Skip to main content

World Fertilizer March 2022

Page 37

MAGAZINE | MARCH 2022

Decarbonization Options for Syngas Plants Using Green & Blue Hydrogen Through Benchmarking

Base case benchmark Conventional efficiency improvements Green H2 process upgrades Blue H2 technology upgrades Reduce OPEX, higher life cycle production & CO2 credits


50 Years of Specialized Multistage Pump Solutions

Engineering Pumps for Better Performance and Longer Life As the largest independent pump rebuilder in the world, Hydro is committed to its customers – not to a brand. Extensive experience with a wide range of pumps, engineering expertise and an unwavering commitment to quality have made Hydro a trusted source of comprehensive pump support for the fertilizer industry. 24/7 Emergency Services l Engineered Pump Repairs l Certified Performance Testing Wireless Condition Monitoring l Engineering Services l Critical Parts Solutions State-of-the-Art Technology l In-depth Knowledge of Major Brands Field Service l Support for Installation & Start-up l Customer Training

Worldwide Service Centers l 800.223.7867 l hydroinc.com


CONTENTS 03 05 10

Comment World News Conflict In Ukraine Causes Urea U-Turn

30

In the wake of the Russia and Ukraine military conflict and following months of price increases, Sophie Mason, Argus Media, UK, considers what may be in store for the urea market this year.

Film Protection Against Corrosion

Andre de Bache, Kurita Europe, Germany, demonstrates how water and energy savings were realised at an ammonia plant in the Netherlands through the use of film-forming products that form a hydrophobic barrier against corrosive agents.

FILM PROTECTION AGAINST CORROSION

CONFLICT IN UKRAINE CAUSES UREA U-TURN

Andre de Bache, Kurita Europe, Germany, demonstrates how water and energy savings were realised at an ammonia plant in the Netherlands through the use of film-forming products that form a hydrophobic barrier against corrosive agents.

H

igh-pressure (HP) steam systems in ammonia plants are characterised by high heat flux densities in several waste heat boilers in the ammonia production process, which makes proper water and steam treatment essential. Traditional treatment programmes usually combining ammonia or alkalising amines with phosphate and dispersants are frequently applied. Some plants additionally use reducing agents, such as carbohydrazide (CHZ) or diethyl hydroxylamine (DEHA), to keep the dissolved oxygen concentration in the lower ppb range and so avoid any chance of oxygen corrosion.

Kurita’s Cetamine® technology, based on film-forming substances (FFS) combined with low volatile and high volatile alkalising amines, removes the need for reducing agents and inorganic treatment programmes, such as phosphates or caustic. The FFS adsorbs onto metal/metal oxide surfaces to form a hydrophobic film or barrier, which prevents corrosion by stopping water and other corrosive agents from contacting the metal/metal oxide surface. Furthermore, the thin film fosters the formation of a smooth and compact iron oxide layer.1 Film-forming products (FFP) based on FFS or film-forming amines (FFA) are increasingly being used as

In the wake of the Russia and Ukraine military conflict and following months of price increases, Sophie Mason, Argus Media, UK, considers what may be in store for the urea market this year.

U

rea prices have increased substantially over the last 18 months, from lows of US$230/t in June 2020 to US$900/t in December 2021 at FOB Black Sea, quadrupling to highs of US$1000/t at CFR India at the market’s 2021 peak. Prices had been undergoing a downwards price correction in the first two months of 2022 as anticipated. And Argus viewed 2022 as a year where events and uncertainty in global gas markets would either allow nitrogen prices to adjust downwards, or recreate conditions where nitrogen prices are pushed back up towards record highs. We had expected the former,

but the latter is almost a certainty given the military conflict between Russia and Ukraine. Nitrogen markets, like those for other bulk commodities, are cyclical and mean reverting. They move through alternating supply- and demand-driven pricing phases and, like other commodities, are typically supplydriven. The urea market entered a demand-driven pricing phase in 2H21 when a year-long bull run in the grains markets kicked off and increased global fertilizer demand. The global economy had started its gradual recovery from COVID-19 and demand for commodities was growing again.

10

17

10

11

35

Steam Reforming Catalysts With Flower Power

Stefan Gebert and Scott Osborne, Clariant Catalysts, explain how a new generation of flower-shaped steam reforming catalysts are driving productivity in syngas production.

23

27

30 31

30

A Helping Hand

Mads Feddersen, Haldor Topsoe, Denmark, shows how, in lieu of recent revolutionary technological breakthroughs, production capacity at existing ammonia facilities can be increased through the addition of heat exchange reforming technology.

Fertilizer’s 2030 Mission

Urvi Mathur, Neelam Aqua, India, explains how the use of enhanced efficiency fertilizer can help the world to achieve the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals by 2030.

41

45

Granular Modelling For Granulation Plants

Edward DeRose and Robert Tinsley, Hatch, USA, explore the creation of a process simulator capable of producing a numerically rigorous mass and energy balance for an ammonium phosphate granulation plant.

Healthy Soil For A Rich Harvest

Thomas Lansdorf, Eirich, Germany, discusses the current trend towards fertilizers in granulate form and explains why a combination of soil improvers and fertilizers can provide a significant and lasting boost to harvest yields.

‘Dirty Sulfur’ Pump Problem-solving

Jan Hermans, Sulphurnet-Liquid Sulphur Processing, the Netherlands, and Martha Villaseñor, Weir Minerals Lewis Pumps, USA, offer advice on how to overcome the challenges presented by ‘dirty sulfur’ pumps for smoother operation.

MAGAZINE | MARCH 2022

Decarbonization Options for Syngas Plants Using Green & Blue Hydrogen Through Benchmarking

Base case benchmark Conventional efficiency improvements Green H2 process upgrades Blue H2 technology upgrades

ON THE COVER

BD Energy Systems, LLC (BDE), a world leader in turnkey revamp solutions, is based in Houston, Texas, US. BDE’s success comes from highly experienced engineers with more than 300 years of combined experience specialising in syngas plants and fired equipment technologies. BDE has executed >275 successful projects globally in ammonia, methanol, hydrogen, GTL of various licensors, executing syngas plant studies providing decarbonisation options for existing syngas plants using green and blue hydrogen through benchmarking. Scan the QR code on the front cover to access a technical article.

Reduce OPEX, higher life cycle production & CO2 credits

Copyright © Palladian Publications Ltd 2022. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner. All views expressed in this journal are those of the respective contributors and are not necessarily the opinions of the publisher, neither does the publisher endorse any of the claims made in the advertisements. Printed in the UK.

like World Fertilizer

join World Fertilizer

follow @WorldFertilizer CBP006075


COMMENT CONTACT US MANAGING EDITOR James Little james.little@palladianpublications.com

SENIOR EDITOR Callum O’Reilly callum.oreilly@palladianpublications.com

DEPUTY EDITOR Nicholas Woodroof nicholas.woodroof@palladianpublications.com

EDITORIAL ASSISTANT Jessica Casey jessica.casey@palladianpublications.com

SALES DIRECTOR Rod Hardy rod.hardy@palladianpublications.com

SALES MANAGER Ben Macleod ben.macleod@palladianpublications.com

PRODUCTION Freya Anderson freya.anderson@palladianpublications.com

ADMINISTRATION MANAGER Laura White laura.white@palladianpublications.com

DIGITAL ADMINISTRATOR Lauren Fox lauren.fox@palladianpublications.com

DIGITAL EVENTS COORDINATOR Louise Cameron louise.cameron@palladianpublications.com

VIDEO CONTENT ASSISTANT Molly Bryant molly.bryant@palladianpublications.com

Palladian Publications Ltd, 15 South Street, Farnham, Surrey GU9 7QU, UK Tel: +44 (0) 1252 718 999 Website: www.worldfertilizer.com

SUBSCRIPTIONS World Fertilizer (ISSN No: 2398-4384) is published 8 times a year by Palladian Publications Ltd, UK. World Fertilizer Subscription rates: Annual subscription: £50 UK including postage £60 overseas (postage airmail) Two year discounted rate: £80 UK including postage £96 (postage airmail). Subscription claims: Claims for non receipt of issues must be made within 3 months of publication of the issue or they will not be honoured without charge.

NICHOLAS WOODROOF, DEPUTY EDITOR

A

war “that we thought was only to find in history books” was the comment of one German minister on Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.1 Of all the responses from Western politicians to the crisis, this seemed particularly striking. It indicated a cast-iron belief, perhaps bordering on complacency, that land warfare in Europe was a thing of the past, something that happens elsewhere. President Vladimir Putin has shattered this notion. Along with the horrendous images and stories of human suffering that are populating our newsfeeds, another consequence of the invasion has been disruption to the global supply of key commodities from Russia. The skyrocketing price of oil and gas will not have escaped the attention of many, but the potential impact on food security is cause for greater concern. As readers of World Fertilizer will be aware, many countries source considerable quantities of fertilizer and raw materials vital to fertilizer production from Russia, as well as its ally Belarus. A statement by Svein Tore Holsether, President and CEO of Norway’s Yara International – whose office in the Ukrainian capital Kiev was hit by a missile on 26 February (thankfully no-one was physically harmed) – encapsulated a key strategic dilemma: ‘Russia and Ukraine are world powers in a global and fragile food system…the biggest sources of raw material to Europe’s food production are being subject to limitations, and there are no short-term solutions…cut[ting] off Russia from international food chains…may have considerable social consequences.’2 For all of the West’s sanctions, this reality of dependency cannot be wished away overnight; greater shortages and higher potash, urea and ammonium nitrate prices – compounding the effects of the energy crisis – seem inevitable for farmers for as long as war continues, sanctions are escalated and Russia and Belarus are treated as pariah states by the international community. Governments must focus on doing what they can, diplomatically and economically, to weaken the Russian state and bring an end to the war as quickly as possible. But policymakers, strategists and industry would also do well to consider how the dominance Russia and Belarus have established over these crucial supply chains can be permanently overturned, as challenging as the consequences may be. Despite the grim situation in Ukraine, some optimism can be drawn from the waning severity of the COVID-19 pandemic in many parts of the world. International travel and in-person events are feasible once again. World Fertilizer will be attending the CRU Nitrogen + Syngas Conference & Exhibition in Berlin this month, and I’m very much looking forward to meeting fellow delegates and learning about the latest developments in the nitrogen and syngas industries.

References 1.

2.

BBC News, ‘Ukraine conflict world reaction: Sanctions, refugees and fears of war’, https://www.bbc. co.uk/news/world-europe-60507016 (24 February 2022). HOLSETHER, S.T., ‘War and food crisis in Europe’, https://www.yara.com/news-and-media/news/ archive/news-2022/war-and-food-crisis-in-europe/ (01 March 2022).

MARCH 2022 | WORLD FERTILIZER | 3


REVAMPING. INCREASED CAPACITY, OPTIMIZED QUALITY.

EXCEED YOUR MAX Do you believe that you have already achieved maximum capacity? Do you think that it is simply not possible to create a better prill? Or have other people told you this? For many existing prilling towers there is potential for a significant increase in performance. So think again, and exceed your max.

Discover your Revamp Potential Find out what the modernization of your prilling equipment can offer you at:

KREBER.NL/REVAMP-POTENTIAL-SCAN

Get advice from a prilling expert +31 (0) 10 248 02 22 • info@kreber.nl • www.kreber.nl


WORLD NEWS BRAZIL Verde to reach 3 million t potash production capacity in 2022

V

erde AgriTech has started work to double the capacity of its second production facility, currently under construction (Plant 2), located in the Brazilian state of Minas Gerais. Verde will also upgrade local infrastructure to sustain Plant 2’s increased output and enable a future Plant 3 (Expansion Plan). Plant 2 is on track to start production in 3Q22, and the enlarged production capacity is expected to be in operation in early 4Q22. Verde expects to start construction on Plant 3 in 2023, depending on permits. In the face of recent geopolitical events involving Russia and Ukraine, notably the collateral impact of economic sanctions on Russia and its ally Belarus on the potash supply to Brazil, Verde’s Board of Directors has unanimously approved an accelerated investment programme to sustain the Expansion Plan. Plant 2 is on track to reach commercial production of Verde’s multinutrient potassium products, BAKS® and K Forte® sold internationally as Super Greensand®, by 3Q22 with an initial operational capacity of 1.2 million tpy.

The company will simultaneously work on the Expansion Plan with two core objectives: firstly, to expand Plant 2’s operational capacity from 1.2 million tpy to 2.4 million tpy by 4Q22, and secondly to upgrade local infrastructure to sustain Plant 2’s logistics with added capacity to enable a future Plant 3. By 4Q22, with Plant 2’s expansion, Verde expects to have raised its overall production capacity to 3 million tpy, becoming Brazil’s largest potash producer. On 10 February 2022, the company received a further 2.5 million tpy mining concession, bringing the total capacity now fully permitted to mine to 2.83 million tpy. Brazil ranks second in global potash consumption and first in imports. The country relies on imports for more than 96% of its potash needs. In 2021 Brazil’s consumption of potash (in K2O) was 7.92 million t, which is equivalent to 79.2 million t of Verde’s Product. The market stood at 3.99 million t (in K2O) in 2010 and 2.71 million t (in K2O) in 2000, reflecting Brazil’s growing agricultural production.

INDIA Nuberg EPC to construct brownfield NPK plant

N

uberg EPC has been contracted by Fertilisers And Chemicals Travancore Ltd. (FACT) to construct a brownfield 1650 tpd NPK plant on an EPC-LSTK basis. FACT, a Government of India enterprise, is one of India’s first large-scale fertilizer companies. The NPK plant is being built within FACT’s existing manufacturing facility of Cochin Division (CD) at Ambalam Edu in Ernakulam district in the state of Kerala, and will increase the total production capacity of complex fertilizers to 3650 tpd. Nuberg EPC will execute the project based on Pre-Neutralizer with Pipe Reactor (PN+PR) technology licensed from INCRO S.A. (Spain). The plant will be capable of producing various grades of NPKs. The company is taking up the project on an LSTK basis and the project is scheduled to be completed by mid-2023. The plant will be primarily designed to produce NPK 20:20:0:13, having a rated capacity of 75 tpd in a single stream from PN technology and DAP 18:46:0 using PN+PR technology, and meeting FCO requirements using ammonia, phosphoric acid, sulfuric acid, urea, filler etc. as required. In addition to the above two grades, the company

will carry out the design and detailed engineering of the plant to enable future production of different grades of NPKs, such as 10:26:26, 16:20:0, 28:28:0, 12:32:16, and 14:35:14 using ammonia, phosphoric acid, sulfuric acid, muriate of potash, urea etc. as required for meeting FCO requirements. In October 2021, Nuberg EPC was awarded two sulfuric acid plant projects in Gamasa City, Egypt, and Oromia, Ethiopia. The 500 million tpd and 5 MW Rating STG Set in Egypt and 50 tpd sulfuric acid and 40 tpd aluminium sulfate revamp project in Ethiopia were won on an EPC and LSTK basis. The Egypt project is scheduled to be delivered in 22 months and the Ethiopia project in 15 months from the contract LC opening date. The projects will draw upon Nuberg EPC’s sulfuric acid technology, Double Contact Double Absorption (DCDA), and execution capability. In this process, the product gases sulfur dioxide (SO2) and sulfur trioxide (SO3) are passed through absorption towers twice to achieve further absorption and production of higher-grade sulfuric acid. MARCH 2022 | WORLD FERTILIZER | 5


WORLD NEWS NEWS IN BRIEF HIGHLIGHTS

MOROCCO Koch to acquire 50% stake in Jorf

Fertilizers Co. III from OCP

K

och Ag & Energy Solutions (Koch) and OCP have signed an agreement under which a Koch affiliate will acquire a 50% interest in Jorf Fertilizers Co. III (JFC III) from OCP. When closed, the transaction will establish a 50/50 joint venture. JFC III owns and operates an integrated phosphate fertilizer production facility in Jorf Lasfar, Morocco, with the capacity to produce up to 1.1 million metric tpy

Nutrien anticipates prolonged fertilizer supply disruption from invasion of Ukraine Grupa Azoty subsidiary implementing ammonia plant upgrade Casale to design new ammonia converter for Yara facility Geotechnical drilling completed at site of Cabinda phosphate project Yara completes divestment of Salitre phosphate mining project to EuroChem

of phosphate-based fertilizers. JFC III is one component of the Jorf Fertilizer Complex, the world’s largest phosphate fertilizer production platform. JFC III’s production will be marketed by OCP and Koch Fertilizer, LLC. Additionally, the companies will collaborate on the supply of ammonia and sulfur to OCP and leverage their logistical capabilities for the shipment of fertilizers from Morocco.

RUSSIA Togliattiazot suspends transit of ammonia

T

he Russian company Togliattiazot (TOAZ) has said that due to the situation in Ukraine it has decided to suspend the transit of ammonia, citing concerns about the safety of people living near the Togliatti-Odessa ammonia pipeline. TOAZ has shut down operation of four ammonia units and put three ammonia units into a reduced load mode. The company has said that ammonia production will continue in the quantity sufficient

to ensure the internal production of urea and urea formaldehyde concentrate, as well as to ensure fulfillment of all obligations to the consumers of ammonia, shipment to whom is performed by railway. The rest of the production facilities at the company’s industrial site, as well as all auxiliary services, are operating normally. The company has said it is working on alternative ways to deliver to consumers, including increasing railway shipments.

Visit our website for more news:

US Waggaman ammonia plant undergoing repair work

www.worldfertilizer.com

I

6 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

ncitec Pivot Ltd. has said that investigations into an incident at its Waggaman, Louisiana, US, ammonia plant have confirmed that a rupture occurred in a section of pipe, resulting in a release of hydrogen. Extensive investigations have revealed only minor damage

to surrounding equipment, and repair work is primarily focused on the damaged spool piece. Analysis indicates that the damage mechanism is limited to this section of pipe. IPL expects it will take between 6 and 8 weeks to complete the repairs and restart the plant.


WORLD NEWS DIARY DATES Fertilizer Latino Americano 2022 21 – 23 March 2022 Miami, Florida, US events.crugroup.com/ fertilizerlatinoamericano/home

CRU Nitrogen + Syngas 2022 28 – 30 March 2022 Berlin, Germany events.crugroup.com/ nitrogenandsyngas/home

CRU Nitrogen + Syngas USA 2022 02 – 04 May 2022 Tulsa, Oklahoma, US events.crugroup.com/nitrogenusa/ home

66th Annual Safety in Ammonia Plants and Related Facilities Symposium 11 – 15 September 2022 Chicago, Illinois, US aiche.org/conferences/annualsafety-ammonia-plants-andrelated-facilities-symposium/2022

Turbomachinery & Pump Symposia 2022 13 – 15 September 2022 Houston, Texas, US tps.tamu.edu/

ANNA 2022 02 – 07 October 2022 Houston, Texas, US an-na.org

To stay informed about the status of industry events and any potential postponements or cancellations of events due to COVID-19, visit World Fertilizer’s events page: www.worldfertilizer.com/events

GERMANY First drillhole completed at South Harz Potash’s

Ohmgebirge licence

S

outh Harz Potash has announced that drilling of the first of two confirmatory drillholes within the Ohmgebirge Mining Licence (Ohmgebirge) area of its potash project in Germany has been successfully completed. The first confirmatory drillhole, OHM-02, was designed to twin and confirm the results of the historic drillhole, Kal Wr 6 Liese, which was drilled in 1906. This historic drillhole recorded potash within the Staßfurt Potash Horizon from a depth of 651.7 m to 657.20 m (5.5 m thickness) with an historic reported grade of 14.4% K 2O. Drilling of OHM-02, located 115 m west of the historic drillhole, has been safely completed to a final depth of 718 m, in order to fully penetrate the known Staßfurt Potash Horizon. Critically, OHM-02 intercepted the top of the Staßfurt Potash Horizon at 651.3 m, which is effectively the same depth as recorded in the historic drillhole. It also showed excellent stratigraphic correlation with the historic hole. The intercept returned in OHM-02 extended

to a depth of 666.54 m. The core from OHM-02 is being prepared ahead of despatch for assay with results expected to be received in approximately 4 weeks. Downhole geophysics are also set to be conducted on OHM-02 prior to the final grouting of the drillhole. Drilling of the other confirmatory drillhole, OHM-01, is scheduled to be completed by late April, having been delayed by harsh weather, with assays likely to be received by mid/late May. Drilling and assay of core from the two confirmatory drillholes is intended to allow South Harz to upgrade a substantial proportion of the current Ohmgebirge JORC (2012) Inferred Mineral Resource estimate to the Indicated category. Subject to concurrent and satisfactory advancement of all modifying factors, this is expected to allow the release of a comprehensive Scoping Study. The Scoping Study is expected to be completed during June 2022, provided there are no further unforeseen technical delays.

UK Anglo American to invest £440 million in Woodsmith

polyhalite project in 2022

A

nglo American has said that investment in the Woodsmith polyhalite project in North Yorkshire, UK, in 2022 is expected to be around £440 million (US$584 million) as the company further develops the detailed design engineering, with expected changes to the phasing of work, particularly at the Woodsmith mine site near Whitby. Anglo American invested nearly £390 million (US$518 million) in the project in 2021, with excavation of the

8 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

mineral transport tunnel from the mine to a processing plant in Teesside passing 18 km by the end of the year, beyond the intermediate access shaft site at Lockwood Beck. The tunnel will be 37 km long once complete. The Lockwood Beck shaft is complete, having reached its target depth of 383 m, and shaft lining is currently under way. At the mine head itself, shaft boring has started in the services shaft, while progress is also being made on the production shaft infrastructure.


Designing our future together Stamicarbon: Pioneers in developing and licensing state-of-the-art fertilizer plants For more information visit: www.stamicarbon.com

BLAKE ARNOLDS, 4 5th Generation farmer

SAM ARNOLDS, 43

C-COMMUNITY STAMICARB8002

4th Generation farmer


CONFLICT IN UKRAINE CAUSES UREA U-TURN In the wake of the Russia and Ukraine military conflict and following months of price increases, Sophie Mason, Argus Media, UK, considers what may be in store for the urea market this year.

U

rea prices have increased substantially over the last 18 months, from lows of US$230/t in June 2020 to US$900/t in December 2021 at FOB Black Sea, quadrupling to highs of US$1000/t at CFR India at the market’s 2021 peak. Prices had been undergoing a downwards price correction in the first two months of 2022 as anticipated. And Argus viewed 2022 as a year where events and uncertainty in global gas markets would either allow nitrogen prices to adjust downwards, or recreate conditions where nitrogen prices are pushed back up towards record highs. We had expected the former,

10

but the latter is almost a certainty given the military conflict between Russia and Ukraine. Nitrogen markets, like those for other bulk commodities, are cyclical and mean reverting. They move through alternating supply- and demand-driven pricing phases and, like other commodities, are typically supply-driven. The urea market entered a demand-driven pricing phase in 2H21 when a year-long bull run in the grains markets kicked off and increased global fertilizer demand. The global economy had started its gradual recovery from COVID-19 and demand for commodities was growing again.


11


US plants in February and September and cut US urea supply by an estimated 1.2 million t. By October, urea demand requirements were high enough to force buyers to pay higher urea prices and bring idled EU producers back into production. Indian import buying was the primary driver of prices in 2H21. Indian production fell in 2021, and new plants it had hoped to put in to production severely underperformed. But once seasonal Indian demand had subsided in January 2022 and EU gas prices had retreated below US$30/million Btu, prices began a swift and ongoing downwards correction. Figure 2 compares previous urea pricing cycles with the events of the last 18 months. Argus has adjusted the historical time series for inflation, converting the prices in constant 2021 US dollars. This shows that despite hitting an all-time nominal record in current dollars last year, it was not a real record. The real record in inflation-adjusted constant dollars was set at the top of the 2008 price peak, on the eve of the global financial crisis. Whether we would see a repeat of the collapse that followed was at the forefront of people’s minds. The macro background remained inflationary and the global economy had shown no signs of a sustained contraction. Perhaps more interesting will be the effect this period of high gas and nitrogen pricing Figure 1. Natural gas prices, weekly average, 2019 – January 2022. Source: Argus Natural Gas has on the industry’s reports. capital investment patterns. The future of heavy industry and the role it will play in country and company net zero strategies is being increasingly questioned, especially in the EU. Discussions within the fertilizer industry were already underway and have largely centred around the high costs of bringing ‘green’ ammonia to market. The recent run-up in nitrogen prices has, perhaps, made these costs look more tolerable. And the uncertainty and risks that Figure 2. Urea pricing cycles, 1986 – 2022, basis FOB Black Sea prilled. Source: Argus Urea surround both current Analytics. Corn prices peaked in July 2021 and, initially, so too did urea prices. But at this point, extraordinary events in the gas market shifted urea into a supply-driven pricing phase where record gas prices (as can be seen in Figure 1) began to make European and Ukrainian nitrogen production uneconomical, swiftly forcing many producers to idle production and be pushed out of the market. China’s own energy crisis starved domestic urea producers of coal, causing supply concerns and leading to state intervention. The government ordered an effective urea export ban, initially limiting exports for 9 months. Russia followed suit and introduced fertilizer export quotas for 6 months that would cap exports at 2020 levels and prevent incremental production from leaving the country. The weather also played a role in limiting urea production. Winter storms and a hurricane closed

12 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022


and future global gas supplies may be making a move to green production methods and a more fixed cost base more attractive, despite the costs involved. After all, there is a likelihood of future increases to both direct carbon costs, as well as the potential for growing indirect costs incurred through higher risk premiums being placed on the hydrocarbon industry’s cost of capital.

Urea outlook for 2022 Urea’s bull run to US$1000/t last year had market stakeholders questioning if we were set to see a repeat in 2022 or if the price correction we had been tracking would be sustained. Prior to the military conflict between Russia and Ukraine, we had not expected to see a repeat of 2022 for several reasons. Urea prices began a downwards correction at the start of 2022, following the conclusion of, what was thought to be, India’s final tender for the 2021/2022 season. Producer length, as new capacity finally ramped up, and buyer hesitancy, in the absence of any immediate demand requirements, weighed heavily on January and February 2022 prices. The extent of the urea price rise last year resulted in demand destruction in several key markets and minimised early seasonal requirements as a result. By mid-February, the market was yet to find its new equilibrium point and even an unexpected Indian tender did not provide the price support producers had been hoping for. We did not expect price stability to be found until prices corrected enough to incentivise purchasing for the spring planting season and natural gas prices in the northern hemisphere would set the price floor. At the end of 1Q22, and the start of the summer injection season, the level of required restocking was expected to prevent a normalisation of gas prices to below US$10/million Btu. Support from gas fundamentals was to negate the downwards pressure arising from the oversupply of urea which could come to market with the return of Chinese exports by the end of 2Q22 and new capacity additions. And urea prices looked set to

remain above US$400/t during the summer months under previous EU gas price assumptions. Beyond the summer months, gas markets were likely to tighten once again, assuming no new meaningful supply from Nord Stream 2 or that existing or new European assets would contribute to the European gas balance. And urea prices would rise, but not to the extent that they did in 3Q21 and 4Q21. Besides the considerable volume of new capacity to be commissioned in 2022, several of the key consumers that fuelled the rapid price escalation, such as India and the US, will not feature as heavily in the import market in 2H22 as they did last year. India’s domestic production is rising following the commissioning of Ramagundam and the start of gas flow to Matix Fertilizer’s unit. In light of this, new capacity for 2022 and the long-term agreement signed between India’s RCF and Oman’s OQ Trading, India’s tender requirement for 2022/2023 will be reduced by as much as 3 million t. And in the US, though supportive crop price levels can be attributed to the substantial rise in US import demand in 2021, a large portion of the tonnes bought ahead of typical buying seasons were to cover production losses brought about by weather events. These factors remain true. But the reaction within the energy markets to current events and the threat of loss of supply from Russian and Ukrainian producers means the forecast outlined above no longer holds true. Urea prices were the first to react to the escalation, with Egyptian values rising some US$200/t, and the potential for further price rises has to be considered.

Sanctions so far…

On 24 February, the conflict in Ukraine escalated far beyond Argus’ expectations. The immediate impact on fertilizer markets has been limited in terms of physical supply disruptions, with the exception of ammonia, but huge in terms of psychological shock, greatly increasing the risk profile of fertilizer trade. Booking freight from Russian ports is looking to be an early and growing problem and may result in Russian producers offering discounts on FOB sales to offset from risk premiums faced by vessels loading at Russian ports. The impact of the removal of Russia from the SWIFT financial transaction system and the sanctioning of Russian banks on Russian fertilizer sales is uncertain. Many Russian producers process fertilizer transactions through Swiss trading subsidiaries, and Argus is unsure of how these will be affected in the short run. Figure 3. Average European producer costs, US$/t. Source: Argus Fertilizer Analytics. 14 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022


J&H EQUIPMENT INC.

The World Leader in Vibrating Wire Screens SBS Screen Feeder

MOD 3 Vibrating Screen With Hopper

Bucket Elevator Head Section Chain Mill

Electromechanical 3-Way Splitter

The J&H engineering team has over 45 years of experience in material handling, priding itself on swift solutions to client needs.

J&H Equipment Inc.

140 Sunshine Way, Alpharetta, GA 30005 Phone (770) 992-1606 | Fax (770) 992-1983 Web Site: www.jhequipment.com


But despite no direct sanctioning of Russian fertilizer trade and EU ports remaining open to Russian cargos, we are already seeing impacts on fertilizer shipping decisions. Nominated vessels are loading as normal, but the fixing of future fertilizer cargos appears increasingly problematic for Russia. We are already hearing reports of ‘self-sanctioning’ as some Western companies that would normally be importing Russian fertilizer pre-empt tighter sanctions. Only sales to those European or American buyers worried about the optics of taking Russian fertilizer cargos would likely be affected by this, but others outside of the EU may also be growing concerned about the extraterritorial effects tighter US sanctions are likely to have. Russia exported 6.52 million t of urea to world markets in 2021, according to Russian customs data, down from 7.05 million t in 2020. Some 40% of its 2021 exports – 2.64 million t – went to EU/UK markets and the US. Blocking these exports would create huge difficulties for both Russian exporters and European importers. Both would struggle to find alternative destinations and origins in the short-term. Replacing prilled urea for non-fertilizer use would present the greatest problem for European and US buyers. Replacement supply of granular urea, however, would be less of a problem given the large export capacities of producers in North and West Africa.

Gas markets are already pricing in risk premiums, with implications for nitrogen producers

LEADING PROCESS TECHNOLOGY FOR OUR FUTURE ↘ WASTE HEAT RECOVERY SYSTEMS ↘ WASTE HEAT BOILERS for ammonia, methanol and hydrogen plants

↘ SYNLOOP WASTE HEAT BOILERS for ammonia plants

www.borsig.de/pro BORSIG Process Heat Exchanger GmbH Phone: +49 (0)30 4301-01 Fax: +49 (0)30 4301-2447 E-mail: info@pro.borsig.de Egellsstrasse 21, 13507 Berlin Germany

The European gas market has pre-emptively priced in a risk premium of around US$10/million Btu, moving from the mid-US$20/million Btu range to the mid-US$30/million Btu level. This will disproportionally affect the nitrogen industry, given the industry’s gas-based cost structure and that EU nitrogen producers have been setting the industry’s marginal cost over the last year. In Figure 3 we have analysed the impact of the premium EU gas markets are currently pricing in at TTF hub (Netherlands) on European nitrogen producers. We have assumed pre-conflict TTF gas pricing at US$25/million Btu and post-conflict at US$35/million Btu and US$45/million Btu, with carbon priced at US$80/t CO2e in all instances.

Initial thoughts as US and EU sanctions ratchet up As sanctions on Russia expand, all fertilizer products will face upwards price pressure should sanctions directly target fertilizer HS codes, fertilizer producers or their owners. Any limits on Russian exports will make global fertilizer markets less efficient. This means that buyers within the sanctioning jurisdictions – EU, US, UK, Japan et al – will lose bargaining power as the pool of available sellers decreases with Russia and Belarus’s enforced absence. Longer journeys to less-optimal markets will also reduce Russian producer netbacks. In addition to any trade disruption, ammonia, urea and other nitrogen fertilizer prices will undergo a substantial cost-push as the risk premiums on gas increase the industry’s marginal cost of supply. And actual disruption to Russian gas flows have the potential to push gas prices and nitrogen costs higher still.


Steam Reforming Catalysts With Flower Power Stefan Gebert and Scott Osborne, Clariant Catalysts, explain how a new generation of flower-shaped steam reforming catalysts are driving greater efficiency in syngas production.

S

team methane reforming is the most common method used to convert hydrocarbon feedstocks like natural gas (mainly consisting of methane) into synthesis gas (syngas), which is a mixture of hydrogen, carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide. At the heart of this process is the steam methane reformer. The reforming furnace consists of numerous vertical tubes 10 – 14 m in length loaded with a nickel-based catalyst and externally fired by a number of burners. The location of the burners may be at the top, bottom or sides of the reformer, depending on the process design licensor. Within a reformer, each of the vertical tubes can be considered as a separate reactor running in parallel with the others. A major challenge for syngas producers is that the steam reformer is extremely cost-intensive. Firstly, the extreme temperatures (up to more than 900˚C) needed for the reaction require the use of expensive materials for the furnace and tubes. Additionally, the endothermic reforming reaction requires an intense amount of heat to be transferred into the tubes, placing a significant burden on a syngas plant’s energy and OPEX. 17


Catalyst quality is critical As catalysts are fundamental to the reforming reaction, their quality has a direct impact on the costs and efficiency of a syngas plant’s processes. To ensure optimal production of syngas, steam reforming catalysts must fulfil several system needs.

Activity

Figure 1. ReforMax 330 LDP steam reforming catalyst.

The most fundamental requirement is high intrinsic and apparent catalyst activity. The intrinsic activity is impacted by several factors, including concentration and dispersion of the active metal (nickel), the composition of the carrier material and the interaction between nickel and the carrier. Additionally, the apparent activity of the catalyst, as determined by parameters such as geometric surface area, pore volume and pore size distribution, plays a very important role in the reforming reaction.

Stability Due to the extreme operating temperatures required (which often approach tube material limitations), preventing nickel sintering and resultant catalyst deactivation are vital to the long lifetime of both the catalyst and reformer tubes.

Figure 2. ReforMax 330 LDP Plus steam reforming catalyst.

Mechanical strength Whenever the plant undergoes shutdown or start-up procedures, the reactor tubes experience thermal cycling in which they may expand or contract to a greater degree than the enclosed catalyst particles, putting extreme localised strain on the catalyst. For this reason, it is essential that the steam reforming catalyst exhibits excellent robustness.

Pressure drop

Figure 3. Increased void fraction. 18 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

A syngas plant can have up to several hundred reformer tubes. Throughout the lifetime of the catalyst charge, all tubes need to maintain the same low pressure drop level to ensure favourable reformer performance. An increase in the pressure drop will typically lead to an increase in syngas compression energy consumption in a downstream ammonia or methanol synthesis loop. Furthermore, the pressure drop limits the gas throughput through the steam reformer, which can


result in a bottleneck for the syngas production capacity. Consequently, a catalyst that lowers the pressure drop is preferred.

Shape and formulation impacts Other favourable catalyst characteristics include those that improve heat transfer in the catalyst bed and offer high resistance to carbon formation. Catalysts differ in particle size, aspect ratio of height to diameter, void spaces in holes and external channels, as well as in the packing property between their particles. All these shape characteristics impact the geometric surface area and, as a consequence, the activity of the loaded volume, as well as the pressure drop across the catalyst bed. While these factors can be enhanced through shape optimisation, it is also important to maintain a high overall crush strength as one of the key constraints. A high-performing steam reforming catalyst supports the lowest possible methane content at the tube outlets, thereby increasing the hydrogen yield and reducing the energy costs associated with the inert level and purge of an ammonia or methanol synthesis loop. Furthermore, good catalyst performance is required to ensure low tube wall temperatures (TWT), and therefore a long tube lifetime.

Original catalyst series Nickel catalysts have been used for many decades in commercial steam methane reformers. Among these is Clariant’s ReforMax 330/210 LDP series, which was

designed with the goal of lowering the pressure drop. The 10-hole shape (Figure 1) also provides an optimal balance of geometric surface area and uniform radial crush strength, leading to enhanced activity, extended catalyst lifetime, reduced TWT and consistently low methane slip. The individual catalyst particles are composed of active metal nickel oxide applied on a calcium aluminate-based carrier. The high content of irreversibly formed hibonite (CaAl12O19) included in the carrier chemistry contributes greatly to the catalyst particle’s mechanical strength. Due to its robustness, the catalyst is also able to withstand poisoning (carbon formation) to a certain extent, as it can be quickly regenerated through steaming. The catalysts have consistently demonstrated strong performance in industrial applications for a large variety of process designs and feed conditions. Currently, more than 230 ammonia, methanol and hydrogen reformers globally operate using the LDP catalyst series.

New catalyst series The company recently developed and introduced its next generation of steam reforming catalysts. The ReforMax 330 LDP Plus series is distinguished by an 8-hole, flower-like structure (Figure 2), which represents an improvement over its 10-hole predecessor. While the new series preserves the activity levels and durability of the original, it can also significantly reduce the pressure drop, thereby raising production efficiency. As before, plant operators have a choice of non-promoted (ReforMax 330 LDP Plus) or lightly alkalised (ReforMax 210 LDP Plus) versions of the catalyst.

The Doyle and EMT Alliance

Can provide you with all the Blending, Bagging and Transport equipment you need.

High Speed Bagging Line

Weighcont Blender

* Capacity of 20 to 200 ton per hour. * Unlimited number of hoppers. * Computer controlled. * Custom built.

Fertilizer Inhibitor Treating Unit * Portable. * Stainless steel. * Computer controlled. * High Capacity 120 m³ per hour.

EMT

Molenpad 10, 1756 EE ‘t Zand The Nederlands. Tel.+31 (0) 224 591213 email: emt@emt.tech www.emt.tech

* For big bags - jumbo bags. * Capacity 50 to 70 ton m³ per hour. * 120 kg to 1250 kg bags. * Suitable for granular and powder materials. * Available with dust reducing system.

Shamrock Blender

* Capacity of 25 to 70 ton/m³ per hour. * Machine size 4,5-5,4-7-9-11,5-14 ton. * Easy and gentle blending process. * Blending and weighing are separated.

Doyle Equipment Manufacturing 1 Jack Doyle Industrial Drive, Palmyra, MO. 63461 USA. Tel. +1(217) 222-1592 & +1(573) 300-4009 doyle@doylemfg.com, www.doylemfg.com


Commercial application and validation

Figure 4. Reduced pressure drop.

Figure 5. Real-time, 3D heat profile of furnace. As with the previous generation, the geometry of the new series continues to provide high surface area, which is responsible for the long-term activity of the catalyst. Another similarity is the uneven number of holes in the outer ring, resulting in a uniform stress distribution as well as high crush strength and mechanical robustness, regardless of the direction of the force. What has changed considerably is the catalysts’ increased void fraction, both within and between particles (Figure 3). Through this, the catalyst can reduce pressure drop in the reactor tubes by around 20% (Figure 4). Provided there are no other process limitations, producers have the option to increase gas throughput by up to 11%, thereby raising their production rates. Alternatively, they could continue current throughput levels at a reduced compressor load in the downstream ammonia or methanol synthesis loop and thus lower energy expenditures. A further benefit of the higher internal void fraction (larger holes) is that it greatly enhances heat transfer in the steam reformer. 20 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

The catalyst is already in operation at a number of plants. Customers are experiencing significant monetary benefits due to the lower pressure drop compared to previous catalyst charges. One example is at a KBR-designed ammonia plant in North America with a top-fired primary reformer. The customer selected ReforMax LDP Plus with the intention of reducing operating costs. The catalyst was started up in September 2019, and over the first 2 years the customer measured a reduction in pressure drop of 4 psi (equivalent to 0.3 bar) across the entire reformer, which is approximately 16% lower than the performance of the previous catalyst. Looking at the catalyst in the tubes alone, the expected 20% pressure drop reduction was achieved. Furthermore, a TWT survey proves that the catalyst provides good heat transfer, as evidenced by a uniform temperature distribution across the tubes, with a 1522˚F (828˚C) average TWT obtained on a recent survey. The catalyst has been stable so far, and is still at the same start-of-run (SOR) pressure drop and methane leakage after 2 years of operation. Based on the energy savings and natural gas pricing in North America, the customer is achieving an estimated energy cost saving of US$45 000/yr, which will amount to more than US$270 000 over the catalyst’s estimated useful life.

Spotting the hot spots As previously mentioned, uniform and consistent heat distribution among the reformer tube walls is another critical factor affecting process efficiency. In the case of uneven firing, there is a risk of the tubes overheating (so-called ‘hot spots’), which can severely shorten their durability and lifetime. The strain on the hot tubes grows exponentially and may even lead to tube ruptures. However, the problem cannot be solved through overly careful firing, which lowers the reaction rate, raises energy consumption and/or decreases production yield. Thus, it is essential to observe TWT to ensure equal heat distribution and monitor catalyst performance. To meet customers’ needs for enhanced reformer monitoring, Clariant offers its ReforSafE service in three levels that differ in their degree of detail concerning collecting and examining data.


We are everything sulphur and much more Comprimo and Chemetics – delivering sulphur and sulphuric acid solutions for a more sustainable world. Through everything we do, we provide maximum long-term profits for our customers while meeting the most stringent environmental requirements. Helping our customers to be better neighbours is always good business for them and us. Learn more with one of our experts email: sulphursolutions@worley.com

worley.com/comprimo

worley.com/chemetics


First service level The first service level (ReforSafE Standard) is a quick TWT check performed with a Land Cyclops pyrometer. The company visits the plant to carry out a visual inspection of the furnace and collect relevant information such as steam-to-carbon ratio and methane slip to evaluate the catalyst’s performance. The service includes TWT evaluation through peepholes and temperature correction. The scope of the first service level covers: Ensuring safe reformer operation. Evaluation of TWT. Evaluation of catalyst performance.

Second service level In the second service level (ReforSafE Premium), both burners and TWT are evaluated through the peepholes with a high-resolution thermal imaging borescope that measures temperatures from 600 to 1800˚C (1112 to 3272˚F) at a short, accuracy-enhancing wavelength, and provides a thermal image of 656 x 494 px (+320 000 temperature points). This real-time, 3D heat profile includes all tube rows of the furnace (Figure 5), and can be easily examined for areas of non-homogeneous heat distribution and hot spots on the tubes. The equipment also provides live thermal images of reformer tubes, burners and refractory. The temperature survey also includes recommendations for burner adjustments. The scope of the thermal imaging service, beyond that offered by the first service level, is: Evaluating the performance of burners and the pressure of fuel headers.

Providing recommendations for burner adjustment and optimisation.

Third service level In the third service level (ReforSafE Premium Plus), additional readings are taken with a LAND Gold Cup reflector, which provides greater accuracy, as its near-perfect reflectance blocks background radiation, thus creating a black body for measurements. Using direct tube contact, the Gold Cup establishes a seal between the tube surface and the instrument, shielding the thermocouple from additional radiation around the tube. As already mentioned, the Gold Cup measurements provide accurate temperature data, as they are not affected by tube emissivity, hot background reflections or side path emissions. This information, along with the thermal imaging data gathered, is used to calculate a formula for temperature corrections of future pyrometer measurements. The scope of the thermal imaging and Gold Cup service, beyond that offered by the second service level, is: Determination of tube emissivity. Providing a correction formula for measuring true TWT. Operator training on how to measure and correct true TWT.

Conclusion As the demand for syngas continues to grow, so will the need for greater economy, efficiency and reliability in its production processes. These goals can be achieved through a combination of innovative steam reforming catalysts and service possibilities.

Need a reprint?

We can tailor to your requirements, produce 1 - 12 page formats, print colour or mono and more +44 (0)1252 718999 reprints@worldfertilizer.com


A Helping Hand Mads Feddersen, Haldor Topsoe, Denmark, shows how, in lieu of recent revolutionary technological breakthroughs, production capacity at existing ammonia facilities can be increased through the addition of heat exchange reforming technology.

A

mmonia production is a relatively mature business that saw most of its revolutionary improvements prior to the 1950s. The early developments, such as the Birkeland-Eyde electric arc process, the cyanamide process and finally the Haber-Bosch process, were instrumental in reducing energy consumption per unit of ammonia produced, with the Haber-Bosch process representing the ultimate breakthrough that led to the first industrial-scale plant.

23


challenges in accommodating a higher feed flow due to pressure drop constraints, one solution is to bypass part of the feed in a parallel unit. Such debottlenecking of the reforming section can be achieved through application of Topsoe’s Heat Exchange Reformer (HTER) technology, which reduces the load in the existing SMR and at the same time increases the generation of syngas. Heat exchange reforming technology utilises the sensible heat of the hot process gas from the secondary reformer for reforming a part of the feed bypassing the SMR. In this way the duty of the SMR can be reduced, thereby reducing fuel firing in the SMR. The HTER is an add-on to the existing reforming section and can normally be installed with relatively minor modifications to the existing equipment (Figure 2). Its introduction in a 2200 tpd ammonia plant ensures that capacity can be further increased, resulting in an overall Revamping the reforming section capacity increase of 17% when combined with a booster In order to substantially increase ammonia production converter in the ammonia loop to take care of the increased in existing facilities, more syngas is required for the syngas amount and an iron chromium-free catalyst in ammonia synthesis loop. In most cases, this will require a the existing high-temperature shift (HTS) reactor. The higher capacity in the reformer section. As the tubular additional equipment required for such a revamp can be reformer/steam methane reformer (SMR) may have installed without other major modifications envisioned. The operating steam-to-carbon (S/C) ratio in the primary reformer is at 2.2, and the methane slip is maintained at the same level compared to the original case by additional reforming duty in the HTER. This revamp feature could ensure that the front-end can handle 20% additional natural gas. The natural gas compressor inside battery limits (ISBL) delivers at a Figure 1. Impact of ammonia technology developments on energy consumption. slightly higher pressure in the front-end to ensure that the load on the synthesis gas compressor is within the limits, depending on how the synthesis gas compressor is rated. In a situation where the synthesis gas compressor needs to be debottlenecked, a chilling system could, for example, be introduced interstage in the make-up part. In an existing plant, plot availability is often an issue. However, the HTER takes up limited space and Topsoe has experience of installing them in space-constrained plants. Figure 2. HTER addition in traditional plants. This ensures that a tailor-made solution to install the reactor can Table 1. Production and consumption figures with S-50 + HTER + SK-501 Flex be achieved. Traditional layout S-50 + HTER + SK-501 Flex As can be seen from Table 1, the production cost per tonne of Ammonia production, tpd 2200 2574 ammonia on the basis of natural Feed + fuel consumption, % 100 106 gas consumption decreases by 9%, Specific NG consumption/t 100 91 and the natural gas consumption ammonia, % increases by only 6% to gain a Since then, developments have proceeded via smaller incremental improvements – primarily in steam reforming of natural gas – which have brought energy consumption steadily lower towards the theoretical minimum (Figure 1). In the absence of recent revolutionary technological advancements, the industry has sought to improve profitability in other ways during the last few decades. There are two general trends emerging in today’s market – one being consolidation in the form of large plants that place a high priority on efficiency and CAPEX, and the other the revamping of older plants to increase capacity and at the same time reduce energy consumption. This article will show one way of adding more production capacity to an existing facility and at the same time reduce net energy consumption.

24 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022


TITAN™ - Strong under pressure

Ensure reliable operation with superior steam reforming catalyst

• • • •

Stable activity – increased conversion Optimal size and shape – lowest industry pressure drop High mechanical strength – longer lifetime Faster start-up

info.topsoe.com/titan


Figure 3. Schematics for alternative fuel usage in auxiliary boiler. Table 2. Production and consumption figures with HTER + S-50 Before revamp

After revamp with HTER + S-50

Ammonia production, tpd

1350

1668

Specific NG consumption/t ammonia, %

100

92

the addition of a steam-fired reboiler, higher circulation rates or increased solution concentration. Installing the HTER together with an S-50 booster converter and the iron chromium-free SK-501 FlexTM catalyst can boost capacity by 17%, with a significant reduction in net energy consumption. The payback period for such a revamp is around 2 years, with due consideration to utility costs, including steam.

Industrial experience in ammonia plants

Figure 4. HTER installation next to SMR. capacity increase of 17%. The suggested modifications will increase earnings by 20%, which is a significant improvement in the OPEX of the ammonia plant. By installing an HTER, fuel consumption is reduced by 20%, which can be efficiently utilised as feed. It has also been observed that natural gas used as fuel in ammonia units is sometimes priced higher than that used as feed for the process. Installation can therefore be beneficial in such scenarios, as fuel consumption could be reduced in the ammonia ISBL and freed-up natural gas could be used for consumption as feed to boost capacity. The steam production is minimised, which could be regulated to match specific requirements (Figure 3). It should be noted that freed-up natural gas is utilised for ammonia production; however, the HTER provides the option to use cheaper or more readily available fuels for steam generation. The increased load in the CO2 removal system may be a bottleneck. This can be addressed by a combination of various but relatively small modifications. These could, for example, entail modification of solution pumps, 26 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

In 2017, a Southeast Asian ammonia producer installed a HTER in their Topsoe-licensed ammonia plant. At the same time, a S-50 booster converter was installed in the ammonia synthesis loop to optimise conversion of the increased amount of synthesis gas. The installation of these two additional pieces of equipment, as well as other modifications required, was carried out during a normal, planned turnaround. Loading of the catalyst in the HTER and in the S-50 was performed under supervision by company personnel using in-house developed loading methods to ensure the successful performance of these units. Reduction of the ammonia synthesis catalyst was achieved in conjunction with the start-up of the plant after the turnaround. The results of the debottlenecking are listed in Table 2. Another industrial reference is a recently commissioned grassroots plant. From the early design phase, one of the key design criteria was to minimise energy consumption as much as possible in order to have a competitive edge in the market. Based on Topsoe’s licensed ammonia technology, the plant uses an HTER in the reforming section in order to minimise energy consumption and CO2 emissions. Located in Central Europe with a design capacity of 1600 tpd of ammonia, this plant was initially started up in 2018 and became the plant with the lowest energy consumption of any licensed by the company. Figure 4 shows the location of the HTER next to the SMR.

Conclusion Technologies such as those discussed in this article have resulted in a more efficient way of using feedstocks in order to produce ammonia in higher quantities and at lower cost. An additional key benefit is a reduction in net energy consumption.


FERTILIZER'S 2030 MISSION Urvi Mathur, Neelam Aqua, India, explains how the use of enhanced efficiency fertilizer can help the world to achieve the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals by 2030.

1

7 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) were adopted by the United Nations (UN) in September 2015 and are intended to be achieved by the year 2030. The 17 goals are an immediate call to action on complex and interconnected global issues, such as poverty, hunger, climate change, access to clean water and conflict. It is believed by the UN and world leaders that these goals can be fulfilled through nations, governments and business organisations collaborating and taking an integrated approach towards protecting humanity, ecosystems, biodiversity and the planet. More than 175 countries have already committed themselves to sustainable development with these 17 goals in mind, focusing on prosperity for people and the planet in the present and into the future. The common thread connecting and binding the SDGs is agriculture. When the agricultural revolution took place approximately 10 000 years ago it was a turning point in the history of civilisation, as humans began to settle and grow their food. Henceforth, agriculture has been a core requirement for the existence of almost all human societies. Since then, the agricultural industry has drastically changed in all aspects: environmental, social

and economic. From the time of the first revolution, there was (and continues to be) expansion and exploitation, feeding people at the expense of forests, wildlife and water and destabilising the climate in the process. As the global population is predicted to reach an all-time high of 10 billion by 2030, so food production must be increased by 60 – 70% to ensure proper food security for all nations. Given the current context of climate change and water scarcity across the world, the second revolution in agriculture must be based on the values and guidelines of the Sustainable Agricultural System, ensuring a healthy and prosperous world by 2030.

The need for greater sustainability in agriculture There is a dire need for improvement in the agricultural industry so that it can ensure the well-being of every citizen, without causing extensive harm to the environment. To ensure sustainable agriculture, focus must not just be limited to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions but rather extended to the responsibilities of ensuring food security, zero hunger, clean water and 27


sanitation, water use efficiency in agriculture and protection and restoration of ecosystems. A change in the types of fertilizer used could have a substantial, positive effect in addressing these global issues, which have a common and root cause in the low nutrient efficiency of urea and NPK fertilizer. Low nutrient efficiency is an imperative issue, as crops and plantations are not able to consume the nutrients as per their requirements, resulting in low crop yield in fields and, eventually, hunger and malnutrition, both of which are experienced throughout the world. The low nutrient efficiency of such widely used fertilizer contributes heavily to global warming and climate change. Approximately 50% of fertilizers are lost through the processes of volatilisation, nitrification and denitrification.1 The urea or any other nitrogenous fertilizer lost through these processes has caused severe damage to the environment and ecological cycles. In volatilisation, the urea not consumed by the crops is lost to the atmosphere in the gaseous form of nitrous oxide. Nitrous oxide is a potent greenhouse gas, with 300 times more potential of capturing heat than carbon dioxide. The nitrous oxide emissions from the agricultural industry have increased over the past few decades due to the excess use of such mineralised fertilizers. Around 80% of the nitrous oxide is emitted during an agricultural process in the food cycle.2 From the processes of nitrification and denitrification, nitrogen is available in the form of nitrate for crops and plantations. The mobile nature of nitrate in the soil results in leaching, which is responsible for soil acidification and groundwater pollution – thus making water hazardous for drinking and other human activities. The issue of groundwater pollution is particularly alarming for the 2.5 billion people around the world who rely solely on groundwater resources to meet their basic needs. As approximately 40% of the Earth’s land is farmland, a total transition towards a sustainable agriculture system will only take place with the collaboration of different industries altogether.

Enhanced efficiency fertilizer Enhanced efficiency fertilizer can be the catalyst for a smooth transformation towards improved, sustainable agriculture. Enhanced efficiency fertilizer tackles the issue of low nutrient use efficiency – a dominant problem throughout mineralised and nitrogenous fertilizers and a root cause of inadequate plant nutrition, malnutrition and food insecurity. Urea is responsible for feeding almost half of the world, hence making it essential for sufficient crop yield and food security. Consequently, the total abandonment of nitrogenous fertilizers is not a feasible solution for reducing the impacts of climate change. The whole concept of efficient fertilizer is based on the improvement of widely used nitrogenous fertilizers. An efficient fertilizer must fulfil the nutritious requirements of crops and plantations, and in turn reduce loss of nitrogen through the processes of volatilisation, nitrification and denitrification. The commonly used efficient fertilizers in the market are often identified as slow- and controlled-release fertilizers. The manner in which slow-release fertilizers provide nitrogen for plants is 28 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

what makes them smart, effective and efficient compared to other, conventional fertilizers. Nitrogenous and mineralised fertilizers rapidly release nitrogen once applied into the field, causing an outburst of nitrogen for crops and plantations to consume. The issue with this is that crops and plantations do not require such high amounts of nitrogen in their initial stages of growth and development. The nitrogen that is thus not consumed by crops and plantations is then lost through emissions in the atmosphere and leaching in the soil, making application an inefficient process. Slow-release fertilizers supply nutrients at a much slower rate compared to other nutrient fertilizers such as urea and ammonium nitrate. This concept of nitrogen application overcomes the disadvantage of applying conventional straight nitrogen fertilizer on one occasion, resulting in copious amounts of nutrients in crops’ early stages of growth and development but scarcity at the later stages. Slow-release fertilizers meet the nutritional requirements of crops by releasing nutrients in a sigmoidal pattern that enriches the plants as per their needs. Slow- and controlled-release fertilizers can be formulated with myriad types of nitrogen and urea inhibitor additives. Neelam Aqua, based in India, manufactures nitrogen inhibitor additives for the slow release of nitrogen, including NEELCOAT DS and UREACOAT. In correlation with a slow release of nitrogen, these two additives have anticaking and suppressant properties. The former is derived from plant extracts of the neem tree. The neem tree’s extracts, such as neem oil and neem cake, are actively used as slow-release organic fertilizer in small-scale farming and gardening, as they have a high proportion of NPK nutrients and azadirachtin to keep soil pests away. While relying on purely plant-based fertilizer might not fulfil the nutritious requirements of plantations, using neem as an additive has enhanced the industrial mineral fertilizer that is used. NEELCOAT DS successfully ensures a slower release of nitrogen when coated on urea granules. By integrating plant-based material, such as neem, into the fertilizer, Neelam Aqua is promoting the proper use of controlled-release fertilizers.

Conclusion By even making the slightest change to enhance the efficiency of mineral fertilizers that are widely used there will be a huge impact on the global issues of world hunger, climate change and poverty. Bill Gates once said that fertilizers “are a magical innovation that’s responsible for saving millions of lives from hunger and lifting millions more out of poverty by boosting agricultural productivity”. The agricultural industry, accounting for millions of lives, requires innovation of its key elements, such as fertilizer; doing so will have a significant, positive impact in addressing climate change and food insecurity.

References 1.

2.

AULAKH, M.S., and SINGH, B., ‘Nitrogen losses and fertilizer N use efficiency in irrigated porous soils’, Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems, Vol. 47, No. 3 (October 1996), pp. 197 – 212. WOZNIACKA, G., ‘The Greenhouse Gas No One’s Talking About: Nitrous Oxide on Farms, Explained’, Civil Eats (19 September 2019), https://civileats.com/2019/09/19/the-greenhouse-gas-no-onestalking-about-nitrous-oxide-on-farms-explained/


Global Publication

The premier source of technical and analytical information for the renewable energy industry, covering solar, wind, bioenergy and storage. Subscribe online at: www.energyglobal.com/magazine


FILM PROTECTION AGAINST CORROSION

30


Andre de Bache, Kurita Europe, Germany, demonstrates how water and energy savings were realised at an ammonia plant in the Netherlands through the use of film-forming products that form a hydrophobic barrier against corrosive agents.

H

igh-pressure (HP) steam systems in ammonia plants are characterised by high heat flux densities in several waste heat boilers in the ammonia production process, which makes proper water and steam treatment essential. Traditional treatment programmes usually combining ammonia or alkalising amines with phosphate and dispersants are frequently applied. Some plants additionally use reducing agents, such as carbohydrazide (CHZ) or diethyl hydroxylamine (DEHA), to keep the dissolved oxygen concentration in the lower ppb range and so avoid any chance of oxygen corrosion.

Kurita’s Cetamine® technology, based on film-forming substances (FFS) combined with low volatile and high volatile alkalising amines, removes the need for reducing agents and inorganic treatment programmes, such as phosphates or caustic. The FFS adsorbs onto metal/metal oxide surfaces to form a hydrophobic film or barrier, which prevents corrosion by stopping water and other corrosive agents from contacting the metal/metal oxide surface. Furthermore, the thin film fosters the formation of a smooth and compact iron oxide layer.1 Film-forming products (FFP) based on FFS or film-forming amines (FFA) are increasingly being used as

31


an alternative to conventional treatment programmes for water/steam cycle protection against corrosion in industrial steam generators. FFP can provide the following advantages when compared to traditional treatment programmes: Formation of clean, smooth heat transfer surfaces. Reduction of energy and water consumption due to blowdown optimisation and better heat transfer. Reduction of CO2 emissions due to lower energy consumption. Mitigation of flow-accelerated corrosion (FAC). Strong protection during outages and lay-up periods. Significant reduction of corrosion and metal oxide transport. The number of systems treated with FFP has significantly increased over recent years. As a result, the International Association for the Properties of Water and Steam (IAPWS) has released two Technical Guidance Documents (TGDs) that focus on the application of FFS in industrial steam generators and in fossil, combined cycle and biomass power plants. In these TGDs three substances, including oleyl propylenediamine (OLDA), are listed. These have been the subject of intensive research and significant application experience.2,3 Before being converted to Cetamine technology in 2013, the boiler water treatment programme at an ammonia production plant in the Netherlands had been based on hydrazine, trisodium phosphate (TSP) and ammonia since the plant’s start-up. Several boiler tube failures occurred in the HP steam system under this conventional treatment programme. The root causes for repeated tube failures have been investigated and identified as iron oxide transportation caused by erosion and FAC as well as deposition on surfaces with high heat flux densities combined with phosphate hideout. As will be shown later, since the installation of the new treatment programme important water and energy savings have been realised through blowdown reduction, and no tube failures have occurred.4

Figure 1. Simplified flow scheme of HP steam system. 32 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

Water/steam system Feedwater consists of make-up water, stripped process condensate and turbine condensate. All streams pass a condensate polishing unit (CPU) that consists of a candle filter and a mixed bed polisher with cation and anion resins. For process condensates, separate cation and anion resin beds are used additionally. Steam is generated in three process waste heat boilers: Secondary reformer waste heat boiler. High-temperature shift (HTS) waste heat boiler. Ammonia converter waste heat boiler. The steam is then sent to a common steam drum operating at 125 bar. Saturated steam from the steam drum is superheated to 525˚C. All three waste heat boilers are orientated horizontally and have natural feedwater circulation through the steam drum.4 These waste heat boilers are characterised by high heat flux densities, with 320 kW/m² in the ammonia converter and above 450 kW/m² in the secondary reformer. A simplified flow scheme of the HP steam system is shown in Figure 1.4

Boiler tube failures under a conventional treatment programme Following the start-up of the plant in the Netherlands, multiple boiler tube failures occurred in the secondary reformer and ammonia converter waste heat boilers. One of the root causes was phosphate hideout combined with magnetite deposition on heat transfer surfaces in the highest heat flux densities. The waste heat boilers are constructed out of carbon steel. Under operating high-temperature boiler conditions, a protective magnetite layer is usually formed on carbon steel surfaces in two directions: As a dense magnetite layer into the metal surface (topotactical). As a porous, relatively loose layer on the metal surface (epitactical).


