Eviction bill could help residents if lease expires

Five states have similar laws

BY ANDREW KENNEY COLORADO PUBLIC RADIO

A bill advancing through the Colorado legislature would make it easier for renters to stay in their homes even after their lease expires, and it also would give them other protections against eviction.

Currently, when a lease ends the landlord can decide whether the tenant gets to stay. For example, they could simply refuse to o er a renewal of the current lease — forcing the tenant to leave or be evicted. at system makes it too easy for landlords to get rid of renters, even if the renters have done nothing wrong, said Rep. Javier Mabrey, a Democratic sponsor of the bill, H.B. 23-1171.

‘’When their leases are up, the landlord refuses to o er a new lease,” Mabrey said at a committee hearing on Wednesday. “We’re trying to prevent that kind of retaliation.” e bill passed the House Transportation, Housing & Local Government committee on a party-line vote on March 1. e proposal would allow landlords to make a “reasonable” rent increase when they renew the lease. But Mabrey said that was not meant to act as a form of rent control. (He is running another bill on that topic.)

Under the new proposal, some of the power would shift to the tenant. In many cases, landlords would essentially be required to o er a renewal of the lease in “substantially identical” terms. If they fail to do so, renters could keep paying rent under the terms of the previous lease — and they would be protected from eviction.

Opponents of the bill, including real-estate interests and smaller landlords, warned it would place an undue burden on landlords. ey also said it could lead some to leave the market or raise rents.

“We’re just trying to prevent retaliatory rent increases,” Mabrey said.

At the hearing, renters and their advocates described cases where landlords refused to renew leases for retaliatory or discriminatory reasons, such as because of a renter’s immigration status or because the renter had asked for repairs. Others talked about being forced out of their homes as the landlord pursued higher rents.

“ is goes back to the prevention of homelessness and making sure that we keep people in their homes,” said Rep. Serena GonzalesGuttierez, a Democratic cosponsor of the bill. Sen. Julie Gonzales also is sponsoring the bill.

Drew Hamrick, a representative of the Colorado Apartment Association, argued that renters already have protections against certain non-renewals. State and federal law already forbid landlords from refusing to renew for a variety of reasons, including as retaliation for making maintenance requests or as an act of discrimination against protected classes, he said. e bill would still allow landlords to evict people who commit “substantial” violations of the lease, including failure to pay or refusing to let a landlord into the property.

Mabrey, the sponsor, argued that those laws are hard to enforce because it’s often impossible to prove why a landlord has refused to renew a lease. A broader law will protect more people’s rights, he said.

“It is incredibly hard, incredibly hard to prove discrimination in court … especially for a pro se tenant who doesn’t have an attorney,” he said.

Hamrick said landlords need to be able to end a rental relationship. It’s often the best way to deal with issues where a renter is misbehaving but the landlord can’t prove it, he said.

“Just hold your noses, let it go for another three months, and (don’t) renew the lease,” he said of the current approach, which he favors.

In other situations, though, landlords would have to pay to get rid of renters.

For example, if a property owner wanted to demolish, renovate or redevelop their home, they would have to provide “relocation assistance” to the renter, paying the renter the equivalent of at least two months’ rent. e same would apply when owners want to live in the property themselves.

In those situations, the landlord would have to give up to 120 days’ notice, which advocates argued would help tenants nd a new place.

One witness, eviction defense attorney Spencer Bailey, described the case of an 87-year-old man he represented, for whom he used a pseudonym. e bill “would give people like Mr. Jones substantially more time to nd somewhere to live,” Bailey said. e bill’s next step is the House oor, where it would need to win a majority of the chamber. It also would require approval by the Senate before it heads to Gov. Jared Polis. is story is from CPR News, a nonpro t news source. Used by permission. For more, and to support Colorado Public Radio, visit cpr.org.

“He had always paid his rent on time. Mr. Jones had never broken any rules, never had any complaints. He was given only three weeks to move out after living in a place for almost two decades, and he had nowhere to go,” Bailey said, adding that the man had been on a monthto month lease.

