Skip to main content

Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 12th Edition by Peter Baily David Farmer Ba

Page 1

Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 1

27/09/2021 12:27


At Pearson, we have a simple mission: to help people make more of their lives through learning. We combine innovative learning technology with trusted content and educational expertise to provide engaging and effective learning experiences that serve people wherever and whenever they are learning. From classroom to boardroom, our curriculum materials, digital learning tools and testing programmes help to educate millions of people worldwide – more than any other private enterprise. Every day our work helps learning flourish, and wherever learning flourishes, so do people. To learn more, please visit us at www.pearson.com/uk

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 2

27/09/2021 12:27


Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age

Twelfth edition Peter Baily David Farmer Barry Crocker David Jessop

Harlow, England • London • New York • Boston • San Francisco • Toronto • Sydney • Dubai • Singapore • Hong Kong Tokyo • Seoul • Taipei • New Delhi • Cape Town • São Paulo • Mexico City • Madrid • Amsterdam • Munich • Paris • Milan

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 3

27/09/2021 12:27


PEARSON EDUCATION LIMITED KAO Two KAO Park Harlow CM17 9NA United Kingdom Tel: +44 (0)1279 623623 Web: www.pearson.com/uk First published 1968 (print) Ninth edition 2005 (print) Tenth edition 2008 (print and electronic) Eleventh edition 2015 (print and electronic) Twelfth edition 2022 (print and electronic) © Institute of Purchasing and Supply 1968, 1974 (print) © Peter Baily and David Farmer 1977, 1981, 1985, 1990 (print) © Peter Baily, David Farmer, David Jessop and David Jones 1994, 1998, 2005 (print) © Peter Baily, David Farmer, Barry Crocker, David Jessop and David Jones 2008, 2015 (print and electronic) © Pearson Education Limited 2022 (print and electronic) The rights of Peter Baily, David Farmer, Barry Crocker and David Jessop to be identified as authors of this work have been asserted by them in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. The print publication is protected by copyright. Prior to any prohibited reproduction, storage in a retrieval system, distribution or transmission in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, recording or otherwise, permission should be obtained from the publisher or, where applicable, a licence permitting restricted copying in the United Kingdom should be obtained from the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, Barnard’s Inn, 86 Fetter Lane, London EC4A 1EN. The ePublication is protected by copyright and must not be copied, reproduced, transferred, distributed, leased, licensed or publicly performed or used in any way except as specifically permitted in writing by the publishers, as allowed under the terms and conditions under which it was purchased, or as strictly permitted by applicable copyright law. Any unauthorised distribution or use of this text may be a direct infringement of the authors’ and the publisher’s rights and those responsible may be liable in law accordingly. All trademarks used herein are the property of their respective owners. The use of any trademark in this text does not vest in the author or publisher any trademark ownership rights in such trademarks, nor does the use of such trademarks imply any affiliation with or endorsement of this book by such owners. Pearson Education is not responsible for the content of third-party internet sites. ISBN: 978-1-292-39749-8 (print) 978-1-292-39750-4 (PDF) 978-1-292-39751-1 (ePub) British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for the print edition is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Baily, Peter J. H., author. | Farmer, David H., author. | Crocker, Barry, author. | Jessop, David (Co-author of Procurement principles and management), author. Title: Procurement principles and management in the digital age / Peter Baily, David Farmer, Barry Crocker, David Jessop. Description: Twelfth edition. | Harlow, England ; New York : Pearson, 2022. | Includes index. Identifiers: LCCN 2021036890 | ISBN 9781292397498 (paperback) | ISBN 9781292397511 (epub) | ISBN 9781292397504 (pdf) Subjects: LCSH: Purchasing--Management. | Industrial procurement--Management. Classification: LCC HF5437 .P7995 2022 | DDC 658.7/2--dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2021036890 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 26 25 24 23 22 Front cover image: elanabsl/Shutterstock Cover designed by Two Associates Print edition typeset in 9.5/13pt Stone Serif ITC Pro by Straive Printed in Slovakia by Neografia NOTE THAT ANY PAGE CROSS REFERENCES REFER TO THE PRINT EDITION

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 4

27/09/2021 12:27


Contents Preface

xiv

Acknowledgements

xvii

Part 1 PROCUREMENT OBJECTIVES AND DEVELOPMENT 1 Procurement scope and development Introduction Objectives of this chapter The scope of purchasing Sustainable procurement The procurement cycle Procurement transformations The changing role of procurement and supply Proactive procurement The changing nature of relationships Procurement positioning Supplier preferencing Total acquisition cost and total cost of ownership Procurement development Best practice in strategic supply management Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

2 Strategic procurement and supply chain management Introduction Objectives of this chapter Strategic procurement The concept of strategy The mission statement Levels of strategy Category management (CM) Skills for category management Strategic management

1 3 3 3 4 5 9 16 19 23 24 26 31 33 35 39 40 41 41

43 43 43 44 46 46 47 48 50 51

v

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 5

27/09/2021 12:27


Contents

Strategic analysis Strategic development Strategy implementation Objectives for purchasing/procurement Selecting a strategy Effective supply market strategies Integrated approaches The supply chain Supply chain resilience The supply chain concept in action Improving the efficiency of the supply chain Hierarchy of objectives The future of procurement and supply management Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

3 Public sector procurement Introduction Objectives of this chapter Part A Historic background Public sector sustainability and social value Third sector – not-for-profit procurement UK National Health Service (NHS) UK Metropolitan Police procurement The Ministry of Defence (MoD) Part B The EU and procurement EU competition procurement cycle for goods and services EU procurement directives Public procurement after Brexit Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

Part 2 KEY PROCUREMENT ISSUES 4 Outsourcing Introduction Objectives of this chapter Outsourcing Outsourcing methodologies Outsourcing – pitfalls How to avoid pitfalls

51 58 59 59 61 62 63 64 65 69 70 75 80 85 85 86

89 89 89 90 90 93 94 96 97 98 103 103 104 104 105 107 107 108

111 113 113 113 114 121 124 126

vi

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 6

27/09/2021 12:27


Contents

Outsourcing update Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

5 Quality management Introduction Objectives of this chapter What is quality? Continuous improvement Statistical process control Taguchi methods for the ‘off-line’ control of quality Failure mode and effect analysis The House of Quality Specification Producing a specification Sustainable specifications Early supplier involvement Standardisation Correction of defects Quality circles Value analysis/value engineering Make-or-buy decisions Six Sigma Quality update: Quality 4.0 Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

6 Inventory management Introduction Objectives of this chapter Provisioning systems Order quantities and stock control Materials requirements planning (MRP) Manufacturing resource planning (MRP2) Enterprise resource planning (ERP) Just-in-time (JIT) Lean and agile supply Vendor-managed inventory (VMI) Covid-19: just-in-case inventory? Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

128 130 130 131

133 133 133 134 138 140 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 151 152 154 157 157 158 159

160 160 160 161 161 167 170 173 174 178 187 189 192 192 192

vii

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 7

27/09/2021 12:27


Contents

7 Lead time and time compression

194

Introduction Objectives of this chapter Time and competitive advantage On-time delivery Lead-time improvement Effect of Covid-19 pandemic on supply chains Supply chain resilience Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

194 194 194 198 204 205 205 205 206 206

8 Sourcing strategies and relationships

208

Introduction Objectives of this chapter The nature of the sourcing decision Attributes of a good supplier Sourcing decisions Sources of information on potential suppliers Supplier evaluation Carter’s 10 Cs model Impact of supply chain disruption – Covid-19 pandemic Award criteria Sustainable sourcing The right relationship Other aspects of sourcing Collaboration and partnering The Bensaou model of relationship management Tiering of suppliers Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

9 Price and total cost of ownership (TCO) Introduction Objectives of this chapter Factors affecting pricing decisions How buyers obtain prices Auctions Discounts Price analysis and cost analysis Pricing major contracts Investment appraisal Learning curves and experience curves

208 208 209 210 210 212 213 219 223 223 225 227 229 232 236 240 242 243 243

245 245 245 245 253 253 253 255 265 268 269

viii

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 8

27/09/2021 12:27


Contents

Conclusion Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

10 Negotiations Introduction Objectives of this chapter Negotiation Negotiation skills Preparation The introductory stage The discussion stage The agreement stage The post-negotiation stage SPEED negotiation process Competition and cooperation in negotiation Distributive and integrative approaches Body language Negotiation strategies Best practice negotiation Summaries of other examples of best practice negotiation approaches Virtual negotiations Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

Part 3 APPLICATIONS 11 Project procurement Introduction Objectives of this chapter Introduction to projects Project planning Project control The ‘should cost model’ (SCM) Subcontracting Network analysis Risk Disaster recovery Blockchain in project management Predictive analytics Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

271 271 271 272

273 273 273 273 275 276 284 284 286 286 286 287 293 294 294 295 299 300 302 302 302

305 307 307 307 308 309 310 316 316 318 323 328 329 330 330 331 331

ix

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 9

27/09/2021 12:27


Contents

12 Procurement of commodities

333

Introduction Objectives of this chapter The principal commodities Why do commodity prices fluctuate? Price stabilisation schemes The role of the speculator Hedging with futures contracts The difference between futures and forwards Some buying techniques Indifference prices Traded options Rare earth metals Application of Blockchain for sustainability and traceability Glossary Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

333 333 334 337 338 339 339 341 342 344 347 348 348 349 349 350 350

13 International sourcing, global sourcing and onshoring

352

Introduction Objectives of this chapter Global sourcing and international procurement Why source internationally? Increases in offshoring Issues with international sourcing Incoterms (2020) How to change Countertrade Latest developments – onshoring and nearshoring Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

14 Capital procurement Introduction Objectives of this chapter The acquisition of capital equipment What are capital items? Leasing and hiring of capital equipment Capital requisitions The project approach Lifetime costs Investment appraisal

