GTAAonline Magazine - February 2024

Page 1

2024 New Rental 2023 Review Vital Services Disruption Update AGM & Annual Dinner
February
14,000 PRODUCTS Contact us: 1.800.207.8325 sales@hsbuild.com HSBUILD.COM Serving the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) & its surrounding regions, including Ottawa, Kingston, Kitchener-Waterloo, Hamilton, London, and Burlington. For All Maintenance Needs!

PRESIDENT’S Message

Congratulations to Margaret Herd, this year’s winner of the Sam Grossman Award of Excellence. It was great to see her onstage and hear her acceptance speech. Margaret is an inspiration to our industry, and a role model to many. In keeping with great moments, Margaret was presented the award after a rousing introduction by Laura Holland. An apropos moment with two leaders in our sector. Yes, they’re both women, so that made is more special. But even if they weren’t, the moment was extraordinary.

Thank you to Laura Holland, who recently ended her term as GTAA’s Chair. In fact, she was Chair for two terms (four years). The pandemic caused havoc and included the cancellation of gatherings and events. But the core of what GTAA does is policy work. Laura was always front and centre at our meetings with municipal government officials – Mayors, politicians, and various senior level bureaucrats. Many other industry peers, especially Directors on GTAA’s Board, also actively promote our interests on a regular basis by attending these meetings. This is on top of their daily responsibilities, and their effort is greatly appreciated.

Our recent Annual Dinner included a celebratory toast for our 25th Anniversary. Joining me on stage for the festivities were: Brad Butt, GTAA’s first fulltime President; Sam Grossman, GTAA’s first Chair; and Laura Holland, current Chair. The audience included many who have been with us since the beginning in 1998. Many who joined us along the way. And lots of new faces –these were a combination of young people at longstanding GTAA Members, and from the many companies that recently joined our association. This breadth and diversity brings a balance of knowledge and fresh ideas.

Thanks for being a part of our journey. We’ll work together to promote our interests to generally unsympathetic politicians – who often do the ‘vote thing’ instead of the ‘right thing’.

The future looks extremely promising, and we look forward to the next 25 years working with you.

gtaaonline.com | 5
A n n u a l G e n e r a l M e e t i n g A n n u a l G e n e r a l M e e t i n g & D i n n e r & D i n n e r A n n u a l G o l f T o u r n a m e n t A n n u a l G o l f T o u r n a m e n t 30 30 27 27 G T A A G T A A E V E N T S E V E N T S O C T O C T P a r k v i e w M a n o r P a r k v i e w M a n o r SAVE THE DATES SAVE THE DATES 111 1 M A Y M A Y J U L Y J U L Y N i g h t a t t h e R a c e s N i g h t a t t h e R a c e s L i o n h e a d G o l f C l u b L i o n h e a d G o l f C l u b W o o d b i n e R a c e t r a c k W o o d b i n e R a c e t a c k 2024 2024 6 | February 2024 MILLENNIUM Members

100% of packages accepted in every size and shape

Smart technology & design for easy-to-use experience

Unparalleled service, support teams available 24/7 for carriers, residents and communities

Indoor - Outdoor and refrigerated models available

Multiple revenue opportunities

99.9% uptime guaranteed

Why do property owners and managers prefer

Luxer

One?

Luxer One and Coinamatic have partnered together to provide over 15 years of experience in multifamily lockers as well as over 75 years of experience operating and serving this multi-family industry.

We strive to provide the best product, delivery and installation experience, and user experience to building residents, carriers and property managers alike!

us today at 1-877-755-5302

Luxer One Contactless Parcel Delivery Lockers
or info@coinamatic.com for more information PARTNE R REGISTERED
Contact

Publisher

Nishant Rai

Account Executive

Justin Kreslin

Editorial

Daryl Chong

Creative Director / Designer

Scott Clark

Office Manager

Geeta Lokhram

Published By:

GTAAOnline is published monthly by RHB Inc. on behalf of the Greater Toronto Apartment Association (GTAA) and is distributed online through controlled circulation to the GTAA membership.

Please contact the Publisher for advertising dates and rates. Opinions expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of the GTAA Board or management. GTAA accepts no liability for information contained herein.

Opinions expressed in articles are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of the GTAA Board or management. GTAA and RHB Inc. accept no liability for information contained herein. All rights reserved. Contents may not be reproduced without the written permission from the publisher. P.O.

All contents copyright ©

8 | February 2024 FEBRUARY 2024 In this ISSUE
Box
Maple, ON
416-236-7473
696,
L6A 1S7
RHB
10 New Rental 2023 Review 16 Vital Services Disruption Plan Updated Form and Guidance Document 18 Toronto's Building Emissions Performance Reporting By-Law 20 Annual General Meeting 24 Annual Dinner 28 Charitable Foundation Donates $150,000 at Annual Dinner 30 Margaret Herd - Sam Grossman Award of Excellence 32 Dinner Raffle 34 HST & GST Exemption for Purpose-Built Rental 36 Rent Collection 101
Inc.
Exclusive Insurance Rates for the Rental Housing Industry Member and supplier members of apartment associations have access to exclusive discounts on home and auto insurance with Westland MyGroup. Click or call for a quote today for a chance to WIN $5,000: westlandmygroup.ca/GTAA | 1-844-999-7687

New Rental 2023 Review

Urbanation publishes quarterly UrbanRental Reports detailing development in the Greater Toronto Area (and beyond). Per these reports, 26 new rental buildings opened in 2023. These added 5,543 brand new suites to our purpose-built rental (“PBR”) inventory. 2023 doubled the region’s output in 2022, where 2,750 units were opened in 16 new apartment buildings.

The openings in 2023 were the highest single year total since the rental boom of the 1960s-1970s. But some of 2023’s output was the clearing of lingering delays due to the pandemic.

To put in proper perspective, the 5-year average of new openings is 2,625 units in Toronto, and only 833 units per year in the 905 belt immediately surrounding Toronto (does not include Hamilton). A decent year, but still chronically low. Recall that in 2022, only 10 new rental building opened in Toronto, totalling 1,486 suites, and 6 buildings with 1,259 units in the rest of the GTA. While in 2021, there were 2,800 new units housed in 9 new rental buildings in Toronto, and merely 2 with just 347 units in the surrounding area.

The ever-increasing cost of ownership coupled to the demand for housing that supports massive new immigration targets means that purpose-built rental housing is in huge demand. The crux of our housing supply shortage is more than four decades of insignificant development of PBR.

10 | February 2024

BRITISH COLUMBIA

VANCOUVER

Lance Coulson***

Executive Vice President lance.coulson@cbre.com 604. 662. 5141

VANCOUVER

Greg Ambrose* Vice President greg.ambrose@cbre.com

604. 662. 5178

EDMONTON

David Young*

Executive Vice President dave.young@cbre.com 780. 917. 4625

EDMONTON

Thomas Chibri* Vice President thomas.chibri@cbre.com 780. 424. 5475

CALGARY

Richie Bhamra*

Executive Vice President richie.bhamra@cbre.com 403. 303. 4569

TORONTO

David Montressor* Vice Chairman

TORONTO

Tom Schuster*

Associate Director tom.schuster@cbre.com 416. 847. 3257

WATERLOO

Martin Cote* Vice President martin.cote@cbre.com

519. 340. 2317

david.montressor@cbre.com 416. 815. 2332 LONDON

Kevin MacDougall** Vice President kevin.macdougall@cbre.com 519. 286. 2013

OTTAWA

Nico Zentil* Executive Vice President nico.zentil@cbre.com 613. 788. 2708

Scan to receive Apartment Listings and Market Research

HALIFAX

Robert

HALIFAX

Chris

NEWFOUNDLAND NEW BRUNSWICK NOVA SCOTIA QUÉBEC
COLUMBIA ALBERTA
MANITOBA ONTARIO Sales Representative * Broker ** Personal Real Estate Corporation *** National Apartment Group
375.
Associate
514. 375. 0830
BRITISH
SASKATCHEWAN
MONTREAL Patrick Beaulé* Executive Vice President patrick.beaule@cbre.com 514.
0828 MONTREAL David Vu*
david.vu@cbre.com
Mussett* Executive Vice President robert.mussett@cbre.com 902. 492. 2065
Carter* Senior Vice President chris.carter@cbre.com 902. 492. 2085
REGION
WATERLOO REGION
James Craig* Vice President james.craig2@cbre.com 519. 340. 2330
9 OFFICES ACROSS CANADA 15 SALES PROFESSIONALS $22B+ HISTORICAL SALES VOLUME
ONTARIO
ALBERTA NOVA SCOTIA
QUÉBEC gtaaonline.com | 11

The following table is from Urbanation’s four quarterly UrbanRental reports lists 2023’s PBR openings across the GTA.

12 | February 2024 2023 Purpose-Built Rental Openings across the GTA Developer Name Address Storeys Suites 2023 Occupancy Woodbourne Residences at The Well - A 425 Wellington St West, Toronto 16 171 February Princess Management The Kipton 55 Warrender Ave, Toronto 16 254 March TAS The Campbell 299 Campbell Ave, Toronto 14 226 March Kiya 513 Dundas 513 Dundas St East, Whitby 6 73 March Woodbourne Residences at The Well - B 435 Wellington St West, Toronto 16 160 April Lormel Homes LNX Residences 2376 Dundas St West, Toronto 27 393 April Benvenuto Group Aberdeen on The Kingsway 299 The Kingsway, Toronto 9 81 April Starlight Investments Sheridan Crossing 2215 Sheridan Park Dr, Mississauga 17 138 May Concert Properties 20 Samuel Wood 20 Samuel Wood Way, Toronto 21 233 June The Rose Corporation The Bakerfield 195 Deerfield Rd, Newmarket 15 216 June Dream Unlimited, Tricon, Kilmer Group Maple House at Canary Landing 131, 151 & 181 Mill St, Toronto 25, 16 & 16 539 August Woodbourne, RioCanLiving FourFifty The Well 450 Front St, Toronto 46 592 August Clifton Blake College West 897 College St, Toronto 7 76 September SmartCentresREIT The Millway 185 Millway Ave, Vaughan 36 & 5 458 September Destaron Property Management Marlborough Manor 1254 Marlborough Crt, Oakville 6 70 September Camrost-Felcorp, DiamondCorp, DawscoGroup 36 Brentcliffe Luxury Rentals 36 Brentcliffe Rd, Toronto 18 262 October Arcanos Property Management The Hampton 101 Roehampton Ave, Toronto 38 255 October Oben Flats The Fairbank 2280 Eglinton Ave W, Toronto 8 141 October Collecdev 480 Wilson 480 Wilson Ave, Toronto 12 50 October Medallion Corporation Emery Crossing 15 Vena Way, Toronto 30 & 26 514 October Boardwalk REIT, Redwood Properties 45 Railroad - South Tower 45 Railroad St, Brampton 25 180 November Daniels Corporation, Choice Properties REIT Uniti Rentals 10 Lagerfeld Dr, Brampton 27 302 November Starlight Investments Oakhill 291 Queens Ave, Oakville 10 159 November

New is 20-years old (since 2003), and the following table (courtesy of Urbantion) shows the size of the new inventory and the Q4 vacancy rates year-over-year. Former Toronto is the old City of Toronto prior to amalgamation, generally known as downtown. Outer 416 are the former pre-amalgamation municipalities (including North York, Etobicoke and Scarborough). GTA 905 is the immediate area surrounding Toronto (excludes Hamilton).

gtaaonline.com | 13 Q4 2023 UrbanRental 9 2,410 1,220 2,467 1,359 2,421 785 476 333 127 1,532 678 287 347 1,259 1,596 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 GTA New Purpose-built Rental Completions by Region GTA 905 Outer 416 Former Toronto 3,873 1,983 3,147 2,745 5,549 43.9% 44.3% 62.4% $4.55 $4.01 $3.59 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 Former Toronto Outer 416 905 Region GTA Former Toronto Outer 416 905 Region GTA Absorption Rates and Average Rents PSF for GTA Purpose-built Rentals Completed in 2023 Absorption Rate Avg. Rent PSF: Q4-23

It’s difficult to draw trends due to the relatively small number of new buildings each year. There is considerable annual fluctuation, and whenever a significant increase occurs it is misconstrued as a boom or a rental renaissance. While Toronto saw 2.6X more new units in 2023 versus 2022, there was a correspondingly sharp 50% decrease in 2022 versus 2021. Even the biggest year in the past few decades pales when compared to almost any year in the mid-1960s to mid-1970s.

We need more purpose-built rental supply.

14 | February 2024
PBR Developments by Year Toronto, 905, GTA Toronto 905 GTA # Units # Buildings # Units # Buildings # Units # Buildings 2023 3,947 18 1,596 8 5,543 26 2022 1,486 10 1,259 6 2,745 16 2021 2,800 9 347 2 3,147 11 2020 1,381 6 287 3 1,668 9 2019 3,510 10 678 3 4,188 13 2018 1,323 5 144 1 1,467 6 2017 1,026 3 736 3 1,762 6 2016 1,048 8 661 4 1,709 12 2015 571 3 187 2 758 5 2014 518 2 480 3 998 5 Total 17,610 74 6,375 35 23,985 109 avg/y past 10 1,761 7.4 638 3.5 2,399 10.9 2014-2023 17,610 74 6375 35 23,985 109 2004-2013 3,588 16 1,440 9 5,028 25 Total 20 years 21,198 90 7,815 44 29,013 134 avg/y past 20 1,060 4.5 391 2 1,451 6.7
New
Here are more granular details regarding local development in the PBR universe using Urbanation’s database.

National Apartment Group - Ontario

Ontario’s multi-residential sector remains one of the most resilient segments of commercial real estate capital markets. Notwithstanding market volatility over the last 18 months, investor sentiment for multifamily assets remains strong. At the onset of 2024, values have weathered the impact of higher borrowing costs and are well-positioned to counteract higher interest rates through recurring income growth. Please see below for a summary of recent deals and active listings as of Q1 2024.

For additional info on cap rates, valuations, and market trends in the current investment landscape, please reach out to a member of the CBRE National Apartment Group.

Park Vista Apartments

Toronto, Ontario

4 Properties | 370 Units

ACTIVE LISTING

2300 Marine Drive, Oakville, Ontario

47 Suites | $438,298 per Suite

Closed December 2023

SOLD FOR: $20,600,000

For more information, please contact:

David Montressor * Vice Chairman

(416) 815-2332

david.montressor@cbre.com

* Sales Representative 2

Scan to receive

Tom Schuster * Associate Director

(416) 847-3257

tom.schuster@cbre.com

Apartment Listings and Market Research

Premier Niagara Region Apartment Portfolio Welland, Ontario

5 Properties | 427 Units

ACTIVE LISTING

3385 Dundas Street West, Toronto, Ontario

131 Units | $671,756 Per Suite

Closed January 2024

SOLD FOR: $88,000,000

PARK VISTA 121 SUITES 6 PARK VISTA 108 SUITES 8 PARK VISTA 56 SUITES 7 PARK VISTA 85 SUITES

Vital Services Disruption Plan

Updated Form and Guidance Document

After months of back-and-forth with the City of Toronto’s Legal Department, they have updated the Vital Services Disruption Plan Form and the companion Guidance Document. Recall that GTAA won the legal application a year ago, so many of the previous requirements are no longer mandatory.

The preamble/background introduction paragraph on the Form states:

“This form includes standards and minimum requirements in Sections 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 that must be provided along with some optional services you may provide but are not required to provide [see items marked as “OPTIONAL” in sections 5 and 6]. Owners/operators must begin implementing the Vital Service Disruption Plan once they have identified an unplanned vital service disruption.”

The City’s Guidance Document states (starting at the bottom of page 1) the following:

“The Vital Services Disruption Plan also includes optional provisions Section 5 (drinking water, kitchen access and other) and Section 6 (lodging, drinking water, food, clothing and personal items).”

GTAA strongly recommends that you use the updated form and write “NONE” in the Optional sections. Here are scans of the updated VSDP Form:

5. Services for tenants during shelter-in-place events

Heat

Confirm that the owner/operator will provide tenants with resources to safely heat their units to a minimum temperature of 21 degrees between September 15 and June 1 within 24 hours of the disruption onset during periods where electricity and/or gas are not available (at the expense of the owner/operator). Note: the installation of some temporary generators or heating devices may require approval of the Electrical Safety Authority or the Technical Standards

Fire Safety Plan

Confirm that the owner/operator will continue to meet all obligations under the Ontario Fire Code and implement the necessary provisions of the approved Fire Safety Plan.

Building Security

Confirm that the owner/operator will secure the premises in the event that a vital service disruption has an impact on normal day-to-day security measures.

Drinking Water (Optional)

If the owner/operator chooses to provide tenants with drinking water within 24 hours of a disruption onset where water has been discontinued (at the expense of the owner/ operator) please specify.

Kitchen access (may include access to operating appliances and/or hot meals, meal vouchers, or food)

(Optional) If the owner/operator chooses to provide tenants with access to operating cooking and refrigeration appliances and/or food, such as hot meals and/or meal vouchers within 24 hours of the disruption onset (at the expense of the owner/operator) please specify.

Other Provisions (Optional)

Describe any other provisions that the owner/operator chooses to provide (for example access to generators, blankets, and bathing facilities).

 Yes

Specify how:

 Yes

Specify how:

 Yes

Specify how:

Indicate what, if any, services will be provided to tenants:

Indicate what, if any, services will be provided to tenants:

Indicate what, if any, services will be provided to tenants:

16 | February 2024

6. Services for displaced tenants during evacuations

Fire Safety Plan

Confirm that the owner/operator shall continue to meet all obligations under the Ontario Fire Code and implement the necessary provisions of the approved Fire Safety Plan.

Building Security

Confirm that the owner/operator shall secure the premises in the event that a vital service disruption has an impact on normal day-to-day security measures

Unit Access

Provided that it is safe to enter the apartment building, confirm that tenants will be granted with access to their unit:

• for a minimum of one hour within two weeks after an evacuation order; and

• for a minimum of one hour every four weeks thereafter.

Lodging (Optional)

If the owner/operator chooses to provide tenants with appropriate lodging within 24 hours of the disruption onset (at the expense of the owner/operator) please specify.

Drinking Water (Optional)

If the owner/operator chooses to provide tenants with drinking water within 24 hours of a disruption onset where water has been discontinued (at the expense of the owner/ operator) please specify.

Food (may include hot meals, meal vouchers, and/or kitchen access) (Optional)

If the owner/operator chooses to provide tenants with food, such as hot meals, meal vouchers, and/or access to a kitchen (including access to operating cooking and refrigeration appliances) within 24 hours of the disruption onset, please specify.

Clothing (Optional)

If the owner/operator chooses to provide this service, specify how tenants will access clothing in the event they do not have access to their units.

Personal Items (Optional)

If the owner/operator chooses to provide this service, specify how tenants will access personal items such as toiletries.

 Yes

Specify how:

 Yes

Specify how:

 Yes

Specify how:

Indicate what, if any, services will be provided to tenants:

Indicate what, if any, services will be provided to tenants:

Indicate what, if any, services will be provided to tenants:

Indicate what, if any, services will be provided to tenants:

Indicate what, if any, services will be provided to tenants:

It is always best to obtain original forms from the original source. Expand the Vital Service Disruption Response section to download the Form and the Guidance document from Toronto’s webpage: Here

| 17
gtaaonline.com

Toronto’s Building Emissions Performance Reporting By-Law

In December 2023, Toronto Council adopted a new by-law that requires owners of large and mediumsized buildings to report building energy and water use data to the City, annually. It will be identical to the provincial Energy and Water Reporting and Benchmarking (EWRB) program that currently requires buildings above 50,000 square feet to report their performance data on an annual basis; except Toronto will expand it to medium-sized buildings that are more than 929 m2 (approximately 10,000 ft2). A typical multiresidential property with 15 average-sized units would likely reach this gross floor threshold. In addition to apartments, Toronto’s by-law includes buildings from the commercial, institutional and industrial sectors.

Toronto will align their reporting deadlines to match the Province’s. In Toronto, buildings with gross floor areas of 4,645 m2 (50,000 ft2) will be required to report on July 1, 2024. Buildings that are more than 929 m2 (10,000 ft2) will start reporting on July 1, 2025. This additional year provides the city with time to educate building owners and streamline their internal process.

According to the City, existing buildings are Toronto’s largest source of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, accounting for approximately 58% of total community-wide emissions. Toronto’s Net Zero Existing Buildings Strategy focuses on reducing emissions from existing buildings with the ultimate target of achieving net zero emissions by 2040, and an interim target of cutting emissions nearly in half by 2030, relative to 2008 levels.

The City further states that, “The impacts of the proposed By-law on property owners are nonmonetary in nature. The cost associated with reporting stems from the time required to gather energy and water data and enter it into the City’s reporting tool. This is a relatively small time-commitment, estimated at a few hours of time annually, per building. A potential side effect of the Emissions Performance Reporting By-law could yield a possible energy cost savings by encouraging property owners to more closely track and better manage their buildings’ energy and water use.”

Driven by the old management adage “you can’t manage what you don’t measure” Toronto’s and Ontario’s required tracking, benchmarking, and reporting energy use is the first step towards better managing energy use and energy operating costs, and to improving building efficiency and energy and emissions performance.

Emissions performance reporting will impact owners of buildings that range different types of property owners, from corporate owners of large commercial and multi-residential real-estate portfolios to smaller corporate owners to single individuals who may own only one or a few buildings. The city claims to understand that the introduction of the proposed By-law will have different impacts on these different types of property owners and anticipate that property owners with smaller buildings will face greater challenges than property owners with larger buildings because property owners with smaller buildings likely have fewer resources to dedicate to reporting and less previous experience with building emissions performance reporting, while property owners with larger buildings are likely already reporting similar data.

To facilitate the reporting process for property owners with smaller buildings and mitigate the time impact associated with reporting, Toronto’s Environment & Climate Division staff have created several resources to assist property owners, including:

• A series of step-by-step instructional videos to educate and assist property owners with the process of entering their data into the reporting tool and submitting emissions performance reports for their buildings;

• Written documents summarizing the reporting process;

• A dedicated email address where property owners can ask questions and reach out for support.

Environment & Climate Division staff also intend to take the following actions during By-law implementation to further mitigate impacts on property owners:

• Procure the services of a dedicated Help Centre to provide property owners with assistance and support during the reporting process;

• Work with water, electricity and natural gas utilities to make reporting easier by enabling direct upload of data.

The City estimates approximately 5,800 property owners will be affected, who own approximately a total of 16,100 buildings. Of this total, 7,500 buildings are already required to report (larger than 4,645m2) via obligation under Province’s O.Reg. 506/18: Reporting

18 | February 2024

Here’s a detailed breakdown:

Toronto intends to use Energy Star Portfolio Manager which was developed by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and modified for use in Canada by Natural Resources Canada (NRCan), and already used in Ontario for EWRB.

Property owners that will be required to submit report information under Toronto’s By-law and the Province’s Energy and Water Reporting and Benchmarking (EWRB) program will be able to do so with minimal additional effort. Rather than entering the report information for their building multiple times, a property owner will simply create a single profile for their building in the Energy Star Portfolio Manager reporting tool, and then click on one link to report their information to the Province, and another link to report their information to the City. As such, reporting to the City of Toronto adds negligible additional burden to property owners who are already required to report their information for their buildings under EWRB.

GTAA will provide a webinar for small building owners who are unfamiliar with the reporting requirements. Members will be notified well in advance of the July 2025 deadline.

Consider us for your next vertical transportation project! elevatorconsultant.com 416.77 7.0660 Maintenance Audit Reports, Due Diligence Inspections Tailored Maintenance Service Contracts Equipment Evaluation Reports Elevator Traffic Studies Modernization Design and Project Management New Construction Design and Project Management 130+ years in du st r y expe r ienc e gtaaonline.com | 19 of Energy Consumption and Water Use (O.Reg. 506/18) and O.Reg. 507/18: Broader Public Sector: Energy Reporting and Conservation and Demand Management Plans (O.Reg. 507/18)
Number of Affected Buildings by Size Size Category Number of Buildings in Toronto Number of Property Owners 929-2,322 m2 (~10,000-24,999 ft2) 5,400 2,300 2,323-4,645 m2 (~25,000-49,999 ft2) 3,200 1,400 4,645-9,290 m2 (~50,000-99,999 ft2) 2,600 1,000 9,290-23,225 m2 (~100,000-249,999 ft2) 2,800 700 23,226 m2 + (~250,000 ft2) 2,100 400

Annual General Meeting

October 19, 2023

Our 2023 Annual General Meeting was very well attended as Members arrived early to hear our Chair’s annual summary and the Treasurer’s report. Our digital Annual Report was electronically distributed and our audited financial statements were mailed to each member, well in advance. The meeting commenced on time, ran smoothly and was informative.

Seven nominations were received by the advertised closing at 3 PM on September 19, 2023 for Director positions on our Board.

CONGRATULATIONS to the following GTAA Members who have joined our Board of Directors for a three-year term (November 2023 – October 2026):

• Cora Armstrong – Schickedanz Bros. Properties

• George Espinola – Medallion Corporation

• Perry Fryers – WJ Properties

• Yehudi Hendler – Y.L. Hendler Ltd.

• Jordan Rose – Glen Corporation

• Gloria Salomon – DBS Developments

• Paul Smith – DMS Property Management Ltd

20 | February 2024

At the first Board of Directors meeting of the new term held on October 24, 2023, the Executive Committee members, Standing Committee Chairs, and Charitable Foundation Board were selected.

Board of Directors

November 2023 – October 2024

Executive Committee

Left to right:

Perry Fryers

Cora Armstrong – 2nd Vice Chair

Yehudi Hendler – Treasurer

Laura Holland – Past Chair

Martin Tovey

Gloria Salomon

Justin Taylor – Chair

Absent form photo

Kris Boyce – 1st Vice Chair

Paul Smith – Secretary

Charitable Foundation Board of Directors

Margaret Herd (Park Property Management) – Chair

Peter Altobelli (Yardi Systems)

Daryl Chong (GTAA)

Perry Fryers (WJ Properties)

Bert C Grant (Lawrence Construction Company)

Yehudi Hendler (Y.L. Hendler Ltd.)

Justin Taylor (Greenrock Realty Advisors)

Standing Committees

The Greater Toronto Apartment Association has five standing committees that deal with a variety of matters that are of great importance to the apartment industry and to our members. Members join these committees to participate more actively in the decision making of the GTAA. Each committee has a specific role and being part of it comes with some commitment. Attending and participating at meetings and voting on issues are the main responsibilities.

Political Action & Municipal Liaison

Justin Taylor & Laura Holland – Co-Chairs

Policy, Administration & Finance Committee

Yehudi Hendler – Chair

Utilities, Environment & Communications Committee

Perry Fryers – Chair

Education & Training Committee

Cora Armstrong – Chair

Members’ Services & Fundraising Committee

Laura Holland – Chair

22 | February 2024
Left to right: Lorne Stephenson (Q Residential), Kris Boyce (Signet Group), Andrew Lowe (Oxford Properties), Yehudi Hendler (Y.L. Hendler Ltd.), Justin Taylor (Greenrock Real Estate Advisors), Perry Fryers (WJ Properties), Jordan Rose (Glen Corporation), Annette M. Mincer (Direct Properties), Laura Holland (BentallGreenOak), Cora Armstrong (Schickedanz Brothers), Gloria Salomon (DBS Developments), George Espinola (Medallion Properties), Bert C. Grant (Lawrence Construction Co.), Paula Agnelli (BentallGreenOak), Martin Tovey (Minto Apartments), Absent from photo: Mark Hales (Realstar Management), Neil Sigler (Gold Seal Management), Paul Smith (DMS Property Management), Steven Weinrieb (Park Property Management)

Annual Dinner Happy 25 Years!

A record setting crowd more than 550 members and their guests attended this year’s festivities. Immediately after business was completed at our Annual General Meeting, everyone poured into the main reception area of Parkview Manor, for our renowned cocktail party. The best two hours of the year to mix and mingle with the industry’s finest. Then we entered the spacious dining room for a delicious multi-course meal.

We started the evening with a moment of reflection to acknowledge tragic events and to recognize those from our industry family who sadly passed away.

To celebrate our 25th Anniversary, each table simultaneously popped a bottle of prosecco and rose for a toast which included Sam Grossman, our first Chair, and Brad Butt, our previous President who joined Laura Holland, Chair and Daryl Chong on stage.

Chair Laura Holland provided a summary of our past year, highlighting our achievements and noted some issues that will soon arise.

Laura recalled that last year, from the same podium she advised we had just finished our Ontario Superior Court challenge against the City. The following month, in November 2022 we received a favourable ruling. The decision ordered the City to quash two sections of their by-law, which, if left unchanged, would require housing providers to provide the full cost of resident displacement due to major events, such as fire, flood. This created a large liability for our industry. Fortunately, with Board direction, we continued to fight and were successful in our legal battle. The City did not appeal this ruling, so it is solidly in place.