The dense topotactical layer acts as natural protection against corrosion. However, under recirculating boiler conditions, the upper porous practical layer is sensitive to erosion; consequently it can be partially flushed away from the surface and transported from turbulent zones to less turbulent areas, where it predominantly settles at heat transfer surfaces. This leads to boiler tube failures, especially in high heat flux density areas.4

Change of focus The main aim of boiler water treatment is to ensure safe and economical operation of the system. Treatment concepts for boiler systems and steam generators have developed in recent years, focusing on technologies that enable savings and improve system reliability and lifetime. Kurita has developed several technologies for safe and economical boiler operation, contributing to water and energy savings and reducing CO2 emissions. With Cetamine technology, the focus of the treatment programme changes from bulk water chemistry to metal/metal oxide water interface chemistry. The aims are, firstly, to keep boiler tubes clean from porous oxide deposits resulting from iron transport due to FAC in pre-boiler systems under conventional treatment and, secondly, to mitigate FAC in general.4 One key benefit of applying FFA is the reduction of FAC. Scientific studies on the effectiveness of Cetamine G851 in mitigating single-phase FAC have been carried out at the University of New Brunswick in Canada. In a HP water loop simulating feedwater temperatures of 140˚C (reflecting the most critical conditions with a maximum solubility of magnetite), the corrosion rates have been determined at a feedwater flow velocity of 4.6 m/sec. in a test tube with an inner diameter of 1.6 mm. The corrosion rates have been monitored in dependency on the pH value and the concentration of the active FFA.5 During the first period of the test (Figure 2, red area), the corrosion rate in neutral demineralised water was determined with 2.8 mm/yr as a blank value. The pH was set to 9.6 by dosing of ammonia, leading to a decreased corrosion rate of 0.11 mm/yr (grey area). In the next period of the test (blue area), the pH value was adjusted to 9.2, increasing the corrosion rate to 0.99 mm/yr. In the final period (green area), Cetamine G851 was dosed to the system while keeping the pH at a constant level of 9.2. The application of the FFA-based product led to a reduction of the corrosion rate by a factor of ca. 5 to 0.2 mm/yr. The change of treatment programme at the plant in the Netherlands was realised without any separate offline chemical system cleaning. The TSP dosage was stopped and after 3 days (when phosphate levels dropped below 2 ppm) the dosage of Cetamine was started using the existing dosing tank and pump. The product is dosed at a rate that ensures that only a small amount of the active FFS is detectable in the condensate,

feedwater and boiler water.4 Kurita provides analytical tools for the determination of the product in water samples as well as on system surfaces. The company has developed a wipe test to semi-quantitatively determine the adsorbed Cetamine on the inner surfaces of water/steam cycles immediately onsite during plant inspections, in a non-destructive manner. The Cetamine treatment programme is an all-volatile treatment concept, which means that the adsorption and protection of system parts also take place in the steam and condensate system. Equally, in industrial systems such as ammonia plants where steam has direct contact with process catalysts, the water/steam cycle treatment programme must be compatible with process catalysts under the applied conditions. After more than 7 years, it has been clearly demonstrated that the treatment concept does not negatively impact the performance of the catalysts, including reforming and shift conversion catalysts. In 2016 the plant was shut down for planned maintenance. Although the water side of the waste heat boilers was not accessed, several other pieces of equipment were shown to be effectively protected against corrosion by a thin, uniform, adherent,


Conclusion HP systems in ammonia plants are characterised by high heat flux densities, which makes the application of proper water and steam treatment essential. Treatment programmes based on FFA provide several advantages over traditional treatment programmes. Lower corrosion products in feedwater and condensate reduce the risk of fouling of thermally highly loaded heat transfer surfaces. In the course of an FFA-based treatment programme the potential risk of phosphate hideout and related corrosion phenomena was eliminated and the continuous blowdown reduced, generating substantial annual savings.

Figure 2. Effectiveness of Cetamine G851 on single-phase FAC. non-dusting, slightly hydrophobic magnetite layer with a thickness of approximately 5 µm.4 As of now no further tube failures have occurred in the waste heat boilers. The potential risk of phosphate hideout and related corrosion phenomena experienced in the past has been removed. In the course of the treatment programme, the continuous blowdown of the HP steam drum has been reduced by 70%, representing significant water and energy savings that have been quantified as annual savings of approximately €165 000, based on evaluations and costs for water and energy in 2017. Annual savings are expected to be even higher currently, given the significant increase in energy costs.

References 1.

2.

3.

4. 5.

TOPP, H., HATER, W., DE BACHE, A., and ZUM KOLK, C., ‘Film-Forming Amines in Shell Boilers’, PowerPlant Chemistry, Issue 14(1) (2012), pp. 38 – 48. International Association for the Properties of Water and Steam, ‘Technical Guidance Document: Application of Film Forming Amines in Fossil, Combined Cycle, and Biomass Power Plants’, IAPWS TGD816 (2019), available from http://www.iapws.org International Association for the Properties of Water and Steam, ‘Technical Guidance Document: Application of Film Forming Substances in Industrial Steam Generators’, IAPWS TGD11-19 (2019), available from http://www.iapws.org RAEYMAEKERS, F., Ammonia Technical Manual (2017). WEERAKUL, S., LEAUKOSOL, N., LISTER, D. H., MORI, S., and HATER, W., ‘Effects on Flow-Accelerated Corrosion of Oleylpropanediamine Under Single-Phase Water Conditions Pertinent to Power Plant Feedwater’, Corrosion, Vol. 76, Issue 2 (February 2020), pp. 217 – 230.

Global Publication Stay informed

Keep up to date with us to hear the latest World Fertilizer news

 Register at www.worldfertilizer.com


Edward DeRose and Robert Tinsley, Hatch, USA, explore the creation of a process simulator capable of producing a numerically rigorous mass and energy balance for an ammonium phosphate granulation plant.

W

ith the uptick in the phosphate fertilizer market, Hatch has seen an increased demand and urgency from clients to expedite engineering design, construction and start-up of ammonium phosphate granulation plants. Operators are eager for optimised engineering schedules and getting new fertilizer production online as quickly as possible, while maintaining safety and quality.

Ammonium phosphate granulation plant process model The company has developed and verified with operational data an ammonium phosphate granulation plant process model in SysCAD to better serve client projects within the phosphate industry. By utilising Hatch’s granulation plant process simulator, it is possible to enhance the analysis of process flowsheets, incorporate improved process designs

35


became more efficient with tools such as Microsoft Excel. Over the years, Excel models have been enhanced to incorporate improvements aimed at streamlining design activities outside of the software itself. With that said, significant challenges exist while using Excel to wholly model a processing plant, even when including exhaustive lookup tables and speciated data. Spreadsheets are generally built from the ground up, with no thermodynamic, physical or chemical data to rely on, and have no simple means for error checking. On top of this, Excel modelling for material and energy balances tends to be a cumbersome and slow task. Circular references as well as program crashes tend to be a common point of error, which limits accuracy and efficiency. Excel balances also need to be rebuilt and customised for each plant design. It is impossible to build a comprehensive balance that can be interchanged with countless plant configurations. To create a reliable process model for an ammonium phosphate granulation plant, a detailed understanding of the process chemistry is required, including but not limited to the behaviour of ammonium phosphate compounds at varying concentrations and temperatures. This knowledge must be coupled with robust industry knowledge of the interactions between each unit operation and the materials feeding into and Figure 1. Preneutralisation: preneutraliser and pipe reactor graphics window. out of the system. The company’s phosphate engineers have created a process simulator capable of producing a numerically rigorous mass and energy balance for an ammonium phosphate granulation plant. The tool can be modified to countless variations of product specifications, production rates and flowsheet configurations. Building this tool within modelling software allows for seamless integration of powerful convergence algorithms, control loops, background physio-chemical equilibrium, aqueous thermodynamics and extensive databases containing critical information on the physical properties of the process components. Figure 2. Drying: combustion chamber and dryer graphics window. and ultimately drive expedient and well-informed engineering decisions. Designing ammonium phosphate fertilizer granulation plants is a tedious and time-intensive process. For years, specifying unit operations and process equipment was done on a per unit basis, making it very challenging to produce comprehensive plant-wide closed material and energy balances. Granulation plants are highly interconnected; even a small modification in one area of the plant can have a significant impact on overall plant operability and the plant water balance. With the advancement of computer technology, the efforts required to complete constituent-based plant-wide material and energy balances have evolved and

36 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022


Global Publication

A new magazine focused on the global hydrogen sector

Subscribe for free: www.globalhydrogenreview.com


Figure 3. Size separation: screening, milling and recycle graphics window.

Figure 4. Lo-mol scrubbing: acid scrubbers graphics window.

Although there are tried-and-true process technologies within the phosphate industry, many of these technologies matured before steady-state simulation was practical. The presented work constitutes an effort to increase rigour in process technology evaluation and improve the efficiency in order to produce a reliable output of an ammonium phosphate fertilizer granulation plant using SysCAD. The model generated by the company’s phosphate engineers is not limited in its ability to model different grades or production rates of fertilizers, nor is it limited in its ability to generate a reliable output based on a particular flowsheet selection, titration methodology or equipment layout. Hatch has worked over the last 2 years to develop the granulation plant simulation model and improve the predictability and accuracy of the tool. The granulation model has been built using industry standard design criteria for unit operations and refined through a validation process that involved calibration to actual plant operating data. Generally, industry technology providers can produce heat and material balances quickly, but these models are often unique to a particular licensed plant design. This limitation can serve as a challenge, as countless different configurations of ammonium phosphate granulation plants exist, and plant modifications are continually made by producers to maximise throughput, improve environmental compliance and maximise plant efficiency, making each operating plant unique and different. This is particularly true when evaluating scrubbing circuits, heat recovery systems and titration methodologies.

Benefits of SysCAD software

Figure 5. Granulation: granulator graphics window. 38 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

The benefits of using the SysCAD software for plant simulation have been well-documented across various industries. In the case of modelling an ammonium phosphate granulation plant, one of the key benefits includes the software’s capability to integrate with third-party thermodynamic equilibrium and property calculations. The success/accuracy of a plant simulation model starts with a strong fundamental understanding of the process chemistry taking place within the plant being simulated. SysCAD’s integration with high-fidelity thermophysical software enables prediction and understanding of solution chemistry and physical equilibrium. In ammonium phosphate fertilizer plants, solution chemistry predictions enable more


35th

Nitrogen + Syngas 2022 Conference & Exhibition

28-30 March 2022 • Estrel, Berlin, Germany • Live and Virtual

The world's leading technical event returns LIVE to Berlin + live streamed

Hybrid for 2022

The most important annual European event in N2 & syngas.

740+

Delegates

Esben Sorensen, Technical Sales Director, Haldor Topsoe

330+

A must attend event for Syngas and Nitrogen producers!

Companies

Miroslav Dimitrov, Production & Maintenance Manager, Neochim PLC

46+

Countries

For sponsorship and exhibition opportunities, please contact Michelle Bingham:

Michelle.Bingham@crugroup.com

+44 (0)20 7903 2159

Gold Sponsors

Official Publications

Ratings Partner

Supported by ®

Discover why you should attend: www.nitrogensyngas.com

#CRUNitrogen


complex simulation of unit operations such as reactors, evaporators and scrubbers. In the past, this has been an area in which heat and material balances built in Microsoft Excel and other similar platforms have fallen short. Hatch’s SysCAD model is malleable and can be tailored to any plant design or flowsheet. Building the simulation model in the SysCAD software allowed the company’s engineers to incorporate maximum flexibility into the tool to accommodate unique client demands. For example, many clients operate their granulation plant with only a pipe reactor and do not use a preneutraliser. The SysCAD software allows the plant balance to be easily modified by turning unit operations on/off as required. Some clients use sulfuric acid and/or filler for grade control; these input streams can be toggled to simulate plant operation and support balance convergence. It is possible to use the tool to generate converged heat and material balances for different ammonium phosphate granulation product specifications, regardless of how unique or specialised. The simulation is capable of modelling micronutrient-enhanced products. Coupled with a deep industry process knowledge, Hatch’s tool significantly reduces the time required to produce a converged, comprehensive and accurate heat and material balance for an ammonium phosphate granulation plant when compared to using other tools and software.

Plant conversion projects benefit from plant capacity analyses and a detailed evaluation of existing equipment. Before evaluating the converted plant design, a validation process is made much simpler with the use of simulation software. Provided there is existing plant data and a strong understanding of the existing flowsheet, a validation model can be produced by the company’s phosphate engineers to tune the behaviour of simulation. This validation effort enables better evaluation of what challenges may arise when converting a plant’s production line, increasing throughput or making an upgrade or modification to a unit operation. An example of model validation in an ammonium phosphate fertilizer plant that is critically important to the water balance is around the burner/dryer. Chemical components of a burner’s fuel can be selected while configuring the model and a prediction of higher heating value and lower heating value is calculated. With knowledge of an existing plant’s combustion air fan operation, quench air fan operation and burner temperature profiles, an estimate of environmental heat loss can be calculated and programmed into the model. SysCAD also enables the prediction of environmental heat loss given ambient conditions from unit operations. The use of SysCAD process modelling simulation provides value to the entire lifecycle of projects, including plant operation. Achieving a well-maintained mass and energy balance is a significant challenge to manufacturers due to the ever-changing nature of industrial facilities. The use of simulation software helps to ease this challenge and, if maintained, provides a digital environment to troubleshoot, monitor and optimise the performance of a plant. Evaluating changes in a digital modelling environment minimises the risk associated with large plant changes, as well as daily decisions for production planning and surge/availability analysis. As mined ore grades continue to decrease in many industries, a more intimate understanding of impurity effects on a process is necessary. Sensitivity analyses, chemistry predictions/evaluation and flowsheet configurations can be investigated to meet the challenge of declining raw material quality. Consideration of the addition of unit operations for impurity removal and project laboratory test work definition is enhanced with the use of simulation software.

Conclusion

Figure 6. Phosphate fertilizer. 40 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

Hatch has been able to employ the SysCAD simulation software to support client needs that range from identifying and resolving plant bottlenecks, to scrubber configuration modifications aimed at meeting environmental regulations, to supporting the design of granulation plant conversions in order to produce micronutrient-enhanced fertilizers. Using the granulation plant process simulator means that the analysis of process flowsheets can be enhanced, improved process designs can be incorporated and, ultimately, timelier and well-informed engineering decisions can be made for operators.


HEALTHY G SOIL FOR A RICH HARVEST

ood soil is the key to successful farming. When it is good, it provides the conditions that have to be in place before the nutrients from the fertilizer can be delivered to the crops. Particularly when cultivating crop plants with very high nutrient demands, regular liming of the soil is essential. Currently, there is a clear trend towards fertilizers in granulate form – they are fast, efficient and can be used all year round. Eirich has recognised the demand for these products. The machine builder from Hardheim, Germany, supplies production machinery and plants for granulated lime and other granulated soil improvers to customers around the world.

Fine-tuning the soil ahead of fertilizing

Thomas Lansdorf, Eirich, Germany, discusses the current trend towards fertilizers in granulate form and explains why a combination of soil improvers and fertilizers can provide a significant and lasting boost to harvest yields.

Most types of crop plants are cormophytes. These form roots through which nutrients are drawn from the soil. Afterwards they need to be converted into a form in which they can be utilised by the plant – for example, ammonium compounds, which are initially converted through nitrification to nitrate. To do this, the fine roots of the plant form symbiotic associations with bacteria and fungi. Nutrients can only be stored and utilised in soils that are rich in humus. As Germany’s regulations on the use of fertilizers restrict the use of nitrogen and phosphate fertilizers in particular, soil efficiency needs to be further optimised in order for the nutrients to be utilised. The goal is to achieve a humus-rich, loose soil structure that will ensure optimum availability of the nutrients.

41


The correct pH value will set nutrients free Most plants prefer neutral or slightly acidic soil. The correct pH value is a key prerequisite for the absorption of nutrients. Most soils in Central Europe are too acidic and too deficient in lime. In order to maintain efficacy, these soils need to be limed on a regular basis. In the process, the pH value plays a key role in terms of nutrient availability. A pH value in the range of 6.5 to 7.5 will ensure high availability of the most important nutrients. In addition, biological activity by microorganisms is encouraged under these conditions. These biological processes promote degradation and conversion processes in the soil. Decomposition of harvest residues, in particular, helps to ensure that valuable humic acids continuously accumulate in the soil.

Calcium loosens the soil The continuous rise in maize cultivation in Central Europe has increasingly led to soil erosion. The trigger for this is silting and compaction of the soil, which prevents soil aeration and makes it more difficult for the soil to absorb water. With more frequent heavy rainfall events, this leads to increased accumulation of surface water. As a result, soil material,

particularly on hillsides and slopes, is continuously carried away. In order to improve water absorption in the soil, the ground needs to have a loose, crumbly structure. Ideally, the soil should be rich in lime, humus and clay, and it is advantageous if the pH value is neutral to slightly acidic. Alongside the pH value, it is also important to consider the cation-exchange capacity (CEC). This is a measure of how well the soil is able to retain cations such as Ca2+, Mg2+ or K+. If soils acidify, then the proportion of H3O+ ions increases, displacing the Ca2+ ions. As a result, clay flocculation is reduced and the soil becomes increasingly compacted. In cases like this, increased use of biogas residues, pig manure or cattle slurry will not lead to an improvement. Quite the opposite actually – the high levels of nitrogen bound in ammonium are converted through nitrification to nitrate, which then also leads to long-term acidification of the soil.

About limestone, burnt lime and slaked lime

Additional liming of the soil is essential, particularly for increased cultivation of crops with high nutrient demands such as maize, cabbage and potatoes. The high demand for nitrogen during growth can only be met if there is an adequate supply of lime. Soil structure is demonstrably improved by this. When using limestone (CaCO3), the recommended amount is approximately 1000 kg/ha. Calcium carbonate must be present in a finely ground form so that it can be made available in the soil sufficiently quickly. Burnt lime, CaO, or slaked lime, Ca(OH)2, are also often used. Both of these forms of lime are highly alkaline and very fast-acting, and they have a higher calcium content than limestone. However, the energy-intensive production process of lime burning is facing increasing criticism. For this reason, Figure 1. FluxxMill and Eirich OrbitMill for fine grinding of industrial minerals. The climate-neutral calcium carbonate will final product is approximately d97 = 20 µm up to 400 µm. be used increasingly in the future. Another factor is the spreading and distribution of the lime on the fields. The easiest way to do this is to spread the lime on fields after they are harvested. This stubble field liming is particularly straightforward, because the soils offer sufficient stability and load-bearing capacity for the heavy spreading vehicles. Granulated lime can be spread very easily and efficiently from spring to autumn using centrifugal broadcasters.

Producing granulated lime around the clock

Figure 2. Various soil improvers that are dust-free and easily spreadable. When water is added, they quickly dissolve in soil.

42 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

Naturally mined lime or dolomite is ground in order to produce the granulate. Here, the target particle size is below 200 µm – the finer the lime, the faster it is available in the soil. In addition to efficacy in the soil, the


Relax, particle distribution also enhances the properties during the granulating process. Raw materials that have the consistency of a fine powder develop higher adhesion forces between the particles and produce sufficiently stable granules. Tumbling mills are often used here for grinding. Eirich recommends the FluxxMill for this, which is a horizontal drum ball mill, as well as the OrbitMill®, which is a centrifugal ball mill. These mills can be used for cost-effective dry grinding of lime, dolomite and similar minerals. The size of the feed material can be up to between 20 and 30 mm, and a grinding fineness of 20 µm (d97-value) can be produced (Figure 1). After grinding, the raw materials are moistened for subsequent pelletising. This can be carried out in an Eirich intensive mixer. At smaller throughput rates (i.e. up to around 10 tph) this is usually done in batch mode. For larger amounts, an Eirich continuous mixer can be used. Depending on the design, the average retention time can be between 60 and 90 seconds. In place of water, a diluted binder solution is often fed in. Depending on availability, either lignosulfonates or molasses are used as the binding agent. After the moistening step, a highly homogeneous, dust-free pre-granulate forms in the mixer. Use of the intensive mixer ensures uniform moisture levels throughout, and any loose lumps are completely broken down in the process. The more consistent the infeed material, the more trouble-free the downstream pelletising process is. As a result, it is possible to achieve high throughput rates and high yields. The granulates produced offer high compressive strength, despite the addition of only small amounts of binding agent. When the granulate is moistened (e.g. by rain) it dissolves quickly (Figure 2). This is a key prerequisite for rapid availability in the soil. During pelletising, grain size distributions from 2 to 6 mm are normally the target. This makes for efficient and cost-effective spreading via a centrifugal broadcaster.

Low-sulfur soils need gypsum Anhydrite is a crystal water-free variant of gypsum. This rock-forming mineral is naturally abundant in large quantities. Johann Friedrich Mayer (1719 – 1798), an agricultural scientist and parish priest from southern Germany, recognised the benefits of anhydrite as a fertilizer early on. Anhydrite is particularly suitable for use on alkaline and low-sulfur soils. Due to its high calcium content, it has a similar effect to lime and dolomite, but without increasing the pH value. Components containing clay flocculate and thus counteract compaction of the soil. In addition, the sulfate component covers the sulfur demand of leguminous plants, which are increasingly popular in organic farming. As an alternative to anhydrite, flue gas desulfurisation (FGD) gypsum can also be used, which is significantly cheaper. This is calcium sulfate dihydrate (CaSO4·2H2O), with comparable fertilizing properties to anhydrite. In the UK, a plant was constructed for this purpose to produce granulated lime with FGD gypsum. Figure 3 shows an Eirich Intensive Mixer RV16 and Disk Pelletizer.

Of dynamite and marine algae Every year, the Nobel Prize awards attract great interest. They are the legacy of Swedish chemist Alfred Nobel, who became rich thanks to his invention of dynamite. Nitroglycerin is an excellent explosive, but it is also very

it’s Venti.

We comply with international standards. Venti Oelde supplies fans and accessories for the chemical and petrochemical industry according to international standards and customer specifications. In addition to many design advantages, the Venti solution impresses with pinpoint engineering, which optimises the fans for the entire system.

Long service life High operational safety High energy efficiency and s

ee us

at

en + 22 g o r t 0 Ni as 2 Syng

Come

n 2022 Berli arch 30 M – 8 2 8 d no. Stan

We make air work for you | www.venti-oelde.com


sensitive to knocks and therefore very dangerous to handle. By chance, Nobel discovered that a mixture of 25% diatomaceous earth and 75% nitroglycerin can be safely transported. The reason for this is the larger internal surface area of the silicic acid. Silicic acid is formed through deposits of marine algae. The shells consist largely of amorphous silicic acid. 1 gram has a surface area of around 20 m2. As a soil improver, diatomaceous earth stores water and nutrients. It also provides a habitat for bacteria and microorganisms. The best way for diatomaceous earth to be used is as a spreadable granulate. Australian company Agripower uses mixing technology from Eirich for this (Figure 4). As the first step, diatomaceous earth is mixed with the binding agent bentonite and moistened in an intensive mixer of type R33/7. The microgranulate is then pelletised in two disk pelletisers of type TR45, with a grain size distribution of between 2 and 4 mm in the granulate. This set-up is capable of producing approximately 40 tph of granulate around the clock.

Peat for smoky whisky and healthy plant growth Humic acids are high-molecular organic compounds. They are formed by the degradation of dead plant matter and contain a large number of complex polyphenols. If the malt used in whisky production is dried with peat fire, this gives the final product its typical smoky flavour; Scottish Islay whiskies are famous for their peaty, phenolic taste. Plants benefit from the water storage capacity of the peat, which also offers a fertile home for microorganisms, fungi and bacteria. As a result, humic acids are classed as bioeffectors. Normally, plenty of humic acids should be present naturally in the soil, but if this is not the case they can be added as soil improvers. Leonardite contains large quantities of humic acids (up to 90%) and is therefore used directly as a soil improver (Figure 2). It is a soft, waxy, shiny and vitreous mineraloid and is produced during the mining of lignite. The positive properties of leonardite can be combined with nutrient salts. Leonardite can be mixed with different minerals and granulated in an Eirich mixer. In the process, producers will benefit from an efficient and cost-effective production process. Once the raw materials have been thoroughly mixed, liquid is added. A granulate forms in just a few minutes. By optimising the recipe and process control, it is possible to manufacture larger granules directly in the mixer.

First focus on the soil, then think about fertilizer

Figure 3. Example of a plant for pelletising limestone, gypsum and other soil conditioner.

Figure 4. Production plant for pelletising diatomaceous earth, consisting of an Eirich intensive mixer R33/7 and two pelletising plates TR45. 44 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

No house can stand without solid foundations. And in exactly the same way, it only makes sense to add fertilizer to soil if the soil is actually capable of storing the added nutrients. The ideal solution is a good combination of soil improvers and fertilizers. This can provide a significant and lasting boost to the harvest yield. Although nitrogen is highly abundant in the air around us, the production of nitrogen fertilizers is very energy-intensive. The use of phosphorus is becoming increasingly rare now, and it is already seen as one of the more sought-after raw materials of the future. Consequently, the key to sustainable agriculture must therefore be the efficient use of raw materials. The use of soil improvers is a good solution here. Not only are they comparatively inexpensive, but they are also environmentally safe to use. Current trends show a rising demand for granulates that are both easy to measure out and easy to spread.


‘Dirty Sulfur’ Pump Problem-solving Jan Hermans, Sulphurnet-Liquid Sulphur Processing, the Netherlands, and Martha Villaseñor, Weir Minerals Lewis Pumps, USA, offer advice on how to overcome the challenges presented by ‘dirty sulfur’ pumps for smoother operation.

P

umping molten sulfur is not an easy task, as it is of high density, almost twice the specific gravity of water. It also solidifies below 120˚C (250˚F). Operators of plants that are burning sulfur will already know about the added challenges of supply, and the inevitable impurities that can be present. To maintain sulfur in its molten state, a pump with a rugged mechanical design that can manage a high specific gravity of 1.8 fluid with a steam jacketed shaft column and discharge pipe is required. Additionally, the pump must be designed to deal with a range of foreign solids. This is why these applications are referred to as ‘dirty sulfur’. The root cause of pump problems in a ‘dirty sulfur’ application can stem from: � Poor pump design and materials. � Clogged filters. � Poor sulfur processing. � Inadequate maintenance.

This article offers some considerations and best practices that Sulphurnet-Liquid Sulphur Processing and Weir Minerals have developed.

Pump design and materials are crucial ‘Clean sulfur’ processes require a robust vertical jacketed pump with a one-piece, large diameter shaft for increased power and radial load requirements. While the bearings are immersed in and lubricated by the sulfur, the pump shaft sealing arrangement does not come in contact with the molten sulfur by nature of the pump design. In ‘dirty sulfur’ applications, a vertical pump’s critical high-wear parts should be made from hardened steel. Some replicators make these parts out of alternate materials such as stainless steel. However, regular stainless steel does not have the hardness of the hardened steel used in Lewis® pump parts (~120 versus ~500 Brinell). Replicated parts may also lack 45


the close tolerance fit and abrasion resistance of original equipment manufacturer (OEM) parts. As a matter of good practice in ‘dirty sulfur’ applications, pumps that have closed or semi-open impellers should be designed so that a maintenance engineer can renew the tolerances between the impeller, suction wear plate and suction head by adjusting the pump shaft (Figure 1) – a distinguishing feature of Lewis pumps. Unlike ‘clean sulfur’ applications, the bearings of a pump are not submerged in ‘dirty sulfur’. Instead, they have lower and upper ball bearings to handle the radial loads. In theory, this should be enough to guarantee trouble-free performance. However, reality can present some conflicting scenarios.

In ‘dirty sulfur’ applications, foreign matter often clogs the suction head filter, which leads to pump starvation. Occasionally, these solids can get caught in the pump’s wetted parts. When using pumps in ‘dirty sulfur’, the total dynamic head can vary greatly: from almost no system resistance when the filter is clean to excessive losses when the filter is dirty. At start-up, when system resistance is low, the pump can run out of the flow curve, pumping such a large volume of sulfur that it is cavitating. As the filter gets dirty, the total dynamic head through the filter exceeds what the pump was designed for and flow rate declines. Neither extreme is good for the pump, nor the product. Keeping a steady flow of sulfur through the filter is crucial and benefits cake quality and consistency.

The dirt in ‘dirty sulfur’ can still cause problems

Poor processing design or procedures can create solids that overwhelm the pump

Unfortunately, it is fairly common for pumps in ‘dirty sulfur’ filter feed applications to break down. During a plant visit, the maintenance engineer said that the pump shaft had failed three times in a 6-month period. When it was working, the pump failed to deliver its designed flow rate at times. What was really going on? Well, as a pump manufacturer, the first response was to get the flow meters out: where is the pump operating along the flow curve?

Powdered lime needs to remain powdery To control the acidity of sulfur, manufacturers add lime, Ca(OH)2. The lime reacts with the acid present in the sulfur, forming gypsum (CaSO4). It is crucial that when the lime is added, it is in a powdery form and it does not create large gypsum lumps. Otherwise, the acid will not be adequately neutralised and the lumps could be caught inside the pump impeller and casing.

The melting plant and pump tank should keep solids suspended

Figure 1. A dirty sulfur cantilever Lewis pump with semi-open impeller and suction wear plate. Tight tolerances can be maintained to ensure high efficiency throughout the life of the pump.

A sulfur melting plant can include a melting tank, a melting tank with overflow tank, an underground melting tank and/or a pump pit. Depending on the design, the following problems can affect pump operation: � Inadequate tank agitation: can allow solids to accumulate at the pump inlet. It is important that the pump pit has agitation, preventing the solids from settling. � Solids overflowing from the melting tank into the pump pit: lumps and heavier solids should settle in the melting tank and be removed through a bottom drain. When agitation speed is high, a strainer can be installed in the overflow to prevent lumps from entering the pump pit.

The liquid sulfur filter draining process and procedure matter

Figure 2. A liquid sulfur filter. 46 | WORLD FERTILIZER | MARCH 2022

When a sulfur process team drains the liquid sulfur filter, it is crucial that they follow the correct procedure – otherwise an excessive amount of solids can build up in the pump pit. Two common shortcuts that cause pump problems are: � The drain’s flow rate is too high: this can cause filter cake erosion (Figure 2) and the return of an excessive volume of solids to the pump pit. � Incorrect draining sequence: to prevent a long downtime, the sulfur process team may leave the filter drain open, thereby driving a large percentage of the solids into it. Instead, it would be better to drain the filter through the filtrate outlet for as long as possible (using air


pressure). This approach would mean far fewer solids (only about one-third of the tank’s volume) would be returned to the pump pit.

the pump would be better off without a strainer and focus instead on better lime dosing and filter draining procedures (see previous discussion).

Talk with the OEM about installation and modifications

Using a variable frequency drive to ramp flow up and down

Any number of seemingly sensible, site-specific modifications can render a powerful, robust pump in ‘dirty sulfur’ weak and problematic. The following considerations should be kept in mind when installing a pump:

Pumps in ‘dirty sulfur’ applications are chosen based on the desired flow rate and the highest head possible. In other words, the pump is sized to meet the most demanding requirements. However, at filter start-up there are basically no restrictions. As the filter begins to fill, resistance grows, the head increases and flow rate is cut back. With barely any restrictions at start-up, the pump is operating almost out of the flow curve (Figure 3).

Installing suction extensions and strainers

As an example, a Lewis vertical cantilever pump is available in lengths of up to 84 in. If a longer length is needed, a suction extension could be added. Would it work, based on net positive suction head available (NPSHA) calculations? There are other factors to be mindful of. It is imperative to consider the geographical location of a pump; sea level versus high elevation makes a significant difference in NPSH. A 2-m extension may be feasible for a pump operating at sea level, but completely infeasible for the same pump operating at an elevation of 3000 m (10 000 ft). Another important consideration is that during start-up it is important to comply with the minimal submergence requirement so that the pump is primed. Once the pump is primed it can lift Figure 3. Lewis 2CLS vertical cantilever pump curve. sulfur through the suction extension without any problems. If the pump is not primed, entrained air can get into the pump head, forming air pockets. With lesser amounts of entrained air, the pump capacity can be weakened. However, if air is present the pump can become air-bound, stopping flow through the pump completely. A similar note of caution is sounded for suction strainers – the manufacturer should be consulted. While suction strainers are considered by some to be a ‘must’ for ‘dirty sulfur’ pump applications, the strainer can cause blinding. Blinding, or blockage of the suction filter screen, prevents the molten sulfur from flowing to the pump inlet. Starved for flow, Figure 4. Lewis 2CLS vertical cantilever pump curves at different speeds.

MARCH 2022 | WORLD FERTILIZER | 47


else can cause damaging pump vibrations because regular commercial bearings are not designed for the high radial loading vertical sulfur pumps endure. In addition, the upper and lower bearings both need Figure 5. Abrasion-worn semi-open impeller of a Lewis cantilever pump in ‘dirty sulfur’ application. to be serviced at the same time. Unfortunately, it is common for maintenance teams to overlook For this reason it is highly recommended to operate these the lower ball bearings. pumps with a variable frequency drive (VFD) – this is much less expensive in the long run and offers much finer control than throttle control valves. To send a constant flow of sulfur at a Suction wear plate impeller clearance lower head, the pump needs to operate at a decreased speed. Even though pumps manufactured for ‘dirty sulfur’ applications In Figure 4, for example, the speed was brought down from are made with hardened iron to resist the abrasion caused 1800 rpm (60 HZ) to 1212 rpm (40 HZ) to maintain 25 m3/hr at by small solids, with time, the design clearances are lost. A key component of the ‘dirty sulfur’ pump is the suction wear 12 m of head. plate. To lengthen the service life of the impeller, the wear plate needs to be adjusted periodically to maintain a proper Decrease downtime by following clearance from the impeller blades (Figure 5). recommended maintenance practices

Bearings

Conclusion

Cantilever pumps do not have submerged ball bearings. Instead, they use upper and lower bearings. It is critical to use high-capacity replacement ball bearings according to the manufacturer’s recommendation. Using anything

In sum, pumping ‘molten sulfur’ through filters is a dirty business! Hopefully the best practices and considerations outlined in this article can help plant managers to achieve more cost-effective and successful operations.

AD INDEX OFC | BD Energy Systems

IFC | Hydro, Inc.

13 | Boldrocchi Group

07 | Indo Amines

16 | Borsig

15 | J&H Equipment Inc.

21 | Chemetics

04 | Kreber

33 | Comessa 39 | CRU Nitrogen + Syngas 2022 19 | EMT/Doyle Equipment Manufacturing

IBC | Neelam Aqua & Speciality Chem(P) Ltd. 22, 29, 34 & 37 | Palladian Publications

OBC | Schmidt + Clemens Group

02 | Eurotecnica

09 | Stamicarbon

25 | Haldor Topsoe

43 | Venti Oelde


Maximizing plant performance by building on the S+C technological edge in high-alloy stainless steel products. Our principle: Listen & Resolve • S+C High Alloyed Steel • Cast and Spun Cast Materials & Components • Advanced Engineering Services • Innovative Centralloy® Alloys & Technologies • Project and Emergency Management • Inspection & Monitoring Services • On-Site Services Visit us on: schmidt-clemens.com

Schmidt + Clemens Group | Lindlar Germany | Tel: +49 2266-92-0 E-Mail: petrochemical@schmidt-clemens.de


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook