The Summation Quarterly, Winter 2021

Announcements ESRBA Member Spotlight Young Lawyers Division The Bottom Line

p. 6 p. 7 p. 17 p. 18

THE C. ROGER VINSON

AMERICAN INN OF COURT

Winter 2021 | VOLUME 10, ISSUE 4 | ESRBA.COM

Want More

Clients?

JOIN OUR

LAWYER

REFERRAL

SERVICE

L arry a. a . M atthews Certified Supreme Court Mediator • Proven experience in the resolution of civil and commercial disputes

• No cancellation or administrative fees • No multiple parties fees

• Professional conference & meeting rooms

• Experience in arbitration and other dispute resolutions • Available throughout the Florida Panhandle and South Alabama area

• Video Conferencing Available

SIGN UP TODAY CONTACT US AT

850.434.6009 OR LRS@ESRBA.COM

ESRBA.COM 913 Gulf Breeze Parkway, Suite 33 Gulf Breeze, FL 32561 | 850.434.2200 Pensacola | Panama City | Mobile, AL lmatthews@matthewshigginslaw.com MatthewsHigginsLaw.com

MONTHLY UPDATES KNOWLEDGEABLE STAFF LOW ANNUAL FEE

Winter 2021 | 3

ESRBA Member Discounts Caseroads

Caseroads features rich practice management software that costs up to 70% less than other providers. It is designed to be incredibly easy to use and allows you to securely work from anywhere.

Get all the functionality you need for one low price per user. Let us help you get started with a risk free, 30-day no cost trial plus a 10% discount for Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association members using the promo code ESRBA10.

Digital Boardwalk

Award-winning technology services for firms of all sizes. ESRBA members can achieve reliability, security and peace of mind through special pricing from Digital Boardwalk, recently named one of the top managed service providers in Florida on the prestigious 2020 annual Channel Futures MSP 501 rankings. The ESRBA-exclusive offer is extended on new recurring and non-recurring services including managed I. T. and subscription services, support, installation fees, labor and more. Sign up at www. digitalboardwalk.com/esrba.

Documate

Documate is an easy-to-use, powerful document automation platform for building both internal and client-facing tools. It allows for complex conditional logic, numerical/date calculations, collecting lists, payment/signature/CMS integrations, client-facing capabilities, client portal and whitelabeling to build your own “TurboTax” for law. Get 10% off and a free trial with code ESRBA10. Visit www.documate. org or book a live demo at www.calendly.com/ documate.

Gravity Legal

Get paid faster, reduce your accounts receivable, take electronic payments into trust, accept credit card, debit cards and eCheck and integrate with many of your existing systems. Gravity Legal is the financial payments and money management platform for innovative entrepreneurial attorneys and law firms. ESRBA members have the option of two compelling pricing plans and receive a year of free ACH(eCheck) on transactions up to $15,000.

Sign up at gravity-legal.com/esrba.

Phipps Reporting

Phipps Reporting is your one-stop shop for your litigation needs: court reporting, process serving, video recording, interpreting services, case management, trial litigation support, on-line notary services. Offices from Miami to Panama City; satellite offices worldwide. Contact Joann Gore, Business Development Director, to schedule FREE training or services: jgore@phippsreporting.com, 850-610-0227.

Red Cave Law Firm Consulting

Members can access world-class business management consulting for law firms at an exclusive discount. We can help you to build a modern law firm, get efficient and increase your revenue. Start today! redcavelegal.com/esrba.

National Purchasing Partners (NPP)

Through a partnership with National Purchasing Partners (NPP), ESRBA members can receive discounts and special offers from the national retailers listed below. NPP is a B2B marketplace where members can save on products and services they use every day. Membership with NPP is FREE. To access the discounts listed below and more, enroll your company today!

American Express

Business cards for companies of all sizes. Get built in tools, perks and rewards for businesses like yours—backed by the award-winning customer service and support of American Express. Choose the right solutions for your business. Sign up and save at mynpp.com/association/esrba/.

Hotelogical

Receive up to 70% OFF hotels and resorts worldwide with a FREE access to Hotelogical’s unpublished, member-only rates. Start saving with special member deals at mynpp.com/association/ esrba/.

Office Depot

With more than 16,000 in-stock office supply products, Office Depot products and services meet the needs of NPP members nationwide. Sign up and save at mynpp.com/association/esrba/.

Priceline

NPP members save up to 25% on select hotels when packaged with a rental car, flight or additional hotel booking. Sign up to access deeply discounted hotel deals worldwide at mynpp.com/ association/esrba/.

Verizon Wireless

Eligible businesses can receive 22% OFF monthly access fees* and up to 35% OFF select smartphones, tablets and accessories. Enroll your business and start saving with the nation’s largest, most reliable 4G LTE network at mynpp.com/ association/esrba/.

For more information and details pertaining to ESRBA’s Member Discount partners, please visit esrba.com/for-attorneys/member-discounts/.

Business participation in the ESRBA Member Benefits & Discount Program does not constitute endorsement, recommendation or favoring by ESRBA.

Contents 12

10

Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association 260 South Tarragona Street, Suite 160 Pensacola, FL 32502 Phone: 850.434.8135 email: esrba@esrba.com Lawyer Referral Service: 850.434.6009

Member Services Coordinator Stephen Hayward stephen@esrba.com Lawyer Referral Service Marilyn Kelley lrs@esrba.com

Executive Director Jeff Nall jeff@esrba.com

19

Published quarterly by the Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association as a service to its membership.

Articles appearing in The Summation are not to be construed as official expressions of the views of the Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association. Official positions are expressed only by formal resolutions adopted by a majority of the membership and will be so designated when published. Editorials are expressions of the opinion of the Editor.

Due date for all advertisements, articles and announcements is the first of the month for the issue you wish to advertise in.

Address all editorial correspondence to the Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association office. For all inquiries concerning advertising rates contact Ballinger Publishing.

The Summation Committee is dedicated to providing a publication to the legal community which contains articles that are accurate, informative, entertaining, educational, relevant and timely.

ESRBA Member Discounts

Page 3

From the President

Page 5

Announcements

Page 6

On the Move

Page 7

Better Know a Local Attorney: ESRBA Member Spotlight

Page 7

Sponsor Profiles

Page 8

Leo Thomas: Trailblazing Visionary and Dedicated Family Man

Page 10

News from the Clerk of the Circuit Court and Comptroller

Page 11

Feature - The C. Roger Vinson American Inn of Court

Page 12

Make Supporting our Foundation a Year-end Tradition

Page 15

Report from the Board of Governors

Page 16

Young Lawyer’s Division

Page 17

The Bottom Line

Page 18

Editor Morgan Cole

Argo Corner

Page 19

Assistant Editor Dakota Parks

October Bar Meeting Photos

Page 20

Summation Committee If you have any comments or suggestions about The Summation, please feel free to express them to any of the committee members. If you would like to join the committee, please call the Bar office at 434.8135.

Gerald McGill Caroline Peterson Jenice Jones Sheryl Lowenthal

Charlie Penrod Codey Leigh Allison Newton Shekka Drayton

Christine Kelly Garrett Hallbauer Dakota Parks

Owner Malcolm Ballinger

Art Director Guy Stevens

Publisher Malcolm Ballinger

Graphic Designer & Ad Coordinator Garrett Hallbauer

Executive Editor Kelly Oden

Sales & Marketing Paula Rode, ext. 28 Becky Hildebrand, ext. 23

Visit our Website at BallingerPublishing.com Editorial Offices: 21 East Garden Street, Suite 205 | Pensacola, Florida 32502 850-433-1166 | Fax: 850-435-9174 Reproduction or use of the contents herein is prohibited without written permission from the publisher.

Comments and opinions expressed in this magazine represent the personal views of the individuals to whom they are attributed and/or the person identified as the author of the article, and they are not necessarily those of the publisher. This magazine accepts no responsibility for these opinions. The publisher reserves the right to edit all manuscripts. All advertising information is the responsibility of the individual advertiser. Appearance in this magazine does not necessarily reflect endorsement of any products or services by Ballinger Publishing. © 2021 Ballinger Publishing. All Rights Reserved.

Winter 2021 | 5

From the President Greetings and Happy Holidays colleagues, partners and friends!

As we approach the end of 2021, I want to tell you how personally thankful I am for each of you and your support. Thus, I want to share some of our recent accomplishments and tell you about the good that (together) we’ll be continuing to do for our association, our profession and our community.

Garrett P. LaBorde

It has certainly been a very busy fall… Just in the last quarter, we have envisioned and launched our Strategic Plan, continued to expand our number of community sponsors, held a fantastic Roundtable & Mixer with the Board of the Escambia County Medical Society (with several ideas for joint community projects/member events already in the works) and we hosted a number of valuable CLEs and several fantastic monthly Bar Lunches!

On November 5th, we hosted a very informative Town Hall meeting with our 1st Judicial Circuit Board of Governors Representative Jeremy Branning to gather member input on the recent recommendations of the Supreme Court’s Special Committee to Improve the Delivery of Legal Services.

On November 8th, Circuit Judge Gary Bergosh was ESRBA’s honoree at the statewide inaugural “The Florida Patriot: Honoring Legal Leader Veterans” virtual event. Nine voluntary bar associations from across the state came together to create the event and recognize veteran leadership in the legal community and military service. It was my pleasure to join Judge Bergosh in his chambers to attend the event and present this distinguished award to him in person.

At our November Executive Council meeting, following helpful input from our members, we

approved our official Strategic Plan to guide us through the remainder of this Bar year and to prepare the association for years to come. The Strategic Planning process was facilitated by Rebecca Bandy and Katie Young, respectively the Executive Director and Assistant Director with The Florida Bar’s Henry Latimer Center for Professionalism, in coordination with our Executive Director, Jeff Nall.

Our ESRBA committees have been hard at work and includes the newly formed: Communications, Social Media and Web Committee (Co-Chaired by Shekka Drayton and Joe Passeretti) and our long-needed Diversity and Inclusion Committee (Chaired

by Shekka Drayton). Keep your eyes on ESRBA social media and eblasts for a number of Substantive (practice area) Committees that we’ll be creating/reactivating for you to join as well.

Finally, during these holidays and as we get ready for 2022, we have much to be thankful for and even MORE to look forward to. So, I hope you will join us for our big 2021 ESRBA Holiday Party on December 16th at 5eleven Palafox from 6 pm until 8 pm. Not only is this year’s expanded, festive, sophisticated event free, it is open to all members, Judges, sponsors, community partners and their guests. We are especially delighted that Florida Bar President Mike Tanner will be our special guest! I would like to personally thank the event sponsors listed on page 9.

I always welcome your input on ways to ever-better serve you, the ESRBA and our communities!

Happy Holidays!

6 | The Summation

Announcements The Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association

Executive Council Officers President Garrett P. LaBorde Vice President Aaron T. McCurdy Secretary Christine A. Kelly Fausel Treasurer Joe Passeretti Immediate Past President Heather F. Lindsay Executive Council Ryan Cardoso Shekka Drayton Jessica Etherton Rebecca Gilliland Joe Kirkland Stephen Luongo John Mahoney II Amie Remington Rachel Sheffield Aaron Watson Young Lawyer Representative Andrew Spencer

Don’t forget that members save 40% on our ever expanding library of CLEs

Scan this QR code to check out our current selection of great CLE programming!

Stay current on everything going on with the Escambia – Santa Rosa County Bar Association

Be sure to check out the ESRBA website for all upcoming events.

Coming Soon!

Be on the lookout for the new 2022 Membership Directories!

Circuit Judge Gary Bergosh Honored at The Florida Patriot: Honoring Legal Leader Veterans Event Circuit Judge Gary Bergosh was recently selected by the Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association to be honored at the statewide inaugural The Florida Patriot: Honoring Legal Leader Veterans virtual event on Monday, November 8, 2021.

More than 100 Florida voluntary bar leaders and members of the judiciary gathered to honor the nine award recipients. The honorees were selected by the participating voluntary bar associations for their leadership in the legal community and military service. Judge Bergosh was presented his award by Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association President Garrett LaBorde.

The Florida Bar President Mike Tanner provided a welcome, which was followed by a key note address from Maria Chapa Lopez, 20th United States Attorney for the Middle District of Florida.

Also recognized at the event were honorees Brigadier General Edward Merrigan (Broward County Bar Association), Judge Daryl Trawick (Dade County Bar Association), Judge Luis Delgado Jr. (Palm Beach County Bar Association), Judge Jerry Brewer (Orange County Bar Association), Matthew Hall, Esquire (Hillsborough County Bar Association), Judge Steve Berlin (St. Petersburg Bar Association), Judge Lee Haworth (Sarasota Bar Association) and Judge Mose Floyd ( Jacksonville Bar Association).

Zarzaur Receives Philanthropy Award from the West Florida Chapter of the Association of Fundraising Professionals Joe Zarzaur, a Board-Certified Civil Trial Lawyer and founder of Zarzaur Law, P.A., received the Outstanding Business of The Year award by the West Florida Chapter of the Association of Fundraising Professionals. This award is in recognition of Zarzaur Law’s commitment to the local community.

“Joe and the entire Zarzaur Law Firm could not be more deserving of the AFP’s Outstanding Corporation Award. It’s not often that you see a small company do so much good for the community.” Said Stacey Kostevicki, Executive Director of Gulf Coast Kids’ House, “From the Gallery Night Legal Graffiti, which has benefited nearly every charity agency in the area to Joe’s sponsorship of the Gavel Guys and Gavel Girls. Zarzaur Law seeks to highlight the good in the community and to seek justice for their clients and the citizens of Escambia County.”

While there are many events, programs and community initiatives that Joe Zarzaur and the team of Zarzaur Law have been a part of, the most recognized philanthropic activity led by the firm is “Legal Graffiti.”

“Legal Graffiti” is an event hosted at Zarzaur Law during each Gallery Night in downtown Pensacola. “Legal Graffiti” is an opportunity for anyone to make a donation and then create artwork on the recycled billboard vinyl covered wall at the Zarzaur Law office building using spray paint. The event raises money for non-profits & charities within the area. Donations are matched by the firm and given to the charity of choice. Recipients include ARC Gateway, American Cancer Society, Big Brothers Big Sisters of NWFL, Manna Food Pantries, Pathways for Change, Autism Pensacola, Emerald Coast Legal Aid, Guardian Ad Litem, Favor House and Gulf Coast Kids’ House just to name a few.

National Philanthropy Day is designed to celebrate and highlight the accomplishments of giving, volunteering and charitable engagement within our community.

“In the past seven years of hosting the “Legal Graffiti” event, the firm has donated more than $100,000 to local charities.” Joe Zarzaur, Owner of Zarzaur Law, P.A. “We are honored and humbled to receive this recognition and plan to continue our outreach efforts and make a lasting impact in our community.”

The Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Foundation

Board of Directors Officers President Shekka Drayton Vice President D. Steve Traylor, Jr. Secretary & Treasurer John “Buz” Windham Directors Sheldon Bernau Jeremy Branning Jodi Dubose Stephen Echsner Cameron Townes Gore Kristin Haul Garrett P. LaBorde (ESRBA President) Heather Lindsay Patrick Martin Adrianna Spain Warren Todd Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association Young Lawyers Division

Board of Directors Officers President Andrew Spencer Vice President Michelle Nguyen Treasurer Logan Sliva Secretary Brooke DiSalvo Directors Travis Morock Cecily Parker

We’re Social! Connect with us on social media.

ESRBA FACEBOOK FACEBOOK.COM/ESRBAFL

YLD FACEBOOOK FACEBOOK.COM/ESRBAYLD

TWITTER TWITTER.COM/ESRBAFL

LINKEDIN LINKEDIN.COM/COMPANY/ESCAMBIASANTA-ROSA-BAR-ASSOCIATION

Winter 2021 | 7

On the Move Moorhead Law Group is pleased to announce that Trip Maygarden has joined the firm’s real estate practice group. His primary focus is real estate law, including the acquisition, sale, leasing, financing and development of real property.

“Trip is an excellent addition to our team. His legal expertise and commitment to our community make him a perfect fit,” says Steve Moorhead, Founder and Managing Partner of the firm.

Trip received his bachelor’s degree from the University of Alabama and his law degree from Cumberland School of Law. As a native of Pensacola, he is proud to serve the legal needs of the

community in which he was raised.

He and his wife, Adrienne, live in Gulf Breeze and are the proud parents to one child. In his limited free time, Trip serves on several charitable and civic organizations and enjoys Alabama football.

Emmanuel Sheppard & Condon is pleased to announce that Clay H. Whittaker has joined the firm as an attorney in the construction law practice group. Clay will work alongside the firm’s experienced 26 attorneys and 40+ staff members who proudly serve clients from offices in Pensacola, Pace, South Walton and Tallahassee.

Board-certified by the Florida Bar in Construction Law since 2016, Clay represents developers, owners, design professionals, contractors and subcontractors in all matters related to construction.

In addition to his construction practice, Clay handles all matters of domestic adoptions, including newborn, stepparent, relative, adult and second parent adoptions. Clay is a licensed attorney in Florida and Alabama and practices in both state and federal courts.

Beggs & Lane is pleased to announce that Susan J. Salamone has joined the firm as an associate in its Pensacola

office. Ms. Salamone is a member of the firm’s Real Estate Group. Ms. Salamone assists the Real Estate Group primarily in the areas of commercial and residential real estate transactions, commercial lending transactions and general business transactions.

“We are glad to have Susan on our team. Her background and talent will be an asset to our clients and the firm,” said J. Nixon Daniel, III, managing partner at Beggs and Lane.

Ms. Salamone received her juris doctorate with honors from Loyola University New Orleans in 2014.

Better Know a Local Attorney ESRBA Member Spotlight

A

special thank you to one of our newest members, Madison Leonard

for volunteering to be the second entry in the ESRBA’s member spotlight series, Better Know a Local Attorney.

Madison Leonard is an Associate Attorney in Moorhead Law Group’s Pensacola office.

Madison earned her law degree, cum laude, from Mississippi College School of Law in Jackson, Mississippi. Throughout law school, Madison externed at the Madison/Rankin County

Circuit Court, served as Vice President of the Women’s Student Bar Association and served Moorhead Law Group as a law clerk. Prior to law school, she played college soccer for Mississippi College for four years.

Madison was born and raised in Pensacola and is excited to help serve the community she loves so dearly at a firm that feels like family. In her spare time, Madison enjoys reading, running, spending time with family and enjoying everything Pensacola has to offer.

ESRBA: Favorite fictional lawyer?

ML: Vincent “Vinny” Gambini.

ESRBA: Who are your mentors/ role models?

ML: In general, my greatest mentors and role models are my parents: Keith and Melinda Leonard. In the legal field, my mentors are

the great attorneys I have the privilege of working with at Moorhead Law Group.

ESRBA: When you aren’t in the office, where might we find you?

ML: Spending time with friends or family!

ESRBA: What is your favorite part about practicing law?

ML: The ability to form meaningful relationships with a variety of different people.

ESRBA: What made you decide to join Moorhead Law Group?

ML: I have been a law clerk at Moorhead Law Group for three years while on breaks from school, so everyone already felt like family. It was a no brainer to come back and join as an attorney!

ESRBA: How does it feel to pass the Florida Bar Exam?

ML: SO good!! I checked the list several different times throughout the day just to make sure it was real. I was so relieved, proud, excited and emotional all at the same time. It was a very good day!

ESRBA: What’s your coffee order or favorite mid-day snack?

ML: My go-to snack is popcorn.

Every time!

ESRBA: Final Question, Law & Order: Great TV series or Greatest TV Series?

ML: Very close to being the greatest… but I think I would have to pick The Office over everything else!

I prefer to watch feel-good, non-law related TV shows in my free time!

8 | The Summation

Sponsor Profiles across various practice areas such as Business Law, Personal Injury, Family Law, Community Association Law, Real Estate Law, Employment Law, Construction Law and Criminal Defense. The firm has office locations along the Gulf Coast in Pensacola, Pace, South Walton and Tallahassee, as well virtual appointments.

Emmanuel Sheppard & Condon

E

mmanuel Sheppard & Condon is a fullservice law firm dedicated to protecting individual’s and businesses’ interests. Experienced, effective and evolving since 1913, Emmanuel Sheppard & Condon stands at the ready to tackle legal issues across a broad spectrum of practice areas. Our team of attorneys, paralegals and staff help individuals, small businesses, employers and major corporations

Our experienced attorneys are recognized as leaders in their areas of practices and in the community, serving on many legal and philanthropic boards. Many of our attorneys carry esteemed distinctions being board-certified

by The Florida Bar. Their ongoing dedication to their profession is an example of how Emmanuel Sheppard & Condon has our clients’ best interests at heart. Our firm was honored with Martindale Hubbell’s most prestigious AV rating, which is given to only 5% of lawyers across the United States, as well as awarded “Best Law Firm” by local publications, three years

in a row. Our firm is a proven asset, and we are ready to fight for you.

Maintaining strong client relationships is not only important to us, but essential in how we practice law. Emmanuel Sheppard and Condon’s commitment to the people living along the Gulf Coast is reflected in its many charitable, entrepreneurial and educational initiatives. We’re proud to call this region home and we believe in giving back to the community. Over the years, we’ve provided services in the aftermath of natural disasters, offered scholarships and more. The firm also has a long history of pro bono service, offering essential legal services to selected individuals and organizations. We will continue this tradition of standing with the Gulf Coast for years to come.

For more information about Emmanuel Sheppard and Condon, visit esclaw.com.

Trinitas Christian School S

ince 1999, Trinitas Christian School has been partnering with parents in the Greater Pensacola area to provide something very unique: a Christ-centered classical education in a stimulating academic environment. The academics at Trinitas are on par with high-pressure prep schools but without that kind of pressure.

Our model isn’t based on students competing against each other in the classroom, but on students glorifying God with their very best, day-in and day-out. Trinitas teachers encourage students to take satisfaction in doing their best with the abilities and resources

God has given them. Remarkably, this focus produces more than just high academics.

Trinitas offers solid academics and high standards of behavior within a loving and safe Christian environment. Our teachers go beyond teaching subjects and pour themselves into forming virtue and character in the students. Our students thrive in a Christian community that affirms and strengthens their faith. Their affections are shaped so that they delight in core studies such as Latin, Greek and rhetoric; activities such as art, music, poetry and drama; and

extra-curriculars such as athletics and mock trial.

Are you are looking for a school where parents are welcomed?

Where like-minded families create a culture and community that

extends beyond the school day? If you are searching for a school that embodies all these elements—a school that educates children not only for graduation but for all of life—visit trinitaschristian.org to schedule a school tour today.

SCAN THE QR CODE TO JOIN US

@ 5ELEVEN PALAFOX THURSDAY, DECEMBER 16TH

TIME: 6-8 PM

SPECIAL GUEST : FL BAR PRESIDENT MIKE TANNER HOLIDAY MUSIC BY THE GUFFMAN TRIO HORS D'OEUVRES / CASH BAR 1 BEVERAGE TICKET PER PERSON THANK YOU TO OUR SPONSORS HOLIDAY MUSIC BY THE GUFFMAN TRIO CATERED HORS D'OEUVRES / BAR

10 | The Summation

Leo Thomas:

Trailblazing Visionary and Dedicated Family Man

by Virginia Buchanan, Esquire

I

t was a cold Pensacola morning on January 28, 1977, around 3 a.m. when Joyce Hawthorne shot her husband to death while he lay in his bed. She shot him with nine bullets from five different guns. Afterwards, she called the police and reported that she killed him. This seemingly open and shut case exemplifies what Leo Thomas did best as a criminal defense attorney. He defended Joyce at each of the three trial proceedings for her husband’s death. In the first trial, she was convicted of murder in the first degree. Leo appealed, and it was reversed. In her second trial, she was convicted of second degree murder. Leo appealed, and it, too, was reversed. In the third trial, she was convicted of manslaughter. Leo appealed, and, alas, it was also reversed.

In each trial, Leo brilliantly and timely identified evidentiary and other issues that he believed prejudiced his client’s right to a fair trial, and each time he persuaded the appellate court to give Ms. Hawthorne another opportunity for justice. After the third trial and third successful appeal, Leo filed a motion to dismiss, and the trial judge dismissed the case entirely, declaring that it would be cruel and unusual punishment to put this woman through yet another trial. Leo raised and successfully used for the first time the battered woman syndrome as a justifiable form of self-defense. Because of his tireless efforts, the court allowed both the abuse and threats directed to Ms. Hawthorne and her children, as well as the psychological harm that resulted from the abuse, to be presented to the jury. The legal landscape changed dramatically for battered spouses after this case. It was widely reported in the legal literature but also in popular media, being the subject of books, articles, newspaper headlines (including the New York Times) and even a Phil Donahue segment. “The Hawthorne case reflected how tenacious he was and demonstrated the superb lawyering that was typical of Leo Thomas,” said Clay Mitchell, his law partner.

“Throughout his years of practice, Leo showed remarkable wisdom and uncanny ability in the cases he handled,” Mitchell said.

Leo was a true stereotypical Italian: he loved his family and great Italian food. His mom,

Clay Mitchell, Leo Thomas, Mark Proctor, Troy Rafferty and Mike Papantonio

Sandra Garcia, was born in Sicily and lived there until she moved to New York, where Leo was born. She affectionately called Leo “DonLeo” and was totally dedicated to him, and he to her, until her death at the age of 104 years. Leo’s Dad disappeared from the family home when Leo was 14, and the rumor is that he was shot to death in a poker game. Leo became the man of the family and took on a lot of responsibility. Before becoming a lawyer, Leo had positions that were challenging and dangerous, but because he was raised in the “Spanish Harlem” section of New York, he had no fear. He completed his military service in the United States Army where he served as a member of the military police. He later worked as a detective with the predecessor agency of the DEA in what was known then as the Federal Bureau of Narcotics (FBN). As an undercover agent, he participated in numerous high-level investigations, including the case that was the subject of the movie The French Connection.

Although the intrigue was at times intoxicating, Leo wanted a different life, one in which he could use his knowledge of the criminal justice system and have a family of his own. His brilliance had been revealed at Columbia University, and he was able to transition readily to being a high profile and extremely successful criminal defense lawyer.

When he wasn’t lawyering, he was busy with family and friends.

Leo’s daughter, Melina, laughingly says that her Dad was a foodie—“he loved eating, talking about eating and planning to eat.” She also says that he was a cigar aficionado who reveled in the aroma and taste of a great Cuban. He loved poker night at Stanley Levin’s, playing softball with the Levin Papantonio firm team, news from all outlets, the New Orleans Saints and trips to Disney with the family at Bar Convention time. Melina described him as being loving and generous to a fault—always there to help when he was needed.

Those of us who were lucky enough to work with him on a daily basis had the opportunity and privilege to admire this highly motivated, brilliant lawyer in action, and we were luckier still that we could call him “friend.” We will cherish always the memories of Leo and David Levin sharing insults and insights on Blab TV’s Law Line, as well as the images of Clay and Leo discussing world issues, along with Leo and Troy trading barbs at a fast and furious pace. Treasured times among people who loved and respected one another.

We have lost some great folks who are larger than life and who give more than they take.

Leo is one of them.

Winter 2021 | 11

News from the Clerk of the Circuit Court and Comptroller Pam Childers

Marsy’s Law and Court Records – What You Need to Know

O

n Thursday, November 18, 2021, the Supreme Court of Florida issued SC20-1128, creating rule 2.423 of the Florida Rules of General Practice and Judicial Administration (“rule 2.423” or the “rule”).

Rule 2.423 governs the public access to and the protection of confidential crime victim information and was adopted in response to the recent victims’ rights constitutional amendment, known as “Marsy’s Law,” found at art. I, §16(b)of the Florida Constitution. The rule went into effect immediately upon release of the Supreme Court’s opinion.

Who is Marsy? Marsalee (Marsy) Ann Nicholas was a California college student who was stalked and murdered by an ex-boyfriend in November 1983. Shortly after her murder, Marsy’s family (having no idea the ex-boyfriend had been released on bail) was confronted by him at a local market.

Marsy’s Law was established to provide crime victims and their families with certain rights to be protected with the same vigor as the protections of the accused. The Supreme Court’s implementation of Marsy’s Law in SC20-1128 specifically provides that “… confidential crime victim information is determined to be confidential on the grounds that confidentiality is required to comply with the Florida Constitution.”

What is confidential crime victim information?

As defined by rule 2.423, confidential crime victim information “…means any information contained within a court record that could be used to locate or harass the victim or the victim’s family, or which could disclose confidential or

privileged information of the victim.” Who is the victim? For the purposes of the rule, the victim is defined in part as “…a person who suffers…harm as the result of the commission or attempted commission of a crime…against whom the crime…is committed.” Victim also includes “…the victim’s lawful representative, the parent or guardian of a minor victim or the next of kin of a homicide victim…” but does not include the accused.

How is confidential crime victim information designated? Rule 2.423 requires that the filer of an initial charging document shall prominently indicate the existence of confidential crime victim information. Upon the indication of existence of such information by the filer, the Clerk of Court (the “Clerk”) is required to designate and maintain the confidentiality of such information within the initial charging document. If the initial charging document does not contain confidential crime victim information filers of subsequent filings must ascertain whether the document contains confidential crime victim information. If so, the filer must file a Notice of Confidential Crime Victim Information within Court Filing (the “Notice”). The Notice form is attached as Appendix A to SC20-1128.

Who else may request the designation of crime victim information? Rule 2.423(d)(3) also allows the following person(s) to file the Notice: a crime victim; a party; or any affected nonparty. A crime victim, party or affected nonparty may utilize the Notice to identify the location of previously filed confidential crime victim information. Any and all filers

of subsequent court filings after designation of confidential crime victim information must either limit such information or file the Notice with each subsequent court filing if the filing contains confidential crime victim information.

What is the Clerk of Court’s role when the Notice is filed? The rule requires the Clerk to review all filings subject to the Notice to determine whether the information is confidential subject to art. I, §16(b) (5), Fla. Const. If the Clerk determines the information is confidential, the Clerk shall maintain the confidentiality of any such information within the court record.

If, however, the Clerk determines that the information is not confidential, the filer of the Notice shall be notified by the Clerk in writing within five days of the filing of the Notice.

The filer of the Notice may then file a motion pursuant to rule 2.420(d)(3). The information will be maintained by the Clerk as confidential for 10 days, unless a motion is filed within the 10 day period.

We encourage you to take a moment to review rule 2.423 and the new Notice of Confidential Crime Victim Information within Court Filing form. Please take note of the information required in the Notice and make sure to provide all of the information requested when submitting the Notice to ensure that requests for confidentiality can be processed quickly and efficiently.

Authored by Cassie Gilmore, Director of Court Services, Criminal, on behalf of Pam Childers, Clerk of the Circuit Court and Comptroller

12 | The Summation

THE C. ROGER VINSON AMERICAN INN OF COURT

by Elizabeth M. Timothy, Chief United States Magistrate Judge Northern District of Florida

I

can say with certainty that one of the highlights of my career has been the honor of serving as President of the Pensacola American Inn of Court for the past two years.1 It was a tumultuous time during my tenure, when the world seemed to have turned upside down overnight.

Lawyers’ familiar routines, such as attending depositions and hearings, engaging in mediation and trying cases in person, abruptly stopped. Seemingly without warning, state and federal courts around the country were faced with major problems in need of speedy resolution in order to ensure that justice continued to be served. At the same time, leaders of Inns around the country were faced with a daunting question: how to persevere, much less prosper, during a pandemic, knowing that the main benefit of Inn membership is in-person interaction, education and socialization. Before explaining how the Pensacola Inn fared, I will provide a historical background of the larger American Inns of Court concept—and why 2021 was such a monumental year for the Pensacola Inn.

organization should be founded.

He envisioned that a national organization could promote, establish and assist American Inns while promoting the Inns’ core goals—legal excellence, civility, professionalism and ethics. The committee later reported an enthusiastic “yes” to the Judicial Conference and proposed the creation of the AIC Foundation. The Conference agreed and thus endorsed the American Inns concept and the formation of a national structure.

The AIC Foundation was established in 1985.

The American Inns of Court (AIC) idea began in the late 1970s, spurred by then-Chief Justice Warren Burger’s vision of adapting the traditional English model of legal apprenticeship to the needs of the American legal system. Justice Burger’s vision ultimately led to the establishment of the first American Inn of Court in Utah just over forty years ago, in 1980.

By 1983, additional American Inns formed in the District of Columbia and three other states.

The essence of the AIC movement has been, and is, a recurring focus on honing the skills, civility and professionalism that epitomize effective advocacy.

To state it more formally: The Mission of the AIC and its individual chapters, such as ours here in Pensacola, is to advance the rule of law by achieving the highest level of, and fostering excellence in, professionalism— through example, education and mentoring. As is often said, the law is a noble profession, but that can remain true only if attorneys uphold their ethical obligations and advocate in a manner that befits their profession. This theme is common among all Inns.

In 1983, as Inns were forming around the country, Chief Justice Burger created a committee of the United States’ Judicial Conference to explore whether the American Inn concept was of value to the administration of justice in the United States and, if so, whether a national

The AIC movement has grown faster than any other organization of legal professionals. Today, there are nearly 400 chartered American Inns in forty-eight states, the District of Columbia, Guam and Tokyo and nearly 30,000 active members nationwide.

There are those who criticize Inns, claiming our professionalism efforts fail to reach the target audience. In other words, they say,

Winter 2021 | 13

we are “preaching to the choir.”

However, as former Florida Bar President Hank Coxe once responded, “It is okay to preach to the choir … as long as our efforts result in expanding the size of the choir.” And I’m proud to say that we have accomplished this in Pensacola.

The Pensacola American Inn of Court (PAIC) began thirty years ago, in 1991, when eight judges and sixteen attorneys met to formally organize an AIC Chapter in Pensacola. These “inaugural” judges and lawyers may fairly be described as the “who’s who” of the Pensacola legal community at the time.2 Since 1991, 600 local attorneys and judges have participated, and the PAIC’s current roster consists of about sixty-five active members. It could be larger, but it is limited to that size by design.

Eight judges still participate each year, and each judge is assigned to lead a team. The teams, which are also referred to as “pupillage groups,” vary slightly in size, but each team is comprised of “Masters”—attorneys with more than fifteen years of experience,

“Barristers”—attorneys with at least five years of experience and “Juniors”—attorneys with less than five years of experience.

The team designs are, in effect, an American adaptation of the pupillage system that is basic to the English Inns of Court. That is, they are designed to bridge the gap between formal law school education and legal practice by offering continuing education in the Common Law tradition, throughout all stages of an attorney’s career.

The PAIC’s active year generally follows the school year, from about September to May. Its members meet once a month to hear a team’s educational presentation. Each team presents once over the course of the term, and the presentations are followed by a social and dinner.

The PAIC also holds an end-ofyear party in June.

Our Inn was able to continue this tradition during the pandemic by offering a “hybrid” presentation format, providing members the option to attend each presentation in person at the federal courthouse, in

a socially-distanced space or remotely by Zoom. The post-presentation socials and end-of-year party were held in outdoor spaces. Remarkably, the PAIC’s attendance numbers were the same, if not better, than in years prior, and the new venue for the socials turned out to be preferred over the former, indoor space. So, all in all, the year was a success, despite the pandemic. It would not have been possible, however, were it not for the assistance of federal court staff—including Shane Shao (IT) and law clerks Allison Hunnicutt and Shannon Morris.

Likewise, the PAIC board was of invaluable assistance, and I am grateful to each of them ( Jeremy Branning, Ron Johnson, Judge David Langham and Dave McGee) for their support, encouragement and tireless assistance.

Turning now to the end-ofyear party, held in June 2021.

We gathered at the Hancock Whitney Club at the Blue Wahoos stadium, where we were treated to fantastic views and fabulous meals. The party was more formal than the usual PAIC end-of-year party, but such was only fitting, as the party was held in honor of our Inn’s thirty-year anniversary.

As I mentioned at the event, our Inn most definitely could not have survived and thrived for three decades were it not for the time and energy expended by so many dedicated and longstanding lawyer and judge members—each of whom has participated on a volunteer basis, often donating substantial time and even money without seeking any recognition whatsoever. Awards were presented to past-presidents and

attorneys with fifteen or more years of membership.3 I then presented awards— replicas of the original PAIC Charter—to two of the inaugural members in attendance, Ed Moore and Don Partington. I read the Charter’s introduction: Inasmuch as Roy M. Kinsey and H. Edward Moore and Donald H. Partington have made due and proper application to the American Inns of Court Foundation for a charter to organize, establish and carry on activities as a participating American Inn of the American Inns of Court Foundation... the American Inns of Court Foundation... does hereby grant American Inns of Court Foundation Charter No. 148 to the above-named applicants... [said chapter] to be known as the Pensacola American Inn of Court in Pensacola, Florida.

As those recognitions drew to a close, some in the audience began to notice that the back of the venue was filling with young people, obviously including elementary-school-aged children and older. It was a standingroom only crowd. It was then that I turned my attention to the Honorable C. Roger Vinson, who was sitting just a few feet in front of me with his wife, Ellen.

I announced that Judge Vinson, too, was a charter member and had served as the PAIC’s first President, and I presented a replica of the Charter to him as well. I then asked Judge Vinson to bear with me while I shared more information about our founding president’s impressive background. In summary, I noted the following:

14 | The Summation

Judge Vinson graduated from the United States Naval Academy in 1962 and then served for six years as a Naval Aviator. He obtained his law degree from Vanderbilt, where he served on the law review and was a Patrick Wilson Merit Scholar. He practiced law with Beggs & Lane in Pensacola for about twelve years, until he was appointed to the United States District Court for the Northern District of Florida by President Reagan in 1983. He has served continuously since that time, including seven years as Chief Judge.

Judge Vinson also served on the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, the United States Judicial Conference’s Advisory Committee on Civil Rules, the Judicial Conference’s Committee on Bankruptcy Administration, the Eleventh Circuit’s Pattern Jury Instruction Committee and the Eleventh Circuit’s Judicial Council and its Executive Committee.

He was President of the Eleventh Circuit District Judges Association and the Northwest Florida Federal Bar Association, among many other such positions.

Next, I announced that, considering Judge Vinson’s amazing career—and his instrumental role in forming the PAIC, it was not surprising that the board and membership had voted, unanimously, to

rename the Pensacola American Inn of Court to the C. Roger Vinson American Inn of Court.

The moment we had all been waiting for—well, everyone except Judge Vinson—had finally arrived! Remarkably, Judge Vinson had no idea this honor was about to be bestowed, as we somehow managed to keep the name change a secret from him. I presented a mounted, ceremonial charter to Judge Vinson, bearing his name, at which point it became obvious that the standing-room only crowd gathered for the occasion was Judge Vinson’s extended and proud family, dozens of them. It was heartwarming to see them there, to say the least. And I couldn’t help but notice the look exchanged between Judge Vinson and Ellen, which made clear that—much to his delight— Judge Vinson knew Ellen had played a role in the surprise.

After receiving the new Charter and learning of the renaming, Judge Vinson addressed the crowd. He humbly insisted that credit for the Inn’s founding belonged to others, including Ed Moore, Don Partington and Roy Kinsey, among others, in that regard. He reiterated the mission of the Inn, the Inn’s goal of professionalism and the undeniable value of mentoring.

He noted that attorneys are always mentoring, for better or worse, pointing out that even the most rudimentary of legal interactions can shape

perceptions in the community and among our peers. His comments were moving, and it was clear his heart was touched by the decision to rename our Inn in his honor. It is a moment I will never forget. As the evening concluded, Judge Vinson remained seated at the President’s table, posing for photographs with the parade of proud grandchildren, other family members and numerous well-wishers. Congratulations, Judge Vinson, on this welldeserved recognition.

I have now passed the “presidential gavel” to Judge Stephen A. Pitre, who will serve as president of the C. Roger Vinson American Inn of Court, for the 2021–2022 and 2022– 2023 terms. Judge Pitre kicked off the new year with a social in September 2021, during which he provided an inspirational message and welcome. Our teams

are formed, and our monthly educational programs began in October—and so the tradition continues. I have no doubt that Judge Pitre will lead our Inn with honor and determination, as the Inn embarks on its fourth decade and does so under a new name.

In conclusion, I take a moment to reflect on the discussions surrounding the decision to rename our Inn in honor of Judge Vinson. Much was said. The most poignant references were to Judge Vinson’s commitment to this Inn and his exemplification of patience, honor, manners and professionalism. Judge Vinson is the epitome of that for which the Inn stands and strives to instill in its members. I am grateful that efforts to rename the Inn reached fruition under my watch and on the occasion of the Inn’s thirtieth anniversary. Judge Vinson is a colleague, mentor and friend, who well-deserves this honor.

1

The Pensacola American Inn of Court is now known as the C. Roger Vinson American Inn of Court.

2

The judges were Roger Vinson, Susan M. Novotny, Lacey A. Collier, William J. Green, Michael Jones, John P. Kuder, Edward P. Nickinson, III, and G.J. Roark, III. The attorneys were H. Edward Moore, Roy M. Kinsey, Jr., Donald Partington, William H. Clark, Robert Mayes, A.G. Condon, Jr., Robert L. Crongeyer, Patrick G. Emmanuel, Fletcher Flemming, Robert P. Gaines, Larry Hill, T. Sol Johnson, Danny L. Kepner, Lefferts L. Mabie, Jr., James M. Wilson, and W.H.F. Wiltshire.

3

More specifically, awards were presented to longstanding members or past-presidents in attendance, including Judge Gary Bergosh (past-president (“PP”)), Judge Michael Allen (PP), Steven Baker, Philip Bates, Jeremy Branning, Judge Miles Davis (PP), Judge Ross Goodman (PP), Joseph Hammons, Ron Johnson, Judge David Langham (PP), David McGee, Keith McIver, Ed Moore, Don Partington, and Kim Skievaski (PP).

Winter 2021 | 15

Make Supporting our Foundation a Year-end Tradition

T

he December holiday season is often a time when we pause a moment to count our blessing and

reflect on what we can do to make a difference. As you contemplate your year-end giving, we encourage you to consider making a donation to the Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Foundation.

As the Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Foundation, the philanthropic arm of the ESRBA, is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt charitable organization.

All contributions to the Foundation are tax deductible.

Gulf Coast Kids House, Law Week designated charities such as Backpack Buddies and the First Judicial Circuit High School Mock Trial competitions. Most recently, the Foundation provided grants to Kairos Outside, a program that offers a comfortable, non-judging retreat for women to support each other as they journey through the incarceration of a friend or relative, Legal Services of North Florida’s Jazz for Justice and Santa Rosa Teen Court.

By making a donation to the Foundation, you can be part of providing financial resources for projects that reflect mission of the Foundation:

Over the years, the Foundation has served as a conduit for ESRBA-related fundraisers to help area • Greater accessibility to the organizations and programs, judicial system; as well as awarded grants • Improvements to the totaling more than $200,00 for overall quality of the various endeavors. Recipients administration of justice; have included Lakeview’s • Law-related education and Breakfast with Santa initiative,

increased public awareness of the judicial system; and • Improved management and operation of the court system.

In addition to its grant program, the Foundation also pays tribute to the legal community with its Wall of Honor. Created in 2007, The Wall of Honor, honors and commemorates deceased attorneys and judges of the First Judicial Court. The memorial display is located on the first floor of the M.C. Blanchard Center, Pensacola, Escambia County, Florida.

In 2018, The EscambiaSanta Rosa Bar Foundation launched an initiative to further enhance the M. C. Blanchard Judicial Building by displaying donated artwork in prominent locations. A resolution of the Board of County Commissioners of Escambia County, Florida, supporting the Art in the

Court project and authorizing the acceptance of artwork donated for display.

For more information on the Foundation, please visit esrba. com/bar-foundation or call 850-434-8135. Donations can be made online at esrba. com/bar-foundation/donate/.

Checks can be made out to Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Foundation and sent to 260 S. Tarragona Street, Suite 160, Pensacola Florida, 32502.

We would like to recognize and thank the following Foundation leadership for their service: President Shekka Drayton, Vice President D. Steve Traylor, Jr., Secretary and Treasurer John “Buz” Windham and directors Sheldon Bernau, Jeremy Branning, Jodi Dubose, Stephen Echsner, Cameron Townes Gore, Kristin Haul, Garrett LaBorde, Heather Lindsay, Patrick Martin, Adrianna Spain and Warren Todd.

A copy of the official registration and financial information may be obtained from the Division of Consumer Services by calling toll-free 1-800-help-fla or online at www.floridaconsumerhelp.com. Registration does not imply endorsement, approval or recommendation by the state.” Registration #: ch12356

16 | The Summation

Report from the Board of Governors from Jeremy Branning

T

he Florida Bar Board of Governors met in person (with some members attending via Zoom video conference) on October 1, 2021. The major actions of the Board and reports received included:

The Board requested a four-month extension (to February 11, 2022) from the October 11 deadline the Supreme Court set for developing proposed Bar Rule 3-5.2 for temporarily suspending lawyers who face felony charges. The Disciplinary Procedure Committee asked the board to seek more time to develop the rule after the Criminal Law Section expressed due process concerns and committed to providing an alternative proposal for consideration

by December 1. In a June letter, justices cited a “continuing need to protect the public,” and noted that Bar Rule 3-7.2 provides for suspensions only after a determination of guilt has been made in a criminal case.

The Special Committee for the Review of Professionalism in Florida reported that it is on track to deliver final recommendations to the board by December. The committee was directed

to review the Bar’s professionalism standards, how they are taught to law students and lawyers and reinforced throughout a lawyer’s career and how they are enforced.

The Board approved a recommendation developed by the COVID-19 Pandemic Recovery Task Force to ask the Supreme Court to consider a managed mediation program to address an expected flood of evictions. The recommendations are based on a 2009 report by a Florida Supreme Court task force that recommended a managed mediation program to address an avalanche of mortgage foreclosures that accompanied an economic downturn.

The Board of Governors completed an initial review of several proposed rule amendments regarding disciplinary procedures. The proposals include amendments to Bar Rule 3-5.1, which addresses minor misconduct. Another proposed amendment to Rule 3-5.1 would give a respondent 30 days instead of 15 to accept or reject a Board of Governors or grievance committee offer of minor misconduct.

A proposed amendment to Bar Rule 3-7.9, regarding Consent Judgment, would make changes to subdivisions (a) and (b) that would “ensure that the appropriate constituent of the client, the designated reviewer, reviews and approves rejection of an offer by a respondent, and Bar counsel alone cannot reject an offer by a respondent,” according to a staff analysis. Read more in the Bar News.

Special appointments to be made at the December meeting: • Florida Realtor-Attorney Joint Committee (six lawyers, one from each appellate district and one at-large; two-year terms beginning January 1, 2022) • Eleventh Circuit Judicial Conference (Northern District) (1 lawyer for four-year term beginning January 1, 2022) • Florida Rural Legal Services Board of Directors (1 lawyer for three-year term beginning January 1, 2022)

Winter 2021 | 17

Young Lawyer’s Division YLD Gears Up for the New Year

by Andrew Spencer, YLD President

I

recently had the opportunity to present at the ESRBA November bar luncheon along with YLD’s

secretary, Brooke DiSalvo and treasurer, Logan Sliva. We reported some standard information, like YLD’s recent events and events on the horizon.

But we also took the chance to have a discussion about YLD’s core principals, purpose and benefits. I wanted to use this article to touch on the topics and, hopefully, encourage more young lawyers to join and get involved.

When drilling down on the YLD’s core principals and purpose, three overlapping categories stuck out to me: relationships/ networking, community service and bar involvement. We all know that on the relationships/networking-side, the YLD hosts social events and gives young lawyers the chance to meet one another.

But what occurred to me when thinking through the category were some of the reasons it is important beyond those that are obvious.

One is simply fostering a sense of being a connected part of our legal community from a young age. There is an invaluable benefit in, for example, going to the courthouse for a hearing (back when

we did that) and bumping into another young lawyer you’ve interacted with before, or even just recognize from a YLD event. It can help new lawyers feel like they are part of the Bar and belong, particularly in the early years when it is not uncommon to question whether you have any idea what you are doing.

Even a quick exchange can help build a relationship (and incidentally calm pre-hearing nerves).

Building new relationships and establishing a sense of connection within the community also aides in fostering and promoting civility and professionalism in our practice. The Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association may already be the most civil in the state, and YLD has an important responsibility to ensure that trend continues by helping to instill these values in our young lawyers.

Fostering involvement in community service is another critical part of what we do at the YLD. Not only does community service benefit the local initiatives we support, it also provides additional avenues for young lawyers to interact with and get to know one another outside of purely social settings.

It can also help to expose young lawyers to different types of community service and ultimately develop and grow an interest and continuing involvement in beneficial community work.

Bar involvement is the final category that is a core purpose and benefit of the YLD. Getting involved at the YLD level with lawyers of similar age and experience can help foster further and continued involvement with the Bar as a whole. It is also an excellent place for young lawyers to gain leadership experience that will benefit them far into the future in any context. And helping develop future leaders for our Bar Association in particular is a key part of our mission.

The benefits and advantages of the YLD, however, are only as good as the involvement of its members. If you work with young lawyers who are not members, please consider encouraging them to join. If you work with young lawyers who are members but not involved, please consider encouraging them to come out to our events. The more lawyers we have actively involved, the more benefit we provide to our members, the community and the Bar at large.

18 | The Summation

The Bottom Line Remembering a Rockstar Paralegal

by Attorneys and Staff at Perry & Young, P.A.

T

here are many who dedicate their lives to the legal profession.

But one special individual who was once described as a “rockstar paralegal” with the upmost diligence and professionalism, dedicated her life as a Florida Registered Paralegal at the Perry & Young law firm in Panama City, Panama City Beach, Tallahassee and Marianna, Florida.

Dolores Marie Dubich Coleman, 60, of Youngstown, Fla., formerly of Slovan, was born on March 2, 1961. She passed away Friday, July 2, 2021, in Florida, after a courageous battle with cancer. Surviving are her husband, Kelly Coleman of Florida; son Zachary Austin Coleman of Florida; sisters Charlotte ( John) Richards of Slovan, Barbara ( John) Capo of Cecil and Nancy (Mark) Burd of Eldersville; niece Erin (Matthew) Grady of Minnesota; nephew Marko Burd of Eldersville; and numerous dogs, cats and her goats.

Dolores was a graduate of Burgettstown High School and West Virginia University before serving her country in the U.S. Army. After being honorably discharged, Dolores went on

to serve in the legal system for over 30 years as a Florida Registered Paralegal. Dolores was also a member of the Northwest Florida Paralegal Association.

The Perry & Young law firm describes Dolores as a kind, attentive and thoughtful individual who loved to work and be active. She was known to have a “just keep going” spirit about her that was infectious to coworkers and clients. Dolores was known for giving the most thoughtful gifts and never missed a special day.

She also kept busy with her flowers around her home, especially harvesting her figs and grapes. And even after working and gardening, there was no rest for Dolores. If she could find a good yard sale or some time to bargain shop, she would. She was so thoughtful, if she found a coupon for something YOU liked, she would deliver to you along with a kind note. She was also an avid Steelers fan.

Her professional contributions to the Perry & Young law firm will never be forgotten.

Dolores played an integral part in bringing civil justice to the clients she worked with. Her career accomplishments and overall positive

Dolores in her garden

outlook on life will be something the Perry & Young law firm will always cherish. She was the epitome of a professional paralegal. She will be missed.

Let us paralegals all strive to be a “rockstar paralegal” like Dolores, and that’s the Bottom Line.

Winter 2021 | 19

Argo Corner CSEC in Northwest Florida: Identification, Intervention and Services for Child Survivors of Human Trafficking

by Autumn Bess may find themselves in a situation with no perceivable exit.

Early intervention is the most viable form of abuse prevention for CSEC survivors. It is crucial to identify vulnerabilities that make youth more susceptible to trafficking before the traffickers themselves do. With such frequent interaction between survivors and courtroom workgroups, youth in the criminal justice system depend upon screenings and the watchful eyes of those within the legal community to intervene and refer services that may save a life. Referrals to services, such as respite care to meet the immediate needs of survivors and long-term rehabilitation centers, work to prevent Florida’s children from being trafficked further.

T

he rapidly increasing rate of commercialized sexual exploitation of children (CSEC) in the Florida Panhandle has resulted in the direct involvement of the criminal justice system with child survivors of human trafficking. This article will examine identifiable risk factors for exploitation, early intervention resources, as well as the available service spectrum for CSEC survivors in Northwest Florida to prioritize identification, prevention and response to human trafficking within the State of Florida’s legal community. Ultimately, proper use of these skills within the legal system will prevent future re-traumatization of exploited children, promote rehabilitation in the long-term and keep CSEC survivors out of the courtroom.

Key identifiable demographics for CSEC victims are often overlooked, ranging from victim socioeconomic background to juvenile justice involvement. Of victims reported to Florida’s Abuse Hotline, 55% had some form of involvement with the Department of Juvenile Justice, of which only 1% had been arrested for prostitution. Victims also

displayed frequent instances of running away and were likely to have three or more foster care placements. Due to the extensive rates of juvenile delinquency and behavioral difficulties, CSEC survivors are often overlooked by the legal community and are not afforded the resources necessary to recover them from a life of slavery.

A common misconception about trafficking survivors is the involvement of Hollywoodesque abduction of children. Fewer than 10% of child sex trafficking cases involve kidnapping, and the reality is much grimmer.

Traffickers tend to target uniquely vulnerable youth, including those within the foster care system, those living in poverty or runaway and homeless youth, investing extensive lengths of time into building trusted relationship with their victim. Many victims and their traffickers go undetected due to the seemingly unoffensive nature of such relationships.

Additionally, traffickers are often parents, foster parents or relatives, which makes interfamilial trafficking uniquely difficult to detect. Through coercion, manipulation and unavoidable living conditions, victims

One facility in the Florida panhandle is working to combat human trafficking by providing services for child and adolescent survivors of child sex trafficking; The Secret Place Home serves as an advocacy center and service provider for child survivors of human trafficking in the State of Florida.

The facility offers services including various therapies implementing trauma informed care as well as independent living skills and family wrap-around services to aid in survivor rehabilitation and reintegration. Referrals for youth aged 13-24 suspected of or at risk for exploitation can be submitted directly through the organization’s home webpage.

Due to the hazy information the public holds about the true nature of child sexual exploitation in the State of Florida, survivors typically spend their lifetimes embedded in the legal system without proper intervention and care. With proper identification and early intervention, the legal community of Florida can become advocates for children who otherwise would remain unseen and voiceless, stopping local human trafficking in its tracks.

20 | The Summation

October Bar Meeting

Rachel Sheffield and Dr. Craig Henry

ESRBA Garrett P. LaBorde and Circuit Judge Gary Bergosh

ESRBA Vice President and Sponsorship Chair Aaron T. McCurdy with sponsors James Cowart (Trinitas Christian School), Anne Douglass Williams (Synovus), Stefani Reynolds (Cox Media), Alivia Kust (Cox Business) and Sheldon Bernau (Synovus)

ESRBA Vice President Aaron T. McCurdy, Judge David Langham and ESRBA President Garrett P. LaBorde

Chief Judge John Miller and County Judge Robert Hilliard

To all our Annual Sponsors

Thank Thank you you Platinum Sponsors

Gold Sponsor

Silver Sponsor

Emmanuel Sheppard & Condon Bronze Sponsors

Clio® Henry Chiropractic LexisNexis® Med-Link Synovus® Trinitas Christian School

Need a Lawyer?

It is always a good idea to check with a lawyer before you make an important decision—whether you are buying a house, making a business deal, or settling a dispute. A short talk with a lawyer often tells you all you need to know—how serious a problem is, how to handle it swiftly and how to make sure it is settled for good.

Get Answers to Legal Questions Such As...

• Marriage, Divorce & Family Matters • Business Problems • Criminal Charges of Juvenile Hearings • Wills, Trusts & Property of Decreased Relatives • Tax Problems & Planning • Corporation & Partnership Matters

• Credit or Collection Problems • Real Estate Purchases, Sales or Disputes • Consumer Problems • Landlord/Tenant Relations • Injuries to Yourself or Family Members • Property Damage • Job Discrimination or Employer/

• • • • •

Employee Disputes Workers’ Compensation Patents, Trademarks or Copyrights Wages & Benefits Social Security Disability Labor Law

With over 50 participating local attorneys experienced in many different areas of law, we can help you find an attorney to handle your case.

Your call is free. When you meet with your lawyer, there will be a small fee of $40.00 for the first half-hour consultation. Fees for additional services after the first half-hour are arranged between you and your lawyer.

We do not have attorneys who accept pro bono or contingency cases.

CHECK OUT OUR LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE TODAY! 850.434.6009 | LRS@ESRBA.COM | ESRBA.COM Lawyer Referral Service is a public service provided by the Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association

M E D I AT I O N S T H R O U G H O U T F L O R I DA

Resolve Your Cases Through Mediation & Arbitration n

User-Friendly Online Scheduling

n

No Administrative Fees

n

Zoom Video Conferencing

Eric H. Luckman

Jose G. Rodriguez

Donald G. Korman

Philip G. Thompson

Ira S. Bergman

Andrew Y. Winston

Personal Injury & Wrongful Death Insurance Coverage & Bad Faith Business & Commercial Breach of Contract Construction Defects

Medical Malpractice Product Liability Hospital & Nursing Home Workers Compensation

BallingerPublishing.com

8 5 0. 4 4 3 .1 1 66

877-380-3133 • mediationworksfl.com

A Higginbotham Company

Your trusted insurance firm of over 25 years is now backed by Higginbotham, one of the largest independent insurance firms in the US. As proud as we are to be on top, our number one priority is you. With Higginbotham, we can offer a single source solution to secure your financial future.

11 West Garden Street, Pensacola, FL 32502 850-484-7911 | www.mcmahonhadder.com

Business Insurance | Risk Management | Employee Benefits Benefit Administration | Life Insurance | Executive Benefits Retirement Plans | HR Services | Home & Auto