THE NINETEEN ELEVEN
DEBATE TEAM University of Washington- University of Idaho Moscow, March 25, 19 10
QUESTION:
Resolved, That all corporations engaged in interstate commerce should be required to take mtt a federal charter. Concessio11s: ( 1) S uch legislation is constitutional; ( 2) a federal license shall not be available as an a lternative solution. TilE SPF..\ KI':RS.
Negative-\ Vashington
:\ffirmati ve-Idaho P .\UL DutHH£
RAy CLIFFORD
fR.\ TwE£UY
REUBto:N
Jo 11 N
LLOYD BLACK
RocK
J!Tum
SPE,\KER T.N REFUTATION.
JonN RocK ........... . .. Affirmative .................. Idaho
Chair111a11 . ......................... PROF.
JoHN
F.
M.\CL\NE
JUDGES. J-loN.
T. T.
KEt~L
lioN.
TT. P.
KNIGHT
flol'\.}. L.
Decision-vVashington 2; Idaho 1. ETGIITY-FOUR
l\lcCLE.\R