Bethany Today Magazine 2026 Edition

2026 TODAY

F OF

aces

BETHANY

CONTRIBUTORS Caylin Angel Deno Emili ‘78 Noah Gill Aster Luke Emily Luke

SENIOR ADMINISTRATION Jamie Caridi, Ph.D.

DESIGN Emily Luke

Vice President for Finance & CFO

PHOTOGRAPHY Caylin Angel Joe Bruggeman ‘25, MBA ‘26 Noah Gill ‘23 Colin Herb Emily Luke Trista Nickole Morris ‘26 Anna Winesdoerffer

President

Jeffrey R. Breese, Ph.D.

Vice President of Academic Affairs & Chief Academic Officer

Sue Halulko

Jason Koegler

Vice President for Advancement

Sarah Sherinian

Vice President for Student Success and Operational Excellence / Chief Financial Aid Officer

Gerald E. Stebbins

Vice President & Dean of Students

Lori Weaver

Vice President for Enrollment, Marketing, & Communications

Jill Willson

Chief of Staff

Jen Windmiller, MBA ‘23 Director of Athletics

Marc Chernenko ‘78 General Counsel

BOARD OF TRUSTEES Todd Adams Thaddaeus Allen, ‘92, Vice Chair Ken Bado, ‘77, Chair Scott Brooks, ‘78 Steven Butschi Jamie Caridi Michelle Chen ‘91 Richard (Rick) G. Clancy III, ‘76 Evelyn del Cerro, ‘85 Taylor (Nutting) Gurbacs Logan Hassig, ‘70 Dean Haubrich, ‘64 Patrick Hosey, ‘80 Carmina Hughes, ‘76, Secretary Joyce Pollack Jefferson, ‘77 Asa Johnson Arthur B. Keys, Jr., ‘67 S. Dean Lesiak, ‘74 Sean McBride, ‘86 Michele Myauo ‘00 Chris Payne, ‘81 Georgiana Riley, ‘71 Jhamal Robinson, ‘98 Edward J. See, ‘83 Jay Smith ‘71 Kathy Tucker, ‘85 Don Waugaman, ‘70 Jeffrey Woda, ‘87, Treasurer

2026 TODAY IN THIS ISSUE

IN EVERY ISSUE

2 Faces of Bethany

Noteworthy 8 Student Spotlights 20 Alumni Spotlights 24 Faculty Spotlights 32 Bison Athletics 36

22

Class Notes 41

Leading Through Curiosity & Community

25 Changing the Game for Women Bethany Magazine is an annual publication of Bethany College. For additional copies of this publication, or more information, call 304.829.7633.

30 Homecoming

Issue Date: 2026 Printed in the U.S.A. © Bethany College 2026 Get the latest events, sports, updates, and much more at www.bethanywv.edu.

Would you like to receive alumni news and event notices via email? Be sure to update your contact information with the Office of Alumni Relations at 304.829.7633 or alumni@bethanywv.edu.

No part of this publication may be reproduced without the prior permission from Bethany College.

Bethany admits students of any race, color, sex, handicap, and national or ethnic origin.

F OF

aces

BETHANY

One of the aspects I cherish most about Bethany College is the way our community comes alive through the people who make it their own.

Every day, I am reminded that our strength and spirit are found not in buildings or programs alone. They live in the students who challenge themselves to grow, the faculty who guide them with wisdom and care, and the alumni and trustees who carry Bethany’s values into the wider world.

This edition of “Bethany Today Magazine” proudly features our new “Faces of Bethany” series, which shines a spotlight on these exceptional members of our community.

From professors mentoring students in the classroom to alumni leading with integrity and creativity in their professions, each story highlights the ways individuals make a lasting impact here. What connects them all is a shared resolve: investing their time, talent, and passion to shape and sustain a thriving community.

These profiles are reminders of what makes Bethany distinctive. They show the personal dedication and leadership that ripple outward, inspiring those around them and strengthening the College in ways both visible and unseen.

While the pages ahead give a glimpse of these inspiring stories, I encourage you to explore the full series online, where you can meet even more of the people who give Bethany its heart and character.

I hope these stories bring you the same sense of pride and connection that they inspire in all of us here on campus. As you read, I hope you are reminded of the remarkable ways individuals contribute to the life of our College—and of the power of our shared community.

With appreciation for all who bring the best of Bethany to life, Jamie Caridi, Ph.D. President, Bethany College 2 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

A Bethany Voice on the

NATIONAL STAGE When EVELYN DEL CERRO ‘85 arrived at Bethany College in the fall of 1981, she carried with her the determined spirit of a New Yorker ready to build something meaningful. Born and raised in New York City, she quickly found her place among the campus’ tight-knit community, immersing herself in student media, athletics, and leadership, all experiences that would propel her into a distinguished career in broadcast journalism.

At Bethany, Evelyn embraced every opportunity to learn, grow, and lead. She joined Zeta Tau Alpha, played on the softball team, contributed to “The Tower” newspaper, and became an active member of the Women in Communications collegiate chapter. But it was behind the microphone and soundboard at WVBC, the College’s radio station, where she found her calling.

She served as the station’s student manager and hosted a weekly radio show, “The Magic Bus,” sparking a love for broadcasting that would guide her professional life. “I have so many favorite things about my time at Bethany,” Evelyn shared, “but if I had to narrow it down, I would say my time at WVBC, the life-long friends I made, my Comps experience, and the impact so many faculty members had on my development and my career.”

Evelyn came to Bethany for a degree and left with lifelong connections and a sense of purpose.

“I believe that Bethany was not just a college I attended but rather a nurturing community that I lived in while attending college,” she said. “I credit so much of my successes to my Bethany experience.”

That foundation led her to ABC/Disney in 1988, marking the beginning of an extraordinary career. She started in the publishing division before serving 12 years as an E.N.G. production manager for “World News Tonight with Peter Jennings.” During that time, she helped cover some of the most defining news moments in modern history, including the attacks on the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001. For her role in the coverage, she earned both a George Foster Peabody Award and a DuPont-Columbia Award, two of journalism’s highest honors.

In 2003, she transitioned to WABC, the local ABC affiliate in New York, where she now oversees local

programming, FCC compliance, and music rights and licensing. Her work contributes to producing the nationally beloved daytime show, “Live with Kelly and Mark,” Evelyn’s leadership and creativity have earned her five New York Emmy Awards for programming focused on breast cancer awareness and child protection.

Even as her career soared, she stayed connected to the place where it all began. Since graduating in 1985, Evelyn has been a constant presence in Bethany’s communication community, serving as an inaugural member of the Communications Wall of Fame, speaking in classes, leading as the Grand Marshal of the 2010 Homecoming parade, keynoting the 2012 Keresty Lectures in Journalism, participating in the 2023 Bethany Connect Speaker Series, and moderating the 2025 Women in Leadership Symposium panel on networking. In January 2024, she joined the Bethany College Board of Trustees, continuing her service to the institution she credits with launching her journey.

“I stayed in touch with several of my professors for many years,” she noted, reflecting on the lifelong mentorships and friendships built in Bethany’s hills.

More than 40 years after arriving on campus, Evelyn del Cerro remains a shining example of what it means to be a Bethanian, grounded in community, driven by curiosity, and committed to elevating others. Her broadcast career, marked by excellence and impact, began with a college radio microphone in West Virginia and grew into a legacy that continues to inspire future generations of Bethany students.

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 3

LEADING PURPOSE with

in the Biotech World When MICHELLE CHEN ‘91 arrived at Bethany College, she found herself in an environment that encouraged curiosity, exploration, and a sense of purpose.

Those values have guided her ever since, and today, they’re at the heart of her work leading one of the most innovative biotechnology companies in the world.

Michelle, a 1991 Bethany graduate, serves as the Chief Business Officer at Insilico Medicine, a global leader in artificial intelligence-driven drug discovery. Based in the San Francisco Bay Area, she oversees corporate strategy, business development, and U.S. operations for a company that uses generative AI to design and develop new therapeutics, technology that has the potential to transform how medicines are discovered and delivered to patients worldwide.

Her journey from the rolling hills of Bethany to the frontiers of biotech innovation reflects both scientific excellence and a human-centered approach to leadership.

After earning her degree from Bethany, Michelle went on to complete a Ph.D. in Biochemistry from the University of Washington and postdoctoral training at the University of California, San Francisco, later pursuing bioinformatics studies at Stanford University. She has since built a distinguished career spanning both large pharmaceutical organizations and emerging biotech firms, including Roche, Merck & Co., and BioMarin Pharmaceutical.

“I really cherished my time at Bethany, where I spent many hours in Richardson Hall, Old Main, and the Bethany House,” said Michelle “Not only did Bethany provide me with a strong liberal arts foundation and the opportunity to learn from exceptional, caring professors, but it also allowed me to build lasting friendships with students who were genuinely curious about other cultures and the world beyond our campus. Bethany was a very special chapter in my life.”

At Insilico Medicine, Michelle’s leadership has been instrumental in forging strategic partnerships. Among them, a groundbreaking collaboration with Sanofi valued

4 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

at more than $1 billion. Her ability to bridge science and business has earned her recognition as one of the Top 25 Biotechnology Executives of 2024 by “The Healthcare Technology Report.”

Despite her global reach, Michelle has remained deeply connected to her alma mater. In 2024, she joined the Bethany College Board of Trustees, bringing with her a wealth of experience in science, technology, and international leadership. Through this role, she hopes to inspire current students to see the power of a liberal-arts education as a foundation for innovation and purposedriven work.

“Leadership isn’t just about results—it’s about the ‘why’ behind what we do,” Michelle shared in “The Enterprise World.” “For me, that ‘why’ has always been about helping people live healthier lives through science and collaboration.”

Whether she’s negotiating international partnerships, mentoring young professionals, or helping guide Bethany’s future, Michelle embodies what it means to lead with purpose—a value she traces all the way back to her days on campus.

Her story reminds us that the impact of a Bethany education can reach far beyond the classroom, sometimes all the way to the front lines of global innovation.

A GLOBAL PATH, A Purpose-Driven Perspective

When STEVEN BUTSCHI ‘23 walks across the historic brick paths of Bethany College, he brings with him a perspective shaped by continents, industries, and innovation. Though not an alumnus, he has become a deeply engaged member of the Bethany community, one whose global experiences and professional leadership reflect the curiosity and commitment that define so many Bethanians.

Raised in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, Steven set his sights far beyond his hometown early on. College took him to the East Coast, and an immersive year abroad in Paris expanded his worldview even further. Those experiences sparked a lifelong fascination with culture, learning, and the power of connection. After graduating from Brown University, during the difficult job market of 2008, he spent a summer leading sixteen teenagers across France, teaching them language and confidence along the way.

His early career began in research consulting for Fortune 500 companies, a path that ultimately led to an unexpected opportunity at Google. What he initially imagined would be a short-term role, has grown into a remarkable 16-year journey at one of the world’s most influential technology companies. Today, Steven serves as Google’s director of the

North American Google education go-to-market and partnerships team, helping school districts, universities, and colleges leverage tools like Google Workspace and Chromebooks to personalize learning and improve access for students of all backgrounds.

Throughout his tenure, Steven has played a pivotal role in bringing Google Apps and Chromebooks into classrooms across K–12 and higher education. His leadership became even more impactful during the COVID-19 pandemic, when millions of students and educators relied on tools like Meet, Docs, Analytics, and Data Studio to stay connected, collaborate remotely, and keep learning moving forward during unprecedented disruption. For Steven, this work isn’t just technological; it’s deeply human. It’s about expanding opportunities, reducing barriers, and supporting the people who shape the future every day. That work will also be the focus of his presentation as the featured speaker for Bethany’s 2026 Grimes Lecture Series during Homecoming Weekend.

That same focus on people is what draws him to Bethany. “Every time I step on campus, I can feel the sense of community,” he shared. “People genuinely care about one another, and when alums come together, there’s a camaraderie that’s truly special.” The rolling hills, the forests, and the close-knit spirit remind him that true strength comes from relationships.

Serving on the Bethany College Board of Trustees has broadened his approach to leadership, offering a new lens for evaluating mission-driven work. “There are so many angles to consider when making a decision, how it affects the mission, the financials, the culture,” he said.

“I’m grateful to work with a board that asks thoughtful questions and is committed to helping Bethany be the best institution it can be.”

From guiding global education initiatives at Google to helping shape the future of Bethany College, Steven’s story is grounded in growth, service, and the belief that learning should always be within reach. His journey, spanning worldwide, is a reminder that communities aren’t just a place. They’re a purpose.

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 5

Teaching, Mentorship, and the

BETHANY WAY

When DR. LISA REILLY arrived at Bethany, she was beginning her career rooted in curiosity, connection, and the joy of watching students grow. Originally from Franklin, Pennsylvania, Lisa earned her Bachelor of Science in chemistry from Mercyhurst University before completing her Ph.D. in analytical chemistry at Oklahoma State University. After a research post-doctoral experience, she knew her heart was set not on the lab bench alone, but on teaching.

“I started to look for a primarily undergraduate institution because I knew I wanted to go into teaching,” she reflected. Bethany quickly stood out. After interviewing on campus, meeting students, faculty, and staff, she knew it stood out. She accepted the offer, and, as she puts it, “the rest is history.”

Today, Lisa serves as an associate professor of chemistry, holds the Goulding-Woolery professorship in chemistry, and serves as both chair and associate provost, shaping academic life at Bethany in both the classroom 6 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

and the administrative wing. Her workload is broad, but her philosophy is simple: students come first.

Lisa teaches everything from general chemistry to advanced coursework, and even statistics at times.

What she enjoys most isn’t tied to a specific subject, but to a specific moment, “teaching any course is about working to see a student’s ‘light bulb’ go on when they learn something new,” she said. Whether it’s demonstrating natural indicators like red cabbage or guiding students through complex atomic modeling, she thrives on the instant when a student looks up and says, “I got it,” and then proves it on the next problem. “That is the enjoyment of teaching,” she said.

One of her most meaningful experiences has been shepherding students from their earliest days to capstone completion. Many of her first-year students return to work with her on senior research, comprehensive exams, and graduation prep. “Experiencing their growth from first-year student to being ready to start their next chapter is impactful,” she said. She gets to see the full arc from tentative problem-solving to confident scientific reasoning, and that continuity fuels her dedication.

That continuity extends beyond academics, too. Lisa believes Bethany’s special character comes from truly knowing students. She doesn’t just teach them in the classroom, but she also cheers for them on athletic fields, attends performances, visits exhibitions, and shows up at student-led events. Those encounters, she believes, are part of the education.

“The focus on knowing your students is what is special,” she said, and for Lisa, that means meeting the whole person, not just the major declared on paper.

Dr. Lisa Reilly’s story is one of intentional teaching, steady mentorship, and the kind of community engagement that makes Bethany distinct. Through her roles as professor, chair, and academic leader, she embodies the Bethany tradition in educating students not just for the workforce, but for life.

The Heartbeat of a

TRUE BETHANIAN GARY FIELDS ‘68 represents what it means to be a true Bethanian. A Bethany native, Gary grew up just steps from campus and was shaped by the College long before he enrolled. His mother, once a pianist for silent films during the Depression, later served as administrative assistant to presidents Wilbur Cramblet and Dr. Perry Gresham. While working at the College, she pursued her own education beginning at Bethany before earning a master’s degree in education from West Virginia University and then returning to teaching in the Bethany grade school until retirement.

Thanks to Bethany’s support, Gary was able to pursue his education as a non-traditional student and graduated in his late twenties. He went on to build a successful career in the Treasury Department at what is now Smurfit WestRock, PLC, headquartered in Ireland.

Gary continues a remarkable Bethany lineage. His great-uncle, Oreon E. Scott, honored each year through the Disciples of Christ lecture series, has a legacy deeply intertwined with the College. Gary’s grandfather, William H. Fields ’01, served as a Disciples of Christ minister in Wheeling, and members of the Fields family founded four churches in the Northern Panhandle in the early 1900s.

Across generations, the Scott and Fields families have proudly supported and graduated from Bethany College, with two Scott family members even serving as Bethany’s postmasters.

Bethany also played a role in Gary’s greatest personal blessing, meeting his wife, Ana Maria, originally from Buenos Aires, while both were building successful finance careers in New York City. Today, Gary and Ana Maria are honoring the College that shaped their journey. In 2025, they contributed a generous $100,000 matching gift. For every dollar

donated through the end of the year, they matched it, doubling the impact up to $100,000. They are also planning to include Bethany in their estate plans by joining the Bronze Bison Society.

Gary and Ana Maria’s generosity reflects the heart of Bethany, rooted in tradition, driven by purpose, and always investing in future generations.

F OF

aces

BETHANY UNLOCK THE REST OF THE SERIES ONLINE

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 7

NEW Bison NEW YEAR,

NOTEWORTHY

The Class of 2029 took their first steps into Bethany life by walking through the Oglebay Gates and signing the historic Matriculation Book, a timeless tradition that officially welcomes every new student into the Bethany family.

The Start of Something Extraordinary With a nod to time-honored traditions and an eye toward bold new beginnings, Bethany College ushered in the 2025–26 academic year at its annual Fall Convocation.

Featured speaker Dr. Gary Kappel ‘74, professor Emeritus and Bethany historian, delivered an inspiring address titled “Yes, It Is All About You,” encouraging students to approach their studies with curiosity and purpose.

During the convocation, Bethany President Dr. Jamie Caridi awarded Assistant Professor of Biology Dr. Kathy Baker-Brosh ’86

8 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

the Faculty Award for Excellence in Teaching and Scholarship and recognized Assistant Director of Athletics for Sports Medicine and Head Athletic Trainer, Kacey Morrison with the Staff Service Award. Additional honors included the awarding of the Anna Ruth Bourne Award to Phi Mu, the W. Kirk Woolery Award to Phi Kappa Phi, the John R. Taylor Memorial Award in Liberal Arts to Professor of Computer Science Fujiko Nito, and the Richard B. Kinney FirstYear Leadership Award to Molly Mitchell ’28. The event honored student and faculty achievements, reminding the Bethany community that its legacy of learning and leadership continues to thrive.

Caridi awards Dr. Kathy Baker-Brosh ‘86 the Presidential Faculty Award.

Caridi awards Kacey Morrison the Presidential Staff Award.

PREACHING Through the

Fire

Voices from across the faith community gathered in Washington, Pennsylvania, as Kimberly R. Wagner led the 2026 Oreon E. Scott Lectures with a stirring exploration of faith, trauma, and the evolving call to ministry. Through sharp insight and honest reflection, the series sparked conversation that lingered well beyond the final session.

Law School Bound During Fall Break of 2025, Bethany students visited Duquesne University’s Thomas Kline School of Law in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, led by AVP of Student Life and Pre-Law Advisor Khali Carpenter.

Students attended a first-year Civil Procedure class, toured the facilities, and heard from admissions counselors and student ambassadors about law school life and the application process. The trip also highlighted Bethany’s accelerated 3+3 dual degree program, allowing students to earn both a bachelor’s degree and a Juris Doctor in six years.

MAKING WAVES at E-Day Left to right: Natalie Dushole ‘28, Leah Dunmire ‘26, Dr. Kathy Baker-Brosh ‘86, Grayson Wallace ‘27, Anna Kovach ‘26, and Kenneth Jackson ‘29.

Biology and environmental science students from Bethany, accompanied by Dr. Kathy Baker-Brosh ‘86, traveled to the West Virginia State Capitol for Environmental Day 2026, where they explored advocacy efforts focused on clean water, sustainable energy, and other key issues impacting the state.

The group, many involved in campus organizations such as Greener Bethany, Tri Beta, and Outdoor Club, networked with leaders and learned about environmental priorities in West Virginia. Natalie Dushole ‘28 was invited by West Virginia Rivers after receiving a grant to restore the riparian buffer along Buffalo Creek by planting trees to protect water quality.

Left to right: Cole Thomas ‘28, Madison Wagoner ‘26, Grace Gatts ‘28, Kathryn Botti ‘26, Ryan Reasbeck ‘26, and Jordan Christner ‘28.

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 9

Freedom

&

FOUNDATIONS

Bethany College welcomed Dr. Kristine A. Culp, dean of the Disciples Divinity House and associate professor of theology at the University of Chicago, as the featured speaker for the College’s 186th Founder’s Day Convocation in March of 2026. In her address, “Three Dr. Kristine A. Culp delivers the Founder’s Day address.

Forms of Freedom,” Culp explored themes of community, responsibility, and intellectual engagement that resonate with Bethany’s mission.

During the convocation, the College recognized Dr. Kayce Mobley, assistant professor and chair of history and political science, as the inaugural award recipient for the Dr. John U. and Marianne S. Davis Educational Advancement award presented by Scott Thompson ‘78, co-director of the Beta Theta Pi Charitable Foundation. This award was established to honor John, a long-time Bethany education professor and active member of the Beta Theta Pi fraternity, and his wife, Marianne, a 20-year teacher at Bethany Primary School and at the College.

The celebration continued with the traditional Founder’s Day events such as a community luncheon and the wreath-laying ceremony, Scott Thompson ‘78 awards the bringing together students, faculty, alumni, and Dr. John U. and Marianne S. Davis friends to honor nearly two centuries of Bethany’s Educational Advancement Award. history and impact.

10 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

Dr. Kayce Mobley receives the Dr. John U. and Marianne S. Davis Educational Advancement award.

PLAY BALL A Field of Legacy

In 2025, Bethany College celebrated the restoration of its baseball field and honored the legacy of longtime trustee G. Ogden Nutting. The field, now refreshed and ready for play, stands as a tribute to a man whose vision and dedication helped shape the College for generations.

Nutting, who served on the Board of Trustees for 45 years, guided Bethany through decades of growth and change. His influence can be seen across campus, from the Nutting Gymnasium to the Ogden Dining Hall, but his greatest impact is felt in the students whose lives he touched.

After significant weather damage left the field in disrepair, the future of Bison baseball seemed uncertain.

Thanks to the generosity of the Nutting family, players now enjoy a safe, high-quality facility. “Because of this gift, today’s and tomorrow’s Bison baseball players will compete on a field that matches their talent and ambition,” Bethany President Dr. Jamie Caridi said.

The Nutting family’s connection to Bethany spans three generations. Ogden’s son, Bob Nutting, also served as a trustee, and his granddaughter, Taylor (Nutting) Gurbacs, now sits on the board and leads the Nutting Family Foundation. Their continued involvement reflects a family tradition of service, loyalty, and belief in the College’s mission.

The dedication ceremony included reflections from Caridi, General Counsel Marc Chernenko ’78, Director of Athletics Jen Windmiller, MBA ‘23, baseball player Sonny Peluchette ‘26, and Gurbacs. Speakers shared stories of Nutting’s generosity and the significance of the restored field for current and future Bison athletes.

“Let this field carry forward the spirit of the man we honor today,” Caridi said. “A man who gave deeply, served faithfully, and left Bethany better than he found it.”

Left to right: Cassandra Burkhead ‘28, Gianna Metz ‘29, Natalie DuShole ‘28, Mary Tracey ‘27, Caitlin O’Farrell ‘28, Joseph Koval ‘26

Above: Emma Fleckenstein ‘26, Chloe Lee ‘26

Left to right: Joseph Koval ‘26 (behind), Leah Dunmire ‘27 (front), Caitlin O’Farrell ‘28, Mary Tracey ‘27

CHEMISTRY STUDENTS EARN

National Recognition Bethany College’s American Chemical Society (ACS) student chapter has earned the Outstanding Chapter Award, the highest distinction given by the ACS Undergraduate Office. Among only 90 chapters nationwide selected, and the smallest college represented, Bethany is celebrating a standout achievement in undergraduate science leadership.

The recognition coincided with National Chemistry Week, where students led a series of creative, hands-on events including a campus-wide spice scavenger hunt, community volunteer work at Carnegie Science Center, trivia events celebrating scientific discovery and LGBTQ+ scientists, a fundraising bake sale, and a STEM picnic that brought together students and athletes to highlight science in everyday life.

“At a small school like Bethany, where students have so many opportunities to engage through athletics, Greek life, and clubs or honor societies, it is always amazing for me to see what the students are able to organize and accomplish within their professional organizations like the American Chemical Society Bethany Affiliate Chapter,” said Dr. Scott Brothers, assistant professor of chemistry and the chapter advisor. “With our small student population, the clubs may not be extremely large, but their impact always is.”

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 11

Legacy of Impact

During BC Pride Homecoming 2025, Bethany College dedicated the newly named Brooks Family Breezeway in Old Main to celebrate the leadership and generosity of Scott S. Brooks ’78, alumnus, trustee, and chair of the integral Build for a Lifetime Campaign.

Under Brooks’ guidance, the campaign surpassed its $20 million goal, raising more than $30 million to support student success and campus transformation.

President Dr. Jamie Caridi praised Brooks for “setting the standard of excellence for current and future generations.” The ceremony also highlighted Brooks’ lifelong ties to the Psi Chapter of Beta Theta Pi and announced that new plaques honoring his impact will be permanently installed in the men’s and women’s lacrosse locker rooms.

The Brooks Family Breezeway now stands as a daily reminder of Brooks’ long-lasting commitment to Bethany and the strength of the community he helped shape.

$1.15M

Boosts Bethany STEM and Nursing

Bethany College has been awarded $1.15 million in federal Congressionally Directed Spending to strengthen STEM and health sciences education and expand nursing workforce development in West Virginia’s Northern Panhandle. The funding comes with the support of U.S. Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va., and U.S. Sen. Jim Justice, R-W.Va. The project is in support of two major initiatives: the creation of a Health and Allied Health Sciences Lab to serve Bethany’s newly launched nursing and health services programs, and the expansion of nursing education at Bethany

12 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

Caridi and Brooks unveil the new plaque.

Brooks stands with members of the men’s and women’s lacrosse teams.

College in partnership with West Virginia Wesleyan College, with clinical training partners including WVU Medicine Wheeling Hospital and Reynolds Memorial Hospital.

“This investment will help Bethany build state-ofthe-art learning environments that prepare students for high-demand careers in nursing, allied health, biology, and chemistry—right here in our rural community,” said Bethany President Dr. Jamie Caridi. “It strengthens our ability to educate the next generation of health and STEM professionals while supporting workforce needs.”

Demand for skilled professionals in nursing, allied health, and core sciences continues to grow across the region. The funding will help students pursue specialized training closer to home while supporting a full-cycle science education experience, from foundational lab instruction through clinical preparation.

“This investment in Bethany College will strengthen STEM and nursing education in West Virginia’s Northern Panhandle and help meet the growing demand for health care professionals,” Sen. Capito said.

“Investing in our future right here in West Virginia is the best use of money I can think of, especially regarding the education of our aspiring healthcare professionals,” Sen. Justice said. “This funding will open doors for students and expand healthcare career opportunities in our state.”

As an institution serving a rural region, Bethany continues to expand access to STEM and health career pathways while strengthening partnerships with area secondary schools to connect more students to opportunities in science and healthcare.

PROMOTIONS & TRANSITIONS MISSY DRYER, MBA ‘26 Director of Financial Aid & Institutional Research 10/1/2025 JASON KOEGLER Vice President for Advancement 10/1/2025 LORI WEAVER Vice President for Enrollment, Marketing, & Communications 10/1/2025 KARA WHITE Director of Housekeeping 10/1/2025 ANNA WINESDOERFFER Assistant Vice President for Enrollment Marketing & Strategy 10/1/2025

NEW FACULTY AND STAFF

BROOKE GARRISON Enrollment Counselor 9/5/2025

AIDEN REAMS Staff Accountant 1/19/2026

CAYLIN ANGEL Digital Marketing & Social Media Specialist 9/15/2025

REBECCA FORNEY Dean of Graduate & Online Enrollment 2/9/2026

BRIAN SHAW Director of Advancement Services 9/15/2025

ELIZABETH BAIN ‘25 Enrollment Operations & Recruitment Specialist 2/16/2026

TAYLOR OVERHOLT College Counselor 10/1/2025

JEFFREY R. BREESE Vice President for Academic Affairs and Chief Academic Officer 7/1/2026

ELIZABETH ROMANEK Assistant Director of Admissions & Recruitment Events 10/14/2025

SARAH SHERINIAN VP for Student Success & Operational Excellence; Chief Financial Aid Officer 11/1/2025

JESSICA REAMS, MBA, CPFC Assistant Vice President for Business & Finance 6/1/2026

CHRISTOPHER FOX Director of Student Accounts 11/17/2025

JENNIFER PARKER Associate Vice President of Advancement 7/6/2026

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 13

Honoring Bethany’s

Brightest

In April 2026, the Bethany community gathered to celebrate student achievement during Honors Day, a long-standing tradition that recognizes excellence in academics, leadership, and service. The ceremony marked a moment of reflection and celebration for the 2025–2026 academic year, honoring students through department awards, college-wide recognitions, and acknowledgment of those named to the President’s and Dean’s lists.

Among the top honors, Daphne Tennant ‘26 (pictured above) received the John R. Taylor Memorial Award

in Liberal Arts, while Mary Tracey ‘27 and Cameron Bailey ‘27 were named outstanding junior woman and man.

Madison Buxton ‘26 earned the Bethany 2000 Prize, and Annabella “Anna” Kovach ‘26 received the Francis O. Carfer Prize, the College’s highest student honor, for her service, leadership, and academic achievement.

Additional students were recognized across disciplines and for high

Brick Project Groundbreaking

Etched in Tradition Thank you to everyone who participated in Bethany College’s Brick and Paver Project. Your generosity is creating a lasting legacy at the heart of campus, where future Bethanians will follow in your footsteps. Each brick tells a story, preserving memories and honoring the community for generations to come.

14 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

achievement, while Phi Mu and Beta Theta Pi earned top scholastic honors among student organizations.

After the convocation, students shared their work at the annual Symposium of Scholarship and Creative Work, presenting their research and creative projects through posters and presentations that reflected the depth and rigor of their Bethany experience.

ACR

SS THE MILES

Over the 2025-2026 fiscal year, Bethanians have gathered together again and again – both in person and virtually - to refresh their shared history while laughter and conversions echo wall to wall.

Though many years may have passed since alumni graduated from Bethany, their bonds are stronger than ever, and keep the spirit of Bethany proud and flourishing.

Alumni events took place in: New York City, New York Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania St. Augustine, Florida Arlington, Virginia Bel Air, Maryland Chapel Hill, North Carolina Scotland

UPCOMING EVENTS >>

Interested in hosting a gathering in your area? To coordinate a regional event, contact the Alumni Office at alumni@bethanywv.edu.

Jay Smith ’71 Returns to Serve Bethany Bethany College is pleased to welcome Larry “Jay” Smith ’71 to its Board of Trustees. A distinguished leader in financial services, Smith brings more than five decades of experience in financial planning, consulting, and organizational leadership to his alma mater.

Over the course of his career, Smith held key roles with CIGNA and Wealth Enhancement Group and founded Sound Financial Solutions, L.P., which he led until its acquisition in 2017.

He currently serves as president of SFS Interests, Inc., where he advises businesses and individuals on estate planning and business transitions.

In addition to his professional accomplishments, Smith has remained deeply engaged in service and leadership, contributing to numerous professional and nonprofit organizations. His past involvement includes leadership roles with the Houston Society for Financial Service Professionals and board service with Brite Divinity School at Texas Christian University and CompUDopt.

Smith’s connection to Bethany and his broad experience across corporate and nonprofit sectors position him to make a meaningful impact as a trustee.

Reflecting on his appointment, Smith shared his admiration for the College’s recent progress and his enthusiasm for supporting its continued growth and renewal.

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 15

No Barriers. Just Opportunity.

Bethany College is taking bold steps to broaden access, affordability, and student success.

HIGH-ACHIEVING STUDENTS ARE CHOOSING BETHANY

WV TUITION COVERED

Momentum is building. From Scholars Day to competitive academic programs, Bethany continues to attract driven, highachieving students ready to lead.

Programs like the Honors Program, Kalon Leadership Scholars, and the President’s Ambassador Program empower students to excel in and beyond the classroom.

This is where ambition meets opportunity.

For students across West Virginia, a Bethany education is now within reach.

Through WV Tuition Covered, eligible in-state students can receive 100% tuition coverage, removing one of the biggest barriers to earning a degree.

This initiative reflects Bethany’s focus on opening doors and creating real pathways for students across the region.

A Bethany education defined by excellence begins here.

WHAT’S NEW AT BETHANY? NURSING Direct pathway partnerships for in-demand careers GAME DEVELOPMENT Hands-on learning connected to Bethany’s esports arena AI & CYBERSECURITY Cutting-edge undergraduate and graduate pathways

A PLACE TO

Belong

Experiences that Set Bethany Apart

16 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

EXERCISE SCIENCE Expanded focus on performance, health, and careers

Building Lifelong Connections

Where Students Find Their People

Learning that Leads to Outcomes

Stay With the Place That Knows You. Go Further.

Bethany Online makes it possible to take the next step without putting life on hold.

100% ONLINE PROGRAMS

DESIGNED FOR WORKING PROFESSIONALS

COMPLETE YOUR DEGREE IN AS LITTLE AS 12 MONTHS

AFFORDABLE TUITION WITH ALUMNI DISCOUNTS

Programs include:

MBA | M.Ed. | Sport Management | AI-Driven Cybersecurity NEW! Applied Sport Management Certificate 12-credit pathway to Bethany’s M.A. in Sport Management.

Explore Bethany Online graduate programs and certificates and find the right fit for your next step>>

“Coming back to Bethany was an easy decision. It’s helping me grow professionally while staying connected to a place that’s always felt like home.”

- Jennifer Rohrig ‘11, MBA Student

BE PART OF BETHANY’S NEXT CHAPTER WITH THE ALUMNI REFERRAL SCHOLARSHIP Know a future Bethanian? When you refer a student and they enroll, they’ll receive a $2,000 Alumni Referral Scholarship ($500 per year for four years) to support their Bethany education.

Who can you refer?

• • • • •

Family members Children Students you mentor Colleagues and employees Members of your community It takes less than 30 seconds. Scan the QR code or visit www.BethanyWV.edu/refer.

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 17

STEPPING UP AND

Standing Out

Bethany College’s 11th Annual Women & Leadership Symposium opened with a clear message: step up, be ready, and don’t limit what’s possible.

Centered on the theme “Winning in the Workplace and Beyond,” the two-day event brought together alumnae, students, and professionals for conversations rooted in growth, connection, and shared insight.

Keynote speaker Toria Tolley ’78, an Emmy Award-winning journalist and former CNN anchor, set the tone with reflections on communication, confidence, and leading in high-pressure environments.

“Learn as much as you can, because you could be doing it all,” said Tolley. “Being prepared and willing to step up makes all the difference.”

Attendees also participated in breakout sessions led by accomplished alumnae and professionals, including “From Paychecks to Passion Projects” with Kelly Murray ’09; “Winning in the Workplace” with Jennifer Fleahman Rohrig ’11; “Climbing the Ladder to Success: Capitalizing on Wins and Losses” with Jen Windmiller, MBA ’23; and “The Next Chapter: You’re Free. Now What” with Dr. Gail Frankle ’77.

An expert panel further explored the symposium’s theme, featuring Dr. Kelly Chaney ’05, Lindsey Faddish ’11, Kristy Howell ’04, Michele Myauo ’00, and Erica Pietranton ’09, with Tolley serving as the moderator.

The event also recognized seniors Amelia Scott and Catha Maria Recabeitia as recipients of the Scarlett Foster Scholarship for their academic achievement and leadership. Named in honor of alumna Ann Wilkin Trombadore ’51, the symposium continues to serve as a cornerstone event, reflecting Bethany’s commitment to empowering women and fostering leadership development.

The College extends its gratitude to the Women & Leadership Symposium planning committee and event sponsors for their support in making the event a success.

18 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

The Class of 2026 Steps Forward A standing ovation of family, friends, faculty, staff, and alumni set the tone as Bethany College celebrated the Class of 2026 during its 186th Commencement Ceremony. Graduates were recognized for their academic achievement and the years of effort that brought them to this moment, as well as the community that supported them along the way.

President Dr. Jamie Caridi congratulated graduates and recognized the support systems that helped bring them to this milestone. He encouraged students to move forward with confidence and to define success in meaningful ways, reminding them that Bethany will always remain part of their journey.

During the ceremony, Bethany College conferred an honorary doctorate upon Bob Orr ’75, Emmy Award-winning journalist and longtime CBS News correspondent, in recognition of his distinguished career in broadcast journalism.

In Orr’s commencement address, he urged graduates to prioritize genuine conversation, empathy, and critical thinking in an increasingly divided world. He encouraged students to build relationships, engage with differing perspectives, and lead with truth and civility as they move into the future.

We congratulate the Class of 2026 and celebrate the impact our graduates will make beyond campus.

Hearts Open

to What Comes Next

Bethany College’s Baccalaureate service offered the Class of 2026 a moment to pause, reflect, and look ahead with intention. The Rev. Dr. Lee Hull Moses delivered a message that centered on compassion and the courage to remain open in an uncertain world, challenging graduates to embrace “hearts of flesh” over “hearts of stone.” Her words acknowledged both the beauty and difficulty of what lies ahead, reminding students that a meaningful life requires not only strength, but a willingness to be changed by what they encounter.

By the end of the service, the message lingered— an invitation to carry forward not just what they have learned, but how they will live, lead, and care for others beyond Bethany.

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 19

STUDENT SPOTLIGHTS WATCH VIDEO

Comps A Bethany Tradition of Excellence Each year, a distinctive quiet settles over Bethany’s campus. The familiar hum of student life is replaced by the gentle turning of textbook pages and the focused rhythm of pencils meeting paper. With Comprehensive Exams fast approaching, Bethany seniors devoted themselves to study and reflection, preparing to demonstrate the depth of knowledge and critical thinking they have developed throughout their collegiate journey.

This longstanding tradition—both respected and revered—serves as the culminating academic experience for every Bethanian. The final oral examinations test not only intellect, but poise and confidence before faculty and peers. What begins in quiet determination concludes in celebration, as successful graduates emerge from their exams to the cheers of classmates, faculty, family, and friends. Confetti fills the air, champagne corks pop, and joy echoes across the hills of Bethany.

To the newest members of our alumni family, we extend our heartfelt congratulations. You leave these halls not only as graduates, but as proud representatives of Bethany’s reflection of scholarship, character, and community.

Congratulations to another remarkable class of acCOMPlished Bethanians.

20 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

Focused. Driven. Future-Ready.

Where Math Meets Art When you meet Rebecca “Bug” Nanney ‘27, it’s easy to see how creativity and curiosity shape her life at Bethany College. Originally from Mount Pleasant, Pennsylvania, she’s double majoring in mathematics and visual arts.

Bethany was already part of Nanney’s story long before she arrived on campus. Both of her grandparents and an aunt are alumni, but the decision to attend came sooner than expected. “My dad texted me in the middle of the school day and said, ‘Deposit submitted,’” Nanney laughed. When asking him to look into more scholarship opportunities, “he thought I meant go ahead and do it [deposit] but honestly, I probably would’ve ended up at Bethany anyways.”

Her artistic work extends beyond campus, too. The summer of 2025, she collaborated with a professional illustrator on a children’s book and launched her own art website for prints and commissions. In Bethany’s theatre program, small productions have helped her grow new skills. “There’s a lot that’s student-led,” she said. “You learn to wear a lot of hats here.”

What she loves most about Bethany is the personal connection. “Professors notice when you’re curious or trying something new,” she said. “You wouldn’t get that kind of individual attention at a bigger school.”

As she looks ahead, Bug is excited to find a path that blends her passions. “I don’t know exactly what’s next,” she said, “but I’m learning so much here that I know I’ll find my path.”

Born and raised just outside Pittsburgh in Bethel Park, Pennsylvania, Ben Guffey ’26 has built his Bethany experience on drive, growth, and long-term vision. A sports management major with minors in communication and business administration, Ben is ready to take the next step toward a career in financial advising.

Athletics have shaped much of Guffey’s journey. After playing on the men’s varsity basketball team for his first two years, he stepped away to focus on his professional goals, though not without carrying forward the discipline, teamwork, and resilience that athletics instilled. As he explained, “Athletics teach many valuable life lessons, and I am grateful to have learned about these lessons to prepare myself for life moving forward.”

Guffey’s early professional experiences reflect both exploration and clarity. “During my freshman year, I interned with the Washington Wild Things as an operations and food & beverage manager, which helped me develop strong organizational and leadership skills,” he said. “While that experience was valuable, it led me to realize that my true interest lies in business rather than the sports industry.”

That realization led him to downtown Pittsburgh, where he began working with Equitable Advisors as an operations and marketing intern. “In this role, I assisted with organizing marketing initiatives, supporting day-to-day operational tasks, and gaining insight into how financial advisory teams serve clients efficiently,” he said. “Through this experience, I developed a deeper understanding of the financial services industry, client communication, and the importance of organization and attention to detail. This internship played a major role in solidifying my interest in pursuing a career as a financial advisor.”

Guffey credits his growth to a strong support system as well as the environment he found at Bethany. “Bethany College has significantly contributed to my growth as both a student and an individual,” he said. “As a student-athlete, I learned how to balance demanding academic responsibilities with athletics, which strengthened my time management, discipline, and leadership skills. Bethany has also provided a close-knit community, supportive faculty, and opportunities that have helped me gain confidence and prepare for life after graduation.”

Ben is already preparing for his next steps. “My goal is to become a licensed financial advisor and help individuals and families put their goals first so they can confidently achieve what they set out to accomplish,” he said.

Beyond the classroom, Guffey was a member of Omicron Delta Kappa Honor Society, participated in the Honors Program, and remained connected to the basketball community that shaped his early college years.

With his professional path already in motion, Guffey is looking forward to his next chapter after Bethany.

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 21

LEADING THROUGH

&

Curiosity Community For biology major Leah Dunmire ‘27, Bethany College is the perfect blend of exploration, challenge, and community. A native of Clymer, Pennsylvania, Dunmire first learned about Bethany through her guidance counselor. “When I came here, I just fell in love,” she said. “The campus atmosphere and the quiet nature that surrounds everything, it just felt right.”

Bethany’s people have made all the difference.

“Every professor has time to help, and upperclassmen are always eager to show new students the ropes,” she said. That support has shaped her Bethany experience and helped her grow into a campus leader. Dunmire holds executive roles in ACS, Tri-Beta, the outdoors club, and Animal Advocacy. “They don’t just throw you to the wolves,” she laughed. “They make sure you’re comfortable stepping into those roles.”

In the classroom and lab, Dunmire has evolved from a curious freshman to a confident researcher.

Under the guidance of Dr. Kathy Baker-Brosh, she is studying an intriguing set of mastodon bones excavated near Bethany in the 1930s. Her project centers on a single bone fragment marked by a mysterious puncture. “We’re asking a simple-but22 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

big question,” she explained. “Could this mark be from a human tool, or is it a natural injury from the environment?”

Her research involves documenting the entire collection, exploring radiocarbon dating and strontium isotope analysis, and consulting with experts from Meadowcroft and Penn State. “The groundwork matters,” she said. “It’s easily 20+ hours and counting.”

Dunmire’s curiosity extends beyond academics. A freshman-year trip with the outdoors club took her to the Grand Canyon, Antelope Canyon, and Death Valley, an adventure she never imagined so early in college. “It really helped me grow into myself,” she said.

As she looks toward the future, Dunmire is considering veterinary medicine but remains open to possibilities.

“Bethany has prepared me for what’s next,” she said.

“Here, you don’t just learn—you discover who you are.”

WATCH VIDEO

2026

Graduate Spotlights Maddi Buxton | POLITICAL SCIENCE

FAVORITE MEMORIES

& RELIGIOUS STUDIES

“Getting engaged after passing my comprehensive exams feels like the obvious answer, but it’s closely followed by completing my senior projects, Passover dinner at Dr. Deal’s, and the occasional stint in the Boomer costume.”

Gavin McAllister|SPANISH LANGUAGE AND CULTURES

“As my internship, I taught a section of Spanish 120 under the supervision of our Fulbright Scholar for the Spring 2025 semester. It was especially eyeopening because I got to experience how valuable a humanities degree program is — it can be applied through various disciplines, such as education.

Now, I’m a high school teacher.”

Deena Rosenthal | PSYCH, PRE-OT

Trista Nickole Morris | SPORTS COMMUNICATIONS

“My favorite memory at Bethany is being right in the middle of the intensity-capturing athletes in their most high stakes moments during game action, while also experiencing it first hand as a player. One moment that stands out most is making a diving play in a softball game at home, giving everything I had, even hitting my head on the fence and still completing the play. It’s a moment that reflects my passion for the game and my ability to see it from both sides. Capturing the same grit, emotion, and determination I live out myself.”

“My favorite Bethany memory would have to be being an executive member for SAC! Planning concerts, food trucks, trips and various other activities was so fun. It made me feel like Bethany was extremely unique compared to other schools.”

Meet the Students Our student profile series highlights the journeys and ambitions of Bethany students, offering a window into who they are and how their time at the College is helping them grow. These narratives celebrate personal growth, curiosity, and the unique ways each student is forever changed by the Bethany experience. Read more student stories beyond these pages >> BETHANY MAGAZINE | 23

ALUMNI SPOTLIGHTS ALUMNI COUNCIL 2025-2026 JIM PORTER, 1986 Council President Tampa, FL ANGELA RYDER BADO, 1977 Council Vice President McKinney, TX ROBERT “BOB” BROSH, PH.D., 1985 Bel Air, MD KEVIN CLANCY, 2009 Bethany, WV BRUCE H. FAHEY, 1977 Akron, OH ALICIA JORDAN, 1999 St. Clairsville, OH BETH BENATTI KENNEDY, 1988 Beverly, MA VAL KNAPP, 1977 Columbus, OH BETH MARTIN, 1988 University Heights, OH KERRY McCANN, 1977 Pittsburgh, PA STEPHANIE PAWLOWSKI, 2001 Pittsburgh, PA KEITH PIASECKI, 1998 Smyrna, GA

From Bethany to

BIG IMPACT KRISTY HOWELL ‘04 built the foundation for her global career at Bethany, where she studied economics with a focus on international economics, along with minors in Spanish and accounting. Today, she serves as an economist and deputy division chief in the Statistics Department at the International Monetary Fund (IMF), supporting countries in strengthening economic data systems and informing policy decisions. In her role, Howell oversees training, technical assistance, and regional engagement across the Middle East and Central Asia, helping countries build strong statistical systems and produce high-quality economic data. She has also contributed to international efforts to modernize economic measurement standards and leads a task team focused on improving the consistency of global statistics on trade and investment.

After graduating, Howell began her career at the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, where she spent 16 years advancing into the Senior Executive Service. Her early academic experiences at Bethany played a key part in that success. Along the way, her interest in international collaboration grew, sparked by her involvement in Spanish Club and Model United Nations during her

time at Bethany. “Courses I took at Bethany in economy macroeconomics, international trade theory, and accounting proved especially relevant to my work,” she said.

While her professional achievements span continents, some of Howell’s most meaningful Bethany memories were formed closer to home on the course, in the pool, and among teammates.

As a member of the cross country and swimming and diving teams, she found a sense of community that extended far beyond competition. It was also at Bethany where she met her husband, TJ Howell, a fellow student-athlete.

More than two decades later, their shared passion for running continues, including years spent coaching their son’s youth running program and passing along lessons once learned from their own coach.

Beyond academics and athletics, Howell credits her involvement in Phi Mu and campus life with shaping the skills that have defined her leadership style. Balancing rigorous coursework with athletics and extracurriculars helped her develop discipline, time management, and a deep understanding of teamwork, all qualities that continue to guide her work on the global stage.

ASHLEY KANOTZ SUBASIC, 2006 Valley Grove, WV RALPH VOCK, 1977 Clermont, FL RICK ZARNOCH, 1980 Columbus, OH

24 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

Left to right: Janice Masters ‘04,Terrence Copney ‘12, Hayley McNerny ‘03, Holly McNerny ‘04, Patrick Crossey ‘04

Changing the Game

for Women

Left to right: Laurie Conway ’09, Bethany Stickradt ’11, Kaitlyn Kelly Black ’12, Janice Masters ‘04, and Evelyn del Cerro ’85 serve on the panel for the 2025 Women & Leadership Symposium.

JANICE MASTERS ’04 found her place at Bethany College through athletics, leadership, and community, all experiences that continue to shape her professional and personal journey today. A sports management major, Masters recalls her time on campus as one filled with connection, from long softball bus trips to Phi Mu nights at the house. The relationships built with her teammates and sorority sisters remain some of her most meaningful memories and confirmed that Bethany was truly the right place for her.

Following graduation in 2004, Masters remained at Bethany as a graduate assistant while earning her master’s degree at West Virginia University. She later relocated to Pittsburgh, where she spent more than 15 years building a successful career at the intersection of sports and business.

During that time, she established herself as a leader in the marketing industry while simultaneously competing at the professional level in both softball and women’s tackle football, demonstrating a rare commitment to excellence on and off the field.

Masters’ dual passions ultimately led her to become a Partner and Director of Client Services at a full-service

marketing firm in Pittsburgh, while also stepping into national leadership in sports as Commissioner of the Women’s National Football Conference (WNFC) beginning in 2019. Following the sale of the marketing firm in 2024, she shifted her focus entirely to the WNFC, where she now serves as Commissioner and General Manager. In this role, Masters is dedicated to accelerating equity for women and girls in sports through the power of football and creating sustainable opportunities at every level of the game.

Now residing in Pittsburgh with her family, Masters remains deeply engaged in her community, regularly participating in and promoting local events. She also hosts and leads coaching and player clinics for adult women and young female athletes, expanding access, visibility, and opportunity for women in sports.

Masters continues to stay connected to Bethany by returning to campus annually for Homecoming and participating in panels and campus events whenever possible. In 2024, she attended Bethany’s Women & Leadership event, an experience she describes as both impactful and inspiring. Reflecting on the event, she encourages both students and alumni to attend, noting the value of shared stories, mentorship, and meaningful connections across generations of Bethanians.

Looking back, Masters believes the friendships formed at Bethany are among the most enduring aspects of her experience. “The relationships I built with fellow students, teammates, and alumni are ones I will always cherish,” she shares. “Even as I meet alumni I didn’t overlap with on campus, I’m reminded how much we all share through the traditions, experiences, and memories that tie us back to Bethany.”

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 25

COACHING WITH PURPOSE The Making of a Coach For NATE MARKO ’19, Bethany College was where his passion for leadership, teamwork, and personal growth took shape.

Drawn to the College’s close-knit community and the opportunity to continue his baseball career, he found the perfect balance of academics and athletics. As a double major in sport management and business management, Marko stayed actively involved on campus as a member of the baseball team, Beta Theta Pi fraternity, and student clubs, while also competing in dragon boat racing.

Today, Marko serves as the hitting coach at Youngstown State University, where he mentors student-athletes and applies the lessons he first developed at Bethany. “My time as a studentathlete taught me discipline, accountability, and how to work effectively with others toward a common goal,” he said.

In his role, Marko places a strong emphasis on building relationships with his players, understanding that trust and communication are essential to their success. He strives to create an environment where student-athletes feel supported both on and off the field, an approach shaped by the community he experienced at Bethany.

He emphasizes that success in coaching requires patience and persistence, noting that “breaking into the coaching profession takes time, and you won’t land your dream job right away.”

He also believes that “every task matters.”

“Coaching baseball is a blessing and a privilege,” Marko said. “Even on the longest days, I take a step back and appreciate that I get to make an impact doing something I love.”

From Bethany to the collegiate level, Marko continues to embody the values of hard work, humility, and purpose.

26 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

From Star Player to Head Coach at

23

At just 23 years old, RILEY FELTON ’23, M.Ed. ’25, was named head coach of Bethany’s women’s volleyball program, making her the youngest head coach in any sport within the Presidents’ Athletic Conference (PAC). A two-time PAC champion, four-time All-PAC selection, and 2023 PAC Tournament MVP herself, Felton has quickly transitioned from standout student-athlete to confident leader.

“My time at Bethany was truly transformative,” Felton said. “Being a part of the Bethany College women’s volleyball team was one of the most rewarding experiences of my college career. Serving as team captain and helping lead our team to a PAC Championship taught me the value of leadership, teamwork, and perseverance.”

Beyond the court, Felton worked closely with professors in the Psychology Department and participated in programs such as the NCAA Career in Sports Forum. “Those opportunities helped me grow both personally and professionally,” she shared.

“Bethany’s supportive and close-knit community shaped me into the confident person I am today. I’m proud to be a Bethany graduate and will always carry with me the sense of community, purpose, and determination that Bethany instilled in me.”

Felton now leads the next generation of Bison with that same passion and pride. “I’m incredibly honored to step into this role at a place I proudly call home,” she said. “Our program has shaped me in countless ways, and I’m committed to building on its legacy of pride, passion, and competitive excellence.”

From Bethany to the Operating Room JOSEPH GRESCHNER ’13, a biology graduate, has built an accomplished career in podiatric medicine at Bethany College, where his biology studies and close-knit campus experience helped shape both his professional path and lifelong connections. After completing elite foot and ankle training across the country, he returned home to West Virginia and now owns Greschner Foot & Ankle Specialists in Morgantown, providing comprehensive surgical and nonsurgical care to patients throughout the region.

Reflecting on his journey, Greschner says, “Bethany College is a wonderful opportunity in such a beautiful place. If you allow it, Bethany can take you anywhere in the world you would like to go.”

Though his career has taken him far beyond campus, the friendships and community formed at Bethany continue to guide him, proving that a Bethany beginning can truly lead anywhere.

Rising Voice in the Newsroom OLIVIA ZINN ’24 has quickly made her mark in the world of broadcast journalism. A native of Philippi, West Virginia, Zinn graduated summa cum laude with majors in communications and Spanish, distinguishing herself as a student leader who revived Bethany’s PRSSA chapter, studied Left to right: Zinn, Kayla abroad, and contributed extensively Drabek, Gracie Gonzales to campus media. “There is nothing like having a close relationship with your educators,” she said.

“Bethany’s flexibility allowed me to complete two majors in four years.”

Her professional journey began while still a student, joining WTOV9 as a temporary reporter in 2022 before transitioning to a full-time position after graduation. “I started part-time while I was still in school,” she said, “and when the time came, they signed me on full-time. That experience changed everything.” Today, she serves as the station’s morning coanchor for “News9 Sunrise,” covering breaking news, elections, and community stories with skill and authenticity. “I deal with breaking news, hard news, and stories that affect real people,” Zinn explained. “It’s fastpaced, but I love it.”

Zinn’s reporting has already gained national attention; her coverage of the June 2025 Ohio County floods aired on CNN, FOX News, and the National Weather Desk, showcasing the impact and professionalism that define her young career.

“I’ve always loved storytelling,” she said.

“Being able to wake up every day and give people the information they need—that’s what motivates me.”

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 27

Back Where It Began

That vision ultimately became reality. Today, she describes her work as both fulfilling and student-centered.

For Dr. Kathy Baker-Brosh ’86, Bethany “I absolutely enjoy my job. The best part is working College is both where her academic journey with students to achieve goals,” she said. began and where it continues today. Now a A central part of her role is mentoring student research, professor of biology, she first discovered her passion something she calls the most rewarding aspect of her work for teaching as an undergraduate on the same campus where at Bethany. she now mentors students.

“Mentoring research projects is my favorite part of being “From the time I was an undergraduate student, I knew a professor at Bethany,” she said. “Working with students I wanted to be a professor,” she said. “I thought teaching a as they design their projects, work through data collection, subject I love while living in a walkable college community and prepare written reports and posters and presentations is surrounded by music, theater productions, the library, sports, satisfying. I like helping them find grant money for projects arts, and academics all within a college town would be a and internships in their fields of interest.” fabulous lifestyle.”

In the classroom, she connects biology to students’ future careers in fields such as pre-med, nursing, exercise science, and conservation biology, helping them see the real-world relevance of their studies.

For Baker-Brosh, Bethany’s defining strength is its sense of shared purpose between campus and community.

“My favorite part about Bethany is being immersed in a community that is focused on student education and student personal growth,” she said. “The community of Bethany: the College and town, are committed to support the students. Bethany thrives because we all work together toward student success.”

For Baker-Brosh, returning to Bethany Baker-Brosh gives students a hands-on as a faculty member brings her story experience with Madagascar hissing full circle, from student discovering her cockroaches in class. calling to professor helping shape the next generation.

28 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

Built for JUSTICE When Matt Donahue ‘02 arrived at Bethany College, he was searching for a place where he could grow, lead, and challenge himself. What he found was the perfect combination of opportunity and community. Drawn by the competitive financial aid package and the promise of individualized experiences, Matt chose Bethany as the place where he would shape his future.

As a psychology major, Matt loved exploring how people think, behave, and make decisions. “I enjoyed learning about the human mind in an academic and research sense,” he shared. That curiosity paired naturally with his growing interest in service and justice — interests strengthened through the roles he took on across campus.

Matt threw himself into Bethany life, as he joined the Sigma Nu fraternity, competed on the cross country and track teams, served in Student Government, and even volunteered with the Bethany Volunteer Fire Department. Each experience added a layer of confidence and responsibility, preparing him for a life committed to public service.

After graduating in 2002, Matt pursued a career in law, one that would see him take on some of Ohio’s most critical legal roles. He began as an assistant county prosecutor before joining the Ohio Attorney General’s Office, where he served as a prosecutor and later became section chief of the Special Prosecutions Section. Today, he is the chief legal counsel for Ohio Governor Mike DeWine, a role rooted in leadership,

integrity, and a deep understanding of the justice system.

Looking back, Matt sees Bethany as the place that helped him discover his potential. “Bethany gave me individualized opportunities that encouraged me to connect with people and step into leadership,” he said.

For students considering a similar path, his advice is straightforward and heartfelt: “Keep at it. If you know where you want to practice law, go to law school in that geographic area. And with the rise of AI in the legal profession, make sure you’re willing to be a courtroom lawyer, and willing to know how to connect with people.”

From student leader and volunteer firefighter to one of Ohio’s top legal voices, Matt Donahue’s journey reflects the power of dedication, service, and the kind of personal growth that begins at Bethany.

Bethany College Class of 1975

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 29

BC PRIDE Bethany 2025 Homecoming Bethany College rolled out the green-and-white carpet for BC Pride Homecoming 2025, welcoming alumni, students, families, and friends for a weekend filled with tradition, connection, and celebration. From start to finish, the College buzzed with pride as generations of Bethanians came together to honor the past and celebrate the future.

Bethany College Class of 1985

30 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

Tim Keating

Dr. Lisa M. Reilly

Maj. Gary R. “Craig” Wagner

ALUMNI HONORS Tim Keating ’75 received the Distinguished Alumni Achievement Award for his remarkable career in collegiate football coaching; Dr. Lisa M. Reilly earned the James E. Allison Award for Teaching Excellence for her outstanding contributions as a teacher, scholar, and mentor in chemistry; and Major Gary R. “Craig” Wagner ’85 was recognized with the Outstanding Community Service Award for more than four decades of service in the military, aviation, firefighting, and community leadership.

WATCH OUR VIDEO & Recapture the Energy!

GRIMES LECTURE Emmy Award–winning journalist Bob Orr ’75 returned to campus for the Grimes Lecture Series, sharing insights from his distinguished career at CBS News and reflecting on the importance of truth and integrity in journalism. His message inspired students and alumni alike, reminding them that the lessons learned at Bethany last a lifetime.

GAME DAY The Bison football team faced Case Western Reserve in a Homecoming matchup that brought students, alumni, and fans together in a show of Bethany pride. During halftime, Cody Davis and Lauren Cooper were crowned Homecoming King and Queen, earning cheers from the crowd as the campus celebrated their leadership and dedication to the College. After the football game, alumni enjoyed a lively 5th Quarter Party and Open Mic Night, celebrating community and creativity. BC Pride Homecoming 2025 was a joyful reminder of what unites the Bethany family—tradition, friendship, and shared pride.

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 31

FACULTY SPOTLIGHTS

A Professor Who Made a DIFFERENCE When Brooke High School senior Elijah Lanigan filled out his Governor’s Honors Academy application, he knew exactly who he wanted to recognize. Like every student in the program, Lanigan was asked to nominate a teacher who had left a mark on his life. Most students choose a high school or middle school teacher. As a participant of the Bethany College - Brooke Collegiate Academy, Lanigan asked if he could do something different.

“I want to nominate my college professor,” he said. “He’s my favorite teacher I’ve ever had.”

That teacher is Dr. Aaron Honsowetz, an associate economics professor at Bethany College, whose student’s heartfelt nomination led to his selection as Outstanding Educator 2025 from the West Virginia Governor’s Honors Academy.

For Honsowetz, who has taught at Bethany since 2015, the recognition was more than just a plaque or a title. “The

32 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

“

“The greatest reward is knowing that your students feel seen, supported, and challenged.”

- HONSOWETZ

humbling part of the award is having a student nominate you in the first place,” he said. “As an educator, you work hard to help your students grow into the best version of themselves, and to have one of them recognize that is more rewarding than the award itself.”

Lanigan’s note to his professor was simple but powerful: “Your advice is unmatched, and your help is absurdly useful.”

For Honsowetz, that kind of feedback is a reminder of why he loves teaching at a small liberal arts college. “Bethany College is a place where professors are able to challenge students to grow intellectually and personally,” he explained.

“And because of the small college environment, we can follow up with the students and make sure they rise to pursue that challenge.”

At the end of the day, Honsowetz insists the real story isn’t about him; it’s about the relationships that define education.

“The greatest reward is knowing that your students feel seen, supported, and challenged,” he said.

BUILDING FUTURES For more than two decades, Associate Provost of Academic Affairs Melanee Sinclair has helped shape Bethany College’s academic programs and professional pathways. As chair and program director for social work, she balances administrative leadership with hands-on teaching that prepares students for meaningful careers.

A first-generation college student from northwestern Pennsylvania, Sinclair reflects, “My father was a steel worker, and my mom was a homemaker.” She

attended West Virginia Wesleyan College because “I wanted to attend a religiously affiliated small liberal arts college. I graduated a long time ago,” she added with humor.

“I started teaching at Bethany College in 2003 when a full-time faculty in social work did not renew his contract [and] I came as an adjunct to teach Social Problems.” From there, she grew her impact. “I have been very fortunate to have the opportunity to lean in the areas that I am interested in programmatically,” she said. She developed courses in equine assisted interventions, family and child welfare, and served as field coordinator until 2020. “I developed many new host agencies allowing our students many more options.”

“

I am very proud that all our students who have gone on to graduate programs can say that they have been very prepared for the coursework.

- SINCLAIR

In the classroom, she emphasizes structure and professional identity.

“Students have input in due dates, [and] I encourage students to understand that they are responsible for their own professional identity.”

Most of all, Sinclair values the people and outcomes. “My favorite part of Bethany are some of the people I have met here,” she said, noting pride in graduates who thrive in fields from therapy to law enforcement. “I am very proud that all our students who have gone on to graduate programs can say that they have been very prepared for the coursework.”

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 33

Exploring FAITH & CULTURE Dr. Holly Hillgardner’s path to Bethany College began with a student who inspired her to take a closer look at the institution. She was quickly drawn to Bethany’s foundation in faith, inquiry, and open dialogue, rooted in its founding by Alexander Campbell, one of the principal founders of the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ), Now serving as Gresham Professor of Religious Studies, Hillgardner brings a global and interdisciplinary approach to the classroom. She introduces students to religious diversity through engaging courses, including a popular yoga studies class that blends history with hands-on learning. Her passion for experiential education extends beyond campus, where she has led international trips and hopes to do so again.

When asked what makes Bethany’s learning environment distinct, Hillgardner points to the strength of its community and sense of place. “We are an inclusive and caring community situated in the foothills of Appalachia,” she said. “It’s a transformative place to learn with few distractions from the interdisciplinary liberal arts education.” For Hillgardner, that environment, shaped

by Alexander Campbell’s belief in education as a moral and intellectual calling, creates space for students to ask meaningful questions and grow.

For students considering religious studies, she encourages curiosity over assumption. “Religious studies offers exciting lenses to study history, culture, languages, theology, politics, and more! It’s not just for people who consider themselves religious,” she said. “Some of our students do not consider themselves religious personally, but they know they live in a religious world and want to understand it better.”

“

Religious studies offers exciting lenses to study history, culture, languages, theology, politics, and more!

- HILLGARDNER

34 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

“

There’s something about the small-town feel of Bethany and the charm of a small school. I’m really committed to the liberal arts identity.

- DEIULIIS

Finding PASSION & PURPOSE Through Communication For Dr. Dave DeIuliis, associate professor of communication, teaching at Bethany College is all about connection and curiosity. “I want the classroom to be a workout for the brain,” he explained. “If you come in and open your mind and engage, you’re doing an intellectual workout for the hour we’re together.”

A Pittsburgh native with degrees from Penn State and a Ph.D. from Duquesne University, DeIuliis joined Bethany eight years ago after teaching at several regional universities. “I drove to the campus and loved it,” he said.

“I applied for the job, talked to different people, and came to love Bethany. I thought it was a really good fit for me.”

His enthusiasm fills every class. “I am passionate about what I teach,” he shared. “If students aren’t passionate about it, I hope they can at least see its value in their life.”

For him, what makes Bethany special is the community and the liberal arts identity. “There’s something about the small-town feel of Bethany and the charm of a small school,” he said. “I’m really committed to the liberal arts identity. All those factors kind of converged and made it a good fit for my sensibilities and Bethany’s mission.”

His favorite moments at Bethany come from seeing students grow academically, personally, and professionally.

“It’s really gratifying to see students go from freshmen to seniors and then get jobs or go to grad school,” he said.

