Hometown Oneonta 08-29-19

AUTUMN Dreams

INSIDE!

►CELEBRATE FALL AROUND OTSEGO LAKE

13 Friday Sept. .com a t n o e n o x ted Volume 11, No. 47

HOMETOWN !

E RE

F

ONEONTA

& The Otsego-Delaware Dispatch

Oneonta, N.Y., Thursday, August 29, 2019

Visit www.

AllOTSEGO.com

MUSICA, MAESTROS!

City of The Hills

Beginning Sept. 7, 3 Conductors Will Compete This Fall To Lead Catskill Symphony By LIBBY CUDMORE ONEONTA

C Ian Austin/HOMETOWN ONEONTA

Sam Campolo, a member of ZBT fraternity, remembers his friendship with Nicholas Stagnitta, 21, Patchogue, during a vigil on Tuesday, Aug. 27 in the SUNY Oneonta’s President’s Garden. The young man, who died suddenly this week, “was so full of life, and now everything feels empty,” he said.

Council Looks Into Dog Park For City Parks ONEONTA

T

he city’s Operations, Planning and Evaluations Committe is again exploring the possibility of a dog park in the city. “There are a lot of dog lovers in Oneonta,” said Common Council member Michele Frazier, First Ward. OPEC asked City Manager George Korthauer, Parks and Recreation and Engineering, to explore the costs and sites. Details at

all it Oneonta’s “Next Top Conductor.” Silus Nathanial Huff, Carolyn Watson and Maciej Żółtowski will each conduct one of three concerts in the Catskill Symphony Orchestra’s search for their new conductor, following the retirement of Maestro Charles Schneider last year.

►WHO WILL HOLD BATON? YOU CAN HELP CHOOSE

T

hree conductors will perform locally this fall and you will be asked to assess how they do, as Catskill Symphony Orchestra recruits a sucessor to founding maestro Chuck Schneider, as follows: •Saturday, Sept. 7 – SILAS HUFF, music director, New York City’s Astoria Symphony, Colorado pops and other orchestras. •Saturday, Oct. 12 – CAROLYN WATSON, director, orchestral studies, University of Kansas, won international conducting competition. •Saturday, Nov. 16 – MACIEJ Żółtowski, violinist, composer, collaborator with

Huff

WATCH FOR PROGRESS AT SHELTER SITE

$2M DOWN, $1M TO GO

AllOTSEGO.com

AllOTSEGO.com

►COUNTY CLERK Kathy Sinnott Gardner accused the Cuomo Administration of a “money grab” by charging drivers $25 for new plates after paint started peeling off existing ones. Want to keep your current plates? $45. ►SUNY ONEONTA and the United University Professions have reached an agreement to increase the pay and prospect for adjunct professors. ► HANZOLO, the Cooperstown band, won Albany’s Battle of the Bands and a featured spot Sept. 14 at PearlPalooza, the city’s downtown music festival ►A PROPANE TRUCK driver was found dead in his cab after the vehicle ran off the road near Hobart. Troopers suspect the man may have been stricken medically.

Jim Kevlin/HOMETOWN ONEONTA

Better Exchange Thrift Store Manager Sara Lucas sets up panels showing artist’s renderings of the prospective animal shelter, on view for the first time at the Saturday, Aug. 24, groundbreaking.

ceremony on the site across Route By JIM KEVLIN 28 from Kevin’s Ford. “That’s a good thing when people make INDEX individual contributions. It’s their shelter. It’s the people’s shelter.” o far, 100 individual conAt the groundbreaking, Anita tributions have been made Vitullo of Clinton, Staffworks to the new Susquehanna president and a donor to animal ►DONATE to the causes, announced her $250,000 Animal Shelter, and more of the kind are needed to reach the new SSPCA’s “Shelter matching grant has been met Us” fund drive at fundraising goal of $3 million, by donations, netting $500,000 www. sqspca.org according to SSPCA Executive toward achieving the $2 million Director Stacie Haynes. mark. “It’s the individuals we have to count With that mark met, and a new goal of on,” said Haynes in the afterglow of Sat$3 million set, SSPCA board chair Gaylord urday, Aug. 24’s upbeat groundbreaking Please See SHELTER, A9

S

Żółtowski

Polish symphony orchestras. All concerts at 7:30 p.m., SUNY Oneonta’s Hunt Union Ballroom For tickets, visit: https://catskillsymphony.net/purchase-tickets/

www.

ON

Watson

“Our search for the new conductor started last September,” Laurie Zimniewicz, search committee chair. “We had 73 local, national and international candidates apply. We narrowed it down to 12, then nine, then five and then three.” Now, the Symphony is asking for audience help in choosing the next conductor. This fall, the three finalists will each spend a week in Oneonta, meeting with the board, Symphony patrons, the Please See CSO, A9

FENIMORE EXHIBIT ENDING

This Is Last Weekend For Rock, Roll Photos By LIBBY CUDMORE COOPERSTOWN

‘H

view are costumes and instruments on loan from the Rock & Roll Hall. “The last three weeks, it’s been mobbed,” said D’Ambrosio. “People realized it’s closing, and that’s

erb Ritts: The Rock Portraits” was a game-changer for The Fenimore Art Museum. “Our admissions at The Fenimore were up 13 percent from last year,” said Paul D’Ambrosio, president. “This tells us that we need to Jim Kevlin/HOMETOWN ONEONTA keep appealing to Fenimore President D’Ambrosio a broader, younger discusses Ritts’ iconic Madonna audience.” portrait. If you want to see it, The portraits this is your last chance. The – Monday, Sept. exhibit closes Sept. 2. 2, is the exhibit’s last day – include Madonna, increased turnout, but July David Bowie, Prince and had a lot of momentum too. other music icons. It was The symposium was comloaned by the Rock & Roll pletely packed.” Hall of Fame and the Herb While “2019 is not a Ritts Foundation. Also on Please See ROCK, A9

Despite Village Atty.’s Warning, Trustees Vote To Fly Pride Flag By JENNIFER HILL COOPERSTOWN

A

month after voting unanimously to fly the Pride Flag on the flagpole next June, village trustees once again debated and, in the end, affirmed their decision. “I gave every member of

this board every opportunity to table this motion,” said Trustee MacGuire Benton, who introduced the resolution at the board’s July meeting. “For any vote you can have a discussion. We don’t need a unique, complex way to vote on flags,” he said. The debates started when the board’s “Adhoc Committee Please See FLAG, A8

HOMETOWN ONEONTA, OTSEGO COUNTY’S LARGEST CIRCULATION NEWSPAPER 2010 WINNER OF The Otsego County Chamber/KEY BANK SMALL BUSINESS AWARD

A-2 HOMETOWN ONEONTA

HOMETOWN People

EIGHT HONORED AS JOB CORPS COMMUNITY PARTNERS

THURSDAY, August 29, 2019

Harris Takes 9th Atchison Cup Title At Otsego County Championship

Justin Harris, Unadilla, holds his Atchison Cup

Ian Austin/HOMETOWN ONEONTA at the end of the annual Otsego County Gold

Ahead of the sixth annual Oneonta Job Corps community softball game on Friday, Aug. 23 at Damaschke Field, executive director Chris Kuhn inducted eight community partners into the Oneonta Job Corps Community Partnership Hall of Fame. From left, Kristen Winn and Michelle Zuk Family Resource Network, Lee and Joanne Fisher, Oneonta NAACP, Sonia Shultis, Tribe Yoga, Molly Swain, community leader & activist, Lynn Bailey, YMCA, Valarie Adams and Kimberly Lorraine, United Way, Kuhn, Bob the Bulldog and Jocelyn Plows, administrative assistant.

s

amantha Butcher, the former assistant tennis coach at SUNY Oneonta, has joined Hartwick College as their head tennis coach this season. A second head coach, Nora Fallon-Oben, will lead the women’s lacrosse coach, Fallon-Oben had been an assistant at Hamilton for the last four years. Kayla Houle and Eric Luben were both named assistant athletic trainers. Houle returns to Oneonta after graduating with a Master of Science in Athletic Training from

Lock Haven University in May 2019. She has previous athletic training experience at Lock Haven, Binghamton Butcher University, Williamsport Area High School and at her alma mater, SUNY Oneonta. Luben had been an athletic trainer at Wayne Memorial Hospital in Honesdale, PA since 1997. The list of new assistant coaches is as follows: • Avery Blackmon (women’s lacrosse), who

recently finished a recordsetting career at Georgetown College; • Courtney Chase (women’s basketball), who spent last season as a volunteer assistant at Mount Holyoke College while working to complete her Master of Science in Sport Management from UMass Amherst; • Tom Peabody (football, defensive backs), who had an excellent three-year career as a linebacker for the Hawks from 2016-2018; • Logan Sharp (men’s basketball), who spent the last two seasons as an assistant at Eastern Nazarene College;

ONEONTA

C

arding 75 on Saturday and 69 on Sunday to make a 144 total, Justin Harris, Unadilla, seized his ninth Atchison Cup at the 42nd annual Otsego County Amateur Championship, • Lou Walker (swimming held Saturday-Sunday, Aug. 24-25. and diving), who had a Patti Canner won her first legendary career as head Atchison cup for the women’s swimming and diving coach tournament with 94 the first day at Syracuse University from and 88 the second for a total of 1975-2011, before relo182. Lathan, Canner and cating to Texas to work in Day one was played at Colonial Witlsie high school athletics. Ridge Golf Course in Laurens and • Carissa Warren (field day two was played at the Oneonta hockey), who crossed West County Club. In all, 59 competitors played over five men’s Street following a very flights and one ladies flight. impressive career at SUNY Michael Schulte took second place with 149 and Levi Oneonta. Decker finished third at 152. With 155, Bruce Miller was In addition to Peabody’s fourth and John Courtney was in fifth with 158. hiring for ’Wick football, Nick Lambros totalled 157 to win the Senior 1 division. Matt Ali was promoted and With 167, Al Puylara was second and Bob Zeh, 170, was will now be the Special third. Teams Coordinator in Lauren Lathan and Michelle Witlsie tied at 189 to take addition to coaching wide second place for the women’s division, receivers and tight ends, and The Atchison Cup is awarded in memory of Bill Atchison Nate Farley was promoted Sr. from part-time to full-time.

8 Coaches Join Hartwick College Athletic Department ONEONTA

Championship. With him is PGA professional Matt Schulte.

Watch Your Money Grow With Us.

2•00 2•25

% %

APY* on a 12-Month CD

APY* on a 18-Month CD

Hometown banking advantages that only Bank of Cooperstown can provide: ŕ Ž -YPLUKS` WYVMLZZPVUHS SVJHS ZLY]PJL HUK Z\WWVY[ ŕ Ž 9LPU]LZ[TLU[ VM `V\Y KLWVZP[Z [V OLSW KYP]L SVJHS JVTT\UP[` HUK I\ZPULZZ NYV^[O Âś ILJH\ZL what starts here, stays here! Stop in or call one of our branches and open a CD today. Ask us about our other CD specials.

*The above Annual Percentage Yield (APY) is effective as of August 12, 2019, and is subject to change without notice. Minimum deposit required is $1,000. To obtain the special rate, customer must have a USNY Bank checking account with direct deposit of paycheck from employer, pension or government benefits. Without a USNY Bank checking account and direct deposit, a 12-month CD will yield an APY of 1.75% and an 18-month CD will yield an APY of 2.00%. Penalties may apply for early withdrawal, which may reduce earnings. Other restrictions may apply. Consumer accounts only. No brokered or municipal accounts. Call or visit branch for details.

