SHIFTING GROUND Untrodden Sites of Architectural History
ARCHITECTURAL HISTORY MA 2025–26 THE BARTLETT SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE
The Bartlett School of Architecture, UCL 22 Gordon Street London WC1H 0QB
This publication brings together research papers produced by the 2025–26 Architectural History MA cohort. The work was presented at a symposium held on November 21, 2026, and an accompanying exhibition that ran from November 18 to 25, 2026 at the Bartlett School of Architecture. © 2026 The Bartlett School of Architecture, UCL. This is an academic publication for internal circulation only. It is not for sale and has not been produced for commercial purposes. Images are reproduced for scholarly purposes and remain the property of their respective rights holders. Individual essays © 2026 by their respective authors. Printed with Mixam
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ARCHITECTURAL HISTORY MA Cohort & Academic Staff
6
Introduction
9
PART I: LIMINAL EDIFICES
10
Performative Britishness: RIBA Validation, Colonial Architectural Education, and the Construction of Professional Authority in Hong Kong, 1950–1968 Sherry Ho
12
Building a Constitution: The Dusted Past of Constitutional Imagination in the Political Organisation of Architects’ Revolutionary Council and New Architecture Movement Dávid Pieš
18
Urban Surfaces and the St George’s Cross: How are the Politics of English Nationalism Inscribed on, Performed and Encountered in England’s Urban Areas? Rose McEnroe
24
Pat’s Climkit: Contemporary Pedagogies for Climate-Intelligent Architecture María Devecyan
30
Reading the Waters: Representation and Memory in Beijing’s Water System Yuxuan Liu
38
PART II: DOMESTIC PRACTICES
44
Drawing the Fleet: Uncovering a Maritime Informal Settlement in Kuwait Ali Alramadhan
46
The Familiar Elsewhere: Wallpaper as a Living Domestic Surface Nina Cao 52 The Society of Cooperative Dwellings: Collective Living and Contradiction Since the 1970s Jack Case
58
PART III: (IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
64
Contemporary Death Monuments: An Exploration of the Peoples Pyramid and its Annual Construction at the Bricklaying Ceremony During the Peoples Day of the Dead in Liverpool Sarah-Jane Miller
66
Trading Places: London’s Investment Banking Architecture Since Big Bang Richard Fryer
72
Architectures of Visibility: The British Museum, the Benin Bronzes, and the Question of Narrative Authority over Colonial History Gareth Hughes
78
From Animal to Commodity: The Architecture of Conversion in an Industrial Pig Chain Elizaveta Provotorova
84
COHORT & ACADEMIC STAFF
6
Established in 1981, the Architectural History MA is a 12-month, architectural history and theory masters course, offering full and part-time modes of study, and auditing from PhD and other masters courses.
TAUGHT MODULES Critical Methodologies of Architectural History Research and Dissemination of Architectural History Architecture in Britain Since the 17th Century Critical Spatial Practice: Site-Writing Histories of Global London, 1900 to the Present Materialist Ecological Architecture Multiple Modernities Practices of Criticism Representations of Cities
GRADUATING COHORT 2025–26 Ali Alramadhan Sophie Burke Nina Cao Jack Case María Devecyan Richard Fryer Claire Graham Bingcan Han Sherry Ho Gareth Hughes Federica Ionta Yuxuan Liu Rose McEnroe Sarah-Jane Miller Dávid Pieš Elizaveta Provotorova Yanjing Ren Aadya Seksaria Wenxuan Su Lucinda Warchol
2025–26 CORE TEACHING STAFF Professor Barbara Penner (co-director) Dr Robin Wilson (co-director) Professor Iain Borden Professor Eva Branscome Professor Ben Campkin Professor Mario Carpo Professor Murray Fraser Professor Peg Rawes Professor Jane Rendell Professor Tania Sengupta Dr Azadeh Zaferani
OTHER ACADEMIC COLLEAGUES AND VISITING SPEAKERS CONTRIBUTING IN 2025–26 Thomas Aquilina Iain Chambers Professor Edward Denison Tom Dyckhoff Christophe Gérard Dr Polly Gould Dr Muhamad Hafeda Dr Emily Mann Professor Clare Melhuish Hilary Powell Professor Guang Yu Ren Vicky Richardson Dr David Roberts Agnese Sanvito Dr Iulia Statica Survey of London (Dr Aileen Read and Colin Thom) Dr Adam Walls Dr Stamatis Zografos
POSTGRADUATE TEACHING ASSISTANT (PGTA) Paola Camasso
EDUCATION ADMINISTRATORS Drew Pessoa and Emmy Thittanond
DEPARTMENTAL TUTOR Dr William Hodgson
7
INTRODUCTION
Shifting Ground: Untrodden Sites of Architectural History brings together the work of the Architectural History MA 2025–26 cohort at the Bartlett School of Architecture. It is a compendium of excursions across architectural history. Some engage with objects of study that first and foremost challenge the limits of what we consider a site of architectural inquiry: a flag, a contemporary death monument, and the body of a pig. Others work with familiar architectures and habitual methods, but in strange combinations that produce unique outcomes: an urban surface is interviewed by the author, a 60-year-old institutional archive becomes a craft book, and a maritime fleet is drafted into a set of architectural drawings. These exercises reveal how even seemingly well-trodden sites can—paradoxically—through the very act of being revisited, yield possibilities of historical study that have been trampled beneath the surface. We, the authors, understand the situatedness of our work within a field of architectural history that has been, and continues to be, in rapid evolution. The question of what counts as architectural history is not new. We are not looking to topple the pillars of our discipline, but to poke them, give them a little shake, and check whether anything has shifted places. It takes time and volume to break ground. Sometimes this happens by reiterating old questions across multiple sites and sometimes by reframing existing sites through unfamiliar language; always by reorienting the focus. The examined sites are as much material as they are representational, a diversity reflected in the three sections into which this book is organised: Liminal Edifices, Domestic Practices, and (In)Visible Products. In Part I: Liminal Edifices, the authors explore frameworks that surround the practice of architecture such as accreditation systems, architectural movements, and educational archives; in Part II: Domestic Practices, they ask how material and organisational practices constitute a home, from the individual to the urban scale; and in Part III: (In)Visible Products, architecture is examined through the corporate structures (conspicuous or concealed) that shape its final form. The categories in this publication are equally untrodden. Rather than strict disciplinary or methodological frameworks, they are makeshift configurations assembled to bring forth the common political, pedagogical and methodological concerns of the cohort. They should be read as provisional milieus that illuminate a certain shared language. Leaning back, a little, against the pillars of architectural history and theory, some climbed the pillars, some painted them over, or added a new one (will it hold?), others tried to chip away at them. Whether with care or contempt, with nuance or conviction, all embraced the pillars’ existence, resulting in a manifold collection of works that above all insist on the value of producing critical architectural history to aid disciplinary self-examination and interdisciplinary thought. Mayhap, the ground shifts not only when we move beyond the established sites of architectural history, but also when we return to them or recognise the departure from them through different questions, methods, and passions. María Devecyan and Dávid Pieš
9
LIMINAL EDIFICES
Performative Britishness: RIBA Validation, Colonial Architectural Education, and the Construction of Professional Authority in Hong Kong, 1950–1968
SHERRY HO Building a Constitution: The Dusted Past of Constitutional Imagination in the Political Organisation of Architects’ Revolutionary Council and New Architecture Movement
DÁVID PIEŠ Urban Surfaces and the St George’s Cross: How are the Politics of English Nationalism Inscribed on, Performed and Encountered in England’s Urban Areas?
ROSE MCENROE Pat’s Climkit: Contemporary Pedagogies for Climate-Intelligent Architecture
MARÍA DEVECYAN Reading the Waters: Representation and Memory in Beijing’s Water System
YUXUAN LIU
This chapter collects works in which the object of study is not building per se, but rather the organisations that surround it. These organisations can be material, as seen in Rose McEnroe’s experimental reading of the St George’s Cross mapped on urban surfaces, or representational, like Yuxuan Liu’s exploration of cultural representation as a producer of meaning in the context of Beijing’s imperial water system. They can also be institutional, as is the case with the three works whose main field of work is the archive: Sherry Ho goes to The National Archives and the Hong Kong University archives to disentangle Royal Institute of British Architects’ technologies of colonial power; Dávid Pieš re-reads the political organisations of the Architects’ Revolutionary Council and the New Architecture Movement through ideas of constitutional imagination and politics as world-making; and María Devecyan treats a 1970s toolkit for teaching climatic design simultaneously as a historical artefact and a contemporary pedagogic tool. These complex systems that environ architectural practice, either by design (accreditation systems, educational archives) or eventuality (architectural-political movements, ideological inscriptions on urban space, representations of the city in cultural media), are interpreted as the apparatuses through which the discipline organises, justifies, and reproduces itself.
12
PERFORMATIVE BRITISHNESS: RIBA VALIDATION, COLONIAL ARCHITECTURAL EDUCATION, AND THE CONSTRUCTION OF PROFESSIONAL AUTHORITY IN HONG KONG, 1950–1968
SHERRY HO
LIMINAL EDIFICES
This dissertation examines architectural education at the University of Hong Kong (HKU) between 1950 and 1968 through its relationship with the Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA). It argues that validation was not simply an administrative process, but a mechanism through which British professional authority was exercised in colonial Hong Kong. Drawing on archival material from The National Archives and HKU’s own archives, the dissertation traces the adaptation of architectural education to local conditions, the circulation of knowledge between Hong Kong, Britain and other colonies, and the continued authority of metropolitan institutions. Following the Second World War, Hong Kong underwent rapid urbanisation and economic expansion, creating an urgent demand for professionally trained architects.1 The establishment of HKU’s Department of Architecture in 1950 represented an important milestone in the colony’s educational development. However, its success depended not merely upon developing an architectural curriculum, but also upon securing professional recognition from the RIBA.2 Although the Architects Registration Council of the United Kingdom (ARCUK) held statutory responsibility for architectural registration in Britain, the RIBA exercised substantial influence over architectural education through its examinations, assessments and validation of architectural schools. This dissertation draws upon Michel Foucault’s concept of examination to analyse how accreditation functioned as a technology of professional power, Émile Durkheim’s sociology of the professions to explain the social authority of professional organisations, Pierre Bourdieu’s concepts of field and symbolic capital to examine competition for professional legitimacy, and Edward Said’s work on representation and colonial knowledge. The research centres on four bodies of archival material. The National Archives file CO 1030/178 contains Colonial Office correspondence concerning HKU’s architectural education, RIBA recognition, regional professional registration, and exchanges between Hong Kong, Singapore and Malaya. File BW 90/2242 contains material relating to architectural education across the British Empire and Commonwealth, including the 1953 Conference on Tropical Architecture. File BW 90/1643 contains inspection reports, correspondence and memoranda concerning staffing, curriculum, professional examinations and negotiations over RIBA recognition at HKU. Finally, HKU’s archives provide internal reports, examination records Christian Caryl, Building the Dragon City: History of the Faculty of Architecture at the University of Hong Kong (Hong Kong University Press, 2012), 14. 2 Mark Crinson and Jules Lubbock, Architecture—Art or Profession? Three Hundred Years of Architectural Education in Britain (Manchester University Press, 1994), 89, 158–59. 1
13
14
PERFORMATIVE BRITISHNESS
and correspondence concerning the department’s development. Together, these sources allow metropolitan, colonial-governmental and university perspectives to be compared. The dissertation identifies three interconnected processes. First, professional architectural knowledge at HKU was actively produced rather than simply imported. Gordon Brown, J. M. Richards, Scandinavian tutors, Chinese specialists and other staff members developed a curriculum combining British professional education with Chinese architectural history, climatic knowledge and local building practices. Architectural education therefore involved negotiation between different forms of expertise rather than the straightforward transplantation of a British model. Fig. 1 Programme of Conference on Tropical Architecture at the Bartlett School of Architecture, 1953, covering climate, planning, building standards, construction, architectural education and professional practice. The National Archives, BW 90/2242.
