Volume 26 Issue 29

August 8, 2021

GREATER HOUSTON EDITION

Vol. 26, Issue 29

who police

the police?

“Addressing Current & Historical

Realties Affecting Our Community”

Rep. Harold V. Dutton Jr.

HISD: GET OUT OF THE WAY

By: Nevaeh Richardson

Rep. Harold V. Dutton Jr. (District 142) is Chairman of the Committee on Juvenile Justice and Family Issues, and a member of the Public Education Committee where he has served longer than any member in Texas’ history.

He is an attorney, a member of Kappa Alpha Psi Fraternity and a 32nd Degree Mason. A native Houstonian and a lifelong Democrat,

Dutton’s roots began in the Kelly Courts.

Dutton attended Texas Southern University (“TSU”), where he earned a BBA in Accounting. His academic and professional achievements resulted in his designation as a “Distinguished Alumnus” by the TSU School of Business. He spoke to AfricanAmerican New&Issues about his role in

politics and education, and what is needed to better prepare our children’s future.

AANI: Where did you grow up and what high school did you attend?

Dutton: I grew up in Fifth Ward, Texas

and I went to school in northeast Houston graduating from the fantastic Phyllis Dutton Jr. cont’d page 3

“OUR VOTE AND OUR MONEY ARE THE TWO MOST POWERFUL THINGS WE HAVE. BE CAREFUL WHO YOU GIVE THEM TO.” - ROY DOUGLAS MALONSON

2 AFRAMNEWS.COM

President/Chief Editor

Tristar

Griselda Ramirez: Production

August 8, 2021

GREATER HOUSTON EDITION

EDITORIAL

REVIEW OF THE NEGATIVE PORTRAYAL OF REP. HAROLD DUTTON By: William M. Trotter II

Office: (713) 692-1892 Wednesday – Friday, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

A July 27th Houston Chronicle article painted a picture of Representative Dutton that sparked my interest.

While the Houston Independent School District (HISD) earned an overall “B” rating by the Texas Education Agency under the state accountability system for the 2018 -2019 academic year. 250 out of 271 rated campuses earneda passing grade. Fifty-seven HISD campuses earned A’s, 78 earned B’s, 86 earned C’s and 29 eaened D’s. 21 HISD schools received an “F” rating for the 2018 – 2019 school year.

This matter seemingly arose from policy disagreements on a bill that would clear the way for state education officials to replace Houston Independent School District’s school board.

Dutton was responding to the pattern of low academic performance of Wheatley students.

Dutton is a Wheatley graduate.

The opposing party was apparently State Rep. Alma Allen, whose daughter is the HISD school board president, and engaged Dutton with a bombardment of questions.

Rep. Allen’s efforts eventually killed the bill by invoking a procedural point, and emphasized that “local control” was being attacked. I thought

it best to check the statutes and administrative code because if the largest school district is exempted from the accountability requirements, how can the other 1,028 districts be held to the accountability standards and made to ensure that they m a i nt a i n a quality education system for all of its c it i z e ns .

I realize Rep. Allen’s son is on the state’s Board of Education, but what are the rules to

mandated the creation of the Texas public school accountability system to rate school districts and evaluate campuses.

Texasprovidesannual academic accountability ratings to its public school districts, charters and schools. The ratings are based on performance on state standardized tests; graduation rates; and college, career, and military readiness outcomes.

The ratings examine student

ensure Texas students are given a quality education.

The Texas Education Agency (TEA) accredits public schools in Texas at the district level for grades K-12. The Accreditation Status, Standards, and Sanctions section of the Texas Administrative Code (TAC) states how accreditation statuses will be determined and assigned to school districts.

The Texas Legislature in 1993 enacted statutes that

achievement, school progress, and whether districts and campuses are closing achievement gaps among various student groups. Other districtlevel sanctions referenced in TEC §39.102 include, but are not limited to, the appointment of a monitor, conservator, management team, or board of managers to a district. Wheatley was low performing for seven years.

After a school has been found to be

unacceptable, corrective actions should be implemented and produce a campus improvement plan. In Wheatley’s case, no corrective actions have been implemented after 7 years of continuous failure.

No campus improvement plan has been developed nor implemented.

I read a recent article published in the Houston Chronicle written by Jacob Carpenter.

HISD filed a bare-bones appeal of Wheatley ‘F’ rating. The article is shared to give those thinking of the HISD Administration’s zeal, dedication or intention to improve Wheatley High School by focusing on education quality. It reads, “If Houston ISD trustees expected the district’s administration to make an impassioned, detailed appeal to the state for an accountability reprieve at Wheatley High School — a lastditch effort to avoid severe state sanctions tied to chronically low performance at the campus — they did not get it from Interim Superintendent Grenita Lathan. Instead, Lathan submitted a twopage, bare-bones case for

Review cont’d page 4

GREATER HOUSTON EDITION Dutton Jr. cont’d Wheatley High School in 1961.

AANI: What did you do before getting into politics?

Dutton: Well, I did

a number of things after I graduated from Texas Southern University. In 1966, Conoco recruited me to come work for them. I had not been the greatest student at TSU, but fortunately the dean had come to me the year before I graduated and told me that I needed to go talk to different companies that were coming to the school to recruit. So, I did that, only because I was just trying to have fun, but it turned out that I had created such an aura with the interviewers that they all

August 8, 2021 came back the next year looking for me. Conoco was one of the companies, and they hired me.

I went to work in Houston first for a week, and then I got transferred to Ponca City, Oklahoma, where I became the first Black professional Conoco had ever hired. Ponca City is a town of about 30,000 people and only 500 of them were Black, so it was a real eye-opener for me because having grown up in Fifth Ward and attending Texas Southern University, I was accustomed to my environment being an allBlack environment.

So, I was a little taken back when I got there but I ended up enjoying it because the town itself was integrated with the

exception of housing. I decided I was going to live over where Blacks had been prohibited from living, over in the northeast/northwest part of the town.

And so, the newspapers and everybody in the city knew who I was because they did a big spread on me in the newspaper that I’d been planted there by the NAACP to cause trouble, and because they didn’t use the name of the person, I didn’t really know they were talking about me, I thought Conoco had hired somebody else. But then I later found out a couple of days after it was published in the paper that they were talking about me!

But I decided to stay. I helped create what was later called the Ponca City

AFRAMNEWS.COM 3 Bi-racial Council, and we essentially changed a lot of things in that town.

Conoco had never actually had a big refinery there and they hadn’t hired anybody Black, ever. So, one of the things I did is started to teach Black men how to pass the tests, and as a result they hired their first Black person at the refinery while I was there. So, I stayed at Conoco about 18 years, I later got transferred back to Houston, where I became, sort of the person who everybody looked at because I’ve been the first Black professional hired. I stayed in Houston for a while. Conoco then transferred me to New York and then after that I got transferred to London, England and stayed there

for a while, and then came back to Connecticut, and then back to Houston.

AANI: Why and how did you get into politics?

Dutton: Mickey Leland

and El Franco Lee and I went to breakfast one morning because Franco had been the State Representative in District 142, and immediately before him Mickey had been the State Representative in what became District 142 as well.

So, they had this idea during breakfast that Franco was going to run for County Commissioner, and they wanted me to run for State Representative, and I said, “well that sounds like a great idea but I’m not going to do it,” because

Dutton Jr. cont’d page 4

A Great Place to

Start !

Fall Semester Starts August 30 Affordable tuition • Credits that transfer to universities Workforce training • 30+ fully-online degree programs 06.28.21.02

Financial Aid Available!

LoneStar.edu/Register 832.813.6200

4 AFRAMNEWS.COM Review cont’d overturning Wheatley’s failing grade to the Texas Education Agency, infusing the request with none of the emotion that trustees displayed last month when they ordered her to file an appeal. Rather, Lathan briefly recounted the reasons trustees expressed for supporting an appeal — the lingering effects of Hurricane Harvey, some signs of progress at Wheatley, the impact of sanctions on a district — that her administration believes is doomed to fail.”

While Dutton is sharply focused on Wheatley, he is looking at a pattern of disfunction that continues today.

Our children deserve schools that practice continuous improvement toward the goal of helping students reach proficiency in reading

Dutton Jr. cont’d I thought I was going to stay at Conoco. But they convinced me after a long time to do it for one session.

I told them I would do it for one session. I came to the legislature and worked that one session, and I was quite disillusioned when I got there because I just didn’t like it. I said I was never going to do it again, and so I fired my whole staff, I went to Houston and one day I was playing dominoes with an older guy over on Lockwood and he asked me “well how did you like it?”

And so, I said, “well I didn’t like it,” and he said, “what didn’t you like about it?”

And I said, “I didn’t like the people in the legislature.”

August 8, 2021

GREATER HOUSTON EDITION

and mathematics and to graduate on time with a regular diploma, Especially in Texas, we cannot afford to be complacent about any school because the individual toll for any student “left behind” is unacceptable.

Most of the affected schools are concentrated in highpoverty communities, that does not mean that high poverty is the cause of low performance. The Wheatley High School that produced Rep. Barbara Jordan, Rep. Mickey Leland, Commissioner El Franco Lee, doctors, lawyers, educators, musicians, scientists and other professionals stand for the proposition that the amount of money in your pockets has nothing to do with the quality of you mind.

Wheatley is a critical site for an education intervention and for improving student achievement.

At the

campus-level, organization and administration (e.g., strong principal, teachers working together) and, in some cases, external “best practice” models or methods are needed to help turn Wheatley around, whether there exists clusters of persistently lowachieving students or an entire student body that is low-achieving, considering the practice of busing better students out of Wheatley’s enrollment zone.

It seems that Representative Dutton is sending a message to School leaders in our community. He seems to be insisting that principals should set up-to-date and challenging expectations for all our students, and relentlessly focus on improving teacher content knowledge, upgrading the content of the school curriculum, and improve classroom learning and

the interaction between teachers and students. So if he is accused of anything at all, He is guilty of insisting that Wheatley students are given a quality and competitive education.

After high school students transform into young adults and hopefully productive citizens with sustainable incomes. Poorly prepared students tend to become poorly prepared college students and adversely impact the workforce and the future tax base, I happen to have heard Rep Dutton emphasize two quotes by Dr, Benjamin Mays, “Not failure, but low aim is sin” and “Whatever you do, strive to do it so well that no man living and no man dead and no man yet to be born could do it any better” We would have different

outcomes in our schools, if these were the ,mantra of School Leaders..

He said, “well let me ask you this, are you ever going to be in a position where you decide who the people are who come?” I said no.

And he said, “you need to learn to work with whoever shows up.” And I thought about that and it stayed on my mind for a while, until I decided “you know what, he’s right. I’m going to go back because I really want to help my community.”

“Harold, why are you on the Public Education Committee?” I wanted to be on Public Education Committee because I had already seen the sort of decline in the education outcomes of students at Wheatley High School.

Back in the year 2000, I sponsored what was called the “Phyllis Wheatley Purple and White Gala,” which honored all of the Miss Wheatleys at Wheatley High School, starting with the first one. We had about 30 of them who all came, it was a beautiful affair. One of the things I noticed more than anything was they all had to give me their bios and so I had them plastered on the wall with their

picture. One of the things I noticed was the earlier Miss Wheatleys were all quite accomplished, but when we got through the late ‘80s, there was a huge decline in the education accomplishments of the others. I was shocked at that and that’s one of the reasons I got on the education committee. I realized that there was a huge decline occurring in education, not just in Wheatley but in all of northeast Houston.

of Public Ed. at that time Jimmie Don Aycock. He and I had been talking and I had been showing him numbers about what was happening in Houston.

At that time, I had been arguing about Kashmere High School because it had been low-performing and been failing for more than five consecutive school years. In almost every case, they were getting an “F” because the students were not passing the standardized tests, and most often they weren’t passing the tests because they were not able to pass the math portion. So, I met with the superintendent at

AANI: How did you become involved in public education?

Dutton: That kind of

brings me to where I am now because during the legislature, I asked to be on the public education committee. Some of my friends at that time said

AANI: You sponsored an amendment to a bill that allowed the state to take over a school district. Why? Dutton: Let me tell you

about what I did back in 2015. In 2015, the chair

Dutton Jr. cont’d page 5

GREATER HOUSTON EDITION Dutton Jr. cont’d that time and I asked him did he know why Kashmere was failing?

He said he didn’t know.

