DAMN째 magazine # 34 BANGLADESH
Back to Dhaka Louis Kahn's masterpiece three decades later High-minded and optimistic types might assume that architecture can influence behaviour. And perhaps it can. But if the situation in Dhaka is anything to go by, then no matter how grand the building, it cannot dissuade corrupt humans in powerful positions from behaving corruptly. We are talking here about the Parliament in Bangladesh. For some 30 years now this handsome edifice has embellished the capital city with its grandeur, impressing and inspiring the citizens who look upon it whilst those inhabiting it, appointed to function as representatives of the people, continue their untoward manner of operations without the least regard for what the building exudes. text and images VEERLE DEVOS (except where mentioned otherwise)
Military Police at the National Parliament House, Sher-e-Bangla Nagar, Dhaka, Bangladesh
56
57
DAMN° magazine # 34 BANGLADESH
Inside the building, Kahn uses different geometric shapes: windows in the form of circles and triangles, corridors, lifts, stairs, light courts and circular areas that are all horizontally and vertically interlinked.
Bangladesh became independent, but due to the subsequent Liberation War the building wasn't completed until 1982, eight years after Kahn’s death. In 1989 Jatiyo Sangsad Bhaban received the Aga Khan Award for Architecture.
Facing page: The parabolic shell roof of the Parliament Chamber, which can house up to 354 members. The space is lit from above by an octagonal opening with an umbrella-like ceiling. As the sun moves across the sky during the day, the light shifts and changes. Kahn was a master in designing with light.
High hopes
Thanks to the great Estonian-American architect Louis Kahn, Bangladesh, one of the world's poorest countries, has one of the finest national parliament buildings ever built. What kind of activity can you expect of the parliament in such a building, in a country where over 40% of the population struggles to survive and where democracy is sclerosed? Not earth-shatteringly much, it seems. Jatiyo Sangsad Bhaban, as the building complex in Bengali is called, was Kahn's last project during the decade before his death. It was the Government of Pakistan that ordered its construction, to house the federal power of what was then still West and East Pakistan. In 1971
58
As an architect, Kahn felt inspired by classical antiquity and the European Middle Ages. Thus, Kahn's style tends to the monumental and monolithic. In the Bengali capital Dhaka, on a 900-acre site, he built a robust fortresslike building in concrete, surrounded by parkland and a manmade lake that makes the building appear to float on water. The parliament building is extraordinarily spacious for a country of 161 million people where space has become precious. The lake keeps the building cool but also reflects watery Bangladesh - the Bengali’s live on a flood plain between three rivers: Ganges, Brahmaputra and Meghna. This makes the country very fertile, but also very prone to both flooding and droughts. Natural disasters such as floods, tropical cyclones and tornadoes, affect the country almost every year. Especially the many landless, who in this overpopulated country cannot live anywhere other than on the flood plains, and are therefore often the victims. In the overcrowded, honking, pol-
luted, congested, and densely inhabited capital of Dhaka, the Parliament building rises up like a fata morgana of peacefulness and quiet. It’s usually difficult to approach the building closely. Since Bangladesh fell prey to terrorist attacks a couple of years ago, armed guards prevent Bengalis from looking at this rare strip of open space in their capital, along with the few curious tourists who make it all the way to Bangladesh and who want to take pictures of the world famous Parliament building from too close-by. The ones who actually manage to visit not only the gardens but also the building itself, have usually had to bribe a couple of employees. "That is the scourge of Bangladesh", says one functionary, "virtually all politicians and officials are corrupt. With money you can get everything done. This mentality destroys our country.” Miraculously, we pay nothing, and we even smuggle our cameras inside. We take pictures when our official escort is purposely not watching. He does this with good reason: “People feel that is has been enough. We all adore the building that professor Kahn has given us, but we are really fedup with what actually happens in this building: corrupt politicians are destroying our country. It’s about time the world knows”, he says.
59
DAMN° magazine # 34 BANGLADESH
The Post Office, with employee Abdul Jalil who has been working here for 27 years.
Low-impact
Politicians only show-up when there’s a parliamentary session, and today there’s obviously none. Also, due to the traffic jams during rush hours, people avoid driving 10 km to the city centre for a meeting. We find a few stalwart characters within the enormous assembly building: the librarian, a leading official, postmen, a guard from the Air Force, and several others with unnamed jobs. They all love the building, and give us a genuine Bengali smile when we ask about political activities in their huge and peaceful office. All of them are good people caught in a country that doesn’t work properly.
