1 e 20ll Siz Fu
ollision C
e VD nsid ID rI CS ste C- Po AR sh 0 C ra
2010 Vol. 5 Iss.2
&
C
The International Compendium for Crash Research
Volume 5 Issue 2
Volume 5, Issue 2 - Fall 2010
Time Development of Delta-V & PDOF
during a collision
Crash Data Collection Guide for GM Airbag Electronic Control Units
Beyond the Drag Factor Accident Reconstruction Testing
Speedometers
Post-Collision Readings & Vehicle Impact Speeds
Filament Analysis of Light Bulbs
!
Collision: The International Compendium for Crash Research
Fall 2010
www.collisionpublishing.com
If you found this article useful, look into a subscription to Collision Magazine at www.CollisionMagazine.com
Find out more about the next EDR User’s Summit at EDRSummit.com
Contents features 10
Fall 2010
Model For Analyzing Single Vehicle Rollover Accidents By Juan M. Herrera And Anselmo Najera G.
22
Devices For Accident Reconstruction Testing Beyond The Drag Factor By Brad Muir And Jon Northrup
32
Post-Collision Speedometer Readings And Vehicle Impact Speeds By Robert D. Anderson
42
Determining A “Best Effort” Heavy Truck Acceleration Rate Based On Time, Weight & Distance
The cover shot was taken at the 2010 ARC-CSI Crash Conference by Sam Morris, Las Vegas Sun. This image is used with permission from Library Services Specialist, Las Vegas Sun, Greenspun Newsroom. Cover layout and design by Scott Baker, Collision Publishing, LLC. © 2010 Collision Publishing, LLC. All rights reserved.
By David A. Stopper, Phillip D. Darnell And Christopher C. Voeglie
48
Light Bulb Filament Analysis From The 2010 ARC-CSI Crash Conference By Christopher J. Brignola
58
Crash Data Collection Guide For GM Airbag Electronic Control Units By Donald Floyd
76
10
Time Development Of Delta-V Recording And PDOF During A Collision By Bruno Schmidt
86
Vehicle Navigation GPS Units Could Be The Overlooked EDR By Timothy J. Reust
92
The Butterfly Effect Of Crash Investigations By Robert Miller
98
58
EDRs And Restraint Systems By Bill Davies
102
86
Reading Data From International Medium And Heavy Duty Truck Electronic Control Modules By Dustin Nolen and Gary Johnson
108
Cone Of Departure: A Good Idea, But Not A Law By Wade Bartlett and Bruno Schmidt
www.collisionpublishing.com
Collision Magazine 3
32
Collision Magazine
www.collisionpublishing.com
Post-Collision
Speedometer Readings and Vehicle Impact Speeds Robert D. Anderson, M.S. Biomechanics Analysis
A
bstract The appropriateness of using or representing the residual post-collision speedometer reading as an indicator of that vehicle’s speed at impact is addressed by a review of the history of crash evidence involving speedometers, crash test results, exemplar instrument clusters and case studies in which the post-collision speedometer readings are compared to those obtained by traditional accident reconstruction techniques, including speeds downloaded from event data recorders. It is concluded that a non-zero post-collision speedometer reading may or may not coincide with that vehicle’s approximate speed at impact. In a review of case studies, it was found more times than not that the residual speedometer reading was found to not represent that vehicle’s speed at impact. This coincides with the observation that the readings of most unpowered exemplar instrument clusters could be easily altered with vibration or even changes in orientation, as could occur during post-impact travel of the vehicle or during post collision handling of the vehicle, such as towing. There appears to be a subset of vehicles that are equipped with instruments whose indicator needles demonstrate an increased resistance to movement combined with a lower susceptibility to needle motion during changes in orientation, vibration and shock.
In general, the practice of including post-collision speedometer readings into a reconstruction as evidence of that vehicle’s speed at impact is strongly cautioned against. Although under certain circumstancwww.collisionpublishing.com
es such as a sudden power loss during the collision in a vehicle equipped with the type of speedometer with increased resistance to needle motion, it stands to reason that there is a propensity for the post-collision reading to reflect the speedometer reading at impact. Under such circumstances it is recommended that the speedometer type be verified by acquiring an exemplar instrument cluster, conducting stand tests, or a full system demonstration. If the behavior of the speedometer can be confirmed then the residual speedometer reading can be cautiously used as corroborative evidence in a situationally complete reconstruction.
I
ntroduction Speedometers have been standard equipment in automobiles for about a hundred years. Mechanical speedometers were common until the 1980’s when electronic speedometers became popular.1 Mechanical speedometers typically involve a small rotating magnet on the end of a spinning cable that is attached the output shaft of the drive line or a wheel. The magnet interacts with a cup that is attached to the base of the needle, which is held toward zero using a spring. As the cable rotates, eddy currents are induced in the cup which produces a magnetic field that interacts with the spinning magnet to produce a drag on the cup, which displaces the needle in the direction of the cable’s rotation. The faster the cable rotates, the drag increases and the needle is displacement increases. The needle displacement can then be calibrated against known speeds. For mechanical speedometers, the post-collision speedometer reading may or may not indicate the vehicle’s impact speed.2,3,4,5,6,7 The reading is typically at or near zero2,6 especially with heavy pre-impact braking.3,4 The needle can “jump” or be “flicked” to an erroneously high reading during impact.3,6 The nature of the damage to the vehicle and/or speedometer may indicate whether or not the speedometer reading is valid.2,4 Occasionally, speedometer assemblies are examined under UV light or removed for examination in a Collision Magazine 33