. The politician is not concerned with asking questions about the state of affairs or seeking knowledge beyond polling and statistical measures of the wants of their constituents. This mindset is not necessarily the fault of the individual politician. The system upon which most modern democracies are founded values productivity and compromise on passing legislation in order to accommodate ever-growing populations and issues. The mindset fostered by this system generates a kind of will amongst the citizens to elect those that they think will be the best at “getting things done.” Simply pushing something through to the next committee or out on a ballot takes priority over philosophizing about the issues at hand, creating a “machine” like the political system that Weber theorized. Ironically, the modern productive politician is actually neither productive nor the best suited for combating political issues today. When all politicians attempt to complete political tasks protecting their own individual interests, competing interests nullify any productivity at all. The philosopher-politician must not prioritize productivity over thought nor compromise over morals. This figure can be equated with Weber’s “politician of responsibility” or “realization,”
8
25th Anniversary Edition
someone who is uniquely situated to hold political office, not because of their mass voting appeal but because of their ability to stand up against the irrationality of the pseudo-productive politician. More importantly, there are two methods of political action that the philosopher-politician takes: first, they take into account the deficiencies of the public, and second, they do not burden the results of their own action on the public. At first, this may seem like the philosopher-politician is not to be held accountable by the public, but this is not the case. Philosopher-politicians have a unique set of abilities that the pseudo-productive politician and the voting masses do not have: the philosophical thinking that requires time, patience, and devotion to the public. The pseudo-productive politician, in their effort to maximize the amount of legislative output, does not have the time nor the patience to engage in theoretical analysis. More importantly, they do not have the innate devotion to serve the masses, who also do not always have the time, as a collective, to engage in the questions that political philosophy asks. It is the duty of any politician in a representative democracy to serve the masses, and the philosopher-politician is uniquely skilled to do so, not because of their charismatic or popular appeal but because of their desire to strategize about political issues that have potential impacts in the long term as well as the short term. The philosopher-politician doesn’t require certain training or knowledge,
diverging from Plato’s concept of the philosopher-king; according to Weber, philosopher-politicians are held to the same standards for removal as current politicians, and, most importantly, they are not monarchical. But why are philosopher-politicians and thinking democracies necessary? The Carnegie Endowment for International Relations argues that “not only are doubts about the value and wisdom of democracy getting a much wider hearing than they were a decade or two ago, so too are voices arguing that authoritarian regimes might be more capable and effective.” The masses are losing faith in the pseudo-productive politician who posits their legislative output as indicative of their ability to represent the public interest and instead are turning to those that promise even more radical immediate change. The philosopher-politician is in a unique position to help curb this movement towards the extreme because, while the authoritarian may be able to push through change quickly, the change is ultimately a negative one since so much time is spent getting it through the next political hurdle that no thought is actually put into the change in the first place. The ideological notion of a philosopher-politician would create another kind of radical change: slower and more thoughtful processes of politics and legislation. The philosopher-politician model provides the much-needed application of the principle that “slow and steady wins the race” to politics.
Alumni Editor’s Note
AN ALAN CHEN EDITOR’S NOTE A LETTER FROM 2024 EDITOR-IN-CHIEF,
I
t’s a surreal coincidence that CPR finds itself celebrating a major milestone in its life at the same time as the U.S. As these 25th and 250th anniversaries converge, I find myself reflecting on the long history of the publication against the even longer history of the nation. Back in 2024, when I first stepped into the role of editor-in-chief, I remember feeling so energized to build upon the foundation that I had inherited from previous editors. But when the spring 2024 campus protests and ensuing speech crackdown demanded that the editorial board shift its attention elsewhere, I began to realize how easily time slips away. Of the many new initiatives that we had planned to cultivate, we were only able to plant the seeds for a select handful. Yet, hearing from the people who have since taken the helm of the publication, I am in awe of everything that has
been accomplished: a burgeoning Interviews cohort, nearly 150,000 annual readers, and unwavering coverage of the issues that matter to the staff of CPR. Whether in 25 years or 250, it never ceases to amaze me just how much can be accomplished in what once seemed to be hardly enough time. One might imagine that the founding forebears would feel this today, and I certainly know that we who left CPR years ago feel this now too. And so, in this light, for every future member of CPR that hungers to turn an idea into reality, I hope you can savor the process—because as slow as it may seem in the moment, it will one day have passed by in the blink of a byline. The heartiest of congratulations to every writer, editor, and artist that has helped make CPR what it is—and what a powerful thing it has become. We the alumni cannot wait to hear what else this publication and its members go on to do. 9
Columbia Political Review
an article from the archive
BUBBA’S PLAYBOOK OCTOBER 31, 2010 BY TAYLOR THOMPSON
J
ust under two years ago, a young Democratic president took office after leading his party to majorities in both chambers of Congress, reshaping the political landscape after a period of conservative dominance. After enduring bruising legislative battles on top priorities like comprehensive health care reform, the Democrats stand to lose both the House and the Senate, and a new generation of Republicans is waiting to deliver on a muchhyped manifesto for change. To top it off, the president’s prospects for reelection aren’t looking particularly promising either. That this could be said of two Presidents—Bill Clinton in 1994 and Barack Obama in 2010—says two things. Mark Twain was probably right when he said that history doesn’t repeat itself; it rhymes. But given the points of similarity that do exist, Obama should expect the worst and make use of the lessons of 1994 to understand how he can thrive with a Republican-controlled Congress. Clinton not only went on to be reelected, but even more remarkably, managed to spend most of the time after the Democrats’ 1994 midterm defeat outmaneuvering and outsmarting his Republican foes. How did he do it? More importantly, what lessons does the story of Clinton’s comeback hold for Obama?
