BUDGET 2024 Discussion Draft NOVEMB ER 29, 2023
INTRODUCTION The proposed Federation budget reflects two significant changes: 1) The fiscal year has been changed from November 1 - October 31 to January 1 - December 31, and 2) rather than align with the Community Impact Areas as was done the previous 4 years, it is built and presented based on the organization’s Strategic Priorities for 2024 as discussed previously by the board. As a result, there is no side by side comparison with Fiscal 2023 but when we are able, the narrative underscores significant changes in FY 24 from the previous year. When combined, we are able to show the impact of our Campaign for Jewish Buffalo underscoring how these funds are used toward achieving our mission to inspire, collaborate, lead and enrich our Jewish community in Buffalo, in Israel and around the world. The budget is presented as a recommendation of the Finance Committee to the Board of Governors for approval on November 29, 2023. The pages that follow provide details on total revenue available to Federation to allocate, an overview of expenses and revenue and a breakdown of expense following the format of the Strategic Priorities worksheet.
Page 2
TOTAL FEDERATION REVENUE We begin the budgeting process each year by looking at our cash position and the total revenue available for operations and grants. The sources of revenue are net campaign funds, investment funds, grants, fees and restricted funds for overseas grants. Despite our community decreasing in size, we have done an excellent job maintaining the Campaign for Jewish Buffalo. However, as our community continues to age and we are not able to replace the loss of major donors at equal levels, we are anticipating $100,000 less of funds in 2024 coming from campaign dollars. One of our goals for this year is for Federation to rely less on campaign funds internally so that we can keep agency funding level. Click HERE for more campaign donor detail. The total revenue we estimate for FY 24 is $3,390,200. The following provides a detailed breakdown:
Campaign Fund Revenue Available Funds for Grants
$2,000,000
Other Restricted Campaign Funds Funds for JFNA Dues Benderson Funds (to be determined by family) Total Restricted Campaign Funds Sub Total Campaign
$88,433 $350,000 $438,433 $2,438,433
Other Federation Revenue Investment Funds Distribution
$783,000
Additional Revenue (Grants, Fees, Other Fundraising)
$565,200
Restricted Funds for Overseas Grants
$102,000
Sub Total Other
$1,450,200
TOTAL FEDERATION REVENUE
$3,888,633
Restricted Campaign Funds
($438,433)
Campaign Write Offs
($60,000)
TOTAL AVAILABLE FEDERATION REVENUE
Of the total revenue, the Benderson Funds (that have to be secured each year), are not available to us to allocate and JFNA dues are a fixed expense. In addition, we assume roughly a 3% write off for pledges (budgeted at $60,000). As a result, the funds available to us to spend are just under $3.4M, and cover our operating budget ($2,522,276), community partner grants ($672,250) overseas grants ($195,500), as detailed later in the presentation.
Cash Position Lastly, we are beginning the new fiscal year on January 1 in a positive cash position which allows us to distribute grants in a timely manner as well as to support our operations.
$3,390,200 Page 3
Strategic Priorities for 2024 Below is are the Strategic Priorities for 2024 as discussed by the board in previous months. We have created this budget narrative to align with this layout. The chart below is interactive enabling you to click on an area of interest to go directly to that page.
NEW & REFRESHED PROJECTS
SUSTAINING PROGRAMS
Young Adult Engagement
Cemetery Restoration
Israel Engagement
Belonging
Combatting Hate & antisemitism
Middlescence
Immersive Experiences
HERO
JCRC
Partner Grants
LiNK Jewish Buffalo
Secure Jewish Buffalo
DEVELOPMENT
OPERATIONS
Page 4
Philanthropy Strategy [Planning & Execution]
Communication Strategy
Finance Strategy
Impact & Growth
People Plan
KEY ASSUMPTIONS & CONSIDERATIONS • Change in fiscal year provides an opportunity to alter our budget structure. • Campaign resources will begin to decrease and fundraising strategy must pivot. • Less campaign resources dedicated to Federation programs in order to maintain agency support. • Growth in security efforts particularly with synagogues. • Investment in sustaining programs will be strong with emphasis on immersive travel. • Staff size will decrease but investment and support of team will increase.
EXPENSES
$426,360
Expenses for Federation are aligned with the strategic priories. In the sustaining program areas, cost includes both staffing and programming. When applicable, a portion of Debbie Pivarsi (CFO), Rob Goldberg (CEO), Miriam Abramovich (COO) and Stacey Block (Director of Operations) are included as overhead costs in each associated program area and noted in the narrative.
Secure Jewish Buffalo
$110,000
Here is a summary of expenses beginning with operations, the bottom line on the priorities chart.
LiNK
$419,886
HERO
$135,497
JCRC
$221,590
Israel Advocacy
$57,265
Immersive Experience
$52,000
OPERATIONS Communication Strategy
$321,685
Finance - Impact & Growth
$757,993
HBLA
$20,000
DEVELOPMENT SUSTAINING PROGRAMS
TOTAL
$2,522,276 Page 5
OPERATIONS We have doubled-down on our operational systems by realigning staff resources and investing in a data collection and management systems. In January of this year, we promoted Miriam Abramovich to Chief Operating Officer and began to build out our operations team led by Stacey Block; this team serves as the backbone of the agency and supports the work of each program area. Operations includes all staff benefits (see People Plan for details), professional fees (such as audit), Zoom phone/meetings (an expense budgeted at $32,400), postage, rent and storage. The operations budget also reflects all of our operational costs of our sustaining programs, such as meetings and staff costs for travel, supplies and professional development together rather than separate them out as has been done previously. Communications: We seek to expand our communications efforts and have convened a Communications Strategy Task Force chaired by Jennifer Patrick and led by Jill Komm. Members include: Ezra Rich, Darci Cramer and Todd Geise. The task force met in » early October and discussed how best to ensure consistent messaging of the Federation and how communication output is also a vehicle to help support/grow overall giving. Next steps include meeting with program leaders of each area to help align the Federation brand/messaging with their work and creating a Communication Workplan for 2024 that will provide guidelines and layout a yearly planning cycle. Close to 90% of communications costs are staff-related with a new part-time position included. Additional funds are allocated for sponsorships (of agency and synagogue events), printing, and website. There is revenue generated by communications services provided to Foundation for Jewish Philanthropy ($35,000, an increase of $10,000 from FY ’23) and Jewish Family Services. Am Yisrael Chai!
The Award Winning
BUFFALO, ISRAEL & THE JEWISH WORLD | BUFFALOJEWISHFEDERATION.ORG
NOVEMBER 2023 | CHESHVAN-KISLEV 5784
( PG 4 )
DON’T MISS: HRC is now HERO (6)
Page 6
INSIDE:
Challah Prince (7)
LOOK:
Meet Regina ( 11 )
Impact and Growth: Among our operations priorities is an upgrade to Salesforce. We have completed phase one of that effort through a contract with Beyond the Horizon for a cost to date of $70,000. Our anticipated cost for Phase Two during 2024 is $10,000. Note that this is not a budgetary expense but rather a capital investment as approved by the Board. The outcomes that we seek through this investment is that all current donor and engagement data exists side by side in Salesforce and all new engagement and donor data will be added in real time, and in sync with other platforms. We will also be able to produce robust dashboard and data reporting. All federation professionals will be trained to use Salesforce as a tool for tracking constituent information and engagement across all program areas. Salesforce will now provide a secure, collaborative, used, and accessible living source of data which allows the Buffalo Jewish Federation to both see itself clearly and inform how mission is achieved. Information Technology: Working together with our current IT provider, MVP, we are aiming to streamline support services and consolidation of equipment in 2024 as we create a plan to move to a fully cloud based infrastructure. We recently added an electronic Help Desk on all computers for ease of reporting technology issues. Stacey Block is now the lead contact for MVP and will be working closely with them to move us to a fully virtual environment. Our budgetary cost for IT support is $33,600. HBLA: We continue to share the support of the Hebrew Benevolent Free Loan Association with Foundation for Jewish Philanthropies and it is included in Operations. The cost of the support, $20,000, is provided through a Campaign Grant.