352 352 353 355 356 357 362 365 367 368 371 372 372

375 375 375 375 377 377 378 379 380 380

x

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 10

27/09/2021 12:27


Contents

Investment appraisal criteria Conclusion Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

15 Retail procurement Introduction Objectives of this chapter Retailing Retailing research Supply chains in retailing Indirect procurement Application of technology Brands Developments in the retail sector Conclusion Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

16 Services procurement Introduction Objectives of this chapter Special factors Service quality Managing perceptions and satisfaction Procurement of marketing services Procuring public relations (PR) How to buy legal services Procurement of consultancy services Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

382 387 387 387 388

389 389 389 390 392 392 394 394 395 396 400 401 401 401

403 403 403 403 405 407 413 418 421 423 429 429 430

17 Corporate social responsibility and sustainability

431

Introduction Objectives of this chapter Corporate social responsibility (CSR) Sustainability Business drivers for socially responsible procurement Social Accountability 8000 (SA8000) Three pillars of CSR Diversity

431 432 432 434 442 444 447 449

xi

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 11

27/09/2021 12:27


Contents

Social value Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

Part 4 INDUSTRY 4.0: E-PROCUREMENT SYSTEMS AND CONTRACT MANAGEMENT 18 Industry 4.0: e-procurement, digitalisation and analytics Introduction Objectives of this chapter What is e-procurement? The benefits of e-procurement Complex procurement Reverse auctions Measuring the benefits of e-procurement Industry 4.0 Analytics Conclusion Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

19 Contract law Introduction Objectives of this chapter Contract law International contract law Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

20 Contract management Introduction Objectives of this chapter Contract management Critical success factors The Contract Management Cycle Trust 360-degree relationship assessment, measurement and feedback Performance management A balanced performance measurement system Benefits of contract management Examples of performance metrics

452 452 453 453

457 459 459 459 460 462 462 463 466 468 479 482 483 483 483

486 486 486 486 514 515 516 516

517 517 517 517 518 520 529 531 533 534 535 537

xii

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 12

27/09/2021 12:27


Contents

Service level agreements (SLAs) Procurement as the intelligent customer Benchmarking in procurement and supply Summary Self-assessment tasks References and further reading

539 543 544 545 545 546

Index

548

Publisher’s acknowledgements

563

Supporting resources Visit go.pearson.com/uk/he/resources to find valuable online resources For instructors ■ An Instructor’s Manual that includes learning objectives, a list of the case studies, figures and research boxes within each chapter and teaching notes. ■ A set of PowerPoint slides from the book. For more information please contact your local Pearson Education sales representative or visit go.pearson.com/uk/he/resources

xiii

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 13

27/09/2021 12:27


Preface The original text was written over 40 years ago by Peter Baily and David Farmer and was in its day one of a very small number of specialised texts relating to the field of purchasing and supply. Since that time, purchasing and supply chain management has become recognised as a crucial strategic activity by those concerned with organisational management and as a recognised academic discipline, with a growing number of university professors dedicated to the subject area. It is reassuring to note that the literature on the subject continues to expand, as does the amount of academic and practitioner interest in it, reflected in the now substantial number of university degrees available at both under- and postgraduate level. The visionary and pioneering work that Peter and David took part in, probably to some extent as a gesture of faith, is now fully justified. The text could not have survived for this length of time without continuous change, and of course the idea behind this new edition is to continue that process. It should be pointed out that the change process is evolutionary, and that we have taken care to balance the newer philosophies emerging in our profession with the proven and established thinking and practice. This text is not of the ‘read this and it will change your life’ genre; rather it is, we hope, a reflection of sound mainstream practice, accompanied by comment on the way things seem to be going, and insights into developing ideas and approaches. This twelfth edition has been substantially updated with many additions in the form of more detailed case studies, additional academic content and the inclusion of more practical examples of best practice in many key areas.

Revisions and additions Specifically, readers will note the following new elements: the inclusion of three self-assessment tasks at the end of each chapter; a comprehensive review of the future of procurement; ■ material explaining the long-term changes in strategy in response to supply disruptions caused by disasters and by the Covid-19 pandemic inserted into various chapters; ■ ■

xiv

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 14

27/09/2021 12:27


Preface

a revised chapter considering Industry 4.0 tools such as e-procurement, Blockchain, the Internet of Things, Big Data, artificial intelligence (AI), bots, digitalisation and analytics; ■ diversity and supplier diversity considered in detail; ■ the inclusion of supply chain resilience approaches; ■ considerable coverage of sustainability provided across relevant chapters; ■ the inclusion of social value strategies and approaches; ■ the inclusion of virtual negotiation approaches in response to the growing trend of working from home; ■ in the wake of the Covid-19 pandemic, updated additional material ­exploring offshoring/onshoring; ■ third sector/not-for-profit procurement considered; ■ additional material for coverage of risk; ■ consideration of just-in-case inventory as a method of improving resilience; ■ the inclusion of the procurement of consultancy; ■ the inclusion of a Contract Management Cycle; ■ retail procurement completely revised to include omnichannel challenges and digital tools; ■ supplier relationship management (SRM) expanded to include two-way, 360-degree relationship measurement; ■ the addition of quality function deployment (QFD) and the House of Quality (HOQ); ■ ratio analysis for analysing financial viability of suppliers now included. ■

We are very grateful for the contribution of Alexis Brooks CIMA and David Moore of Cranfield University to the revised Chapter 3 on the subject of buying for government and public services. We also thank Neil Fuller, a chief examiner for the Chartered Institute of Procurement and Supply, for his help and advice, and for his contribution of material included in our treatment of the ‘quality’ theme. Finally, we thank Ray Carter for his permission for inclusion of 10 Cs and Paul Jackson for his permission for inclusion of extracts from his ‘Three Pillars’ article and the ‘Category Management Rainbow’ article. The text is, as before, organised into four parts. The first, on the theme of objectives and development and covering Chapters 1–3, deals with the scope of procurement activity and its evolution, relevant strategic issues and ­considerations, the structure and organisation of procurement and ­public sector procurement. The second part, Chapters 4–10, looks at the key procurement variables of quality, inventory, lead time, sourcing, total cost of ownership and price and negotiation. Part 3, Chapters 11–17, concerns itself with important procurement activities and applications, dealing with ­processes associated with buying in particular markets or economic sectors. The final part, covering Chapters 18–20, deals with Industry 4.0, contract law and contract management. We continue to hope that the text will appeal to those in the practitioner and academic communities. We have attempted to strike a balance between

xv

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 15

27/09/2021 12:27


Preface

the demands of a pure academic text and the sometimes-simplistic treatment of ideas encountered in the literature aimed at managers. We are grateful for the help and support of many colleagues and friends who have contributed in a great variety of ways, and to the copyright holders of some of the included material. Specific acknowledgements are, of course, made at the appropriate points in the text. Barry Crocker

xvi

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 16

27/09/2021 12:27


Acknowledgements We would like to thank the reviewers, John Bancroft, Oxford Brookes University; Dr Kamila Walters, University of Brighton; Nicholas Barnett, University of Westminster; Dr Trevor Stone, University of Lincoln; and Alexa Kirkaldy, University of Warwick, for their valuable feedback. We should also like to thank Rosalind, without whom this edition would not have been possible.

xvii

F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 17

27/09/2021 12:27


F01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 18

27/09/2021 12:27


Part 1 Procurement objectives and development Chapter 1 Procurement scope and development Chapter 2 Strategic procurement and supply chain management Chapter 3 Public sector procurement

1

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 1

24/09/2021 11:22


M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 2

24/09/2021 11:22


1 Procurement scope and development Introduction Procurement is facing increasing complexity and challenges as, in addition to delivering sourcing cost savings, it is expected to enhance its influence and extend its value-adding impact into strategic areas such as sustainability, diversity, ­digitalisation, risk management, corporate strategy alignment and innovation. In this chapter we examine the developing role of the procurement and supply function in managing challenges, and comment upon the ways in which the activity can contribute to the efficiency and effectiveness of an organisation, offering mini case studies demonstrating how companies are developing their procurement contribution in terms of value added. We shall highlight how purchasing has become a subset of procurement, including the objectives and phases of the procurement cycle. We will identify ways of measuring the stage of development reached by an organisation and demonstrate how the development stage reached can affect performance of the procurement activity.

Objectives of this chapter To discuss the scope of purchasing and procurement ■ To identify the procurement cycle concept ■ To introduce the concept of sustainable procurement ■ To introduce a category of risks, including fraud and corruption risks ■ To discuss the changing role of purchasing and supply ■ To examine the ‘total acquisition cost’ concept ■ To highlight the evolution of concepts relating to purchasing development and the emergence of procurement ■ To identify key practices encountered in developed strategic procurement ■ To provide mini case studies demonstrating how companies are developing their procurement functions ■

3

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 3

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

The scope of purchasing A well-known statement of the objectives of purchasing is: to acquire the right quality of material, at the right time, in the right quantity, from the right source, at the right price. This is known as the five rights. This statement is criticised by some as being rather superficial and simplistic. This is undoubtedly a valid comment, though the definition does provide a practical starting point for discussion. For present purposes, the following broad statement of objectives is suggested: To supply the organisation with a flow of materials and services to meet its needs ■ To ensure continuity of supply by maintaining effective relationships with existing sources and by developing other sources of supply either as alternatives or to meet emerging or planned needs ■ To buy efficiently and wisely, obtaining by ethical, diverse and sustainable means the best value for every pound spent ■ To maintain sound cooperative relationships with other departments, providing information and advice as necessary to ensure the effective operation of the organisation as a whole ■ To develop staff, policies, procedures and organisation to ensure the achievement of these objectives ■ To employ digital and analytical tools to add value. ■

Companies therefore need to be adopting procurement’s contribution in terms of adding value, strategic alignment and as a key driver of competitive advantage.