Carla Friedli, who leases out a home she owns in Longmont, said that relocation fees would disrupt her retirement plans.

“I really might be forced to sell this home or change the terms of my lease now to account for two months, plus an additional month of relocation fees,” said Friedli, who described herself as an educator and mental health worker.

Five other states have a similar “just cause” or “good cause” eviction law, including New Jersey, California, New Hampshire, Oregon, Washington, according to the National Low Income Housing Coalition. ough those states’ laws have di erent details.

Thu 3/16

Teague Starbuck @ 5pm The Pint Room, 2620 W Belleview Ave, Lit‐tleton

Mon 3/20

Crestone Peak Ages 13-14 - 2023

League Session #2 @ 3:30pm / $300

Mar 20th - Apr 29th

Elevation Volleyball Club, 12987 E Adam Aircraft Drive, Englewood. 720-524-4136

Torreys Peak Ages 8-11 - 2023

League Session #2 @ 3:30pm / $300

Mar 20th - Apr 29th

Elevation Volleyball Club, 12987 E Adam Aircraft Drive, Englewood. 720-524-4136

Modern Swing Mondays @ 5pm / $10

Stampede, 2430 South Havana, Aurora

The Reverend Peyton's Big Damn Band @ 7pm Swallow Hill, 71 E Yale Ave, Den‐ver

Fri 3/17

Vagabon @ 7pm Gothic Theatre, 3263 S Broadway, Englewood

Vamonos Pest/Mobro: Mobro at Brewability Lab @ 5pm Brewability Lab, 3445 S Broadway, Englewood

Tue 3/21

Zoology Comparative Anatomy Dissections @ 7am / $75

Mar 21st - Mar 23rd

Valor Christian High School - Academic Building, 3775 Grace Blvd., Highlands Ranch. 303-471-3000

The Greatest Game Ever Played (AM Session) @ 8am / Free

Mar 21st - Mar 22nd

Valor Athletic Building, 3775 Grace Blvd, Highlands Ranch. 303-471-3000

Black Market Translation @ 6pm D3 Arts, 3614 Morrison Rd, Denver

Weyes Blood @ 7pm Gothic Theatre, 3263 S Broadway, Englewood

Sat 3/18

Justin Willman: Pace Center @ 3pm Pace Center, Pikes Peak Avenue, Parker

Dear Marsha,: St Paddy's with DM and her Freaky Band @ 7pm Toley’s on the Creek, 16728 E Smoky Hill Rd Suite 11C, Centen‐nial

5th Annual ฀ShamROCK

Stampede for PTSD ฀ @ 9am / Free-$35 500 Fairgrounds Road, Castle Rock

6 Million Dollar Band @ 6pm Pindustry, 7939 E Arapahoe Rd, Centen‐nial

Jay_Martin @ 6:30pm Rocker Spirits, 5587 S Hill St, Littleton

Jill Tasei: Comedy Show @ 5:30pm BS Comedy Club, 207 E Wolfens‐berger Rd, Castle Rock

Tei Shi @ 7pm Gothic Theatre, 3263 S Broadway, Engle‐wood

EL FANTASMA - GERARDO DIAZ @ 7:30pm / $70

Stampede, 2430 South Havana, Aurora

Sun 3/19

The Church @ 7pm

Gothic Theatre, 3263 S Broadway, Englewood

Wed 3/22

Ladies Night @ 5pm / $10

Stampede, 2430 South Havana, Aurora

Rayland Baxter @ 6pm Gothic Theatre, 3263 S Broadway, Engle‐wood

DJ Rockstar Aaron: Forbidden Bingo at 'Bout Time Pub & Grub @ 7pm Bout Time Pub & Grub, 3580 S Platte River Dr A, Sheridan

Charles Ellsworth @ Englewood Tavern @ 6pm

The Englewood Tavern, 4386 S Broadway, Englewood

Thu 3/23

Pinback @ 7pm Gothic Theatre, 3263 S Broadway, Engle‐wood