I couldn’t believe that, and so I went up to the school board members, some of whom were not located specifically in my area, and I asked them why was that the case, why couldn’t they help get a certain type of math teacher.

What I was told at the time by them was that I needed to talk to my school board members, that was their problem. I said no, I don’t think so, you may have gotten elected on the school board from a particular area, but you represent all of HISD. What I left there with was a feeling that they just didn’t have any skin in the game when it came to trying to fix the schools in northeast Houston.

I said to Aycock, we need to do something about that. He said, “well Harold, what could we do?” The next morning when I met with him, I told him, “Why don’t we put an amendment in the bill that says if a school district lets any campus within a school district fail for five consecutive years, the state can take over the whole district.”

Now I never thought that would happen because I thought

surely the district would fix the schools that were failing for that long. The unfortunate thing is, we got a number of campuses across the state after we passed House Bill 1842 which that amendment was in, that wanted to eliminate failing campuses within their school district.

However, HISD didn’t do that, we finally got Kashmere out of the struggle so that it was no longer failing, but Wheatley all of a sudden stood out like a sore thumb, because to date Wheatley has been failing for more than almost nine consecutive years.

During last year when the TEA decided that they would come in and take over the school district on the basis of House Bill 1842, HISD got their lawyers to spend an enormous amount of money to file an injunction against the state, prohibiting the state from taking over HISD. Well, the lower court ruled in HISD’s favor and kept the TEA from taking over the school district.

That got appealed to the Court of Appeals and the injunctive relief was again provided to HISD alleging that basically the Commissioner of Education didn’t have the authority to do just about anything.

As a result, our state accountability system was now

August 8, 2021 blown up because the Commissioner of Education couldn’t do what the legislature wanted them to do in terms of just providing an accountability system for all of the schools in Texas.

One of the things I did during the last session, was I filed a bill that would have changed all that, such that it would have allowed HISD to be taken over. That bill got killed based on a point of order Representative Allen whose daughter is the president of the Houston School Board… when we tried to revive the bill, we did so but we left intact the lawsuit that was being appealed to the State Supreme Court. So now what we’re going to do is, we’re going to live by the opinion of what the State Supreme Court is, and I’m hoping the State Supreme Court sides with the state as far as House Bill 1842 and all the other bills that are concerned because we have to have an accountability system.

If they do otherwise, that will scrap our accountability system, and then the legislature will have to come back to try to create another accountability system.

One of the other bills that I filed that finally passed was House Bill

Dutton Jr. cont’d page 6

AFRAMNEWS.COM 5

WE’RE HIRING Bus Operators and Mechanics

EMPLOYEE INCENTIVES Bus Operators up to $4,000* Bus Mechanics up to $8,000*

APPLY NOW Scan here or visit WorkforMETRO.org Call 713-739-4953 for additional information.

METRO IS AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER.

*New hires only, incentive paid after six months.

6 AFRAMNEWS.COM Dutton Jr. cont’d 4545. One of the things the federal government did this time was, they gave Texas about $17 billion that we were required to give to school districts almost without any guidepost attached to it. What I’ve asked them to do in the bill was for each school district to tell me how they were going to use the money, and the money was going to be allocated based on the Title I students that a school has. I was afraid that money would be spent, not on improving student outcomes, particularly those students at the bottom. So, what I did in House Bill 4545 was decided that we create a fund of about $250 million that would go to school districts to provide tutoring to those students who had failed the 2019 STAAR test.

Those were the students we identified that were at the bottom pre-pandemic. Of course, after the pandemic, we recognized that many of those students had done nothing but set a new level for the bottom, so we needed to do what we could for them. The way that would work is we would provide $1000 for each student that a school district got to improve beyond their STAAR tests in 2019. There was a whole outcry, particularly led by all of the people in the legislature who were representing HISD who said they don’t like student outcome-based funding.

What struck me as strange is that HISD was looking for a new school superintendent and when

August 8, 2021 they got one, one of the things they negotiated in that particular contract with the new school superintendent was outcome-based funding for students that the superintendent can get up to $150,000 more in income if he or she improved student outcomes. Well, I thought that was totally contradictory to what they were espousing in House Bill 4545 because they basically alleged that they didn’t like it and yet they turned around and put in a contract student outcomebased funding only for the superintendent.

The difficulty has been trying to deal with some of the hypocrisy in HISD. One of the things we did, not this session but last session, we created House Bill 3.

House Bill 3 provided all kinds of incentives for school districts to pay teachers up to $32,000 more a year. House Bill 3 was going into some of the schools that were consistently lowperforming and rated “F.” For example, Dallas ISD used House Bill 3 and, as I understand it, they no longer have campuses that are failing.

What did HISD do? They did absolutely nothing.

They did not use House Bill 3 to try to improve the schools in northeast Houston.

What they simply did is promote what they call their “Choice Program,” where students, supposedly, can go to any campus, which in HISD’s case causes all of the students who want a good education in northeast Houston to

have to get on a bus to go across town to another school. To me, that’s not a choice, that’s a sentence for all those students who can’t get out of that area to go across town.

We have a self-interest in trying to improve the schools in Houston, and I have dedicated my session to making sure that we begin to get those kinds of improvements because I don’t think that from where I sit, I have seen that the school board is going to play fair with students and families in northeast Houston. When I look around at what some young students are doing and creating all kinds of problems for themselves and their futures, and engaging in criminal activity, many times that’s happening because these kids don’t have much in the way of options because we have not allowed them to get the proper education so they can begin to make the right choices and create a future for themselves.

We’re not only doing a disservice to them, we’re also doing a disservice to the children that they have, and their children. We’re ruining generations of children simply because we don’t educate, and I know for a fact, there is nothing wrong with the children while people try to suggest that they’re from a poor area, well the area was even more poor when I came along, and yet we learned.

We learned because we had committed teachers, sometimes we didn’t have the right resources or the resources that other kids had, many of the books

GREATER HOUSTON EDITION we had were second-hand books that came to us from across town.

HISD has not faced up to its responsibility for students in northeast Houston, and to me that’s almost criminal because when these kids go astray and do what they’re doing sometimes we shake our heads and wonder ‘gosh how could a kid do that?’

Well, a kid could do that because we haven’t helped them get other options in their life, because we simply didn’t provide an education for them, and that’s a problem that we need to all join together to try to solve. If the HISD school board won’t address it, then I’m all for having somebody else take a look at it.

AANI: It sounds to me like HISD is actively againsttheimprovement of schools on the Northeast side but not only those schools… as a graduate of Jack Yates High School, seeing the decline you speak about among Yates alumni from the 50s-60s era are way more educated and successful than the ones now… not only seeing that at Yates but at Worthing and other historic Black high schools. We know it’s a lack of resources, but why is it that HISD isn’t fighting for those resources?

Dutton: I think you probably ought to ask them.

When you go back and look at the history of HISD, if you go back and look at the desegregation lawsuits that were happening way back in the ‘60s, you see when HISD agreed to settle these lawsuits… one of the things they said in these lawsuits is that they were going to create programs to stop white flight away from the district. Think about that, they created programs to stop white flight away from the district. That means that the primary focus is not going to be on the children that I represent because their focus is going to be on trying to do something that keeps kids from leaving the district. Well who is leaving the district? Well, white kids.

The truth of the matter is, HISD is becoming more a district that’s dominated by students of color. I will tell you this, there are people who say, ‘well, the state ought to step up and do more in funding public education.’ I agree with them, I tell people Dutton Jr. cont’d page 7

GREATER HOUSTON EDITION

A/C & HEATING

August 8, 2021

AFRAMNEWS.COM 7

MARKETPLACE CHURCH

CHURCH

JAMAICAN FOOD

SOUL FOOD

MRS. EʼS KITCHEN

THE ISLANDS HAS LANDED IN ACRES HOME

ARTS, GIFTS

2213 S. VICTORY DR. HOUSTON, TEXAS 77088

832.328.5220

OPEN Wed., Thurs., Fri. 10am – 4pm

PLEASE WEAR MASKS

LANDSCAPING Landscaping by the Jelks

FLOWERS

713.692.1195

6130 Wheatley St. Houston, Texas 77091

CHEMICAL

OPEN

Wed., Thurs., Fri. 10am – 4pm

713.692.1100

PLEASE WEAR MASKS 6130 Wheatley St. Houston, Texas 77091

www.shirleyannflowershop.com

INSURANCE

A Ministry Committed to the Worth of the WORD and Energetic Evangelism

www.williewrightjr.com

Terrence Jelks

6030 Pebble Ln., Houston, TX 77087

Cell:832.713.0102

jamesbond6030pebble@gmail.com

MAILING

E-Z MAIL MANAGEMENT WE OFFER QUALITY SERVICE AT A COMPETITIVE PRICE

Services: Direct Mail Consulting, 1st Class Mail, Standard/NonProfit Mail, Mail Merge, Folding/ Tabbing/Inserting, Mailing Lists, Postcards, Political Mail, Bulk Mailing, Courier Services

713-780-9804 ezmailhou@aol.com

INSURANCE

PROFESSIONAL - CHRIS CASHIN -

713.568.9467 CIGHOUSTON.COM

“Christ-centered, Bible-based, and Prayer-minded”

2810 Rosedale St. Houston, TX 77004

Services: Mowing, Landscape Renovation, Edging, General Lawn Clean Up, Shrub Trimming and Removal, Brush Clearing, Lawn Fertilization, Flower Bed Installations

CALL US TODAY

CHURCH Willie Wright Jr. Ministries, Inc.

COMMERCIAL AND RESIDENTIAL

AFRAMNEWS.COM African-American News&Issues

SHOE REPAIR

MON - SAT 11AM-6PM

soul food only sold on saturday 2201 W. LITTLE YORK RD. HOUSTON, TX 77091

(LOCATED INSIDE: FLOYDʼS PREMIER SERVICE)

832.277.0563

Dutton Jr. cont’d I agree with them in that respect, but I don’t think that explains the differences between Wheatley and Lamar.

That doesn’t explain the difference between Yates and Lamar.

Even in this financial climate, Lamar seems to get all the resources it needs. My question is, why can’t these other schools, the Wheatleys, the Kashmeres, the Yates, the Washingtons, the Worthings, and the like get their fair share of resources? I don’t mean just money either, I mean teachers.

When you look at the schools that I just named, and you look at the principals and how often the leadership is changed in those schools, versus the leadership in the schools on the other side of town, one of the things you see quite readily is that we have a higher turnover in Black schools, than they do in schools on the other side of town. To me, that’s a problem,

and I think that has always been a problem.

I just think that HISD has lost its way. They’re not doing the kinds of things that you ought to do to improve the schools in northeast Houston.

I think there’s this idea that something is wrong with the students in Northeast Houston, not something is wrong in what we’re giving the students or what we’re not giving the students in Northeast Houston.

HISD ought to step up and provide us the kind of education that we deserve and demand or get the hell out of the way and let somebody else do it!

AANI: Tell the people, what’s next for Rep. Dutton?

Dutton: What’s

next? Well, I’m going to stay on this until we get it right. What’s next for me is I’m going to keep fighting to make sure that we improve the environment for students learning in Northeast Houston and for all the students who’ve been left out. I’m going to keep fighting to make sure that HISD pays attention to them and brings them every resource we can to make sure they learn and that they can have a future that is as bright as anybody’s.

- AANI

8 AFRAMNEWS.COM

August 8, 2021

GREATER HOUSTON EDITION

Warehouse Team

NOW HIRING FULL TIME

ORDER SELECTORS

18

$

per hour

($37,440 yr)

Plus Additional

BECOME

AN H-E-B PARTNER TODAY AND EARN UP TO

$500

in awards

30 Days = $100 60 Days = $150 90 Days = $250

Competitive Benefits

Partner Stock Plan Parental Leave Paid Time Off & Sick Pay Company Paid Holidays (7 days) Pay Review 2 times a year 401K plan with 4% company match H-E-B product discount program ($400 average yearly savings) Health, Vision & Dental benefits are eligible on Day 1 24/7 access to Magenta Health Primary Care Clinics

Amazing Opportunity Scholarship Program Career and Leadership Development

Premiums

Overnight + $.0.50 Hour Weekend + $.0.50 Hour Freezer + $1.00 Hour

Productivity Incentives & Overtime!

No previous experience required.

We train onsite.

TO A P P LY TEXT “SELECTOR” TO 81931 OR SCAN

VOTED 2021 BEST PLACES TO WORK ©2021 H-E-B, 21-7766