Compensation in the family business

By Norbert E. Schwarz

can be more easily accepted because they are based on non-emotional, rational criteria. What can be a very personal issue is thus depersonalized.

viduals often believe their own jobs to be more important and therefore worth more. Generally, this philosophy tends to favor those in lesser positions and may demotivate those aspiring to greater responsibilities and rewards.

While this method might seem feasible for a second generation of two or three siblings and two parents, as the family grows and generations pass, few companies can financially support equal pay for a growing base of cousins. Equal pay may also tend to encourage entitlement. Moreover, the distinction between rewards for ownership and those for performance can be distorted.

Flexible Pay

fN DEVELOPING policy concernIing compensation for family members, the first step is to adopt a compensation philosophy, the principles that guide compensation decisions. Generally speaking, there are four basic compensation philosophies: market pay, equal pay, flexible pay or tailored pay. Each approach has its pros and cons.

Market Pay

With a philosophy of market pay, compensation is determined by breaking down jobs into various elements that are graded in terms of value. Compensation is generally based on the difficulty of the job, as well as the background and experience necessary to function in the position. Positions normally are assigned a salary range with low, midpoint and high indicated levels. The assumption is that an individual may begin at the low point and progress to the high point if he or she is performing well in the position.

Compensation is based on what similar companies are paying for similar positions, comparing geographical area. industry and company size. Thus, pay is determined by merit within a market. In addition to base salary, some studies also give information on performance-based compensation such as bonuses and stock options.

The market pay philosophy tends to eliminate subjective judgment from the process. Compensation decisions

What market pay does not, however, take into account is unique individual contributions to an overall effort, longevity, or a company's capacity to pay competitive wages. Nor are other perks and benefits taken into account, although some studies do include information on benefits normally available. In a family business, this approach does not accommodate the concept of equality for family members, nor does it take individual needs into account.

Finally, it would not take into account a family owner's desire to pay less or more than market standards.

Equal Pay

Some family businesses believe in equal pay for all. All jobs held by family owners get the same amount of pay. regardless o[ position or complexity (sometimes pay is adjusted for longevity).

Those who adopt this philosophy generally place equality at the top of their priorities. Their belief is that the business exists for the benefit of the family, and every family member should benefit equally. In multifamily companies, this philosophy may also tend to minimize conflict between families due to perceptions of compensation favoritism. This philosophy tends to work best when family members have very similar responsibilities and contribute equally to the success of the overall business.

The downside of this philosophy comes when positions do not carry equal responsibilities or impact on the overall success of the business. Even in cases where jobs are similar, indi-

This philosophy relates to compensation determined by a board or individual based on a variety of factors. Some companies that use this method maintain that it provides greater flexibility and allows subjective factors as well as objective methods to be used in determining compensation.

This method will frequently combine market study information with individual company cultural measures to arrive at compensation. It also allows for the family to make allowances for differing needs within its ranks. Many family business owners tend to favor this method because of the flexibility and authority it offers the senior manager or board.

In cases where the decision-making authority rests with an individual, such as with a parent, perceived favoritism can cause conflict with the parent as well as within the family. The parent is placed at the center of this sensitive issue, with a very real prospect of being the source of family disharmony. In many cases, final decisions are arrived at through individual negotiation, which increases perception of lack of fairness.

Likewise, because the family system is based in part on equality and in part on emotionally based decision making, justification of individual compensation becomes difficult.

