Skip to main content

Church Panel on Copper Mining in Puerto Rico (1971)

Page 1

........


CHURCH PANEL ON COPPER MINING IN PUERTO RICO Coleg io de Abogados San Jua n, Puer t o Ri co - January 2 1 · 22, 19 71

RECOMMENDATIONS FINDINGS BACKGROUND SUMMARY OF TESTIMONY APPENDIX


Photography by Toge Fujihira, United Methodist Board of Missions

The Church Panel on Copper Mining in Puerto Rico extends its sincere appreciation to the Colegio de Abogados for its assistance in carrying out the hearings in San Juan, Puerto Rico .

Copyright, 1971 , by NIM


RECOMMENOATIONS THE CHURCH PANEL ON COPPER MINING IN PUERTO R 1c o RE c o MM EN os T HA T AME R 1CAN METAL CLIMAX , INC ., ANO KENNECOTT COPPER CORPORATION POSTPOSE MINING IN THE ISLANO OF PUERTO RICO BECAUSE OF THE OANGER SUCH MINING WILL BE TO THE HEALTH ANO WELL -BEING OF THE PEOPLE OF PUERTO RICO, ANO FURTHER RECOMMENOS THAT : ( 1)

Th e co m pa n ies d isc lose t o t he pu b li c th eir comp let e cur re nt and

f uture p ro p osa ls t o th e Gover nment w hi c h are n o t protected far propr ieta ry and co m pe t i ti ve reaso n s. Spec ifi ca ll y, full d isc losu1·e o f th ose sec ti o ns, t oge th er w ith sup po rti ng d at a, w hich in vo lve eco n omi c, soc ial, and eco logi ca l issues is im porta nt in th at th ey invo lve th e p ro t ec ti o n o f th e pu bli c and th e pub li c inte1·est. (2)

Th e co mp an ies be ava il ab le far an d pa1·tic ipate in th e pub li c

h ear in gs t o be held by th e gove rn ment o f Pu erto Ri co . (Sr. Pedro A . Ge labe1· t , Exec u t ive Secre t ary of t h e Mini n g Co m m iss ion, an nounced at th e h ea r i ng in Sa n Ju an o n Thursday, Jan u ary 2 1, 197 1, t h at t h e Governm ent woul d h o ld pub l ic h ear in gs com m en cing th e latt e1· part o f Feb ru ary, 197 1. )


(3) The companies be conscious of the social imp act of the proposed mining of copper in Puerto Rico and not enter into copper mining without the ex pressed, uncoerced consent of the people of Puerto Rico and particularly those in the area where the mining is projected to occur. (4) The agencies and instrumentalities of the churches in the United States represented in the Church Panel on Copper Mining in Puerto Rico prepare and support appropriate stockholder resolutions that implement the recommendations and findings of the panel. (5) The churches of the United States support those efforts of the churches in Puerto Rico to: a) support and participate in the projected public hearings by the Governm ent of Puerto Rico on copper mining ; b) encourage the Government of Puerto Rico to issue more specific guidelines befare negoti ations w ith the co m pani es (s u c h guidelines to include sp ecific meth od s for e nforcement); c) det ermin e, in th e light of the public hearings, the wi ll o f th e people of Pu erto Rico as to th e mining of cop per in Pu e rto Rico and t o support th eir positi o n . (6 ) Th e c hu rc hes of the United States e ncourage th eir co nst it u e nc ies to support th e work of o rgani zation s such as th e Con sum ers ln st it ute of the University of Pu erto Ri co , Prog ra m a d e Re novac ion y lnv est igac io n Soc ia l Para Ad iestram iento e n la Mi ssion (PRISA) , and Misio n Industr ia l de Pu erto Rico in sofa r as th ese orga ni zatio ns work to pro mote t he se lf - de te rm in at ion of th e peo p le of Pu erto Rico in su c h matters as coppe r mi ning w hi ch infl uence t heir hea lt h a nd we ll - be ing.

2


PANEL FINDINGS

ROLE OF THE CHURCH ( 1) For man y years the churches part1c1pating in the hearing have used their human and financia! resources to minister to and with the people of Puerto Rico . lt was called to our attention by sorne of our church leaders in Puerto Rico that we have investments in corporations currently developing plans for mining copper in Puerto Rico. Further, it was maintained that the proposed copper mining activities were contrary to the well being of the people of Puerto Rico by not giving adequate considerations to the social, economic, and ecological costs resulting from the proposed mining venture.

(2) As a corporate stockholder , the church has a responsibility that its investments, at best, further the human concerns of the church, or at least it should not invest in companies whose business or business practices are contrary to these concerns.

Panel members Carolyn Wilhel m and Ted Lockwood

3


Rev. Fernando Vazquez at the site of an exp loratory cut in the proposed mining area

ECOLOGY (3 )

Test imony received and eva lu ated at th e hearing suggests

th a t saf eg u a rd s and control s to en sure maintenance of appropri at e en vironmental qu ality are not ad equ at e. Whi le any min e c1¡eat es sorn e ecologi cal changes, ser ious concerns , par t icu larly about th e disposa l of mili tailings and sme lter sulfur dio x id e, requi re fu rt her eva lu ation of th e curre nt proposal. The agreem en t should reflect an over ¡ all ecologica l p lan for the area. (4) The mining and w aste di sposa l system wi ll leave large ba1¡ren areas if nothing is done to reclaim them. So far as can be det ermined there are no present plans for reclamation ot the area w hen mining is completed.

4


ECONOMIC (5) Th ere is high un employm ent and severe poverty in Puerto Rico and especially in the proposed mining are a. There is no clear evidence that the proposed mining and smelting would contribute significantly to the reduction of unemployment and poverty, eit her through direct empl oyme nt or the growth of satel lite indu str ies. (6) According to t est imony, United Stat es corporations and interests ow n in excess of seventy (70) per ce nt of the means of production in Puerto Rico . Such predominant economic power creates undue leverage on the economic life and decisions of the peop le of Pu erto Ri co. Owne rship of mines by N or t h American corporations would ad d significantly to an already d isproportionate

Un ited

States presence.

Great

co ncern was

ex pressed by witnesses th at Pu erto Ric an resources would be u sed to benefit North Americ an s. l f Pu erto Rico decides to postpone development

of

its copper

resources,

it

will

not

lose an

opportunity but merely postpone it. ( 7) Th e proposed proj ec t wi ll require significant kno w n ex penditu res and unkn own further ex penditures on t h e p art of the Commonwealth for roads and power bu il t to st andard s needed by th e mine an d in excess of those n eeded in agri culture and ligh t industry. Such ex pend itu res 1路educe th e net return to th e gove rnment from th e prnject. (8)

No ex p l icit provisions h ave bee n m ade t o ensure t h at soc ial

costs from po lluti o n, soc ial di slocation , etc., are b orn e by th e comp an y and not transfe rred to the pub lic. (9)

Th ere is no ove rall lo ng 路 t erm Pu erto Ric an d evel opme nt

p lan t o schedul e th e use of Pu erto Rico 's re sources, w ith th ose of oth er counh ies , in a co . ordin ated m anner to m eet th e h opes and aspirations of th e Pue1路to Ri ca n p eop le.

SOCIAL AND CULTURAL ( 1O) T es tim ony 1路eceived at th e 'h ea ring suggests that t ra diti o nal Americ an economi c devel o pm ent and contrnl have, on b alan ce, bee n den im ental to th e soc ial and cu ltu ral life of Puert o Rico. Th e mining ventu re as now p roposed w ould increase th e negative eff ect s o n Puerto R ican cultu re and soc iety. Specifical ly , in

5


relation to the area of the proposed mines (an area seen by many Puerto Ricans to be the heartland of their cultural and nation al identity), adverse effects could be expected from : - Forced change from an agricultura! to a mining economy - Dislocation and relocation of people with the concomm ittant disruption of communities and families. ( 11)

Moreover, because of increased economic dependency on

the United States, that would result from the proposed mining, the Puerto Rican people will have even less freedom than they now have to make decisions affecting their cultural values.

POLITICAL DEVELOPMENT (12)

The projected

political

issue in

mining of copper is a highly explosive

Puerto

Rico which

involves people across

political party lin es. Th is is evidenced by (a) the secrecy to date regarding the proposed mining project, (b) allegations of repression against so rne who have spoken against such mining, (c) the credibility gap experienced by the public - at - large on both the "pro" and "con" sides, (d) allegations of political imperia l ism, and (e) discussions of the potential for violence if the contracts are signed.