Second, this knowledge developed within an inter-colonial network. Discussions involving Hong Kong, Singapore and Malaya, alongside the emergence of tropical architecture as a professional category, enabled architectural knowledge to circulate across territorial boundaries. These exchanges also revealed competition and cooperation between colonial institutions seeking resources, professional recognition and educational development. Third, the circulation of architectural knowledge did not eliminate institutional hierarchy. Through visiting boards, examinations and
LIMINAL EDIFICES
Fig. 2 The article examined the adaptation of architectural design to Hong Kong’s climatic conditions, local materials and construction practices. The article illustrates how architectural knowledge was actively produced and adapted within the colonial context, rather than simply transferred from Britain. Reproduced from “Buildings in Hong Kong: Architect R. Gordon Brown,” The Architectural Review 119, no. 713 (June 1956): 316.
15
16
PERFORMATIVE BRITISHNESS
professional recognition, the RIBA retained substantial power to determine whether locally adapted architectural education satisfied established professional standards. Although colonial schools could develop their own curricula and respond to local conditions, their professional legitimacy remained dependent upon recognition from metropolitan institutions. This created a persistent tension within the professional identity of the colonial architect. HKU’s architectural education attempted to reconcile British professional standards with Chinese architectural traditions, local construction practices and climatic conditions. Yet the process through which architects acquired professional legitimacy reproduced the unequal relationship between colony and metropole. The colonial architect was required simultaneously to demonstrate responsiveness to local conditions and conformity with standards established elsewhere. The archival evidence demonstrates considerable flexibility within this relationship. Chinese architectural history could enter the curriculum, Scandinavian architects could influence studio teaching, tropical climatic knowledge could become a field of expertise, and educational programmes could respond to local construction conditions. Nevertheless, the more fundamental inequality concerned who possessed the authority to determine which adaptations were professionally legitimate. Colonial institutions could participate in producing architectural knowledge, while metropolitan professional institutions retained disproportionate power to classify, validate and confer recognition upon it. The history of architectural education at HKU therefore reveals a broader paradox of professionalisation under colonialism. Professional education promised to create architects capable of exercising independent judgement and assuming cultural and social responsibility, yet professional recognition remained structured by unequal institutional relationships. The colonial architect was neither simply a recipient of British knowledge nor a local practitioner resisting metropolitan influence, but a professional formed through negotiation within an unequal institutional field. The central problem was ultimately not who could produce architectural knowledge, but who possessed the authority to decide when that knowledge counted as professional. Questions about what makes an architect an architect, or what constitutes architectural education, cannot therefore be separated from the historical structures through which professional legitimacy was established. The dissertation also raises questions beyond the formal end of colonial rule. The legacy of empire may persist through institutional
LIMINAL EDIFICES
prestige, professional networks and the unequal distribution of authority rather than through the direct continuation of colonial institutions. Further research could examine how British architectural schools, professional organisations and architectural journals contributed to the circulation and recognition of architectural knowledge across the colonial and postcolonial world, and whether older geographical hierarchies of professional authority have been reproduced or transformed. Fig. 3 RIBA correspondence concerning the proposed professional recognition of the HKU Architecture degree in Malaya. Royal Institute of British Architects to A. M. Mackintosh, Colonial Office, May 27, 1955, The National Archives, CO 1030/178.
17
18
BUILDING A CONSTITUTION: THE DUSTED PAST OF CONSTITUTIONAL IMAGINATION IN THE POLITICAL ORGANISATION OF ARCHITECTS’ REVOLUTIONARY COUNCIL AND NEW ARCHITECTURE MOVEMENT DÁVID PIEŠ
LIMINAL EDIFICES
This thesis engages with the archival material of the Architects’ Revolutionary Council (ARC) and the New Architecture Movement (NAM), tracing their political development through the lens of political philosophy. Its archive is well known, yet it contains layers of political imagination that have remained unnoticed in the research and archival work, namely, the tool of political imagination embodied by constitutional thinking. The archival route therefore found its way into an analysis of why the political organisations hoped to govern themselves within the framework of constitutionally binding constraints. For me, it remained exceptionally curious why architectural organisations decided to work with such a charged term–how it has benefited them and how its actual usage or enforcement took shape, or if at all. Nevertheless, partly, what remained on my mind is the performative or aesthetic aspect of the term, which combines effectively the world-making potential of law and politics1 and how it rests its authority on the symbolic level of meaning. Here, therefore, the shape of the dissertation was decided to be about political operations within the world of architecture. How the archival material exposes certain decisions, strategies or vocabularies. And also, how the political and constitutional theory that converges in the concepts of democracy, authority, legitimacy and power (hegemony) can inform the behaviour of ARC and NAM. This application of political theory to the decision-making or strategies of the ARC and NAM movements also isn’t accidental. It stems from multiple archival essays found in the MayDay Rooms archive, where the prominent figure within the movements, Brian Anson, argues that the architectural profession is essentially a society within a society. And therefore, should be deemed with the tools of how to govern it as a larger society. In the first chapter, the history of these movements is told through a narrow lens, one that focuses on the production, articulation or identification of who the enemy is, against whom the political struggle ought to be oriented. The second chapter of this thesis tries to inform what tends to be the political logic in a democratic society; the logic of competition or, in fiercer words, antagonism. Chantal Mouffe and Ernesto Laclau are read here through the problem of how opposition might be organised and sustained. Chantal Mouffe’s theory of agonistic democracy provides a framework for understanding this tension. For Mouffe, political antagonism is ineradicable: collective identities emerge through relations of difference, and radical politics requires the identification of an adversary. Martin Loughlin, “‘Sovereignty and the Persistence of the Aesthetic’: Some Thoughts on Academic Writing,” Modern Law Review Forum (2024), 3, https://www.modernlawreview.co.uk/ sovereignty-persistence-aesthetic-thoughts-academic-writing/.
1
19
20
BUILDING A CONSTITUTION
Fig. 1 Screenshot of a scanned archival excerpt from the extensive document capturing the emergence of Constitution and the thinking and drafting surrounding it. “4th Annual Congress Cheltenham,” New Architecture Movement, 32.
Given that the organisation of ARC and NAM was informed by constitutional aesthetics, Martin Loughlin’s account of the constitutional imagination becomes crucial to further theoretically informing the thesis. For him, constitutional imagination operates through a tension between ideology and utopia: it draws upon existing political arrangements (ideology) while projecting an order that does not yet exist, by criticising the always-existing status quo (utopia). A constitution thus occupies an unstable position between the reproduction of established authority and the possibility of transforming it. A constitution is not simply a legal instrument that mirrors an existing political order; it is a performative text that seeks to bring a particular order into being. What happens within the order, however, is necessarily agonistic; it is an adversarial struggle for the interpretation of the constitution. Or a negotiation of how far the elasticity of non-enforcement can go. It presupposes conflict. It is only curious, then, that knowing both the archive and the theory, two things need to be said. One follows from the other, and both are dealt with in Chapter 3. The logic of political struggle is that hegemony exists and, once defeated, is substituted by another. The conflict never ends, and once victories are achieved, a vision of counterattack needs to be kept in mind. The constitutional imagination that ARC and NAM seemed to be working with, oddly, had a mostly inward agenda. It therefore operated as a rule-binding pillar within the movements, but did not involve their adversaries, the RIBA and ARCUK. It is difficult to trace the enforcement of such a constitution when it did not involve the adversarial counterpart. And then it might lack longevity, which later showed itself in the struggle against the mandatory fee scales. It was a struggle for the possibility of fighting,
LIMINAL EDIFICES
in simplified terms, so that architectural studios could compete not only through the quality of their work (if fee scales were mandatory, then for a certain architectural product, all studios were forced to ask for the same fee) but also through prices. It was a good struggle against what was reported as “one of the most total monopolies the MMC had ever investigated”,2 which was later completely crushed by neoliberal policies and considered by John Allan as follows: “[i]n retrospect, it might be suggested that the abandonment of the MMF—whether or not of benefit to the public—has done nothing but damage to the profession.”3 The ever-changing context of political struggles tends to be facilitated or mediated by the presence of a constitution, which acts as a pillar of checks and balances. As this thesis suggests, it is precisely these checks and balances that seem to be missing from the archival material of ARC and NAM. This absence transformed what was a clear political success into an uneasy moment located within the new economic model. ARC and NAM soon ceased to exist as John Allan, “NAM Outlines – 2015: The ARCUK Initiative,” New Architecture Movement, February 2015, 3, https://newarchitecturemovement.org/files/original/ d6f06ac91b95b00e4eeb418a3bf465ba.pdf. 3 Allan, “NAM Outlines,” 4–5 2
Fig. 2 Criteria for a satisfactory fee system proposed by NAM as part of the broader “Way Ahead” document. “Way Ahead,” New Architecture Movement.
21
22
BUILDING A CONSTITUTION
Fig. 3 Scanned draft of the constitution, with the draft crossed out, perhaps indicating the seriousness of the attempt to write it. New Architecture Movement.
LIMINAL EDIFICES
organisations and dispersed into other projects and with them went the vision of a constitution. An attempt of vision which I find brave and inspiring with the grand vision it offers. Adversaries change; the constitution remains. These criticisms offer a vision of how the constitutional imagination informing the texts of ARC and NAM lacked the stability and continuity that a constitution is often expected to provide. The final chapter therefore discusses the constitution as a public space, invoking Hannah Arendt’s vision–not without its problems–of it as a pillar of stability and longevity around which all parties of any kind can gather and row. Had all sides of the struggle been involved, its longevity, enforcement and interpretative contestation might have been more sustainable. Ultimately, the struggle for better architecture was a struggle for the people. And that struggle, by any means, was a good one. It yet opens the question of how ‘the people’ can benefit more from such a struggle.
23
24
URBAN SURFACES AND THE ST GEORGE’S CROSS: HOW ARE THE POLITICS OF ENGLISH NATIONALISM INSCRIBED ON, PERFORMED AND ENCOUNTERED IN ENGLAND’S URBAN AREAS? ROSE MCENROE
LIMINAL EDIFICES
Urban surfaces are spatialised, temporal structures where power struggles are continuously written and rewritten, creating layers of negotiation that build up the material and historically symbolic texture of a place. They are archives, playgrounds, stores of messages, boundaries, story tellers, markers of territories and canvases. Urban surfaces are also integrated into the living infrastructure of a place. They are functional and highly regulated; both ignored and politicised, and part of our everyday lives as the rounded surface of a local lamppost or the walls on either side of a pedestrian bridge. In this dissertation, I took these notions of urban surfaces and placed them alongside discussions of contemporary English nationalism to understand how perceived political alienation and patriotism are translated onto the skin of England’s urban areas, and how various encounters of these surface inscriptions alter perceptions of urban order. Nationalism has multiple manifestations in Britain, each one rooted in complex histories and fierce national pride. While this dissertation looked solely to English nationalism, it acknowledged that it is almost impossible to entirely isolate the English context from Britain as a whole. It was, however, specifically English nationalism that came to the forefront of the British press in the summer of 2025. English flags began to appear on public lampposts in and around Birmingham, quickly spreading to the rest of the country and building a momentum fuelled by far-right activists and anti-migrant rallies mingled with August heat.1 Red spray paint was bought en masse and any surface with a white background was at risk of being appropriated into a St George’s Cross. The campaign, haphazardly coined Operation Raise the Colours by its leaders, reignited a public debate about the St George’s Cross that is never far from the surface of English politics: who and what does it actually represent? The spray-painted and hand-drawn red lines littering urban surfaces renewed conversations of belonging and hostility, interacting with, utilising and becoming part of urban surfaces. This dissertation sought to understand how they did so. The main themes throughout this research are united by their interests in exploring the slight cracks in the everyday and by an attempt to read the moments that disturb what we see and what we expect to see in an urban environment. This thematic direction led me to undertake a methodological approach that does not fit within the realms of traditional architectural historical research in both its process and its visual output. Studying the everyday, the transgressive and the Joe Mulhall, “‘Operation Raise the Colours’ Organised by Well-Known Far-Right Extremists,” HOPE not hate, August 22, 2025, https:// hopenothate.org.uk/2025/08/22/operation-raise-the-colours-organised-by-well-known-far-right-extremists/; Esther Addley, “‘A Dangerous Moment’: The Emboldening of Britain’s Far Right,” Guardian, August 24, 2025, https://www.theguardian.com/news/ng-interactive/2025/aug/24/ britain-far-right-emboldened-migration-nationalism.
1
25
26
URBAN SURFACES AND THE ST GEORGE’S CROSS
LIMINAL EDIFICES
27
28
URBAN SURFACES AND THE ST GEORGE’S CROSS
Fig. 1 (prev) Annotated image of the St George’s crosses spray painted onto the bins as an experimental ‘wall interviewing’ approach to reading the bin’s surfaces. Accompanied analysis in the dissertation’s second chapter, ‘Private Space.’ Image by the author.
ephemeral means that my objects of study are not part of a codified system of semiotics bound together by formal archives. Therefore, it is through my own encounters with these moments that I used the method of wall interviewing (derived largely from Andron’s work) to decode urban surfaces. These encounters occurred through various conditions of perception, for example while travelling by train, by car or scrolling through Instagram, to explore the intricate spatial and temporal differences between how an inscription is approached and then left behind. Wall interviewing “looks at signs in space rather than how space becomes a sign”2 treating them as “localised inscriptive artefacts, rather than focusing on their production, reception or regulation.”3 The process of wall interviewing involves an element of “imagining a dialogue with non-human subjects” but it is ultimately driven by the goal of creating an “attunement with urban surfaces.”4 The annotated images produced through this method served to dissect the entanglement of signs surrounding the inscription and its wider site and offer a form of visual, procedural evidence.5 The method ultimately asks: what can be read and understood by looking? How can we listen to spatial stories told by fragments of urban life?6 Exploring the spatial and temporal dimensions of urban encounters underpinned a significant thematic intention of this research. I attempted to unravel these intertwined dimensions by looking through the lens of public space and asking, ‘What kind of temporary spatial encounters and disruptions are created by nationalist appropriations of public urban surfaces?’ The reproduction of the English nation at a local scale, both as surface inscriptions and as material flags hung on street furniture, are acts and objects that reoccurred throughout this research. Turning to spaces that are characterised by inaccessibility, I asked ‘How are private and semi-private spaces used to perform nationalism?’ to understand how privacy is folded into these reproductions of the nation and explore how they can be performed from a private space to a public space. Everyday urban life is widely experienced, recorded and reproduced through the screen of devices that take us into digital spaces. I explored encounters within digital space through the themes of placelessness and hyperlocality, historical appropriation and the temporality of online interactions. These themes were brought together in the following question: Sabina Andron, “Surface Semiotics, a manual for knowing surfaces,” in Urban Surfaces, Graffiti and the Right to the City, (Routledge, 2024), 14. 3 Sabina Andron, “Interviewing Walls: Towards a method of reading hybrid surface inscriptions,” in Graffiti and Street Art: Reading, Writing and Representing the City, ed. Konstantinos Avramidis and Myrto Tsilimpounidi, (Routledge, 2017), 71. 4 Andron, “Surface Semiotics,” 48. 5 Andron, “Interviewing Walls.” 6 Iain Borden et al., eds., The Unknown City: Contesting Architecture and Social Space (MIT Press, 2001), 4. 2
LIMINAL EDIFICES
‘How are images of nationalist surface appropriations reproduced and reperformed in digital spaces? And how does this online culture reinforce imaginaries of medieval England?’ The historically deep-rooted divisions that the St George’s Cross symbolises cannot be single-handedly solved by the study or practice of architecture itself. Perhaps what architectural history can offer, however, is a way to read, listen and even translate the lived experiences of a crisis in national identity as it is inscribed onto urban surfaces.
Fig. 2 A pedestrian crossing bridge on the A102 in south-east London with spray painted St George’s crosses on its surface, embedded within a network of road signs. Analysed in detail in the dissertation’s first chapter, ‘Public Space’. Photograph by the author.
29
30
PAT’S CLIMKIT: CONTEMPORARY PEDAGOGIES FOR CLIMATEINTELLIGENT ARCHITECTURE
MARÍA DEVECYAN
LIMINAL EDIFICES
Between the late 1960s and the early 1990s, environmental design professor Patrick Wakely (1939–2026) assembled “Pat’s Climkit.” This is a folder containing a collection of teaching material for his courses at the Architectural Association’s (AA) Department of Tropical Studies (DTS) and at the Bartlett Development Planning Unit (DPU) of University College London (UCL). This thesis begins with my discovery of the folder at the AA Archives, where it is part of the recently catalogued Department of Tropical Architecture Archive, and the questions that emerged as I observed, analysed, and experimented with it. Through archival research, hands-on interactions with the material, and conversations with environmental design educators, the Climkit will be interpreted simultaneously as a historical artefact and as a contemporary tool. Presumably for Wakely’s sole personal use in teaching, the Climkit is a compilation of lecture notes, student work, quizzes, course programmes, calculation sheets, journal articles, and other miscellaneous papers. The specific technical knowledge that the material is based on can be assumed to have been advanced by now, but I do not look to validate the environmental design theory itself. Instead, what I propose is that recuperating the Climkit’s pedagogic approach based on interactive visual material and empirical tools can have significant value, especially as architectural education faces the task of how to address the climate emergency.1 This thesis is premised on the belief that, alongside the discussions on the definition of ‘climate’ and its broader sociopolitical implications, it is essential that the discipline reflect on how to create critical yet robust pedagogies on the technical side of climatic architecture, as those will inform the most incisive as well as creative experiments. The DTS was a programme at the AA that sought to train architects in the challenges of designing architecture for tropical climates.2 While the environmental discourse that it promoted was technical, it was not necessarily technological; the spirit of its curriculum was, in essence, using high-tech tools to refine low-tech design. The foremost example of this is the heliodon, a device that simulates solar angles at any point in time on physical models, which had its own dedicated course. Theories of learning were part of the DTS curriculum. While the tools being foregrounded in this thesis must be interrogated through critical lenses of coloniality and technology, their value lies not just in Tülay Atak et al., eds., Pedagogical Experiments in Architecture for a Changing Climate (Routledge, 2024), i. 2 Patrick Wakely, “The Development of a School: An Account of the Department of Development and Tropical Studies of the Architectural Association,” Habitat International 7, no. 5 (1983): 338. 1
31
32
Fig. 1 Brochure with a panorama showing 24 hours of sun in northern Norway during the summer. The composite image creates a wave-like path of the sun moving across the landscape. Courtesy AA Archives.
PAT’S CLIMKIT
the knowledge that they carry but in the ‘learning-by-doing’ attitude towards pedagogy and practice of environmental design that they embody. The Climkit is read as a carefully curated synthesis of these pedagogical pursuits. A curiosity about the Climkit is that its visual language is significantly more technical than that of other contemporaneous material produced on the relationship between climate and architecture. Instead of the prevalent human figure of the Olgyay brothers’ diagrams,3 the Climkit centres images of the sun or of the instrument, reflecting the technically rigorous ethos of the climate courses despite their essentially humanitarian aim. To argue for the contemporary value of the empirical tools in the Climkit, I put it to the test. Many of the exercises—graphs, calculations, geometric observations—have detailed instructions, as if the goal were to remove the expert as the intermediary between architects and good climatic design. “Interactions” refer to my method of recreating the tools in the Climkit, manipulating them, and recording and reflecting on the results to unearth the embodied knowledge that it contains. They are a combination of systematic tasks and speculative tests based on my own experience and interpretations. At some point, Wakely found and stored in the folder a brochure titled “Norway… Land of the Midnight Sun” that shows a panorama of the sun throughout 24 hours. For an in-depth analysis of the Olgyays’ images, see Daniel Barber’s “The Nature of the Image: Olgyay and Olgyay’s Architectural-Climatic Diagrams in the 1950s,” Public Culture 29, no. 1 (81) (2017): 129–164, https://doi. org/10.1215/08992363-3644433.
3
LIMINAL EDIFICES
If the photographs were arranged to form a cylinder, with the observer on the inside, it would be seen that the sun moves in a perfectly flat but somewhat tilted plane which lies closest to the horizon in the north and highest above in the south. I printed the scanned brochure on tracing paper, drew a curve through the 24 suns to visualise the path, and shaped it into a cylinder that revealed the flat tilted plane. This very straightforward exercise shows what the Climkit aimed to offer and exemplified: practical teaching tools, with prompts that speak to the effectiveness of simple visual and spatial demonstrations of common-sense knowledge to incorporate basic principles.
Fig. 2 Interaction I - Solar Geometry: the Norwegian sun panorama printed in trace paper and shaped into a cylinder in order to visualise the flat plane formed by the path of the sun in 24 hours. Image by the author.
33
LIMINAL EDIFICES
The interactions with the Climkit as a method of historical inquiry showcase why, when discussing concepts such as performance, movement (of air, of heat, of the sun), and interaction, it is not enough to look at the material: recreating and actually deploying the tool becomes essential. Joana Gonçalves, a Brazilian environmental designer and educator who is shaping the technical curricula at the AA and the Bartlett, agrees, and is reincorporating these pedagogical strategies into undergraduate architecture courses as a key step for students to understand climatic phenomena and become proficient in environmental design. Scattered examples of pedagogical efforts that embody the practical values of the Climkit already exist—mostly led by former members of the DTS and their grand-disciples—as what Ilya Prigogine called small islands of coherence. Across the ocean from Gonçalves, for example, are John Martin Evans and Silvia de Schiller, a duo of architects that have profoundly shaped the landscape of environmental design teaching in Latin America. Evans, who developed many of the tools in the Climkit, taught the “Heliodon” course in the DTS, and to this day, teaches the same to students in Buenos Aires, Argentina, and throughout the region. Students arrived from all over to the DTS, and teaching extended internationally with travelling workshops,4 making its legacy a multigenerational global network of academic departments and practices of environmental design. These ramifications, however, were not uniform across space and time. The empirical tools became widespread as the DTS propagated, but while this pedagogy flourished in the peripheral networks, in London computer science and consultancy took over relatively quickly. The conservative nature of education in Latin America kept these tools active, while in the European context there was a loss of this knowledge. The temporal asynchronicity between different geographic regions means that what DTS founders saw as a linear transmission of knowledge with London at its centre is nowadays closer to a feedback loop: at a time when studies show that the Tropics are growing by 0.5° of latitude per decade,5 the recuperation of these tools is relevant in all contexts. The DTS had a mission to build local capacity, which they achieved, and this is an opportunity to decentre the authority of London-based departments of tropical architecture. The Extension Service was a programme of short courses run by the DTS in “Third World” institutions. For further reading, see Wakely’s “An Experimental Educational Extension Service to Schools of Architecture and Physical Planning” (1979). 5 Paul W. Staten et al., “Re-Examining Tropical Expansion,” Nature Climate Change 8, no. 9 (2018): 768–75, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41558-018-0246-2. 4
35
38
READING THE WATERS: REPRESENTATION AND MEMORY IN BEIJING’S WATER SYSTEM
YUXUAN LIU
LIMINAL EDIFICES
This dissertation examines how Beijing’s imperial water system— specifically the Western Park Lakes (Xiyuan Sanhai), Shichahai, and Kunming Lake—was represented, mediated, and remembered between 1985 and 1995. It argues that these waters were not neutral landscapes or passive containers of history, but were actively produced as “readable scenery” through imperial painting, poetry, and ritual. Later, amid the rapid urban transformation of the late twentieth century, they were transformed into contested sites of memory. By tracing the shift from water as an unacknowledged everyday background to water as a lost gaze, and finally to a site of personal and collective trauma, this research positions cultural representation not as supplementary evidence to urban history, but as an active producer of spatial meaning. Existing scholarship on Beijing’s water system has largely focused on its engineering history, imperial garden design, or heritage preservation. While valuable, these studies tend to treat water spaces as either physical infrastructure or scenic relics, often overlooking how such spaces were lived, remembered, and narrated by ordinary citizens. This dissertation addresses this gap by turning to cultural texts—literature, popular music, and film—to recover the affective and perceptual dimensions of Beijing’s waters during a decade when old Beijing had not yet fully become the “old Beijing” of tourist handbooks, and the new Beijing had not yet thoroughly overwritten bodily memory. The dissertation is structured in three movements. The first movement (Chapter 2) establishes the historical baseline of the water system. From the Three Seas of the Western Garden to Shichahai and Kunming Lake, these bodies of water were repeatedly shaped by images, poetry, and imperial ritual. Under the Qing dynasty, the Qianlong Emperor’s poems and imperial drawings on the waters transformed these spaces into an imaginative dimension. The water was not merely a physical entity but a highly legible landscape order, watched, written about, and controlled. This “readable scenery” did not disappear with the end of the imperial system; rather, in the midto-late 1980s, it re-entered the core zone of cultural representation in more complex and uncertain forms. The second movement (Chapter 3) analyses three cultural texts that span three media—literature, music, and the moving image—to trace the arc of memory. Liu Xinwu’s novel The Wedding Party (1985) records the water system as an unconscious environment of everyday life.1 In the novel, Houhai and the Yinding Bridge are not main objects of narration but rather background spaces where market life unfolds naturally. The bell and drum towers function as a temporal 1
Liu Xinwu, The Wedding Party (People’s Literature Publishing House, 1985).
39
40
READING THE WATERS
Fig. 1 A section of Xu Yang, Poetic Imagery of the Jade Belt Bridge, ink and colour on paper, 15.4 × 124 cm. Image from the Beijing Palace Museum website.
scale, sustaining a traditional rhythm of life. Here, water is an “environment of memory” (milieu de mémoire), an invisible foundation upon which everyday life unfolds, rather than a “site of memory” (lieu de mémoire) requiring preservation.2 However, this invisible presence began to undergo a fundamental transformation after 1985. As urban redevelopment advanced, the hutong fabric around the Rear Sea was eroded, and the spatial density loosened. Liu Xinwu’s text thus possesses an unintended historicity: it preserved a moment when urban space had not yet realised it was about to disappear. If Liu Xinwu records the final moment of everyday background, He Yong’s rock song “The Bell and Drum Towers” (1994) marks the birth of a new cultural emotion: indignation and mourning for an already lost urban memory. The lyric “From the Yinding Bridge you can no longer see clearly, no longer see clearly that Western Hill” points directly to the real event in which the completion of the Pierre Nora, “Between Memory and History: Les Lieux de Mémoire,” Representations 26 (1989): 7–24.
2
LIMINAL EDIFICES
Jishuitan Hospital building in 1984 blocked the view. What was lost was not merely a scenic view, but a shared viewing experience and a bodily urban knowledge. He Yong’s absolute tone of mourning— provoked by the rock form—constitutes an urban emotional structure belonging to Beijing youth in the early 1990s: a protest against the way modernisation rewrites urban history. Lou Ye’s film Summer Palace (2006), though made in the 2000s, looks back on memories of the late 1980s, constructing Kunming Lake as an emotional symbol whose full meaning only becomes legible in retrospect. By situating Kunming Lake as the site of love’s happiest moment, the film loads this body of water with a particular emotional density: it becomes a temporal “before”—the brief interval of happiness before everything is lost. The water moves, the boat sways, and the viewer, like the protagonist Yu Hong, loses the ability to tell whether this is real or already a memory. Here, Kunming Lake ceases to be silent historical scenery and becomes the space in which a generation voices its sense of loss.
41
42
READING THE WATERS
The third movement (Chapters 4 and 5) reflects on the politics of nostalgia and the limits of representation. If these works generate memory rather than restore it, then the question is not whether they faithfully reflect a vanished Beijing, but how they shape the terms through which later subjects recognise, mourn, and inhabit the city. Nostalgia as an affective structure always faces an ethical difficulty: in giving lost spaces their meaning, it also erases the roughness, hardship, and coercion that once existed. Liu Xinwu’s warmth toward neighbourhood life may obscure the genuine overcrowding of courtyard living; Lou Ye’s shimmering surface of Kunming Lake may aestheticise trauma into something watchable. Finally, the dissertation turns to a self-reflexive form of dérive along the waterway from Beihai to Kunming Lake. The introduction of Guy Debord’s concept of the dérive is not an attempt to reach a “real” site more authentic than any text, but to reclaim a bodily passage that is temporary, imprecise, and not entirely scripted. However, in the old city of Beijing, where waterways are bounded by walls, admission fees, and tourist management, any dérive is constrained from the beginning. The route was chosen in advance, and the researcher cannot enter these spaces without prior assumptions— Qianlong’s poems, Liu Xinwu’s novel, He Yong’s voice all shaped what I looked at. This passage may have been brief, fragmentary, and even failed. But it is precisely its incompleteness that distinguishes it from a conventional site visit. It allowed a little unexplained space to reappear within places already saturated with text.
Fig. 2 Screen captures from the music video of the song “The Bell and Drum Towers.” Rumizhuanrumi, “He Yong, the Bell and Drum Towers (1994),” Bilibili, 2015, https://www. bilibili.com/es/video/ BV14s411272T/?share_ source=copy_web.
The dissertation concludes that Beijing’s waters are not simply remnants of imperial space, but active sites where memory, representation, and urban change converge. The water remains, the bridge remains, and He Yong has gone. What has changed is the relationship between people and these spaces. This study does not claim to resolve that change. It hopes only to show how, in a period of rapid urban transformation, the imperial water system became one of the few continuous threads along which Beijing’s urban past could still be remembered, contested, and imagined otherwise.
LIMINAL EDIFICES
Fig. 3 Yu and Zhou wandering and boating in Summer Palace, Yu writing her diary. Stills from Summer Palace, directed by Lou Ye, 2006.
43
DOMESTIC PRACTICES
Drawing the Fleet: Uncovering a Maritime Informal Settlement in Kuwait
ALI ALRAMADHAN The Familiar Elsewhere: Wallpaper as a Living Domestic Surface
NINA CAO The Society of Cooperative Dwellings: Collective Living and Contradiction Since the 1970s
JACK CASE
This next chapter brings together papers in which domesticity is examined as a practice. Domestic spaces are constituted through both material and organisational practices, and from the individual to the urban scale. Ali Alramadhan documents a maritime fleet as a vernacular urban assemblage of dwellings, examining the practices that make the fishing dhows habitable; Nina Cao explores wallpaper as a commodified agent of domesticity across England and China, through embodied experience and the tracing of trade routes; and Jack Case chronicles the trials, triumphs, and tribulations of cooperative housing schemes in 1970s London, with a view to supporting akin contemporary endeavours. The three consider how a space becomes a home, but also the deeper entanglements between domesticity and economic, social, cultural, and ideological factors.
46
DRAWING THE FLEET: UNCOVERING A MARITIME INFORMAL SETTLEMENT IN KUWAIT
ALI ALRAMADHAN
DOMESTIC PRACTICES
At Al Kout in Fahaheel, Kuwait, a fleet of Lanj Al-Boom fishing dhows sits moored hull-to-hull along the working harbour. The boats are used for coastal fishing, but they are also lived in by the migrant fishermen who work aboard them. When the vessels return from sea and gather side by side, they form clusters that function as temporary settlements on water. My dissertation asks: how does a working fishing fleet become both a dwelling and a settlement? I began by trying to understand the boat itself. The dhow has a long history in Kuwait, where different types supported fishing, pearling and trade before the oil era.1 Today it is also a national heritage image. I visited the Al Qalaf workshop to gain a sense of the history behind the boat and the craft of dhow building. There, the sons of shipwrights continue to make dhow models using inherited techniques without conventional architectural drawings. The visit helped me understand that the boats at Al Kout are not preserved historical objects. They are contemporary fishing vessels, made in fibreglass in the UAE, while retaining the form and profile of the coastal dhow.2 From the workshop, my study moved to Al Kout itself. I walked through the working wharf, fish market, leisure waterfront and private marina, following the different ways the harbour is occupied. From above, Al Kout appears as one continuous waterfront. On foot, however, it separates into two different conditions. On the labour side, fishermen unload their catch, equipment moves between boats and quay, and the market continues the working cycle of the fleet. On the leisure side, yachts, promenades and the private marina produce another relationship with the same water. This contrast became important to the dissertation. Al Kout’s mall and souq use a stylised Gulf architectural language, while the working dhows beside them are presented as maritime heritage. Yet the boats are not static displays. They leave, return, fish, carry equipment and are lived in. The heritage image therefore depends on an active working system. The fishermen themselves are largely absent from the official heritage image, even though their labour keeps the boats active. Laurajane Smith’s argument that heritage is produced through present-day practices became useful to my reading of this condition.3 The next stage of the research was to board the dhow. I crossed the harbour by dinghy from the leisure marina towards the working fleet and boarded four vessels tied together near the fuelling dock. Once aboard, I found that the boats were stabilised by being tied to one Yacoub Yusuf Al-Hijji, The Art of Dhow-Building in Kuwait (Centre for Research and Studies on Kuwait; London Centre of Arab Studies, 2001), 3. 2 Guided visit with workshop guide, Al Qalaf workshop at Al-Qallallef Diwaniya, Kuwait, conducted by author, July 14, 2026. 3 Laurajane Smith, Uses of Heritage (Routledge, 2006), 44. 1
47
48
DRAWING THE FLEET
Fig. 1 Program diagram of the site. Noting that the position of the boats changes due to the frequency of satellite images taken per month. Google Earth.
DOMESTIC PRACTICES
Fig. 2 Example of user-led retrofit to create a micro enclave for crew activity on open deck. Photograph by the author, July 25, 2026.
49
50
Fig. 3 Section through four adjoining fishing dhows at Al Kout, showing the hull-to-hull arrangement, shared edges and occupation that allow separate vessels to operate as a continuous spatial cluster. Drawing by the author, 2026.
DRAWING THE FLEET
another, behaving less like isolated vessels and more like a connected structure. The Lanj arrives as a working boat, roughly fifteen metres long, with most of its surface left open for fishing. It is not designed as a home. The fishermen therefore make it habitable through modest additions. Fabric is stretched across poles to create shade; plywood is fixed over the canopy; ropes become clotheslines; water is stored in drums; a hanging sheet provides privacy around the toilet; and the cabin floor is altered to create storage and a sleeping surface. Fans, air-conditioning units and generators allow the cabin to function in Kuwait’s summer heat.4 These changes are practical and often reversible, limited by the fact that the fishermen do not own the vessels. What interested me most was that the same kinds of adaptations appeared repeatedly across different boats. The fishermen told me that some crews had lived aboard for many years and that others followed solutions already established within the fleet. The similarity also comes from the boat itself, because the Lanj offers only certain places where additions can be made. I describe this as a learned vernacular of inhabitation: repeated spatial practices produced through use, observation and necessity rather than formal design. This relates to Huda Tayob’s argument that migrant spaces, often reduced to the category of the informal, are made by their occupants rather than by architects.5 I then widened the study from the single dhow to the fleet. The boats do not occupy fixed berths. They leave at different times, return from fishing and find places alongside other vessels. The overall shape of Al Kout site visit, fishermen, July 25, 2026. Huda Tayob, “Architecture-by-Migrants: The Porous Infrastructures of Bellville,” Anthropology Southern Africa 42, no. 1 (2019): 50.
4 5
DOMESTIC PRACTICES
the cluster therefore changes constantly, but certain relations recur: boats remain close enough to cross between, crews gather around particular vessels, and access is maintained through local decisions about mooring. The fleet has no overall permanent plan, yet it still produces a recognisable order. From the promenade it can appear as a dense collection of boats; from within, it resolves into repeated units, local decisions and shared relationships. One element made this collective organisation clearer. Within each cluster I found a larger vessel that the fishermen used for cooking and socialising. I began to think of it as the “mother boat.” Ordinary dhows provide spaces for work and sleep, while the larger boat provides a kitchen, an occupiable roof and a place where different crews gather. Domestic life is therefore distributed across the cluster rather than contained within a single vessel. At the scale of the fleet, this recurring organisation resembles what Stan Allen describes as a field condition: an order produced through local relationships rather than a fixed overall form.6 The boats do not follow a predetermined layout, yet patterns of adjacency, access and gathering repeatedly emerge between them. The architecture therefore lies as much in the relationships between vessels as in the vessels themselves. Movement is essential to this condition. The boats must leave the cluster in order to work, and when they return the cluster forms again in a slightly different arrangement. The home travels with the fishermen: the same cabin used for sleeping is part of the working vessel at sea, and the same deck shifts between domestic and fishing activity. Mobility here is not simply a choice; it is shaped by fishing, season, labour and ownership. The settlement remains provisional because the activity that sustains it also requires its individual parts to continually leave and return. The dissertation ultimately argues that the architectural significance of Al Kout lies less in any fixed form than in the practices that continually produce it. A boat becomes a dwelling through repeated adaptation, and separate boats become a settlement through mooring, crossing, gathering and departure. Through observation, photography, drawing, photogrammetry, informal conversations and satellite imagery, I aimed to bring into architectural view a condition usually overlooked in histories of the Kuwaiti dhow. Those histories explain how the dhow was built, sailed and represented. My research asks how it is lived today.
Stan Allen, “Field Conditions,” in The Digital Turn in Architecture 1992–2012, ed. Mario Carpo (Wiley, 2013), 63–79.
6
51
52
THE FAMILIAR ELSEWHERE: WALLPAPER AS A LIVING DOMESTIC SURFACE
NINA CAO
DOMESTIC PRACTICES
My earliest understanding of wallpaper was tactile. In my parents’ bedroom, pale-purple flocked paper carried slightly raised floral patterns that seemed to invite touch. As a child, I often ran my fingers across them. My mother saw the same surface differently. She warned me that oil and dirt from my hands would stain it, and that damage to one area might eventually mean replacing the whole wall. What attracted me as texture appeared to her as something difficult to clean and expensive to maintain. This memory cannot stand as evidence of nineteenth-century domestic life. It does, however, offer a way into the question that shaped this research: what happens when a designed image becomes a surface that has to be lived with? A wall can be understood through looking, touching, cleaning or repairing it. These are not equivalent forms of knowledge. The Familiar Elsewhere asks how displaced surfaces, commodities and cultural references came to appear naturally at home within a settled interior. Wallpaper is useful for thinking through this question because it sits uneasily between commodity and architecture. Before installation, it exists as sheets, rolls, samples or painted panels. It can be transported, stored, cut and sold independently of any room. Once pasted to a wall, however, its edges can almost disappear. Separate pieces begin to read as one surface. The dissertation follows this process through three terms: fragment, fiction and friction. Fragment describes the material condition of wallpaper before and during installation. Fiction refers to the coherence produced when separate surfaces and objects are made to appear part of a settled whole. Friction begins when occupation places pressure on that coherence through touch, dirt, damp, cleaning and repair. Here, fiction does not mean falsehood. It describes the work involved in making an interior appear complete. The Chinese wallpaper at Harewood House makes this process especially clear. In December 1769, Thomas Chippendale’s workmen spent twenty-eight hours hanging what a surviving account called “India paper” in the Chintz Bedroom.1 The painted sheets had been made elsewhere and then adjusted to the dimensions of a particular room in Yorkshire. Corners, doors and architectural fittings interrupted the image. The paper had to be cut and joined around them. The seams remained, even when careful hanging made them less obvious. Installation did not remove fragmentation; it made it less visible. David Pullins, “Robert Adam’s Neoclassical Chinoiserie,” West 86th: A Journal of Decorative Arts, Design History, and Material Culture 24, no. 2 (2017): 188.
1
53
54
THE FAMILIAR ELSEWHERE
The later history of the Harewood paper shows that this relationship with architecture was never fixed. The paper was removed in the 1880s, stored for more than a century, rediscovered in 1988 and reinstalled in the East Bedroom in 2008. The material survived, but the room it had originally formed did not. Wallpaper could cease to belong to one interior and later acquire an architectural role somewhere else. By the late nineteenth century, the same logic extended beyond the paper itself. At Red House, surviving murals and decorative surfaces existed alongside textiles, furniture, ceramics and objects acquired by later occupants, particularly Charles and Clara Holme. These things came from different moments and different places, but repeated occupation allowed them to settle into the same domestic environment. Wallpaper occupied an intermediate position. It remained thin and removable, yet once installed it provided a background against which other objects could be seen together. This kind of coherence was also produced through print and retail. Founded by Charles Holme in 1893, The Studio turned interiors into photographs and descriptions. A “Corner of a Bedroom” could suggest an entire domestic world. Readers saw selected fragments and were encouraged to imagine the room beyond the frame.
Fig. 1 Detail showing the junction between sections of Chinese wallpaper in the East Bedroom, Harewood House. @ifwallscouldtalk, October 25, 2024. Instagram, https:// www.instagram.com/p/ DBllhVvMn3X/.
DOMESTIC PRACTICES
Fig. 2 Liberty & Co. notices advertising “Japanese Paper Leather,” undated. Liberty Archives, Westminster City Archives, Acc. 788/106/1. Photograph by the author.
Liberty & Co. worked in the opposite direction, breaking the artistic interior into purchasable parts: papers, textiles, ceramics, bronzes and curios that could be selected and rearranged in another home. The movement of these objects also complicates the idea of “elsewhere.” Liberty’s Japanese Paper Leather, for example, was advertised for walls, dados, ceilings and panels, although Arthur Lasenby Liberty acknowledged that its use as a wall covering was “essentially an adaptation for export trade.”2 Such materials did not enter British homes as intact pieces of another domestic culture. Their identities had already been altered through manufacture, trade and retail classification. “Elsewhere” was produced through circulation as much as it was carried by the object itself. But the finished room was not the end of the story. Once occupied, wallpaper entered forms of contact that designers and retailers could only partly anticipate. Wallpapers and Hygiene, published for the 1927 Ideal Home Exhibition, described wallpaper as porous, moisture-regulating and “essential for healthy homes.”3 Yet these claims depended on the condition of the wall beneath and on correct installation. Damp, cracks and concealed defects did not always reveal themselves at first sight. They became known over time. Cleaning produced another kind of knowledge. Someone responsible for maintaining a wall might understand its behaviour more closely Arthur Lasenby Liberty, “The Industrial Arts and Manufactures of Japan,” Journal of the Society of Arts 38 (June 6, 1890): 683. 3 WallPaper Manufacturers Ltd., Ideal Papers for Ideal Homes: Ideal Home Exhibition, Olympia 1927 (WallPaper Manufacturers Ltd., 1927), unpaginated. 2
55
56
THE FAMILIAR ELSEWHERE
than the person who designed or sold it. Wallpaper was difficult in this respect. If left alone, it could gather dust and stains. If cleaned too directly, water or friction could damage the paper, pigment or texture. Re-papering might restore the appearance of cleanliness while leaving damp or infestation unresolved behind the new surface. The wall could look complete again without the underlying problem having disappeared. This is why wallpaper matters beyond the history of decoration. The completion of a building does not mark the completion of its interior. Once occupied, surfaces continue to change. They are touched, cleaned, stained, repaired, covered and replaced. Their chronology does not always match that of the structure around them. I eventually touched those raised flowers in my parents’ bedroom in secret. My mother knew the wall through the work required to care for it; I knew it through curiosity and touch. Neither experience is more complete than the other. Both belong to the material history of the surface. The familiar elsewhere names this kind of belonging. Familiarity is not simply a quality that an object or room possesses. It builds slowly through repeated contact. Seen through wallpaper, the interior is less a finished image than something that continues to take shape through the ordinary work of living within it.
DOMESTIC PRACTICES
Fig. 3 Wallpaper in the bedroom where the author grew up, Tianjin, China. Photograph by the author, 2026.
57
58
THE SOCIETY OF COOPERATIVE DWELLINGS: COLLECTIVE LIVING AND CONTRADICTION SINCE THE 1970S
JACK CASE
DOMESTIC PRACTICES
The Society of Cooperative Dwellings (SCD) was a housing association, active from 1968 until 1986, that lobbied for, constructed, and provided services for housing cooperatives in the UK. Their work is representative of an unusually favourable social and political climate in the late 1970s in which various factors converged to create mechanisms for the state funding of purpose-built self-governing housing estates. This was, however, immediately followed by a drastic ‘neoliberal’ turn in British politics which the organisation was unable to survive. SCD’s projects have since met a variety of fates: some have been demolished and some have been sold off, while others still function democratically and according to ‘cooperative’ principles. Today, the remaining buildings read as strange and austere relics of a lost ambition for a more collective mode of housing. This thesis draws primarily on original archival material I have gathered over the past two years from the largest SCD project still in operation, a cooperative in Deptford, South London. Through a discussion of a handful of key artefacts I look at the intersections of economic, social and ideological factors that shaped the architecture of SCD’s estates and scrutinise the decisions made in their conception. I then go on to situate their work in wider histories by looking both to the past and abroad, before ultimately attempting to make sense of the legacy of these projects and their current relevance. Emerging from student organisations in the late 1960s, in their relatively short history SCD transitioned from a prospective provider of student accommodation, to housing for ‘young and mobile’ people, and eventually to a less proscriptive semi-communal form of co-operative housing. In the first section of the thesis I look at the history of their emergence through a study of a selection of early reports and publications made by the organisation, which I read alongside accounts given by key figures in the organisation, and external factors such as demographic changes and the impact of local and national government housing policy. Arbell et al explain how at this time, “housing cooperatives had a rare window of opportunity” as “community activists established themselves as credible political actors and forged a closer relationship with local councils, gained access to material resources, information and political networks”1 and started to influence national policy. Reg Freeson, sympathetic to the wider cooperative project, was appointed Housing Minister in 1974 and established a centrally funded Cooperative Housing Agency, as well as making amendments to the Housing Act in 1975 that allowed housing cooperatives to register as associations and gain access to the recently established Housing Association Grant (HAG). This covered as much as 95% of the costs of a new-build or renovation work. As Yael Arbell, Paul Chatterton and Lucie Middlemiss, “Contested subjectivities in a UK housing cooperative: old hippies and Thatcher’s children negotiating the commons,” Geoforum, 110 (2020): 58–66, https://doi.org/10.1016/j. geoforum.2020.01.017.
1
59
60
THE SOCIETY OF COOPERATIVE DWELLINGS
a result, this period can be characterised as a high-water mark in the relationship between the state and cooperative housing. I follow this with a look at SCD’s role at the intersection of the state and the ‘countercultural’ movements of the 1970s, studying various features of the designs of the cooperatives: large shared houses, community halls, farmhouse kitchens, quasi-vernacular building forms and low density urban scale. I look at the floor plans of the housing cooperatives in conjunction with a discussion of a striking set of illustrations by Peter Salter, rendered in an acid-coded array of dazzling perspective and projection types, drawn to help prospective founders of cooperatives navigate bureaucratic and administrative procedures as well as architectural considerations. These provide a fascinating window into a time in which, due to the provision of the HAG, inexperienced groups were able to embark on the development of experimental housing projects, as well as a visceral example of SCD’s attempt to create a widespread cooperative housing movement. However, drawings also contain glimpses of the limitations of ‘countercultural’ thinking, the ill-defined or half-hearted extent to which such ideas were integrated, and the unstable nature of state support, factors which were to become critical once the cooperatives were operational. As the organisation moved into the 1980s, it found itself hugely vulnerable with the onset of a hostile Neoliberal political landscape, following the election of Thatcher’s government in 1979. I look at this period through accounts in SCOOP, the organisation’s in-house publication which functioned as a kind of newsletter, informing members of affiliated coops of the goings-on in the organisation as well as a forum for discussion and debate about the direction of both it and the wider movement. Through this section I find a series of key issues in the aims of SCD and shortcomings in the conception of their projects, arguing these were, alongside the more obvious external pressures, major factors for the demise of the organisation: a contradiction between the aims of creating a cohesive, democratic self-governing community and providing housing for young and transient people, hasty project planning, inadequate research into possible forms of domestic arrangement, a lack of generosity in the architecture, naivety about the dynamics of gender and class within domestic space as well as an overestimation of the desirability of voluntary participation. Despite this, some of these structures established in the 1970s have proved resilient enough to have endured the twists and turns of what is now almost fifty years and continue to provide secure and affordable housing. This is followed by the final section of the thesis, an exploration of how this 1970s generation of developments fits into wider histories of cooperative and communal housing. Here I draw heavily on
DOMESTIC PRACTICES
secondary texts to outline what I believe are two strands in the history of British cooperative housing: one that has sought to create a new set of living arrangements primarily through a set of legal and ownership arrangements, and another that focuses on architectural and spatial drivers for cooperation, with the latter drawing in particular on feminist thinking about domestic space. I then conclude by addressing the question of whether SCD’s projects can be considered ‘successful’ or not in achieving their aims and assessing the relevance of such projects in today’s context, characterised roughly as beginning with the crisis of 2008. This study responds to Birchall’s observation that “co-operators, through lack of a sense of history, have often ‘reinvented the wheel,’”2 failing to learn from past mistakes. I hope that these insights into the thinking behind, and the struggles within, this particular idiosyncratic strand of alternative housing history in Britain will be useful to groups considering pursuing similar forms of life today.
Birchall, Johnston, The Hidden History of Co-operative Housing in Britain, Brunel University (1991), 4.
2
Fig. 1 Outdoor Meeting at Deptford Housing Cooperative. “SCD’s June Conference” SCOOP. June 1978. SCOOP Collection, Deptford Housing Cooperative Archive, London.
61
62
THE SOCIETY OF COOPERATIVE DWELLINGS
Fig. 2 “DoE.” Society for Cooperative Dwellings. New Build Design Manual for Single People Sharing. (Society for Cooperative Dwellings, 1979), Drawing no. 9.
DOMESTIC PRACTICES
Fig. 3 “Cooking Eating Living takes place in focal point of the House. The Kitchen.” Society for Cooperative Dwellings. New Build Design Manual for Single People Sharing. (Society for Cooperative Dwellings, 1979), Drawing no. 15.
63
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
Contemporary Death Monuments: An Exploration of the Peoples Pyramid and its Annual Construction at the Bricklaying Ceremony During the Peoples Day of the Dead in Liverpool
SARAH-JANE MILLER Trading Places: London’s Investment Banking Architecture Since Big Bang
RICHARD FRYER Architectures of Visibility: The British Museum, the Benin Bronzes, and the Question of Narrative Authority over Colonial History
GARETH HUGHES From Animal to Commodity: The Architecture of Conversion in an Industrial Pig Chain
ELIZAVETA PROVOTOROVA
The following chapter gathers works in which architecture is examined through the corporate structures—whether those are conspicuous or concealed—that shape its visible form. They ask what a building is, when it is also an asset, a brand, or a product. Sarah-Jane Miller looks at The Peoples Pyramid, a contemporary death monument with a cult following, as an architectural ritual that costs £123; Richard Fryer traces the evolution of investment bank geography and architecture in the City of London over the past forty years through a study of typology; Gareth Hughes understands museums as narrative builders, and analyses the spatial implications of this agency in the British Museum’s Benin collection; and Elizaveta Provotorova identifies the architectural forms of the spaces that make up the pig production chain through public record documents and perimetral fieldwork. Some reveal the underlying corporate systems that hide in plain sight, while others jump through bureaucratic hoops and literal fences to discover them.
66
CONTEMPORARY DEATH MONUMENTS: AN EXPLORATION OF THE PEOPLES PYRAMID AND ITS ANNUAL CONSTRUCTION AT THE BRICKLAYING CEREMONY DURING THE PEOPLES DAY OF THE DEAD IN LIVERPOOL SARAH-JANE MILLER
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
23rd November 2025 Birkenhead Day of the Dead. We enter Birkenhead Park at about 7 p.m., down a traffic-conelined walkway following the lasers which are making the shape of a pyramid. We see the KLF ice-cream van, it has DJ decks in the back. I can’t see who it is playing, but I am told afterwards that Jimmy Cauty is live mixing Music for Funerals and Bricklaying Ceremonies Volume 2 by TowerBlock11 (a.k.a. Jimmy Cauty). The music repeats every twenty-three seconds in true Discordian style. The music has an unmistakably KLF sound. It uses echoey samples of someone on a walkie-talkie/shortwave radio (like “3 a.m. Eternal”), a droning background, a foghorn and electronic pips. Images of a spaceman/woman, flowers, ice-cream cones are shown on the screen. It repeats. We are in a waiting room. This is not the formal, stuffy “family waiting room” at the crematorium. This is something totally different. Something for the ravers. After what feels like a long period of being held in the waiting room, staring at the stage and screen, suddenly the ceremony begins. The music changes to “The Ancestors” (the second track on the album lasting 3:21). Images of the eighty-nine people who have been MuMufied between 2018 and 2024 are flashed on the screen in quick succession. We see a photo of three people on each screen, and their names above their photo. They are shown in the order in which they were MuMufied, starting with Simon Cauty (Jimmy Cauty’s brother) who was the first brick in the pyramid. The effect of flashing the images quickly produces a strobe effect. The KLF have always loved a strobe effect! The music changes to “The Bricklaying”: a 4:31-long track2 played on repeat. These repeated tunes burrow into your brain and come back to you as earworms over the following weeks and months. The Undertaker (Claire Phillips), The Bricklayer (Daisy Campbell) and two bricklaying assistants take to the stage. The images on the screen are of giant daisies floating up over a cornfield into a bright blue sky. Images change: hearts, skulls, bricks, ice-cream cones, pyramids (the image is the same as the pyramid found on the hardback cover of 2023: A Trilogy), the words “Calling all Brick Bearers,” there is a moving eye on top of the pyramid now.
TowerBlock1, Music for Funerals and Bricklaying Ceremonies Volume 2 (L-13, 2025), Bandcamp, digital download, https://towerblock1.bandcamp.com/album/ music-for-funerals-and-bricklaying-ceremonies-volume-2. 2 TowerBlock1, “The Bricklaying,” Music for Funerals. 1
67
68
CONTEMPORARY DEATH MONUMENTS
While the music and images play, a name is called. It is the name of the person who is to be MuMufied and have their brick added to the pyramid. Each brick contains twenty-three grams of cremated human remains. The crowd cheers at each name being called. The homemade foghorns are blown. The brick bearers: the family of the person, who is now a brick, climb three steps onto a runway on the stage. They hand their brick to The Bricklayer. Some brick bearers wear full hi-vis, others a subtle neon Pyramid Builders Hat. The Bricklayer lifts up the brick to about head height. The family go and stand to the side of the stage. The Undertaker reads twenty-three words about the life of the MuMufied. For Chris Chestnutt they say “He was an architect. He liked bricks. Now he is a brick,” the crowd laughs. This is an unusual tribute to a deceased architect. In addition to carrying the brick, the two brick bearers also hold up a large wooden architect’s T-square. Most of the families and friends have chosen words that try and sum up the life and personality of the deceased. The Bricklayer performs a ritual performance. Cement is put onto the top of the brick with a magnetic trowel. (These can be purchased from L-13 Light Industrial— currently sold out.)3 The Bricklayer is wearing a bespoke hooded boiler suit costume. The hood is the all-seeing eye and is illuminated inside. The Bricklayer is joined by two other people in high vis Pyramid Builder boiler suits of the kind sold by L-13 light industrial.4 They are a man and a woman, who copy her movements in a form of ritual dance. The Bricklayer builds the brick into the pyramid. She exhales dramatically and blows out into the audience as she opens her arms wide, squats down and then slaps the magnetic trowel onto her utility belt. The two bricklaying assistants do the same all in unison. A pause. The Bricklayer and two assistants slap their magnetic trowels together loudly and synchronise putting their trowels noisily onto their belts. There is great physicality in the choreography of the dance. Thought appears to have been given to make a ritual and a space for each brick bearer to observe their loved one being greeted, received and physically cemented into the pyramid. This ritual ceremonial bricklaying is repeated for each brick. Once all the bricks have been built into the pyramid, chains are attached to the foundation stone and a crane is used to lift the Peoples Pyramid The Peoples Pyramid, “FUUK DEATH Memento Mori PYRAMID BUILDER’S Tool Set,” November 25, 2022, https://www.thepeoplespyramid. org/product/fuuk-death-memento-mori-pyramid-builders-tool-set/. 4 The Peoples Pyramid, “K2 Klobber,” accessed August 28, 2026, https://shop. thepeoplespyramid.org/. 3
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
Fig. 1 The Bricklayer and two assistants receive the brick and cement it into the Peoples Pyramid. The Peoples Pyramid bricklaying ceremony, Birkenhead Park, November 23, 2025. Photograph by Thomas Ecke, courtesy of The Peoples Pyramid.
69
70
CONTEMPORARY DEATH MONUMENTS
Fig. 2 Traffic cones show us the way in Birkenhead Park. Photograph courtesy of The Peoples Pyramid.
Fig. 3 Brick of Mu, box and certificate. Image courtesy of K2 Klobber, The Peoples Pyramid.
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
onto a flatbed truck, which will drive the pyramid to the storage facility until next year’s ceremony. Music called “The Levitation” is played with the associated video.5 The images are of people in space suits levitating into the sky from a field, quick-fire images of the 140 people who are now bricks (including today’s MuMufied), images of the JAMs logo, ice-cream cones are shown. Logos of the Peoples Pyramid, K2 Plant Hire and the JAMs are shown too. The KLF had a saying “turn up the strobe” and the strobe is on maximum for the levitation. The ceremony takes about two hours in total from our arrival at Birkenhead Park. Then we dance. The music is commercial dance music from the 1990s (but definitely no KLF tracks!), many people have left. When we have danced enough, we go home. There is an after-life party in Birkenhead at a live music and arts venue called Future Yard. When I die I will be a brick.
5
TowerBlock1, “The Levitation,” Music for Funerals.
71
72
TRADING PLACES: LONDON’S INVESTMENT BANKING ARCHITECTURE SINCE BIG BANG
RICHARD FRYER
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
This year marks the fortieth anniversary of the deregulation of the London Stock Exchange, known colloquially as ‘Big Bang.’ This event permanently changed the City of London’s urban geography and investment banking architecture. It created new spatial requirements for an office typology: large floor plates, taller floor-to-ceiling heights, flexible office space and capacity for rapidly changing technology. These new requirements were necessary to support large trading floors with rows of dealer boards. The resulting buildings moved away from the City’s traditional heartland around the Bank of England, and became less concerned with stylistic expression than with providing specialised financial infrastructure. This paper examines the myth of organisational identity expressed through architectural style and form. Historically, banking architecture was easy to identify. In the 1920s, banks were represented by monumental, neoclassical Portland stone frontages expressing permanence, authority and security through the architecture. After the wartime bombing of the City, Holden and Holford laid out plans for its reconstruction,1 which were executed through the Martin-Mealand scheme during the 1950s and 1960s. London Wall, Cheapside and Paternoster Square were rebuilt as glass-steel-concrete visions of International Style modernism. This imported, ready-made style added generic office space into the City. By the 1980s, function increasingly determined form, as demands for floor space, services and flexibility progressively relegated architectural style to a secondary consideration. As Big Bang approached, the first response to the new spatial requirements was 1 Finsbury Avenue by Peter Foggo and Arup Associates (fig. 1). This was based on the northern border of the City in a brownfield site. It was a fresh vision of high-tech modernism, adopting new building techniques and construction management. However, its importance lay behind the façade: large floor plates, tall floor-to-ceiling heights, an atrium and shell-and-core construction.2 The workspace designed by Francis Duffy and DEWG architects allowed clients to customise the interior to adapt to working practices and changing technology.3 Unusual for investment banks, the building received critical architectural acclaim. The limited space in the City required a creative approach to identify suitable sites for investment banking. In the West End, former department stores and post office buildings were retrofitted. At Charles Holden and William Graham Holford, The City of London : A Record of Destruction and Survival; the Building Development of the City, the Damage Suffered in the Years 1940-45, and the Proposals for Reconstruction as Incorporated in the Final Report of the Planning Consultants, Presented, in 1947, to the Court of Common Council. Published on behalf of the Corporation of London by Architectural Press, 1951. 2 Kenneth Powell, 1 Finsbury Avenue (Lund Humphries, 2020), 67. 3 Francis Duffy, The New Office (Conran Octopus, 1997), 43. 1
73
74
TRADING PLACES
Victoria station, an oversite development created a large, glazed hightech trading floor (fig. 2). These spaces were short-lived responses to provide the necessary floor space during a period of rapid expansion. The success of 1 Finsbury Avenue spawned two more buildings, leading to the creation of Broadgate. Early on, the City of London planners remarked that “we were getting in the first phases of Broadgate too much the same [as 1 Finsbury Avenue]”4 and directed Foggo to use stone cladding instead. A small, but significant change of direction, pushing the overall styling towards postmodernism. The remaining Broadgate and Bishopsgate development, led by Bruce Graham and SOM architects, adopted a Chicago-influenced flavour of Corporate Postmodernism (fig. 3). The former printing district around Fleet Street, in the west of the City, provided ample space for new offices for the two largest investment banks: Goldman Sachs and J.P. Morgan. Their Postmodern buildings were hidden from view behind the historic façades of Fleet Street and Embankment. The adoption of Corporate Postmodernism by investment banks was about to enter a new phase. There was insufficient space in the City to accommodate the expansive demands of banks. Further east, in the former docklands, a new district was rising. Initiated as an enterprise zone with little planning control or official interference, Canary Wharf could easily accommodate the spatial requirements for investment banks. Bruce Graham with SOM architects created a masterplan5 and identified two banks, temporarily located in the West End, to become the first tenants on Cabot Square: Credit Suisse and Morgan Stanley. SOM’s Corporate Postmodernism was transplanted wholesale to Canary Wharf. By the early 2000s, the architectural styling shifted abruptly to late-Modernism, brought on by a new roster of leading architects. The distinguishing feature of these singular late-Modernist glazed towers is their uniformity (fig. 4). In Venturi and Scott Brown’s terms, they are “decorated sheds”6 providing little clue to the activity performed inside, only the branded signage identifying each bank. The most recent developments in the City of London are “groundscrapers,” the product of planning controls and need for larger open spaces with clear sightlines. The form flows around the functional requirements of football field-size trading floors (fig. 5).
Peter Rees, interview by Richard Fryer, July 2026, 47:04–47:52. “The Architecture of Big Bang,” Architectural Review, October 2016, originally published May 1988. 6 Robert Venturi, Denise Scott Brown, and Steven Izenour, Learning from Las Vegas, rev. ed. (MIT Press, 1977), 90–92. 4 5
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
Fig. 1 1 Finsbury Avenue, 2026. Photograph taken by the author.
Fig. 2 111 Buckingham Palace Road, 2026. Photograph taken by the author.
75
76
Fig. 3 135 Bishopsgate, 2026. Photograph taken by the author.
Fig. 4 Canary Wharf “decorated sheds.” Photograph by mattbuck, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.
Fig. 5 5 Broadgate, 2026. Photograph taken by the author.
TRADING PLACES
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
There is no one style that defines investment banking architecture. The widespread adoption of Postmodernism was a convenience, at a point when there was massive demand for space. Time has not been a friend to Postmodernist buildings, which have become an endangered species.7 The style was always secondary to the primary purpose of making money. The question of organisational identity expressed through architecture is further complicated by real-world events. During the 1990s, corporate mergers and acquisitions created a mosaic of multiple locations and buildings for banks. During the financial crisis, organisational identity could change overnight: J.P. Morgan occupied Lehman’s Canary Wharf headquarters, and Bank of America occupied Merrill Lynch’s new City headquarters. The pragmatism of a good deal and fitness for purpose of a building, overriding any corporate alignment embodied with architectural styling. Over forty years, what emerges is an evolving architectural typology: high-tech modernism followed by Corporate Postmodernism; glazed late-Modernist towers dominating where planning permits and groundscrapers where building space permits. The only common factor between buildings is scale and monumentality. The style evolves, but the underlying spatial and functional requirements remain the same. The wholesale demolition and rebuilding, or recladding, of Broadgate signals the lack of corporate empathy for architectural styling. This evolution has taken place in parallel with the process of organisational consolidation. An organisation’s identity is a production of the fragments of corporate cultures and values accumulated by mergers and acquisitions. Paradoxically, the consolidation of organisations into a small number of singular buildings has been enabled by an opposite process within the workplace, desubstantiation. Originally, investment banks were “financial factories” maintaining all functions in one place or close proximity. By the 2000s, virtual desktops and the cloud removed the requirement to host computers and in-house data centres. Subsequently, non-core work functions were moved to offshore locations, and working practices and processes became increasingly automated. Only the few remained—buildings and people. Investment bank architecture is best understood from the inside out, it is driven by functional necessity not stylistic organisational identity. The monolithic, singular “decorated sheds” are testament to the myth of organisational identity embodied in architectural form. HM Government, “Broadgate Square now immune from listing,” accessed August 21, 2026, https://www.gov.uk/government/news/ broadgate-square-now-immune-from-listing.
7
77
78
ARCHITECTURES OF VISIBILITY: THE BRITISH MUSEUM, THE BENIN BRONZES, AND THE QUESTION OF NARRATIVE AUTHORITY OVER COLONIAL HISTORY
GARETH HUGHES
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
Museums are often presented as institutions of preservation; places in which objects are protected, researched, and made available to the public. Yet a museum does not simply receive history and place it on display. Architecture directs movement, galleries establish proximity and sequence, stores and archives separate some forms of knowledge from public view. Classification, interpretation, conservation, and display therefore shape what an object can mean within the institution. The Benin Bronzes offer a revealing case. Removed from Benin City during the British military expedition of 1897, they have become central to debates about restitution, ownership, conservation, and museum ethics. This dissertation approaches the question from a different starting point: not simply where the objects should be held, but how the museum reconstructs the historical relationships through which they are seen and understood. The Bronzes did not enter European collections as autonomous works of art. Many formed part of the royal palace in Benin City, where architecture, ceremony, political authority, and material culture were closely connected. Brass plaques were mounted on palace pillars, commemorative heads belonged to ancestral altars, bells, swords, staffs, ivory, and regalia participated in the ceremonial life of the Edo court. Their significance therefore depended upon relationships between objects, spaces, practices, and authority.1 The 1897 invasion violently dismantled these relationships. British forces defeated and deposed Oba Ovonramwen, destroyed parts of Benin City, burned the palace, and looted its contents. Objects were detached from architectural and ceremonial settings and dispersed through the art market, private collections, and museums across Europe and North America.2 In museums, fragments of a political and ritual system were reorganised according to new categories: art, ethnography, material type, chronology, and geography. The dissertation argues that this transformation is not simply historical; it continues through the museum’s contemporary systems of visibility. To be visible is not merely to be physically present. A history can be acknowledged in a label while remaining less prominent than the history of craftsmanship, material production, or aesthetic achievement. Conversely, detailed knowledge of acquisition, conservation, or provenance may exist in archives, collection records, stores, or curatorial files without becoming visible to ordinary visitors. Concealment therefore need not mean deliberate omission; it can
Paula Ben-Amos, The Art of Benin (Thames and Hudson, 1995), 66–89, 102–35. Barnaby Phillips, Loot: Britain and the Benin Bronzes (Oneworld, 2021), 50–61; Dan Hicks, The Brutish Museums: The Benin Bronzes, Colonial Violence and Cultural Restitution (Pluto Press, 2020), 99–151. 1 2
79
80
ARCHITECTURES OF VISIBILITY
emerge through the distribution of knowledge across institutional spaces.3 The British Museum provides the principal case study. Gallery 25 is reached through a carefully structured route from the monumental entrance and Great Court, through the African galleries and into a more enclosed basement environment. By the time visitors reach the Benin collection, they have already encountered a sequence of displays establishing African material and artistic production as the wider interpretive framework. Within Gallery 25, the Benin objects are presented primarily through individual works and the sophistication of Edo brass casting. The plaques are arranged in a grid that partially acknowledges their former architectural setting, but the palace itself is absent. The display currently presents 105 historic objects from the Kingdom of Benin, while a further 863 objects remain in storage, excluding archaeological material, photographs, and contemporary works.4 The visitor therefore encounters only a small proportion of the material held by the Museum. This does not mean that colonial violence is absent from Gallery 25. A dedicated panel, “Benin: Colonial Conquest and Military Looting,” explicitly describes the 1897 expedition and the removal of objects from the palace.5 The dissertation’s argument is instead about proportion and emphasis. The history of violence is present, but it does not occupy the same physical or interpretive weight as the history of craftsmanship. Exhibition history demonstrates that this arrangement is not inevitable. The 1970–73 exhibition Divine Kingship in Africa presented Benin material through kingship, ritual, palace architecture, ancestor altars, regalia, and contemporary royal traditions.6 The comparison demonstrates that the same collection can produce different historical narratives depending upon the spatial and curatorial relationships established around it. The question of visibility extends beyond the gallery; conservation, storage, archives, and specialist expertise are necessary to museum practice, but they also form part of the institutional authority through which contested collections are retained. If technical capacity to care for an object becomes an argument for continued ownership or control, conservation becomes more than a material responsibility: it becomes part of the politics of custodianship. Restitution therefore
Swati Chattopadhyay, Small Spaces: Recasting the Architecture of Empire (Bloomsbury Visual Arts, 2023); Hicks, The Brutish Museums. 4 Julie Hudson, Curator, Africa Collections, British Museum, email to author, June 30, 2026. 5 British Museum, Gallery 25, “Benin: Colonial Conquest and Military Looting,” display text transcribed by author, July 25, 2026. 6 William Fagg, Divine Kingship in Africa (Trustees of the British Museum, 1970). 3
82
ARCHITECTURES OF VISIBILITY
Fig. 2 Room in Gallery 25 displaying textiles, personal adornment, and brass casting, with the Benin Bronzes occupying the left of the image as well as the back wall where plaques are displayed on steel columns. The dark ceiling emphasises the closed-in nature of the basement room, with low lighting and small general area curating a claustrophobic gallery despite generous circulation space. Photograph by the author, Gallery of Textiles, Personal Adornment, Brass Casting, Gallery 25, British Museum, London, July 25, 2026.
Fig. 3 Digital Benin website showing access to 5,314 objects held in global institutions including those held within Nigeria. Items are categorised by use, and show both the English and Edo designation. They are displayed alongside their physical location and any available provenance. Screenshot of the Digital Benin catalogue interface, Digital Benin, “Catalogue.” 2026.
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
needs to be understood not simply as the movement of objects, but as a redistribution of authority. The final part of the dissertation considers what such redistribution might look like. The National Museum Benin City and the Museum of West African Art (MOWAA) offer cultural infrastructure within the geographical and historical context from which the objects originated. MOWAA combines galleries with storage, conservation, research, training, and public engagement, proposing an institutional model in which the production of knowledge is not secondary to display.7 International restitution agreements demonstrate that ownership, care, and display can also be separated: objects can change legal ownership while remaining temporarily on loan to European museums.8 Digital Benin provides another form of reconnection, bringing together records of thousands of dispersed objects, provenance information, archives, oral histories, and Edo terminology. It cannot restore the palace or substitute for physical restitution, but it makes relationships visible that individual museums cannot represent alone.9 The dissertation ultimately argues for a plural museum landscape rather than the replacement of one universal museum with another. The Benin collection cannot be made materially whole again, and no exhibition can recreate the world destroyed in 1897. What can change is who determines the relationships through which its fragments are interpreted, conserved, displayed, researched, and remembered. Restitution is therefore not only a question of where objects reside. It is a question of narrative authority. The task is not to make the fragments speak as though the rupture never happened, but to ensure that they are no longer made to speak only through the institutions that hold them.
Museum of West African Art, “MOWAA Institute,” accessed August 2, 2026, https://wearemowaa.org/what-we-do; Austine Emifoniye, “Heritage Management and Community Engagement: The Story of the National Museum, Benin City, Nigeria,” International Journal of Current Research in the Humanities 26, no. 1 (2023): 387–400. 8 Federal Foreign Office, “Joint Declaration on the Return of Benin Bronzes and Bilateral Museum Cooperation,” July 1, 2022, https://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/ resource/blob/2540404/8a42afe8f5d79683391f8188ee9ee016/220701-beninbronzen-polerkl-data.pdf; Horniman Museum and Gardens, “Benin Kingdom Display,” accessed August 2, 2026, https://www.horniman.ac.uk/project/ benin-redisplay/. 9 Digital Benin, “About,” accessed September 5, 2026, https://digitalbenin.org/ about. 7
83
84
FROM ANIMAL TO COMMODITY: THE ARCHITECTURE OF CONVERSION IN AN INDUSTRIAL PIG CHAIN
ELIZAVETA PROVOTOROVA
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
On June 1, 2025 there were 4.7 million pigs in the United Kingdom. Ninety-one percent of them, 4.3 million, were fattening pigs: animals raised for slaughter.1 When read alongside every other part of industrial meat production—animal feed crops, land and fertilisers for them, water at every stage, sheds and land for housing the pigs, transport, and the buildings for processing pigs into meat—the national pig population becomes a demand for resources far beyond the UK. From the nineteenth century, Britain laid the foundations of the food systems we now have, by solving the logistical problem of social metabolism: the break between countryside and city rebuilt as a permanent traffic between an island and its frontiers.2 Today, environmental critiques of industrialised farming recognise the contribution of its national and international arrangements to critical planetary tipping points. Of the nine planetary boundaries that measure this risk, seven have now been crossed, and agriculture is the principal driver of four of them.3 Industrial meat production does not exist outside the built environment, and buildings can say what planetary accounts cannot: where the disproportion sits, what it is made of, or what would have to be altered to change it. Architectural history is equipped to show how the buildings of this system organise more than eighty billion lives a year,4 down to the square metres and the minutes of their existence. The scale of the farming system does not argue against attention to the particular; it argues for it, since the system exists nowhere except in particular places. In my dissertation, I look at a triangle on the map of Norfolk, small enough to drive around in under an hour, which contains the whole life cycle of an industrial UK pig (fig. 1). Inside this triangle are three sites: a breeding unit, a finishing unit, and a slaughterhouse. By following the pig through these sites, I trace how the architecture of industrial animal farming is built around the animal’s capacity to reproduce and grow, and the industry’s means of taking it apart. Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, “Livestock Populations in the United Kingdom at 1 June 2025,” GOV.UK, March 26, 2026, sec. 1.2, https:// www.gov.uk/government/statistics/livestock-populations-in-the-united-kingdom/ livestock-populations-in-the-united-kingdom-at-1-june-2025. 2 Chris Otter, Diet for a Large Planet: Industrial Britain, Food Systems, and World Ecology (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2020), 2; for his use of Marx’s concept of social metabolism, see 18. 3 Boris Sakschewski et al., Planetary Health Check 2025: A Scientific Assessment of the State of the Planet (Potsdam: Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, 2025), 11, https://publications.pik-potsdam.de/rest/items/item_32589_5/component/ file_33151/content; Bruce M. Campbell et al., “Agriculture Production as a Major Driver of the Earth System Exceeding Planetary Boundaries,” Ecology and Society 22, no. 4 (2017): art. 8, https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-09595-220408. 4 Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, “Crops and Livestock Products: Producing Animals/Slaughtered,” FAOSTAT, with major processing by Our World in Data, “Land Animals Slaughtered for Meat,” accessed September 9, 2026, https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/ land-animals-slaughtered-for-meat. 1
85
86
FROM ANIMAL TO COMMODITY
In doing so, I show both the dematerialisation of the living animal into quantities and commodities, and the buildings and processes of which that transformation consists. The breeding unit has two parts: the breeding and farrowing fields (fig. 2). The comparison of the breeding field with the panopticon suggests itself the moment the field is seen from above. Within the biopolitical strand of animal studies, Alex Mackintosh points to the passage in which Michel Foucault suggests an older model for Bentham’s panopticon: Le Vau’s menagerie at Versailles, whose central octagonal pavilion overlooked the animal enclosures arranged around it. Between Versailles and this field the diagram passed through the human prison and came back to animals, now stripped of the menagerie’s spectacle, and the animal’s moments of extreme pain “were replaced by a great confinement,” in which “behaviour is modified through architecture.”5 The company records sows as “bearer biological assets.”6 Silvia Federici’s metaphor of the “natural breeding-machine”7 that is the female body can be used here as a literal description of a sow inside the industrial farming system and its language; and what makes the organism function like a machine is the built environment itself. Each moment in her reproductive cycle corresponds to a specific space along her cyclical route through the breeding unit and is controlled by it. The architecture here secures an unceasing output of “consumable biological assets,” the company’s term for piglets raised for meat.8 Cherry Tree Farm is the indoor finishing unit (fig. 3) where a pig arrives to be fed until reaching “slaughter weight.”9 The site has a substantial planning record, and the discrepancies between the approved drawings and the standing sheds carry much of the evidence. I argue that almost every part of the working farm can be read as an example of the relationship between the body and the building, and propose four such readings. The first is how the body forms the Alex Mackintosh, “Foucault’s Menagerie: Cock Fighting, Bear Baiting, and the Genealogy of Human-Animal Power,” in Foucault and Animals, ed. Matthew Chrulew and Dinesh Joseph Wadiwel, Human-Animal Studies 18 (Brill, 2017), 163–64, citing Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison, trans. Alan Sheridan (Penguin Books, 1977), 203; the quotations at 175 and 179–80. 6 Cranswick plc, Annual Report & Accounts 2026: 52 Weeks Ended 28 March 2026 (Cranswick plc, 2026), 167, note 15, “Biological Assets,” https://cranswick.plc. uk/investors/reports-accounts. 7 Silvia Federici, Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body and Primitive Accumulation (Autonomedia, 2004), 91. 8 Cranswick plc, Annual Report & Accounts 2026, 167, note 15. 9 MPA Global Solutions Ltd., Environmental Impact Assessment: Proposed Pig Finishing Unit, Cherry Tree Farm, Stow Bedon, Norfolk, report for Wayland Farms Ltd., prepared by Aamer Raza, January 2019, planning application 3PL/2017/0878/F, Breckland Council Planning Public Access, https://publicportal.breckland.gov. uk/planning. 5
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
Fig. 1 The three sites of a pig production chain in Norfolk. Base map: Google Maps, map data © 2026 Google, accessed September 9, 2026. Aerial views: Google Earth, imagery from April 20, 2025 (breeding unit, slaughterhouse) and March 8, 2025 (finishing unit), © 2025 Airbus, accessed September 9, 2026. Annotations by the author.
87
88
FROM ANIMAL TO COMMODITY
Fig. 2 The breeding unit: the two communal sow fields, where sows are kept together for insemination and during pregnancy (above), and the individual farrowing and suckling plots (below). Google Earth, imagery © 2025 Airbus, dated April 20, 2025, accessed September 9, 2026.
Fig. 3 Cherry Tree Farm. Existing site 3D model (above) and proposed site 3D model (below). Clayland Architects, drawing no. 1717/03, Expansion of Existing Piggery Farm, Cherry Tree Farm, Stow Bedon, for Wayland Farms Ltd., file ‘1717 03 Existing and Proposed Site 3D Model. pdf’, planning application 3PL/2017/0878/F, Breckland Council Planning Public Access.
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
built environment. The second is how the built environment controls and reshapes the living animal, extending Bruno Latour’s argument that artefacts prescribe behaviour.10 The third is how the body resists the making and remaking of itself by non-living matter, following Tony Weis’s concept of biophysical instabilities that industrial farming has to constantly override.11 The fourth is how buildings benefit from what Les Beldo calls “metabolic labor”: the voluntary and involuntary vital processes of the animal, extracted by industrial farming.12 The slaughterhouse is the last site of the production chain, at which the building takes the previously produced and constructed body apart, and the animal leaves the site distributed between products, by-products, effluent, and air. The site’s archive contains eighteen years of planning documents, recording the facility’s continuous modifications and extensions, yet never counting the number of animals slaughtered or presenting any of the works as an expansion of output.13 Sigfried Giedion’s obstacle—“killing itself then cannot be mechanized”14—has since been overcome by “the best available technology for this purpose,”15 a phrase that is used to describe the CO2 gas chamber system: a version of a paternoster lift (fig. 4), although this one stops at the bottom for several minutes for the CO2 to take its permanent effect. The neutrality of killing that Giedion described has since spread into every aspect of production, including its architectural planning: the archive that repeatedly specifies the colour of the cladding down to an RAL number does not, in most applications, even discuss the building’s purpose, which is to provide the company with the means to turn its “biological assets” into commodities.
10 Bruno Latour, “Where Are the Missing Masses? The Sociology of a Few Mundane Artifacts,” in Shaping Technology/Building Society: Studies in Sociotechnical Change, ed. Wiebe E. Bijker and John Law (MIT Press, 1992), 225–58. 11 Tony Weis, The Ecological Hoofprint: The Global Burden of Industrial Livestock (Zed Books, 2013), 115–21. 12 Les Beldo, “Metabolic Labor: Broiler Chickens and the Exploitation of Vitality,” Environmental Humanities 9, no. 1 (2017): 108–28. 13 For the site’s planning record, see the applications for Cranswick Country Foods (Norfolk), Brandon Road, Watton, from 3PL/2008/0547/O to PL/2025/1874/ FMIN, Breckland Council Planning Public Access, https://publicportal. breckland.gov.uk/planning. On the absence of any declared increase in output, see for example Norfolk County Council, highways consultation response, August 14, 2013, planning application 3PL/2013/0690/F (“there is no increase in output intended as a result of this proposal”); and Cranswick Country Foods (Norfolk), supporting statement, Rev A, 2025, planning application PL/2025/0953/FMIN (“No additional staff or production capacity is proposed”). 14 Sigfried Giedion, Mechanization Takes Command: A Contribution to Anonymous History (Oxford University Press, 1948), 246. 15 Cranswick Country Foods (Norfolk), planning statement, 2016, prepared by Peter Haddon and Partners Architects, file “PLANNING STATEMENT.pdf,” planning application 3PL/2016/0573/F, Breckland Council Planning Public Access, https://publicportal.breckland.gov.uk/planning/.
89
90
FROM ANIMAL TO COMMODITY
Fig. 4 A CO2 stunning lift. Marel, Backloader G3 RelaX, product brochure, ref. Jan17-ENG, accessed September 9, 2026.
(IN)VISIBLE PRODUCTS
Finally, after the rendering of bodies comes the rendering of image.16 The company calls the chain “farm to fork” and illustrates it with images of sows on green grass,17 while the corporate archive performs a linguistic operation and produces what Carol J. Adams calls an “absent referent.”18 But the concealment also takes a built form, different at each stage: the absent building of breeding, the anonymous building of finishing, the closed building of slaughter. Therefore, vocabulary and architecture work together to execute the commodification of the living body, simultaneously concealing meaning and matter. The carbon footprint of the company’s sites is offset across three continents,19 returning the buildings to the planetary scale. What presents itself as how modern food is appears in built form as a settlement between profit, the animal’s biology, and regulation at different scales; a settlement struck in steel and concrete and capable of being struck otherwise, as the histories of these buildings record.
16 On the double sense of rendering (the industrial processing of animal remains and the making of a copy) see Nicole Shukin, Animal Capital: Rendering Life in Biopolitical Times (University of Minnesota Press, 2009), 20. 17 “From Farm to Fork,” Cranswick plc, accessed September 9, 2026, https:// cranswick.plc.uk/our-story-old/from-farm-to-fork. 18 Carol J. Adams, The Sexual Politics of Meat: A Feminist-Vegetarian Critical Theory, 20th anniversary ed. (Continuum, 2010), 66. 19 Cranswick plc, Carbon Neutral Manufacturing: Qualifying Explanatory Statement, PAS 2060:2014 (Cranswick plc, 2023), “CCF Watton — Emission Management” and “Climate Contribution Portfolio,” https://cranswick.plc.uk/responsibility/ group-policies-reports.
91
PUBLICATION TEAM María Devecyan Richard Fryer Dávid Pieš
SYMPOSIUM TEAM Federica Ionta Rose McEnroe Elizaveta Provotorova
EXHIBITION TEAM María Devecyan Sherry Ho Dávid Pieš Lucinda Warchol