60
We visit the Parliament building with Shahnawaz Bappy, a young architect based in Dhaka, who on the 27th of August will give a lecture at the Backstage Architecture book launch in Venice. On that occasion, Shahnawaz will talk about his mission to create a better society through architecture, amidst a thoroughly corrupt Bengali political system. “Kahn was a visionary who knew very well what he was doing: he designed Jatiyo Sangsad Bhaban for an ideal society. It’s not a coincidence that he built a huge esplanade for the people (currently a no-go zone for the public), and a discreet side entrance corridor for the Members of Parliament – his message is clear: the MPs have to serve the people, not the other way around. Also, the building reflects dignity and righteousness, and thus challenges MPs to a government that is enlightened, peaceful, good and wise." But does it really have an impact on them? Public anxiety
Quite a relevant question, now that the country is again going through its umpteenth crisis: the recent period has been very tumultuous - an opposition leader was kidnapped, homemade bombs were exploded in the streets of Dhaka, there were violent strikes and demonstrations every day, and the army is ready to take over the lot – the Bengalis are scared and have started to prepare for martial law. “We are anxious about our security”, Shahnawaz
Bappy states. “The opposition will organise more protests, and the government will send more police in to stop them. This will completely paralyse public life. It happened before; the last time was in 2006, when the army declared a state of emergency that remained until the 2008 elections. If the army takes a governmental position, foreign countries will stop their help, which is a disaster in a poor country entirely dependent on that help, like ours. We hope they’ll find another solution than strikes and violence.”
Indigenous technologies were employed to build the various parts of the complex, from the assembly hall to the mosque. Kahn used red brick produced by local craftsmen. The concrete walls are inlaid with bands of white marble. That a unique design of such magnitude was realised in Bangladesh solely with local materials, skills and technology, is in itself no mean achievement.
When asked whether the building might inspire the politicians to better governance and probity, Nawas laughs scornfully. “In Bangladesh there is no democracy – there’s an alternation of power between the two great political families, each led by a woman. The current Prime Minister, Sheikh Hasina, from the centre-left Bangladesh Awami League and her archrival, Khaleda Zia, from the centre-right Bangladesh Nationalist Party, have alternated power since 1990. In 2014 we’ll have elections, but the Bengali people don’t expect anything. Nothing but misery, in any case.” Some say Bangladesh has demo-sclerosis: a democracy that is sclerosed; the veins and brain of democracy are silted-up. The idea of a committed democracy operating in this splendid, robust piece of architecture seems to be nothing more than a mirage.
61
DAMN° magazine # 34 BANGLADESH
EINDHOVEN NS STATION
IJK STD
T
RIE
ALE
RK MA
ER
LG
IZ
VE
VE HEU
EMM ASIN GEL
KE
KA
SG
NAA
RA CH
LSTR
T
AA T
IN KLE
2 HERTOGSTRAA T
L WA
EB
ER
G
1 RG
E BE
GROT
Apart from the Parliament building, the Jatiyo Sangsad Bhaban complex also includes hostels, dining halls, a hospital, meeting rooms, offices, eating places and a mosque. Lift operator Ali Hussain has been working at the Parliament for 32 years: "Professor Kahn thought of the well-being of the employees when he was designing the building. Our national parliament is an oasis of peace and harmony. I very much enjoy working here."
62
Grim prospects
"We love the building itself but not what is happening inside”, confirm the residents who live in the surrounds. They tend their shops in the boulevards near the site. Previously they were allowed on the site to sell tea and food, but now they are banned because of the terrorist threat. Mahbub Morshed, a journalist from The Daily Star newspaper, who’s having his morning coffee in one of the shops, told us: “The fact that the Bengali people love the Parliament building is not only about the beauty of it, it also has to do with the fact that the building and its gardens are so very spacious. The compound used to be open to all, and people came here to rest, eat peanuts and drink tea. Every night, couples and friends came together. It was one of the very few open spaces in Dhaka. Now the public must be satisfied with the wide footpath overlooking the Parliament. But yes, the beauty of the building also inspires people. Jatiyo Sangsad Bhaban is a permanent reference of quality and an inspi-
ration for our architects. Well, that is in theory, because in practice our architects only come up with ugly concrete and glass structures, inspired by Dubai. We have very few landmark buildings. And the new ones are not as prominent as the Parliament. So we usually don’t ask who built it. In a developing country like Bangladesh, architecture is not a priority. Architects are not important in Bengali society, and there are very few. Not many universities even have architecture in their curriculum. 250 graduating architects a year in a population of this size is not enough." Kahn died of a heart attack in a men's restroom in New York, in 1974. He had just returned from a work trip to Bangladesh. In 2004 Kahn's son, Nathaniel Kahn, made a film about his father's life: 'My Architect'. Part of it plays in Bangladesh. Louis Kahn's building in Dhaka remains a lasting challenge for politicians to make democracy more than an evaporating illusion.#
63