Skip to main content

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS BETWEEN DEM FROM TOPOGRAPHIC, ASTER GDEM AND SRTM DEM

Page 1

Int. J. of Geology Earth Sci., 2016 Geol. & & Earth Sci., 2016

Aminu Abdulwahab et al., 2016 ISSN 2395-647X www.ijges.com Vol. 2, No. 2, June 2016 © 2016 IJGES. All Rights Reserved

Review Article

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS BETWEEN DEM FROM TOPOGRAPHIC, ASTER GDEM AND SRTM DEM Aminu Abdulwahab1*, Babangida Baiya2, Gundiri I Abalis3 and Bello Ali Garba3

*Corresponding Author: Aminu Abdulwahab  Alaminu53@gmail.com

The difference between the DEM generated from Topographical map, ASTER DEM 1.5 arc second and SRTM DEM 3 arc second has been determine. As the ASTER GDEM has been known to be the highest resolution global digital elevation model purported to be 30m spacing (1 or 1.5) arc second, we have compared three different DEM’s by digitizing the contour of the existing topographical map covering the research area and downloading the ASTER GDEM data and SRTM data from online source. 3-D coordinates of some scattered was selected and generated from the three DEM created. Contour was also generated from the all the DEMs for further comparison. However, the contour value on the existing topographical map was converted from feet to meter to correspond with the ASTER GDEM and the SRTM DEM unit. The result of this research work was based on the Models generated from the 3D data obtained from the topographical DEM, ASTER GDEM and the SRTM DEM, Geographic information system GIS software like Global Mapper 13, Surfer 10 and ArcGIS 10.0 software was also used in doing the analysis. The height obtained from the topographic map was orthometric Height while the ASTER GDEM/SRTM DEM is an ellipsoidal height. In this study, the difference between the DEM generated from Topographical map, ASTER DEM 1.5 arc second and SRTM DEM 3 arc second has been determine. As the ASTER GDEM has been known to be the highest resolution global digital elevation model purported to be 30 m spacing i.e. 1 or 1.5 arc second, we have compare the three different DEM’s by digitizing the contour of the existing topographical map covering the research area as well downloaded the ASTER GDEM data and SRTM data from online source. 3-D coordinates of the some scattered was selected and generated from the three DEM created. Contour was also generated from the all the DEMs for further comparison. However, the contour value on the existing topographical map was converted from feet to meter to correspond with the ASTER GDEM and the SRTM DEM unit. The result of this research work was based on the Models generated from the 3D data obtained from the topographical DEM, ASTER GDEM and the SRTM DEM, Geographic information system GIS software like Global Mapper 13, Surfer 10 and ArcGIS 10.0 software was also used in doing the analysis. It is and evidence that the height obtained from the topographic map was orthometricHeight (Benchmark Elevations), and the ASTER GDEM/SRTM DEM is an ellipsoidal height (Geodetic Height). Keywords: Digital Elevation Model, Topographical Map, GIS, ASTER, GDEM, SRTM 1

Department of Surveying and Geo-informatics, School of Environmental Science and Technology, Federal Polytechnic Mubi, PMB 35, Adamawa State, Nigeria.

This article can be downloaded from http://www.ijges.com/current-issue.php 1


Int. J. of Geology & Earth Sci., 2016

Aminu Abdulwahab et al., 2016

INTRODUCTION

surface. DEM data, likeother spatial data sets, are subject to error (USGS, 1995; Monmonier, 1991; Wright, 1942). Many DEM users perceive that DEM uncertainty affects the outcomes of their applications.However, the effects of DEM error on elevation andderived parameters are often not evaluated by DEM users (Wechsler, 2003), and methods to address DEM error have not been systematically integrated with GIS software packages” (Suzanne P Wechsler and Charles N Kroll, 2006).

The use of computer system and programs have revolutionizethe way in which we analysis, processing and present spatial data that referenced to the earth surface. “Digital Elevation Models (DEMs) provide one of the most usefuldigital data sets for a wide range of users” (Guth, 2010). The need for globalcoverage with a medium scale DEM (1-3 arc second, or 30-100 mpost spacing’s) led to the Shuttle Radar Topography Mission (SRTM; Farr et al., 2007), and the recent release of the ASTERGDEM. These DEMs have similar data spacing (3" for the publicly available SRTM, 1" for ASTER), with GDEM havingnear global coverage (N83º to S83º) while the SRTM is limited tolatitudes from N60º to S56º. The SRTM collected its data inunder two weeks, and can be considered an instantaneous snap shot of earth’s topography, while GDEM has required yearsto collect data. Because GDEM covered a greater area covered with finer spatial resolution, it has the potential to create betteranalyses. However, the SRTM’s true effective resolution is lessthan the 1" data collected worldwide and released in the UnitedStates (Guth, 2006).

This research work will focus on a comparative analysis between DEMs produced from Topographic Map of Mubi at a scale of 1:50000, SRTM DEM at 3 arc second data and ASTER GDEM 1.5 arc second data in other to determine which DEM truly represent the topography of the study area. We have also carried out some additional analysis that further depicts the terrain from derived parameter such as the vector, slope, aspect, view shade, Line of site Profiles and contour at a suitable interval because it gives more sensitive representation of the DEMs accuracy quality also the demand that users will put on DEMs.

“Digital elevation models are a valuable and usefuldata source for many natural resource related Geographic Information System (GIS) applications. Representation ofelevation in a grid framework enables neighborhood computationsof parameters, such as slope and flow direction,which are used to identify ridges and valleys and derivethe topographic index, a statistic that indicates the propensity for surface saturation (Beven and Kirkby, 1979; Quinn et al., 1991). Although a DEM is a model of the elevation surface, it is often not treated as a model, but is accepted asa true representation of the earth’s

METHODOLOGY In this research work, three DEMs wereproduced. The first DEM was from existing Topographic map which gives information relating to the height of points below or above the mean sea level (UBA topo sheet 156NE) at a scale of 1:50,000 was scanned in which all the contours were in feet, the contours were automatically converted to meter unit in the global mapper, 17 GCP were selected and mark on the topo map for georeferencing and there was a 0.00 error in the georeferencing process. Then the Digitizing

This article can be downloaded from http://www.ijges.com/current-issue.php 2


Int. J. of Geology & Earth Sci., 2016

Aminu Abdulwahab et al., 2016

process commence accordingly using the Global Mapper 13 software and the corresponding contour values in meter was assign at the existing interval of 50ft. The digitized contour was further processed to form the desired DEM of the research area using the same Global mapper software for further comparison.

contour values available, DEM of the area can be produced through the process of scanning/ digitization of those contours at the given interval using the appropriate software such as Global Mapper or Ilwis and this software can also be used to smooth the surface of the DEM. In this research work, the topographic Map

The second DEM was from the SRTM DEM 3 arc second data Acquired from online source through the Global mapper 13.0 software, the data was analyzed and processed for further comparison.

covering Mubi was scanned and imported into

The third DEM was from the ASTER GDEM 1.5 arc second data also acquired from the online source through Global Mapper 13.0 software, the data was analyzed and processed for further comparison.

the appropriate modules of the Global Mapper to

The fact that many geomorphometric parameters Differ with DEM spacing, we createdan approximately 1.5 arc second and 3 arc second DEMs through the process of decimation of thedigitized Topographical Map data. Although the two DEMs, i.e., ASTERand SRTM data represent Digital Surface Models (DSMs) that willmodel the first desired reflective surface. These models looks like the DEM generated from the Topographical map data.

“This procedure can also be achieved by ordinary

Global Mapper software, it was further georeferenced. All the contours were digitized and elevation values were assigned to them. The elevation value of the contours was process using automatically generate the DEM of the study area as shown in Figure 1. The X, Y, Z coordinates of some selected points was generated from the First DEM of the topo mapas shown in Table 1. Kriging in ArcGIS, and choosing this technique gives higher precision even if the area is small. Table 1: X, Y with Topo Elevation CPID 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30

GENERATION OF DEM FROM TOPOGRAPHICAL MAP A Digital Terrain Model (DTM), also known as a Digital Surface Model (DSM) or Digital Elevation Model (DEM) is a topographic mode of the “bare earth”. All features such as vegetation, buildings, bridges, etc., are removed to create the bare earth/ DTM. Provided the topographical map of an area of study is available with the contour lines and the

Eastings X Northings Y TOPO Z 310021.618 1136212.252 574.209 309634.769 1136807.404 565.301 310358.871 1136956.192 579.100 310983.781 1136847.081 579.100 311499.580 1136757.808 579.100 311380.549 1136152.737 579.100 311545.869 1135732.823 579.100 311744.253 1135812.177 580.781 311777.318 1135937.820 582.498 312603.918 1137009.095 583.840 313040.363 1136394.104 589.128 312980.848 1135514.601 610.162 313099.878 1134840.095 609.600 311096.199 1134754.129 588.963 311082.973 1135078.156 582.203 311598.772 1135514.601 579.100 311016.845 1135693.147 579.100 310877.976 1135534.439 579.100 310540.723 1135230.250 586.414 310434.918 1135164.122 586.172 310401.854 1135772.500 579.100 310223.309 1135726.211 579.100 309409.934 1135699.759 571.794 309370.257 1135521.214 574.264 309634.769 1135203.799 578.494 310315.888 1135071.543 585.838 309152.035 1134787.193 589.219 308563.495 1135726.211 579.100 308794.943 1134172.202 598.280 309767.025 1134502.842 608.294

This article can be downloaded from http://www.ijges.com/current-issue.php 3


Int. J. of Geology & Earth Sci., 2016

Aminu Abdulwahab et al., 2016

This is because Kriging provides a fine-scale interpolation leading to an almost smooth surface” (Kumura, 2008).

Figure 2: DEM from ASTER GDEM

Figure 1: DEM from Topographical Map

Table 2: X, Y with ASTER Elevation CPID 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30

GENERATION OF DEM FROM ASTER GDEM The ASTER GDEM that cover the research area was acquired from online source through the global mapper software by specifying the extend of the of the study then clicking on the Download online data then selecting the worldwide data picking the ASTER GDEM worldwide elevation Data (1.5 arc second) then finally Ok. This download the ASTER GDEM covering the research area and it was saved for further analysis as shown in Figure 2.

Eastings X Northings Y ASTER Z 310021.618 1136212.252 559.709 309634.769 1136807.404 556.266 310358.871 1136956.192 570.980 310983.781 1136847.081 574.190 311499.580 1136757.808 573.664 311380.549 1136152.737 569.828 311545.869 1135732.823 568.391 311744.253 1135812.177 570.583 311777.318 1135937.820 570.766 312603.918 1137009.095 578.800 313040.363 1136394.104 582.564 312980.848 1135514.601 592.379 313099.878 1134840.095 593.670 311096.199 1134754.129 574.135 311082.973 1135078.156 576.110 311598.772 1135514.601 570.281 311016.845 1135693.147 568.541 310877.976 1135534.439 572.087 310540.723 1135230.250 580.142 310434.918 1135164.122 580.714 310401.854 1135772.500 565.641 310223.309 1135726.211 572.040 309409.934 1135699.759 563.773 309370.257 1135521.214 564.008 309634.769 1135203.799 569.078 310315.888 1135071.543 580.116 309152.035 1134787.193 573.946 308563.495 1135726.211 568.845 308794.943 1134172.202 587.370 309767.025 1134502.842 589.026

GENERATION OF DEM FROM SRTM DEM

The X, Y, coordinate of some selected points that were generated from the topographical map was used to determine the Z value the of ASTER DEM elevation in Table 2 for more advance comparing of elevation data of the Second produced DEMs.

The SRTM DEM that cover the research area was acquired from online source through the global mapper software by specifying the extend of the of the study then clicking on the Download online

This article can be downloaded from http://www.ijges.com/current-issue.php 4


Int. J. of Geology & Earth Sci., 2016

Aminu Abdulwahab et al., 2016

data then selecting the worldwide data picking the SRTM DEM worldwide elevation Data (3 arc second) then finally Ok. This download the SRTM DEM covering the research area and it was saved for further analysis as shown in Figure 3.

The X, Y, coordinate of some selected points that were generated from the topographical map was used to determine the Z value the of ASTER DEM elevation Table 3 for more advance comparing of elevation data of the third produced DEMs.

CONTOUR MAPS CREATION

Figure 3: DEM of SRTM

Contours are lines that connect points of equal value (such as elevation, temperature, precipitation, pollution, or atmospheric pressure). The distribution of the lines shows how values change across a surface. Where there is little change in a value, the lines are spaced farther apart. Where the values rise or fall rapidly, the lines are closer together (ESRI, 2010). To create contour maps from the DEMs. The file/generate contour from the Global Mapper modules was used the desired contour interval was specified for the three DEMs and the contours were automatically generated from the Current DEMs Layer at an interval of 5 meter for each the DEMs.The three contours are shown in Figures 4, 5 and 6.

Table 3: X, Y with SRTM Elevation CPID 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30

Eastings X Northings Y SRTM Z 310021.618 1136212.252 569.971 309634.769 1136807.404 567.707 310358.871 1136956.192 584.417 310983.781 1136847.081 588.585 311499.580 1136757.808 589.132 311380.549 1136152.737 579.956 311545.869 1135732.823 581.779 311744.253 1135812.177 582.886 311777.318 1135937.820 585.271 312603.918 1137009.095 591.462 313040.363 1136394.104 592.655 312980.848 1135514.601 611.984 313099.878 1134840.095 607.202 311096.199 1134754.129 592.442 311082.973 1135078.156 588.306 311598.772 1135514.601 583.674 311016.845 1135693.147 579.913 310877.976 1135534.439 584.738 310540.723 1135230.250 590.877 310434.918 1135164.122 591.869 310401.854 1135772.500 578.946 310223.309 1135726.211 581.538 309409.934 1135699.759 574.753 309370.257 1135521.214 577.752 309634.769 1135203.799 582.345 310315.888 1135071.543 589.634 309152.035 1134787.193 586.664 308563.495 1135726.211 582.348 308794.943 1134172.202 599.425 309767.025 1134502.842 602.570

Figure 4: Contour from Topo Map 5m Interval

1138000

700 690 680 670

1137000

660 650 640 1136000

630 620 610 600

1135000

590 580 570 1134000

560

309000

0

310000

1000

311000

2000

312000

3000

This article can be downloaded from http://www.ijges.com/current-issue.php 5

313000

4000

314000


Int. J. of Geology & Earth Sci., 2016

Aminu Abdulwahab et al., 2016

maximal change of elevation values (Shary et. al., 2002), ranging from 0° to 90°. The slop was generated base on the DEMs of the study area as shown in Figure 7, 8 and 9.

Figure 5: Contour from SRTM 5m Interval

1138000

680 675 670 665 660 655 650 645 640 635 630 625 620 615 610 605 600 595 590 585 580 575 570 565 560 555 550

1137000

1136000

1135000

1134000

309000

310000

0

311000

1000

312000

2000

313000

3000

Geometrically, slope describes the angle between the horizontal plane and the tangential to the surface and slope is expressed as follows:

S  arctan( p 2  q 2 )1/ 2 Figure 7: Slope from Topo Map DEM

314000

4000

Figure 6: Contour from ASTER GDEM 5m Interval

1138000

680 675 670 665 660 655 650 645 640 635 630 625 620 615 610 605 600 595 590 585 580 575 570 565 560 555 550

1137000

1136000

1135000

1134000

309000

310000

0

311000

1000

312000

2000

313000

3000

Figure 8: Slope from SRTM DEM

314000

4000

SLOPE MAPS CREATION One of the most important geomorphometric parameters of terrain surface is slope, it represent an important role in determining the geomorphologic processes that affect a certain area. It represents the quantitative measure of This article can be downloaded from http://www.ijges.com/current-issue.php 6

...(1)


Int. J. of Geology & Earth Sci., 2016

Aminu Abdulwahab et al., 2016

Figure 9: Slope from ASTER GDEM

Figure 10: Aspect from Topo Map

Figure 11: Aspect from SRTM DEM

where Slope gradient can be expressed in either degrees or radians, but more commonly Percentages are used to refer to slope values (tan (S) *100).

ASPECT MAPS CREATION Aspect can be thought of as the slope direction. Aspect identifies the downslope direction of the maximum rate of change in value from each cell to its neighbors. The values of the output raster will be the compass direction of the aspect.It is measured clockwise in degrees from 0 (due north) to 360 (again due north), coming full circle. Flat areas having no downslope direction are given a value of -1. (ESRI 2010) as shown in Figures (10, 11 and 12).

Figure 12: Aspect from ASTER GDEM

Aspect maps can also shows a region of maximum descend that is evaluated from the DEM. According to (Li et al., 2004), Aspect is defined as the direction of the biggest slope vector on the tangent plane projected onto the horizontal plane. Aspect is the bearing (or azimuth) of the slope direction, and its angle ranges from 0 to

360° in a clockwise direction. Aspect is computed from the directional slopes (where ι = Slope) obtained, using equation 2. ...(2)

This article can be downloaded from http://www.ijges.com/current-issue.php 7


Int. J. of Geology & Earth Sci., 2016

Aminu Abdulwahab et al., 2016

PROFILES CREATION

SHADED RELIEF MAP

Profile curvature is the curvature of a line formed by the intersection of a fictional vertical plane with

Shaded relief maps are raster maps based on grid files, the three DEMs were exported to grid file from the Global Mapper software for advance analysis in Surfer 10 software. These maps use colors to indicate the local orientation of the surface relative to a user-defined light source direction (Golden software 2011). Surfer 10 software was used to determine the orientation of each grid cell and calculates reflectance of a point light source on the x, y, and z grid surface. The light source can be thought of as the sun shining on a topographic surface. Portions of the surface that face away from the light source reflect less light toward the viewer and thus appear darkeras shown in Figure (16,17 and 18).

the ground surface. While a zero value of profile curvature indicates a flat surface, negative values indicate that the surface is upwardly concave and positive values indicate that the surface is upwardly convex (Evans 1972, quoted by (Shary et. al., 2002). In this research, from Figure (1, 2 and 3), A line from Point A to B was created on the three DEMs with equal x, y coordinates and the profiles were generated along these lines (A to B) to determine the difference in the profile across them as shown in Figure (13, 14 and 15). Figure 13: Profile from Topo Map DEM

Figure 16: Shade Relief from Topo Map

1138000

1137000

1136000

1135000

Figure 14: Profile from SRTM DEM 1134000

309000

310000 0

311000 1000

312000 2000

313000 3000

314000 4000

Figure 17: Shade Relief from SRTM DEM

1138000

Figure 15: Profile from ASTER GDEM

1137000

1136000

1135000

1134000

309000

310000

0

311000

1000

312000

2000

This article can be downloaded from http://www.ijges.com/current-issue.php 8

313000

3000

314000

4000


Int. J. of Geology & Earth Sci., 2016

Aminu Abdulwahab et al., 2016

DEM profile falls between the Topo and the ASTER GDEM, “suggesting a possiblehorizontal shift of the points (ASTER GDEM Validation Team, 2009, corrected for a problem like this in Japan). While visual comparisons are important, because DEMs provide avaluable base map, quantitative measures should back up the qualitative visual assessments. This study looked at both elevation and slope distributions”(Suzanne P Wechsler and Charles N Kroll, 2006).

Figure 18: Shade Relief from ASTER GDEM 1138000

1137000

1136000

1135000

1134000

309000

310000

0

311000

1000

312000

2000

313000

3000

314000

CONCLUSION

4000

RESULTS

From the results of this research work, we have come up with the conclusion that the ASTERGDEM yield suitable results from the slope analysis of the DEMs and are more related to the Topographical DEM than the SRTM DEM. Although, the ASTER GDEM has a 1" resolution while the SRTM DEM is a 3" resolution DEM and from the contour analysis Figure 4, 5 and 6 the two contour of ASTER GDEM and SRTM DEM looks alike while the contour from topographical Map looks different because it were digitized from an existing topo sheet. The shade relief map shows that the existing contour of the topo map has a very high interval which will affect the result of the analysis, yet, the three profiles from Figure 13, 14 and 15 shows terrain harmony in shape from point A to B.

Visual Comparisons The best and simplest method of DEMs comparison covering same area was through Visual Comparison of 3D graphical maps such as shade relief and Profile Figure (13, 14 and 15). Figure (16, 17 and 18) represent the three comparisons, it was scaled so that the pixel resolution data is correct for the exported grid file of ASTER GDEM1.5 arc second, SRTM DEM 3 arc second and DEM from Topographical Map of the research area. The ASTER GDEM shows less detail than any of the otherdata sets, even the 3" SRTM, and shows a number of artifacts,especially on Hilly Ground. In Figure 16, one of the comparison DEMs isthe Topographic product. In Figure 17 the 3" SRTM data,Shows much less visual detail than the 1" ASTER GDEM, which actually showsmore detail than the 3" SRTM. A second visual technique super imposes topographic profiles from each of the DEMs (Figure 13, 14 and 15). This shows the relativeRelationships of the different DEMs; in this case the ASTERGDEM tends to be below the others, although in the topographical DEM is higher than the others Figure (13), while SRTM

The real resolution of the ASTER GDEM, compared to higherresolution DEMs, appears to be about 3". This is slightly betterthan the SRTM DEM.Consideration should be given to distributing the ASTERGDEM in either 2" or 3" resolution. This would match its true effective resolution, and would decrease storage costs by 4 or 9 times. The ASTER GDEM appears to have the lowest quality inregions of low slope, which is also true with the topo DEM, but to a much lesserextent, for the SRTM DEM.

This article can be downloaded from http://www.ijges.com/current-issue.php 9


Int. J. of Geology & Earth Sci., 2016

Aminu Abdulwahab et al., 2016

REFERENCES 1.

Beven K and Kirkby M (1979), “A physically based variable contributing area model of basin hydrology”, Hydrological Sciences Bulletin, Vol. 24, No. 1, pp. 43–69.

2.

ESRI (2010), IDRISI Guide to GIS and Image Processing.

3.

Farr T G, Rosen P A, Caro E (2007), “The shuttle radar topography mission”, Reviews of Geophysics, Vol. 45, No. 2, RG2004, doi:10.1029/2005RG000183. Clarks Lab, Clarks University, MA, USA. Ver 96.

4.

Gesch D B, Oimoen M, Greenlee S, Nelson C, Steuck M and Tyler D (2002), “The national elevation dataset”, Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing, Vol. 68, No. 1, pp. 5-11.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

Hirt C, Filmer M S and Featherstone W E (2010), “Comparison and validation of the recent freely available ASTER-GDEM ver1, SRTM ver4.1 and GEODATA DEM-9S ver3 digital elevation models over Australia”, Australian Journal of Earth Sciences, Vol. 57, No. 3, pp.337-347.

10. Intermap Technologies (2010), “Product Handbook & Quick Start Guide, Standard Edition”, v4.4: https://www.vtrenz.net/ imarkownerfiles/ownerassets/868/ Intermap%20Product%20Handbook% 20v4.3_for_web.pdf (accessed 23 Aug. 2010). 11.

Geo Base (2007), “Canadian Digital Elevation Data, Level 1 Product Specifications”, Edition 3.0, http:// geobase.ca/geobase/en/data/cded/ description.html (accessed 1 Sept. 2010).

Jarvis A, Reuter H L, Nelson A, and Guevara E (2008), “Hole-filled SRTM for the globe Version 4”, available from the CGIAR-CSI SRTM 90m Database: http:// srtm.csi.cgiar.org.

12. Kumura N (2008), “Application of Participatory G.I.S. for Rural Community Development and Local Level Spatial Planning System in Sri Lanka”, Sri Lanka Rural Development Seminar.

Guth P L (2006), “Geomorphometry from SRTM: Comparison to NED”, Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing, Vol. 72, No. 3, pp. 269-277.

13. Lehner B, Verdin K and Jarvis J (2008), “HydroSHEDS Technical Documentation”, Version 1.1: http://gisdata.usgs.net/ HydroSHEDS/downloads/ HydroSHEDS_TechDoc_v11.pdf (accessed 23 Aug. 2010).

Guth P L (2009), “Geomorphometry in MICRODEM”, In Hengl T, Reuter H I (Eds.), Geomorphometry: concepts, software, applications. Developments in Soil Science Series, Elsevier, pp. 351-366.

14. Li Z, Zhu Q and Gold C (2005), “Digital terrain modelling: Principles and methodology”, CRC Press. Boca Raton.

Hayakawa Y S, Oguchi T and Lin Z (2008), “Comparison of new and existing global digital elevation models: ASTER G-DEM and SRTM-3”, Geophysical Research Letters, Vol. 35, L17404, doi:10.1029/ 2008GL035036.

15. Monmonier M (1991), How to Lie with Maps, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois, p. 207. 16. USGS (2005), “Documentation for the

This article can be downloaded from http://www.ijges.com/current-issue.php 10


Int. J. of Geology & Earth Sci., 2016

Aminu Abdulwahab et al., 2016

Shuttle Radar Topography Mission Water Body data files”, http://dds.cr.usgs.gov/srtm/ version 2_1/SWBD/SWBD_Documentation/Readme_SRTM_Water_Body_ Data.pdf (accessed 2 Sept. 2010).

Urban and Regional Information Systems Association Journal, Vol. 15, No. 2, pp. 57–64. 18. Wright J (1942), “Map makers are human: Comments on the subjective in maps”, The Geographical Review, Vol. 32, No. 4, pp.

17. Wechsler S (2003), “Perceptions of digital elevation model uncertainty by DEM users”,

527–544.

This article can be downloaded from http://www.ijges.com/current-issue.php 11


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS BETWEEN DEM FROM TOPOGRAPHIC, ASTER GDEM AND SRTM DEM by Aminu Abdulwahab - Issuu