BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT

Mock Trial Develops Skills—and Friendships—That Will Last a Lifetime

By Heidi Atwell

Each year, hundreds of nervous teenagers stand before judges and attorneys in courtrooms across the state, palms sweating and hearts racing, ready to plead their case. No, it’s not a rise in juvenile delinquency. It’s the regional

High School Mock Trial Competition.

In early fall, North Carolina high school teams are given a fictional case, complete with affidavits and exhibits. They spend the next several months working together to build and present their cases, with some students acting as attorneys and others portraying witnesses. “It’s a mix of acting and debate, but pumped with steroids, and set in a real courtroom,” says Central Carolina Homeschoolers coach Darren Allen, a District Court Judge in Randolph County.

After months of practicing and fine-tuning their arguments, approximately 90 teams come together to compete in 10 regionals across the state, with the 10 regional champions plus two at-large teams moving on to the state competition. The state champion then advances to compete against over forty other state champions at the National High School Mock Trial Championship.

“My favorite part of mock trial has been the team. I found a really great community within the team.”

In its 11-year history, under the leadership of Coach Allen, the Central Carolina Homeschool (CCH) mock trial team has been one of the strongest and most consistent teams in the country. Their teams have won 6 state championships, finishing in the top 10 nationally 5 times. In 2017, the Central Carolina Homeschoolers were crowned National Champions.

They’ve also won several pre-season tournaments, including tournaments at Yale University, and their students have earned dozens of individual outstanding witness and attorney awards.

“I’ve been blessed to coach dozens of amazingly talented kids. It’s so rewarding watching kids—especially those who struggle early— develop their confidence, and then use that confidence to thrive under pressure.”

While the CCH mock trial team has an incredible list of accolades, their value lies in their faith and their witness to others. Team members take turns sharing a verse or devotion before each practice, and have a time of worship and prayer before each competition. They go into the competitions with the attitude that no matter what happens in the courtroom, their main purpose is to glorify God and treat their competition with respect and kindness. In 2019, the Central Carolina Homeschoolers won the national Larry Bakko Award for Professionalism and Civility in competition, voted upon by the other student-competitors. “It’s a testament to the character of these kids that they can go out in a diverse field of over 500 students from all over the country and stand out for their kindness,” says Coach Allen. Few extracurricular activities offer the level of intellectual stimulation, critical thinking, and personal growth that high school mock trial programs provide. “I’m a big fan of sports, but there is no comparison between the benefits of sports and the benefits of mock trial,” according to Coach Allen. “The skills developed in mock trial can be applied to every facet of life, no matter what career path a student takes. Few people will go on to dribble a ball for a living. Everyone needs to communicate and persuade.”

Coach Allen emphasizes, “Mock trial isn’t just for future lawyers. In my time as a coach, I have only coached a handful of future lawyers. I’ve coached many more kids who chose a different path: businessmen and businesswomen, actresses, doctors, pharmacists, teachers, ministers, surveyors, secretaries, moms—you name it.” Listed below are some of the benefits of mock trial.

Knowledge of the Legal System

Public Speaking and Communication

One of the most valuable skills fostered by mock trial is effective public speaking. Attorneys are required to present opening statements, conduct direct and cross-examinations, and deliver closing arguments. Witnesses must answer questions clearly and conversationally while making eye contact with the jury. All team members must be aware of their non-verbal communication and how they present themselves.

This cultivates confidence, eloquence, and the ability to articulate thoughts clearly—skills that will be invaluable in future college and job interviews and are indispensable in any profession.

Through the analysis of case law and crafting of arguments, participants acquire a firsthand appreciation for the complexities of law. Whether a witness or an attorney, students will learn more about our legal system than they even realize. Real law is built into the cases in such a way that it is broken down into small manageable parts and then explained and applied to the case. Occasionally the mock trial experience even sparks an interest in pursuing legal studies or related fields in the future.

Critical Thinking and Problem-Solving

Mock trial helps students develop critical thinking and problem-solving skills. Participants must analyze evidence, anticipate opposing arguments, and craft compelling rebuttals. Mock trial hones the ability to see multiple perspectives, strengthening their capacity to make informed decisions in various aspects of life. Students must also learn to be adaptable. Participants often experience unexpected developments during the proceedings and students have to roll with the punches and handle mistakes with grace. “Probably the most important skill to develop is the courage to keep going when things get tough,” says Coach Allen.

Teamwork, Leadership, and Friendship

High school mock trial is a team effort. Participants must work together to create a cohesive legal strategy, synchronize their arguments, and support each other during the intense competition. This collaborative atmosphere teaches students the importance of teamwork, compromise, and effective communication—skills that are fundamental in both personal and professional relationships. The Central Carolina Homeschoolers has had three students win the statewide scholarship for recognition for Inspirational Team Leadership.

“My advice to anyone thinking of joining the mock trial team is to believe in yourself. You’re capable of so much more than you think!”

—Haley Kramer

Most importantly, the CCH mock trial team is like a family. Seniors hang out with freshmen, not because they have to, but because they want to. Team members go out for dinner together after practices and get together for social activities throughout the year, building relationships that will last a lifetime. n

The CCH mock trial team is currently gearing up for their 2023-2024 academic season. Practices are held in Asheboro. If you are interested in being a part of the team, contact Coach Allen at dcallen07@gmail.com to determine your eligibility.