PUERTO RICAN GOVERNMENT (13) Th ere has been a "cloak of secrecy" over the proposed mining project since the ear ly 1960's. Thi s includes preliminary negotiations between the government and Kennecott and AMAX; the draft agreement submitted by the companies on December 5, 1969; and government studies, surveys and reports regarding the proposed m in ing project. Th is secrecy, coupled with attendant rumors and contrad ictory statements from the parties involved, has led to a widen ing confusion for the public. (14) lt was not until testimony presented by the government at th is heari ng on Janu ary 21, 1971, that the government revealed it wou ld schedu le public hearings, beginning the last week of February, on the proposed mining project. Th e Government also said it would prepare and issue detailed guidelines prior to resuming official negotiations with the companies.

6


( 15) Testimony presented by the government on January 21, 1971 , also indicated that there had been no planning to date for setting up enforcement mechanisms for environmental protection in the proposed mining area . There is also evidence th at currently there are in sufficient enforcement mechanisms for protection against d anger to the environment in Puerto Rico in connection with the ra pid industriali zation.

Dr. Rafae l Ramirez, con su ltant to pane l

7


COPPER COMPANIES ( 16)

The companies, also fo ll owi ng t h e road of secrec y , have

refused not on ly to disc lose t he provis io n s of the draft agreement of December 1969, but also refu sed to participate in th e h earings of Jan uary 2 1 - 22, 197 1. Du ri n g the h earings serious all egations were made concern in g operatio ns o f eith er or both co m pa n ies in other parts of the wor ld, i nc ludi n g a number of states of t h e Un it ed States, and t heir adverse effect s in the areas of economic distribution, eco logica l responsib il ity and soc ial d islocati on.

BACKGROUND ON ECUMENICAL PANEL ON COPPER MINING IN PUERTO RICO Pu rp ose The stated purpose of the public hearings in Sa n Juan, he ld January 21 - 22, 197 1, was "to cleterm ine t h e legitimacy of postpo n in g m in in g in the isl and of Puerto Rico by the Ken necott Copper Company and t h e Ameri ca n Metal ClĂ­ma x Company due to t h e potential danger such mining migh t be to the health and we ll - being of the peop le of Puerto Rico ."

'

T he Con ce rn of t he Chu rches

N a tiona l church groups have substantia l ho ldi n gs in American corporat ions through the i r endowment and pension funds . I n recent years t hey have become increasing ly interested i n t h e re latio n sh ip between these investments and t h e m issio n program of the c hu rc h es . l ssues such as apartheid practices of so u thern Afri ca, ecology, se lf determination far third wor ld people , minority hir i ng, and m i nority empowerment in the U .S. are matters o f program act io n . Th e concern of the churc hes is to determ i ne how to con nec t i nvestment po li cy ancl practice with their program goa ls.

Ai m of the Heari ngs These hearings aim at deve lop i ng a factua l basis to guide the ch u rches as investors in any action they may wish to take to inf luence these two coppe r compa nies . They were he ld to determ i ne wheth er there are se rious issues raised for church investors in the proposed Puerto Rica n copper mining.

8 ------

--

~


History

Representat ives of the si x churches sponsoring the hearings, which together hold 60 ,000 shares of stock in American Metal ClĂ­max and 143,000 shares of stock in Kennecott Copper, met in New York Janua ry 7 to determine whether or not there shou Id be a concerted effort on thei r part to determine their positions on the projected min ing project . They decided that they would jo in in the holding Gf public hea rings in San Ju a n in arder to hear and evaluate ali sides of the is su es involved . This action grew out of a request by the Episcopal Diocese of Puerto Rico to its national church fo r support for the Diocese's opposition to the copper mining . lt requested the church to use the influences of its stock holdings to persuade the companies to delay their action. In response to th is request the Standing Committee on Social Criteria for 1 nvestments of the Episcopal Church sought and received the authori zation of the Episcopal Executive Council to consult with ex ecutives of the concerned companies (Kennecott and AMAX), to conduct public hearings, and, if necessary, to file stockholder resolutions for the annual meetings of the companies. Th e Episcopal Committee then invited representatives of the other d e nominations noted below to join in sponsoring these hearings to determine the facts in the matter .

The Hearings

Th e panel issued 51 persona l invitations to professional ex perts recomm e nded by Mr . lan McGregor, Chairman, America n Metal ClĂ­max , lnc . a nd th e Rev. Ri chard W. Gillett, Exec utive Directo r, Mi sion Industrial de Puerto Rico . A personal invitation was give n to Governor Lui s A. Ferre . Mr . Robert Potte r and Dr . Hugh White met priv ately, a week in advance of the hea ring, with the Han . Santi ago Soler Fava le , Executive Assista nt to Governor Ferre, and the Hon . Antonio Santiago Va zqu ez , Secret a ry of the Dept. of Public Work s, to brief them on the purpose of th e hearing as well as to invite them to testify. Si x d ays in advance of the hearing, public notice was made in El Mundo and in the San Ju a n Star, th e Spanish and Engli sh newspape rs with the la rgest c ircu lation s.

9 -

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

- -

-

- -

-

- -

-

-

-

-

-

-

-


Mr. Robert Potter, panel member

Mr . Horace Gale, panel member

'ยบ


The Convenors and Panel Members The United Church Board for Homeland Ministries, the Pen sion Boards of th e United Church of Christ, and the United Chu rc h Found ation Mr. Rich ard Dubi e Americ an Baptist Hom e Mission Society Mr. Horace Gale Women' s Di vision and National Division of the Board of Missions, United Methodi st Church Ms. Florence Little Ms . Carolyn Wilhelm Ms. Edgar Di x on The Rev. Kim Jefferson Coordinating

Committee

on

lnter

- American

Affairs,

United

Presbyterian Church, U.S.A . The Rev . Gilbert Marrero The Rev. Samuel J. Velez Standing Committee on Social Criteria for lnvestments of the Executive Council of the Episcopal Church Mr. Robert Potter Dr . Karl Gregory The Rev. Ted Lockwood The Rev. Everett Francis ¡ Board of Social Ministry of the Lutheran Church in America Th e Rev . Franklin L . Jensen The Rev. Victor Rodriguez (Where more than two members are listed, additional persons were presentas observers or alternatives.) Advisors to the panel on technical, socia l, and cultural m atters were: Dr. David Brooks, Mineral Economist, Ottawa, Canad a Dr. Rafael L. Ramire z, Social Sciences Research Center, University of Puerto Rico Staff to the panel were: Dr . Hugh C. White, Jr ., NIM Ms . Judith Gardner, NIM Mr . Jesse Christman, NIM

11


Panel Members Go To The Mining Site Most of the members of the panel were present, the day befare the hearings opened, far a trip to the mountai n area of Utuado , Lares, and Adjuntas where the proposed mining is to be located. Dr . David Brooks accompanied the panel to the site of the companies' investigory exploration . He answered questions that the panel put to him regarding the minerals that were exposed by the large cut into the mountains ide that they visited. He discussed the effects of the exposure of th e minerals to the air and water at the site and other possible environmental effects far the area of the proposed mining . Further, the panel members spoke to local residents and members of the student brigades. They questioned those with whom they spoke with regard to the agric ultura! development of the area as well as its cultural aspects. Citrus trees and coffee plants were abundan t th roughout the area. Th e popu lation density was sufficient ly high that the panel saw housing or sma ll town s throughout the trip and on eve ry mountainside. Th e scarcity of people in their late teens and twenties was noted by severa l panel members .

SUMMARY OF M IN ING PROCESS Th e evening pr ior to the beginning of th e hearings was spent by pane l members in receiving background on the mining process and in sett lin g details far the set up of the hear ings. Dr. Brooks presented to the panel a short introdu ction to th e manner in w hi ch copper is m in ed. A summ ary of that presentation fo ll ows: Th e process begin s w ith ex plorntion . In th e ear ly sixties prospecting rights were g1路anted by th e governm ent of Puerto Rico. (The government, by law , 1路eta ins the rnine rn l rights of th e enti re land su rface of Pu erto Rico.) Th e faur areas of concern from a stanclpoint of ecological issu es are the a1路eas in w hi ch the mining, mi lli ng, tr ansportatio n o f tailing s, and sme lting take place . (The fifth are a wo u lcl be that of th e refinin g, if th at we re to be clon e on the island .)