*OLZ[U\[ :[ c *VVWLYZ[V^U 5@ c 4HPU :[ c 6ULVU[H 5@ c Open 8:30 a.m. – 5:00 p.m. (Monday – Friday)

IHURVMJVVWLYZ[V^U JVT

THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL & HOMETOWN ONEONTA A-3

THURSDAY, August 29, 2019

Presented by our friends at EMPIRE TOYOTA

Presented by our friends at

8/30/19 5pm - 9pm

Balloon Launch at 6pm

8/31/19 3pm - 9pm Balloon Launch at 6am Balloon Launch at 6pm Balloon Glow at dusk

BALLOON EVENTS WEATHER & WIND PERMITTING!

9/1/19 Balloon Launch 6am

THANK YOU

ENTERTAINMENT SCHEDULE

TO OUR EVENT SPONSORS:

1k | 5k | 10k

FRIDAY - 5PM - 9PM

5:00PM: VENDORS OPEN 5:00PM: BOUNCE HOUSES & ROCK WALL OPEN 5:00PM: MIKE THE JUGGLER 5:00PM: BECCA FRAME & THE TALL BOYS 6:00PM: BALLOON LAUNCH 7:15PM: ROUNDHOUSE ROCKERS

September 31,2019 | Neahwa Park, Oneonta To Register Visit: www.friendsofrecoverydo.org

SATURDAY - 3PM - 9PM

6:00AM: BALLOON LAUNCH 9:00AM: ROTHENBERGER RUN 3:00PM: TOM & DOUG’S CRUISE IN 3:00PM: VENDORS OPEN 3:00PM: BOUNCE HOUSES & ROCK WALL OPEN 3:00PM: MIKE THE JUGGLER 3:00PM: EVVERGREEN 4:00PM: JIM OKEY MAGIC SHOW 3:30PM: UTICA ZOOMOBILE 5:15PM: HANZOLO 5:30PM: ANIMAL ADVENTURE ZOO TO YOU 6:00PM: JIM OKEY MAGIC SHOW 6:00PM: BALLOON LAUNCH 7:30PM: HOP CITY HELLCATS DUSK: BALLOON GLOW

Join us for the Rothenberger Road to Recovery Run in an effort to reduce the stigma associated with Substance Use Disorders. Help us reduce the stigma, allowing individuals to feel supported and safe enough to ask for help!

Special thanks to Five Star Subaru, City of Oneonta, Town of Oneonta, Mike Ranieri, BalloonNY, our event & balloon sponsors, our members, our volunteers, Hartwick College students, SUNY Oneonta students and Job Corps students & staff!

ONEONTA OUT OF THE DARKNESS WALK SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 21, 2019 6TH WARD BOOSTER CLUB FIELD • ONEONTA REGISTRATION 9 AM, WALK BEGINS 10:30 AM Register at afsp.org/oneonta

! ! ! !

WEEKLY SPECIALS! Margarita Mondays! Taco Tuesdays! Happy Hour and Special Salsa Dancing Nights DINE IN or TAKE ouT!

Lower Level Clinton Plaza 19 Clinton Plaza Oneonta 607-431-9898

1k | 5k | 10k Saturday, August 31, 2019

IA

DG

E WIL

L

Cooperstown’s Newspaper

OUNDED

JU

& The Otsego-Delaware Dispatch

•F

1808 BY

ONEONTA

R

IN

HOMETOWN

O M C O PE

To Register Visit: www.friendsofrecoverydo.org

For 211 Years

AllOTSEGO.com

A-4 HOMETOWN ONEONTA

HOMETOWN Views

THURSDAY, August 29, 2019

EDITORIAL

How Often Can We Help Something First-Rate Happen?

S

olicitations, by phone, Staffworks’ president and mail, email philanthropist to the pet or in person, world, underscored the many are a pesky part of ways “Shelter Us” is 21st century life. top notch in her remarks The advantages Saturday, Aug. 24, at the the Susquehanna groundbreaking on Route SPCA’s “Shelter Us” 28 at Index. campaign for $3 milShe talked about ►DONATE to the “dynamic leadership,” and lion to build a new SSPCA’s “Shelter how the shelter’s dynamo animal shelter are: one, the people who Us” fund drive at executive director, Stacie are running it are our www. sqspca.org Haynes, called her and “did neighors – we know a good job of convincing them. And, two, everything me” to provide support. Add about it is first rate. board chair Gaylord Dillingham Anita Vitullo of Clinton, and “Shelter Us” chair Anne

Vitullo, who was announcing “Shelter Us” had raised the $250,000 needed to match her matching grant, went on to speak about commitment, and customer service, and mission – all the things that, no doubt, has made her placement company successful, too. Add in creativity and innovation. Vitullo told how Haynes collaborated with Sheriff Richard J. Devlin Jr. and District Attorney John Muehl in creating a county The Freeman’s Journal Animal Cruelty Task Force, to Why is this woman smiling? get ahead of some of the pet and Stacie Haynes is about to farm-animal related fiascos of the announce “Shelter Us” met past few years. its initial $2 million goal.

LETTERS

THEY’RE THE TOPS

When Stars & Stripes Works, Rainbow Won’t Be Necessary To the Editor: A letter to the editor and a column in last week’s newspaper on the display of the Rainbow flag lacks perspective – to the point of blindness – particularly where the Rainbow flag is conflated with the Confederate flag. The six stripes – red, orange, yellow, green, blue and violet – of the 1978 Rainbow flag is a worldwide emblem representing an ongoing struggle for equal rights under the law for LGBTQ people. These rights are basic: the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness,

• Another aspect of the drive that hasn’t been reported on yet is bringing in Scott Learned, principal in Design Learned, a cuttingedge shelter-design company from Norwich, Conn. Learned, who is considered among the best in the business, doesn’t even call what he does shelter design. He uses the term “animal-care facility engineering.” When you visit a Learned shelter, Haynes will tell you, you don’t hear the barking that Please See EDITORIAL, A5

Ron Ranc and Roxana Hurlburt, partners in ISD Tech, Oneonta, express thanks for being recognized with the Bank of Cooperstown’s Environmental Award for recycling 84,000 pounds of computer equipment since 2011. The Otsego County Chamber’s Summer Soirée awards banquet was Thursday, Aug. 22, at the Clark Sports Center, Cooperstown.

to freedom of expression and association, to living openly without discrimination, to personal autonomy. The rights have to do with parenthood and families, intimate relationships, and protections in the workplace and in health care. In other words, the rights that all U.S. citizens enjoy. The modern display of the Confederate flag means something totally different. It means the denial of equal rights. It is about white supremacy. It is embraced by the Ku Klux Klan. It does not represent liberty and Please See SEWARD, A6

POEM TO THE EDITOR Ian Austin/The Freeman’s Journal

South Main Street When I was a bit too young, a girl and I snuck into the city’s sewers. We crawled through narrow places with trickling water, splashing in puddles and neat little streams I watched her bend beneath concrete and pipes, strain to look up at the drains that filtered in light from some half-recognized street, and I thought of other secret places. We burst into light, unearthed near some computer repair shop and made our way out from a large concrete

Ellen Tillapaugh Kuch and Gary Herzig, Cooperstown and Oneonta’s mayors, exchange notes at the Soirée. Behind them is Bank of Cooperstown President Scott White.

culvert, new armpit hair moist with sweat, tickling my arms. We ended up on the sidewalk, South Main Street, and walked back to her house with soggy shoes, hands almost brushing. Gianluca Avanzato Oneonta Editor’s Note: Avanzato has just published “City of the Hills,” poems about his native city.

HOMETOWN

ONEONTA

& The Otsego-Delaware Dispatch

Oneonta Y Director Frank Russo, center, dips into the Townsend Catering buffet. At left are architect Jim Jordan and Cynthia Andela of Andela Products. At right is Veronica Pokorny, Paperkite Creative.

George Busch – not that George Bush, he told the audience, but NBT Insurance Agency vice president/ sales – presents the NBT Bank Quality of Life Award to Clark Sports Center Director Val Paige.

James C. Kevlin Editor & Publisher

FROM THE EDITOR

Tara Barnwell

Questions Are Neutral. Answers, Not So Much

Advertising Director & General Manager

Libby Cudmore Managing Editor

Larissa Ryan Business Manager

Thom Rhodes Advertising Consultant

Jennifer Hill Reporter

Ian Austin Photographer

Ivan Potocnik Web Architect

Kathleen Peters Graphics & Production

Tom Heitz Consultant

Amanda Wilsey Consultant

IN MEMORIAM: Mary Joan Kevlin, Co-Publisher, 2006-17 MEMBER OF New York Press Association • The Otsego County Chamber Published weekly by Iron String Press, Inc. 21 Railroad Ave., Cooperstown NY 13326 Telephone: (607) 547-6103. Fax: (607) 547-6080. E-mail: info@allotsego.com • www.allotsego.com

A

sking questions: It’s a method of teaching that goes back to earlier than 399 B.C. and Socrates, the seminal thinker who laid the foundation for much subsequent Western thought. Hence, the Socratic Method. The idea is that a question, in itself, is neutral; at worst – or best? – a provocation to think. It’s the resulting answers to the question that aren’t neutral. The hope is that, tested by argumentation, open debate will lead to the best consensus. So it’s with some surprise that the AllOTSEGO.com Poll, begun in February with the question, “Do you want marijuana stores operating in Otsego County?” has become controversial. There’s a Facebook component for

further debate. Sure, some of the questions deal with edgy topics, but we’re living in an edgy time: • Does the massacre of 50 people at a mosque in New Zealand require more regulation JIM KEVLIN of the internet? • Should allegations that Joe Biden touched a female Nevada legislator inappropriately cause him to end his prospective presidential campaign? • A federal commission is studying whether all women should be required

from the editor

to register for the draft, as are men. Should they? • The state Legislature in Albany is considering allowing illegal aliens to obtain driver’s licenses. Do you Socrates with support that his mouth open: legislation? • With Con- Asking a question, no doubt. gressional hearings underway, do you agree descendants of American slaves should receive reparations?\ Please See QUESTIONS, A5

THURSDAY, August 29, 2019

HOMETOWN

History

HOMETOWN ONEONTA A-5

Compiled by Tom Heitz and SHARON STUART, with resources courtesy of The Fenimore Art Museum Research Library

150 Years Ago

80 Years Ago

Delaware Academy – The fall term of this institution opened very favorably last week. The gentlemen in charge are men of large experience in teaching, and we can assure parents and scholars that an opportunity is now offered for a thorough and complete course of education. The corps of teachers in the Academy excel in scholarship, and are fully prepared to give scholars a full and complete Academic course. The buildings have been refitted and are in perfect condition. The library is the largest and best selected in the county, and the laboratory is in complete order, and the boarding halls are open for boarders on reasonable terms. We know of no institution so complete and perfect in all respects and so desirable for scholars seeking education. September 1869

125 Years Ago Stamford was visited by a big fire last week Tuesday evening. The Tanner House, just below the Village of Stamford, was discovered to be on fire. The fire was in the top of the house and spread rapidly. It was soon beyond control and all that could be done was to save furniture from the lower stories. Only one stream of water could be turned on the flames and what could be done had to be done very quickly. By midnight the building was burned to the ground. September 1894

100 Years Ago Two automobiles collided late Saturday afternoon at a sharp turn of the state road just west of Davenport Center. One of the cars was a large Auburn sedan driving west from Kingston, and the other a Buick six. The Auburn car skidded on the slippery road in making the turn and sideswiped the Buick, itself landing on the bank. The driver, in righting the car, sideswiped a tree and then ran head-on into another tree, practically demolishing his car. The Buick was less seriously damaged and taken to the local garage for repairs. Of the occupants of the cars two women and a man were injured but none seriously. The occupants of the Auburn car, who were from New Jersey on their way to Norwich, were taken to Oneonta, where they caught the evening train. September 1919

