BE
Healthy ™
Sponsored by
Boston Public Health Commission
VOL. 4 • NO. 6
© February 2010
Vitamin D
PH OTO BY TON Y IRVIN G
A dose of sunshine goes a long way
Born and raised in Haiti, Gerda Paulissaint, 46, came to Boston about 12 years ago and a funny thing happened. She started having all sorts of aches and pains. Walking up a flight of stairs was particularly painful. “It was as if my legs were talking back to me,” she remembers. She knew she had high blood pressure, but that didn’t explain that sort of pain or her restless sleep. She dismissed all of her symptoms as simply the result of stress. Without much further thought, she quietly went on with her work as a community health advocate at Mattapan Community Health Center. And then a light switch turned on. Many of her patients were complaining of similar aches and pains and most of them had received blood test results
showing they lacked a sufficient amount of vitamin D. “Wait a minute,” she recalls thinking. It finally donned on her that she too might be short on vitamin D. She didn’t wait for a test to confirm her theory. She purchased a supply of over-the-counter vitamin D supplements. Evidently it helped. Paulissaint later requested a test to determine whether she was deficient. The test revealed a level of 38 nanograms per milliliter (ng/mL) — a number within the acceptable range, but just barely. The lack of vitamin D is not all that uncommon. The recent National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), a program sponsored by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, found that a large portion of adults
in the United States had low levels of vitamin D. Adolescents are not immune. A 2004 study by Children’s Hospital Boston determined Gerda Paulissaint, a medical advocate at Mattapan Community Health Center, attributed her aches and pains to low levels of vitamin D. that the problem was common in otherwise healthy index, an indicator of excessive weight. adolescents. Almost one-fourth of the So severe is the problem that rickets patients studied were low in the vitamin — once considered a thing of the past and 5 percent were severely deficient. — has re-emerged in infants and chilThe researchers further determined dren, particularly among blacks and that race, diet, lifestyle and season all those who are lactose intolerant. played a role. Vitamin D deficiency was Dr. Michael F. Holick, a leading more prevalent in black teenagers, those authority on vitamin D and professor of who consumed more soft drinks than Gerda, continued to page 4 milk and those with a high body mass
The man to see on vitamin D Of all Douglas Fairhurst’s medical problems, the most bewildering were his weakening muscles. An avid bicyclist, Fairhurst, 74, could barely lift his leg much less pedal a bike. “I could hardly walk,” he said. That’s when Fairhurst turned to Dr. Douglass Bibuld, the medical director of Mattapan Community Health Center. An expert on vitamin D, Dr. Bibuld was well aware of the benefits that accrue from the aptly named “Sunshine Vitamin.” Received primarily from the sun’s ultraviolet rays, vitamin D is known for its ability to maintain healthy bones. But given the fact that almost every cell is equipped to interact with vitamin D, Dr. Bibuld is convinced that the benefits extend far beyond bone health and includes protecting the immune system and preserving muscle strength. Equally important, Dr. Bibuld was aware of the prevalence of inadequate levels of vitamin D among older blacks — a deficiency that scientists attribute to increased risks for several life-threatening diseases and debilitating conditions. It didn’t take long before Dr. Bibuld prescribed a heavy dose of vitamin D for
PH O TO BY TO N Y IRVIN G
scores between 20 and 29 are considered insufficient. Scores of 30 or more are considered sufficient. Fairhurst’s reading was 32 — and that was after the heavy doses. And therein lies one of the problems now under serious debate within the medical community: Just what level of vitamin D in the blood is required for optimal health? The Vitamin D Council, a California-based non-profit established to increase awareness about vitamin D deficiencies and its related diseases, recommends a reading of 50 to 80 ng/ml for everyone all year round. According to the Council, at levels below 50, the body uses vitamin D as quickly as it is made. Above 50, the Because of weakness in his legs, Douglas Fairhurst body begins to store it for future use. was unable to ride his bike. After several months of a A related debate swirls around the prescription of vitamin D, he’s back in form. recommended daily allowance for viFairhurst — and that appeared to at least tamin D. The Academy of Pediatric Medicine restore a barely adequate level. recently increased its recommendations from The 25-hydroxy vitamin D test is the 200 International Units (IU) to 400 IU a day most accurate way to measure how much for children and adolescents. vitamin D is in the body. A reading below 20 The Institute of Medicine (IOM), a nonnanograms per milliliter (ng/mL) is deficient; profit organization that provides advice on
