Case Capsule: An Appraisal Using Installed Reproduction Cost By Scott Cullen, RCA #348
Introduction A Tree Trespass Appraisal Case. A recent real world case involved a trespass in which at least six mature, standing trees and an uncertain number of small trees or bushes (underwood) were cut and removed without permission from the tree owner’s side of a shared boundary with an abutting real property. The tree stumps were also removed, limiting available evidence. This case required monetary appraisal of the cut trees and underwood, and I was the Plaintiff’s tree appraiser. The total appraised value1 was $112,000 and the case settled for $95,000. Because the case settled out of court, this case capsule disguises the location and applicable law while preserving key elements of the case and the appraisal. Location. The properties were located in the State of Bliss, which is east of the Mississippi River and west of the Atlantic Ocean. In Bliss as in most U.S. states, standing trees, growing in the “landscape,” whether naturally occurring or planted, are real estate.2 In Bliss, there is a Tree Trespass Statute, §T of the Bliss Real Property Gotcha Law.3 Purposes of this Case Capsule. The purposes of this case capsule are a) to explain the meaning of the terms “damage,” “damages,” and “measures of damages,” b) to provide an example of identifying the appraisal problem as described in the Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th Edition (CTLA 2020)4, c) to provide an example of applicable and relevant use of installed reproduction cost in the cost approach, and d) to add to the secondary tree appraisal literature which may inform development of the 11th Edition5. Damage Merriam-Webster (2026) defines damage (noun) as “loss or harm resulting from injury to person, property, or reputation.” Black’s Law Dictionary, Twelfth Edition (Garner 2024) defines damage (noun) as “1. Loss or injury to person or property; esp. physical harm that is done to something or to part of someone’s body. 2. By extension, any bad effect on something.” The 10th Edition does not define damage, but describes assessing physical damage or injury to landscape plants (pp. 50-51).
Defined in the appraisal problem section of this case capsule.
1 2
Contrasted to personal property such as nursery stock. See the Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th Edition, pp. 11-12.
3
This case capsule purposely disguises the actual state and statute. Tree appraisers may be familiar with applicable laws in their practice regions but should not give legal advice to their appraisal clients. Tree appraisers should rely on competent legal instruction on the particular applicable law in any particular case. Bliss happens to have a tree trespass statute, but in many U.S. states or Canadian provinces tree trespass is treated in the common or case law (explanation of the difference is beyond the scope of this case capsule).
The 10th Edition was released in August 2018 (CTLA 2018a, dark green cover). Within months, the first printing was withdrawn to correct formatting, typography, and other errors (CTLA 2018b). A second printing, released in July 2019 (CTLA 2019, light green cover), still contained errors and significant conceptual flaws. In November 2019, some of the 10th Edition worksheets were revealed to be unworkable (Cullen 2019). Revised worksheets (ISA 2020a, 2020b) attempted to correct errors and are included in the 10th Edition Revised (CTLA 2020, light green cover). The Quebec Chapter of the International Society of Arboriculture released a French translation and adaptation, of the 2020 Revised Edition, for the Canadian province of Quebec (SIAQ 2023, advertised with blue cover).
4
References in this article are to the 10th Edition Revised (2020); however, pagination is generally consistent in the three printings. 5
The 8th, 9th, and 10th Editions were authored by the Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers—CTLA (10th Edition, pp. 2-3). In December 2023 ISA (ISA 2024a), with support from the other CTLA organizations, announced that public comments on the 10th Edition would be accepted throughout 2024 (see also ISA 2024b), followed by a five-year drafting and review process leading to publication of the 11th Edition by 2030. ISA (2025) subsequently announced appointment of members of the seven CTLA organizations in 11th Edition content and administrative roles.
American Society of Consulting Arborists®
29
Arboricultural Consultant volume 59 issue 4 2026
Case Capsule: An Appraisal Using Installed Reproduction Cost continued
Damages and Measure of Damages Appraisals are often needed to calculate or estimate the amount or quantum of damages to be claimed in a dispute, such as a tree trespass case. Tree appraisers who work in dispute settings, including litigation, should understand the meaning of “damages” and “measure of damages,” two distinct terms. Damages. Damages means monetary compensation—claimed by or ordered to be paid to a claimant or plaintiff— for actual damage, harm. injury, or loss (such as cut, damaged, or destroyed trees). See generally Appraisal Institute 2026b; Dunster 2018, p. 161; Garner 2024. Garner (2011) explained that “the word damage… is to be distinguished from its plural–damages” [emphases in original].6 Measure of Damages. The measure of damages is the legal basis for calculating damages; or the test by which the amount of damages is ascertained (see generally Dunster 2018, p. 161; Garner 2024). Stebbins and Sabo (1972) noted that “the purpose of a measure of damages is to ascertain what compensation to award the injured person.” Black (1990) described measure of damages as “the rule, or rather the system of rules, governing the adjustment or apportionment of damages as a compensation for injuries in an action at law.” Measures of damages for trees. Dunster (2018, p. 161) explained that for damage to trees the measure of damages might be: • the commodity value of the trees as stumpage or timber, or • the diminution in the value of the real estate on account of tree loss, or • the cost to restore the property to pre-damage condition. Which of those measures of damages for trees is applicable to a particular case varies a) among jurisdictions (for example, the law in the State of Bliss may vary from the law in the State of Shock), b) even within a jurisdiction based on the type of property or type of ownership, and c) with the facts of the case. Who decides? The applicable measure of damages is a matter of law. The tree appraiser does not determine or select the measure of damages which applies in a particular legal setting, but can properly receive an instruction on the law from a lawyer as to the applicable measure of damages. Identifying the Appraisal Problem — 10th Edition The 10th Edition (p. 18) explains that “the first step in the appraisal process is to identify the appraisal problem.” The 10th Edition does not define appraisal problem. Clark (2016) described it as “the context for the assignment, the question being asked, and the issue to be resolved.” Cullen described it as ““a careful and specific statement of the client’s question about value and its context” (2016) and explained that the “appraisal problem is described by a set of assumptions, circumstances, facts, and (where appropriate) legal context” (2018). The 10th Edition (pp. 18-24) lists six parameters of the appraisal problem: a) the client and intended users of the appraisal, b) the intended use of the appraisal, c) the type and definition of the assignment result, d) the effective date of the appraisal, e) the relevant characteristics of the tree or landscape being appraised, f) any assumptions and/or limiting conditions.
6
See also McCormick (1935, p. 2, f.n. 1.
American Society of Consulting Arborists®
30
Arboricultural Consultant volume 59 issue 4 2026
Case Capsule: An Appraisal Using Installed Reproduction Cost continued
Cullen (2024 §4) explained that these six problem-specific parameters must be identified in every assignment, whether simple or complex. Detailed explanation of all of these six parameters is beyond the scope of this case capsule. Readers should refer to the 10th Edition, or to Scope of Work (Coleman 2020). The 9th Edition. Cullen (2026 Appendix I) noted that the 9th Edition (CTLA 2000) remains in use. While the 9th Edition did not use the term appraisal problem, it clearly described identifying the intended use of the appraisal (p. 11), what is being appraised (pp. 13-17), and the type of value (p.19). Identifying this Appraisal Problem For readability, the complete identification of this case capsule’s appraisal problem, as an example, is provided in Appendix I. This case capsule focuses on two of the six problem-specific parameters: the intended use of the appraisal (i.e., litigation); and the type of opinion or assignment result (i.e., based on installed reproduction cost). Intended Use of this Appraisal. The 10th Edition (p. 19) explains that “the credibility of an appraisal is always judged or measured in terms of the intended use of the appraisal.” Coleman (2020 p. 29) similarly noted that “credibility relates directly to— and is measured in light of—intended use.” The intended use of this appraisal is litigation. In litigation appraisals, the type of opinion or assignment result—the next problem-specific parameter to be identified by the appraiser—is a function of the legal measure of damages (described above) which applies in the particular litigation. Type of Opinion or Assignment Result. Coleman (2020 p. 41) cautioned “keep in mind that the valuer does not decide what type of value [assignment result] will apply; he or she merely identifies the type needed given the nature of the client’s problem.” The Appraisal of Real Estate (Appraisal Institute 2026a, p. 39) explains that type and definition of value depend on the intended use of the appraisal. The 10th Edition (p. 22) notes that “the definition should come from an authoritative source [such as standards or texts], applicable law or regulation or an engagement letter.” “…the valuer does not decide what type of value will apply; he or she merely identifies the type needed given the nature of the client’s problem.”
Recall that this litigation appraisal problem involves tree trespass in the State of Bliss, and that in Bliss the Tree Trespass Statute is §T of the Bliss Real Property Gotcha Law. And as noted above, the applicable measure of damages in a litigation is a matter of law. I asked for and received an instruction on the law, from the hiring lawyer. That instruction on the law was that the available measure of damages in Bliss is the cost to return the property to pre-existing condition. Installed reproduction cost. Returning a property to pre-existing condition after trees are destroyed requires restoring the size and number of trees which were destroyed. The 10th Edition (p. 55) describes the “cost to duplicate or replicate the item being appraised” as a reproduction cost7. Restoring those trees requires obtaining them, delivering them to the property, and installing them. This litigation appraisal problem required installed reproduction cost data. 7
The scope of this case was limited to the monetary damages for the trees and smaller plants. If other property damage such as soil compaction, soil erosion, environmental contamination, etc. had required restoration to pre-existing property condition, the costs to do so could be “additional costs” (10th Edition p.65). Strictly speaking, they would not be appraised items; they would be conditions requiring additional cost estimates.
American Society of Consulting Arborists®
31
Arboricultural Consultant volume 59 issue 4 2026
Case Capsule: An Appraisal Using Installed Reproduction Cost continued
Replacement Value. The type of opinion in this litigation appraisal problem was defined as Replacement Value, that is, “the installed reproduction cost to return the real property to pre-existing condition; less depreciation for physical condition, functional factors, and external factors; unrelated to the market value of the real property.” This appraisal problem considered pre-existing condition to include any loss in benefits, function, or utility as reflected by the depreciation.8 Solving this Appraisal Problem As noted in the Introduction, the stumps had been removed, limiting the available evidence. Based on measurement of nearby remaining trees, historical aerial photos, the tree owner’s photos and videos taken before the trespass, and the tree owner’s description, I determined that six trees with an average caliper9 of 14” were removed. While 14” caliper trees of some species were available from a regional nursery, I used the cost of 12” caliper trees from that nursery as a conservative factor. I used installed costs in the Reproduction Cost Method and Direct Cost Technique (DCT).10,11 After depreciation for physical condition, functional factors, and external factors the Replacement Value of the six trees was about $105,000. Adding the Replacement Value of the smaller trees and bushes and the Statutory Value, the total appraised value was about $112,000. The case settled for about $95,000. Summary and Discussion This case capsule describes a recent real world appraisal using installed reproduction cost. It explains the meaning of the terms “damage,” “damages,” and “measure of damages.” It also explains that in the 10th Edition identifying the appraisal problem is the first step in the appraisal process and that the appraiser must identify six problem-specific parameters in every appraisal. Appendix I in this case capsule provides the identification of this appraisal problem as an example. The key problem-specific parameters in this case capsule are the intended use of the appraisal (i.e, litigation) and the type of value or assignment result (i.e., based on installed reproduction cost). Appraisers do not decide what type of value or assignment result will apply, but identify the type needed given the nature of the client’s appraisal problem. The measure of damages and legal instruction. In litigation appraisals the type of value or assignment result is a function of a measure of damages which is a matter of law. Appraisers properly accept instructions on the law from lawyers. Accepting an instruction on the law is not advocacy and is not biased. Coleman (2020 p. 48) noted that “it is incumbent on the valuer to find out which laws and regulations, if any, apply in an assignment… the valuer may need to obtain legal opinion from an attorney regarding their interpretation.” A legal instruction on the applicable measure of damages is not an instruction on the amount or quantum of damages expected of the appraiser.
8
Other appraisal problems may not deduct depreciation from basic cost (as defined in the 10th Edition).
9
Trunk diameter measured at 12 inches above grade. In this appraisal there happened to be a regional nursery stocking large caliper shade trees which enabled use of the Direct Cost Technique (DCT). If such large caliper nursery stock was not available the Trunk Formula Technique (TFT) would have been used. The requirement for installed cost would be the same.
10
The reproduction cost method uses “the cost to duplicate or replicate the item being appraised.” The Direct Cost Technique (DCT) “estimates actual costs to install…a landscape item.” (10th Edition p.55) Thus, this appraisal used the estimated installed cost for 12” caliper trees. An appraiser could include extraordinary establishments costs as part of the total installed cost for each tree (see Cullen 2022). This appraisal did not use an extrapolated cost technique (10th Edition p. 57) starting with the installed cost for a much smaller nursery tree.
11
American Society of Consulting Arborists®
32
Arboricultural Consultant volume 59 issue 4 2026
Case Capsule: An Appraisal Using Installed Reproduction Cost continued
Installed reproduction cost. This case capsule documents appropriate and relevant use of installed reproduction cost based on the legal measure of damages applicable to the appraisal problem. Cullen and McNeil (2020 Appendix III) explained that in the cost approach, total cost includes delivery and installation. Cullen (2022) explained that delivery and planting are not additional costs and that when “appraising trees that are growing or standing in the ground and intended to remain there, delivery, planting, and establishment costs are an inherent and indispensable part of total cost.” “…when appraising trees that are growing or standing in the ground and intended to remain there, delivery, planting, and establishment costs are an inherent and indispensable part of total cost.”
Some tree appraisers may believe that installed costs will not be credible in their appraisal problems and so may suggest that professional guidance should exclude installed costs in any appraisal problems, particularly using the Trunk Formula Technique (TFT).12 Identifying the appraisal problem, as the first step in the appraisal process, gives all appraisers the flexibility to solve any appraisal problem—litigation13 or otherwise. Excluding installed costs in professional guidance would a) miss the point of the flexibility provided by identifying the six problem-specific parameters in every appraisal problem and b) ignore the total cost concept noted above. The appraisal problem for the same number, size, and species of trees in a trespass litigation in another state, might vary from the appraisal problem in this case capsule. Appendix 1: Identification of this Appraisal Problem Client.
Jusitn Case, Esq. and the firm of Case & Case, LLP.
Intended Users. Jusitn Case, Esq., the firm of Case & Case, LLP, and Mr. and Mrs. Tree Owner. Type of Opinion.
Identification of trees that were cut, topped, or damaged (injured) on this parcel on or about June 2025.
Replacement Value of at least 6 trees, and a number of smaller trees (underwood) that were cut, topped, or damaged (injured) on this parcel on or about July 2025.
Definition of Value. In this appraisal Replacement Value is defined as the installed reproduction cost to return the real property to pre-existing condition; less depreciation for physical condition, functional factors, and external factors; unrelated to the market value of the real property. 12
Your instruction on the law is that §T of the Bliss Real Property Gotcha Law provides a remedy for unauthorized tree cutting, topping, or damage (injury); and that the available measure of damages is the cost to return the real property to pre-existing condition.
Credibly applying depreciation to installed costs, in the 10th Edition Reproduction Cost Method or Functional Replacement Cost Method, is beyond the scope of this case capsule.
Cullen and McNeil (2020) observed that in a litigation setting, professional guidance which excludes installed costs effectively excludes otherwise admissible evidence by making it professionally improper to even develop it.
13
American Society of Consulting Arborists®
33
Arboricultural Consultant volume 59 issue 4 2026
Case Capsule: An Appraisal Using Installed Reproduction Cost continued
Date of Loss.
The trees were cut, topped, or damaged (injured) on or about July 2025.
Effective Date. Replacement Value is as of Fall 2025, reflecting nursery costs for the earliest planting window. Relevant Property Characteristics.
At lease six (6) trees, and a number of smaller trees (underwood) on Parcel 12-72/Q that were cut, topped, or damaged (injured) on or about July 2025. Tree characteristics are described in detail in the report.
Assumptions and Limiting Conditions.
This appraisal relied on publicly available aerial photos, photos and videos taken before the trespass, and a professional survey of the parcel boundary. All are assumed to be reliable.
Literature Cited
Appraisal Institute. 2026a. The Appraisal of Real Estate, 16th Ed. Appraisal Institute, Chicago, IL. 681pp. Appraisal Institute. 2026b. The Dictionary of Real Estate Appraisal, 8th Ed. Appraisal Institute, Chicago. 356pp. Black, Henry Campbell. 1990. Black’s Law Dictionary, Sixth Edition. West Group, St. Paul, MN. 1657pp. Clark, Jim. 2016. CTLA representative report. Arboricultural Consultant 49(4):35. Coleman, Stephanie. 2020. Scope of Work, Third Edition. Appraisal Institute, Chicago. 120 pp. CTLA (Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers). 2000. Guide for Plant Appraisal, 9th Ed. International Society of Arboriculture, Champaign, IL. 143pp. CTLA (Council of Tree & Landscape Appraisers). 2018a. Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th Edition [first printing]. International Society of Arboriculture, Champaign, IL. 170 pp. CTLA (Council of Tree & Landscape Appraisers). 2018b. Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th Edition. Corrigendum, Nov. 27, 2018, International Society of Arboriculture, Champaign, IL. CTLA (Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers). 2019. Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th Ed. (second printing). International Society of Arboriculture, Atlanta, GA. 181pp. CTLA (Council of Tree & Landscape Appraisers). 2020. Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th Edition Revised [third printing]. International Society of Arboriculture, Atlanta, GA. 181 pp. Cullen, Scott. 2016. Trees, real estate, and market value: The real deal. Arboricultural Consultant 49(4):13-19. Cullen, Scott. 2018. Tree appraisal: Understanding the assignment, appraisal problem, and scope of work. Arboricultural Consultant 51(1):3-6. Cullen, Scott. 2019. 10th Edition worksheets that don't work. ASCA Exchange Post, Nov. 6, 2019. https://exchange.ascaconsultants.org Cullen, Scott. 2022. Tree appraisal: Planting is not an additional cost - part 1. Arboricultural Consultant 55(4):4-12. Cullen, Scott. 2024. Tree appraisal: A vision for the future. Arboricultural Consultant 54(4):7-14. Cullen, Scott. 2026. Tree appraisal: Credible and reasonable as terms of art. Arboricultural Consultant 59(3):37-60. Cullen, Scott and Joe McNeil. 2020. Tree appraisal: Installed unit costs. Arboricultural Consultant 53(3):4-11. Dunster, Julian A. 2018. Trees and the Law in Canada. Dunster & Associates, Victoria, BC, CANADA. 261pp. Garner, Bryan A. (Ed.). 2024. Black’s Law Dictionary, Twelfth Edition. Thomson Reuters, St. Paul, MN. 2071pp. Garner, Bryan A. 2011. Garner’s Dictionary of Legal Usage, Third Edition. Oxford University Press, Inc., New York, NY. 991pp. ISA. 2020a. Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th Edition: Revised Corrigenda. https://wwv.isa-arbor.com/store/productfiles/Gui deforPlantAppraisal10thEditionRevised-2178-GPA_Corrigenda.pdf (accessed October 13, 2026) ISA. 2020b. Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th Edition: Revised Forms. ISA Today, Nov. 17, 2020. ISA. 2024a. Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers Outlines Path for New Edition of Guide for Plant Appraisal. https:// www.isa-arbor.com/Newsroom/council-of-tree-and-landscape-appraisers-outlines-path-for-new-edition-of-guide-forplant-appraisal (accessed May 10, 2026) ISA. 2024b. Public review of the Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th Edition. Arboricultural Consultant 57(1):11.
American Society of Consulting Arborists®
34
Arboricultural Consultant volume 59 issue 4 2026
Case Capsule: An Appraisal Using Installed Reproduction Cost continued
ISA. 2025. ISA Today May. Guide for Plant Appraisal Update. https://www.isa-arbor.com/Publications/ISA-Today/Issue/ Article/category/may-2025/guide-for-plant-appraisal-update (accessed May 10, 2026) McCormick, Charles T. 1935. Damages (23rd Reprint 1985). West Publishing Company, St. Paul, MN. 811pp. Merriam-Webster. 2026. Damage. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/damage (accessed October 16, 2026) SIAQ (La Société internationale d'arboriculture Québec inc.). 2023. Guide pour l'évaluation monétaire des végétaux 2023. Traduction en français et adaptation de 10e édition américaine 2020. SIAQ, Laval, QC, Canada. Stebbins, Evelyn and Charels G. Sabo. 1972. Damages for loss of trees. Cleveland State Law Review 21(1):175-181 (January).
Backmatter
Acknowledgments: Honorary Life Member Joe McNeil, RCA# 299 and Jan Scow RCA #382 graciously provided insightful comments on a draft of this article. Scott Cullen, Honorary Life Member, RCA #348, has been involved in various aspects of arboriculture since 1971. He is a full-time consultant based in the tri-state metropolitan New York area. He is an ISA Certified Arborist, a CT Licensed Arborist, a NJ Licensed Tree Expert, a RI Licensed Arborist, and also holds the ISA TRAQ credential. Scott is a CT Licensed Real Estate Broker, and earned a master’s degree in real estate development and investment from New York University. He was a member of ISA’s Plant Appraisal and Valuation Committee from its founding circa 2004 through its sunset in 2024, and was ISA’s representative to CTLA from 2011–2014.
American Society of Consulting Arborists®
35
Arboricultural Consultant volume 59 issue 4 2026