Tailored Pay

In some cases, we have seen companies that have combined various factors to determine compensation. To accommodate the desire to support all family members of the coming generation, a base dividend or related compensation is set at a level that enhances the standard of living and can be distributed consistently year to

\ cirr. Thc ilnroLlnt rs gcncIullr kr-pt

Iori crroLLgh tLr lri irirl thc tlcr clopnrr-rrt ol lr se nsc o1 cntitlcnrcnt. l ltorc cnrl)l()\ctl in llre brrsilte\\ lt'ecl\c sillufics tllilt irrc rietcr-nrinctl lrr nlrlkct conrlitions. lhcr lLlso lcecirc |cllor'- lliutcc eontItnslLliorr blr:ctl trn lLuhicr in! pe i'sonrLl !olLls. l: ri cll lL: ()lr lhc or cr-lll pe r-lirnlrne c ol thc e onrplLrrr

Itutr'1irc Ilttlilr nrcnrbcr': lrl:o nrlrr lllrr. :tlr r'l)1r,'111111111 lrr l).rt li. i1,;11. 1', i \r'\'l)lit,ll:l| .,'irll\,1ll\ l),1 |r,lltlitll. r' tlrlorrglr c\llri rli\ itlcntls ol tli:tlitrrr tiorrs.

Ilclirlc lllr\ l)llilo\()l)lrr i: rLLloPtctl. thc holtt-rl illtrl \aniof nlulirgcl: :hrrLrlrl ll tl(ler'\l,lttrl .lt:rt. lt,rl.lr't t \ lrr'. l,rl ir rll. ln(l gLlirlclincr 1or contllcrtrlLtion. Il' r,rn|cali\tic ()r' i)()tcntiullr rlctlinrcntal guiclclrrtcs crrst. tirc bourrl rhoulcl nesotiate an iicccl)tablr- solutlon \\ itlr shareirolclcrr.

Nortc- ol thc lirlcgoinc philostrphics i: gtutt'ltntccrl 1o elirlinlite ri i:scnt rr itlrin thc rrrnk: ol tlrc Iltntilr. Onc cltn onlt stlire tLr nrininri,rc urrnlliet iLri s i ng l'rtrn'r conrpcnsltion.

I)crhirps thc nrost l)()tcnt tool lirr' rttinirrtrzing conl'lict is tLr cllrlil'r llrntil,r r ulucs utttl plrilo;oplrr tolr riltl titc bttsutcss urttl 1o ccluclrte thc llrntilr on tlrc concel)t ol conrpcn:ulion. \ltinlLenlcnt ln(l tltc bolrnl slrorrlrl lLlso rrnrlcr' stltnrl tlrc relrlistie o\l)cetlrtions oj sluLr-clroltlcls Iol dir irlcnrls lrntl tltc l)f()\l)cel lilt- lIt lrceclttlrirlc int|cl:t irt rrrlrrc lirr' (hcil irtrc\tllaltt. NllLnlL!litrrt cr.pccllrtiorrs lrntl lintitin!, lLttrturlcs ol' cr)trtlcnrclll clrn bc llrc nro:1 cl'lce tir c ttto]s irt nrotir utinq rrunrr!crncnt lintl tcu lt trl inl shltrcholtlcrr l'or- tlrcir' Plrtrclrt PrrrVision ol cuIitul.

!)t. .\t ltttttt, is Lt tt'nirtt tttlt islt r,l 'l ltt l:Ltrttilt Iitr.tirtt s\ ( ()n\ultin< (;t t)ul) Ittt.. ,\lttt'it'1ttt. (itr (,\l)()t .:.;l ()6.1.1 ll( ttttt ltt rtrtt ltcd ul .st lttur:GL tlttntiltbttti n(\.\.(ont. Iltltt'itttt'tl t itlt 1tt'nttlssittrt lt ont Tltt' l- titrtil.t 1Jil.rile.r.r .lrArlrl., r1 1 r,1tt t i,4ItIt't! ltrrltlit tttit)n ()l l:ttntil\ l,ntt r'1tt itt I'tthli:ltct s. Ntt ltttt tit,tt t)l tlti\ ttt ti( lt nt(t\ ltt' t t'1tt 0tlttt t'tl t illtttttt l)( t Dt i \slrttt t,l I trntilt Lrttt'r'1tri:t' I'trltli:ltr,

Ffeseru'r - '2s,.40 and .Go

Boratetreated wood

13702 Blh Street East Sumner, WA 98390 253-863-4495. FAX 253-863-.1037 v/ww su periorwoodtreatin g co m