Colorado Starbucks baristas testify in federal trial

Case largest workers’ action alleging union busting

BY MATT BLOOM COLORADO PUBLIC RADIO

Starbucks broke the law when it discouraged union support at four of its stores in Colorado, a federal prosecutor said during opening arguments in the co ee company’s latest labor rights trial this month.

Store managers dissuaded workers from voting in favor of unionization during all-sta meetings, and punished pro-union baristas through write-ups and wrongful terminations, said Isabel Saveland, a National Labor Relations Board attorney representing workers from Denver and Colorado Springs.

“Starbucks’ unlawful tactics go against unionization and our country’s laws,” said Saveland during her opening arguments in federal court in Denver.

e case is the largest legal action workers have taken against the company’s alleged union busting in the wake of a wave of organizing at Starbucks locations in the state last year. Last month, a federal judge ruled in favor of workers at another union store in Denver.

More than 270 of the co ee giant’s locations across the United States have unionized since December 2021. e location in Superior joined Starbucks Workers United last April, followed by locations in Denver,

Colorado Springs and Greeley. e latest trial involves charges from two stores from Denver: 16th Avenue and Tremont Pl. and Leetsdale Dr., as well as two stores in Colorado Springs: Academy Blvd. and Flintridge Dr. and Brookside St. and Nevada Ave., which the company has since shuttered.

Attorneys representing Starbucks called the latest set of allegations overblown and defended the company’s actions.

“What we’re looking at is a bunch of green employees who don’t like playing by the rules,” said Kevin Kraham, an attorney with Littler Men- delson, during opening remarks. “ e real world has consequences and people are held accountable.” e case includes six unfair labor practice charges in total, along with three wrongful termination complaints. An administrative law judge combined the proceedings into one trial earlier this year due to their similarities.

In the wrongful ring charges, the NLRB claims Starbucks let union workers go for minor policy violations. In one case, a worker at the company’s 16th and Tremont store accidentally left $40 in a lockbox unsecured overnight.

On his nal warning, a manager included a past tardy he had never been written up for.

“ e employee was upset and told his managers it was all about retaliation for his union support,” said Saveland. “ e store said no, it wasn’t.”

In another case, a Colorado Springs shift supervisor was red for cursing at a teenage subordinate. Another employee at the Leetsdale Starbucks was red after touching a cake pop by hand and serving it to a customer after it brie y dropped onto a sanitized counter.

Managers coached the employee on what to say in a written statement about the incident and then later used it against her during her termination, Saveland said.

Starbucks attorneys said the rings were justi ed.

“A ve-second rule doesn’t apply at Starbucks,” Kraham said. “Just because employees support unionization doesn’t mean that they get to break the rules.” e company’s attorneys pushed back against allegations of unfair labor practices.

Workers allege the company unfairly enforced workplace policies against union supporters, which would be a violation of federal law.

In one case, a union supporter was told to remove a Starbucks Workers United shirt they wore to work. Managers also took down a union brochure that workers posted on a break room bulletin board.

“It’s not a billboard for anybody to come in and put up what they wish,” Kraham said. “And in all of these incidents workers were not held accountable in the slightest.” e trial is expected to last through March 17 and include testimony from workers and store managers involved in some of the incidents. On March 13, the NLRB presented its rst witness, Bradley Kurtz, a barista at the Starbucks on Academy and Flintridge in Colorado Springs.

Saveland played a 90-minute recording that Kurtz took during a captive audience meeting the store manager held ahead of the store’s union election. In it, managers are heard discussing the changes that come along with forming a union. Managers in the tape said electing a union would potentially have a negative impact on employee bene ts.

Shortly before the captive audience meeting, Kurtz, a union organizer, had explained to a store manager that workers would be organizing and asked if the manager wanted to take part in a press conference he was planning to announce the vote.

“I wanted this to be a bipartisan e ort,” Kurtz testi ed.

“What did he say?” Saveland asked.

“He had some phone calls he needed to make,” Kurtz said. “And then I think he gave me a hug.”

Thu 3/30

Trevor Noah

@ 8pm Bellco Theatre, 1100 Stout Street, Denver

Denver Nuggets vs. New Orleans

Pelicans

@ 8pm / $29-$3970

Ball Arena, 1000 Chopper Circle, Denver

Fri 3/31

Standley Lake Bird Walk

@ 7am

Standley Lake Regional Park, 8600 Simms Street, Westminster. prl@ cityofwestminster.us, 303-6582794

Mon 4/03

World Party Day @ 5pm Eagle Pointe Recreation Center, 6060 E. Parkway Dr., Commerce City. 303-2893760

Who Loves April?

@ 7pm

Apr 3rd - Apr 24th

Bison Ridge Recreation Center, 13905 E. 112th Avenue, Commerce City. 303-2893760

The Well @ 7pm HQ, 60 S Broadway, Denver

True Crime and Teatime @ 5pm

Anythink Huron Street, 9417 Huron Street, Thornton. swhitelonis@any thinklibraries.org, 303-452-7534

Wed 4/05

Hot Buttered Rum @ 6pm eTown Hall, 1535 Spruce St, Boulder

Clay Creations @ 11:30pm

Apr 5th - Apr 26th

Eagle Pointe Recreation Center, 6060 E. Parkway Dr., Commerce City. 303-2893760

John Mayer - Solo @ 7:30pm / $49.50-$199.50

Ball Arena, 1000 Chopper Circle, Denver

Colorado Mammoth vs. Las Vegas Desert Dogs @ 7pm / $20-$999

Ball Arena, 1000 Chopper Circle, Denver

Dive Bards @ 7pm

Trailside Saloon, 10360 Colorado Blvd, Thornton

Colorado Avalanche vs. Dallas Stars @ 7pm / $79-$999

Ball Arena, 1000 Chopper Circle, Denver

Colorado Rapids vs. Los Angeles

Football Club @ 7:30pm / $25-$999

DICK'S Sporting Goods Park, 6000 Victory Way, Commerce City

Sun 4/02

80's Prom 21+ @ 1am

Apr 2nd - Apr 1st

Severo Y Grupo Fuego

@ 8pm

American Legion, 5421 E 71st Ave, Commerce City

Phat Daddy @ 9pm

Hoffbrau, 9110 Wadsworth Pkwy, West‐minster

Red Sweater and Volunteer Social at Eagle Pointe

@ 10:30pm

Eagle Pointe Recreation Center, 6060 E. Parkway Dr., Commerce City. 303-2893760

Sat 4/01

Easter Eggstravaganza

@ 4pm Eagle Pointe Recreation Center, 6060 E. Parkway Dr., Commerce City. 303-2893760

Bison Ridge Recreation Center, 13905 E. 112th Avenue, Commerce City. 303-2893760

Rose's Pawn Shop: Larimer Lounge @ 7:30pm Larimer Lounge, 2721 Larimer St, Denver

Joy Oladokun @ 7:30pm

Ball Arena, 1000 Chopper Cir, Denver Club Level Seating: John Mayer @ 7:30pm / $199.50

Ball Arena, 1000 Chopper Circle, Denver

April Showers @ 8pm

Apr 3rd - Apr 24th

Bison Ridge Recreation Center, 13905 E. 112th Avenue, Commerce City. 303-2893760

Archery @ 10:30pm

Apr 3rd - Apr 5th

Eagle Pointe Recreation Center, 6060 East Parkway Dr., Commerce City. 303-2893760

Tue 4/04

Boot camp April 2023 @ 12am

Apr 4th - Apr 26th

Fort Lupton Recreation & Parks De‐partment, 203 S Harrison, Fort Lupton. 303-857-4200

Gambling Trip-"The Century Casino"(4/4) @ 3pm

Eagle Pointe Recreation Center, 6060 E. Parkway Dr., Commerce City. 303-2893760

Denver Nuggets vs. Golden State Warriors @ 6:30pm / $74-$6705

Ball Arena, 1000 Chopper Circle, Denver

Mad Science @ 4pm

Apr 4th - Apr 25th

Eagle Pointe Recreation Center, 6060 E. Parkway Dr., Commerce City. 303-2893760

Thu 4/06

Family Makerspace @ 12am

Apr 6th - Apr 5th

Eagle Pointe Recreation Center, 6060 E. Parkway Dr., Commerce City. 303-2893760

Nutrition Wednesdays @ 1:15am

Apr 6th - Apr 26th

Fort Lupton Recreation & Parks De‐partment, 203 S Harrison, Fort Lupton. 303-857-4200

Job and Career Fair @ 12:30pm Fort Lupton High School, 530 Reynolds Street, Fort Lupton. jhowell@weld8.org, 303-547-7725

Colorado Rockies vs. Washington Nationals @ 2:10pm / $50-$350

Coors Field, 2001 Blake St., Den‐ver