THANKSGIVING 2026 CATERING MENU
ATTENTION CARLINO'S CUSTOMERS Prices: Pricing and availability of all menu items are subject to change without notice or reprinting of the menu due to unforeseen cost increases of domestic and imported products and materials used to pack items for transport. For the most current pricing, please visit www.carlinosmarket.com or call us at 610.649.4046. Orders & Cancellations: All orders over $100 require credit card payment to secure the order. The card will be charged on the day of the pick-up. We offer pick-up in-store at both locations. Please place your order with the store you intend to pick-up at. We understand that things change and accept changes and cancellations up to 48 hours in advance with no charge. Orders or parts of orders that are canceled within 48 hours of pick-up will be subject to a 50% cancellation fee. Online cancellation requests must receive a reply email from us to be considered valid. Allergies & Dietary Accommodations: Our chefs, owners, and staff take allergies very seriously. Carlino’s is NOT a nut-free, glutenfree, wheat-free, dairy-free, seed-free, soy-free facility. Many of our foods contain one or more common allergens. It is crucial that if you have severe allergies, you understand that there is a risk of cross-contamination despite our best efforts due to the presence of these items in our facility. We can and will do our best to accommodate any allergies or sensitivities as long as we are made aware of the allergies. Please work with one of our order specialists to decide the best course of action for planning a menu around allergens. For a complete list of our ordering FAQs, please visit www.carlinosmarket.com. Contact us at 610.649.4046 with any questions.
24 Hours Notice is Appreciated
TABLE of CONTENTS ALL NATUR AL SOUPS, C HEESE & ANTIPASTI ...................................
4
TR ADITIONAL HOLIDAY MAIN COURSES ............................................
6 SIDES & ACCOMPANIMENTS .................. 10 HOMEMADE BAKED GOODS & DESSERTS ................................................
13
HOMEMADE BREADS ................................
14
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ................................................
15
ALL-NATURAL SOUPS Roasted Butternut Squash Soup (vg wf df)
Roasted butternut squash, potatoes, celery, carrots, onions, shallots, vegetable stock .............................................................................................................................................. $14.99/qt (serves 2-4)
Traditional Holiday Soup
Classic “wedding” soup with escarole, chicken, pastina, chicken stock, and baby beef meatballs .............................................................................................................................................. $15.99/qt (serves 2-4)
CHEESE & ANTIPASTI Pair with Amédée II Était Une Fois Luberon Rosé, Cassarà Kilim Rosso
Brandied Cranberry Baked Brie en Croûte
French brie filled with brandied cranberry & orange pepper jam, Dijon mustard, fresh rosemary, and enrobed in buttery puff pastry, parbaked; simply reheat, bake, and serve warm with fresh baguette or crackers *does not include bread or crackers
............................................................................................................................. $19.99 (8oz brie - serves up to 6)
Harvest Party Board
French brie topped with cranberry, Mustard Seed Gouda, 24-month Parmigiano Reggiano, Aged Cheddar, pumpkin ricotta spread, Wensleydale cheddar with cranberries, sweet & hot soppressata, Genoa salami, rustic crackers, Marcona almonds, dried fruit, Italian mixed olives, fig jam, honey, decorated with fresh seasonal garnish ......................................................................................................................... $124.99 (one size - serves up to 12)
Roasted Butternut Squash Soup
4 | www.carlinosmarket.com
610.649.4046
v (vegetarian) | vg (vegan) | wf (wheat free) | df (dairy free) | k (kosher)
Harvest Party Board
610.649.4046 | www.carlinosmarket.com | 5
TRADITIONAL HOLIDAY MAIN COURSES *Our turkeys are locally raised, family-farmed, non-GMO, vegetarian-fed, and humanely handled Pair with Amédeé Pinot Noir, Tilli Concetto Pecorino