“You get to witness their journey and realize how much they’ve evolved.”

To Dr. DeIuliis, Bethany truly feels like home. “It’s a unique kind of place,” he said. “It’s not perfect—no home is—but it’s home for me. Even with its quirks, there’s something here you can just feel. Bethany is a really good place to discover yourself.”

Last Lecture, Lasting Influence Bethany College honored three distinguished faculty members, Dr. Peter Ehni, Professor Fujiko Nito, and Dr. Patrick Sutherland, during its annual Last Lecture series, celebrating their lasting contributions and the generations of students they have impacted.

Ehni, associate professor of math and science, joined Bethany in 2019 and delivered, “How to Make a Million Dollars Raising Honeybees.” Drawing from his work in beekeeping, Ehni blended humor with education while exploring both the science and business of apiculture.

He discussed the challenges and rewards of the field and encouraged students to remain curious, continue learning, and engage in hands-on practice.

Nito, professor of computer science and co-director of the Japan outreach program, has been a member of the Bethany faculty since 1985. In “Bridging Worlds: Computing and Japan at Bethany,” she reflected on more than four decades of teaching. Nito traced the evolution of technology while highlighting her role in expanding Bethany’s computer science programs and global initiatives. She also shared her journey from engineering to education and spoke to the importance of innovation, persistence, and cultural connection in shaping student success.

Sutherland, chair of the Department of Communications and Media Arts, joined Bethany in 1989 and delivered a lecture centered on his career in communications and media.

Drawing from his background in radio, television, and higher education, Sutherland shared lessons on growth, resilience, and the value of relationships. He encouraged students to embrace challenges, seek mentorship, and take full advantage of a liberal arts education.

Together, these faculty members represent decades of service and a lasting impact on Bethany College. The College extends its sincere gratitude and congratulations for their dedication to teaching, mentorship, and the countless students whose lives they have shaped.

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 35

CROSS COUNTRY

BISON ATHLETICS FOOTBALL

The 2025 football season closed the Brandon Robinson era of the Bison football program but not before the Green and White managed to get a 17-12 win in a shootout with Thiel for the team’s first win since 2024.

Quarterback Brett Phillips ‘27 earned his second straight All-Presidents’ Athletic Conference honorable mention after throwing for 1,615 yards with 12 touchdowns and a 63.8% completion percentage despite missing three games to injuries. He also rushed for a team-best 330 yards on 87 carries with two touchdowns.

Defensive end Amarion Williams ‘26 ended his Green and White career after leading the defense where he was fourth on the team with 48 tackles and a team-leading 13.5 tackles for loss. He was also fifth in the conference with 6.5 sacks and added five forced fumbles which was tied for second in all of NCAA Division III to receive All-PAC honorable mention The Bison enter the 2026 season with high hopes as David Blake was named the 12th coach in program history in December 2025, signaling a high-energy for the Bethany program looking to redefine its identity in the PAC.

36 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

WOMEN’S SOCCER

The 2025 campaign marked the beginning of the Olivia Wilkerson era of the women’s soccer program after she was named the team’s head coach last summer.

Wilkerson and the Bison had a tough schedule ahead of them but were able to salvage a few victories highlighted by a season-ending 6-1 triumph over Thiel.

On a team that carried 13 seniors, Monica Bird ‘26 capped off her outstanding Bethany career by scoring a team-best six goals and adding one assist for 13 points on her way to an All-PAC honorable mention.

Shunnye Christopher ‘26 also contributed five goals and two assists for the Green and White, while goalkeeper Hope Fair ‘27 defended goal for the Bison with 77 saves despite missing part of the season due to injury.

With a large group of graduated seniors, Wilkerson will look to Jordan Palmer ‘27, Brionna Bash ‘27, and Avallina Aurilio ‘27 to lead a young Bison squad in 2026.

SWIMMING & DIVING

The Bison swimming & diving team made the most of the 2025-26 season and ended the year with a bang. Head Coach Jeani Humpe lost a handful of key contributors from previous year’s squad but fielded a team filled with young, dedicated, and competitive swimmers.

The Bison were led by JulieAnne Humpe ‘28 who is the team’s only returner from the previous season. Humpe competed in all nine meets and placed tenth at the PAC Championships in both the 100-yard and 200-yard backstroke to earn all 18 of the team’s points. She was also named to the 2025-26 PAC Sportsmanship Team and is the first Bison swimmer in program history to be named to the College Sports Communicators Academic All-District Team.

Corbin Henry ‘29 and Jailyn Cline ‘29 were both massive additions to the team and took on a lot of the team’s load in their first collegiate seasons.

They both competed well at their first PAC Championships and are primed for standout careers at Bethany.

After losing several key runners from the 2024 team, the Bethany cross country program had almost an entirely new look but was still able to compete with the top teams in the Presidents’ Athletic Conference.

Head Coach Jordan Johnson relied on Deena Rosenthal ‘25 and junior Mary Tracey ‘27 as the team’s only two returners.

Rosenthal and Tracey both finished within the top 15 at the La Roche Invitational and also ran the PAC Championship’s 6K course with times of 30:31.9 and 33:34.1, respectively.

MEN’S VOLLEYBALL

The Bison men’s volleyball team continues to make history in their third season as Head Coach Chuck Shoemaker led the program to its first conference victory over Hiram on March 6. Bethany also earned another thrilling win over Carlow in a five-set thriller to improve on their record from the past two seasons.

Although the 2026 squad had a large core of young student-athletes, Riley Burdett ‘28 led the Bison with another breakout season, where he had a team-best 95 kills after earning all-conference honors a season ago. Defensively, Cole Thomas ‘27 led the way with 115 digs while Zachary Kay ‘29 broke through in his first collegiate season with a team-high 236 assists and 11 service aces.

Fortunately for Shoemaker and the Bison, the team had no graduating seniors on this season’s roster, meaning that the entire 2026 team can return to suit up for the Bison in 2027.

MEN’S BASKETBALL

Brandon Thorsen entered his first full season as the men’s basketball head coach after serving as the program’s interim head coach in 2022-23. No stranger to Bethany, he has been a key part of the Bison’s men’s basketball program since 2021 when he joined as a graduate assistant. In his first season as head coach, he led the Bison to the program’s first 10-win season in eight years.

Two impact transfers that led the Green and White in 2025-26, were guard Co Rose ‘26 and forward Jayden Jackson ‘28.

Rose was the team’s scoring leader with 448 points for an average of 18.6 points per game while Jackson led the team in rebounding with 191 boards. Both Rose and Jackson received All-Presidents’ Athletic Conference honorable mention.

Guard Troy Hixson ‘25 put an end to a historic career where he became the 28th player in program history to score 1,000 career points and ranks sixth on Bethany’s all-time three-point field goals leaderboard.

WOMEN’S BASKETBALL

The 2025-26 season was a historic one for the Bison and Head Coach Mikayla Lopez as the team’s 17-10 record marked the program’s best season since winning 17 games in 2011-12. The Green and White’s record-setting season was highlighted by a stretch where the Bison won 13 of 14 games, including a nine-game win streak.

All-PAC guard Lindsey Garrison ‘25 wrapped up one of the greatest careers in Bethany women’s basketball history after leading the team in scoring with 411 points.

Garrison also broke the program record for most three-point field goals in a career and eclipsed 1,500 career points.

The Bison also had the best in the Presidents’ Athletic Conference as Lindsey

MEN’S SOCCER

WOMEN’S VOLLEYBALL

The women’s volleyball program welcomed back a familiar face as Bethany graduate Riley Felton ‘23, M.Ed. ‘25 was named head coach in May 2025 after five standout years as a middle blocker for the Bison. Felton now serves as the youngest head coach in the Presidents’ Athletic Conference and won seven games in her first season.

The Bison were led by Averie Braymer ‘26 and Andie Clark ‘26 on the offensive and defensive side of the net, respectively.

Braymer led the team with a career-high 228 kills and 276.5 total points on the year to earn All-PAC honorable mention.

Clark tallied a career-high 395 digs while also serving up 32 aces to lead the team.

Leading a large incoming class was Grace Padavick ‘29, who led the team in assists with 457, added 184 digs, and was named PAC Newcomer of the Week in October 2025. Combined the offensive power of Isabella Poppelriter ‘29, who had 96 kills, and Layla Smith ‘29, who had 89 kills, the future of the Bison has all it needs to contend for another PAC title.

Perhaps Bethany’s biggest turnaround from the 2024 season took place on Hoag Field where Head Coach Matt Wolf took the men’s soccer program from winning just one game a year ago to fighting for a spot in the PAC Tournament in 2025.

Leading the way for the Bison were Pablo Aguilera ‘26 and Ian Stempler ‘26.

Aguilera was named All-PAC honorable mention after scoring a team-best 11 points with four goals while Stempler led the team with five goals and 10 points in his final season. The Bison defense allowed only 1.94 goals per game on average and was held down by Nahuel Vivas ‘26 who also earned all-conference honors.

Although the team will lose many key players from the 2025 team in 2026, Wolf welcomes an incoming class of 30 studentathletes to help Bethany secure their first conference tournament appearance since the 2022 season, where the Bison reached the PAC Championship Game.

Best ‘29 was named PAC Newcomer of the Year and won the conference’s weekly award for first-years a record seven times.

Forward Kaedlee Potter ‘26 and guard Ella Simpson ‘28 also put together allconference campaigns for Bethany to help lead the team to its fourth-straight PAC Tournament appearance.

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 37

WOMEN’S WRESTLING

After a record-setting inaugural season, the Bison women’s wrestling program entered the 2025-26 campaign with a larger roster and larger expectations. Head Coach Pete Di Pol put Bethany on the map in 2024 and with the help of three returning upperclassmen and several impact freshmen, did so again this year.

The Bison traveled to Cedar Falls, Iowa, in January 2026 to compete at the National Wrestling Coaches Association National Dual Meet Championships against the best teams in the country.

Bethany won two duals at the Championships and finished in 13th place before returning home to complete a 16-5 record on the year, including a 29-18 victory over No. 25 nationally ranked Gannon.

Four Bison reached the second day of the NCAA Regional Championships as Rose Mary Dodd ‘29, MyJanniea Baptist ‘29, Ashley Campbell ‘29, and Taelor Rae Busch ‘29 helped lead the Green and White to a tenth-place finish.

In 2026-27, Di Pol and this season’s dominant rising sophomore class have the chance to win a conference championship in the Presidents’ Athletic Conference’s first year sponsoring women’s wrestling.

38 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

VARSITY DEBUT

MEN’S WRESTLING

Just one year after the women’s wrestling program made its varsity debut, the Bethany men’s wrestling team made its 2025-26 return after a near 50-year hiatus. Head Coach Pete Di Pol put together a roster of 18 young men to put the Bison back in the limelight for the first time since 1978.

Competing in a stacked Presidents’ Athletic Conference, the young men’s wrestling team earned three victories on the year, including the program’s first win of the 21st century in a 57-0 shutout of Penn State-Altoona in November 2025. The Bison also rallied back to defeat NCAA Division II Davis & Elkins by a score of 30-29 at the Glenville State Quad before securing their first conference victory over Waynesburg 3621. The historic comeback season was concluded by the team scoring 23.5 points at the PAC Championships and 9.5 at the NCAA Region IV Championships.

Bethany was led by All-PAC Jonathan Braun ‘27, who had a team-leading 28 victories with 13 wins by fall. His 2025-26 season landed him a three-seed going into the PAC tournament where he rattled off two pins in the 174-pound consolation bracket to earn third place and an All-PAC honorable mention. Braun then also represented the Bison in the NCAA Regionals by picking up a win despite wrestling up a weight class.

Heavyweight Zach Kuneff ‘26 also earned all-conference honors after winning 20 matches on the year and going 4-1 at the PAC tournament for another Bison third-place finish in their first season.

Although he missed half of the season due to injury, Angelo Di Pol ‘28 still racked up 20 wins with nine pins for the Bison and notched a 10-7 decision victory at the NCAA Regional tournament. Harrison Spadoni ‘29 was Bethany’s last 20-match winner after a solid season, as he and Angelo Di Pol will return to lead a young and hungry Bison team in their quest for a PAC Championship.

CAPTAIN of a COMEBACK

In its first season since being reestablished, the Bethany College men’s wrestling program is already building momentum, led by student-athletes like Angelo Di Pol ‘28.

Angelo brings Division I experience to Bethany, as he earned the program’s first win since 1975 and finished the season with a 16-7 record at the 125-pound weight class. His decision to transfer to Bethany proved to be a turning point, as he found a stronger sense of fit, purpose, and opportunity within the program.

Now serving as a team captain, Angelo plays a key role in shaping the culture of a young program and said, ‘it’s [a] new [program] so we’re building it from the ground up which makes it really special,” he said.

For Angelo, the opportunity to compete alongside his teammates is special, but what is more meaningful to him is his relationship with his head coach and father, Pete Di Pol. “Because my dad is the coach, Bethany felt like home,” Angelo said.

Beyond the mat, Angelo enjoys spending time outdoors, with interests like fly fishing that reflect his appreciation for focus, patience, and discipline, all qualities that translate directly into his approach to wrestling.

Through the challenges of the sport, Angelo has developed resilience, discipline, and leadership qualities that continue to define both his wrestling career and his role in Bethany’s growing men’s wrestling program.

BASEBALL

SOFTBALL

Bethany posted a 30-12 overall record and a 15-7 mark in the Presidents’ Athletic Conference, reaching the 30-win mark for just the fifth time in program history.

The Bison advanced to the PAC Tournament, finishing one game shy of the conference championship series.

Emma Jackson ‘26 led the Bison in most statistical categories including hits with 60, RBI with 51, doubles with 14, home runs with 10, and batting average with .455. Jackson’s 10 homers and 51 RBI led the conference and are new single-season program records. Bethany also had an impact transfer in Trinity Edge ‘28, who led the Bison pitching staff with a 17-6 record and a 2.61 ERA with 136 strikeouts. Both Jackson and Edge earned All-PAC honors as well as catcher Olivia Kidd ‘28 and shortstop Brooke Markland ‘26.

Although Jackson and Markland have played their final games for the Bison, eight players who appeared in 20 or more games this season, including six starters, are set to return as the Green and White continue to build on a program with a deep history of winning.

With a brand-new turf field at Bethany Park, the Bison baseball team had a season to remember. Head Coach Michael Finlan’s squad had the thirdbest season in program history as they finished the year with 26 wins: just one shy of tying the 2000 and 2019 teams.

The Bison also clinched a spot in the PAC Tournament for the first time in seven years, where they defeated Allegheny 11-5 in the opening round.

Bethany’s record season was led by six all-conference players with five of them batting over .300 on the year.

Second baseman Jaden Nestor-Fox ‘26 had 57 hits to lead the team, while utility player Marco Gonzalez ‘28 also recorded 57 hits and hit a team-leading .377 in his first season as a Bison. Third baseman Gian DeGenova ‘27 lifted six home runs and drove in 45 RBI, while left fielder Devin Toothman ‘26 stole 34 bases to set the program’s singleseason stolen bases record.

The Bison pitching staff was anchored by Payton Zupko ‘26, who finished the season with an 8-1 record and three saves. In the team’s postseason victory over Allegheny, Zupko struck out his 66th batter of the year to break the record for most strikeouts in a season by a Bethany pitcher.

TRACK

WOMEN’S LACROSSE

The Bethany women’s lacrosse team had the best season in program history as Head Coach Molly Nuri led the Bison to an 8-9 record and the team’s first-ever PAC Tournament appearance. The Green and White’s season was highlighted by an 8-7 home overtime victory over La Roche, a 17-0 win over Hiram for the first shutout in program history, and the postseason-clinching triumph over Allegheny on the final day of the season.

Leading the Bison were defender Emily Wenger ‘26 and attack Tatum Severe ‘27.

Wenger had a record-setting season where she led the team in most statistical categories and was named the 2026 PAC Defensive Player of the Year. She finished the season with a conference-leading 102 ground balls while also scoring 34 goals with a team-high 14 assists for 48 points. Wenger set the Bethany singleseason record in assists, draw controls, and caused turnovers to earn a spot on the All-PAC first team. Severe also received all-conference honors after leading the team in scoring with 37 goals and 11 assists for 48 points. She was the Bison’s representative on the 2026 PAC All-Tournament Team and earned second-team All-PAC honors.

Despite only having a 15-player roster this season, Coach Nuri will bring in a large freshman class and will return eight key starters to help lead Bethany to another playoff push.

second place in the weight throw while Madi Donelson ‘27 led the women’s team with a The Bison indoor track & field team placed eight top five finishers at the 2025-26 second-place finish in the 60.

In the outdoor season, a revamped men’s PAC Championships, including the long jump champion Jason Ellman ‘29, who went 4x100-meter relay team took the track for the Bison. Ellman and McClinton were on to jump a 6.99 at the NCAA Division joined by Jamari Curlett ‘29 and Ziacheas III Indoor Championships to take home White ‘29 as they ran a 40.64 in the relay to All-American honors. At the conference championships, Ellman also finished second win the PAC Championship and to qualify for the NCAA Outdoor Championships. in the 200-meter dash with a time of 21.72 Ellman also went on to take second in the seconds and third in the 60-meter dash 200-meter dash, second in the long jump, with a time of 6.87 to be named the PAC and third in the 100-meter dash to be Newcomer of the Year. Caliyph McClinton named the PAC’s 2025-26 Most Valuable ‘27 and Mykel Davis ‘27 earned a silver medal in the Player. Curlett earned another conference title in the 100, where he took first with a 60 and the time of 10.62 seconds. The final Bethany high jump, champion came in the hammer throw as respectively, Koda Moore ‘26 unloaded a 45.58-meter to earn allregion honors throw to bring home the Bison’s third gold with Ellman. medal of the PAC Outdoor Championships.

Jalen Britton ‘27 also BETHANY MAGAZINE | 39 took home

MEN’S LACROSSE

In his second season as head coach, Harold Pallone III brought in a large incoming class to make up for seven seniors graduating last year. The young Bison had to take on a grueling PAC schedule but was able to highlight their season with a 13-0 win over La Roche for the team’s first win of the year.

The Bison were led by their only senior, attack Justice Smith ‘26, who led the team in both goals with 19 and in points with 24. Levi Connally ‘29 led the Bethany defense and was on pace to shatter the program’s singleseason ground balls record, finishing just shy with 86 on the year.

However, the 2026 campaign meant just a little more as Coach Pallone’s squad played for a fallen teammate. In March 2026, the men’s lacrosse team hosted the Darren Foxwell Memorial Game to remember the life of a future Bison who tragically passed in a car accident before enrolling at Bethany in the fall. Coach Pallone and the team welcomed Darren’s family and gifted them with a helmet and a jersey bearing his high school lacrosse number, #17, in the Green and White.

GOLF

This season, the Bethany golf teams brought back every golfer who represented the Bison in last year’s PAC Championships. One of those returners was Jude Smith ‘27, who earned his third All-PAC selection after finishing seventh in this season’s conference tournament with a four-round score of 302 (+18). Smith also led the team to a tournament win at the Golden Eagle Invitational where both he and the team took home first place and marked the lowest team score under the tenure of head coach Kailey Pettit with a round of 307 (+19). The Bison were also led by Payton Hildebrand ‘27, who won the Geneva Spring Opener with a score of 73 (+1) to lead Bethany to another tournament victory. Also making an impact in their first seasons were Jacob Bursey ‘29, Ian Longo ‘29, and Brayden Roberts ‘29.

Although the Bison competed individually all year on the women’s side, Natalie DuDhole ‘28 led the way for the Green and White at the PAC Championships with a score of 377 (+89) to finish 19th overall while Shelby Cascioli ‘29 opened her Bethany career with a 403 (+115) at the conference tournament.

PROMOTIONS & TRANSITIONS BRANDON THORSEN Head Men’s Basketball Coach 7/28/2025 COLIN HERB Director of Athletics Media Strategy & Content; Assistant Wrestling Coach 7/30/2025 PETE DI POL Director of Wrestling Operations & Assistant Athletic Director 11/1/2025

40 | BETHANY MAGAZINE

NEW COACHES & STAFF NOAH GILL ‘23 Director of Athletics Communications 7/30/2025 TYLER HIETT Assistant Athletic Trainer 10/20/2025 DAVID BLAKE Head Football Coach 12/22/2025 CHRIS KIEDAISCH Offensive Coordinator – Football 1/19/2026

JOSHUA PERRY Defensive Coordinator – Football 1/19/2026 OLIVIA WILKERSON Head Coach Women’s Soccer 3/16/2026 JONNA BURKE Head Women’s Basketball Coach 7/1/2026 DANIELLE FINLAN Track and Field and Cross Country Head Coach 7/1/2026 JAMES COLEMAN Swimming & Diving Head Coach 7/1/2026

Save the Date

2027

MARCH 11

FOUNDER’S DAY

MARCH 23

DAY OF GIVING

APRIL 15

HONORS DAY & SYMPOSIUM OF SCHOLARSHIP & CREATIVE WORK

APRIL 16-17 ANN W. TROMBADORE WOMEN & LEADERSHIP SYMPOSIUM MAY 14

BACCALAUREATE

MAY 15

COMMENCEMENT

CLASS NOTES

Births LISA CANNISTRARO ‘08 welcomed Julia Mae on Jan. 29, 2025.

KYLE MINGER ‘16 and RHIANNA MINGER PETRONE ‘15 welcomed Kambrie on Sept. 14, 2025.

Marriages HADDAE ALLEN ‘23 and MARK LAVEZZA ‘23, MBA ‘24, were married on April 25, 2026, at the Parkersburg Country Club.

JESS WAKEFIELD KILGORE ‘91 and GWENDOLYN POOLE were married on May 4, 2025.

Career Updates NICOLE HAWKINS ‘02 was named Charles County Public School’s 2025-26 Principal Of The Year.

ROBERT WHITMAN ‘78 retired after 46 years in the airline business.

BETHANY MAGAZINE | 41

31 E Campus Drive Bethany, West Virginia 26032