iATHOLIC
Aavasn nosum
0£6£
NOII33l"i03
3N
News & Herald
lzcoo-sgi-
g Catholics
in
Western North Carolina
Volume
in the Diocese of Charlotte
1
Number 31
April 10, 1992
•
epare Ye The Way.
On
Anti-Catholic Bias Alleged
Of Protestant Preschool
Part
Director
By JOANN KEANE Associate Editor
CHARLOTTE
—
Phones were ringand conversations buzzed following a
news report of alleged religious discrimina-
Church has asked Central Piedmont Community College to replace an early childhood instructor the school was supplying as
tion at a Charlotte non-denominational
a teacher
Church.
ity)
ing,
The Charlotte Observer first reported Piedmont Community College
that Central
was ending
its
teaching relationship with
Calvary Church, following a church daycare official's refusal to allow a Catholic
work with their staff. The controversy began as Calvary's
teacher to
school director, Pat Collins, stated her pref-
erence for a "Christian Protestant" to
fulfill
the third-party training of her teachers.
The discriminatory remark spurred angry reaction in the Catholic community. ve-year-old Elizabeth frican
Palm
Osbom
helps her grandmother, Elizabeth Haubenreiser, sort through the
crosses that will be distributed at St. Patrick Cathedral in Charlotte
ne crosses are
handmade
in several villages in the
on Palm Sunday,
Photo by
he would
like to
lot
mend
the
rift.
But the
rift
of work.
take his child out of Calvary's day school
Sues
\bortionist r
By
Pro-Life Activists
Greensboro
or Picketing
Home
ill
and Linda Winfield's
life
at the local
Today, :tive
it
centered
on
evolves around taking an
ful, non-violent picketing on a public street can be prohibited," says attorney Art
for U.S.
a candidate
are outraged
by
the
ing, since they did not
hundreds of unborn
chil-
each week in the Greensboro
The preliminary injunction, which was is
the
first
my
look like the person
Kaplan
such legal action
may
he
is this is
not a discrimination
is
he
"The irony is
who has done wrong."
not be breaking man's
four
set the callers'
minds in motion. "I would guess half or more were talking about that subject either directly or indirectly," said Boggan. About half way through his morning show, Boggan was able to reach Rhoads for on-air comments. Rhoads was quick to say that neither he nor his congregation are anti-Catholic and that it was not a discrimination issue. In light of the Calvary situation,
some
parents are questioning their decision to
couple,
One who wish to remain anonymous, is
distressed over their choice of schools since
reading of Ring's situation. It ' s adifficult situation they face;
they ve '
been pleased with the care their child has received at the AA-rated day school. But, in their
minds, they cannot reconcile the injus-
tice.
"It's
a matter of principle," said the
"Our perception of
preschooler's father.
Calvary preschool was that as non-denominational, there
would be no discrimination That's the surprise, to
faith.
find discrimination in
how you
practice
Christianity."
FatherEdSheridan,pastorofSt. Gabriel in Charlotte, said
it
is
the responsibility of
parents to be aware of all the events involv-
says.
Collins could not be reached for
are guilty for
praying and carrying signs, then what guilty of?" asks Bill Winfield.
heart
propounded as he
of Christian
com-
ing their children's education,
early
bulletin,
ment.
that we're being hauled to court and made to
lea.
development
affiliation.
Rhoads says Calvary Church does not discriminate in its hiring practices and has several Catholics on staff. "What hurts me issue,"
we
early childhood
based on her religious
were escorted to and from picketing sites by "If he (Kaplan) says
perform her duties as an instructor
CPCC's
for
break any laws and
police.
couple say they will continue to be
[sued Feb. 20,
ability to
in
em from peaceful picketing on the street 'a physician who performs abortions, the
lien killed
is
was denied the
Parish in Charlotte, said she
charges, especially extortion and racketeer-
Despite an unusual injunction barring
atholic
it
Supreme Court review."
The Winfields
stand against abortion and fighting a
jitnesses for the
The injunction says that peaceful, law-
Donaldson. "In that respect,
country club.
gal battle for their efforts.
I
'
years ago,
imbing the ladders of the world and playg tennis
topics
Kathleen Ring, a member of St. Gabriel
Associate Editor
— Three
to
work together instead of fueling bigotry. The story prompted a flurry of listener reaction to a radio talk show host who brought up the stoiy as well as several irate letters to The Charlotte Observer.
CAROL HAZARD
GREENSBORO
Another said churches need
program.
(facil-
Do you want
send children to Calvary preschool.
One Catholic parent says he's going to
JOANN KEANE
non-denominational
comment?" Boggan 's question was one of
Rev. Ross Rhoads, pastor of Calvary, said needs a
Diocese of Masasi in Tanzania.
to
at the
because she was Catholic.
CPCC's
Ring, an instructor for
no matter which school they choose. In the Sunday he reminds parents of their duty as
childhood education program and an em-
primary educators of children to fully un-
ployee of the community college, had been
derstand the teaching methods and curricu-
assigned to Calvary, but had not yet begun
lums offered by schools.
formal instruction.
When
Collins discov-
ered Ring was a Catholic, she refused Ring s '
Iken in North Carolina and one of only a lindful
of similar, yet unresolved cases
In granting the injunction, Guilford
lounty Superior Court Judge Thomas Ross lid he felt "the privacy of one's
protected
own home
is
expertise,
breakingGod'slawsand"he will bejudged," says Bill Winfield. "What's
Irtionwide.
|i
laws in killing unborn babies; but he
tant?
able
Ring say s a chance meeting with Collins
more impor-
To keep him from feeling uncomfortin his home or keep him from killing
based on Catholicism.
at
a local high school basketball
game
babies."
"We pursued conversation, and (Collins) acted excited about the CPCC program for
By
leveling the racketeering charge,
her teachers.' During the conversation, Ring '
ng" f The
injunction bans the Winfields
and
her pro-life activists from marching within
Kaplan is putting the Winfields on the same preposterous level as convicted Mafia leader John
Gotti, Winfield says.
of Dr. Richard Kaplan,
The charge is absurd, says Walter Weber
and gynecologist who perims abortions at a Greensboro clinic. Kaplan has sued the Winfields for
of Free Speech Advocates, a national pro-
trrassment, private nuisance, public nui-
First Amendment rights and legitimate forms
nce, intentional infliction of emotional
of protest," he says.
X) feet of the street l
obstetrician
stress,
and extortion and rackpering. He has asked for unspecified monary compensation for damages, punitive images, triple damages and attorney fees well as a permanent injunction against the [o-lifers.
The case involves
First
Amendment
pies of free speech, and consequently, has potential for being heard in the U.S.
upreme Court, say attorneys for the 'infields.
"To apply damages and
mentioned her Catholicism.
"When
is
calls
were not
finally
made phone con-
Collins told her she wanted a "Chris-
life,"
says Alan
Duncan of Smith, Helms, Mulliss and Moore. Kaplan could not be reached for
comment. The law suit was filed after the Winfields and several other pro-lifers picketed for 45
Ring's emotions ran the gamut as came over the phone
minutes a day for three consecutive days
See Sue, Page
1
Ring said "Collins admitted a mistake that (Collins) should have gone
was made;
to a Christian college, not a public institution, to obtain training instructors." "It's
urging that
illegal
handguns be turned
in to
The
religious leaders said
should be turned
in
Mother's Day, May
Day
will
during the 10.
handguns
week before
They said Mother's
be a special day of prayer for the
a grave injustice to
me
and the
Catholic community. Calvary Church out
and out discriminated towards me," said Ring.
Local talk show host, Henry Boggan to his listeners, "Calvary
posed the question
society.
The
actions
came at the request of San
Antonio Mayor Nelson Wolff after a three-
Collins' statement
about impermissible intrusion
Kaplan's private home
San
family and for an end to violence in our
When Ring tian Protestant."
to litigate the case in the newspaper.
—
(CNS)
religious leaders of other denominations in
make arrangements
phone
Ring.
line.
into
my
At that point, I knew something was wrong, that I was not wanted," said
Kaplan's attorney says he does not "This case
called to
SAN ANTONIO
Antonio's Catholic bishops have joined
the city.
returned.
tact,
want
I
with Calvary,
injunctions againt the Winfields cuts into
invasion of privacy, interference
1th civil rights,
le
life legal project.
Anti-Gun Campaign
seated her next to the Calvary school director.
from this kind of targeted pick-
Texas Bishops Join
week campaign by the city to get people to turn in illegal weapons brought in only 20 guns.
Bishop Edmond Carmody, the former San Antonio auxiliary who was recently named bishop of Tyler, Texas, said something has to be done to make parents aware of what their children are doing. "Parents must take this deadly temptation away from their children," he said. See Guns,