Skip to main content

The College Hill Independent Vol. 40 Issue 1

Page 3

A Brown/RISD Weekly February 07, 2020 Volume 40, Issue 01

03 FLIGHTS OF FANCY Zach Ngin

05 CRISIS IN DISCOURSE Emily Rust

11 TAKING 287G AGREEMENTS TO COURT Sara Van Horn

A personal meditation on Fred Moten and Stefano Harney’s concept of the undercommons

Suppression, hysteria, sinophobia: coronavirus and the perpetuation of fear through Western media and the Chinese government

An interview with activist Sherrie Andre, who will go on trial for their involvement in avv #ShutDownICE nonviolent direct action


Cover

FROM THE EDITORS

News

We’re gonna be honest. There’s a lot of stuff going on this week. 1917 has 10 Oscar nominations. You’re holding issue one of the Indy in your trusting hands. It’s early in the morning and we can’t think of anything else.

My Own Summer Mia Scarpa Mixed Media

02

17

Week in Keeping Busy Muram Ibrahim, Bilal Memon, Harry Levine & Nick Roblee-Strauss Two Rallies Anchita Dasgupta & Peder Schaefer

Features

We also have a few confessions to make. We’re new to this. We’re a little too patriotic, a little too militant. We’re guilty on two counts of murder in the nth degree. We’re guilty of delivering you the news exactly as promised—no ifs, apps, or Buttigieg. We’re guilty of five of the seven deadly sins. We’re guilty of green eggs and ham. It’s early in the morning, but the crowds are cheering in unprecedented numbers, our right hand is on The Undercommons, our left hand raised.

03

Flights of Fancy Zach Ngin

09

Nước is Water Agnes Cẩm Ngọc Trần

We swear an oath to you, Indy.

Metro 08

13

Molehills Out of Mountains Ricardo Gomez & Deb Marini Taking 287g Agreements to Court Sara Van Horn

Ephemera 07

Big Girls Cry Big Clown Tears Liana Chaplain & Sindura Sriram

Science+Tech 05

11

Crisis in Discourse Emily Rust

Literary

MISSION STATEMENT

Rabbits Zachary Baytosh

The College Hill Independent is a Providence-based publication written, illustrated, designed, and edited by students from Brown and RISD. We are committed to publishing politically engaged and accessible work. While the Indy is financed by Brown University, we hold ourselves accountable to our readers across the Providence community. The Indy rejects content that explicitly or implicitly perpetuates racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, xenophobia, ableism and/or classism.

Arts 15

18

This Land, This Land, This Land Isabel Guarnieri

X

Though this list is not exhaustive, the Indy strives to address these systems of oppression by centering the voices, opinions, and efforts of marginalized people in Providence and beyond.

Home Jacob Alabab-Moser & Ethan Murakami

The Indy is constantly evolving: we are always working to make our staff and content more inclusive. Though our editing process provides an internal structure for accountability, we always welcome letters to the editor.

WEEK IN REVIEW Emily Rust NEWS Peder Schaefer, Anchita Dasgupta, Tristan Harris METRO Ricardo Gomez, Deb Marini, Miles Guggenheim ARTS Zachary Barnes, Isabelle Rea, Eve O’Shea FEATURES Mia Pattillo, Audrey Buhain, Nick Roblee-Strauss

07 FEBRUARY 2020

SCIENCE + TECH Bilal Memon, Izzi Olive, Andy Rickert LITERARY Catherine Habgood, Star Su EPHEMERA Sindura Sriram, Liana Chaplain X Jacob Alabab-Moser, Ethan Murakami LIST Cate Turner, Ella Comberg, XingXing Shou

VOL 40 ISSUE 01

STAFF WRITERS Anabelle Johnston, Emma Kofman, Eduardo Gutiérrez Peña, Jennifer Katz, Jorge Palacios, Kion You, Zach Ngin, Uwa Ede-Osifo, Kaela Hines, Mara Cavallaro, Leela Berman, Muram Ibrahim, Evan Lincoln, Evie Hidysmith, Alana Baer, Nell Salzman COPY EDITORS Christine Huynh, Sarah Goldman, Muskaan Garg, Thomas Patti, Josephine Bleakley, Ella Spungen, Marina Hunt, Seth Israel

DESIGN EDITORS Ella Rosenblatt, Daniel Navratil DESIGNERS Amos Jackson, Kathryn Li, Anna Brinkhuis, Katherine Sang ILLUSTRATORS Natasha Brennan, Sandra Moore, Eliza Macneal, Sophia Meng, Bella Carlos, Veronica Tucker, Sylvia Atwood, Leslie Benavides Floria, Ryn Kang, Pia Mileaf-Patel ART DIRECTOR Claire Schlaikjer

BUSINESS Caín Yepez, Abby Yuan SOCIAL MEDIA Muskaan Garg SENIOR EDITORS Cate Turner, Tara Sharma, Ben Bienstock, Wen Zhuang, Ella Comberg, Tiara Sharma, Chris Packs, Olivia Kan-Sperling

MVP Emily Rust +++ The College Hill Independent is printed by TCI Press in Seekonk, Massachusetts.

MANAGING EDITORS Matt Ishimaru, Sara Van Horn, Alex Westfall

@THEINDY_TWEETS

WWW.THEINDY.ORG


MEGAN THEE STALLION + G-EAZY = <3 Celebrity gossip rarely startles us anymore. Impeachment proceedings and foreign assassinations have occupied our attention and chipped away at our sense of propriety until only the basest crimes elicit a response. That said, occasionally the headlines of tabloid news so trouble our preconceptions and shake the foundations of our reality that there is nothing more to do than spend the next eight hours scrolling online and arguing with strangers on the internet. Our jaws dropped as we perused Twitter while brushing our teeth on Monday morning. Shocked, we accidentally swallowed our toothpaste when coming across what would be the first of countless tweets expressing confusion after videos circulated of rappers Megan Thee Stallion (Megan Pete) and G-Eazy (Gerald Gillum) kissing and cuddling. Megan Thee Stallion and G-Eazy emerge from starkly different spheres of hip-hop. Megan, as she has discussed in the past, comes from a line of Black women rappers who powerfully carved their own space in the genre. Lil Kim, Queen Latifah, and Nicki Minaj paved the way for artists like Megan Thee Stallion and Rico Nasty to be bashful, fun, and sexually liberated. The crux of Megan’s persona and her Hot Girl movement is about doing what one wants, when one wants to, and how one wants to—regardless of other people's opinions, especially those of men. In an interview with the Root, Megan explained the Hot Girl movement, “It’s just basically about women—and men—just being unapologetically them, just having a good-ass time, hyping

up your friends, doing you, not giving a damn about what nobody got to say about it.” For many, Megan is the best of rap’s past and future: brash, upfront lyrics combined with a danceable beat through the voice of a modern woman. She likes anime! She’s in college! She is the shining star of rap music. ...And G-Eazy is decidedly not. A white pop-rapper from the Bay Area, he emerged from good time, white college rap—Blackbear and Hoodie Allen being the biggest exports of that scene. His music quickly shifted to a more lucrative lane, emphasizing moodiness and sex appeal. With his slicked back hair, leather jacket, and general unkemptness, G-Eazy exudes a Starbucks-branded biker appeal that proved popular, especially with young, white women. His most notable songs include “Tumblr Girls,” an ode to the girls with “skinny waists and drug habits.” G-Eazy’s manufactured aesthetic bled into his personal life. His previous famous partners, including Lana Del Rey and Halsey (who's relationship with G-Eazy ended in public acrimony), conformed to his style. Seeing G-Eazy kiss Megan on his Instagram story, people on twitter loudly shouted their criticism and anger at Megan for dating a white man. Twitter user @ilovesmokingmid said “megan thee stallion if you would like to disappoint your fanbase again pleaseee text me.” When relying on stereotypes to fill in the gaps of celebrities’ personalities, anything they do out of the archetype surprises us. Reducing celebrities to their archetypes is particularly harmful to Black

women, who are often pigeonholed and punished when they move away from their predesignated roles. Black women rappers, who redefine femininity through empowering songs and powerful attitudes, are shamed and demeaned from the very start of their careers. Underlying many of these tweets is an entitlement rooted in misogyny and racism to police Black women. Ironically, Megan has insisted that she is not in a relationship with G-Eazy. “Just” celebrity gossip, Megan Thee Stallion became the #1 Twitter trending topic in the world: as soon as a Black woman acts outside of the strict boundaries placed on her, chaos ensues. Celebrities project a curated two-dimensional persona. However, fans often mistake the two-dimensional for the three-dimensional. So, the public relationship between G-Eazy and Megan—the image of them hanging out and kissing—questions our entitlement to make judgements about them. We don’t know them! And that’s okay. -MI, HL, & BM

WEEK IN KEEPING BUSY MOOS PAST MIDNIGHT Despite the optimism of hopeful Democrats to put Trump out to pasture, the impeachment process finished this Wednesday to no avail. While the media churned out updates around the clock to satisfy the spectators at home, the nodding-off senators stayed up each night until two in the morning—well past any Boomer’s bedtime. Among the snoring crowd, however, savvy senators fought the urge to drift into slumber with some exciting new focus tactics. Although the impeachment will be voted almost entirely along party lines, when it comes to passing the time, the distinction between drooping Dems and collapsing Conservatives is insignificant. Weary and without witness, these legislators lighten this lackluster litigation with the latest leisures of the youth. You guessed it! Those whirling doodahs of yesteryear are back: Fidget spinners have entered Congress. On January 23, Senator Richard Burr (R-NC) passed out spinners and stress balls to keep his friends’ congressional claws in motion. The ‘publican posse zoomed their triangular trophies with all the enthusiasm of the tweens who first turned these teacher-taunting toys. Still, not all statesmen join Burr in his Gen-Z joys. “Sunflower seeds keep you alert and allow me to listen,” says Senator Tim Scott (R-SC). Having described in a Fox op-ed this impeachment as ‘political theater,’ it is good to know that Scott opted for a nutritious alternative to popcorn. Burr challenges this pragmatism by displaying his exposed ankles; this Carolinian elephant needs no socks. Hands and jaws in motion— for hours on end—leave these senators thirsty, but a

THE COLLEGE HILL INDEPENDENT

dry impeachment is no drought for this dehydrated impeachment team. For most senators, water alone is enough to satisfy a parched throat. And while U.S. Senator Tom Udall (D-NM) and U.S. Representative Alan Lowenthal (D-CA) announced plans to introduce anti-single use plastic bottle legislation this fall, their respective Hydro Flasks were noted absent. Ukranian diplomat George Kent, alone in remembering his 64 oz. Nalgene, captivated the hearts and minds of plastic purgers everywhere. For the rest of the senators, single-use plastic reigned supreme. While water is suitable libation for most of our elected officials, some need a beverage with more body to keep their impeachment faces glowing. While Representatives may ask ‘Got Milk?’ to no avail, calcium-deficient Senators, need not worry. Milk has been available to lactase-producing senators since 1966, when Senator Everett Dirksen requested something more nourishing than water. Tom Cotton of Arkansas, a noted drinker of milk, enjoys his candies, cookies, and cakes with a creamy glass of moojuice. Although his love for the drink is purportedly routine, an anonymous Senate page reassured us that he nevers consumes the fatty beverage without a sweet solid its side. Even Elizabeth Warren was spotted entering the impeachment hearings with a glass firmly in her grasp, Perhaps the presidential hopeful nods to the milk-manic voters in Wisconsin and Pennsylvania, who could possibly swing blue for a Dem who’s pro-moo. As expected, Ted Cruz’s milk

habits are less reassuring. The longtime dairy fan indulges in milk only in the dead of night, guzzling from his goblet just as the session comes to a close. Going back to 2014, he expressed his family’s love for the mammalian delight in a tweet: “Wow...the first sentence Caroline ever said was ‘I like butter.’” Mitt Romney, rebel as he is, slurped from a spotted plastic bottle of chocolate milk. As the sole Republican to vote for impeachment on grounds of abuse of power, this dig to the milk establishment suits his fresh 2020 image swimmingly. For the Democrats and their beloved decorum, this impeachment has not been a success. While it is clear that a sitting president leveraging military aid for investigations into a political rival will be tolerated, Americans needn’t worry: the similarly hard-to-digest lactose will certainly be tolerated as well. -NRS

BY Muram Ibrahim, Harry Levine, Bilal Memon and Nick Roblee-Strauss ILLUSTRATION Floria Tsui DESIGN Anna Brinkhuis

WEEK IN REVIEW

02


Flights of Fantasy BY Zach Ngin ILLUSTRATION Claire Schlaikjer DESIGN Daniel Navratil

I’m trying to remember where I was when I first read The Undercommons. I don’t remember where I started it, but I must have been somewhere far from home. This book moved (with) me. In a coffee shop on the other side of the country, I was somewhere near the end. And somewhere in the middle, I was sitting on the snowy side of a road, on the other side of a blind underpass. Out of view, beyond the tunnel, was a detention center. I had sat down to record the sounds of cars and how they traveled from one side of blindness to another. Horns came blasting through the tunnel, around the bend; they came as notes and as groans, in short, staccato bursts. Occasionally, overhead, a train went by. I sat and read and listened to the sonic commerce between the detention center and the world outside. I was in my first year of college, and I was sitting somewhere in the surrounding, somewhere between the prison and the university, listening to the distances. Through the essays that make up The Undercommons: Fugitive Planning and Black Study, Fred Moten and Stefano Harney ask what lies beneath and beyond institutions of control: the prison and the university, the slave ship and the settlement, systems of debt and credit. Their central concept, “the undercommons,” refers simply to the ungovernable realm of social life, the place where we—colonized, queer, otherwise marginal—make meaning with each other. It is not so much an excavation of resistance or a primer for revolution as a celebration of their inescapable, improvised fact. The undercommons are ineluctably other but never elsewhere. This is the enlightenment’s shadow archive, its flights of fantasy, its maroon community, the fugitive commons just beyond its blind underpass. And the things we’ve been waiting for: they’ve been here, if you listen; they are here, we are here; just listen.

On Fred Moten and Stefano Harney’s Undercommons

+++ The Undercommons was published in 2013 by Minor Compositions, a radical publisher that distributes electronic copies of its titles for free. Since then, it has become a touchstone for academics, artists, activists, and others. The book’s most famous essay, “The University and the Undercommons,” examines the relationship between the university and broader structures of law and order. “The university,” Moten and Harney write, “is not the opposite of the prison, since they are both involved in their way with the reduction and command of the social individual.” In their view, both university and prison are enlisted in the same war against social life—a conquest that extracts what it can (as knowledge, as culture) and discards the rest (as waste, as criminality). Both are invested in a logic of prescription: on one side, an academic program of critique; on the other, a carceral program of correction. In the face of these conditions, they argue, “one can only sneak into the university and steal what one can. To abuse its hospitality, to spite its mission, to join its refugee colony, its gypsy encampment, to be in but not of—this is the path of the subversive intellectual in the modern university.” This line is one of the book’s most cited: it offers to its readers a slogan, a clarion call, a shock of recognition. A shock of recognition. I want to dwell on that phrase for a minute. Those words may come closest to what I’m trying to say about this book. By now, I’ve read and reread its passages countless times, and I could never say that I completely understand it. The Undercommons is a book that creates and sustains its

03

FEATURES

07 FEB 2020


own dense language, more a sound and feel than a for this practice is Black study. Moten offers an expla- the proprietary relations of self-possession. In other constellation of concepts. Refusing to fall neatly into nation of the concept in an interview with Stevphen words, following Afro-pessimist scholar Frank a particular form or vernacular, it invites unsettled Shukaitis included in the book: Wilderson, they remain in the hold of the ship, despite readings, unsettling readings. It’s a style that carries their fantasies of flight—and this is where they find, as it holds, that makes a home in motion only, never We are committed to the idea that study is where they are found. “The hold’s terrible gift was to setting down its bags, never settling its debts. Yet it is what you do with other people. It’s talking and gather dispossessed feelings in common, to create a this very sense of unsettledness that made it feel so walking around with other people, working, new feel in the undercommons,” they write. “To have welcoming to me. More than anything else, it offers dancing, suffering, some irreducible converbeen shipped is to have been moved by others, with itself as a social space: where phrases and sounds and gence of all three, held under the name of others. It is to feel at home with the homeless, at ease citations collide, gathered from the world and given speculative practice...The point of calling it with the fugitive, at peace with the pursued, at rest to the world. The book invests its hopes in those colli‘study’ is to mark that the incessant and irrewith the ones who consent not to be one.” The undersions, in the touch between people and objects and versible intellectuality of these activities is commons is therefore neither a settled location or a words that—though fleeting—changes everything. already present. gathering of individuals: it is the feel of holding and The difficulty of the undercommons is the difficulty of being held, the gathering of a chorus, “an improvisafinding connection in an atomized, alienated society. Moten and Harney reject the distinction between tion that proceeds from somewhere on the other side Their book reached me as an invitation to try. As productive and unproductive activity, between of an unasked question.” All are invited into the ceaseMoten and Harney write, “This information can never creative and uncreative ways of being in the world with less movement of things. be lost, only irrevocably given in transit. We could others. They ignore the call to order that separates the never provide a whole bunch of smooth transitions for chatter in the classroom from the production of knowl+++ this order of ditches and hidden spans.” edge, the noise of the crowd from the show onstage. By I see The Undercommons as an experiment: what recognizing all social life as intellectual and creative, The Undercommons is an experiment in refusing the does it mean to live and write in the wake of slavery Moten and Harney access a riotous, wayward history conditions of logistics: Moten and Harney want (us) to and settler colonialism and capitalist modernity? In of thought. This book is, in part, a love letter to the think, to pause, to interrupt, to experiment. They are other words, how do we devise a grammar of broken- university’s undercommons: its “maroon commu- clear that this project neither begins nor ends in the ness, a language that honors the ruins that we live nities of composition teachers, mentorless graduate university, but this is the place from which they write. among? The answers, for Moten and Harney, if they students, adjunct Marxist historians, out or queer Part of what feels so urgent about their work is that they are anywhere, lie in the cadence of their sentences, management professors, state college ethnic studies really question why study, in their sense of the word, their sonic proximities, their fugitive intimacy. “Here departments, closed-down film programs, visa-ex- is so difficult in institutions supposedly devoted to it. they meet those others who dwell in a different pired Yemeni student newspaper editors, historically “That's what we were trying to understand,” Moten compulsion, in the same debt, a distance, forgetting, black college sociologists, and feminist engineers.” says in the interview with Shukaitis. “How come we remembering again but only after,” they write. “These But it also refuses to recognize the university as the can't be together and think together in a way that feels other ones carry bags of newspaper clippings, or sit center of study. In fact, its authors are interested in how good, the way it should feel good? Everybody is pissed at the end of the bar, or stand at the stove cooking, or the conditions of academic labor actively suppress the off all the time and feels bad, but very seldom do you sit on a box at a newsstand, or speak through bars, or kinds of study that we desire most. enter into a conversation where people are going, ‘why speak in tongues. These other ones have a passion to is it that this doesn't feel good to us?’” tell you what they have found, and they are surprised +++ Moten and Harney insist on having that converyou want to listen, even though they’ve been expecting sation. They ponder the university’s investments in you.” There is so much that we’ve wanted to hear from “To work today is to be asked, more and more, to do isolation and atomization, in instrumental ways of one another, Moten and Harney seem to say. There is without thinking, to feel without emotion, to move seeing. They insist that we attend to our feelings of so much for us to say to each other. without friction, to adapt without question, to translate stress and busyness, scarcity and precarity—in other without pause, to desire without purpose, to connect words, to the sense that we have nothing to give each +++ without interruption,” write Moten and Harney at other, that there is nothing we owe each other. And the beginning of their final essay, “Fantasy in the they insist that we keep moving, beyond austerity, Moten and Harney, who met as undergraduates at Hold.” The line is intentionally placeless and vague. beyond critique, beyond opposition. “We run looking Harvard, bring rich intellectual genealogies and It describes a dream as old as modernity, the time for a weapon and keep running looking to drop it,” they languages to their common project. Moten, who of “today”: this is a dream of total alienation, beyond write. “And we can drop it, because however armed, teaches at New York University, is a poet and scholar human space and time, beyond the work of human however hard, the enemy we face is also illusory.” Our who draws on Black radical thought, particularly hands. These conditions, which Moten and Harney time and our attention, our care and our love: this is Saidiya Hartman’s work on subjection and Édouard describe as logistical, apply to both the contempo- all we have, “the mutual debt that can never be made Glissant’s theory of Relation. Harney, who lives in rary academy and the founding of modernity. To work good,” our cause for suffering and celebration. Singapore, is a scholar of labor and management who today, the authors argue, is to work in the wake of Reading The Undercommons helped me insist on relies on the language of Italian autonomist Marxism. slavery and settlement, to work with their languages having that conversation. This book moved (with) me. Together, they ask to read alongside others engaged and institutions, their desires and visions. It may feel My copy, borrowed on interlibrary loan, began to bear in this massive project of knowing and living other- irresponsible—harmful, even—to draw a line from the traces of its movement: all the times I pulled it out wise: a few recent examples are Jack Halberstam’s The chattel slavery to the conditions of labor in the modern of my backpack, the times that someone lent breath to Queer Art of Failure, la paperson’s A Third University university. But to be clear, they are not suggesting its sentences. It became an occasion to say, We’re here is Possible, and Hartman’s Wayward Lives, Beautiful an equivalence or even an analogy: the movement of to study. Why doesn’t this feel good? And to ask, Why Experiments. Though this context helps us locate their essay is better described as contextualization is the work of being a student so often in opposition their work, they would probably resist any attempt to and speculation. They challenge us to consider the to practices of care—for ourselves and for each other, situate them in a single lineage or settled position. On violence that founded our world and how it continues for this city, this land, this world? The Undercommons the occasion of their book’s translation into Spanish, to condition what is thinkable and possible within the became, in short, an occasion for study: for talking they said in an interview, “Even within what might institutions that we have inherited. and walking around with others, among others, be called our own context, as tightly as anyone might For Moten and Harney, both the violence and the lingering on benches and in vacant seminar rooms, ever want to define it, in order for our work to be read possibility begin in the hold of a ship, in the trans- listening together to the distances. Another university at all it will have had to have been translated, moved, port of objects, of people enslaved and imprisoned, is possible, and it’s already here somewhere, its cover displaced.” refugees and laborers, in moving and being made to creased from being passed back and forth, from being From the perspective of the undercommons, all move. This movement cannot be reversed or wished held until long overdue. knowledge is a product of these unlikely displace- away. The authors refuse offers of assimilation and ments and entanglements, unsettled in its origins and rites of respectability. They refuse to advance from ZACH NGIN B’22 is convinced that we owe each unsettling in its effects. Moten and Harney’s name objecthood to subjecthood, from dispossession to other everything.

THE COLLEGE HILL INDEPENDENT

FEATURES

04


CRISIS IN DISCOURSE

In recent years, China has moved up the value chain. No longer the world’s cheap factory, it has passed on the manufacturing torch to countries like India, BY Emily Rust Malaysia, and Vietnam. However, some things are still ILLUSTRATION Sylvia Atwood made in China—which the Western media will not let DESIGN Ella Rosenblatt the country forget. Of course, some of this recent scapegoating has focused on the wrong target. The novel coronavirus itself was not made in China. Believed to have come from an animal, an outbreak of the virus could have, in theory, emerged in any place where humans do issue. The flow of constant information that we are resources towards eradicating the slightest hint of any not take necessary precautions when in contact with subject to has strengthened our feeling that we must person speaking about the virus, and I promise you wildlife. The epidemic, on the other hand, was made always have something to say, for fear of falling behind. that any conversation or literature pertaining to the in China. This is not because of the Chinese people, or As this Indy editor, however, has learned over the last virus will be completely eliminated during the next Chinese culinary practices, or Chinese culture—the few weeks, being levelheaded is not the same thing seven days.” The Onion article is dismally accurate, epidemic has reached the point it has today because of as being aloof. There is no reason to create a sense of aside from its absolute blame on Xi Jinping. In reality, the poor governance of the Chinese Communist Party crisis when that energy could be spent on individuals it was the Wuhan authorities who stood for most of the (CCP). and families who are actually impacted by the virus. “elimination of conversation and literature” during the In China, the CCP has the incentive and means to Empathy and solidarity rarely sound like hysteria. outbreak’s early stages, as they channeled resources downplay and hide information about the epidemic— into the containment of discourse rather than the primarily online but also in hospital reports. This kind containment of disease. +++ of censorship was initially used by local officials to Although Xi Jinping’s policies have worsened the prevent the central government from catching wind Last week, New York Times reporter Chris Buckley central-local disconnect, this is far from the first time it of the problem. However, cover-ups remained after tweeted a photo of a red banner in Wuhan that reads “ has brought harm to the Chinese people. An infamous the management of the epidemic was assumed by 科学防,不恐慌,莫让谣言帮倒忙.” (Scientific preven- example is the economic campaign known as the Great central authorities. No longer about saving face within tion, don’t panic, don’t let rumors do more harm than Leap Forward, in which local officials felt pressured by the Chinese government, a portion of such a lack of help.) Political banners like this are common in China, their superiors’ unrealistic production goals to falsify transparency is about saving face on the international usually displaying dogmatic slogans that encourage grain yields. Largely due to this disconnect, the Great stage. This is more than just an authoritarian impulse leading a “文明” (civilized) life, celebrating the Leap Forward resulted in the starvation of millions of to control the flow of information. Among the biggest harmony of the supposedly united Chinese people, people in the late 1950s and early 1960s. fears of Chinese leader Xi Jinping and his counterparts and imbuing oneself with “Xi Jinping thought”. In December, local officials silenced doctors is weakness—the perception that they are no longer in ‘No panicking’ and ‘no rumormongering’ are and other whistleblowers for warning about what control. As the virus spreads, Xi Jinping’s governance solid standards to live by no matter where you reside. they feared could develop into a SARS-like epidemic. tactics become discredited in the overseas eyes of both However, the banners shed light on a deplorable aspect According to the New York Times, officials told doctors his allies and enemies. of the Chinese government’s initial handling of the not to “use the words viral pneumonia” in their reports. The last time an outbreak like this happened in outbreak. While US discourse of the epidemic has One doctor was forced by police to sign a statement China was in 2003, when severe acute respiratory involved excessive hysteria, far too much time has that he had engaged in “illegal behavior” for raising syndrome (SARS) infected over 8,000 people and passed before any kind of discourse was allowed in red flags. Following an announcement in late January killed 774. Since then, the media environment has China. The virus was first detected in December, but that the disease did indeed spread from human to undergone an extraordinary transformation. This, in the full-scale fight against the epidemic only began human, it was revealed that fourteen medical workers turn, has changed the way we confront disease and in the third week of January. The government’s more had been infected by a single patient. The city governcrisis. Relative to 2003, the public has a different role than month-long delay in acknowledging and tackling ment’s calculated denial of the virus exposed Wuhan’s in the way current events are conceptualized today. No the virus results from a problem that has plagued party 11 million people to a danger that doctors had perceived longer having to seek out the news, we receive it in a politics throughout the history of the People’s Republic early on. deluge of live updates on social media. Even in China, of China (PRC). The red banners are in place not just to instill calmwhere social media is limited by the Great Firewall, This problem is the disconnect between the central ness in the traumatized Wuhan population, but to the ubiquity of news has made ordinary people engage party leadership based in Beijing and the local officials serve as a warning to people who are tempted to share with current events in a new way, on platforms like who oversee provinces, townships, and villages. When information condemning the government. In fact, one Weibo and WeChat. For the CCP, the optics of the it comes to sensitive issues, these local officials err of the whistleblowers who was reprimanded by police recent coronavirus epidemic are higher stakes than towards secrecy for fear of being dismissed or other- has now contracted the virus, a tangible and devasthey were during SARS. This visibility has made the wise penalized, a dynamic that goes hand in hand with tating consequence of the central-local disconnect. As party feel particularly vulnerable, which has resulted the punishment of whistleblowers. Just as the outbreak reported by the Shanghai-based, online publication with even more draconian control. The Chinese and spread of SARS in 2003 was concealed by local offi- Sixth Tone, this doctor, named Li Wenliang, had “been government’s insistence on suppressing discourse cials for months, Wuhan authorities made great efforts working on the front lines of the epidemic” until he about the coronavirus prevents its control measures to downplay the virus in December. In fact, Mayor of began to develop a cough and fever. He and his parents from functioning at full force. Wuhan Zhou Xianwang shifted some of the blame to were hospitalized in early January. In a text message The discourse surrounding the coronavirus has Beijing in an interview with China Central Television to Chris Buckley, Doctor Li wrote, “If the officials had been suppressed in some places and amplified in in late January. Wearing a face mask, Mayor Zhou disclosed information about the epidemic earlier, I others. This swelling virality has only encouraged explained that his delay in releasing sensitive informa- think it would have been a lot better. There should be more fear. In China, due to the fears of the govern- tion was a result of rules that required approval from more openness and transparency.” ment, the epidemic has been exacerbated by a lack of Beijing. Though implicit, this critique of Xi Jinping’s Now that the handling of the epidemic has been discourse. In the US, irrational panic has prevented top-down leadership style was shockingly blunt. extended to Beijing, it is central authorities who people from respecting the actuality and gravity of A headline by the satirical publication the Onion are in charge of stifling discourse of the virus. Last the issue. Across the world, this sense of alarm has captured the dark undertone of Buckley’s banner well: Friday, Hu Xijing, editor of the CCP-controlled publiprompted bigoted scapegoating to come out of the “Xi Jinping Vows To Combat Coronavirus By Making cation the Global Times, wrote an article criticizing woodwork both online and in people’s actions. It Illegal To Mention Within A Week.” A fabricated the government for its lack of transparency and delay Discourse shapes the way that we conceive of an quote in the article reads, “We are directing massive in confronting the epidemic. Within a few hours, the