Mining Area Th e mine wi ll be an open pit. Far every foot of depth that th e mining goes clow n at least two f ee t of land outward w ill be neecl ecl in orde1路 that the wa lls o f the pit m ay remai n st able. .-, 1L..


Mountain area of proposed mines The ore will be mined in batches. lt will be drilled, blasted , and then removed. Most of the equipment will probably be electrical in which case a source of large amounts of electrical power will be necessary. There will also be a large volume of unuseable rock above the ore deposits which will have to be removed and disposed of somewhere.

Milling area The mili is a concentrating process by which the ore is placed in an organic foam which separates out the heads (concentrate which then contains 30 - 40% copper as opposed to the .8% copper content of the original rock) . These heads will be then transported to the smelter . The "tailings," that remaining rock which will go unused and will contain less than .05% copper, are then disposed of. 95 % of all the rock dug out in the process of mining will end upas tailings. The mili is gen erally located within the mining pit .

13


Smelter The smelting process is usually a pyro - metalurgical concentrate process, similar to a blast furnace, in which the copper concentrate is melted and additives are used to produce "blister" copper or cathodes (which are approximate ly 99% pure copper.) Mr. Ackerman of AMAX has stated that 92% of the sulfur dioxide resulting from this process will be recovered and made into sulfuric acid. There are nevertheless dangers of air pollution at this stage . They involve the remaining S0 2 gases that would be emitted into the atmosphere.

Refining There is considerable doubt at the present time as to whether or not the final refining process will be done in Puerto Rico . Although the companies have offered to transport refin ed copper to Puerto Rico free of charge, there remains great doubt as to whether fabricating industries would be stimulated. And, in the absence of such additional development, the merits of the project must be further questioned.

Fabrication The final phase of the copper process is the fabrication of copper wire, tubing and other products .

American Metal Climax, lnc. and Kennecott Copper Corporation The Standing Committee on Social Criteria of the Executive Council of the Episcopal Church requested that they be al lowed to meet with executives of AMAX and Ke nn ecott in December to discu ss with them their concerns as stockholders in those companies. Kennecott replied and refused to meet with representatives of the committee. AMAX agreed to meet with representatives of that committee, Mr. Robert Potter , the Rt . Rev. Francisco Reus - Froylan, and Mr . Richard Gillett . The meeting took place on December 11 . Mr . lan MacGregor, Chairman of AMAX and Messrs. Towers and Ostrander represented the companv. The company submitted a list of twenty (20) e xperts in the field of mining to the committee and suggested that contact be made with them.

14


1nvitations to testify at the hearings were sent to ea ch of those persons suggested by the company . 1nvitations to testify at the hearings were extended to both of the companies . Both companies refused to be present at the heari ngs and neither sent testimony of any kind to be entered in the record of the hearings.

The Hearings The Hearings were held at the Colegio de Abogados (Bar Association) in San Ju a n, Ponce de Leon 808, beginning at 9 :00 a.m . on Thursday , .January 21, and ending on F riday, Janua ry 22, 1971 . The following pages co nta in summaries of the testimony presented to the panel at the hearings.

In amving at its recommendations a nd findings the Pan e l took into co nsid e ration th a t: ( 1) the compan ies did not p1¡esent testimony; (2) the Gove rnment of Pu erto Ri co d es ignated Sr . Gel abert, Exec uti ve Secretary of the Mining Commi ss ion, as its offici a l re prese ntative at t he hear ings ; (3 ) a m ajority of those test ifying in person were against th e mining operat ion a nd ge nera lly suppo rtiv e of se lf - determin ation for th e Pu erto Ri ca n people; a nd (4) a ll persons suggest ed by th e coppe r compan ies we re invited tn tes tifv .

Dr . David Brooks, consultant to panel

15


Bi shop Reu s, Epi scopal Bi shop of Pu erto Rico

SUMMARIES OF TESTIMONY AT THE HEARINGS Thursday 2 1 January 19 71 Th e Rt. Rev. Francisco Reus - Froylan, Episcopa l Bishop of Puerto Rico Rejects the premise that the q uality of hum an lit e is based o nly on eco nomic and in d ustria l development. Because of the dangers of eco logica l damage, cu ltural disorientatio n and the government and the campan ies' over estimating th e benef i ts of the m in es , the mining operation shoul d not be undertake n as i t would merely add to the curre nt crisis of rapid i ndustria li zatio n of th e is land. Th e values and l ite sty les of the people in the rura l areas wou ld be traumat ically effected by the changes brought by the mines . Lic. Angel G. Hermida, Professor of L aw at th e Univ ers ity of Pu eno Rico and member of the M in ing Commission of the Bar Associat i on, and Lic . A ndres Salas - Soler, member of the Mining Commissi on of the Bar A ssoc iation.

16


Presented a resolution passed by the Bar Association and forwarded to the Governor and the Mining Commission requesting that the Government make public ali information about the negotiations with the companies and that no final contract be signed without there being full time for adequate study and reaction by the people to the proposed mining. The Bar Association is currently conducting a study, being done by engineers, biologists, attorneys, etc., of the implications of the proposed mining. Dr . Jaro Mayda, Professor of Law, University of Puerto Rico The broad ecological issues involved in the mining have not been discussed. There must be consideration of the development of the island as a total ecological unit. No one really knows what the ecological results will be. The Government has not enforced previous ecological standards set by law and therefore cannot be expected to do it now. lt has had the legal power to do so since 1950. Examples : - the Condado lagoon pollution, - water purity standards, - pollution from the petro - chemical industry on the south coast . Dr. Mayda supports agricultura! development of the mountain area.

Dr . Jaro Mayd a, Professor of Law at U.P .R.

17


Sr. Pedro M atos Matos, insurance m an in Utu ado (in the mining are a) . Is opposed to foreign ex p loi tation of Puerto Rico's n atur al resource s which will on ly make Pu erto Ri co poorer as it m ak es t he U .S. richer . Stated th at the current p lan is ju st the beginning of th e companies' pl ans for ex ploitation of the mineral resources of th e area. Poi lu tion is the fou rth most important prob lem after political . soc ial, and economic issues are considered . Th e G ov ernm ent centers on th e pollution issu e in an effort to avoid the m or e important qu es tion s. Ag ricultu re has no t bee n d eve loped by th e Gove rnm ent a) becau se t here is no t as mu ch pro fit t o th e po li t ici an s b)

in ag1¡icultu re as in inclu stry, and because Pu erto Ri co is m aintai ned as a con sum er o f U .S.

goocls

and

thu s cli sc ou ra gecl

fr o m

grow in g

eno ugh foo cl fo r its ow n neecl s. Th e area is no t sparsely popul at ecl as th e co m pa ni es all ege. Th ere are mo re t h an 180 peop le per scÂĄu are mil e in th e mining area. (As compared with 18 peop le pe r scÂĄ uare mil e in Ari zo na, w h ere copper is also mi necl.) Famili es h ave alreacly bee n di sp laced. T he rich vege t atio n in th e area speaks f a r th e f ertilit y o f th e land. Sr. Matos repor t ee! that a study h ad bee n clo ne b y Sr. Fau sti n o Rive ra L opez from th e Regiona l Offi ce o f th e Oep artm ent of Agric ultu re w hi ch st ates t h at eve n at th e prese nt uncl erdevelo ped rate of agr icu lt ure in th e area it p rod uces m o re th an th e m in es wou ld in eco no mi c be nef its. A t present more th an h alf o f the area resi d ents oppose t he m inin g. Rev. Fern ando Vazquez, M ethodist mini st er from th e p ro posed m ining area. Th e ma in p ro b lem is h ow litt le inform at ion th e p eop le of th e area have been ab le to get ab out t h e p ropo sed m ines. Peop le w h o are publi cly o pposed to th e mining pro p asa ! are be ing persecutecl by Go vern me nt o f f ic ials and ot hers in t h e area.

18

-- -- -- -- -- -- ~


Supports agricultura! development of the area and distribution of products to slum communities at reduced prices wh ich would be possible if distribution middlemen cou ld be eliminated.

Mr. Morris Moses, econom ist with the Puerto Rico Development Group, a consulting firm . Presented econom ic tables, based on conditions that are no longer applicab le to the current proposal, which indicated the relative profits to be made by the Government and the companies . The figures indic ated that: On the basis of 70 ,000 tons of copper extract ion annua lly, - 1,350 jobs wou ld be created through the refining process, - 4,000 jobs wo uld be included through the fabr ication process, and - the government would receive $7.7 million annua lly. The Gov ernme nt wou ld collect 50% of app licable taxes ov er the next 34 years. There would be no infrastructure costs of the Government other than the alread y projected expansion of the highway (PR #10) into the area.