health issues, recommends 400 IU a day for adults up to the age of 60 and 600 IU for those over 60. But even the Institute has doubts and is revising its recommendations. Vitamin D specialists, such as Dr. Bibuld and Boston University School of Medicine’s Dr. Michael Holick, argue that 600 IU are barely enough and contend that at least 1,000 IU are needed to allow vitamin D to perform all of its functions. Don’t get Dr. Bibuld started on the current recommended daily allowance of 400 IU. “That’s way too low,” he said. He recommends 4,000 IU a day for blacks — and much more for those who are deficient. The Mattapan Community Health Center is squarely behind Dr. Bibuld on vitamin D. The Center is now part of a collaboration with the American Public Health Association to develop a national policy on vitamin D. From what the Center has seen, the numbers are alarming in the black community. With the assistance of Dr. Holick, they found that in 2007, 85 percent of their patients tested for vitamin D levels had Douglas continued to page 4
Calcium and vitamin D: The dynamic duo Many of us were taught growing up that calcium is the building block to healthy bones — drinking milk and eating dairy products will make us healthy and strong. This adage is undisputedly true, but what we didn’t know was that vitamin D is required for calcium to do its job. If calcium is the building block to healthy bones, vitamin D is considered the cement. Without an adequate supply, calcium can not be utilized by our bodies to build strong bones and perform other vital physiological functions. Calcium is absorbed through the small intestine, and this process is not possible without ample amounts of vitamin D. The two work in unison to build a healthy body. “Vitamin D’s role in keeping our bodies functioning properly has been underappreciated,” says Dr. Jan Cook, Medical Director of Medical Innovation and Leadership for Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts. “It plays an extremely important role in the body’s absorption of calcium and is vital to a person’s development, growth, and maintenance of a healthy body.”
blood — are secreted with calcium’s help. So important are these functions to survival that, when levels of calcium fall below the required level, the body robs the vital mineral from the bones — the storehouse of calcium. So you can see why maintaining a good level of calcium and vitamin D is critical.
Calcium for life It is clear then that too little calcium can result in bone loss, particularly in postmenopausal women. The National Institutes of Health has determined that women may lose as much as 5 percent of their bone mass every year after menopause. Men are not exempt. According to the website www.aboutcalcium.com, men are also vulnerable to bone loss and need to consume adequate calcium through their older years as a preventive measure, and in their younger years to achieve peak bone mass. Children often don’t get enough calcium, which is essential to build their growing bones. A lack of calcium in childhood can also have a lasting health impact. In recognition of this fact, the Massachusetts Department of Public Health has taken an active role in targeting youth for the prevention of adult bone loss. This action stems from research findings that suggest the most important period for adequate calcium and vitamin D absorption is during teenage years. Studies have shown that peak bone mass is reached around the age of 20. After adolescence, as the body ages, bones gradually deteriorate. Your body needs more calcium as you age. The federal government’s recommended daily requirement for infants is 210 milligrams (mg), whereas adults 19 to 50 years should get a minimum of 1,000 mg per day. Over 50, you need at least 1,200 mg per day. Calcium intake above the recommended daily requirement is usually not a problem. However, over a long period of time, people ingesting large amounts of calcium (above 2,500 mg per day) can get kidney stones. The good news is that it’s easy to get calcium. It’s found natu-
Without calcium, muscles would not contract, nerve cells would not communicate with each other, the heart would not beat effectively.
A Powerhouse Scientists are learning more every day about the important link between calcium and vitamin D. Researchers have discovered that vitamin D actually regulates the amount of calcium in our bodies. Vitamin D increases the rate at which calcium is reabsorbed from the food in the gastro-intestinal tract. Without adequate levels of vitamin D, a large percentage of dietary calcium is never absorbed by the intestine and instead is lost as waste products. Sounds scientific, but it is a very important fact to know! Calcium is the most common mineral in the body and one of the most important for proper functioning. Although 99 percent of calcium is found in bones and teeth, it’s that 1 percent that’s the powerhouse of the body. Without calcium, muscles would not contract, nerve cells would not communicate with each other, the heart would not beat effectively. Blood clots because of calcium, and hormones, such as insulin — which regulates sugar in the
rally in dairy products, leafy green vegetables and certain seafood, and is added to foods, such as cereals and orange juice. Supplements can help when diets are lacking.
Where’s the calcium? Calcium is found in dairy products including yogurt, cheeses and milk; to reduce fat intake try skim milk or low fat products.
Dark, leafy green vegetables such as spinach, kale, collard greens, and broccoli are all good sources of calcium. These foods are great in salads, stir-fries or even on their own.
Seafood like sardines, pink salmon, ocean perch, blue crab, clams and rainbow trout can be a tasty way to up your intake.
Select foods, including cereal and orange juice, are often fortified with calcium and can be good sources.
So many choices Calcium can also be obtained through supplements, but the trick is to determine which one. There are many choices — carbonate, citrate, lactate, gluconate. Here are some helpful tips. • Calcium carbonate contains the most calcium per pill (40 percent), but should be taken after meals. • Calcium citrate contains less calcium per pill (20 percent), but does not need to be taken with food. • Determine the amount of “elemental calcium” — the amount available for the body to absorb and what’s counted in the recommended daily dose of calcium. If not specified, check the Nutrition Facts label. The amount of elemental calcium will be listed in milligrams (mg) according to “serving size” — generally one or two tablets. • Gluconate and lactate contain low content of elemental calcium, and would require several tablets to meet the calcium requirement. • Avoid dolomite, oyster shell and bone meal calcium. They might contain metals and lead. • Look for USP (United States Pharmacopeia) symbol on the package, which designates standards for quality and purity. • If the symbol is not listed, you can test the quality of pill by dissolving it in clear vinegar. Stir occasionally. If the pill dissolves within 30 minutes, it will also dissolve in your stomach.
2 BE Healthy • http://behealthy.baystatebanner.com
Questions & Answers 1. Why does obesity increase the risk of vitamin D deficiency or insufficiency? Vitamin D is a fat soluble vitamin which means it is stored in our fat cells. As our weight and percentage of body fat increase, vitamin D levels fall. Overweight individuals appear to deposit some of their vitamin D in their excessive fatty tissue, making it more difficult to raise their vitamin D levels. Studies have shown that obese people tend to obtain lower levels of vitamin D — even when exposed to ultraviolet light or when taking vitamin D supplements.
February is Vitamin D Deficiency Month
A closer look IM AG E F R O M D EL AVAL
Lisa Michelle Owens, M.D. Medical Director Brigham Primary Physicians at Faulkner Hospital
2. Why are vitamin D supplements necessary for breastfeeding babies? Breastfeeding babies get their milk from their mom and human milk does not have adequate amounts of vitamin D to meet the needs of a growing baby. 3. What’s the best source of vitamin D for vegetarians? Depending on the foods they embrace, vegetarians can get vitamin D from foods fortified with vitamin D, such as cow or soy milk, yogurt, orange juice and certain cereals. Vitamin D supplements and sun exposure are also opportunities for boosting vitamin D levels in those who do not eat fish. 4. Why does vitamin D deficiency increase during the winter in northern cities? Vitamin D insufficiency or deficiency increases during the winter months because of the increased prevalence of overcast days and the reduced strength of ultraviolet B rays — the major source of vitamin D development. The significant decrease in sunlight results in dramatic decrease in the activation of vitamin D in our skin.
Links to low levels Several studies suggest that normal levels of vitamin D are required to reduce the risk for many chronic illnesses, such as:
Vitamin D deficiency and insufficiency are common in young people. So much so that rickets, or bone weakness, has made a comeback. Rickets is seen more frequently in black children often due to less time playing outdoors and low consumption of dairy products particularly in those who are lactose intolerant. Teens who favor soft drinks and iced teas over fortified milk and cereal are also hard hit. The American Academy of Pediatrics recently revised its guidelines and now recommends a minimum daily intake of 400 IU of vitamin D beginning soon after birth and continuing through adolescence.
• Rickets • Osteomalacia (adult rickets) • Osteoporosis • Fractures and falls • Osteoarthritis • Bone and muscle pain • Muscle weakness • Heart disease • Heart failure • Stroke • Hypertension • Depression • Schizophrenia • Multiple sclerosis
• • • • • • • • • • • •
Asthma Flu Obesity Inflammatory diseases Breast cancer Colon cancer Prostate cancer Autoimmune diseases Diabetes 1 and 2 Fibromyalgia Chronic fatigue syndrome Metabolic syndrome
5. If a person prefers to avoid the sun, is it possible to obtain adequate levels of vitamin D through the diet? Yes, but the amounts required may be excessive. Milk and orange juice are classic beverages fortified with vitamin D. Yogurt is often fortified with vitamin D as well. It is important to note that cheese, which is a good source of calcium, does not contain high amounts of vitamin D. Oily fish, such as salmon and mackerel, is the best natural source of vitamin D in the diet. 6. Is there a risk of getting too much vitamin D? Vitamin D toxicity is rare and occurs only with very excessive use of vitamin D supplements. It is not possible to get too much vitamin D from the sun. Toxic levels of vitamin D can cause nonspecific symptoms such as nausea, vomiting, poor appetite, constipation, weakness, and weight loss. More serious side effects include elevated blood levels of calcium, causing mental status changes such as confusion and heart rhythm abnormalities. 7. What’s the difference between vitamin D2 and vitamin D3? When people have very low levels of vitamin D, or are considered deficient, doctors will prescribe high doses of vitamin D2 (available by prescription only) to take once a week for a few months. The dose is usually 50,000 International Unit (IU). When levels improve, doctors then switch them to once daily vitamin D3, which is available as an over-the-counter supplement. If a person has mildly low levels of vitamin D, or are considered insufficient, doctors will start them on daily vitamin D3 from the very beginning. The supplements typically are sold in doses of 1,000 to 2,000 IU.
Who’s at risk? •
African Americans – melanin reduces the skin’s ability to make vitamin D
•
Those with limited exposure to sunlight
•
Breastfed infants – mother’s milk does not contain enough vitamin D
•
Elderly – less able to convert vitamin D to its active form
•
Vegetarians that follow a strict plant-based diet
•
People with certain intestinal problems, such as celiac disease
•
Obese people – excess fat impedes the circulation of vitamin D
The information presented in BE HEALTHY is for educational purposes only, and is not intended to take the place of consultation with your private physician. We recommend that you take advantage of screenings appropriate to your age, sex, and risk factors and make timely visits to your primary care physician.
BE Healthy • http://behealthy.baystatebanner.com 3
Gerda continued from page 1 person, season, city and time of day. medicine, physiology and biophysics at Processing those sunrays is a group Boston University School of Medicine, effort among the skin, liver and kidney. is unequivocal about the importance of But in order for the process to work, the vitamin D and its proper levels required UVB rays have to be long and strong for optimal health. enough to pull off the job. And they are He refers to several studies that — from the spring through early fall. But have linked low vitamin D levels with in the late fall and winter, they are too the risk of heart disease, stroke, multiple short and that explains increased defisclerosis, type 1 diabetes, depression, asthma, many cancers and diseases of the ciencies during cold months. A major biological function of vitaimmune system. min D is to help the body absorb calcium In the most recent issue of the Anand phosphorus. Calcium is stored in nals of Family Medicine, a study indicated that disproportionately low vitamin bones, but is a major workhorse throughD levels might explain higher death rates out the body. It makes the heart work and muscles contract. If vitamin D does not from cardiovascular disease in blacks. do its job, the body “robs Peter to pay The researchers concluded that vitamin D levels might be an independent — and Paul” by taking calcium from the bones and using it elsewhere. The impact on possibly modifiable — risk factor for bones can be devastating. cardiovascular disease. That’s why low levels of vitamin D The importance of vitamin D is a are associated with osteoporosis, rickets subject of on-going debate. Researchers in children and osteomalacia, or soft from Massachusetts General Hospital bones in adults. Fractures and falls are found that it may be vitamin D — not common in those lacking vitamin D. C — that keeps colds, the flu and other The issue of vitamin D is of particrespiratory illnesses at bay. They noted that people with asthma and emphysema, ular interest to blacks. Melanin – the substance that gives skin its color – provides for example, might be particularly susa barrier to UVB in ceptible to respirathe skin. That does tory infections from not mean skin of vitamin D deficiency darker hues cannot — an indication make vitamin D – it to some medical just takes more time. experts that it might While it may take also play a key whites and people role in the immune with light skin about system. 10 minutes to proVitamin D is cess sufficient levels a bit of an enigma. of vitamin D, it may For starters, it really require blacks closer isn’t a vitamin at all. to an hour. Vitamins are organic All of this was compounds that the new to Paulissaint. body needs but canHaving enough not make on its own. Douglass Bibuld, MD sunshine was not a Rather, the body Medical Director problem when she receives its vitamins Mattapan Community Health Center lived in Haiti. But from the food and living in Boston liquids that we eat presented an entirely different challenge, and drink. especially considering that symptoms Unlike other vitamins, vitamin D is for Vitamin D deficiency are subtle and made by the body, is found in very few often unrecognized. foods, and, oddly enough, is actually a Aches and pains, fatigue, sleepless hormone. nights—all can be signs of the deficiency Appropriately named the “Sunshine and are often dismissed as the result of Vitamin,” vitamin D’s major source is aging or a stressful lifestyle. More often the sun — ultraviolet B (UVB) rays to be exact — the same rays responsible for than not, doctors are not looking for it and seldom order up the right tests. suntans and sunburns. A true believer in the power of vitaAnd skin cancer. min D, Palissaint readily admits to back The American Academy of Dersliding once. matology warns against unprotected During a summer vacation in Haiti, exposure to ultraviolet rays. The Acadshe stopped taking the supplements. emy declared “There is no scientifically validated, safe threshold level of UV (in- There was little need on a Caribbean cluding UVB) exposure from the sun that island. But when she returned to Boston allows for maximal vitamin D synthesis and did not resume taking the supplewithout increasing skin cancer risk.” ments, she paid the price. A follow-up Dr. Deborah Scott, a dermatologist test revealed that her vitamin D level had at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, says dropped to 25.8 ng/mL — considered the sun is an excellent source of vitamin below the standard for healthy living. D. But everyone — including AfriShe is on a two - month prescription of can Americans — must guard against 50,000 IU a week to get her numbers excessive exposure. “There’s a balance back up. between sun exposure and vitamin D,” Paulissaint is now a vitamin D conshe said. vert; there’s no turning back. “I feel way, But where that balance lies is a bit way better,” she said. tricky. The times of exposure — and “I’m a new woman now.” resultant vitamin D levels — vary by
Want to know the score? The 25-hydroxy vitamin D test measures the level of vitamin D in the body. Vitamin D Status Deficient Insufficient Sufficient
Value Less than 20 nanograms/milliliter (ng/mL) 20 to 29 ng/mL 30 ng/mL or more
The Vitamin D Council recommends a minimum reading of 50 ng/mL
4 BE Healthy • http://behealthy.baystatebanner.com
Looking for vitamin D? You might not find enough in food. Food does not provide an adequate single source of vitamin D to maintain optimal health. Only cod liver oil, salmon and mackerel are high in vitamin D. Below are examples of how much you’d have to consume of a particular food to meet the current recommended daily allowance of 400 IU.
5 cups 50 ounces
of fortified yogurt
of Swiss cheese.
10 cups of fortified cereal
one 3-ounce
4 glasses
serving of sockeye salmon
of fortified milk
17 egg yolks
Even varying the amounts and types of food would fall short and may be contrary to a healthy eating plan. In addition, these estimates are based on 400 IU. Scientists now recommend that people consume at least 1,000 IU of vitamin D a day, thereby tripling the above amounts. That is why supplements and/or limited time in the sun are recommended to attain a healthy level of vitamin D in the blood.
How to get your D Look to the sun In general, five to ten minutes twice a week in the summer sun without sunscreen will make about 10,000 to 20,000 IU for those with fair skin. It will take a darker skinned person about six times that amount of time. Doctors recommend you put on sunscreen or cover up after the minutes in the sun.
Take a pill If you prefer to avoid sun, supplements are required. New guidelines on daily required intake are forthcoming. Specialists in vitamin D recommend a minimum of 1,000 IU a day for optimal health. Your doctor can best advise you.
Douglas
continued from page 1
scores of below 20 ng/mL — well below the recommended minimum of 30, and, worse, the average score was about 13 in the winter months. Dr. Bibuld understands part of the problem — at least among blacks — is that higher levels of melanin makes it more difficult to process ultraviolet B rays. Melanin tends to block rather than absorb the sun. That process is worse for the elderly whose bodies are unable to produce vitamin D as easily as in their younger days. Dr. Bibuld believes that everyone should have a baseline test and go from there. For the most part, it’s easy to get a good dose of vitamin D and it doesn’t cost a dime — at least in the summer. Just five to 10 minutes of sun twice a week — or thirty minutes for those of darker skin is enough. It’s possible to make over 10,000 IU in that short period of time. Supplements and fatty fish can complement the sun when necessary. And don’t worry. According to Dr. Holick, it’s impossible to overdose on vitamin D from the sun. The body stops making the vitamin when it has ample supply. Even
overdoses from supplements are basically unheard of. Dr. Bibuld well recognizes the implications of vitamin D and its potential impact on health. “You can’t correct health disparities overnight,” he acknowledged. “But think of what this could do to health care costs and the impact on the cost of the insurance industry. It’s huge.” Just ask Fairhurst. At a subsequent doctor’s appointment, Fairhurst put on a performance. “Look,” he proudly proclaimed as he held up his leg. At first Dr. Bibuld missed the point. He thought that Fairhurst wanted his leg examined. But then he realized that Fairhurst’s strength had returned. More important, Fairhurst boasted, he was able to walk without difficulty. Fairhurst admits he had never heard of vitamin D before meeting Dr. Bibuld and had no understanding of its impact on the body. But he does now. For him, the evidence is clear. “I can ride my bike again,” he said.
Comments on Be Healthy? Contact Health Editor Karen Miller at kmiller@bannerpub.com.