05

SCIENCE + TECH

07 FEB 2020


article was removed from the Global Times website.

travelled to Wuhan to attend to the sick—fully aware and tourists have reported an increase in sinophobic that their government is likely withholding vital infor- outbursts. For example, customers from the Chinese +++ mation from them. Tens of millions of people living in mainland have been refused entry at restaurants Hubei province in China are living in quarantine. Not in places like Hong Kong, South Korea, Japan, and Although some might experience a degree of déjà allowed out of the cities they were in at the time of lock- Vietnam. Two weeks ago, in the Indonesian tourist vu based on the similarities between the handling down, these people are trapped in their own homes. city Bukittinggi, hundreds of people marched outside of SARS and the coronavirus, the epidemics differ The elderly especially suffer from this sudden imposed a hotel where Chinese people were staying, protesting in the way they were conceived of and made viral by isolation. And at the backdrop of all of this is the Spring against their presence in Indonesia. Similarly, on the media. When SARS dotted headlines across the Festival, China’s happiest and most carefree time of January 29, protesters organized a rally in Seoul calling world in 2003, editors at news publications possessed year. The outbreak has brought a fierce halt to public for a ban on the entry of Chinese people into South more concentrated power over what stories would be and family celebrations of the holiday throughout the Korea. The same day, a man in Australia died of a heart published in the following day’s paper. Armed with country. attack after bystanders reportedly refused to give him their phones and followers, reporters nowadays make In stark contrast, US discourse surrounding CPR in fear of getting sick. more of those decisions on the spot, minute by minute. the virus has been ridden with a disappointing level On January 30, the World Health Organization In the decentralized media environment of our current of ignorance and hysteria. Disease is not romantic. (WHO) declared the coronavirus outbreak a global moment, readers of the news become a part of the Lockdowns are not exciting. Extremes should not be health emergency. At the same time, the international conversation in a far more publicized way. Our news- fetishized. The hysteria surrounding the virus in the body stated that measures interfering with trade and feeds provide us with access to other people’s opinions, media has perpetuated the damage caused by the transportation have the potential to impede efforts and the ability to share our own, to an extent that at disease. to address the epidemic. In the week that followed, times does more harm than good. An effective way of countering these alarmist several countries—including the US, Singapore, and Less and less do we see a distinction between the narratives is to humanize those experiencing the Australia—imposed restrictions and bans on noncitcoverage of news and reactions to it. To stay informed, coronavirus on the ground. For example, Sixth Tone izens who have recently visited China. This disregard users of Twitter, Facebook, and even Instagram no has published several articles over the last few weeks for expert advice sheds further light on the ignorance longer have to actively pursue the news. Besides, the that have shed light on the experiences of people inherent in all the Trump administration’s travel bans. line between reporter and reader has become blurred. affected by the virus in Wuhan and China. James Although WHO chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus Although reporters associated with corporate media Palmer, senior editor at Foreign Policy has authored a declared on February 4 that such measures could continue to hold significant sway over news coverage, number of thoughtful pieces on the outbreak. For CNN, “have the effect of increasing fear and stigma, with Twitter makes it possible for anyone with a phone to Nectar Gan wrote an article about how the coronavirus little public health benefit,” the US stands its ground. share information and input on viral stories. Due to outbreak has made the people of Wuhan outcasts in social media, people feel a growing compulsion to their own country. Elisabeth Rosenthal, who covered +++ engage with what is going on in the world through the SARS epidemic in 2003, wrote a levelheaded short and punchy commentary. While this kind of New York Times op-ed entitled “How to Avoid the Although the ramifications of the epidemic—and the news-sharing allows for a communal experience of Coronavirus? Wash Your Hands.” To shield yourself discourses surrounding it—can be felt on a global significant events, tweets and memes often veer in the from the mostly China-based epidemic that mainly scale, it is the people of Wuhan and Hubei province direction of making light of news that deserves sober endangers the elderly and those with pre-existing who get the short end of the stick. Even within China, respect. conditions, staying calm and following Rosenthal’s they are shunned—their birthplace has become There are things to be said for the benefits of titular advice goes a long way. synonymous with disease. To their government, their social media on the dissemination of news. For one, health and safety was worth less than saving face. The the power that small groups of editors once had over +++ blame placed on the people of Wuhan and Hubei has reporting has been somewhat dismantled. Moreover, resulted in the scapegoating of complete strangers tweets from events like protests can inform and Along with a suppressed discourse in China and located far away from them. The sensitive nature of all impact what is written after the fact. TV has less of a hysteria in the US, the coronavirus outbreak has also things political in China makes it difficult for medical monopoly on live coverage, as stories that unfold in the spurred a worldwide normalization of sinophobia. personnel working at Hubei’s overcrowded hospitals moment become more accessible through avenues like In mid-January, when the international spotlight to do their jobs. This epidemic has and will continue to Facebook Live. The public serves as witness, reporter, became directed at the outbreak, publications placed render the province’s poor people and migrant workers and consumer all at once, giving people not associated an emphasis on a Wuhan wet market claimed to be the most vulnerable. In some tragic cases, the governwith mainstream media influence over what becomes origin of the virus. Getting most of its demand from ment’s handling of the virus has proved fatal: in a town news. practitioners of traditional Chinese medicine, the near Wuhan, a disabled teenager was found dead after On the flip side, our new relationship with news is country’s wildlife trade became the focus of discus- his father was placed in quarantine and no one came to not all beneficial, evident in the sense of crisis that has sions that swiftly broadened into a scapegoating of take care of him. developed around the coronavirus outside of China. Chinese people and their cultural practices. These kinds of outbreaks will persist if the strucIt is natural that the idea of contagion makes people The Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market consists of ture and governance of the CCP does not change. alarmed. Nevertheless, social media platforms and stalls selling meat, poultry, fish, as well as more ‘exotic’ Perhaps this one will serve as a rude awakening for their constant live updates have made the virus feel animals like rats, snakes, wolves, and bats. Although Xi Jinping that even microscopic particles have the unrealistically proximate to people in the US. When the role of the market in the outbreak has since come power to mobilize against the thickest hubris. After the most of us learn of the latest news through the reac- into question, non-Chinese people unquestioningly outbreak reaches its peak and the epidemic is stopped, tions of others—when memes occupy the same space revived the far-too-common narrative about Asians one can only hope that the party will tackle the strucas reporting—representations of an event encroach on and their supposedly ‘savage’ eating habits. And while tural central-local disconnect that they failed to get rid its reality. experts have not unanimously agreed on what animal of after SARS. After a coronavirus scare at USC, students posted was the source of the virus, a viral video of a woman Besides his photo of the banner, some of Chris memes about the disease online. As a friend from my eating a bat convinced thousands of social media users Buckley’s other tweets emphasize the “unearthly quiet” high school in Beijing told me, “It’s funny to them that Chinese bat-eating was the source of the outbreak. of Wuhan. As online discourse about the virus amplicause it’s not concerning them right now. It’s even more Chinese people were quick to point out that bats are fies day by day, the people of Wuhan continue to hold frustrating when I hear people say ‘I’m scared I wanna not a delicacy in Wuhan, nor was the video even taken their breath. The only sound to be heard in the deserted go home’ when I can’t go home.” Although the corona- in China. As Twitter user @rzhong notes,“People are streets is the barking of dogs, at times in chorus. In virus is serious and deserves our attention, its coverage really just telling anyone Asian to stop eating bats like Buckley’s speculations about these dogs—"perhaps has developed an unnecessary atmosphere of fear in I have a bat granola bar in my purse next to my keys or stressed at being locked inside, perhaps their humans places where people are not at risk. The increasingly something.” Wang Mengyun is a travel show host and aren’t around”—we are given a small glimpse into the intertwined relationship between news and social the video is from her trip to the island country Palau grim silence of the usually bustling city. Soon, the media invites people to insert themselves into current a few years ago. In his article “Don’t Blame Bat Soup internet will move onto new fixations. By then, maybe events. This epidemic is overwhelmingly affecting for the Wuhan Virus,” James Palmer points out the Wuhan’s soundtrack will feature something more than Chinese people and has so far only claimed Chinese hypocrisy of this finger-pointing: “Sampling the bat stillness, as the city comes to figure out a new normal. lives. That fact should certainly bring about strong was simply an addition to the well-trodden cannon of emotions—though hopefully not panic of contracting adventurism and enthusiasm for unusual foods that EMILY RUST B’22 prefers this political slogan: 武汉 the virus oneself. Even if people infected with the virus numerous American chefs and travel hosts have shown 加油,中国加油! have made their way to this country, there is for the in the past.” time being no reason for anyone in Rhode Island to Xenophobic attitudes are based in ignorance and believe they are at risk. fear. As the coronavirus has made its way to other parts News is news for a reason. It is far better to discuss of the world, Chinese people have increasingly been it than to leave it ignored. But the way we engage scapegoated for its spread. As Palmer explains in the with news matters; not all attention is good atten- article, it is not uncommon for images and videos of tion. At the time of writing, the virus has taken more Chinese people eating insects, snakes, or mice to circuthan 560 lives. Over 28,000 people are confirmed late online. People’s sinophobic comments became all sick worldwide, but more infections are likely unre- the more acute in the context of the coronavirus, when ported. Needless to say, each of those individuals has this scrutiny of perceived culinary practices is “mixed a web of friends and family mourning their deaths with another old racist idea: that the ‘dirty’ Chinese or invested in their recovery. Health personnel from are carriers of disease.” across China have mobilized, left their loved ones, and Across the world, Chinese and Asian residents

THE COLLEGE HILL INDEPENDENT

SCIENCE + TECH

06


BIG GIRLS CRY BIG CLOWN TEARS

07

I MISS MY MOMMY EVERY DAY

CVS CASHIER A LITTLE RACIST

GIANT EYE ALWAYS WATCHING

EM O WASN’T JU ST A PH A S E

EPHEMERA

07 FEB 2020


MOLEHILLS OUT OF MOU N TA INS

BY Deb Marini & Ricardo Gomez ILLUSTRATION Claire Schlaikjer DESIGN Ella Rosenblatt and Matt Ishimaru

A CLOSE LOOK AT GOVERNOR R AIMONDO’S 2021 BUDGET PROPOSAL Reading budgets is like eating broccoli stems: miser- Island Brotherhood of Correctional Officers (RIBCO), Additionally, the cost to operate the benefits infraable! Gina Governor Raimondo’s annual budget who claimed that High Security is a “deterrent” for structure project has grown to more than $656 million proposal, released this past January, is a multivolume violence in the state’s lower-security prisons and one of after Gov. Gina Raimondo’s administration reached a work whose natural expansiveness—it’s legally the strongest forms of protection for correctional offi- deal to extend Deloitte’s contract through 2021 despite mandated to cover every piece of state spending— cers. The union set aside $100,000 for a campaign to its serious failures leading to the damaging 2016 tends to convolute and cloud a lot of the issues it covers. slander the governor and her budget director, Jonathan launch. Reports in 2019 disclosed that state taxpayers This bureaucratic obscurity is only made worse by Wormer, in retaliation for the budget proposal. One will put up $154 million for UHIP while the rest of cost media outlets choosing to highlight the more sensa- radio spot called on listeners to tell the governor to will be covered by the federal government. tional line items, such as marijuana legalization and rescind her proposal “because if she doesn’t, blood will To justify the cost of UHIP, state officials stressed tax hikes. be on her hands.” how UHIP would pay for itself by more efficiently The College Hill Independent decided to do a deep High Security is one of the easiest locations for removing ineligible individuals from social services. dive into Raimondo’s FY 2021 Budget Proposal and COs to get overtime hours and RIDOC has an institu- In 2017, officials set out their vision of optimizing pulled out two pieces of important legislation—moun- tional trend of officers taking advantage of overtime. the deployment of social services by establishing tains, if you will—that have been tucked neatly within In 2018, 37% of full-time employees pulled at least one the aggressive goal of removing 20,000 individuals the bill and remanufactured into molehills. One line 32-hour “quad” (four consecutive 8 hour shifts) in 2018. from Rhode Island’s Medicaid on a curt four-month item produces savings by addressing the cost, rather While Raimondo’s plan guaranteed job security for timetable. Healthcare means humans lives and here, than the ethics of keeping people in the state’s most all COs employed at High Security during the renova- optimization is being articulated in terms of more effiinefficiently run prison. The other saves the state tions, there was no guarantee for overtime availability. ciently depriving people of healthcare. money by cutting 5,500 people off of Medicaid. Both The proposed renovations were ultimately denied That UHIP delivers essential services to some, turn people into numbers, then numbers into savings. by the General Assembly, who left out $45 million in while depriving others of those very same services, borrowing that the project hinged on. makes reporting on the issue a critical concern to the +++ In the FY 2021 budget, Raimondo is now proposing public. According to the most recent oversight report, to close down two of the 12-inmate units in High “as of January 11, 2020, open incidents totaled 206 – a Raimondo proposed a number of changes to the Rhode Security in order to net $777,292 in savings for the state 97 percent drop since December 2017.” This report Island Department of Corrections (RIDOC), one of through the reduction of CO overtime. Consequently, implies that UHIP has improved since its launch and is which intends to send 24 men to out-of-state prisons in the 24 people in these units would be sent to out-of- actually mitigating problems of bureaucratic excess in order to save money in the state’s most expensive and state prisons in return for 24 people from out-of-state, order to help people. inefficient prison: the High Security Facility. and both groups, now that they are distanced from What remains questionable is the state’s commitAn understanding of the proposal requires a bit most “enemy threats,” could be housed in their “actual ment to making sure that UHIP’s operations remain of history on the nature of the state’s prisons. Rhode classification levels.” While the original plan would equitable and transparent. That the UHIP’s most Island contains only one prison for each carceral have saved money and moderately improved living recent update saw 5,500 Rhode Islanders kicked off security level—intake services, minimum, medium, conditions for the men in High Security, this new plan Medicaid without proper notice makes it abundantly maximum, and super maximum—for men held under merely saves money. RIBCO has not yet issued a state- clear that UHIP still needs to be carefully monitored the jurisdiction of RIDOC. According to language ment against or in support of this new proposal. despite its apparent efficiency improvements. “Why utilized by the Providence Journal and by the correcWhile it may be too early to make any predictions, did the Raimondo administration not disclose this?” tional officers union, the super maximum facility, High it seems likely that this provision in the budget proposal Sam Bell, a State Senator, asked. “Now that Raimondo Security, is meant to house the “worst of the worst.” will slide through the State House this spring if RIBCO hired the ProJo’s ace health and human services In reality, most of the men in High Security are there or any activist groups representing the people incar- reporter Jennifer Bogdan to run her communications, because they were unable to be rightfully placed in the cerated at High Security do not speak up. Raimondo’s are there enough reporters keeping track on UHIP?” lower security levels because of “enemy issues” iden- budget also proposes an elimination of overtime in Clearly, the question of democratic control and transtified by RIDOC, such as rival gang members. The RIDOC for non-Correctional Officers and a stricter parency remains a continuous source of concern. As invisible hand of administrative discretion also plays a enforcement of sick leave policies among COs, both Senator Bell explains, “In the previous Medicaid significant and obscure role in the moving of men from of which may distract RIBCO from the High Security purges, you were supposed to get one letter and a lower-security prisons to High Security. closures. 10-day warning where you had a chance to try and save The facility was built in 1981 at the onset of the Currently, there are about 80 people in Cranston your healthcare if the information behind the denial tough-on-crime era and, to this day, continues to spending up to 23 hours a day in solitary confinement. was incorrect.” The most recent update—which failed perform as such. Men incarcerated in High Security Their connections to their friends and family on the to send those warnings—calls attention to transparspend up to twenty-three hours a day in solitary outside are already strikingly limited, and the transfer ency issues. UHIP deals in matters of human life and confinement for indefinite periods of time, a prac- of 24 of them could only isolate them more. While the operates with very little interaction with the lives it tice known to have extremely negative psychological transfer could prove beneficial to some, it is guaran- effects most. and physiological effects counteractive to RIDOC’s teed not to benefit the 50 men left behind in archaic, The absence of clear means to appeal decisions goals of rehabilitation. In 2017, a Rhode Island Special cruel conditions. of disqualification and the failure to send out proper Legislative Commission investigated RIDOC’s use notice about terminations mirrors how the budget of solitary confinement and at the commission’s +++ affects Rhode Islanders immediately while remaining conclusion sent RIDOC a number of recommendaconceptually inaccessible. tions. Some, such as reformed policy statements, were According to a report from the Senate Fiscal Office, the adopted. Others, such as limits on time spent in soli- Governor’s budget also includes an update to health +++ tary, were ignored. care technology that will deny Medicaid to 5,500 Change to High Security is primarily discussed Rhode Islanders. When Rhode Island launched the At the end of the day, these aspects of Governor in terms of financial savings, not in terms of common Unified Health Infrastructure Project (UHIP) in 2016, Raimondo’s budget proposal prioritize theoretical humanity. Keeping over 80 men imprisoned within the system was meant to centralize and simplify the savings over human lives. While it's not emblematic High Security cost the state an annual $195,244 per deployment of benefits like food stamps, Medicaid, of active immorality in her camp, it does expose the person in 2019, while each of the 400 men at Maximum and child care assistance for hundreds of thousands dangers of the “numbers game” she is forced to play by Security cost the state an annual $82,115 each. These of Rhode Islanders. Despite a variety of red flags, the a state that demands savings and a statehouse that is at costs come from the building’s physical construction; infrastructure project was launched without a backup the mercy of lobbyists and unions. its poor sight lines, outdated design, and lack of proper and led to a series of payment disputes, disruptively programming space demand more correctional offi- overcrowded field offices, and application backlogs DEB MARINI B’22 and RICARDO GOMEZ B’22 cers-per-inmate. High Security is founded both histor- so immense that the ACLU of Rhode Island sued over love Kafka and all things bureau. ically and physically in inhumane, punitive practices, the issue. Behind this debacle—which put a hold on but the high costs seem to consistently be the key force the many services essential to Rhode Islanders—was motivating policymakers to take action. Deloitte, a multinational professional services firm Raimondo first addressed High Security in her that designed the error-ridden computer system. budget report last year. She suggested that the state Deloitte’s mismanagement of this state project put a could realize $5.1 million in savings through a $66 serious spotlight on the role of private business entities million capital improvements project that would reno- in the provisioning of vital public benefits. vate the facility in a way that would reduce the number of correctional officers needed and avoid future maintenance. This plan was met with immense pushback from the correctional officers union, the Rhode

THE COLLEGE HILL INDEPENDENT

METRO

08


BY Agnes Cẩm Ngọc Trần ILLUSTRATION David González DESIGN Cate Turner

N ƯỚC IS WATER

Nước is water. Nước is country. The streams and seas of nước that my parents crossed in 1979 to reach a new nước. When my mom tells me stories of her childhood in Vietnam, the streams and seas of her words flow into veins and a heartbeat. The streams that my great-grandparents floated down to settle in Rạch Giá. The sea that my grandmother caught in her broken fishnets and small hands. The river that saved my uncle. The ocean that brought my family a new life, but took the lives of others. After my great-great-grandmother passed into her next life, my great-great-grandfather, heartbroken, took his children and floated down the river in search of their next life. They lived off of the nước until the stream’s fingers carried them to Rạch Giá, where my grandmother would grow up. My grandmother also lived off of the nước, travelling from dock to dock to repair the nets of fishermen with her small hands. She married my grandfather, a lieutenant, and traveled with him across the nước to a small island where he was stationed. When she became pregnant with my aunt, later the eldest of eight, my grandfather gambled away his earnings and drank everything but nước and she stood by the docks and cried and begged to the passing boats until eventually one took pity on her tears and took her across the nước back home to Rạch Giá and she would never go anywhere with my grandfather again. Except once in 1979 across the nước to a new nước called America. Now when my grandmother presses her hand against my cheek to snuff kisses against my hair, I can feel the wrinkle of her fishnet fingers, as if she stayed in the nước for too long.

Ma is ghost. Mạ is rice seedling. Mả is tomb. Má is mother. Depending on how you let go of your breath, ma can mean life or death. My family history is submerged in the smoke of hungry ma and village shamans, in unmarked mả and bony earth, in fields of mạ and leaf houses. My grandfather is still an alcoholic. He comes to California from Ohio every summer and sits in my backyard with all the uncles and drinks everything but nước. As his

09

FEATURES

drawled words mix with the smoke of his cigarette, of hungry ma. I wonder what the Vietnamese and the smoke begins to flow into the shape of figures, of Cambodian fought over. It was probably over who my grandfather leading his soldiers, of an ambush by owned the nước. The ma own the land now. They the communists, of my grandfather using a grenade to make up the land now, the bones and flesh of the earth. save his men, of my grandfather checking the smoked The land owns them now. I wonder if their families bodies for anything to send home, of a whole platoon of lit incense and paper money and put out mangos and wispy ma that were only fourteen years old, of a whole tea for them at the altar, honored their memory and platoon of wispy fourteen year old ma that each only fed their hungry souls until their stomachs and hearts owned a fistful of rice to send home. After the smoke of were full enough to make the journey to the next life. I his cigarette and grenade clears, I can begin to under- wonder if their families didn’t, and if they turned into stand why he doesn’t drink nước. hungry ma, lost and far away from their nước without After the war ended, my grandfather took his even the faintest trail of incense to guide them home family deep into rural South Vietnam to escape reedu- or into their next life. They are forgotten and forsaken cation camps and persecution. There was still nước, in in both altar and memory, tied in body and spirit to the the form of rivers, but there was more land, stretches of land that they owned that now owns them. Ma can’t sugarcane fields and graveyards between each home. cross bodies of nước. Bodies of spirits, bodies of land, My má tells me there were more ma than people. I bodies of nước. Bound by bodies in life and in death. believe her. She tells me of the pebbles that would hit I wonder where my aunt is now, wonder if her bones her everytime she passed the leaf house of a widow, are under some new private resort construction or if where every evening, the widow would sit by the mả they’re still there, drowning in the sea of skeletons and and ma in front of the leaf house. She tells me of the spirits in a place where there is more bone than land or legless Cambodian woman that my grandpa pretended nước. not to see while he worked in the sugarcane fields. She tells me of the other shadows and voices that lived in their leaf house with her, my two aunts, my uncle, and Digging mả. my grandparents. Digging up ma. My aunt died in that house. She was younger than I am now. I don’t even know her name. There is no trace Digging up ma of her, no pictures, no memories, no mả or ma. She only in search for a mả for her. exists in the story of her death. My grandmother asked her if she wanted to return to the city to live with her sister. My aunt whose name I do not know and whose face I will never know decided she would return to On the same night of her death and burial, my the city once the season for her favorite fruit came, so uncle suddenly got the same illness. My grandfather that she could eat it before she left. She died before her took his family away to the nước that the ma couldn’t favorite fruit ripened. On a day that my grandfather cross. He put them all on their little boat and they went left the leaf house to work in the sugarcane fields, she down the nước, away from the sea of skeletons. They suddenly didn’t feel well. My mom told me that she sat were in the middle of the river when the boat’s motor by her bedside with their older brother and talked and and my uncle’s breathing stopped. laughed with my aunt like normal. They were in the My grandmother screamed and cried for help as middle of a conversation when she died with her eyes they drifted. My grandfather cursed and swore and open. told Ông Trờ—the Man in the Sky—that he would give My mom told me that my grandfather’s aura is his life for his son’s. Fate had it so that a woman, in a strong, strong enough to repel the hungry ma. When place where there were more spirits than people, found my aunt contracted her illness, my grandfather was them drifting in the nước and told them about the gone. But in the early morning, he returned suddenly, famous herbalist who just happened to live nearby. on the basis of a bad feeling. By the time he came back, In the broken yellow light of his home, the herbalist she was already dead. submerged my uncle in a tank of nước. They spent the rest of the day breaking the earth. My má remembers vividly when my uncle started Digging graves. Digging up graves. Digging up graves to breathe again. He broke out of the nước and out of in search of a grave for her. Digging mả. Digging up ma. death and spluttered, chest heaving again with life. Digging up ma in search for a mả for her. Every hole After coming back to life, my uncle would tell they dug was filled with the bodies and bones of others. my grandmother that the hungry ma wouldn’t stop Bones streamed through the rotting earth like a river. following him. My grandmother sought out the help of They had to bury her in the bones of another, of a few a shaman. others, drown her in the sea of skeletons because there “Let me take him as my godson,” the shaman told was no land or nước. my grandparents. They obliged. Land broken by an old Cambodian battlefield. For years after this incident, my uncle would Land broken by bodies of nước. Land broken by bodies remain in a state of sickness. But whenever his

07 FEB 2020


godfather came up the alley that led to their new home, Philippines. When they crossed the nước to the his illness would immediately clear. But my grand- refugee camps, they could have been mistaken for father’s promise to the Man in the Sky was neither ma. They were hosed down with clean nước because forgotten nor forsaken. For decades after, when one they stank so badly from their time floating. of them became ill, the same illness would haunt the They spent months on that island, unable to cross other, regardless of the nước that separated them. the nước like ma because they had nowhere to go, no trail of incense smoke to follow. The only smoke came from black clouds above burning boats in the middle of the nước. Occasionally they saw small Nước is water. boats almost make it to shore, only to be reeled back Ma is ghost. into the nước by Thai pirates. They saw those boats Ma nước is water ghost. pulled all the way to the horizon where nước and sky were indistinguishable. For days, those boats would stay trapped at that blur between nước and sky. My grandfather decided they would cross the nước There was nothing to be done until the pirates left before they became ma and couldn’t. He decided this and those boats slowly drifted back to the shore that on a night when he hadn’t drunk nước. “We are leaving they were so close to days earlier. The women had to this nước tomorrow,” he promised. Come with us and be carried off or limp to land with broken bodies, and cross the nước or stay here until the ma of you is bound no men ever made it past the nước. Ma cannot cross to this nước forever. Die for this nước, die in this nước, nước, but the living can, and oftentimes, the living die because of this nước. are to be more feared. Only the really desperate believed him and came the next evening. My grandfather, true to his drunken word, stole a small fishing boat that the new governNước is water. ment had claimed ownership of. They had to leave Nước is country. those that were bound to the warm land or sweet thunderstorms, those that were bound by too much age or Nước is where too little age, those that could not or would not swim in we, uncertain nước to a foreign nước. then and now, My grandfather took his children and my grandmother and a few other families. They floated in the here and there, nước for days, weeks. Pirates circled them but left when are bound to. my grandfather brandished his only grenade. Not all boat people are as lucky. My father’s fishing boat was ransacked by pirates who took generations of wealth and left them nothing but nước. My godmother fell off Some of us are floating, drifting down the her family’s fishing boat and drowned and when she streams of nước as we get from here to there or from was hauled back up from the nước and from the dead, there to here and try to make here or there home. she asked her mother why she could suddenly see so Some of us are drowning, struggling to stay afloat many people on the boat—the boat people who had not in the heavy waves of foggy nước as neither there been as lucky and had become ma nước, the unfortu- becomes here nor here becomes there. But some of nate that had died watery deaths, that are bound to the us are swimming in the nước, almost grounded in nước, that cannot cross to land. the new nước, as here and there become one. Nước My má’s fishing boat floated in the nước for weeks has become both home and the space between home until the nước looked like land, like an island in the and here, or home and there. We are the ma nước,

THE COLLEGE HILL INDEPENDENT

forever bound to the nước, haunted by the ma of aunts whose names we do not know whose faces we will never know, haunted by hot summer smoke and fistfuls of rice, haunted by the histories of our families. We are the ma nước, forever bound to the nước between here and there, with Vietnam’s streams and seas and rivers and oceans surging through our veins.

Nước is water. Ma is ghost. Ma nước is water ghost. Ma nước is us.

FEATURES

10


RABBITS BY Zachary Baytosh ILLUSTRATION Georgianna Stoukides DESIGN Amos Jackson

Alexa could not remember when she began to allow them. That she definitely remembered. They hadn’t the rabbits to sleep with her, in their bed, when Rob really talked that weekend, not that they had been was away. It had been sometime at the end of April, avoiding each other, they just hadn’t talked, minus she knew. Sometime after her birthday, which they a quick call Saturday night to check in—he was had spent mostly in the car, driving back from Rob’s always really sweet about that—but that barely even parent’s house in the country, but definitely before counted anymore. And the rabbits didn’t come up— their anniversary. She knew because she had slept with that weekend, during their call. She was meaning to the rabbits that night—the night of their anniversary. tell him, to talk to him about them, but what was she Rob had had an exam the next morning, early, and so supposed to do? Drop the rabbits into the conversation he couldn’t stay. The drive would have been too long, straight away? “Oh honey! how was your day? by the back to school the next morning, and he needed the way: rabbits.” rest. It was an important exam. So she had slept alone, But then, after the hellos, their conversation took a the night of their anniversary, with the rabbits curled different turn: something his professor had said that he up in their empty sheets. It was comforting, that was thought she would appreciate, and oh, how that same all. Like a stuffed animal: warm, soft. Sleeping with a professor was getting married—married again, that stuffed animal wasn’t that strange. is—to Professor Horrowitz, did Alexa remember her? That wasn’t the first time she had slept with them Professor Horrowitz from child development, she’d though—the rabbits. She was already used to it by then, started teaching the same semester that Alexa had she remembered. She had been sort of looking forward declared and—yes, yes she did remember her, though to it, actually, when she’d kissed Rob goodbye as he not well, she never did much with child development, left—it was long past ten, and he had done the dishes for and wow isn’t she like, like, twenty years younger her, so all she had to do was fold the pile of laundry, still than him?—and he said that he knew, right? and he sitting on the living room couch, tidy up a bit, undress, guessed that love really was blind, though not as blind and go to sleep. She had been looking forward to it, that as Professor Horrowitz’s husband would be soon, sorry, was the point: getting the rabbits out of their cardboard only joking, a bad joke—she still laughed—and wasn’t box in the closet, where she kept them when Rob was it amazing all these people getting married: even Pete over. Rob had made up for it in the end—their anniver- and Anna had gotten married, and, did you know? sary. He was sweet like that. He had showed up with Franz and Ellie—wait, really? since when?—and soon flowers the next Friday night. They’d made a weekend everyone would be hitched and there’d be no one left, of it. They stayed in all day, both days, watched movies; ha-ha, and that it was time for him to go now. He loved Rob had brought her breakfast in bed. The rabbits had her so much. And where, in all of that, was she going to stayed hidden away then. find time to explain to him how her friend—co-worker— Hidden wasn’t the word Alexa would have used. acquaintance really, had given her two beautiful, white Alexa hadn’t told Rob about the rabbits yet. She rabbits. couldn’t remember the reason. Maybe there wasn’t They really were beautiful. They were small one. She just hadn’t told him. It wasn’t like she was things: soft and innocent, gentle, warm. They made embarrassed about it—she really wasn’t. There was her feel comfortable, just looking at them. And their nothing to be embarrassed about. Plenty of people had eyes could melt your heart. rabbits. Plenty of people slept with their pets. Dogs His kid had won them—he had said—at a fair. But and things. It was good for you. She knew she had his wife, well she had seen his wife at Clarence’s retireread about it when she was still in school—back when ment party: pale and sickly and beautiful—he loved her she and Rob had first met—though why or when she but...Alexa knew how she was. Pretty picky. Doesn’t do couldn’t remember. Rob might have known. They’d well with “rodents.” He needed to find a place for them, been in the same program and he always had a memory and he’d seen them, and well, he said that they’d made for things like that: book titles and birthdays and dates him think of her. So… if she wanted… she could. The and names. offer was always open… But she just hadn’t told him. That was all. They She had taken him up on it. It was an impulsive weren’t even a secret, really—the rabbits. She had thing—she hadn’t even thought to check with Rob. kept them in the closet at first, a space-saving device. Anyway, it was her apartment, and the rabbits were It wasn’t about hiding them. It was a small apartment small. Her co-worker—acquaintance—friend helped after all, and for some reason the closet was practi- her move the box from the back of his car to the back cally walk in—well, not really walk in, but spacious. It of her car. After work, all alone out in the parking lot. was big, that was the point. It had been a good place to No, don’t worry, he had it, he’d moved her hands, the put the box. And anyway, it wasn’t like the door was rabbits’ dark eyes looking up at her. locked—what was one of theirs was both of theirs, they And after that first phone call, when she didn’t tell were both very firm on that—he could have looked Rob, it became harder to bring them up. Rob stayed the inside anytime. She wasn’t hiding them. She just hadn’t night that Monday, but she forgot to mention it—she told him. They had been a gift. really did. She’d been excited to see him, to talk. And Rob had been in the city, at his roommate’s apart- she had fed the rabbits before he came and they got to ment—his apartment, rather—when she had gotten talking about other things, mostly about his work and

11

LITERARY

school, really, and he was already asleep by the time the thought of them crept back into her mind and she got up, careful not to wake him, to check on them and give them food and water. She spent some time sitting in the warm closet, with the soft yellow light on and the door open just a crack, caressing them, gently. He didn’t stir when she got back into bed. He didn’t seem to notice she was gone. The next morning, she was tired and he said he had a headache and they made and ate breakfast almost in silence—a companionable silence, of course, chewing on toast. He took her plate and threw out the last crust, overdone, which she hadn’t gotten around to eating yet, and washed it and downed three Advil. Then he left, back to university for the rest of the week. Just like that it was a secret. Of course, they didn’t keep secrets, but she didn’t try to tell him about them after—she would have had to explain why she hadn’t told him about them before. She would have, of course. Explained it. She would have told him all about it if he had asked. But he never asked, and anyway, they were only rabbits. How long had it taken her to move her late night visits from the closet, to dozing on the floor with the rabbits in her arms, to the empty bed? That was what she could not recall. It was after the first litter had been born. She knew that. Perhaps they were already grown. Had it been weeks? a month or two? since that night in the parking lot. She could not remember. The litter had been large, and largely unintentional. She had named them at first, the two rabbits, Chester and Evan. They were Chester and Evelyn now. Her co-worker hadn’t told her about that. She hadn’t bothered to name their children: eight rabbits in all, all pale white with the same deep dark eyes as their parents. The same eyes which made something go soft down in her chest. There were too many to keep straight. She had told her friend—co-worker— about it and he’d smiled. “Well, I guess you’re a grandmother now.” He’d said. She’d never liked that: when people talked about their pets like they were children. It seemed desperate, sad, but she smiled too. There were so many of them, she’d said. Eight children. “Eight?” he’d said. “Better get rid of some of them, three is too much.” He’d been talking about his own kids, joking. She’d seen them, in the single photograph on the desk in his office, facing inwards, next to the ceramic paperweight in the shape of an apple and a mug full of mismatched pens. The paperweight had a bite taken out of it, sharp edged and glittering in the overhead. She’d laughed at his comment and she wasn’t sure why. Two weeks after that—no, maybe three?—had been her and Rob’s anniversary, and the car ride, and the night alone. So it was somewhere in there then, that she’d started sleeping with the rabbits, that she’d brought them into her bed. At first, it was only once in awhile. When she needed them—they were a comfort—like on the night of their anniversary. Or when she was cold—it was winter after all. And then slowly it was every night. And at first it was only a rabbit or two, but

07 FEB 2020


then she began to worry. She began to worry that the other rabbits perhaps felt unattended to, not suitably loved, that they would wander. And so it became two, and then three, and then it was every rabbit, a pile of smooth white fur and dark sweet eyes, that rose and fell in the night with their collective breath. And it became harder to hide them. Not that she hid them. But it became more obvious that the rabbits were there, in her room and in her bed, and that they were there often, the thick white hairs, first times two, then times ten shedding off and lodging themselves in the cracks in the floorboards, clinging to carpets and to her favorite black dress which she kept hung and ready on the back of the closet door for their dates, just in case—her and Robert’s dates. And then the second litter came. It was not long after the first, but long enough that she had been bringing all of the rabbits to sleep with her at night for some time now, and now there were sixteen, eighteen? Nearly too many to count, all piled in the box in her closet, a wriggling mass of white fur and pink noses and deep, dark, gentle eyes. The box began to stink, began to reek, and so she threw it out in the dumpster, in the parking lot after work. It stank too badly to use her own trash. And she asked if maybe her acquaintance, her co-worker knew how to

THE COLLEGE HILL INDEPENDENT

get the smell of rabbit urine out of a carpet. But instead he smiled and said he had to go. He had gotten them at a fair, remember? His boy had gotten them. He didn’t know much about taking care of rabbits. And she was left scouring the internet before she finally gave up and used baking soda and vinegar and scrubbed and scrubbed the closet and her car and her clothes until they smelled like slightly vinegary urine and still she slept with the rabbits every night— because it was cold outside that December. She got a new cardboard box, and then two more, so there were three boxes filled with rabbits now in her tiny apartment. And she put one in the closet, and one underneath the bed, and another in the pantry, and she insisted on cooking when Rob came over even though she loved it when he cooked. He didn’t mind though. He let her cook, and he did the dishes instead, and he never even came near the pantry. And still the closet smelled. If Rob noticed, he didn’t comment. Anyway, old apartments in out of the way places aren’t known for the fragrant smells. School was busy and so there was too little time to talk about trivial things, and he was gone so fast, and there so infrequently, a few days a week at most, that maybe, possibly, he didn’t even notice the change.

By now all the rabbits were fully grown, and she had lost track which was Chester and which was Evan, or Evelyn, in the wriggling sea of noses and eyes and in the moving of box to box. The next litter was not long to come. Had she wanted to undo what she had done, to give the first two at least back to her co-worker, to have divided up the rest and sold them off or given them away. Had she wanted that, she wouldn’t have even been able to identify the right ones. Still, something prevented her from doing anything at all. She could have done it. She could’ve given them away. It wouldn’t have been that hard. She could have told Rob even, come clean, surely he would have helped—he was sweet like that. But she didn’t and he didn’t and the rabbits stayed and the rabbits multiplied, as rabbits do.

LITERARY

12


Taking 287g Agreements to the Courtroom BY Sara Van Horn ILLUSTRATION Alex Westfall DESIGN Amos Jackson PHOTO Steve Ahlquist

An interview with activist Sherrie Andre

content warning: police violence Late in the summer of 2018, four activists from the facility. I scaled a 26-foot-pole tripod—which essen- wants people to go build the border wall, but his policy FANG Collective, a nonviolent direct action group, tially looks like a camera tripod—and climbed to the top crosses these state boundaries by not allowing people blockaded the entrances to the Bristol County House of of it. The police arrived and were pretty aggressive and to access other people in their community. It’s just a Corrections, a detention facility in North Dartmouth, violently removed me and the other person who was very strange thing. I don’t believe in the borders themMassachusetts. They used cement blocks and hand- on another structure next to me. I personally landed selves, but it’s interesting how it plays out for people painted banners. They scaled 26-foot tripod structures. on my tailbone pretty hard on the pavement. The who benefit from an oppressive system. By preventing the flow of vehicles, they disrupted police officers then proceeded to try to remove my gear, the normal functioning of the facility and created which essentially was just a bunch of men standing The Indy: What are 287g agreements? a powerful, visual reminder of the daily injustices over me with knives as they tried to cut my gear off of happening inside. This direct action protest, resulting my body that was attached to the climb-line to make Andre: A 287g agreement is an agreement between in the arrests of the four protestors, marked the launch sure I was safe. Another police officer proceeded to use local law enforcement and ICE. The sheriff has the of the FANG Collective’s Shut Down ICE campaign, pain compliance to try to get me to remove myself from power to make that decision through policy. The agreewhich seeks to end all collaboration between local law a piece of equipment that I had locked myself to. They ment essentially protects the racist actions of police enforcement agencies and Immigration and Customs eventually removed the poles and dragged my body off officers so they can pick and choose who they would Enforcement (ICE). The action—taken in solidarity to the side and removed my equipment and arrested like to target, arrest, and run a background check to with a hunger strike organized by people imprisoned in me and the rest of the people and brought us to the see if they potentially have any criminal charges— the facility—aimed to shed light on the horrific condi- Ash Street Jail where we tried to express to whatever which police officers do anyway—but also to see if they tions inside the Bristol County House of Corrections. medical professional was there that we could poten- have an immigration status for which they could then Overseen by Sheriff Thomas Hodgson, the tially have concussions and have been harmed. He just be detained by ICE. It’s a way of creating these protecBristol County House of Corrections has received said that we were fine and never examined us. No one tions for police officers to continue to act racist—to national attention over its abusive guards, medical ever asked if we were okay. I was never asked if I was specifically target people of color and black folks and neglect, inadequate food, and lack of mental health okay or if I had been hurt in any way. arrest them under the potential assumption that they care, according to the criminal justice news source would have past criminal charges and then expect the Appeal. Unsurprisingly, Sheriff Hodgson—who The Indy: Why did you choose to be involved in the them to be held accountable for these charges in a has famously sent ICE detainees at the Bristol County action? different way after they have served their time. I say House of Corrections to help build President Trump’s this without feeling like people should have to serve southern border wall—is facing lawsuits and inves- Andre: One of the reasons I chose to participate in time in jail at all, but in general, because this is the tigations over the mistreatment of people impris- that action is that I come from a mixed-status family. system that we have, that is how the 287g agreements oned inside his facility. The Bristol County House of A lot of my family members are from Southeast Asia or act out these protections and this continued racism in Corrections also has extremely high suicide rates. Portugal and it was important to me to target a facility the criminal justice system. Bristol County is one of three counties in New that has a 287g agreement with ICE that the people England with a 287g agreement, a legal contract that within my immediate family—but also within the The Indy: What are the best ways to end these agreedeputizes local law enforcement to act as immigration immigrant community of Providence—would poten- ments? And what is the importance of direct action in agents within their jurisdictions. This allows police tially be impacted by. They would potentially be sent this campaign? officers to question people about their immigration to the Bristol County House of Corrections. It was status and detain people on immigration charges. The important to me to do something about that, to raise Andre: These agreements can be ended at any time. Massachusetts Department of Corrections also has awareness about how that specific county has a 287g It’s very simple. The people within their own commua 287g agreement. Additionally, Bristol County has agreement which essentially deputizes sheriffs so that nities need to hold their elected officials accountable an Intergovernmental Service Agreement (IGSA), a they can arrest and detain people on behalf of ICE. A and let them know that they are not interested in these federal contract in which local jails and prisons provide lot of people that I’ve been working with locally and agreements existing and harming the people both in space for the detention of undocumented people. (The in community groups have gone through that process their immediate community and the communities Wyatt Detention Facility in Central Falls, Rhode Island and have been held at the Bristol County House of that are neighboring them. The best way to start that has also faced increasing protests and public outrage Corrections. I don’t live in Massachusetts, but they is education: being aware of whether you have a 287g over its IGSA agreement.) have been holding people who are residents of Rhode or IGSA agreement, determining who the person was One of the activists from the FANG Collective, Island that the Wyatt Detention Facility can’t hold. who made that decision, making sure that person is Sherrie Andre, will go to trial in the New Bedford very aware that you do not want this agreement, and District Court on March 4th and 5th. Co-founder of The Indy: How do you understand this action being working with other elected officials—who have more the FANG Collective, Andre is facing up to 30 days important to the Shut Down ICE campaign? clout—to get that person not to make these agreements. in jail for their involvement in the nonviolent direct I think direct action plays a role here because there action last summer. The College Hill Independent talked Andre: This was not the action that we participated are people like me who don’t always benefit from this with Andre about why they chose to participate in the in to raise awareness about these conditions. We did unjust system because of my racial identity and how protest, the role of direct action in the Shut Down ICE a lot of community-building and had conversations I navigate the world. In some ways, I’m very aware of campaign, and the importance of organizing around a with people who were impacted by this facility, but it the privileges I do have, but I’m not always going to culture of care. was the first direct action that we had done to launch have access to elected officials or be taken seriously for our Shut Down ICE campaign with the hopes that it whatever reason, whether it be gender, race, or age, just +++ would bring more attention to that particular facility because those biases exist. I’m never going to get into a and Sheriff Hodgson and how he essentially runs this room or sit down for a conversation where my thoughts The Indy: Could you talk about your experience in facility in a way that people are harmed. There are high and opinions are taken very seriously, but I also believe the nonviolent direct action last summer and, if you’re rates of suicide, high rates of solitary confinement, that as a person who currently has bodily privilege and comfortable, your experience with Sheriff Hodgson and people who don’t receive their medication. We the ability to take action, I should. I want to utilize the and the police? wanted to raise awareness for people who don’t realize resources that I have, which isn’t a lot. I can’t hire a that even though this facility is in Massachusetts, it’s lawyer to sue, I can’t vote in Massachusetts to vote that Sherrie Andre: Last summer, I participated in a nonvi- still impacting people who are here in Rhode Island. sheriff out, and I can’t have a say in public hearings as olent direct action where a group of people deployed And I think it’s just an interesting and ironic thing that to whether I agree to these agreements, because I’m structures to blockade the exits and entrances of the Sheriff Hodgson believes so strongly in borders and just not taken seriously. So the best thing I can do is to

13

METRO

7 FEB 2020


around providing support and not organizing around a campaign. For people to observe and respect that is so important and valuable in our movement work. I feel like it gets undervalued. There are literally tons of people organizing around providing support not just for me, but for everybody who is going to be in that courtroom that day. I just think this is like a learning moment for myself included, and for everyone doing this work, about the ways we can shift how much we’ve been utilizing action culture to actually enact a culture of care. And if people are interested in joining some sort of care team, they can email contact@thefanguse my body in a way that I can raise awareness about collective.org. And people can write letters of support. these unjust conditions. There’s a generated one that people can just sign their name, but writing personal ones are also helpful for The Indy: What has your experience been through the me. And if people are interested in supporting undoculegal process? their own counties? mented people, people can donate to AMOR [Alliance to Mobilize Our Resistance] or join one of AMOR’s Andre: It’s been awful. But it’s also awful for lots Andre: If people are interested in fighting these agree- teams if they are local to Rhode Island. Support other of other people who are going through the system ments, I would say a few things. The first is just know groups or local teams that provide this kind of support who don’t have as much support as I have. I'm very who your people are. Be very aware that the ways to undocumented community members. Do anything. privileged to have an entire team of people who are in which they will surveil you or intimidate you are Do anything. Please. supporting me through this process. In some ways, much different than the ways that you are prepared to direct action makes people put you on this pedestal deal with. So, just make sure you are very clear with The Indy: Anything else you’d like to emphasize or when you don’t need to be. There is no reason for that who your people are so that you still feel safe in your highlight? to exist when there are lots of people in this system community when other people outside of it are trying who are not given the attention and resources that to make you feel like you don’t have any power or the Andre: I just want people to be aware that these they deserve, so it’s good to acknowledge that too. I’m ability to make change. Also, determine how much you agreements exist—and they might exist where you the only one who is going to trial to fight the 10-day are willing to lose and give up doing this work because live—and that we can still fight them. Even though sentence. My lawyer seems hopeful, but I’ve just been there are so many people who have been doing this Sheriff Hodgson and other people who are in positions in the courtroom so many times—and not even how work for so long who don’t have a lot of the things that of power are able to make decisions through policy, it I’ve been treated, I’ve just seen how they treat other you would imagine a 'normal life' quote unquote would doesn’t mean we have to accept them. And we don’t people in the courtroom in that system so awfully that look like. Come into this work humbly and recognize have to accept how they are implemented in a harmful I don’t really have as much hope as my lawyer. But for that people have already sacrificed so much for you way. me, it’s another way to raise awareness about these even to participate and just create space for that within agreements and Sheriff Hodgson and how awful he yourself. And if you’re somebody who has been doing +++ is and how he is the person who is making these deci- this work for a really long time and are really interested sions—not only for Bristol County but for other coun- in shifting your targets and the work that you’re doing, Sherrie Andre’s court date was originially scheduled ties—and is also just a really racist person. don’t give up, even though it’s really hard. It’s going to for January 7th. On the morning of their trial, more get very hard, and it’s very scary, but remember that than 100 people showed up in support. Yet despite the The Indy: My understanding is that you’re contesting everybody is so appreciative. preparation of both Andre’s legal team and the prosethese charges by going to court. Why are you going to cution, the judge inexplicably postponed the trial and trial? The Indy: What kind of community support are you court officers agressively removed all supporters from looking for? the courtroom. To show up in solidarity with Andre, Andre: I’m going to trial because it’s definitely a privcome to the New Bedford District Court at 8:30am on ilege to be able to engage in process even if it’s not Andre: I think it would be great if people are able to March 4th and 5th. To show written support for Andre, always the most just. It’s another opportunity to raise come to the trial to support me but also to support the you can sign an online petition or submit a letter of your awareness about these 287g agreements and ICE’s other people in the courtroom who are going through own to Support@ShutDownICEnow.org. To donate or involvement with Bristol Country and how Sheriff the court process that day. So don’t feel like you have join the FANG Collective’s Shut Down ICE campaign, Hodgson is the person who makes these agreements to spend the whole time in the trial with me. Feel free visit shutdownicenow.org. with ICE that impact people who don’t have a say as to to move about the court and sit in and bear witness to whether or not they even agree to how that will impact what is happening to other people. We’re also asking This interview has been lightly edited and abridged for their community. people, if you are coming and if you are able, to bring clarity. cash to help pay other people’s fines who are going The Indy: What advice would you give activists around through the court that day. It’s also just an inter- SARA VAN HORN B’21 wants to see another packed the country who are looking to end 287g agreements in esting time to see so many people I love organizing courtroom.

THE COLLEGE HILL INDEPENDENT

METRO

14


THIS LAND, THIS LAND, THIS LAND BY Isabel Guarnieri ILLUSTRATION Leslie Benavides DESIGN Ella Rosenblatt

As a small crowd of us huddle on the cold stone stair- blueprints, and images with an emphasis on the munic- Revolution have been erased from popular history. case, Lynsea Montanari—a Narragansett visual artist— ipal government that span from its 1636 founding to According to Trouillot, every historical narrative opens the night with a song. To honor the space we are the present, according to the city website. Something contains a bundle of silences. This silencing occurs in, she explains. As Lynsea starts to sing, the atrium troubled Anna about the call, even made her hesitant at four stages: the making of sources, the making of of Providence City Hall seems to deepen her bellows, to apply—the prompt made no mention of indigenous archives, the making of narrative, and the making of amplifying how her voice rises and falls. Your spirit is history, and required no engagement with Native what we call “history”—or what is granted “official” watching over me, I know you are in the sky, she sings voices. Realizing she was not in the position to channel retrospective significance. And these silences build on in Narragansett three times: for the past, the present, that identity herself, Anna reached out to the Director each other. A historical narrative skews when certain and the future. of the Tomaquag Museum, Loren Spears, with whom voices or populations are excluded in the creation of We were all gathered that evening, January 23, she’d worked with in the past, to see if the Museum archives. Entire histories can go unwritten, and for 2020, for the opening of an exhibit in the Gallery at would partner with her during the residency. Spears many, forgotten. Providence City Hall, entitled “All That You See Is(n’t) redirected Anna to her niece, 24-year-old visual artist What Lynsea encountered in the City Archives’ Yours.” The collaborative mixed-media installation and Narragansett language activist Lynsea Montanari. 40,000 cubic feet of records was a gaping hole, an features the work of two artists: Lynsea Montanari, a Together, Anna and Lynsea faced a daunting task: absence that mirrors the silencing of Native history student at College Unbound from the Narragansett use the City Archives, a source of historical knowl- and voices in museums, school curricula, and history Tribe, and Anna Snyder, a white RISD alumna who edge shaped by the structures of power that continue textbooks across the United States. To make up for the spearheads projects at the intersection of public art to marginalize Narragansett and other Native peoples, silence, Lynsea turned to other sources, conducting and education in Providence. Their exhibit marks the to create an exhibit that would represent Colonial oral histories with her grandmother, who passed away inaugural ACT Public Art Residency, a partnership Providence in all of its violence and complexity. while research for the exhibit was underway. Oral between Providence’s Department of Art, Culture, + For six months, Anna spent about 15 to 20 hours histories are a research method often employed by Tourism (ACT) and the Providence City Archives. The a week in the City Archives, combing through town queer, Black and feminist scholars to move beyond the project, according to the official press release, aims to meeting minutes and city logs. She struggled to make limits of the current archive and re-center personal “infuse artistic practices...into the operations of the sense of the dull records—not sure yet what narrative narratives that have been marginalized from maincity.” The residency is built for artists to work with and she was trying to tell. But again and again, Anna came stream historical discourse. This in-family archive within the City Archives to craft a public art exhibition across an obsession with borders and demarcating supplemented the research Lynsea’s family took on in response to a prompt. space—map after hand-drawn map scrawled with collectively using sources like religious texts, allowing This year, the ACT’s prompt was “Colonial “Stephen Dexter’s land” or “Joseph Williams’ land.” her to explore themes like spirituality, family, and the Providence,” understood to begin with the founding She was stunned by the banality of these entries, the concept of generations. of Providence in 1636. State-sponsored narratives of “violence made boring” that was concealed in layers of Colonial Providence tend to center around the figure city bureaucracy. “It just looked like a city entry,” Anna +++ of Roger Williams and the importance of religious told me. “But what it actually means is that someone freedom, as Rhode Island was the first colony with is dying, or being removed from their source of food.” “All That You See Is(n’t) Yours” is divided in three a secular government. But this focus obscures the Suddenly, it all became clear. Lynsea and Anna agreed sections across the second floor of City Hall. While the displacement and massacre of Indigenous tribes that on an overarching theme to frame the exhibit: property, residency was shared, Lynsea and Anna created most preceded Providence’s founding. The official press and the juxtaposition between Indigenous concepts of pieces individually to explore distinct themes based release states that Lynsea and Anna’s exhibit “inter- collective ownership and the colonial violence of land on their archival sources; Anna relying on material rogat[es] the City’s complex colonial legacies.” But theft and appropriation. from the white colonist archives, and Lynsea using her the artists’ pieces, infused with their own identities Lynsea approached the prompt quite differently. family and other research to delve into Native history and interests, do far more than that—they raise ques- She brought her grandmother to the archives to help and spirituality. The two collaborated on one piece, in tions about the silences in the archive and expose guide her research, but found it did not have the infor- which Lynsea painted a colorful watercolor of a birch the tensions inherent to telling a story about Native mation she was looking for. Lynsea was most inter- forest over which Anna laid black-and-white colonial displacement in the seat of city power. ested in how to represent not just a period of history, houses. The piece, “A Cluster of Colonial Houses,” but a people—especially Indigenous women, chil- visualizes settler colonists’ encroachment on Native +++ dren, and elders. Rather than what she called Anna’s land, but is also representative of larger clashes in the search for “concretes,” or documents related to land exhibit: white and Native, monochrome and color, When the ACT Public Art Residency program publi- and materials, Lynsea was looking for indigenous archive and stories, nature and property. cized a call for artists in late 2018, it caught Anna’s voices, which the City Archives lacked. “We have been In one corner of the atrium hang Lynsea’s three attention straight away. A graduate in printmaking so dehumanized throughout history,” Lynsea told me, portraits exploring Indigenous and colonist spiritufrom RISD, she recently went back to school to pursue stepping away from the gallery opening, “I felt that ality. Two are in vivid color and portray distinct intera degree in History at the University of Rhode Island. what I needed to share was stories.” pretations of the Manitou, a spirit that inhabits all life. She had just taken a whole semester’s worth of courses The archive is not a neutral collection of histor- One of the paintings, entitled “Manitou,” depicts a about the history of Colonial Rhode Island and knew ical records. Michel-Rolph Trouillot’s seminal work face carved into a tree trunk, surrounded by a ring of that background would be invaluable in the archive. “Silencing the Past” examines the power relations pink and blue flowers. The painting recalls the historThe Providence City Archives on the fifth floor of inherent in the production of historical knowledge, ical practice of carving Manitou statues into trees and City Hall holds a collection of manuscripts, maps, interrogating how monumental events like the Haitian utensils, a way, according to the exhibit guide, “of

15

ARTS

07 FEB 2020


Exhibiting visual narratives of Narragansett indigeneity and settler violence in the house Colonial Providence built.

manifesting the spiritual world into our physical world.” of private land ownership. As detailed in an essay by Providence we live in today. I wonder if public art funcLynsea imbues the painting’s details with the memory Brown Ph.D Candidate Alexandra Peck about the tioning within the institution of the city and the state of her grandmother, using a holly tree that shares her game’s history among Native tribes in Rhode Island, can ever reconcile this. As Eve Tuck and K. Wayne name and carving the names of her grandmother’s hubbub players gambled valuable belongings—such Yang write in, “Decolonization Is Not a Metaphor,” the children into its trunk. Speaking at the exhibit opening, as wampum beads and longhouses, using the game to language of decolonizing schools and art museums Lynsea makes constant reference to her grandmother: redistribute wealth and resources across the commu- obscures that actual decolonization necessitates the “grandmothers are what ground us in our community.” nity. Staged against Anna’s pigs and fences, the juxta- physical and literal repatriation of Indigenous land and Lynsea’s art practice is rooted in love­­, fusing personal position between family and individual, collective and life. details into larger Native imagery to portray herself private, becomes even more striking. I ask both Lynsea and Anna about where they and her family as part of a community that has been see hope in the exhibit. I ask how they tried to imbue and still is here. +++ it in the work, perhaps because I want so badly to find On the opposite side of the room, Anna and it too. And it is there, especially in the stories of interLynsea’s pieces are staged against each other to high- In my interviews with Anna and Lynsea, and my generational love and community that Lynsea paints light distinct conceptions of private and collective time at the exhibit opening, I feel a recurring sense and sculpts, a sense of reclaiming history and making ownership.Anna portrays the takeover of Native land of discomfort about the exhibit site itself. How can an Native art for and by Native people. Telling stories in large, shallow wooden boxes hanging on the wall that exhibit about settler violence against Native peoples of Indigenous history and present affirms and, for start open and unbound, but become more segmented. ignore the history of the very land it sits on? The offi- outsiders, acts as an essential reminder that Native The sections in the boxes create little cubbies, where cial press release and exhibit guide do not mention people are still here. “It is so difficult to talk about Anna placed hand-painted pigs and models of colo- this gap—another silence that builds on thousands of how you are oppressed today when people don’t even nial infrastructure like fences. Pigs became a point of others. know you exist,” Lynsea tells me with a joking frustrafascination for Anna throughout the project—another I am not the only one that notices this discrepancy. tion. “Our stories are still untold. Just speaking them object she kept encountering in the archive that When Lynsea stands to speak at the gallery opening, into truth is activism.” For Anna, the exhibit explains seemed mundane but was symbolic of how settler colo- she welcomes the audience by addressing the tension history in a way that she hopes will translate into a call nists thought they were entering an untouched world. directly. “Thank you all for coming today to the land to action, especially in relation to the global climate Brought by colonists from Europe, pigs were destruc- of the Narragansett people,” Lynsea states. “I know crisis in which indigenous activists have been on the tive forces on Native land, she explained, destroying we don’t talk about it a lot, but here and everywhere forefront of demanding an overhaul in global climate crops and food stores and causing long periods of that you are walking is Indigenous land, not only in policy. “In order to survive the climate crisis, we need starvation over the winter months. For Lynsea, the Rhode Island but in America.” The group of about 20 to adopt how Native people interact with the earth and symbol of the pigs also resonated as one of careless people gathered on the staircase—friends, family, and planet,” she explains, “Indigenous knowledge is the violence. Speaking at the exhibit opening, she offered, the City officials that had helped bring the exhibit future if we are smart enough to listen.” Anna hopes “Everyone cares about the big things. But when you together—nod in acknowledgement, many exclaiming that the audience of the exhibit will make the connectalk about capturing a life, small things like pigs can be loudly in support. I sense a somberness in the air—a tion between history, the art, and how its significance so harmful.” I think about what Anna told me about mix of gratitude and pride with an acknowledgement touches now and extends into the future. But there is so the “violence made boring'' she encountered in the of where we are, and what art can speak to but never much that remains unsaid. In order to start to fill these archive, how it reduced Native land displacement to resolve. silences, Native people need to be brought, intentioncounting livestock, or marking borders. In her piece, Public art is free and accessible, a model that often ally and continuously, to the forefront of constructing she transforms the mundane into sinister characters— works to counter the institutional obstacles posed by art nuanced and complete histories. the fences appear large and industrial, the pigs almost museums, which are often expensive and perceived as After both Lynsea and Anna speak, and give their demonic in black-and-white. Here, the pigs stand in for spaces reserved for the elite. According to Providence’s thanks, Lynsea’s family—mother, father, aunt, and the colonists: leaping and bounding over uncharted “Art in City Life Plan,” dedicated to increasing public siblings—gather on stage. As Lynsea’s father beats a land that gets split up as they multiply. art and encouraging collaboration between artists and drum, the eight of them sing a song that he explains Enclosed in a glass case in front of Anna’s box of the city, the plan aims to shape Providence’s visual means We are still here. Together, they sing it through works, Lynsea has crafted seven hubbub bowls—one identity, improve quality of life for every resident, and three times: past, present, and future. for her and each of her siblings—used for the tradi- strengthen community ties. However, as a venue for a tional gambling game of hubbub. According to the public art residency, City Hall presents numerous chal- ISABEL GUARNIERI ‘20 thinks you should go see this exhibit guide, the face of each bowl contains distinct lenges. As Anna pointed out to me, Providence’s City exhibit for yourself. imagery from Narragansett stories, whether that be Hall is only open on weekdays from 8:30 in the morning the stars of Orion’s Belt or the crow, that are inspired until 4:30 in the afternoon, excluding an audience that by each of her sibling’s personalities and demonstrate works any day job. Moreover, many communities are All That You See Is(n’t) Yours is on view at Providence how “we bring spirituality into everything we do.” not comfortable voluntarily walking into the seat of City Hall until March 16th. Seven is more symbolic than just the number of chil- city authority. Lynsea’s relationship to City Hall is even dren in Lynsea’s family. Rather, she explains that she more complicated. “This space is not special to me.” has been taught to make an impact long after she is She affirms, “This was Indigenous land; this was all gone, to always think of the next seven generations. Indigenous land.” An exhibit about Native land exproThe physicality of the bowls—a hint of movement and priation in City Hall cannot and does not even pretend play—also ground Colonial Providence as linked to that it aims to change this reality. her lived experience and present rather than an intanThere are many people who have the privilege gible history. In an exhibit setting, the bowls are also of not thinking about history; colonists have not a reclamation of how Native peoples’ everyday objects taken their land, erased their languages, or enslaved are co-opted into museum spaces as items for display their ancestors. History has, in fact, enriched their to be gazed upon and explained. By recreating hubbub lives in a million invisible ways and built the founbowls as artistic pieces, and making them explic- dation of the position in the world they occupy today. itly personal, Lynsea’s work has a clear audience: her History, to many, can be categorized and segmented family and her community. The symbolism of the off­­—delineating a certain period of time that constihubbub game also directly contradicts conceptions tutes “Colonial Providence” as if that differs from the

THE COLLEGE HILL INDEPENDENT

ARTS

16


TWO RALLIES BY Anchita Dasgupta and Peder Schaefer ILLUSTRATION Eliza Macneal

chapter of the Kashmir Solidarity Movement (KSM)— night who stressed the transformational potential of a that originated in Indian-occupied Kashmir, which Sanders presidency. Speakers included students from continues to resist a brutal 30-year-long military occu- Brown University, the Community College of Rhode pation by India. In organizing the protest with KSM, Island, Providence College, and local high schoolers the event recognized that the idea of freedom means from the MET School. A number of students were different things for people who identify with India organizers with Sunrise, the climate justice advocacy and acknowledged their right to not participate in any movement, reflecting the bottom-up, activist roots of As New Delhi witnessed Brazilian dictator Jair aspect of the stand-in that does not align with their much of the Sanders campaign. Bolsonaro, Chief Guest of India’s 71st Republic Day beliefs. The keynote speaker was Palestinian-American military parade, walk down the streets flanked by Meanwhile, not far from Brown, the South Asian human rights activist Linda Sarsour, founder and India’s Hindu nationalist Prime Minister Narendra community at Harvard University also observed director of the Arab-American Association of New Modi, protests against the government’s new citizen- Republic Day by organizing a 24-hour tag-team protest York, a co-chair of the 2017 Women’s March, and a ship law surged across the nation. January 26 is usually at Harvard Square. Ruha Shadab, a graduate student longtime Sanders supporter. Last year, Sarsour spoke a commemoration of the adoption of the Indian in Public Policy at the Harvard Kennedy School, spoke at Brown University in support of the student-led Constitution and the country’s entry into its post-co- about the “organic nature” of the event which, she movement urging the Brown Corporation to divest lonial period. But this year, it was observed as a day of claimed, did not have a core organizing team but was an from companies profiting from human rights abuses in mourning by Indian students—both across the country all-hands-on-deck effort by its supporters. “Everyone Palestine. and in the diaspora—as they gathered across university gave it their all,” said Ruha, who added that cartons “Nothing about what Bernie Sanders is fighting for campuses singing songs of resistance and demanding of samosas were brought and shared by the protestors is radical,” said Sarsour, responding to a widespread freedom from fascist oppression by the Hindu nation- during a day that was celebrated through songs, poetry, belief that Sanders’ politics are pushing the Democratic alist government. and speeches against Hindu nationalist fascism. Ruha party too far to the left. “There’s nothing radical about A vigil titled “Stand in for the Pro-Democracy emphasized the significance of the protest lasting 24 the idea that everybody deserves healthcare… [or] high Movement in India” and organized by a handful of hours, which had a turnout of over 200 students at its quality public education [or] a $15 dollar minumum South Asian students from Brown University and the busiest hour and a minimum of six at other times. wage.” She said that the day after a Sanders inauguraRhode Island School of Design reiterated this sentiOrganizers of both events expressed that they tion (which she would proudly attend), she would be ment as they stood on the steps of Faunce House, were hopeful for the future and thought it was unlikely protesting outside the White House to ensure that his protesting the rise of fascism under India’s current that the movement would fizzle out. “This [law] affects presidency remained a movement of the people. Hindu nationalist regime. More specifically, they us fundamentally,” said Ruha. “It is hard to become After the event, Alex Gourevitch, a professor of protested against the new Citizenship Amendment Act complacent.” Meanwhile, students at Brown and RISD Political Science at Brown University, asked attendees (CAA) of India, which has come under fire for making have said that they plan on hosting teach-ins on the law to sign up to canvass for Sanders’ campaign in New religion a basis for extending citizenship in the country in the upcoming months to continue building on the Hampshire in the days leading up to the primary elecand raising legal obstructions to Muslim refugees’ momentum the movement has gained internationally, tion on February 11. Speakers throughout the night, a pathway to citizenship. Since December 12, the day the while trying to build cross-campus solidarity among number of whom had canvassed before, spoke of the Act was adopted by the Parliament, students, women, the South Asian student diaspora in the US. direct impact canvassing can have on those who might intellectuals, and working-class members have taken When asked about the significance of this dias- not otherwise go to the ballot box on election day. to the streets demanding a revocation of this act which poric mobilization, Kushagra Agarwal, a sophomore at Mary Paolino, a retired elementary school teacher they believe violates the secular ethos of the Indian Brown said, “this matters because the Indian govern- who worked in the Providence Public School system, constitution. ment cares about its public image in the US.” Indeed, said that she hadn’t been so excited for a candidate Echoing a practice that has grown increasingly if the pressure against the Act continues to mount as since Robert Kennedy ran for president in 1968. She popular across student protests in India, the gath- it has over the last two months—both at home within said that Sanders' support for human rights separated ered students collectively read the Preamble to the India as well as in the diasporic community—it seems him from the other candidates and that she would be Constitution in an effort to remind the government of unlikely that the government will be able to persist in canvassing for him in New Hampshire in February. the founding ideals of the Constitution that this law its indifference to student protests. In the shadow of a contentious political period— undermines. The gathering also sang Hum Dekhenge, with ongoing impeachment proceedings, rising white an Urdu ghazal written by the poet Faiz Ahmed Faiz nationalism and fears of an imperial presidency—the to protest the military dictatorship of General Zia Ul Sanders rally offered a vision of a brighter political Haq in Pakistan, which has become the anthem of the future. In 2016, Sanders beat Hillary Clinton in the anti-CAA student protests. Rhode Island Democratic primaries by over 15,000 The protest began with a minute of silence for the votes. Sanders supporters at the rally hope to repli26 people who had lost their lives to police violence cate those margins in 2020 and support the Sanders while protesting the new law, and was followed by campaign throughout New England, including next students sharing personal reflections on the law. Aryan Stepping up to the microphone at a student rally week’s New Hampshire democratic primary where Srivastava, a sophomore at Brown, talked about how supporting Bernie Sanders last Tuesday, James Callow, Sanders leads in the most recent polling. the student protests in India have created an opportu- a student at the Community College of Rhode Island, nity for young people to engage with the Islamophobic told the crowd the heartbreaking story of his mother’s PEDER SCHAEFER ’22 and ANCHITA DASGUPTA ideas held by a sizeable majority of the older genera- passing from a preventable form of cancer. Callow, ’21 enjoy watching videos of Bernie shooting hoops. tion and break down the institutionalsized hatred for only 16 at the time of his mother’s death, said she the Muslim community of India. was confronted with a choice: sell the family home The event also included a call and response to to fund treatment, or keep a roof over her son’s head “Azaadi,” a chant—led by a representative of the Brown and hope for the best. “That is the world that we live in today,” said Callow, a field organizer for the Sanders 2020 campaign. “Those are the problems that Senator Bernie Sanders is fighting to address.” The rally was hosted by student organizers of the Rhode Island Students for Bernie coalition at the Columbus Theater in Providence. Students and activists from across the state were attracted by Sanders’ promise of a political revolution in America that will fundamentally shift politics. Emotions in the room were high, with hundreds of attendees riveted by an array of speakers—student activists, academics, and organizers—throughout the night. “Another world is possible,” said Jennifer EppsAddison, the president of the Center for Popular Democracy and one of the keynote speakers. “We’re not just here to return to the status-quo…We’re here building this movement, supporting candidates who will walk side by side with us to help us build the country of our dreams.” Epps-Addison echoed speakers throughout the

University students organize against the rise of fascism in India

RI students organize Bernie rally

17

NEWS: BYTES

07 FEB 2020


This Spring, X is looking to publish a wide range of image- and hybrid text-based work. Mediums can be photo, documentation of sculpture or painting, and basically whatever can get printed on our page. While not all pieces must fit within this loose theme, this semester we are interested in the ideas of home, placemaking, and belonging, as well as those of diaspora and identity. We accept and encourage all forms of work—please don’t hesitate to send any work or email your preliminary idea to theindyx@gmail.com.

THE COLLEGE HILL INDEPENDENT

X

18


the list is back!

fri 2.7

2.7 - 2.13

They Might Be Giants Columbus Theatre, 270 Broadway 9PM It’s the 30th anniversary of Flood’s release, the album that every middle school social studies teacher lost their virginity to. Come out to hear the crown gem of the nerd rock genre, alongside circuit board-soldering hobbyists, eBay bidders, and dads with plastic-framed glasses. Sorry, no kids allowed! (The show is 16+.)

sat 2.8

sun 2.9

RI Labor for Bernie Meeting Knight Memorial Library, 275 Elmwood Ave 3PM If you are a union member, join Providence DSA to help pass a resolution in support of Bernie with your local. The event will also help build a base for the political revolution post-2020. And if you’re not in a union but still interested in organizing for Bernie before the RI primary on April 28, join RI for Bernie which is currently collecting signatures to get Bernie on the ballot.

NOH8 photoshoot Jala Studio Yoga & Art, 285 S Main St. Started in 2009 in support of marriage equality, NOH8 has been plastering duct tape over the mouths of celebrities for over a decade. If you’re a member of the Glee cast or support the right to marry, this may be the event for you. This is also a great opportunity for a professional headshot, so long as having silver duct tape over your mouth in it isn’t a deterrent.

mon 2.10

tue 2.11

The Time is Already screening and training Acoustic Java Café and Microcinema, 204 South Main St. The Time is Already, a new film directed by Providencebased filmmaker Selene Means, will be followed by aW training on legislative advocacy for LGBT rights by several Providence organizations. The film and training are particularly relevant in the wake of the South Dakota House of Representatives passing HB 1057, a law barring medical profession from offering hormones, puberty blockers, or any other gender-affirmative procedures to patients under 16.

The Evolving Image of Shaker Life John Hay Library at Brown University, 20 Prospect St. Join historian Rob Emlen for a talk about the perception of the Shakers. In the nineteenth century, Americans learned about the celebate Christians through printed matter; today, I enjoy their rustic furniture and chunky knits. As I always say: I don’t want to be part of any utopian society that would have me as a member.

wed 2.12

thu 2.13

Alexander Herbert and T. Bloodhound Riffraff bookstore and bar, 60 Valley Street, Unit 107A Alexander Herbert, a doctoral student at Brandeis and the author of What About Tomorrow: An Oral History of Russian Punk from the Soviet Era to Pussy Riot, will speak about punk culture and its politics. He will be musically accompanied by songwriter T. Bloodhound.

DiscoTech 002 The Parlour, 1119 N Main St. This is the second in a new monthly series showcasing Providence House music. Come sweat out your Friday Night freaking Fever with HUGE and Sex on Decks.

In December, the Independent published “Save the BCSC,” an op-ed by Brown alumni standing in support of student activists fighting for transparency in administrative practices to uphold the mission of the Brown Center for Students of Color. That piece was accompanied by a list of signees to the writers’ petition, which they invite all supporters to sign at tinyurl.com/ AlumniBCSCPetition. An updated list of signees since December appears below. Aditya Kumar ‘13-‘17 Alexandra Wells Alexandrina Agloro, '01-'05 Alysha Aziz Amelia Anthony Ana Rosa Marx Angelica Johnsen, B’14-18 Anne Fosburg, '13-'17.5 Anne Zhao, '15-'19 Anthony Walley Arisa Lohmeier '10-'14 Arthur Sun, '18.5 Asante Crews '13-'19 Becki Marcus '16-'20 Bee Vang Belinda Zhou, '13-'17 Bethany Hung, '15-'19 Bianca Camacho '12-'16 Brian Elizalde, '15-'19 Brian Lin, '08-'12 Brittany Hodges ‘17 Brownsyne Tucker Edmonds, AB ‘00/MD ‘05

Camera Ford ’12–’16 Jason Sperber, ‘92-’00 Oluwatomisin Onabanjo Victoria Kidd, Carlos Aramayo, ‘10-‘14 Jenny Li Oren Karp '12-'16 Carmen Zheng ‘15-‘19 Jess Brown, ‘12-’16 Paige Aniyah Morris, ‘12-16 Wendy Castillo, Chahney Young Hinds, ‘08-’12 Jieyi Cai '13-'17 Paloma Orozco Scott '18 ‘11-‘15 Christine Shio Lim Julian Chan, ‘88-’92 Paul Tran ‘10-‘14 Yasmin Toney Cici Osias Justice Gaines, ‘12-’16 Rafael D. González Cruz Yvonne Diabene ‘19 Clare Kim, '11-'15, MAT '16 Justin Williams, ‘08-’12 Rahil Rojiani 09-13 & many others Clarion Heard, ‘08-’13 Justine Stewart '11 Rakan Aboneaaj who have shown Courtney Hoggard ‘15-‘19 Kara Roanhorse '14- '18 Ralanda Nelson '12 support in their Daniel Prada, ‘08-’12 Katelynn Pan Reva Dhingra '14 own ways Devika Girish, ‘17 Katherine Ferguson, ‘14-17 Rishi Wagle Donovan Dennis '16 Keith Catone, '00 Roksana Borzouei ‘13-‘17 Emilio Leanza, '11-'15 Kshitij Sachan Ruhan Nagra, '06-'10 Emily Sun '14 -'18 Lily Meyersohn Ruth Miller, '15-'19 Emily Yoshioka ‘15-‘19, Lina Lalwani ‘15-‘19 Saba Shevidi, ’16 MPH ‘20 Lytisha Wyatt ‘11-‘15 Sabrina Whitfill ‘19 Erin Malimban ‘15-‘19 Malcolm Shanks, ‘07-’11 Sam Jones, '14-'18 Evelyn Nimaja, ‘11-‘15 Manuel Contreras '16 Sana Teramoto Ezza Ahmed Marc Briz '14 Sandra K Haley, PhD '17 Gabriela Àlvarez Mari Yoshihara, '92 MA, Sarah Day Dayon, ‘11-’15 Gareth Chen, '13-'17 '97 PhD Sharina Gordon, ‘09-’13 Gavriel Cutipa-Zorn, ‘08-’12 Matthew dang 17.5 AB ScB Sierra Edd '14- '18 Gio Santiago Maya Finoh, '13-'17 Sofia Robledo Rower Grace Mano Micaela Burgess, ‘13-‘17 Soyoon Kim Héctor Peralta ‘12-‘16 Nancy Truong, '13-'17 Stephanie Harris, ‘10-’14 helen mcdonald Natasha Go, ‘06-’10 Stephanie Medina '10-14' Hisa Hashisaka, ‘10-’14 Natasha Lewis ‘96-‘00 Tala Doumani ‘17 Isissa Komada-John ‘10 Naveen Srinivasan, '15-'19, '19-'20 Tamica Ramos-Robinson ‘00 Iyad Owen-Elia ‘17.5 Nicolas Montano, 13’-17’ Tho Phan ’07-’11 J. Kirkland Ricw '12-'16 Nicole Parrish Maldonado, ‘08-’12 Tyrah Green Jacob Alabab-Moser '16-'20 Nicole Ubinas, ‘14-‘18 Uche Onwunaka, '15-'19 Jacquelyn Silva '06 -'10 Nikkolette Lee '14-'18 Urska Manners '00 Jada Pulley '12-'16 Nour Asfour ‘18 Veda SunkaraB'19B'20 Jamie Meader ‘17, MAT ‘18 Olivia Moscicki, '14-'18 Victoria Huynh, '15-'19


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook