Anna Serio
A Return to Childhood & the Reimagination of Child Play Structures
1 1
2
“Play gives children a chance to practice what they are learning.� -Mr. Rogers
3
3
To be actively, passionately, and emotionally invested in the future of our children is to be invested in the future of our country and our world. When children are obligated to play in areas that are not conducive to fun, learning, or safety, we not only teach them that they are not worth spending time and effort on, but we force them to look for fun and adventure elsewhere, which can turn into a variety of consequences for both children and their guardians. Architecture is a profession that focuses primarily on adults and the experience of those who are fully-grown while ignoring those in the most important physical and mental development stages of their lives.
Children need safe, thought-through, and well-designed outlets for play and fun that are not the single-minded “kit of parts� replicated on hundreds of thousands of playgrounds across the country. By expanding beyond the parameters of safety, simplicity, and inexpensiveness, we allow our children to grow through both mind and body; in including them in the architecture we design for the populace, we encourage a sense of belonging and inclusiveness in defiance of age discrepancies between the old and the young.
4
4
THESIS STATEMENT
5
5
CONTENTS
6
6
Introductory Narratives Design Narratives
8 10
Precedent Studies
10
The Playscape & Associated Opportunities
14
Senda’s Principles of Structure of Space & Equipment for Play
18
Senda’s Six Types of Spaces as Play Environments for Children
20
Analytical Research Survey of Regional Playground Opinions Subjectively Important Play Qualities The Issue of Safety
Prototype Design
22 22 24 26
30
Form Studies The Site
32 34
Midterm
36
Final Design
38
Exhibit
Bibliography
50
53
7
INTRODUCTORY NARRATIVES What problem am I trying to solve? Who am I designing for? What methods will I use to conduct research?
8
8
QUESTION How can we as architects improve the conditions of children’s play and exercise in the United States, and therefore encourage a healthy and active lifestyle throughout the years of early, middle, and late childhood?
AUDIENCE Children, Child Caregivers, Parents & Guardians, Playground Designers, Designers of Other Child-Centric Spaces
METHODS Precedent & Case Studies, Book & Article Research, Interviews & First-hand Accounts, Diagramming, Making, Compiling Precedent & Case Studies, Book & Article Research, Interviews & First-hand Accounts, Diagramming, Making, Compiling
9
9
10 10
CASE STUDY 1 City Museum St. Louis, MO
Founded in 1993 by sculptor Bob Cassilly Includes features such as “Enchanted Caves,” aquarium, skate park, 10-floor slide, and uncountable amount of climbing and exploration opportunities Named one of the “Great Public Spaces” by the Project for Public Spaces Not restricted to children’s use- open for all ages
11 11
CASE STUDY 2
Darling Quarter Playscape Sydney, Australia 3.7 square acre playground in Sydney dedicated to children’s play and learning Landscape project that “encourages children to interact with nature and natural systems and allows elements of managed risk” -Architecture AU
Intended for use as an urban renewal project in the Darling Harbor area of Sydney
12 12
13 13
THE PLAYSCAPE Locations, Opportunities, and States of Minds which Encourage Growth Through Play
14 14
Spinning Nature Trails High Spaces
Parks Hills
Children’s Museums Tunnels- inside & out Road Spaces
Temporary Opportunities Imagination
Deviation Fear & Discomfort
Exploration Opportunities
15 15
16
Associated Conclusion Play does not need to be prescribed by architecture; it can be found anywhere. It is simply the architect’s job to create healthy and safe opportunities for play in built environments targeted to children.
17 17
Mitsuru Senda’s Seven Principles of Structure of Space & Equipment for Play
In his book “Design of Children’s Play Environments”, Mitsuru Senda outlines requisite needs that foster healthy and effective child play structures. Constantly repeated, these seven principles are his chosen vocabulary for what should comprise any given play structure or landscape.
18 18
Safe but Rich in Variety
Dizziness
Circulation of Play
Symbolic High Places
Not Singularly PatternedShortcuts & Bypasses
Large & Small Gathering Spaces
Open with Access Routes
19 19
Nature Play
Senda’s Six Types of Spaces as Play Environments for Children Continuing in his book, Senda also outlines six forms in which play and playscapes can be found. These indicate that play does not
Open Spaces
Road Spaces
Adventure Spaces
necessitate a built environment versus a natural environment, but rather that it can be inspired by a variety of spaces.
Hideout Spaces
Play Structure Spaces
20 20
Swinging
Being in a tunnel
Dizziness Rather than simply being disoriented from spinning, Senda categorizes dizziness into
Being in a maze
five different categories, all considering the factor as a form of excitement and discomfort that creates exhilaration.
Being on a Slope
Being in a High Space 21 21
TEACHER/PARENT SURVEY Excellent 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2
Poor
22 22
6.2/10
Average rating parents & teachers give local playgrounds
REGIONAL PLAYGROUND OPINIONS FROM PARENTS & TEACHERS
23 23
Design Research Surveys Because I learned quickly how difficult it would be to conduct research on children due to their status as minors, I resorted to sending out a survey to parents and teachers across America. They gave me opinions on their local playgrounds and let me know what they thought to be the most important features of a children’s play environment. In addition, I found already-conducted surveys on the quality of playgrounds in the United States versus the rest of the world. While the USA did not do poorly in relation to the rest of the world, it failed to hold a candle to regions such as Scandinavia and Japan.
Variety
Excitement entt Unique 24 24
FAVORITE PLAY EQUIPMENT
COUNTRIES/REGIONS WITH HIGHESTRATED PLAYSCAPES western
Other
The Americas
Environmental Play
Chile
central
USA Northern Europe chile
Slide
Oceania
Europe
Zip Line/ Swings slide
usa
northern
climbing equipment
zip line/ swings
environmental play
Climbing Equipment
other
FAVORITE PLAY EQUIPMENT
Asiaeurope
Western Europe asia
Central Europe oceania
the americas
COUNTRIES/REGIONS WITH HIGHESTRATED PLAYSCAPES
IMPORTANT PLAYGROUND QUALITIES according to parents & guardians
Time Nature/ Environment Safety Aesthetics
Parent/Child Interaction
eness enes 25 25
SAFETY SURVEY
26 26
61%
The percentage of playgrounds in Chicago earning scores consistent with American safety standards
MAJOR SAFETY ISSUES OF CONCERN:
MOST NEEDED CHANGES TO CURRENT PLAYGROUND EQUIPMENT
Playgrounds in Chicago Meeting Safety Standards in 2010 (%)
Safety Item Separate areas for ages 2–5 and 5–12
26
Appropriate depth of loose fill provided
1
Free of head entrapments
48
Free of rust & peeling paint
38
Free of splinters
34
Properly closed S-hooks
46
MOST COMMON SAFETY ISSUES WITH MODERN PLAYGROUNDS: Fall Surfacing Equipment Maintenance 27 27
28
Associated Conclusion While I believed much of the reasoning for our current state of play environments is over-concern with safety, it seems to be quite the opposite. Over 1/3 of playgrounds in Chicago still do not comply with modern safety standards.
29 29
PROTOTYPE DESIGN
30
The beginning of the design phase was driven by the previous conclusion that children do not need to a prescription for play. Rather, the more immediate need is for safe and stimulating play areas and objects. To begin, I created several oddly-shaped objects to observe how children might play or interact with them. In this way, it becomes a “build your own playplace� kind of environment. 31
FORM STUDIES 32
Site Selection: 1931 W Lake St, Chicago, IL
33
THE SITE
Intended as a sample location for the prototype, the site is located on the west side of the city of Chicago, in a developing area of much diversity in both race and income. The design is to be an adaptive reuse of an unused warehouse which currently consists of two stories, several existing doors and windows, and original wooden trusses at the back of the structure. To the east side exists a small outdoor area; the lower level of the floor to which that exterior space opens to will be demolished so that the second level cantilevers over the space. To the west side there is currently a lot which is used to store junk cars- this will be cleared and use for another outdoor space and entry sequence. Each space is intended for separate entries for the older and younger children, as a major factor that came up as problematic (in a safety sense) in many current playgrounds is the lack of separation between the older and younger children.
34
older kids area
younger kids area
direct lighting opportunities
indirect lighting opportunities 35
36
MIDTERM COLLAGES
37
38
FINAL DESIGN
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
FINAL MODEL
48
49
50
THESIS EXHIBIT: May 12-29, 2018 Block 37 3rd Floor, Chicago, IL
51
52 32
Working Bibliography Bibliography Allen, Erin M., et al. “Playground Safety and Quality in Chicago.” Pediatrics, vol. 131, no. 2, pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/131/2/233. Bachrach, Julia Sniderman. “Playground Movement.” Encyclopedia of Chicago, www.encyclopedia.chicagohistory.org/pages/976.html. Broto, Carles. New Playground Design: Design Guidelines And Case Studies. Barcelona : Linksbooks, 2012. Print. Burkhalter, Gabriela,eds. The Playground Project. : . Print. “Chicago Park District.” Playgrounds, www.chicagoparkdistrict.com/facilities/playgrounds/. Cohen, Bronwen. “Space to Develop: How Architecture Can Play a Vital Role in Young Children’s Lives.” CELE Exchange. Centre for Effective Learning Environments, vol. 2010, no. 6-10, July 2010, pp. 1-6. EBSCOhost Cristea, Irina.Zündel, Grégoire, eds. Time For Play: Why Architecture Should Take Happiness Seriously. : Print. Galindo, Michelle. Playground Design. [Salenstein, Switzerland] : Braun Publishing, 2012. Print. King, Pete and Justine Howard. “Children’s Perceptions of Choice in Relation to Their Play at Home, in the School Playground and at the Out-Of-School Club.” Children & Society, vol. 28, no. 2, Mar. 2014, pp. 116-127. EBSCOhost, doi:10.1111/j.1099-0860.2012.00455.x. Lande, Samantha, and Korey Huyler. “The Best Playgrounds in Chicago.” Time Out Chicago, 15 Apr. 2015, www.timeout.com/chicago/kids/activities/best-chicago-playgrounds. Letourneau, Susan M., et al. “What do Caregivers Notice and Value about how Children Learn through Play in a Children’s Museum?” Journal of Museum Education, vol. 42, no. 1, 2017, pp. 87-98. Parmet, Sharon. “Where Do the Children Play? In Renovated Playgrounds, Study Says.” Where Do the Children Play? In Renovated Playgrounds, Study Says | UIC Today, UIC Today, 13 Jan. 2016. Senda, Mitsuru. Design of Children’s Play Environments. McGraw-Hill, 1992. Solomon, Susan G. American Playgrounds: Revitalizing Community Space. Hanover [N.H.] : University Press Of New England, 2005. Print. Tippens, William W., and Julia Sniderman. “The Planning and Design of Chicago’s Neighborhood Parks.” In A Breath of Fresh Air: Chicago’s Parks of the Progressive Era, Chicago Public Library Cultural Center, 1989. Toker, Leona. “playgrounds.” Style, vol. 50, no. 4, 2016, pp. 489-492.
53 33