10
25th Anniversary Edition
Sex scandals and impeachment trials notwithstanding, Clinton enjoyed enormous successes as President. The economy boomed. He presided over a federal government with a projected budget surplus for the first time since 1969. He signed a landmark welfare reform bill. Newt Gingrich was embarrassingly deposed as Speaker of the House just four years after taking office, reflecting the reversal of his party’s fortunes. President Clinton left the White House with high approval ratings and great goodwill. He has long been marked as one of the most gifted politicians in modern history, but his turning the tide so decidedly in his favor easily ranks as one of the most surprising and important comeback stories in American politics. Surprising because after losing Congress in 1994, Clinton was practically a lame duck. Important because as even casual political observers will note, Obama may very well find himself in Clinton’s shoes in just a few short weeks. It is very rare for presidents of either party to pick up seats during midterm elections. What distinguished 1994 from many other midterm election years was the extent of the political damage done to the incumbent President. In 1994, voters rebuked President Clinton for overreaching on a mandate that was, in fact, much wobblier than
Obama’s. By trying to advance a liberal agenda on issues ranging from the economy to gays in the military to his disastrous attempt at comprehensive health care reform, Clinton received backlash from a skeptical and uneasy electorate. The country had not turned its back on Reagan’s still-potent legacy; rather, voters put a moderate Southerner into office with under 40 percent of the national popular vote. Clinton made the mistake of attempting to make sweeping changes that were largely out of step with what the country wanted. This, paired with a sluggish economy and Americans’ time-honored convention of midterm reversals, resulted in a blowout that swung 54 seats in the House and 8 seats in the Senate to the Republicans. Having lost both chambers of Congress and virtually all of his political momentum in this “Republican Revolution,” the President was faced with a choice between lame-duckhood and handing Newt Gingrich and the Republicans “carte blanche.” Obviously, neither was acceptable, so Clinton went back to his Southern Democratic roots—he triangulated. Rather than taking a left turn to rally the Democratic base (historically a bad move, since the true balance of power in American politics lies with independent voters and moderates), Clinton co-opted
Article from the Archive
Republican prescriptions like welfare reform and a pro-growth stance on economic issues while at the same time using the art of compromise to institute incremental, moderately progressive programs like the State Children’s Health Insurance Program. The net effect of Clinton’s Third Way politics was to move the country forward in ways that attracted bipartisan support, both in Congress and the electorate. President Obama will have to learn very well from 1994, as it now appears that he will lose the House and retain the senate by a razor-thin margin. The key to Clinton’s recovery was his understanding, at the most basic level, of the political dynamics of the country, and his ability to put those insights to effective use. It has been argued that Clinton possesses truly unique assets that Obama does not, such as his noted ability to empathize with the American people and the slipperiness that so many still associate with his political persona. These traits line up exactly with two of Obama’s perceived weaknesses as a politician: his often aloof persona, professorial style, and ironic inability to talk his administration out of trouble. But such critiques of Obama’s political ability are misplaced. It is important to note that Obama came to national prominence on the basis of a powerful personal narrative and soaring rhetoric, and that throughout his political career, from the Jeremiah Wright controversy to his alleged status as a closet Muslim to the health care debate, Barack Obama has shown prodigious ability to rise to the oratorical occasion. Speeches alone will not be enough, of course. The Republicans will benefit from the continuing fallout from the sluggish economy and the government’s bailouts of big business. And increasingly the GOP has countered its label as the “Party of No” by moving a set of young, articulate intellectuals like Eric Cantor
of Virginia and Paul Ryan of Wisconsin to center stage. The latter’s budget plan, while debated in policy circles, has drawn praise for being clear-sighted and reality-based in its approach to America’s fiscal problems. The fact remains, however, that while the Obama administration is bruised, the president’s opponents doubt his ability to recover at their own peril. Barack Obama has the weapons to get back up and start fighting; he just needs to know how to use them. For that he needs to pick up a copy of Bubba’s playbook. “I disagree with you, but I don’t think you’re Hitler.” That comedian Jon Stewart is holding a Rally to Restore Sanity at the end of this month based on this sentiment speaks volumes about the popular appeal of centrism and civil, moderate discourse. One of the basic facts of American political life is that elections are won in the center. Both Clinton and Obama took note of this early on in their presidential campaigns for the presidency and used it to their advantage. Interestingly, however, both lost the center ground (and thus political momentum) during their first two years as president, contributing to their losses in the midterms. In general terms, both Presidents tried to effect sweeping “generational” liberal reforms on questionably robust mandates, such as comprehensive health care reform. And they did so in ways which ultimately hurt their standing with a majority of voters. The minutiae of these political battles are not of direct concern to the midterm elections; there are too many factors involved to make sweeping statements about the effect of a few particular bills. What is clear is that after losing in 1994, a politically chastened Clinton moved back to the center (to his roots as a founding member of the Democratic Leadership Council) as a matter of necessity—it was the only way to remain relevant with the GOP in control of
Congress. The Clinton who declared that the “era of big government is over” and pronounced an “end to welfare as we know it” was not the President Clinton who tried to pass HillaryCare or allow gays to serve openly in the military. Signing the Defense of Marriage Act and advocating for free trade (one of Clinton’s few early successes) might have been anathema to some on the left, but they were supported by a country that was, and remains, largely center-right. Landmark pieces of legislation like the Recovery Act and health care reform may have reached Barack Obama’s desk, but they have become a rallying cry for those who see a federal government growing too big, too fast. The raw political power of fiscal conservatism in the current environment cannot be underestimated. A less ambitious federal government, and by necessity, a less expansive progressive agenda, will be the price of Obama will have to pay in his second term. Just as Bill Clinton did the unthinkable and compromised with Republicans on welfare reform, Barack Obama will likely have to settle for cuts in discretionary spending and retain the Bush tax cuts for all income brackets, at least until the economy has recovered. The key for the President is to counterpunch the Republicans effectively. If he can coopt parts of their agenda in the same vein as Clinton’s welfare reform gambit (tax and budget reforms come to mind here), he can score points with the electorate, throw the GOP off balance, and improve his political position, ultimately resulting in better, more measured policy solutions to the problems facing America. The Congressional Republicans during Barack Obama’s first two years in office have been nothing but consistent. They have attempted to obstruct every major initiatives (and most minor ones) of this administration and the result has been gridlock. It could be argued that the kind of 11
Columbia Political Review
centrism espoused by Clinton would simply be met with continued opposition as the Republicans try to position themselves to retake the White House in 2012. But key domestic problems like the economy, tax policy, energy and immigration, all demand realistic, substantive policy prescriptions crafted by both parties. Such compromises may seem unattainable given the bitter partisanship that currently grips the political arena, and indeed, they probably are. The essential factor that will break the gridlock is a president who will find a way to force the Republicans to become a part of his government. Moderating his approach is only the setup for this more important, but riskier, step. It took a shutdown of the federal government for Clinton to gain the upper hand over Republicans in 1995. An impasse in negotiations over the 1996 budget forced the shutter of nonessential services for several weeks in late 1995 and early 1996. While Republicans blamed Clinton for the debacle, he argued that their proposed cuts would harm the country, and more importantly, allowed Newt Gingrich’s behavior during the episode to severely harm his standing with voters. By deftly handling the Republicans and allowing them to make unforced errors, Clinton ultimately backed the GOP into a corner. The 1995 shutdown was the high-water mark of the Republican Revolution, and while the partisan bickering continued, the Republicans had pushed the outer limits of the public’s tolerance for such antics. After that point, with the Republicans
12
25th Anniversary Edition
as partners in delivering major pieces of legislation, such as the welfare reform bill in 1996 and the Balanced Budget Act of 1997, Clinton made real progress. Barack Obama should expect obstructionism from Congressional Republicans in the wake of their midterm gains, but he need not be resigned to it indefinitely. With unemployment at 9.6 percent, the Republicans will have no choice but to work with the President, and vice versa. Whether they do so willingly or due to their own mistakes is ultimately irrelevant, but Clinton’s example is instructive: It would be best for Obama to wait until an opportune moment and call the Republicans’ bluff rather than try to appear conciliatory right away. Appeasement would weaken his negotiating position, and worse, could make him look ineffective if he is rebuffed. The best place to corner the Republicans, just as during the Clinton years, will be on the inevitable confrontation over the budget. Predictably, Obama will be opposed to the fiscal plans of the Republicans, which will likely include austerity measures of some kind. The prospect of cuts in popular programs naturally works to Obama’s favor, but the key will be for Obama to strike the right balance between political expediency and prudent policy, as Clinton did to great effect. The way back for Obama is fraught with difficulty, given the depth of the anger in the country and the damage done to his political “hope” branding. There is also some suggestion that
the departure of Clinton-era players like economic adviser Larry Summers and outgoing Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel will increase the influence of less pragmatic voices within the administration and drive Obama further left. That would be a fatal error. Such a shift cannot be ruled out, but the factors involved weigh heavily against it. President Obama’s tightknit inner circle of advisers is filled with brilliant strategists, and this must be extended to include interim Chief of Staff Pete Rouse, who brings a wealth of experience, contacts, and perspective to the job. As students of political history, Obama’s advisors are well aware that ceding the mantle of centrist, common sense governance to the Republicans would put a gun to the head of the Democrats’ future electoral prospects. And fighting for election in 2012 on the basis of President Obama’s uneven and unpopular record would pull the trigger. The two rules which guided President Clinton paved the way for his eventual comeback—take and keep the center ground, and force the Republicans to take ownership—are directly applicable here. If the President takes note of these lessons of recent political history, then his—and the country’s— chances for success will improve greatly, perhaps beyond what would have been possible if his party wins the midterms. If he does not, then chances are we’ll have to say goodbye to Obama in 2012 and throw Barry’s playbook onto the trash heap of history.
Alumni Editor’s Note
AN ALEX SIEGAL EDITOR’S NOTE A LETTER FROM 2020 EDITOR-IN-CHIEF,
T
he last time I wrote to this publication’s staff and audience, in December 2020, it was to celebrate our work expanding the platform in the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic. We took a group of forty staff members, scaled up production to include over one hundred students, and opened our pages to pitches from new writers inside and outside of the campus community. Two weeks after I wrote my final Letter from the Editor, the January 6th insurrection at the Capitol struck at the heart of what it means to live in a democratic society that values the kind of work CPR does. And though that grisly and
shameful event is over six years in the past now, it still shapes our lived present. Nor is it lost on me how challenging the more recent past has been for campus discourse at Columbia, too. That makes CPR’s work all the more important. What you do to build a practice and a culture of informed, deliberative, long-form political thought is beating against the current, but in desperately short supply. I am so excited to have seen how much the publication has grown, and cannot wait to see what the next 25 years bring.
13
International
Columbia Political Review
IRAN ON THE an article from the archive
MARCH 1, 2005 BY PAUL SONNE
Iran wants nuclear weapons, and it is about to get them.
I
f not seriously deterred, Iran will undoubtedly (really, this time) possess nukes within the next two to three years. It is universally regarded— even by the French—that Iran’s nuclear program is much more advanced than Iraq’s ever was, and, even though Iran is a signatory of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, leaders in Tehran refused to ratify the treaty in July 2003. That refusal effectively barred weapons inspectors from obtaining more extensive access to Iran’s nuclear development facilities, which experts currently number around ninety. If they so desire, the Iranian government may even have the opportunity to buy a nuclear weapon wholesale. After all, upwards of 40,000 Soviet-era nuclear weapons are housed in poorly secured facilities, and Graham Allison, a Harvard nuclear proliferation expert and former Department of Defense official, has noted North Korea’s potential to become “a sort of Nukes ‘R’ Us.” If (or rather when) Iran takes a seat at the table of nuclear powers, the political climate in the Middle East will change significantly for the worse. Armed with nuclear weap-
14
25th Anniversary Edition
ons, Iran will have less incentive to cease its support of terrorist organizations like Hezbollah and move toward peace with Israel. Additionally, if Iran acquires nuclear weapons, it is very likely that a domino effect will occur, with other countries in the Middle East, such as Saudi Arabia and Egypt, suddenly wishing to obtain weapons of their own. A nuclear Iran would have the potential to incite chaos within Iraq’s nascent and insecure government, and there is always the remote chance that the mullahs would put a nuke in the hands of terrorists.
If Iran Gets the Bomb
What does the US do if Iran gets nuclear weapons? That’s the million-dollar question. The $64,000 answer—the best the US will be able to do for now—is to follow a policy of deterrence and supplement it with containment. “We try to deal with the problem as we did with a much more serious enemy [the USSR] for a much longer time, and that is through deterrence,” said Richard Betts, Professor of War and Peace Studies at Columbia University. “We make it clear to Iran that if they use those weapons against us or our friends, retaliation will be devastating and they will wish they
hadn’t.” A comprehensive policy of deterrence would include extensive multilateral diplomacy, a clear articulation of what actions would trigger an American military response, an increase in ground intelligence, and possibly continued sanctions. With regard to allies, the Bush Administration would have to garner more support than it did with Iraq. While it must lead the effort to deter and contain a nuclear-armed Iran, the US cannot afford to allow the Europeans to sit on the sidelines. The Bush Administration, however, lost much of its credibility after the WMD faux pas in Iraq and it could be difficult to construct a unified US-EU policy toward a nuclear Iran. But this sort of policy would be absolutely necessary. “We must never allow these [small nuclear states] to get into a large-scale nuclear-armed coalition. Clearly the coalition dynamic is a game you have to play. Allies cannot just depend on [the US] without contributing,” said Baker Spring, the F.M. Kirby Research Fellow in National Security Policy at the Heritage Foundation. “The greatest source of security for lesser powers that are friends and allies of the US is the US security guarantee.” Iran is a radical state with a radical
Article from the Archive
E BRINK government that has been known to support terrorist groups in the past, and adding nuclear weapons to its long list of undesirables isn’t going to be something to celebrate. Yet that doesn’t mean it will be an out-andout nightmare. “It’s not the end of the world,” said Robert Jervis, the Adlai E. Stevenson Professor of Political Science at Columbia University. “A lot of countries have gotten powerful weapons. They are much better for deterrence than for offense. While I would prefer Iran not to have nuclear weapons, I think what Iran will be able to do with them is quite limited. They’ll be able to deter an attack from the US, and deter an attack from Iraq.” Henry Sokolski, the Director of the Nonproliferation Policy Education Center, agreed: “Even if Iran gets nuclear weapons, it may not lead to nuclear or total war.” As an alternative to invasion or bombing, he envisions the US and its allies containing Iran as the US did the Soviet Union. “If the Iranian government won’t change immediately, I am a proponent of competition. Look at the Cold War. The fact is that we kept up the pressure, didn’t go to war, and eventually the regime gave way.”
How Does the US Prevent Iran from Going Nuclear?
As of now, Iran is not a nuclear power, and it may be possible for the US to prevent it from becoming one. Most would like to see the US tackle Iran diplomatically, but what, exactly, is the most viable diplomatic approach? In his book The Persian Puzzle, the Brookings Institution’s Kenneth Pollack suggested a mixed-bag policy that includes carrots- and-sticks, containment, and a strong willingness on behalf of the US to strike a bargain. Working with its European allies, the US would employ loans and liberalized trade on the “carrots” side, compounded with sanctions on the “sticks” side. The US must be willing to provide Iran with significant “benchmark” rewards for progress made; that is, the US shouldn’t expect the world in exchange for a pittance. And the US has a lot to bargain with. Sanctions currently cripple a good portion of Iran’s economy, and disputes over formerly frozen assets constantly arise between the US and Iran. The US could support Iran’s efforts to become a member of the World Trade Organization. As Pollack pointed out, if the US were to ensure the shutdown of Iran’s nucle-
ar program, the Bush Administration should even be willing to provide it with bilateral economic assistance. Although Condoleezza Rice met with European leaders in February, the US has not taken a leadership role in the allied French, German and British effort to strike a disarmament deal with Iran. In addition, the Bush Administration has yet to rule out the possibility of American military action against Iran—a possibility that some analysts deem an impending reality. The US military could launch a preemptive strike on Iranian nuclear development facilities. However, a preemptive strike would inevitably fail to cover every Iranian nuclear development site, as Iranians have taken great pains to conceal their nuclear development facilities. As Betts pointed out, “Even if you mount a successful disarming attack, you have to face the question of what you do when they rebuild the capacity, and haven’t you given them additional incentives to strike at you?” In January, Vice President Dick Cheney suggested that Israel might take preemptive action before Iran obtains nuclear weapons. This would be similar to the 1981 bombing of Osirak, during which Israel carried
15
Columbia Political Review
out a raid on Iraq’s emerging nuclear development plants. “We do have the capabilities to pose a credible military threat. Israel looks like the most attractive option,” said Allison. That said, a number of experts have disputed the purported success of the 1981 Osirak raid and thus have called into question the effectiveness of an Israeli attack on Iran. “New analysis suggests Osirak actually pushed Iraq into new and better ways of creating nuclear weapons,” said Jervis. Betts agreed. “I do not think the Israeli attack on Osirak was an unqualified success.” He added, “If the Israelis do it, the Americans are going to get blamed for it. It inflames the region. It increases all of the incentives that have grown, recently anyway, for Muslims to see the United States as an enemy.” But, while military action against Iran has serious limitations, many experts have not ruled out the pos-
16
25th Anniversary Edition
sibility that the Bush Administration may go ahead and strike, or even invade and occupy Iran. Of course, a long-term military occupation—déjà vu, anyone?— would pose problems of its own. “If you invade the country and sit on it,” said Betts, “then they can’t do anything, but then the question is, how long are you going to stay? In Iraq, one thing people haven’t faced is that once we leave, we have no automatic assurance that the new Iraqi government won’t have an interest in getting weapons of mass destruction. So what are we going to do if a quasi-democratic Iraq starts a nuclear program? Are we going to invade it all over again?” Some see internal regime change as a possible alternative to military action. Abbas Milani of the Hoover Institution thinks that, if the US were to enter into a serious dialogue with the Iranian people about democracy, the prospect of regime change from within Iran’s boundaries is very pos-
sible. Milani does not suggest that the US “pour money” into the democratic cause or force democratization militarily, but rather that the US should allow cultural exchanges, and set in place radio and television programs geared toward fostering a discussion of democracy within Iran. Betts, among others, takes issue with Milani’s claim. “The more actively we try [to foster regime change], probably the more counter-productive the efforts will be, because it will validate the charges of the Iranian zealots that the Americans are trying to interfere in their country.” And, once again, there’s no guarantee a new regime wouldn’t try to go nuclear. So, other than a combination of carrots, sticks, cooperation, and hope, what can the US do about Iran? According to Pollack, not much. “How to handle Iran and, in particular, its pursuit of nuclear weapons is a problem from Hell,” he wrote. “There simply is no school solution.”
Article from the Archive
an article from the archive
“FAILURE WILL BE DEVASTATING”
AN INTERVIEW WITH SECRETARY-GENERAL ANTÓNIO GUTERRES DECEMBER 30, 2020 BY ADITYA SHARMA
António Guterres is the Secretary-General of the United Nations. Elected to succeed Ban Ki-moon in 2017, his tenure has been marked by the COVID-19 pandemic, the war in Syria, and the battle against climate change, among other major international crises. Before taking the top job at the U.N., he served as the organization’s High Commissioner for Refugees and spent seven years as the Prime Minister of Portugal. On December 2, hours after his speech at Columbia’s World Leaders Forum, I spoke to Mr. Guterres in an exclusive interview for the Columbia Political Review. We discussed the international response to COVID-19, the global battle against climate change, and how to shore up multilateralism, among other pressing topics.
Your speech this morning mostly focused on the dangers of climate change. Columbia has recently announced the launch of a new climate school, and climate issues are very important to our students here. What role do you see for universities and university students in the climate battle?
One of the key aspects of successfully fighting climate change is to make sure that science is respected, and a lot of universities have been essential in providing the adequate science that has allowed those who are committed to fighting to do it the right way. I do believe that universities have a double role: on one hand, to provide the science that is needed
for us to be able to adopt the right strategies and the right measures and policies related to climate change; and secondly, to put pressure on governments, local authorities, and business to decarbonize for us to be able to reach the end of this century with not more than 1.5 degrees Celsius of temperature growth.
17
Columbia Political Review COP26, the next U.N. climate summit, will meet in Glasgow in less than a year. What are your hopes for the summit? Are there concrete measures you hope will come out of it? I hope that even before the summit presents a so-called Nationally-Determined Contribution, in relation to climate action, that are in line with what the scientific community tells us, which means a reduction of emissions in the next decade corresponding to 45% of the levels that existed in 2010, and pointing to zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050. As the flip-side, we hope that the COP will finally be able to come to an agreement on the implementation of Article 6 of the Paris Agreement (on carbon markets), and at the same time that there will be a strong impulse in relation to more ambition in finance, for the commitments made in Paris to be respected, and for a massive mobilization in both public and private funding.
18
25th Anniversary Edition
You have praised the European Union as being a model for climate measures, particularly its European Green Deal and Next Generation E.U. initiatives. Its member states, however, are among the world’s wealthiest countries, and the cost of the entire package comes to some €1.85 trillion. As you said in your speech earlier today, the world’s poorer countries are also the most vulnerable to the effects of climate change. What can developing countries do to sustainably pursue a similar path? First of all, it’s very important what the European Union is doing in relation to its own efforts in mitigation, and its commitment to net-zero [emissions] and its measures to get there. But it’s also very important that all countries, including the European ones, are able to meet the commitments made in Paris, namely to mobilize $100 billion from public and private sources to support developing countries in both mitigation and adaptation. Developing countries must do as much as possible not to repeat the mistakes that developed countries have [made] in the past. It is necessary to bet on economic growth, on job creation, on energy being accessible to everybody, on [the] eradication of poverty. But today, it is proven that the most efficient and cheapest way is with a green strategy, is renewable energies, is not going on investing in what will be, in the near future, stranded assets in which a lot of money could be wasted today. So, developing countries must learn from the mistakes made in the past by developed countries and adopt a development strategy that is green and in line with the objectives of climate action.
You began a recent article by declaring: “COVID-19 is a test of international cooperation—and it is a test the world is failing.” Despite some of the successes of the W.H.O.’s COVAX initiative, multiple countries have turned inwards, practicing a sort of “vaccine nationalism.” Is there a solution to this isolationism? In what way can the international community continue to encourage a joint handling of COVID-19 and future pandemics? If COVID-19 has taught us a lesson, it is that a world in disunity and largely in disarray, with each country having its own strategy without any effective coordination of the different actions to contain the pandemic, makes the virus move from east to west, from north to south, in a first wave, second wave, probably third wave. [This] means that approaches based on inward-looking visions by governments, or on populism, have largely failed. What we need is effective international cooperation, what we need is for the recommendations of the World Health Organization to be followed, and what we need is the capacity to mobilize now the resources to make sure that the vaccines that start becoming available will be treated as global public goods, for the globe, and accessible everywhere, because that is the only way to eradicate the disease.
Article from the Archive If, as you say, countries are failing to engage with one another properly on pandemic respvonse, it does not augur well for the fight against climate change. How would you characterize the current level of climate cooperation among the international community? Well, we are still far from where we need to be, but I hope that we learn lessons from the failures of global disunity. The negative consequences that disunity caused, in relation to the containment of the pandemic, will force states to understand that it’s time to come together and to adopt a multilateral approach to climate action. If we do not learn our lesson from what has happened with Covid, [we] would be doing something very stupid. Technology and data have risen to prominence as the major national-security worry for many countries. A number of Western countries have banned Chinese telecoms firms from their networks, and the flow of data and technology between countries is increasingly constrained. The U.N. has recently launched a Cybersecurity and New Technologies programme: what effect do you hope this will have on the international cybersecurity landscape? This is something that, I believe, needs a very strong spirit of negotiation and compromise. There are conflicting interests, there are natural concerns in many countries about what other countries are doing. But my belief is that we cannot move to a world divided into two, with two economies, two dominant currencies, two internets, two competing strategies on artificial intelligence. I think we need to create conditions for compromise, for trust to be re-established, and for good practices to be followed, in order to be able to have a common commitment for the world to guarantee that [such] technologies become a force for good, and that their negative impacts can be avoided.
COVID-19 was only the latest salvo to batter international institutions, following the rise of a number of isolationist national leaders in recent years. This is coupled with structural problems: you recently said that the U.N.’s “present architecture is in many aspects outdated.” What reforms are needed to ensure that the organization remains effective and relevant despite the threats it faces? Well, we have done a lot in order to increase the efficiency of the secretariat, in order to improve coordination between the different agencies, but there is a basic question of rigidly pushing up power within the international system. The institutions that we have, the U.N., the Bretton-Woods system, and others were made after the Second World War, and they correspond to the world at that time. If you look at the Security Council or the I.M.F. or the World Bank, if you look at the composition, the voting power, they correspond to a world that no longer exists. And so, it would be important for the international institutions to adapt, and to do the reforms necessary to reflect what the world is [like] today.
More generally, in your view, how vulnerable are multilateral institutions at a time when globalization seems to be in reverse? For our part, what can students do to help strengthen multilateralism? Multilateral institutions are obviously vulnerable, in the sense that we do not have a global government system, and much less a democratic global government system. A lot of multilateral institutions have no real powers; they have the capacity to raise their voices, they have some convening capacity, but they have no real power. If you look at COVID-19, the World Health Organization could make recommendations to member states, but member states went on doing whatever they wanted. So, we need a multilateral vision that is more networked, more inclusive, to reflect the voices of society and the youth, [and] of the business community. We need a multilateral system that has teeth, and an appetite to bite whenever necessary in order to guarantee that we have a global governance that the challenges we face in today’s world require. I believe that the youth will have the capacity to avoid the mistakes of my generation, and will understand that either we are together, or—in a world in which the challenges are global— we will fail. Failure will be devastating for the planet.
19
LEFT G N G I G N I N G A H N A T F H E L
Columbia Political Review
APRIL 30, 2005 BY BENJAMIN LEVITAN
I
f a donkey brays in the woods, but nobody hears it, does it make a sound? Democrats must wonder. And what makes them all the more ignorant is that donkeys aren’t normally found in the woods. In the elections of 1954, the Democratic Party gained control of the House of Representatives and the Senate. It was not to lose control of either chamber until 1980, and, even then, it held onto the House, Senate, or presidency for the next twenty years. One Republican senator’s renunciation of his party then threw the Senate back into Democratic hands, but it was not to last. For the past twoand- a-half years, the Democrats have found themselves disempowered, and they can’t figure out what to do. When they were last in this situation, during the first two years of the Eisenhower Administration, television was only beginning to establish itself as a tool for political communication. Since then, the personalization of politics in the press has grown to make the Democrats’ current problem as bad as possible. The media aren’t biased against liberals; rather, liberals need to learn how to use the media. The most clear-cut illustration of this personalization is the increased focus on the presidency that television heralded. “Before 1963 and the advent of thirty-minute, picture-driv-
20
25th Anniversary Edition
en television news, Congress and the presidency got about equal coverage,” said Thomas Patterson, Bradlee Professor of Government at Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government. “As television whetted the appetite for news about presidents, newspapers followed along, so for both of them now, on average, it’s pretty close to two to one, presidency news versus congressional news.” The trend has larger implications than what citizens see each night on the news; it also affects how they view government as a whole. “Most Americans think that the presidency is the heart of the system,” said Patterson, “even though, if you look at the Constitution, that’s not true.” “It’s just much easier to think of the government run by the president than it is to think of the government run by the president and the courts and the two houses of Congress,” said Marion Just, Professor of Political Science at Wellesley College and Research Associate of the Joan Shorenstein Center on Press, Politics, and Public Policy at the Kennedy School; “[The president is] one person, you get to know him as a person, he has a wife, he has a dog.” The wife is Laura. The dog is Barney. The president is George W. Bush, as seen on TV.
The Emergence of the TV President
The second half of 1963 is not easy to forget. Alabama Governor George Wallace was shutting down schools in Alabama to prevent integration. Black protesters were being sup-
pressed with clubs and tear gas in Louisiana. American “advisers” were in the early stages of being slaughtered in Vietnam. President John F. Kennedy was assassinated in Dallas. It’s no wonder that CBS’s extension of its evening news broadcast from fifteen minutes to thirty minutes doesn’t show up in most high school history textbooks. But, in terms of its influence on American politics— or, rather, the influence of the trend it foretold—it’s every bit as worthy of attention. Television producers were immediately aware that longer broadcasts allowed for more personal interaction with newsworthy figures: the main feature on the first extended news broadcast was an interview with President Kennedy. A week later, when NBC extended its broadcast, too, whom did they decide to interview? JFK. There were no flashy or fantastic effects when Walter Cronkite, reading from a paper on his desk, welcomed America to the first ever half-hour nightly news broadcast. His Kennedy interview began almost immediately, delayed only by the brief, obligatory recitation of major headlines. The camera captured Cronkite and Kennedy sitting awkwardly on the beach in front of Kennedy’s “Summer White House” (somehow even harder to take seriously than Bush’s “working holidays” at his Texas ranch) in Hyannis Port, Massachusetts. The most striking part of the interview for anyone under the age of fifty is how uncomfortable both men looked, but it’s more evident, surprisingly, in the famously telegenic Kennedy. He slouched in his chair, his left shoulder slanting out of the frame
Article from the Archive
rchive a e h t le from an artic of the camera. He spent much of the time looking down, and a wide view showed him picking something off of his pants. Occasionally, between sentences, the camera would present them from behind, showing both men with the ocean in front of them. This was Cronkite’s first question: “How seriously do you think this civil rights situation is going to affect your chances, assuming you’ll be the nominee of the Democratic Party next year, in 1964?” Kennedy’s answer, notable more for length than for content, endured uninterrupted for one minute and fifty seconds, and that was merely the first of many questions. (That doesn’t compare, though, with the three minutes and eleven seconds of footage that would be shown later in the broadcast of the Tokyo production of “My Fair Lady,” which took thirty minutes longer to perform than the Broadway version “because,” the correspondent explained, “it takes that much longer to say it in Japanese.”) In other answers, Kennedy touched on the economy— we need a tax cut because of “the lift it would give the economy, the assurance it would give us against another recession” (take that, Democrats!)— and Vietnam—“I know people don’t like Americans to be engaged in this kind of an effort, 47 Americans have been killed in combat with the enemy.” But one’s lasting impression is of the interview’s pace, informal and measured. If the relaxed quality of such interviews was not to last, the fascination with the presidency surely was. The next day, The New York Times published this assessment of the broadcast: “The C.B.S. News Department could hardly have picked a more difficult evening to introduce the ad-
vantages of having a half-hour rather than 15 minutes to cover the news. The Labor Day Weekend is traditionally barren of hard developments in journalism and C.B.S. had to do a bit of padding.” It’s an astounding review, considering what was happening in Alabama and Louisiana at that very moment. Plus, travel that weekend was the deadliest in Labor Day’s history; one automobile collision in Texas killed nine people. The next day, the federal minimum wage was to rise a dime to $1.25 an hour, but that news was glossed over in bulletin form. Late in the broadcast, Cronkite offered a one-line “post-script” to the integration story, saying that the school board in Alabama, rather than defy the Governor’s orders by opening schools Tuesday, would wait until Friday. If that was a weekend “barren of hard developments,” then today’s world is comparatively unexciting. But 24-hour cable channels have somehow, thank heavens, found a way to fill the time without ever resorting to padding.
The American Civil-Uncivil War
When Jon Stewart of Comedy Central’s “The Daily Show” was a guest on CNN’s “Crossfire” last October, he explained his decision to appear this way: “I made a special effort to come on this show today because I have, privately, amongst my friends, and also in occasional newspapers and television shows, mentioned this show as being bad. I thought that that wasn’t fair and I should come here and tell you, I don’t—it’s not so much that it’s bad as it’s hurting America.” The main difference between “The Daily Show” and “Crossfire,” Stewart explained, aside from one’s being a comedy show and the other’s being, um, something else, is that “we
[at “The Daily Show”] have civilized discourse.” Stewart inadvertently illustrated his point about incivility by telling “Crossfire” co-host Tucker Carlson, “You’re as big a dick on your show as you are on any show.” The contrast between current debate shows and early news broadcasts is stark, but the trajectory from one to the other is fairly straightforward. When an audience watches the news, it seeks a personal connection with not only the subjects of the stories but also the news anchors delivering the information. It’s true more with television than with radio and much more true with television than with newspapers. Perhaps that’s why, since the early sixties, survey respondents have been more likely to trust the television than the newspaper, should facts presented by the two media conflict. That had been true of radio, too. In a 1941 Roper poll, 38 percent of respondents said that radio provided “more accurate” war news, compared to 21 percent who said the same of newspapers. ABC was a latecomer to thirty-minute nightly news, introducing it four years after its competitors, and even then its ratings suffered. What followed is spelled out clearly in Eric Alterman’s Sound and Fury: The Making of the Punditocracy. Like other networks, ABC featured nightly commentaries on the news, but the men who delivered them changed from night to night, and, though audiences liked the concept, they wanted consistency—they wanted news stars. So the network chose a liberal and a conservative to appear together every night, anointing them television’s first daily pundits. The arrangement was short-lived—the news department was uneasy about having commentaries by people who had no previously unreleased information. But the concept had been created, and the next year, “Agron21
Columbia Political Review sky & Company,” starring opinionated journalists, debuted on CBS. It was what Alterman called a “pundit sitcom” with stock characters, each having a well-defined and predictable pattern of thought and speech, who were encouraged to become impassioned. It remained on the air for eighteen years. By the time its run ended, “Agronsky & Company” had spawned modified imitations, the most notable of which was “The McLaughlin Group,” which arose in 1983. Rarely, Alterman noted, had any show “eliminated the politician and allowed journalists to question one another.” Moreover, “some panelists were only nominally journalists.” The show preserved the idea of stock characters; moreover, panelists would scream over one another, and the content of the show changed with the host’s whim. In other words, “The McLaughlin Group” was a show that needed only flashier graphics and more attractive panelists to look completely modern ( incidentally, both the graphics and the attractive panelists are still missing). Television in this format has grown in prominence for several reasons, not the least of which is its cost-effectiveness. The other is the tendency of the media to play up conflict, a tactic offering a bounty of benefits to reporters and producers. In her book Common Knowledge, Just, along with co-authors, lays out the various frames through which people view the news. Someone watching a story about Social Security through an economic frame, for example, might have a different reaction from someone watching the identical story through a human impact frame. The frame that the media have found most accessible, though,
22
25th Anniversary Edition
is the conflict frame. Although people can understand even complicated issues, like Social Security, that affect them personally, Just said, “if you start to say to people, ‘private accounts, invest this, invest that,’ a little bit of the ‘My eyes glaze over’ starts to take effect.” Certain economic issues are presented especially poorly in the media because, she speculated, “I think most journalists don’t understand numbers.” Where comprehension ends, conflict begins. Journalists turn to conflict not only because it gets people’s attention but also because it allows them to report about issues that they don’t actually understand. They can present a fight rather than a discussion of economic policy. Consider pundits on television debate shows who talk about the economy, the military, social issues, and more, all in one night. Then, imagine the ramifications if they were expected to understand what they talked about. Another reason for how common these shows have become is that the news now competes for ratings with entertainment, not just other news shows, and conflict is entertaining. When debate is presented with too much insolence, however, it can have serious effects on the way that people view their government. The February 2005 issue of the American Political Science Review contains an article by Diana C. Mutz and Byron Reeves called “The New Videomalaise: Effects of Televised Incivility on Political Trust.” The authors conducted an experiment in which they exposed subjects to televised debate, some civil, some uncivil, and tested their impressions
afterwards. They argued that, while political incivility hasn’t necessarily increased in recent decades, television exposes people to incivility more often and more intimately. “We propose,” they wrote, “this means that people expect political actors who appear on television to abide by the same social norms acknowledged by ordinary Americans.… We hypothesize that when political actors violate interpersonal social norms on television, viewers react as they would if they were witnessing the same interaction in real life.” What they found is that, when exposed to a high level of incivility, viewers have less trust in proponents of the opposing view. “I find that attitudes toward the side that you are on, that you agree with, are not harmed at all by them being expressed in an uncivil fashion,” said Mutz, Samuel A. Stouffer Professor of Political Science and Communication at the University of Pennsylvania. “But your attitude toward the opposition, the other side, does become delegitimized when they express preferences in that way.” The problem is that it’s that very same uncivil discourse that attracts the most attention. Mutz said, “I paid a professional editor to edit these shots together for me—they were done on a talk-show set, and so forth—and, I mean, even he thought the civil versions were incredibly boring. He’s like, ‘God, I’m gonna fall asleep editing these.’” Jon Stewart, in his “Crossfire” appearance, expressed a central dilemma of the news media:
Article from the Archive “I watch your show every day, and it kills me. Oh, it’s so painful to watch.” One wonders why he watches “Crossfire” every day—surely, he could have others scan it for “Daily Show” fodder—if it causes so much pain. One could wonder, with academic detachment, why people watch uncivil shows at all, but such shows nonetheless routinely grab more viewers than civil ones do. “Politics is not that intrinsically interesting to most people,” said Mutz, providing a likely explanation, “but watching the drama of human conflict can be interesting even if you’re not that interested in politics.” A discussion about Medicare might not enthrall anyone, but if Mr. Liberal is about to kill Mr. Conservative over it, right there on the television screen, who could look away? Whatever happens to be the topic of discussion is secondary to the human conflict between the pundits. But there’s a problem, even aside from losing trust in an uncivil talking head. Mutz and Reeves found that the civility of the conflict affects the extent to which viewers retain information. “We found no difference in the extent to which people felt they were informed by the program,” Mutz said, but “there is a difference in the level of information they retain. They don’t remember much of anything about the other side except how mad they were” after viewing uncivil discourse.
Fighting for Attention
Imagine being a Democrat in Congress, with no access to the White House Press Corps and, as the minority in both the House and the Senate, no ability to call hearings. Your problem isn’t that the media will completely ignore your party; rather, it’s that you’re likely to be portrayed from the standpoint of conflict. “[Democrats] are relegated to being the other voice, you know, the responding voice, for the most part, in the news,” said Patterson. “Journalists seek that voice out; they like the conflict, so it’s not as if they’re going to ignore these people, but it’s a pretty weak media platform.” The most convenient way for Democrats to garner media attention is to appear on TV debate shows, which thrive on an atmosphere of hostility. It’s convenient because shows like those need two opposing sides, which, in the narrow confines of TV talk, usually means plucking guests from different points on the liberalconservative spectrum. Thus, Democrats are invited without having to push through major legislation. Inevitably, that applies only when those shows invite politicians in the first place, rather than rely on their regular hosts. Even when guests are invited, hosts remain in control and make conflict impossible to avoid. On shows like “Crossfire” and Fox News’s
“The O’Reilly Factor,” if the guest remains steadfastly calm, the host(s) will pick up the slack and get angry. A causal relationship between the rise of constant television news and negative reporting on politics is only arguable, but a correlation is evident. Referring to the press playing up “the underside of politics,” Patterson said, “It got regularly worse as you went through the sixties to the late eighties. And certainly the tip of that iceberg is in the nineties with the coverage of the Clinton presidency.” When asked how much negative coverage affects the way that the public views its leaders, he said that “about half of the presidential nominees over the last 25 years or so, by the end of the campaign, have had a negative image or nearly. To go back and look at the early years of the Gallup Poll, there’s one out there in the first thirty years or so—Barry Goldwater.” Surveys have shown that people hold seemingly contradictory opinions about conflict in government. At the beginning of 1977, when Democrats reoccupied the White House and still maintained their congressional monopoly, several polls asked citizens about the implications of one-party rule. A Roper poll asked whether respondents thought that it’s “better to have one political party
23
Columbia Political Review
in control of both Congress and the White House, or that it is better to have opposite parties in control of the two branches?” Forty-eight percent of respondents preferred two-party rule, while only 36 percent chose one-party. A CBS News/New York Times poll from January of that year asked, “Do you think the government will work better now that the President and the majority of Congress both belong to the same political party, or don’t you think it will work better?” In this case, 75 percent said that the government would “work better” under the new conditions, and only fifteen percent disagreed. That 75 percent figure dropped dramatically by April, after Congress and the President had been forced to work together for a few months, but people still said the government worked better under one party-rule by a ratio of almost two to one. A possible explanation is that most Americans have some understanding of the balance of power among the branches of government, and, at least in principle, they approve. But “Americans don’t like to see conflict in Washington,” said Just. “They would like people to have their best interests at heart, and they imagine that those are unitary. You know, ‘Do what’s best for us, and don’t argue about it. Don’t seek political gain, 24
25th Anniversary Edition
just go ahead and do that one thing that’s going to make things better.’” So Democrats who secure public attention by creating conflict might also secure public ire. This could relate back to Mutz’s study about civility in government. The same people who understand that conflict is necessary react negatively when it’s presented to them in an in-your-face fashion. That type of conflict increases the public’s irritation with politicians because the opposing side appears to look increasingly ridiculous and, perhaps more damningly, groundless. Much fuss has been made recently about the rising levels of polarization in national politics, and Mutz believes that conflicts played out on television in a confrontational manner may contribute to that. “It’s a polarizing influence because both sides come to see the other side as less legitimate,” she said. “The chances for compromise and that sort of thing become less and less because both sides become convinced that the people on the other side are just a bunch of idiots… so it works against a politics of compromise.” Not that there’s anything wrong with a refusal to compromise, unless you’re in the inopportune position of having very little political power, as Democrats seem to be.
What’s a Democrat to Do?
One disappointing feature that has accompanied the rise of uncivil discourse on television has been the decline of investigative journalism. Journalists rely increasingly on news releases that come directly from government sources, rather than digging for news on their own. During the first Persian Gulf War, over half of the lead stories on evening news broadcasts could be traced back to the White House, State Department, or Pentagon, all of which fall under the Executive Branch. Thus, when liberals accuse conservative commentators of inanely rehashing government talking points, they’re right to do so; that’s the job of real journalists. A former New York Times White House correspondent once said, “I’ve had stories on page one just because the president burped” (which further reinforces the idea that Republicans need not worry that their agenda will be disseminated widely). A main problem with less investigative journalism— and one that relates to uncivil discourse— is that the media commonly report what is said, not what is happening. If two opposing sides dispute whether a statement is true or false, the media might cover the disagreement but not say who is right, either to prevent the illusion of bias or to avoid doing more work. What this means for Democrats is that their side of issues will not au-
Article from the Archive
tomatically be depicted in the media—they have to speak up, which is harder than it may appear. A major impediment to that is their minority status in both houses of Congress, meaning that they cannot call a hearing on any issue. Not only are hearings sure to draw attention to a cause, but they present that cause in a way that is usually civilized, without forcing Democrats to speak too harshly. “The nice thing about hearings, very much like the nice thing about the 9/11 Commission,” said Patterson, “is that it allows you to call people and have other voices, and then in some ways, what you’re doing is, you’re merely shedding the light.” Given their minority status, there is only one way besides conflict to ensure coverage, maybe even positive coverage, in the media: personality. Once Democrats figure out what they want to say, they’ll need to find someone who can say it. That person needs to reach out, through the media, at a personal level. “My more recent research is on emotional connection between candidates and the public,” said Just, “and I do think that’s what the Democrats were lacking the last two [presidential elections].” As of when this magazine went to press, the Democrats had not rallied enthusiastically around any national figure. They were fond of Sen. John Kerry when he ran for president, but the hollowness of their affection became evident immediately after the
election, when Kerry dropped from view. Sen. Barack Obama of Illinois is popular and articulate but has served in national office for fewer than four months and, as a junior senator, is abiding by the rules of propriety and keeping quiet. Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid has institutional authority but has yet to prove his ability to reignite the party. Sen. Ted Kennedy of Massachusetts is well-known but is perceived as perhaps too liberal and is certainly not part of the party’s future: he has served in the Senate continuously since before the advent of thirty-minute nightly news broadcasts. Plus, the second picture on the biography page of his website shows him shaking hands with a dog. Whom does that leave? The options are slim. “You can see [New York Sen.] Hillary Clinton coming up into view in that way,” said Patterson. “She’s getting pretty good press right now, and she’s getting quite a lot of it.…I suppose, right now, she’s probably the one who predictably could speak out on an issue in the name of the party and get attention.” Aside from being well-known, Clinton is unquestionably the senator—from either party—with the most famous family (well, living family; sorry, Teddy), which helps to humanize her against the backdrop of Congress as an institution. Not to mention that her husband was the last Democrat who connected to the public in the way that none of them can today. It goes without saying that Clin-
ton has her drawbacks, and this article is far from an endorsement of her. But if she or any other Democrat can make a personal connection with voters, then Democrats should be prepared to accept it. In the name of party unity, high-level Democrats are currently working out the kinks in their message and contemplating the nuances of how much room there is for dissent and public opinion. All of that work, though, is futile without an ambassador to the public, and it might be he—or she—who ultimately is empowered to decide the message of the party. If it seems undemocratic to let a single figure, chosen by likeability, determine a party’s message, bear in mind that Democratic officials are presently crafting that message based largely on what they think would win the most votes. It’s democratic, if not pretty, either way, as long as the person or the platform has public support. Currently, though, the Democrats with the most institutional power lack national popular appeal. It might soon be time for the party to see if it can rise to the challenge that it has often bestowed upon others: let the popular displace the powerful. Then the media might start to pay attention.
25
Columbia Political Review
AN INTERVIEW WITH 2008-2009 PUBLISHER,
SAJAA AHMED WITH 2024-2026 COLUMNIST,
ISHAAN BARRETT WITH 2021 PUBLISHER,
RACHEL BARKIN INTERVIEWED BY PARINI RAO, FORMER MANAGING EDITOR OF INTERVIEWS
WHAT FIRST DREW YOU TO CPR? SAJAA: Moving to NYC from suburban New Jersey as a first-year student was a culture shock. Finding where I fit took well into my sophomore year when I decided not to pursue pre-med, freeing me to imagine life outside of STEM. My love of writing, combined with relentless procrastination and Libra indecision, immediately ruled out the daily routine of Spec (and very nearly prevented me from submitting these responses). I had been enamored with magazines since childhood, viewing physical media and short form writing the most difficult of any; it was a sign you had made it and then people made art or selected it to go with your writing, and I wanted to make “it” though I still wonder what that means or looks like. 26
25th Anniversary Edition
ISHAAN: Before I began writing for CPR, I spent a few semesters writing for the Spectator focusing on architectural criticism. My first piece for them covered the recent closure of Columbia’s main gates back in October 2023. Back then, my work discussed the intersection between architecture and politics on campus, but leveraged a focus on politics in the background. I wanted to write more clearly, critically, and openly about politics. I felt CPR was the place to start doing that and learn from a group of peers who cared deeply about getting better at political writing. RACHEL: My best friend Ellie saw that CPR posted in a Facebook group for Columbia College about joining, and Ellie sent it to me, and she knew that I really liked writing and writing
about politics. So she sent it to me, and we applied together. And during the interview, I could tell that they were really invested in their members, and that they were really looking to to mentor people and improve their writing and help them find their find their writing voice. And so, after they gave me an offer, I was really excited to accept. And my best friend, Ellie, also accepted, so it was really exciting our freshman year to be able to join together and both find our writing voices and write really interesting articles.
WHAT ROLE DOES CPR SERVE FOR STUDENTS AS AN UNDERGRADUATE PUBLICATION? SAJAA: It provides a space for collaborative exploration and political
Alumni Interview team-building across diverse viewpoints, an environment once celebrated in disciplines where CPR and CPU alumni now lead. As a free, physical publication, distribution days to all the residence halls were a highlight and likely served as the precursor to my later work canvassing my community as an organizer in local politics. ISHAAN: I think CPR is unique for two reasons. It encourages you to focus deeply on political topics and issues you care about, but exposes you to new ideas through deep discussion and collaboration with your peers. I spent my time at CPR focusing almost exclusively on executive power and the presidency. I developed clear criticisms and questions about the changing politics happening in the White House. But I also saw about the issues and ideas that were on the minds of my fellow writers. And I learned to have a stake in them by reading their work. I became a better writer and more rounded thinker because of it. RACHEL: I’m sure other people might have different thoughts, but I really think it’s to hone students’ writing and editing skills. I think, of course, it’s important to accurately write about issues that are happening in the world and on campus. But I also think it’s equally important that the club recognizes its role in serving as an extracurricular. That is, I think, one of the most important extracurriculars to help people, especially those who maybe didn’t write a lot in high school, didn’t have those opportunities to join a school publication, and really help them become better writers and editors through the partnerships that editors and writers have together in the organization; that certainly was what happened for me. It definitely helped me immensely improve my writing and editing skills.
WHAT DID BEING PART OF CPR MEAN TO YOU IN COLLEGE, AND HOW HAS YOUR REFLECTION CHANGED? SAJAA: It created space for a thoughtful intersection of ideas while staying current. My era was pre-smartphone but early social media; we launched a certainly-now-defunct CUPolitics blog, our first Facebook group, and a Twitter account before I graduated in 2010 and still it was our “weekly roundup” email sent to our listserv (the same as a substack!) that was most impactful and had the widest readership. Experience with early Twitter prepared me to follow the Arab Spring in real-time when Twitter’s relevance shaped the course of immediate geopolitics, to create a viral account based on memes, and watch the platform fall to the depths of a pay-per-view, colonized legacy platform inhabited mainly by predators that rarely worth perusal. Reflecting on it now, I wonder where traditional readership of CPR fits in today’s influencer-driven political culture, where facts are consumed in 15-second soundbites. ISHAAN: Being in CPR meant a lot to me while I was in college. I enjoyed being part of a group of people who cared deeply about writing about politics, and doing that work as best as we possibly could. I think my perspective has remained the same. I look back on my time at CPR fondly because I became more articulate and clear about what I cared about and, at the end of the day, became better at communicating those cares with others. RACHEL: Yeah, I think that it really helped build my confidence as a writer and editor. I think it’s normal, especially when you’re starting undergrad with a lot of really smart people. It can you can feel really intimidated by everyone else, and I think writing,
receiving feedback, improving from that feedback really helped improve my confidence and led me to seek out other opportunities as well. And I think also something that was really amazing about the Columbia Political Review was the community that I had. I met so many impressive upperclassmen... and so to learn from them and also be in a community with them was was really rewarding because I was inspired by the career paths that they took. I was. They gave me advice, so it was a really supportive community, both professionally, academically, and socially.
HOW DID YOUR EXPERIENCES AT CPR HELP YOU THROUGHOUT YOUR CAREER OR MANIFEST? SAJAA: I initially envisioned a journalism career, but the 2007 fiscal crisis and the rise of the blogosphere signaled that traditional media was on its way out. Instead, I applied CPR’s core skill sets: teamwork, editing, and redlining to law school, litigation, and prosecution. Ultimately, it was most applicable to my local political organizing, whether mentoring youth on campaigns or learning from longtime Hudson Valley activists who have been organizing since the days of Pete Seeger and Vietnam: CPR and CPU enabled a group of diverse politically-minded youth to work with the teams of Senators, world leaders, and more, preparing me for the challenges of the evolving press, most recently serving as the Communications Director for a small District Attorney’s Office. ISHAAN: Today I work in technology consulting at a small firm in midtown. Being good at communicating ideas is super important, especially when you work directly with corporate clients. I think learning to formulate, critique, and defend ideas is a cornerstone of good problem solving. 27
Columbia Political Review The more you are able to examine an idea from multiple sides, the better you are at anticipating and solving for issues that might come up later. RACHEL: I think I learned that opinions can change, and so I wrote about a lot of things that I really cared about, and I did research on those topics. But I think it’s also important to be open to the fact that new information can change your mind. Not necessarily saying that I changed my mind on anything I wrote about, but I do think my views on those issues are more nuanced now, so I don’t know if that answers your question. But I think if I’m reflecting back on it, I would have still kept my passion about the issues, but with the understanding that you know issues are very nuanced and opinions and facts can change over time.
DURING YOUR TIME AT CPR, WHAT WAS YOUR “POLITICAL MOMENT”? HOW DID IT SHAPE CPR? SAJAA: While Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s campus address was the most glaring moment of my overall time at Columbia, the moment that truly shaped my CPR experience was our December 2008 issue featuring Bryan Lowder’s cover story Between the Trenches, addressing ROTC’s campus ban under “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” and cover art by Rebekah Kim entitled “Stars, Stripes, and Rainbows”. The campus community was in a heated debate after then-Senators McCain and Obama both called for ROTC’s return to campus before publication; there was much discussion about the cover art and whether it was overly sexual; serving as publisher and working with EIC Karen Leung on that issue is still one of my proudest accomplishments. It showed me that speech and art can highlight deep pain of marginalized groups, but they also open essential pathways to dialogue, institutional 28
25th Anniversary Edition
growth, and mutual understanding. ISHAAN: This question is super easy: it was the 2024 election. I think we had very little idea about what politics and the functioning of our government would look like when January 2025 rolled around. I remember hearing about the shuttering of USAID and the slashing of other federal programs like it. A parent of my friend from high school lost her job because of those funding cuts, and it ignited a deep fascination with executive politics that became my focus at CPR. RACHEL: I’m not sure if I had a political moment, but something that was really cool was that I would learn about certain political theories in class, and then things would happen in the world, and I would be able to directly apply the theories I learned in class to those political issues. That was something that only CPR could have offered for me, because it gave me a lot of space and discretion to write about what I wanted. A lot of things happened while I was in undergrad, and a way that I digested and understood things was through having that opportunity to write articles, to discuss with other people in CPR what they thought about those issues, and then refine my ideas based on those discussions.
HOW DO YOU SEE CPR CONTINUING ITS EVOLUTION IN AN ADAPTING MEDIA LANDSCAPE? SAJAA: In an era dominated by AI slop and personality-driven media, CPR’s commitment to pure, unmonetized free speech is vital. The Interviews feature is a fantastic addition that can help leaders and students grow. Adapting short-form vertical media without paywalls can draw today’s students back into meaningful dialogue and rigorous analysis and
hopefully one day everyone can shed their reliance on corporate institutions to control the narrative. ISHAAN: I have been enjoying CPR’s video interviews and posts on social media. There is a huge audience of students that use Instagram Reels and other platforms to get their news and to connect with other folks on campus. I see CPR continuing to invest time and resources in producing video content for social media, and I’m willing to bet that those commitments will pay off through higher views and engagement with CPR’s work writ large. RACHEL: Well, I’m sure you guys know more than me, but I still follow CPR on Instagram, and I like that you guys have been including more video format. I think videos grab people’s attention on social media. I don’t think that should replace long form writing because what’s most important is, in my opinion, is developing members’ writing and editing skills, not capturing people’s opinions per se. But I do think that those videos are a great idea, especially to promote awareness about political topics.
IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE YOU’D LIKE TO SHARE? SAJAA: CPR remains a rare, necessary proving ground for deliberate thought, reminding us that localized engagement and open discourse are the bedrock of lasting civic impact; my hope is it continues to attract the wayward political souls (but perhaps not the perpetually late) like me who still believe mutual compassion and democracy are possible. RACHEL: I think that Columbia Political Review, at least for me, was as important as the classes that I took in undergrad because of the ability to write about really complex topics and distill them in a digestible way for the public. I think that’s a really important skill, no matter what in-
Alumni Interview dustry you’re going in. I came into undergrad potentially with misconceptions about what good writing is. For example, I thought that good writing was using a lot of flowery language and impressive vocab, but now I think, especially with the help of my Columbia Political Review editors, I understand that good writing is clear, succinct, digestible for the public, and I think that’s something that you don’t necessarily always
learn in class, and so I think that I would definitely encourage people to join the Columbia Political Review. It was hands-down the best part of my undergrad experience. It helped me become a better writer and thinker. I was able to surround myself with really impressive people that I could learn from. It really pushed me to grow as a person. So, I definitely encourage it for all undergrads.
VISIT OUR WEBSITE FOR VIDEO INTERVIEWS WITH: 2010-2011 EDITOR-IN-CHIEF,
MARK HAY
& 2013 EDITOR-IN-CHIEF,
GEETIKA RUDRA WHAT FIRST DREW YOU TO CPR?
WHAT FIRST DREW YOU TO CPR?
MARK: Well, as far as what drew me to CPR, I was writing relatively prolifically for just about every Columbia publication at the time. I did not see myself going into media when I first got into Columbia, because even at the time that did not seem like the best plan for the future or plan for a career, but I was inexurably drawn towards it, and I was a double major in political science. So when I was encountering topics of interest to me within the realm of political science, I wanted an outlet for some of the thoughts that were flying through my head, and that led me to CPR.
GEETIKA: I always loved political magazines. Growing up I read Newsweek and the New York Times’ magazine, and I just like loved journalism and current affairs and so when I went to Columbia I knew I wanted to do something with student journalism... I just fell in love with I guess the format of the [Columbia] Political Review. Because we were publishing quarterly, we were very thoughtful and do very good like long form journalism...I really enjoyed being able to go deep and long on like certain topics. And then I also just loved the community.
29
HTTPS://WWW.CPREVIEW.ORG/