Thursday, October 22, 2026 The Press-Sentinel 5A
Opinion
Mistakes were made—and you and I made them “As fallible human beings, all of us share the impulse to justify ourselves and avoid taking responsibility for actions that turn out to be harmful, immoral, or stupid. … The higher the stakes—emotional, financial, moral— the greater the difficulty [in saying ‘I was wrong’].” —Carol Tavris and Elliot Aronson, Mistakes Were Made (but Not by Me) ••• I used to think that most people are fundamentally rational. I used to think that most people, if confronted with clear and convincing evidence of a mistake in judgment, would eventually acknowledge the error. I used to think that carefully educating people with verifiable facts was the best way to sway someone from a previously stakedout position. I used to think that voters, when shown that a political figure was openly acting contrary to the reasons those voters gave for choosing that figure, would come to change their minds about their support. I used to think that, even if it collided with a well-developed theory of the crime, obvious and compelling evidence of an alternate explanation would prompt law-enforcement officers and prosecutors to
My Opinion ttt
revise their views. I used to think that, at their core, most people in DREW most DAVIS cases Columnist would like to know if they were mistaken about a belief or position. And I was wrong. I’ve gradually learned— from research, reflection and sheer experience— that people really, really don’t like to admit being wrong. If confronted with evidence that they have done something wrong or accepted faulty reasoning, the natural response is to “double down.” And the more important the issue, and the more strongly expressed the original stand, the more forceful the resistance to the new evidence. And nowhere have I seen this tendency better explained than in the acclaimed book Mistakes Were Made (but Not by Me): Why We Justify Foolish Beliefs, Bad Decisions, and Hurtful Acts by social psychologists Carol Tavris and Elliot Aronson.
Relying on scientific evidence and real-life examples, the authors clearly explain—in a way that makes fascinating reading—how our psychology really works. They show how ingrained prejudices and unreliable memories allow us to justify obviously poor judgment and how that tendency can have disastrous effects in all kinds of spheres. You can see it in previously loving couples who come to despise each other. You can see it in psychotherapists—as opposed to clinical psychologists—who in some cases have been shown to have (inadvertently) implanted false memories of past abuse in suggestible patients under hypnosis. You can see it in the nationalistic fervor that makes war more likely by keeping leaders and citizens of different countries from even trying to empathize with those elsewhere. The chapter “Law and Disorder” opens with an account of a man imprisoned for a murder he was later determined not to have committed. Despite an absence of physical evidence, he was convicted largely on the testimony of two unreliable witnesses, including a jailhouse snitch. And when a judge finally overturned the con-
theory predicts, the stronger and more pervasive the criticism, the stronger and more entrenched the need to ignore it,” the authors explain. As someone who prides himself on his rationality, I’m rational enough to know that I’m not immune to feeling these irrational tendencies myself. We’re all susceptible to the siren song of self-justification. The good news is that being aware of these tendencies can help us recognize and—at least partially—compensate for them. Indeed, it was Supreme Court Justice Robert H. Jackson who said in 1948 (as quoted in Mistakes Were Made), “I see no reason why I should be consciously wrong today because I was unconsciously wrong yesterday.” Thus, as Michael Shermer, editor of the magazine Skeptic and author of the book Why People Believe Weird Things, says of Tavris and Aronson’s work, “If this book doesn’t change the way we think about our mistakes, then we’re all doomed.” drewdavis@thepress-sentinel.com
viction on grounds that the prosecution had improperly withheld relevant information, prosecutors still refused to believe they could have been wrong. Having reported on exactly the same sequence of events in a Wayne County case, I found that example particularly resonant. The book shows how people with similar positions can diverge because, when one makes an initial error in judgment, that person is often willing to compound it by trying to justify it. A basically good, basically smart person often acts poorly and foolishly to avoid admitting that one particular judgment was not especially good or smart. The latest edition of the book—with a chapter “Dissonance, Democracy, and the Demagogue”—even shows how cognitive dissonance explains how people who would have opposed almost everything Donald Trump now represents have come to radically shift their positions in order to avoid admitting an initial mistake. (For the record, the book offers examples of this kind of phenomenon across the political spectrum. The case of Pope Pius XI and Mussolini is especially instructive.) “Indeed, as dissonance
Support Wayne County’s Gold Star families BY CRISTINA JOHNSON
In reality, military service affects the entire family. In return, service members’ families place their trust in the nation to honor their sacrifice with a commitment that extends well beyond a service member’s time on active duty. However, for those who lose a loved one, that commitment gains in significance because they must often face financial strains far greater than any civilian may realize—on top of profound grief. As such, Gold Star Mothers and Families Day (observed last month) becomes an opportunity to look beyond the ceremonies and consider what survivors may still face. When unforeseen hurdles—particularly service-related toxic exposures—contribute to a veteran’s illness and death, what support remains for the family left behind? In Wayne County, the
question is deeply personal and very real, reflected in the county’s remembering 40 Gold Star veterans who gave their lives in service to our country. Additionally, more than 1,500 veterans live in the county, with approximately 480 residing in Jesup. Across Georgia, more than 600,000 veterans live in the state’s communities, while nationally the number is nearly 15.7 million. Supporting the families left behind should be a fundamental part of honoring military service—a commitment that lasts long after the service. For the vast majority of military families, financial pressure was an everyday occurrence long before a service member passed away. Many veterans develop diseases from toxic exposures as a consequence of their service, including exposures to Agent Orange, asbestos, PFAS, VOCs and other toxic substances.
What makes these exposures especially dangerous is that the illnesses they cause may not become apparent until years—even decades—after a service member has left the military. Upon such diagnosis, the family’s priorities may shift: A spouse or parent may have to step in as a primary caregiver to manage treatment and daily life. And, if the veteran dies, survivors must move forward while carrying both the emotional loss and the income disruption that preceded it. Meaningful support for the families left behind Even if surviving families’ financial reality cannot be solved with only a benefit program, any financial help is welcome in dire situations. As of Dec. 1, 2025, spouses of service members who passed away on or after Jan. 1, 1993, may receive a tax-free
PRESSTALK
Our Declaration of Independence, Constitution and population of Christian people are under attack by radical Islamist extremists who are trying to destroy our Christian society. While this spiritual war has been brewing for centuries, it came to a head when we attacked Iran to stop them from having atomic bombs. We have won that war, and they will not have atomic bombs, but the spiritual war against America has not stopped. Have you noticed the recent tremendous in-
crease in Islamic people with extreme agendas in American politics and in American cities and states? Christianity in America under attack in New York City, Minnesota, and many other America cities and states. Politicians with these extreme ideologies are running for political office and winning. The heart and soul of our country is under attack, and we Christians need to stand up and fight! We fight by praying for God’s help! 2 Chronicles 7:14 tells us clearly, “If my people which are called by my name, shall humble themselves, and pray,
actment would provide an increase in DIC through additional cost-of-living adjustments. While it is a meaningful step forward, it doesn’t address the limitations of a fixed benefit, which cannot reflect the unique losses experienced by each family. For veterans’ families who may have already sacrificed years of income, time and energy to care for the loved one, every shortcoming can enhance the burden rather than relieving it. Addressing these needs is part of honoring our responsibility to the families who stood alongside those who served and shared in their sacrifices. (Editor’s note: Cristina Johnson is a Navy veteran advocate at the Asbestos Ships Organization, a nonprofit that raises awareness about toxic exposure on Navy ships.)
DENTY
ttt
America is still Christian nation
monthly payment of $1,699.36 through the Dependency and Indemnity Compensation (DIC) program. The amount increases if the veteran had a service-related disability diagnosis before his death, the surviving spouse is also disabled, and a minor lives in the household. But DIC is limited because of remarriage rules that can affect eligibility. Although survivors may also qualify for other programs—such as CHAMPVA and Survivors’ Pension—these options have strict requirements that can make it difficult to access them. Recognizing that there’s a need for further action in modernizing DIC, the Sharri Briley and Eric Edmundson Veterans Benefits Expansion Act of 2026 passed the House in May. It was referred to the Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee in June. Among other updates, its full en-
and seek my face, and turn from their wicked ways; then I will hear from heaven, and I will forgive their sin, and heal their land.” This is for anyone who considers themselves God’s people! We are to support and attend our local church, raise Christian children, and conduct ourselves as Christ has shown in His life on earth. If you haven’t been attending and supporting a Christian church, you should try it; you might like it. P.J. Collipp, MD Jesup
Continued from page 4A
minded me why I was teaching each classic, literature that stands the test of time. When I returned to the classroom a quarter-century later, rereading each selection before I taught it again for 17 years gave me the opportunity to make the study each year fit the needs and interests of each new class. Adams is correct: Literature changes for the reader because the reader has changed first. Because the world changes, a reader brings new perspective to each book read.
As with any topic, there are always naysayers. Dissenter Oscar Schwartz, Australian journalist, concludes, “The most obvious argument against rereading is, of course, that there just isn’t enough time. … For those who do not reread, a book is like a little life. When it ends, it dies—or it lives on, imperfectly and embellished in your memories.” Schwartz did not change my habit of rereading books. British author and scholar C.S. Lewis counters, “An unliter-
ary man may be defined as one who reads books once only. … We do not enjoy a story fully at the first reading. Not till the curiosity, the sheer narrative lust, has been given its sop and laid asleep, are we at leisure to savor the real beauties. Till then, it is like wasting great wine on a ravenous natural thirst which merely wants cold wetness.” (Jamie Denty can be reached at jamiedenty@darientel.net.)