19


Sr. Pedro A. Gelabert, Executive Secretary of the Mining Commission of Puerto Rico. A.

Senor Gelabert began his testimony with a discussion of the mining laws and the responsibilities and powers of the Mining Commission to grant exploration rights, control damage to the environment, etc .

B.

Pollution Control Measures Proposed Control of air pollution from dust will mainly be accompli shed through the use of wetting agents, hoods, and oth er dust collecting devices. Most SO 2 gases would be recovered and converted to sulfuric acid far commercial use and sale. The emission of 0.25% by volume of S02 into the air through a specially designed stack (500 - 600 fe et h igh) has not been approved by th e Mining Commission because of the already high concentrations of SO 2 in the area proposed far the smelter .

Water Pollution Control s - Proposed Surplus and run off waters to be recycled far use in concentration process.

20


Tailings (waste crushed rock) Disposal Tailings to be disposed of in the ocean or inland . This has not been determ ined as yet . Environmental pollution is not a negotiable issue as far as the Mining Commission is concerned. None of the above measures have been approved as yet. Past failure of the Gov ernment to overcome pollution problems shouldn't be rea son to evaluate future performance. C.

Economic Aspects The companies estimate an average production of 48,000 tons of copper per year for 30 years and total production of copp er, su lfu ric acid and other m ineral s at $1,540 million. Th e comp anies estimate 1,600 to 2,000 jobs during the first three ye ars of construction with 800 jobs thereafter through the sm elting and acid production st ages.

D.

Soci al A spects Th e only infra stru cture costs to th e Gove rnm ent wo uld be th e reco nstruction o f high way PR # 10 between A rec ibo and Pon ce w hich wou ld be done 1·ega 1·dless of the mining. L and use woul d in clud e 550 ac 1·es fo1· th e actu al pits w ith an add ition al 2,900 acres for othe1· uses for a t ota l of apprnx im at ely 3, 500 acres. Th e t o t al number of fa mili es effec t ed wou ld be 38.

In the n ex t f ew weeks th e Mining Commi ss ion w ill make the proposals public. Publi c h ear ings wi ll be held beginning th e last wee k of Feb1·uary, 1971, on th e copper mining issue. N ego ti atio n s betwee n the Minin g Commission and t he companies wi ll be h eld . lf contracts a1·e sign ed the M ining Commission 1·etain s t he power to suspend all opera ti o ns if th ere is non · comp li ance w ith t he co ntract 0 1· if po lluti o n occ urs.

21


KARST AREA LARES • TANAMAD

PROPOSE[ • UTUADO RIO VIVI

ADJUNTAS • CONCENTRATES TO SMELTER

ENSENADA

~

Current mining proposal calls for piping tailings to southern coast. Other possibilities considered were


SWAMP AREA 1

TAILING PIPELINE

TAILING & - PROPOSED CONCENTRATE PIPELINE

the dis-

posal in the Karst area or filling a swamp adjacent to the town of Arecibo.


Sr. Gelabert does not understand the secrecy surrounding the negotiations. He has been in office only one and a half months and has criticized the Government for its secrecy. The newest methods for recovery of S02 have been developed by the Japanese. The companies have promised to use these methods in Puerto Rico . Simultaneous development of m1nrng and agriculture would be possible in the area of the proposed mines. There has been no decision as to whether or not there wil 1 be a public referendum on the decision to mine the copper. He fears that the people wouldn't have sufficient technical knowledge to enable them to make the wisest decision . lf it looks like there will be only small benefits to the people of Puerto Rico from the proposed mining the Government probably won't go ahead with it. No plan as yet has been developed for monitoring pollution although studies are underway regarding current base data for the are a.

Bishop Antonio Ramos, Epi sco pa l Bi shop of Co sta Rica

24 -

-

-

-

-

- -

-

- -

- - -

-

-

-

_____,,,,.


The Rt. Rev. Antonio Ramos, Citizen of Puerto Rico and Episcopal Bishop of Costa Rica The government is only emphasizing the economic aspects of the mines, not the social, cultural, and spiritual aspects. Th e c urrent hear ings hold new hope for the churches to examine their own policies as they have been agents of complicity in the exploitation of the developing nations by American economic interests through th eir investments. A lmost all of the information given by testimony was furnished by the companies.

the

Government

On e of th e contributions the churches could make in this situation would be to help to make technical information available to the masses so that they can make decisions about this issue which will effect the entire nation. Aside from the problem of popular participation, political issues still remain. Development of the economic resources of Puerto Rico should assure development of man and self - determination for the island. Current situations do not allow that development, and handing over the copper deposits for foreign exploitation will only serve to strengthen foreign control of the island . This exploitation of the copper deposits is part of a whole colonial system in which people are forced to depend on centers of decision - making which are not in their hands.

Mr. Lawrence Hill, President, the Natural History Society of Puerto Rico The Society has met with AMAX to discuss the issues. lf this mining venture is the beginning of extraction of various minerals from Puerto Rico , the environmental effects and impacts of expanded mining could be far more ranging and deleterious than what is now foreseen for the present proposal. There is no reason that the copper must be mined now . lt may be that there would be a more advantageous time in the future. Are there alternative investments and uses of the area w hich would be lower in c0st, economic, social and ecological, to the people of Puerto Rico?

25


Mr. L awre nce Hill, Natural History Society of Pu erto Rico "What environm enta l co nseque nces can b e predicted or expec t ed from a deci sion to permit th e extract ion and milling of copper ore, and the subseq u ent disposal of was t el An und er ly in g prem ise is t hat once environm ental dam age occu rs, correct ive ac tion is slow to respo nd or is impossibl e t o impl eme nt . Th e damages are often irreversibl e." Th e Soc iety beli eves t hat adequa t e study has n o t been comp leted and that no ba lanced d ec ision ca n be made by th e Government until such studi es can b e comp leted . Sr. Pedro Baijes Chapel, Aux ili ary Secretary G eneral of the Mov ement for 1ndep end ence. Pu e rto Ric o h as limited reso urces, and fu ll cap itali st ic exp loitat ion of those min era l resources w ill enrich on ly a few rath er th an th e peop le of the entire island. Th ere wi ll be mass ive effects on the ecology, but the primary con sid eration s must be for the po li tic al effects of th e mining. Th ere is no reaso n to deli ver these resources into foreign h and s w hich have not only been quic k to ex p lo it th e ch eap and abu nd a nt labor force of th e island but have also been ir res pon sibl e about m aintaining t h e ecolog ica l balance .

26


The Gov ern ment h as gu arante ed the companies that labor unions will not interfere with their plans . Government faci lit ies have been offered to th e companies. Exp loitation of th e copper resources and the economic ties involv ed the rein w ill give the present Gov ernm ent a lever for fu tu re po i iti ca l rel ations . Th e Mov em ent for lnd epe nd ence w ill use ali public forums op en to th em to disc uss th e above problems. M o re th an 90% of th e p eopl e in th e minin g area are opposed to th e proposed min es.

Dr. M ax imo Cera m e Vivas, Direct or, Oepartm ent of M arin e Sciences, U ni vers i ty of Pu erto R ico , Mayaguez Campus "P u erto Ri co, du e to its c lim ate, limited t erritor ial ex t ensio n, pop ul ation de n sity , and natural features, cannot tolerate th e eco log ica l im pact of a coppe r mining and sme ltin g operat ion ." Exposure of th e min era Is in th e ea rth t o air or wate r w ill result in th e crea tion of sul f u r ic ac id and red u ce or elimin at e th e alka lini ty o f th e wa ters.

27


There will be serious environmental risk stemming from the tailings from the concentrator. The tailings (estimated at 15,000 tons per day) will smother 5,000 square miles of the ocean bottom in the Caribbean Sea. Not only will the tailings be toxic but thrnugh mechanical smothering alone they will eliminate those bottom organisms that can neither escape or survive . This effect could possibly change the ocean food chain in the area. The tailings will be washed shoreward dueto the movement of the currents in that area. There is no precipitous cliff over which the tailings can be dumped as the company alleges. Past experience with environmental effects of industries in Puerto Rico indicates that major ecological damage occurs and the Government does not act to stop it . The effects of the emission of the 12% S0 2 gases which will not be recovered will cause danger to plant and anima l life . "We insist that under the existing and foreseen environmental controls on the island, and judging by the inadequacy of regulatory agencies before the existing pollution problems, we must have no pretentions about being able to mine a nd sme lt copper here without seriously threatening our ecology. lf environmental controls were ever possib le, these shou ld be made to demonstrate their effectiveness by handling existing problems before embarking upan problems of copper mining magnitude." The copper deposits in Puerto Rico should not be mined.