Whole Herb-Roasted Turkey
Locally raised, family-farmed, non-GMO, vegetarian-fed, all-natural, and antibiotic-free whole turkey, brined and rubbed with Carlino’s signature blend of herbs and seasonings, homemade turkey gravy on the side (2 quarts) *Served whole, fully cooked, and ready to heat
.................................................................................................. $190.00 (20-22 lbs, serves up to 20 with leftovers)
Boneless Turkey Breast
All-natural turkey breast, brined and seasoned with fresh herbs, roasted to perfection and served whole with Carlino’s homemade turkey gravy on the side (2 quarts) *Served whole, fully cooked, and ready to heat
................................................................................................................... $175.00 (serves up to 20 with leftovers)
Sliced Boneless Turkey Breast
All-natural turkey breast, brined and seasoned with fresh herbs, slow-roasted, sliced, and served with Carlino’s homemade turkey gravy on the side (1 quart) *Served whole, fully cooked, and ready to heat
................................................................................................................................. $89.00 (5 lbs, serves up to 12)
Holiday Extras Cranberry Relish (vg wf df)
Whole cranberries, orange peel and juice ........................................................ $7.99/pt (16oz)
All-Natural Turkey Gravy
Natural turkey drippings, butter, fresh herbs, flour ........................................................ $8.99/qt (32oz)
Sliced Boneless Turkey Breast
6 | www.carlinosmarket.com
610.649.4046
v (vegetarian) | vg (vegan) | wf (wheat free) | df (dairy free) | k (kosher)
Cranberry Relish
Whole Herb-Roasted Turkey
All-Natural Turkey Gravy
610.649.4046 | www.carlinosmarket.com | 7
Sliced Boneles Turkey Breast All-Natural Turkey Gravy
Cranberry Relish
8 | www.carlinosmarket.com
610.649.4046
v (vegetarian) | vg (vegan) | wf (wheat free) | df (dairy free) | k (kosher)
Roasted Brussels Sprouts
Garlic & Shallot Mashed Potatoes
ss
Whole Herb-Roasted Turkey
Traditional Italian Sausage Stuffing
610.649.4046 | www.carlinosmarket.com | 9
SIDES & ACCOMPANIMENTS (One size, serves up to 8)
Traditional Italian Sausage Stuffing
Roasted Root Vegetables (vg wf df)
Homemade focaccia bread, chicken stock, celery, carrots, onions, butter, extra virgin olive oil, avocado oil, homemade Italian pork sausage, signature seasoning blend, fresh herbs ....................................................................... $34.99
Garlic & Shallot Mashed Potatoes (v wf)
Pair with Cassarà Jacaranda, Milo Malbec Estate
Signature Cranberry Stuffing
Homemade focaccia bread, chicken stock, celery, carrots, onions, butter, extra virgin olive oil, avocado oil, dried cranberries, fresh herbs ....................................................................... $34.99
Holiday Grown-Up Mac N' Cheese (v)
Carlino’s organic treccioni pasta, signature imported cheese blend, house focaccia croutons, baked to golden ....................................................................... $34.99
Autumn Quinoa Bowl (vg wf)
Quinoa, sweet potato, radicchio, celery, green onion, pomegranate arils, pepitas, fresh Italian parsley, maple and apple cider vinaigrette *served chilled or warmed
....................................................................... $42.99
Beets, parsnips, butternut squash, rutabaga, and turnips slow-roasted with a medley of fresh herbs and olive oil ....................................................................... $39.99
Whipped russet potatoes blended with roasted garlic, shallots, butter, cream, and fresh herbs, seasoned with sea salt and cracked black pepper ....................................................................... $32.99
Roasted Sweet Potatoes (vg wf df) Pair with Milo Blanc de Blancs Reserve
Skin-on sweet potatoes, bell peppers, and sweet onions, seasoned with rosemary, garlic, extra virgin olive oil, and oven-roasted with white wine ....................................................................... $32.99
Roasted Brussels Sprouts (vg wf df)
Roasted Brussels sprouts tossed with dried cranberries, walnuts, extra virgin olive oil, avocado oil, sea salt, and cracked black pepper. ....................................................................... $42.99
Roasted Brussels Sprouts
Roasted Sweet Potatoes
10 | www.carlinosmarket.com
610.649.4046
v (vegetarian) | vg (vegan) | wf (wheat free) | df (dairy free) | k (kosher)
Garlic & Shallot Mashed Potatoes
Traditional Italian Sausage Stuffing
Roasted Root Vegetables
610.649.4046 | www.carlinosmarket.com | 11
Old Fashioned Lattice Apple Pie
Pumpkin Pie
New! Caramel Apple Pecan Pie
12 | www.carlinosmarket.com
610.649.4046
v (vegetarian) | vg (vegan) | wf (wheat free) | df (dairy free) | k (kosher)
HOMEMADE BAKED GOODS & DESSERTS Homemade Desserts Thanksgiving Sweets Tray
A festive assortment of chocolate chip cookies, pumpkin crinkle cookies, gingersnaps, pumpkin spice cake bites, caramel-iced brownie bites, and white chocolate-covered pretzels ..................................... $56.99 (one size - 32 pieces)
Pumpkin Cheesecake
New York–style spiced pumpkin cheesecake, chocolate cookie crumb crust, topped with chocolate fudge and chocolate decor ........................................ $29.99 (6" - serves up to 8)
Old Fashioned Handmade Pies Pumpkin Pie
Pair with Angela's Rosé Spumante
Pumpkin spiced with cinnamon, ginger, cloves, maple whipped cream ......................................... $24.99 (10" - serves 8-12)
Old Fashioned Lattice Apple Pie
Fresh apples, cinnamon, a touch of nutmeg, flaky lattice crust ............................................ $26.99 (9" - serves 8-12)
New! Caramel Apple Pecan Pie
Fresh apples, cinnamon, toasted pecans, buttery caramel, flaky double crust ............................................ $29.99 (9" - serves 8-12)
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie
A decadent dark chocolate, pecan, and bourbon filling, buttery crust ............................................ $29.99 (9" - serves 8-12)
Pumpkin Cheesecake
610.649.4046 | www.carlinosmarket.com | 13
HOMEMADE BREADS Harvest Cornbread (v)
Classic buttermilk cornbread made with roasted corn kernels ...................................................... $7.99 (serves 6-8)
Parker House Rolls (v)
Cranberry Walnut Bread (v)
Rustic round loaf made with a blend of whole grain and unbleached white flours, cranberries, and toasted walnuts ......................................................................... $8.99
Premium red winter wheat white flour, potato, butter, and sea salt .............................................................. $7.80/dozen
Cranberry Walnut Bread Harvest Cornbread
14 | www.carlinosmarket.com
610.649.4046
v (vegetarian) | vg (vegan) | wf (wheat free) | df (dairy free) | k (kosher)
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS How big is the turkey?
We cannot guarantee the weight of the turkeys until they are in our kitchens. The bird will weigh between 20 and 22 pounds, serving up to 20 guests.
If it says wheat free, does that mean the item is gluten free?
No. Our items labeled wheat-free do not contain gluten, but they are NOT made in a gluten-free facility. There is a risk of cross-contamination.
Do you offer delivery?
We are unable to accommodate deliveries during the holiday season. Pre-ordered items must be picked up at our stores.
What is your cancellation policy?
Orders or parts of orders canceled within 48 hours of pick-up will incur a 50% cancellation fee. Online cancellation requests must receive a reply email from us to be considered valid.
When is the earliest pick-up?
The earliest pick-up is 10:00 am. Orders must be picked up within the time slot selected when you place your order. Please refrain from picking up your order sooner than your selected time slot.
How do I reheat the food?
Visit our website and select "Reheating Instructions" under the Catering section. You can also scan here to see our Thanksgiving Menu Reheating Instructions.
610.649.4046 | www.carlinosmarket.com | 15
All seasonal items are made in small batches. Please pre-order to ensure availability. Pre-Order by November 19th, or until we reach capacity, for in-store pickup November 23rd–25th, 2026. Thanksgiving holiday items are available in-store on Monday, November 23rd–25th. Our markets will be closed on Thanksgiving Day.
2616 E. County Line Rd. Ardmore, PA 19003 128 W. Market St. West Chester, PA 19382 www.carlinosmarket.com | 610.649.4046