Skip to main content

Legal Process Outsourcing in India

Page 1

Aeren LPO Patent Research Services

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Patent Research Services  Patentability Search  Validity/Invalidity  Freedom to Operate  State of Art  Evidence of Use  Patent Drafting & Illustration  IP Commercialization

Confidential

© Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Patentability Search A patentability search is performed to know whether an invention is new and non-obvious, or not. It identifies any patent or non-patent literature existing prior to the invention at hand. The prior art search results assist the patent attorney or patent agent in writing a patent application and to draw up the broadest possible set of claims. It helps in preempting the examiner's prior art rejections thus speeding up the patent prosecution by allowing claims to be tailored to avoid the prior art before the Examiner's own search. The cost of preparing, filing, and prosecuting a patent application is substantial and is much greater than the cost of a patentability search. One study suggests that conducting a patentability search improves the chances of receiving a patent. The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) recommends that a patentability search be conducted: "A search of all previous public disclosures (prior art) including, but not limited to, previously patented inventions in the U.S. should be conducted to determine if your invention has been publicly disclosed and thus is not patentable. While a search of the prior art before the filing of an application is not required, it is advisable to do so." USPTO on conducting a prior art search. The European Patent Office (EPO) agrees that an inventor should obtain a prior art search: "Where do inventors go wrong? When it comes to prior art searching, many inventors simply scratch the surface. By far the most common mistake they make is to assume that their idea is novel, when a simple patent search would tell them that it was not. They then make things worse by spending often large sums of money on an idea that is extremely unlikely to be commercially successful." EPO on conducting a prior art search.

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Patentability Search

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Patentability Search

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Validity/Invalidity A Patent Validity Search or Patent Invalidity Search involves exhaustive patent and non-patent search. In this search patent and non-patent literature is located that predate a critical date that corresponds to a subject patent. The critical date is the date of invention. In case of continuation in part and divisional patents, the critical date is taken as the priority date. These dates are governed by 35 U.S.C. § 102(a), (b), or (e). It also involves analysis of image file wrapper to see the reason of allowance of a particular subject patent. According to the study “Patent Validity Litigation in the Courts”, 2001 (by Janis) of Federal Circuit and District Court cases , 54% of the court decisions patent claims sustained a validity challenge. Thus, 46% of the decisions found patent invalidity. Patent examiners have limited time and resources to conduct their prior art searches. Thus there is a high probability to gather court admissible evidences by conducting a detailed validity or invalidity search. These court admissible evidences can be used to question the patent’s claims and to prove that the patent should not have been granted.

Confidential

© Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Validity/Invalidity

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Validity/Invalidity

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Freedom to Operate According to a survey carried out by Derwent in Europe, over 70% of the companies involved in the survey admitted that they had spent money on R&D and patent developments and later found that the product or technology in development was already protected by a competitor’s patent. Freedom to Operate search is performed to identify the patents and applications which may cover a proposed or existing product or method. This search is jurisdiction sensitive and involved the current legal status of the identified patents. It ensures that the proposed product/method does not infringe any in-force patents. In case it does, appropriate business actions can be taken, before launching the respective product in a particular jurisdiction. It also opens doors for some design-around before the launch of the product to avoid any future litigations. Similarly licensing options can be explored for providing a safe platform for the launch of the product. It helps in formulating the risk assessment related to infringement of granted patents and potential infringement of pending patent applications.

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Freedom to Operate

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Freedom to Operate

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


State of Art This search involves searching of both patent and non-patent literature to identify art related to a specific technology. This art helps in identifying the up-to-date information level of development in a particular technology area. This art can be analyzed to guide the R&D team in their research operations. The R&D team can build upon the already known art and formulate its investment and acquisition strategy. It also focuses on the recent developments and their trends developing in a specific field of technology.

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


State of Art

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


State of Art

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Evidence of Use In this search non-patent literature is searched to identify some products which are infringing upon a subject patent. All the sub clauses of the claims are mapped to the product specifications. Complete reverse engineering of the product can be performed to establish the court admissible document to prove that that the patent is being infringed upon. This assists in evaluating and negotiating while licensing-in and licensing-out. It supports in patent valuation, competitive intelligence investigations. It acts as a door opener to monetize ones patent portfolio.

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Evidence of Use

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Evidence of Use

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Patent Drafting & Illustration Services In this the domain expert gathers the invention details from the inventor using the standardized invention disclosure form template. Then, the domain expert drafts the patent application in compliance with the PTO guidelines. The informal drawings/photographs are converted into accurate and professional AutoCAD drawings which are in compliance with the patent office guidelines. The patent application is then filed with the PTO. Renewals of the patent is managed during its lifecycle. All communications (office actions) with the patent office are managed from the filing till the expiry of the patent.

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Patent Drafting & Illustration Services

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Patent Drafting & Illustration Services

Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


IP Commercialization • Licensing Studies • Identifying and analysing prior technology transfer deals in the subject technology domain. • Royalty rates, upfront fee, and deal structure advisory. • Term sheet analysis and drafting. • Technology transfer support • Invention/technology analysis • Identifying potential buyers/licensees • IP/Technology marketing pack development • Connecting with the regional technology brokers • Front-end IP commercialization in India. • Patent/technology valuation • Patent portfolio scoring • Propriety in-house valuation model * Our team has successfull track record of facilitating multi million tech transfer deals

Confidential

© Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


THANK YOU

For more details please visit our website www.aerenlpo.com Confidential

Š Aeren LPO. 2013. All Rights Reserved - Privileged and


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook