Carboniferous Giants and Mass Extinction, by George R. McGhee Jr. (preface)

Carboniferous Giants and Mass Extinction THE LATE PALEOZOIC ICE AGE WORLD

George R. McGhee Jr.

Preface

I

magine living in a world in which a dragonfly-like insect with a wingspan similar to that of a seagull zooms past your head; multilegged millipedes as long as a small car and as wide as a truck tire are crawling along on the ground; venomous scorpions, stingers held curved over their backs, are as long as mid-sized dogs; and salamander-like animals are neither cute nor tiny—they are as long as alligators and have mouths full of sharp-pointed, deadly teeth.

Imagine living in a world with huge expanses of land covered by tropical rainforests, a green band that stretches around the middle of the planet across all of the continents. Rainforests in which you discover, when you go hiking through them, very strange-looking trees: from a distance they look as though they have no leaves, even though the upper part of the trunk and the drooping branches of the tree are green. On closer examination, through a pair of field glasses, you can see that the tops of these trees do have leaves, but they are peculiar small bladelike leaves that partially overlap each other and wrap spirally around the branches and upper trunks. The tops of the trees thus have a somewhat fuzzy look, as though they were wearing green sweatshirts of leaves with multiple sleeves-of-leaves extending out along all of their branches. These peculiar sleeves-of-leaves look somewhat like those we

x | Preface

see in our club mosses, but our little club mosses stand only 12 to 13 centimeters (five inches) high and these strange trees are gigantic, towering 50 meters (164 feet) into the sky.

Imagine living in a world in which a giant continent sits over the South Pole, a continent over five times larger than Antarctica—over twice the size of Africa, our largest single free-standing landmass surrounded by water—that is covered with vast rivers of ice sheets stretching away from a huge, white, glacial polar cap.

That world is not imaginary; it is the Earth—not our modern Earth, obviously, but rather the Earth as it existed in the Carboniferous Period of the Paleozoic world, over 300 million years ago. All of the things described here actually existed on that Earth—the giant animals, the giant trees, the giant continent, the giant glacial ice cap. There were giants in the Earth in those days.

This book is about that ancient Earth: how it came to be, and how it ended.

We will examine the various hypotheses as to how animals, insects in particular, could have become so gigantic. We will examine the evolution of the great tropical rainforests that at first glance appear similar to those of our modern Earth, but that turn out to have been very different. The legacy of those great rainforests can be found around the world today in the massive deposits of coal that are found in Carboniferous strata—the huge volume of organic carbon that give the geologic period Carboniferous its name. Those coal deposits have been one of our major sources of energy since the beginning of the industrial era, and the burning of those coal deposits is releasing 300-million-year-old carbon dioxide back into our atmosphere and heating up the planet. The ancient Carboniferous Earth is transforming the modern Earth.

The Paleozoic world was totally destroyed in the end-Permian mass extinction, the greatest biodiversity crisis to occur since the evolution of animal life on Earth. The great ice caps of the Late Paleozoic Ice Age melted, the Earth began to warm, and the most catastrophic volcanic eruptions in Earth history began to inject trillions of tons of greenhouse gases into the Earth’s atmosphere. The resultant “Hot Earth” lasted for five million years, an apocalyptic world in which the tropics were lethally hot—a world in which vertebrate land animals could only survive in cooler latitudes higher than 30° in the Northern Hemisphere and higher than 40° in the Southern Hemisphere. In stark contrast to our modern world—where the equatorial tropics harbor the highest diversity of life on the planet—the equatorial region of that Hot Earth was almost totally barren.

Preface | xi

Even in the oceans, the equatorial temperatures were so high that fish and other vertebrate animals could only exist in the cooler waters of the high latitudes of the Earth. How could this have happened to the Earth? In this book we will examine in detail the triggers of the end-Permian mass extinction, and the nightmarish world that resulted.

This book is a summary of over four decades of my research into the ecological consequences of the Late Paleozoic extinctions, and I thank Columbia University Press, publishers of my previous books The Late Devonian Mass Extinction (1996) and When the Invasion of Land Failed: The Legacy of the Devonian Extinctions (2013), for making this third volume possible. I thank three anonymous reviewers of the manuscript for comments and suggestions that have helped me to improve the final book. And last, I thank my wife, Marae, for her patient love.

—H E R M A N N

P F E F F E R K O R N , University of Pennsylvania

“Carboniferous Giants and Mass Extinction is comprehensive and well researched and provides fascinating insights into the complex Carboniferous world. It has amazing presentation, including depth, perception, and interpretation, and the writing style is readable and captivating. This work will be a valuable reference for geology students and others interested in past earth climates.”

—P E T E R

E. I S A A C S O N , University of Idaho

George R. McGhee Jr. is Distinguished Professor of Paleobiology at Rutgers University and a Member of the Konrad Lorenz Institute for Evolution and Cognition Research in Klosterneuburg, Austria. He has held research positions at the University of Tübingen, the Field Museum of Natural History, and the American Museum of Natural History. His books include When the Invasion of Land Failed: The Legacy of the Devonian Extinctions (Columbia, 2013).

Printed in the U.S.A.

Columbia University Press/New York cup.columbia.edu

ISBN: 978-0-231-18097-9

Columbia

Cover design: Lisa Hamm Cover image: © Richard Bizley / Science Source

Carboniferous Giants and Mass Extinction

“Carboniferous Giants and Mass Extinction is a superb and unique synthesis of the current knowledge of processes and conditions during the Late Paleozoic, incorporating the results from all subdisciplines of the earth and life sciences.

McGhee demonstrates his expertise and knowledge in all the subdisciplines in a magnificent way. The book is a pleasure to read and at the same time erudite.”

McGhee Jr.

More than 300 million years ago

, in the Carboniferous period of the Paleozoic era, dog-sized scorpions and millipedes as long as a car walked the earth, and tropical rainforests towered into the sky. In Carboniferous Giants and Mass Extinction, George R. McGhee Jr. explores this ancient world, explaining its origins, its downfall in the end-Permian mass extinction, and how its legacies still affect us today. He offers a comprehensive portrait of the effects of prehistoric climate change on global ecology and the forces that brought this world to an abrupt and violent end. Synthesizing decades of research and new discoveries, this comprehensive book provides a wealth of insights into past and present extinction events and climate change.

Carboniferous Giants and Mass Extinction THE LATE PALEOZOIC ICE AGE WORLD

George R. McGhee Jr.