+ Giving. Growing. Together.
Page 7
PEOPLE PLAN We are in the second year of implementing our Strategic People Plan, which includes ongoing realignment with our strategic priorities, succession planning, and pairing of Federation functions and professionals. This 2023 phase of this plan was highlighted by shifting roles especially for Miriam Abramovich who was promoted to Chief Operating Officer in January. As stated earlier, the Operating budget accounts for a portion of Debbie Pivarsi, Rob Goldberg, Miriam Abramovich, and Stacey Block in each associated program area. Three other significant people changes include: Randi Morkisz has moved from full-time to part-time, Chana Kotzin has left her position as Director of the Jewish Buffalo History Center, and Ellen Goldstein will be leaving at the end of December as Editor of the Jewish Journal.
Total FTE’s have been reduced from 19 to 17.5 for FY 24.
CLICK HERE TO VIEW STAFF
FY 23
FY 24
19
17.5
Total Compensation
$1,464,430
$1,410,137
Health Benefits Costs
$119,000
$121,000
Retirement/401k Costs
$28,000
$48,000
Total FTEs
Page 8
While compensation represents 55% of the overall operating expenses, the overall cost of salaries will decrease by $50,000 in the new fiscal year. Health insurance and retirement benefits have been adjusted in part based on the discussion during the spring Board of Governors and subsequent Executive Committee meetings when leadership reinforced our goal to provide a generous and competitive benefit package to the professional team. And, as discussed previously with the Board, a new personnel manual developed in partnership with ESC will be implemented in 2024. The new manual ensures that Federation is fully in compliance with all NY State Labor Laws and ensures transparency, clarity and equity in refreshed PTO and expense reimbursement policies. Additional highlights include: • Employees eligible for health insurance can choose from two plans. The premium plan includes a 15% employee contribution and the secondary plan remains at the present level of 10%. Even assuming an overall increase in cost by 14.3%, the budgetary cost is relatively the same as 2023. • We are offering a new 401K plan to replace the current Simple IRA plan. All employees working 20+ hours are eligible after completing one year of service. We are matching up to 4% contributed by employees resulting in an increase to the budget of an estimated $20,000 for 16 staff members. • Employees will benefit from the addition of two new paid holidays, MLK Day and Juneteenth.
Page 9
DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY We have replaced the former Campaign Cabinet with a new Development Leadership Council led by Vice President Marc Brown. The Council pairs volunteer leaders with professionals from throughout Federation to focus on several key areas including New Donors, Corporate Giving and Supplemental Campaigns. See below for a diagram of the new Council.
Chair of Development Marc Brown (Vice President of Federation) Chair Women’s Philanthropy
Chair Major Donors
Chair Life & Legacy
Chair New Donors
Chair Corporate Giving
Chair Supplemental Giving
Amelida Ortiz Weinmann
Rise Kulick
Howard Rosenhoch
TBD
Frank Altman
Deborah Goldman
Professional Miriam Abramovich
Professional Randi Morkisz
Professional Randi Morkisz
Professional Lauren Bloomberg
Professional Jill Komm
Professional Rob Goldberg
Grant Funding
Professional Mike Steklof
Donor Rentention and Growth - Professional Stacey Block ANNUAL CAMPAIGN DONORS GIVING UNDER $5000 | PHONATHONS | MAILED SOLICITATION | DATA AND IMPACT
Erin Casper - Management of Development Leadership Council
Stewards
Stewards
Stewards
Stewards
Stewards
ANNUAL CAMPAIGN
ANNUAL CAMPAIGN DONORS GIVING $5,000 +
ENDOWMENTS
ANNUAL CAMPAIGN (UNDER 5 YEARS)
CORPORATE GIVING
LION OF JUDAH POMEGRANATE SOCIETY NATIONAL WOMEN’S PHILANTHROPY LION/POM EVENTS
TOTAL GIVING $10,000 + MAJOR DONOR EVENT
LIFE & LEGACY PROGRAM
NEW DONOR EFFORTS
Stewards
Grant Writers
HRC CAMPAIGN
NYS
CEMETERY CORP
LiNK
CORPORATE SPONSORS
LINK CAMPAIGN
I&O
CORPORATE FOUNDATIONS
SECURE JEWISH BUFFALO
NEW GRANT OPPORTUNITIES
JCRC CAMPAIGN
SHINE A LIGHT FOUNDATION
NWP LION CONFERENCE
HGF
DIGNITY GROWS
SECURITY
Page 10
We have also realigned our staffing for development as Randi Morkisz is now working half-time and focused solely on major gifts and Life and Legacy. We have not replaced Randi but have repositioned Miriam to focus more of her attention on development and have enlisted other staff like Lauren Bloomberg and Erin Casper to support our development efforts. With the realignment, the staffing cost is approximately $50,000
less than in 2023. We continue to grabble with the number of donors decreasing while seeking to maintain a successful Campaign for Jewish Buffalo. As noted in the introduction, as we move into 2024 we anticipate a loss of approximately $100,00 due to death or donors moving out of the community. Below is a chart that compares each of the last campaign years and below that a second chart that catalogues the average of gifts (including and not including major donors): Campaign Year
# of Donors
Donor $
# of Corp
Corporate $
# of Funds
Fund $
Total Giving
Total # of Gifts
2021
1282
$2,059,036.57
8
$121,791.00
22
$86,160.43
$2,266,988.00
1312
2022
1137
$2,013,139.00
8
$120,786.00
24
$186,320.00
$2,320,245.00
1169
2023
1012
$1,793,970.00
4
$82,300.00
8
$24,060.00
$1,900,330.00*
1024
* There is an expectation that we will end the year between $2M-2.3M.
Campaign Year
Average Gift (all divisions)
Average gift without Major/Leadership Donors
Average gift for Major/Leadership Donors
2021
$1,727.89
$516.79
$10,302.56
2022
$1,984.81
$512.63
$10,822.36
2023
$1,855.79
$459.43
$9,291.29 Page 11
SUSTAINING PROGRAMS LiNK Jewish Buffalo, led by Dr. Mike Steklof, continues to provide an array of programming for hundreds of individuals through PJ Library, Belonging, the Buffalo Teen Initiative and Middle School Engagement, Young Adult Engagement, and Adult Engagement, including new programs for those 55+. The total cost of LiNK is just under $420,000 and is offset by $68,000 of designated income. The cost is $85,000 less than last year, in part due to shifting roles for Miriam Abramovich, who spent over 50% of her time in 2023 overseeing LiNK, and moving some of the professional development and staffing costs to operations.
Immersive travel continues to be a core strategy of engagement. However, given the war in Israel with Hamas, we assume that most travel to Israel will be curtailed for 2024, including plans for Israel NOW, a unique trip for 8th graders that we were planning for February. However, we have budgeted expense of $52,000, with offsetting income of $30,000, that includes costs associated with Exploring our Roots trip to Poland and Austria, the inaugural KOLOT program in memory of Leslie Shuman Kramer z”l, and Momentum (that has been postponed but hopefully will take place in the late summer).
The Holocaust Education and Resource Organization (formally HRC), led by Lauren Bloomberg, will continue to address antisemitism and teach the lessons of the Holocaust through an array of programs, including: The Annual Teachers Conference, Yom HaShoah Commemoration (held this year at Roswell Park), and The Arts and Writing Contest. HERO has also initiated an effort to remember three Righteous Among the Nations who called WNY home through an outdoor mural at Roswell Park that will be unveiled in the Spring. Costs for the mural are covered through grants, individual gifts from family members of those remembered, funds from Roswell and dollars secured by Senator Tim Kennedy. The budget also includes an investment in 2G and 3G training and support of the Descendants Group and Speakers Bureau. The cost of HERO is $135, 497, slightly less than last year due to staffing realignment, and is offset through $70,000 of designated income.
Page 12
SUSTAINING PROGRAMS We continue to address security needs through the leadership of Susan DeMari, Director of Community Security. The cost for Secure Jewish Buffalo is $110,000 and covers staffing and travel expense, grants to fortify physical assets, and funds dedicated to underwrite the rising cost of armed security at synagogues and other institutions. Income for Security derives from contributions and a matching grant of $55,000 from JFNA through their “LiveSecure” program.
Our Jewish Community Relations Council (JCRC) focuses on creating a civil and caring community through building bridges throughout WNY. Costs for JCRC include a staff team led by Mara Koven-Gelman and remain similar to 2023. Program costs include a Legislative Breakfast in February, a visit from leaders of Roots, an Israeli grassroots movement that brings Israelis and Palestinians together, the East Side Garden Walk and other efforts. The cost of JCRC is $221,590, $55,000 less than last year due to the cost of the 2023 Civic Leaders Trip to Israel, and is offset through $80,000 of designated income.
PARTNER G RA N TS
Campaign resources are primarily used to make grants to both support Federation-led programs as well as to local community agencies and overseas partners.
Page 13
LOCAL PARTNER GRANTS & CONGREGATIONAL SUPPORT The following are Partner Grants to agencies, organizations and programs outside of Federation. The chart below captures all of the funds provided in 2023 and the proposed grants to 9 entities including the Community Religious School, the Community Educator position at UB. PROPOSED 2024
2023 GRANTS
PURPOSE
Cemetery Corp
$36,000
$36,000
Maintenance of Cemeteries
Chabad of Buffalo
$32,500
$32,500
Jewish Engagement & Learning
Hillel of Buffalo
$90,000
$90,000
Jewish Engagement/Israel Advocacy
JCC
$200,000
$210,000
Cultural Arts and JRT
JFS
$123,750
$123,750
Support Services for Jewish Buffalo
Park School/Kadimah Scholars
$75,000
$80,000
Jewish Education
Ohr Temimim
$75,000
$65,100
Jewish Education
Community Educator
$30,000
$32,000
Jewish Education
Community Religious School
$10,000
$10,000
Jewish Education/Outreach
TOTAL
$672,250
$679,350
AGENCY
Page 14
The chart below provides congregational support in 2023 and proposed support in 2024 (security is estimated). In 2023, each of the congregations were provided funds to offset the cost of armed security personal for Shabbat and holiday services. In addition, Shir Shalom, Temple Beth Tzedek and Kehilat Ohr Tzion (6 months) were allocated funds to support their rabbis work with Federation. For 2024, we will be providing a new grant to Temple Beth Zion, that is in the process of searching for a new Assistant Rabbi (or Cantor), and will be renewing the grant for Kehillat Ohr Tzion, that is searching for a rabbi to replace Ori Bergman who is leaving this summer. Both positions are effective July 1
CONGREGATION
PROPOSED/ ESTIMATED 2024
2023 GRANTS
PURPOSE
Temple Beth Zion
$15,000
$4,317
Security Officers/Rabbinic Support
Temple Beth Tzedek
$25,000
$26,405
Security Officers/Rabbinic Support
Congregation Shir Shalom
$13,000
$12,540
Security Officers/Rabbinic Support
KOT
$11,000
$10,320
Security Officers/Rabbinic Support
Knesset Center
$2,000
$1,690
Security Officers
TOTAL
$66,000
$55,272
Page 15
OVERSEAS PARTNER GRANTS We are required as a member of Jewish Federations of North America (JFNA) to allocate a minimum of approximately $200,000 to overseas support (a calculation of roughly 10% of our discretionary campaign funds). Overseas Partner Core Grants remained unchanged for our three historic partners – Jewish Agency for Israel (JAFI), Joint Distribution Committee (JDC) and World ORT. Also note that the JAFI grant includes a core unrestricted allocation and funds set aside to support our Partnership2Gether program in the Western Galilee, an effort that is led by JAFI. We are also recommending continuing with a second year for additional grants totaling $22,500 to support 5 programs: Abayudaya Jewish Community of Uganda ($5,000 to be matched by $2,500 from the Temple Beth Tzedek Men’s Club), ALMA: Pre-Military Academy for Female Leadership ($3,500), Hand in Hand ($3,500), Krembo Wings ($3,500), ORT: YOUniversity After-School Enrichment for Ukrainian Refugees in Mateh Asher ($5,000), and iRep: Israel Religious Expression Platform ($5,000). The following graph and chart provide an overview of the recommendation: Other Grants 12% ORT 8%
JAFI – CORE 42% JDC 25%
Page 16
JAFI P2G 13%
JAFI – CORE
$83,000
JAFI P2G – Western Galilee
$25,000
JDC – CORE
$50,000
ORT – CORE
$15,000
Other Grants
$22,500
TOTAL
$195,500
CAMPAIGN PARTNER GRANTS As indicated above, campaign dollars have been set aside to also make grants to programs and services that Federation administers such as the Jewish Journal, LiNK Jewish Buffalo, HERO, the JCRC and the Hebrew Benevolent Loan Association (HBLA). The overall cost for the grants is $1,177,000, a decrease of nearly
$250,000 from 2023, in part due to the suspension of grants for the Jewish Buffalo History Center and Planning, and our ability to maintain costs. The following are the recommended campaign grants to Federation side by side with grants in 2023, each of which reflects changes in cost as well as secured or anticipated designated income. The one significant increase from 2023 if for JCRC that benefit the previous two years from a a grant ($25,000 each year) from West-Herr Automotive.
PROGRAM AREA
PROPOSED YR 24
GRANTS YR 23
Jewish Buffalo Communications (Jewish Journal / My Jewish Buffalo)
$120,000
$120,000
LiNK Jewish Buffalo
$352,000
$442,000
Holocaust Education and Resource Organization (HERO)
$66,000
$90,000
0
$40,000
Israel Programming
$60,000
$76,000
Hebrew Benevolent Free Loan Assoc. (HBLA)
$20,000
$20,000
Talent and Leadership
$42,000
$65,000
0
$46,000
Jewish Community Relations (JCRC)
$142,000
$100,000
Development
$375,000
$422,000
TOTAL
$1,177,000
$1,421,000
Jewish Buffalo History Center
Planning
Page 17
OPERATING REVENUE SUMMARY Income Area
Proposed 2024
Budget 2023
Unrestricted Funds
$168,000
$168,000
Day/Joseph Fund
$615,000
$580,000
Campaign Partner Grants
$1,177,000
$1,421,000
Security Designated
$110,000
$50,000
Corporate Sponsors
$100,000
$50,000
LiNK
$68,000
$94,300
HERO
$70,000
$62,500
JCRC
$80,000
$125,000
Central Services
$62,200
$55,000
Additional Revenue/Other
$75,000
$40,000
$2,525,200
$2,645,800
TOTAL
• Day/Joseph Fund: Increase of $35K. We have budgeted 4% and are still within our spend limit of 7%. • Campaign Partner Grants: Decrease from $1,421K to $1,177K as we are relying less on campaign dollars in order to ensure that agencies remain whole. LiNK Down – due in part to shifting Miriam’s responsibilities from link to development and operations Pause on staffing the Jewish Buffalo History Center Elimination of planning department and shifting Mandy’s responsibilities to Operations Page 18
Talent and Leadership to match professional development expense Increase in JCRC funding to account for lack of West Herr gift (until 2025) and no Civic Leaders Immersion Trip Security income – Doubling our security income through “Live Secure” matching JFNA grant