Skip to main content

Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF) Book

Page 1

FIRST TO

SHIELD, FIRST TO

FALL,

AND LAST TO

RECOVER:

THE

GREEN ASSESSMENT AND RECOVERY FRAMEWORK (GARF) BIODIVERSITY & ECOSYSTEM LOSS AND DAMAGE ASSESSMENT AND PLANNING FOR ECOSYSTEM RECOVERY AND RESILIENCE


FIRST TO SHIELD, FIRST TO FALL, AND LAST TO RECOVER:

THE GREEN ASSESSMENT AND RECOVERY FRAMEWORK (GARF)

Biodiversity & Ecosystem Loss and Damage Assessment and Planning for Ecosystem Recovery and Resilience

Editors: Neil Aldrin Mallari Jennica Paula Masigan

Developed by the Center for Conservation Innovations Ph Inc. (CCIPH) and the Philippine Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR), with support from the Government of Canada


ii |

Biodiversity & Ecosystem Loss and Damage Assessment and Planning for Ecosystem Recovery and Resilience

Contents Foreward . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

vi

Acknowledgement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

x

Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

01

Acronyms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

.

Part 1 The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework Making the Invisible Visible . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

06

The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework . . . . . . . . .

10

GARF in the Policy Landscape . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

22

Lessons from the Initial GARF Pilots . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

27

The Future of GARF . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

28

Part 2 GARF in Practice Across the Philippines

Mindoro scops owl (Otus mindorensis) © John Lister Bibar, CCIPH

NCR: A Greener Canopy in the La Mesa Watershed . . . . . . .

40

REGION I: Assessing Ecosystem Damage, Biodiversity, and Recovery Needs at Bessang Pass Natural Monument/Landmark . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

46

REGION II: Typhoon Egayʼs Impacts on Baggao Wildlife Sanctuary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

52

REGION III: Tracing Super Typhoon Kardingʼs Impact in Minalungao National Park . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

54

CAR: Mapping Potential Vegetation Change after Typhoon Emong in Calanasan, Apayao . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

58

CALABARZON: Vegetation Recovery in Mts. Palay-Palay– Mataas na Gulod Protected Landscape . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

63

MIMAROPA: What an Oil Spill Reveals about GARFʼs Limits .

66

REGION V: Biodiversity and Ecosystem Loss and Damage in Bicol Natural Park (BNP) Following Successive Tropical Cyclones in 2020 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

71

REGION V: Typhoon Disruptions on Unstable Slopes of Bulusan Volcano Natural Park . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

78

REGION VI: Typhoon Odette Stripped the Canopy of IlogHilabangan Watershed Forest Reserve . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

82


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

REGION VII: After Odette—Reading the Carood Watershed Landscape . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

| iii

88

REGION VIII: Panaon Island after Typhoon Odette—What GARF 93 Revealed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . REGION IX: Building a GARF Baseline for Pasonanca Natural Park . 99 ........................................................ REGION X: Assessing Typhoon Odetteʼs Impacts in Camiguin . . . . 104 ........................................................ REGION XI: Landslide Disturbance in Mainit Hot Spring Protected Landscape . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

111

REGION XII: Impacts of Severe Tropical Storm Paeng on Mount 116 Matutum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . REGION XIII: Post-Typhoon Ecological Assessment of the Dinagat 120 Islands Protected Landscape and Seascape . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Part 3 GARF Methods, Tools, and Analytical Approaches Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125 Stage 1 - Rapid Appraisal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

126

Defining the Hazard Footprint . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 126 Establishing Pre- and Post-Event Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 128 Identifying Reference Areas for Ground Validation . . . . . . . . . . . . .

134

Stage 2 – Post-Disaster Comprehensive Assessment . . . . . . . . . . . 135 Bringing the Maps to the Ground: Ground Validation of Detected 135 Changes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Land-Cover Classification and Change Assessment . . . . . . . . . . .

138

Rapid Biodiversity Assessment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

142

Stage 3 - Ecosystem Restoration and Resilience Planning . . . . . . . 154 Establishing a Coordinating Mechanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 155 Validating and Sharing Assessment Findings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 155 Determining Appropriate Restoration Strategies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 156 Examining Recovery Potential through Restoration Catalyst Plots . 160 Developing an Ecosystem Restoration and Resilience Plan . . . . . .

163 Philippine Eagle (Pithecophaga jefferyi) © John Lister Bibar, CCIPH


& Ecosystem Loss and Damage Assessment iv | Biodiversity and Planning for Ecosystem Recovery and Resilience

First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF): Assessing Biodiversity & Ecosystem Loss and Damage and Planning for Ecosystem Recovery and Resilience Published by: Center for Conservation Innovations Ph Inc. (CCIPH) 208 Civic Prime Building, Civic Drive, Alabang, Muntinlupa City, Philippines https://conservation-innovations.org/ info@conservation-innovations.org Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) Visayas Avenue, Diliman, Quezon City, Metro Manila, Philippines ccs@denr.gov.ph With support from: The Government of Canada through the Building Capacities for Eco-Resilience in the Philippines Project.

Year of publication: 2026 Editorial and Technical Team [Names to be supplied.] Technical Contributors [Names to be supplied.]

About This Publication This publication consolidates lessons, methods, and applications from the development and refinement of the Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF) through post-disaster ecological assessments in the Philippines. It draws on GARF pilot applications, regional demonstrations, technical reports, training activities, and continuing work under the Building Capacities for EcoResilience in the Philippines project.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Disclaimer The findings, interpretations, and conclusions in this publication are based on information available at the time of assessment. Post-disaster ecological conditions may continue to change, and some findings may require further field validation, monitoring, or analysis. The views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect those of the Government of Canada, DENR, or other partner institutions. Maps in this publication are intended for technical and informational purposes only. They do not imply official recognition of administrative, political, ancestral-domain, protected-area, or other boundaries.

Photographs, Maps, and Illustrations Unless otherwise indicated, CCIPH and DENR produced the photographs, maps, diagrams, and illustrations in this publication. Individual credits are provided where applicable.

Suggested Citation [Authors or editors]. 2026. First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)—Assessing Biodiversity and Ecosystem Loss and Damage and Planning for Ecosystem Recovery and Resilience. [Publisher]. [Place of publication].

ISBN: [To be assigned.] © 2026 Center for Conservation Innovations PH, Inc. All rights reserved.

© CCIPH

|v


& Ecosystem Loss and Damage Assessment viii | Biodiversity and Planning for Ecosystem Recovery and Resilience

Mangaratem, Pangasinan, Philippines © CCIPH

Protecting biodiversity and restoring ecosystems is a shared responsibility that requires sustained commitment and collective action. When we protect and restore healthy ecosystems, we are also investing in safer and more resilient communities H.E. David Hartman Ambassador of Canada to the Philippines


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| ix

Foreword Biodiversity and healthy ecosystems are vital for environmental sustainability, climate resilience, and the well-being of communities. In the Philippines, a country rich in natural resources and highly exposed to disasters, healthy and resilient ecosystems help reduce risks, protect livelihoods, and support recovery. As climate change and pressures on natural resources intensify, ecosystems are increasingly degraded, limiting their capacity to protect communities from climate and disaster risks. Recovery is about more than rebuilding damaged infrastructure such as roads, bridges and buildings. It also means understanding what has been lost in nature and restoring the ecosystems that help protect communities and support livelihoods. This publication, First to Shield, First to Fall, Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF), presents the results of applying the GARF, a methodology developed by the Center for Conservation Innovations Philippines, Inc. (CCIPH) in partnership with the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR). GARF provides a practical tool for documenting environmental conditions, identifying areas of degradation, and informing recovery and restoration efforts. Canada is proud to support the continued strengthening and refinement of GARF through the Building Capacities for Eco-Resilience in the Philippines Project, a PHP 129 million (CAD 3.1 million) initiative being implemented by CCIPH from 2025 to 2029. This investment reflects Canadaʼs commitment to advancing climate resilience, biodiversity, and sustainable development both at home and in the Philippines. Through our partnership with government institutions, civil society organizations, and local communities,

H.E. David Hartman Ambassador of Canada to the Philippines

we are working to strengthen disaster resilience, promote environmental stewardship, and ensure that ecosystem restoration efforts are inclusive, gender-responsive, and informed by local knowledge and experience. The findings and recovery plans presented in this publication represent an important step toward translating environmental assessments into meaningful action. They can help inform policy and planning, guide the allocation of resources, and strengthen collaboration among stakeholders. They also demonstrate how practical tools and approaches can contribute to broader discussions on climate adaptation, biodiversity conservation, disaster risk reduction, and loss and damage. Protecting biodiversity and restoring ecosystems is a shared responsibility that requires sustained commitment and collective action. When we protect and restore healthy ecosystems, we are also investing in safer and more resilient communities. I hope this publication will serve as a valuable resource for policymakers, practitioners, and development partners and help advance efforts to restore ecosystems, strengthen resilience, and safeguard our natural heritage for future generations.

Mindoro Boobook (Ninox mindorensis) © John Lister Bibar, CCIPH


© Kieth Pacardo for Ekomunikatib Multimedia Consultancy Services

Part 1

The Green Assessment & Recovery Framework [Author name(s) and affiliation(s) to be supplied.]


06 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK

Making the Invisible Visible When disaster strikes, its consequences are quickly translated into numbers: lives lost, families displaced, houses destroyed, roads and bridges damaged, crops lost, and businesses interrupted. These figures guide emergency response, direct resources, and shape priorities for recovery and reconstruction. Post-disaster assessments begin with immediate human needs. Governments need to know how many people require shelter, where roads have been cut off, how much agricultural production has been lost, and what infrastructure must be rebuilt. Yet damage to biodiversity and ecosystems can be less visible in these assessments. An area may still be classified as forest on a map even after much of its canopy has been stripped away because the damage may not change its mapped land-cover classification. A mangrove belt may remain standing but have less capacity to reduce wave energy or provide nursery habitat where young fish grow. A watershedʼs boundaries may remain unchanged even as its soils erode, its streams become obstructed, or its ability to regulate water changes. A species may persist after a disaster even as its habitat shrinks, becomes more fragmented, or becomes less capable of supporting a viable population—one that can sustain itself over time. Communities may still have access to the same landscape but find that the water, food, medicine, fish, forest products, or culturally important places they depend on are less abundant, degraded, or harder to access. These losses can be difficult to detect and measure, making them easier to overlook. The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF) seeks to address this gap. The problem is not that biodiversity and ecosystems are absent from disaster discussions. Rather, assessments can remain relatively narrow, emphasizing visible or monetizable losses such as timber losses or reduced production. Non-economic, cumulative, or difficult-toattribute impacts may receive less attention, partly because no single standardized metric captures the full range of biodiversity and ecosystem loss. This matters because ecosystems are not merely the backdrop against which disasters occur; they help sustain human security. When ecosystems are damaged, disruptions to their functions and services can affect people and places beyond the disasterʼs immediate footprint.

GARF assessment team in action © CCIPH


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 07

When nature thrives, life grows © John Lister Bibar, CCIPH

Losses that do not fit neatly into a ledger Some disaster-related ecosystem losses can be expressed in economic terms¹. Estimates of damage and losses affecting crops, fisheries, timber resources, and tourism assets may draw on changes in production, replacement costs, or forgone income. Carbon emissions from vegetation loss can also be estimated using biomass and emissions factors, although expressing these emissions in monetary terms requires a separate valuation step. Selected ecosystem services can also be incorporated into economic accounting frameworks². Monetary valuation alone cannot fully capture many ecological losses. These include losses involving biodiversity and ecosystem services, territory and habitability, and cultural heritage³. Habitat loss for a species with a restricted geographic range, for example, may increase its risk of extinction and diminish a landscapeʼs conservation value. Forest fragmentation can disrupt connections between wildlife populations, restrict movement and access to resources, and affect breeding. These effects may persist for years before measurable population declines become evident. Similarly, the market value of resources extracted from ancestral forests or culturally significant coastal ecosystems cannot fully represent the losses caused by their degradation. These ecosystems may also embody cultural identity, customary tenure, traditional practices, and knowledge passed between generations. Financial compensation may not adequately redress these losses. These impacts include forms of non-economic loss and damage (NELD). GARF was developed to assess such losses and damage associated with sudden-onset disasters and extreme weather events. Both categories fall within GARFʼs scope and may overlap. Conventional post-disaster assessments may not fully capture these impacts. _______________________________ ¹ Botzen, W., Deschenes, O. & Sanders, M. 2019. The Economic Impacts of Natural Disasters: A Review of Models and Empirical Studies. Review of Environmental Economics and Policy. 13. 167-188. 10.1093/reep/rez004. ² Mallari, N. A., Rosales, R. M., Castillo, G., Delos Angeles, M. S., Francisco, H., Orbeta, E., Predo, C., Arcenas, A., Balangue, T., Lasmarias, N., Coroza, O., Masigan, J. P., Bautista, M. A., Edaño, J. W., Jimenez, J. P., Palermo, F., Parr, R. A., Shiraishi, J., Tee, C. K., Uy, Q. A., Yu, L., & Abdao, D. R. 2024. Sukat ng Kalikasan. Department of Environment and Natural Resources.


08 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK Some ecological impacts may be irreversible, occur when critical thresholds are crossed, or become apparent only over time⁴. A local population of an endemic species cannot simply be replaced by a population elsewhere. A fragmented habitat network may retain much of its total area but lose enough connections to isolate populations. Ecological degradation may also have delayed effects: species declines, altered hydrology (changes in how water moves and is stored), reduced regeneration, or changes in ecosystem functions may become evident only months or years after a disaster.

Dry river section documented during the green assessment last April 2022 © Jhonny Wyne Edaño, CCIPH

In Palawan, we observed dry sections in several rivers and streams around four months after Typhoon Odette, while residents reported substantially lower water flow than before the typhoon based on their observations. Fieldwork took place under conditions the team experienced as extremely hot, although no temperature analysis was conducted. While no hydrological study was undertaken to establish causation, these observations suggested a possible interaction between post-typhoon canopy loss and dry-season conditions.

GARF asks not only “Where did the damage occur, and how extensive was it?ˮ but also “What conservation values were affected? Who or what depends on them? How reversible are the changes? What would recovery require?ˮ

We are not okay if nature is not okay Forest damage means more than reduced tree cover. It can also reduce access to rattan, resin, food, medicinal plants, hunting areas, or water. Reef damage can reduce fish catches, alter fishing grounds, weaken coastal protection, and cause the loss of habitat that supports fisheries. Women, Indigenous Peoples, and other groups facing structural inequalities are often among those most dependent on local ecosystems for water, food, medicine, and livelihoods. They also face barriers to accessing resources and recovery support and participating in decisionmaking. When ecosystem damage is overlooked, these groups may experience prolonged losses even after roads, houses, and other infrastructure have been repaired. Community wellbeing is therefore closely linked to the condition of the ecosystems on which people depend.

_______________________________ ³ UNFCCC. 2024. Non-Economic Losses: Featuring Loss of Territory and Habitability, Ecosystem Services and Biodiversity, and Cultural Heritage. Executive Committee of the Warsaw International Mechanism for Loss and Damage. United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. ⁴ Center for Conservation Innovations Philippines, Inc. (CCIPH). 202. Green Assessment and Recovery Framework: A Biodiversity and Ecosystem-based Analysis for Post-Disaster Needs Assessment and Resilience Planning. CCIPH Briefer.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 09

Recovery requires more than rebuilding what was physically damaged. Reconstruction can reinforce vulnerability if it proceeds without an understanding of damage to the ecosystems that support the affected landscape. For example, tree planting may take place in areas already regenerating naturally, while more severely degraded areas receive insufficient support. Pressures that made an ecosystem vulnerable before the disaster, such as extraction, invasive species, or inappropriate land use, may also remain unaddressed.

Indigenous Communities through the lens © Pauline Abello De Castro and Rubelyn Batistin, CCIPH

Ecosystem restoration is therefore an integral part of post-disaster recovery. It need not recreate the landscape exactly as it was before the disaster. Where pre-disaster conditions were already degraded or vulnerable, recreating them may reproduce the same risks. Green recovery should strengthen the resilience of both nature and people. GARF therefore links assessment directly to recovery and restoration planning.

1


10 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK

Following the disaster, teams traverse the affected landscape to assess environmental damage, document changes in habitat conditions, and support recovery planning © Jhonny Wyne Edaño, CCIPH

The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF) provides a practical approach to assessing how climate-related disasters affect ecosystems, biodiversity, and the communities that depend on them, and to using this evidence to guide recovery. It combines two complementary processes: Green Assessment identifies and assesses ecosystem damage, biodiversity loss, and their impacts; Green Recovery Planning translates these findings into practical actions for ecosystem restoration and resilience. GARF is designed to complement existing climate change adaptation (CCA) and disaster risk reduction (DRR) efforts in the Philippines. It supports the Post-Disaster Needs Assessment (PDNA) by providing evidence on biodiversity loss and damage to forests, wetlands, mangroves, coral reefs, and other ecosystems for consideration alongside damage and losses affecting homes, infrastructure, livelihoods, and other economic assets. GARF has three stages. Stages 1 and 2 constitute the Green Assessment, a step-by-step process for determining what was damaged, where the damage occurred, and how severe it is. Stage 3 uses these findings to develop an Ecosystem Restoration and Resilience Plan. This site-specific green recovery plan identifies what needs restoration, who will be responsible, how recovery will be monitored, and what resources are needed.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF) diagram

Satellite images pre-and post-disaster event

Secondary data on land cover and biodiversity present

Stage 1 Triage or Rapid Appraisal to determine extent of damage to ecosystem

Maps showing pre- & postdister changes in the area of interest (AOI)

Ground Turning Survey

Stage 2

Preliminary Species Distribution Models

Biodivesity and habitat field assessment

Community FGDʼs and Ground Validation

Earth Observation Data

Post-disaster compehensive assesssment of biodiversity and ecosystem Land cover and eco-disaster maps

Pre- and post disaster extent of suitable habitats

Analysis capacity for ecosystem restoration and identification of barriers to participation

Participation consultation and planning with key stakeholders and management authorities

Stage 3 Ecosystem restoration and resillence planning

Green recovery-plan

Green recovery monitoring plan

Resource Mobilization Plant

All methods and outputs within this framework are science-based, right based and gender responsive

| 11


12 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK The framework is designed for post-disaster conditions. Immediate humanitarian and lifesaving efforts—including search and rescue, evacuation, shelter, food, water, and medical assistance—take priority. Once these efforts are underway, Stage 1 can use freely available satellite data and other existing information to rapidly identify areas where ecosystems and biodiversity may have been affected. Stage 2 takes the assessment into the field. Trained government technical officers and other local teams verify satellite-based findings, assess biodiversity and ecosystem conditions, and work with communities to document impacts that satellite imagery alone may not reveal. Stage 3 brings these findings into participatory planning involving local governments, protected-area authorities, national agencies, communities, civil society organizations, and academic institutions. Together, the three stages connect rapid assessment, field verification, and recovery planning. This sequence can help teams identify potential ecosystem damage and biodiversity loss, verify findings on the ground, and translate evidence into practical restoration and riskreduction measures. Although GARF is primarily a post-disaster framework, important baseline information can be established or strengthened before an event. This includes data on ecosystem extent and condition, species distributions, and community resource use, which provide reference points for post-disaster comparison. Building these baselines in advance can make subsequent GARF assessments faster, more reliable, and more useful for green reconstruction, ecosystem restoration, and disaster risk reduction. GARF was piloted in Palawan and Siargao following Super Typhoon Odette in 2021. It helped assess ecological loss and damage, identify priority areas and actions for recovery and restoration, and inform measures to reduce future disaster risks. By incorporating ecosystem damage and biodiversity loss into recovery planning, GARF helps decision-makers identify what needs restoration, where action is most urgent, and how investments can strengthen ecosystems and the communities that depend on them.

Damage vegetation in the coastal area of SIPLAS © CCIPH


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Stage 1: Triage or Rapid Appraisal Stage 1 rapidly identifies areas where ecosystems and biodiversity may have been affected by an extreme weather event. Teams can conduct it remotely using satellite images and existing information, without immediately entering the field. It has two main components: rapid mapping and preliminary biodiversity assessment. First, rapid mapping compares satellite images taken before and after the event to identify changes in vegetation. The normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) and enhanced vegetation index (EVI) help assess vegetation conditions. Changes in these indices can identify potentially damaged areas for further assessment. Second, teams review existing biodiversity information—including species records, scientific studies, and other available data—to identify species and habitats that may have been affected. Where sufficient data are available, species-distribution or habitat-suitability models can estimate the extent, fragmentation, and connectivity of suitable habitat and its overlap with mapped disturbance. Comparisons of preand post-event outputs may indicate changes in suitable habitat for selected species, but they do not confirm species presence or disaster impacts. Finally, teams combine vegetation-change maps with known or estimated species distributions and habitat locations to map potential priority sites. These sites guide field surveys and ground validation in Stage 2. Together, these steps provide an initial picture of possible ecological damage and help direct limited field resources to the areas most likely to have been affected.

| 13

Aerial photo of river in between valleys in Siargao Island, Philippines.© CCIPH


14 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK

Stage 2: Post-disaster Comprehensive Assessment The post-disaster comprehensive assessment combines aerial ground-truthing using remotely piloted aircraft systems (RPAS), rapid biodiversity assessment (RBA), and community focus group discussions (FGDs) and key informant interviews (KIIs). RPAS, or drones, are used to rapidly capture detailed photographs of disaster-affected areas and document visible damage. The resulting aerial photographs are processed into orthomosaics— images stitched together and geometrically corrected to function as maps—and interpreted to identify land-cover classes. Because RPAS surveys may be limited by available resources, permit requirements, difficult access, or poor weather, they are complemented by surveys conducted on the ground. Together, these surveys strengthen the information used to map changed or damaged areas. The reference data used to train and validate random forest classifications vary by site and may include field observations, RPAS imagery, existing land-cover datasets, satellite imagery, and other available information. Pre-disaster reference data likewise depend on the sources available for each assessment. Random forest classification is then used to map land cover and compare pre- and post-disaster conditions. Where appropriate, the resulting maps identify areas classified as damaged across forests, mangroves, croplands, grasslands, and settlements. RBA evaluates the post-disaster status of selected trigger species and their remaining habitats, emphasizing rare, threatened, and endemic species. Field methods—including transect surveys, point counts, camera trapping, acoustic monitoring, and mist netting—document species occurrences, detections, encounter rates, and habitat conditions. Habitat assessments examine damage to vegetation, nesting and breeding sites, and food resources. Where sufficient data are available, species–habitat models help identify potentially vulnerable habitats and prioritize areas for conservation, rehabilitation, and recovery. Teams also conduct FGDs and KIIs with communities and other relevant stakeholders to validate field findings and document local knowledge and experiences. These consultations help identify how changes in biodiversity, ecosystems, and ecosystem services have affected livelihoods, safety, cultural values, and community well-being. © CCIPH


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Stage 2 also incorporates complementary indicators for assessing non-economic loss and damage. These indicators include: changes in species diversity and composition, changes in species occurrence and relative abundance changes in the predicted extent and distribution of suitable habitat habitat fragmentation and connectivity

Stage 3: Ecosystem Restoration and Resilience Planning Stage 3 uses findings from Stages 1 and 2 to develop a Green Recovery Plan for restoration and resilience planning. The program identifies actions to restore affected ecosystems and strengthen their ability to withstand future disasters, estimates costs, sets out how progress will be monitored, and identifies funding and resource needs. It is developed through participatory workshops involving the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR), local governments, communities, civil society organizations, and academic institutions. Within the broader GARF approach, assessment findings inform a restoration framework tailored to each ecosystem type and site condition and guide Stage 3 recovery planning. Possible approaches include protection and natural recovery, assisted natural regeneration, active restoration using native species, or a combination of approaches over time. These examples are illustrative; the full restoration methodology will be elaborated in a separate companion publication. The restoration approach depends on the extent of damage, ecosystem type and condition, past disturbances, terrain, water conditions, land tenure, accessibility, community capacity, and availability of suitable planting materials. Restoration follows the principles of ecological succession, prioritizing spontaneous natural regeneration wherever natural recovery processes remain viable. Protecting existing vegetation and allowing ecosystems to recover naturally supports the gradual development of ecological structure, species diversity, and ecosystem functions. If natural regeneration is insufficient or constrained, assisted natural regeneration, enrichment planting, or other active interventions may be introduced to address recovery barriers. Considering these factors helps ensure that restoration is appropriate to local conditions, supports natural ecological processes, and strengthens long-term ecosystem resilience.

| 15


16 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK Box 1: Palawan Case Study Field observations recorded numerous fallen and uprooted trees, broken trunks, and trees stripped of their leaves. Damage appeared to increase with elevation, particularly along exposed mountain ridges. Many relatively intact forests occurred in gullies and valley bottoms, where surrounding ridges may have provided protection from strong winds. These observations suggest that forest location and terrain influenced the extent of damage.

Habitat Damage in Palawan © Jhonny Wyne Edaño, CCIPH GARF documented extensive damage to Palawanʼs forests following Super Typhoon Odette (Rai). An estimated 156,371 hectares of land were damaged, with the greatest impacts recorded in northern and central Palawan. Before the typhoon, these areas contained about 221,125 hectares of dense, closedcanopy forest. After Odette, approximately 125,581 hectares of this forest were mapped as more open forest or areas with little or no forest cover, indicating extensive changes in forest cover after the event.

The typhoon also affected biodiversity and wildlife habitats. GARF used selected species, including the Palawan hornbill (Anthracoceros marchei) and Busuanga wart-frog (Limnonectes acanthi), as both indicator and umbrella species. As indicators, they can help reveal ecological conditions; as umbrella species, protecting them and their habitats may also benefit other species. Habitat-suitability models indicated greater fragmentation of modeled suitable forest habitat after the disaster. These findings suggest reduced habitat connectivity, which may isolate local populations and affect their long-term survival.

Palawan Green Assessment Land Cover and Change Map


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 17

Species Distribution Model Map

Box 1: Palawan Case Study (cont.) Changes in river flow, increased siltation, and localized droughts were also observed in some areas. Landslides were prominent on steep terrain where heavy rainfall saturated the soil. These impacts displaced some local and Indigenous families living near forests. Damage to coconut plantations and forest resources, including almaciga resin, rattan, and honey, reduced important sources of food and income for forest-dependent communities. Impacts on lowlands, croplands, and other vegetation were ess severe, while forests in PPSNRP

and the Cleopatraʼs Needle massif sustained some of the greatest damage. The GARF pilot highlighted the value of sciencebased assessments focused on biodiversity and ecosystems for guiding post-disaster response and selecting restoration strategies. The pilot also informed the development of the Green Recovery Plan (GRP), which identifies actions to restore ecosystems affected by climate-related disasters and strengthen their resilience to future impacts.

Post-typhoon forest assessment showing fallen and broken trees obstructing access through the forest understory © Mary Ann Bautista, CCIPH


18 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK Box 2: SIPLAS Case Study seagrass (4,275 hectares), corals tainted with algae (1,530 hectares), or corals with sand (1,273 hectares). Some areas previously mapped as coral mixed with rubble or algae were subsequently mapped as dominated by seagrass or sand. These changes were particularly evident in shallow and nearshore areas. Algae also occurred alongside corals, rubble, seagrass, and sand. Measuring the seagrass canopy height during high tide in Siargao © CCIPH Super Typhoon Odetteʼs impacts on the Siargao Island Protected Landscape and Seascape (SIPLAS) highlight the vulnerability of coastal and island ecosystems to extreme weather events. Understanding the damage helps guide recovery and protect ecosystems and the communities that depend on them. Benthic mapping—mapping habitats on the seafloor— compared marine habitats a few months before Odette with those mapped in September 2022, several months after the typhoon. The maps showed substantial changes in the distribution of seafloor habitats. Before Odette, coral habitats covered an estimated 11,696 hectares, the largest mapped habitat class. Several months after the typhoon, much of this area was mapped as rubble (2,013 hectares), rock (437 hectares),

The maps showed a substantial reduction in the area classified as coral habitat and an apparent increase in areas dominated by seagrass and algae several months after the typhoon. Strong waves and water movement generated by Odette may have contributed by breaking corals and disturbing the seafloor. However, maps of conditions several months after the event cannot establish the causes of all observed changes. Continued monitoring is needed to determine whether these habitats recover naturally or undergo longer-term changes. The findings highlight the need to reduce additional pressures on damaged coral reefs during recovery. Poorly managed boat traffic, anchoring, and contact with boat hulls or propellers can further damage corals. Protecting remaining coral habitats and reducing these pressures can support reef recovery and the ecological and economic benefits that marine ecosystems provide to Siargaoʼs communities.

SIPLAS Pre-Odette Benthic Map (2021)


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Box 2: SIPLAS Case Study (cont.)

