Skip to main content

Friday, November 20, 2026

Page 1

SINCE 1891

THE BROWN DAILY HERALD VOLUME CLXI, ISSUE 22

BROWNDAILYHERALD.COM

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2026 ANTHONY CIANFLONE / HERALD

UNIVERSITY ADMINISTRATION

Brown posts $50.4 million operating deficit in 2026 report The University also cited a “management view deficit figure” of $2 million BY ETHAN SCHENKER STAFF WRITER

Brown reports over $20 million in ‘unplanned’ expenses from Dec. 13 shooting Security expenditures and legal fees contributed to unexpected costs BY ETHAN SCHENKER STAFF WRITER Brown’s response to the Dec. 13 mass shooting led to more than $20 million of “unplanned expenses” during the fiscal year 2026, according to the annual financial report released on Thursday. In the months after the attack, the University’s expenses included student support costs, payments for construction around impacted areas, external review

costs and legal fees, among others. The tragedy “required an urgent and sustained institutional response that carried both human and financial costs,” the report reads. In May, the University also set aside $15 million in the fiscal year 2027 budget for shooting-related costs. “We expect many of these costs to stabilize and become part of the annual operating budget in the coming years for the new infrastructure Brown has put in place,” Michael White, chief financial officer and vice president for finance and administrative services, wrote in an email to The Herald. In the months following the shooting,

the Brown Annual Fund, the University’s immediate-use funding resource, also saw a “record-breaking” 17% increase in donations in FY26, according to the annual report. “In the wake of the December tragedy, Brunonians from all over the world supported students who needed emergency funds for clothes, travel costs and other necessities,” Paxson wrote. Many also donated to the Ever True Support Fund, which supports short and long-term recovery efforts. White did not directly respond to a request for a breakdown of the $20 million

SEE EXPENSES PAGE 2

Brown reported a $50.4 million operating deficit for the fiscal year 2026 based on generally accepted accounting principles, according to an annual financial report released by the University on Thursday. But in other parts of the report, President Christina Paxson P’19 P’MD’20 wrote that the University ended the year with a $2 million operating deficit. The $48.4 million difference between the two deficit figures exists because the $50.4 million figure reflects the GAAP calculation, while the $2 million value reflects a “management view deficit figure,” Chief Financial Officer and Vice President for Finance and Administrative Services Michael White wrote in an email to The Herald. White wrote that the “management view” differs from the GAAP calculations in “depreciation, employee benefit costs and accruals.” According to the University’s audited financial statements,

the University’s depreciation costs increased by just $1 million between 2025 and 2026, and the growth of employee benefit spending remained at a similar rate as last year. The report specified that, unless otherwise noted, “narratives, charts and tables” in the publication represented GAAP-calculated figures. In the report’s references to the $2 million deficit figure, though, it did not specifically explain how that number was calculated. GAAP is a widely-used set of standards based on established conventions that determine how financial statements are created and presented. According to White, the University first began publishing GAAP figures as part of their annual financial reports in 2019. White wrote that the University’s “management view” figure “offers a clear and more direct picture of current finances.” White explained that GAAP guidelines include “revenue when it’s earned and expenses when they are incurred,” while the “management view focuses on resources available and how those are deployed in a given fiscal year.” White added that in FY25, the University’s GAAP calculated surplus was

SEE ADMINISTRATION PAGE 2

FACULTY

Code of conduct draft reverses proposed changes regarding academic freedom, protest The revised code aims to align with Brown’s Statement of Values and Voice BY JEREMIAH FARR AND SEYLA FERNANDEZ SENIOR STAFF WRITERS On Nov. 12, President Christina Paxson P’19 P’MD’20 and Faculty Executive Committee Chair Colleen Dalton, a professor of Earth, environmental and planetary sciences, sent faculty a revised set of proposed changes to the University Code of Conduct in a Today@Brown message. The most recent draft of the code amends changes recommended by the University Values and Voice Implementation Working Group in October. This draft alters the wording on academic freedom policies and protest, and maintains the removal of the University’s financial disclosure policies. This is the second set of proposed revisions to the code of conduct to align with the University’s Statement of University Values and Voice, which was approved in 2025 following campus discussion about divestment. The statement defines what Brown’s “voice” — or stance on public issues — and core institutional values are. Faculty were first informed of proposed

Sports

changes — including alterations to the Protest and Demonstration Policy, the Political Activity Policy and the Events Disruption Protocol — at the October faculty meeting. The revisions sparked concerns from some faculty members. A Today@Brown message formally announcing the October changes included a form for community members to provide feedback on the proposed changes. The second set of revisions is based on feedback collected by the form, which closed on Nov. 6. A Nov. 19 faculty town hall will be held for further discussion on the code of conduct revisions. The Herald compared both sets of proposed changes to the original code of conduct. University Values and Voice statement added to the code of conduct The current code of conduct’s policy statement lays out the “primary principles that the University expects Brown community members to uphold.” In both the October and November revised versions of the code of conduct, the UVV statement is added to the “Policy Statement” section. Many of the items formerly in the policy statement section — such as academic freedom and nondiscrimination — are moved into a following section on “Complying with the

University Code of Conduct.” The existing code of conduct states that community members “are responsible for sustaining the highest ethical standards of the University, and of the broader community in which they function. The University values integrity, honesty and fairness, and strives to integrate these values into its teaching, research and business activities.” The October proposal begins by emphasizing that all community members are accountable for following the policies outlined in the code and states that “members of the community are guided by the core institutional values of Brown University.” The four paragraphs that follow this statement are taken from the UVV, which did not exist at the time the existing code was created. The four values pulled from the UVV are “the pursuit of knowledge and understanding; academic freedom and freedom of expression; a commitment to openness and diversity of ideas, perspectives and experiences; and responsibility for a thriving academic community. The second draft maintains these proposed changes. 1966 academic freedom policy added to replace October’s stricter academic freedom section

SEE SOCCER PAGE 6

The current code of conduct contains a definition of academic freedom established in 1966. The policy — which currently lives under the overarching “Policy Statement” section and in the full faculty rules and regulations — states that academic freedom “is essential to the function of education and to the pursuit of scholarship in universities” and emphasizes that members of the campus community will have “full freedom in their teaching, learning and research.” The October draft added a new section to the code of conduct, which placed more stringent terms on academic freedom. The section stated that “academic freedom is earned through training and demonstrated competence, is therefore limited to areas of professional knowledge and imposes responsibilities on those who exercise it.” The October draft also added a provision that “the right to protest, dissent and criticize is not unlimited; it excludes actions that deprive others in the Brown community of the right to participate fully in University life as these are contrary to the University mission and values.” “Within the University, in accord with core institutional values, (freedom of expression) is the right to communicate ideas and engage in reasoned and informed protest, dissent and criticism,” the October

post- Magazine

draft also states. The line about protest and criticism not being unlimited, along with the added provisions about academic freedom, were removed in the November draft. Instead, the new section on academic freedom once again included the 1966 statement on academic freedom. The 1966 statement and the UVV statement “both speak to academic freedom and freedom of expression, albeit with somewhat different language,” Paxson and Dalton wrote in Thursday’s message. “Given that both currently exist with the same standing in terms of faculty and Corporation approval, we think it is prudent to include both verbatim in the University Code of Conduct.” Financial reporting and University contracts stipulations removed Both the October and November drafts also propose removing sections on financial reporting and University contracts. According to the current code of conduct, community members must “adhere to University policies for financial accounts, reports, expense reimbursements, time and effort submissions and other transac-

SEE FACULTY PAGE 3

SEE POST- PAGE 8


PAGE 2

Friday, November 20, 2026

UNIVERSITY NEWS EXPENSES FROM PAGE 1 in post-shooting spending. Following the shooting, the University “quickly allocated substantial resources” to increase security measures and support services and construct structures restricting access to the areas near the scene of the shooting. Ten Barus and Holley classrooms that closed after the shooting are currently undergoing renovation and are expected to reopen in summer 2027. Brown also bought plane tickets as well

as phones and laptops for students forced to abandon their belongings while fleeing the attack, according to the report. In January, the University announced plans to double the number of Department of Public Safety and Emergency Management officers on patrol shifts. The University also installed new panic buttons to classrooms and blue light emergency phones. Since December 2025, Brown has added more than 700 security cameras on cam-

pus. Last month, University officials scaled back Brown’s use of security guards. The change marks a shift from acute emergency staffing to a long-term security posture, The Herald reported. Brown also retained Rhode Island’s former United States Attorney Zachary Cunha ’98 to represent the University in connection with shooting-related legal matters. In Dec. 2025, the Department of Education announced an investigation over

compliance with campus safety laws. In April, three students injured in the shooting filed three lawsuits against the University for alleged security failures. Brown also launched three external reviews since the shooting. Global consulting firm Teneo Risk conducted two reviews — one analyzing the University’s operations before, during and after the shooting and another assessing campus-wide safety and security. The third review was conducted

by national security firm COSECURE to examine the physical security of campus infrastructure. In August, Teneo released an executive summary of their after-action review, which stated that it was “highly unlikely” the shooting could have been prevented.

after reaching a voluntary agreement with the federal government in July 2025. In 2026 Brown’s fiscal health was particularly impacted by federal policy and the $20 million in unplanned expenses from the Dec. 13 shooting, Paxson wrote. But citing growth in University assets to over $10 billion and the University-computed $2 million deficit figure, she wrote that “Brown closed FY26 in a significantly stronger financial position than the previous year.” The University reported a 19.6% return on its endowment during the fiscal year, a jump from an 11.9% growth rate in

FY25. Paxson wrote that the University plans to reduce the 5.5% portion it draws from its endowment to 5% over a “multiyear period.” Moody’s, a major credit rating firm, downgraded Brown’s credit outlook from stable to “negative” this summer, citing “weakening in already thin operating performance that could persist for several years.” In response to questions about the rating, White wrote that “Brown has a robust multi-year financial plan that projected the deficit for this year as well as deficits for at least two more fiscal years,

so the FY26 result was not unexpected.” “Brown is focused on maintaining close controls on expense growth and growing new areas of revenue over the next several years,” White added. “We continue to closely manage the operating deficit through a period of significant strategic investment in our research enterprise and our partner health systems.” Interest also fueled the University’s growing expenses. The University’s spending on interest grew from $38.2 million to $66.5 million. The annual report notes that during nine months of

FY26, the University had $800 million in outstanding commercial loans, which were secured amid threats to federal funding. In an email, White wrote that he does not expect the heightened interest spending “to grow materially in the short term,” adding that “we both borrowed and repaid a $500 million term loan in FY26, which accounts for the majority of the increase in interest expense.”

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 19, 2026.

ADMINISTRATION FROM PAGE 1 $2.6 million, while the management view figure was a $16 million surplus. The management view $16 million surplus figure was not reported in the FY25 report. White wrote that “moving forward, we’ll replicate the approach taken in this FY26 report with both (the management view and GAAP) results clearly identified.” In FY26, Brown saw a nearly 37% increase in award funding from the previous fiscal year, which Paxson attributed to Brown’s “success in securing large grants” and the resumption of funding

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 19, 2026.

CRIME

Racist, anti-Black graffiti found at Ladd Observatory The graffiti was discovered during a routine site assessment BY ZARINA HAMILTON UNIVERSITY NEWS EDITOR On Friday morning, the Department of Public Safety and Emergency Management was notified that racist and anti-Black graffiti had been spray-painted on the Ladd Observatory. Community members were informed of the incident approximately eight hours later, at which point the graffiti had been removed. The graffiti was found by a University staff member while “conducting a routine site assessment” at the observatory, ac-

cording to Hugh Clements, Brown police chief and vice president for public safety and emergency management. He added that the graffiti was spray-painted on “a low-traffic alcove that is not readily visible to individuals passing by.” Following the staff member’s report, Facilities Management documented and removed the graffiti, according to Clements. “We continuously evaluate campus security infrastructure and maintain regular patrols across all University properties as part of our commitment to crime prevention,” he wrote in an email to The Herald. DPSEM is working with the Providence Police Department to identify the perpetrator and “determine if there is any connection to broader activity in the area,” Clements wrote.

Following the removal and investigation of the graffiti, the incident was brought to the Office of Equity Compliance and Reporting “to ensure full Title VI compliance and institutional accountability,” Poitevien wrote. Additional response will be determined by the Campus Climate Response Team, which works to develop and implement strategies addressing concerns related to campus climate, Poitevien added. “We remain steadfast in our commitment to confronting hate and maintaining welcoming, inclusive spaces across our campus,” Poitevien wrote. CLAIRE KE / HERALD

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 16, 2026.

The graffiti, which has since been removed, was discovered during a routine site assessment by University staff.

INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS

After CPT work authorization suspension, international students may face career challenges Brown will not approve CPT authorization for undergraduates BY ZARINA HAMILTON AND RACHEL WICKER UNIVERSITY NEWS EDITOR AND SENIOR STAFF WRITER

A senior was supposed to spend her last semester this fall completing an internship through the Brown in Washington program. But in August, she received word from Brown that her Curricular Practical Training authorization request would not be approved. “This popped up, like, three days before I was supposed to go on my flight for D.C.,” the senior, who was granted anonymity because she is currently applying for a different form of work authorization, said. “Everything was planned.” CPT is a form of work authorization that allows international students to complete internships and similar work programs in the United States. In August, the Student and Exchange Visitor Program sent a message to many U.S. universities stating that CPT authorization may be granted only for work required by or “formally recognized

as part of” an academic program. Last Wednesday, the Office of International Student and Scholar Services officially notified F-1 students that the University will indefinitely suspend Curricular Practical Training authorizations for undergraduate students. Currently, no undergraduate programs at Brown include a work requirement, but students enrolled in six different masters programs remain eligible through internship and practicum requirements. In the past, international students have used CPT authorization to complete extracurricular work and internships related to their areas of study. The message added that noncompliance with updated practical training requirements could result in the revocation of the institution’s ability to enroll international students on F-1 or M-1 visas. Following this broadcast message, Brown launched a review of their CPT guidelines and updated eligibility to align with SEVP’s interpretation. According to ISSS’s website, international undergraduate students hoping to intern in the United States will still be able to receive pre-completion Optional Practical Training authorization, which requires an application to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services and costs $470.

But relying on OPT for a summer internship directly subtracts from the typical one year of OPT that is already allotted after graduation. If you work two summers with OPT, “that’s six months already gone,” explained the senior. “It becomes very tricky because they have to choose whether to intern during their undergrad or to save that time for post-grad.” Since OPT authorization takes several months to be approved by the USCIS, many international students are “scrambling” to secure their internships as soon as possible, the student said. “I’ve noticed a common theme where technically there’s still an option, but there (are) so many hurdles,” she said. She added that the Trump administration’s policies regarding international students’ statuses are designed to make students “feel unwelcome” and create “extra barriers for (them) to be here.” The White House did not respond to a request for comment. An international student from Vietnam, who requested anonymity out of concern about his visa status, wrote in a message to The Herald that he was in the process of early recruiting for summer finance internships when he learned of the CPT suspension.

“Getting that email in the middle of recruiting season was rough,” he wrote, adding that summer finance internships are critical for future employment in the field. Now, if he gets an internship, he will have to use OPT, which will leave him with less OPT time to work in the U.S. after graduation. The CPT suspension “makes an existing gap bigger,” he wrote. “My domestic friends can just take a summer internship. We have to either skip it or burn time we’ll need later.” He also worries that the CPT suspension might make Brown “a harder sell for international applicants down the line.” “I hope Brown pushes back where it can and looks into options like credit-bearing internship courses,” he added. “We all saw it coming,” an international student from a country in the Middle East, who also wished to remain anonymous due to concerns for her visa status, wrote in a message to The Herald. “It’s extremely disappointing.” The student expressed concern that employers may start “automatically rejecting international students since there is no guarantee (they’ll) get work authorization.” “I hope that Brown offers alternative solutions like more on-campus summer research opportunities or employment that prioritizes international students, since we

won’t have options to gain work experience outside campus anymore,” she added. On-campus employment, including the completion of Undergraduate Teaching and Research Awards, does not require special work authorization for F-1 students. In a message to The Herald, Andrew Shiotani, director of ISSS, wrote that Brown “has been engaged in an intensive review of (its) CPT policies and procedures” since the new federal guidelines were released in August. Brown’s update to CPT authorizations was intended “to reflect how these guidelines may impact different students in different degree programs,” he wrote. Several other Ivy League institutions have halted CPT authorizations for students’ degrees without a formal work or internship requirement following the SEVP’s warning, including Harvard, Columbia and Penn. “Our advisors have been meeting with students regularly since the August 2026 messages, and are continuing to support them through these developments,” Shiotani added.

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 16, 2026.


THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

PAGE 3

UNIVERSITY NEWS FACULTY FROM PAGE 1 tions and documents.” The current code also emphasizes that University financial reports will be updated to remain accurate and comprehensive. The existing code also requires that only community members “possessing authority delegated by an appropriate University official may enter into agreements or contracts on behalf of the University.” Community members without such authority cannot sign agreements on behalf of Brown. The October draft proposed the removal of both sections from the code. This

change was upheld in the November draft. History of the UVV Statement The UVV statement was created following discussion about divestment from companies with ties to the Israeli government and military in 2024. According to a report from the Ad Hoc Committee on University Values and Voice, opposing student-led proposals on potential divestment “generated significant interest in the question of University values,” which had not been explicitly defined at the time.

In Dec. 2024, the Ad Hoc Committee was convened and charged with defining Brown’s central values and creating a statement that outlines how the University can publicly use its institutional voice. In May 2025, the UVV statement created by the Ad Hoc Committee was approved by faculty vote. The Corporation — Brown’s highest governing body — also approved the statement later that month. The committee recommended the creation of a working group to “guide implementation” of the UVV statement, includ-

ing “reviewing alignment between current University policies, committee, charges and related governance structures to ensure consistency” with the UVV statement, according to a May 2025 faculty motion. The working group, which is chaired by Bernard Reginster, professor of natural theology and the associate director for the Center for Philosophy, Politics and Economics, proposed both sets of revisions for the code of conduct. Reginster wrote in an email to The Herald that the working group is “grateful for

the thoughtful feedback” that they received from the Brown community on the October code of conduct draft. “The updated draft just released remains work in progress,” he added. Thursday’s announcement to the faculty included an invitation for faculty members to take part in a town hall on Nov. 19 to discuss the proposed changes.

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 16, 2026.

ACADEMICS

Thomas Politano ’27 named Rhodes Scholar Politano plans to complete two one-year master’s degrees at Oxford BY SOFIA TIMPONE AND IVY HUANG CONTRIBUTING WRITER AND UNIVERSITY NEWS AND SCIENCE & RESEARCH EDITOR As a high schooler at a vocational school in Massachusetts, Thomas Politano ’27 thought he would become a landscaper after graduation. Instead, Politano is now finishing his English degree at Brown and will soon be heading across the Atlantic after receiving one of the most prestigious merit-based awards in the world. On Saturday, Politano was named one of the 32 American Rhodes Scholars for 2027. The scholarship allows students to pursue a fully funded graduate degree at the University of Oxford. Next fall, Politano will begin his studies at Oxford, where he intends to complete two one-year master’s degrees: one in English and another in world literatures in English. He hopes to use his time at Oxford to form a “meaningful” research question that might guide his pursuit of an American PhD. At Oxford, Politano also plans to delve into comparative literature with Chinese

texts after taking numerous Mandarin classes at Brown and an intensive course through the Princeton in Beijing program last summer. “I wasn’t planning to apply to college until I learned from a mentor that (it) was a possibility, that I could even get into college, let alone Brown,” he said. “I’m just very grateful to have had such extraordinary help and to have had such extraordinary people to show me that these

with the language.” Politano is currently working on an honors thesis on Virginia Woolf ’s novel “Jacob’s Room,” in which he is “asking questions about how she represents death and absence and how that intersects with representations of space and rooms.” At Brown, Politano is a writing fellow at the Sheridan Center for Teaching and Learning and tutors with the Brown Tutoring Corps. In the long term, he hopes

opportunities were available.” “The person who studied landscaping is very much alive in the scholarship that he pursues,” said Associate Professor of English Ravit Reichman, who wrote a recommendation letter for Politano. “He really nurtures the very texts that he’s writing about. He honors their organic fabric, like someone who tills soil and nurtures a landscape.” When Politano entered Brown, he initially planned to concentrate in economics but was not excited about taking microeconomics — instead, he wanted to take a literature class. He declared as an English concentrator during his sophomore year. “I think that deep down I always knew that I enjoyed literature the most,” he said. “I just love reading, and I love having a very textual object to study.” Politano is particularly interested in modernism “because there was so much formal play and inventiveness going on

to become a professor. “I want to teach because a lot of teachers have changed my life, and they brought me here,” he said. Reichman said she was watching a production of “Spring Awakening” with a colleague, her husband and children when Politano texted her the good news. “We put them on FaceTime and all just squealed with delight,” she said. Associate Professor of Slavic Studies Michal Oklot, who taught Politano in a class on novelist and poet Vladimir Nabokov, also wrote a recommendation for him. Oklot told The Herald that “Thomas is patient … he reads deeply, he reads slowly and closely.” Reichman felt similarly. She said that Politano inspires “others to slow down, and to stand still for a moment in a world that is whizzing.” “Thomas makes an art of lingering,” Reichman said. “There’s something breath-

SELINA KAO / HERALD

Looking back at his formative experiences and his time at Brown, Politano said that he learned the importance of gratitude. taking about Thomas’ ability to linger.” In her recommendation letter, Wenhui Chen, an associate teaching professor of East Asian studies, highlighted Politano’s “openness to different fields of learning,” Chen said. “He took the time to explore a wide range of topics (and) different courses,” she said. Looking back at his formative experiences and his time at Brown, Politano said

that he learned the importance of gratitude. Receiving the Rhodes Scholarship “really is, at the end of the day, I think, a group effort,” he added. “It was not just me — it was my entire family and my social circles and my friends and my professors and my teachers.”

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 18, 2026.

Submissions: The Brown Daily Herald publishes submissions in the form of op-eds and letters to the editor.

SINCE 1891

THE BROWN DAILY HERALD 136TH EDITORIAL BOARD Editor-in-Chief Cate Latimer

Rebecca Goodman

Managing Editors Ciara Meyer Elise Haulund Claire Song

University News Editors Emily Feil Rebecca Goodman Samah Hamid Zarina Hamilton Ivy Huang Ian Ritter Alejandro Ruiz Roma Shah

Senior Editors Hadley Carr Paul Hudes Max Robinson POST- MAGAZINE Editor-in-Chief Elaina Bayard

COMMENTARY Head of Editorial Page Board Ethan Canfield

NEWS Metro Editors Michelle Bi Pavani Durbhakula Talia Egnal Emily Feil Amber Marcus-Blank Science & Research Editors Ivy Huang Ian Ritter Alice Xie Arts & Culture Editors Ann Gray Golpira

Sports Editor Sajiv Mehta

Opinions Editors Talia Berkwits Ethan Canfield Christian Davis Isabella Gardiner Avery Kaak CJ Lair Clara Murray Arya Vishwakarma PRODUCTION Copy Desk Chief Chelsea Long

Assistant Copy Chief Sofia Segarra

Games Chief Paul Hudes

Design Chiefs Emily Bao Maggie Ruan

Podcast Chief Talia LeVine

Design Editors Chloe Johnson Kailey Marti MULTIMEDIA Photo Chiefs Annamaria Luecht Kaia Yalamanchili Illustration Chiefs Kendra Eastep Isabela Guillen

Multimedia Editors Marat Basaria Harry Guo Horatio Hamilton Selina Kao Diya Khetan Ella Le Kenna Lee JJ Li Jake Parker

Op-eds are typically between 600 and 900 words and advance a clear argument related to a topic of campus discourse. You can submit op-eds to opinions@browndailyherald.com. Letters to the editor should be around 250 words and respond to an article or column that has appeared in The Herald, or critique or commend The Herald’s editorial decisions. You can submit letters to the editor to letters@browndailyherald.com. Submissions undergo multiple rounds of editing. These rounds of editing generally take place over the course of one evening, and you may have to respond to edits late in the evening. If you know you will be unable to do so, please mention that in your email, and we will do our best to work with you. Submissions can build on reporting from The Herald, reporting elsewhere, official statements from the University or other groups and other reputable sources, but they cannot break news or contain information that The Herald cannot verify. Because we cannot publish unsubstantiated information, failure to provide appropriate sources may mean we have to modify or remove unverified claims. The Herald will not publish anonymous submissions or submissions authored by organizations. Leaders of student organizations can be identified as such but cannot write under the byline of their organization. The Herald cannot publish all submissions it receives and reserves the right to edit all submissions. All submissions to The Herald cannot have been previously published elsewhere (in print or online — including personal blogs and social media) and must be exclusive to The Herald. Once your submission is published in The Herald, The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. owns the copyright to the materials.

Video Chiefs Cienna Cheng Cody Cheng

BUSINESS General Managers Arjun Deshpande Anum Azhar

Social Media Chiefs Nate Barkow Annika Melwani

Sales Directors Arjun Ray Hannah Han

Technology Chief Yassir Aouf Data Desk Chief Caleb Ellenberg

Finance Director Sydney Wright

Corrections: The Brown Daily Herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with the most accurate information possible. Corrections may be submitted up to seven calendar days after publication. Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. Postmaster: Please send corrections to P.O. Box 2538, Providence, RI 02906.

Office Manager Cary Warner

Advertising: The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at its discretion.

@the_herald

facebook.com/browndailyherald

@browndailyherald

@browndailyherald

88 Benevolent, Providence, RI (401) 351-3372 www.browndailyherald.com Editorial: herald@browndailyherald.com Advertising: advertising@browndailyherald.com

Commentary: The editorial is the majority opinion of the editorial page board of The Brown Daily Herald. The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily reflect the views of The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Columns, letters and comics reflect the opinions of their authors only.

The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. is a financially independent, nonprofit media organization bringing you The Brown Daily Herald and Post- Magazine. The Brown Daily Herald has served the Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday through Friday during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during Commencement and once during Orientation by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Single copy free for each member of the community. Subscription prices: $200 one year daily, $100 one semester daily. Copyright 2023 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved.


PAGE 4

Friday, November 20, 2026

METRO CITY HALL

Providence Police Chief Oscar Perez to retire in January Mayor-elect Morales’s administration will find Perez’s replacement

that he expected Perez to remain in his role as chief of police. “I’m committed to ensuring that our

BY MIRIAM DAVISON AND MICHELLE BI SENIOR STAFF WRITER AND METRO EDITOR On Tuesday, Providence Chief of Police Oscar Perez announced that he plans to retire in January 2027, ending a 32-year career in the Providence Police Department. “As Chief, I am proud to lead a department committed to making Providence safer while strengthening the relationship between our officers and the communities we serve,” Perez wrote in his retirement letter addressed to Mayor Brett Smiley and shared with The Herald. In the letter, he pointed to historic lows in violent crime and reflected on the Dec. 13 shooting at Brown. “The mass shooting at Brown University was among the most heartbreaking experiences of my career,” Perez wrote. “I remain grateful to our officers, first responders, law enforcement partners and community members who came together during an extraordinarily difficult time for our city.” At a Tuesday press conference, Perez said his decision came after considering retirement “for a while,” adding that his “family has taken the back seat for years.” Mayor-elect David Morales MPA’19

SOPHIA LENG / HERALD

Morales previously told The Herald that he expected Perez to remain in his role as chief of police. wrote in a statement that Perez informed him that he is stepping down “to spend time with his wife and focus on her care as she faces serious health challenges.” At the press conference, Smiley, who appointed Perez in February 2023, praised Perez’s leadership and the sacrifices he and his family made throughout his career. “For 32 years, Oscar Perez has put the City of Providence first and his family

second, and they’ve willingly made that sacrifice alongside of him,” Smiley said. “I will say personally, over the last four years, it has been the most comforting part of my service to know that he’s been leading the effort to keep this community safe, and has done so with fantastic success.” When asked during the press conference if Morales’s opposition to Flock cameras was a factor in his decision to retire,

Perez said he would have stepped down even if Smiley had been reelected. “I’ve been contemplating (retirement) more for family and personal reasons,” he said. He added that the technology reflects “national standards” and “best practices.” Providence’s current resources are “the reason why we’ve been so successful in fighting crime,” he said. Morales previously told The Herald

Providence Police Department has the resources, support and strong, steady leadership our officers need,” Morales wrote in his statement. Perez is the first Latino chief of the department. He immigrated from Colombia as a child and joined the department in 1994 as a patrol officer. He also previously served as a district commander for South Providence, where he conducted work on community relations initiatives. “I never thought for one second on May 13 of 1994 that I was going to be the chief of this great police department,” he said. “The city is extremely diverse, and I think the new chief needs to really understand what type of city we have,” he said. Perez expressed confidence in the department’s current staff, particularly in Deputy Chief Timothy O’Hara. “I think he’s ready to take the role,” Perez said of O’Hara, adding that the decision “has to be made by the new administration.” Kristy dosReis, Providence’s chief public information officer for public safety, confirmed to The Herald that the search for the next chief will be conducted by the Morales administration.

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 17, 2026.

STATE POLITICS

Bill raises concerns about energy infrastructure projects, community input The bill has been criticized by preservationists and climate researchers BY ROARK PETERMANN AND JACOB RACZYNSKI CONTRIBUTING WRITER AND STAFF WRITER On Thursday, the U.S. Senate passed the “Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026.” The bill, which was co-sponsored by U.S. Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), limits the scope of environmental and preservation policies, proposes expedited environmental review procedures and modifies energy infrastructure permit guidelines. Local preservation advocates and climate researchers told The Herald that they believe the bill could limit community input on federally supported projects and may not meaningfully grow green energy infrastructure projects. The bill revises Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, which stated that relevant parties — a as state historic preservation officers, Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations and the public — shall be consulted during the preservation review and implementation process. “BAAJA makes that optional,” said Executive Director of the Rhode Island Historical Preservation and Heritage Commission Jeffrey Emidy. The bill proposes new language for the section, stating that federal officials “may consult” with relevant parties. The new list of parties specified for consultation under BAAJA does not include the public. Providence Preservation Society Executive Director Marisa Angell Brown believes this exclusion will particularly affect vulner-

The bill expedites processes for environmental projects, including renewable energy infrastructure development able communities that are historically affected by infrastructure development projects. “The common concern here is about community participation,” said Angell Brown. “It’s the under-resourced communities that really need some of this regulation the most.” The bill expedites processes for environmental projects, including renewable energy infrastructure development. Some climate researchers question the benefits of its actual impact. In a statement to The Herald, Professor of Environment, Society and Sociology

Timmons Roberts, a senior researcher at the Climate and Development Lab, wrote that “there is a chance the bill could help unlock some renewables (or) grid buildout, but it is highly uncertain.” Roberts also wrote that he was concerned about the bill’s “potential gutting” of the National Environmental Policy Act and the Endangered Species Act. Director of Public Citizen’s Climate Accountability Project and former R.I. State Rep. Aaron Regunberg ’12 said the bill “functionally repeals” NEPA and ESA. He explained that the bill

“delegates core obligations (and) core responsibilities” of ESA to the states, and, as a result, the acts might not be enforced in states that “don’t have the resources and capacity” to enact them, like Rhode Island, he said. Under the bill, many federally supported projects would no longer be required to undergo NEPA-required reviews. Calvin Woodruff ’29, a student researcher in Roberts’s ENVS 1574: “Climate Policy Research: Organizations and Obstruction,” said restrictive ordinances against renewables, which put constraints

SELINA KAO / HERALD

on renewable energy projects that may lead to their cancellation, could be countered by permitting reform legislation like BAAJA. But “changing the permitting process should not stifle community voices,” he said. “Communities should always have an input on projects being developed in their town.” “And even if that does end up blocking renewable projects, I think we need that,” Woodruff added. Whitehouse’s office did not immediately respond to a request for comment.


THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

PAGE 5

METRO CITY HALL

Providence City Council votes to ban Flock cameras The Council chose to end its use of automated license plate readers BY TALIA KATZ SENIOR STAFF WRITER On Thursday, the Providence City Council voted to pass an ordinance banning the use of automated license plate readers by a 10-4 vote. The ordinance requires the city to “immediately deactivate and discontinue its use” of all ALPRs, including Flock cameras, and terminate all agreements it has with ALPR companies. The city also may not acquire or use data from ALPRs, including from external owners. The council must vote to pass the ordinance a second time. It will then go to the mayor, who can either sign or veto it. “I think we’re being given a false choice between safety and civil liberties,” councilor Sue AnderBois (Ward-3) said during the hearing. “The real safety concerns for our neighbors that we witness every day” come from ALPR cameras, she added. The decision comes amid nationwide protests calling for an end to Flock camera use due to surveillance concerns and fears of privacy violations. The ordinance cites specific concerns including Immigration and Customs Enforcement use of Flock data “to kidnap immigrant neighbors,” authorized users using the data to stalk partners and ex-partners and ALPRs’ misidentification of individuals and vehicles. “We appreciate the City Council’s thoughtful consideration of this ordinance and recognize the importance of balancing privacy, accountability and public safety,” Providence Chief of Police Oscar Perez said in a statement shared with The Herald.

“At the same time, ALPR technology has become an important investigative tool for our detectives, helping identify vehicles, develop leads and solve serious crimes,” he added. “As this ordinance moves forward, we remain committed to working with the City Council and community to address privacy concerns while preserving responsible access to this valuable technology.” “As Providence considers the future of its Flock program, we hope city leaders recognize the impact this technology has already had on public safety,” a Flock spokesperson wrote in an email to The Herald. “We support strong privacy safeguards and local oversight, but communities should not have to choose between protecting privacy and giving law enforcement the tools they need to solve serious crimes, find missing people and keep people safe,” the spokesperson added. ICE did not immediately respond to a request for comment. A report by Rhode Island College students that was presented to the council in May discovered evidence of significant leaks of Providence’s Flock data. The report found that organizations not listed on Providence’s Flock Transparency portal accessed data from Flock cameras in Providence over 3.2 million times between November 2024 and November 2025, across over 1,400 jurisdictions. In October, Rhode Island Gov. Dan McKee placed an indefinite pause on ALPR installations statewide in order to provide state legislators time to draft formal regulations. Over 100 cities nationwide and at least five R.I. towns have terminatedtheir contracts with Flock. Mayor-elect David Morales MPA’19 had previously pledged to work towards ending the city’s contract with Flock during his campaign for City Hall.

HORATIO HAMILTON / HERALD

The decision comes amid nationwide protests calling for an end to Flock camera use due to surveillance concerns and fears of privacy violations. Conversely, defenders of Flock cameras — including Perez and outgoing Mayor Brett Smiley — have pointed to their usein helping identify the perpetrator of the Dec. 13 mass shooting. At Thursday’s meeting, AnderBois asked if Flock “made us safer,” noting that it did not prevent the shooter from carrying out the attack or crossing state lines during his escape. “I have also heard from many members of the Brown community who do not want

our contract relationship with Flock to be made in their name,” she added. According to Flock’s Transparency Portal, there are currently 60 cameras throughout Providence. But the ordinance says that there are reportedly over 100 in operation, due to Flock contracts with Providence and with the Rhode Island State Police. The city and the R.I. State Police did not immediately respond to The Herald’s requests for comment.

The ordinance was previously referred to the Special Committee on Health, Opportunity, Prosperity and Education, which recommended the council adopt the measure. The City entered a three-year contract with Flock in 2023. Its contract was set to expire in May 2027.

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 19, 2026.

EDUCATION

Lendozia Edwards assumes role as Providence interim superintendent Edwards’s interim term will last through June 30, 2028 BY AMBER MARCUS-BLANK METRO EDITOR On Thursday, Lendozia Edwards became the Providence Public School District’s interim superintendent. Edwards, who had served as the district’s chief of schools, is taking over for former superintendent Javier Montañez, who announced his resignation on Oct. 30. Edwards was selected in a unanimous decision by members of the Providence School Board present at a Saturday meeting. She makes history as the first Black woman to serve as PPSD superintendent, according to School Board President Ty’Relle Stephens. Joining the district in 2024, Edwards served as a transformation officer for DelSesto Middle School and Hope High School before beginning her most recent role as chief of schools. Edwards’s interim term will continue through June 30, 2028. “Dr. Edwards knows this district, understands the work ahead and brings a deep commitment to our students and school communities,” Montañez said in a statement shared with The Herald. “I have confidence in her leadership and know she will continue to move this important work forward.” At a Thursday press conference,

COURTESY OF PROVIDENCE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT

Edwards was selected in a unanimous decision by members of the Providence School Board present at a Saturday meeting. members of the school board and may- and thanked Edwards for “stepping up” thing we do,” he said. or-elect David Morales delivered re- to her role. “My approach is straightforward: lismarks before Edwards presented her “We look forward to working with ten to understand, learn from evidence transition plan and visions for the dis- you, and please know that we have your and experience and lead with purpose, trict. back,” Morales added. transparency and accountability,” Ed“You can just feel the positive energy Stephens remarked that Edwards wards said at the conference, adding that and hope,” Morales said. He empha- “understands that student achievement her work will build on the established sized the need for mental health and is not simply one priority among many, progress made by the school board, disacademic support systems for students it is the priority that must guide every- trict members and community partners,

while “honestly examining the challenges that still remain.” Lindsay Paiva, president of the Providence Teachers Union, told The Herald that the school board created a “collaborative process for determining who to select” for the position. The selection process included Paiva and parents, other community members, the Morales administration and a former PPSD student, she told The Herald. While this group did not vote during the process, they were present for the interviews and provided feedback on candidates, she said. Corey Jones, a member of the school board, wrote to The Herald that “we had a lot of great applicants and it wasn’t an easy decision.” Edwards’s “education, experience, empathy and reputation speaks for itself,” he added. In a statement on behalf of the PTU, Paiva said they “look forward to continuing to collaborate with Dr. Edwards to collectively create the schools our students deserve.” “The board under Superintendent Dr. Montañez created our goals and guardrails from listening to communities and families,” Jones wrote. “I expect us to continue working to improve student outcomes with our goals and guardrails as our North Star.” At Wednesday’s school board meeting, Montañez concluded his final day by offering a symbolic key to Edwards, saying “I would like to give you the keys to the kingdom.”


PAGE 6

Friday, November 20, 2026

SPORTS SOCCER

‘We always believed in each other’: Women’s soccer claims Ivy League Tournament title The Bears earned an automatic bid to the NCAA Tournament

BY HARRY GUO SENIOR STAFF WRITER After falling short of the Ivy League regular season title, the women’s soccer team (12-4-2, 4-2-1 Ivy) found redemption on Sunday afternoon, defeating Columbia (6-7-5, 4-1-2) 1-0 in the Ivy League Tournament championship at Burnham Field in Hanover, New Hampshire. The victory marked Brown’s first Ivy League Tournament championship since the tournament’s revival in 2023, securing the Bears’ 11th NCAA Tournament appearance in program history through the conference’s automatic bid. Brown entered the tournament as the fourth seed and faced consecutive matches against the conference’s top teams. But after defeating top-seeded Dartmouth (114-2, 5-2-0) 2-0 in Thursday’s semifinal, Bruno carried their momentum into Sunday’s championship against second-seeded Columbia, which had defeated Princeton (8-6-2, 4-2-1) to advance to the final. Midfielder Joy Okonye ’27 was at the center of both victories, scoring the opening goal against Dartmouth and delivering the championship-winning strike against Columbia. “We’ve been through a lot of ups and downs as a team, but the one thing was that this team never rattled,” Head Coach Kia McNeill said in an interview after Sunday’s win. “We always believed in each other.” The Bears entered Thursday’s semifinal looking to avenge a previous regular season loss to the Big Green — but Dartmouth

COURESTY OF BROWN ATHLETICS

The Bears will now turn their attention to the NCAA Tournament, where they will make their fifth appearance in the last seven seasons. threatened first. off,” Okonye wrote in an email to The HerJust four minutes into the contest, ald. “I was there to finish it off.” Dartmouth defender Kate Ryan fired an But Brown’s offensive run was not finoutside-of-the-foot shot toward the net, ished yet. Just five minutes later, forward forcing goalkeeper Addison Etter ’29 to Claire Silverman ’27 launched a long, lofted tip the ball over the crossbar to save it. pass from Brown’s own half toward forward A minute later, midfielder Audrey Anya Tansil ’30, who was making a dangerLam ’27 tripped a Dartmouth player in- ous run behind the Big Green’s defense. side Brown’s penalty area, giving the Big Tansil outmuscled a Dartmouth deGreen an early opportunity to take the lead fender to collect the pass before finding from the penalty spot. herself one-on-one with the goalkeeper. But Etter was ready. With a clear look at the net, the first-year Anticipating the direction of the shot, calmly slotted a low shot into the botEtter dove low to her left and turned away tom-right corner, doubling Brown’s adthe penalty attempt, keeping the contest vantage to 2-0 and capping off a decisive scoreless as Brown began finding its footing five-minute stretch for Bruno. offensively. After halftime, Brown continued to Twenty-eight minutes in, forward Co- apply offensive pressure, with Lam notchrine Gregory ’27 created an opportunity ing a shot in the 52nd minute and forward inside the penalty area, spinning away Angelina Vargas ’27 registering shots in the from a Dartmouth defender before firing 53rd and 56th minutes, respectively. But a powerful shot toward the net. Although neither team managed to find the back of Dartmouth goalkeeper Ola Goebel initially the net in the second half. saved the shot, Okonye was waiting near Despite Dartmouth holding a narrow the left side of the goal to collect the re- 12-11 advantage in total shots, the Bears bound and slot the ball into the back of the registered six shots on goal compared to net for a 1-0 Bruno advantage. the Big Green’s four. Etter finished the “Corine, our striker, did a great job contest with four saves. spinning her defender and getting her shot The 2-0 victory sent Brown to the Ivy

League Tournament’s championship game for the second time in three seasons. “I think the team did a great job to bounce back and re-focus our attention to Dartmouth,” McNeill wrote in an email to The Herald. McNeill added that after the Bears’ loss to Princeton on Nov. 7 that cost them the regular season conference title, the team “talked about the fact that we can be upset, but we have to move on because we have more to play for.” Returning to Burnham Field on Sunday afternoon, the Bears faced second-seeded Columbia with an opportunity to capture their first Ivy League Tournament championship since its renewal. Brown wasted little time creating its first dangerous offensive opportunities. In the eighth minute, Vargas fired a longrange shot toward the net that bounced awkwardly off the turf, skipping past the Columbia goalkeeper before striking the left post. Gregory and Vargas’s follow-ups were unsuccessful. Around the 17th minute, midfielder Brooke Birtwistle ’28 — who was recently named Ivy League Defensive Player of the Year — delivered a lofted free kick from well outside the penalty area into the Columbia box. Okonye rose to meet the pass with a header, but the Lions’ goalkeeper made a diving save to keep the contest scoreless. Okonye nearly scored again eight minutes later, sending a curling shot that narrowly skimmed the crossbar. Despite Brown’s repeated offensive opportunities, neither side managed to score before halftime, sending the teams into the locker rooms tied 0-0. But less than two minutes after the break, Bruno found their championship moment.

Vargas fired another attempt from outside the penalty area that grazed the hand of a Columbia defender, earning Brown a free kick in a dangerous position just outside the box. Okonye, a three-time AllIvy selection, stepped up to take the kick. With the Columbia defensive wall lined up in front of her, Okonye lofted a shot around the wall and into the left side of the net, giving the Bears a 1-0 lead. The goal marked Okonye’s sixth of the season and the 14th of her collegiate career. “It was incredible,” Okonye said in a post-game interview, crediting her teammates’ belief in her ability to deliver in crucial moments. “I’m just really happy that they trust me,” she added. With the championship now within reach, Brown turned its attention to protecting its narrow advantage. The Bears held firm through the closing stages of the contest, keeping their defense strong as Columbia searched for an equalizer. As the final seconds ticked away, Brown’s bench erupted onto the field, with players rushing to celebrate the program’s first Ivy League Tournament championship since the tournament’s 2023 revival. “I knew we had it in us, and I’m just happy that we were able to get it done,” McNeill said. “It’s really sweet. It’s really special to be able to share this moment with the team.” With the Ivy League Tournament title secured, the Bears will now turn their attention to the NCAA Tournament, where they will make their fifth appearance in the last seven seasons.

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 15, 2026.

FACILITIES

Brown set to open new fitness center in summer 2027 The 13,400-square-foot facility will be located in the Jewelry District. BY SAJIV MEHTA SPORTS EDITOR On Thursday, Brown announced plans to open a new 13,400-square-foot fitness center in the Jewelry District. The facility is set to open in summer 2027 and aims to expand health and wellness opportunities for Brown and local community members. The fitness hub will be housed on the ground floor of 2-3 Davol Square, a building complex that has been vacant for around 10 years. The facility will contain locker rooms, a group fitness studio and a gym with exercise equipment. According to a University press release, the new fitness center “will nearly double Brown’s fitness footprint” through additional workout equipment, fitness classes and personal training. Plans for the facility come in response to a growing demand from community members for increased fitness space. The Division of Athletics and Recreation has seen a 19% increase in visits to its recreational facilities and a 60% increase in wellness program participation over the past four years, according to the press release. In fiscal year 2026, 24% of Jonathan Nelson ’77 Fitness Center traffic came from visitors who were not Brown students, Amy Dean, associate director of athletics and recreation, said in the press release. “The new Davol Square fitness center

will dramatically expand opportunities for fitness and wellness at Brown while supporting community-building in the neighborhood,” Dean said. The University signed a lease for the space this fall and is in the initial stages of construction.

The new fitness center adds to the 33,000-square-foot Nelson and smaller athletics spaces across campus. In January, the University also opened Penner Field House, a 76,000-square-foot indoor turf facility. The construction of the new facility comes alongside other Brown develop-

KAIA YALAMANCHILI / HERALD

The construction comes alongside other Brown developments in the Jewelry District. ments in the Jewelry District, including the relocation of the Graduate School headquarters and the Department of Public Safety and Emergency Management’s

administrative operations to the neighborhood. The University is also buildingthe William A. and Ami Kuan Danoff Life Sciences Laboratories.


THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

PAGE 7

SPORTS FOOTBALL

Football clinches first winning season since 2013 with 28-20 victory over Columbia The Bears remain in the Ivy League title race with one week left BY KEVIN WITTEN STAFF WRITER In their home finale this past Saturday, the Brown football team (6-3, 4-2 Ivy) defeated Columbia (4-5, 1-5) 28-20 to make history — for the first time since 2013, the Bears clinched a winning record. Bruno finished the year undefeated at the Brown Stadium for the first time since 2005. With one game left to play, the Bears are squarely in contention for the Ivy League title. Brown currently sits in second in the Ivy League standings, just behind firstplace Harvard (8-1, 5-1). If the Crimson fall to Yale (5-4, 3-3) this coming weekend, Brown’s final regular-season game against Dartmouth (4-5, 3-3) will decide whether the Bears will claim a share of the Ivy League Championship. Since there is no tiebreaker for a champion in the Ivy League, all teams tied with the top records for league play share the title. Brown rode into Saturday’s game on the heels of a three-game win streak, while Columbia came to Providence having lost its three previous games. Despite the Bruno win, the Lions outgained the Bears 412 yards to 309, had 16 more first downs and held the ball for 24 more minutes. But for the first time all season, Brown did not turn the ball over, and per usual, the defense stayed strong when it mattered most. On the offensive side, running back Matt Childs ’28 delivered a superhuman four-touchdown performance, one point shy of the program’s single-game record. Prior to the victory, 28 graduating student-athletes were honored before a crowd

of friends, family and alumni for senior day. The victory was especially meaningful for players from the class of 2027. “My class especially, we knew we were going to do one thing when we first got here, and we always talked about it since the day that we had been here,” defensive line Ike Odimegwu ’27 told The Herald in a post-game interview. “We wanted to change the narrative about Brown, and I think today, winning out at home, I think we finally did that.” “We got a lot of love for each other and love for this program, and I’m glad it’s starting to blossom,” linebacker Max Malo ’27 told The Herald in a post-game interview. The first quarter was dominated by Columbia. After the Bears and the Lions traded punts, Columbia opened the scoring on their second possession. The Lions sustained a 15-play, 76-yard drive that took up the majority of the first quarter and culminated in a touchdown to make the game 7-0. The Bruno offense failed to respond, as the Bears only moved the chains once before punting to end the first quarter. Columbia promptly drove down the field once more and kicked a field goal to push their lead to 10. Brown quickly found an answer. In an up-tempo offense, Childs got the ball three consecutive times and picked up 19, 13 and 27 yards. Quarterback James Murphy ’27 joined in on the fun, adding 15 yards to push the offense to within a yard of the end zone. Childs got the goal line carry and surged forward for his first score of the day, cutting the deficit to 10-7. On the ensuing kickoff, a pack of Bears swallowed up Columbia’s return man and jarred the football loose. At the bottom of

VANSON VU / HERALD

Brown rode into Saturday’s game on the heels of a three-game win streak, while Columbia came to Providence having lost its three previous games. the pile, defensive back Airiz Coleman Bey ’29 emerged with possession. Despite the excellent starting field position, Brown quickly found themselves behind the sticks facing fourth-and-six. Murphy floated a jump ball to Childs, who made an acrobatic grab inside the 5-yard line. Two plays later, Childs found the end zone for the second time, giving Brown a 14-10 lead that they never gave up. Columbia’s offense began to sputter, and they punted on their next drive. Just over 2 minutes before halftime, Murphy and company got to work. A routine shovel pass to tight end Levi Linowes ’27 turned into a 45-yard gain as the senior bounced off a tackle, got strong blocks downfield and rumbled all the way to the 7-yard line. Childs took the direct snap and powered in for his third touchdown run of the quarter, making the score 21-10. “That’s kind of when I felt unstoppable,” Childs said after the game. “We have a motto in our running back room where if any of us score, we all score.” Similarly to last week’s win over Yale, Brown’s offense hit a lull after halftime.

Brown punted twice in the third quarter, while Columbia grinded out another touchdown drive to bring the game within four points at 21-17. The Lions’ next drive began in the closing minutes of the third quarter, as the visitors quickly moved the ball into Brown territory. A crucial sack by Odimegwu at the start of the fourth quarter killed the drive and brought the captain linebacker within one sack of tying the program’s career record. “I knew that I’d have my one-on-one,” Odimegwu said. “As soon as he overset, I tried to use my two clubs to swipe inside, and the next thing I know, I got the sack.” Bruno’s timely stop revived their momentum. On offense, Murphy hit wide receiver Trevor Foley ’28 underneath on a slant, who turned on the jets for a 33yard pickup. Murphy — who finished the day with a career-high 58 rushing yards — escaped the pocket on the following play and carried the ball into the red zone. “My guys up front were really, really good today. I didn’t get hit at all,” Murphy told The Herald in a post-game interview.

“They gave me the lanes to escape.” Although Saturday’s game marked the first time over the Bears’ win streak that Murphy has not thrown for a touchdown, Perry praised the quarterback’s play. “(Murphy) had his best game,” Perry said. “He was just so good with the ball. It was really never in jeopardy,” he added. Now inside the Columbia 10-yard line, the Bears turned to Childs yet again. For the fourth time that afternoon, the star running back found the end zone, putting Brown up 28-17 with less than 9 minutes to play. “That was the game-centering drive,” Childs said. On their next possession, with time winding down, Columbia kept their offense on the field for fourth-and-5 in their own territory. There, the Brown defense stuffed the Lions short of the line to gain. “We didn’t hit our own specific standard, but at the end of the day, when our names were called and it was down to the wire, we executed and did what we had to do to come out with the win,” Odimegwu said. On a fourth down on Brown’s following possession, Childs appeared to have caught a fifth touchdown, but the score was called back due to a penalty. Columbia notched a field goal in the game’s waning minutes to make the score 28-20, and the Bears ran out the clock to win their fourth consecutive contest. “This is one of my favorite groups to coach and just to be a part of,” Perry said. Looking ahead to next Saturday’s regular-season finale against Dartmouth, Childs said, “Hopefully we’ll be playing more than just for a five-game win streak.”

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 15, 2026.

HOCKEY

Brown men’s ice hockey triumphs over Cornell, Colgate in weekend walloping Head Coach Tom Upton earned his first wins at Brown

BY JAMES LIBRESCO AND RACHEL WICKER SENIOR STAFF WRITERS Men’s ice hockey (2-3, 2-3 ECAC) pummeled Cornell (2-4, 1-3) and Colgate (3-9, 2-2) in back-to-back victories this weekend, skating to a stunning turnaround after starting the season with three straight losses. The pair of wins at Bruno’s first home games of the season were the first victories for new Head Coach Tom Upton, who arrived on College Hill this year from the University of Massachusetts at Amherst. The victories were also the first for a roster nearly half composed of new Brunonians — first-years and transfer students — three of whom cashed in goals in Friday's game against the Big Red. “I know that it hasn’t been the easiest couple months for the guys with that (coaching) change, and they’ve been tremendous,” Upton said after the team’s win over Cornell. “This isn’t just my win. This is all of our wins.” Brown’s game against Cornell began as a defensive battle, with neither team scoring in the first period. Just over six minutes into the match, Brown’s Griffin Erdman ’28 and Cornell’s Reegan Hiscock exchanged jabs to the face — a display of the physicality that would come to shape

the contest. By the end of the scoreless first period, the Bears had attempted 11 shots, while Cornell had attempted six. The second period marked a more thrilling offensive performance, with Bruno netting two goals. The first score came after Charlie Gollob ’28 collected the puck from behind Brown’s goal and slung it to Matteo Danis ’30 at the centerline. Danis cut inward and rushed toward Cornell’s goal, hurling a missile past Cornell goaltender Mathis Rousseau as he entered the end zone. Minutes later, Kevin Fitzgerald ’28, standing behind Cornell’s goal, wove the puck through the Cornell defense to a closely-guarded Cullen Emery ’30, who then sniped the puck past a befuddled Rousseau from close range. In the final nine minutes of the period, the Bears faced relentless pressure from Cornell’s heated attacks, but Bruno goalkeeper Eli Pulver ’28 blocked shot after shot until the buzzer sounded. As the third period commenced, Bruno was quickly snapped back to reality, as Cornell —who was ranked No. 16 in the country ahead of the matchup — did what was expected of it. Just as a Bruno win seemed imminent and the crowd began quieting down, Cornell’s Ivan Zadvernyuk slid a shot into Brown’s goal with just under 14 minutes remaining in the game, leaving the Bears with a narrow 2-1 lead. Suddenly, Bruno’s comfortable lead was transformed into an urgent call to arms — the Big Red restored their momentum and began repeatedly battering

Brown with shots. But the hero of the night for the Bears was Pulver, who, aside from allowing one goal, staunchly withstood Cornell’s barrage of shots in the game’s closing stages. Though Cornell pulled their goalie in favor of a sixth man on offense, Pulver stood strong, earning a total of 24 saves. To cap off the evening, Griffin Erdman ’28 slung the puck nearly the length of the rink into Cornell’s empty net in the game’s final minute — earning his first goal for Brown. “I think we’ve played some good hockey in our first three games, and didn’t get results. And so it was really nice to be able to close it out for the boys,” Erdman said after the game. For Danis, it “felt amazing” to celebrate his first win with the Bears at home. “I think we had a lot of fans and students come home, passionate students, so it was loud. (The) boys had a lot of fun,” he noted. “We shed a lot of energy and a lot of passion in our game.” Less than 24 hours later, the Bears were on the ice again with one target in mind: capitalize on their momentum and clobber Colgate. But throughout the first period, the Bears struggled to find their footing. Colgate pressured the net, slamming one shot after another until they were up 1-0 around halfway into the period. After the game, Upton said that the Bears’ first-period performance was probably the “worst period” they’ve played this year. “We just weren’t competing. We

weren’t checking well. We weren’t hard on pucks,” he said. But the second period featured a renewal of energy and aggression from the Bears. With just under four minutes left in the period, Erdman swung behind Colgate’s goal and slid a pass to Brian Nicholas ’28, who deftly tied the game at one goal apiece. Just two minutes later, Fitzgerald lunged for the puck after a Colgate defender attempted to clear it, knocking it in front of the goal line, where Brendan Tighe ’29 maneuvered through a crowd of Brown and Colgate players to secure his first goal of the season. The period ended with Brown up 2-1. In the third period, Bruno fought to maintain their lead, and an increasingly frustrated Colgate fought to tame the Bears. But the score remained unchanged, and with less than three minutes on the clock, Gollob received a penalty for roughing — giving Colgate a timely power play. Just as Brown’s opponents had done on Friday, Colgate pulled their goalie and pounded the Bears with a two-man offensive advantage. But the Bears did not budge. Nicholas broke out against the aggressive Colgate squad and rifled a pass to Matthew Cataldo ’29, who scored on Colgate’s empty net and gave Brown a 3-1 lead, securing the Bears’ second win in two days. Pulver continued to valiantly defend his goal from the Raiders’ sieges until the clock showed zeroes, to the home crowd’s delight. “Especially early in the year, we have

to focus on how we’re playing and not the results,” said Pulver, who transferred from the University of Wisconsin, which is currently ranked No. 2 in the country. Pulver had 28 saves against Colgate. “(I’m) glad this weekend worked out,” he said, “but there’s lots for us to improve on.” Upton noted that “building a good culture” has always been important to him as a coach. Part of this effort includes weekly culture meetings, which, according to Upton, consist of “open and honest communication” about how the team has been playing, but also about the player’s lives, family background and adversities they’ve faced. “Since we got here in late August, the biggest thing (Upton has) preached, and the whole coaching staff has, is culture within the room,” Danis said. “If we get (good) character guys that believe in each other, believe in themselves, I think you’ll see it on the ice.” The team is set to face Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (4-7-1, 0-3-1) and Union College (6-5, 2-2) this weekend, where they look to continue their newfound winning streak. “Our team felt that we were almost there, and I think this weekend it showed,” Cataldo said. “Now it’s just about continuing the process and not getting complacent.”

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 17, 2026.


minutes before midnight

FEATURE Managing Editor Chloe Costa Baker

Section Editor Christina Li

Section Editors Helen Hen Anika Kotapally

HEAD ILLUSTRATORS Lesa Jae Junyue Ma

ARTS & CULTURE Managing Editor Sasha Gordon

COPY CHIEF Jessica Lee

Section Editors Gabriella Miranda Rebecca Sanchez

by Yana Giannoutsos

NARRATIVE Managing Editor Gabi Yuan

…Out of both solidarity and communal fear, we remained in the classroom after it ended, C@B glowing on our computer screens as we waited

Section Editors Lucie Huang Chelsea Long

out the ten minutes before the clock would strike noon and our fates would be revealed. During that time span, we discussed the most effective

LIFESTYLE Managing Editor Hallel Abrams Gerber

clicking method to outsmart the C@B overlords and guarantee a secured spot in all our desired courses. We mourned the fact that we missed celebrating 11:11 on 11/11. We laughed about

Section Editors Alayna Chen Tatiana von Bothmer

forming a club to improve reaction time, and debated the appropriate number of seconds prior

Friday, November 20, 2026

See Full Issue:

ISSUU.COM/POSTMAGAZINEBDH

Copy Editors Eve Kobell Kate Schuyler Michelle Wassef Su Yang LAYOUT CHIEFS James Farrington Alexa Gay Amber Zhao Layout Designers Hannah Gapp Lily Rantanen Joshua Rezneck Emma Vachal SOCIAL MEDIA Yana Giannoutsos Hung Lam Eva Mahajan Rebecca Sanchez

to registration opening to begin frantic clicks. We settled on five, and wished each other the best of

Protein Sources

luck before the frenzy commenced. The final five seconds were a blur of clicks, profanities, and utterances that sounded like prayers. When our spring semester plans were finalized, we each began to pack up our things

1. Tofurkey 2. The evil protein powder that calls to you in the night 3. Turkey 4. The bowl of stew Esau sold his birthright for 5. Dino Nuggies 6. Hansel and Gretel 7. Mrs. Lovett’s pies 8. Green eggs and ham 9. Andrews miso salmon bowl 10. Spicy with

and head our own ways. It all happened so fast. I was left all alone to cope with the fact that I’d somehow ended up in the Intensive Russian course I’d only put in my back-up cart because I figured it’d be a good story to tell after my college days. I am already terrified. That said, I am a shopping period loyalist and, to date, have only ended up ever actually taking two courses in my pre-registration selection…

ISSUE 10

excerpt from

POST-POURRI Managing Editor Tarini Malhotra

VOL 38

EDITOR-IN-CHIEF Elaina Bayard

NOV 20

PAGE 8

Cover by Hannah Gapp

1

2

3

4

5

cornucopia by Ronan Carolan illustrated by Lila Vianna

Across

6

1. Hits with an open hand, like at the 2022 Oscars 6. For real, in slang 7. Where the odds are never in your favor 8. Leafy green that rhymes with one of Katniss's love interests 9. It might be final, or midterm

7

8

Down 1. A traitor, or Lucy Gray's favorite reptile 2. He speaks for the trees 3. What many may be taking for a speedy ride home next weekend 4. Home to Haymitch, Primrose, and the like 5. Place for a massage

9

8

Want to be involved? Email: elaina_bayard@brown.edu!

“I’m an undergraduate student…and a woman.” “Why would I come to your opps-giving?”


THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

PAGE 9

table of contents 13 working girls and pretty women

1 faint outlines Beatrice Hackett

Madi Diaz

3 who needs a best friend anyway?

15 halfway to halfway

Semi Jung

Emma Savarese

5 seeking alpha

17 minutes before midnight

Vanessa Tao

Yana Gianoutsos

7 summer's end

19 i could not ask and neither could you

Sona Kempner

Ina Ma

9 not just a kids' show Reece Goldman

“Yet, I eagerly eat apple pie, apple strudels, apple turnovers, apple crisp, apple cider donuts, many things apple. Whether naturally or artificially flavored, they are the only means for me to taste its sweetness without its consequences.” — Lynn Nguyen, “a love letter to apples” 11.22.24

“It’s midnight at the library, the very best time for people-watching.” — Sara Harley, “night at the museum” 11.24.25

letter from the editor

overwrought mini crosswords (I’m looking at you, after you _____, you get LMNO). But there are other kinds. Challenge is apparently on many of our minds: In Feature, Beatrice encounters life changes after graduation and Semi learns to go it alone. Vanessa takes us through a Narrative of choice, options, and optimization, and Sona is stymied by what may be an uncrossable distance. In A&C this week, Reece finds that childhood television had more complex moral dilemmas than he remembered, and Madi contrasts popular depictions of

Dear Readers,

sex work in films, plumbing her own positioning on the topic. Emma spars

There’s been tension in “The War Room” of 88 Benevolent this week:

with the speed of college, seemingly unencumbered by Zeno’s paradox in

Should the post- mini crossword be difficult? Are fiendish clues a bug or a

her Lifestyle, and Yana undergoes a sort of time trial by course registration.

feature of peculiar puzzles? This question is almost existential to the nature of

Ronan brings us straight to the cornucopia of The Hunger Games in

the crossword puzzle. Does it exist to truly challenge or merely tease? Even the

Crossword, and Ina confronts perhaps the largest challenge of all: the

premise has a hint of cheek: The name of the game is cross, after all.

historic AO3 outage.

As I’ve struggled with this question this week, it’s begun to tint my whole

Troubles big and small, silly and serious seem to come for us all. Maybe

worldview. I’m writing an essay in forty-five minutes tomorrow, and I’m

it’s something in the air. Maybe we could fight about it. I don’t think we can

well aware that my unedited product can be…thorny. But isn’t the work of

ever wholly get rid of challenge, it’s too essential for growth, but maybe we

interpretation truly a blessing for the reader? I imagine my professor will have

could move…post-.

far more fun reading something off-beat than boilerplate, challenges of my handwriting and Dickinson headcanons be damned. I completed an assignment for my mapping course that is by and large an exercise in copy-and-paste: I was not challenged. Have I learned? Should I meddle until I break it? These are, of course, trivial challenges. Much like my beloved-if-somewhat-

Lovingly quarrelsome,

Sasha Gordon

A&C and Crossword Managing Editor

November 20, 2026

9


PAGE 10

Friday, November 20, 2026

COMMENTARY

Edelson ’29: Ivy League athletics is having an identity crisis In September, members of the Brown women’s gymnastics team arrived at practice to find the “legacy wall,” which had previously held the names of 22 years’ worth of gymnastics athletes and coaches, painted over without input or warning “as part of a planned upgrade to the facility.” The wall was a physical representation of the program’s history, connecting generations of Brunonian gymnasts. Painting over it raises a broader question: How much does Brown value the traditions and history that distinguish its athletic programs? Across Brown and the Ivy League, decisions about athletics facilities and venues increasingly raise questions about the relationship between history and modernization. The Ivy League has an identity crisis. It wants to capitalize on its unique history and traditions while pursuing the modern facilities and experiences that define contemporary college athletics. Rather than clumsily trying to occupy both worlds at the same time, the League should embrace its historical identity and deliberately modernize in ways that preserve it. The Ivy League’s historical identity is its greatest asset. In fact, before being known chiefly as an academic group, the Ivy League was first formed as an athletic conference. Its identity is built around its institutions’ histories, rivalries, traditions and longstanding athletic programs. It boasts many of the oldest rivalries in the country, which the nickname “Ancient Eight” reflects. Beyond its programs, the Ivy League’s historic venues include football facilities like Franklin Field, the Yale Bowland Harvard Stadium, as well as The Palestra, Penn’s basketball stadium, and Yale’s Ingalls Rink. While these venues are by no means the newest, biggest or most luxurious in college sports, their history and distinctive character give them value that a brand-new arena simply cannot replicate. Brown Athletics is no stranger to this phenomenon. In each of the last two seasons, Brown has

played a marquee “home” football game at nearby state-of-the-art Centreville Bank Stadium, against URI in 2025 and Harvard this past fall, rather than historic Brown Stadium. This season, Bruno finished undefeated (4-0) at Brown Stadium, which celebrated its centennial last year, for the first time since 2005. Perhaps if the marquee game had been played on College Hill instead of in Pawtucket, it would have had a different result, like the last time the game was played at Brown Stadium. Brown must consider what it loses when it prioritizes the modern stadium experience over its own storied facilities.

attendance, strong school spiritand the opportunity for each university to showcase its campus. Moving to a permanent professional venue risks making Ivy Madness feel more like a conventional conference tournament and less like a celebration of our eight schools. Outside of the Ivy League, other universities have chosen to prioritize modernity over history. This year, Northwestern University replaced its historic Ryan Field, originally opened in 1926, with a new stadiumdesigned to prioritize the modern football experience. At Northeastern University, the

Earlier this fall, much to my chagrin, the Ivy League announced that Ivy Madness, the Ivy League men’s and women’s basketball championship tournament, will move to the PPL Center in Allentown, Pennsylvania beginning in 2028. The 2027 tournament will take place at Penn’s Palestra, as part of its centennial celebration. The argument for moving the tournament to the PPL Center is understandable: It offers a neutral site, consistent capacity and professional-arena amenities, which the previous campus-host model couldn’t provide. However, the old model led to convenient student

historic Matthews Arena, the oldest ice hockey arena in the world, was demolished earlier this year. In its place, a modern multipurpose athletic facility will be erected, but this comes at the cost of losing a venue whose history is impossible to recreate. Duke University’s Cameron Indoor Stadium, which first opened in 1940, demonstrates that history and modernity don’t have to be mutually exclusive. Duke has made numerous improvements to the facility, like the high-tech scoreboards, upgraded utilities and the additionof a two-story clubhouse, yet they have retained the stadium’s charac-

Pretty much every conversation I’ve had in the last four years with a relative, neighbor or bartender winds up with them asking what I study in school. Usually, I just say I study anthropology and public policy, even though public policy is no longer offered at Brown. In fact, my transcript says “AB - International & Public Affairs (Policy and Governance).” But I figured telling people that would be misleading, since all of my classes have been about U.S. domestic policy, not international politics. The name is also vague — what even are public affairs? The truth is, IAPA is a Frankenstein major, born of the unholy union of three totally distinct fields of study: public policy, development studies and international relations. For years, the Watson Institute offered these as three separate degrees, but in 2019 merged them into one: IAPA. This was a big mistake. The overly broad curriculum of IAPA has eroded its academic rigor, its credentialing value and its student community. The Watson School of International and Public Affairs should reverse its decision and split IAPA into three concentrations once again. The fundamental problem with the IAPA curriculum is that it is overly broad and flexible, which shouldn’t be surprising considering that it’s three disciplines combined into one concentration. Earning an IAPA degree only takes 11 credits, five of which are electives. But the electives are so broad-ranging that seemingly most classes that are remotely related to politics can count, spanning disciplines from education to biology to computer science. There are also some that don’t even seem political at first glance, such as BSS 1300: “Parenting Behaviors and Child Health” and ENVS 1207: “Eco-Entrepreneurship.” This academic year, the policy and governance track had 73 unique electives across 14 departments, development had 67 across 14 and security had 52 across 11. IAPA requires its concentrators to complete one qualitative research methods class, of which there are 13 across six departments, and a quantitative research methods class, of which there are 12 across 10 departments. One of the two can be substituted with a language course. One IAPA concentrator interviewed by The Herald in 2022 said that he had inadvertently completed all of his electives

within his first three semesters at Brown. Comparatively, all of the other social sciences curricula — anthropology, sociology, economics, history and political science — require most or all electives to be taken within the discipline. At the end of the day, I don’t regret concentrating in IAPA. I’ve learned so much from my classes at Watson, and met excellent instructors, peers and mentors. My constructive critique comes from a place of love — and of course, the analytical spirit I learned here at Watson. Interdisciplinary study is what initially attracted me to IAPA, but I soon realized the Open Curriculum gave me plenty of freedom to study broadly outside my concentration requirements, which made IAPA’s flexibility feel redundant. In order for the self-directed education of the Open Curriculum to hold weight, it must be accompanied by a more directed concentration that ensures students master the requisite skills and read the foundational literature of their discipline. But IAPA lacks the mandatory credits that might allow a student to feel as though they are graduating with an academic convention under their belt. Each track has only one core course that all of its students must take: the track foundational, which provides an introduction to the subject and methodologies of policy and governance, security or development, respectively. The other core courses — the gateway, research methods, junior seminar and senior seminar — all have multiple options. Because there is only one such mandatory course for each track and so many options for electives, professors can’t really expect students in high level seminars to have taken any common set of fundamental courses: A scroll through Courses@Brown reveals that the vast majority of IAPA classes have no prerequisites. And if a seminar has to start from the basics, the intellectual depth of class discussion is likely to be limited. I have experienced this effect in the four IAPA junior and senior seminars I’ve taken. IAPA produces jacks of all trades and masters of none. Brown also needs concentration requirements to properly accredit its graduates. Concentrations signal to employers and graduate schools that students learned the requisite skills and knowledge to be profi-

cient in that discipline. But IAPA’s credentialing power is weaker because it is less recognizable. Few other schools offer a degree in “international and public affairs” — besides Brown, I could only find similar degrees offered at Princeton and Columbia. It is relatively new, and its name is vague, so it takes extra explaining to someone reading it on a resume. In many online applications I have filled out, it is nowhere to be found on the dropdown menu for college majors. I can’t help but compare IAPA’s weak structure to my primary concentration, anthropology, which has a far stronger structure and community. Its curriculum is broad in subject matter but unified in its disciplinary approach. Its core classes teach essential skills in ethnographic research, long-form writing and interpretive analysis, and its curriculum of influential texts has brought me countless enriching conversations with my anthropology peers about the likes of Fanon, Lacan and Farmer. Another worthwhile comparison is the new Politics, Philosophy and Economics concentration, which exemplifies how to launch a broad concentration well. Its requirements are rigorous — 18 credits including 9 core classes and requirements in calculus and economics, plus a capstone — ensuring that students give due diligence to each of the three disciplines and take core classes with their peers in the concentration. Evidently, it is possible to offer a broad and multidisciplinary concentration that still maintains cohesive requirements and teaches its students fundamental skills in the field, yet Brown’s IAPA degree fails to achieve this. This problem isn’t new: Back in 2011, a committee convened by the Dean of the College modified the International Relations curriculum midyear, increasing its number of required courses from 11 to 14. The problem, according to the committee’s final reportas summarized in a 2011 Herald editorial, was that IR’s “dependence on other departments and concentrations has resulted in an unsustainable breadth that harms ‘intellectual depth and coherence.’” According to one member of the committee, IR resembled a general education curriculum spanning the social sciences more than a concentration of its own. Another member, a senior IR concentrator, said, “Under the old system, you and I could both be IR concen-

ARIENA THURAIRAJAH / HERALD

Tao ’27: Abolish IAPA

ter and atmosphere, keeping it small and keeping the original roof and seat design. The choice isn’t always necessarily between a historic facility and a more functional, modern one. Instead, it’s between treating history as an asset worth preserving or as an obstacle toward modernization. The case for modernization in Ivy League Athletics is understandable. Modern facilities improve players’ and spectators’ experience, attract larger crowds, improve revenue opportunities and naturally make events more appealing. Historic facilities are by no means automatically good facilities, and history should never excuse neglect. But the Ivy League has an opportunity to choose what its history means. Our history shouldn’t be something the conference invokes in marketing materials while disregarding it in its managerial decisions. The Ivy League will never compete financially with a powerhouse conference like the Big Ten or the Southeastern Conference. Our conference will never be able to win in an outright facilities contest against the wealthiest athletic departments in the country. However, it is our unique history, traditions and rivalries that should keep recruits coming our way. The Ivy League must accept that its history is not an obstacle to overcome in the pursuit of modernity. Instead, this history is the very thing that makes the conference worth distinguishing in the first place. While certainly not certified in the splits or a bar kip, I can confidently say that the 22 years’ worth of history on the gymnasts’ “legacy wall” adds far more value to Brown athletics than a blank wall would.

Clay Edelson ’29 can be reached at clayton_edelson@ brown.edu. Please send responses to this column to letters@ browndailyherald.com and other opinions to opinions@ browndailyherald.com.

trators and have no more than one or two classes in common.” Sounds familiar! The pendulum swung back in 2018, when a report produced by the Office of the Dean of the College recommended that the Watson Institute merge its three concentrations into a single degree. The IR program director and some students lamented this recommendation and the eventual merger for unduly eliminating the international relations degree, creating a program too big to have a tight-knit community and reducing the nuance of distinct concentrations. Again, sounds familiar. Nonetheless, the Watson Institute ultimately went forward with the merger. At the time, the director of the Watson Institute said, “There was some concern (from students) that the requirements in each of (the current) concentrations were sometimes not quite flexible enough.” But now the flexibility has once again gone too far, and the critics have been vindicated. The Watson School should return to offering the three concentrations it did before: public policy, development studies and international relations. It is currently well-positioned to do this: As a school, which it officially became in 2025, it now has access to more funding and intends to double its faculty in the next five years. It makes sense that it should likewise expand its degree programs. This would create opportunities for Watson faculty to sit on curricular committees more specialized to their areas of expertise and increase the depth of their seminars. More importantly, it would ensure Brown is offering its students the chance to pursue cohesive degrees in which they learn the fundamental skills they need to succeed in these fields. At the end of the day, I don’t regret concentrating in IAPA. I’ve learned so much from my classes at Watson, and met excellent instructors, peers and mentors. My constructive critique comes from a place of love — and of course, the analytical spirit I learned here at Watson.

Evan Tao ’27 can be reached at evan_tao@brown.edu. Please send responses to this column to letters@browndailyherald. com and other opinions to opinions@browndailyherald.com.


THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

PAGE 11

COMMENTARY Gold ’29: Kalshi’s prediction markets cast doubt on Brown’s college admissions processes On Oct. 20, Kalshi, a prediction market platform valued at $40 billion, filed a notice with the United States Commodity Futures Trading Commission to open markets that will allow users to make predictions on Brown’s admissions. This is not the first time that prediction markets have taken an interest in college students and campus life. In September 2025, Kalshi infamously published — and later deleted — a post on X claiming that “college campuses are the best place to spark new financial movements and will play a key role in bringing the next 100M users to prediction markets.” Kalshi’s opening of markets to bet on elite universities’ admissions rates not only worsens the already declining public trust in education but also raises real concerns about the sanctity of Brown’s admissions processes. Perhaps the most notorious connection between prediction markets and U.S. colleges comes through bets placed on college football. When markets on NCAA college football opened in September 2025, Kalshi and Polymarket combined saw a total of $4.5 billion dollars throughout the month. Since then, the platforms’ popularity has skyrocketed. Last month, $97.8 billion was traded on Kalshi. When the Brown football team playedHarvard in September, $1,892,283 in bets were placed through Kalshi, despite a match attendance of only 8,065. During the heart of the last college football playoffs, trades on college football reached 32% of Kalshi’s total volume — more than the NFL or NBA. Facing such remarkable numbers, it’s no wonder that companies like Kalshi are invested in college sports. However, these markets’ interest in college students doesn’t end on the field. In 2025, Polymarket began approaching fraternities across the country to leverage their access to

large networks of college-aged men. The company offers cash in exchange for signing up new users through referral codes. In one particularly extreme example, Columbia’s chapter of Sigma Phi Epsilon received over $30,000 from the company in a twoweek period for their referrals. The chapter later received a plaque naming them “the first Polymarket Pledge Class.” In other cases, prediction markets have sponsored clubs favorable to their cause, such as providing $20,000 to seed the founding of a prediction markets club at the University of Chicago. Kalshi’s request to the CFTC shows that prediction markets have no intention to stop at sports or fraternities. After all, that wouldn’t match the company’s stated goal of allowing users to “trade on anything.” By opening trades on elite universities’ admissions rates, Kalshi seeks to profit off the academic futures of America’s youth, employing an admissions system already notorious for its inequity. The practice will further contribute to a growing commodification of selective admissions rates amongst top universities. According to Times Higher Education, perceptions of prestige are largely linked to how selective a university is in admissions. In recent years, this has led many schools to make efforts to expand applicant pools even if they do not accept more students. Opening prediction markets based on the percentage of students admitted to certain schools places a spotlight on these rates, creating further spectacle out of an already problematic situation. Notably, of the 22 schools Kalshi plans to open markets on, all have particularly low admissions rates. Kalshi’s choice to only open markets on a handful of the highest-ranking schools demonstrates their true motive — they’re seeking a spectacle.

Furthermore, these markets will likely undermine trust in college admissions and further contribute to the American public’s increasing distrust of higher education. According to polling conducted in 2019, only 38% of Americans believed the college admissions process to be fair. This number far exceeds the mere 23% of high school students who believed college admissions were fair, according to a 2022 survey conducted by BestColleges. Nearly two-thirds of those same students found the admissions process to be overwhelming. Evidently, there is a need to improve the accessibility of elite college admissions processes to address growing public concerns and an overwhelmed applicant pool. Kalshi’s opening of markets in college admissions will, sadly, achieve the opposite. Condemning the launch of gambling markets in “a process that’s supposed to be educational and benefiting young people,” Chief Executive of the National Association for College Admission Counseling Angel B. Pérez cited his concern that Kalshi’s markets would only increase college applicants’ anxiety. Beyond increasing the spectacle of exclusive admissions practices, Kalshi’s financial incentivization of admissions could make universities more susceptible to real corruption. While admissions officers at institutions like Brown sign “certificates of integrity” prior to each admissions cycle, these markets could reasonably raise questions about the incentivization or further bias within admissions offices. Despite these university measures, and Kalshi’s own restrictions on eligible traders, insider trading within prediction markets is notoriously hard to police. Kalshi has already been the subject of high-profile investigations regarding insider trading, such as a White House teleprompt-

er operator using his access to Trump’s speeches in order to make predictions on his remarks, or perhaps more egregiously, an instance in which a member of U.S. special forces used his knowledge of classified information to cash in a bet on the capture of former Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro. While we may hope that the sanctity of Brown’s admissions office would rise above any potential financial incentives or insider trading, admissions officers are only human. Since their recent boom, prediction markets have repeatedly shown their ability to entice insider trading from the very highest of public offices, and we see no reason to assume college admissions will be any different. At a school that turned away almost 95% of its applicants in the 2026 admissions cycle, a few extra rejections may not turn up in an audit, but they could make all the difference for a prediction market. And with college admissions practices already hidden behind a veil of secrecy, public accountability is an unlikely solution. Considering the fraught relationship between higher education and the American public, opening gambling markets on college admissions won’t provide “a good window into broader economic health, human capital development, social mobility.” Rather, they will simply cast additional doubt on the legitimacy of institutions of higher education and stir further anxieties in the students striving to reach them.

Reid Gold ’29 can be reached at reid_gold@brown. edu. Please send responses to this column to letters@ browndailyherald.com and other opinions to opinions@ browndailyherald.com.

Gourevitch: The UVV Implementation Working Group should never have touched academic freedom Across the country, colleges and universities have spent the past few years placing new limits on academic freedom. For example, Columbia has effectively eliminated faculty and student participation in disciplinary decisions. Northeastern University revised its Code of Student Conduct to create more restrictions on expressive activities and more severe punishments for violations. Swarthmore College introduced speech-related restrictions, including expansive understanding of “bullying and harassment” that applied even to distribution of student zines, and new types of sanctions for violating the rewritten code. And dozens of universities and colleges have placed new burdens on protests. Loyola University Chicago created a new, highly limited, free-speech zone for demonstrations; Vanderbilt University allows daytime public displays for a maximum three consecutive days; Harvard has extensive new blackout days where protests are “generally not permitted.” The University of California, the birthplace of the student free-speech movement, recently banned encampments on all of its campuses. Is our administration now getting in on the game? Recently, a faculty-led working group created by the administration, called the University Values and Voice Implementation Working Group, proposed a comprehensive rewriting of Brown’s Code of Conduct, including substantial changes to the meaning of academic freedom. After considering community feedback to an initial draft, the working group walked back some of the rewrite’s most objectionable language. But the UVV should never have touched academic freedom. Consider the context in which changes are being proposed. The past two years have witnessed extensive attacks on academic freedom from various federal agencies and external actors, coupled with anticipatory obedience by university administrators across the country. Faculty, students and staff

have been fired, lost funding and research opportunities,had visas revoked and threatened with immigration proceedings, had centers closed, all to suppress expressive activities and enforce ideological compliance. At Brown, one professor was deported, another testified to their inability to speak publicly and multiple others were prevented from pursuing their research. Brown faced civil rights complaints that a Department of Justice whistleblower revealed were pretextual. The AAUP has demonstrated that these national Title VI investigations, which included direct targeting of Brown professors, were entirely politically motivated. In many of the above cases, the University never said a word in defense of its own members. It did, however, negotiate secretly with the Trump administration. In light of these experiences, the most urgent priority is vigorous and unequivocal commitment to defending the most expansive academic freedom of its members. That should be easy. Our current Code of Conduct already includes an excellent definition that emphasizes that members have “full freedom in their teaching, learning and research.” It lists expansive examples of this “full freedom,” including the exercise of speech, petition, association, religion, as well as rights to “political activity inside and outside the University” and “the right to petition authorities, the public and the University.” While the changes to language surrounding academic freedom were reverted in the second draft of the UVV’s changes, the administration seems to remain fixated on pursuing the implementation of the UVV’s language. In a recent message, President Christina Paxson P’19 P’MD’20 says the current definition in the Code of Conduct is out of date, and would benefit from “review and discussion” because it is “now 60 years old.” It is true that the Code of Conduct originates from a 1966 Statement on Academic Freedom for Faculty and Students. It was

written in the post-McCarthy era, when many universities responded to extensive government repression and administrative interference by adopting strong definitions of academic freedom. In light of recent events, that is just the kind of definition we ought to affirm outright. But anyhow, the faculty and Corporation already “reviewed and discussed” this definition, when we incorporated it into the Code of Conduct in 2022. This is not some outdated intellectual relic that snuck in, we intentionally adopted that expansive definition for our most fundamental document. The administration also claims there is confusion about Brown’s official definition of academic freedom because, in 2025, the faculty and the Corporation voted on something called the Statement on University Values and Voice. According to Paxson, the 1966 statement in the Code of Conduct and the new UVV Statement “both speak to academic freedom and freedom of expression, albeit with somewhat different language.” Since the two statements have “the same standing” there is therefore confusion about which definition really regulates our activity. They propose incorporating both definitions into the Code of Conduct until we can resolve the conflict. This unnecessarily muddies the waters. The two statements should not be considered of equal standing. The 2025 UVV statement is a narrowly tailored, one-page policy document, whose sole purpose is to restrict the way the University speaks publicly about political matters. The statement says that “use of University voice should concern only those issues that directly influence the University mission.” The definition of academic freedom, and other values, are fit for that one purpose: to guide university officials in identifying when to speak to its “core mission.” The Code of Conduct is a comprehensive document, much wider in scope, laying out basic princi-

ples, rights and responsibilities, for the full range of community members. This makes it more like a constitutional document. Even the president said that the Code of Conduct “collect(s) in one place many of the standards of conduct and behavior expected of University community members” — implicitly acknowledging its fundamental nature. Saying that the UVV and the Code of Conduct are of equal standing is like saying that a law passed by Congress has equal standing with the First Amendment of the Constitution. If a law is inconsistent with the Constitution, we don’t send the law to a committee to resolve tensions. We rewrite the law. Similarly, if the UVV lays out a definition of academic freedom inconsistent with the Code of Conduct, we should alter the UVV. If the administration had wanted to change the Code of Conduct it should have just proposed changing it, rather than try to backdoor changes through "implementation" of the UVV. In any case, the administration and working group is over-reading the differences between the two documents. But if the administration genuinely believes that a materially significant conflict exists, there is a simple solution: Incorporate the Code of Conduct’s definition of academic freedom directly into the UVV. There is no need for more committees and rewrites. If this seems like nitpicking, I can only draw attention to context one more time. It is unclear whether the University really has our backs. Stirring up unnecessary confusion around academic freedom only increases suspicion.

Alexander Gourevitch is an associate professor of political science. He can be reached at Alexander_Gourevitch@ brown.edu. Please send responses to this op-ed to letters@ browndailyherald.com and other op-eds to opinions@ browndailyherald.com.


PAGE 12

Friday, November 20, 2026

ARTS & CULTURE REVIEW

TAPS’s ‘Spring Awakening’ is a powerful display despite disorientating stagecraft The musical explored intense themes surrounding the realities of growing up BY AMELIA BARTER SENIOR STAFF WRITER After eight performances of “Spring Awakening,” the Department of Theater Arts and Performance Studies’s production came to a close this past Sunday. Directed by Adjunct Lecturer Richard Waterhouse and selected and produced by the Sock and Buskin board, the musical featured strong performances but questionable lighting choices in an exploration of the dangers of failing to educate youth about sexuality. The musical featured strong lead performances by Simon Peter Newkirk ’29 and Zoë Espiritu ’29, who played Melchior Gabor and Wendla Bergmann: two young teenagers who fall in love and explore their budding sexuality. The first act introduced the characters through ensemble moments, which

COURTESY OF BROWN UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF THEATRE ARTS AND PERFORMANCE STUDIES VIA ERIN X. SMITHERS.

The musical featured strong lead performances by Simon Peter Newkirk ’29 and Zoë Espiritu ’29, who played Melchior Gabor and Wendla Bergmann. delineated the contrasting lives of boys and girls in late 19th-century Germany. The choreography and blocking skillfully demonstrated the oppressiveness of this society and the quiet ways in which the boys and girls try to fight back. Melchior’s best friend Moritz Stiefel, played by Brodie Gross ’28, sets off the plot

by asking Melchior to educate him on the meaning of his newfound sexual desire. Gross’s astounding performance brought the audience along with his character as he is expelled from school and reaches a breaking point. The strength of Gross’s character work made Moritz’s arc all the more devastating.

Throughout the musical, Ella Piscatello ’27 — a staff writer for The Herald — and Kai Faucher ’27 played the various adult characters — including the shattering performance of Moritz’s father, who berates his son for his academic performance just before his death. Both Piscatello and Faucher handled their many roles very well, often quickly switching from a loving figure to a cruel oppressor. The constantly-changing lighting was, at times, confusing. While the unnatural, bright colors and dynamic shifts occasionally worked, other times, the lighting — such as the rainbow flashing effect — felt a little gimmicky. The LED strips lining the stage and the vertical light bars at the back took the audience out of the performance amid the other lighting setups that were better suited to the setting of the musical. The set and costume design were more cohesive with the overall tone of “Spring Awakening,” with restrictive school uniforms for the boys and decorative arches on the stage’s upper platforms. The musicians were housed underneath the platforms, and

their live renditions of the numbers truly brought the performance to life. The graphic nature of the story was treated with the utmost sincerity. Performances in the last scene — in which the cast sings “The Song of Purple Summer” — were powerfully heartwrenching. The closing number demonstrated the talent of the cast as a whole, bringing back skillful singers Kat Lopez ’27, who played Ilse Neumann, and Jaiden Mathews ’29, who played Ernst Röbel. Elements of the plot featuring Ilse and Ernst were particularly delightful to watch and well-integrated, while some other side plots seemed disjointed and random alongside the rest of the story. But overall, the musical was an entertaining experience that balanced comedy with darker moments in a natural way, giving the real and intense themes of “Spring Awakening” space to breathe.

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 16, 2026.

MUSICAL

Behind the curtain: How Brown students brought ‘Merrily We Roll Along’ to life Brown Musical Forum spent months bringing the musical to the stage BY TIMOTHY RO SENIOR STAFF WRITER After months of rehearsals, revisions and constant work, what began in April with director applications culminated in an on-stage collaboration between actors, musicians, designers and technicians at the Granoff Center for the Creative Arts. The students behind Brown Musical Forum’s production of Stephen Sondheim’s “Merrily We Roll Along” let the show roll on Nov. 12 — this time with the curtains raised and an audience ready to applaud. The Herald followed the production from its early casting stages through its opening night. Where the production began: Directorial appointments and logistics Preparations for “Merrily We Roll Along” began in April, approximately seven months before the curtain rose on the musical, when prospective directors submitted their applications. After interviews, the BMF board chose director Acadia Phillips ’28, who is a writer for post- Magazine, musical director Kaylee Gilbert ’29 and stage manager Sophia Diamond ’29 to help spearhead the production. By early May, the production’s leaders had begun developing their artistic vision and thinking through the logistics of bringing Sondheim’s masterpiece to the stage. Phillips spent much of her summer studying the script, envisioning how scenes would unfold and developing preliminary blocking arrangements. Meanwhile, Gilbert familiarized herself with the score, preparing to conduct performers through Sondheim’s intricate melodies ahead of the fall rehearsals. In addition to creative preparations, producers coordinated logistics with the Undergraduate Finance Board, Brown Arts Institute and Student Activities Office to secure funding, rehearsal spaces and other necessities. Set and costume designers also began developing their plans. When it was time for auditions in

mid-September, months of preparation had already built the foundation for the ambitious production. What began as a collection of musical scores and staging visions took shape through its prospective cast of performers. Finding the cast: Auditions and callbacks For the directing team, the audition process involved not only evaluating individual vocal and acting abilities, but also envisioning the chemistry between performers onstage, Gilbert said. “We had a pretty good idea of our principals after auditions, but callbacks were just a way for us to see chemistry live,” Gilbert added. Ultimately, Karli Cottom ’27 starred as Mary Flynn, Owen Vaccaro ’28 as Charley Kringas and Jake Delesky ’27 as Franklin Shepard. Casting the ensemble was a bit less straightforward, Gilbert said. With many smaller roles, the team considered how individual actors could be optimized to portray different characters throughout the production. Changes in actors’ availability also prompted adjustments to the cast size. Beyond casting, the production faced some challenges with its design team. According to Phillips, the student originally set to work on costume design switched to set design and then withdrew from the production altogether. But the rest of the crew managed to make it work, pulling together the set sketches and finding a new costume designer on a tight turnaround. From the first note to the final rehearsal With all the roles filled and the cast completely assembled, rehearsals began in early October, allowing the cast to start preparing for the big stage. By then, opening night was just over a month away, and the newly assembled cast faced an uphill battle to perfect Sondheim’s intricate score while polishing acting and choreography to bring the score’s story to life. The first two weeks were dedicated almost entirely to music before the production moved to blocking and full scene run-throughs. Under Gilbert, performers worked through every aspect of each song, from individual melodies and overlapping har-

CLAIRE KE / HERALD

After months of preparation, opening night for Brown Musical Forum’s production of Stephen Sondheim’s “Merrily We Roll Along” was Nov. 12. monies to the complex rhythm the musical requires. While Phillips came into the production with specific visual ideas, she explained that directing required an intricate balance between her initial plans and the creative contributions of the performers. “There’s a lot of parts of the process where I would come in with blocking ideas that I’d written, and then they would improvise something, and then we’d be like, ‘No, we like that,’” Phillips said. “It’s been interesting to combine the … very specific images I had with the natural inclinations of the actors.” During an Oct. 6 rehearsal in List Art Building, cast members gathered in the front row of a classroom, singing along as Gilbert accompanied them on the piano. Some tapped pens against nearby surfaces to follow the rhythm while others were seen quietly rehearsing their parts between songs. Laughter and conversation filled the room the entire rehearsal, offering a glimpse into the friendships that had developed over weeks of rehearsals. For Phillips, the cast’s musical talent and chemistry was apparent from the beginning. “I started crying during our first rehearsal when they all started singing the

opening song together, because … they (were) already so good,” Phillips recalled. Yet learning the score was only one part of the large amount of preparation needed for the musical. Ensemble member Joey Fiscella ’27 explained that Sondheim’s compositions require performers to navigate the complex overlapping of lines between characters. “There are a lot of songs, especially in Act Two ... (where) there are oftentimes four, five characters overlapping with different lyrics,” Fiscella said. For Cottom, the musical’s reverse chronology presented another challenge. “Merrily We Roll Along” traces the fluctuating relationships of three friends — Franklin, Charlie and Mary — over nearly two decades, beginning with their fractured relationships in 1976 and moving backward toward their youthful ambitions in 1957. Cottom added that portraying Mary required her to adjust not only her acting but her singing, allowing her voice to reflect the character’s changing age and emotional states. As opening night approached, the cast prepared for the next challenge — bringing the performances all together with sets, lighting, sound and a live orchestra during tech week.

The culmination of everything: Tech week and opening night On Nov. 9, production members rented a U-Haul to transport sets and props into the theater. Months of preparation finally became visible onstage through brightly colored doors and a large backdrop painted sky blue with white clouds. Throughout tech week, performers and crew members worked through cue-to-cue rehearsals, readjusting lighting and sound along the way. As stage manager, Diamond had to oversee nearly every aspect of the production. She described the role of a stage manager as “the glue to bring all parts of the production together.” One challenge involved getting the orchestra and the cast on the same page — literally. Having spent much of the rehearsal process practicing separately, the musicians and actors realized they had been practicing with slightly different sheet music. But a few extra run-throughs smoothened out the bumps. During the dress rehearsals, which took place on Nov. 10 and 11, some older microphones also posed hurdles. On Nov. 12, the production finally reached a completely sold out opening night — the culmination of nearly seven months of preparation. Ensemble member Raghav Ramgopal ’28 was “really excited” to see the audience’s energy. “We’ve had small groups of people watch the show during tech week, but it’s really exciting to be able to see everyone see it,” he said. For Diamond, the evening offered a chance to witness audience reactions to scenes she had spent weeks helping coordinate. For Phillips, the musical’s exploration of friendship and ambition offers a message that extends beyond just a stage. Phillips hopes the story of Franklin, Charlie and Mary can encourage audiences to reflect on their own relationships and their own aspirations. “I feel like this show does a beautiful job of reminding people that there’s value in your dreams,” Phillips said.

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 16, 2026.


THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

PAGE 13

ARTS & CULTURE EVENT

‘Rigorously Curated’ film festival explores sentience, technology and the ‘sad robot’ The festival’s theme was centered around the class ARTS 1550

LORI LAI / HERALD

BY ANJALI DATLA CONTRIBUTING WRITER Last week, the Brown Arts Institute brought students and community members to the movies with “Rigorously Curated” — a free three-day film festival that screened three films with unique cultural perspectives centered around the event’s theme, “Sad Robot (Sentience Was a Mistake).” The festival was held in the Lindemann Performing Arts Center and was part of the BAI’s semesterly film series that began last year. BAI director Sydney Skybetter wrote in an email to The Herald that the series is part of a wider goal for “students to feel welcome in BAI facilities” and be encouraged to “take a class or see another show.” He described this year’s theme as “a way of exploring humanity at a supposed distance from ourselves.” “When we’re thinking about sentience and sad robots, we’re thinking about what it means to be human in an age of great anxiety and technocultural challenges and violence,” Skybetter wrote. The festival’s theme was inspired by the new class ARTS 1550: “Robots (re) Imagined: Art, Engineering and Specu-

lative Futures.” Through a collaboration between the BAI, the Rhode Island School of Design and the Department of Engineering, the course is taught by Associate Professor of Computer Science and Engineering Nora Ayanian and RISD Professor of Experimental and Foundation Studies Paula Gaetano Adi. The class asks students to “design and program robots that move beyond utility, building machines that sense, act and com-

municate in ways that unsettle boundaries between the technical and the aesthetics,” according to the course listing. Gaetano Adi described the festival as a chance for students to extend the conversations they were having in class, where robotics is examined not only from an engineering perspective but also through a cultural and critical lens. The festival opened with the 2008 film “Sleep Dealer,” which follows the cultural

dynamics of the U.S.-Mexico border. Gaetano Adi said that while the film’s themes may have seemed unfamiliar when it first came out, it has since grown more relevant. She added that the film also allowed students in the class to tackle narratives such as Afrofutureism and challenge the narrative in science fiction that centers Western technological progress. “Seeing this conversation happen in (Latin America) really reorients some of

the discussions that we have in relation to robotics,” she said. This cross-cultural focus resonated with Milo Akerman ’28, who attended the Tuesday screening. Ackerman, who is from Argentina, said he “really liked watching a movie in Spanish” and appreciated the way the film “invert(ed) the whole concept of robots as a force of good.” Skybetter wrote that he wanted to take a “transnational approach” during the film selection process. He wrote that the three films offer “three facets of alienation, anxiety and violence, and of who gets to hold power in our emerging technocultural economy, who doesn’t and what the bodily stakes are.” The festival’s second film, “The Mitchells vs. the Machines,” brought an American perspective that Skybetter called “hilarious and queer and playful.” The event’s final film, “Ghost in the Shell” — a Japanese film released in 1995 — allowed viewers to examine what the “self” is, Skybetter wrote. “Watching strange movies in the dark with a room full of strangers is a very different experience from streaming alone on the couch,” Skybetter wrote. “It’s defined by relationality, social cohesion and collaborative potential.”

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 17, 2026.

REVIEW

‘Wild Horse Nine’ struggles to reconcile its complicated characters with Chile’s history The film forces the two men to reckon with each other and themselves BY LIZE DENG STAFF WRITER Martin McDonagh’s “Wild Horse Nine” is a striking but confusing film that struggles under the weight of its diverse themes. It is a comedy bromance, a meditation on mortality and a scathing critique of American foreign policy, all in 116 minutes. McDonagh attempts to execute this complex vision with a plot about two CIA agents who take a holiday to Easter Island before the 1973 Chilean Coup. Chris Carlise (John Malkovich) and his friend and protégé Lee Chesterfield (Sam Rockwell) are CIA operatives based in Santiago, Chile, under a conniving, frustrated and constantly grimacing station chief named MJ (Steve Buscemi). Chris is a seasoned operative increasingly regretful of his involvement in atrocities in Guatemala and Cuba — and now, Chile. “I’ve killed people in countries you can’t even spell,” he says to Lee. We quickly learn that Chris is seriously ill, and his final wish is to travel to Easter Island to see the “big heads.” There, he wants Lee to kill him. As with “In Bruges” and “The Banshees of Inisherin,” McDonagh’s latest film drops two men into an unfamiliar and mystical locale, forcing them to reckon with each other and themselves. But it is the stunning setting of Easter Island that steals the show rather than the plot. Cinematographer Ben Davis introduces the island with sweeping aerial shots fit for either a nature documentary or a tourism ad. The “big heads” — which are actually called “moai” — are awe-inspiring to behold. The moai on Rapa Nui — the Indigenous name for Easter Island — were carved sometime between the 10th cen-

tury and the 16th century, making them at least twice as old as the United States. They stand stoically in the backdrop as Lee and Chris bicker at each other with dialogue that tries to be funny, but is often numbingly repetitive. It’s like watching two elementary school children attempting to insult each other. Except, as with any McDonagh film, there’s a lot more swearing. Indeed, Chris resembles an angsty teenager in a comedy show. On several occasions, he complains that they’re always doing things Lee’s way. Still, there is palpable affection between the two characters. Their bickering, while not always humorous or coherent, makes the agents more endearing. Rockwell and Malkovich

are perfect alongside each other, playing off each other’s energy entertainingly enough to keep the audience invested in their fate. Still, the stellar cast is unable to reconcile the script’s seeming randomness, nor the tensions in the movie’s themes. The film feels emotionally torn, with characters who are meant to be likeable but are unable to escape their dark backstories, struggling to embed comedy within a high-stakes spy plot. This clash is only worsened by the backdrop of one of the darkest and most violent periods in recent South American history. Under President Richard Nixon, the CIA attempted to block the inauguration of Chile’s first democratically-elected Marxist president, Salvador Allende, in

1970. When this failed, the United States continued covert operations to create conditions favourable for a coup, leading to the overthrow of Allende and a brutal 17-year military dictatorship. Between 1973 and 1990, thousands were killed or disappeared under Chile’s military junta. In this context, it’s hard to feel any sympathy for a man like Chris, who has worked to topple elected officials around the world. Regardless of how much he regrets his actions and tries to curb his habit of chronic dishonesty, he remains responsible for truly unforgivable deeds. Chris, on the other hand, is self-aware, remarking that he cares “more about the moths of Chile” than the country’s people. Drowning in Catholic guilt, he wonders

aloud if he will go to heaven. Like the moai, Chris and Lee are weathered but still remarkably strong. After ages of stale petulance, the film’s ending finally reveals two complex and fraught individuals whose humanity has been diminished by the demands of a ravenous American empire. In one of the film’s most memorable scenes, McDonagh creates a visual allusion to the moai as Chris stands stoically against a mountain facing the sea. In that moment, he looks more like a chess piece — a tragic pawn in someone else’s game — than a man.

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 18, 2026.

COURTESY OF SEARCHLIGHT PICTURES

After ages of stale petulance, the film’s ending finally reveals two complex and fraught individuals whose humanity has been diminished by the demands of a ravenous American empire.


PAGE 14

Friday, November 20, 2026

SCIENCE & RESEARCH PUBLIC HEALTH

Study finds 2 in 3 U.S. physicians practice in states that allow noncompete agreements The agreements can limit physicians from leaving negative work conditions BY AISRI VAKALAPUDI CONTRIBUTING WRITER When filling out paperwork for a new job, some doctors must sign noncompete agreements, which bar doctors who leave hospitals or medical practices from joining or opening competing offices within a certain region or period of time. According to new Brown research published in JAMA Internal Medicine, approximately two in every three U.S. physicians practice in states where employers can use noncompete agreements. The study did not directly measure how noncompetes affect physician employment rates or patient access. But the study’s lead author — Assistant Professor of Health Services, Policy and Practice Yashaswini Singh — wrote in an email to The Herald that such agreements “can worsen shortages in underserved communities.” “If a physician wants to change employers but is barred from practicing within a certain region, the only option may be to leave that community entirely,” Singh wrote. “Patients may lose a doctor they have relied on for years.” The researchers reviewed the laws of all 50 states as of July 2026. They found that noncompete agreements are permitted in 16 states and permitted with restrictions

in 15, while 19 states ban them outright. In some states that allow noncompetes, restrictions limit the scope of the agreements. The study found that six states cap the maximum length of an agreement, “ranging from one year in Connecticut, Maryland and Texas to five years in Louisiana.” Texas also limits the geographic reach to five miles, the study reported, and Maryland bars enforcement against physicians earning less than $350,000. According to Singh, the research was motivated by a lack of data on these agreements. “We undertook this study to fill that gap and give policymakers, physicians and the public a clear picture of the legal landscape across states,” she wrote. Isabelle Boun ’27, a co-author on the study, said the research comes amid growing attention to the “corporatization of medicine.” Health systems, insurers and private equity firms employ a rising share of physicians, she added. Leemore Dafny, a professor of business administration and of public policy at Harvard who did not contribute to the study, wrote in an email to The Herald that the research “makes clear that noncompetes are still a live issue for the majority of physicians.” Twelve of the 19 state bans took effect in 2024 or later. Singh wrote that the recent “flurry” of legislative activity spans states with different political leanings. “This isn’t a partisan issue,” she wrote. But none of the recent bans apply to

contracts signed before the laws took effect. “There’s momentum,” Singh wrote, “but most doctors likely have not yet experienced the effects of reform.” Dafny wrote that she thinks “the estimates are conservative as many states’ bans only became effective in 2024 and do not apply to contracts already in place at that time.” The effects of noncompete agreements could be particularly significant in primary care and rural areas, where physician shortages are already present, Boun said. When a doctor’s former employer operates in multiple locations across a region, the agreements’ geographic restrictions can prevent a doctor from working across a much larger area than a single hospital or practice, she added. The findings build on earlier work by Singh and other Brown researchers. The Herald reported on a 2025 study finding that a growing share of healthcare practices were being acquired and consolidated by private equity firms. According to Singh, as health care organizations consolidate, a smaller number of employers may come to dominate the physician labor market in a particular region. In this situation, “a noncompete (agreement) can leave a doctor with very few real alternatives,” she wrote. “That weakens physicians’ ability to negotiate pay and working conditions, or to leave when something isn’t working.” Dafny raised a related concern about how private equity-owned practices en-

MINA STICKLEY / HERALD

force noncompete agreements. She wrote that these employers may be less concerned than others about how these agreements can restrict physician mobility. She added that noncompete agreements can sometimes serve “pro-competitive” purposes, but she wrote that they are often included in employment contracts even when those justifications are absent. In 2024, the Federal Trade Commission finalized a rule that would have banned most noncompete agreements nationwide.

But a federal court blocked the rule before it could take effect. Singh wrote that state legislation offers “valuable lessons” for policymakers, but “a patchwork of state laws can only go so far,” she wrote. “Federal action, especially from Congress, would extend protections to physicians uniformly, no matter where they practice.”

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 18, 2026.

PUBLIC HEALTH

Brown experts weigh in on U.S. loss of measles elimination status The CDC reported about 5,400 cases in the United States this year BY WYATT FOSTER STAFF WRITER On Tuesday, the Pan American Health Organization revoked the United States’ measles elimination status. PAHO awards measles elimination status to countries where endemic transmission of the deadly disease has not occurred

for at least 12 consecutive months, among other criteria. Though the United States has held elimination status since 2000, an outbreak of the disease has now been spreading for 22 months, surpassing the necessary threshold for revocation. So far this year, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has reported about 5,400 confirmed measles cases, scattered across 45 states and the District of Columbia. According to Professor of Epidemiology Jennifer Nuzzo, director of the Pandemic Center at the School of Public Health, there are several reasons why the number of measles cases in the United States has

increased over the past two years. As the United States transitioned out of the COVID-19 pandemic, “public health became part of the political culture wars,” said Scott Rivkees, professor of the practice of health services, policy, and practice and former state surgeon general of Florida. “Politicians hitched their stars to members of the anti-vaccine movement to get votes.” Rivkees said that the anti-vaccination stance of U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. P’07 P’20 “has contributed to the distrust that we’re seeing that is leading to falling

vaccination rates.” “The invisible shield of public health, which has protected Americans for decades, is now crumbling,” Rivkees said, “and it’s crumbling really due to failed public health leadership of the current administration.” HHS and the White House did not respond to The Herald’s request for comment. “Widespread inaccurate information has contributed to declining vaccination rates, and now a disease which should almost never occur is killing people once again,” the Rhode Island Department of

MATHIEU GRECO / HERALD

Though the United States has held measles elimination status since 2000, an outbreak of the disease has now been spreading for 22 months, surpassing the necessary threshold for revocation.

Health wrote in a Tuesday press release. “The majority of (recent measles) cases and deaths are occurring in people who are not vaccinated,” said Nuzzo. Once measles is contracted, there is no treatment doctors can provide to cure the disease. The measles vaccine, which is typically administered to children at about 12 months of age, and again at 4 to 6 years of age, is effective at preventing infection and reducing symptom severity, according to the CDC. According to Nuzzo, a nationwide vaccination rate of about 95% would prevent outbreaks and the spread of measles. Immunocompromised individuals and young infants who cannot receive the vaccine rely on herd immunity to protect themselves from the virus, she said, but the U.S. vaccination rate for measles sits around 90%. “(Medically vulnerable) individuals will end up paying the price,” Rivkees said, “which can be very serious.” Measles symptoms include rashes and high fevers, according to the CDC. Severe cases can cause pneumonia, brain swelling and, in extreme cases, death. Nuzzo added that the change in status may reflect the nation’s potential lack of preparedness for other severe health emergencies. “If you cannot stop a disease like measles, a disease for which we have a well-proven, safe and effective vaccine … that means you have lost the ability to stop other deadly infections,” she said. At the Pandemic Center, Nuzzo said that researchers are monitoring the evolving measles outbreaks alongside federal, state and local response strategies to identify best practices for disease mitigation. “There really needs to be a resounding message that vaccines are safe and that vaccines are effective and that people should get vaccinated,” Rivkees said.


THE BROWN DAILY HERALD

PAGE 15

UNIVERSITY NEWS SPEAKER

Mayor-elect David Morales MPA’19 talks city divestment, rent stabilization at BPU event The Brown Political Union hosted the conversation on Monday

ing the financial burden on taxpayers, Morales told The Herald that divested funds will be reallocated to other investments that see “very similar, if not greater, levels of return.” “I myself do not have concerns that this is going to impact taxpayers or that it’s going to impact our pension,” he said. While he has had friction with the Providence police union in the past, Morales said his focus is on their “shared common interest, which is keeping all our neighbors safe.” He said that he has begun conversations with PPD officers and leadership around public safety. The PPD did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Teresa King, an East Providence resident, said that the event made her “feel more comfortable” with Morales despite his youth. “He seems very earnest, and

BY TALIA KATZ SENIOR STAFF WRITER On Monday, the Brown Political Union hosted a conversation with Mayor-elect David Morales MPA’19 in the second installment of its three-part Fall 2026 Speaker Series. The conversation was moderated by BPU Vice President Rosie Shultz ’27, followed by a Q&A session. At the talk, Morales spoke of the University’s financial contributions to Providence, the future of the city divestment ordinance and the role of democratic socialism across the country, among other topics. Morales began his opening remarks with his characteristic, “Hi, neighbors.” “Providence is an incredibly special city,” he said. “Whether you’re a student or resident here in our city, you’ve probably noticed just how neighborly Providence can be.” In an interview with The Herald before the event, Morales said that one of the first things that struck him about Providence was how “everyone was just one degree of separation from knowing each other.” Morales discussed his experiences in the University’s MPA program at the event and referenced Taubman Center Director Eric Patashnik’s lessons on cost-benefit analysis, which he said he has brought up during floor debates at the State House. Morales also discussed Brown and other Providence private universities’ voluntary Payment in Lieu of Taxes monetary contributions to the city. “We have here a world-class Ivy League institution, one that I’m a proud (alum) of. But at the same time, less than a mile away, we have Hope High School, which is struggling with basic infrastructure conditions,” he said. Morales pointed to Yale’s agreement with New Haven as a model for how elite institutions can contribute to their home cities. Earlier this year, Yale announced it will make voluntary payments totaling

ANTHONY CIANFLONE / HERALD

Morales also discussed Brown and other Providence private universities’ voluntary Payment in Lieu of Taxes monetary contributions to the city. over $230 million to New Haven in six years. Alex Torres-Perez, a spokesperson for the Providence Public School District, wrote in an email to The Herald that this characterization of Hope High School “overlooks the work underway to address longstanding challenges and improve learning environments for our students,” including a new library and media center that received funding from the University. “We look forward to working with Mayor-elect David Morales and his administration to continue advancing these priorities and ensuring Providence students have the schools, resources and opportunities they deserve,” she added. The University did not immediately respond to The Herald’s request for comment. Morales emphasized that he wants the relationship between Providence and its private universities to be “based on collaboration and shared interests,” not antagonism.

The mayor-elect has also been a staunch supporter of rent stabilization. “Reality is, we have watched rents increase by more than 40% here in our capital city since 2020 (and) we have become the least affordable city in America for renters,” Morales said. “We are in a crisis, and it’s going to require action. I believe that action immediately is passing rent stabilization.” Morales told The Herald that he has already had conversations with Governor-elect Helena Foulkes regarding additional funding for Providence from the state, which was part of his campaign platform. While discussing the trend of democratic socialist candidates’ success across the country during the event, Morales said that it sends a message that “neighbors want government officials that are actually going to fight for their needs.” “Democratic socialism to me means the basic principles of fairness,” Morales said. Many aspects of the platform are personal to Morales, who grew up with a

single immigrant mother and depended on services such as Medicaid, public housing and SNAP, he told The Herald. Morales described the grassroots collaboration that led to his election and how “many of our neighbors became engaged in what we call the political process for the first time ever.” He emphasized that his success was the product of “years of collective organizing” and “the determination that we, as a community, can demand so much more.” Morales characterized the passing of Question 7, a city divestment ordinance, as a “mandate” for “moral clarity” in the city’s investment of taxes and pension funds. While critics have warned about future litigation, Morales explained that this is a common argument that he has heard, such as in opposition to rent stabilization. “I’m not going to allow this tactical method of saying, ‘well, you’re going to get sued’ or ‘there’s going to be litigation’ to prevent us from actually embracing our values,” he said. In response to concerns about increas-

that he really does want to solve a lot of the problems we have in Providence,” she said. She was particularly interested in his discussion about the details of implementing rent stabilization. While King supports the policy, she has heard criticisms from her neighbors, and she said she now has “ammunition” to explain to them what exactly Morales’s plan is. To Stephanie Cabrera GS, a master’s student at the School of Public Health, seeing representation as a first-generation student was “really inspiring.” She added that it was interesting to hear about the process of enforcing Question 7, as “there’s a lot of fear mongering” surrounding it. Ashley Mascorro GS, who is also a master’s student at the School of Public Health, added that she has been studying Morales’s “Cover All Kids” legislation — which would extend Medicaid to cover all lower-income children in Rhode Island regardless of immigration status — in class. Mascorro said that hearing from Morales “really was exemplary of being able to connect classroom content to real-life current events.”

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 17, 2026.

UNIVERSITY ADMINISTRATION

University contributes $4.5 million in grants to boost R.I. workforce development The grants help fulfill Brown’s agreement with the federal government BY JEREMIAH FARR SENIOR STAFF WRITER Following a $3 million first round of contributions in January, Brown has awarded another $4.5 million in grants to four nonprofits, the University announced Wednesday. As part of Brown’s July 2025 agreement with the federal governmentto restore federal research funding, the University committed to contribute $50 million over 10 years to workforce development organizations in Rhode Island. Genesis Center and the University of Rhode Island Foundation will each receive $1.5 million, Polaris MEP will receive $1.37 million and the Rhode Island Association for Infant Mental Health will receive $200,000. The newly announced grants aim to “expand job training, connect residents to career opportunities and boost the state’s workforce,” according to the University’s

CLAIRE KE / HERALD

In January, Brown gave its first round of grants, which went to the Community College of Rhode Island and Building Futures. press release. In total, the money from the workforce development grants will expand employment opportunities for over 1,200 R.I. residents, according to the press release. Genesis Center — which provides services like adult education and job training for immigrants, refugees and low-income families — intends to use the $1.5 million to increase the number of participants in its healthcare training programs, according

to the announcement. Genesis Center has trained healthcare workers in partnership with Brown University Health and other local healthcare employers. Polaris MEP, an affiliate of the Manufacturing Extension Partnership National Network, is a nonprofit organization that provides consulting and training to underserved individuals as they navigate their career paths.

Polaris MEP plans to use the $1.37 million to increase the number of participants in their career pathways programs, in partnership with manufacturing businesses and institutions across Rhode Island, and expand training for manufacturing industry-related skills such as welding and industrial maintenance. The $1.5 million grant to the University of Rhode Island Foundation will equip URI’s College of Pharmacy to train up to 90 certified nursing assistants annually, an increase from the current cohort size of 18 students annually. “The initiative directly addresses a critical shortage of staff qualified to administer medications safely in local nursing homes, assisted living facilities, rehabilitation centers and adult day programs,” the announcement states. The Rhode Island Association for Infant Mental Health intends to use their $200,000 grant to help build Rhode Island’s first early childhood mental health workforce development hub. In alignment with a nationally recommended behavioral health framework, the association will train 50 local clinicians to help identify and treat “mental health and developmental chal-

lenges” in children ranging from birth to age 5, according to the statement. In January, Brown gave its first round of grants, which went to the Community College of Rhode Island and Building Futures, a nonprofit dedicated to preparing R.I. residents for careers in construction through apprenticeship programs. Recipients of November’s round of grants were chosen by a committee of faculty, staff and students and Providence community members through a two-part process. In January, the University sent out an open call to submit letters of interest for potential funding. Then, a few of these organizations were invited to submit full proposals which the committee reviewed, according to the announcement. “Committee members assessed proposals evaluating factors such as labor market demand, program design, participant recruitment and retention and employer hiring or promotion commitments,” the press statement reads.

This article originally appeared online at browndailyherald.com on Nov. 19, 2026.


S:9.5"

PAGE 16

Friday, November 20, 2026

T:16"

S:15.5"


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Friday, November 20, 2026 by The Brown Daily Herald - Issuu