60 Years Ago “All the little boys look the same with short haircuts and long trousers.” That was the observation of John Milsome, exchange teacher from England who will teach sixth grade at Chestnut Street school this year. Mr. Milsome, the assis-

male New York State police force to give half of its job openings for years to come to women and members of minority groups. U.S. District Judge James Foley set quotas for future hiring by the police division at 40 percent of all new trooper positions to blacks and Spanish surnamed citizens and 10 percent to women. The ruling will remain in place until the 3,400 member force reflects the racial make-up of the population it serves – a process estimated to require at least five years at current hiring and staffing levels. The civil suit originated with the U.S. Department of Justice in 1977. Judge Foley said he had found no evidence that the past hiring practices had been purposely discriminatory or to any extent selected and continued because of adverse impact upon Negroes, Spanish-surnamed Americans or women. However, he said they had a discriminatory effect in violation of federal law and that must change. September 1979

20 Years Ago The Upstate Home for Children opened a new home on Glens Bridge Road in the Town of Oneonta last week. Five people will live in the home which will be staffed by about 10 people on rotating shifts. The home meets a housing demand for adults with mental and physical handicaps. The home provides a home-like environment where residents are involved in cooking meals and other chores said Bill Twasutyn, Director of Adult Services at the Upstate Home. There is a similar home for six people under the age of 21 in West Oneonta. The residents at the Glens Bridge Road home will range in age from 23 to 29 and will attend programs at the Upstate Home Center on Water Street in September 1939 Oneonta or a program with the Association for Retarded Citizens, Twasutyn said. tant headmaster at Roe Green Primary School, Kingsbury, September 1999 England replaces William Swain, who will teach in England. The swap was made possible through the U.S. Office of Education and the Ministry of the United Kingdom. Standing in the lobby of the 1897 Chestnut Street theatre, Mr. Milsome along with his wife and daughter are living state Sen. Jim Seward, R-Milford, announced a $10,000 at 7 Cleveland Street. Mr. Milsome anticipates no probsenate grant to help the Friends of the Oneonta Theatre lems with American youngsters. “I don’t know baseball reopen the theater.”. but I’m sure the youngsters will teach me. I could tell them The money is an operating grant. Under an agreement about cricket and football (soccer),” he said. Mr. Milsome with the new owner, Thomas Cormier of Burlington Flats, in concluding the interview remarked that Bill Swain, the proprietor of Information Technologies, the Friends will Oneonta teacher who replaced him in England, was probmanage the theater portion of the complex. ably being interviewed by one of our reporters. “The Oneonta Theatre has played an important role in September 1959 local history and the downtown Oneonta economy,” said Seward in making his announcement. I am excited that the role will continue and expand in the future,” he said. A federal judge on Thursday ordered the virtually allSeptermber 2009

10 Years Ago

40 Years Ago

MONEY TALKS

Canary Isn’t Chirping. And Other Indicators Suggest Recession Not Looming

A

re we staring at a recession? You have surely seen or heard reports, opinion and speculation to that effect. Gloom has been a mini-rage lately. A few questions are in order. Are economists able to accurately predict recessions? No. If their accuracy percentages were batting averages you would bench them. Why is the subject of recessions in the air so much lately? The Left salivates at the hint of a recession. Because a recession would inspire voters to kick Trump from office. Thus, critics fill our air waves and opinion columns with gloom and doom. Entertainer Bill

Maher openly dreams of one. NY Times columnist Paul Krugman reckons “Trump Boom to Trump TOM Gloom.” He MORGAN is anxious to scuttle praise for Trump’s economy. Because he predicted horrible endless worldwide calamity right after Trump’s election. Good economic news embarrasses him. Can you predict recessions as

Give. ‘Shelter Us’ Earning It EDITORIAL/From A4 generally erupts. The shelter is designed to house animals in a way that makes them feel safe; they can relax. The pungent smells that can hit you in the face entering some shelters aren’t present in Learned shelters, due to an advanced understanding of what HVAC can do. And there’s much more we’ll learn about in the months ahead. • The most impressive quality in today’s Susquehanna SPCA operation and “Shelter Us” is a focus on best practices. There’s no fear that the need to learn will be interpreted as a shortcoming. That’s a quality of any first-rate institution. Many SPCAs looking for a new building are misdirected, said Carr, who pioneered getting animals out of shelters to fairs and other gatherings where people might want to adopt them, an idea much resisted when she introduced it in the 1990s. “What they really need is help with their operations. What’s the point of building a new building if they don’t modernize their approach to animal welfare.” Now retired from the $17 million Erie County Animal Shelter she helped build and a sought-after consultant, Carr was recruited

by Haynes and Dillingham to advise the Susquehanna SPCA on what it needed to know – much that it didn’t even know it needed to know. At the current Hartwick Seminary operation, Carr was pleasantly surprised: Haynes and her staff and volunteers “were just hungry for knowledge, excited about change, willing to do the hard thing of living in change; there’s nothing more human than being uncomfortable with change.” • All this is part of a piece – to make the resulting shelter at Index as good as it can be. The “Shelter Us” goal has risen from $2 million to $3 million as aspirations rose from good to better to best during efforts to date. “We’re here to do it once and to do it right,” is how Haynes put it during Saturday’s groundbreaking. In an interview, Dillingham was determined to reach the $3 million – and given building decisions that need to be made, to reach it by Christmas. What a great end date that would be. Let’s do it, of course, for the sake of the dogs, cats and others the new shelter will serve. But let’s do it with the assurance the outcome will be as good as it can be – a credit to Otsego County – and our support will only make it better.

well as most economists? Probably. Before you make your prediction, here are a few items to consider. First, recessions are normal and natural. They are like colds and flu. The longer we go without one, the more likely we are to suffer one. We have gone 10 years without one. That is a record. But our recovery from the last one is one of the weakest ever. Some economists argue that this shows our economy has a lot more room for further expansion. Next, we can identify two primary causes of recessions over the last eight decades. One is that the Federal Reserve tightened the

money supply aggressively. The other is that we had imbalances, bubbles. Such as the big housing bubble before the last recession. Well, we do not have either cause at the moment. The Fed is loosening, not tightening. And we have no bubbles in sight. (And they are easy to sight.) Also, we usually have certain conditions BEFORE recessions. We typically have a surging economy. And rising interest rates. And predictions galore that stocks and corporate profits will rise a lot. Well, we do not have these conditions. Instead, the economy is growing steadily. It is not surging. Interest rates are not rising. And

we don’t see a lot of predictions for rocketing stock prices and corporate profits. In recessions, consumers slow their spending. We are seeing the opposite. According to the government. Most big box retailers tell us their sales and profits are climbing. Walmart is so huge that its figures probably give us a better look at consumer spending than the government’s. And Walmart is pretty happy these days. It makes sense that consumers spend more these days. And express higher confidence in the economy. After all, we have full employment. We have more job Please See MORGAN, A6

Questions Don’t Matter. Answers Do QUESTIONS/From A4 The idea was that the poll, and Facebook adjunct, would give local readers a chance to participate in what currently is a rich and hard-argued national debate on multiple issues. No one can say it hasn’t. • That same impetus brought former DEC commissioner Mike Zagata of West Davenport, from the right, and Sustainable Otsego moderator Adrian Kuzminski, from the left, to our editorial pages. Zagata and Kuzminski have enriched our opinion pages, generated fresh thinking, and prompted a steady stream of letters to the editor. (Incidentally, both men are PhDs.) Particularly given that www. AllOTSEGO.com has developed into Otsego County’s Daily Newspaper/ONLINE, with world and national news, comics, Dear Abby and a crossword – as well the most, and most timely, local news – more muscular opinion seemed like a logical addition. But from early on, some local leaders have complained the questions in themselves – not the ensuing debate – were “divisive.” In particular, but not exclusively, the county Democratic chair Aimee Swan and county Rep. Andrew Stammel, D-Town of Oneonta, have struck this note repeatedly.

With Democratic control in Albany, that party has ownership of many of the controversial laws coming out of this year’s session, “Green Light” legislation and marijuana legalization among them. It’s the downside of success: Embrace it! President Trump and his prospective impeachment – for now, in abeyance, it seems – has divided the country and the county as well. Does asking about it split opinions beyond what they already are? More problematic to me is the use of expletives and profanity, which we – me and Managing Editor Libby Cudmore, mostly – remove as soon as we become aware of them. Disagreement’s OK, but let’s be polite about it. • Coming up with questions that speak to whatever the issue of the day happens to be isn’t as easy as it may seem. For instance, take the latest hotpotato: Are Democrats trying to provoke a recession to sink President Trump’s reelection prospects? We didn’t just make it up. That issue was hotly debated the other morning on C-Span Radio; you may have heard it during the Oneonta-Cooperstown/ Cooperstown-Oneonta commute. Plus, Bill Maher called for such on his “Real Time” show and, when

challenged, doubled down. Still, the cries arose again. Stammel called the question “ridiculous and divisive.” Chad McEvoy, who ran for Assembly last year against Brian Miller, R-New Hartford, called it “dumb” and “basically irresponsible.” But those who went beyond that had some interesting things to say. Theresa Gorman: “If we go into a recession, the buck stops with the leadership. Always has, always will.” Janet Rigby posted an Axios headline: “Stocks plunge after Trump’s trade tweets.” And Mike McWherter: “At least he has the guts to challenge a country that sells us junk and laughs at us while doing it.” This is news we can use – opinions, rather – to help us come to our own conclusions. The poll is going to continue. I don’t say this defiantly. I think it’s an important forum – and opportunity – for local discussion. I’m not saying we always get it right. If you don’t like the questions, suggest one yourself. (Email jimk@allotsego.com) But let’s stop blaming a question if we don’t like one set of the answers. Socrates would disapprove. Jim Kevlin is editor/publisher of AllOTSEGO.com, Hometown Oneonta and The Freeman’s Journal.

A-6 THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL & HOMETOWN ONEONTA

THURSDAY, August 29, 2019

AllOTSEGO.opportunities

Does It Seem Like Much Of A Recession? MORGAN/From A5 openings than we have unemployed workers. And wages are rising. Here is a canary in the coal mine for the economy. Weekly unemployment claims. Well, these claims are NOT up. The canary chirps. Here is a common indicator of good figures ahead: How much businesses are investing in new plant and equipment. That figure is down. But only slightly. Another canary in the mine is the trend in home-building and buying. Well, building is down. Buying of existing homes is up. But won’t Trump’s big trade war with China push us into a recession? Maybe, in time. And if we and they open new fronts. But we have not yet imposed many of the tariffs. And we have deferred many others. As for China’s tariffs against our products, they are huge, yes. But the impact on our entire economy is minimal. Britain’s and Germany’s economies are slowing. And the overall EU economy is not much to write home about. Won’t these slowdowns pull us into recession? Our economy has often moved in the opposite direction of theirs. Two further items to consider. One is that we might well have suffered a recession by now without our big tax cuts. And without the slashing of regulations. There is a strong argument that they breathed life into our weak recovery from the last recession. A final item is perception. In the recent past, we had media and political bullhorns convince a majority of Americans that we were in recessions. At times when we were anything but. Given the anti-Trump and left-wing bias of our mainstream media, this is likely the goal of much of our media machine today. In other words, you will probably hear a lot more gloom and doom from them. The difference this time is that Trump wields a bigger bullhorn than the Bushes did. Tom Morgan, the retired Oneonta investment counselor who has a syndicated print and radio column, Money Talk, lives in Franklin.

Administrative Assistant Part-time position (M-F: 9 am - 1 pm) Location: Cooperstown SUMMARY: Under supervision of the Sales Office Manager, the Administrative Assistant provides administrative and secretarial support to the branch office and sales agents. Duties & Responsibilities: Performs general secretarial duties (answering phone, typing, filing, etc.) for the office manager and sales agents. Processes and maintains paperwork, billing, deposits. Responds to emails. Assists Sales Office Manager with a variety of duties. Orders office supplies. Understands ‘real estate’ process and terminology. Knowledge, Skills & Abilities: Ability to maintain a positive and professional attitude when interacting with sales associates, clients, vendors and co-workers. Must possess exemplary customer service skills. Ability to communicate professionally in oral and written fashion. Experience with Profit Power and MLS preferred. Prior experience in an office administrative role is preferred. High school diploma required. 2+ years relevant office experience and supporting a team. Reliable, proactive, and self-motivated. Exceptional attention to detail with the ability to handle multiple duties. Proficient in Microsoft Office programs and data entry. Ability to get things done using strong organizational and time management skills. Takes initiative and works independently Please send resumé to Mary-Ann Morehouse at: maryannmorehouse@howardhanna.com

Parking EnforcEmEnt officEr – full timE

Hanna Holdings, Inc. affiliates and assigns are committed to providing equal employment opportunity to all employees and applicants for employment regardless of such factors as race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, veteran’s status or disability. The Company abides by all local, state and federal laws and regulations affecting the hiring of employees.

The Village of Cooperstown has an opening for a full-time Parking Enforcement Officer. This is a full time position with competitive salary and benefits. Applicants must be a resident of Otsego County. Applications will be accepted until the position is filled. The Village of Cooperstown is an Equal Opportunity Employer. For further information regarding the position and to obtain an application, please contact the Village Administrator’s Office at 607-547-2411 or send your resume and cover letter to:

We’re Hiring!

teri l. Barown, rmc, Village administrator, Village of cooperstown, Po Box 346, cooperstown, nY 13326.

Calibration Technician Case Packer Operators CIP Operators Filler Operators Fruit Room Operators Maintenance Technician Safety Supervisor

Join Our Team of Dedicated and Caring Professionals

Administrative Assistant Victim Resource Coordinator Residential Associates

For our Production Facility in New Berlin, NY

(FT & Sub; works at OFO shelters)

With a growing team of thousands, Chobani strives to stay true to and honor Hamdi’s vision and goals for our company: To develop and foster meaningful relationships with those around us, to give back to our local and global communities, and to create one perfect cup of yogurt at a time.

Building Healthy Families Support Specialist HEAD START POSITIONS

When Stars, Stripes Represents All, No Pride Flag Needed

(All F/T with school breaks & Summers off)

As a company, we’re proud to offer careers with limitless opportunities. We look for only the most passionate and hard-working people who will share this vision and help our rapidly growing company reach the next level. Chobani gives us all the chance to make a difference. For more information and to apply, please visit our website at www.chobani.com/careers.

Center Director SEWARD/From A4 justice for all. Classroom Teacher Under the Constitution’s Assistant Teacher First Amendment, any flag can be flown, including the Nazi Center Associate EEO flag. Would writers in your Center-Based Family Partner newspaper conflate that too with Chobani is an equal opportunity employer. Chobani will not discriminate against any the Rainbow flag? Surely the OFO is a family-oriented organization offering competetive wages, excellent benefits applicant for employment on any basis including, but not limited to: race, color, religion, Village Trustees, a body elected and opportunities for professional growth. For an application, submission instructions, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, age, disability, veteran status, by the community, could and benefit package summary and descriptions of all employment openings, visit marital status, predisposing genetic characteristics and genetic information, or any other did make these distinctions. www.ofoinc.org/jobs EOE Recent articles regarding the classification protected by federal, state and local laws. The leader in developing innovative solutions to promote healthy lives, flag controversy are a near crib thriving families, and caring communities since 1966. of Vice President Mike Pence’s June 2019 comments that “one flag should fly” – this in response to requests by U.S. embassies in Germany, Israel, Brazil and Latvia to fly the Rainbow flag during Pride Month. Pence has a long history of anti-LGBTQ views ...Refusing to display the Rainbow flag on the grounds of patriotism as the vice president did, or on the The Fre Hometo e w AlloTsego.com, Since 2019 grounds of the “neutrality of the Since 1 man’s Journal Since 2 n oneonta 8 0 0 0 8 8 political space,” as one of your columnists suggests, only plays into homophobia and gives it Summer Summer OTSEGO.com­­ JOin TOday INSID room to fester. The lived experiDrea INSIDE! E! D r e ams ms ences of LGBTQ individuals /online HOMET shows how hollow that so-called O V All & The WN O OtsegoN neutrality is. EONTA Delawar City of Th ►SubScribe and enjoy complete acceSS! 99¢/week e Dispa e Hills tch Flying flags gives meaning G A ll e n From H era arlem A in certain environments and ristocra Can He l’s 1st Missio cy To N at certain times. In the current ation’s n: Raise E Heights L nough? climate, a public display of the Oneonta Piques n’s Run For C Rainbow flag becomes all the Gibson, on Faso’s In gress terest more compelling. It makes the A point: We support equal rights Rock F es Memor t T ie for the LGBTQ community in Still Viv s id T Cooperstown. We have your back. Honore SUNY, And look, being LGBTQ is e s W Quality Care Abou Come BHacark twOnicSak Stmude Denayts O not a “belief system” nor a “life- All UR K t Of Life Commun ILIMA NJARO Is ‘Lucki ity , GlAlol be S hIKERS style.” That ab absurdo premise Due To est,’ Clark to an argument is as ridiculous Oneonta ‘Grassro Philo Va Film Fest To as it is insulting and beneath Gets Kid ots J Hai nce’s Re discover l Put On s To y Mitts contempt. The rich and famous have “lifestyles.” Doctors and T ISD Prot D ects Nat ure From lawyers and millennials may Compu ters W have “lifestyles.” Being LGBTQ I is about “life.” When the Stars and Stripes eVeRYTHing YoU eXPeCTeD in YoUR DAilY neWsPAPeR: CoMPleTe, UP-To-THe-MinUTe loCAl neWs represents equal rights for all Join Us! Americans, raising the Rainbow Clark SportS Center WoRlD, nATionAl, sTATe neWs • THings To Do • loCAl ADVeRTising • HoRosCoPe • DeAR ABBY • ColoR CoMiCs & flag will be unnecessary. ISD ROBERT SEWARD Middlefield ►SubScribe at OTSEGO.com • for only per week!

OtsegO COunty’s Daily newspaper/online

AllOTSEGO.com All

Our community thrives when we work together for good

S TO DO

IN GR

Coopersto

.com, OT

wn, Ne

w York,

DOLORE

OPER

IN ON EONT A, CO

OPER

STOW N

E

COO

P

OUND

LI

OTSEGO

L

. 33

COOP ER AND AR STOWN OUND

w.

•F

D GE WI

ISIT ww

ER

BY

211, No

EATE R CO

1808

Volume

wspa per

For 21 1 Year s

Volume

11, No.

E!

FRE

46

Oneonta,

SEGO COUN TY’S DA ILY NE Thursday WSPAPE , Augus R/ONLINE t 15, 201 9 Newssta nd Price $1

N.Y., Th urs

day, Au gust 22, 201

9

Visit ww

S WHA RTON’S ‘M

By JIM

COOPE RSTOW N

Mayor Kuch Ellen Tillapa hol husban ds her (an ugh first grad Gary Kuc d born Mondchild, a h’s) to dau nday, Ap girl, ril 12, Kuch-Cghter Dr. Rac husban ecconi, and hel d Joh her n.

Public For Br Invited Zoningiefing On Change COOPE RST

ULTICU LTURED

KEVLIN

w.

►“A Mu Wharton lticulture com and will be availabd life” by Dolo ►edit MSUpress.or le Sept. 1 on res Ori amazon Disciplin Al: “With g . Determin ►eXce e, Whartons Led The ation, On Phil rPt: “Ekofisk Way”/A lips Petr Trip Ian Aust 4 Builds oleuTon in/H Cam m Boa OMETOWN y rd”/ DraA4 erie ONEONTA go, leftarad and his to be team , stands hon sur He disc ’s payche prise ored with a cks Maed Procladep end – sharpen overed com yor municat mation onalresults. 10t Corporate ed at Dolores ions skil during h Mount ls Wh the arton’sain Div tions with InitiativesJaz z Ban Life,” art Fund forision (FC con I) throdugh availab on with a Jim Kevlin/T cert on urd of industry other youSat he Free ay, le Sep cop ng exe inte Wit man’s Jour ract. 1 on y of “A Mu – enabled cs andAug . 17. h him nal together amazo is cap him orgtain n.com lticultured to clos , to develop Gen e to aniszer pull Sch his team mid a rapport . e deals. with t.

50th

By the

OWN

By JIM

KEVLIN

NBT Ba

nk Qualit

Chambe

CO

r/KEY BAUNTY’S LARG

55 & 70

Countr y Club

oneida

street,

Handcra

motors and

oneont a · ww join us w.Coun on: face book and tryClubau togrou twitter p.Co

nissan

Ba Environmnk of Coop ental Ste erstown wardship Award

m

RES

May Ha

Mary Anne Whela n, the retired Basset doctor,t center, climbed Mount Kilima jaro in n1961, perhap one of s the firs wome t to do n so.

ve Been

If you don’t subscribe, you just won’t know…

0 • $1 00 per

County

fted Gifts

Deliciou

s Food

Among 1st

Women

“There the God was a superst woman s would be disp ition that she said climbed the mouleased if a because . “I guess they ntain,” weren’t we , Whelan did!” physici , the retired an, Bas first wom in 1961 was sett amo en In rece to climb the ng the been in nt weeks, Kili peak. local peothe news as, viamanjaro has ple cou ld followTwitter, Please See WH the ELAN, A9

’S LA Chambe RGEST CI RC r/KEY BANK ULATION NE SMALL BUSIN WSPAPER ESS AW ARD

Saturday, Aug. 31 Otsego & Sund ay, Sept. County Campus 1, 10am , 197 M -5pm ain St., Co operstow n

Congra tulates

y of Lif e Award

TY CONG

• WILL

clients, end of the Publ second ic Invi and ted As his team Please Wyea orr,ME See k MO StIR, arA3ts On SS PCA Si INDEX te

person ES ALL BU T PRINT CIRC SINESS ULATIO AWAR N D

NK SM

.com

IAM SMEN fter 36 1795-97 COOPER, Coo yea the New rs in ist, land , 1799-1801, perstown, York Federal Coopers speculator, foun Guard, State National • JOHN town, Freeman ded reti at adjutant ring Feb. 2 1837-41PRENTISS, Coo ’s Journal pers top com general, the nal edit , Democrat, Free town, man or/p der, German man’s Jour ublishe Tony • DAVID r driven by’s career was 81, 188 WILBER, Milford/ Integrit a set of valu lumber, 7-90, Republi Oneonta, 187 y es: can, mad 3-75 • DAVID farming. fore self first, service e fortune , 1879bein hops, publica F. WILBER, Milf in all we , and excellence n, do. • GEORGE congressmaord/Oneonta, That’s 1895-99 n’s son Oneonta FAIRCHILD, One , hop , Rethe U.S the code of Herald onta, 190 s, banking . Air For own explain 7-19, Rep er, 1st ce, he IBM cha ed. Sunday irman ublican, “I’m not , Aug . 18, in goin intervie change an now,” heg to lenge: Hill homw at his Cemeter said Run e plated his as he contem y Republican ning for the latest cha nominat for 19th ion lDistrict Please See 19T H, A9

Dr. Whe lan

o County

►OTSE GO COUN

ONEONTA

he public briefed will be on prospe cha code that nges in the zonctive Maj. Gen multi-fa will allow mor ing . (Ret.) in the Anthon in the villmily housing e decadehome they y P. Ger Jim Kevlin/H Monday, age at 6 p.m. he public man and OMETOWN Aug. 18,ago. He built in the Today, Aug 5:45 p.m 2019 An . 19, at wife Dia ONEONTA fire hall intervie was relaxed hills aro to the gro is invited Fes the ., Thursd nuAl su w. and upbund Oneont na Are Mo tival Fans Deputy on Chestnut Stre breaking unday, Aug MMEr so a eat in Ma del Citize et, Susque yor Cin on the new . 22, at announ a Sun a hanna SPC dy Falk irEE ns day, ced The Cla Shelter 2,000 FRE A Animal By LIB The pote. rk at noo Sp BY CU SHMAN n Saturday orts Ce Aug. 24, set in mot ntial change DMOR DUE IN ON nter, Co from on Rou , E te ope 28 EON update ion by the 201s were Kev acro rstow TA in’s of of Coo n Ford, south ss Compreh the village’s 6 oodstoc perstow ensive Ma k, baby. n. The eve “Meg call ster Plan the unv nt will include . eiling of and ask me one day ed rend the artist’s ed erin By JEN OTSEG go to this if I wanted to as well gs for the shelter, NIFER O.com as a pho HILL Coopers concert,” said refreshmen to boo That’s A sou Attorneytown Village ts and ado th, ONEONTA opportu and 425 1,525 at SUN struck byth cArolinA man Ma ption nities. Y at That con rtin Tillapaugh Route 8 a car and kille was But arri Hartwick. cert? The . Woodstock are alre ving students cross. near Unadilla d on fam ome 2,00 ON ady look The driv Mot Aug. 15- festival, held ous settling er faces orOTSEG ing bey were retu 0 freshman in. a DWI ond O.com Yasgur ’s 18, 1969, on Ma rnin For inst g here Wednes oF MishAn Bethel Wodairy farm in x ►A FARM estate 21, arri their orie ance, as part of ving the day, Aug. of ntat Village -ANIMAL BAN in thropist Albany-area DlinG the this wee ods, 50 years at ion sam SUNY SUNY of e day k. the ago By JEN Oneonta this year, unanim CherryEliz abe tor Tom s, Cooperstow philanValle “Woods Hartwic Oneonta and NIFER th have to y was n invesstudents Rey k College HILL Village ously ado guilty in Lagan, 61, plea ptednol Please tock was one Boa by ds, “Fast O,”learn to think fast . federal ded the Oneont See FES of fears, whe rd. Rom be sentenc cou COOPE . a, TIVAL, own scaeo’s Please that is. ed at a rt. He will RSTOW can’t be n his hors A11 See CO theer later date eles N dies LLEGE ►BASS replaceclim . Otsego, rosE hill, Tow d. bing, he S, A6 ETT DOR wa ane Mo ll in possibl Land Truswas sold to the n of e under MITO yer theRIES of Coopers exercising has been after a t by the cou Otsego Claare the Villa rk parliam nty boa ge Spo tow at zon n’s the ver that rts rd entary Spo ing ame propose years, whi rts Center for Clark news surf ndmCen committ skir ted the boamaneuentster ’s . The 70 ch may ee syst ace rd’s lob d mat by, at an infoa explain em. iona pop clArK residen l meeting Susque ular rwhy she at half-pric doz featwo e at ►ONEO ts attende with morhanna SPCA, By LIB still goin is d.ture. en sPorts whic e than BY CU tington NTA’S ’49ER Coll By LIB 100 felin h DMOR strong at g BY CU es is E cEntEr 99. the Cali gained vast weais HunDMOR fornia Gold She is ONEONTA lth in E sent a lot town boA candida NBT BAN Rus one COOPE ► ‘OUR of that mon h, and town, thete isn’t living rD QUALITY K’S non of 36 RSTOW in the county agenarN Wilder’s TOWN,’ Thorntoey home. Board of his fall, LIFE AWA OF n clas ian sic play mem perform RD tective the forgotten de, will uring one – after 90,bers will com Fridays ed Wednesday be hamlet of his h at e will Har s clin “We By LIB hom and The membertwick be ics in Chi ’re setting seum’s Fenimo e. a local Philo Van BY CU Marine named for cag DMOR – and they Ian Aust ship’s through lakeside amp re Muwho died Rev. Ken ce film series,”up a co-foun Grassroots Bas o, in/The Free E hitheatr the in der Jeff eball plify why may best exefree said ►TH man e COOPE of James Epineth Hunter, ’s Jourend E HEA see first-ha Idel mnal SE August. RSTOW rect at BassettD NUR isD tEch nd how son got to Chamber Otsego County for N found manscopal Church, or, St. can cha baseball nge Armstro ’s ICU, Mar years the Clark of Commerce who BAN Philo By LIB are availab y Philo Van gery N. ng, has “We wer a life. Vance BY CU ce films hen Ma died. its QualitySports Center chose COO K OF le e at the fea on mo DM League ry tur ama A vie PER ORE Union Whelan Anne be presente of Life Awardfor or get you wood ed top Holly-s a spe three-film seri zon.com. ENVIRO STOWN’S Chicago Boys & Girls Clu was spe stars. ONEONTA es, each r compan aker and to d at its NM a ndin Soi take and Goo sum ENT b Afr with ree in Summer STEWA n care g mer y’s IT nee a talk ica, her Thursda se Please RDSHIP AL friends in Tanzania, ds Please -back follow See IDE It’s also of. a wild idea AWARD Please y, THE FR came up See PH LSON, nforma See CLA . environ a steward of ILO, A9 with A11 EEMAN tion Sys Why men RK, A8 the Divisio tems For res “Since t. jaro, Afrnot scale Mount ’S ns ervation HOMETO ica’s talle place to Inc. isn’t just Kiliman more than 2011, we’ve 2010 W JOURNAL & s, call Ots st? get a new the recycled WN ON electron 84,000 pounds INNERS HOMETO compute Dr. Wh ego Co 2010 ic waste,” r elan of unty Ch WN ONEO WINNEREONTA, OTSE OF said amber, Please Roxana GO NTA, OT OF (60 See ISD The Ot COUNTY 7) 432-4 SEGO , A7 sego 50

The Otseg

OTSEGO

LIFE’

ee Brathw aite, NYTel evolved a rising executi him ve as into Ver operations self in a toug izon h transitio , found “It was to sales. n – from my care the most cha er,” said llen Apex Con Brathw ging transitio stru ction, a aite, now CEO n of pany buil Har residen ding commer lem-based comof tial stru cial ctures and and multipl for the Gol Price Cho ub Compan a board mem e-unit y, which ber pper. operate Among s other thin gs, in sale s, his sala ry Dolores Wh

wooDsto cK

OTSEGO COUNTY’S DAILY NEWSPAPER

STOW N

IN

erstow n’s Ne

NGS TO DO

D

Coop

►THI

AM

►THI NG

JU

OnEOnTa FaMiLy yMCa 607 432 0010 www.oneontaymc a.org

Live Mu

sic includ ing The

Council

Rock Ba

nd Ch ildren

’s Activi

All

ties

Beer &

Wine Tas

ting

99¢

HOMETOWN ONEONTA A-7

THURSDAY, August 29, 2019

IN MEMORIAM Joy Bruen Gardner, 45, Oneonta; Cancer Fells Decorated Firefighter

Robert D. (Bob) Holt, 67; Worked For Sidney Schools, Joined Board SIDNEY – Bob Holt, retired Sidney Central School superintendent of buildings and grounds, then a school board member, stepped aboard the train in the sky for his final journey on May 28, 2019, following his unexpected passing. Robert D. Holt, 67, was born in Camden, N.J., to Robert and Ethel Holt. He graduated from Lenape High School and Rutgers University.

Before moving to Sidney, he worked for the railroad in Pennsylvania. Not long after arriving Robert Holt in Sidney, he began to work for Sidney schools, rising to building and grounds superintendent, then serving a term on the

warehouse clearance* *on all in-stock monuments

Complete On-premise Custom Carving and Lettering Facility 11 Genesee Street, Cherry Valley•607-264-8201 www.cvmemorials.com

Grandma loved her farm, her family, and playing her old guitar. Lester R. Grummons Funeral Home will take the time to find out what made your loved one special. Whether it’s finding just the right flowers, or finding a musician to play her favorite tunes on her old guitar, we’ll do what’s necessary to make her service as unique as she was.

Lester R. Grummons Funeral Home 14 Grand Street, Oneonta • 607-432-6821 www.grummonsfuneralhome.com

versar y Our 131st anni

Tillapaugh Funeral Service Our historic Family Room

Our Chapel comfortably seats over 200. George M. Tillapaugh (1888-1913) · Revo and Anna Tillapaugh (1913-1958) George G. and Marjorie Tillapaugh (1935-1988) · Martin H. Tillapaugh (1988-Present)

dignity · tradition · continuity 28 Pioneer Street, cooPerStown • 607-547-2571 Proudly serving area families since 1888

school board. Bob loved his family, friends, trains, tractors and life. He made friends easily and always was willing to help in any situation. Bob loved to be outdoors and you could often find him in the barn or fields. He was a generous, hardworking, kind man with a big heart; he enjoyed the simple things in life. His greatest joys were spending time with his wife Pam, his family, and friends and talking about trains. Bob will be greatly missed by his wife Pamela, Son, John Sinclair; daughter, Heather Sinclair (Roy Saunders), Mother, Ethel Holt, Brother, Kurt (Lee) Holt, Sister, Nancy King; nephew Justin King, Niece, Beth Anne (Edwin) Medina. He is also survived by his father-in-law, Fred Ankney; brother-in-law, Mike Ankney; Sister-inlaws, Sally (Rick) Van Ess; Theresa Ankney; and several nieces and nephews. Bob was predeceased by his father, Robert Holt, Sr.; Mother-in-law, Helen Ankney and Sister-in-law, Marlene Ankney. A celebration of life will be held 1-3 p.m. Saturday, September 7 at the Maywood Historical Train Depot in Sidney Center.

ONEONTA – Joy Renee Bruen Gardner, 45, a decorated firefighter, passed away Aug. 18, 2019, at Fox Hospital, following a long battle with cancer. Joy was born June 29, 1974, to Jana Cuda of Texas and Robert Bruen Sr. of Arkansas. She married Anthony Gardner of Oneonta on Dec. 12, 2012. Previously, she was a volunteer firefighter for the Laurens Fire Department and Pindars Corners Fire Department. Most recently she became a volunteer for the Meridale Fire Department, where she earned the Distinguished Service Award. She also was a certified emergency

medical technician. Joy worked at A.O. Fox Memorial Hospital in the billing department for several Joy Gardner years before working for the Northeast Parent and Child Society transporting children in foster care to visitation with their families. Joy is survived by her husband, Anthony Gardner; sons Eric Baldwin of Arizona, Thomas Shaw and Bradley Shaw of South Carolina; daughters Angel Shaw and

Sierra Shaw of Oneonta; uncles James Bruen of Poughkeepsie, and Rick Bruen of Massachusetts; mother-in-law Ethel Gardner of Oneonta; twin brother Robert Bruen, Jr. of Mississippi and her daughter’s grandparents Jane Myruski and Richard Shaw of Oneonta. She was predeceased by her sister Christy Bruen. Calling hours will be 9-11 a.m. Saturday, Aug. 31, at Main Street Baptist Church, Oneonta. A memorial service will follow with Pastor Kenneth Zulkowsky officiating. Arrangements have been entrusted to the Johnston Funeral Home.

Jim Porteus, 80; Oneonta Native Loved Trucks

ONEONTA – Oneonta In his son, Curt (Alisa) Porteus; native E. James “Jim” younger grandson, Cassidy (Katie) Porteus, 80, of Bozeman, days, he Porteus; great-grandkids, Mont., a truck driver and competed Zoe, Lexi, Ella and Owen truck enthusiast, passed away in Logger Porteus; step-daughter, peacefully in his sleep on Days in Debi Simpson and her Wednesday, Aug. 14, 2019. Kalispell, sons, Christopher Motichka He was born April 23, 1939, Mont. After (his daughters, Paige and in Oneonta, to James E. and retiring, Aubrey) and T.J. Motichka; James Fanny Ida (Potter) Porteus. Jim drove brother, Tom (Lois) Porteus; Porteus Jim served his country in the trucks on sister-in-law, June Porteus; Army. On January 20, 1968 the Alaska ice roads for and several nieces and Jim and Joann welcomed a couple of years. He nephews. their son, Curt. loved it if the weather was A party to celebrate Jim was a member of the colder than -40 degrees. Jim’s life is planned 1-5 Eagles and loved attending He also ran Porteus BBQ p.m. Sunday, Sept. 15 at any antique truck/tractor and Auction beginning in the Lindley Center, 1102 E. show that he could. This 1989, until later selling the Curtiss St., Bozeman, Mont. company. All are welcome. Guenther H. Dammer, year he was able to attend the 20th annual Brockway Jim was preceded in death In lieu of flowers, 84; German Immigrant Truck show in Cortland, and by his parents; brother, Earl donations may be made to Settled In New Lisbon he had the time of his life. Porteus; and former spouses, Brockway Museum & Truck As a profession, Jim Diane Barnhart Porteus and Preservation Association, NEW LISBON – Guenther was a truck driver and Dutch Porteus. 4386 US-11, Cortland, NY H. Dammer, 84, a German auctioneer. Survivors include his 13045. immigrant and painter, of New Lisbon, passed away at Bassett Saint James Hospital on Episcopal Church Aug. 22, 305 Main Street 2019. Born on Oneonta Dec. 14, Some Places of Worship in Otsego County Sundays 8 and 10 am 1934 in For info, call Thom at 607-547-6103. 607-432-1458 Cologne, Guenther Germany the Dammer First Presbyterian Milford United son of Paul Church Methodist Church St. Mary’s Catholic and Maria Dammer. After Church Church and Pioneer 113 N. Main Street immigrating from Germany in 1965, Guenther enjoyed Streets, Cooperstown Milford 31 Elm Street a 34-year career as a painter, Cooperstown Sundays 10 am Sundays 10:45 am beginning with AT&T, finally Saturdays 4:30 pm 607-547-8401 www.milford.church retiring from Bell Atlantic. Sundays 7:30, 9:30 An avid Mets fan, he was and 11:30 am happiest outdoors hunting, fishing, and the occasional (wink) drink with friends. Schuyler Lake United Guenther is survived by Methodist Church his daughters Erika Dammer 128 Church Street, and Kristen DammerSchuyler Lake Stigi, son-in-law Tom and grandson Jack; his sister and Sundays 8:45 am brother-in-law Helga and Everyone is welcome. Arthur Breen; nephews and niece Arthur Jr. and Eric Breen, James and Stephanie Christian Science Dammer, cousin Rosemarie Society of Oneonta and second cousin Eckhard. Join us for worship in our Upper Room in First United He was predeceased by his Presbyterian Church wife Victoria Jan Scott and newly renovated, bright, (Use elevated walkway) 381 Main Street, Oneonta his brothers Wilhem and Paul family-friendly church. Dammer. Sundays 10:30 am A funeral service was cssoneonta@gmail.com Tuesday Aug. 27, with Sunday Mass: 10:30 am Maureen Joy officiating at Fly Creek United the Johnston Funeral Home, Saturday Vigil: 5 pm Methodist Church in Morris. . Donations in memory of Our QR code will get you to our website. 852 County Hwy 26, Guenther may be made to Fly Creek Saint Mary’s Catholic Church your local SPCA. Sundays 10 am Corner of Walnut and Elm Streets, Oneonta Funeral arrangements are www.StMarysOneonta.org | 607.432.3920 entrusted to the Johnston 607-547-9946 Funeral Home in Morris.

Baseball Fan? Opera or Theatre Buff? Summer Vacationer?

YOUR RADIO,YOUR NEWS. 90.1FM Oneonta

97.3 FM Cooperstown 99.3 FM Oneonta

Award-winning news and programming. Listen from your radio, or any device, or online at wamc.org

A-8 THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL & HOMETOWN ONEONTA

THURSDAY, August 29, 2019

Ignoring Attorney’s Warning, Trustees Vote To Fly Pride Flag, MIA Flag, OK Policy FLAG/From A1 on Vexillology,” chaired by Benton, introduced a policy intended to give the Board guidance and clarity when taking up future proposals to fly flags. But the committee’s resolution on “the Display of Flags at Village Facilities” had the opposite effect. “The policy doesn’t provide a process by which proposals for flying flags will be made, presented, deliberated on, for the rest of them,” said Trustee Joseph Membrino. He said the board should table proposals on flying specific flags before voting

on them, so there would be “a waiting period” and time for the public to weigh in. Trustee Richard Sternberg pointed out trustees can “use the operating system of board” to discuss resolutions after a motion is made and seconded and that they could have voted to table voting on it. Mayor Ellen Tillapaugh Kuch had asked Benton to form a committee to develop a policy on flying flags after Sternberg said earlier this month he would propose flying the POW/ MIA flag in November. Trustee Cynthia Falk, a committee member,

modeled the policy on one developed by Pittsburg, Calif., which addressed the same issue: flying the Pride Flag and other banners on municipal property. A section in the policy that sparked much of the debate stipulates the “Village’s flagpoles are not intended to serve as a forum for free expression by the public” but as “an expression of the Village’s official sentiments.” “The idea that the only portal into this flag flying opportunity is to become a trustee just displays a problem with what we’re doing,” Membrino said. “If a member of the public had proposed flying the Pride Flag, it would have opened it up to public commentary,” Falk responded. “But since a

Jennifer Hill/The Freeman’s Journal & HOMETOWN ONEONTA

Village Trustee Joe Membrino objects to a remark by Trustee MacGuire Benton that anyone wanting to have input into what flag flies on the village flagpole should run for trustee.

trustee had proposed it, only the Village weighed in on it. Village Attorney Martin Tillapaugh raised another issue: The trustees can approve any flag they like; the problem will arise when

B&B

WALK TO END ALZHEIMER’S Neahwa Park, Oneonta Saturday, September 28 | 2 pm RegiSteR tOday:

518.867.4999 | aLZ.ORg/WaLK

Contracting & Landscaping

they say no to a flag, even the Confederate one. “There could be issue of censorship,” he warned. If the Village Board were sued, it would lose the case, he said. The mayor proposed voting for the POW/MIA flag proposal and delaying a vote on the flag-display policy until the Board’s September meeting despite saying earlier she felt “it was a very strong policy.” “Let’s send the policy back for more work that will give us a little more time,” she said. But the board voted against the mayor’s proposal to table the flag

Remodeling | Flooring | Painting | Decking Siding | Pavers | Retaining Walls Driveways | Plant Design | Excavation Septic Systems and much more!

2019 NATIONAL PRESENTING SPONSOR

Robert Baker, Proprietor 763 Charlotte Creek Rd. Oneonta 607-267-4342 • 607-267-1580

2019 LOCAL PRESENTING SPONSOR

Jon Hansen

Since 1983 • All work guaranteed!

Legal

Legal nOtice Notice of formation of SHELLEYFIELD REALTY, LLC. Articles of Organization were filed with the NY Secretary of State on 11/13/18. The office of the LLC is to be located in Otsego County. The Secretary of State has been designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process against it may be served. The Secretary of State shall mail a copy of any process against the LLC served upon it to: The LLC, 438 Mansfield Avenue, Levittown, NY, 11756. The purpose of the LLC is to engage in any lawful act. 6LegalOct.3 Legal nOtice Notice of Formation of MT321 LLC. Arts of Org. filed with New York Secy of State (SSNY) on 8/9/19. Office location: Otsego County. SSNY is designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail process to: 283 County Hwy 57, Cherry Valley, NY 13320. Purpose: any lawful activity. 6LegalOct.3 Legal nOtice

LEGALS

Legal

Legal

Legal

Notice of Public Hearing

persons with disabilities. If special accommodations are needed for persons with disabilities, those with hearing impairments, or those in need of translation from English, those individuals should contact Carol McGovern at mcgovernc@ otsegocounty. com, (607) 5474202 at least one week in advance of the hearing date to allow for necessary arrangements. Written comments may be submitted to Carol McGovern, 197 Main Street, Cooperstown, NY 13326 until September 3, 2019.

NATE LULL, LLC Articles of Org. filed NY Sec. of State (SSNY) 8/6/2019. Office in Otsego Co. SSNY designated Agent of LLC upon whom process may be served. SSNY shall mail copy of process to Nate Lull, LLC, PO Box 185, Gilbertsville, NY 13776 Purpose: Any Lawful purpose. 6LegalSept.26

The County of Otsego will hold a public hearing on September 4, 2019 at 9:55 a.m. at the Otsego County Board Chambers, 197 Main Street, Cooperstown, NY for the purpose of hearing public comments on the County of Otsego’s current Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) project: 868PF28-17, Otsego County Tiny Homes, $300,000. The CDBG program is administered by the New York State Office of Community Renewal (OCR), and provides resources to eligible local governments for housing, economic development, public facilities, public infrastructure, and planning activities, with the principal purpose of benefitting low/moderate income persons. The hearing will provide further information about the progress of the ongoing CDBG project. Comments related to the effectiveness of administration of the CDBG project will also be received at this time. The hearing is being conducted pursuant to Section 570.486, Subpart I of the CFR and in compliance with the requirements of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974, as amended. The Otsego County Board Chambers is accessible to

Dated: August 28, 2019 1LegalAug.29 Legal nOtice NOTICE OF FORMATION OF Bobnick Enterprises II LLC Articles of Org. filed NY Sec. of State (SSNY) 8/8/2019. Office in Otsego Co. SSNY designated Agent of LLC upon whom process may be served. SSNY shall mail copy of process to Stan Bobnick, 754 County Highway 24, Richfield Springs, NY 13439 Purpose: Any Lawful purpose. 6LegalSept.26 Legal nOtice NOTICE OF FORMATION OF

display policy, 4-3, with Tillapaugh, Jeanne Dewey, and Membrino voting “yes” and the remaining trustees – Benton, James Dean, Falk and Sternberg – voting “no.” The trustees then voted unanimously to fly the POW/MIA flag during the month of November “in perpetuity.” After the POW/MIA flag vote, the board approved the flag-display policy, 5-1, with Membrino casting the lone opposing vote. “We’ve opened up Pandora’s Box. Sometimes we have to go ahead and risk it,” said Sternberg.

Legal nOtice NOTICE OF FORMATION OF Grasslands Farm LLC. Articles of Organization filed with the New York Secretary of State (SSNY) on 4/25/2019. Official Location: Otsego County. SSNY designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail process to: 1342 County Highway 10, Laurens, NY 13796. Purpose: any lawful purpose. 6LegalSept.26

Legal

Legal

Legal

Legal

Cooperstown, NY 13326. Purpose is to engage in any and all business activities permitted under NYS laws. 6LegalSept.19

tian Hill Road, Cooperstown, NY 13326. 6LegalSept.12

Purpose: Any lawful purpose. 6LegalSept.12

Legal nOtice

NOTICE OF FORMATION OF

NOTICE OF FORMATION OF

HOME NUISANCE SERVICES, LLC

J. Gorman Fine Jewelry,LLC.

Legal nOtice

Legal nOtice Notice of formation of Limited Liability Company (LLC) Privitera Properties, LLC,

Legal nOtice

NOTICE OF FORMATION of

Articles of Organization were filed with the Secretary of State of New York (SSNY) on May, 23, 2019. Office location: Otsego County. SSNY has been designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail a copy of process to: Privitera Properties, LLC, 3949 West Oneonta, NY 13861. Purpose: Any lawful acts or activities. 6LegalSept.12

Notice of Formation of a NY Limited Liability Company

Base Camp Construction, LLC,

Legal nOtice

a Domestic Limited Liability Company (LLC) with offices located in Otsego County, for the purpose of any lawful act or activity under the Limited Liability Company Law. The Articles of Organization were filed with the Secretary of the State of New York (SSNY) on July 3, 2019. SSNY is the agent designated to receive service of process on behalf of the LLC. SSNY shall mail a copy of such service of process to Michael P. Burns, 372 Chris-

Notice of Formation of

Arts. of Org. filed with SSNY on 4/24/2019. Office Location: Otsego SSNY Desg. as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail process to 7571 State Highway 80, Cooperstown NY 13326. Purpose: Any lawful purpose. 6LegalSept.26

Name: 947 CO HWY 33 LLC

NOTICE OF FORMATION OF

Articles of Organization filing date with Secretary of State (SSNY) was 7 August 2019. Office location: Otsego County. SSNY has been designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served and SSNY shall mail copy of process to 947 Co Hwy 33,

Articles of Organization filed with the New York Secretary of State (SSNY) on 4/25/2019. Official Location: Otsego County. SSNY designated as agent of the

Monday through Friday 8 am - 4:30 pm

LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail process to: 1342 County Highway 10, Laurens, NY 13796. Purpose: any lawful purpose. 6LegalSept.26

Legal nOtice

Tafel Dairy Farm LLC.

607-432-2022

22-26 Watkins Avenue, Oneonta

Articles of Org. filed NY Sec. of State (SSNY) 8/2/2019. Office in Otsego Co. SSNY desig. agent of LLC whom process may be served. SSNY shall mail process to 130 Perkins Rd., West Edmeston, NY 13485. Purpose: Any lawful purpose. 6LegalSept.12 Legal nOtice

SafetyHealth First LLC. Arts. of Org. filed with the SSNY on 07/31/19. Office: Otsego County. SSNY designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY shall mail copy of process to the LLC, c/o Michael Gildea, 60 Brunlar Court, Apartment 47, Cooperstown, NY 13326.

Legal nOtice NOTICE OF FORMATION OF DIPASQUA AIR LLC Articles of Org. filed NY Sec. of State (SSNY) 7/18/2019. Office in Otsego Co. SSNY desig. agent of LLC whom process may be served. SSNY shall mail process to 500 Crumb Hill Rd., Winfield, NY 13491, which is also the principal business location. Purpose: Any lawful purpose. 6LegalSept.5 Legal nOtice NOTICE OF FORMATION OF LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY UNDER NEW YORK LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY LAW 1. The name of the limited liability company (“LLC”) is J/K Distributions, LLC. 2. The date of filing of the Articles of Organization with the Secretary of State is July 22, 2019. 3. The County within the State of New York in which the principal office of the LLC is located is Otsego. 4. The Secretary of State of the State of New York is hereby designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process

Legal

against it may be served. The post office address to which the Secretary of State shall mail a copy of any process against the LLC served upon him or her is: PO Box 599 Unadilla, NY 13849. 5. The character or purpose of the business of the LLC is any purpose allowed by law. 6LegalAug.29 Legal nOtice NOTICE OF FORMATION OF Sweetwater Farm & Orchards, LLC. Arts. of Org. filed with SSNY on 06/11/19. Office location: Otsego SSNY desg. as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY mail process to 286 County Highway 32a, Cherry Valley, New York, 13320. Any lawful purpose. 6LegalAug.29 Legal nOtice Notice of Formation of 604 East Main, LLC. Arts .Of Org. filed with SSNY on 06/13/19. Office location: Ostego. SSNY desg. as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSNY mail process to 286 County Highway 32a Cherry Valley, New York, 13320. Any lawful purpose.

THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL & HOMETOWN ONEONTA A-9

THURSDAY, August 29, 2019

seven, including “the kind and good people” at today’s event and other donors – make eventual success inevitable, regardless of the higher goal. The sizeable revenues from the thrift shop reassured her. And she liked Haynes’ collaboration with Sheriff Richard J. Devlin Jr. and District Attorney John Muehl on creating the Otsego County Animal Cruelty Task Force further impressed Vitullo. In an interview, Haynes said she’s also soliciting funds from the county Board of Representatives, but she said that money will probably be for operations, not the capital drive. “I wish we had more big corporations we could talk to,” she said. “We just don’t. We have to rely on good people who want to save animals.” Still, she’s enthusiastic about how regular donors have stepped up on the current drive, and new ones have joined them. “We have gotten so many new people on board as contributors,” she said. “It’s really been fabulous. And we hope they’ll support us forever.”

AllOTSEGO.homes FOR SALE

2,000-sq-ft House on 3 Acres Richfield Springs Cash $40,000 607-547-2956 d!

paintings, instruments and pencil sketches to form the bridge between his passion for art and music. And the year isn’t over yet. Following the departure of the Ritts exhibit, the Clark gallery will host “Duane Michals: The Portraitist.” “They’re these wonderful conceptual portraits of people,” he said. They’ll also have “Heroines of Abstract Expressionism,” a private, yet-unseen collection of abstract paintings by Lee Krasner, Elaine DeKooning, Perle Fine, Joan Mitchell, and others. “They’re a rarely acknowledged group,” he said. “And yet, they have these great works.” Inspired by the turnout for the Ritts exhibit, next year the Fenimore will host an exhibit of pop artist Keith Haring. “It’s going to be a knockout,” said D’Ambrosio. “We are getting one work that’s 100 inches wide. But no matter what the scale, his style has the same exuberance.” Haring’s sister Kay will be on hand to talk about his life and work, and a Haringinspired mural is being commissioned for Pioneer Park next July. “Keith Haring will attract the same crowd as the Herb Ritts,” said D’Ambrosio.

and to do it right.” Since the original goal was set, the “Shelter Us” committee concluded the shelter had to be moved from the flood plain where it is now located – and that is periodically flooded – to a higher spot. “We have outgrown our facility,” she said, and the former motorcycle repair shop, the 102-year-old organization’s home for the past 30 years, “is no longer meeting our needs.” That required purchase of the former Judith Brown CPA offices south of Cooperstown, just north of the Centers Healthcare nursing home turnoff, and the house next door, and demolition of both buildings. The new site, which will accommodate the shelter and its thrift shop – it generates $90,000 a year toward shelter operations – keeps the facility on Route 28, between Oneonta and Cooperstown and thus convenient and front of mind to thousands of daily commuters. Vitullo’s remarks suggested the components of success – she ticked off

ce

ROCK/From A1 record breaker yet, …it is up there,” said Todd Kenyon, communications director. “I believe with the great fall exhibitions coming in September, it could end up being in the top three.” Rock & Roll President Greg Harris, a CGP graduate and Baseball Hall alumnus, was on hand for the annual gala on Friday, July 12, and served as the moderator for the symposium the following day. The symposium focused on Ritts’ contributions to the modern image of the rock star and included Laurie Kratochvil, Rolling Stone’s former photography director; John Covach, director of the Institute for Popular Music at the Eastman School of Music in Rochester; and Rory Ritts, Herb Ritts’ younger brother. Even the opera crowd got in on the rock and roll. “When there was a matinee at the Glimmerglass Festival, we’d have a line out the door,” D’Ambrosio said. “And they were all here for the Herb Ritts.” In addition to the Ritts exhibit, the Fenimore also hosted Mo Willems “We Are Art,” an exhibition devoted to his “Elephant and Piggy” books, and “Perfect Harmony: The Musical Life and Art of William Sidney Mount,” featuring 25 oil

SHELTER/From A1 Dillingham has set an easy-toremember deadline to complete the fund drive: Christmas Day 2019. Because of the need to lock in the prospective shelter’s design and meet construction deadlines, “by Christmas, the first of the year, we have to have it kind of nailed down,” said Dillingham. Some key donations are still expected, he said, but he’s unsure how large they will be. The Scriven Foundation, which focuses its philanthropy within Otsego County, has also been approached. In the end, the new shelter, planned on Route 28, across the highway from Kevin’s Ford, could cost $3.5 million. If the $3 million goal is reached, the SPCA likely would qualify for a bank mortgage that it could pay off over time, Dillingham said. “Obviously, I’d rather not get a mortgage,” he said. “I’d rather see it free and clear.” In announcing the new goal at Saturday’s ceremony to applause from an enthusiastic crowd, Haynes declared, “We’re here to do it once

du

Last Chance To See Rock, Roll Photos At Fenimore

Jim Kevlin/HOMETOWN ONEONTA & The Freeman’s Journal

Resting from their labors after Saturday, Aug. 24’s groundbreaking on the new Susquehanna Animal Shelter are, from left, “Shelter Us” chair Anne Keith, two benefactresses, Anita Vitullo and Jane Forbes Clark, board chair Gaylord Dillingham, and Executive Director Stacie Haynes. Holding an artist’s rendering of the prospective facility are, front row, from left, SPCA staffers Alexis Izzo, Darla Youngs, Tania Puglia, Allison Hungerford and Kathy Chicorelli; back row, from left, Sara Haddad, Sara Lucas, Betty Steele and Susan Shepard.

re

“The Fairy Tale,” including Moniuszko’s “Concert Overture The Fairy Tale,” and Tchaikovsky’s “Piano Concerto No. 1 in Bflat major, Op. 23” and “Symphony No. 5 in E minor, Op. 64.” Among the biggest assets the search committee is seeking is a dedication to outreach. “All three of them were really impressed by the fact that we have this anonymous donor who gave money so that families with children can come to the symphony for free,” she said. “It’s so important that kids, especially in a rural area, have access to live performance, and the candidates see that they have a real opportunity to reach out to children.” In addition to the college presidents, the candidates will meet with music faculty at both colleges to discuss outreach opportunities in the community and tour the other performance venues. “We want them to get to know the region, including the Glimmerglass Festival and Foothills, so they can understand what the region is,” she said. “We see this as an opportunity to build something larger, and all of these candidates have had creative experiences with outreach, working with other organizations for fundraising and events.” Following the three performances, the Catskill Symphony Orchestra will review all of the feedback and decide who will be the orchestra’s new conductor. “We hope to have a decision made by the end of November.”

ice

CSO/From A1 SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick College presidents, and the musicians, conducting four rehearsals ahead of each performance. Then, each will conduct a concert, and, at the end, the audience will fill out an evaluation of each candidate. Additionally, season ticket holders will be invited to a special pre-show cocktail hour and talk, where they will be able to speak to each conductor. “The board will use feedback from the musicians and the audience in making our final decisions,” said Zimniewicz. On Sept. 7, Huff, the musical director of the Astoria Symphony Orchestra and the Colorado Pops Orchestra, among others, will conduct “The Firebird,” including Johann Strauss Jr.’s “Overture to Die Fledermaus,” Haydn’s “Cello Concerto in D Major, Op. 101,” Verdi’s “Overture to La Forza del Destino” and Stravinsky’s “Firebird Suite, 1919” On Saturday, Oct. 12, Watson, the director of Orchestral Studies at the University of Kansas, will conduct “The Elements,” featuring Jennifer Higdon’s “Fanfare Ritmico,” Gabriel Fauré’s “Pavane for Orchestra,” Bach’s “Ciacona for Solo Violin, BVW 1004, no. 5,” Xavier Montsalvatge’s “Desintegracion Morfologica de la Chacona de J.S. Bach” and Brahms’ “Symphony No. 4 in E minor, Op. 98” And on Saturday, Nov. 16, Żółtowski will conduct

$2M RAISED, $1M TO GO

Pr

3 Musicians Compete To Be CSO Conductor

Cooperstown Land for Sale by Owner 13.25 Acres | $89,000

Open fields, woodlot, 2 ponds, 1,800 ft. on 2 roads, solar home site. Pierstown area. Approved building parcel 607-435-0255 CooperstownProperty.com James@CooperstownProperty.com

AUCTION Real Estate

Online Bidding Only Former Restaurant & Apt. Unreserved Auction 825 Delaware County Rt 11 Davenport, NY 13820

607-865-6951 Online Auction Bidding Begins to Close, Friday, September 6th, 2019 @ 7 pm Former Restaurant w/ Apartment on a Total of 1.25+/- Acres: Large building on heavily traveled Delaware County Rte. 11 about 1 mile from the intersection of NYS Rte 23 in Pindars Corners. This is an excellent location for a commercial enterprise on a busy road, or it could be converted to housing with plenty of off-road parking. The building features a IXOO EDVHPHQW DQG VWRULHV Z DWWLF VSDFH 7KH ¿UVW ÀRRU LQFOXGHV DQ HQclosed porch, front foyer opening to the bar area, large dining room, 2 side rooms, 2 bathrooms, commercial kitchen, and walk-in cooler. The upstairs has been stripped to the studs and it appears someone started framing a 3 bedroom apartment; it’s an open slate to do with whatever you want. The building has sat empty for some time and is in need of work, but it sits in an excellent location in close proximity of Exit 16 of I-88 between Oneonta and Cooperstown, and it “Absolutely Sells to the Highest Bidder Regardless of Price!” Open House: Saturday, August 31st from 9:00 - 10:30 am. Call 607 8656951 anytime with questions. Terms: All bids must be placed via our website. Winning bidder will deposit $5,000 and sign the purchase contract within 3 business days of the online auction’s close. Balance due at closing by October 7th, 2019. A 10% Buyer 3UHPLXP ZLOO EH DGGHG WR WKH ¿QDO ELG WR HTXDO WKH ¿QDO VDOHV SULFH Download the “Bidder Packet” from our website for Maps, Property Specs, Taxes & More Auction Details!

www.lambrechtauction.com

Home of the Week Cooperstown Village

(8618) Enjoy the offerings in this impeccable 3-BR, 2-bath Colonial on a tranquil street. This appealing residence provides a pellet stove, bay windows, natural woodwork, formal DR and eat-in kitchen w/oak cabinets. Laminate flooring, laundry room, ceiling fans. Vinyl siding, large covered deck, mature foliage, large yard. Large 2 car garage. Move-in condition. A charmer! Cooperstown Schools.