SIPLAS Pre-Odette Benthic Map (2022)

SIPLAS Pre-Odette Benthic Cover Change Map (2021-2022)

| 19


20 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK Box 3: (Case study) Translating Ecological Assessments into Action: Green Recovery Planning in PPSRNP

Typhoon Odette (Rai) severely affected the forests of the Puerto Princesa Subterranean River National Park (PPSRNP), highlighting the need for a coordinated, evidence-based approach to ecosystem recovery. Through the Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF), ecological assessments, field validation, and community consultations were brought together to identify the extent of forest damage, assess natural regeneration potential, and determine appropriate restoration measures. The findings provided the basis for interagency coordination and the development of a Green Recovery Plan (GRP) that reflects both ecological conditions and community priorities. Prior to Typhoon Odette (Rai), closed and open forests covered approximately 70% of the Puerto Princesa Subterranean River National Park (PPSRNP). Post-typhoon assessments revealed that 58% of these forests were damaged, with forests in mid- to high-elevation areas converted into open forest or non-forest cover. These findings were among the key results presented during the GARF results-sharing activity in Puerto Princesa. Following the presentation, interagency technical working groups (TWGs) were established in Palawan to validate the GARF results and guide the preparation of GRPs for typhoon-affected areas. The PPSRNP TWG includes representatives from the PPSRNP Protected Area Management Office (PAMO), DENR CENRO Puerto Princesa City, PCSDS, City ENRO, CDRRMO, and Western Philippines University (WPU). The GARF results were also presented to communities in PPSRNP barangays to gather their perspectives on post-disaster recovery and natural

perspectives on post-disaster recovery and natura resource management. Key recommendations include river rehabilitation, reforestation, and the restoration of damaged non-timber forest product (NTFP) harvesting areas. These inputs were consolidated and used to guide the development of the GRPs. To assess forest conditions and regeneration potential one year after the typhoon, restoration catalyst plots were established. A restoration catalyst plot (RCP) is a one-hectare plot with nested circular plots (5-m radius) used to assess site conditions and calculate the average density of both regenerants and seedlings to be planted. The RCP assessment recorded more than 3,000 regenerants across the plots, although fewer than 20% were climax or late-successional species. An average of about 14 mother trees was also observed per plot. These findings suggest that many damaged areas retain the capacity for natural regeneration, but additional interventions are needed to improve species diversity and support forest recovery. The GRP development process considered restoration strategies suited to post-disaster site conditions, drawing on findings from community consultations and restoration catalyst plot assessments. Five interventions were identified: forest protection, spontaneous natural regeneration (SNR), assisted natural regeneration (ANR), ANR with enrichment planting, and monitoring. The priority is to protect remaining intact forests and support natural regeneration, complemented by planting and other revegetation measures where necessary.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Box 3: (Case study) Translating Ecological Assessments into Action: Green Recovery Planning in PPSRNP (cont.)

PPSRNP Green Recover Plan Map indicating restoration strategies (Assisted Natural Regeneration and with Enrichment Planting, Spontaneous Natural Regeneration)

| 21


22 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK

GARF in the Policy Landscape Policy or Framework

How GARF Contributes

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) / Warsaw International Mechanism for Loss and Damage

Operationalizes the assessment of non-economic losses that are often inadequately captured in conventional disaster assessments. GARF generates spatial, ecological, and community-based evidence that can inform loss and damage reporting, technical assistance, and the identification of recovery needs, including potential inputs to financing mechanisms.

Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD)

GARF supports biodiversity conservation, ecosystem restoration, and the integration of biodiversity considerations into disaster risk reduction and climate adaptation.

Kunming–Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework (KMGBF)

Supports implementation of Targets 2, 8, 11, 14, and 21 by identifying disaster-affected ecosystems requiring restoration, assessing climate-related impacts on biodiversity, documenting changes in ecosystem services, and generating biodiversity information for planning and decision-making.

United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification (UNCCD)

Provides evidence on disaster-related degradation and changes in ecosystem condition. GARF can inform land restoration priorities and support land degradation neutrality objectives.

Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction

Strengthens the consideration of nature within disaster risk assessment and recovery planning, particularly under Priority 1 (Understanding Disaster Risk), Priority 2 (Strengthening Disaster Risk Governance), Priority 3 (Investing in Disaster Risk Reduction for Resilience), and Priority 4 (Enhancing Disaster Preparedness and Building Back Better). GARF documents how ecosystem damage may increase future exposure and vulnerability and identifies opportunities to restore natural protective functions as part of risk-informed recovery.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 23

National Adaptation Plan (NAP) of the Philippines

GARF can inform the prioritization of ecosystembased adaptation and nature-based solutions and support the identification of adaptation measures that strengthen ecological resilience and reduce future disaster risks.

National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Plan (NDRRMP), Philippines

Strengthens the ecological dimension of disaster risk reduction and management by integrating biodiversity, ecosystem condition, and ecosystem services into risk assessment, rehabilitation, and recovery planning.

Post-Disaster Needs Assessment (PDNA), Philippines

Complements conventional damage and loss assessments by providing evidence on disaster impacts on biodiversity, ecosystem services, and community resource use. GARF can help identify ecological recovery needs and translate them into restoration priorities and interventions for incorporation into post-disaster rehabilitation and recovery plans.

Philippine Biodiversity Strategy and Action Plan (PBSAP)

Supports national biodiversity conservation and restoration priorities.

Philippine Ecosystem and Natural Capital Accounting System (PENCAS)

Generates spatial and ecological information on changes in ecosystem extent, condition, and services following disasters. Where data are compatible with national accounting standards, GARF outputs can support the updating of physical accounts, the assessment of disaster-related changes in natural capital, and subsequent ecosystem service valuation.

Sukat ng Kalikasan (SnK)

SnK is the building block of GARF. It complements GARF by providing standardized biodiversity, ecosystem, and ecosystem service metrics that can serve as pre-disaster baselines and post-disaster monitoring indicators


24 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK GARF and PDNA: Bringing Nature into Post-Disaster Needs Assessment In the Philippines, the Post-Disaster Needs Assessment (PDNA) forms part of national rehabilitation and recovery planning after major disasters. Under National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC)⁵ guidance, it assesses disaster damage and losses, broader impacts, and recovery needs within and across sectors, drawing on field validation⁶. Its findings guide the identification of interventions, programs, projects, and activities for post-disaster rehabilitation and recovery. GARF can complement PDNA and related environmental assessments by providing more detailed evidence on biodiversity and ecosystems affected by climate-related or sudden-onset disasters. Examples include typhoons and associated hazards or impacts such as flooding, landslides, storm surges, and severe vegetation disturbance. In the Philippines, PDNA and rehabilitation and recovery planning provide channels for ecological evidence to inform recovery across sectors⁷. GARF contributes detailed information where disaster-affected landscapes support water security, food production, livelihoods, biodiversity conservation, and disaster risk reduction. This evidence can help recovery planning address the ecosystems that protect and sustain communities alongside the rebuilding of physical assets.

From ridge to reef, nature thrives in harmony © CCIPH

GARF and PENCAS: Input to Natural Capital Accounts Republic Act No. 11995, or the PENCAS Act, establishes the Philippine Ecosystem and Natural Capital Accounting System (PENCAS) and provides the legal and institutional basis for integrating ecosystem and natural capital accounts into government planning, policy, and decision-making. PENCAS provides a national framework for tracking ecosystem extent, condition, services, and natural capital over time. GARF documents what changed, where, and by how much, providing physical and ecological information that can support valuation. Compatible information can then inform natural capital accounts and, where appropriate, monetary valuation. ___________________________________ ⁵Republic Act 10121 or Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Act of 2010 ⁶ National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC). Ready to Rebuild: Planning Guide Workbook. Quezon City, Philippines: NDRRMC/Office of Civil Defense. ⁷ National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC). National Disaster Response Plan 2024. Quezon City, Philippines: NDRRMC.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 25

Box 4: Tracking Nature’s Loss: Almaciga, Typhoon Odette, and Natural Capital After Typhoon Odette in 2021, damage to Palawanʼs forests was visible, but its implications for the natural resources supporting local communities were less obvious. In Cleopatraʼs Needle Key Biodiversity Area, one such resource was almaciga (Agathis philippinensis), a native tree whose resin supports local livelihoods and has long been harvested as a non-timber forest product. GARF results identified suitable almaciga habitat before the typhoon and estimated how much was subsequently affected. Before Odette, about 14,424.74 hectares were identified as moderately to highly suitable, supporting an estimated 38,566 tappable trees. Post-Odette analysis indicated that about 37% of this habitat, or roughly 5,302 hectares, was affected, including areas containing defoliated, fallen, cracked, or broken trees. The natural capital accounting study examined what these ecological changes meant for the benefits provided by almaciga resin. Using accounts of ecosystem extent and condition and of resin supply and use, it estimated a decline of 459,648 kilograms in resin productivity, equivalent to about ₱3.98 million in lost economic rent. Based on reported harvesting data before and after Odette, estimated damage to the ecosystem service of supplying almaciga resin reached approximately ₱4.13 million. The accounting results can inform decisions about reinvesting in the ecosystems that provide almaciga resin. The study estimates the resource

Almaciga (Agathis philippinensis) © Raffy Mark Failon, CCIPH rent associated with resin production and suggests that a portion could potentially be collected through appropriate fees, charges, or other financing arrangements. The government currently collects a forest charge of ₱1.50 per kilogram of resin, substantially below the estimated underlying resource rent. If allocated to habitat management, such revenues could support monitoring, protection of naturally regenerating seedlings, and sustainable tapping practices.

Post-Odette destruction at Puerto Princesa Subterranean River National Park (PPSRNP) © Jhonny Wyne Edaño, CCIPH


26 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK

Box 4: Tracking Nature’s Loss: Almaciga, Typhoon Odette, and Natural Capital (cont.)

Habitat Suitability Model of Almaciga during Pre-Odette in Palawan

Habitat Suitability Model of Almaciga during Post-Odette in Palawan Sources: (1) Francisco, H. A., Palermo, F. S., Dida, J. V., Castillo, G. B., Predo, C. D., Rosales, R. P., & Dizon, R. R. Accounting for Almaciga Resin Production in Cleopatraʼs Needle Key Biodiversity Area (CN KBA) (2) Coroza, O., Bautista, M. A., Uy, Q. A., Andaya, K. J., Abdao, D. R., Felismino-Inovejas, R. A., Jasmin, C. J., Empillo, L., Batistin, R., Masigan, J. P., & Mallari, N. A. 2025. Green Assessment in Palawan Stage 2: Post-Odette Mapping and Impacts to Biodiversity, Ecosystems, and Community Resource Use. Technical Report. Center for Conservation Innovation PH, Inc. for the USAID Sustainable Interventions for Biodiversity, Oceans, and Landscapes (SIBOL) Activity.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Lessons from the Initial GARF Pilots Applying GARF across different landscapes revealed recurring challenges in data availability, inclusion, institutional coordination, and implementation capacity. These lessons clarified the frameworkʼs strengths and areas for adaptation and improvement.

Science and Evidence Build reliable pre-disaster baselines for biodiversity and for ecosystem extent and condition. Build on existing methods, standardized tools, monitoring systems, and datasets. Interpret post-disaster change in its broader ecological context. Consider pre-existing degradation, land-use pressures, and other drivers alongside the extreme event to assess the causes of observed changes and avoid oversimplification. Define practical indicators and metrics for non-economic loss and damage.

People and Inclusion Integrate gender considerations throughout assessment and analysis. Recognize Indigenous and local knowledge as a valid and complementary source of evidence. Link ecological impacts to livelihoods, well-being, and peopleʼs everyday dependence on natural resources. Account for differences in vulnerability and recovery capacity. Access to resources, alternative livelihoods, institutional support, and decision-making shapes how groups experience and recover from ecological loss.

Institutions and Capacity Plan at the ecosystem scale, across administrative boundaries where needed. Strengthen coordination and information sharing across sectors and agencies. Build the capacity of local government units (LGUs) and communities to apply GARF. Establish institutional ownership by embedding GARF in existing systems, plans, and budgets.

Recovery Expand GARFʼs use through policy adoption, clear implementation arrangements, and monitoring. Expand recovery financing to support ecological resilience alongside relief efforts. Tailor restoration to the needs of each landscape rather than applying uniform interventions. Build wider support for ecosystem-based disaster risk reduction and restoration as investments in resilience.

| 27


28 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK

The Future of GARF Institutionalizing GARF within DENR GARFʼs next phase is to move from project-based application toward a formal role in national environmental and disaster governance. DENRʼs policy on GARF is still being drafted. This process provides an opportunity to define the frameworkʼs scope, when it should be applied, who should lead and finance it, and how its findings should inform recovery and planning. GARF can serve several complementary functions within this policy framework: Document non-economic loss and damage arising from climate-related disasters. Provide ecological evidence for broader post-disaster needs assessment and disaster risk reduction and management (DRRM) planning. Supply spatial and biophysical information to support natural capital accounting under PENCAS. Help identify priorities for ecosystem restoration and resilience. Provide evidence to identify and prioritize nature-based solutions and ecosystembased disaster risk reduction (Eco-DRR) interventions. For GARF to become part of routine institutional practice, the policy must address several operational questions. Clear activation criteria are needed to determine when and at what scale GARF should be applied after a climate-related extreme event. Much environmental work on DRR still focuses on pre-disaster risk assessment, while post-disaster assessments remain limited and often concentrate on production-related losses. Biodiversity and ecosystem loss assessments can be technically demanding, and disasters occur repeatedly and unpredictably. DENR may therefore need a dedicated unit, subsection, technical team, or standing mechanism to coordinate GARF implementation, maintain readiness, and mobilize expertise when disasters occur. Sustained implementation will require training and technical support for regional and field offices. It cannot depend entirely on ad hoc project funds. Because disaster timing is uncertain, GARF will need flexible financing that can be mobilized when required.

Building a Community of Eco-DRR Practitioner Expanding GARF requires both a policy mandate and a broad community of practitioners, including other government agencies, LGUs, local DRRM offices, universities, protectedarea managers, Indigenous Peoplesʼ organizations, and communities. The goal is to develop enough skilled practitioners across these institutions and groups to generate and interpret ecological evidence and use it to guide recovery, restoration, and resilience measures.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Building Capacities for Eco-Resilience in the Philippines Project Briefer

| 29


30 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK Strengthening the Social Dimension of GARF

Talipanan Mangyan students in Oriental Mindoro, Philippines © Pauline Abello De Castro, CCIPH

Early GARF applications documented community resource use and local knowledge, but gave limited attention to gender issues, equity, and social inclusion. Future applications should examine what was affected, who was affected, how impacts differed, and whose knowledge and leadership informed recovery decisions. This requires stronger gender-responsive analysis, greater acknowledgment of Indigenous and local knowledge, closer examination of livelihood dependence and access to resources, and broader participation and control of the most marginalized stakeholders in decision-making. Dependence on natural resources varies within communities according to livelihood, location, sex, age, customary rights, decision-making, access to land and resources, and available alternatives. Women and men may use, manage, or access different resources and therefore experience ecological loss and recovery differently. The same ecosystem disturbance can have different consequences across households and social groups. Future GARF applications should better capture psychosocial impacts—effects on psychological well-being and social relationships—and other non-material losses. Ecosystem changes can affect identity, sense of place, cultural continuity, security, and wellbeing, dimensions of non-economic loss and damage that assessments may overlook.

Expanding GARF to Include Slow-Onset Events GARF was developed primarily for sudden-onset and extreme weather events. Ecological losses can also accumulate through prolonged drought, sea-level rise, salinization, coastal erosion, shifting species distributions, and progressive ecosystem degradation. Coral bleaching can contribute to these losses. Gradual change presents a different assessment challenge. A single event may not provide a clear “beforeˮ and “after,ˮ and determining the causes can be more complex. Future GARF applications will need observations spanning longer periods, reliable ecological baselines, clearly defined thresholds, and indicators that can detect gradual change before ecosystem functions are irreversibly lost. Expanding GARF in this direction could strengthen adaptation planning by identifying where ecosystems are gradually losing resilience, which species and communities face the greatest risks, and where early intervention may prevent larger losses.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 31

Box 5: Findings from Eco-DRR Focus Group Discussions SOUTHERN LEYTE Barriers to Womenʼs Participation and Leadership in Eco-DRR. During the FGD in Silago, a survivor of abuse disclosed her experience to the facilitator before the discussion began. A representative of the Municipal Social Welfare and Development Office (MSWDO) later reported that GBV cases occurred in the community. Participants described the MSWDO as responsive and noted that its staff had received training from CATW-AP through successive programs following Typhoon Odette. Women recommended that men also receive orientation or training on GBV. In the months following Super Typhoon Odette in 2021–2022, CATW-AP, in partnership with UNFPA, provided cash-for-protection assistance to 85 people affected by gender-based violence and the disaster in Silago. Targeted, genderresponsive interventions, including cash-for-work and cash-for-protection, supported women facing particularly difficult recovery conditions (CATW-AP, Quarterly Monitoring Tools, 2022). Rights Awareness. Men generally emphasized their childrenʼs right to complete their education through college. Women cited a wider range of rights, with some emphasis on the right to rest. Relationship with Ecosystems. Women reported gathering cinnamon (bunganon) and medicinal plants associated with postpartum recovery in Mt. Nacolod. They also described using vines (baging) for stomach pain and banaba for kidney

problems. Women generally prepared medicinal plants, while men often gathered them. Women also collected rattan, although participants said that men did so more often. Participants described most households as farming families. Women participants emphasized damage to houses and boats from Typhoon Odette, while men emphasized damaged roads and landslides. This difference may reflect menʼs greater mobility and their focus on barriers to livelihood activities. Women strongly emphasized the need for men to recognize their multiple burdens and disproportionate responsibility for care work. They reported experiencing stress and seeking help from neighbors. Some also used online applications that paid users for watching reels to supplement their income while doing household work. As in the Camiguin FGDs, participants in Southern Leyte were non-Indigenous and did not report a notably high prevalence of early marriage. Opportunities for Rights-Based, GenderResponsive DRR. The FGDs indicated that community understandings of biodiversity were grounded in daily experience and shaped by gendered roles and interactions with ecosystems. Women commonly mentioned animals encountered in their surroundings, including tarsiers, monkeys, hornbills (kalaw), wild pigs, and snakes, as well as plants such as pitcher plants and wild rambutan.

Pintuyan, Southern Leyte, Philippines © Provincial Government of Southern Leyte


32 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK

Box 5: Findings from Eco-DRR Focus Group Discussions (cont.) SOUTHERN LEYTE (cont.) Their responses also emphasized the importance of rivers and waterfalls in daily life. Men identified wildlife such as the king cobra, Philippine eagle, and wild pig, as well as economically and ecologically important trees, including agarwood (lapnisan), cinnamon, and hardwood species such as lauan, yakal, and sudyang. They also identified lakes, forests, caves, farmlands, and springs, which may reflect a more ecological or livelihood-oriented view of biodiversity. Within these discussions, women tended to emphasize everyday and relational knowledge of nature, while men more often emphasized ecological diversity and resource value. These patterns reflect the specific participants and discussions and should not be treated as general differences between women and men. Recommendations. Community members in Catmon, Silago, recommended practical measures to strengthen resilience and restore local ecosystems. Women emphasized reforestation using native and high-value trees such as lauan and agarwood, stronger enforcement against

illegal dumping and tree cutting, and clear for visitors—including university researchers—who leave waste. Men recommended livelihood training and the cultivation of a wider variety of crops and plants to diversify income and strengthen food security. Together, these recommendations linked environmental protection with sustainable livelihoods. Womenʼs focus on reforestation, enforcement, and visitor accountability emphasized the long-term value of forest health and respectful collaboration between communities and institutions. Menʼs proposals for livelihood training and diversified planting emphasized economic resilience. The recommendations support inclusive, community-led programs that integrate conservation, sustainable livelihoods, and institutional accountability. Men also welcomed GBV training that would help community leaders recognize warning signs and respond appropriately. Women called for men to recognize the gendered division of labor and discuss how to address it. Participants also recommended information materials on GBV and available mechanisms for reporting and redress.

Mount Kitanglad, Bukidnon, Philippines © Jesson Morata, SunStar


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 33

Box 5: Findings from Eco-DRR Focus Group Discussions (cont.) BUKIDNON Rights Awareness. Men participants agreed that the concept of human rights had an Indigenous equivalent in the term katungod. When asked which rights were most important to them, many cited the right to plant or farm (magtanim). One participant emphasized the need to respect the Indigenous Peoplesʼ Rights Act; another linked forest loss to landslides. A third emphasized the right to life and discussed mental-health concerns and suicide among young people. Women mainly cited family-related rights, such as peace within the family and childrenʼs welfare. Relationship with Ecosystems. Older men said they could obtain wild boar when the animals entered their farms. When asked how women interacted with nature, they mentioned gathering wild malunggay, mushrooms, and fruits such as lanagom. Women said they gathered natural resources primarily for household use, including fish and frogs from water sources. Barriers to Engagement in Eco-DRR. A time-use exercise showed a gendered division of labor, with women carrying much of the responsibility for care work. Men acknowledged that women also worked on farms and recognized the extent of their workload. The facilitator questioned the traditional description of men as haligi, or pillars, and women as ilaw, or light, asking whether women could also be pillars and men could also be light. Although facilitators did not explicitly use the term “stereotyping,ˮ the materials introduced the concept for further discussion. Women estimated that 99% of them performed farm weeding. They also wove products and undertook most care work. Women described rigid gender stereotyping in the socialization of children, including boys being called bayot when they played with dolls. Women reported that only five women served in the Indigenous Political Structure (IPS) of the Talaandig community. Men could not provide a number but agreed that womenʼs representation was limited. Older women attributed this to insufficient support, favoritism by some male leaders toward relatives, and perceptions that

women lacked determination. They also confirmed that care work constrained participation, describing experiences such as feeling guilty when cooperative leadership reduced the time available for domestic responsibilities. A council elder acknowledged cases of violence against women and said that fear may contribute to underreporting. Participants recommended training for responders and communities to encourage reporting. Women also described cases in which women became mistresses of men with privileged status, including through lending relationships. Older women described continuing arrangedmarriage practices in which the parents of both parties made decisions. They said that, in some cases, a man was arranged to stay in the same room as a girl and that a dowry was provided according to the demands of the girlʼs parents. One woman who belonged to the Iglesia ni Cristo said that her faith prohibited the practice. Participantsʼ accounts indicated intersections between institutional religious beliefs and community practices. Most participants said that early marriage continued and had been observed across generations. At least four male participants faced literacy barriers. Facilitators took steps to include them because they tended not to speak during the discussions. Opportunities. As in Sorsogon, women used the women-only safe space to discuss sensitive concerns. In Bukidnon, these included perceptions that male community leaders favored relatives when resolving disputes. Recommendations. Women recommended empowerment training and the inclusion of more women who had been unable to attend the FGDs so that their barriers could also be addressed. Men emphasized leadership training and the transmission of traditional knowledge to younger generations in support of Eco-DRR.


34 | PART 1: THE GREEN ASSESSMENT & RECOVERY FRAMEWORK

Manual and Aerial GroundTruthing Survey © CCIPH

Positioning GARF within the Global Loss and Damage Agenda Loss and damage assessment has tended to be more straightforward for impacts that can be counted, physically measured, or valued in monetary terms. Ecological and other noneconomic losses are more difficult to capture consistently. How do we measure ecological loss when it is not immediately visible? How do we distinguish temporary degradation from long-term degradation or irreversible loss? How do we identify who is affected when dependence on ecosystems differs across communities and social groups? How do we use better evidence of loss and damage to inform recovery priorities, policy responses, and financing decisions? This is where GARF has a potential role. It offers a structured way to document biodiversity and ecosystem-related loss and damage through spatial analysis, field validation, biodiversity assessment, community knowledge, and recovery planning. In doing so, it can help provide more credible evidence while also identifying which losses may be recoverable, which require active intervention, and which may be difficult or impossible to reverse. As international financing mechanisms for economic and non-economic loss and damage continue to emerge8, the challenge is not only to recognize loss but to document and assess it well enough to inform action and investment.

___________________________________ ⁸ Fund for responding to Loss and Damage (FRLD). 2025. Terms of Reference for the Call for Funding Requests under the Barbados Implementation Modalities. FRLD/BIM/1.


© Kieth Pacardo for Ekomunikatib Multimedia Consultancy Services

Part 2

GARF in Practice across the Philippines


36 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Authors

Principal Compilers, Contributors and Reviewers

NCR — La Mesa Watershed DENR National Capital Region, led by For. Aida Esguerra and For. Arturo Calderon Reviewers/editors: Kissther Purio; Jennica Masigan Region I — Bessang Pass Natural Monument/Landmark DENR Region I, led by Ralphy L. Tan, Alain M. Dayao II, Jozald Kaye P. Ceralde, Merven D. Medrano, and Mary Joy F. Pascua Reviewers/editors: Kristher Purio; Mary Ann Bautista Region II — Baggao Wildlife Sanctuary DENR Region II Green Assessment Team, led by Arnold A. Battung, with Lorraine B. Cabalza, Elvis Tumanguil, Klevin Soriano, Ronald Addatu, Jessie Guerrero, Roselyn T. Gola, Jasmin E. Gannaban, Edmundo Mata, and Johnrey R. Agcaoili. Reviewer/editor: Jennica Masigan Region III — Minalungao National Park DENR Region III GARF Team, led by Mariqueen Andrea D. Arcia, with Emmanuel B. Penson Jr. as assistant team leader, and Janelyn B. Tummiguing, Cedric Al F Roque, Sheila H. Cabrera, Glenn Marc P. Salazar, Brix A. Francisco, Mark Anthony M. Rifa, Castor P. Mejico Jr., Michaelle Mc C. Taguinod, Kristine V. Silvestre, Raquel H. Fernandez, Percival R. Caba, Leovino P. Salamanca Jr., Joed V. Aplacador, Rico D. Linsangan, Rowell M. Cantor, Honey Jane M. Macalinao, and Aljohn A. Fernandez Reviewers/editors: Kristher Purio; Joshua Manila CAR — Calanasan, Apayao Allison Pasamic of LGU Calanasan; Joen Vita, Richard delos Reyes, and Angela Dason of PENRO Apayao Reviewer/editor: Mary Ann Bautista Region IV-A — CALABARZON DENR Region IV-A, including Mark R. Garcia, Jeffrey C. Cabrera, and Sarah Mae G. Villarmino-Estorque Reviewers/editors: Kristher Purio; Joshua Manila Region IV-B — MIMAROPA DENR MIMAROPA Green Assessment Team Reviewers/editors: Kissther Purio; Jennica Masigan Region V — Bicol Natural Park DENR Region V and its field offices and the Bicol Natural Park management team, led by Ma. Pia Cariño and Ralph Portades Reviewer/editor: Czeskian Realo; Mary Ann Bautista San Teodoro, Oriental Mindoro, Philippines © CCIPH San Teodoro, Oriental Mindoro, Philippines © CCIPH

x

x

x


x

© Kieth Pacardo for Ekomunikatib Multimedia Consultancy Services

First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Region V — Bulusan Volcano Natural Park DENR Region V–Sorsogon and the Sorsogon Provincial Planning and Development Office (PPDO), led by John Edward B. de la Cruz, Eleanor D. Lacsi-de la Cruz, and Jasmin P. Loyola Reviewers/editors: Czeskian Realo; Mary Ann Bautista

| 37

Everettʼs Tree Frog (Philautus everetti) © Rhiana Angelita Parr, CCIPH

Region VI — Ilog-Hilabangan Watershed Forest Reserve DENR Region VI–Western Visayas, with personnel from the Regional Office, PENRO Iloilo, PENRO Negros Occidental, and CENRO Kabankalan City Reviewer/editor: Kristher Purio Region VII — Carood Watershed DENR Central Visayas Reviewers/editors: Joshua Manila; Kristher Purio Region VIII — Panaon Island DENR Region VIII and CENRO San Juan Reviewers/editors: Kristher Purio; Jennica Masigan

x

x

Region IX — Pasonanca Natural Park DENR Region IX Zamboanga Peninsula, led by Cyrus B. Bayawa, Robert R. Ortiz, and Leo V. Baes Reviewers/editors: Kristher Purio; Joshua Manila Region X — Camiguin DENR Region X GARF team: Jordan Laranjo, Earl Marc J. Domingo, Juleus Fabre, Edanson Cañete, John Aizer Simudlan, Samsudin Casurra, Redelyn P. Flores, Gabriel Dipus, and Agura Myrasol Reviewers/editors: Jennica Paula Masigan; Russel Atienza Region XI — Mainit Hot Spring Protected Landscape DENR Region XI Reviewer/editor: Kristher Purio Region XII — Mount Matutum DENR Region 12 GARF Team: For. Norhassan T. Pangcoga, For. Datu Ino M. Bagul, Jay C. Salmon, For. Amin Ahsan M. Pabil, James C. Villamon, Melanie Lambac, PASu Efren C. Hibaler, ISA Jomyr H. Flores, FT II Mark-Cel B. Geronimo, FR, Jhannery L. Boclaras Reviewer/editor: Joshua Manila Region XIII — Dinagat Islands DENR Region XIII: For. Marilou Macabuhay; For. Demcris R. Sabuero; For. Liza J. Maturan; Loi Marie O. Alacha PENRO Dinagat Islands: For. Maridel G. Ibarra; For. Arian Meire E. Damalerio; For. Charifie T. Alcarde; Mathet T. Mabascog; For. James Philip G. Alas; For. Joselyn O. Manliguez; Erik Felias; Benjamin Ellazo Reviewer/editor: Mary Ann Bautista


38 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Proofs of Concept GARF has been tested in real landscapes and refined through repeated application and field learning across different ecological and governance contexts in the Philippines. Since its initial applications, GARF has grown from a small set of post-disaster pilots into a broader national learning platform.

350+

DENR Staff Trained

28

Major Pilot Sites

21

Protected Areas Asserted

2

Biosphere Reserves

These milestones matter because the cases that follow are not isolated exercises. They are part of a broader effort to examine how GARF performs across different hazards, ecosystems, data conditions, and management settings. Part 2 presents proofs of concept from across the Philippines. Each case study examines how climate-related disasters and other hazards affect ecosystems, biodiversity, and communities. The case studies represent different stages of GARF application: some sites progressed through all three stages, while assessments at others ended after Stage 1 because of constraints involving time, data, access, or implementation. This variation reflects the conditions under which post-disaster environmental assessments take place.

GARF Stage 2 National Capacity Development Training for DENR © Pauline Abello De Castro, CCIPH


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 39

The case studies are therefore not intended to serve as definitive environmental impact assessments. Instead, they demonstrate how GARF can be applied under different data conditions, levels of technical capacity, ecosystem types, and post-disaster circumstances. Some focus on forests and protected areas; others examine wetlands, agricultural landscapes, coastal systems, watersheds, or highly modified environments. Some rely primarily on remote sensing and existing datasets, while others also incorporate field validation, biodiversity records, local knowledge, or site-specific analysis. Together, the case studies illustrate the frameworkʼs flexibility, its limitations, and the evidence gaps that must be acknowledged. They also demonstrate the potential and practical challenges of scaling GARF nationally.

CAR Apayao

Biosphere Reserve of the yApayaos (BRyA)

Region I Cagayan Valley

Region I Ilocos Norte CAR Benguet

Northern Portion of Itogon (under the Lower Agno Watershed Forest Reserve [LAWFR])

Minalungao National Park

Region I Ilocos Sur

Region V Camarines Sur

Bessang Pass Natural Monument/Landscape

NCR Quezon City

Mount Isarog Natural Park Bicol Natural Park Buhi Wildlife Sanctuary Caramoan National Park

La Mesa Watershed Reservation (LMWR)

Region V Catanduanes

Region IV-A Cavite

Catanduanes Natural Park

Mts. Palay-Palay Mataas na Gulod Protected Landscape

Region IV-B Occidental Mindoro

Region V Sorsogon

F.B. Harrison Game Refuge and Bird Sanctuary (FBH GRBS)

Bulusan Volcano Natural Park

Region IV-B Oriental Mindoro

Region VIII Southern Leyte

Barangay Misong, Pola, Oriental Mindoro

LEGEND: Pilot Sites Demo Sites Incubator Sites

Region III Nueva Ecija

Wildlife Sanctuary of Baggao

Kalbario Patapat Natural Park (KPNP)

Mt. Nacolod Panaon Island

Region IV-B Palawan

Caraga

Kalbario Patapat Natural Park (KPNP)

Puerto Princesa Subterranean River National Park Cleopatraʼs Needle Critical Habitat Roxas, Palawan San Vicente Palawan

Region VII Bohol

Carood Watershed

Region XVIII Negros Occidental

Region VIII Siargao

IlogHilabangan Watershed Forest Reserve

Siargao Island Protected Landscape

Region X Camiguin

Region X Bukidnon

Mt. Timpoong-HibokHibok Natural Heritage

Mt. Kalatungan Range Natural Park

Region IX Zamboanga Zamboanga Peninsula Pasonanca Natural Park

Region XII South Cotabato

Mt. Matutum Protected Landscape

Region XII Davao

Mainit Hot Spring Protected Landscape

CCIPH Eco DRR Site Map

Pilot sites are landscapes where GARF was initially developed, piloted, and refined. Demonstration sites are areas where DENR personnel applied the framework after initial capacity-building activities under the USAID SIBOL project. Incubator sites are Eco-DRR project sites supported by the Government of Canada, where GARF is being further refined, adapted to local conditions, and expanded through field application, training, and institutional learning.


40 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

NCR

A Greener Canopy in the La Mesa Watershed Based on the assessment by: DENR National Capital Region, led by For. Aida Esguerra and For. Arturo Calderon

Landscape

La Mesa Watershed Reservation, spanning parts of Quezon City, Caloocan City, and Rodriguez, Rizal

Ecosystem

Plantation forest and freshwater watershed

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Major typhoons affecting Metro Manila, including Pedring, Mario, and Ulysses

Assessment focus

Changes in vegetation and biodiversity; the assessment did not isolate damage caused by any one typhoon

GARF stages

Stages 1 and 2, excluding assessment of community impacts

© Kieth Pacardo for Ekomunikatib Multimedia Consultancy Services


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 41

A Forest within the Metropolis La Mesa Watershed Reservation covers approximately 2,659 hectares on the edge of Metro Manila. Established to protect water quantity, quality, and security, it comprises a plantation forest and a freshwater system serving a densely populated urban region. Its present forest is the product of decades of planting and management, making La Mesa an unusual GARF case study. The DENRNCR team examined changes in vegetation cover and biodiversity following greening efforts and during a period when several major typhoons affected the region. The assessment therefore examined longerterm forest conditions rather than estimating damage caused by a single event.

Luzon Scops Owl (Otus longicornis)) © DENR National Capital Region

The team compared satellite imagery from June 2010–June 2011 with imagery from June 2022–June 2023. It also surveyed vegetation and fauna and modeled habitat suitability for selected tree species. Together, these approaches provided information about the forest canopy, species composition, and wildlife.

Key Findings The satellite analysis showed a general increase in vegetation greenness. In the earlier imagery, moderately dense forest was the dominant mapped class. In the later imagery, dense forest predominated. This indicates an increase in mapped vegetation density over more than a decade.

Monitoring and assessment activities of DENR National Capital Region © DENR National Capital Region

Assessors recorded 593 trees representing 55 species. Of the individual trees counted, the report classified 355 as indigenous, 17 as endemic, 210 as exotic, and 11 as miscellaneous. The team observed multilayered vegetation and relatively few fallen large trees or dead standing trees. Its fauna surveys recorded 45 species: 33 birds, six reptiles, three amphibians, and three mammals. Wildlife activity was generally higher farther from roads and trails.

A denser canopy does not tell the whole ecological story. La Mesaʼs planting history includes introduced species such as mahogany (Swietenia macrophylla) and yemane (Gmelina arborea), as well as native trees such as narra (Pterocarpus indicus) and molave (Vitex parviflora). The presence of introduced trees reflects earlier planting decisions but raises an important management question: as canopy cover increases, are native species also establishing and regenerating?


42 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

La Mesa Watershed Normalized Difference Vegtation Index (NDVI) Map (2010-2011)

La Mesa Watershed Normalized Difference Vegtation Index (NDVI) Map (2022-2023)


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

The assessment modelled potential habitat for mahogany, yemane, narra, and molave. It identified broadly suitable conditions for narra and areas in the southern watershed that may favor narra and molave. These maps can help direct field checks and consideration of native species enrichment. Modelled suitability, however, is neither a record of a treeʼs presence at every mapped location nor proof that planting is needed there.

Modeled Habitat Suitability for Mahogany (Swietenia macrophylla) in LMWR

Modeled Habitat Suitability for Yemane (Gmelina arborea) in LMWR

| 43


44 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Modeled Habitat Suitability for Molave (Vitex parviflora) in LMWR

Modeled Habitat Suitability for Narra (Pterocarpus indicus) in LMWR


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 45

Management and Recovery Priorities The assessment cannot reconstruct the environmental effects of the typhoons that passed through the region. It does, however, establish a clearer account of the watershedʼs later vegetation and biodiversity condition. Continued monitoring would make that account more useful as baseline data when the next major disturbance occurs.

La Mesa Watershed Reservation © CCIPH

GARF Lesson La Mesa shows why GARF cannot stop at Stage 1 rapid appraisal. The imagery indicated a denser, greener forest, but Stage 2 field surveys found extensive stands of introduced mahogany and yemane alongside native trees. These findings raise concerns about the spread of introduced species. Greater canopy cover does not necessarily indicate better habitat or the recovery of native forest. The evidence also had technical limits. The Landsat imagery made mixed land cover difficult to classify precisely. The planned RPAS survey at the NGP site could not be completed because the available drone lacked the spectral sensors needed for NDVI analysis. Most importantly, the assessment took place long after several typhoons. It documented the forestʼs later condition but could not isolate typhoon damage or measure post-typhoon recovery. GARF needs timely observations and field evidence of species composition to distinguish disaster impacts and to judge whether a denser forest is also becoming a healthier one. Credits and Source Original assessment: Department of Environment and Natural Resources–National Capital Region, Green Assessment Framework Stage 2 in La Mesa Watershed Reservation. Team leader: For. Aida Esguerra. Assistant team leader: For. Arturo Calderon. Rapid Biodiversity Assessment team: Christopher Villarin, Frenz Carlo Balagas, Justin De Ramos, For. Joshua Vasquez, Maria Ella Aquino, For. Aira Marie Carlos, For. Raymond Villar, Felipe Sore Jr., For. Kerk Zairius Calvara, Michelle Gonzales, For. Erisa Joy Arcillas, Vivian Jaen, Emmanuel Cordova, Chard Elson Cariaso, For. Elyzza Mae Torre, Joanne Kim Tacleon, Diego Montesclaros Jr., Francisco Palmero, For. Lemuel Tolosa, Jerry Lanzarote, For. Richelle De Juan, Jeric Agustin, For. Mark Gabriel de Guzman, and Regie Maximo. RPAS ground-truthing team, as listed in the report: Engr. Patrick Macazo, Charleston Bauy, Engr. Jo Christelle Letrero, Febsmarkson Plopino, Engr. Mark Ian Luis, Jondrex Peralta, For. Karen Carandang, and Jonathan Lambiquit.


46 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

REGION I

Assessing Ecosystem Damage, Biodiversity, and Recovery Needs at Bessang Pass Natural Monument/Landmark Based on the assessment by: DENR Region I, led by Ralphy L. Tan, Alain M. Dayao II, Jozald Kaye P. Ceralde, Merven D. Medrano, and Mary Joy F. Pascua Landscape

Bessang Pass Natural Monument/Landmark, Barangay Malaya, Cervantes, Ilocos Sur, at around 1,500 MASL

Ecosystem

Submontane mossy forest, pine forest, and mixed montane rainforest

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Typhoon Egay

Assessment focus

Changes in land cover and biodiversity in response to the reported effects of Typhoon Egay on Northern Luzon

GARF stages

Stages 1 and 2, with preliminary maps for Stage 3

© Kieth Pacardo for Ekomunikatib Multimedia Consultancy Services


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 47

A Mountain Landscape Shaped by Forests and History Bessang Pass Natural Monument/Landmark (BPNML) is a protected mountain landscape and World War II memorial in Cervantes, Ilocos Sur. Its submontane mossy forests, pine forests, and mixed montane rainforests provide important upland habitat for plants and wildlife adapted to high-elevation conditions. Bessang Creek and the Matukbo River cross the protected area and provide water resources for Cervantes and surrounding communities.

Habitat and species captured in Bessang Pass Natural Monument /Landmark. © DENR Region I

In July 2023, Typhoon Egay (international name Doksuri) caused environmental and structural damage in and around BPNML. Prolonged rainfall and strong winds, combined with steep and rugged terrain, contributed to soil erosion, landslides, and rockfalls. DENR Region I applied GARF to assess post-event ecosystem and biodiversity conditions and inform recovery and restoration.

Key Findings GARF Stage 1 NDVI comparison detected little or no vegetation change between the selected pre- and post-Egay images. However, extensive cloud cover affected imagery from August to early November. Landsat 8 surface-reflectance data produced similarly limited results. The analysis therefore could not characterize the full extent of post-typhoon vegetation change.

GARF Stage 2 Because Stage 1 detected little change, the team proceeded to aerial ground-truthing and rapid biodiversity assessment. The resulting land-cover maps indicated more substantial landscape changes than the initial NDVI analysis.


48 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Land-cover maps of BPNML before and after Typhoon Egay

Before Egay, shrubland and open forest covered much of the assessed area. Postevent mapping classified some portions as annual cropland or barren land. Approximately 160.56 hectares of forest were mapped as damaged or disturbed. These changes cannot be attributed entirely to the typhoon because existing activities, including shifting cultivation or kaingin, also affected the area.

Persistent Forest Cover and Forest Change Map in BPNML


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 49

Modeled habitat suitability for Nepenthes alata in BPNML

The biodiversity assessment recorded five endemic plant species and one threatened plant species, including Benguet pine (Pinus kesiya), jewel vine (Strongylodon zschokkei), pitcher plant (Nepenthes alata), ladew (Vaccinium barandanum), and gubangbang (Medinilla pendula). Habitat-suitability modeling indicated that N. alata was associated mainly with higher-elevation open forest.

Species captured in Bessang Pass Natural Monument /Landmark. © DENR Region I

GARF Stage 3 Persistent forests were prioritized for protection. Damaged or disturbed areas were identified for spontaneous natural regeneration (SNR) or assisted natural regeneration (ANR). Areas above 1,500 meters with slopes exceeding 50% were recommended for SNR because of their steep terrain and limited accessibility. Sites proposed for ANR require further field assessment to determine whether enrichment planting or another intervention is appropriate.


50 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Potential areas for spontaneous and assisted natural regeneration

Potential areas for spontaneous and assisted natural regeneration


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 51

Bessang Pass Natural Monument /Landmark. © Mind Trip

Management and Recovery Priorities Based on the GARF results, the following management actions are recommended for the Bessang Pass Natural Monument/Landmark: Prioritize relatively intact and persistent forests for protection, as these areas continue to provide important habitat, water-regulation functions, and sources of biodiversity. Avoid further land conversion and disturbance in these areas. Allow natural recovery in suitable areas. Limiting further disturbance in these areas can support recovery while reducing the risks associated with intensive restoration activities. Existing disturbances such as shifting cultivation or kaingin should be addressed through appropriate management, community engagement, and restoration measures. Where feasible, work with local communities to identify sustainable alternatives that reduce pressure on recovering forest areas.

Monitoring and assessment activities of DENR Region I

Credits and Source: The report data were collected by the Green Assessment Team of DENR Region 1, composed of personnel from the Regional Office, CENRO Bangui, CENRO Laoag, CENRO Bantay, CENRO Tagudin, CENRO Alaminos, and CENRO Dagupan: Ralphy L. Tan, Alain M. Dayao, Jozald Kaye P. Ceralde, Merven D. Medrano, Mary Joy F. Pascua, Cielo Marie Acacio, Gerald Allen Campañano, Rhoel Marcelo, Stanley C. Andres, Maricel D. Reyes, Jeusom Jerie C. Manuel, Dennis J. Abella, Rock D. Baguitan, John Paul V. Ibo, Randy Bolesa, Lester Parian, Kevin Lingaling, Dave Maregmen, Genesis Sison, Epler Telado, and Crisostomo S. Mari, Jr.


52 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

REGION II

Typhoon Egay’s Impacts on Baggao Wildlife Sanctuary Based on an assessment by: DENR Region II Green Assessment Team, led by Arnold A. Battung, with Lorraine B. Cabalza, Elvis Tumanguil, Klevin Soriano, Ronald Addatu, Jessie Guerrero, Roselyn T. Gola, Jasmin E. Gannaban, Edmundo Mata, and Johnrey R. Agcaoili.

Landscape

Baggao Wildlife Sanctuary, Cagayan

Ecosystem

Forest, shrubland, inland water, and agricultural areas

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Typhoon Egay

Assessment focus

Changes in vegetation and habitat, biodiversity, and community resource use

GARF stages

Stages 1 and 2

© Kieth Pacardo for Ekomunikatib Multimedia Consultancy Services


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 53

The Baggao Wildlife Sanctuary Baggao Wildlife Sanctuary is a 574.40-hectare locally declared conservation area in Cagayan. Its forests provide habitat for threatened and endemic species, while residents use parts of the landscape for farming, water, non-timber forest products, and recreation. Community resource mapping also identified an Agta burial ground. These ecological, livelihood, and cultural values made it important to assess more than canopy condition after Typhoon Egay.

Key Findings Field observations indicated less typhoon damage than the NDVI maps alone appeared to suggest. Surveys found limited defoliation and some broken stems and branches but did not detect extensive damage to overall vegetation cover at the locations assessed. These observations do not establish the condition of every part of the sanctuary. Community mapping added values that a vegetation map could not show. Participants identified the sanctuary as a source of clean water and non-timber forest products, as well as a place with caves, falls, springs, hunting areas, and an Agta burial ground. The assessment identified these community resources and cultural values, but did not establish whether Typhoon Egay affected access to them or their condition.

Management and Recovery Priorities No specific recovery interventions were identified at this stage. Timber poaching and kaingin were observed and should be considered when interpreting future changes in forest cover and planning site management.

GARF Lesson Baggao demonstrates why satellite indications of post-event change require field interpretation. Prompt field documentation and a reliable pre-event baseline would help distinguish typhoon effects from timber poaching, kaingin, and other drivers of change. Community follow-up could also determine whether the event affected water sources, forest products, or culturally important places identified during resource mapping. Recording conditions soon after an event and comparing them with a reliable pre-event baseline would help distinguish typhoon damage from timber poaching, kaingin, and other changes. Community observations could also establish whether damage affected water, forest products, and culturally important places, which this assessment identified but did not evaluate for post-typhoon impacts. Credits and Source Assessment credit: DENR Region II Green Assessment Team, led by Arnold A. Battung, with Lorraine B. Cabalza, Elvis Tumanguil, Klevin Soriano, Ronald Addatu, Jessie Guerrero, Roselyn T. Gola, Jasmin E. Gannaban, Edmundo Mata, and Johnrey R. Agcaoili.


54 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

REGION III

Tracing Super Typhoon Karding’s Impact in Minalungao National Park Based on the assessment by: DENR Region III GARF Team, led by Mariqueen Andrea D. Arcia, with Emmanuel B. Penson Jr. as assistant team leader, and Janelyn B. Tummiguing, Cedric Al F Roque, Sheila H. Cabrera, Glenn Marc P. Salazar, Brix A. Francisco, Mark Anthony M. Rifa, Castor P. Mejico Jr., Michaelle Mc C. Taguinod, Kristine V. Silvestre, Raquel H. Fernandez, Percival R. Caba, Leovino P. Salamanca Jr., Joed V. Aplacador, Rico D. Linsangan, Rowell M. Cantor, Honey Jane M. Macalinao, and Aljohn A. Fernandez Landscape

Minalungao National Park

Ecosystem

Agricultural land, limestone forest, rivers, caves, bamboo areas

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Super Typhoon Karding, 2022

Assessment focus

Changes in vegetation and habitat, biodiversity, and community resource use

GARF stages

Stages 1 and 2

© Kieth Pacardo for Ekomunikatib Multimedia Consultancy Services


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 55

Minalungao National Park © Ja Siticer

A landscape of life and livelihood Minalungao National Park in General Tinio, Nueva Ecija, contains limestone forest, agricultural land, rivers, caves, and bamboo areas. These resources provide water, food, income, raw materials, and other ecosystem services to surrounding communities. Community resource mapping identified farm lots, livestock, wildlife, water sources, planted and naturally occurring trees and bamboo, and livelihood activities such as harvesting buho bamboo and producing charcoal. Because communities depend on these resources, the team used the first two GARF stages to examine changes in vegetation and biodiversity and impacts on community resources following Super Typhoon Karding.

Key findings Pre- and post-event NDVI maps indicated reduced vegetation greenness following Karding. Later image classification identified changes between forest and nonforest areas and between open- and

Philippine sailfin lizard (Hydrosaurus pustulatus)

closed-forest conditions. Imagery analyzed approximately two years after the typhoon indicated substantial vegetation recovery after the initial disturbance.

Pre- and Post- extreme events NDVI map of Minalungao National Park


56 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES Before typhoon

After typhoon

Table 3. Summary table of the images before and after the typhoon.

A CENRO Cabanatuan City assessment conducted one week after Karding reported that more than 51% of stems were broken, more than 61% of crowns were defoliated, and more than 45% of trees were bent or uprooted. Stage 2 fieldwork conducted later recorded less visible damage after natural regeneration had begun. The contrast shows why assessment timing matters: conditions observed months or years after a typhoon may differ substantially from the immediate damage. Community observations identified affected plantations, agricultural areas, rivers, water sources, houses, schools, and other resource-dependent areas within MNP. The assessment also documented damage to protected-area facilities and community resources, including vegetation, crops, livestock, houses, and school infrastructure.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 57

Management and Recovery Priorities For GARF, the priority is to identify where forest, riverbank vegetation, and other habitats need protection or restoration, and where damage to these ecosystems has affected water, raw materials, and livelihoods. The assessment also points to continued support for households whose crops, livestock, and plantations were recovering slowly. These findings can inform a later green recovery plan, but GARF Stage 3 has not been completed.

Damaged community resources, including trees, protected area facilities and houses © DENR Region 3

The GARF team also recommended deep wells, building and electrical repairs, engineering inspection, riverbank structures, and rescue and clearing equipment. These water-supply, infrastructure, engineering, and emergency-response measures fall outside GARFʼs ecological assessment and restoration scope. They should be referred to the appropriate LGU, utility, engineering, and disaster-response authorities, informed by GARF findings where ecosystem condition affects planning.

GARF Lesson This case study shows the value of connecting immediate damage records with later ecological and community assessments. Early observations captured severe tree damage; later fieldwork recorded a landscape already undergoing regeneration. Satellite maps, drone imagery, biodiversity surveys, and community accounts each contributed a different part of that timeline. The delay also limited what Stage 2 could establish about Kardingʼs immediate ecological impact. Future assessments need prompt, safely timed documentation after an event, followed by repeat surveys that measure recovery. Reliable pre-event baselines and consistent field locations would make those comparisons stronger. Future GARF applications would benefit from stronger field and geospatial skills, reliable and compatible assessment tools, greater data-processing capacity, and improved community data-collection instruments. The report specifically identified training needs involving QGIS, NDVI processing, MaxEnt, drone operation, Pix4D compatibility, and semistructured FGD and KII guides. Credits and Sources Original assessment: Department of Environment and Natural Resources–Central Luzon. Green Assessment of Minalungao National Park. Team Leader: Mariqueen Andrea D. Arcia, Assistant team leader: Emmanuel B. Penson Jr. Team member: Janelyn B. Tummiguing, Cedric Al F Roque, Sheila H. Cabrera, Glenn Marc P. Salazar, Brix A. Francisco, Mark Anthony M. Rifa, Castor P. Mejico, Jr., Michaelle Mc C. Taguinod, Kristine V. Silvestre, Raquel H. Fernandez, Percival R. Caba, Leovino P. Salamanca, Jr., Joed V. Aplacador, Rico D. Linsangan, Rowell M. Cantor, Honey Jane M. Macalinao, and Aljohn A. Fernandez


58 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

CAR

Mapping Potential Vegetation Change after Typhoon Emong in Calanasan, Apayao Based on the assessment by: Allison Pasamic, LGU Calanasan; Joen Vita, Richard delos Reyes, and Angela Dason, PENRO Apayao

Landscape

Calanasan, Apayao within the yApayaos Biosphere Reserve

Ecosystem

Forest, riverine/freshwater, riparian, agricultural, agroforestry, and grassland/open vegetation ecosystems.

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Typhoon Emong

Assessment focus

Changes in vegetation after Typhoon Emong

GARF stages

Stage 1


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 59

A First Look across an Extensive Forest Landscape Calanasanʼs forested mountains, agricultural areas, and river systems lie within the yApayaos Biosphere Reserve. These interconnected habitats support species of conservation concern, including the Philippine eagle (Pithecophaga jefferyi), and provide resources for surrounding communities. After Typhoon Emong affected the area in July 2025, GARF Stage 1 used satellite imagery to identify potential vegetation changes and locations requiring closer assessment. The assessment mapped approximately 151,949 hectares, allowing an initial comparison across an extensive landscape. NDVI-based classification grouped areas according to vegetation greenness. These classes provide an initial indication of possible vegetation change but require field validation before they can be interpreted as forest damage, land conversion, or ecological recovery.

Key findings Comparison of the selected pre- and post-Emong images indicated shifts among the mapped vegetation classes. The area classified as high-greenness forest decreased by approximately 4,331 hectares. Areas classified as moderate- and low-greenness forest increased by 2,868.78 hectares and 465.50 hectares, respectively. Bare soil or settlement increased by 502.59 hectares, cropland or grassland by 359.25 hectares, and shrubland or mixed vegetation by 212.03 hectares. Areas near river systems also appeared to shift toward lower-greenness classes. Preliminary information from the local government suggested possible conversion to cropland, but the imagery alone cannot confirm whether conversion occurred or when it took place.

NDVI Maps before and after Typhoon Emong


60 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES The mapped shifts may reflect changes in canopy density or vegetation condition. However, satellite data alone cannot determine whether they resulted from typhoonrelated defoliation, land-use activities, seasonal differences, classification effects, or a combination of factors. Field validation is needed to determine what changed on the ground, the extent of any ecological disturbance, and how much of that change can reasonably be linked to Emong.

Pre-event Land Cover Classification Map

Post-event Land Cover Classification Map


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Area by NDVI-Derived Class before and after Typhoon Emong Pre-Emong

Post-Emong

Area (Hectares)

Area (Hectares)

Water/Built--up

1,214.71

1,171.34

-43.37

Baresoil/Settlement

894.72

1,397.31

502.586

Cropland/Grassland

1,827.44

2,186.69

359.25

Grassland/Shrubland

564.98

521.03

-43.951

Shrubland/Mixed Vegetation

3,171.57

3,383.60

212.03

Forest ‘Lowˮ

1,899.48

2,364.98

465.5

Forest “Moderateʼ

5,389.68

8,258.46

2,868.78

Forest ‘Highʼ

136,986.00

132,655.00

-4,331

Total

151,948.59

151,938.41

-10.175

LAND COVER CLASSIFICATION

Net Change

Note: The approximately 10.18-hectare difference between the pre- and post-event totals may reflect differences in pixel coverage, image masking, or assessment boundaries rather than an actual change in landscape area.

Management and Recovery Priorities The immediate priority is Stage 2 field validation of the mapped changes. Sampling should include locations where high-greenness forest declined, bare soil or open vegetation increased, and possible cropland conversion was reported near river systems. Relatively unchanged locations should also be assessed to provide comparison sites. Field surveys should distinguish typhoon-related defoliation, broken or uprooted trees, landslides, agricultural clearing, and other disturbances. Biodiversity assessment can then examine the possible implications of verified habitat changes for species occurrence, food resources, nesting sites, and habitat connectivity. Attention to species of conservation concern should be guided by existing records and verified habitat locations. Community consultations should document whether changes in forests and rivers affected freshwater, wild foods, medicinal plants, rattan, and other locally important resources. Indigenous and local knowledge can help determine when these changes occurred and whether they preceded or followed the typhoon.

| 61


62 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Mt. Kilang, yApayaos Biosphere Reserve. © LGU and PENRO Apayao

GARF Lesson A change in NDVI class is not, by itself, evidence of disaster damage. The 4,331-hectare decline in high-greenness forest identifies questions for investigation: Where did vegetation greenness decrease? What changed on the ground? How much of that change can reasonably be linked to Emong? Preliminary reports of possible cropland conversion near rivers show why this distinction matters. A stronger assessment requires documented image-acquisition dates, comparable seasonal conditions, cloud screening or masking, and consistent classification thresholds. Stage 2 should then connect the mapped signals with habitat condition, biodiversity, and community resource use. This sequence allows GARF to move from detecting possible disturbance to identifying ecological losses and appropriate recovery measures.

Credits and Sources Assessment contributors: Allison Pasamic, LGU Calanasan; Joen Vita, Richard delos Reyes, and Angela Dason, PENRO Apayao.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 63

CALABARZON

Vegetation Recovery in Mts. Palay-Palay– Mataas na Gulod Protected Landscape Based on an assessment by: DENR Region IV-A, including Mark R. Garcia, Jeffrey C. Cabrera, and Sarah Mae G. Villarmino-Estorque

Landscape

Mts. Palay-Palay Mataas na Gulod Protected Landscape (MPPMNGPL)

Ecosystem

Open forest and Secondary-growth forest

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

No specific disaster was assessed; the team applied GARF methods to examine longer-term ecosystem degradation.

Assessment focus

Change in vegetation and biodiversity

GARF stages

Stages 1 and 2, excluding assessment of community impacts

© Kieth Pacardo for Ekomunikatib Multimedia Consultancy Services


64 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

The Ecological Footprint of Tourism Mts. Palay-Palay–Mataas na Gulod Protected Landscape (MPPMNGPL) is a legislated protected area in Cavite. Its surveyed vegetation consists primarily of open forest and secondary-growth forest. The area became a popular ecotourism destination between 2007 and 2016. During this period, high visitor numbers were associated with environmental degradation and pressure on biodiversity. PENRO Cavite closed the protected area to the public in 2017 to support rehabilitation and reopened it on January 12, 2023.

Mts. Palay-Palay–Mataas na Gulod Protected Landscape. © Green Ph

This case differs from the post-disaster assessments elsewhere in the manual. No specific typhoon or other discrete event was identified as the cause of the observed changes. Instead, the assessment applied GARF methods to examine conditions during a period of restricted public access. Stage 1 compared Sentinel-2 NDVI imagery from 2016 and 2022. Stage 2 included drone mapping and a rapid biodiversity survey.

Key Findings During 2007–2016, MPPMGPL became a major/top ecotourism destination because of its pristine and diverse ecosystem. During this period, the environmental condition became degraded and devastated due to the overnumber of visitors and travelers, and the biodiversity condition also worsened. This degradation led PENRO Cavite to close the protected area to the public in 2017 for rehabilitation. The five-year closure provided an opportunity for forest and vegetation recovery. The increase in NDVI values and vegetation cover indicates that secondary-growth and open forest areas experienced ecological improvement during the rehabilitation period. NDVI values ranged from −0.03 to 0.53 in 2016 and from −0.09 to 0.95 in 2022. The assessment estimated vegetation cover at 45– 50% in 2016 and approximately 80% in 2022. These results indicate greater vegetation greenness and mapped cover during the closure period. They do not, by themselves, establish that closure or Map of computed NDVI for year 2016 and 2022 of MPPMNGPL rehabilitation activities caused the change.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 65

Management and Recovery Priorities Sustain ecosystem rehabilitation, regulate visitor pressure, and continuously monitor vegetation and biodiversity recovery. The closure of the protected landscape in 2017 provided an opportunity for the degraded ecosystem to recover, while its reopening in 2023 under a daily carrying-capacity limit established a mechanism for controlling visitor pressure.

Drone mapping was introduced to support the post-event vegetation assessment in Mts. Palay-Palay–Mataas na Gulod Protected Landscape. © DENR Region IV-A

Management should sustain this regulated access while continuing vegetation assessment through remote sensing, NDVI, UAV/drone surveys, and ground truthing, together with field-based biodiversity assessments covering both flora and fauna. These measures provide the basis for tracking whether the improved vegetation condition and biodiversity values observed after the closure are maintained over time. Flight and deployment plan generation using DJI Pilot.

GARF Lesson Processing of aerial the images using Agisoft andremote mapping of the GIS, area drone of interest. The assessment demonstrated value of integrating sensing, mapping, and rapid biodiversity assessment to establish ecosystem and biodiversity conditions. The assessment showed that spatial analysis is strengthened by field validation, providing a clearer basis for understanding ecological conditions in MPPMNGPL.

Continued and adequately representative field monitoring is necessary. The vegetation assessment had limited field coverage because only four of nine plots were surveyed due to weather conditions, while the biodiversity assessment was conducted as a rapid assessment. Thus, recovery assessments can provide useful evidence of ecosystem condition, but repeated field surveys and broader coverage are needed to track biodiversity and ecosystem changes over time The case tests the boundary of GARFʼs post-disaster purpose. Without a defined hazard event and corresponding post-event assessment, the results describe ecological change during a period of restricted access rather than disaster loss and recovery. The case nevertheless shows how GARF methods can help establish a baseline for future disturbance assessment. Credits and Source Original assessment: Department of Environment and Natural Resources - Region IV-A. Green Assessment Framework Stage 1 and Stage 2 in Mts. Palay-Palay Mataas na Gulod Protected Landscape, including Mark R. Garcia, Jeffrey C. Cabrera, and Sarah Mae G. Villarmino-Estorque


66 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

MIMAROPA

What an Oil Spill Reveals about GARF’s Limits Based on an assessment by: DENR MIMAROPA Green Assessment Team

Landscape

Barangay Misong, Pola, Oriental Mindoro

Ecosystem

Mangrove, coastal and marine ecosystems

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

MT Princess Empress oil spill, February 2023

Assessment focus

Land-cover change, extent of oil contamination and mangrove damage, biodiversity, and impacts on community resources and livelihoods

GARF stages

Stages 1 and 2

© Kieth Pacardo for Ekomunikatib Multimedia Consultancy Services


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 67

MT Princess Empress oil spill, February 2023 © Insurance Asia News

Can GARF Be Adapted to Technological Accidents? On February 28, 2023, the MT Princess Empress, carrying 800,000 liters of industrial fuel oil, sank in the Tablas Strait near Baliwangan Point, Naujan, Oriental Mindoro. The spill affected coastal and marine resources and communities in Mindoro. The assessment team selected Barangay Misong in Pola because its mangroves were directly exposed, coastal-dependent communities lived nearby, and the site was accessible. The report identified Misong as one of the areas most directly affected by the spill. Barangay Misong contained approximately 10.06 hectares of mangroves. The report classified 8.43 hectares as affected and 1.62 hectares as contaminated. The assessment combined satellite-based NDVI analysis, RPAS ground-truthing, biodiversity surveys, and community resource mapping to examine land-cover change, oil exposure and possible mangrove damage, and effects on communities and mangrove ecosystems.

Key Findings Satellite analysis indicated generally dense vegetation before and after the spill, with slightly greater variation in post-spill vegetation greenness. NDVI measures vegetation greenness rather than tree numbers, stand density, oil exposure, or chemical contamination. Post-spill classification identified six of 37 assessment points as potentially damaged mangrove and 31 as persistent mangrove cover. These classifications do not demonstrate that the changes were caused by the spill. Oil transported by water may affect roots, sediment, understory vegetation, seedlings, and regenerating plants before canopy effects become visible.


68 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES The mangrove forest was dominated by Avicennia alba, followed by Rhizophora apiculata. The sampled forest had a reported diversity index of 1.6343. Field teams observed oil sheen, scorch marks on stems and roots, and an oil odor in one of 16 sampled quadrats. Similar signs occurred outside the quadrats. Three standing dead mangroves were recorded, but their mortality could not be attributed conclusively to the spill because no visible oil contamination was found in the quadrats where they occurred.

Field teams deployed in the oil-spill affected mangrove forest in Oriental Mindoro observed oil sheen and scorch marks on stems and roots. © DENR MIMAROPA

Community mapping and discussion added a different measure of impact. Participants reported that fish catches remained smaller in quantity and size, with reduced income for fisherfolk, even after many visible signs of the spill had faded. These are community-reported changes, rather than a quantified fisheries time series. Residents also described greater appreciation of mangroves as a buffer and of land-based income options when fishing is disrupted.

Notable Geotags during the Rapid Appraisal and Ground Truthing Survey at Brgy. Misong, Oriental Mindoro


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 69

Flora Sampling Design Map at Brgy. Misong, Oriental Mindoro

Fauna Sampling Design map at Brgy. Misong, Oriental Mindoro

Management and Recovery Priorities Mangroves with documented signs of oil should be revisited to track root, seedling, and tree condition over time. Repeat field observations are especially important because canopy greenness may remain high while contamination affects regenerants or other parts of the ecosystem. Solid waste and mangrove cutting are additional management concerns identified in the assessment. Community coastal monitoring can address these ongoing pressures while


70 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES protecting remaining mangrove patches. Monitoring should also follow aquatic resources and fisherfolk livelihoods, alongside mangrove conditions. The oil spill event in Misong offers an opportunity for an economic valuation study linking changes in ecosystem services to reported declines in fish catch and fishing income. Such a study would need pre-spill fisheries and livelihood data and account for fishing restrictions, seasonal variation, and other influences on catch to estimate losses attributable to the spill.

GARF Lesson This case study reveals a methodological boundary for GARF. Its vegetation indices and ecosystem-themed land-cover change maps were developed mainly for disturbances that alter land cover or canopy condition. It also helps clarify the intended scope of GARF. GARF was developed primarily for climate-related extreme weather events and the biodiversity and ecosystem impacts associated with them. A technological disaster such as an oil spill therefore falls outside its core hazard scope and requires specialized contamination assessment methods that GARF was not designed to provide. The case nevertheless demonstrates the value of several principles embedded in GARF. Remote sensing, field observations, biodiversity information, and community resourceuse evidence can be brought together to understand how an environmental disturbance affects both ecosystems and the people who depend on them. Reports of reduced fish catch and income, for example, showed why recovery cannot be assessed through visible ecosystem condition alone. For oil spills, however, establishing exposure, contamination, and ecological effects requires hazard-specific evidence, such as mapped oil extent and movement, examination of sediments and affected organisms, repeated monitoring for delayed effects, and laboratory testing where chemical contamination must be confirmed. The lesson from Mindoro is therefore not that GARF should be applied directly to technological disasters, but that its integrated approach to ecological and community evidence can inform broader environmental assessment practice. For GARF itself, the framework remains focused on climate-related extreme weather events. Credits and Source Original assessment: Assessment of Mangrove Areas Contaminated by Oil Spill in Barangay Misong, Pola, Oriental Mindoro, MIMAROPA Region. Assessment conducted by: DENR MIMAROPA GAF-RAGTST, with personnel from the Regional Office Conservation and Development Division, Tamaraw Conservation Program, Naujan Lake National Park Protected Area Management Office, and CENRO Socorro. Flora survey: Karla S. Mangundayao, Ma. Fatima I. Critica, Lester John A. Estremera, John Japheth F. Fabellon, Jico V. Eguaras, and Zarex P. Dela Cruz. Fauna survey: Jhoanne Mae E. Dapito, Jose Maria M. Fontanilla, Mikko Angelo C. Reyes, Geronimo S. Barcena, Gener B. Fantuyaw, Arjay R. Dapatnapu, and Eugene D. Elipe. Community resource mapping: Lester John A. Estremera. Rapid appraisal and drone ground verification: Allen M. Ablang and Roberto Martin C. Pagatpatan.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 71

REGION V

Biodiversity and Ecosystem Loss and Damage in Bicol Natural Park (BNP) Following Successive Tropical Cyclones in 2020 Based on the assessment conducted by: DENR Region V and its field offices and the Bicol Natural Park management team, led by Ma. Pia Cariño and Ralph Portadess

Landscape

Bicol Natural Park (BNP)

Ecosystem

Lowland forest and riverine ecosystems

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Successive tropical cyclones Quinta, Rolly, and Ulysses, October–November 2020

Assessment focus

Potential biodiversity loss and ecosystem damage following successive tropical cyclones

GARF stages

Stages 1, 2, and 3


72 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Bicol Natural Park: Ecosystems and Biodiversity at Risk from Successive Tropical Cyclones Bicol Natural Park (BNP) is a legislated protected area in Region V covering approximately 5,466.35 hectares across Camarines Norte and Camarines Sur. It includes portions of Basud and San Lorenzo Ruiz in Camarines Norte and Lupi and Sipocot in Camarines Sur. The park contains three major rivers that provide drinking water and irrigation to surrounding communities, underscoring its ecological and socioeconomic importance. In 2020, BNP and the wider Bicol Region were affected by three successive tropical cyclones over approximately one month between late October and November: Typhoon Quinta (Molave), Super Typhoon Rolly (Goni), and Typhoon Ulysses (Vamco). Quinta struck the region in late October, with reported damage to vegetation and agricultural areas. Rolly made landfall on November 1, bringing destructive winds and heavy rainfall associated with extensive forest-canopy Damaged habitats in Bicol Natural Park disturbance, vegetation damage, and © DENR Region V BNP severe flooding. Before communities and ecosystems had recovered, Ulysses brought additional heavy rainfall and strong winds, contributing to further flooding, landslides, and vegetation damage across Camarines Norte and Camarines Sur. Because the cyclones occurred in close succession, the assessment could not readily distinguish the effects of each event. The cumulative effects of these successive cyclones may have significantly affected the parkʼs forest cover, biodiversity, and ecosystem functions, including watershed protection and water regulation. Given BNPʼs ecological importance and its role in supporting surrounding communities, GARF was applied to systematically assess the potential extent and severity of cyclone-related damage, identify affected habitats and ecosystem services, examine implications for local communities, and inform recovery planning.

Key Findings GARF Stage 1 NDVI maps derived from selected 2019 and 2021 satellite images showed lower vegetation greenness in the northeastern portion of the protected area and higher greenness in the northwestern portion, particularly in San Lorenzo Ruiz, Camarines Norte. These patterns indicate localized differences in vegetation condition but do not, by themselves, establish vegetation loss or recovery.

GARF Stage 2 During GARF Stage 2, aerial ground truthing with a DJI Mavic 3 was used to examine the land-cover conditions identified during the initial assessment. Much of the assessed area


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 73

consisted of perennial cropland, shown in dark brown, particularly banana and coconut plantations. Some areas mapped as shrubland before the cyclones were subsequently mapped as forest, shown in light and dark green, suggesting possible vegetation recovery or natural regeneration. Conversely, parts of Tuaca and San Pascual were mapped as changing from closed forest to barren land, shown from dark green to brown. Further field verification is needed to distinguish temporary canopy disturbance, landslides, and lasting land-cover conversion. Field observations and assessment information identified rainfall-induced landslides and wind damage in higher-elevation portions of Tuaca and San Pascual. These disturbances may have contributed to the mapped vegetation changes. Existing human activities may also have increased the vulnerability of vegetation and soils, although their relative influence was not quantified. The rapid biodiversity assessment documented post-event species richness and habitat conditions; without comparable pre-event biodiversity data, it could not quantify biodiversity loss caused by the cyclones. The survey recorded endemic and native species, with the family Dipterocarpaceae particularly well represented. Recorded trees included red lauan (Shorea negrosensis), dalindingan (Hopea foxworthyi), and manggachapui (Hopea acuminata), indicating that parts of the park retained important native forest elements after the storms.

Pre- and post-event Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) maps derived from 2019 and 2021 satellite imagery. Darker green indicates higher vegetation greenness, particularly in the northeastern portion of BNP, while lighter shades indicate lower greenness across the western and southern portions. The maps show differences in greenness between the selected dates rather than confirmed cyclone-related damage or recovery.


74 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Land-cover maps of Bicol Natural Park before (left) and after (right) the 2020 tropical cyclones, showing mapped forest, cultivated land, and other cover types.

Records of endemic fauna confirmed that affected habitats retained ecological value, but they do not establish population stability or recovery. Because the assessment provides only a post-event snapshot, repeated surveys are needed to determine longer-term changes in species abundance, distribution, and habitat use.

GARF team conducting habitat and flora assessments © DENR Region V BNP

Using the assessmentʼs rating scale, disturbed and undisturbed sites were generally classified at Levels 1–2, corresponding to approximately 0–60% defoliation and 1–50% broken stems. These conditions are consistent with wind and rainfall disturbance but do not, by themselves, attribute the observed damage to a particular cyclone. Pre- and post-event species-distribution models for red lauan predicted a slight reduction in suitable habitat in the eastern portion of BNP. This modeled change indicates potential habitat impacts, not confirmed loss of trees or populations.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Modeled habitat suitability for red lauan. Pre-event (left) and post-event (right) species-distribution models show predicted suitability from unsuitable to highly suitable, with observation points marked. Higher predicted suitability is concentrated in the northeastern portion. The maps indicate potential habitat conditions rather than confirmed species presence or abundance.

Communities within and adjacent to BNP depend on the protected area and surrounding landscape for water, agricultural production, and other natural resources. Community resource mapping and field validation documented extensive pineapple, banana, and coconut plantations, as well as expanding built-up areas associated with population growth and reported encroachment. Other reported pressures included unauthorized resource collection, kaingin, and illegal tree cutting. These activities may compound cyclone-related disturbance and impede ecological recovery.

Community resource map of Bicol Natural Park showing settlements, waterways, cultivated areas, trees, wildlife, and other resources identified by participants.

| 75


76 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Illegal activities within Bicol Natural Park © DENR Region V BNP

GARF Stage 3 Using Stage 2 data, the preliminary recovery plan identified priority sites based on mapped forest-cover change and site conditions. Of approximately 322 hectares mapped as changing from forest to non-forest, about 166 hectares were prioritized for initial recovery: 13 hectares for spontaneous natural regeneration (SNR) and 153 hectares for assisted natural regeneration (ANR). A separate 739 hectares of persistent forest was designated for protection. SNR allows natural recovery, while ANR, with or without enrichment planting, uses active measures to support regeneration.

Restoration-planning grids and blocks in Bicol Natural Park. Numbered spatial units support the selection and sequencing of restoration and protection activities. The left panel covers the park, while the right focuses on the Strict Protection Zone (SPZ).


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 77

Management and Recovery Priorities The preliminary Green Recovery Plan for BNP links restoration of disturbed areas with protection of remaining forest. Field assessments of surviving native trees, regenerating vegetation, seed sources, invasive plants, and continuing disturbance can refine the proposed allocation between spontaneous and assisted natural regeneration. Enrichment planting may be appropriate where verified regeneration gaps justify intervention. Continuing land-use pressures require attention alongside cyclone-related disturbance. Community mapping and aerial observations provide a basis for examining cultivation, settlement expansion, and reported clearing in relation to park boundaries and management zones. Addressing these pressures is essential to sustaining recovery. The pilot findings and preliminary recovery plan provide a foundation for further work under the Eco-DRR project in Camarines Sur. Additional field validation and stakeholder engagement can strengthen restoration priorities, implementation arrangements, and monitoring.

GARF Lesson The BNP case study illustrates the difficulty of assessing ecological impacts after successive disasters. The 2019–2021 comparison encompasses three tropical cyclones and other changes during the interval. It identifies potential disturbance and regeneration but cannot attribute the observed changes to a single cyclone. Pre-disaster baselines, observations between successive events where feasible, and repeated field surveys would strengthen interpretation. Stage 2 also showed why greenness alone is insufficient for assessing ecological condition. Native forest, banana and coconut plantations, and regenerating shrubs can all produce strong vegetation signals while supporting different species and ecological functions. Biodiversity surveys, land-cover interpretation, and community mapping help distinguish these conditions and identify pressures that may persist after the cyclones. The preliminary Stage 3 plan demonstrates a practical transition from assessment to recovery planning. However, mapped forest-to-non-forest change still requires interpretation: temporary canopy disturbance, landslides, and lasting land-cover conversion may require different responses. Restoration priorities are strengthened when each intervention is linked to verified ecological conditions and monitored for its effects on native biodiversity and ecosystem services.

Credits and Source Assessment conducted by DENR Region V, PENRO Camarines Norte, PENRO Camarines Sur, CENRO Sipocot, and CENRO Goa. GARF assessment team: Keith Harvey C. Dimaran, Ma. Pia S. Cariño, Jefferson O. De La Fuente, Loreta Chee T. Olvido, Louna Charisse S. Sapugay, Sonny P. Geromo Jr., Donyell Barrameda, Cheska B. Barreda, Carrie Ann D. Gogola, Terrence O. Morta, Cristina Reburiano, Ronnel Cabase, Angelo A. Calajate, Mark Joseph V. Raviz, Eugene S. Factor, Johanna Vargas, Cyrus Job P. Dela Cruz, Cathleen Kaye V. Abanto, John Mark R. Violeta, Ralph L. Portades, Jaiar Adlawan, Helmarc V. Valencia, Francis David D. Omana, Noel H. Villafuerte, and Eduardo Dacanay.


78 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

REGION V

Typhoon Disruptions on Unstable Slopes of Bulusan Volcano Natural Park Based on the assessment led by: DENR Region V GARF Team, with DENR PENRO Sorsogon and provincial, municipal, and barangay partners in Sorsogon; led by John Edward B. de la Cruz, Eleanor D. Lacsi-de la Cruz, and Jasmin P. Loyola

Landscape

Bulusan Volcano Natural Park (BVNP)

Ecosystems

Dipterocarp and montane forests; grasslands; lakes and freshwater springs; and riverine habitats

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Typhoon Uwan, November 2025

Assessment focus

Potential changes in vegetation and habitat condition, possible effects on freshwater ecosystems, and priorities for field validation

GARF stages

Stage 1 and preliminary Stage 2; comprehensive findings remain pending


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 79

Eco-DRR in Active Volcanic Landscapes and Lakes Located in south-central Sorsogon Province, Bulusan Volcano Natural Park surrounds the active Bulusan Volcano and the Bulusan, Aguingay, and Blackbirdʼs lakes. Recognized as a Key Biodiversity Area and Important Bird Area, the park provides habitat for threatened and restricted-range species, including the Philippine eagle (Pithecophaga jefferyi) and other species endemic to the Philippines. Its ecosystems supply water, support local livelihoods, and sustain ecotourism. They are also exposed to volcanic activity, rainfall-induced landslides, erosion, and sediment movement into rivers and lakes. As an Eco-DRR incubator site under the Building Capacities for Eco-Resilience in the Philippines project, BVNP is applying GARF to assess ecological disturbance and inform recovery planning. Typhoon Uwan in November 2025 provides the event context for the assessment. GARF implementation has reached the initial phase of Stage 2, in which field validation and biodiversity assessment are intended to clarify the extent of disturbance and its implications for habitats and ecosystem services. The findings presented here remain preliminary and subject to validation.

Key Findings The Stage 1 comparison used pre-event NDVI data from April–October 2025 and post-event data from November 2025. It identified areas of lower vegetation greenness, including within mapped closed forest. These changes may be consistent with canopy defoliation and treefall, but the imagery alone cannot confirm their cause or the specific type of damage. Bulusan and Aguingay lakes were also identified as potentially susceptible to sediment inputs, which requires field and hydrological validation. Because closed dipterocarp forests support threatened and endemic wildlife and local livelihoods, they are a priority for field assessment.

Pre- and post-Uwan NDVI maps. The selected images show predominantly high vegetation greenness before the typhoon and more widespread lower values afterward, particularly in the central and southern portions of BVNP. The maps indicate differences in greenness between the selected periods rather than confirmed typhoon damage.

Spatial data were overlaid on existing land-cover maps and species distribution models to identify potential overlap between mapped vegetation change and suitable habitat for selected indicator species. This analysis guided field-validation priorities; it did not independently establish habitat damage, species presence, or population loss. Potential canopy defoliation and treefall in dipterocarp forests could reduce nesting, roosting, and feeding resources for species such as the Luzon hornbill (Penelopides manillae) and golden-crowned flying fox (Acerodon jubatus). If verified, disruption affecting these seed dispersers could also influence forest regeneration.


80 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Transect and plot establishment during the reconnaissance survey in BVNP.

Biodiversity survey methods. Field teams used binoculars to observe wildlife, photographed vegetation, measured trees, and recorded field observations. These activities support consistent documentation of species occurrence and habitat condition during field validation.

On steep slopes, erosion and landslides may affect plants such as Bicol abiki (Pinanga bikolana). Heavy rainfall may also transport sediment and volcanic material through the Cadac-an River Watershed, which covers approximately 59% of BVNP, raising concerns about sediment and debris entering connected freshwater habitats. The extent and causes of these conditions remain subject to field validation and complementary hydrological and geohazard assessment. Preliminary community interviews raised concerns about possible effects of watershed disturbance on freshwater springs that supply surrounding communities. These accounts link watershed condition to drinking-water resources, but effects on individual springs and water quality require further assessment. Interviewees also reported interruptions to ecotourism after damage to watershed and riverine areas and landslides that blocked trails. These disruptions affected livelihood opportunities for local guides, vendors, and other residents who depend on tourism.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 81

Management and Recovery Priorities Completing GARF Stage 2 will strengthen the evidence available for recovery planning. The BVNP Protected Area Management Office identified five rapid biodiversity assessment sites: San Ramon in Barcelona, Inlagadian in Casiguran, San Jose in Bulusan, Cogon in Irosin, and Puting Sapa in Juban. Aerial surveys will examine forest condition and the extent of landslides, erosion, and sediment or volcanic-debris movement within the Cadac-an watershed. Interpretation of suspected lahar deposits and unstable slopes requires coordination with geohazard specialists. Freshwater monitoring is also a priority because of concerns about sedimentation and community dependence on springs and lakes. Regular water-quality testing and aquatic biodiversity assessment can track freshwater condition and guide measures addressing sediment and debris inputs. Coordination with water and health authorities can support assessment of drinking-water safety, while community consultations can document continuing effects on water access and ecotourism livelihoods.

Site selection for GARF Stage 2 field validation in Bulusan Volcano Natural Park. The left map identifies reference points for ground truthing across mapped land-cover conditions. The right map supports the selection of rapid biodiversity assessment sites.

GARF Lesson Bulusan illustrates the practical demands of applying GARF in a landscape exposed to interacting hazards. Typhoon-related disturbance occurs within a volcanic setting, where terrain, sediment movement, access restrictions, and safety conditions influence both ecological impacts and the ability to assess them. Interpreting observed change requires a clear event timeline and evidence that distinguishes weather-related disturbance from volcanic processes and continuing land use. Bulusanʼs lakes and springs also provide an opportunity to extend assessment beyond forest-canopy conditions. Combining terrestrial and freshwater methods would strengthen understanding of how disturbance moves through the landscape and affects ecosystem services. This requires collaboration among biodiversity, geospatial, freshwater, hydrological, and geohazard specialists. Credits and Source Assessment conducted by: DENR Region V GARF Team and DENR PENRO Sorsogon, with the Provincial Government of Sorsogon; the municipal governments of Barcelona, Bulusan, Irosin, Juban, and Casiguran; and the barangay governments of San Ramon, San Jose, Cogon, Puting Sapa, and Inlagadian. GARF assessment team: John Edward B. de la Cruz, Eleanor D. Lacsi-de la Cruz, Jasmin P. Loyola, Ira Coleen A. Sta. Ana, Jeric L. Jaso, and Ryza Carolina Daymon. Source: Bulusan Volcano Natural Park Management Plan.


82 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

REGION VI

Typhoon Odette Stripped the Canopy of Ilog-Hilabangan Watershed Forest Reserve Based on the assessment by: DENR Region VI–Western Visayas, with personnel from the Regional Office, PENRO Iloilo, PENRO Negros Occidental, and CENRO Kabankalan City

Landscape

Ecosystem

Ilog-Hilabangan Watershed Forest Reserve

Watershed, secondary-growth forests, and plantations

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Typhoon Odette, December 2021

Assessment focus

Changes in forest and land cover, habitat condition, biodiversity, species distributions, and community resource use

GARF stages

Stages 1, 2, and 3


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 83

Ilog-Hilabangan Watershed Forest Reserve After Typhoon Odette The Ilog-Hilabangan Watershed Forest Reserve (IHWFR) covers mountain areas of Buenavista and Carabalan in Himamaylan City and Tan-awan and Carlo-an in Kabankalan City. Its landscape includes plantation and second-growth forests, mixed vegetation, grasslands, cultivated areas, and other land-cover types that support biodiversity and community resources. Following Typhoon Odette in December 2021, the assessment documented widespread defoliation, broken stems, uprooted trees, and severely leaning trees. GARF examined these conditions through satellite imagery, aerial ground truthing, biodiversity and habitat surveys, and community interviews. Spatial analysis subsequently informed a Restoration Catalyst Framework intended to guide recovery priorities.

Key Findings Stage 1 analysis indicated a substantial shift in mapped vegetation-density classes following Typhoon Odette. Dense forest declined from 57% of the mapped area before the typhoon to 15% afterward. Over the same period, moderately dense forest increased from 22% to 37%, mixed or less dense vegetation from 12% to 23%, and other cover from 9% to 25%. The classes were derived by calculating NDVI from Landsat red and near-infrared imagery, reclassifying the values by vegetation density, and comparing pre- and post-event conditions. Field observations of defoliation and physical tree damage support this interpretation, although the classification alone cannot establish that all mapped change was caused by Odette.

Pre-Odette NDVI map (2021). Higher vegetation greenness was widespread within IHWFR, particularly in its northern and central portions. Darker green indicates higher greenness, interspersed with patches of lower greenness.


84 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES Aerial and habitat observations documented physical damage beyond changes in greenness, including at sites in Barangays Tan-awan, Buenavista, and Carol-an. Surveyed locations included mixed vegetation, abandoned cultivated or rice areas, defoliated trees, grassland, open forest, shrubland, and mixed vegetation with cropland. Along creeks and in residual forest, the assessment recorded uprooted and leaning trees and other severe habitat damage.

Post-Odette NDVI map (2022). Dark-green areas were less extensive, while lighter-green and yellow patches were more widespread across the watershed. This pattern indicates lower vegetation greenness on the selected post-event image and is consistent with the defoliation and canopy disturbance documented during field assessment.

Despite extensive disturbance, mixed forests, grasslands, and other vegetation communities showed plant succession and visible regrowth, with some affected areas becoming green again. Native regeneration included abundant Hopea philippinensis seedlings near a creek within a mahogany plantation. These observations indicate regeneration at the surveyed sites but do not establish full ecological recovery. AOI Total Area (ha.): 10,531.487 POST / PRE

Closed Forest

Closed Forest

2,324.826

Open Forest

66.846

Non Forest Total

2,382.672

Open Forest

Non Forest

TOTAL 2,314.826

1,600.241

1,667.087

1,293.63

5,255.922

6,549.574

2,893.872

5,255.944

10,531.487

Pre- and post-Odette land-cover statistics.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 85

Comparison of pre- and post-Odette land-cover maps showing mapped vegetation change

Community interviews provided information on wildlife occurrence. All informants reported the continued presence of Visayan warty pigs (Sus cebifrons) and Visayan hornbills (Penelopides panini), while residents reported that Visayan spotted deer (Rusa alfredi) were no longer observed within the reserve. These accounts can guide targeted wildlife surveys but do not establish local extinction or a decline caused by Odette. Delayed field assessment made some storm damage harder to document. Weeds and shrubs had grown over damaged trees, obscuring evidence of the initial disturbance. Field observations therefore captured a landscape already undergoing ecological change, rather than its immediate post-typhoon condition.

Coordination of the team to the LGU Himamaylan

Coordination of the team with the Philippine army


86 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES Management and Recovery Priorities Protection of remaining contiguous second-growth forest should anchor recovery planning. The assessment recommends additional monitoring transects, particularly in Sitio Madaja around Mt. Cansermon, to improve coverage of these habitats. It also proposes reviewing management zones to distinguish plantation forests, cultivated areas, roads, and settlements from remaining forest requiring stricter protection. Any zoning changes would need to follow the applicable planning and approval processes. Restoration should build on surviving native trees and existing regeneration. The occurrence of native seedlings within a mahogany plantation shows why planting decisions should follow field assessment of species composition, recruitment, seed sources, and barriers to recovery. Areas already regenerating may benefit primarily from protection, while sites with persistent regeneration constraints may require assisted recovery. Community participation should support both recovery and long-term protection. The assessment recommends strengthening Peopleʼs Organizations, exploring biodiversityfriendly enterprises such as pandan-based handicrafts, and improving local government support for Bantay Gubat volunteers.

Restoration-priority blocks for Years 1–10. The map shows proposed implementation blocks for forest protection, spontaneous natural regeneration, and assisted natural regeneration or enrichment. Land-cover condition and slope inform the proposed approaches.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 87

GARF Lesson Ilog-Hilabangan demonstrates why post-disaster assessment must account for the time between an event and field validation. Satellite imagery identified changes in vegetation condition, while field observations documented uprooted trees, leaning stems, and regeneration. By the time of assessment, however, weeds and shrubs had obscured some damaged trees. A greener landscape could therefore still contain substantial physical damage. The case also shows why species composition matters when judging recovery. Native regeneration within a mahogany plantation provides information that a vegetation index cannot reveal. Repeat surveys should establish whether regenerating vegetation is rebuilding native habitat and ecological function, alongside restoring canopy cover. Wildlife observations offer another source of evidence, but require careful interpretation. Reports of continued warty pig and hornbill occurrence, and the absence of recent deer sightings, can guide targeted surveys. They cannot independently establish population trends or attribute changes to the typhoon. Credits and Sources Assessment conducted by DENR Region VI–Western Visayas, with the Regional Office, PENRO Iloilo, PENRO Negros Occidental, and CENRO Kabankalan City. Aerial ground-truthing team: Apolinario C. Corbal, Jose Marie T. Tumasis, and Othniel T. Bugna. Rapid biodiversity assessment team: Aiza E. Jarandilla, Rosalie D. Gabat, Ernie T. Villanueva, Raiza C. Golez, and Joelan T. Luberas. Narrative report on the conduct. Local community guides: Christopher Tajonera, Randy Balano, and Wellington Garlet.


88 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

REGION VII

After Odette—Reading the Carood Watershed Landscape Based on the assessment by: DENR Central Visayas

Landscape

Carood Watershed

Ecosystem

Less-dense forest, agricultural land, cropland, grassland, and other nonforest vegetation

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Super Typhoon Odette, December 2021

Assessment focus

Post-Odette habitat and vegetation damage, biodiversity condition, and impacts on community resources

GARF stages

Stages 1 and 2


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 89

A Critical Watershed under Pressure The Carood Watershed covers approximately 25,409.79 hectares in northeastern Bohol. It encompasses all or parts of Ubay, Alicia, Candijay, Mabini, Pilar, Guindulman, Anda, Duero, Sierra Bullones, and San Miguel. The watershed supplies water for domestic use, agriculture, and hydropower. Its landscape comprises forest, agricultural land, cropland, grassland, and other nonforest vegetation. Typhoon Odette damaged forest habitats, plantations, agricultural areas, infrastructure, and water resources within the watershed. The assessment also documented landslide-prone areas, drought-prone areas, extreme heat, and damage to irrigation canals and potable-water sources.

Carood Watershed Landscape © FAO and DENR FMB

The forested area was damaged by previous typhoon Odette in Barangay Canawa, Candijay, Bohol © DENR Central Visayas

Agricultural conversion in the study site in Barangay Cadapdapan, Candijay, Bohol © DENR Central Visayas


90 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Area of Interest Map at Carood Watershed

Key Findings NDVI comparison between 2021 and 2022 indicated substantial changes in vegetation greenness after Odette. Ground verification found damage at several enhanced National Greening Program sites and documented regeneration between June and December 2022. The return of leaves and other vegetation contributed to improved greenness but did not establish recovery of pre-event forest structure, species composition, or ecosystem functions.

NDVI maps before and after Typhoon Odette


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 91

Cadapdapan and Canawa were the focus of detailed ground assessments because of their severe exposure to Typhoon Odette and their location within the Carood Watershed. The assessment documented habitat damage, including forest areas affected by the typhoon and portions of the landscape that had been converted to agricultural land. New cultivation openings within timberland were also observed, particularly in areas that experienced substantial typhoon damage.

Aerial views of less-dense forest and cropland, grassland, or other nonforest vegetation

Carood Watershedʼs NDVI change map

Management and Recovery Priorities Recovery priorities centered on restoring and protecting forest ecosystems affected by Typhoon Odette, particularly through replanting, natural regeneration, and the maintenance and protection of established plantations. The assessment also highlighted the need to address new cultivation openings within timberland and other forms of habitat conversion, while using community resource mapping and participatory assessment to guide interventions and strengthen resilience in affected areas. Water sources and irrigation also warrant follow-up with the affected communities.

GARF Lesson The Carood assessment demonstrates how satellite mapping and field validation can identify landscape-level vegetation change and characterize conditions on the ground. However, later greening alone cannot establish that forest habitat, water resources, or community livelihoods have recovered. Repeated surveys at documented locations, preevent ecological baselines, and follow-up with resource users are needed to distinguish natural regeneration, replanting, land conversion, and continuing loss.


92 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Community resource map for the GARF pilot assessment in the Carood Watershed

Credits and Sources The report data were collected by the Green Assessment Team of DENR Region 7, composed of personnel from the Regional Office, Penro Bohol, Penro Negros Oriental, CENRO Tagbiliran City, CENRO Talibon, and CENRO Ayungon Aerial ground-truthing team: Ciselo C. Albiso, Oscar Y. Ido, Rene Matthew Villaber, and Ariel Jaum Rapid biodiversity assessment team: Ma. Jennen L. Llena, Junar C. Lendio, Oscar Y. Ido, Kim Arlee B. Goloso, Rodrigo G. Daluyo, Christopher T. Bersano, Jimmy Olarita, Joemarc Melecio, Jennifer Inojales, and Rommel E. Torres.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 93

REGION VIII

Panaon Island after Typhoon Odette— What GARF Revealed Based on an assessment by: DENR Region VIII and CENRO San Juan

Landscape

Liloan on Panaon Island

Ecosystem

Forest, intensively used land—including coconut plantations and cropland—rivers, and associated habitats

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Super Typhoon Odette, December 2021

Assessment focus

Post-Odette vegetation damage, biodiversity and habitat condition, community resources, and restoration planning in Liloan

GARF stages

Stages 1, 2, and 3


94 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Typhoon Odette strikes Southern Leyte Liloan lies at the northern end of Panaon Island, with part of the municipality on the Southern Leyte mainland. Its forests, coconut plantations, croplands, and rivers support biodiversity and household livelihoods. After Super Typhoon Odette struck in December 2021, the DENR Region VIII team used preand post-event satellite imagery, aerial surveys, biodiversity and habitat assessments, community resource mapping, and interviews to assess vegetation change and effects on community resources. The findings informed an initial ecosystem restoration and resilience plan.

DENR Region VIII and CENRO–San Juan conducting aerial surveys. © DENR and CENRO - San Juan Region VIII

Key Findings Mapping classified 778.28 hectares of closed forest, 855.11 hectares of open forest, and 1,495.87 hectares of perennial crops as damaged after Odette. These areas represented 68.21%, 85.01%, and 88.49%, respectively, of their corresponding pre-event classes. Only 362.75 hectares of closed forest and 150.82 hectares of open forest remained mapped as intact after the event. Field observations documented defoliation, broken stems, uprooted trees, and canopy opening.

Land Cover and Change Map at Liloan, Panaon Island


Closed forest (ha)

1,141

363

778

Condition

Pre-Odette condition

Mapped as undamaged after Odette

Mapped as damaged after Odette

855

151

1,006

Open forest (ha)

1,496

195

1,691

Perennial crops (ha)

213

11

224

Grassland (ha)

2

3

5

Barren (ha)

65

46

111

Annual cropland (ha)

Damage to land cover Pre- and post-Odette

338

1,342

1,679

Shrubland (ha)

1.81

2.1

3.91

Marshland (ha)

2

—

2

Inland water (ha)

33

150

183

Built-up (ha)

3,783

2,261

6,044

Total (ha)

First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 95


96 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES Landslides and increased water flow affected riverbanks, creeks, road cuts, and slopes, causing exposed rocks and gully erosion.

Landslides observed after Odette © DENR and CENRO - San Juan Region VIII

Other areas showed signs of early regrowth. Grasses, vines, ferns, wildlings, and pioneer plants were recolonizing openings, particularly in shrublands and mixed vegetation. This is a starting point for recovery, although it does not establish that the former forest structure or species composition has returned. Continued disturbance could interrupt succession.

Sample output orthomosaic images © DENR and CENRO - San Juan Region VIII

Habitat-suitability models for the rufous hornbill indicated generally low-to-moderate suitability across the assessed area. Differences between pre- and post-Odette models were small and could not be attributed solely to the typhoon. Land use and earlier disturbances had also shaped the landscape.

Understory and ground cover vegetation underneath the fallen and broken logs © DENR and CENRO - San Juan Region VIII


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Residents reported seeing fewer birds immediately after the typhoon and lower water levels in rivers and waterfalls. These reports identify concerns requiring follow-up, but they do not measure bird survival or establish the cause of changes in water levels.

Biodiversity surveys © DENR and CENRO - San Juan Region VIII

Community resource mapping and key informant interviews documented extensive impacts on houses, farms, crops, coconut stands, and water resources. Key informants reported widespread damage to houses and severe losses to planted crops and coconut farms. They also reported decreases in water levels in rivers and waterfalls.

Community Resources Map in Lilo-an, Southern Leyte e.g., NTFP, Coconut Plantation and Other Agricrops

Typhoon Odetteʼs destruction of coconut stands reduced household income and drove livelihood shifts, including cutting nearly mature coconuts for sale and using damaged forest trees for reconstruction. The collection of fallen trees and evidence of live-tree poaching added pressure on recovering forests, highlighting the need to align livelihood recovery with forest protection and long-term ecosystem resilience.

| 97


98 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES Management and Recovery Priorities Surviving forest patches need protection. Areas with strong natural regrowth may need monitoring and reduced disturbance. Severely damaged sites and unstable slopes require further site-level checks to determine whether assisted regeneration or more active restoration is appropriate.

GARF Lesson On Panaon Island, satellite imagery located extensive post-Odette vegetation change, while forest plots revealed severe damage to individual trees even where substantial canopy remained. Biodiversity surveys and community accounts showed what that damage meant for wildlife habitat and household recovery. The case demonstrates how GARF moves from mapping to field evidence and proposed action and why sampling limits must remain visible when restoration priorities are set.

Credits and Source CENRO San Juan assessment team: Nelson R. Palo (team leader); Paul Verbo (community resource mapping/GIS); Miguelito A. Baja (RPA pilot and data gathering); Jessa C. Nuñez (community organizing and data gathering); Elizabeth E. Lucido (IEC, data encoding, and gathering); Raul G. Buctot (visual observer); Ruben M. Cayetano Jr. (ground control point observer); Lira Dianne M. Bulabog (data encoding); and Nelfon M. Allocod (data gathering).


First toFirst Shield, First toFirst Fall, to and Last to Last Recover: to Shield, Fall, and to Recover: The Green and Recovery Framework (GARF)(GARF) The Assessment Green Assessment and Recovery Framework

| 99

REGION IX

Building a GARF Baseline for Pasonanca Natural Park Based on an assessment by: DENR Region IX Zamboanga Peninsula, led by Cyrus B. Bayawa, Robert R. Ortiz, and Leo V. Baes

Landscape

Pasonanca Natural Park (PaNP)

Ecosystem

Open forest, closed forest, brushland or shrubland, agricultural land, and built-up areas

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

No specific disaster was assessed; the team examined changes in vegetation and biodiversity between 2018 and 2022.

Assessment focus

Change in vegetation and biodiversity

GARF stages

Stages 1 and 2, with initial components of Stage 3


100 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Establishing a GARF Baseline for Pasonanca Natural Park

Pasonanca Natural Park © ASEAN Center for Biodiversity

Pasonanca Natural Park (PaNP) in Region IX is located at the southern end of the Zamboanga Cordillera mountain range. The park covers approximately 12,107 hectares, with an additional 5,307-hectare buffer zone. The landscape supports extensive oldgrowth and secondary forests, together with open forest, brushland/shrubland, agricultural areas, and other land-cover types. These ecosystems provide habitat for diverse flora and fauna. The team compared Landsat-derived NDVI for 2018 and 2022, conducted drone surveys, and used transects and nested quadrats to document vegetation, flora, and fauna. Because no specific disaster

Area of Interest Map at Pasonanca Natural Park

or event date was defined, the assessment describes change over four years and cannot attribute that change to a particular storm or other hazard.

Key Findings Satellite analysis indicated a slight decline in vegetation greenness between 2018 and 2022. However, the four-year comparison could reflect multiple influences, including natural disturbances and land-use change. Without a defined disaster event and an event-specific comparison, the observed decline cannot be attributed to a particular disaster. These results may be used as baseline information.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

NDVI, 2018 (left) and 2022 (right)

Aerial imagery documented closed forest, open forest, perennial crops, annual crops, brushland/shrubland, and built-up areas. This confirmed the mix of forest and other land uses at the selected locations, but at this stage cannot quantify transitions between these classes. Fallen trees were described as damage from strong winds, but the timing and extent of that damage were not established. These observations identify conditions requiring attention without demonstrating the impact of a particular storm.

Annual crop

Perennial crop

Closed forest

Open forest

| 101


102 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Built-up area

Brush/shrubland

Assessors documented five Philippine-endemic plant species and one threatened plant species, malak-malak (Palaquium philippense). They also recorded five fauna species, including three Philippine endemics and two species identified as threatened: the Philippine hawk-eagle (Nisaetus philippensis) and Zamboanga bulbul (Hypsipetes rufigularis). Community resource map depicts waterways, settlements, vegetation, animals, and livelihood activities. It provides a starting point for connecting ecological conditions with community resource use.

Community resource mapping


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 103

Management and Recovery Priorities Priorities include protecting remaining forest cover, monitoring areas with vegetation loss or wind-damaged trees, involving protectedarea occupants in restoration, and collaborating with the Zamboanga City Water District, LGUs, and barangay governments. The report also recommends assigning an on-site forest protection officer and continuing information, education, and communication activities. Further analysis is needed to identify where protection alone is sufficient, where natural regeneration should be supported,

Trees reportedly damaged by strong winds.

and where active restoration is justified. The community map also needs an accompanying account of resource dependence and observed changes to inform those decisions.

GARF Lesson This case illustrates the value of spatial and field data for establishing a baseline, but not for measuring the effects of an unidentified disaster. The 2018–2022 comparison indicates possible vegetation change; species records and photographs of fallen trees provide ecological context but do not establish the timing or scale of event-related loss. Future assessments should identify a specific event, use consistent imagery and field methods, and link proposed interventions to verified site conditions. It also shows why recovery planning needs a clear link to the evidence of damage. The 2018 to 2022 imagery comparison identifies possible vegetation change, but does not isolate a disasterʼs effects. Species records and photographs of fallen trees add ecological context without establishing the scale or timing of loss. The proposed interventions therefore address broader forest-management needs as well as potential recovery needs. Future assessments would benefit from a defined event, consistent imagery and field comparisons, and mapped intervention areas linked to verified conditions. Furthermore, assessments could be strengthened by improving technical capacity, availability of equipment and software, and financial resources. Additional personnel with expertise in flora and fauna identification would also improve the accuracy and efficiency of biodiversity documentation. Credits and Sources Rapid appraisal: Cyrus B. Bayawa, Robert R. Ortiz, and Leo V. Baes. Ground-truthing using remotely piloted aircraft systems (RPAS): first team—Marlon Diego (RPAS pilot), Arby Kane Bella (spotter), and Renato Sapalo (recorder); second team—Angelo Dan T. Delos Santos (RPAS pilot), Gerry Cañete Jr. (spotter), and Robert Ortiz (recorder). Rapid biodiversity assessment team: For. Expedito R. Flores, For. Cyrus B. Bayawa, For. Fortunato N. Acuña, For. Robert R. Ortiz, and Gerry Cañete Jr.


104 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES REGION X

Assessing Typhoon Odette’s Impacts in Camiguin Based on the assessment by DENR Region 10 GARF Team: Jordan Laranjo, Earl Marc J. Domingo, Juleus Fabre, Edanson Cañete, John Aizer Simudlan, Samsudin Casurra, Redelyn P. Flores, Gabriel Dipus, and Agura Myrasol

Landscape

Mts. Timpoong-Hibok-Hibok Natural Monument and the rest of Camiguin Island

Ecosystem

Upland and secondary-growth forests, communitymanaged production forests, mangroves, and beach forest

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Typhoon Odette, December 2021

Assessment focus

Vegetation and habitat disturbance, biodiversity, natural regeneration, and impacts on community resources

GARF stages

Stages 1, 2, and 3


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 105

Applying GARF to Island Ecosystems Typhoon Odette affected Camiguinʼs natural forests, coastal vegetation, plantations, and community resources. Assessing its ecological consequences required looking across different habitats and distinguishing damage that persisted from vegetation that had begun to regenerate. GARF combined satellite analysis with aerial ground-truthing, biodiversity surveys, and community resource mapping. Sentinel-2 imagery covering 2021 and 2022 provided an initial comparison of vegetation conditions. Field assessment in October 2023 examined four priority sites through six drone flights covering 23 reference points.

Team conducting flora and fauna assessments in the beach forest of Mantigue Island.

The assessment documented uneven conditions: an expanding landslide with visible regeneration, damaged production forest, disturbed mangroves, and relatively limited fallen trees in Mantigueʼs beach forest. Community mapping helped connect one of these disturbances to a resource directly managed and used by residents.

Key Findings Following Stage 2, the analysis classified 596 hectares as damaged forest within the mapped assessment area. Of the 2,778 hectares classified as forest before the typhoon, 2,181 hectares remained classified as forest. These estimates apply only to the assessment boundary and are not island-wide totals. Cloud-related gaps in the 2022 imagery and the use of annual comparison periods also limit how confidently the mapped change can be attributed to Odette. The assessment documented landslides within Mts. Timpoong-Hibok-Hibok Natural Monument following Typhoon Odette. During field validation,

Flora assessment within 20 m × 20 m quadrats established at 250-metre intervals along transect lines.

vegetation was regenerating in the primary landslide area. However, expansion along its eastern portion and a newly connected landslide brought the total mapped affected area to 9 hectares, indicating continued disturbance despite localized regrowth.


106 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Pre-and post- Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) Map in Camiguin.

Community mapping connected plantation damage to a locally managed resource. The Campana Farmers Producers Cooperative manages a 178-hectare Community-Based Forest Management Agreement (CBFMA) area and reported an estimated 30% damage to its mangium plantation. Ground validation identified a 1.7-hectare damaged section with an estimated 826 affected trees, described as approximately 40–50 cm in diameter. Fallen trees, broken branches, and canopy openings were documented. Community assessment identified freshwater dependence as well as plantation damage. The cooperative reported that water for farming and domestic use comes from the protected area. This identifies an important ecosystem service requiring attention in recovery planning.

Land-cover map showing forests classified as damaged or persistent within the Camiguin assessment area.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Team conducting the fauna assessment © DENR Region 10

Mangrove damage occurred alongside differences in stand age and existing site pressures. Aerial observations described a shift from dense to sparse vegetation, while field observations recorded uprooted trees and broken branches attributed to Odette. Three quadrats contained 68 mangrove trees representing three species: Sonneratia alba, Rhizophora stylosa, and R. mucronata. Mature S. alba retained strong canopy cover, while planted Rhizophora were described as recently established or at the sapling stage. Low canopy cover in these younger trees therefore cannot be interpreted as typhoon damage alone. Poor mangrove regeneration raised a separate recovery concern. Regeneration was rated poor for all three recorded mangrove species. The team identified seawalls, trails, and cottages as possible influences on site conditions. These observations warrant investigation, but do not establish the relative contributions of infrastructure, storm disturbance, and other factors.

Community resource map of the Campana Farmers Producers Cooperativeʼs CBFMA area and photographs of plantation damage.

| 107


108 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES Mantigueʼs beach forest showed limited visible treefall and continued wildlife use. Aerial observations recorded a small number of fallen trees, particularly in the islandʼs northeastern portion. Field surveys documented seven bird species and an island flying fox roost within the beach forest. These records establish habitat use at the time of assessment, but do not demonstrate that wildlife populations were unaffected or had recovered. Stage 3 translated mapped disturbance into proposed recovery approaches. The plan allocated 62.4 hectares to active restoration and 534 hectares to passive restoration, using slope as a principal criterion. It also proposed protection, natural and assisted regeneration, invasive-species management, and ecological monitoring.

Photographs showing post-Odette damage in the peopleʼs organizationʼs mangium plantation, the northeastern portion of Mantigue Islandʼs beach forest, and a mangrove forest.

Management and Recovery Priorities The pilot Green Recovery Plan identifies 62.4 hectares for active restoration and 534 hectares for passive restoration, using slope as a principal criterion. These initial assignments should be refined through field assessment of surviving native vegetation, regenerant abundance, seed sources, invasive species, erosion, and access conditions. Slope alone does not determine whether planting or natural regeneration is appropriate. Mangrove recovery interventions will also investigate tidal conditions, substrate, infrastructure, and barriers to regeneration before additional planting. Surviving mature trees and naturally establishing seedlings should be protected. Mantigueʼs beach forest and documented flying fox roost should also inform the location and timing of management activities. Plantation rehabilitation will be developed with the Campana cooperative and distinguished from natural-forest restoration. Further assessment will clarify damaged and surviving stock, production losses, and consequences for members. Using 2025 costing assumptions, Stage 3 developed an indicative restoration financing estimate of approximately ₱110.28 million to support initial planning. The estimate is preliminary, not an approved budget, and will require refinement as restoration sites, interventions, implementation arrangements, unit costs, and timelines are confirmed. These findings and plans are outputs of GARFʼs pilot application and will be further refined under the Building Capacities for Eco-Resilience in the Philippines project, where Camiguin is an incubator site. Additional assessment, field validation, and stakeholder engagement can strengthen restoration priorities, costing, implementation arrangements, and monitoring.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Restoration Catalyst Framework developed by DENR Region X to guide restoration and revegetation approaches in Camiguin.

| 109


110 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

GARF Lesson Camiguin demonstrates GARFʼs progression from detecting potential disturbance to validating conditions and planning recovery. Satellite analysis directed attention to changing vegetation; field surveys distinguished fallen plantation trees, mangrove damage, young planted stands, and regenerating habitats. Stage 3 then identified restoration areas, proposed management approaches, and financing needs. The case also shows why recovery cannot be judged through canopy greenness alone. Regeneration occurred alongside landslide expansion. Mangrove canopy condition reflected both disturbance and stand age, while poor regeneration raised questions about longer-term recovery. Monitoring must therefore follow species composition, recruitment, habitat condition, and continuing pressures alongside vegetation cover. Timing remains a major limitation. Fieldwork occurred almost two years after Odette, and the satellite analysis used annual imagery with cloud-related gaps. The assessment documented conditions remaining at that time, but could not fully reconstruct immediate damage or separate all subsequent changes. Earlier observations and repeat monitoring would strengthen interpretation. Community mapping added the connection to ecosystem services: plantation resources and freshwater support livelihoods and everyday needs. Future monitoring should determine whether these services recover, who continues to face reduced access, and what assistance is needed. Finally, the Green Recovery Plan makes the next steps more concrete, but planning is not recovery itself. Site validation, technical capacity, financing, community participation, and monitoring are needed to test whether the proposed interventions restore ecological condition and the services people depend on.

Credits and Sources The report identifies the authorship collectively as the Green Assessment Team of DENR Region 10 and acknowledges the support of PENRO Camiguin, the Local Government Units, USAID-SIBOL, and the Climate Change Service. The Rapid Appraisal and Aerial Ground Truthing teams included Ms. Redelyn P. Flores, Forester Gabriel A. Dipus, Mr. Earl Marc J. Domingo, Forester Jordan B. Laranjo, Mr. Juleus B. Fabre, and Engr. Agura Q. Myrasol. The Rapid Biodiversity Assessment and supporting team included PFM Edanson L. Cañete, Forester John Aizer B. Simudlan, Mr. Samsudin E. Casurra, Forester Paulyn Mae S. Laranjo, EnP, Ms. Kathlyn D. Cagalawan, Forester Jennifer G. Bonggay, EnP, Forester Renerio J. Wabe, FPO Jeral I. Rabille, FPO Eric L. Edulan Jr., and FPO Kris G. Saballa.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

REGION XI

Landslide Disturbance in Mainit Hot Spring Protected Landscape Based on the assessment by: DENR Region XI

Landscape

Mainit Hot Spring Protected Landscape

Ecosystem

Mixed vegetation, forests, agricultural areas, and freshwater systems

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Earthquakes followed by prolonged heavy rainfall in early 2023, associated with landslides

Assessment focus

Changes in biodiversity and habitats, and landsliderelated disturbance

GARF stages

Stages 1, 2 (excluding assessment of community impacts), and 3

| 111


112 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

A Landscape Affected by Successive Disturbances Mainit Hot Spring Protected Landscape contains forests, cultivated areas, waterfalls, caves, hot and cold springs, and waterways connected to the Manat River. Portions of Barangays Mainit and Bukal lie within this approximately 1,422-hectare landscape, where natural vegetation occurs alongside farms and settlements. Earthquakes in early 2023 were followed by prolonged rainfall in March. This case study describes ground shaking, saturated soils, flooding, and landslides affecting the protected area. Assessing ecological disturbance required distinguishing landslide-related vegetation loss

Drone views of vegetation and slope disturbance in Mainit Hot Spring Protected Landscape. Images showed mixed tree cover, including coconut palms and patches of open canopy.

from agricultural conversion and road expansion.

Key Findings Satellite analysis identified potential vegetation gain and loss, but the comparison did not isolate a single event. Stage 1 compared Sentinel-2 imagery from January–December 2022 with imagery from January–June 2023. The latter period spans conditions before and after the March rainfall event. The maps therefore provide an initial indication of change requiring validation before any observed damage can be attributed to earthquakes or rainfall. Aerial ground truthing helped distinguish landslides from other causes of vegetation change. Orthomosaics documented vegetation loss associated with landslides, agricultural conversion, and road expansion. Clearing within the protected landscape warrants verification of its extent, timing, and consistency with protected-area zoning and management prescriptions. The findings show that the observed vegetation loss cannot be attributed solely to earthquakes and heavy rainfall.

Orthomosaic images of vegetation cover in Mainit Hot Spring Protected Landscape. These detailed aerial views help locate vegetation openings for ground verification of their causes and habitat condition.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 113

Ground cracks and erosion occurred near communities and waterways. A large ground crack was documented in Bukal. Other reference points recorded landslides, soil erosion along the Manat River, and slope disturbance near communities. Post-event biodiversity surveys recorded 10 plant species and 16 fauna records. Plants included white lauan, mayapis, apitong, bagtikan, red lauan, and toog, while fauna included guaiabero, Philippine hanging parrot, Mindanao horned frog, Philippine forest rat, and fruit bats. These observations provide a reference for future monitoring, although the absence of comparable pre-event data limits conclusions about event-related changes in species occurrence or abundance.

NDVI-derived maps showing potential vegetation gain and loss between the selected pre- and post-event periods. These patterns require field validation and do not independently establish forest gain or loss.

Community mapping provided resource-use information but only limited impact analysis. Participants included upland farmers, small-scale miners, purok officials, and selected residents of Sitio Puting Bato. The case study noted recurring observations of priority species compared with earlier Biodiversity Monitoring System records but did not quantify changes in resource availability, livelihoods, or ecosystem services.

Community mapping at Sitio Puting Bato, Purok 12, Barangay Mainit, Nabunturan, Davao de Oro, with purok officials, stakeholders, and resource users from MHSPL, including upland farmers, small-scale miners, and selected residents.


114 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Land-cover and aerial validation sites in Mainit Hot Spring Protected Landscape. Brush and shrubs dominate the western portion, perennial crops cover much of the east, and open forest is concentrated in the south. Inland water and built-up areas follow the central river corridor.

Proposed restoration and protection strategies in Mainit Hot Spring Protected Landscape. Green indicates preliminary allocations for active approaches, while red indicates passive approaches.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 115

Management and Recovery Priorities Recovery priorities distinguish landslide-affected habitats from areas undergoing agricultural conversion or road expansion. Protecting surviving vegetation, supporting natural regeneration, and addressing continuing land-use pressures require interventions matched to verified site conditions. The pilot Green Recovery Plan provides an initial spatial basis for this work. Its approximately 125.8-hectare planning area includes changing vegetation and persistent forest, linking habitat protection with recovery. Further assessment of native regeneration, seed sources, invasive species, erosion, and continuing disturbance can refine the preliminary active and passive allocations. Ground cracks, unstable slopes, damaged buildings, roads, and dikes require separate geohazard and engineering assessments. GARF documents ecological disturbance and informs habitat recovery, while structural safety and stabilization decisions fall under the relevant technical authorities.

GARF Lesson This case study demonstrates the importance of interpreting vegetation change within a landscape affected by successive hazards and continuing land use. Satellite mapping identified potential change, while aerial validation revealed landslides, agricultural conversion, and road expansion. Without this distinction, vegetation loss could be incorrectly assigned to a single event and recovery measures directed toward the wrong cause. Biodiversity and community surveys added species and resource-use information, but further analysis is needed to establish ecological loss and its consequences for people. Repeated surveys, verified species identification, and documented changes in resource availability would strengthen the connection between habitat condition and ecosystem services.

Credits and Sources TOriginal assessment: Department of Environment and Natural Resources Region XI, Aerial Ground-Truthing Survey and Rapid Biodiversity Assessment of the Mainit Hot Spring Protected Landscape (MHSPL). Rapid Appraisal team: Clyde G. Dela Peña, Ariel R. Pliego, and Engr. Hyacinth S. Delos Santos. Aerial Ground-Truthing Team, as listed in the report: Jhonitz King P. Isaac, Kelly Pingkian, Rey D. Macaya, Yolly A. Bahinting, For. Dennis E. Ras, and Engr. Hyacinth S. Delos Santos. Rapid Biodiversity Assessment Team, as listed in the report: Jhonitz King P. Isaac, Jan Mar T. Balatico, Honey Vee Esto, Romnick V. Arongan, Yolly A. Bahinting, Ailen Mae L. Abuloc, Jovannie C. Daraug, Elgierich B. Salubre, Rolyne J. Palen, Rvey B. Balaan, Engr. Hyacinth S. Delos Santos, and Arnold Samenado.


116 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES REGION XII

Impacts of Severe Tropical Storm Paeng on Mount Matutum Based on the assessment by DENR Region 12 GARF Team: For. Norhassan T. Pangcoga, For. Datu Ino M. Bagul, Jay C. Salmon, For. Amin Ahsan M. Pabil, James C. Villamon, Melanie Lambac, PASu Efren C. Hibaler, ISA Jomyr H. Flores, FT II Mark-Cel B. Geronimo, FR, Jhannery L. BoclarasReviewed and edited by: Kissther Purio, Jennica Masigan

Landscape

Mount Matutum Protected Landscape (MMPL)

Ecosystem

Open forest, shrub/brush, grassland, and agricultural lands

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Severe Tropical Storm Paeng, 2022

Assessment focus

Post Paeng habitat and vegetation impacts, and biodiversity condition

GARF stages

Stage 1, with preliminary Stage 2 assessments


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 117

Mount Matutum Protected Landscape © Lagaw Juan

MMPL: A Forested Watershed Mount Matutum Protected Landscape (MMPL) lies in South Cotabato, including areas within and around Polomolok. The landscape contains open forest, shrubland or brushland, annual cropland, and perennial cropland and supports threatened and endemic species. The assessment compared Landsat 8-derived NDVI before and after Severe Tropical Storm Paeng and conducted field verification to examine possible changes in vegetation.

Key Findings The selected imagery and verified locations showed limited vegetation change after Paeng. Field verification found that closed forest remained classified as closed forest and detected no substantial change in the assessed open-forest or shrubland areas. These observations do not demonstrate that the entire protected landscape was unaffected. Fieldwork documented species of conservation concern, including Rafflesia verrucosa. The report also identified Nepenthes cf. copelandii and the Philippine warty pig as species requiring continued monitoring. Without comparable pre-Paeng data, these records cannot measure storm-related population loss or recovery. Water sources were identified as a priority for further investigation, particularly creeks, springs, and catchments.


118 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES

Mount Matutum Protected Landscape (MMPL) Pre -Paeng NDVI Map

Mount Matutum Protected Landscape (MMPL) Post - Paeng NDVI Map


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 119

NDVI Change Map at Mount Matutum Protected Landscape (MMPL)

Management and Recovery Priorities Priorities include sustained monitoring of threatened and endemic species and further assessment of creeks, springs, and catchment areas as potential water sources. Longer field periods, adequate personnel, sufficient funding, and appropriate equipment are needed to improve biodiversity documentation and subsequent management decisions.

GARF Lesson The case highlights an implementation requirement: a policy mandate may determine when GARF should be activated, but Stage 2 requires sufficient field time, personnel, equipment, funding, and technical expertise. Heavy rain further constrained the Mount Matutum assessment. Partnerships with state universities and colleges could provide expertise in biodiversity surveys, hydrology, geospatial analysis, and community research while strengthening regional capacity. The case also demonstrates why an assessment should trace changes in an ecosystem service through to their effects on people. Creeks, springs, and catchments were identified as potential water sources, but community resource mapping remained incomplete. The assessment therefore could not determine whether Paeng affected water availability or access or identify the groups dependent on those sources.

Credits and Sources The report data were collected by the Green Assessment Team of DENR Region 12, led by For. Norhassan T. Pangcoga, For. Datu Ino M. Bagul, Jay C. Salmon, For. Amin Ahsan M. Pabil, James C. Villamon, Melanie Lambac, PASu Efren C. Hibaler, ISA Jomyr H. Flores, FT II Mark-Cel B. Geronimo, FR, Jhannery L. Boclaras


120 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES REGION XIII

Post-Typhoon Ecological Assessment of the Dinagat Islands Protected Landscape and Seascape Based on the assessment by: DENR Region XIII—For. Marilou Macabuhay, For. Demcris R. Sabuero, For. Liza J. Maturan, and Loi Marie O. Alacha—and PENRO Dinagat Islands—For. Maridel G. Ibarra, For. Arian Meire E. Damalerio, For. Charifie T. Alcarde, Mathet T. Mabascog, For. James Philip G. Alas, For. Joselyn O. Manliguez, Erik Felias, and Benjamin Ellazo Landscape

Dinagat Islands Protected Landscape and Seascape (DIPLAS)

Ecosystem

Terrestrial forests, mangroves, coastal habitats, and cultivated areas

Hazard, disaster, or extreme event

Typhoon Odette, December 2021

Assessment focus

Potential impacts of Typhoon Odette on forest and mangrove ecosystems within DIPLAS

GARF stages

Stages 1 and 2


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 121

Impacts of Typhoon Odette on a Biodiversity-Rich Island Landscape The Dinagat Islands Protected Landscape and Seascape (DIPLAS) covers approximately 277,529 hectares across 81 barangays. Its marine and forest habitats provide breeding, feeding, nesting, and shelter areas for threatened wildlife, including hornbills, Philippine tarsiers, flying foxes, and marine turtles. Typhoon Odette (Rai), which made landfall on December 16, 2021, caused extensive damage across the province. Strong winds stripped vegetation and uprooted trees across large areas, while coastal ecosystems were also heavily affected. DENR Region XIII and PENRO Dinagat Islands applied GARF Stages 1 and 2 to assess the typhoonʼs potential ecological impacts.

Key Findings NDVI analysis showed changes in vegetation greenness between the selected 2021 and 2022 images, particularly along coastal areas that may contain mangrove habitats. The team conducted aerial ground truthing and rapid biodiversity assessments at predetermined reference points and priority sites to examine these potential changes. Processed aerial imagery and land-cover interpretation showed limited remaining visible vegetation damage at Cabacungan Beach in Barangay Columbos, Basilisa, at the time of assessment. Field observations approximately two years after Odette documented pioneer trees and shrubs regenerating in previously affected areas. Cassava and other cash crops had also been planted in some locations, showing that the observed vegetation included both natural regeneration and cultivated plants.

Aerial imagery of vegetation at Cabacungan, Barangay Columbos, Basilisa, compared with the 2020 land-cover map and pre- and post-event NDVI maps. Yellow represents cropland, while yellow-green represents mangrove areas.


122 | PART 2: GARF IN PRACTICE ACROSS THE PHILIPPINES In contrast, the mangrove forest in Barangay Tigbao, Cagdianao, showed substantial damage. Mapping identified approximately 5.56 hectares of damaged mangrove forest, while field surveys recorded limited regeneration, including young bakauan. Residents reported that flying foxes had previously used the area. Ground observations and aerial imagery supported the interpretation of substantial post-Odette damage, highlighting the need for continued monitoring and site-specific mangrove recovery.

Aerial imagery of the mangrove area in Barangay Tigbao, Cagdianao, compared with the 2020 land-cover map and pre- and post-event NDVI maps. Purple represents mangrove areas, while yellow represents cropland.

The biodiversity assessment in Barangay Columbos recorded 241 individuals representing 48 terrestrial plant species, 18 of which were endemic, and eight fauna species, including the Mindanao hornbill (Penelopides affinis) and rufous hornbill (Buceros hydrocorax). The presence of seed-dispersing hornbills suggests that an ecological process important to forest regeneration may still be functioning, although the records do not establish population stability or recovery. In Barangay Tigbao, the assessment recorded six mangrove species and two fauna species. Community consultations and field observations documented damage to farms, natural vegetation, and other sources of food and income. Trees in natural forests and planted areas were damaged, while residents also reported impacts on marine and coastal resources. Rivers, roads, and coastal areas contained large amounts of debris. Many residents depend primarily on fishing and farming, and coconut farmers reported substantial and prolonged economic losses, with some impacts continuing years after the typhoon.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 123

Management and Recovery Priorities A Green Recovery Plan should prioritize damaged mangrove areas and regular monitoring of natural regeneration. Site-specific restoration should account for ecological conditions, species composition, and damage, with priority given to restoring natural tidal flow and addressing other barriers before planting is considered. Monitoring should track native mangrove establishment, potentially invasive species, and wildlife use—including whether flying foxes return to the affected stand in Tigbao. At Cabacungan, repeated observations should distinguish native regeneration from cultivated vegetation and determine whether forest structure and habitat resources are recovering.

Dinagat Island, Philippines © RJD Explorer

GARF Lesson The assessment revealed a gap in ecosystem coverage. DIPLAS encompasses both a landscape and a seascape, but the documented work focused on terrestrial and mangrove habitats, leaving marine impacts unassessed. Adapting the coastal and marine assessment undertaken in the Siargao Islands Protected Landscape and Seascape could strengthen future GARF applications across interconnected island ecosystems. Expanded coverage could examine marine habitat conditions and their links to fisheries, food provision, and community livelihoods. Community evidence identified impacts on food and income sources that canopy maps could not capture. However, the delayed surveys documented conditions after regeneration and land-use change had already occurred. Timely post-event observations, reliable baselines, and repeated assessments across terrestrial, coastal, and marine habitats would provide a stronger basis for identifying persistent losses and directing recovery.

Credits and Sources Source: Region XIII case-study draft on the post-Odette assessment of the Dinagat Islands Protected Landscape and Seascape. DENR Region XIII: For. Marilou Macabuhay, For. Demcris R. Sabuero, For. Liza J. Maturan, and Loi Marie O. Alacha. PENRO Dinagat Islands: For. Maridel G. Ibarra, For. Arian Meire E. Damalerio, For. Charifie T. Alcarde, Mathet T. Mabascog, For. James Philip G. Alas, For. Joselyn O. Manliguez, Erik Felias, and Benjamin Ellazo.


© Kieth Pacardo for Ekomunikatib Multimedia Consultancy Services

Part 3

GARF Methods, Tools and Analytical Approaches [Author name(s) and affiliation(s) to be supplied.]


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 125

Introduction This part provides the technical guidance for applying the Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF) in practice. While Part I introduces the rationale, structure, and purpose of GARF, the sections that follow describe the methods, information, and analytical approaches used across its three stages in greater detail. GARF is designed to be adaptable. The specific methods used will depend on the ecosystem, disturbance, available data, technical capacity, and decisions that the assessment needs to support. The framework can be applied to protected areas, watersheds, islands, coastal and marine systems, ancestral domains, local conservation areas, production landscapes, or other ecologically and socially meaningful management units. GARF recognizes that ecological disturbances affect communities differently, depending on their access to natural resources, gender roles, responsibilities, and opportunities for participation. Integrating Gender Equality, Disability, and Social Inclusion (GEDSI) throughout the assessment helps identify unequal impacts, recognize diverse knowledge and experiences, and ensure that restoration priorities and recovery efforts are inclusive, genderresponsive, and equitable. The methods described here draw from GARF applications in the Philippines, but they are not intended to prescribe a single institutional arrangement or workflow. Other agencies, organizations, countries, and communities may adapt the approach to their own governance systems and technical contexts, provided they maintain the core purpose: identifying ecological change, understanding its significance for biodiversity and people, and translating evidence into recovery and resilience action.

Lush green Mountain View in Bicol, Philippines © Raffy Peralta via Canva


126 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES

Stage 1: Triage or Rapid Appraisal Stage 1 provides an initial understanding of where ecological disturbance may have occurred and which ecosystem and biodiversity values may be affected. It draws primarily on satellite images, existing biodiversity information, environmental datasets, information on community resource utilization, and other available observation data. The purpose is not yet to produce a complete account of ecosystem loss and damage, but rather, the rapid appraisal provides a practical way to examine a potentially large area, identify patterns of change, and pinpoint locations that need further validation.

Defining the Hazard Footprint The rapid appraisal begins by defining the hazard footprint, which is the area known or expected to have been affected by the extreme weather event. This establishes the initial spatial boundary for the assessment and guides the collection of satellite imagery, landcover data, biodiversity records, hazard information, and other relevant data. The hazard footprint does not need to follow administrative boundaries, as extreme weather events and ecological processes often extend beyond them. Depending on the assessment, it may cover a watershed, coastal zone, forest landscape, wetland, ancestral domain, protected area, or a combination of ecosystems and management units. The following considerations can help define the hazard footprint: The reported or expected extent of the extreme weather event. The ecosystems and habitats likely to have been affected. Areas of high conservation value. Communities and resource-use areas that depend on potentially affected ecosystems.

Post-disaster habitat assessment documenting typhoon-related damage, including fallen and broken trees, snapped trunks, and damaged understory vegetation © CCIPH


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 127

Example of a hazard footprint in Palawan. The map illustrates the initial spatial extent for assessing potential ecosystem disturbance, biodiversity impacts, and areas of cultural and community significance based on the path of Typhoon Rai (locally known as Odette).

Local and Indigenous knowledge is essential at this stage. Consultation with local government agencies, resource managers, local communities, Indigenous Peoples, and other stakeholders can help identify affected areas that may not be evident from existing maps or satellite imagery. These discussions should also consider how women and men use natural resources differently for subsistence and livelihoods, drawing on sex-disaggregated data where available. Cultural and traditional values must likewise be considered, including customary resource-use areas, sacred sites, and other places of cultural significance. Integrating ecological, social, gender, and cultural perspectives helps ensure that the hazard footprint captures areas important to both biodiversity and local communities, providing a more inclusive and representative basis for the assessment. It is useful to define the hazard footprint broadly at first, then narrow the assessment to specific locations as more evidence becomes available. At this stage, the goal is not to pinpoint exactly where damage occurred, but to establish sufficient spatial context to identify patterns of change and areas that may require further investigation. As the assessment progresses, areas showing stronger signs of change can be evaluated alongside biodiversity data, ecosystem types, topography, community observations, accessibility, and other relevant information. This process helps identify priority areas for closer analysis and, where necessary, field validation during Stage 2. Defining the hazard footprint is less about drawing a fixed boundary around the damage and more about establishing a practical starting point from which GARF can begin showing what happened across the landscape or seascape.


128 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES

Post-typhoon tree damage, showing snapped trunks, broken branches, and severe defoliation caused by strong winds.

Establishing Pre- and Post-Event Conditions Comparing Vegetation Indices After defining the hazard footprint, Stage 1 compares landscape conditions before and after an extreme weather event. This comparison provides an initial spatial basis for identifying potential changes and distinguishing new disturbances from conditions that existed before the event. Remote sensing enables rapid assessment of large areas, including locations that may be difficult to access.⁸ GARF uses comparable pre- and post-event satellite imagery and vegetation indices, such as the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) to assess changes in vegetation conditions across the landscape. Image selection should account for cloud cover, image quality, seasonality, acquisition timing, and data availability. Where a single suitable image is unavailable, multiple observations may be combined into representative composites. The goal is to ensure that the two periods are as comparable as possible, reducing the likelihood that observed differences are caused by seasonal or technical variations rather than the event itself. The pre-event condition serves as the baseline for comparison. Where available, this may include satellite imagery, land-cover maps, biodiversity records, previous monitoring data, and other ecological information collected before the event. The post-event condition shows the landscape following the disturbance but should not be treated as a definitive map of damage. These differences should be interpreted as signals of possible ecological disturbance rather than confirmed disaster damage. Changes may result from the extreme weather event, but they may also reflect agricultural cycles, land-use change, earlier disturbance, vegetation recovery, residual cloud effects, or other environmental processes. Although remote sensing enables rapid assessment of extensive or inaccessible landscapes, its findings must be interpreted in the context of these limitations and the environmental conditions of the assessment area.⁹ At this stage, GARF functions as ecological triage: rapidly screening a potentially large landscape or seascape to identify where change appears most pronounced, what ecological values may potentially be exposed, and where more detailed analysis or Stage 2 field validation should be prioritized.

_______________________________ ⁸Joyce, K. E., Belliss, S. E., Samsonov, S. V., McNeill, S. J., & Glassey, P. J. (2009). A review of the status of satellite remote sensing and image processing techniques for mapping natural hazards and disasters. Progress in Physical Geography, 33(2), 183–207.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 129

Box 6: Understanding NDVI and EVI Changes in vegetation are often among the first visible signs of how an extreme weather event has affected a landscape. Following a strong tropical cyclone, forests may experience canopy damage, defoliation, uprooted trees, and vegetation loss. These changes can be difficult to assess across large or inaccessible areas. Satellite imagery provides a practical way to compare vegetation conditions before and after an event and identify areas that may have experienced disturbance. The Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) is commonly used to assess vegetation greenness based on how plants reflect red and near-infrared light. NDVI values range from −1 to +1, with higher positive values generally indicating greener, more vigorous vegetation.¹⁰¹¹ Values near zero are commonly associated with bare soil, built-up areas, or areas with sparse vegetation, while negative values often indicate water or other non-vegetated surfaces. Following a strong tropical cyclone, reductions in NDVI may indicate defoliation, canopy damage, or vegetation loss.¹² The Enhanced Vegetation Index (EVI) provides a complementary measure of vegetation conditions. It is designed to reduce the influence of atmospheric effects and soil background while improving sensitivity in densely

vegetated areas where NDVI may become less responsive to differences in canopy conditions.¹³ Depending on the landscape and available satellite imagery, EVI can provide additional information for interpreting vegetation changes, particularly in tropical forests. In the assessment conducted in Palawan following Typhoon Rai (Odette), pre- and postevent NDVI images were combined into a color composite to visualize changes across the affected landscape. Areas appearing reddish indicated locations with higher vegetation greenness before the typhoon, suggesting possible vegetation loss or canopy disturbance. Bluish areas indicated greater vegetation density after the event, while more neutral tones represented relatively little apparent change. These patterns should be interpreted cautiously. A decline in NDVI or EVI may be consistent with vegetation disturbance, but it does not by itself establish the cause or severity of ecological damage. Changes may also reflect seasonality, agricultural cycles, land-use change, cloud contamination, vegetation recovery, or differences in image acquisition. Vegetation indices are therefore most useful as screening and triage tools, helping identify areas that warrant closer ecological interpretation and, where necessary, field validation.

NDVI change map of Palawan following Typhoon Rai (Odette), showing spatial differences in vegetation between pre- and post-event conditions.

_______________________________

¹⁰Pettorelli, N., Vik, J. O., Mysterud, A., Gaillard, J.-M., Tucker, C. J., & Stenseth, N. C. (2005). Using the satellite-derived NDVI to assess ecological responses to environmental change. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 20(9), 503–510. ¹¹ U.S. Geological Survey (USGS). (2018). Landsat Normalized Difference Vegetation Index. USGS. ¹² Abbas, S., Nichol, J. E., Zhang, J., & Fischer, G. A. (2020). The impact of tropical cyclones on forest structure and vegetation dynamics assessed using remote sensing. Remote Sensing of Environment, 237, 111548. ¹³Huete, A., Didan, K., Miura, T., Rodriguez, E. P., Gao, X., & Ferreira, L. G. (2002). Overview of the radiometric and biophysical performance of the MODIS vegetation indices. Remote Sensing of Environment, 83(1–2), 195–213. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0034-4257(02)00096-2


130 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES Mapping Biodiversity and Suitable Habitats Vegetation change maps show where vegetation conditions may have declined, remained relatively stable, or improved following an extreme weather event. However, these patterns alone do not reveal the potential implications for biodiversity. Their ecological significance becomes clearer when areas of vegetation loss or disturbance overlap with habitats supporting rare, threatened, endemic, or indicator species. GARF therefore integrates existing biodiversity information with mapped landscape change. Relevant sources may include the Biodiversity Assessment and Monitoring System (BAMS), Biodiversity Monitoring System (BMS), LAWIN reports, Sukat ng Kalikasan reports, scientific studies, species online databases, and other records. These provide baseline information on species occurrences, habitat characteristics, and other ecological values that may have been affected by disasters.

Choosing Indicator Species to Help Tell the Story A rapid appraisal cannot assess every species in detail. GARF focuses on one or a group of indicator species whose presence, habitat requirements, and responses to disturbance can help reveal changes in ecosystem conditions. These may include endemic and threatened species associated with specific habitats, as well as species sensitive to environmental change.¹⁴¹⁵¹⁶ Selecting suitable indicators requires more than choosing the rarest or most threatened species. Indicators should be ecologically relevant, representative of the habitats being assessed, sensitive to change, and practical to detect and monitor. Birds, for example, are commonly used because many species respond to changes in habitat and environmental conditions and are relatively easy to identify and monitor¹⁷¹⁸. Endemic and threatened species can also be valuable indicators because their restricted distributions and vulnerability may make them particularly susceptible to habitat alteration.

_______________________________ ¹⁴Landres, P. B., Verner, J., & Thomas, J. W. (1988). Ecological uses of vertebrate indicator species: A critique. Conservation Biology, 2(4), 316–328. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1523-1739.1988.tb00195. ¹⁵Carignan, V., & Villard, M.-A. (2002). Selecting indicator species to monitor ecological integrity: A review. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 78(1), 45–61. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1016136723584 ¹⁶Siddig, A. A. H., Ellison, A. M., Ochs, A., Villar-Leeman, C., & Lau, M. K. (2016). How do ecologists select and use indicator species to monitor ecological change? Insights from 14 years of publication in Ecological Indicators. Ecological Indicators, 60, 223–230. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2015.06.036 ¹⁷Bibby, C. J. (1999). Making the most of birds as environmental indicators. Ostrich, 70(1), 81–88. ¹⁸Fraixedas, S., Lindén, A., Piha, M., Cabeza, M., Gregory, R., & Lehikoinen, A. (2020). A state-of-the-art review on birds as indicators of biodiversity: Advances, challenges, and future directions. Ecological Indicators, 118, 106728.

Spot-throated Flameback (Dinopium everetti) © CCIPH


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 131

Indicator species are not intended to represent all biodiversity. Rather, they provide a practical means of examining how selected ecological values may respond to disturbance when time, data, and resources limit comprehensive assessment¹⁹.

Indicator species are species whose presence, absence, condition, or response to disturbance can provide information about broader ecological conditions. In GARF, they help interpret how habitat change may affect ecosystem quality or integrity. Flagship species are species chosen primarily for their visibility, public appeal, or cultural importance. They are often useful for communication, awareness, or mobilizing support, but they are not necessarily the most informative for detecting ecological change. Keystone species are species that exert a disproportionately large influence on ecosystem structure or function relative to their abundance. Their loss can produce cascading ecological effects. Not all keystone species are practical indicators for rapid assessment, but they may be important where ecosystem function is a central concern.

Palawan Tit (Pardaliparus amabilis) © CCIPH

Trigger species are species selected within GARF because they are expected to help trigger closer investigation or management attention. They may be threatened, endemic, habitat-restricted, disturbance-sensitive, or otherwise important for understanding potential biodiversity impacts following an extreme weather event.

In practice, a single species may fall into more than one category. A threatened endemic hornbill, for example, may function simultaneously as a trigger species, an indicator of forest condition, and a flagship species for conservation communication. GARF does not require all categories to be used. Rather, it encourages the selection of species that are fit for purpose in relation to the landscape, disturbance, and assessment objectives.

_______________________________

¹⁹Caro, T. (2010). Conservation by Proxy: Indicator, Umbrella, Keystone, Flagship, and Other Surrogate Species. Island Press.

Palawan Tit (Pardaliparus amabilis) © CCIPH


132 |

PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES

Philippine tarsier © marcophotos via Canva

Mapping Suitable Habitats of Indicator Species Species Distribution Models (SDMs) can be used to estimate where suitable habitat for selected species may occur by relating known occurrence records to environmental conditions²⁰. Different SDM approaches may be appropriate depending on the available data, species ecology, and analytical objectives. In the GARF case studies presented in this book, Maximum Entropy (MaxEnt) was used because it can work with presence-only occurrence records and a range of environmental predictors, such as vegetation condition, land cover, elevation, and slope²¹²². Model outputs indicate relative habitat suitability. They do not confirm species presence, abundance, population size, or actual habitat condition²³²⁴. By comparing habitatsuitability outputs with vegetation-change maps, GARF can identify areas where potential disturbance overlaps with habitat that may be important for selected species. These areas can then be prioritized for Stage 2 field validation. Habitat modelling is therefore used to target further assessment, not replace field surveys.

_______________________________ ²⁰ Elith, J., & Leathwick, J. R. (2009). Species distribution models: Ecological explanation and prediction across space and time. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics, 40, 677–697. ²¹ Phillips, S. J., Anderson, R. P., & Schapire, R. E. (2006). Maximum entropy modeling of species geographic distributions. Ecological Modelling, 190(3–4), 231–259. ²²Elith, J., Phillips, S. J., Hastie, T., Dudík, M., Chee, Y. E., & Yates, C. J. (2011). A statistical explanation of MaxEnt for ecologists. Diversity and Distributions, 17(1), 43–57. ²³Hernandez, P. A., Graham, C. H., Master, L. L., & Albert, D. L. (2006). The effect of sample size and species characteristics on performance of different species distribution modeling methods. Ecography, 29(5), 773–785. ²⁴Wisz, M. S., Hijmans, R. J., Li, J., Peterson, A. T., Graham, C. H., & Guisan, A. (2008). Effects of sample size on the performance of species distribution models. Diversity and Distributions, 14(5), 763–773.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 133

Box 7: Preliminary biodiversity analysis after Typhoon Rai (Odette) Extreme weather events can alter the distribution and condition of habitats used by wildlife. In Palawan, pre- and post-Typhoon Rai habitatsuitability models were compared for selected indicator species to examine whether areas of potentially suitable habitat had shifted following the event. Areas of higher predicted suitability were concentrated in forest interiors, along ridgelines, and across selected mid-elevation areas. Comparison of pre- and

post-event outputs helped identify locations where changes in vegetation condition overlapped with potentially important habitat for rare, threatened, and endemic species. These modelled changes should not be interpreted as evidence of species loss or population decline. Rather, they provide a spatial indication of where habitat conditions may have changed and where field validation is needed to determine the actual consequences for species and ecosystems.

Niche congruence model of 11 bird species in a pre- and post-Odette scenario showing significant contraction and shifts of species distribution across the landscape. The following birds were modeled: Forest-dwelling bird species with narrow to broad niche widths serve as community indicators of change: Near Threatened Spot-throated Flameback (Dinopium everetti), Palawan Tit (Pardaliparus amabilis), Palawan Blue Flycatcher (Cyornis lemprieri); Vulnerable Palawan PeacockPheasant (Polyplectron napoleonis), Falcated Wren-Babbler (Ptilocichla falcata), Blue-headed Racket-tail (Prioniturus platenae), Palawan Hornbill (Anthracorcercos marchei), Palawan Flycatcher (Ficedula platenae); Endangered Red-headed Flameback (Chrysocolaptes erythrocephalus); and Least Concern Palawan Fairy-bluebird (Irena puella) and Yellow-throated Leafbird (Chloropsis palawanensis).


134 | |PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES Identifying Reference Areas for Ground Validation The final part of rapid appraisal brings together the spatial evidence developed throughout Stage 1. Vegetation-change maps, preliminary habitat suitability models, landcover information, terrain, and available community observations on resource utilization are examined collectively to identify reference areas for possible field validation. These reference areas should represent different ecosystem types, observed vegetation conditions, and levels of potential disturbance. Locations where substantial vegetation change overlaps with important biodiversity values, areas for resource utilization, livelihood, and areas with cultural importance may receive particular attention. The selection process should also consider potential safety and protection concerns. Field visits to isolated or sensitive locations may require additional coordination, appropriate community consent, and safeguards. Teams should consider whether planned activities could create unsafe situations, expose participants to unwanted attention, or compromise confidentiality, especially when dealing with local communities and Indigenous Peoples. At the end of Stage 1, the team determines whether further validation is required. If so, GARF proceeds to Stage 2. Where available evidence is already sufficient for recovery planning, it may proceed directly to Stage 3.

Palawan Flycatcher (Ficedula platenae) © CCIPH


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Stage 2: Post-Disaster Comprehensive Assessment Stage 2 builds on the rapid appraisal by validating and refining the assessment of ecosystem and biodiversity impacts. Field observations, aerial surveys, land-cover analysis, biodiversity assessments, and community consultations are used to determine the extent and severity of ecological damage and distinguish disaster-related impacts from other environmental changes. The assessment also examines effects on ecosystem services and resource-dependent communities while integrating GESI considerations to support safe and meaningful participation. Where relevant, findings may inform ecological asset assessment and natural capital accounting. Stage 2 provides the evidence base for site-specific restoration and resilience planning in Stage 3.

Bringing the Maps to the Ground: Ground Validation of Detected Changes Stage 1 identifies areas where significant landscape changes may have occurred, but satellite observations alone cannot confirm the nature, extent, or causes of these changes. Stage 2 bridges this gap through ground validation, examining selected locations to determine what has changed and how ecosystems have been affected. Combining remotely sensed data with field observations is essential for accurately interpreting landscape changes and producing reliable land-cover information²⁵. Ground validation begins with reconnaissance to assess site conditions, accessibility, and potential risks before field teams are deployed. Local governments, protected-area personnel, communities, and Indigenous Peoples contribute local knowledge about affected areas, access routes, and ecologically or culturally significant sites. Their participation helps refine assessment priorities, guide field activities, and ensure that local circumstances and concerns are considered. Where feasible, preliminary aerial surveys and photographic documentation can further support reconnaissance by identifying areas that require closer examination. Field assessments combine aerial surveys using Remotely Piloted Aircraft Systems (RPAS or drones) with direct ground observations to provide a more comprehensive understanding of ecosystem conditions. Drones survey damage and generate training data for supervised land cover classification. Aerial photographs are processed into orthomosaic images and classified using IPCC land cover classes adapted for postdisaster contexts with a disaster-themed scheme, distinguishing damaged from persistent ecosystems by type and severity.

_______________________________ ²⁵Olofsson, P., Foody, G. M., Herold, M., Stehman, S. V., Woodcock, C. E., & Wulder, M. A. (2014). Good practices for estimating area and assessing accuracy of land change. Remote Sensing of Environment, 148, 42–57. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2014.02.015

| 135


136 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES

Community consultations and reconnaissance activities undertaken with local stakeholders before field assessment.

Manual ground surveys complement these aerial surveys by documenting vegetation structure, understory conditions, and damage that may be difficult to detect from above. These complementary approaches are particularly valuable in landscapes where dense vegetation, challenging terrain, or limited accessibility may constrain either method²⁶. Each field observation is georeferenced and documented through photographs, coordinates, and descriptions of land-cover conditions. These records provide ground reference data for interpreting satellite imagery, verifying observed changes, and distinguishing potential disasterrelated impacts from pre-existing landscape conditions or other disturbances. They also support the interpretation of conditions in nearby areas that cannot be directly surveyed, helping refine the assessment of landscape changes across the broader area of interest.

Aerial survey in Brgy. San Jose, Roxas, Palawan.

_______________________________ ²⁶Anderson, K., & Gaston, K. J. (2013). Lightweight unmanned aerial vehicles will revolutionize spatial ecology. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 11(3), 138–146. https://doi.org/10.1890/120150


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Box 8: Ground Validation Following Typhoon Odette In Palawan, ground validation following Typhoon Odette (Rai) focused on areas identified through the initial vegetationchange analysis. Drone surveys and field observations in Puerto Princesa City, San Vicente, and Roxas documented varying levels of disturbance across forests, mangroves, croplands, and other vegetation types. Aerial images revealed damage, including defoliated canopies and fallen trees, that satellite imagery alone could not clearly capture. The rapid appraisal generated 1,178 reference points, which were used to develop 688 valid reference polygons representing different vegetation and land-cover conditions. These field-based references supported subsequent land-cover classification and change assessment, helping connect satellite-detected changes with actual conditions on the ground and improve understanding of the extent and nature of the disturbance. The rapid appraisal generated 1,178 reference points, which were used to develop 688 valid

reference polygons representing different vegetation and land-cover conditions. These field-based references supported subsequent land-cover classification and change assessment, helping connect satellitedetected changes with actual conditions on the ground and improve understanding of the extent and nature of the disturbance. After the aerial survey in Palawan, images revealed substantial vegetation damage across all sampling sites, including defoliation, canopy loss, uprooted and fallen trees, and broken branches and trunks. These impacts were most evident in mid- to high-elevation forests of PPSRNP and low- to mid-elevation forests of Cleopatraʼs Needle KBA. In Cleopatraʼs Needle, landslides and damage to riverine ecosystems were also documented. Additional observations included defoliated shrubs and coconut palms, damaged mangroves with trees washed ashore, flooding in croplands and perennial crop plantations, and visible damage to infrastructure and settlements.

Sample orthomosaic image surveyed in Brgy Kemdeng with fallen trees on the ground

| 137


138 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES Land-Cover Classification and Change Assessment While ground validation provides detailed information about conditions at selected locations, understanding the full extent of disturbance requires looking at how these conditions vary across the wider landscape. GARF builds on field observations by using land-cover classification and change assessment to develop a broader picture of affected ecosystems and the extent of damage following a disaster. Unlike the vegetation-change maps produced during Stage 1, which highlight changes in vegetation greenness, Stage 2 provides a clearer understanding of the land-cover types associated with these changes and their observed conditions after a disaster. By drawing on field observations, aerial photographs, and other reference information, the assessment helps distinguish forests, mangroves, croplands, grasslands, settlements, and other landcover types. This provides a more detailed understanding of where ecosystem damage may have occurred and supports the identification of areas that may require further assessment, protection, or restoration.

Post-disaster land-cover change map accompanied by groundvalidation photographs illustrating persistent forest, defoliated trees, fallen vegetation, and other observed disturbances.

As mentioned above, aerial surveys provide a clear view of the landscape and generate orthomosaic images. Where available, field observations also help provide a better understanding of vegetation, including canopy cover and plant species. These images and observations are interpreted using internationally recognized land cover categories (IPCC, 2006; FAO, 2002, 2007) and national guidelines (DENR DMC-2005). Areas representing different land cover types are identified and marked on the images to serve as reference samples for the subsequent classification process.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 139

Once the reference samples have been prepared, satellite images are processed to classify the landscape into different land cover or ecosystem types. Satellite images taken before and after an extreme event provide a basis for understanding changes in the landscape. Key features are then extracted from the images, including information on vegetation health, surface moisture, exposed soil, water bodies, and built-up areas. These features help distinguish one land cover type from another.

Comparing land-cover conditions before and after a disaster helps identify where changes have occurred and how different ecosystems have been affected.

Using reference samples directly from the field and secondary high-resolution satellite imagery, GARF may apply supervised classification methods, including machinelearning algorithms such as Random Forest, to identify similar land-cover conditions across areas that were not directly surveyed. The supervised classification helps organize these observations into land cover and ecosystem maps, making it easier to compare conditions across different periods. The resulting maps provide a way to compare landscape conditions before and after the event, helping identify changes in land cover that may indicate damage or disturbance.

An important feature of this approach is the inclusion of disaster-related land-cover classes that distinguish persistent forest from damaged closed forest (fallen trees), damaged open forest (defoliated trees), and other forms of disturbance. These distinctions are important because an ecosystem may retain its broad land-cover classification despite sustaining substantial physical damage. For example, a forest affected by strong winds may remain classified as forest even after experiencing extensive canopy loss or damage to structures. The classification therefore considers not only the type of land cover present but also its condition following the event. Comparing land-cover conditions before and after a disaster helps identify where changes have occurred and how different ecosystems have been affected. The resulting maps are evaluated through accuracy assessments using independent reference observations to determine how reliably land-cover categories have been identified and whether further refinement is needed²⁷. Once validated, these maps provide a spatial basis for estimating the extent and distribution of affected ecosystems and identifying potential ecosystem loss and damage. These estimates are then considered alongside field observations and other available evidence to better understand the nature and possible causes of the changes, including whether they are associated with the disaster, previous land-use changes, or other environmental processes.

_______________________________ ²⁷Olofsson, P., Foody, G. M., Herold, M., Stehman, S. V., Woodcock, C. E., & Wulder, M. A. (2014). Good practices for estimating area and assessing accuracy of land change. Remote Sensing of Environment, 148, 42–57. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2014.02.015


140 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES Box 9: Mapping Land-Cover Changes Following Typhoon Odette In Palawan, land-cover mapping distinguished forest from non-forest areas, followed by a more detailed assessment of vegetation types and disturbance conditions. Random Forest classification through a directchange approach was used to identify areas that remained unchanged and those that showed signs of damage following the extreme event. The classification results indicate substantial land-cover disturbance following Typhoon Odette (Rai), as shown in the map, affecting an estimated 157,577 ha in total. Forests accounted for the largest share of the damage, with approximately 125,581 ha classified as damaged,

equivalent to 57% of the pre-typhoon forest extent. This finding is consistent with field observations of defoliation and fallen trees. Despite the damage, 96,544 ha of forest remained classified as persistent forest after the event. Coastal ecosystems were also heavily affected. Of the 12,851 ha of mapped mangroves, approximately 6,447 ha (50%) were classified as damaged. Disturbance was also recorded across mixed vegetation, croplands, plantations, and settlements, demonstrating that Typhoon Odette (Rai) affected not only natural ecosystems but also agricultural areas and developed landscapes. Taken together, the maps provide a spatial picture of the extent, distribution,

Land cover maps of the hazard footprint pre-Odette (left) and post-Odette (right). The light gray areas (labeled as non-forests) in the post-Odette map were previously dominated by closed and open forests in the pre-Rai period.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Box 9. Mapping Land-Cover Changes Following Typhoon Odette (cont.) and type of post-disaster land-cover disturbance. Combined with field observations, they help identify areas requiring further ecological assessment,

habitat protection, or restoration, and provide a basis for subsequent biodiversity assessment and recovery planning.

Post-typhoon land cover area estimates in Central and Northern Palawan (hazard footprint).

Condition

Closed and Open Forest (ha)

Dense and Sparse Mangroves (ha)

Mixed Vegetation , shrubs, grasslands (ha)

Cropland (ha)

Plantati on (ha)

Settle ment / Builtup (ha)

Overall Total (ha)

Damaged

125,581 (57%)

6,447 (50%)

7,606 (5%)

1,938 (8%)

10,066 (100%)

5,939 (62%)

157,577 (36%)

Persistent

96,544 (43%)

6,404 (50%)

153,926 (95%)

21,152 (92%)

0

3,589 (38%)

281,615 (64%)

Total

222,126 (51%)

12,851 (3%)

161,533 (37%)

23,089 (5%)

10,066 (2%)

9,529 (2%)

439,192 100%

| 141


142 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES Rapid Biodiversity Assessment Changes in land cover do not necessarily reveal the full extent of ecological disturbance. A forest may retain much of its vegetation cover while experiencing changes in habitat structure, species occurrence, and the ecological conditions that support wildlife. Rapid Biodiversity Assessment (RBA) provides a closer examination of these changes by documenting biodiversity and habitat characteristics within selected affected areas. Such fieldbased assessments are important for understanding spatial and temporal patterns of biodiversity and interpreting ecological changes that may not be apparent from landscape-level observations alone²⁸.

RBA results should be interpreted cautiously. Nondetection does not necessarily mean absence, as detectability can be influenced by survey effort, season, weather, species behavior, and accessibility⁴⁹. Likewise, differences in encounter rates should not be interpreted as population decline unless sampling effort and survey conditions are sufficiently comparable across periods.⁵⁰

.

RBA focuses on selected indicator or trigger species, particularly rare, threatened, endemic, and other conservation-important species from Stage 1. Sampling locations are informed by vegetation-change maps, preliminary habitat suitability models, existing biodiversity records, and field conditions. Survey methods should be appropriate to the target taxa and ecosystems and may include transect walks, point counts, vegetation plots, mist-netting, camera traps, and other established techniques. These can generate information on species occurrence, encounter rates, relative abundance, vegetation composition, habitat structure, and observed disturbance. Where comparable historical records are available, the observations can also help examine possible changes in biodiversity following the disturbance. Consistent sampling designs and clearly defined assessment objectives are particularly important when interpreting differences across locations or periods.

GARF team and partners conducting herpetofauna and volant mammal sampling _______________________________ ²⁸ Lindenmayer, D. B., & Likens, G. E. (2010). The science and application of ecological monitoring. Biological Conservation, 143(6), 1317–1328. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2010.02.013 ⁴⁹ MacKenzie, D. I., Nichols, J. D., Lachman, G. B., Droege, S., Royle, J. A., & Langtimm, C. A. (2002). Estimating site occupancy rates when detection probabilities are less than one. Ecology, 83(8), 2248–2255. ⁵⁰Nichols, J. D., & Williams, B. K. (2006). Monitoring for conservation. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 21(12), 668–673. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2006.08.007


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 143

Examples of field techniques that may be used in GARF Rapid Biodiversity Assessment. Methods should be adapted to the target species, ecosystem, available expertise, permits, and field conditions. Taxon/assessment focus

Appropriate techniques

Birds

Point transect²⁹ , transect line³⁰³¹, ditance sampling³², mist netting.

Volant Mammals

Mist netting³⁴ (V-net for insect bats)³⁵³⁶³⁷

Non-volant Mammals

Transect walk³⁸, live trapping/cage trapping, camera trapping³⁹⁴⁰⁴¹

Aphibians and Reptiles

Line Transect⁴², strip transect⁴³, distance sampling⁴⁴, pitfall trapping⁴⁵, sticky trapping, opportunistic sampling⁴⁶⁴⁷

Flora and Habitat

Modified Belt Transect Method⁴⁸

Transects, species observations, and habitat conditions can be mapped alongside land-cover change and habitat-suitability outputs. This helps identify where biodiversity values overlap with observed disturbance and where further monitoring, habitat protection, or restoration may be required. RBA complements landscape-level mapping by showing what species and habitat conditions are present on the ground, how they may have been affected, and where additional ecological action may be needed. ____________________________________________________________ ²⁹Reynolds, R. T., Scott, J. M., & Nussbaum, R. A. (1980). A variable circular-plot method for estimating bird numbers. The Condor, 82(3), 309– 313. ³⁰ Emlen, J. T. (1971). Population densities of birds derived from transect counts. The Auk, 88(2), 323–342.\ ³¹ Bibby, C. J., Burgess, N. D., Hill, D. A., & Mustoe, S. (2000). Bird census techniques (2nd ed.). Academic Press. ³² Buckland, S. T., Anderson, D. R., Burnham, K. P., Laake, J. L., Borchers, D. L., & Thomas, L. (2001). Introduction to distance sampling: Estimating abundance of biological populations. Oxford University Press. ³³Karr, J. R. (1981). Surveying birds with mist nets. Studies in Avian Biology, 6, 62–67. ³⁴Duya, M. R. M., Duya, M. V., Alviola, P. A., Balete, D. S., & Heaney, L. R. (2008). Report on a survey of the mammals of the Sierra Madre Range, Luzon Island, Philippines. Banwa, 4, 41–68. ³⁵Duya, M. R. M., Fidelino, J. S., & Ong, P. S. (2017). Spatial heterogeneity of fruit bats in a primary tropical lowland evergreen rainforest in northeastern Luzon, Philippines. Acta Chiropterologica, 19(2), 305–318. ³⁶Alviola, P. A. (2000). The distribution and ecology of bats in the Polillo Islands, Philippines. In D. Bennett (Ed.), Wildlife of Polillo Island, Philippines (pp. 105–124). ³⁷Sedlock, J. L., Weyandt, S. E., Cororan, L., Damerow, M., Hwa, S.-H., & Pauli, B. (2008). Bat diversity in tropical forest and agro-pastoral habitats within a protected area in the Philippines. Acta Chiropterologica, 10(2), 349–358. ³⁸Heaney, L. R., Balete, D. S., Rickart, E. A., Utzurrum, R. C. B., & Gonzales, P. C. (1999). Mammalian diversity on Mount Isarog, a threatened center of endemism on southern Luzon Island, Philippines. Fieldiana: Zoology, New Series, 95, 1–62. ³⁹Marler, P. N., Calago, S., Ragon, M., & Castro, L. S. G. (2019). Camera trap survey of mammals in Cleopatra's Needle Critical Habitat in Puerto Princesa City, Palawan, Philippines. Journal of Threatened Taxa, 11(13), 14631–14642. ⁴⁰Bejar, S.G.F., Aguilar, R.G., Amberong, A.G.T. et al. Camera traps elicit behavioral responses from wild Philippine tarsiers (Carlito syrichta) on Leyte Island. Primates 66, 431–437 (2025). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10329-025-01202-7 ⁴¹Hoffmann, Anke & Decher, Jan & Rovero, Francesco & Voigt, Christian & Schaer, Juliane. (2010). Field Methods and Techniques for Monitoring Mammals. ⁴²Sanguila, M. B., Plaza, J. L., Mahinay, M. Y., Edma, R. C., Jr., & Brown, R. M. (2021). Herpetological assemblages in tropical forests of the Taguibo Watershed, Butuan City, Eastern Mindanao, Philippines. Philippine Journal of Science, 150(S1), 415–431. ⁴³ Lagat, R. D., & Causaren, R. M. (2018). Initial terrestrial vertebrate diversity assessment in upland Cavite, Philippines. Philippine Journal of Systematic Biology, 12(2). ⁴⁴ Thomas, L., Buckland, S.T., Rexstad, E.A., Laake, J.L., Strindberg, S., Hedley, S.L., Bishop, J.R.B., Marques, T.A. and Burnham, K.P. (2010), Distance software: design and analysis of distance sampling surveys for estimating population size. Journal of Applied Ecology, 47: 5-14. ⁴⁵ Heyer, W. R., Donnelly, M. A., McDiarmid, R. W., Hayek, L.-A. C., & Foster, M. S. (Eds.). (1994). Measuring and monitoring biological diversity: Standard methods for amphibians. Smithsonian Institution Press. ⁴⁶ Supsup, C. E., Asis, A. A., Carestia, U. V., Diesmos, A. C., Mallari, N. A. D., & Brown, R. M. (2020). Variation in species richness, composition and herpetological community structure across a tropical habitat gradient of Palawan Island, Philippines. Herpetozoa, 33, 95–111. ⁴⁷Diesmos, M. L. L., del Prado, Y. L. C., Kim, P. M. M., Caguimbal, N. A. L. E., Venturina, R. E. L., Lorenzo, A. N., II, & Diesmos, A. C. (2026). Amphibians and reptiles of Samar Island Natural Park, Philippines, with an updated checklist, a rediscovery, and new records for Samar Island. ZooKeys, 1269, 303–328. ⁴⁸Biodiversity Management Bureau. (2017). Manual on Biodiversity Assessment and Monitoring System for Terrestrial Ecosystems. Biodiversity Management Bureau and the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH. Manila, Philippines.


144 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES

Box 10: Examining Habitat Conditions and Changes in Suitability In Palawan, habitat-suitability models were developed for 11 indicator species, including the Palawan Hornbill (Anthracoceros marchei) and Palawan Flycatcher (Ficedula platenae). Suitable environmental conditions were concentrated in contiguous natural forests across elevational gradients within the Puerto Princesa Subterranean River National Park (PPSRNP) and Cleopatraʼs Needle massif. Elevation and vegetation conditions were among the strongest predictors of suitability. Speciescongruence maps further highlighted forest blocks potentially important to multiple conservation-priority species.

Comparison of pre- and post-Rai model outputs showed substantial reductions in predicted suitable habitat. For the Palawan Hornbill, suitable habitat declined from 114,564 ha to 82,022 ha, a reduction of 32,542 ha (28%). The Palawan Flycatcher declined from 125,375 ha to 82,139 ha, equivalent to 43,236 ha (34%). The largest reduction was recorded for the Busuanga Wart Frog, whose estimated suitable habitat decreased from 138,503 ha to 69,329 ha, representing a 50% decline. The maps show where suitable environmental conditions were predicted to persist, decline, or shift after Typhoon Odette.

Pre-Rai (left) and post-Rai (right) species distribution models of the Palawan Hornbill (Anthracoceros marchei), Palawan Flycatcher (Ficedula platenae), and Busuanga Wart Frog. Warmer colors indicate higher predicted habitat suitability (blue = not suitable; yellow = low suitability; orange = moderate suitability; red = high suitability).


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Box 10: Examining Habitat Conditions and Changes in Suitability (cont.)

Pre- and post-Odette habitat-suitability and species-congruence maps for selected indicator species in SIPLAS, illustrating areas of retained, reduced, and overlapping predicted suitability. Green indicates lower suitability, while red indicates higher suitability.

| 145


146 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES

Box 10: Examining Habitat Conditions and Changes in Suitability (cont.) Areas retaining higher suitability may be particularly important for habitat protection, ecological connectivity, biodiversity monitoring, and restoration planning. In the Siargao Island Protected Landscape and Seascape (SIPLAS), the post-disaster assessment examined predicted habitat suitability for five indicator species and species groups: the Southern Rufous Hornbill (Buceros mindanensis), Mindanao Hornbill (Penelopides affinis), Island Flying Fox (Pteropus hypomelanus), Begonia species, and Anislag (Flueggea flexuosa). The models showed that suitable habitats were largely fragmented across mainland Siargao, particularly in San Benito, Pilar, and Dapa, where most areas exhibited low to moderate suitability. In contrast, Socorro retained relatively extensive forest habitats that remained suitable for several indicator species. Pre- and post-Odette species-congruence maps in SIPLAS showed that areas of overlapping suitable habitat for multiple species remained concentrated in parts of San Benito, San Isidro, Pilar, Dapa, and especially Socorro.

Although the overall spatial pattern remained broadly similar before and after the typhoon, localized changes in the extent and concentration of overlapping suitable habitats were evident. Much of the landscape continued to show little or no overlap in predicted suitable habitats, indicating that areas capable of supporting multiple conservation-priority species were limited and unevenly distributed. The two case studies show that post-disaster habitat responses can differ markedly across landscapes. In Palawan, the models indicated substantial reductions in predicted suitable habitat for several indicator species. In Siargao, changes were generally smaller and more localized, with habitat fragmentation and preexisting pressures such as forest conversion, logging, and infrastructure development likely also influencing the observed patterns. Note also that changes in predicted suitability should not be interpreted as direct measures of population loss or occupancy change. They represent shifts in modeled environmental suitability and should be interpreted together with field observations.

Flora sampling © Alan Kristofer


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 147

Loboc River, Bohol, Philippines © Alexpunker via Canva


148 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES Biodiversity Indicators for Non-Economic Loss and Damage Assessment Biodiversity loss cannot be understood from changes in area alone. Disturbance can alter species composition, occurrence, habitat quality, ecological connectivity, and the availability of suitable habitat. Such changes may be especially consequential for rare, threatened, endemic, and habitat-specialist species, whose persistence may depend on specific habitat conditions and connected populations. These impacts can persist even where vegetation cover has partially recovered. GARF Stage 2 can help document these less visible dimensions of biodiversity-related non-economic loss and damage. The following indicators may be used depending on comparable data available.

Species diversity and richness. Changes in observed species richness can provide an initial indication of biodiversity change. Species accumulation and rarefaction curves help assess sampling completeness and allow comparisons across different sampling efforts. Richness estimators such as Chao, Jackknife, and bootstrap can further estimate species diversity that may not have been fully captured during surveys. These indices should be interpreted with consideration of sampling completeness, detectability, season, and survey conditions.

Species turnover and community composition. Similar species richness before and after a disturbance does not necessarily mean that the ecological community has remained unchanged. Indicators may include the proportion of species retained, newly recorded, or not detected, as well as changes in community composition by taxonomic group. However, species not recorded after a disaster should not automatically be confirmed as loss, as their detection could be influenced by survey conditions and sampling effort.

Conservation-weighted biodiversity loss. Changes involving endemic, threatened, forest-dependent, or habitat-specialist species may have greater conservation significance than changes involving widespread generalists. Relevant indicators may include changes in richness, occurrence, or relative abundance of priority species, as well as shifts in the representation of specialists, generalists, and edgeassociated species. For example, fewer forest specialists alongside more generalist species may indicate changes in habitat conditions and potential community homogeneity.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 149

Philippine eagle © Wilfredo Garrido via Canva

Changes in suitable habitats. Species distribution models can be used to compare the potential extent and distribution of predicted suitable habitat between assessment periods. Indicators may include suitable habitat area, percentage gain or loss, and shifts in habitat distribution. Environmental predictors such as land cover, elevation, slope, and aspect can help explain modeled patterns, while performance measures such as the Area Under the Curve (AUC) provide information on model discrimination. Changes in predicted suitability should not be interpreted as equivalent to population decline.

Habitat fragmentation and connectivity. The amount of habitat remaining is only one part of the ecological condition. Landscape metrics such as patch number, patch density, mean patch area, and cohesion can help assess whether suitable habitats have become smaller, more fragmented, or increasingly isolated. These measures can also identify disrupted corridors and areas where protection or restoration may improve connectivity.


150 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES

Philippine Indigenous people in traditional dress © terence b via Canva

Understanding Ecosystem Impacts on Local Communities Ecosystem disturbance affects more than the physical landscape. Changes in forests, rivers, wetlands, and coastal ecosystems can disrupt the resources and services that communities depend on for their livelihoods, safety, cultural practices, and everyday well-being. Assessing ecosystem loss and damage therefore requires understanding not only how nature has changed but also how these changes affect the people who depend on it. GARF incorporates community knowledge through Focus Group Discussions (FGDs), Key Informant Interviews (KIIs), community resource mapping (CRMs), and other participatory consultations. These activities help document changes in resource availability, access, and ecosystem services, including food and water supplies, fisheries, agricultural resources, forest products, flood protection, soil stability, and water regulation. They also capture non-economic losses and damage, such as impacts on culturally significant landscapes, traditional practices, community identity, and people's sense of place, values that ecological measurements and economic assessments alone may not fully capture. Ecosystem disturbance affects more than the physical landscape. Changes in forests, rivers, wetlands, and coastal ecosystems can disrupt the resources and services that communities depend on for their livelihoods, safety, cultural practices, and everyday well-being. Assessing ecosystem loss and damage therefore requires understanding not only how nature has changed but also how these changes affect the people who depend on it.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 151

GARF incorporates community knowledge through Focus Group Discussions (FGDs), Key Informant Interviews (KIIs), community resource mapping (CRMs), and other participatory consultations. These activities help document changes in resource availability, access, and ecosystem services, including food and water supplies, fisheries, agricultural resources, forest products, flood protection, soil stability, and water regulation. They also capture noneconomic losses and damage, such as impacts on culturally significant landscapes, traditional practices, community identity, and people's sense of place, values that ecological measurements and economic assessments alone may not fully capture. Local communities and Indigenous Peoples possess valuable knowledge of the ecosystems they have long used, managed, and depended upon. Their observations can reveal changes in wildlife, water sources, resource-use areas, and culturally significant habitats that may not be readily detected through satellite imagery or short field surveys. Recognizing that ecosystem disturbance and recovery affect people differently, GARF integrates Gender Equality and Social Inclusion (GESI) into the assessment. Women, Indigenous Peoples, youth, and other marginalized or underrepresented groups may have different resource needs, livelihood dependencies, experiences of disaster impacts, and opportunities to participate in recovery decisions. Inclusive, accessible, and culturally appropriate consultations help ensure that their knowledge, concerns, and priorities are reflected in the assessment process. This approach also supports meaningful participation, respects rights and decision-making processes, and upholds relevant safeguards, helping ensure that GARF responds to diverse community needs and does not reinforce existing inequalities.

Changes in forests, rivers, wetlands, and coastal ecosystems can disrupt the resources and services that communities depend on for their livelihoods, safety, cultural practices, and everyday well-being. Community observations are integrated with land-cover maps, biodiversity records, and habitat assessments to understand how ecological changes affect ecosystem services and the people who depend on them. A GESI perspective helps reveal how these impacts differ across communities, particularly among marginalized groups, whose resource needs, livelihood dependencies, and access to recovery support may vary. By combining scientific evidence with local knowledge and diverse lived experiences, GARF develops a more comprehensive and inclusive understanding of ecosystem loss and damage. This approach ensures that both ecological impacts and their social and cultural consequences inform recovery planning, helping identify priorities that reflect diverse community needs, uphold Indigenous Peoples' rights, promote equitable participation, and strengthen everyone's capacity to recover.


152 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES Box 11: Understanding Gender Roles, Indigenous Knowledge, and Disaster Vulnerability among AgtaTabangnon Communities in surrounding Bulusan Volcano Natural Park, Sorsogon

FGD with Agta-Tabangnon men in Bulusan, Sorsogon

Focus group discussions with Agta-Tabangnon community members in Bulusan, Sorsogon highlighted how gender roles, Indigenous knowledge, and access to decision-making can shape experiences of disaster and ecosystem recovery. Barriers to Womenʼs Participation and Leadership Among the older women who participated, 3/6 shared leaving school after being forced into marriage. Their experiences highlight how early marriage and unequal gender norms can limit womenʼs education, independence, livelihood opportunities, and participation in community decisions. These responsibilities can affect the time, mobility, and opportunities women have to participate in community consultations, training, ecological assessment, and restoration planning. In communities exposed to typhoons and hazards associated with the active Bulusan Volcano, womenʼs participation in Eco-DRR is essential to ensure that their needs, knowledge, and priorities are reflected in risk reduction and recovery efforts. Relationship with Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services Both men and women demonstrated knowledge

of local wildlife and natural resources, although their experiences differed. Men identified several forest-dwelling animals (tariktik hornbills, monkeys, and bats), while women shared knowledge of orchids and medicinal plants, reflecting their familiarity with resources used in household healthcare. Participants identified forest products such as anahaw and rattan for roofing and household materials, pako fern for food, and tilapia from ponds for consumption and income. They also described traditional uses of medicinal plants, including pamughaton, lakadbulan, manzanilla, anonang, and lingatong. These accounts reflect valuable Indigenous and local knowledge that can support biodiversity conservation and ecosystem management. Forests and other ecosystems also provide essential services, including food, water, livelihood resources, soil stability, and protection from natural hazards. Typhoons and intense rainfall can damage these ecosystems, disrupt livelihoods, and reduce access to natural resources. Hazards associated with the Bulusan Volcano may further threaten communities and surrounding ecosystems. Protecting and restoring these natural systems is therefore an important part of GARF and broader Eco-DRR initiatives, particularly for communities whose livelihoods depend on them.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 153

Box 11: Understanding Gender Roles, Indigenous Knowledge, and Disaster Vulnerability among Agta-Tabangnon Communities in surrounding Bulusan Volcano Natural Park, Sorsogon (cont.) Gender-Based Violence, Safety, and Opportunities for Inclusive Participation and Leadership Women participants reported knowing individuals who had experienced gender-based violence (GBV), while most men were unaware of such cases. Some incidents had been reported to the barangay VAW Desk. Discussions also highlighted concerns about early marriage, restrictions on womenʼs mobility, and the effects of abuse on womenʼs education, mental health, and aspirations. These experiences demonstrate how gender inequality can increase vulnerability during disasters. Women facing violence, restricted mobility, or limited control over resources may have fewer opportunities to access preparedness information, evacuation support, and recovery assistance. Addressing GBV and ensuring safe, confidential, and survivor-centered support are therefore important considerations in inclusive Eco-DRR. These issues are not themselves measures of ecological loss and damage, but they have direct implications for how GARF engagement is designed. GARF and the broader Eco-DRR initiatives should strengthen womenʼs leadership

through accessible and culturally appropriate training, meaningful representation in disaster risk reduction structures, and opportunities to participate in ecosystem assessments, restoration, and recovery planning. Men should also be encouraged to share domestic and caregiving responsibilities and recognize womenʼs contributions and right to participate in community activities. Implication for GARF The Agta-Tabangnon experience shows that community-based assessment should ask more than which resources were affected. It should also consider: Who uses and depends on those resources? Whose ecological knowledge is being captured? Who is able to participate in assessment and recovery decisions? What social or cultural barriers may exclude particular groups? Integrating these questions with ecological evidence allows GARF to develop a more complete understanding of ecosystem loss and damage and supports recovery measures that are both ecologically sound and socially inclusive.

FGD with Agta-Tabangnon women in Bulusan, Sorsogon


154 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES

Stage 3 - Ecosystem Restoration and Resilience Planning Stages 1 and 2 establish the extent of disaster impacts, identify affected ecosystems, and assess the implications for biodiversity and local communities. Stage 3 translates this evidence into recovery action. It evaluates the potential of disturbed ecosystems to recover, identifies priority areas for restoration, and determines appropriate measures to rebuild ecological functions and strengthen long-term resilience. Recovery does not always mean planting trees or introducing new vegetation. Many ecosystems can regenerate naturally through surviving plants, seed dispersal, and ecological succession. However, severe disturbances may limit these processes and require additional support. The key is to determine where protecting ecosystems and allowing natural recovery are sufficient, and where active restoration is necessary⁵¹⁵². Stage 3 brings together landscape assessments, field evidence of natural regeneration, restoration planning, and community participation to guide these decisions. It follows a principle of protecting remaining natural ecosystems, promoting natural regeneration wherever possible, and applying targeted interventions where recovery is unlikely to occur on its own. These priorities are consolidated into an Ecosystem Restoration and Resilience Plan (ERRP), also referred to as a Green Recovery Plan (GRP). The plan outlines priority areas, appropriate restoration approaches, implementation arrangements, resource requirements, and monitoring measures to guide recovery and track progress over time.

Presentation of GARF Results during socialization in Concepcion, Puerto Princesa © City ENRO

_______________________________ ⁵¹ Chazdon, R. L., & Guariguata, M. R. (2016). Natural regeneration as a tool for large-scale forest restoration in the tropics: Prospects and challenges. Biotropica, 48(6), 716–730. https://doi.org/10.1111/btp.12381 ⁵² Elliott, S., Tucker, N. I. J., Shannon, D. P., & Tiansawat, P. (2023). The framework species method: Harnessing natural regeneration to restore tropical forest ecosystems. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 378(1867), 20210073. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2021.0073


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Establishing a Coordinating Mechanism Restoration and recovery planning requires coordination among institutions, communities, and technical groups responsible for managing and using the affected landscape. The appropriate arrangement will depend on the governance context and may take the form of an existing management body, technical working group, community-led structure, or another locally appropriate coordinating platform. Participation may include relevant environmental and disaster management authorities, local governments, Indigenous Peoples and local communities, technical and research institutions, civil society, and other sectors connected to the affected ecosystems. Representation should also enable meaningful participation by women and other groups whose livelihoods, rights, or well-being depend on ecosystem recovery. The coordinating mechanism should support the review of GARF findings, identification of restoration priorities, agreement on appropriate interventions, assignment of responsibilities, mobilization of resources, and establishment of monitoring arrangements.

Validating and Sharing Assessment Findings Restoration and recovery planning begins by sharing the findings of the earlier GARF stages with communities connected to the affected landscape. Land cover change maps, biodiversity assessments results, and changes in ecosystem services provide a basis for discussing the impacts and identifying recovery needs. Presenting these findings in accessible formats allows stakeholders to validate the results, share local observations, and identify important areas or concerns that may have been overlooked. While scientific assessments provide essential evidence, they may not fully capture the ecological and social significance of a landscape. Local and Indigenous knowledge can offer valuable insights into changes in wildlife, habitats, natural resources, and the ecosystem services that support community livelihoods and well-being. Through consultations, these perspectives are considered alongside scientific findings to better understand which areas are recovering naturally and which may require further protection or restoration. These discussions also help ensure that restoration priorities reflect not only ecological conditions but also the different ways community members experience disaster impacts. Women and men, Indigenous Peoples, farmers, youth, persons with disabilities, and other affected groups may have distinct concerns and priorities shaped by their roles, responsibilities, livelihoods, access to resources, and dependence on ecosystem services. A gender-responsive and inclusive approach recognizes these differences and creates opportunities for all groups to meaningfully participate in identifying the ecosystems and services most important to their recovery. Bringing these perspectives together provides a shared basis for identifying where restoration is needed, what type of intervention is appropriate, and whose needs and knowledge should inform implementation.

| 155


156 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES

Presentation of GARF Results during socialization in Concepcion, Puerto Princesa © City ENRO

Determining Appropriate Restoration Strategies Once assessment findings have been validated, the coordinating group identifies appropriate restoration strategies for affected ecosystems. Restoration of damaged ecosystems may range from protecting remnant vegetation and allowing natural recovery to applying active interventions that accelerate regeneration or reintroduce plant species representative of the target ecosystem. Selecting the most appropriate approach requires an understanding of the extent and nature of damage, the level of ecosystem degradation, the capacity for natural recovery, and the factors that may influence restoration success. A Restoration Catalyst Framework can help guide this process by identifying suitable interventions and determining when additional support is needed. The framework is designed to complement established ecosystem conservation and restoration approaches. For forest ecosystems, the priority is to protect remaining natural forests, promote natural regeneration wherever possible, and undertake planting or revegetation only where necessary. This approach helps avoid unnecessary interventions while directing resources to areas where restoration is most needed. Developing a framework suited to a specific area of interest begins with defining the restoration goals and desired ecological outcomes. Land-cover or benthic-cover maps are then examined to identify affected ecosystem types, the distribution and concentration of damage, and, where possible, the specific types and severity of disturbance. Based on these findings, affected areas are assessed based on different factors such as topography, level of degradation, sources of regeneration, and regeneration potential. These help determine which areas can recover naturally and which require active intervention.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 157

Appropriate restoration strategies are then identified based on the ecosystemʼs capacity for natural recovery. Potential barriers to restoration, including ecological, environmental, social, and institutional constraints, are also assessed, along with measures to address them. Finally, key decision points are established to guide the selection and sequencing of interventions. These decisions can be presented in a simple flow diagram to provide a clear and practical pathway for determining the most suitable restoration approach for each affected area. Restoration strategies may include, but are not limited to, the following approaches: Protection of persistent forests and other remaining natural ecosystems;

Spontaneous Natural Regeneration (SNR)⁵³ in areas with high natural recovery potential or where active restoration is unsuitable; Assisted Natural Regeneration (ANR)⁵⁴, with or without enrichment planting, in moderately damaged areas where intervention is needed to accelerate recovery; Reforestation or ecological rehabilitation in severely degraded areas where natural recovery is unlikely to happen with active interventions; and Approaches such as Maximum Diversity Planting⁵⁵ or the Framework Species Method⁵⁶ may be appropriate in some forest-restoration contexts. Other ecosystems, including mangroves, wetlands, freshwater systems, grasslands, and coastal or marine habitats, require strategies suited to their ecological processes and disturbance conditions. Restoration planning should also identify ecological, social, institutional, and resourcerelated barriers that could limit implementation or long-term recovery. Where communities depend directly on affected ecosystems, complementary livelihood measures such as agroforestry, sustainable non-timber forest product use, analog forestry⁵⁷ may be incorporated to reduce pressure on recovering ecosystems and support local resilience.

_______________________________ ⁵³ Chazdon, R. L., & Guariguata, M. R. (2016). Natural regeneration as a tool for large-scale forest restoration in the tropics: Prospects and challenges. Biotropica, 48(6), 716–730. https://doi.org/10.1111/btp.12381 ⁵⁴ Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. (2019). Restoring forest landscapes through assisted natural regeneration (ANR): A practical manual. FAO. ⁵⁵ ICLEI South Asia. (2022). Guidelines for development of Miyawaki forests in India. SDC-supported CapaCITIES II Project. ⁵⁶ Elliott, S., Tucker, N. I. J., Shannon, D. P., & Tiansawat, P. (2023). The framework species method: Harnessing natural regeneration to restore tropical forest ecosystems. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 378(1867), 20210073. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2021.0073 ⁵⁷ Senanayake, R., & Jack, J. (1998). Analogue forestry: An introduction. Monash Publications in Geography (No. 49). Department of Geography and Environmental Science, Monash University


158 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES Box 12: Forest Restoration Catalyst Framework Forest restoration has traditionally focused on addressing human-induced degradation and improving habitat conditions. However, restoring ecosystems affected by climate-induced disasters requires approaches that account for the extent and severity of damage, as well as the ecosystemʼs capacity for natural recovery. While damaged forests may retain the ability to regenerate, large-scale disturbances can disrupt ecological succession, reduce natural regeneration, and delay recovery of forest structure and biodiversity.

Damaged forests with fallen trees require a more detailed assessment to determine their recovery potential. Factors such as slope, elevation, existing vegetation, regenerant density and diversity, and the presence of mother trees help guide the selection of restoration strategies. Young trees, seedlings, wildlings, root suckers, and stump sprouts that naturally emerge to rebuild a degraded forest canopy are considered regenerants. Field validation is essential for assessing these biophysical conditions and determining the most appropriate interventions.

These challenges became evident following Typhoon Odette (Rai), which caused extensive damage to forests and other ecosystems in Palawan. The resulting changes in land cover and forest conditions highlighted the need for a systematic approach to determine where natural regeneration could be sustained and where additional restoration interventions were necessary. In response, the Forest Restoration Catalyst Framework by CCIPH was developed to guide the assessment of typhoondamaged forests and identify appropriate recovery strategies. By prioritizing natural regeneration where viable and recommending targeted interventions where recovery is constrained, the framework supports evidence-based restoration and long-term ecosystem resilience.

For example, sites with steep slopes (above 50%) and elevations exceeding 500 meters above sea level may be better suited to Spontaneous Natural Regeneration (SNR), particularly where natural recovery is already occurring. SNR allows vegetation to recover with minimal intervention. However, this does not mean abandoning the site. Regular monitoring is still necessary to track natural recolonization, identify emerging threats, and determine whether additional support is needed.

The process begins by defining restoration objectives and identifying target areas using post-disaster landcover maps and field observations. Based on the land cover maps generated in GARF stage 2, affected forests are generally classified into three conditions: persistent forests, damaged forests with defoliated trees, and damaged forests with fallen trees. Protecting persistent forests is an immediate priority, as they provide important habitat, seed sources, and natural regeneration. Areas with extensive vegetation loss, meanwhile, may require additional interventions to support ecosystem recovery. Damaged forests with defoliated trees may recover naturally if the trees survive the effects of the disturbance. However, damaged trees may remain vulnerable to delayed mortality, insect attacks, and fungal infections. Regular monitoring is therefore important to assess their condition and survival. Trees with a low likelihood of recovery, such as severely leaning or heavily infected individuals, may be removed and replaced through enrichment planting where appropriate.

Natural regeneration may also be constrained by limiting factors that prevent seeds from establishing and plants from surviving. These may include poor soil conditions, limited water availability, persistent ground disturbance, and accumulated post-disaster debris. Identifying these constraints is essential to determining appropriate site treatments or mitigating measures. Once these limitations have been addressed, the density and composition of regenerants per hectare should be assessed to guide further restoration decisions. Sites with more than 800 regenerants per hectare may be suitable for Assisted Natural Regeneration (ANR). This approach supports the growth and survival of native vegetation already present by reducing threats and improving conditions for natural recovery. In contrast, sites with fewer than 800 regenerants per hectare, particularly those dominated by grasses and herbs, may require active planting or revegetation. Methods such as the Framework Species Method (FSM), Maximum Diversity Planting, the Miyawaki Method, and Analog Forestry may be considered depending on site conditions and restoration objectives. The composition of regenerants is also equally


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 159

Box 12: Forest Restoration Catalyst Framework (cont.)

Forest Restoration Catalyst Framework. The framework guides the selection of restoration strategies based on ecosystem condition, natural regeneration potential, and limiting factors, with monitoring and reassessment supporting adaptive management. important. Where more than 70% of regenerants consist of pioneer or early-successional species, ANR may need to be complemented by enrichment planting to increase species diversity and promote the development of a more representative forest community. Other planting approaches, such as FSM, maximum diversity planting, or analog forestry, may also be considered where natural regeneration alone is insufficient.

These restoration strategies are not mutually exclusive and may be combined depending on site conditions and recovery objectives. Protection and monitoring remain essential throughout the process, regardless of the intervention selected. Rather than imposing a fixed endpoint, restoration aims to support natural ecological processes and guide degraded ecosystems toward a more diverse, functional, and resilient condition.


160 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES Examining Recovery Potential through Restoration Catalyst Plots Restoration Catalyst Plots (RCPs) provide site-level information on vegetation condition, natural regeneration, species composition, soil characteristics, and threats that may influence recovery. Each RCP covers a one-hectare area (100 m × 100 m). Within this area, nested circular subplots, each with a 5-meter radius, are established at designated sampling locations to assess natural regeneration and characterize site conditions. These subplots serve as the primary sampling units for recording regenerants, identifying tree species, and estimating regenerant density. Soil characteristics and potential threats to vegetation establishment are also assessed within the RCP. Regenerant density is calculated from the number of individuals recorded relative to the total sampled area and expressed as the estimated number of regenerants per hectare. Together with species diversity and composition, this provides an indication of the site's natural regeneration capacity and helps determine whether active restoration interventions are necessary. As a general guide, approximately 800 regenerants per hectare may be sufficient to support canopy closure, while 2,500 seedlings per hectare is considered the maximum planting density. These figures help guide decisions on whether existing natural regeneration is adequate or whether additional planting is needed. Species composition is also considered; when more than 80% of regenerants are pioneering species, enrichment planting may be considered to increase species diversity and introduce a broader range of native species. These thresholds should be interpreted alongside site conditions, species characteristics, and restoration objectives. RCP results help determine the type and intensity of intervention required. Sites with adequate natural regeneration may primarily require protection, while areas with limited regeneration or constrained recovery may benefit from Assisted Natural Regeneration, enrichment planting, or more active restoration. Matching restoration strategies to observed site conditions and recovery potential avoids unnecessary intervention and directs resources toward areas where additional restoration support is most needed.

GARF team members and partners doing establishment and assessment


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

RCP diagram

| 161


162 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES Box 13: Application of Restoration Catalyst Plots in Marufinas, Palawan The Restoration Catalyst Plot (RCP) approach was applied in Sitio Yabu, Barangay Marufinas, Palawan to guide restoration planning within a 70.61-ha priority area identified under the Green Recovery Plan for the Puerto Princesa Subterranean River National Park (PPSRNP). Six RCPs were established with the participation community members from the Samahan ng Magsasaka sa Marufinas (SMM), Marufinas Women's Association (MWA), and Samahan ng Pangkabuhayan sa Marufinas (SPKM), and PPSRNP forest rangers. What the RCPs showed The plots revealed that natural regeneration was already occurring across much of the site, but the condition and composition of regenerating vegetation varied. Several plots were located near abandoned kaingin or uma areas where Acacia mangium had become dominant. Pioneer species were generally more abundant than secondary and climax species, indicating that regeneration was occurring but that species composition remained simplified in some areas. Regeneration density also differed among sites. The SMM R-01 plot recorded more than 2,500 regenerants/ha, while the SPKM plots contained approximately 2,450 regenerants/ha. These densities indicated substantial natural regeneration and reduced the need for intensive

planting. Soil conditions were generally dry and sandy to silty, with low organic matter. Because some areas are close to the Babuyan River, riparian conditions also need to be considered when selecting species for enrichment planting. What this meant for restoring damaged forests in PPSRNP The RCP results indicated that ANR should be the main restoration approach rather than large-scale activating tree planting. The priority was to protect existing regenerants and reduce pressures that could prevent their survival. In areas dominated by pioneer or invasive species, additional interventions were recommended, including selective thinning, invasive-species control, and enrichment planting with native secondary and late-successional species. The intensity of intervention differed by site. Around 150 seedlings/ha were recommended near the SMM plots, compared with approximately 450 seedlings/ha near the MWA plots. In the SPKM plots, the priority was to maintain and protect existing regeneration rather than introduce substantial additional planting. Across the restoration area, complementary measures included protection of remaining forest patches, regular patrols and threat monitoring, invasive-species management, and firebreak establishment near adjacent kaingin areas.

Field photos of POs in Marufinas during RCP establishment and boundary delineation.


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 163

Box 13: Application of Restoration Catalyst Plots in Marufinas, Palawan (cont.)

Figure x. Proposed green recovery site of POs in Marufinas with the location of RCPs established.

Developing an Ecosystem Restoration and Resilience Plan The restoration strategies identified through Stage 3 are consolidated into an Ecosystem Restoration and Resilience Plan (ERRP). The ERRP translates assessment findings and restoration priorities into a coordinated, time-bound plan for ecosystem recovery and longterm resilience. It draws on pilot study results, including community consultations and Restoration Catalyst Plot assessments, to develop strategies suited to local ecological and social conditions. Planning workshops may be conducted to agree on restoration objectives, priority areas, activities, indicators, timelines, responsibilities, and monitoring arrangements. The coordinating body reviews the results of GARF Stages 1 and 2, assigns responsibilities based on institutional mandates and technical capacity, and identifies additional partners that can contribute expertise, resources, financing, monitoring support, or community engagement.


164 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES The planning process should also provide meaningful opportunities for women, Indigenous Peoples, persons with disabilities, and other underrepresented groups to participate in restoration activities, training, employment, monitoring, and leadership. Participation should be based on knowledge, interests, and capacities rather than gender or social stereotypes. Where appropriate, gender-responsive budgeting can help ensure that resources and opportunities are distributed equitably. Safeguarding measures should be integrated into activities involving paid labor, access to project resources, and participation in restoration programs. These measures help reduce risks of exploitation, harassment, abuse, and other forms of harm during implementation.

Box 14: Green Recovery Planning in Palawan In Palawan, a Technical Working Group (TWG) was formed to implement GARF Stage 3. It brought together representatives from the Puerto Princesa Subterranean River National Park, Cleopatra's Needle Critical Habitat, San Vicente, and Roxas. Using the results of GARF Stages 1 and 2 and restoration strategies identified through the Restoration Catalyst Framework, Green Recovery Plans were developed for each landscape. Each plan defined a shared direction for recovering typhoon-affected ecosystems while accounting for the ecological conditions, management arrangements, and community priorities of each landscape. GRP targets are expressed in hectares allocated to Protection, Spontaneous Natural Regeneration (SNR), Assisted Natural Regeneration (ANR), ANR with enrichment planting, and locally appropriate strategies. Maps identified proposed

intervention areas, while annual targets and implementation schedules provided a basis for sequencing activities over a five- to ten-year period. The plans also included logical frameworks linking activities, expected outputs, responsible institutions, indicators, resource requirements, means of verification, and external factors that could affect implementation. These elements provided a practical basis for coordination, resource mobilization, and monitoring. The four Palawan GRPs demonstrate how GARF translates disaster impact assessments into coordinated ecosystem recovery and resilience planning. Ultimately, these plans help ensure that post-disaster restoration goes beyond repairing immediate damage and contributes to healthier ecosystems, more resilient communities, and better-prepared landscapes for future hazards.

Green recovery planning workshops in Palawan


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

Box 14: Green Recovery Planning in Palawan (cont.)

| 165


166 | PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES

Box 14: Green Recovery Planning in Palawan (cont.)


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover: The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF)

| 167

Costing and Financing Restoration Ecological restoration requires sustained investment beyond the initial establishment of restoration sites. Activities such as protection, site preparation, planting, maintenance, community engagement, and monitoring each carry specific resource requirements. Understanding these costs helps ensure that restoration priorities are feasible and can be sustained over time. Stage 3 uses activity-based costing to translate restoration strategies into realistic financial requirements.Activities identified in the plan are translated into requirements for labor, planting materials, transportation, equipment, maintenance, monitoring, and other implementation needs. Costs will vary according to site condition and intervention intensity. Areas suitable for natural regeneration may require little or no planting but may still require protection, invasive-species control, patrols, monitoring, or other management inputs. Costing should also be used to identify potential financing gaps and opportunities to integrate restoration priorities into existing programs, management plans, institutional budgets, and other financing mechanisms.

sample worksheet for costing

Technical Box In Palawan, Green Recovery Planning helped secure several institutional commitments to support post-Typhoon Odette restoration. On August 27, 2023, the Protected Area Management Board of Puerto Princesa Subterranean River National Park (PPSRNP) adopted Resolution No. 046-2023, approving an annual allocation of ₱15 million for the park's Green Recovery Plan. This commitment was complemented by Puerto Princesa City's General Appropriation Ordinance No. 1-2023, adopted on December 11, 2023, authorizing the city's General Fund Budget for fiscal year 2024. Institutional support also extended to other restoration landscapes. On February 6, 2024, Sangguniang Panlungsod Resolution No. 1022-2024 expressed support for postOdette Green Recovery efforts in PPSRNP and Cleopatra's Needle Critical Habitat. The municipalities of Roxas and San Vicente also adopted their respective Green Recovery Plans through Sangguniang Bayan Resolution No. 1060-2024 and Resolution No. 2024-032. Together, these measures demonstrate how restoration planning can translate into formal government recognition, financial commitments, and coordinated support across different levels of government. Peopleʼs organizations led by women or Indigenous communities were also given the opportunity to lead their own restoration efforts and apply grants in various institutions. Some of the organizations assisted by the TWG include the Samahan ng mga Katutubong Tagbanwa sa Itaytay, Port Barton (SAKATIPBA), Samahan ng Magsasaka sa Marufinas (SMM), Magayen It Buenavista Multi-purpose Cooperative (MIBMC), Marufinas Women's Association (MWA), Samahang Pangkabuhayan ng Kababaihan sa Marufinas (SPKM), Nagkakaisang Samahan ng Isla Filomina Diving Site (NSIFDS), and Caruray Agricultural Marketing Association Inc. (CAMA).


168

PART 3: GARF METHODS, TOOLS AND ANALYTICAL APPROACHES

Monitoring Recovery and Strengthening Resilience Ecological restoration is a long-term process whose success goes beyond the number of hectares restored or seedlings planted. It depends on whether ecosystems are recovering their biodiversity, ecological structure and functions, and capacity to withstand future disturbances. Because ecological recovery varies across sites and develops over many years, its progress must be assessed through consistent monitoring of both ecosystem conditions and the effectiveness of restoration interventions. Monitoring and evaluation (M&E) are essential to the implementation of the ERRP or GRP. Monitoring tracks restoration progress, species recruitment, and changes in site conditions, while helping identify problems early so that corrective actions can be taken. Evaluation determines whether activities are being implemented as planned and achieving their intended ecological outcomes. Together, these processes promote transparency, accountability, and informed decision-making. Monitoring should continue throughout implementation, with periodic evaluations to assess whether restoration approaches remain appropriate as ecological conditions change. At the end of the five-year planning period, a comprehensive evaluation can assess ecosystem recovery, identify remaining constraints, and inform the next phase of restoration. Areas with strong natural regeneration may need continued protection, while sites with poor recruitment, low seedling survival, or persistent disturbances may require adjusted or more intensive interventions. M&E therefore supports adaptive management by ensuring that restoration strategies, resource allocation, and management priorities respond to actual site conditions and recovery trends. Continued participation by local communities, Indigenous Peoples, and responsible institutions further strengthens monitoring and helps sustain stewardship beyond the initial planning period.

Kawasan Falls, Cebu, Philippines © Oneinchpunch via Canva


First to Shield, First to Fall, and Last to Recover The Green Assessment and Recovery Framework (GARF): Assessing Biodiversity & Ecosystem Loss and Damage and Planning for Ecosystem Recovery and Resilience


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook