SINCE 1891
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD VOLUME CLVIV, ISSUE 2
THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 1, 2024
BROWNDAILYHERALD.COM
WHAT’S INSIDE
METRO
Pay-for-Success pilots in R.I. SEE HOUSING PAGE 4
ARTS & CULTURE
New season of ‘Single’s Inferno’: laughs, red flags SEE INFERNO PAGE 11
ARTS & CULTURE CLAIRE DIEPENBROCK / HERALD
The Office of Institutional Equity and Diversity will continue to oversee employment-based affirmative action and bias incident reports, according to the Jan. 31 announcement.
Brown-RISD Exhibition
SEE EXHIBITION PAGE 10
New University office to oversee federal compliance, BPLO Union Recognisation investigations
UNIVERSITY NEWS
SEE POSTDOC PAGE 3
Compliance functions moved from OIED amid ongoing investigations, campus climate concerns BY SAMANTHA CHAMBERS UNIVERSITY NEWS EDITOR
The University’s compliance and federal investigatory operations have been moved from the Office of Institutional Equity and Diversity to the newly-created Office of Equity Compliance and Reporting under the Division of Campus
Life, according to a Jan. 31 Today@ Brown announcement by President Christina Paxson P’19 P’MD’20. The transition is effective Thursday, according to Vice President for Campus Life Eric Estes, who will oversee the OECR. The office will inherit oversight of Title IV, VII and IX, along with the Americans with Disabilities Act and Section 504 from OIED. Collectively, these laws address discrimination, harassment, sexual misconduct and accessibility accommodations. Staff involved with compliance will also move to the OECR.
OIED will continue to manage bias incident reports and employment-based affirmative action, but will refer reports “that may require further investigation” to Campus Life, according to the announcement. The transition comes amid 14 pending investigations into the University by the Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights. Of these investigations, three were opened last month — one pertaining to an alleged Title VI violation, and the two others on alleged disability-based discrimination and retaliation.
Estes added that the office transition will not affect ways the University processes information requests related to federal investigations. “In the event the University receives requests for information from regulatory and investigative agencies, Brown’s Office of General Counsel coordinates the University’s response,” Estes wrote. “That will remain the case moving forward, even as we have reorganized the ways in which various administrative units work together on campus to address reports of bias, discrimination and harassment.”
ARTS & CULTURE
SEE OECR PAGE 3
AFFINITY & ACTIVISM
ADMISSIONS
CCE stops inviting fos- PPE hosts panel on sil fuel firms to recruit affirmative action Agreement follows months of meetings with Sunrise Brown members BY ETHAN SCHENKER SENIOR STAFF WRITER The Center for Career Exploration will no longer invite fossil fuel companies to host on-campus recruitment events, according to a May 2023 email reviewed by The Herald from Matthew Donato, the executive director of the CCE, to leaders of climate activism group Sunrise Brown. Sunrise announced the change on a Jan. 13 Instagram post. Companies on the Carbon Underground 200 — a list of businesses with the largest holdings in fossil fuels — or those that fall under the “Oil & Gas Industry” category on Handshake are now
excluded from the CCE’s annual recruiting invitation email sent to employers each spring, Donato wrote in an email to The Herald. But companies may still request to participate in on-campus recruiting events and can continue to post jobs on Handshake. “Informed by student interests, we reconsidered what companies we were actively inviting to campus,” Donato wrote, noting that the CCE “has not modified its recruiting policies with regard to fossil fuel companies.” The change does not appear on the CCE’s website, and the decision to stop inviting fossil fuel companies to recruit on campus was not publicly communicated. This development falls short of a complete victory for members of Sunrise, who argue that the industry has a
SEE CCE PAGE 3
Panelists discussed issues of racial diversity, standards for admissions BY TOM LI AND SOPHIA WOTMAN METRO EDITOR AND SENIOR STAFF WRITER The Center for Philosophy, Politics and Economics hosted a Wednesday evening event at which panelists addressed affirmative action and anti-discrimination policies in the college admissions process. Titled “After Affirmative Action: Democracy and the University,” the event constitutes another component of an ongoing national discussion of affirmative action following the Supreme Court’s 2023 ruling on race-conscious admissions.
Organized by the Center’s Democracy Project, the panel featured John Friedman, a professor of economics and international and public affairs; Logan Powell, the University’s associate provost for enrollment and dean of admission; and Michael Roth, president of Wesleyan University. Bonnie Honig, a Democracy Project director and professor of political science and modern culture and media, moderated the panel. Honig began the panel by explaining the rationale for the event: “to look at how universities that care about diversity and equality should respond to (the Supreme Court) decision,” Students Fair Admissions Inc. v. President & Fellows of Harvard College. “Universities are important parts
SEE PANEL PAGE 12
SEE BROWN-RISD PAGE 10
METRO
SEE BRIDGE PAGE 4
PAGE 2
THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 1, 2024
TODAY WEEK IN HIGHER ED
ADVERTISEMENT
1
KAIOLENA TACAZON / HERALD
University of Florida programs could be affected by shutdown of state funding
First passed by Governor Ron DeSantis, the May 2023 DEI funding ban is now in effect. In January 2023, Florida ordered an audit of the university that found that $5 million was going towards programs relating to DEI and critical race theory. At the time of the audit, nine colleges at the University of Florida had deans who were responsible for DEI, but now, a year later, eight deans remain, but not in their former positions. Some of the colleges are changing the names of their DEI programs and positions that enforce it to be in line with the law.
2
Project on history of Jewish, Black Americans at Rutgers wins grant
The Bildner Center for the Study of Jewish Life received a grant of over $10,000 from the New Jersey Council for the Humanities to study the historical intersection of Black and Jewish Americans and explore why the two groups have been targeted together as well as misconceptions regarding
3
Billionaire says he will halt donations to Harvard after antisemitism allegations
Ken Griffin, who recently donated $300 million to the Faculty of Arts and Sciences said he would not donate to Harvard until they “get back to their roots of educating American children.” He also added that Harvard students were “whiny snowflakes.” The Graduate School of Arts and Sciences as well as the financial aid office are both named after Griffin.
THIS WEEKEND T. Bains — The Ideological Origins of the British Empire in South Asia February 2nd 2 p.m. - 4 p.m. Watson Institute
Auditions: Writing is Live February 2nd - 4th 6:00 p.m. - 5:00 p.m. Stuart Theatre
New Year New Me Social: Vision Board and Movie Night February 2nd 6:00 - 8:30 p.m. Page-Robinson Hall (GBC Lounge)
American Physician-Scientist Association Conference February 3rd 8:15 a.m. - 3 p.m. The Warren Alpert Medical School
NEXT WEEK Our Storied Health (Mossville: When Great Trees Fall) Feburary 5th 6:00pm Granoff Center
Study Abroad in the UK information Session Feburary 6th 11:00am - 12:00pm Virtual
Community Care Day and Welcome Back Feburary 7th 12:00pm - 5:00pm Page-Robinson Hall (GBC Lounge)
Dionne Brand: A Literary Reading Feburary 8th 5:30pm Churchill House
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
WEB EXCLUSIVE
Meet GPTA, a new AI assistant for CSCI 0150 students
PAGE 3
UNIVERSITY NEWS
OECR FROM PAGE 1 Currently, the Division of Campus Life oversees multiple front-facing centers, offices and programs, including Counseling and Psychological Services, Residential Life and Student Accessibility Services. “We have a streamlined approach, and that’s going to make it easier — not only for students, but also for faculty, staff and anyone who wants to make a complaint,” said Sylvia Carey-Butler, vice president for institutional equity
and diversity, in an interview with The Herald. “We don’t want anything to fall through the cracks.” In the announcement, Paxson stressed the importance of “maintaining a diverse and inclusive community and strengthening our responses to incidents of bias, harassment and discrimination” as part of the decision to form the new office. In providing additional context for the decision, Paxson cited the Supreme Court’s 2023 decision that declared race-conscious admissions
unconstitutional as well as “concerns over campus climate” related to the ongoing Israel-Palestine war. At a Dec. 5 faculty meeting, Paxson also said the University will determine whether it needs to “enhance” its Title VI policies, The Herald previously reported. For internal investigations and complaints, the new office will combine aspects of the investigative process into one unit and provide closer connection between incident report and incident management services on
campus, according to the announcement. As part of the updates, the University also created a new complaint submission process — featured on the incident report site — that will no longer require complainants to self-determine the categorization of an alleged incident. Paxson also wrote in the announcement that both OIED and OECR have collaborated “to ensure a seamless transition for individuals with pending cases.”
STAFF & STUDENT LABOR
Brown postdoc union wins University recognition BPLO secures majority, bypasses election process following voluntary recognition
Brown Sunrise members interrupt Nikki Haley
BY GRACE HU SENIOR STAFF WRITER After receiving word on Tuesday that their card check agreement is complete, the University officially recognized the Brown University Postdoc Labor Organization as a union, according to a BPLO Instagram post. BPLO announced their intention to unionize Dec. 8 and filed a representation petition with the National Labor Relations Board Dec. 28 to demonstrate adequate support to form a union. After the petition was filed, federal mediators certified that BPLO’s list of signatories matched the list of people Brown considers to be part of the postdoctoral bargaining unit. Because the University agreed to voluntarily recognize the union, BPLO did not have to undergo an election process through the NLRB to be formally recognized. A spokesperson for the University did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Prior to the card check’s comple-
VISIONS members talk publication past, future READ IT ONLINE
BROWNDAILYHERALD.COM
tion, University spokesperson Brian Clark told The Herald that if the mediators determine that “a majority of the proposed postdoctoral bargaining unit wishes to be represented by the union,” the University is prepared to “recognize the union and begin work toward negotiating a collective bargaining agreement,” The Herald previously reported. According to the post, the voluntarily recognized bargaining unit represents “postdoctoral research associates, postdoctoral fellows and Dean’s Faculty Fellows paid directly by Brown.” The post adds that hospital-affiliated postdocs not employed by the University are not officially considered part of the currently recognized bargaining unit at this time. Now that the union has received official and voluntary recognition from the University, BPLO representatives and University administrators can begin contract negotiations. “The fact that the union was recognized so quickly is a testament to how united, enthusiastic, and determined the whole postdoc community has been about forming our union,” wrote Postdoctoral Research Fellow and BPLO organizer Sarah Neville.
DANA RICHIE / HERALD
In an interview with The Herald prior to the completion of the card check agreement, postdoctoral research associate and BPLO organizer Caroline Keroack said the goal of BPLO “is to get a contract put together” this year. Keroack continued, “We’re looking forward to … seeing what we can win for the postdocs. Everyone deserves to have a union, and we’re really excited to see who does it next. We’re excited to help the next people.”
Now, BPLO is also turning its sights to include hospital-based postdoctoral fellows — who are affiliated with the Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior — in the union, wrote Neville, who is part of the group of postdocs currently unrecognized by the University as part of the bargaining unit, in an email to The Herald. This article was originally published online Jan. 31, 2024.
Submissions: The Brown Daily Herald publishes submissions in the form of op-eds and letters to the editor.
SINCE 1891
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
Op-eds are typically between 600 and 900 words and advance a clear argument related to a topic of campus discourse. You can submit op-eds to opinions@browndailyherald.com. Letters to the editor should be around 250 words and respond to an article or column that has appeared in The Herald, or critique or commend The Herald’s editorial decisions. You can submit letters to the editor to letters@browndailyherald.com.
134TH EDITORIAL BOARD
Gabriella Vulakh
Paulie Malherbe
Gray Martens
Editor-in-Chief
Arts & Culture Editors
Yael Wellisch
Design Editors
Neil Mehta
Isabel Hahn
MULTIMEDIA
Ashley Guo
Managing Editors
Rya Vallabhaneni
Photo Chiefs
Tiffany Tran
Julia Vaz
Sports Editors
Claire Diepenbrock
Designers
Charlie Clynes
Dennis Carey
Dana Richie
Allyson Chen
information that The Herald cannot verify. Because we cannot publish unsubstantiated information,
Senior Editors
Linus Lawrence
Photo Editors
Joyce Gao
failure to provide appropriate sources may mean we have to modify or remove unverified claims.
Finn Kirkpatrick
University News Editors
Mathieu Greco
Michelle Jun
The Herald will not publish anonymous submissions or submissions authored by organizations. Leaders
Kathy Wang
Samantha Chambers
Lilly Nguyen
Menasha Leport
of student organizations can be identified as such but cannot write under the byline of their organization.
POST- MAGAZINE
Julianna Chang
Kaiolena Tacazon
Nathaniel Scott
Editor-in-Chief
Owen Dahlkamp
Social Media Chief
Kaiolena Tacazon
Joseph Maffa
Ryan Doherty
Kaiolena Tacazon
Angela Xu
including personal blogs and social media) and must be exclusive to The Herald. Once your submission
NEWS
Katie Jain
Podcast Editors
BUSINESS
is published in The Herald, The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. owns the copyright to the materials.
Metro Editors
Kelvin Jiang
Finn Kirkpatrick
General Managers
Commentary: The editorial is the majority opinion of the editorial page board of The Brown Daily Herald.
Avani Ghosh
Anisha Kumar
Jacob Smollen
Benjamin Moshes
The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily reflect the views of The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Columns,
Mikayla Kennedy
Aniyah Nelson
Director of Technology
Alex Zhou
letters and comics reflect the opinions of their authors only.
Tom Li
Jennifer Shim
Ty Pham-Swann
Sales Director
Corrections: The Brown Daily Herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with
Rhea Rasquinha
COMMENTARY
PRODUCTION
Samantha Sinensky
the most accurate information possible. Corrections may be submitted up to seven calendar days after
Jack Tajmajer
Opinions Chief
Copy Desk Chief
Finance Director
publication. Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. Postmaster: Please send corrections to P.O. Box
Science & Research Editors
Alissa Simon
Anna Dubey
Mason Mead
Owen Dahlkamp
Opinions Editors
Junior Copy Desk Chief
Office Manager
Advertising: The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at
Ryan Doherty
Juliet Fang
Anna Dubey
Cary Warner
its discretion.
Kelvin Jiang
Anusha Gupta
Design Chief
@the_herald
@browndailyherald
88 Benevolent, Providence, RI (401) 351-3372 www.browndailyherald.com Editorial: herald@browndailyherald.com Advertising: advertising@browndailyherald.com
Submissions undergo multiple rounds of editing. These rounds of editing generally take place over the course of one evening, and you may have to respond to edits late in the evening. If you know you will be unable to do so, please mention that in your email, and we will do our best to work with you. Submissions can build on reporting from The Herald, reporting elsewhere, official statements from the University or other groups and other reputable sources, but they cannot break news or contain
The Herald cannot publish all submissions it receives and reserves the right to edit all submissions. All submissions to The Herald cannot have been previously published elsewhere (in print or online —
2538, Providence, RI 02906.
The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. is a financially independent, nonprofit media organization bringing you The Brown Daily Herald and Post- Magazine. The Brown Daily Herald has served the Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday through Friday during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during Commencement and once during Orientation by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Single copy free for each member of the community. Subscription prices: $200 one year daily, $100 one semester daily. Copyright 2023 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved.
PAGE 4
THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 1, 2024
METRO
TRANSPORTATION
East Providence businesses reflect on I-195 Washington Bridge closure Business owners highlight reduced customers, financial worries, overall frustration BY SANAI RASHID SENIOR STAFF WRITER On Dec. 11, the Rhode Island Department of Transportation shut down the westbound side of the I-195 Washington Bridge due to structural concerns, causing traffic delays. On Jan. 26, the United States Department of Justice and Office of the Inspector General released a federal investigation into the bridge’s closure. Built in 1969, the Washington Bridge allows drivers to travel over the Seekonk River from Providence to East Providence and also access Seekonk, Massachusetts. The bridge’s closure has negatively impacted small businesses in East Providence, which rely on patrons traveling across the bridge from Providence and further west. On Jan. 22, RIDOT Director Peter Alviti announced that the Washington Bridge may need to be torn down completely and rebuilt, WBUR reported. Updates are pending, but Alviti has said that the bridge will take priority over all other transportation projects in the state. In fall 2023, engineers began working on the bridge as part of the $78 million Washington Bridge reconstruction project, a plan RIDOT financed to “address chronic congestion issues on the Interstate,” according to the department’s website. It soon became apparent that there were significant issues on the westbound side of the bridge and closing these lanes would be necessary to address safety concerns. A detailed report has since been released providing sketches and images of the deficient infrastructure. The closure of the westbound side of
the bridge led to heavy congestion. More than 96,000 vehicles drive over the bridge each day, according to RIDOT. Public safety alerts warned drivers to avoid the area around I-95 and to find alternative routes. “It was a nightmare that first day when the highway wasn’t open,” Alisha Rodriguez, owner of Lavish Salon in East Providence, told The Herald. “All of East Providence was bumper to bumper, and there were cops blocking every single side street because people were trying to cut through. I couldn’t even get into the parking lot of my salon because there was so much traffic.” A day after the bridge’s initial closure Alviti provided more insight into the situation. “On each side of the bridge, there are eight major pins that hold beams in place,” he said in a press conference with Gov. Dan McKee. “When one pin becomes deficient it can have a compounding effect on the other pins which is what happened in this case.” A 2020 infrastructure report card compiled by the Rhode Island Section of the American Society of Civil Engineers found that Rhode Island had the highest percentage of structurally deficient bridges in the country. On Dec. 15, RIDOT opened bypass lanes to provide some traffic leeway. The department also created a temporary ferry service between Bristol and Providence as an alternative route for commuters. Due to low ridership, the ferry’s service ended on Jan. 19. Asher Schofield, co-owner of Frog & Toad has noticed changes across his businesses. “The number (of customers) have remained unchanged at our West end location,” Schofield told The Herald. “But for folks that do drive to come and see us at our store in East Providence, that number has definitely reduced.”
“There’s the actual anecdotal experiential delay in your drive through that traffic, but moreover it’s what’s being talked about on the radio, on coffee breaks, at the bar and at night,” Schofield added. “Everybody’s talking about the bridge closure and for good reasons. But after a while, the hyperbole surrounding it becomes even more of a deterrent than the physical deterrent does.” To alleviate the impact of road closures on small businesses, the U.S. Small Business Administration has encouraged businesses to apply for low-interest, longterm Economic Injury Disaster Loans. According to the administration’s website, businesses in Providence, Bristol and Kent counties, among others, can apply for these loans. “690 applications [have been] submitted for this disaster declaration,” wrote Matthew Spoehr, deputy district director of the Rhode Island District Office of the U.S. Small Business Administration, in an email to The Herald. While there have been five approvals as of date, Spoehr expects these numbers to increase. “Many of the business affected will not truly start to realize the depth of the economic injury they sustained from this event until many months down the road,” he added. But, many business owners stressed that these loans can not fix their immediate problems. Some who received loans during the pandemic are wary of taking out additional loans from the SBA prior to paying off their existing debts. “I haven’t tried to apply for a SBA loan, because I still haven’t finished paying my loans from COVID,” said Minerva’s Pizza owner Kaylin Hibachi. “I’ve had to hire additional staff, which is additional money and still customers are not satisfied because they’re not getting the orders in a timely fashion.” Jackson Rosh, the restaurant manager
of East Providence’s Honeybird, told The Herald his business has been one of the lucky ones. He shared that revenue has remained relatively steady due to loyal customers. “We’ve been able to keep business good, but it’s definitely not because of the state supporting that,” Rosh told The Herald. “It’s because our community is so good.” “I don’t know what the full bridge rebuild is going to mean for our area,” Schofield said. “But I do think that we are due an explanation for where our state government failed us. This is a failure.”
AVERY GUO / HERALD
Schofield also expressed concerns about state transportation funding. “We’ve decided to invest most of our resources for … automobile (transit), and not so much in alternative modes of transit,” he added, highlighting the reduced funds allocated towards the Rhode Island Public Transit Authority. “I just hope that Rhode Islanders don’t become passive with regard to this longer term (transportation) story,” Schofield added. This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Jan. 29, 2024.
HOUSING
State-based pilot program aims to provide 125 housing slots to vulnerable individuals by late 2025 Leaders of program emphasize importance of support services, affordable housing
A state-based pilot program launched last month aims to provide 125 permanent supportive housing slots for especially
but also communities across the country win because the social service investments, safety net investments, are keeping people housed, educated (and) working,” he said. The program is estimated to save between $15,000 and $20,000 per individual on an annual basis, according to EOHHS. Program recipients will be selected from a list of roughly 300 eligible individuals created by RICEH.
worries that we have at the coalition … is that we don’t have enough affordable units currently to move people that are in shelter, out of shelter.” “When people are leaving shelters in our system in Rhode Island …in (the) most likely cases they’re going back out on the street,” he added. In the fall, Crossroads Rhode Island began construction on a housing devel-
vulnerable unhoused individuals by Sep. 30, 2025 using private investor funding. The pay-for-success program — which reduces the government’s investment risk by only paying private investors if they achieve specific targets — will serve those who are high utilizers of Medicaid, have a high level of involvement with the Department of Corrections, or are high utilizers of homelessness services based on Homeless Management & Information System data. According to Allison Arden, the program’s director at the state Executive Office of Health and Human Services, this is the first time the state has used a pay-for-success funding model that could be applied to other social services. The program, led by the EOHHS and The Rhode Island Coalition to End Homelessness, partners with nonprofit organizations, including Crossroads Rhode Island, East Bay Community Action Program, House of Hope and OpenDoors RI, to deliver support services.
“We’re casting as wide a net as we can,” Espinoza said. He explained that, because eligible individuals can be difficult to reach, a large list is useful for providers. Espinoza added that “the larger number highlights the need” for the program. A major factor affecting individuals’ ability to access housing is the lack of affordable housing in the state, Espinoza said. In an email to The Herald, Arden wrote that EOHHS “anticipate(s) challenges in placing enrolled participants into housing as the program relies on existing housing inventory.” “The absence of dedicated housing vouchers for this program, poses potential difficulties in connecting participants with available housing subsidies,” Arden added. As of October 2023, only five Rhode Island communities possess at least 10% of affordable housing. Espinoza stressed the necessity of affordable housing to tangibly address the housing crisis. “I think one of the major
opment that will provide 176 apartments to formerly unhoused adults. The town of Middletown has been working to convert two former schools into affordable housing. In addition, Governor McKee’s 2025 fiscal budget proposes a $100 million bond to support the production of affordable and middle-income housing and infrastructure. Still, Espinoza noted that there is a significant delay between planning and beginning construction on affordable housing projects and getting individuals into housing. “Between breaking ground and actually having folks live in units, it takes about two years,” he said. Espinoza recognized the high costs of projects targeting housing, but emphasized their importance nonetheless. “When you’re in a housing crisis, such as we are in, and such as our country is in, you need to fund that to get out of it.”
BY MIKAYLA KENNEDY METRO EDITOR
KAITLYN STANTON / HERALD
According to the program description, those partners will help beneficiaries navigate the housing search process, providing resources like vouchers and subsidies, so they can obtain stable housing. Juan Espinoza, communications and development manager for RICEH, explained that supportive housing includes additional services, like helping recipients access mental health support, health care and career opportunities. The program, Espinoza said, seeks to help at-risk individuals “move back up the ladder” through housing and auxiliary services, like weekly in-person check-ins from service providers. Arden shared that some of the success-
ful outcomes for the program will include fewer instances of unnecessary emergency department use, lower re-incarceration rates and increased retention of stable housing for individuals. In 2022, the General Assembly allotted $6 million for the pilot program, The Herald previously reported. The pay-for-success program will be partly funded by Maycomb Capital, a venture capital firm that funds “workforce development, early childhood, homelessness, healthcare, social services and financial services,” according to its website. Espinoza said he believes that the program is “a way where everyone wins.” “The private sector makes a little bit,
This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Jan. 30, 2024.
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
PAGE 5
METRO
BEYOND BROWN
Tomaquag Museum, RISD students collaborate on new archival center design Currently in pre-construction, museum’s new campus will incorporate student proposals BY CIARA MEYER SENIOR STAFF WRITER For five hours straight, two days per week, every week of the fall semester, a group of students at the Rhode Island School of Design listened eagerly to lectures about local Indigenous history, sifted through samples of native plants and reviewed blueprints. Their mission? To design a 10,000-square-foot multipurpose archival research center for the Tomaquag Museum’s new campus, located on historically Narragansett and Niantic land owned by the University of Rhode Island in Kingston. While the museum has yet to announce a timeline for construction on the new campus and center, Assistant Director Silvermoon LaRose said elements of multiple student designs may appear in the building. According to the museum’s website, the new campus will make room for at least 10 times more annual visitors than the current location in Exeter, R.I. “We’re very off the beaten path,” said the museum’s executive director, Lorén Spears, so “we want to get into a location where we’re more accessible for the general public.” The new campus will be both larger and accessible to bike paths and public transit routes. An improved archival space is also central to the new location. “Currently, our archival spaces and our collection spaces are kind of tucked all over the place,” Spears explained. In the new location, “we’ll have a better system for care and preservation of collections,” she said.
COURTESY OF JIAMIN YANG
The RISD class in which students worked on potential designs for the museum’s new location, co-taught by LaRose and Assistant Professor of Interior Architecture Francesca Liuni, represented a collaboration between a historian and designer. “I’m not a historian of Native American history,” Liuni said. “I told my department head that we need to co-teach it because I don’t have expertise here.” While LaRose said the museum had a long list of dreams for the space, the practical parameters were simple. “All we
COURTESY OF FRANCESSCA LIUNI
Assistant Director Silvermoon LaRose said elements of multiple student designs may appear on the museum’s new campus, which will make room for at least 10 times more annual visitors than the current location, according to the museum.
knew is we got 10,000 square feet. And we’d like it to be one floor. And it’s got to fit a lot of stuff in there,” LaRose said. In talking with students, Liuni and LaRose both emphasized the significance that the space would have to the local Indigenous community. Since 1958, the Tomaquag Museum has represented multiple southern New England tribal nations, and counts itself as “Rhode Island’s only museum entirely dedicated to telling the story of the Indigenous peoples of this land.” “These belongings are reflective of our families, our history, our continuance as a community,” LaRose said. “We’re doing this for our next generations.” As an exercise, LaRose and Liuni had students design archival spaces that reflected the values of their own cultures, encouraging them to think about things they would want to preserve, make public or keep private. The exercise “allowed me to see that one box doesn’t fit all,” said Marianna Pasaret, a graduate student in interior architecture at RISD. “I looked at it more as a home rather than just a storage space.” With these sensitivities in mind, LaRose and Liuni urged students to incorporate elements of Indigenous design into their work without resorting to stereotypes. After seeing the final projects, Spears said students “really understood what we were trying to talk about when we’re talking about indigenizing design.” Pasaret modeled her work after a beaver dam, since the word Tomaquag translates to “beaver” in the Narragansett language. She also used various native materials as inspiration, incorporating traditional basket weaving and pine composites into her work. Jiamin Yang, a graduate student of exhibition and narrative environments at RISD, said she was inspired by a visit to the museum site this fall. After being shown local plants, Yang decided to center her work after the “very strong connection between humans and nature” for the Indigenous communities of
COURTESY OF FRANCESSCA LIUNI
southern New England. Her final work included separate buildings, blurring the lines between indoor and outdoor museum spaces. Both Pasaret and Yang said they enjoyed having the opportunity to design for a real client. “Sometimes in art school it’s very easy to just … let your ideas go crazy,” Pasaret said. Having to follow a budget and strict square footage requirements “made it more real” and offered “fun constraints to work with as designers.” The students weren’t the only ones who learned from the class. “From every lecture of Silvermoon’s, I learned a billion new things,” said Liuni. She said she hopes to teach similar collaborative studios again in the future. LaRose was excited to teach Indigenous history to students, a subject that she said had been poorly taught in her own educational experience. “Rhode Island for a long time has been limited on its inclusion and focus on indigenous
history,” she said. “And so there was just nothing but opportunity to do more and to do better.” “Being able to have a school offer classes … that bring in these native perspectives increases the availability of what’s being offered to these students to engage with,” LaRose said. Since the architecture for the new campus hasn’t yet been finalized, “it’s actually a great opportunity to bring these ideas in now, to help facilitate that for when we’re ready,” LaRose said. And while some designs would be “exorbitantly costly,” Spears acknowledged, they still offered a good starting point for the campus’ design, once the museum gets past the current regulatory pre-construction phase. What’s next for the student designs? “The beauty of young and vibrant students’ ideas is that we can utilize some of the elements of those … to inspire the work that we’re doing with our architect team,” Spears said.
PAGE 6
THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 1, 2024
SPORTS WOMEN’S BASKETBALL
‘By any means’: Women’s Basketball takes low-scoring 35-31 victory over Dartmouth Bears hang on despite shooting 19.7% from field, Arnolie tallies new career-high
“Especially with Alyssa out today … we knew that people who might not usually have a lot of rebounds needed
BY LINUS LAWRENCE SPORTS EDITOR In a defensive duel at the Pizzitola Sports Center on Saturday afternoon, the Brown women’s basketball team (13-5, 4-1 Ivy) held off Dartmouth (6-11, 0-5 Ivy) to seize a tense 35-31 victory. The game featured Brown’s fewest points scored and allowed this season by a wide margin, as well as the second-fewest points the Bears have won with in program history, according to Brown Athletics. “No one ever likes to have a game where their shots aren’t falling. It’s a really frustrating thing, especially when it seems to be everyone on the team,” said Grace Arnolie ’26. “We’re just always gonna keep pushing even if the game’s not going exactly how we want, and we’re always gonna find a way to win,” Arnolie added. “Today, that was our defense, our rebounding, and just getting gritty when we needed to.” “We have this phrase that we say — ‘BAM Squad’ — and it stands for ‘By Any Means,’” said Head Coach Monique LeBlanc. “That’s something we have to continue to lean into on nights like this where it’s really tough to get scoring going.” Neither team’s shots were falling from the get-go, with the Bears going 8-for-34 and the Big Green going 4-for-28 from the field in the first
COURTESY OF EMMA C. MARION VIA BROWN ATHLETICS
“We need to be comfortable playing not as the underdog, (but) I think we might be the underdog in these upcoming games,” said Head Coach Monique LeBlanc. half. Despite their low shooting percentage, Bruno doubled Dartmouth’s score in each of the first two quarters, bringing the score to 10-5 and then 18-9 at the half. But just when Bruno seemed to be coasting to victory, the Big Green rallied in the second half, going on 10-0 and 8-1 runs in the third and fourth quarters, respectively, to pull two behind. “I thought early in the game, we got great looks and they weren’t hitting, and so we just wanted to keep encouraging the team,” LeBlanc said. “It was really hard to just get an easy bucket in this game.” With the score at 33-31 and Brown
having committed three straight turnovers, the Big Green inbounded the ball with just 15 seconds to go. As nerves pinched throughout the Pizz, Dartmouth’s Cate MacDonald was called for a pivotal travel, giving the Bears possession and forcing the trailing visitors team to foul. At the line — and with the game on the line — Arnolie drained both free throws to seal a 35-31 Bears victory. “I’m happy that I could … put my team in the best position (with) low seconds on the clock,” she said. Holding Dartmouth to just 31 points, the Bears’ defense now ranks 2nd in the League with 56.2 points allowed per game. This was the Bears’
fifth victory this season while scoring under 60 points. Ada Anamekwe ’26 was the Bears’ top scorer of the afternoon with nine points. Only one player in the contest — Dartmouth’s MacDonald — broke double-digits with 11. In a game when the Bears’ offense sputtered — shooting 19.7% to Dartmouth’s 21.7% — Arnolie led a resurgent rebounding effort which ultimately gave Bruno the edge by out-boarding the Big Green 57-43. With the team’s top rebounder Alyssa Moreland ’26 unavailable, Arnolie stepped up to tally 13 rebounds — a new career-high — while Kyla Jones ’24 also racked up double-digits.
to step up and make up for her powerful presence inside,” Arnolie said. “We knew we were gonna be the smaller team, but that doesn’t mean that we don’t have to go and find rebounds and catch them,” Anamekwe said. “Even though we’re the shorter team, we made it a point that we’re going to search (and) scour for every rebound just because that’s who we are as a team.” Anamekwe spoke to the importance of the lessons the Bears — now sitting at 13-5 after a roaring start to the season — can take from a game they were expected to win over the Big Green, who are currently in last place. “A win is a win, but obviously this is a teaching moment from us,” she said. “We need to come in and be the tougher team, not the underdog. We need to learn how to play like the tougher team.” The Bears will now embark on a weekend road trip to face Princeton — the five-time reigning champs — and a Penn team which the Bears hope to battle for a spot in the Ivy League Tournament this March. “We need to be comfortable playing not as the underdog, (but) I think we might be the underdog in these upcoming games,” LeBlanc said. “So we can embrace that at least for next weekend.” This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Jan. 29, 2024.
WOMEN’S HOCKEY
Women’s hockey gets back at No. 8 Quinnipiac with 4-1 victory Bears snap three-week win drought with win fueled by elite offensive performance BY COOPER HERMAN SENIOR STAFF WRITER In the team’s “best game of the season” — according to Head Coach Melanie Ruzzi — the women’s hockey team (9-12-2, 5-9-2 ECAC) hosted No. 8 Quinnipiac (21-7-1, 10-7-0 ECAC) at Meehan Auditorium Saturday afternoon. Though the Bobcats defeated Brown 1-0 earlier this season, the Bears were able to flip the story on Saturday. The Bears began Saturday’s contest showcasing their offensive prowess, creating offensive opportunities at will and leading fast break on fast break. Within the game’s first minute, the Bears already launched three shots at the Quinnipiac defense. Led by Meadow Carman ’24.5, Ava DeCoste ’27 and Maya Mangiafico ’24, the Bears maintained their offensive presence throughout the entire period. The climax of the first period came as Brown goaltender Kaley Doyle ’24 saved two Quinnipiac shots back-toback at the 17:42 and 17:45 marks. Doyle masterfully shielded the goal, deflecting the puck that was fired by two Bobcat forwards. Quinnipiac goalie Logan Angers also impressively withstood a powerful first-period Brown performance, saving
12 shots. At the end of the first period, Brown had 24 shots to Quinnipiac’s 10 — the game appearing a defensive battle. The second period escalated quickly, and — just 59 seconds into the period — Brown’s Cameron Sikich ’25 fired a shot at Quinnipiac that ricocheted off the crossbar, ringing loudly into the depths of Meehan. Later on, the Bears roamed close to another goal when India McDadi ’26 had a one-onone fast break. McDadi rapidly moved the puck side-to-side and launched it at Bobcat goalie, though Quinnipiac came up with yet another defensive stop. The Bears’ defense finally broke down at the 16:11 mark when Quinnipiac’s Zoe Uens got the puck after a successful face off and scored — leaving Brown down 1-0 at the end of the second period. But just as things seemed to be moving in the wrong direction for Bruno, Gali Levy ’26 shifted the momentum with a stylish goal assisted by Sam Broz ’27, bringing the Bears to an even 1-1 at the third period’s 1:59 mark. Not long after, Margot Norehad ’27 gave Bruno the lead with a spectacular goal — one that would later be featured as the #1 play on SportsCenter’s “Top 10 Plays” of the day. Skating behind the Quinnipiac goal, Norehad maneuvered the puck into the upper-left corner of the goal to give the
COURTESY OF ASHTON ROBERTSON VIA BROWN ATHLETICS
Margot Norehad ’27’s goal landed the No. 1 ranked play on SportsCenter’s Top 10. Bears the lead with ten minutes left. As the Bears’ defense held relentlessly on the 2-1 lead, Quinnipiac brought out their goalie for additional offense. To Quinnipiac’s dismay, the Bears were able to capitalize on the empty net, as Broz and Jade Iginla ’26 each scored a goal in the period’s final two minutes, securing
a 4-1 Bruno victory. “It’s a signature win for our program as we make our strides here. Everyone was exceptional. Yesterday was about Doyle, today was about possessing the puck on offense on all three lines and our defense,” said Ruzzi in a statement to Brown Athletics. “It was a full team effort
of great play.” The Bears’ next challenge will come on Friday at 6 p.m. in Schenectady, N.Y, where Brown will face off against Union College (8-17-2).
This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Jan. 28, 2024.
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
PAGE 7
SPORTS
MEN’S BASKETBALL
Heartbreak in Hanover: Men’s basketball gives up 14 point lead, loses 75-71 Game in Hanover coincides with Dartmouth alumni weekend BY LYDELL DYER SENIOR STAFF WRITER On Saturday afternoon, the men’s basketball team (5-14, 1-3 Ivy) faced the Big Green (5-12, 1-3 Ivy) in Hanover, New Hampshire. During Dartmouth’s alumni weekend contest, the Bears looked to rebound from last week’s one-point loss to Cornell, while Dartmouth — egged on by a crowd of over 800 — sought to clinch their first Ivy League victory of the season. After taking a resounding 14-point lead in the first half, the Bears ultimately fell to the Big Green 75-71. “I know this group will come together and figure out the shortcomings that we have had,” Malachi Ndur ’24 — who posted 14-points and three rebounds with three blocks — wrote to The Herald, following the loss. “As a team, we want to bounce back from the performance and outcome against Dartmouth. I know we will turn things around and make it to the Ivy League tournament.” Brown’s offense was led by Nana Owusu-Anane ’25, who delivered a season-high 21-point performance last week. The 6’8” forward dominated the glass again on Saturday, posting 20 points and notching nine rebounds. Alongside Owusu-Anane, the
SPORTS
BY THE NUMBERS
35
The number of points the women’s basketball team scored in their victory against Dartmouth.
192.900 The score of the women’s gymnastics team in a tri-meet against Alaska Anchorage and Southern Connecticut State. Jessica Lin’s beam performance earned her Gymnastics East Conference’s Specialist of the Week.
6
The number of matches won by Men’s Tennis to secure their victory against Sienna.
COURTESY OF EMMA MARION / BROWN ATHLETICS
Converting 87.5% of free throws and going 8-11 from the field, Brown buried the Big Green with a game-high 14-point lead halfway through the first. starting five comprised Kino Lilly Jr. ’25 and going 8-11 from the field, Brown and three blocks — the Bears then pushed — the Ivy League’s leading scorer — Felix buried the Big Green with a game-high in transition, scoring seven points off turnKloman ’24, Aaron Cooley ’25 and Kalu 14-point lead halfway through the first. overs in the first ten minutes alone. By the Anya ’26. But it was the complementary play of end of the first half, Brown had proven its Just six minutes into the game, the the defense that launched Brown’s offen- prowess, entering the locker room 37-26. Bears went on a crushing 10-0 run to claim sive flurry. The Bears kept their would-be Coming out of halftime, Dartmouth a 12-3 lead. Spurred by Lilly’s lethal threeattackers out of the paint, employing a revived their offense, cutting Brown’s lead point game and the performance of both press-heavy defense that forced the Big to a slim one-point margin in ten minutes. Anya and Owusu-Anane, Brown’s offense Green to shoot from deep. Capitalizing on With a dwindling clock and a roaring crowd overwhelmed the struggling Dartmouth dominant defensive stands — including at their back, the Bears found themselves defense. Converting 87.5% of free throws fourteen defensive rebounds, five steals pitted in an offensive shootout.
SCORES RECAP WOMEN’S ICE HOCKEY VS. PRINCETON VS. QUINNIPIAC
(OT) T, 1-1 W 4-1
FENCING ERIC SOLLEE INVITATIONAL 4-2 GYMNASTICS VS. ALASKA W 192.900 ANCHORAGE -192.425 VS. SOUTHERN W 192.900 CONNECTICUT STATE -191.100 BASKETBALL VS. DARTMOUTH
W 35-31
MEN’S SWIM VS. CORNELL
L 115.5-184.5
TENNIS VS. BOSTON COLLEGE VS. SIENA
W 5-2 W 6-1
BASKETBALL VS. DARTMOUTH
L 71-75
WRESTLING VS. CORNELL VS. BINGHAMTON
L -1-41 L 9-24
Bruno tried to combat the 21 points the Big Green generated off three pointers in the second half, looking to a distance game of their own. Ndur hit triple after triple, knocking down 100% of his attempts from beyond the arc. “I always try to let things flow naturally,” Ndur wrote in a message to The Herald. “I was in the right spots at the right time. I have the confidence in myself and from my teammates and coaches to shoot when I am open, so I kept getting opportunities and capitalizing on them.” Combined with Ndur’s performance, stellar play by an elusive Kimo Ferrari ’24 gave Bruno a 2-point lead with two minutes left. “I think we let Dartmouth get some confidence and rhythm too early in the second half,” wrote Ndur in a message to The Herald. “After we let them get into rhythm, they started hitting some tough shots, and things compiled from there. I think, as a unit, we have to be better about putting teams away and finishing games.” In the final minutes, the Big Green capitalized by drawing fouls, claiming a 75-71 victory. The Bears now prepare for this weekend’s double-header at the Pizzitola Sports Center, where they will host Penn at 7 p.m. on Friday night, and Princeton at 6 p.m. on Saturday. This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Jan. 29, 2024.
PAGE 8
THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 1, 2024
COMMENTARY
Sandhu ’25: Fear Of Many Opportunities As you weave through parked cars and scattered shopping carts, the bold red lettering on the warehouse beckons you: COSTCO. At
nar that inspired me to study literature from around the world. Brown’s emphasis on interdisciplinary studies allowed my diverse
— coupled with an intense pressure to succeed — begin to second guess their decisions. As I repeatedly modified my course of study,
demic exploration by underwriting our journey. While students may be unsure about their eventual concentration, they can be as-
the door, you confidently display your membership card as a smiling employee welcomes you inside. Flat-screen TVs line the walls, displaying vivid images that catch your eye. The smell of freshly baked bread wafts through the air. You even try a sample or two. And yet, your cart remains empty. Surrounded by countless items that compete for your attention, you suddenly wish you had come to Costco with a shopping list. Walking through the Van Wickle Gates, gripping a brand new Brown ID, can feel a lot like walking through Costco. First-years arriving at College Hill are met with a plethora of choice: Not only do students choose new friends, academic clubs and cultural organizations, they also select from a wide array of over 2,000 courses in 45 departments with minimal core requirements. Brown advertises its Open Curriculum as fertile ground for academic creativity and self-discovery — and this freedom can also prove daunting. I found that the more I explored different academic paths, the more I accumulated additional interests and additional doubts. My first semester course load consisted of big lecture classes in chemistry, calculus and neuroscience as well as a First-Year Semi-
interests to co-exist in an academic utopia, while simultaneously raising uncertainties about which career path I’d eventually choose.
I often wondered if I was trading off chasing my dreams with setting myself up for a lucrative career. Some decisions introduce more risk, while others require years of grad
sured of graduating with a degree. Instead of viewing the college experience as a race that was slowed down by exploratory “detours,” I began to appreciate that the reason our curriculum is so effective is that it makes room for midstream adjustments that ultimately benefit long-term academic, career and personal success. Some students need time to explore and others find their passion right away. Though this framework can remove the pressure of having everything figured out, it preserves the joy and agency that lives in the process of discovery itself. So, the next time you find yourself wandering the aisles of Costco, be sure to take your time, look around, try something new, and you might just end up with a cart full of inspired possibilities. And a $1.50 hotdog on your way out wouldn’t hurt.
“ Brown can be fertile ground for
academic creativity and selfdiscovery. However, this freedom can also prove daunting.
Students at Brown “have greater freedom to study what they choose and the flexibility to discover what they love,” according to the University’s website.” As a first-year student, I believed students could spend four years dabbling in anything and everything and miraculously wrap it all up with a degree and a career path. But in reality, Brown students surrounded by a dizzying array of choices
school. Choosing one academic possibility means giving up another, and that can feel like a loss. But in retrospect, I only smile at my worries. What I could only realize in my third year after successfully committing to my field of interest was that the Open Curriculum was my anchor all along. Brown mitigates some of the risks of aca-
Meher Sandhu ’25 can be reached at meher_sandhu@brown.edu. Please send responses to this opinion to letters@browndailyherald.com and other op-eds to opinions@browndailyherald.com. This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Jan. 28, 2024.
Chang ‘27: Forget e-scooters — long live RIPTA! I don’t like cars. They’re loud, expensive and they spew carbon dioxide everywhere. However, rentable electric scooters are not the solution, and actually contribute to net emissions. It’s time for Providence to promote more a environmentally friendly mode of transportation: the RIPTA bus system. There is no doubt that curtailing car use is a vital part of combating climate change. Cars and other light-duty vehicles make up nearly half of all greenhouse gas emissions in the transportation sector and a sixth of overall emissions in the U.S. Unless we want houses in Kansas to become ocean-front property, we need to rethink our transportation system. Credit where credit’s due: the municipal government of Providence has attempted to promote alternatives to cars multiple times in the past via the Shared Micromobility Program. Started in 2018, the program partners with private companies that rent out electric bicycles and scooters by the minute. Today, Providence partners with companies Bird, Spin and Veo, and the companies’ vehicles are ubiquitous throughout the city. Even so, e-scooters have failed to live up to promises of environmentalism, and Providence would be better off prioritizing the RIPTA bus system. Let’s start with claims about environmentalism. A major sales pitch is that e-scooters reduce total emissions by replacing trips that would otherwise be made by car. It is certainly true that electric bikes and scooters
are far more environmentally friendly than cars due to reduced energy consumption. However, according to a study conducted by North Carolina State University in 2019, only 34 percent of rides on e-scooters replace car rides. The rest replace more efficient and environmentally-friendly methods of transportation such as bicycles (e-bikes includ-
minute rental fee. The rider would pay a total of $2.40 in this case. Veo offers the most generous deal, allowing low-income riders to pay a monthly fee of $5.00, which then gives subscribers access to 30 minutes of riding time per day free of charge, with no unlocking fee. For context, a RIPTA fare with no discount costs $2.00 for an hour of unlimited
“
Instead of continuing to fall for hype, Providence must prioritize systems of transportation that will benefit both residents and the planet
ed), buses and walking. The result is that although car emissions decrease, e-scooters create a net increase in greenhouse gas emissions. The idea that e-scooters are more cost-effective for low-income people in Providence is also dubious. Bird applies a 50 percent discount for low-income riders, which when applied to the local pricing scheme yields an upfront fee of $0.50 and an additional fee $0.20 per minute. Meanwhile, Spin has a discounted rate of $0.50 along with a $0.10/
rides. In this scenario, only Veo beats out the standard RIPTA fare assuming a 19 minute commute. Of course, this relies on there being a Veo brand e-scooter consistently available near the rider’s home address. I do believe that the Shared Micromobility Program as a whole can be redeemed. One change is to force companies to alter their fleet composition to include more bicycles as opposed to scooters. As it stands, the limits imposed by the city of Providence upon micromobility companies are equal for scooters
and bicycles. These limits could be adjusted to increase the number of e-bikes, which produce one-fifth of the amount of carbon dioxide compared to scooters. Instead of going all-in on e-scooters, Providence can both reduce its negative impact on the environment as well as help the economically disadvantaged by providing subsidies for low-income residents to take the RIPTA. Although the RIPTA does offer reduced fares, only senior citizens and persons with disabilities are eligible. Providing financial incentives to broaden the number of people who take the bus would have two positive effects. The first is that low-income residents would have increased access to affordable transportation, which is critical for escaping poverty. The second is that it would reduce RIPTA’s emissions per capita. Buses are much more efficient than cars and scooters in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, but only if there is high ridership. The scooters scattered across the streets of Providence do next-to-nothing to ameliorate the problems with our transportation system. Instead of continuing to fall for the hype, Providence must prioritize systems of transportation that will benefit both residents and the planet.
Victor Chang ’27 can be reached at victor_a_chang@brown.edu. Please send responses to this opinion to letters@ browndailyherald.com and other op-eds to opinions@browndailyherald.com.
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
PAGE 9
METRO
PAGE 10
ARTS & CULTURE
THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 1, 2024
EXHIBITION
‘While the Sap Flows’: 16th annual Brown-RISD student-run exhibition opens at Granoff Dual degree students create exhibition exploring intimacy, materiality BY RYA VALLABHANENI ARTS & CULTURE EDITOR When entering the Granoff Center for the Creative Arts, visitors are met with two options: entering a small room on their left or ascending to the fourth floor. If they choose the first path, they will find a mahogany string instrument, or a colorful mobile meant to mimic a dancer’s torso. If they choose the second, they will likely encounter various ceramics, large paintings and clouds made of glass. All of these diverse pieces are part of “While the Sap Flows,” the BrownRISD dual degree program’s 16th annual student-organized exhibition. Opened on Jan. 20, the exhibition will remain on view until Feb. 25. Spread out across the Granoff’s first to fourth floors, the exhibition exclusively features the work of dual degree students. Centered around themes of intimacy and materiality, the exhibition is the culmination of months of hard work — organized, promoted and curated completely by dual-degrees, said Anay Agarwal ’28, a member of the graphics and reception committees. Part of Agarwal’s work involved creating promotional materials for the exhibit and setting up a dry floral arranging activity for the opening reception. “I really liked the presentation of the event,” said Isabella Yoo ’25, a Brown student who attended the exhi-
DANA RICHIE, RYA VALLABHANENI / HERALD
Centered around themes of intimacy and materiality, the exhibition is the culmination of months of hard work — organized, promoted and curated all by dual-degrees, according to Anay Agarwal ’28.
bition’s reception. “I thought the bouquet-making was a very nice touch.” Agarwal explained that students on the exhibition committee are responsible for coming up with the year’s themes and curating the exhibit. This year, Naya Lee Chang ’24, a former member of the exhibition committee, is presenting a tunnel book called “Looking Back.” She explained that her piece is about the story of a previous long-distance relationship. “This is probably the one piece of personal work I’ve ever made in my life,” Chang said. “But I felt it fit with the theme.” Lucinda Drake ’25 chose to present a set of hand-colored photos accompanied by one woodblock print. Drake, who studies Illustration and Literary Arts, explained that her series “Open Casket” was created as a celebration of death. Her hand-colored photos showcase deceased animals that she encountered, knit clothing for and then buried. “I like the idea of having new ceremonies around death, and trying to integrate warmth into it — both emotional warmth and literally physical warmth,” Drake said. Drake is also showing a separate woodblock entitled “It’s so boring not to be in love,” displayed on the third floor. “I have been more and more appreciative of the (dual degree) program over time,” said Chang, who studies Furniture Design and History. “As a fifth-year now, I have a good understanding of the resources we have both at Brown and RISD.” Agarwal explained that the around 75 dual degree students form a relatively tight-knit group. “It’s really easy to get insular with the program,” Agarwal said. “So it’s really exciting to see my friends from Brown and friends from RISD both be able to come to this (exhibition) that, at (its) core, is celebrating the dual degree students.” This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Jan. 29, 2024.
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
PAGE 11
ARTS & CULTURE
REVIEW
‘Mean Girls’ remake fails to add musical twist on teenage classic Film loses substance in attempts to be both more current, true to its roots BY CAMPBELL LOI SENIOR STAFF WRITER The late ’90s and early 2000s were a golden age for teen comedy. The era brought countless classics like “10 Things I Hate About You,” “Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen” and “Clueless” to the big screens which then became staples at sleepovers for years to come. Among the most well-known films of that era was “Mean Girls,” whose widespread popularity has made pink a staple for Wednesday outfits and Oct. 3 a “national holiday.” Ever since its remake was announced back in 2020, fans and movie watchers alike have speculated about what the new version would look like — and if it could live up the original’s high status in popular culture. Now, the wait is finally over. The newest iteration of the 2004 cult classic follows the same plotline as its predecessor. After being homeschooled in Kenya, Cady Heron (Angourie Rice) is thrust into the chaotic realities of an American public school and quickly gets to know the Plastics — the school’s A-list clique and apex predators led by Regina George (Reneé Rapp). After Cady makes the mistake of falling for Aaron Samuels (Christopher Briney), Regina’s ex-boyfriend, she devises a plan with friends Janis (Auli‘i Cravalho) and Damian (Jaquel Spivey) to end Regina’s evil rule. Despite the faithful plot, many fans of the original movie were confused when the widely anticipated remake turned out to be a musical,
adapted from its years on Broadway. While the movie-musical phenomenon is nothing new, the genre has been falling out of style in Hollywood. With the exceptions of some such as “La La Land,” most movie musicals have struggled to match the same success they’ve seen in the past. The official trailer for “Mean Girls” notably leaves out the film’s theatrical aspects. “We didn’t want to run out and say it’s a musical because people tend to treat musicals differently,” said Marc Weinstock, president of global marketing and distribution at Paramount, the movie’s distributor, in an interview with Variety. He added that the small music note in the movie’s title provided “hints to it without being overbearing.” Other recent releases such as “Wonka” or “The Color Purple” have followed similar patterns in their promotions, demonstrating what seems to be an industry-wide aversion to explicitly advertising movies as musicals. But being a musical was not what doomed “Mean Girls” to fail, but rather its inability to fully commit to such a label. In an attempt to make the genre more palatable and appease broader audiences, the vast majority of musical numbers from Broadway’s original score were cut and those that remained were stripped down from full orchestrations to minimalistic pop adaptations. The movie was also significantly hindered by a lack of vocal prowess from its leading couple. Though Rapp, Cravalho and Spivey all gave outstanding performances in their respective roles, Rice’s limited range and vocal power led to a significant simplification of Cady’s solos.
COURTESY OF PARAMOUNT
It was not being a musical that doomed “Mean Girls” to fail, but rather its hesitance to fully commit to the genre. Meanwhile, Briney’s lack of musical experience resulted in the exclusion of Aaron’s numbers from the movie altogether. The reduced number of musical numbers impacted important plot points, particularly jeopardizing character development. Discarded tracks from the Broadway show such as “It Roars,” “Fearless” and “More Is Better” provided crucial peeks into Cady’s inner monologue, providing necessary context for her later actions. Without these insights, the plotline felt clunky, confusing and at times even impossible to follow — especially for those not already familiar with the original story.
This disappointing final product begs the question: If the music wasn’t a priority for the movie, neither in sound nor in promotions, then why produce a musical at all? Trying to please fans of both the original “Mean Girls” and its Broadway adaptation proved to be harder than making “fetch” happen, and both audiences were left frustrated. Perhaps, this can serve as a lesson for future movie musicals producers to fully embrace the dramatics unique to the genre. This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald. com on Jan. 28, 2024.
REVIEW
New season of ‘Single’s Inferno’: theatrics, laughs, red flags
From “Hell Island” to “Paradise Island,” contestants search for love BY REBECCA WENG SENIOR STAFF WRITER In December 2023, Netflix premiered the third season of “Single’s Inferno,” a South Korean dating show. Known for its dramatic plots and mysterious guests, the series has kept audiences eagerly waiting for its annual return. This latest season is the most successful so far, with over 71 million hours of views alone, compared to 79 million hours from the previous two seasons combined. In “Single’s Inferno,” six female and six male guests are brought to “Hell Island,” where they are given limited food and makeshift cabins to sleep
in. With no access to social media or external contacts, guests are forced to overcome the challenges of living together while trying to find love. Every afternoon, contestants are given a chance to escape to “Paradise Island,” a luxury hotel, if they succssfully match with another guest on the island. It’s only during these date nights that contestants are allowed to reveal details of their personal lives, such as occupations and ages. Midway through the show, a secret participant is introduced to the island to disrupt the relationship web. Finally, at the end of eight days, contestants make their dramatic final decision about who they’d like to end up with, attempting to “hold hands” with their desired date. In this season, the immediate twist comes after the first date night, when viewers learn that, for the first time, there will be two “Hell Islands” with
completely different casts. Though the two islands, which guests were allowed to switch between, brought immediate suspense to the show, the tension only lasted until episode three, when all members came together as one cast for the rest of the season. Season three also increased the frequency of date nights compared to prior seasons by making it mandatory for participants to match with another guest every day. This rule change certainly enhanced the dramatic elements of the show, allowing the audience to observe different combinations of couples in every episode. But it also pushed guests to go on dates even when they weren’t interested, limiting opportunities for those with more meaningful connections to get to know each other. One of the season’s participants, Lee Gwan-hee, a 34-year-old professional basketball player in the Korean
COURTESY OF TUDUM BY NETFLIX
This season often pushed guests to go on dates even when they weren’t interested, limiting opportunities for those with more meaningful connections to get to know each other. Basketball League, caused much debate online for being a “walking red flag.” Known for his situationships with the “33% Trio” — three fellow female guests on the island — Gwan-hee surprises the audience with one change of heart after another. While Gwan-hee’s drama is undoubtedly entertaining, it took away from other guests’ screen time, who had fewer opportunities to showcase their personalities and interests. Out of all of its seasons, the latest installment of “Single’s Inferno,” while definitely the most theatrical, is also the most unbalanced. The season did provide millions of viewers with laughs during the winter holidays, but the reality of the relationships developed in the show may be called into question.
UPCOMING PERFORMANCES Introductory Workshop: Bharatanatyam with Sunanda Narayanan The Lindemann Performing Arts Center Movement Lab Feb.2, 4:00 p.m. - 6:00 p.m.
IGCAC Welcome Back Arch Sing Faunce Arch Feb. 3, 2:00 p.m.
Kriolu Voices Sounding: Cabo Verdean/American Music and Politics in Rhode Island Capeverdean American Community Development Center Feb. 3, 4:00 p.m.
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
PANEL FROM PAGE 1 of the democratic landscape,” Honig added. “The court decision on affirmative action from the perspective of democracy and democratic theory is part of a larger struggle in the U.S. right now over education, democratic values and the limits and reach of state power.” Honig went on to cite controversies in Virginia over critical race theory and anti-LGBTQ+ statutes in Florida, as “developments that share one goal: to cultivate mistrust in institutions of higher education.” Powell began his portion of the panel by emphasizing the principle of “racial diversity in classrooms” as crucial for the “foundational growth of students who contribute to society.” He went on to explain the implications of the Supreme Court’s decision on the University’s admissions policies. Powell pointed to a quote from Chief Justice John Roberts’ majority opinion in SFFA v. Harvard: “Nothing in this opinion should be construed as prohibiting universities from considering an applicant’s discussion of how race affected his or her life, be it through discrimination, inspiration or otherwise.” “That’s what we had been doing at Brown all along … Race in and of itself was never the reason an applicant was admitted, denied (or) waitlisted,” Powell said. Powell also highlighted the addition of new short answer essays that
CCE FROM PAGE 1 decades-long history of spreading science disinformation and should not have any relationship with the CCE. Still, Sunrise Brown co-founder Isaac Slevin ’25 said the agreement is “a very important first step in acknowledging the harm that these companies are doing and how their mission runs completely counter to Brown.” Sunrise reached the agreement with the CCE after a series of meetings with the Center’s staff that began in fall 2022. According to Sunrise Co-Hub Coordinator Caitlyn Carpenter ’26, the group’s leaders first approached Donato after SLB — the world’s largest offshore drilling company — and ExxonMobil hosted recruiting events with the CCE in fall 2022. The latter was disrupted by nearly 60 student protestors. Since then, Sunrise has met with CCE staff nearly a dozen times, with Dean of the College Rashid Zia joining on several occasions, Slevin said. Members of the group also hand-delivered letters to CCE staff members detailing “how fossil fuel companies are destroying our future and lying to us.” According to Carpenter, conversations initially began as discussions about how the CCE could implement a fossil-free career policy. But negotiations soon hit “a barrier” that Slevin said the two parties “didn’t ultimately get over.” Sunrise members argued that the CCE’s association with fossil fuel companies was a violation of the University’s Business Ethics Policy, which governs relationships between the University and the suppliers with which it conducts business. According to the policy, “the University will not … conduct business with individuals and organizations that directly support the creation and dissemination of science disinformation.”
allow applicants to “talk about their background, their lived experience (and) experiences with inspiration, courage, leadership, etc.” These additions come as the SFFA case has eliminated the ability for admissions officers to view applicants’ selected races and ethnicities on the Common App portal, he said. Finally, Powell lamented the impact of the decision on applicants, “who — in some cases — don’t want to relive the trauma of discrimination,” he said. Applicants may “want to tell stories of hope and joy and excellence, but (could) feel compelled to talk about painful experiences” instead. Roth discussed how Wesleyan University has attempted to “achieve diversity” in “the absence of affirmative action.” The school ended legacy admissions in July 2023, a decision Roth said was motivated by the desire “to send a signal to Black and brown students in particular that we value diversity.” Roth highlighted a focus on supporting economically disadvantaged schools, noting Wesleyan’s partnership with the National Education Equity Foundation, “which offers credit-bearing courses in Title I high-poverty high schools,” he said. But he also warned that “there are really good reasons to be suspicious about affirmative action.” “It shows that places like (Wesleyan) and (Brown) do not have intellectual diversity at the level that allows us to really learn ideas,” he said. Noting
Sunrise member Gus Konigsmark ’26, who called on the University to adopt a fossil-free careers policy in an April 2023 op-ed published in The Herald, said in an interview that he believes that the CCE’s current practice of allowing fossil fuel companies to recruit at Brown “contradicts the spirit of Brown’s Business Ethics Policy,” even if it isn’t an outright violation. Whether the CCE is violating University policy, Konigsmark said, depends on the definition of “business.” According to the CCE’s recruiting fee schedule, for-profit companies must pay $800 to secure a table at an in-person career fair, $350 for a “table” at a virtual fair and $150 to host an information session. “There is not a list of ‘approved’ or ‘unapproved’ companies or industries with which departments and individuals at Brown can or cannot engage with,” University Spokesperson Brian Clark wrote in an email to The Herald. “Rather, we have broader policy in place rooted in the agreed-upon principles, and that policy guides specific decisions by members of the Brown community as they fulfill roles and responsibilities on campus.” “Rather than focusing on how to prevent departments or groups from inviting such companies to campus, (Donato) and I were looking for ways to build partnerships across campus to engage and invite employers who are directly working to make a positive impact on climate change,” Zia wrote in an email to The Herald. “We appreciated those concerns and agreed with some, yet we were equally focused on not preventing other Brown students from accessing employment opportunities that they might be interested in exploring,” Donato wrote in an email to The Herald. Several Sunrise members familiar with the discussions told The Herald that Donato did not seem to believe he had the
PAGE 12
UNIVERSITY NEWS Brown’s progressive-leaning student body, Roth asked, “Who is going to bring to you (the) intelligent conservative ideas and mores that may not fly in Brooklyn Heights?” Friedman highlighted the power of admissions officers in shaping the “trajectory” of applicants’ lives. “We … are now like the gatekeepers to who gets access to this enormous boost in your life trajectory,” he said. “We need to think about who is getting that boost.” “There’s an enormous amount of evidence about how, depending on the circumstances of your birth, there are very unequal life trajectories,” he added, noting that race and socioeconomic status are particularly relevant in determining that trajectory. Following the opening remarks from the panelists, the event progressed into an hour-long question-and-answer session. One audience member asked about the implications of replacing consideration of race with consideration of socioeconomic status as a method of introducing diversity. Differences in life trajectories across racial lines persist “even when you look at people who have the same level of income or education,” Friedman responded. “Just (to give) an example, children of Black millionaires are more likely to end up in prison at age 30 than the children of white families earning, like, $50,000 a year,” he said. Another audience member asked
how admissions policies at elite universities could put pressure on wealthier families which, they observed, tend to prefer private schools instead of the public educational system. “Wesleyan works extra hard to find public school graduates so that we have less of a disproportionate student body from private schools,” Roth responded. “That (sends) a signal to parents — ‘well, if you want to get into Brown or Wesleyan, then you want to go to the local school, rather than to go to private school.’” But Powell highlighted another factor: “Who made the decision for the student to go to the school?” he said. “Should we hold it against a student if a parent chose to live in a particular place or to send them to a particular school?” “We’re sensitive to that as well,” he added. Other attendees asked about differences in educational investment between communities, the importance of intellectual diversity in admissions and the impact of affirmative action on Asian American students. Alex Shieh ’27 attended the event because of his interest in affirmative action, as well as the different perspectives offered by the panel. “I think it’s important to … hear different perspectives to inform your own,” he said. Shieh asked the panel about the role of Asian American students in affirmative action policies. “I think a lot of times in the affirmative action
debate, there is a lot more focus on African Americans and white students,” he said. “It is important to focus on how this affects everyone.” Shieh also said he wished there were more people opposed to affirmative action represented on the panel. Nathan Seelig ’27 found particular interest in the discussion of standardized test scores and their prediction of college success, a relationship explored in a new Opportunity Insights study led by Friedman, The Herald previously reported. Seelig found Friedman’s point that data from “the SAT is not necessarily the means of injustice, or something that creates bias, but rather it reflects bias and injustice in society,” especially interesting, he said. Curious about how Brown addresses “questions of meritocracy and equity,” Daniel Schiffman ’27 came to the event to learn about how admissions has shifted its policies. He also noted the panel’s focus on the issue of diversity and the various ways it applies to the admissions process. Diversity remains at the forefront of discussions surrounding affirmative action and the future of admissions in higher education. “We are committed, as an institution and as an office of college admission, to the values of the University,” Powell said. These values are “to build diverse classes of students — diversity as broadly defined as possible — with a focus on academic excellence.”
CHRIS NGUYEN / HERALD
authority to implement further recruitment restrictions without a corresponding University-wide policy. “There are so many things that the University does to make sure that it is acting independently and in its students’ best interests, protecting freedom of inquiry and the freedom to research all these different ideas, so it was bizarre to us that keeping out disinformation from recruiting events did not count,” Slevin said. Brown students have collectively submitted only 22 applications to the 88 job openings currently listed by Oil & Gas companies on Handshake — a figure Donato shared as an indication that “there is
little value to Brown students for the CCE to actively seek on-campus participation from these companies.” On Tuesday, student activists at Sunrise urged the University to adopt a fossil-free careers policy in a presentation to the Advisory Committee on University Resource Management, The Herald previously reported. At the meeting, Sunrise also outlined a proposal for implementing a fossil-free faculty retirement plan and prohibiting researchers from accepting funds from the fossil fuel industry. The group first outlined these goals in its Dissociate Now report released in February 2023 and has continued pushing
for them through its “Dissociate and Respect” campaign. The Committee plans to review Sunrise’s proposal and submit official recommendations to the University. In the coming months, Sunrise will shift its focus to the “Respect” portion of the campaign, which examines how Brown engages with the Providence community. “We’re really talking about respect,” Slevin said. “Respect for the community and its residents, respect from an institution with a $6 billion endowment, and needing a more ethical way of conducting research and fundamentally engaging with the community.”