Sr. lrvin Torres Torres, Sociologist from Utu ado (in the proposed mining area) and staff member of PRISA What is involved for the churches in the copper mining issue is w hether or not they w ill be agents of complicity (as they h ave been in the past) to genocid e upon the Pu erto Ri ca n people. (Genocide is defin ed by the UN as "the wi llful destruction of a people ora culture .") What is at stake is the w hole culture of Puer to Rico : the coffee and mountain culture which are th e hub of th e Puerto Ri ca n ide ntity . No price can be put on the cultu re that wou ld be di srupted by this mining. Ho w w ill sub - educated farmers adjust their ve ry beings and way of life in a n alien surround ing7 Slum be lts in San Ju an should demonstrate fully w ha t has .happe ned to

28


people that have been displaced from sugar plantations and tobacco farms. In 1900, the second appointed civilian governor of the island, William Hunt, made a survey which indicated that the island could comfortably support 5 million people. (Current population: 3.5 million.} The reason that there is now such extreme poverty and that one third of the population has moved to the U.S. is that the economy does not serve the needs of the Puerto R ican peo ple but instead serves the U.S. "When the U.S. needed sugar, we grew sugar, when it needed cheap labor, we were cheap labor. Now it needs copper." Men in dark suits will come telling how they will provide jobs for every man, woman, and child on the island. They have come befare in the name of the industrialization program, the migrant worker program, the army and navy bases, and the petro chemical industry. None of their promises have ever come true. And in the meantime Puerto Ricans have been drafted, immigrated, urbanly renovated, educated in the American Way of Lite, their family structure "modernized" and they have been conspicuously consumed. Puerto Rico is the fourth most important market for the U.S. to the benefit of Wall Street. Why does this situation exist? Because Puerto Rico is a colony and the colonies are made to be exploited . The Government is nothing more than the old colonial Government with another name and administrators who have their hands tied . Sr. Torres then went on to document cases in which promises of jobs were made in the past and not fulfilled. He said that the hearing itself is a manifestation of colonialism which should be eliminated . Favors agricultura! development of the proposed mining area . Dr. Oswaldo Ramirez Torres, Chemist Did not take a position as to whether or not the mines should be opened but said that the community, through its representatives, should be able to choose acceptable levels of pollu t ion.

29


There are two majar areas of concern : the mining area itself and the area where the smelter is located. Far the mining area, he described essentially the same pollution control measures that the Government representatives outlined . He stated that the emission of S0 2 gases, if a closed system of a calcinator were u sed, wou Id be below the 1967 feder a l standards. He submitted 43 pages of testimony (in Spanish) outlining specific control measures that could be taken which would keep environmental damage to a mĂ­nimum . Prof . Federico R. Hernandez, head of the Consumers Resea rch ln stitute of t he Uni versity of Pu erto Rico Prof. El ias Gu ti errez, Economist with Consum er s Rese arch Prof . Ped ro Parrill a, Economi st with Consum e rs Resea rc h Prof . Neftal i Ga rcia, Chemi st w ith Con sum ers Resea rc h Su ggest ed tw o possibl e actions by th e churches: T o try t o involve other stockhol d ers in th e companies involved . Make fund s avail ab le t o improve evalu ation of th e min ing a nd to fight it. T he Socia l co sts of th e m ining mu st be consid ered a nd we igh ed against th e soc ia l cost s o f a ltern ati ve inv estm e nts in th e area . Th ey m ade pub lic for th e f irst tim e th e comp any' s last p ropo sa l (d ated Dece m ber 196 9) to t h e Gov ernm e nt w h ich indi cat ed th at tw o new p ub lic high wa ys would h ave to be built in th e area (at pu blic ex pe nse ) as we ll as ex t e nsiv e im p rov e me nt of th e current hi ghwa y so that it could h andle th e heavy e quip me nt need ed fo r th e mines. The improvement would be more th an would be necessa ry we re the regĂ­an to remain mainly agri c ultura! as it now is. The proposal had been given t o the lnstitute b y som eo ne w ho had stol e n it from the Government offices . The companies' estim ates, and therefo re ali of its figu res, a re probably estim at es of about 50% of the co pper th at w ould actu a lly be mined . Further , the grade of the c op per (said b y th e companies to be .7 % by vol u me) is lower th a n th e actu a l grad e

30 - - - - -- - - -


Members of Consumers Research lnstitute of the University of Puerto Rico which is .8%. (Average grades mined in the U.S. get as low as .5% .) The companies are asking for additional land which would total between 36 - 40,000 acres as compared to the figure of 3 ,500 acres given by the Government . Cu rrent negotiations indicate that 33 1/3% of the profits from the mining will go the Government while 72% was recently paid by the same companies to the Government of Chile. 2% royalties will be paid to Puerto Rico while many other cou ntries get 9 %. The Government has not in the past enforced pollution control or planning . They denied the existence of a market for 40 tons per day of sulfuric acid which the smelter will produce. Stated that the proposals would be made public and available to those who want them.

31


Sr . Benjamin Ortiz and Sr . Richard Gillett, Mision Industrial de Puerto Rico Frid ay, 22 January 1971 Benjamín Ortiz Bel aval, Associate Director, Puerto Rico 1ndustrial Mi ss ion. Th e companies involv ed in the proposed mining venture in Puerto Rico contro l $3 billion in investments around the wo rld including 49% of th e copper of Chile. Kennecott has recent ly acqu ired Peabody Coal and thus h as becom e th e largest producer of co al in the U .S. There have been anti - tru st suits un success fully brought by the U. S. Gov ernment again st K ennecott . lf th e U .S. Government cannot exe1·c ise contro l over the power of a company such as this one, how can the Governrnent of Puerto Rico b e expec ted to do so? Th e Governrnent sa ys that ali pollution from the min es can be contro ll ed and th at 4,000 j obs in mining and sa t ellit e indu stl'i es w ould be created. Th e petra - chem ica l compani es promi sed 35,000 jobs of which only 5,000 actua ll y deve loped. Th e Mining Commi ss ion won't wa it far an end o f th e studi es that are being co ndu ct ed regarding wat e1· pollution.

32


A Vice President of American Metal Climax referred to the study done by Engineering Science as the most complete study done to date of the environmental aspects of the mining. The study itself indicates that more study is necessary. The mines should be exploited only when there can be absolute safeguards which protect the people of the island economically, ecologically, and culturally . That is not possible now. Supports the development of agriculture alternative to the mines .

in the area as an

The cultural results of North American investment can be seen throughout the island . The churches should: Use their shares of stock to mak e the issue relevent in the center of th ese companies. Try to stop the mines. lnvest in other companies. Analyze the soc io - cultural results of investments in Third World countries. lnves tigate soc io - cu ltural stud ies of w hat happens to to wns w hen th ey are imp acted from indu str ial exp loitati o n. ln ves tig at e a11d d et ermin e inv es tment poli cy w ith re gard to th e qu es tion

of w hether or not companies operate in

co untri es where o ligarchie s are

in co ntro l such as

in

Paraguay, South Afri ca, and Bra zil. Th e

combination

of

politica l

and

eco nom ic

power

is

cve rwhe lmingl y large ! 01· th e peop le of any developing country to h ave t o d ea l w ith. Sr. Ramon R . Rodriguez, Jr., Pres idente, ISL ENOS DE BOR INOUEN AS I CUADI S, ln c. T w o thi1·ds of th e inhalJitants o f th e islancl of Puer t o Ri co are p oo r . Sr. Rod rigu ez' organi z¡1tio n is an orga ni zation to protect ancl h elp th e poor p eop le o f th e islancl. Fo r th at

1 ca so n

he

protests th e mining. lt wo ulcl o nly increase th e rctnks o f t he poor and clisp lacecl. Th ere are too m any alreacl y.

33


Sr. Ramon Ororio & Ms. Carmen Lopez, Student Brigades Against the Mining Ms. Carmen Noelia Lopez, Student Brigades Against the Mining .

Th e proposed mining operation will endanger the Puerto Rican nationality, their right to self - determin a tion, and their hope for nation al sovereignty . Sh e o utlin ed th e way th e brigad es were organi zed . Students have gon e into th e mountains, sorne on a perm a nent b as is, sorne during b rea ks from their studi es, in order to educate th e people about issu es invo lved in th e propo sed mining of copper in th eir area. Th ey have organi zed loca l groups aga in st th e mines and a re c oll ec ting sign atures on pe titions to submit to the Government in oppo sition to th e mining . Me mbers o f th e brigad es h ave been persecuted by th e police a nd other la nd ow ners in th e a rea . Th e ir o ngo ing wo rk is for th e most part possible be cause of th e economic su p port th a t th ey rĂŠceive from local citizen s. Sr. Ramon Ororio, Brigad e Me mber

Resid e nts of t h e a rea a re opposed to the mining dueto: Th e m a nn er in w hi c h the t e rrain would be ch a nged such t hat it w oul d no lo ng er be suitable for agri c ulture.

34


Air pollution factors w hich, even if small, would be se rious dueto the high populat ion density in the area . The use of /arge a mounts of water far the mining operation (about 3,000 gallons per minute) . The Government hasn't provided adequate water far the residents of th e area (many must go to public spigots and carry water to their homes) and is now making big promises to the companies far the provision of water far the mines. Much of th e employment possible in the mines is of a highly technical nature a nd would be given to technicians brought in from somewh e re e/se . Politi c ally the island has colonial status. Exploitation of the copper resources would solidify that colonial status and make it even more difficult far the people to fight far independence. Dr. Jose Francisco Cadilla, Professor of geology, geography and mathematics at the University of Puerto Rico, farmer chief geologist far the Government of Puerto Rico. The mining laws of Puerto Rico are inadequate in that they deal with conservation of resources in a very general way and do not dea/ with permanent damage done to the environment. There was a Planning Board study done in 1965 which opposed the mines because of the considerable relocation and retraining problem involved due to the fact that the popu/ation of the proposed mining area is primarily fema/e and adolescent with a 5th grade educational leve/. The study was repressed by the Government. 1n 1967 a comm ittee called the Johnson Committee did a study of the water and air pollution possibilities. The study concluded that the mining was not feasible far the above reasons and was taken out of circulation by the Government. 'f

Another study, done by the Aquaducts and Water Commission reported on water use and consumption as well as possible changes in acidity and taste of the water . This report was a/so withdrawn from circu/ation by the Government. Dr. Cadilla listed severa/ countries in which the political situation has been dictated by the role of American capital. He stated th at

35


sever<J I wa rs an d oth er m ajor poi iti ca l con se qu ences h ad 1·esu 1t ed from th e e f fo rt s o f th e U.S. gove rnment to p ro tect th e interes t s o f U .S. ca pi ta li st s o p eratin g in for eign countri es. Furth er, he stated th a t th ose w ho hol d ec onomi c interes t s in th ese countr ies are <i frn id o f high er t axes, redu ced profits, or th e d evelopment of so c ial ist rep u b l ic s. Thi s h as b ee n p articu lar l y tru e of m inin g in te1·es ts. Transc ulturali za ti o n (th e sub st itu t io n of o ne culture fo r ano th er ) is u sed in st ead o f so lvin g th e ce ntral probl em w hi ch is o n e o f ind ep ende nc e and se l f · dete rmin a ti o n fo r th e countri es invo lved . H e chroni c led seve ral i nc id ents in w hi ch th e G overn m ent or re p rese n ta ti ves o f th e co mµ an ies h ad m ad e µ ubli c st ateme nts a t d ifferent tim es OI" in d i f f e1·ent loca ti o ns in w hich th ey bl at ant ly co nt i-adi cted th em se lves. H e read th e f o l l ow ing st at em ent tak en fr om a p ubli ca ti o n of Vi si on , l n c . : "A rece nt symp osi um o n copper 's futur e in Barr on 's m acle a point th at m ay app ly to m any m in era ls. ' Because o f t he da n ge r o f air µ o llut io n ,' obse rved Sim o n Strau ss o f A meri ca n Sm elt i ng and R e finin g, ' it is p rol.Ja b ly goi ng t o b e ver y d i ffi cu l t to b uil d a n ew coµ per sm elter anywh ere in th e wes t ern U .S., par ti cul ar ly i n Ari zo n a.' 'A vo id ing fum es fro rn sm el ters,' sa id l an M ac Grego r of Am er ica n M et al C l im ax, 'wi ll ad d f antas t ica ll y to cap i t al cos t, and t h a t is w hy y o u see so m any d eve lo pm ent s of c opp er proj ec t s t ak in g p lace abroad .' " A l l o f th e lak es i n Pu ert o Ri co are de f ic ient. In 1964 th ere w as a dri l l in g ope rati o n by Po nce Mini ng (a w h o ll y - ow ned su b sid i ar y of AMA X ) w hi ch C<tu sed dro ug h t in sorne f arm s in the area and w h ere t h e cause an d e f fect relati o nshi p were so c lea r t h at t he co m pa n y was fo rced to pay da rn ages t o th e farm ers eff ec t ed . H e furt he1· sta t es th at th ere are m o re iron d epos its in Pu erto Ri c o th an th er e are d ep os i ts of c opper . (Th e t esti rn o n y fr om th e f o ll ow ing t w o sources we re subm itt ed t o th e pane l in w r i t te n fo rm and are b ri ef ly summ ar i zed h ere.)

Regina ld P. Bri ggs, Env i ronm en ta l Geo lo gi st " I n sh o rt, eco lo gi ca l eff ec t s in th e propo sed m in i ng area n o lo nge r con st itute larg e issu es. l f th e w ork is do n e as p lann ed

36


deleterious effects wil l be at a m1nimum. The problem of effluents from the smelter planned for the south coast remains a concern, but this is another area entirely." Th ere Vl(ill be substantially economic boost to the people of Pu erto Rico in the new job s createcl in the mining process and th e support industries as we ll as in the possible development of sate lite industries. "Presently the majority of the people in west - central Pu erto Rico appear to have two basic cho ices. They can continue in a marginal agricultura! existence, with their simplest needs met in part by Governme nt handouts . Or they can abandon thei1¡ w ay of life and migrate to large centers such as San Juan and New York w h ere they are subjected to pressures and influences which they perhaps are not prepared to meet. In my view, the mining project presents a good th ird alternative. Th e jobs come to the mountains. Th e people can stay home, still enjoying an essentially pastoral life, at the same time also enjoying improved standards of living. This certainly cannot be bad." The rea l issue is political. He questions the role of the church in a political situation. Says that it has no business there and that the opposition to the mining is using the ecological, social and economic arguments as a means to the political end they seek . Mr. Briggs denies the competence of people who have advised the panel. He sa y s of "the marine biologist, Chairman of a University department, a spec ialist in benthic organisms, and a compelling speaker:" "Give n his ignorance of the subject at hand a few years ago, and the press of ali his duties and speaking engagements , how can he have become an expert on mining and related fields? Pl ai nly he cannot have done so . He is unqualified, incompetent, in the matter at hand." Of the geologist, who is " a former State Geologist" he said: "However, you will find no well qualified geologist who will respect his unchecked scientific opinion. In addit ion, it is well known that he is politically motivated . . . 1 consider him incompetent in ali essentials in the question of effects of the proposed mining."

37


In regard to "the scientist from . . . Chicago . . . (who) is a member of the Advisory Board to the Commonwealth's Area of Natural Resources .. . 1 have found no indications that he is qualified in mining and related problems. In fact, it would seem that he's not too familiar with Puerto Rico in general." "To conclude, it is my opinion that there are no issues in the copper mining project that warrant Church intervention . The only large issue is political, and in this th e Church has no business. In short the Church has been duped , used for political purposes. lt should get out of this situation, gracefully if possibl e, but by ali mea ns get out." ''This matter, (sic) never should have reached yo ur comm ittee. Aside from the opportunity it gav e you to visit Puerto Rico, 1 find it regrettable that you r tim e has been wast ed on a case resulting from superfi cial and bia sed investigations by a Church committee advised by person s whose compet ence and motiv ation are dubiou s at best ." Ma rc Mess ing, Fri end s of the Earth .

" Th e p rim ary fac t o rs involved in th e dec isio n eith er t o proceed w ith t he p ro posed pl ans, amend th em , o r abando n t hem , are t hose whi ch involve th e imm ed iate soc io - eco no m ic adva ntages a n d t h e eco logi cal disadva ntages whi ch th e pro ject wi ll pred ictab ly create. Th ere w ill be additi o na l jobs and cap ita l brought in to t he area wh ic h w ill presu mab ly be benef ic ia! to the com muni ty, ;md t he re w ill be a ir and wat er pollu t io n resu lt ing from t he m inin g and sme lti ng o perations whic h w ill const it ute d isadvantages of ot her so rts to t he com muni t y . Bo th th ese advantages and d isadvan tages involve quant ita ti ve fi gures w hi ch are de batab le, and th e d ec ision ul t im at e ly req uires a q ua l itati ve eva lu ati o n w hic h we ighs t he two ." " T he second ary facto rs inv o lv ed in clud e cultural q uesti o ns, lo ng ra nge eco no mi c q uestion s and ad diti onal eco log ica l qu esti o ns. Th e ro le t hat th e int rod uction of t hi s indu stry woul d pl ay in Pu ert o R ico 's t ra nsition fr o m an ag ri cu lt u ra l t o an in c reas ingly indu stria l soc iety; th e effects of th e hi ghly visib le ope n - pi t o perat ion s a n d s m e lt ing p lant upon touri st t rad e; t he psycho lo gica l cost of inc reas ing indu st ry , noi se, a nd po llution u pon t he res iden t s; and th e ec ol og ica l effects res ulting fr om th e acc umul at ion of polluta nts in t he envi ro nm e nt for however long th e minin g co ntinu ed ali con stitu te co nsidera ti o ns w h ic h can a lso be foresee n, bu t are less eas ily quantifi ed or com pa red ."

38


"The tertiary factors, however , are even less predictable, and for th a t reaso n eve n more potentially dangerous , than either the primary or seco nd ar y factors. The ecological effects of climactic alterations c reat ed by th e smelting pl a nt are speculative; the eco nomi c effects of th e cumulative dumping upan the ecology or th e beauty of the Ca ribbea n are unpredictable; and the potential e pid e miologi ca l effects which could result from either ecological disruptions or unforeseen a tmospheric chemical reactions are even more se rious a nd more difficult to anticipate . Yet these are th e kinds of considerations which are attendant upan our present ecological - technological situation and are potentially more d a ngerous than a ny we can foresee." "I nsofar as the mineral resources of the island are concerned , their value can only be enhanced by their protection . The fund ame ntal usefulln ess of copper to society is so great that it is in no foreseeable danger of depreciating in either demand or value; a nd in vi ew of the present state of technology for its recove ry it is reasonable to assume that improved techniques could soo n minimi ze the adverse effects a nd pote ntial dangers discussecl a bove . In fact, it was the finding of the National A caclemyof Sc ien ces ' Committee on Min era l Scie nce and T ec hnol ogy that "The st ate of min eral technology in the United States is wre tc hed, " and that numerou s countries were more adva nced in their techniques .. . In view of these facts, and the ser ious n a ture of the questions raised by the techniques the Unitecl Stat es is presently re lying u pa n and planning to u se in Pu erto Rico, it wou Id seem no less th an reaso nabl e to demand th at the compa ni es involved in th e extrac tion of minerals from Pu erto Ri co e m p loy me thods which wou Id comp lete ly safeguard the Puerto Rica n e nvironm e nt . lf no such methods are ava il ab le , th en it w ould see m aclv antageo us to de lay ex trac tion until th ey are; both the island a nd the min era ls can await their avai labil ity ." "Finally, if it is ultim at e ly deemecl necessary to go ahead with th e open - pit mining operations in th e near future despite these consicl era ti o ns and these risks, th ere are certain safeguards wh ich ca n be t a ke n . In sum they am ount to the in siste nce on th e part of the Pu erto Rica n government th at only th e latest state - of - the a rt processes a nd controls be used , a nd that careful reclamation policies a nd procedures be strictly d efin ed and e nforc ed . T ailings should not be dumped into the sea where tidal move ments and eco lo gica l relations a re not we ll understood; unrecovered water should not be u sed for th e inexpe nsi ve tran sport of these in ert mineral wast es; a tmosp he ri c sulphe r dioxide pollution shou ld not be permitted; a nd a li other facets of the mining process should be

39


strictly regulated. Furthermore there should be rigid standards regarding the grading, drainage, backfillings, plantings, and revegetation of the areas involved, as well as provisions far the protection from possible health hazards created by the operations, despoliation of natural resources, interruption of important ecological structures, soil erosion, forest disruption, water pollution, air contamination, weather interference, and any other physical effects which would undermine the imm ediate econom ic advantayes of the project." Rev. Frank Jensen, Rev. VĂ­ctor Rodriguez, panel members

Dr. Ka rl Gregory & Mr . Kim Jeffe rson, pan e l me mbers

40


INDE X OF APPENDICES 1.

L etter s o f 1 nv itatio n to t he first p ane l meet ing , 1/ 6/7 1, in New Yo r k. Se nt t o cl enom inatio n al exec u t ives.

2.

A gencia fo r th e fi rst m ee ti n g of t h e Pan el, 1/6/71 .

3.

Press re lease issuecl Monclay , Jan . 18 . 19 71. ann ou ncing the p lan for t h e h o ld in g o f p u b li c heari ngs in Pu erto R ico .

4.

Background p aper, r eleasecl w i t h the above. revi ew ing t he mak e · up ancl h istory of t h e Panel .

5.

L ett er of inv i t a t ion to t h e press in Puerto R ico . 1/ 19/7 1.

6.

Sta tem ent p rep arecl for th e pr ess in Pu erto Ri co to exp lain the make - up of th e Pan el. ( In Sp an ish )

7.

Th e Pl an fo r th e H ea1·ings, inc lucl in g purpose . conven ers. m ember shi p, ;i ncl sc h edu les of execut ive sess ions ancl pub li c h ea r ings.

8.

Ag encia o f Pan el Or ient a tion . Jan . 20, 1971 .

9.

Li st of th ose invi tecl to tes ti fy at th e hearings .

10.

Copy of th e le tt er of inv itat 1o n sen t to t he fifty - one pe rsons l ist ecl in number 9.

11 .

Aclv ert isements of the hea ri ng wh ich appea red in the San Ju an Star ancl El Mundo six day s pr io r to the h ea ring s.

12.

An intervi ew vv ith Dr . Rich ard L evins. U nive rsity o f Chi cag o. prepar ecl by M ision Indu st r ial ele Pu er t o Ri co. ~ntit l e d, "Sorn e Eco log ica l Asp ec t s Concern ing t he Pr oposed Mining of Copper in Pu erto R ico" w hich was su bmitted to t h e pane l at their first meeting .

13.

A paper compa 1·in g the pos it ions of th e Epi sco pa l Di ocese of Pu er to R ico and t h e A m er ican M eta l Clim ax Company, ;::i rep ared by Mi sio n In d u str ial d e Pu erto Ri co , w hi ch was subm itted to tt1e Pan el at th eir f irst m eet in g.

41


14.

Newspaper articles and editorials from the San Juan newspapers from 22 January through 30 January . (Many are in Spanish of which sorne have been translated by Mision Industrial.)

15.

Correspondence with the Companies Dec. 11, 1970, from Robert Potter to Mr. lan MacGregor of. American Metal Climax, lnc., thanking him for meeting with Mr. Potter, Mr. Gillett, and Bishop Reus, requesting the company's list of experts, and noting that the company had refused to make its proposals to the government available to this group of stockholders. Dec. 28, 1970, from MacGregor to Potter, stating that he appreciated the opportunity to meet with Potter, Gillett, and Reus, believes that differences in points of view can be minimi zed through thorough understanding, that AMAX fully complies with the laws of the federal government and the Commonwealth, shares the concern for the well - being of the Pu erto R ica n peopl e and the envi ronment, and that AMAX has succeeded (presumably in environmenta l control) in other places. States that Ackerman is w illing to meet w ith the Bishop and Dick Gillett, suggests tbat the Bi shop meet with Governor Ferre , and wishes the committee well. Jan . 12, 1971, from Potter to MacGregor of AMAX and to Frank R. Milliken, Presid ent of Kennecott Copper, inviting these ge ntl e men o r oth er off ice rs of their camp an ;es to atte nd and t estify at the hear ings . To MacG regor, st ates regret t hat the pro posals have not been mad e public. To Millik e n, sta t es that he regrets the fact t he Kenn ecott official s have refused to meet with represe nta tives of the Episcopal stockholders of Ke nnecott. J an . 14, 1971, from MacGregor to Potte r, acknowledging rece ipt of th e in vitation, d ec lining to attend du e to th e fact th at their views w ith regard to th e issues had not changed since their meeting two week s prio r, noted that most of th e peopl e suggested by th e company as ex perts had been invited to te stify, fe lt th at many of these ex pert s might refuse to testify dueto p rofession a l reason s, and trusts th at t he company will continu e to h ave th e suppo rt of the church as it has had in the past . J an . 15, 19 71 , fro m Milli ke n to Potte r, th anking him for th e invi tatio n to testi fy, dec lin ing th e invitation ¡ du e to sc hedul e con fl ic t s and th e be lief that pu bli c iss u es mi ght " more app ro p ria te ly be cond ucted by th e res po nsibl e gov ernm e nt

42


agencies," ancl assu ring Po tte r of th eir w ill i n gn ess to t a k e "any feas ibl e p1·eca ution to protec t ancl enh an ce t he e nv ironrn ent."

J an.

18,

1971, fro rn Potter to M ac Gregor with a carbon to

Millik en _ Expressing regre t th at they refused to testify at the h ea rin9s, informing them of t h e m ee ting s with the government off ic ials and th eir agreenient to testify, exp ressing co ncern over th e sec r ec y of th e compa ni es and the governm en t w hich only se 1·ves to co nf i rm

th e n eecl

for the hearings. Asks that they

r econsicl er ancl assures th em that the hearings wi ll be conductecl in a r esponsilJ le ancl respectfu l mann er. Noting th at all expe rts suggestecl by the co mpany were invitecl. J an . 27, 19 71 , fr o m MacGrego r to Potter.

16 .

Correspo nd ance w ith th e Government of Puerto Rico. Janu a1·y

13, 1971, from Pott er to th e H on . Anton io Santiago

Va ¿q u eL , Secretary o í tl1 e D epa nm en t of PuiJ l rc Works , t hankin g him fa r ni ce tin 9 w itl 1 Dr. W hit c ancl Pott er il nd far offerr ng to prov icl e w it nesses a t t h c h ea r ings, a1-ran yin9 for· futu r e con tac t rega rclin g clet <1il s, st a ting

th c int en tio n

to ho lcl h ear·in gs in a

r·espon silJl e 111 ar111 er am i to cJi sc u ss the finding s oí th e Pane l wi th th e gov ernin ent w h en th ey are d c t erm in ed . ce to t h e H an . Sa nti a90 So ler F ava lc. Jan . 13 , 197 1, fro m Po tt er to th e H o 11 . Santi ago Sol er F ava le, Executi vc As srst ant to Governor F erre, ex p1·ess in g app reciat io n fa r th e 111ce ti ng tl iey h ac l , i11f o r miny him o f th e ir m ee t in g w ith Dr .

Sw 1t iayo

V <11q u e1

w ho

élCJl' eecl

th at

so meon c

from

th e

gove rn m en l wo ulcl t cs tify, ;111d érssu rin g h im th a t th e hea ring s w ill IJ e co ncJ u c ted in a rcspor1si lJl e 111C1 r1n cr·_

17.

Mi sce ll aneous Corres pond enc e : Jan . 20, 197 1, fr o rn D eLJ n B. Boga r!, Chi c f of Caribb ea n Di str ict, Wa ter Resou r·ces D iv ision , U .S . G eo lo9ica l Surv ey, ~ f ec li ning th e inv itati o n to p art ic i¡ rn te in th c hea r in9s, cli sc u ss in9 th e wo rk of th e Wa ter Rc su u1 ces Di v isio n ar1cJ it s imp arti ality, statin g h is lieli e f th <r t th e p <Hw l hc1 > d ¡¡11;cu r1 cc ive tl positi on, dml hi s r e91·e t at "sce irHJ r1 !pr ese r1t <1l rves of chur·c h cs er1t e1 co ntr ove rsia ! issues t h at 11 eecl

tu IH ! t h!c itl t, tl u n

1: r1 111e >h 1: d

w itl1

tll 1~

th e l>asis o f fac t r a th er

e111u t iu11<1li s111

t11 at

rc li gion

th an to IJe i11 vé1r ialJ ly

( jl...! 1I C I i J t l.!~1. ' '

43 - - -- - - - - - - -

- ------


Jan. 27 , 197 1, fro m Potter to Bog an. ex p 1·essing r egre t th at Bo g<.1 rt in te1·pre t ed t h e group as having a prec o n ce ived position, .1ssu r ing hi m th a t th is is not tr u e, and ex pl ai ni ng t h e ob j ective of til e Pane l. Jan . 2 2, 1971, fro m F ra nc isc o Apo n t e · Perez , P1·esid en t of t h e Bu r As·; oc ia t io n o f Pu ert o Ri co, t o Pott er , th ankin g him for h is le t tc 1· o f Jan . 14, st ating hi s p leasure at m ee t i ng Potte r , and assu r in g h im of t h e Co leg i o's pl eas u re in aiclin g i n th e p r ep ai-a ti o n o f th e h ea ri ngs . JJ 11. 2 7. 197 1, from Potter t o Ap o nt e · Pere z, t h an k i ng hi m for all of th e co u rt es i es ex t end ed i n th e ca rry i ng out of t h e hear ings. 18.

Ag end <.1 for th e h ea 1·ings.

19 .

W ri tt en c op ies of t h e t es timony o f th e fo l low ing:

Lic . Angel G. Hermid a, Prof essor of L aw at th e U n iv ers ity of Pu erto R ico . (T h i s is a copy of th e Bar A ssoci ati on r eso lut ion to th e gov ernment . In Sp an i sh . And a book on Mining i n Pu erto R ico . I n Spa n ish .)

Prof. Jaro M ayd a, L aw Prof ess or at th e Univ . o f Pu ert o Ri co . Sr . Pedro M ato s M ato s, insuran ce m an fr o m U tu ad o. Mr. Morri s Moses, econom ist w it h th e Pu erto R ican D evelopment Group , a co nsult in g firm . T ab les p rese nted .

Sr.

Pedro

A.

Gelabert ,

Exec ut ive

Sec re t ary

of

th e

M in ing

Co mm iss io n of Pu erto Ri co .

Mr. Lawrence Hill, Presid ent, t h e N atura l Hi sto ry Soc ie ty of Pu er t o Rico .

Sr.

Pedro Ba ij es Ch apel, A u x i li ary Sec ret ary G en eral of th e

Movem ent f o r lnd ep end ence . (Testimo n y i n Spa n ish)

Dr. M ax imo Ceram e Viv as, M ar i n e Eco log ist . Sr . lrvin T ores Tores , so c i o log ist from U tu ado, st aff m emb er of PR ISA . T es t i m o ny i n ro u gh dr aft fo r m . D r. O swa ldo Ra mi rez To rres , Ch em i st . (4 3 p ages of t ec hn ical inform at i o n in Spa n i sh.)

44 - - - -- - - - - - - -- - - - - - -


Consumers Research lnstitute of U . P. R., tcible copiecl from the company proposal to the government ancl a t ab le prepared by them. (In Span ish.) Sr. Ramon R. Rodreguez, Jr., Presid ent, BORINOUEN ASICUADIS, lnc. (In Spanish.)

ISLENOS

DE

: 1 Dr. Jose Francisco mathematics at the (The only part of quote he used from Sr. Benjamin 1 ndustrial de submitted

Dacilla, Professor of geology, geography, and University of Puerto Rico. his testimony that we have is a copy of the a publication of VISION, lnc.)

Ortiz Belaval, Associate Director of Mision Puerto Rico. (Not complete testimony. H e

newspaper

articles

and

other

publications

which

:;upported his testimony including the proposed plan for the agricultura! development of the area. In Spanish and English with a summary translation in English .) Reginald P. Briggs, Environmental Geologi st. Mr. Marc Messing, F riends of the Earth. 20 .

Copy of the Mining Laws of Puerto Rico.

21.

Report of Dr. David Brook s, Min era l Economi st to the Panel.

22.

Report of Dr . Rafael Ramire z, Social Anthropologist to the Panel.

(The above listed clocuments are avai lable from NIM, 10600 Purit an, Detroit, Michigan 48238, (313) 342-4414, at cost.) 23 .

Copy of the latest proposal by the companies of the Government of PJerto Rico .

45


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Church Panel on Copper Mining in Puerto Rico (1971) by La Colección Puertorriqueña - Issuu