Mini case study – Hertz Buyers have been urged to remember their business’s overall strategy when trying to transform their procurement. If procurement cannot align itself with what the organisation wants to achieve, it will not get the support for what it wants.

In addition, we might add some more specific objectives, such as: To select the best suppliers in the market To help generate the effective development of new products ■ To protect the company’s cost structure ■ To maintain the correct quality/value balance ■ To monitor supply market trends ■ To negotiate effectively in order to work with suppliers who will seek mutual benefit through economically superior performance ■ To adopt environmentally responsible and sustainable supply management ■ To promote diversity in the supply chain. ■ ■

4

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 4

24/09/2021 11:22


Sustainable procurement

Sustainable procurement Sustainable procurement can be defined as: a process whereby procurement meets their needs for goods and services in a way that achieves value for money on a whole-life basis in terms of generating benefits not only for the organisation, but also to society and the economy whilst minimizing damage to the environment.

Four key aims are: To minimise negative impacts of goods, works or services across their life cycle and through the supply chain ■ To minimise demand for non-renewable resources ■ To ensure that fair contract prices and terms are applied and respected ■ To promote diversity and equality throughout the supply chain. ■

(Sustainable sourcing is covered in Chapters 8 and 17 in detail, and in other chapters as appropriate.) It is by including many of these objectives that purchasing has evolved into procurement. Indeed, many commentators state that following the Covid-19 pandemic, procurement’s critical business role has finally being recognised. CIPS support this view in that, in the past, procurement had been focused on delivering value and ensuring consistency and continuity of supply, whereas now it is about managing the risk agenda (issues such as modern slavery, sustainability, diversity and innovation).

■ Risk management Risks can be categorised as follows: Operational risk: Operational supplier failure can delay or interrupt the inbound flow of goods and materials, potentially leading to loss of revenue. ■ Quality risk: Low-cost country sourcing has exposed procurement to new suppliers whose perception of quality and adherence to standards may not match those of its customer or tier-one suppliers. (Tier-one suppliers provide products and components directly to original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) and also manage tier two, with whom only they have contracts.) ■ Compliance risk: Accordingly, with increased regulations and heightened awareness of social, ethical and sustainability requirements, procurement carries a significant risk of legal intervention, damage to reputation and additional costs. ■ Strategic risk: The strategic risks arise from commercial exposure to loss or theft of intellectual property (IP), threatening market share and position. ■

Procurement must identify, evaluate and mitigate these risks and develop contingency plans, and must set up a risk management process to monitor and measure exposure, potential mitigation costs and effectiveness. Once

5

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 5

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

established, effective risk management is sustained throughout the supplier relationship, not just at contract or renewal. Risks can be reduced by effective procurement through: encouraging the proactive monitoring, identification and assessment of supply chain, supplier and supply market risks; ■ providing greater end-to-end supply chain data sharing, transparency and visibility for ‘early warning’ risk identification; ■ transparency and trust in individual supplier relationships; ■ improving security and continuity of supply; ■ rigorous selection of long-term strategic supply chain partners; ■ effective management of contracts and supplier performance in order to minimise financial, project, operational and reputational risk; ■ encouraging systems integration, reducing risks arising from complexity, incompatibility and coordination issues; ■ encouraging supply chain mapping for risk and vulnerability identification; ■ end-to-end supply chain visibility, to support corporate social responsibility, sustainability and diversity. ■

The following case demonstrates efforts to gain visibility and traceability beyond tier two.

Case study – VF Corporation The firm has mapped its tier-one to tier-four suppliers as part of efforts to improve supply chain sustainability and worker wellbeing by enhancing its traceability mapping programme to trace its supply chain, from raw materials conversion to product distribution. Traceability is key to building an ethical and sustainable supply chain and drives improvements for both people and sustainability in the supply chain.

■ Fraud and corruption risk There are two main categories of fraud: 1 Removal of funds or assets: theft of cash or stock; ■ procurement fraud (e.g. collusion over inflated or duplicated invoices); ■ misuse of assets. ■

2 Intentional misrepresentation of the company’s financial position: ■ ■

overstating profits; misrepresentation to induce a contract.

6

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 6

24/09/2021 11:22


Sustainable procurement

The four main preconditions for fraud are: 1 Motive: a reason why they need money or feel entitled to defraud the organisation. 2 There must be opportunity: to remove the assets, and to derive gain from them. 3 There must be a failure of internal control or fraud risk management. 4 There must be assets worth stealing. Fraud prevention measures comprise the following: clarity around the definition and consequences of fraud; creating a well-defined process for dealing with fraud (processing evidence); ■ implementing spend analysis techniques for clear visibility, tracking and monitoring and auditing of expenditure. ■ ■

The UK Bribery Act 2010 covers explanation of bribery, being bribed, bribery of officials and failure of an organisation to prevent bribery on its behalf.

■ Risk mitigation

Research The following strategies are being pursued post-Covid in order to mitigate risks: ■ ■ ■ ■ ■

improved visibility into tier two and three; agility in switching suppliers; closer collaboration; increasing inventory (just-in-case); multi-sourcing.

The Chartered Institute of Procurement and Supply (the CIPS) has a risk index to understand the risks to which supply chains are exposed (see Chapters 11 and 20 for additional coverage of risk). However, research appears to indicate that there are still difficulties with the perception of procurement. Over half of senior management fail to understand procurement’s broader strategic impact, seeing it as negotiating savings, not working strategically; although the top 25 per cent have the highest return on investment in procurement, and perform better at: reducing working capital; operational efficiencies and cost savings; ■ risk management; ■ using analytics; ■ advanced sourcing methods; ■ working with suppliers to improve innovation and risk management. ■ ■

7

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 7

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

State-of-the-art procurement has shifted towards becoming a business partner that supports the organisation in achieving the broader enterprise goals. Let us now briefly introduce a summary of the differences between purchasing and procurement. Purchasing is: reactive – obtaining inputs in response to requests; transactional – concerned with processing purchase orders and contracts; ■ tactical – focused on short-term processes and goals. ■ ■

Procurement involves the process of selecting vendors, establishing payment terms, strategic vetting, selection, the negotiation of contracts and actual purchasing of goods. It is concerned with acquiring (procuring) all the goods, services and work that is vital to an organisation. Procurement is, essentially, the overarching or umbrella term within which purchasing can be found. Procurement is therefore: a wider term than purchasing, including purchasing, hiring, leasing and outsourcing; ■ a broader process than purchasing, in that purchasing is described in terms of purchase to pay (P2P) – i.e. purchase order, expediting, receipt of delivery and payment – whereas procurement includes activities prior to the act of purchase, such as: – identification and definition of a business need; – surveying the market to identify potential suppliers and gather intelligence (e.g. availability, price, technology and sustainability); – sourcing (identifying and selecting suppliers); – negotiation and development of contracts. ■

and activities after the purchase, such as: – ongoing contract management – ensuring that both sides fulfil their obligations under a contract; – supplier relationship management, dispute resolution and contract review. ■ more proactive, relational (with both internal and external stakeholders), strategic, integrated with other functions (i.e. cross-functional teams CFTs) and aligned with the strategic goals.

Case study – Kraft Heinz (KH ) KH aims to save $1.2 billion in four years through procurement by changing from cost reduction to continuous improvement, innovation and building ‘true supplier partnerships’ in the following ways: 1 Sourcing excellence: KH will address unexplored opportunities while strengthening key relationships through digitalisation to address its spend risks and drive efficiency.

8

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 8

24/09/2021 11:22


The procurement cycle

2 External manufacturing: KH is replacing transactional approaches with collaboration to enhance innovation. 3 Procurement centre: Indirect spend had more than 20,000 suppliers, therefore KH is looking to centralise this spend to ‘ensure proper visibility and control to drive consolidation of spend with contracts, utilising automation to drive price savings’ (e.g. previously similar materials had been bought across the company with a 20 to 30 per cent price difference). 4 Design to value: KH intends to implement a ‘design to value’ methodology, which would drive value engineering to feed innovation to remove cost out and add value, enabled by strong supplier collaboration with key strategic suppliers, to co-develop initiatives that drive efficiencies, innovation and sustainability (Hart, 2020).

Case study – Ford Purchasing and supply management for many is now directly linked to their companies’ business strategies and they recognise that it has a real impact on competitive advantage. Ford Motor Company believes that procurement controls the ultimate profitability of the company.

The procurement cycle A typical procurement cycle is depicted in Figure 1.1. All companies have a procurement cycle, although it may not be adding value; therefore, we shall show how to ensure that the procurement cycle can add value by evaluating the added value potential at each phase of the cycle.

■ Identify the need The normal procedure would be to issue a requisition, although, using a materials requirements planning (MRP) system, the identification of the need may instead be signalled by a ‘bill of materials’ (BOM). Procurement can challenge the need to add value by: challenging over-specification or unnecessary variation; suggesting alternatives that will offer better quality or a lower price; ■ ensuring sustainability concerns are considered. ■ ■

This challenge is a key potential source of added value, since it is designed to minimise waste in the form of unnecessary variation, features, quality, service levels and unnecessary costs.

9

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 9

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

Figure 1.1 A generic procurement cycle

Define the need Specification Identify the need Requisition or bill of materials Contract and supplier relationship management Monitor, review and maintain performance

Develop contract terms

Source the market Identify potential suppliers

Evaluate suppliers

Award the contract

Invite quotes/tenders RFQ or ITT

Negotiate best value

Analyse quotations and select supplier

■ Define the need A specification is a detailed description of the requirement, which can be communicated to potential suppliers. Detailed descriptions may already exist, but for new procurements they may have to be drawn up in the form of: specifications; service level agreements (added to the specification of services); ■ contract terms that set out the obligations of both buyer and seller in relation to the fulfilment of the specification. ■ ■

Specification

A specification can be simply defined as a ‘statement of the requirements to be satisfied in the supply of product or service’. The purpose and value added of an effective specification is to: define the requirement – stakeholders consider what they really need in order to add value; ■ communicate the requirement clearly to suppliers, so that they can plan to conform and use their expertise for innovative or lower-cost solutions; ■ provide a means of evaluating the quality or conformance of the goods or services supplied, to ensure that ‘right quality’ is achieved, and to minimise failure costs; ■ support standardisation and consistency, where items are multi-sourced; ■ to enable a sustainable design. ■

10

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 10

24/09/2021 11:22


The procurement cycle

There are two main types of specification: conformance specification and performance (or functional) specification. (These are outlined in Chapter 5.)

Early supplier involvement (ESI)

The principle of (ESI) is that procurement should involve suppliers at an early stage in the product or service development process. The main purpose of ESI is to enable a pre-qualified supplier (with proven supply and technical abilities) to contribute technical expertise, which procurement may lack, by making proactive suggestions to improve product or service design, to reduce the costs of production and to suggest alternative materials or methods at a time when changes are still possible. Figure 1.2 depicts how cost is committed and the positive effect of ESI.

■ Develop contract terms The role of a contract is to set out the roles, rights and obligations of both parties in a transaction or relationship. A contract implies an intention to ‘enter into legal relations’ – that is, both parties agree to be legally bound by the specified roles and responsibilities. Contract terms are statements by the parties to the contract as to what they understand their rights and obligations to be under the contract; they define the content of the ‘offer’ (or counter offer), which becomes binding once accepted by the other party (see Chapter 19 on contract law).

■ Source the market ‘Surveying the market’ means identifying or locating suppliers that may potentially be able to supply the requirement. Buyers need constantly to be monitoring the supply market(s). Today, procurement is under considerable pressure to

Figure 1.2 Specification and cost

Cost How we commit to cost

Identify need

Specify need

Cost-down impact of early buyer and supplier involvement

How we spend the money

Source

Install

Buy

Commission Time

11

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 11

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

deliver value-adding business performance, and it is no longer enough to build a supply management capability that is efficient, demand-driven, or even transparent. Procurement must offer something that is value adding: a new supply where the strategic scope of procurement’s value is delivered via innovation.

Questions to ask

How deep is the supply market intelligence capability? Is procurement proactively identifying emerging potential suppliers? Is thinking limited to tried-and-tested regional/local suppliers, even though the potential supply market may be global? By seriously considering the whole market, a more effective option may be discovered. For instance, following the Covid-19 pandemic supply disruption, a multi-source approach has increased (see Chapters 8 and 13 for coverage of sourcing options in the light of severe disruptions such as the Covid pandemic).

■ Evaluate suppliers The purpose of supplier appraisal or pre-qualification is to ensure that a potential supplier will be able to perform any contract or tender that is awarded, to the required standard. Such a process adds value by avoiding the wasted costs, time, effort and embarrassment of awarding a contract (on the basis of lowest price) to a tenderer who subsequently turns out to: lack capacity or technical capability to handle the work; have systems and values that are incompatible with the buying organisation; ■ be financially unstable and unable to complete the work because of cashflow problems or business failure. ■ ■

In addition, having a list of pre-qualified suppliers reduces the investigations needed for individual tenders and purchases: the buyer already knows that any supplier on the approved list has been assessed as capable of fulfilling requirements (see Carter’s 10 Cs model in Chapter 8).

■ Invite quotes/tenders Procurement may send an ‘enquiry’ or request for quotation to one or more short-listed suppliers. The RFQ (request for quotation) will set out the details of the requirement.

Competitive bidding or tendering

The organisation may prefer to use a competitive bidding or tendering procedure, in which pre-qualified suppliers are issued with an invitation to tender (ITT), or an invitation to bid for a contract, with the buyer intending to choose the supplier submitting the best proposal or the lowest price. There are several value-adding advantages to competitive bidding or tendering as opposed to negotiation: it ensures fairness and genuine competition between suppliers; it ensures that procurement decisions are soundly based on cost and

12

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 12

24/09/2021 11:22


The procurement cycle

Figure 1.3 Competitive tendering

Conditions when it is not appropriate Cost of supply is impossible to estimate

Other criteria such as quality and service are equally important as cost

Where scope and/or cost are likely to change

Where it is more appropriate to negotiate for complex and specific requirements

value for money; and it also engages a wide choice of suppliers, which may encourage innovative solutions to requirements. However, there are occasions when competitive tendering may not be appropriate (see Figure 1.3).

■ Analyse quotations and select supplier The general principle is that the successful tenderer will be the one with the lower total cost of ownership or the ‘most economically advantageous tender’. Therefore, a structured objective scoring system is essential for assessing bids. Here are three scoring mechanisms, each of which have cost marked against a 0–100 scale weighted at 50 per cent. This is then added to 50 per cent of the nonprice score.

Percentage scoring

Figure 1.4 Evaluating tenders – percentage scoring

In Figure 1.4, the lowest bid, A, is given a score of 100, B is 20 per cent more expensive so gets 80, and C is 30 per cent more so scores 70. The advantage of this method is it is simple and fair; the disadvantage is it produces high scores for cost in comparison to non-cost. In this method, C wins.

Percentage scoring Supplier

Quality

Weighted (50%)

Cost (£m)

Cost score

Weighted (50%)

Grand total

A

54

27

10

100

50

77

B

84

42

12

80

40

82

C

96

48

13

70

35

83

13

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 13

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

Figure 1.5 Evaluating tenders – scoring by rank

Scoring by rank Supplier

Quality

Weighted (50%)

Cost (£m)

Cost score

Weighted (50%)

Grand total

A

54

27

10

100

50

77

B

84

42

12

50

25

67

C

96

48

13

0

0

48

Scoring by rank

Figure 1.5 shows the highest price, 0, and the lowest, 100. All others are scored at equal increments, thus using the full range of scores. However, this method is unfair as two suppliers who are very close receive vastly different scores. Secondly, it distorts the weighting amplifying cost, so that an expensive bid, no matter how high the quality, cannot win. In this method, A wins.

Highest/lowest conceivable price

In this method (see Figure 1.6), you must first predetermine the highest and lowest conceivable prices. Let’s say £15m is the highest, scoring 0, and £7.5m is the lowest, scoring 100. High bids are punished but it will lead to scores of about 50–75 in line with non-cost, and bids very close are scored similarly, making it fair. In this method, B wins. Having looked at the three methods of evaluating tenders, the third method appears to be fairest and reflects valid decisions.

■ Negotiate best value Negotiation may be the main approach by which contract terms are arrived at, especially the added value of negotiating lean and agile approaches, innovation and continuous improvement (see Chapter 10 on negotiations).

Figure 1.6 Evaluating highest/ lowest conceivable price/cost

Highest/lowest conceivable price/cost Supplier

Quality

Weighted (50%)

Cost (£m)

Cost score

Weighted (50%)

Grand total

A

54

27

10

66

33

60

B

84

42

12

40

20

62

C

96

48

13

26

13

61

14

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 14

24/09/2021 11:22


The procurement cycle

■ Award the contract The contract should now be formally recognised by issuing the relevant contract documentation. Typically, the components for the actual contract will be the specification and/or invitation to tender, the supplier’s written proposal, plus any terms or modifications that may have been agreed in negotiation (see Chapter 18 for ‘smart contracts’).

The purchaseto-pay (P2P) sequence

Once the contract has been awarded, a new sequence of activity is required known as the purchase-to-pay, or P2P, sequence (see Figure 1.7).

■ Contract management and supplier relationship management Managing a contract effectively contributes towards added value by reducing the risk of non-conformance and ensuring continuity of supply. Contract management includes the use of key performance indicators (KPIs) and service level agreements (SLAs) (see Chapter 20 for a comprehensive coverage of contract management). Figure 1.8 compares contract management and supplier relationship management (SRM).

Figure 1.7 Purchase-to-pay (P2P) sequence

BUYER

Purchase order

SUPPLIER

Procurement

Order acknowledgment

Sales

Chasing expediting Fulfillment/operations Goods inward

Advice note (with delivery)

Goods received note

Invoice

Accounts

Payment

Accounts

15

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 15

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

Figure 1.8 Contract management versus supplier relationship management (SRM)

Contract management

SRM

Individual contract

Management of the relationship

Fixed duration

Open-ended, long-term and continuous relationship

Arms length/transactional

Long-term collaboration

Compliance with the contract

Developing and improving supplier capabilities and performance to contribute to objectives

Relationship focused on contract performance

Types of relationship, deepening of trust, integration, compatibility, joint values and relationship measurement

Terms of contract are clear cut

Terms and values are much less explicit and are negotiated over time (e.g. relationship charter)

Primarily operational – administration, supplier performance and governance

Tactical and strategic – supplier development

Procurement transformations We have seen how a procurement cycle can add value. There must be a focus on delivering value – that is the essence of procurement, as an excessive focus on the lowest price following a transactional and reactive process can be hugely expensive, with non-compliance causing the supply chain to falter, thus failing to meet customer requirements. Figure 1.9 provides a useful summary of the different ways in which procurement can add value, which resonates well with some of our previous observations.

Research A recent ‘Advanced Procurement Trends Report’ found just 40 per cent of respondents said cost-cutting was their main objective, compared to 80 per cent three years ago, emphasising a move to a more strategic approach, improving contract management and effective spend analysis. This supports the view that the historically tactical perception of procurement is starting to fade in favour of a much more strategic and critical function. This view is also supported by Syson, who states that purchasing has been transformed from a service function (whose aims were expressed in the price, quality and delivery equation) to one (procurement) that makes a contribution to sustainable competitive advantage by reducing the cost of ownership, cycle time and improving time to market.

16

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 16

24/09/2021 11:22


Procurement transformations

Figure 1.9 Approaches to add value

Manage and mitigate risk

Avoid ineffective spend

Continuous improvement

Insource/outsource

Optimise specifications

Drive compliance VALUE ADDED LEVERS

Drive supplier performance Supply innovation

Minimise TCO

Extend market research Competition

Sustainable supply chains

Case study – TransGrid Energy provider TransGrid was overall winner at the CIPS Australasia SM awards 2020 for lifting procurement from a ‘transactional focus to a strategic business partner’, working collaboratively with the business to deliver previously untapped value for money. The company developed a ‘transformation roadmap’ embarking on a technology transformation to digitise procurement, and established a supplier relationship management programme. TransGrid wanted to ensure a ‘business-aligned, enterprise-wide procurement capability that is focused on outcomes for the stakeholders’. Benefits included: 43 per cent reduction of the PO cycle time; end-to-end RFX lead times cut by 25 per cent; ■ higher throughput and increased satisfaction; ■ generating $4.5m savings in 2018 and $6.1m in 2019; ■ contribution to business growth. ■ ■

(Hart, 2020)

Firms need access to competitive and productive supply markets if they are to be in business at all. The trend is from tactical to strategic procurement, establishing collaborative relationships with external resources and securing major business advantage from procurement.

17

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 17

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

Case study – Emirates airline Emirates transformed procurement from transactional purchasing to an adding-value function. It needed to get greater value from its AED1.3 billion annual spend. To achieve this, procurement moved from rubberstamping POs to a strategic, value-adding function, increasing sourcing transparency and building the right talent and culture. The airline adopted four key approaches: people – recruiting and training a team with a shared vision; governance – covering policies, culture and performance reporting; ■ positioning – ensuring procurement is seen as leaders in sourcing solutions; ■ technology – for efficient and effective delivery. ■ ■

Benefits of the transformation included: AED85m in savings; improved requisition to order time from 35.1 days to 4.1 by a P2P that would speed-up transactions; ■ improved spend visibility; ■ paying suppliers on time; ■ savings through better contract compliance. ■ ■

It is necessary to look at what transformation means from a procurement perspective: essentially it can be defined as organisational change management, designed to improve procurement processes, activities and relationships. As a general principle, this means that procurement transformation should address: strategy and performance; ■ the structure of resources and how they are organised; ■ improving the overall effectiveness of the systems supporting procurement; ■ governance; ■ risk management; ■ sustainability and diversity to ensure compliance with business policy and legislation. ■

Three steps to success need to be negotiated: 1 Establishing a compelling case for change. 2 Finding a realistic and value-creating solution that supports the wider business vision and brings clarity of mind to the end goal. 3 Executing the transformation based on changing behaviour, culture and mind-set.

18

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 18

24/09/2021 11:22


The changing role of procurement and supply

■ Critical success factors – points to consider Procurement transformations require a clear vision from the top, an unswerving desire to make it happen and commitment from everyone to ensure the changes are sustained over the long term. All good procurement functions continually challenge themselves to answer the following questions. How well does my current strategy and organisation support the delivery of the organisation’s strategy and objectives? Is this delivering the value it could? If the answer to one or both of these questions is not positive, you have the basis for a case for change. Simply to improve service levels or to cut costs is no longer enough. Procurement must focus on its relationship to end-market performance. In many cases, procurement has moved through evolution of its role to devolution of much of the more straightforward buying activity, while retaining and developing its strategic contribution. Indeed, advances in artificial intelligence, advanced analytics, bot technology and digital supply chain connectivity will have a profound impact on procurement and will optimise and automate the transactional parts of the process while improving the speed of decision making (see Chapter 18 for Industry 4.0 and digitalisation).

The changing role of procurement and supply As we have indicated, procurement is seen by many of today’s successful organisations as an activity of considerable strategic importance. The fact that the strategic role and contribution of procurement and supply is well recognised in many leading commercial concerns has meant that the strategic procurement decisions are taken by procurement involvement at board level, rather than by a departmental manager.

Mini case study – Nokia The answer to whether procurement is strategic is yes, if one considers strategic contribution to an organisation to be any activity that drives market penetration, revenue growth, profit maximisation and shareholder value. For any function, including procurement, to be considered strategic, it must align itself directly with these organisational priorities. The case for direct procurement as a strategic contributor to an organisation’s agenda is well proven in many Fortune 500 organisations, such as IBM and Ford, in which there are numerous examples of supply markets being managed to drive margin, market position and value. There have been a number of well-publicised examples, such as GlaxoSmithKline, where the contribution of procurement has been an important part of post-merger cost-efficiency improvement. Nokia has been recognised as having designed and used all areas of its supply chain for competitive advantage. Both financial and value benefits can be delivered from strategic

19

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 19

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

procurement and its procurement professionals know that the segmentation of categories and supplier relationships are at the heart of delivering both strategic and tactical value to an organisation. If this happens, the organisation can focus on managing its supply base for speed to market, cost advantage, innovation and value. This will always be of interest in the boardroom and can only be considered strategic.

■ Leading-edge concepts Approaches and concepts that might be considered under this heading are: best-practice benchmarking; ■ total quality management (TQM); ■ just-in-time philosophies and lean production; ■ supply chain concepts; ■ tiering and empowerment of suppliers; ■ relationship management; ■ customer focus; ■ corporate social responsibility (CSR); ■ diversity in the workforce and supply base; ■ social value; ■ sustainability. ■

Research Leading procurement functions are: ■ ■ ■ ■

85 per cent aligned with corporate strategy; influencing less-common areas of spend such as R&D, marketing and legal; increasing collaboration with suppliers on innovation; emphasising sustainability and diversity.

Case study – Inmarsat Inmarsat (a mobile satellite communication company) had a plan to repurpose its contracts team and bring in procurement and category management specialists. Procurement processes had been insular, with technical experts developing solutions with incumbent suppliers and procurement not involved until asked to draw up the deal. Procurement was now to have early involvement, with the technical experts delivering about $100 million of savings in just three years (Buist, 2018).

20

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 20

24/09/2021 11:22


The changing role of procurement and supply

Table 1.1 Some reasons for the increased importance and recognition of procurement

TOTAL ORGANISATIONAL EXPENDITURE Labour and overheads

Externally provided resources

Decreasing because of:

Increasing because of:

● automation

● greater specialisation on part of buying

organisations

● more efficient work ● competitiveness depending on access to

‘best practice’

● ‘outsourcing’ policies ● focus on core competencies ● development of specialised contractors ● easier access to world supply market ● complex technology restricting breadth of

‘make’ capabilities ● flexibility depending on external rather than

dedicated ‘owned’ assets ● closer coordination with key suppliers

■ Increasing proportion of revenue spent externally As outlined in Table 1.1, organisations are spending a greater proportion of their income externally and less on internal costs such as wages and overheads. With the increased share of the expenditure comes an increasing responsibility for procurement.

■ Innovation As product life cycles get shorter, reaction times are being compressed. Procurement must be prepared to help initiate new ideas and developments. A good deal of attention is being paid today to ‘time-to-market’ initiatives. New products cannot be developed and marketed rapidly without a proactive procurement function.

Case study – AstraZeneca Collaborating with suppliers has improved the speed of product development to reduce time to market by reducing the time it takes to swop data by 70 per cent, which has taken weeks out of the process. The supplier development involved has incentivised structures to share gains (Leach, 2011).

A successful innovation programme relies on a strong foundation built on market research, problem definition and trialling, according to Cummins (Patchett, 2019). The following actions are essential to build a successful innovation approach: 1 Network and collaborate – networking with diverse companies and industry peers. 2 Problem definition – stakeholder workshops are used.

21

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 21

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

3 Launch and trial – it is important to continuously de-risk the process to mitigate problems and reduce barriers during this stage. 4 Scale it up – communication plans are vital during the onboarding of suppliers to ensure problems are identified and suppliers are supported. Royal London managed to onboard a start-up supplier that was loss-making and weaker on risk, but which had ‘an extraordinary product’ (Jacobs, 2018). They were then able to get a new product to market in three months, giving them considerable competitive advantage over other firms. Indeed, a common view of procurement is that the Covid-19 pandemic proved to be a catalyst for innovation, such as an increased adoption of digital procurement tools to improve supplier vulnerability and risk exposure.

■ Visibility of procurement Certainly, it is the case that crises such as earthquakes and the Covid-19 pandemic have put a focus on procurement and the supply chain and have exposed weaknesses such as a lack of visibility, flexibility and agility. This could represent a defining moment as procurement, once seen as the blocker within the business either looking to cut costs or impose unnecessary gateways, has suddenly become the key that unlocks critical supplies, goods and services.

Figure 1.10 The increasing importance of purchasing and supply in the manufacturing sector

In large automotive, electronic and retail organisations, percentages of boughtout material and services expenditure in relation to sales income run at between 60 and 90 per cent. It is interesting to note that this proportion has been increasing steadily for many years (see Figure 1.10).

100

Profit

80 Disposal of revenue (%)

The level and percentage of purchased goods and services

Wages, salaries and overheads 60

40 Materials and services 20

0 1960

1970

1980

1990

2000

2010

today

Year

22

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 22

24/09/2021 11:22


Proactive procurement

Structural changes Moves towards materials management, logistics and supply chain concepts have in turn helped to develop the procurement and supply function.

Proactive procurement As the level of attention paid to procurement and supply increases, the work tends to become more strategic in emphasis, concentrating more upon such activities as negotiating longer-term relationships, sustainability, diversity, social value, supplier development and total cost reduction, rather than ordering and replenishing routines.

Research A survey by PA Consulting identified six dimensions to optimising total costs: 1 2 3 4 5 6

Strategy Organisation and governance Processes Tools Competencies and skills Methodologies.

If procurement focuses on these areas, cost optimisation does not just protect organisations during uncertain times, it also identifies ways to increase margins, gains new product insight and facilitates innovation (Hart, 2020).

Procurement should become a consultant and change agent for internal customers being guided by business priorities, whether they be speed, quality, risk or innovation. Leading procurement utilises techniques including TCO (total cost of ownership), cost analysis, benchmarking, managing demand and specifications, ensuring supply continuity and mitigating risk, promoting sustainability, and accessing new developments and innovations. Table 1.2 compares and contrasts reactive with proactive procurement.

Case study – Feedwater Feedwater believes purchasing should be as effective in promoting business growth as it is in controlling costs. By working cleverly with suppliers through strategic alliances – by sharing information, or getting goods on a just-in-time basis – it can deliver better value for money to clients and enhance profitability.

23

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 23

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

Table 1.2 Changing ­purchasing roles: reactive and proactive buying

Reactive buying

Proactive buying

● Purchasing is a cost centre

● Procurement can add value

● Purchasing receives specifications

● Procurement (and suppliers) contribute to

● Purchasing rejects defective material ● Purchasing reports to finance or

production

specification ● Procurement avoids defective supplies ● Procurement is a main management function

● Buyers respond to market conditions

● Procurement contributes to making markets

● Problems are suppliers’ responsibility

● Problems are a shared responsibility

● Price is key variable

● Total cost and value are key variables

● Emphasis on today

● Emphasis on strategic

● Systems independent of suppliers

● Systems integrated with suppliers’ systems,

● Users or designers specify

utilising digital tools

● Negotiations win/lose

● Buyers and suppliers contribute to specification

● Plenty of suppliers = security

● Negotiations win–win (or better)

● Plenty of stock = security ● Information is power ● Little attention to sustainability, diversity

or social value ● Lack of integration internally ● Purchasing is not aligned to corporate strategy ● Little analysis of demand

● Internal and external cross-functional team

working ● Plenty of suppliers = lost opportunities ● Plenty of stock = waste ● Information is valuable if shared ● Sustainability, social value and diversity are

pursued ● Procurement objectives are aligned with

corporate objective ● Advanced analytics employed

The changing nature of relationships Much more attention has been paid in recent years to the development of ‘mutual’ supplier–buyer relationships, where the benefits of doing business together arise from ideas of sharing as well as exchanging. In a mutual relationship the emphasis is on building a satisfactory outcome together with, for example, such things as technology. Confidence and support are invested on both sides with the intention of adding value – a process not possible with a simple transaction. The organisations concerned seek to come closer together and to identify overlapping interests. (These ideas will be referred to in more detail in Chapter 8.) Figures 1.11 and 1.12 enable a comparison between the transactional and the mutual relationship. The list of shared benefits is by way of example only and will vary between relationships.

Figure 1.11 The ‘transactional’ relationship

Money Buyer

Seller Work

24

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 24

24/09/2021 11:22


The changing nature of relationships

Figure 1.12 The ‘mutual’ relationship Confidence Technology

Buyer

Commitment Seller Efficiency Information Support

Case study – Britvic The procurement function was historically positioned in a supporting role, mainly working on delivering a large number of marketing projects linked to brand activity, looking at things within a very short window of time, and not able to concentrate on the purchasing basics. The team was supporting some business needs, but not the needs of the business overall. Britvic had to ensure that procurement best practices were redefined and embedded. This included spend analysis, market knowledge and assessment, contract management, supplier segmentation, risk assessment, cost structure, benchmarking of costs against markets and understanding the overall main business needs. The introduction of category management was a key milestone. This started to pave the way to strategic thinking and strategic sourcing. Stakeholders were proactively pursued on important business matters as opposed to being the ones making requests of the procurement team. Market information was provided to them to guide them on the correct business choices, and they were also asked to be decision makers on long-term strategies. Procurement generalists in business units needed to be backed up by category specialists. The procurement function promised a return over three years of 15 times the investment it was requesting from the business. Britvic was ready to launch the following strategies: a sustainable sourcing initiative; a complexity reduction programme; ■ long-term sourcing strategies; ■ development of new partnerships throughout the world. ■ ■

25

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 25

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

Now procurement staff are active members of all the leadership teams in business units; they provide guidance from a macroeconomic point of view; they bring ideas to all functions to impact the bottom line; and they add value. The procurement function has become a revenue stream for the company: it impacts the profit and loss with initiatives that are truly above budget. Cross-functional work will be key in the years to come. Procurement either leads the projects Britvic has identified for another function, or is asked to be a core member in projects from other functions. But it is far from financial deliverables only. The team has really improved on strategic thinking, has managed to think outside the box and do things differently. Influencing stakeholders, as a skill, has been key. Procurement will only be considered worthy of a board position if the function is core to the business – that is, critical to the bottom line. Impact on profit and loss can be measured in two ways: Impact is linked to the product/activity a company delivers because this product/activity is directly linked to the cost of goods or services. ■ Impact is created by procurement coming up with commercial ideas/ proposals that deliver beyond their expected scope of activity or deliverables. ■

Britvic is tapping into long-term relationships to bring in innovation, but is also looking at developing new ones that can impact the development of its products.

Procurement positioning Of course, it is not the case that any organisation will wish to develop mutual or partnership relationships with all of its suppliers. Pareto’s principle applies: it will generally be found that 80 per cent of expenditure will be with 20 per cent of suppliers, and it is likely to be those suppliers with whom large sums of money are spent that will be the ones with whom closer relationships are sought. A useful tool in determining those suppliers with whom close relationships might best be sought is the ‘procurement positioning’ tool, based on the work of Kraljic (1983), illustrated by Figure 1.13. The horizontal axis, labelled ‘Market complexity/risk’, is concerned with the degree of difficulty associated with sourcing a product or service, or the vulnerability of the client organisation to a failure of the supplier to provide the product or service on time, or to the failure ‘in service’ of a supply. The vertical axis, ‘Spend/profit potential’, is used to indicate the extent of the potential of the supply to contribute to the profitability (or efficiency) of the buying concern. This profit potential might be realised by achieving lower costs, either by paying a lower price for a good or service or by introducing more efficient buying methods.

26

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 26

24/09/2021 11:22


Procurement positioning

Figure 1.13 Kraljic procurement positioning

High

Spend/profit potential

Leverage

Strategic

Aggregate spend and maintain competition

Long-term collaboration with selected key suppliers

Non-critical

Bottleneck

Increase role of systems to reduce buying effort

Continuity of supply

Low Low

Decrease uniqueness of suppliers

Market complexity/risk

High

The foundation of procurement positioning is the division of key items procured into four categories on the basis of their associated risks and procurement potential.

■ Risk Risk consists of: ■ ■

supply risk – risks of vulnerability of the business to unreliability of supply; technical risk – risks arising during and after installation. The principal factors determining risk are:

the reliability of the sources of supply; the availability of the commodity or service required; ■ the degree of response by suppliers to the company’s requirements; ■ the quality of the product in relation to the role it is required to fulfil. ■ ■

Supply risk measures both the likelihood of a commodity or service not being available when it is required and the costs resulting from its non-availability. ‘Non-availability’ does not simply mean that an item is not physically present, but also includes failure to be effectively present due to, for example, a quality failure.

■ Procurement potential Procurement potential is the degree of opportunity that exists for the process of procuring the commodity or service under consideration to contribute to company profitability. It is a measure of the benefits that can be achieved by using an appropriate procurement strategy, as opposed to the unquestioning, mechanistic placement of orders. The benefits potentially include:

27

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 27

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

reducing the total cost of ownership (TCO); improving the quality of the procurement process; ■ improving the efficiency of the procurement process; ■ earlier sales or production due to reduced cycle time. ■ ■

■ The four categories The key commodities or services for which a company wishes to develop tailored procurement strategies can be ranked as high or low in terms both of risk exposure and of procurement potential. The score of an item in respect of each of these criteria determines the positioning of the commodity or service on the procurement positioning/ targeting matrix. The quadrants of the matrix represent the four categories, which are: Strategic Leverage ■ Bottleneck ■ Non-critical. ■ ■

The factors to be taken into account when determining risk and procurement potential will vary according to the circumstances of the company carrying out the assessment (see Tables 1.3 and 1.4). Successful application of the tool depends upon a coordinated, cross-functional team effort resulting in a common view of the relevant factors shared by everyone involved in the procurement process.

Table 1.3 Examples of factors determining risk

Table 1.4 Examples of factors determining procurement potential

Factor

High risk

Low risk

Experience with the product

First-time purchase

Frequent purchase

Supply/demand balance

Demand exceeds supply

Excess capacity exists

Supply chain complexity

Many parties (e.g. OEM, agent)

Direct purchase from OEM

Financial risks

High cost (e.g. lost production)

Low cost

Safety and environmental risk

High in environmentally sensitive area

Low at remote location

Design maturity

New, innovative design

Proven design

Manufacturing complexity

Complex

Simple

Factor

High potential

Low potential

Structure of the market

Many competing sources

Monopoly or oligopoly

Value of spend

High value

Low value

Supply/demand balance

Spare capacity

No excess capacity

Efficiency of the procurement process

Identical process applied to all purchases, little automation

Contract types and procedures promote continuous improvement

Development of the procurement process

Low or no early buyer involvement, users agree specifications with suppliers

Experienced cross-functional teams

28

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 28

24/09/2021 11:22


Procurement positioning

The same commodity may fall into different categories depending on use, location and other factors, and some commodities are far too broad to fit into a single category. It is important to be aware that the category for a given item may change over time due to changes in the market or the procurement organisation.

Strategic items

Strategic items are those with high risk and high procurement potential. All companies have certain commodities and services that are vital to their operation. In many cases these are also high in value and therefore provide a significant opportunity for increasing profit through the application of appropriate procurement strategies. Such items are categorised as strategic. Typically, essential considerations include supply continuity, quality, company image and total cost.

Bottleneck items

Bottleneck items are those with high risk and low procurement potential. This category, as with the strategic category, covers items that will stop or severely impair company operations if they are not available. Unlike strategic items, however, a common characteristic of items in the bottleneck category is that there are a small number of potential sources resulting in limited opportunities for negotiation. Having to deal with only one or a restricted number of suppliers results in a ‘bottleneck’ in the procurement process. This is an undesirable category for the buying company and efforts should be made to move items into another category by relaxing specifications and/or developing new sources of supply. When it is preferred to take a more structured approach, this can be done by using a seven-step method (see Table 1.5).

Table 1.5 The seven-step method

1

Define the risk and procurement potential factors considered to be relevant for the ­commodity or service in question.

2

If some factors are judged to be more important than others, assign a weighting to each factor according to its perceived impact.

3

Define a scale against which to assess each factor. The higher end of the scale should correspond to high risk or procurement potential and the lower end to low risk or procurement potential. For example, for supply/demand balance: Demand exceeds supply = 4 Demand equal to supply = 3 Ample capacity = 2 Considerable over-capacity = 1

4

Calculate the maximum score for weighted risk factors and weighted procurement potential factors in order to determine the dimensions of the procurement targeting matrix.

5

Assess each risk and profitability factor according to the defined scale.

6

For each factor, multiply the weighting by the corresponding assessment and then calculate the total score for risk factors and the total score for procurement potential factors.

7

Use the two total scores to position the commodity or service on the procurement targeting matrix.

29

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 29

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

Leverage items

Leverage items are those with low risk and high procurement potential. Typically, items in this category are standard items purchased in volume, which are readily available from a range of sources, and so the company is likely to be in a strong negotiating position due to the combination of a high spend value and competing suitable suppliers. It is important to aggregate volumes in order to maximise leverage.

Non-critical items

Non-critical items are those with low risk and low procurement potential. Typically, these are low-value, homogenous items; therefore, detailed negotiations and detailed attention are not cost justified. The procurement process in this category needs to be simple and efficient.

■ Procurement strategies/tactics for each quadrant Each quadrant of the procurement targeting matrix requires a different strategic and tactical approach to procurement.

Strategic items

For strategic items, the recommended strategy is to establish close relationships or partnerships with trustworthy, reliable suppliers in order to minimise the risk of non-availability and maximise the procurement potential. Possible tactics include: direct negotiation; ■ involvement in supplier quality management; ■ developing close collaborative relationships. ■

Bottleneck items

For bottleneck items, for which the risk of non-availability is the principal consideration, the strategic aim should be to ensure continuity of supply. The supply risk can be reduced through a combination of: maintaining a detailed knowledge of the market; accurately forecasting requirements and planning procurement; ■ using medium-term contracts; ■ carefully managing relationships with existing suppliers; ■ value analysis in order to simplify the specification and open up more competition. ■ ■

Leverage items

For leverage items, the principal consideration is the procurement potential offered by the procurement process and therefore the strategic aim is to maximise the company’s commercial advantage. Analytics are used here to maximise potential leverage. Multiple sourcing and competitive tendering may be used in order to encourage suppliers to price competitively. Ideally, contracts should allow the flexibility

30

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 30

24/09/2021 11:22


Supplier preferencing

to change suppliers at short notice. It may be practical to arrange for supplier stockholding and just-in-time delivery arrangements. In addition, it is likely to be beneficial to encourage: standardisation; switching to industry standards where possible; ■ coordination between business units and companies in order to strengthen the negotiating position. ■ ■

Non-critical items

Risks associated with non-critical items are minimal and, as such, the strategy for these items should be to adopt simple, cost-effective procurement techniques. Possible techniques are: e-procurement/fully automated ordering (for stock items), e.g. the Internet of Things (IoT); ■ direct call-off by users from suppliers on the basis of blanket agreements; ■ purchase by users using field order or procurement card procedures; ■ supplier rationalisation; ■ outsourcing; ■ vendor-managed inventory (VMI). ■

Supplier preferencing The technique presented so far looks at the market from the customer’s perspective. Each potential supplier will also have a view of the market and of the potential customer. Therefore, before finalising the procurement strategy and tactics, it is essential to consider the chosen supplier’s view of the purchaser. This is known as supplier preferencing. One way in which the supplier may view the customer is on the basis of the relative value (i.e. what proportion of company profits the customer generates) and the other factors that make a particular customer more or less attractive – for example, the quality of the relationship and the prestige of the account. It is advisable to check a potential supplier’s view before entering into negotiations (see Figure 1.14), as it will indicate whether the supplier’s and customer’s views are compatible.

■ Development and core account If the supplier views the customer as being in the development or core account categories, this will not result in any difficulty in the relationship from the ­customer’s point of view, regardless of the procurement positioning/targeting category in which the customer places the item.

31

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 31

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

Figure 1.14 Supplier objectives High Development

Core

Nurture customer Expand business Seek new opportunities

Defend vigorously Manage closely High service and response

Nuisance

Exploitable

Low attention Little interest Withdraw in easiest manner

Premium price Short-term advantage Risk losing customer

Account attraction

Low Low

Relative value (potential profit)

High

■ Nuisance and exploitable If the customer regards an item as leverage but the chosen supplier regards the business as unimportant because, from its perspective, the customer falls into the nuisance or exploit category, competitive tenders or direct negotiations are unlikely to produce the commercial advantage sought. Better terms are likely to be achieved by approaching suppliers who regard the customer as being in the development or core account categories. More serious difficulties may arise if a supplier who views the customer in a negative way supplies items that are strategic or bottleneck from the customer’s point of view. The fewer the number of sources, the more vulnerable the customer. In the short term, it is advisable to take extra care to maintain good relationships, although entering into negotiations about partnerships is unlikely to be productive. Where possible, the customer should try to switch to a supplier to whom its account is more attractive. Another possibility is for the customer to link the purchase of strategic or bottleneck items with other items that are of more interest to the supplier, in order to change the supplier’s perception of the customer’s account to core or development.

Research Mining company Anglo American states ‘business is so competitive that procurement need to make their organisation as attractive as possible to suppliers; by doing this you become first in line for the best prices and products’. If procurement suspect that they are not customer of first choice they can improve the relationship by:

32

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 32

24/09/2021 11:22


Total acquisition cost and total cost of ownership

providing regular, realistic forecasts to suppliers in order to aid planning; delivering consistent messages to suppliers who need to know what procurement requires from them; ■ asking suppliers how they can help you reach your goals. ■ ■

(Morrisey, 2006)

In the medium term, it is advisable for the customer to renew efforts to move items out of the strategic and bottleneck categories.

Case study – E.ON UK E.ON UK is training its staff beyond traditional procurement skills, so that they see themselves as internal consultants. As they have developed, there is a greater focus on risk management. The perception of purchasing used to be that it was about cutting costs, and their targets centred around this. Now they focus on analysing opportunities and aligning them to the business strategy, sourcing appropriately and going through contracting and negotiation. The board now is more concerned about spreading procurement’s value around the organisation.

Total acquisition cost and total cost of ownership Buying price is probably the factor most often associated with procurement responsibilities. Since prices are affected by costs, at least in the long run, an important function of procurement is to work with colleagues and suppliers to eradicate unnecessary costs. These could result from over-specification; purchasing a non-standard item when a standard alternative is acceptable; unnecessary packaging; and, where significant transport costs are involved, the design of the product in terms of transportation utility. The total acquisition cost is more than simply price, and has a bearing on developing the wider role of purchasing into total cost management. It is the total you actually pay for goods and services, including such things as tooling, duty, inventory-carrying costs, inspection, remedy or rectification and so on. It is an obvious fact, yet a commonly ignored one, that a low price may lead to a high total acquisition cost. Of course, once materials or goods have been acquired, they may attract further costs while in use. With this in mind, some organisations prefer the expression ‘total cost of ownership’ when referring to capital goods or materials that will be retained for some time.

33

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 33

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

Price is the most visible of the various costs that arise from making most acquisitions, and in many cases it will be the biggest component of cost too. The ‘price/ cost iceberg’, shown in Figure 1.15, helps us to remember the hidden costs, and to account for them in our business decision making.

Case study – Siemens Siemens believes that with supplier partnerships, to take cost out of a supply chain is only one element of the partnership approach. Innovation, in the sense of developing new products and services and doing so quicker or better than competitors, is what differentiates successful companies from the rest. The reason is that, these days, much of the innovation is likely to come from the supply base.

■ Supply continuity Another aspect of total acquisition cost is the negative effect of supply failure on company sales. Material economics and assurance of supply are critical in a capital-intensive assembly industry dealing with oligopolistic suppliers, as supply failure may adversely affect corporate objectives. Apart from the direct impact on costs, competitors may gain larger sales if supply failure affects production. The car maker Nissan, for example, works with suppliers to continually improve its performance using Kaizen techniques. Kaizen translates from Japanese as ‘constant improvement’ and is pursued through slow, steady change. The Kaizen

Figure 1.15 The price/cost iceberg

Price Delivery Support Defective work Consumables Training Inventory costs Delay Inspection Handling costs etc.

34

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 34

24/09/2021 11:22


Procurement development

Table 1.6 Comparative total acquisition costs of a commodity purchased by IBM

Procurement overview Commodity: Monitor

Description: Monochrome monitor

Contract period: 52 weeks

Contract volume: 134 K

Quote ref.: Example

Part no.: 1111111 Japan MATSUSUKI

Germany EUROMONITOR

Scotland VISIONTUBES

Ex-factory cost

10.000

11.000

11.500

Procurement m/power

0.070

0.154

0.057

Function manpower

0.050

0.165

0.034

Inventory finance

0.173

0.036

0.028

Capital tooling

0.037

0.060

0.022

Airfreight penalty

2.65

N/A

N/A

Freight – vendor

1.500

0.500

0.300

Freight – IBM estimate

0.300

0.120

0.100

Duty

0.490

N/A

N/A

IPO charge

0.066

N/A

N/A

Cancellation

1.400

0.440

0.230

Total uplift

5.236

0.974

0.472

Total cost

15.236

11.974

11.972

20,416,763

16,046,453

16,043,581

IBM contract spend

Note: The figures are hypothetical and the suppliers fictitious.

process encourages logical systematic thinking; it starts by recognising that things are never perfect and by identifying the areas where something can be done to improve matters.

Total acquisition costs

Table 1.6 shows a hypothetical example of a component that might be bought by IBM in the United Kingdom. The Japanese supplier is the cheapest, but the total acquisition cost would be much lower if the item were purchased from the supplier in Scotland. IBM defines total acquisition cost as: ‘All costs, including the purchase price, related to the process of bringing a supplier’s product and/or service to the point of consumption.’

Procurement development We have seen that procurement is now recognised in organisations as an area for reducing costs and adding value. The ability of organisations to drive costs down and eventually out of the supply chain is affected by the stage of development of the procurement activity. Partnerships, reducing acquisition costs, strategic outsourcing and e-commerce, are all dependent on the appropriate level of development of the procurement activity. In very general terms, the ways in which procurement has developed over the years and the characteristics associated with these general development phases can be summarised as follows.

35

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 35

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

Thirty years ago: – Procurement and supply was concerned with buying supplies at the lowest price; activity essentially clerical. – There was little involvement with suppliers. – Procurement was reactive. ■ Fifteen years ago: – Procurement and supply was still concerned with lowest price but aware of other factors affecting price, such as quality and delivery. – It was more involved with suppliers and other internal functions. ■ Today: – Procurement and supply is becoming strategically involved as it is seen as giving the organisation a strategic advantage. – It is closely involved with suppliers and those other activities concerned more with true ownership cost than price. – There is devolution of straightforward buying activities closer to the point of use. ■ In the future: – There will be an application of leading-edge concepts throughout the supply chain. – Value addition will displace cost reduction as the primary role. – The potential of developing technology will be realised, such as artificial intelligence, digitalisation, Blockchain, Big Data, the Internet of Things (IoT) and predictive analytics. These tools can help automate end-to-end processes, save time, improve accuracy and provide greater visibility and transparency in the supply chain (see Chapter 2 for the future of procurement and Chapter 18 for full coverage of digitalisation and analytics). There will be total customer focus. – Sustainability, diversity and social value will be uppermost. ■

The following case study demonstrates how some large organisations have only recently transformed their procurement.

Case study – Manchester Airports Group (MAG) MAG has, in the past, had a lack of alignment with and credibility within the business, meaning budget holders were carrying out their own procurement, risking non-compliance and procurement unable to impact on the business in the longer term. Now they have moved to a more strategic supply chain function: budget holders no longer sign contracts as procurement now do so, thus reducing risk. MAG’s procurement is reducing carbon emissions and contributing to social value by looking at how local the group’s spend is.

36

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 36

24/09/2021 11:22


Procurement development

MAG believes that there are three main things procurement and supply professionals must do to add value: understand the business; think long term; and build relationships. This work has also increased spend coverage from 25 to 90 per cent. Steps MAG has taken to transform the function include: establishing a signature authority demarcation between budget owners and procurement; ■ carrying out a spend analysis and people, processes and technology benchmarking; ■ working to develop a deep understanding of the group’s business strategies and objectives; ■ setting joint objectives with key budget holders; ■ articulating new goals and strategies to the team. ■

As the MAG case study demonstrates, many successful organisations have well-developed, strategically proactive procurement departments that are capable of making major contributions to their organisation and the supply chains they are involved with, while there are other organisations where procurement remains relatively undeveloped and reactive, with all the characteristics of purchasing activities of 15 years ago. The evolution of purchasing into procurement is demonstrated by Reck and Long (1988) who produced a four-stage purchasing development model when they began investigating the contributions that purchasing could make to organisational strategic roles. These four stages of development and the characteristics of each stage are shown in Figure 1.16. This framework moves us forward, but its major defect is that only four stages are contemplated and the variables are not operational. As the MAG case study demonstrates, there remain large procurement functions that are only just emerging into the highest stage of development.

■ Seven area of focus In order to transform procurement, thereby turning challenges into opportunities, organisations need to focus on: improving core value chains; ■ transformational digital capabilities; ■ risk management; ■ innovation; ■ sustainability; ■ social value; and ■ diversity. ■

37

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 37

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

Figure 1.16 A four-stage purchasing development model

Passive Definition The purchasing function has no strategic direction and primarily reacts to the requests of other functions. Characteristics High proportion of purchaser’s time is spent on quick-fix and routine operations Purchasing function and individual performance are based on efficiency measures Little interfunctional communication takes place because of purchasing’s low visibility Supplier selection is based on price and availability

Independent Definition The purchasing function adopts the latest purchasing techniques and practices, but its strategic direction is independent of the firm’s competitive strategy. Characteristics Performance is primarily based on cost reduction and efficiency measures Co-ordination links are established between purchasing and technical disciplines Top management recognises the importance of professional development Top management recognises the opportunities in purchasing for contributing to profitability

Supportive Definition The purchasing function supports the firm’s competitive strategy by adopting purchasing techniques and practices which strengthen the firm’s competitive position. Characteristics Purchasers are included in sales proposal teams Suppliers are considered a resource which is carefully selected and motivated People are considered a resource with emphasis on experience, motivation and attitude Markets, products and suppliers are continuously monitored and analysed

Integrative Definition Purchasing’s strategy is fully integrated into the firm’s competitive strategy and constitutes part of an integrated effort among functional peers to formulate and implement a strategic plan. Characteristics Cross-functional training of purchasing professionals/executives is made available Permanent lines of communication are established among other functional areas Professional development focuses on strategic elements of the competitive strategy Purchasing performance is measured in terms of contributions to the firm’s success

(Source: Reck and Long, 1988)

38

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 38

24/09/2021 11:22


Best practice in strategic supply management

Best practice in strategic supply management The following diagram (Figure 1.17) includes many examples of best practice. Clearly, this good practice will not be practicable in an organisation with a less than fully developed procurement function. The following list outlines some key change dimensions that procurement needs to address. Risk management: move from compliance to risk mitigation. Sustainability: move beyond cost by mapping supply chains for social value. ■ Globalisation: expertise still required but, following the Covid-19 pandemic disruptions, the trend to move sources out of China and nearer to home has accelerated. ■ Integration: develop supplier and market information and share with partners. ■ Innovation: increased resources invested in new products and new methods. ■ Collaboration: emphasising sustainability and resilience. ■ Information: digitalisation, advanced data mining and analytics to improve visibility throughout the supply chain. ■ People: attract diverse talent. ■ ■

Several practitioners provide a useful array of views on the status and influence of procurement. The Royal British Legion believes that procurement staff are seen not as buyers but managers of value and reducers of risk, talking much more about benefits than pricing and cost – benefits such as mitigated risk or added value, especially in terms of social responsibility and sustainability. Northumbrian Water state procurement has been driving value through strategic collaborations such as supplier innovation, SRM and proactive risk analysis. And Maximus Healthcare highlights the need to show the business that procurement is aligned to its needs and understanding its priorities, which are then built into

Figure 1.17 Best practice in strategic supply management

Align and integrate procurement strategy with corporate strategy Contract and supplier relationship management Lean agile supply Kaizen TQM Six Sigma Value added and elimination of waste

Digitalisation, AI, Blockchain and analytics

Openness, honesty and trust with partners

Innovation CSR, sustainability and diversity CSR

Global sourcing expertise

Responsive and ready for change

39

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 39

24/09/2021 11:22


Chapter 1 • Procurement scope and development

the dashboard for procurement so that it mirrors the priorities that the business really values. With each crisis and impending threat to supply chain security, procurement is gradually and increasingly being viewed as a high-value strategic activity and a critical component in achieving organisational objectives. Procurement has finally moved centre stage, with roles as enablers, risk managers and collaborative business partners with strategic alignment and integration, thus changing the perception of procurement.

Research Research by Bain & Company shows that world-class procurement organisations can reduce a company’s purchasing cost base by an average of 8–12 per cent and deliver additional annual savings of 2–3 per cent. The case studies contained in this chapter demonstrate clearly that the following sets of capabilities can help make transformations to more strategic contributions: Structure and process create clear roles for cross-functional teams. Talent and skills of world-class procurement teams deliver market expertise, analysis and insights. ■ Digital tools and systems provide spending visibility and track supplier performance, including metrics and a procurement savings dashboard. ■ ■

(Schannon et al., 2016)

Procurement must continue to invest in digitalising the supply chain in order to be more responsive and have improved access to smart data while building ever-closer collaboration with suppliers. Communication, building trust and transparency has become more important than ever before. (See Chapter 2 for more on the future of procurement.)

Summary 1

A broad introduction to the scope of purchasing and procurement is given.

2

We highlight the importance of a strategic procurement function within organisations, emphasising sustainability, diversity and social value.

3

Categories of risk, including fraud and corruption, are highlighted.

4

Procurement has had to adapt to becoming more proactive. More emphasis is given to supplier relationships, with both sides investing time and support to achieve mutually beneficial goals.

5

Total cost is an all-inclusive measure of the cost of ownership. It is influenced by factors that can be improved with the involvement of an informed purchasing team.

40

M01 Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 97498.indd 40

24/09/2021 11:22


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Procurement Principles and Management in the Digital Age 12th Edition by Peter Baily David Farmer Ba by AnswerDone - Issuu