Hubbell’s Exclusive—$259,000

157 Main Street, Cooperstown • 607-547-5740 www.hubbellsrealestate.com

AllOTSEGO.homes

A-10 THE FREEMAN’S JOURNAL & HOMETOWN ONEONTA

lis NE tiN W g!

THURSDAY, August 29, 2019

MLS#118224 $639,000 Owner Financing Possible! Perfection! Custom log home. Great room w/fireplace, waterfalls, stream, bridge, pond, deck. Hunting, hiking on 53 acres. Call David K. Mattice @ 607-434-1647 (cell)

MLS#120257 $469,000 Ready to Sell! Presently realizing $2,500/wk as a baseball rental w/Cooperstown Lodging. 2,731 sq ft home on 108 acres w/streams. New septic 2018. Call Donna Schulz @ 607-267-6330 (cell)

MLS#114624 $59,900 MLS#122007 $245,000 1982 double-wide w/3 BRs, 2 baths and 1½ story, 2-car Secluded Peaceful 1-floor home w/2,746 garage. New heatingSetting system, updated electrical, new sqwalls ft onand 4 acres in in Otego. enclosed ceiling 1 BR. Energy-efficient, New ceiling in master bath. porch, 2 decks. 4 BRs,@3607-267-2681 baths. Call Sharon P. Teator (cell) Call Carol Olsen @ 607-434-7436 (cell)

MLS#121223 $299,000 Goodyear Lake Home 3-BR, 2-bath remodeled home w/paddleboat, canoe, kayaks. Successful baseball rental. Large decks, great lawn. Call Stephen Colwell@ 607-435-6542 (cell)

PR NE iC W E!

4914 State Hwy 28 Cooperstown 607-547-5933

MLS#121000 $198,000 Stunning Views, Privacy Deeded Lake rights. Near Wilbur State Park. 3-BR log home on 5 acres. 3-car garage w/workshop, deck, views. Newer roof. Call Carol Olsen @ 607-434-7436 (cell)

221 Main Street, Andes 845-676-3600

lis NE tiN W g!

www.howardhanna.com

MLS#122696 $199,000 Village Victorian Extraordinaire 2,500 sq ft home plus 2-story chestnut barn, private backyard, covered porch, swimming pool w/deck. Call Kathy Fistrowicz @ 607-267-2683 (cell)

MLS#122406 $393,000 75' Lake Frontage 2 totally renovated homes. Bungalow is a studio on the water, outbuildings. Sleeps 8, great income. Call George (Rod) Sluyter @ 315-520-6512 (cell)

lis NE tiN W g!

MLS#122838 $83,000 This gem of a house offers 4 BRs, 2 baths, enclosed 3-season porch, 2-story garage. Move-in ready. House sold as is! Call Emily King @ 607-373-2500 (cell)

75 Market Street Oneonta 607-433-1020

MLS#121550 $399,000 Views of Goodyear Lake on 92+ Acres! Seclusion! Large 4-BR, 3-bath contemporary home, just 2 miles to I-88 in Oneonta. Location and privacy. Call Carol Olsen @ 607-434-7436 (cell)

lis NE tiN W g!

lis NE tiN W g!

MLS#123008 $178,000 Meticulously Maintained Oneonta Ranch 4 BRs, 2 baths, many new upgrades. Nestled on nearly a half acre of trees, berry bushes etc. Won’t last! Call David K. Mattice @ 607-434-1647 (cell)

MLS#121150 $249,000 Cooperstown Area Commercial Opportunity! Massive exposure, extensive parking. 3,000 sq ft building was constructed in 2013. Call Katherine Fistrowicz @ 607-267-2683 (cell)

MLS#122333 $319,900 Rare Cooperstown Village Home on Double Lot bordering protected woods. Just a block from Main Street. baths, view fromtocovered porch. Spacious3 4BRs, BR,2½ 2 bath house is close I-88. Large Call Kathyworkshop/garage, Fistrowicz @ 607-267-2683 backyard, small shed.(cell) Make your appointment today. Priced to go this week! Virtual Tour: www.RealEstateShows.com/708598

MLS#122114 $279,995 Canadarago Lake Home Year-round, low maintenance home w/2-stall garage. Gently sloping lot w/easy water access. Call Rodney Campbell @ 315-868-0148 (cell)

MLS#122673 $99,900 Commercial Listing Concrete block building is suitable for store, service station, etc. Includes 3-BR single-wide on 3.97 acres. 5 minutes to Oneonta. Call Sharon Teator @ 607-267-2681 (cell)

MLS#120714 $649,900 Full Lake View and 100' Water Frontage 23 acres, open living space. 3 garages, fenced dog yard. Patio and pool face sunset and lake. Call George (Rod) Sluyter @ 315-520-6512 (cell)

MLS#122028 $139,000 2007 Ranch! 2 BRs, 3 baths on 8.99 acres. A/C, stone fireplace, hot tub, patio, garage, pond. Call Sharon P. Teator @ 607-267-2681 (cell)

MLS#121011 $379,900 Circa 1850 Modernized Farmhouse w/workshop, garage. Apartment w/private entrance. 7 BRs, 4 baths, 2 kitchens. Pond, landscaped lawns, fields. Call George (Rod) Sluyter @ 315-520-6512 (cell)

Locally owned and operated Single and multi-family homes Commercial property and land

99 Main Street, Oneonta office 607.441.7312 fax 607.432.7580

This 3-BR home has lots of character w/2 BRs, full bath, kitchen and spacious LR w/ wood flooring and pellet stove all on first floor. Upstairs: another BR or art studio. Patio w/large yard, large shed, on 1/3 acre. Close to Little League field and Riverside Elementary School. Come take a look, this is a pretty cool house. MLS#123010 $119,900

www.oneontarealty.com Lizabeth Rose, Broker/Owner

Immaculate Village Home Conveniently located, just a short drive to Oneonta! Exterior features a large private yard, storage shed, and attached 2-car insulated garage w/workshop! First floor features updated kitchen w/pantry, formal DR, large LR w/pellet stove and hardwood floors, ½ bath, office, first-floor BR. Upstairs features 3 good-sized BRs, large full bath. You won’t want to miss this one. MLS#123033 $129,900

Cricket Keto, Licensed Assoc. Broker Peter D. Clark, Consultant

Affordable Country Living Beautiful 4-BR,

2-bath home on 10 private acres. Land on both sides of a maintained road surrounded by 1,600 acres of State forest. Attached greenhouse, new metal roof and generator, 2-car detached garage, 3 attached shed structures. Fenced vegetable garden, fruit and nut trees, perennial flowers. A quiet place in the country just minutes from all the attractions Cooperstown has to offer. Milford School District.

157 Main Street,Cooperstown 607-547-5740

www.hubbellsrealestate.com

Exclusively offered at $229,000

Your Private Refuge

(8647) Well kept, 3-BR, 3-bath, contemporary home on 7.33 acres. Great room, vaulted ceilings, skylights, finished walk-out basement w/kitchen. Open floor plan, loft, bamboo flooring, main-level master BR, modern kitchen w/quartz countertop. 2-car garage, patio, deck overlooking pond. Cooperstown Schools.

Hubbell’s Exclusive—$289,000

An Outstanding Lifestyle!

(8558) Enchanting 2006 home in a private country setting w/perennial gardens, pond on 2.89 acres. Walk-out basement, formal DR, 3 BRs, 2 baths, gas fireplace, French doors, family room. Skylight, oak floors, master bath. Custom kitchen, radiantfloor heat. 2-car garage. Cooperstown Schools.

Hubbell’s Exclusive—$349,000

OUNDED

IA

JU

DG

E WIL

L

Cooperstown’s Newspaper

•F

1808 BY

& The Otsego-Delaware Dispatch

R

IN

ONEONTA

O M C O PE

SELLING OR BUYING? DO IT ALL HERE! 607-547-6103

HOMETOWN

For 211 Years

John Mitchell Real Estate

216 Main Street, Cooperstown • 607-547-8551 • 607-547-1029 (fax) www.johnmitchellrealestate.com • info@johnmitchellrealestate.com

Let Us Take You Home

Debbie Watkins-Parker Mike Winslow, Broker Dave LaDuke, Broker 914-489-3523 607-435-0183 607-435-2405 Laura Coleman Madeline K. Woerner Jane McCoy Kristen Bellois 607-437-4881 607-434-3697 607-232-3442 607-282-2251

View our listings • List with us! johnmitchellrealestate.com

ProPErty dEtAiLs —9.80 acres intErior FEAturEs —4 BRs, 2 full baths —Cottage style home built 1920 —Unfinished lower level w/walk-out, Bilco doors

Don Olin

REALTY, INC

AllOTSEGO.com

—Fully applianced eat-in kitchen w/granite countertops —Hardwood and carpet flooring —LR, den/office —Pantry, laundry —First-floor bath —Baseboard hot-water oil heat —Full house generator

—House is fully updated. Renovations began in 1980. ExtErior FEAturEs —Frame construction, metal roof, wood siding —Detached 2-car garage —Open, covered porch

37 Chestnut street · Cooperstown · 607-547-5622 · 607-547-5653 (fax) parking is never a problem! For Appointment Only Call: M. Margaret Savoie, Real Estate Broker/Owner – 547-5334 Marion King, Real Estate Associate Broker – 547-5332 Eric Hill, Real Estate Associate Broker – 547-5557 Donald DuBois, Real Estate Associate Broker – 547-5105

Timothy Donahue, Real Estate Associate Broker – 293-8874 Madeline Sansevere, Real Estate Salesperson – 435-4311 Catherine Raddatz, Real Estate Salesperson – 547-8958 Michael Welch, Real Estate Salesperson – 547-8502

For reliable, honest answers to any of your real estate questions, call 607.547.5622 or visit our website www.donolinrealty.com

New Purchases and Refinances Debt Consolidation Free Pre-Qualification Fast Approvals • Low Rates

Matt Schuermann

Registered Mortgage Broker NYS Banking Dept.

20 Chestnut Street • Suite 1 • Cooperstown 607-547-5007 www.leatherstockingmortgage.com

BUY • SELL • RENT Also specializing in Property Management

Rob Lee Licensed Real Estate Salesperson 607-434-5177 roblee1943@gmail.com