Laura noted that during our past year, that Premier Ford and the Progressive Conservatives were re-elected to a second majority, providing stability, and general support for our industry. A few months later, in October, Mayor Tory easily returned for his third term, providing stability at City Hall. Tory’s return would have allowed us to proceed with a new “Rental Housing Roundtable” working group to recommend incentives to build new rental supply. This was started, but unfortunately stalled with the departure of John Tory.

As our membership year concluded, the residents of Toronto went to the polls and elected Mayor Olivia Chow. Now in place, with newly bestowed ‘strong Mayor’ powers, she has changed the direction of City Hall. It was still early days, but we are already felt the shift.

She highlighted our spectacular golf day in May, where through a sold out crowd and incredible support from our sponsors we raised a record-setting $85,000 for our Charitable Foundation.

That this combined with the large donations from seven major sponsors as well as many individual and smaller contributions, has allowed us to continue funding many organizations that assist with housing. Including the $140,000 in donations presented at this annual dinner.

We donated $20,000 in Annual Scholarships, and the evening’s raffle draw provided the children living in the City’s Shelters and Hostel with $10,000 used for a fun event of their choosing.

Laura closed her comments by thanking all of GTAA’s Members for their continued commitment to our association. We currently have more than 153,000 paid units in our membership, 200 suppliers, and 24 Millennium Members. We are large and strong and we look forward to continuing our work together to protect and improve our industry.

24 | February 2024
gtaaonline.com | 25
Platinum Dinner
25
Celebratory
a u D io/ v isual r egistration m
C aron Dé C or & e ntertainment Center P ie C es
Co C ktail r e C e P tion Post- e vent e ntertainment Coat C he C k
Photogra P hy
th a nniversary g ift
b ubbly
a
Dinner Wine

Annual Dinner Happy 25 Years!

Charitable Foundation Donates $150,000 at Annual Dinner

Our Charitable Foundation celebrated our 18th year by presenting $140,000 to seven worthy organizations who each work tirelessly to help those in our community who need some assistance. Our Charitable Foundation Board is pleased to recognize Greenrock Real Estate Advisors, Park Property Management and Yardi Systems as our Platinum Sponsors; Lawrence Construction and WJ Properties as our Gold Sponsors; Preston Group, and Homestead Land Holdings as Silver Sponsors of our Foundation.

Margaret Herd, Chair of the GTAA Charitable Foundation presented $20,000 cheques to the seven partnering agencies at our annual dinner. These dedicated community-based organizations are making a tremendous difference in the lives of the homeless and hard to house. We are proud to support and assist them in assisting others.

Each of the following grant recipients each received $20,000 from GTAA’s Charitable Foundation:

Albiona Centre

Eva’s Initiatives

Home Suite Hope

Nellie’s

The Redwood

360° Kids

Kehilla Residential Programme

Our annual Scholarship Awards were presented before the academic year started for four very qualified and deserving residents in our buildings. Chinechem, Ivy, Saba, and Zarif were delighted, as were their families, to each receive $5,000. GTAA’s scholarship award is $4,000 and each of building owners provided an additional $1,000 to help their winning resident. Well done!

The Foundation Board sincerely thanks everyone for your support and attendance at our Golf Tournament and Chair’s Luncheon. Our events and direct donations enable us to make these contributions. It is only possible for the Foundation to make these significant investments in the community with the ongoing generous support of seven main corporate sponsors. Platinum ($15,000), Gold ($10,000) and Silver ($5,000) Sponsors generously donate directly to the Foundation each year.

GTAA Charitable Foundation’s Major Sponsors:

Platinum Sponsor

Peter Altobelli of Yardi Systems

Justin Taylor of Greenrock Real Estate Advisors

Margaret Herd of Park Property Management

Gold Sponsor

Bert C. Grant of Lawrence Construction Company

Perry Fryers of WJ Properties

Silver Sponsor

Gloria Salomon of Preston Group

Vera Tahiraj of Homestead Land Holdings

The Charitable Foundation continued to sponsor ore than 150 children living in Toronto’s family shelter system throughout the pandemic. While the kids were unable to gather for a fun filled day, the Family Residences staff with the children and families came up with creative ways to enjoy being at home. Now that the restrictions have been lifted we’re looking forward to hearing how the kids decided to enjoy this year’s $10,000 donation.

You can donate personally and corporately to the Charitable Foundation so that our industry may continue and even expand on our annual efforts to make a positive difference. Please contact GTAA (info@gtaaonline.com) to request the donation form.

28 | February 2024

S e r v i c e s W E p r o v i d e :

T r a n s p a r e n t C o l l e c t i o n s

S t a f f T r a i n i n g S e r v i c e s

A R M a n a g e m e n t

A R C o n s u l t i n g

C a l l S e r v i c e s

G O B E Y O N D C O L L E C T . C O M
E x p e r i e n c e d / T r a n s p a r e n t / E f f e c t i v e
R E C O V E R Y
C A L L 1 - 8 7 7 - 3 0 0 - 6 0 0 6
Credit Bureau reporting Live Login to your accounts In-house and former tenant collections Cyber insured
M A X I M I Z E D D E B T

Margaret Herd Sam Grossman Award of Excellence

The Greater Toronto Apartment Association’s Founding Chair Sam Grossman was a leader in the property management industry. Sam played a major role in the development of the GTAA and encouraged all in the industry to participate in the association’s endeavours.

GTAA’s Executive Committee established the Sam Grossman Award of Excellence to recognize an individual in the property management industry that has made a significant contribution to their company, our industry and society.

Sam Grossman attended and introduced this year’s recipient –Margaret Herd!

Laura Holland provided a summary of Margaret’s accomplishments spanning her career and life, to date. Here are just some of the highlights:

Margaret Herd has been in this industry for over 40 years, working her way up the ladder in an industry where there were not a lot of women at the boardroom table.

In 1980, Margaret started with Park Property as a junior accounts receivable clerk. At that time, they managed 4,500 units and had 100 staff.

Margaret went back to school at the age of 40 where she achieved her certificate of business management from UofT. This helped Margaret in her journey to her current role as Senior Vice President. Margaret currently oversees a portfolio of more than 91 apartment buildings, with 11,000 doors and a team of nearly 300.

Margaret is actively involved with new rental construction. In 2009 she and her colleagues at Park developed 91-suites at 88 Spadina Road, which was followed by 211 suites on Isabella Street. Margaret and her team are in various stages of approvals and construction of 7 rental buildings with more than 1,500 suites.

When she’s not building, she’s buying, last year Park Property purchased 12 buildings with more than 2,100 units (and a shopping mall).

Margaret understands that it is important to be involved. In her spare time, she is Chair of GTAA’s Charitable Foundation’s Board of Directors, is on FRPO’s Board and is a past-Chair.

Outside of our industry, she is a founding member of the Down Syndrome Association of Toronto and an advocate for persons with intellectual disabilities. Margaret married her childhood sweetheart, David, and they’ve raised 3 children, Nicholas, Mackenzie & Katrina. Nicolas, Margaret’s eldest son, has Down syndrome, which at the time of his birth, there was very little support for families that had children with disabilities. This is where Margaret leaned in and was a founding member of the Down Syndrome Association of Toronto and helped many other families. Nicholas is now an internet celebrity and star of Keeping it Real with Nick. He was creative director of Free Bird, an animated short film that was long listed for an Academy Award.

Margaret is also on L’Arche Toronto’s capital campaign committee which is raising $3.8 million toward the construction of a fully supported home for persons with intellectual disabilities.

30 | February 2024
. Building Envelope Repairs Parking Structure Roof Assessment & Replacement Window Upgrades Site Improvements Interior Upgrades 2051 Williams Parkway, Units 20 & 21 Brampton, Ontario L6S 5T4 t (905) 792-7792 D AV R O C . C O M © D A V R O C & A S SOCI A T E S L T D Ass e t Tran s f o rm a �o n Project Managers DAV ROC & AS S OCIAT E S LTD

Dinner Raffle

Let’s thank our Members who generously donated to this year’s raffle:

Platinum Donors

AFPS - Accurate Fire Protection & Security

Home Depot

Gold Donors

Coinamatic

Silver Donors

Schickedanz Bros.

Enerstream Agency Services Rental Housing Business

FirstOnSite

Minto Rent Check Credit Bureau

Yardi Roma Building Restoration

Wyse Meter Solutions

The contributions of our sponsors provided fantastic curated prize packages that included:

Grand Prize: $6,500 Air Canada gift card

Great experiences including premium Maple Leaf and Raptors tickets with dinner, and a fabulous Shop til you Drop day which included an Uber ride to haul your shopping bags home.

This year to ensure everyone was included in the fun and excitement, every attendee receive a raffle draw ticket on their way in. The winners were thrilled to win, and all participants were delighted to donate to the kids. We sent $10,000 to the City of Toronto’s Family Residences to fund some special events for children living in the City’s hostels and shelters.

Thank you for supporting the kids!

32 | February 2024

*

A ordable Housing Multi-Residential Program

New higher incentives are available to cover more of your project costs for energy e ciency upgrades. The A ordable Housing Multi-Residential program helps close the funding gap for housing providers who need to replace aging equipment. Plus, get free insuite upgrades and technical assistance every step of the way.

Why upgrade now?

• Reduce energy, maintenance and operating costs.

• Control costs more e ectively with automated systems.

• Improve energy e ciency and reduce emissions.

• Enhance resident comfort, health and well-being.

Incentives for building upgrades

• Boilers

• Building automation controls

• Ventilation technologies

• Variable frequency drives

• Water heaters

• Energy assessments

Increased incentives now available
and more: Complimentary technical help and incentives up to $200,000
Let’s get started! Contact an Energy Solutions Advisor today. enbridgegas.com/a ordable energyservices@enbridge.com 1-866-844-9994 Is your building eligible? This program is for: • Eligible market rate multiresidential buildings† • Shelters, co-ops and non-profit housing • Social and municipal housing providers * HST is not applicable and will not be added to incentive payments. Incentive o ers are subject to change based on budget availability. O er available to qualified participants only. Contact your Energy Solutions Advisor to confirm eligibility. Terms and conditions apply. Visit enbridgegas.com/a ordable for details. † To determine if you qualify as a market-rate multi-residential housing provider, please reach out to energyservices@enbridge.com with your rent roll information. Additional terms and conditions may apply. © 2024 Enbridge Gas Inc. All rights reserved. ENB 2001 02/2024

HST & GST Exemption For Purpose-Built Rental

On November 1, 2023 the Ontario government announced its intent to remove the full eight per cent provincial portion of the Harmonized Sales Tax (HST) on qualifying new purpose-built rental housing in order to get more rental homes built across the province. The removal of the provincial portion of the HST would apply to new purpose-built rental housing such as apartment buildings, student housing and senior residences built specifically for long-term rental accommodation, that meet the criteria. The enhanced rebate would apply to qualifying projects that begin construction between September 14, 2023 and December 31, 2030, and complete construction by December 31, 2035.

This aligned with the federal government’s enhanced GST New Residential Rental Property Rebate announced on September 14, 2023. The details were introduced in Bill C-56, Affordable Housing and Groceries Act, which received its first reading in the House of Commons September 31, 2023.

Together, the provincial and federal actions would remove the full 13 per cent HST on qualifying new purpose-built rental housing in Ontario, helping to get more housing built.

Under the former process, purpose-built rental developers were able to claim input tax credits on construction costs as projects were built. The builder then self-assessed sales tax once the residential complex has achieved substantial completion and at least one individual has moved into a unit in the complex. In Ontario, which is under the harmonized sales tax (HST) regime, the sales tax self-assessed is equal to 13%.

The former GST rental rebate provided a builder with a rebate of 36% of the 5% GST assessed on the value of the rental unit, for a rebate equivalent to 1.8% of the value of the rental unit. The rebate is currently reduced for any rental units with a fair market value of $350,000 or more, and it is reduced to 0% at a fair market value of $450,000.

Prior to the introduction of the ‘tax exemption’ for purpose-built rental developments, the Ontario HST New Residential Rental Property Rebate was equal to 75 per cent of the 8% provincial portion of the HST paid, up to a maximum rebate of $24,000. The enhanced rebate would be equal to 100 per cent of the provincial portion of the HST, with no maximum rebate amount.

The enhanced Ontario HST New Residential Rental Property Rebate would be equal to 100 per cent of the provincial portion of the HST, with no maximum rebate amount.

To qualify for the enhanced HST New Residential Rental Property Rebate, new residential units must be in buildings with at least four private apartment units or at least 10 private rooms or suites and have at least 90 per cent of residential units designated for longterm rental.

For a residential rental unit valued at $500,000, the enhanced Ontario HST New Residential Rental Property Rebate would deliver $40,000 in HST relief. When combined with the enhanced GST New Residential Rental Property Rebate, the total rebate amount would be $65,000.

34 | February 2024
O ers available for a limited time to eligible new customers where access/technology permits, subject to change without notice. O er end dates vary by address/occupancy date and are subject to board approval. O ers are subject to the terms of your building’s bulk agreement with Rogers including providing name with purchaser fi rst name, last name and municipal address for o er redemption. O er end dates vary by address/occupancy date and are subject to board approval. Data usage subject to Rogers Terms of Service and Acceptable Use Policy (see rogers. com/terms). 1 The X1 Voice Remote from Comcast was the recipient of an award for “Contextual Voice Navigation for Discovering and Interacting with TV Content” in 2017. 2 Based on Ignite WiFi Gateway (Gen 2) modem with Wi-Fi 6 technology, available with Ignite Internet 500u and above for Rogers fi bre-to-the-home and fi bre-to-the-neighbourhood service areas. 3 See rogers.com/about-advanced-security. *This is a special rate for this service under a bulk arrangement between Rogers and your builder. If the bulk arrangement ends, this service will be cancelled. At that time, you may choose to subscribe to services with Rogers at then-current rates, subject to any applicable rate increases. Discount applies to monthly service fee for core services only. Additional optional add-ons and pay-per-use rates are not included with the o er. ™TORONTO BLUE JAYS, uniform, all related marks and designs and the player photograph are trademarks and/or copyright of Rogers Blue Jays Baseball Partnership, used under licence. ™Rogers & Design and Ignite Internet are trademarks of or used under license from Rogers Communications Inc. or an a liate used under license. © 2022 Ignite TVTM Enjoy our fastest fibre-powered Internet Contact a Rogers rep to ask about our special o ers Enjoy all your favourite content, movies and shows in one place Ignite InternetTM The most advanced WiFi security3 Fibre Powered Internet The most powerful WiFi Technology2 Award Winning Voice Remote1 Personalized Entertainment Ignite your entertainment. Get the ultimate entertainment experience powered by fibre-powered Ignite Internet 1-866-902-9534 Integrated Content Experience Plus, ask how you can save on a wireless plan.

Rent Collection 101

Delinquent rents have always been a challenging topic. And although the balance owed by nonpaying residents typically hovered between 0.5% to 3% of revenue for most medium and large size landlords, the issue was not one of the major concerns for operations. This missing revenue has now doubled in some cases. Welcome to the postCOVID world of rental arrears!

As the LTB and other provincially equivalent boards have fallen behind in processing, and in many cases have become way more tenant friendly (or debt tolerant), non-paying residents are staying in units longer and are owing way larger sums. At collection agencies focused on collecting delinquent rents, the problem is just as acute. Listings of rent debts have multiplied in numbers while balances have shot up significantly. Where in the past a typical rental debt was a few thousand dollars, these same buildings are now registering delinquent debts of tens of thousands of dollars per unit!

In the past, recovering a few thousand dollars of debts from a former tenant was more than feasible. Now, the same tenant faced with a ten-to-twentythousand-dollar balance owing will just throw in the towel. Collection agencies are also being challenged: more listings and bigger balances should equal greater recoveries, right? Wrong! These expectations are unrealistic as tenants – and consumers in general – are feeling the pinch or rather more of a bite out of their finances as inflationary pressures grow. Basically, everyone is hurting and those with lower incomes, the very people who you are renting to (especially in class B and C), are feeling it the most.

Tackling the receivables nightmare now needs to go further than just listing accounts to your collection agency. Here are some additional ways you can impact your AR woes:

Proper on-boarding with maximum back-up being requested is your first step in insuring your

tenant revenues. It is a fact that a big number of uncollectable accounts landing at collection agencies are missing contact information; or in a large percentage of cases: updated contact information. Operators need to get in the habit of “forcing” tenants to update their contact numbers and emails on a regular basis. This strategy can be a game changer. Guarantors, guarantors, guarantors! Where a former tenant might give-up on a large balance outstanding and just accept the consequences of a negative credit record, a guarantor most of the time will not. Collection agents love to handle accounts with one or more guarantors!

Door knocking is also where it’s at! It is recommended that you either dedicate a person at head office to do your “door knocking” or inquire at your collection agency if they offer such a service. Most collection agencies handle so called first-party collections and charges are usually fee based. It is not advisable to require your site teams to door knock! Why? Because they spend every day at the building and perhaps even live in one of the units. So, for the operator to expect a member on site to knock on the door of delinquent neighbours is quite absurd. And it will almost certainly not result in significant recoveries. Timely forwarding of accounts to the paralegal and to the collection agency is also key. A delinquency can quickly run up to tens of thousands of dollars with delays at the board and processing times. The sooner you handle your bad debt column, the better. A 30 to 60 day pass off to your agents is a must.

These debts do not stop with an LTB (or Regie) judgment. A well-structured small claims (or petit creance) program is also a cornerstone to curbing delinquency and recovering tenant related AR.

More than ever, operators need to focus on customized receivables strategies. There is really an endless list of ideas, which of course need to be implemented.

36 | February 2024
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.