W UF Ç W b ñ IL Ç ñ
, 1q ,(#h
. 9 ? r
q n
q
q
k q
/ E /cP0 )# "u
q
q q
k q q
"G GJ8
q
q q
q
/ E
7k .XE
q
q q
7k .t 7# .c G J .0LE G f #R .+ GK+ .$1Qh @ .,9O GQO k
q
GQJ G Y.X.# 2k
.0JE8 "uS8 29 G 7# .c G J .0LE G )# 71(0J G 70LE G L29c8
@ .,1k 2&.& .r .1 2O .1P G "G GJ9 2O .1P G
7O
q
, GJ0JE8
71(0J G
q q
70LE G
7 #P#
v 1 . S8
)#
J 0M0
q
.#h
q
2,k ;)0J G .+h / C ,O GLk $ G I .1D 2k 2O .O C LV(b /!b .+Q.E$8 .+ ,2&.& .r .1 q
q q
q
v!8 ,71(0O IJ1rc1 f .P&) G W .28Q G .+h 71& .P&) G I .1E G L+ ._# )# L,_# %+ #1 s!c98 q
-Pl(1
-9q 0bh
q
,I .1E Gh
f.u G
/ E
-90DQ
.,1
f .,9P0
/
7>QJ
-
OJE8
29 G
q
/ -& $ 2& .P&E L,_# .+h @iLG C 7 hO 2k h C -9 hO 2k J> G.8 A G.O ,)0LG! .1h q A . >Q C
2k
q
71(;) G
ILS9(#
71D .( G
f .0O $ G
)#
fC
)#h
70OJc8
J .c$9?#
)#
OJb
.,1kh
o
d$9?#
ILU .c$ G
q J . & . 0J G
r n q
@)1(1c#
7 ,11
hC
2k
LVE(0
q q
Q1
ahLc$ G
/E
7 hO
)#
71D .( G
)#
q q
:8 .1h
,% .c G
k
q ,71(0J G
.$k
J .c$9?$ G
.Y0 C
"1
,3PEk q
q
Zc1 Q .S9& G / E 7k .XE ,A .c$> 70LS2 G .,1!b :rl8 G 29 G 70h .$P G J .& .0J G .,$+ C "V8
/
q
q
q
.+Q .S9& G 7cqQ :& .t fEh , .$+L1eh 70P.2 Gh 71OhJ(, .t 71qLS G J .& .0J G q
q
q k
q
.,k ,2(0J G OJc9 G )# .b.& aLc8h /E 7 hO )# .$k @70h .$P G J .& .0J G 728L# / E q
Zc2t
J .& .0J G
IOJc9#
2+
IL?, G 72P& O .0OR G "cl1
721tL9 G
2k
L11f8
/ E
q y71#.r Gz
q
q q
71& .uP G
.,921tL8
fC
jC
l q OJc8
, "1U C
q
.#E
q q 3 q q .1(0O IOJc9# JJe .,& C j C ,2(0O h C ,711Lc G J .c$9?$ G
q iO C
.#
.+h
, .,1k
q q
/!b 711hQh $ G dhJ G Zc1 2k d .E G .+
7!# .c G
J1 G
Q GLr9O Gh
.,1 E
q
712(> $ G q
q
q
.$t ,2(0J G A .$9& / G =1D )# 71& .uP G @d .<$ G "12O
,LU .c$ G
% .c G
J .$O
)#
7 $O
:E2U C
29 G
q fC
jC
,JD Gh
)0O q
O G Lk $ G
7OQ .$#
fC
i.O q
)_ G
a Lc 8
3 .fk
/
29 G
,)0J G
5
7 hJ .k = 1D
q
71(0J G
)#
q
@71(0J G q
q
q
70OJc9 G
L1e
e .# C
q q
7 0LE G
q
70OJc8
gK+
q q
q
71$+ C
JO GOR G
q
71& .uP G
.,921tL8
7# .c 7#Jr$ q
q
G
G
6
WH0 .# 2k "t .S# .1.cU 7 .,(b @9(0 / 71(0J ) 1([ . $ 7 J ) 11 J D 7 $ ; .# LS& 2(0J %1!c9
)t .# C L1k.8
=1D
)#
3 @ .1(0O
q
hC
G
Gh
h
G
I
J q
h
q
jC
e GO
,g
q
h
G
%+LF .cR
G
.2c! @)0J
G h C IO
G
Jc8 Jc9# 7 J :& .t FX "uS1 71(0J 70LE 7 #P# L28 7c1 .& 7O .$# 71(0J L .cS 7O .$# 28 #8 =1E1 01U Jc9 .u0 .# .(+ 7 .[ 71(0J 70 Jc9 :& .t "1U L1e -Pl& d$9?$ J1 .r8 )# J?9P$ %!q #9 .c# LS$ d$9?$ /!b )1c90 .$# 7 J /!b 7;JE9P# .rD L0Lr8 )# -c299P0 .# 2(0J Jc9 "# .c9! 72O .($ .c0LS9 dX .$0 d1\9P0 Ll 70LE K+ 2(c8 ",k @71(0J 70LE .,(11 )# 7(1c# 3 &P 28 #0 .(+ .t 7 2k L .cS K+ :& .t .0 .(!b 71(0J L .cR .+ -(b 71 .>) 7 .E# 7O J K+ J$c8 K 2O .O $ k q GO
q
IO
q
FQ
G
GPE
F
q
G
Gh
G
O
G
Y
O
G
h
G
G
R
G f
h
q
fC
,
E ,
h
G
q
q
G
q
h
F
h ,
h
Gh
g
q jC
hO
:
n q O
G
q q
hC
G
q
fC
?f
C
Gh
q
fC
G
q
C O
GPE
q
h
dG
q q
G
Q
G
k
b
SQ
q
hC
q
q
JG p
G
k
q
Q
hC
h
G
G
J
q q
G
g
GQ
?
q
G
j
q q
G
hh
q
G
G g
71(0J 70LE q
G
k
C
h
G
G Oh
JD
g F
q
G
G
2+ .#
.b .28 L\0 K &P .k .13$O .(0 /(290 J )# Jb %!c d# .(0 7 J 2(291 .b .P8 .r1X 71(0J 70LE .?# L; #90 J# / .+ / 29 7 J 2k dO .+ 71(0J 70LE .?# .r )u$0 "+ .13$O ., .13$O .(0 /(298 k
k
o
M
O
h
j
dG
q
G
G
G
h
,
k
q
k
G
G
k
Q
q
hC
q
hC
q
O
dh
G
h
i
q jC
G
d
E
G
d
fE
d
G
h
?
2k 7# .c
:
q
q q
G
fC
q
q q
G
q
k GO
G
?
k
Q
Q
q
O
q
7\!P 7kLc# M!9P0 7!,O $ K+ )b 71 .>) / "U.9 71D L Lk $ .1E1 s!c9$ 3& .? 2k .+ /(c$1 71(0J 70LE %1_(8 .?# %+L .cR Lk $ 7O .$# .,$1_(8 =1D )# "1 -& Jr9c0 .# J0JE8 =1D )# / @ 71(0J q
,
q
h
G
G Qh O
e
G g
G
q
G OG
F
G I
OG
G
G
G
q
Qh O
Q
,
q
E
q q
G
G fE
G
d
h
q
2+ h
:
,i
LG 7!,O L8 2O .O $ C
LG
K
j
G
q e
.c
q
G
Q
G
q
O
G
q
q
?IO q
G J
O
F
/E
C
hO
J ?
71O .O $
G dG
&P K+
)#h
G G
7 )# %1_(9 K+ m!9H0 "+ .[) JE8 71&.& .r .c0LS9 )11 7tL9S# L10 .c# )# "+ 71(0J %+L .cR Lk $ .$0 - 0G JE# 71(0 L .cR 7O .$# L_E0 2([. LS$! sE0 "+ ?i
)#
q
C O
G G
G
q
G
F
Q
fC
OG
q
G
-
G SQ
G Y
q
q
-
.E!\V$ J0JE8 J1 L9l8 2$!c =E2 71?,(# :& .t .$!k @71(0J 70LE .,l# J0JE8 )# / J1 / .t 7O J .X.# k GA
q
G
G
q q
G e
V
q
G
G
k q hC
q
q
q
f
GQ
G Y
q #
7
7 .c
q :2+h ,dh $ G d G&P G /!b q ?71([. G J .c0LS9 G d1$> 2k
q
728L9
q G 7#Jr$ G
# iLG C 7!,O C OL8 .(+h
q qq Gh .,&.$Y#h 71(0J G 70LE G e.,l# "+ q q g .(290 jK G v P )b m!9H# e.,l# ,d .<$ G "12O /!b ,2q 1Lc G YLS$! "+ q ?2q 1Lf G YLS$ G q k )0 .29 G h C a 09G / G / E JO C 29 G "# G.c G 2+ .$k , .1 .?0E H G.? G f .t GPEh q qq ?71(0J G 70LE G e.,l# J0JE8 2k q q q qq q JL# 29 G 71H0Q .9 G ahL_ .1 70LE G gK+ e.,l# 2k IL;&$ G "# G.c G s!c98 "+ q q ?7(1c# 71(#R J GL9k 2k J .c$9?$ G .,1 q q o q qq q 70LE G %1_(8 71!$b 2k - J>h fE - e.,l$ G 2k )0 .29 G GK+ L;&0 JD j C / E p q ?71(0J G q q 7O GQJ G LVD )# J1 / f .t ,gO.>h )# srE9! h C )0 .29 G GK+ Q .,^)h 6 Zc1 7O GQO Q .19G .1 .+J0JE8 %8h , .,8 .c0LS8h dhJ G )# OJb )11 7&Q .r$ G qq qq q 70LE G %1_(8 bL[ )11 7&Q .r# A GL>E aJ,1 711hQh $ G J .c0LS9 Gh 711Lc G J .c0LS9 G q q q qq q q cL9S8 .# %+ C /!b a.q. Gh ,71(0J G 70LE G JE8 29 G 71&.& .r G O.1r G f .11h 71(0J G q 2+ 711Lb dhO K 0; JL19G G Jqh @-1k m!9H8 .#h 7O GQJ G Y.X.# J .c0LS9 G -1k q q qq .1& .$ Ch GL9!?&Eh 70O .E8 / G .1OhQ 711hQh $ G dhJ G )#h ,LF GM? Gh LV#h f .(2 q @71 GQJl G q /(298 dhJ G gK+ :& .t GPE .# .+h 2q O .O C Q .29b G Q .19G / G GK+ 2k 2bhQ Jqh k q k 3 3 .1$OQ .(0O f .1(298 .$,&.u LF GM? Gh LV# /!b Q .19G / G dq.k @ / h C ., .1$OQ .(0O 4 q q q n qq 3 )# "t /(291k 711hQh $ G dhJ G .# Ch @- .1$OQ )0O 0k f .(2 .# C ,e 0O) G .+h q q q 7P1(t /(298 2,k GL9!?&E .# C ,7 hJ G )b )0J G "Vk CJ2# 71& .$!c G .1& .$ Ch .1OhQ k k @O 02! 71q $OQ 7P1(t GL9!?&E q q "t 2k "F .P# IJb =E1 /!b e.r0 jK G 2q rk $ G fQ .r$ G @,($ G J$9b G Jqh q q Qh .E$ G 2k 7&Q .r$! :cYG 29 G 71O .O $ G "F .P$ G JOJD Jqh @IJD /!b f.& .q JD
:71 .9 G q q U.V( G d 0G )# f .11 -1kh ,)0J G )# 7 hJ G mq.$1 s!c90 :dh $ G Q.E$ G k q 3 q ? / h C .1$OQ .(0O /(298 7O GQJ G Y.X.# 7 hJ G "+ :7!V G J GP 71&.& .r G
@7 hJ G .,1 aL9c8 29 G f .0O $ G :2& .<
E
G Q.
$ G
-
q
7 q .c G 7 Jr G #
#
8
$
q [. G Q.9OJ G 2k O .r9b / G 70q Lq D := .< q qq q @71(0J G 70LE G )# 2([. G A .Yr G mq.# :d1 L
E E E
@ 2(
G
7 q J G LF .cS G 7OQ . OhJD :Q .H
@ 1(0
q
$#
#
G Q.
$ G
-
G Q.
$ G
-
G Q.
$ G
-
d298 J1 / f .t ,g 0b C IQ tK G J /D .P9 G b 71 .>) G 7 h .E k q . Q \8h . 8 #S 7 GJ1 = D 7 q J G 7 q Lq E G . 1 JLq 9 G 7 q H Q .9 G D GL G k 7 q J G 7 q Lq E G dXh b /hq C aLq c9 v Ph ,Q Vc G Lq b . 8 .r 2\8 L ._ h q q k : .O 7 H Q .8 G b O >h srE9 . .;h ,7< JE Gh 7 Jr G J .c 9? G k fE( e l G k .29 G v K :POq Ch ,7 > 7 q J G 7 q Lq E G e l J JE8 k a GL9b 0 : K1o 9 G J G \H G b aLq c9 v Kth ,iLG C 7 > ) J >h . Q 9OO .rDh . hO . 1 aLn 9c G f .P ) G b rD .rD F2V9 7 q J G 7 q Lq E .1 ILU .c G dhJ G L 8 .OO _c b :Vq 7
)#
.
+ .
,
1(0
&
0
1
0
$
)#
1(0
/!
$+
1
0
., $
.
,
)#
!
.
#
0
)#
/!
2
1
0
# /!
1&
,
2
#
.
)0
3
3 0 .
0
!
"# .
2
)
"
,
1
$0
1(0
2
$
0
., #
!
,
$
+
#
$
2
0
2
)#
3
3 1
,
$
&
.
)#
@
1(0
$
1
%
. 9 1 cU 7 O J , .
h
GQ
0
# -1!
G aG
&
J
+C 2
k
k k 7 q J G 7 q Lq E G dq Gh b A Y G ] P8 E /hq C 7O GQJ G aJ 8 q k < 9 G q >Q .H G . L _ _ 8 bL[ q C b a q Gh ,7 Q .r G Y X GK IO .2c t . C A . 1 v P d299P . h ,7 q b IQ V1 7 q J G LF .cS G 7OQ . 7 q .c G 7\ P G 7 DQ Quc 7 q J G LF .cS G 7OQ . dYH8 jK G q .r G _ 9 G jK Gh ,7 q J G LF .cR 7OQ . 0G O GLk $ G u jK G q .r G Q .[) G k 7 q F .Yr G J GO . 9> / Gh 7 V G J GP 7 q .r Gh 7 q Q 9OJ G U V G [ .2 9O G u q q q q . lq h q [ G YLS G iJ 7 J G 7 LE G e l . ? 1 Quc8 9 G dhJ G
2
2
1(0
" $ $
/!
2
+ @
!
#
0
+ ,
)
!
#
(
0
@ ,(# -
(
%+
2(
,
. .
1(!
.
&
)#
.
$0
0 .
$
1(0
.
%1
(
2&.&
.
0
.#
$#
2&.&
)
1&.&
$
1(0
$# -
!
.#
/
/!
#
1(0
$# -
,
1!
0
%+
1
%1
)#
0
1(0
#
.
(
2
)# -
., #
,!$
(
)
$
$0
2
7 q .r G J .O GQJ G 8 CJ1 . d . u9O G 7 h .E E 7O GQJ G aJ 8 . t d 0G , . OhJDh . 9 . Dh . _ 8 bL[ f . 28h 7 q .c G J . q Lq E G 7O GQOh E8 q G MLR q >Q .H Gh q G GJ G . r Ln V c1 7 q J G 7 q Lq E .1 s q c9 G jqQ 9OJ G W _c k 7 q Q 9OJ G U V G IA GLq J b GJ1 Jrk . 1 O Vr G J JE8h q r n q J Jc G L ^ Jrk k Gh MLRh F X 8 E 7> .E1 W C ILU .c G L 8 .OJ G q q q q q q sEt ,7 O . P G J . LE Gh j CL Gh L 2c9 G 7 LD b JQ E 8 9 G J .O GQJ G q q q C /E , . b G C b J . q c ? Gh 7 q O . P G H GMD $ G m #8h H .H9 / Gh FRL9 G 7 q J G 7 q Lq E G dh . 98 d> GL 7 q 1Lc G 7 q q rE G J .29u G q G aD 0 G )#
1& . &
-
)#
+
2
%
, 0 $
2!
#
)#
2
,0
0 .
0
,
@ 1(0
0
/!
0
(
(
#
)#
1
#
!
$
.
/
& -&
1
"1!
.
@ $,
0
/!
.
(
.
$
$
$
1
1 .
$
0
2
1
1
,
(
1
1 $
/
1
1(0
0
.&
#
(
@)11
1
-&
$
,$1
(
.
,
1
#
0
1
2
&
$
.!
$
)#
q
7# .c
9
q
71&.& .r
q q
J .O GQJ G
G
.,(b :;JE8
.$!q 29
q
7# .c
G
q q J .0LE G
G
q
71(0J
)#
q
7#Jr$
G
q q
70LE .k
G
q
@d# .> q
%8
q ,711Lc G
Jrk
7O GQJ1
7r!c9$
o
7$F .q 2k
L QJ #
GJ(O
.U.VG
G
gK+
.,Yc1 Lk G.8 Jrk 712(> $ G d> GL$ 729u# 2k LG! G
,"12>h q
71&.& .q
JhL11
7v1v&.v& .vrv L2b
LPl0
/!b
G
G
/!bh
G
70 GJ1
O .$9b / G
q
. # .+h
q q J .0LE G
,7# .c G
.# C @ .P&Lkh 71tL1# $ G G
Heinonline
J .v0QhJv G
729u$
G
2vk
2k
29 G
IJE9$ G
729u# o
3v9vt
q j.(P G
:!$b
q
q
"vt
c G L9R / G
%vYv8
s0L[ @
QO .V$ G
G
)#
q q
b.rE G
729u#h
71!t 729u# 2k
JhL11
7b.$?#
q
2k
71tL1# $ G
/ E
7k .X) .1
q
q
.1& .\0L1 )# "t 2k 7VVH9#
.,1!b
q
d.VE G q
2v9v G
7v1v&.v& .vrv
7#JH
)#
Gh
G W .r( G %+ C L GLH9O G 2k
G
J .0 /. Gh
.,c1$>
)#
.v#
3 9u
d> GL$
G
q
2k
G
q
q
q
7c# .?
71tL1# $ G 7c# .?
G o
/!b
7r!c9$
q
q ,71& .(2! G
q
.,2!>
)#
gK,1
G
.# C @ .,8Q.!1h 71&.& .r
G
.,Yc1h
r n
q
G
d> GL$
G
q
.,1bLl1 71& .(2!
q
L29c8 29
q
2k
J .29u#
J / .r$ G
)#
7!q )# %eL
q
I L<t
G
:& .t Jqh @7O GQJ
q
G
71&.& .r
d> GL$
G
QO .V$ G
Gh q
,7# .c G
.$t 711Lc
d> GL$
o
7c# .?
711Lc
q k
3
.1O .O C
q
q
.+
d> GL$
G
k
v!8
G
q
G )# A2S1
q q
7f! .1 7VVH9$
q
JD Gh m &# 2k "1Vl9
G
HeinOnline.org
q
Jrk 71&.& .r
J .v2v9vuv$v G
G
q
gK+
G
%8
%98h
G
%vHvX C
q ,7VVH9$ G
: .,& G.(bh @y:&L9&) Gz
7O GQJ G %1Pr8 q q
70LE
Gz
f G . (b
:E8
q dh $ G
H .2 G q
@y7&Q .r#
2k
q
71(0J
G
q q
7 0LE
dq.#z
G
A .>
71&.& .q
Jqh
-
q
r n :)1$Pq
q
.c
q
@71# 0O) G q ,y71&.& .r Gh
q
7 0L_ (
G
q
.+QhK>h 71(0J
q
G 2k
7 q q
71(0J hJ Gh
70LE
G
Gz
q
7; 0; )$Y8h
@7$0Jr G J .c$9?$ G 2k
@21Lf G %
q dh $ G
/ E n
:d.Vk
7 O G QJ
/ E
%1Pr8
G
q
%8
q q IL_& ,Q.\9 Gh I #S( G 2k :71(0J G
71H0Q .8
q dh $ G
f G.(c1
r n ,)11 .1
q
7 1(0J G
q q
Jr9c$
,y7$0Jr G J .c0LS9 G q
"Vl
G
G Q . P# : 2& . < G
"Vl
G
G
q q
70LD
.< G "Vl G
:=
"$Ek 2& .< G %Pr G
q
q
70Lul
G
.+QhK>
q :71(0J G
q q
7 0LE
q
G :dh $ G
q
.# C
n r :)1!Vk )#
@71(0J Gh
o q
% Pq
G :dh $ G
G
7 0LE
f G.(b
q q
7 0LE
H .2 G
"Vl
q
m # 8h G
7 .c 7 Jr q
q
#
#
G
$ G
10
LSb dO .9
/ E
Lr
G f
7 J 7 LE .1
q G )# , 1(0
q q
.r
q
0
G
2&.&
G aG
L9b /
G :2&
.<
"Vl G
G
LSc Lr LU .c 7 J 7 J 7 LE b :E8 .< .2 .> 7 LE c1 $ Pq .< .2 Pr8 8 V k b 9R LU .c L 8 .OJ 7 LE b . L; J 7 J 1 7q 0c . $ Vl 7 9OJ 7 J 7 LE JD .< Vl . .r 7 J 7 LE _ 8 b . < Pr D V k m #8 L M? LV 7 1Lc .c LS9 k 7 J 7 LE $ Vl .O 7 1 $ .c LS9 k 7 J 7 LE .< Vl . . L9 ? U 9 u . b 7 .c 7O J 7 8 .G : 9R Jq k 7 H .9 s .; d> L .V 7 .q 7b 29 ._D 0 L l LG sE k 7 .r s .; @)0
@yI
k 7 J q
2
1(0
$ G
q q
0
G
Gz
h
q
1(0
Gh
q dh
f G.(
q q
0
G
r n :)1$
G
/ E
n r :)1!
7 J q
@ 1(0
G
q q
0
G /!
+
Ch )0
Gh
q
.9H
#
q :2&.&
LP $ &
q
1(0
G
q q
2&
/!
q
1(0
G
0
G
2&
G
G A
q q
$ G
Gh ,yI
( z
f G.(
2&
G
%
"
G
G
"
G
G
"$
q
:)1!
.2 7 Jl
, FG
q , 1 GQ
G
1
q
# : 1
G ,
q q : 1 h Qh
hQ
G J
G
J
0
q
G 2
0
q
2
G
1(0
1(0
q q
0
G
)#
q
q q
0
G
G :dh
G
G
: 2&
G
"
G
"
G
@ 1& $ C , G
@ .9 F
)1(
&
)#
sE
!#
-1 E 2
" q
1
q
.
)
G
#C
#
q
/!
#
G
GQ
$
G
G
h
n
r
@f (
1
G
: 2&
G Oh
h
% h
q
0
G
q
%1
G
G W $& C :dh
G
%1
G
G H
H
"$
G )1
h
@ 0Q.
,yIQ
Gz f G.(
G f
!$
G
!
h
&E
h
n
0Q
G
F
. Gh
,
@S ,
$ Gh
G
G
k
G 1
QO
$ G
Ch ,)2(
$F
.
!# 2
#
q
#h
,J
1&.&
G
F
. Gh
ºWOM b Ç W d(Ç ñ ñ ñ ÑuD Çè ÉQAM Ç w ñ
W ÑUI WO u U WO ÑU2 ÉdE ñ ñ
11
q dh$G H.2 G
bONL2
q
q
Jr8 3cV0 29 Jrc$ .E!\V$ )# 71(0J 70LE .r )u$0 .E!\V# )# .u90 K -Pl& F!\V$ / v .c0 @ .,VH0 JD m0Lc8 K+ @ .,#.,l# J0JE8 =1D )# )0 .28 09G =E1 .X.# .O .O 2+ )11 M1$8 29 .O J 2k 71.cV M8 @70LE )0J 2+ .E!\V$ Religious freedom )11 M1$0 %,Yc2k Liberty Freedom .$+ )1E!\V# .$+ )1E!\V$ )0K+ . O J Zc 1 2 k J 1 @Religious liberty )# .cO.8 L<t .,l# .+ $ L0 .+ .?8 7$; / .k L9# 3 3 .1O .1O .rD -&.t / L1S0 J0 K Religious liberty )# L1G $ @ .13&.& .q %0
G
J
g
I
G
q
f
j
J
q
G
G
h
o q
G
J
GQ
G
G
G
E
h
a
O GO
q
n
r
k
r
G
q
C
n
q q
G
G
P O
fE
h
Gh k
Y
q q
Gh
;
G
q
Gh
h
d
G
C
J
G
n
r
h
q
fC
e
J
GQ
G
hP
G
q
q dh
G
fEh q
k
fC
i
h
G
q
q
q
fC
E
q
hC
E
hC
d
j
;f
r jC
G
OG
,
G
)1(
q
k
7\28L$ L[ $ Jc8 .+ .Y0 Jrc# 7 #P# 71(0J 70LE m0Lc8 "c?0 .$# "t %Y8 29 7 J d$9?$ 71(0J .PO&$ Lk $ %+ 70LE K,1 @ .+ JD ., .?# 71(0J 70LE .,l# 2k L;&8 .,c1$> L[ $ K+ @ /&+ q
G aG
q
q
G O
G
h
Gh
,
q
h
Gh
q
)2(
Oh
q
C I
h
G
q
J
q q
q
G
Gh
,O G
G
h
q q
h
G
g
q
q q
G
q
,
G
G e
aG
G g
A
70LD .,& #1 71(0J 70LE %,Yc1 Lc0 =1E1 .l0Lc9 :b.(8 Jrk K LG! %,Yc1 L0 7 J "2q )# J1q $ -b.YG Jb 2(0J 2P(u ._( Jr9c$ 7Pk .(# sD 71(0J .PO&$ )11 7D.9l# 7Pk .(# 2(c8 71(0J 70LE 2k 71b .$9> / 71q 0G $ L10 .c$ sk .,1 .$P# 7Pk .(# 2+ J .P 2(0J Jr9c$ )# .# d$9?# 2k J .P )0J 70 .$D sD LG s0Lk J(b 2+ )1D 7 # P# LG L0 .$1k 70 .E ) d$9?$ /!b 7 .\ 712(> $ q q
q
G
q q
G
i
h ;
q
G
;
h ,
q
Gh
q
G
h
a
q
,J
q j
G
q
q
G J
G
q
G
e
,G
q
h
q
G
G
q
G/
h
M
h
G e
G
,
F
G
q
q q
G fC
q
G
G
q
JG
G
F
q
fC
fh
B
i
;
)3(
G
q
O
G
G
hC
B
G
FQ
G
hC
q
KOSHY, Ninan, Religious Freedom in a changing world, Risk books series, WCC Publications, Geneva, 1992, p. 22. Ibidem.. NORTHCOTT, Cecil, Religious Liberty, Nothumberland Press united, Great Britain, March 1948, p. 14. 13
G
)1(
)2( )3(
7 .r 7O &Q
#
:P
1
.r . _ 8 7 J 7 LE
q GQO - 2&.&
2,
k
,$1
G
L_ 7PO& q
1(0
q
0
G
G
14
Lk t J VHS L Y .1 s c98 7U .G 7 #P 7 J 7 LE 7U .G 7 #P 8 JE1 J $ 7 .c .P q
"
,O
o
(0 2
q
q
2
i
@
)#
q
( h
1$
G
q
# - GP
q
# 2+
q
q
)4(
q
!
)0
q
, #
G f
p
1(0
q q
0
G
G "F
G
$ G )#
9 7 M 3PE1 . l Lc8 m 9H 7 J 7 LE aD 0 Lk $ JE . .c28 LG d 9? m Lc9 m 9H . 0G LO # 1 d 9? b L9l J JE8 7 J 0h G
G
, 0
G
q
$ G hC OG
0
G gO
!
k
$
q
0
1(0
B / E
@
$
)5(
G
# )#
0
$
g
q
q q
0
G
$ G )#
fC
!
G
n
$ G /!
0h @ ,
k
o
q
0 G 0
V
1(0
G
. c 9? J b 7 J 7 LE l L_ > Jc8 eL .1 J t #8 7 J 7 LE .1 L9b / J [ 9P b LU .c b IOL8 L9b .P ) rD 7 .c . LE JD . .29b 7 J s .; J J c 7 [ L 8 . OJ 9P J
$
1
$ G J q
1(0
h
q q
0
G
q
q q
0
G
e ., #
G
aG
q
/ E
G
/ E
2 h
( G -
aG
.+h
G
&
,f
b.
G
q
@ 1 h
q ?f.
u98
6 %#h ?f.&
q
#
h
G
q
2(
Gh
l
q
/!
q , 1(0
$
)10.
q q J 0
G
)# %
O
r n
. G
. G )#
F
hC
0
$ G
%+ C
i
. G
1
q
1(
Gh
/!
q
G
h
+
q
C 2
q
1(0
G
q q
0
G
+Q
G
G i.
#
E
. r . Lq 9 7 J 7 LE . 1 V r G
$ G
I
O.
.k
$ G
$
q q
q
71(0J G 70LE G m0Lc8
J k LD )0
hC
2
G
3
. 9b u
b (
G
f.
2
G
k . 9G / sD .P * u #1 7 J 7 LE Lc8 L X b Lr9P L ul8 & . 1 J L K Jr9c 7 0c LP k Jr9c J v L .cR 7O . q
Q 1
G
0 f C h , g 1$
z
q
-1!
q y 1&
f.
q
Gh
0
q
1(0
f
q
0h g 1
) 6(
@
&
f
-1 E jO 0
G 2
q q
0
G
$
a
0 0 j
,
$ G h C )0
G
G
P
o
6
$ G
G
Q $#
F
E b . Jr9c . 9b b L L2? / L9l8 7 J 7 LE .k b L2? b c Lk ? 0k L X LE 8 m .H K b L2c r 9c K J m .H8 7 L .cR r[ k L9R / . c . s 9c k Ll sD c8 9 .2c J rc 7 LE1 .Y 7 LE Jr9c 7 LE k J rb . 9b Jb k rD .Y JE J rb K Jr9c .9H .P ) sD k $ > <9 .> J
.
& /!
#
o
/!
6
hC
k q
(1 # $ G
j
G
o
0h @
k
(0O
q q
0
)7(
(
!
$ G
0 fC 2
@
Q
0 j
yI
0
1
O
f
R.
q
G
F
IO
G e
q dh
2
G
h
I
Gh
1
I
z 2
q q
0
G
q
- O GQE
G
S.
hC
2
0
cG
G
k
q q
0
G
q
q )0O j C b (
&
@g 1$
q
2
q
1(0
C V
1(0O
2(
G
q
o
0
0
G
q
hC
fC
)0
G
n
A $ G
)1 # )0O V
- (
) 8(
G /!
q
0 f C h C ,-1!
+ )
g
# h C )0O b (
q q
0C
k
0
-
0 Ch ,IO
# I
q
G
-
. G
" $ 0
:f ,
q
q
W
Gh
@296U ,1996 ,f@
b
rE G ,7
uE G - 7 hJ G ,
q
O. P G
q
,7
q q
1 f .P ) G b rDh 7 .c G J . LE G ,/
G
q
q q
.c G J . LE Gh f .P ) G b rD , q
_ 9 G QO C 7 O . P G
_
G
q
q ,2(
@392-391U ,1985 , 1 #
G
G QG
q
$
#
uG
G ,7
q
1
,e 1 q
# GQ ,Q $ ,2&.1 q q
1
2 (0
h
KNOITZ, Milton R., Religious Liberty and Conscience, a constitutional inquiry, The Viking Press, printed in USA, 1968, p. 87. BATES M, Searle, Religious Liberty ± An Inquiry, Harper and Brothers, New York, London, 1946, p. 301-302. . ( )1 & . # 0 Pb L1 / # 0 & . JE M .b . #. 2 1 %1 ( 1 1 % ( f J2b J2b P1 7 c .? J # 0 @316U ,1998 ,",($ G Q GO ,dq G
G
q
.c G J . LE Gh
G
)4(
)5(
)6( )7( )8(
J1,$8
15
Jr9c#
hC
q j #1 f .$0) G eJb
)0O
q
)10(
Q .19G / G
@
k
k .Y0 C OLl
2
71& .u#E OLl
q
sD
G
F($0
G
.,
k
2&
jK G
.<
G
-
>.
q q
Pl & 7 0LE
-
q
) 9(
.# C
G
gJ0L0
@
k
c
G
.P0Lu8
/( $
71q (0J G 70LE G LU .(b q q
q
@2
q
>Q .G LGBh
rn :)1(; G
G GO LV(b
2!
Liberte de conscience ± Liberty
L1$ Y
r n
)0
LV(b
q q
q q
q G f.u98
70LE
G
o aLc0h :2q !G GJ
70LE1
G
q
71(0J
)#
LV (c
G
-
G
of conscience
@
M
q
uE90h -t.!O 3q GL0
%
@
)11(
Pl &
-
q
q q
b .(9b G
2
70LDz
-&
k
-!
c?0 AL$
f . P&) G
q q
q (0J G j Cz ,2
"$
n q
S1
q
d O. 8
;
L1$ Y
,
%
%
?c$
)12(
q q
7 0LD
G
)13(
yf .0O $ G
LV (c
G
2(
q -&
"
-
)14(
2
q
71O .1P
k
)1
71O .1P
k L1$Y G m0Lc8 G
2
/ L1H
G
q
71lP!l
Gh
c L1$ Y
q .(9b G
2
LS
2( 0
q
f .P&) G
@
7f!
.+
q
2
G
k L1$Y k q
.c29#
G
1h Llu q
711 .r(
Gh
G
G
2
q q
1
q
k .# C
f .th
Q . 19G / G q
G A G Q! G h
71lP!l
q q
L1$ Y
k 7!1U C 70LD
2+
2
q q
q
q
G dhJ G
<
" #
,-1k dhJ G
q jL1S29 G W .S(
9 O .$t .,1([ G.$
% 1
q
@dh
-
$G
Q!1 GL[
Pr
%
Zc1 m!9H8
G -
,H .9u!
2&
.<
G H .2 G
7<0JE
.1 F$P8 / 2
q
k 71(0J
7POq &$
G
f.$Y#
9
2
q q
.+h
G
70LE
G
G ,f .P&) G
,-(0O
)#
b.
2
7 hJ
k GQJV#
mq.#
G
rDh 7# .c q
q
k
k .Y0 C -rD
.+L1eh d0LS9!
)#
G
L11f8
)
J
.0LE
G
k
.1 .0/R.$
8
,4W ,)10 0$!
%!
c
G Q GO ,2L ,jLVb q
q j.
f
G
q
?c# JF GL
)9(
298
/(
GJ# ,LYG ,LYG
%
G
J(b .rD / -XLb
G
,f GL2> ,O.cP#
G
)10(
,J@ / ,f .(2
@207U
q
,1981
q
71# 0O) G 7c0LS
/ E "
n q q
70LE
G
.1 d299P0 .$#
q
b =0JE
q q
G
IQhLY
OLl G
70LEk
G
7 J
9
k
G J GJr9c$ G
@ 1(0
2
>.91
G A GQ! Gh J GJr9c$ G
70LD L12c8 )1
G
- ,1
p
n o G aLc1k M 0\U / G
2
U$G
Q.cR
aLc0h
k L1$ Y
G
JD C
,
. P&E
2&
#1 .Y0 C
)15(
2+h
q
[ .1
q y71b .$9> / Gh
@
q q f.u$ G dh $ G
q
k
l H0 . #
@
70LD
2
-1
q jQ.9OJ G
#1
G
0\U / Gh 7f!
)11(
@954U
q
7v1vcv# .v?v
7vPvOq &v$v
G
G ,2vX .vrv G Q.vVv(v# :Lv8 ,jQ.v9vOJv q
@474U
@475U
=7v hJv G
,-Pl& q
k
G
q
n
7v0Lv_v(v
sD / dX.#
@
,mv0E ,2v(v1v# -
,1996 ,e
@
/
o
h C ,"v1v# .v+hO
LS(
Gh J .O GQJ!
-v1v1v v1v
,d0R.9 Gh
@f@U
d>L$ G d> GQ @ .r1;h .[ .28Q G
k 7v1v&.v& .vrv
2v
k
?vcv$v G
%v
G
2
k
j CL G
70LE1 L1$Y
j CL Gh
Gz ,2v& .v<v G AMv?v G ,e .vcv q
G
q q
Lul
G
q q
70LD ]28L8 .$t q
70LE1 71(0J
9OJv G
q jQ.v v
G
q q
.r
f.v& v v G
G
q q
70LE
G
@f@U
7q 0b
k ]v1vO.v G
2v
6 )1
28
)12(
,@f@e
)13(
,@f@e
)14(
fC
b
/!
q ,f.v#OE ,W .v1Q
)15(
7&Q .r# 7O GQO - 2q &.& .r G .,$1_(8h 71q (0J G 70q LE G
16
,)0O h C IJ1rb b .(9b / J1D. Gh 2q O .O $ G LV(c G yL1$Y Gz L29c0 ,v K q qq q 70Lq E G 2k L1$Y G LV(b 71$+ C RL28 .(+ )#h @70Lq E G gK+ f.$Y# 2l9(0 -&hO )#h q q -1!b A .(1h @OLl G J GQ .1G )b dh $ G dh&P$ G .,k ,O .r9b / G L+.> -&.u 71(0J G q )16( q q "1 .q L1e 2c12[ sD .+h @ -1L1 -9q 0b 3PE1 -90DQh -lq G.# OLl G 2(20 :d .q .#J(b Jacques Martain f .8Q .# c .> v P )b L2q bh @bLH! «... (one) he is free to choose his religious path at his own risk, his )17( freedom of conscience is natural, inviolable right.»
q Y.& jq $ L1G $ G GK+ VLq c90 / C VL9l0 , GL3 Dh .2k F .U OLl G Q .1G 28 #1 h q v$v0 .vEv& /v!vb jqOq .v$v G h C 2q vPvlv(v G ]vfvYv G h C g GLvt) G Y G.v& C -v& .v1vth -v9v# GLvt Q q q q )18( q -F .$9& Gh -8 GJr9c# 32P1 M11$8 j C -rE1 d$9?$ G SQ .$0 / Ch , "r9P$ G )19( q @ 2 (0J G q q q LVE(0h -Pl& )11h -(11 OLl G -OQ .$0 GK+ 2q !G GJ G 71(0J G 70Lq E G L,_# fE q $0 f C fhO )# -Pl& OLl G 2k gL1; #8 gLo 1$X gQ .9G G .# e GO .# ,)0LG! G b.rD Q k 6 o .Y0 C 2q !G GJ G 3& .? G GK+ )b L2c0h @)!c G / E LLH0 % h -Pl& J .&.(u# 2k 2r1 .Ok .O Ch f .P&) G b.rD eJq C )# L29c8 29 G )O .r9b / G h C( yIJ1rc G 70q Lq Dz F!\V$1 k )20( @ iLG $ G -q.rDh f .P&) G J .0q Lq E 01U C )#
h C 71 .qQ h C J1q jq C aLc0 / s!\# 3& .> 71q (0J G 70q Lq E G )# 3& .? G GK+ q .,1 d9$90 29 G 791 .< G 71q O .O $ G b.rE G )# L1$Y G 70q Lq Ek @7 hJ G "2q )# %1_(8 f C / E .,9OQ .$$ f .P&) G L .9E0 / ,-8 GK1 7r1V h .,2D .U 7#R / .,&.u h ;OLl G q 7b .$? G e .1q "2q /9D .,8LR .2# d1\9P0 PE ,S .( G )# 7b.$?# d# f.u0 )21( k @ 0U C @
232U ,1971 ,JhL11 ,2W ,)10 0$!
%!
c G Q GO ,y .,$uDh=
Religious Liberty ± An Inquiry, p. 373 NORTHCOT, Religious Liberty, p. 15. MOJZEZ, Paul, Religious Liberty in Eastern Europe and the USSR before and after the Great Transformation, East European Monographs, 1992, p. 12. BATES, op. cit, p. 374 COOKSON, Catherine, editor, Encyclopedia of Religious Freedom, Routledge, New York, BATES,
London, 2003, p. 398.
)16( )17( )18( )19( )20(
,f .vPv&) G b.vrvEv J .v#.v!vcv$v Gh J .vO GQJv G MvtLv# ,f .vPv&) G b.vrvD 7v0q Q.v9vOO ,jJv>h d .v0Lv2ve ,:v1 .v; )21( @49U ,1993 ,IL+ .r G
17
J
Liberte de culte ± 71q (0J G LF .cS G
1,$8
Q $# .+h :2q >Q .H G LV(c G @Freedom of worship q n r qq q q 7OQ .$# 70LD j C ,2>Q .H G 2(0J G Jr9c$ G L,_$1 2& .< G LV(c G s!c90 q )22( -F .$9& G )b OLl G L2c0 L,_$ G GK+ d 0G )$k @ )!c G 2k gQ .,^Eh f .$0) G nqq q q q 70LD 2\c0 L12c8 .+h @2(0J G gJr9c# .,2>.9P0 71(0O LF .cR IQ.U 2k 2(0J G q k q q -(b L12c9 G )# -2D .U )u$90 % GPE Jr9c# j $ 71r1rD 7$1q / PE ,ihJ> L1$Y G q @2q b .$9> / G Jc2 G L1$Y G 70Lq D 2\c0 jK G .+ 2q >Q .H G L12c9 Gh @)!c G 2k q q q @fB 2k 71&.& .qh 71b .$9> G 7 #P# / E 79E1 70OLk 7 #P# )# L# $ G d.q E90 ,Km ,(1D h C %1_(8 h C 71 .qQ jq $ VLq c90 / L1$Y G 70q Lq D -9OQ .$# A .(; C 2k f .t fEh ,OLl .k q q q 3!\98 71(!b IQ.V1 gJr9c# )bh .,(b L12c9 Gh ,71(0J G gLF .cR 7OQ .$$k ,J1q )# 3& .? G GK,k @ .,$1!qE 2k T1c0 29 G 7 hJ G 2k 70Q .P G )1& G.r Gh %_( G I .b GL# q q q qq 7$_& C )# 7 hJ G -XLl8 .$1 J1r# ,dh $ G 3& .? G Quc1h ,71(0J G 70LE G q k )23( qq Zc1 .,1!b OL8 ,7# .c G J .0LE G )# .+L1ft 2,k @ .b .28 FX.1O .$t )1& G.qh q )24( q q L12c9 Gh 71(0J G LF .cS G 7OQ .$$k @ )0LG! G 70Lq E1 e GJ\U / G eJb .,$+ C O.1r G q q / "uS1h )0LG! G b.rD e GL9D G Q .[E )$Xz .$90 f C 3?0 2(0J G Jr9c$ G )b q q )25( .# .E& /!b , yiLG $ G f .0O $ G LF .cRh J GJr9c# OJ,0 jK G M11$9 G / E jO&0 o "uS1 2q (0J G Jr9c$ G 7OQ .$# )# YLq l98 .$t @7O GQJ G )# 2& .< G H .2 G 2k "V6 l1O q @71(0J G LF .cS G 7OQ .$# 7 #P# Rh .?98 iLG C b.rD 2q (!b 7O .
iLG $ G 7#q .c G J .0q Lq E Gh 71q (0J G 70q Lq E G q e .$Y& / G sD -!k @2q b .$> h C jqOLk .E& /!b .#q E 71q (0J G -90q Lq D OLl G SQ .$0 q gO /h $ )#q &0 f C 2k sE G OLl! .$t @71q (0O 7b.$?# Q1O #8 h C 71q (0O 7b.$?# / E k q q qq q q q .Y0 C 2>Q .H G 71(0J G 70LE G L,_# /!b 38L90h @3O .($ G 2(0J G %1!c9 G LVr G q 2q (0J G %,1bh 71$(8 /!b %+Jb .P8 29 G J .#.!c$ G /!b d.VE G 2k O GLk $ G sD q
G ,W .1q Q LEBRETON, Gilles, LiberteÂs Publiques et droit de L'homme, 6eÁme eÂdition, Armand Colin, 2003, p. 399. MOJZEZ; op. cit, p. 22. q qq q @271U ,7# .c G J .0LE Gh f .P&) G b.rD ,Q .$b q
@232U ,e .c G jQ.9OJ G f.& .r G
2
k ]1O.
)22( )23( )24( )25(
7 Q .r 7O GQO &
- 2q &.& .r G
#
7b P .$
. _ 8h 7 q J G 7 q LE G ,$1
7 q FL 72O .
h
#
1
#
(
1(0
e 0bE
(#
"
18
0
F .Oh
b
/!
d.VE G
2
k sq E G
\c . q
%,1
0
@
q
O.1r
,gLS&h
$#
)26(
q
q
71 9u .
#
h
.1 7 < 9 G O r G Zc1 O >h IQhLY .1 d299P8 b rE G gK t f C L e . t dh J G 7 hO jq C G GO O GLk $ G . OQ . 7 q .b 7 q Lq D jq C b 7XhLl G k k 7 q Lq E1h ,L 2c9 Gh j CL G 7 q Lq E1 . O .O C .[ .28Q G 7\28L 7 q J G 7 q Lq E .k .l B LtP q . . b ? k m &8 9 G 7k .EV G 7 q Lq Dh ,Y . 9> / Gh d q ?9 G 7 q Lq E1h , c9 G q )27( q 7 K G h C 7 q c G h C 7 q Lul G J . q Lq E .1 aLc o gK bLG h C c . 9 G j Ch kq q q q q qq j $ Q .u E j Ch ,7k .t IQ tK G 7 Lul G b rE G c . 9 G IQhLY .1 32P 7 LE G q JD E q >Q .H G . L _ k 7 q J G 7 q Lq E G k .2k O L;& J . q Lq E G gK 7 q Lq D )28( . ! $ $
$
.1
.
)#
0
"
1
#
,
.$
,
# 2
0
, &
+ ,
$
# 2
0
.
0
2
$
0
@
$
0
0
&
%1!
0
, &
!
1
/!
1(0
0. ( $
0
1(0
+ "
$
1(+
@
.
2
#
#
2
&
$0
3 1
0
,
/
.
0
0
0
0
0
+ )#
0
@
-(
b L2 c . 6
0
#
h C 2q (0J
#
q q qq q qq G O .r9b / G 70LD )$Y98 71(0J G 70LE G fE d.r G 7U 0Gh q qq qq @71(0J G LF .cS G 7OQ .$# 70LDh ,L1$Y G 70LE1
The scope of religious liberty 71q (0J G 70q Lq E G d .?# k q k q q qq h C ? GJr9c# h C .(0O OLl G gL29c0 .# "u dP90 3DQ 71(0J G 70LE G d .?# "+ q 70q Lq E G 3>.$1h - "+ ?OLl G -1k T1c0 jK G d$9?$ G 3PE1 s1Y0h dP9q 0 -&E k q 71 .>) G "2q ? GJr9c# h C .(k 0O .+ gL29c0 .# "t )b L12c9 G 2k sq E G OLl! - 71q (0J G k q q @y)0Oz 7$!u1 O.Vr$ G .# J0JE8 /h C jLE G )# f .t ,7!,O $ G gK+ )b k q M 0\U / G 2kh /h C 7f! G 2k )0J G 7$!t m0Lc8 71 .9 G J GLrl G dh .(98 k
. .;
@ 1&
)0
I.q r G IO .2b
k
J G F!\V$1 O.Vr$ G :/ h $ G ILrl G 7f! G 2k )0J G - C
.Y C 0
ch
2( 0
P Jr8h
@-
0
u G IO .2b
c
2( 0
,f .0O C
c >h
- $
,)0J G
MOJZES, op. cit, p.22.
)26(
qq q ,7v1vO .v1vPv G %v_v(v G ,2v&.v1vPv1 2q v(vfv G Jv2vb u G Jv2vb :yJ .v0LvEv Gh b.vrvEv!v 7vlv!v9vHv$v G J .v$v1vPvrv9v Gz dv> GQ )27( 389-381U
@
KOSHY, op. cit, pp.30-31.
)28(
J1,$8
19
j C )0
q
J
k
.Y0 L0
G e.0 -& C
C O
h @i.
r9
7b . \
Gh YQ. Gh
. P0Jr8 7q .H 71c12\ @ 7&.(0J .PE .0
Gh , ,
h
Q
q
G
G
)29(
Gh H
q
G e
JH9O %uE 7\!P L,r 2(c0 -& .,(# J0Jb 70.f .c# )0J! /(c# "$E0 @-O .O -$uD -u!# .(0 -& )# .r0 @ L+ .r .r .# .2q / .rc .EU .bJ0 2, dX .Y0 2(c0 @ 7#JH 7b .[) d$> @ .2c #k .u$ M? /(c$ "U .+ 7b . \ . OL ) b .+ 7U .H .Y0 70.f! 2& .c$ )# @ .1Vc .+ JY .0 Lt .$t )0J 2&J0 2 (0 v .# Lc .r9k #S .c )0J 7$!u1 7& .0 .(0 - KH8 ) 0J 1 7 & . 0 . (0 @ 28 .b .P&) .,1 J2c0 29 .O .$$ .r9b / .$?# 2(c8 .0 @71& LV( .1 .2+K# .Y0 2(c0 )0J @71O .1O 71lP!k 71& .$0 .u8 Jq .r9b / @-1 @ @@@7!# eG
Gh
Gh n
h
d
E
h
G
G
k
G
C
r jC
h
Gh
P
:
f
Oh
y
O
:d
k
E
h
,
C
G
O
G
G
J
C
jC
Q
h
G
G
G
;f
Gh
f GOh
J GO
G
q
hC
,
Gh
Y
hC
G
P
G
G
:
G
)32(
O
f GOh
:
f
E f
O
q
O Ch
J GO
G
q
Gh
b L1P0
K 3+K$
j
G
G
hC
7r0L\
f.&
Gh
.r
Gh
Y
q
LS
G
k
.Y0
-& C
@
J
hC
Lc0 . b .03L_& L$
)0
C
)34(
Q
q
)33(
-1!
G
G
OC
IO
Oh
q
q
Gh
:d
Gh ,f
d
I
o
G
,
q
Gh
I
k
g
k
h
q
f
H
h
)30(
h
C
)31(
h
GOz
f
n
r
q
G
k
Gh
d GR
k
f GO
jC
q
G
O
,
AG
q
I
k
C
G
Oh
C
n
H
:I
q
G
n
h
d
IO
q
Gh
G
3 1!$
a
h
h
A
.k d# Religion 7$!t 71P&Ll 70M1!u&) )19f! 2k )0J "1 .r0 ]1L 2(c8 29 Religare 2+ 71(18 0 7f! )# .,!U 7$!t 2+ al! 2(c8 29 Ligere K> )# .,Pl(1 7$!u @ To tie or bind .YH 2k 2(c8 29 Religio 7$!t .,(# s9R @ (Acting with care) 70 .(c1 LV9 @ 0>) 71SH d# 7, ! sE1 .cS .,8 / .$c9O 3!e bQ
q
(
G
G
G
G
G
)35(
Y
yd
Gh
G
G
Q
Gz
q
,I
L 1 LU .c$ Lul 0O) "^ 2k .1E 729u# @# 7<0JD 70.f 7b.O.# 7f! G
G
Gh
a
@688U ,j.
L11
,)
q
G
q
q
,Jh
h
)36(
Gh
@67U ,1998 ,Jh 1
h
C
Gh
q
G
G
Q
)37(
r n
G
q
h
G
q
Gh
G
,
G
Q GO ,2
G Q GO ,e
G
q
,
,
f
G
.r9b / G 70LD 9
?c#
) # %
?c# J L .cP# Q1$G L1P18 L$c I1S J$D .X
%
q q
O
G
G ,O
FG
,
,)
G(
C
)29(
,
G
)30(
C ,
Q
)31(
@479U ,e1958 /v+1377 @169U ,J@
/ 7b .2\! ,
Jh
L11
Q GO ,)0O H
LS$
@502U ,2000 ,b
.1
,13
@#
Lc
,H
LU .c$
G Q GO ,I
G
q
G f
711Lc
@68U ,O
G
.P
7f!
,Q. G
2 q q
_(# )1
k J?($
.r9b / G 70LD
E
)32(
G
)33(
L P18
, 1
ESPOSITO, John L., World Religions Today, Oxford university press, 2002, p. 6. ,3
M?
A v
v G
LU .vcv$v
, v
Gh
=v0JvEv
G
q
2v#
0vO) Gh
q
1Lvcv
2v
G
Lvuvlv
G
.Ev!v\vVv# 7vb.vO.v#
J v
,)O(
. 2 729u#
@873U ,2002 ,f (
L>
Q G v1v
Ibid. .>
,2v# v,v
,2000-1940
)34( )35( )36( )37(
7&Q .r# 7O GQO - 2q &.& .r G .,$1_(8h 71q (0J G 70q LE G
20
q q :IJb f .c# 711Lc G 7f! G q
2
k .$t
Religion 7 u h $!
k q 3 ,LF .cR 7# .qE .,(11 m &0 ,S .( G )# 7lF .\ .1b .$9> G .# ._& .#E 2(c8 Jrk q q d .V8 .1 f .$0Eh ,s!\$ G 2q 8 GK G d .$u G L# #1 f .$0Eh ,J G.!V G Zc21 J2c8h q WHS .1 7Uq .G 7 .D .+ h C ,@@f.u G 2k 7 .D -(# /$O C 71q & .DhQ I.q r1 f .P&) G q q q Y.SG 2k e GL9D G h C ,u .1 s!c98 70O .b d .$b C )#h JF .rbh m[ G.b )# 7l &# q )38( "12O /!b y)0Oz 7$!uk iLG $ G J .f! G 2k .# C @ 7l[ .b h C IO .b h C f.& .r
LG Gh C 2k Zong-Jiao 7$!t JL,^ f C / E )1V G 2k aO GL# ., )u0 % d .<$ G 2(c8 .# 2k ,a 0O $ Gh IL1Sb h C 7!12q 2(c8 Zong 7$!uk @LSb dO .9 G fLr G q %1 .c8 2+ 71(1V G 7f! G 2k )0J G 7kO GL$ G 7$!u .k , GKu+h @%1 .c9 G Jiao 7$!t F!\V# aLc8 % 29 G f .1 .1 G /!b s2\(0 -Pl& L# $ Gh @)39(7!12r G h C a 0O $ G q k L26 c0o f .t 71q & .1 .1 G J1 .r9 G 2lk @ .Y0 C LSb dO .9 G fLr G 2k /E «Shukyo» )0J G q q f GL9q .1h @s0L\ G j C Michi h C To h C Do v 1 .#E 71(0J G SQ GJ$ G 2k )0J G )b q Butsudo, the 71 .9 G J .E!\V$ G JL,^ ,7r1 .P G J .$!u G iJD(1 %!c$ G %O G )40( @ GKu+h ,y GP.1 s0L[z j C ,way of the Buddua
M
0\U /
q
G
G
2k )0J
q o 6 J GO .2c Gh JF .rc G 7b.$?#z -& #1 )0J G aLc0 :2bLS q %,9q 0bh ,%,1L1 S .( G 7q 0b %1_(9 -& .E2O u G .,bLR
GM 2
m0Lc8
0\ U /
9G
G
-H +
2k
G r Gh e .uD $ Gh
) 1& .
@
)41(
q
yZc2 G
Yc21
%,
q o
JRL0 jK G 2q , ) G dX. Gh @,($ Gh s0L\ Gz -& #1 71q # 0O) G 7b.O.$ G -kLc8h q )42( @ yJ 0# .c$ Gh c.!P G 2k L1H G / Eh ,J GO .r9b / G 2k sE G q
/
E
o
D. .1 A .12& $ G /!b 7 M($ G .0 .Yr G 7b.$?#z -& #1 )0J G %,Yc1 aLq c0h 70q Q .2G) G .0 .Yr G f.q u98h @y71q F .S&Eh 70q Q .2GE :)1r $n Pq / E %Pr8h ,70q LS2 G 70 GJ, Gh 2
873 U ,Lul
@
GJ
.E!\V# 7b.O.#
,2# .,> )38(
COOKSON, op.cit, p. 50. ELIADE, Mircea, The Encyclopedia of Religion, vol.7, Macmillan publishing company, New York, 1993, p. 520.
vv v v v v G vv v v v G d v C J v v v v v v v v
J .vb.vO.v# 7v!vPv!vO ,Y- C ,1 L ,)1$!P$
J(b -rl
.U
. E ! \ V # 7 b . O. #
q
q
)39( )40(
,sv1vkQ ,%v?vcv G )41(
270U ,1998 ,f .(2 729u# ,71# 0O) Gh 711Lc G J .E!\V$ G q q )42( @www.islampedia.com :71&hL9u ) G 71# 0O) G 7b.O.$ G
@
J1,$8
21
7 .S&) .0 .Yr q
)# 1F
q
.
G
G f
u98 )1D 2k @
Jc ._E$
,e
)43(
J GQ
Gh O
>
b JE98 29 s .rE )# .2> . /!b "$9S8 29 s .rE
. .
Gh J
q
)
G
K
G
G
F
G
G
G
F
G
2H!2 3PE1 > 7P$G %0Lu Lr 2k .$t )0J 7$!u I H / .c8 - .q 2k J1D.9 /(c$1 )0J $ ->. 2+ m0Lc9! 5 4 3 / .c8 - .rt 0O) J(b J1D.9 .k @ LKJ 2k / .c8 - .q v Kk .PE 2(c0 )0J 2& .< ->. @ 8 7 6 i h .k .V .O 2k - .q 7E8 .l .O %uE 2(c0 = .< ->. @ .2O .E# X W - .q j v!$ %uD 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 mO.0 .O 2k .$t .O 2k - .q 2k .$t .2c -1 )0J0 K )0J .+ d1 L ->. @ .Yq SRQPONMLKJI 71.9 P O / .c8 - .q 2k .$t 7!$ .+ Q# .H ->. @ 0O) 2(c0 )44(
.
g
h
G
fB
JOQh
G
{:
G
G
,
G
q , dh
G
G
G
h
:
h
)45(
{
:
,e
,H
{
:J
G
G
:
G
,
-,+ G
h
G
)49(
uG
G
IQ
G
jC
G
,}
f
jC
:
G
)48(
}
)46(
G
}
{
}
{
}
{
:
:
G
h
:
,
IQ
)47(
}
IQ
n
IQ
O
G
uG
j
G
G
:
G
G
G
,}
gD
{ :
h
)50(
G
q
{
:
G
h
:
G
G
e
G
h
)51(
@ q
71b .$9> G IL+ ._t
) 0J G
m0Lc8
}
71& .<
Q Lrl
:
G I
G
$ 2& .P&) .$9> / L+ .^ )# .,& 2(0J .r9b / L+ .^ )b .r0 ),$\8 7 .D .+ 2& .P&) .r9b / LX )# 70L\k LX )0J :2($k L1$Y .,1 )uP0 Ql( .,1 )11 .P&) M1$0 )0J - 0G )# @
@/
h
q
q
G
G
q
h
f
o q
G
Y
,
G
q
G
G
,
G
O
jC
q
E
G
G
O
J G Qh
,
G
I
q
)52(
y
h
d
I Qh
G
G
E
z
h
G
E
p
S
.2b 7$>L8 q
,Oh
JE
G
%1OL9
@20U
J
/h .E#h
%1+ .l$ G 2k
7P# .H 7(P
,2005 ,
G
7c .\#
G ,17 O
-
Jb
PE J2b .(1 . E JR $ k L ._ .2R $ -1 .9t
)0J Gh "rc G ,)1
@%0Lu G fBLr G 2
G
q
721\
,42-7U ,
@53
70! G/J .k .V
@33
.$1!O )1 "8.r$ 7; JE vv vv vv
,1990
vv
, v G
vv
vv
vv vv
v G
vv
%vv0Lvvuvv G fBLvvrvv G 2vvk Q GO
q
,2v#
LvvF .vv_vv(vv
0vO) G Fv!v\vVv$v
G
Gh
H vv vv
O
)46(
O
)47(
G IQ.
O
)48(
IQ.
O
)49(
G IQ.
O
)50(
vv G
)51(
70! G/mO.0
vv
IOQ G
q vv vv
vv G
L2
IA G
vv
G hC
G
71.9
J vv
vv vv
q
2vk ,2vvF G vv q
70! G/
)45(
.9t 2k . 71O.O$ .E!\V$ L # . P % 1+ L 1 m & # 2 k . tK # 2 H! 2
.2R$G
g vv vv
vv
vv G
v vv
G v E
v
vv
v
IQ
vv
vv
,
)44(
O
G I.
G IQ.
70! G/J .k .V
@76
f vv
dB IQ.
70! G/L#M
@11
)43(
G
G
70! G/f GL$b
@20
hQ
G ,j
( Gh g
F
@19
,g q
1
G I
q
vv
vv
v
vv vv v G
@40-39U @1163-1162U
q
,3 L ,2
1Lc
G
Lul
G J
.E!\V# 7b.O.#
,
.>
2# ,
)52(
7 .r 7O &Q
#
q GQO - 2&.&
.r . _ 8 7 J 7 LE ,$1
G
q
( h
1(0
q
0
G
G
22
#1 ? .1 Ll ]1L8 7 U = D J m Lc8 u LS L H 9 s L\ . 9G k 7 rc 7 LD Vq .P * L9 K 1 $ .r #1 J Herbert Spencer LP 2O L1L Lc .E k . uP J m Lc 8 L k l b Vb Z .e S s .l .r9b / . X . q .l8 . J .rb 09G d . $ b sl98 . t S c9 L Qt . Lc L ul9 3 \9 LO u > b. . k u / q V8 u / . V8 > Jt #1 J Max Miller b r J LG! Yc1 L . 0 8 b L 2c 9 Jc29P u .?8 / K <D .2 LG s Lk Jr9 D k 7 $ Luk $ m 9H 7D . .t . Jr9c &1 k dY8 9 . $ .Y .r9 / mq K Lc8 Jq .9c 7 ! l 1 L9c8 / 9 7D . .t b J8 / 9 J r 9c 9 > Jc29P u LS J1 . q 0G . ._ : .q 7 ! Luk Zk :r \ 9 7 2 .t J1 . . q
q
-&
, Y .$
2
$
0
G
O
Q 1
G
!
G
2
G
-& C
.
1
q q
#
0
)# ,)0
/
C
&
f
)0
)0
!
J
+
/!
2
q
q jC
0
fC
0 .,
i
@y%,
G
a
q
0
q
,
G .+h , +
!!1#
q
# a
F
1
)
!
G
A2
e. 0
)0
G
fC
# Q.
%,
G
# "
O.
G
"
C )# M
h
F
G
,
!
O
0
Gz
q
"$
0 f C )1
/!
fC
z :-&
0
,& $0E 2
q y2F ,&
0h @
)0
G
q
)55(
i
2
Gz
q
q
G - 1!
f.&
G
G
G
q
q
/!
yI 1
#
.+ f.
q
$0
q
2 O
G
1
Gh
q
q
0
j
@
h
# f 0O
G q
0h @
q d. h , g Q .
$0
a
)54(
q
$ 0h @
)53(
0h
q
3 1($
)
(
G
)
c
q
-&
0
G
/ E b.
G
-&E ,-(
1
G
q
0
-&.
)56(
jC
,
g
G
yY G.&
!
G
+
G
)1
# )#
1
k
0C O
M GhQ C q
Y
#
&
hC
.$ G
q
1
V
J (F
hQ
3 1
fh
+
G
#
C
@
h
#
, ,
G
G
)1
# IQ
$ G
O
2
Ch
(0
+
)57(
Qh
&
0
B
J (F
hQ
q
/!
k
)#
G
q
- ,
sP9 ._ #1 J Emile Durkheim . b . Mb L? 7OJr .b X D J8 d ?8 .O . J r 9c K LE9 7P t bJ8 JD 7 c 7b . >
t 9
q
#
&z
e
-&
)0 q
)
,
$
0
j
#
Q $$ G h
J
@
1(
y
.#
$ G g
JG
)59(
.
J
/
d.
Qh
+h @%0
I
Y G.& C
G
q
0.( #
Gh
2
$
f 0O
G
2
0
&G
)58(
G
2
G
-&.
q
0P .
G
k
- E fh
& $ 0E h
Lb v K .O . Jr9c 9S1 .E8 J ]O k . 1 .c & t
% 0 , Qh O
G
I
a
!
@
)#
G
)#
)#
Q
2
z
e., $
G
$ G
I
, +.
2
,
JG
2
G
/
"1#E
a
q
Q $$ Gh
J
q
W
h
$ G
JG
q j.1&
. G
G
q
2
,
)1!#
Gh )1(#
$ G "
«A religion is a unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things, that is to say, things set apart and forbidden ± beliefs and practices @1163-1162U ,J
J 0b
,)0
G A
J GQ.
S
(# ,2(0 q
J dk J #S(# G
G
G
J 71+ .# )b =E1
)0
h
q
G
.E!\V$ 7b.O.# .P&) )0 Lk G
,f
G
O
,S G
.> P sS
,2# , ,M G.
@23U ,1994 ,
G
v
G
v
v1v
v(v
)v0 v G
)vv0 vv G e.vv,vv vv# iDQ
vv
vv vv
v0 v v
J vv
2v
vv vv(vv G
T v v(v G
v& v0
v G
Y v v
v
q U v
vv,vv
g
@)0
!
,2v& v v G
@ vv1vv
q
2
"v
v v G
q
vv1vv h
vv vv G
%v
#O )55(
@24U ,@f@e
)56(
$
vv1vv G.vv$vv Gh
vv G
z
v$v!v
G /(
$
q ,dh
v v G
vv&
f vv q
q
. G 2
,2v& v v G
I
#
G
G
b.vv vv
k
)54(
@f@U ,@f@e
0 b) 7 e . U J b J m L c 8 k . r .< Vl .< Pr $ .2 d> J l Q u c 8 . R. r K k 7 . 9 7 J s ; .P ) rE .c J cX b . 9> / c .1 L; #9 .2 .e 7l 9 H @ @ P 7 . J .28 #1 .H .2c .u c 8 / 7 P t 7 t aD 0 @ @ P c .Yb d > . k LH 9 7 J 7PO& . c8 1 7 E P f
)53(
H v v G
v
q
2vv$vv
vv
2+h ,
GQ
)57(
vv vv G
!
$ G
@26U ,
S
e ,M G.
G
)58(
@27U ,
S
e
,M G.v
v G
)59(
q
v G q
IO v v v G
@)1 # )0O A
f v
v#
2v(v v
C
1$
y v
,1
W
v1v(v
(0 2
fC
G
q
1(0
v
G
v0 q
$ G
(+ 2(
"
q , 1
1
$ G
23
J1,$8
which unite into one single moral community called a Church, all those who adhere to them». )60(
fC
)u$0
LGB
,
.$k
d$9?#
)61(
)0J
7OQ .$$
2k
G
JD Gh
7$!u
q
m0Lc8
G f .0O $ G ILF GO
)$X
7 $;
,v P
Q1!k
"GJ0
/
.#
k A .(1h k 2k .(0O
/!b
d$9?#
k
L29c0
@ .rD / FX.1O .# .E& /!b
p
q
G
",k @71(0J
q q
7 0LE
G d .?#
Q .[E
J0JE8
2 k ) 0J
q q
G
m0Lc8 71$+ C 28 #8
.(+ )#
q
q q 2kh O .r9b / G GK+ -(t f .t .$,# 71(0J G -90LD SQ .$0 -& C A .bO / G OLl! sE0 k n o J0JE8 d .?# 2k 7$!t f.& .r! "+ :LGB d G&O ML\0 .(+h ? GO.>.# f .t 7 hO q q .$ L0 .f# m0Lc8 2 hJ G f.& .r! "+h ? .,(b L12c9 G OLl! sE0 29 G f .0O $ G /)0J G k q q q q q @ .b .28 .,1 E bL\9 G %91O J /D .P9 G gK+ ?2([. G YLS$ G gLr0 q jC
q
r n
.,0LV(c1
q
71(0J
G
q q
7 0LE
G I #S&
)#
q dh $ G
Zc1 )b 71 .>) G 7
h .E$1
dh .(91k
7 #P#
: .,(#h J /D .P9 G q q
q q
7O GQJ G
H .2 G
v
q
.# C
q Ph , .+Q.\8h
70LE
G - f .#M Gh f .u$ G a 09G G /!b - J .c$9?$ G d1$> :kLb "+ q q q q q q q ?IOJE# 71(#R IL9k 2k JL,^ 71(0J G 70LE G fE d.r G )u$0 "+h ?71(0J G
RhL1
)b
Q.,^
q fC
=0JE
G
q ,)1c90
J (b
.+h
q
-& C
q q J .0LE G d .?# 2k )1<D .2 G o q q q G L# $ G KG C ,71(0J G 70LE G
Zc1
iL0
,Q .29b / G )1c1 2 .9 F!\V# h C ILuk q 6 q q q q q h C )#R 2k h C OJE# JD Gh "# .b h C 32O )b J #90 % 70OLk 70LEt 70LE G gK+ k q r n q 7rD / h C 7r1 .O 7c$9?# IJb K GJD Ch H .2O $ 7?19& JL,^ "1 ,)0OJE# I0Q .8 q n q q q o /!bh JL,^ 7?19& 2+h @71(0J G 70LE .1 e.1 G aLc0 .# .,c1$> JJ h , .,Yc1 q k q .# IL9l G 2k .1hQh C 2k .U.VG ,%1$V8h Q.V8 s1 .O L1e )bh O.Vr# L1e .E& q q q 2(0J G M 0U) G 7tLD .,$+ C f .t IJb "# G.b :c$9> G .#J(b e1700-1500 )11 q )62( q q Q.[ Jq 71H0Q .9 G IL9l G v!8 2k 2q E1P$ G HLf G f C )# %eL .1h @ IL1,S G
BOWKER, John, ed., The Oxford Dictionary of world Religions, Oxford university press, 1997, p. xv.
q :d> GQ dh $ G e .r$ G ,2v# .v,v> :dv> GQ
q
2k 21Lf
)v0Jv
G
Lul
G J .vlv0Lvcv8
q G e .$9+ G A GL>
)v # Jv0Mv # /v!vb
)# :8 C 7
q
h .E#
Y 0v[ 0v h ,The
@889-873U
q
.,8 GP JE1 )0J
G
m0Lc8 7
q h .E# fE
)60(
)61(
encyclopedia of religion, p. 282
,2q 1Lc
G
Lul G J .E!\V# 7b.O.#
TIERNEY, Brian, Religious rights : A Historical Perspective, in Religious Liberty in The Western Thought, edited by Noel Reynolds, scholars press, 1996, p. 46.
)62(
7& .r# 7O Q
q GQO - 2&.&
.r .,$1_(8 71(0J 70LE G
q
h
q
G
q
G
24
q
:r<2& L0L# LU Jc1 / .( L8 % 71(0J 70LE 71c12\ .rE 70L_& 71(0J 70LE L1e LG .0LE1 ., 0G )# L9b / ",P )# .t J1 .r8 )# 71& .; 71D .& 2k @ LG #9# 7!DL# 2k 2([. LS$ L9b . 1 : 1_ D 2 9 %91O .# .E& /!b 71(0J 70LE .1 L9b / 2k 2([. LS$ LG #8 /!b 38L8 /!b 2 J .9P$ /!b .$1_(8 .0LE Jq )# Jc8 .,& .rD / -E1X.8 @ 7 11 $ J )11 .q 0c %1_(8 J1cU Gh ,
q
G
q q
YG
G
E Q
i
C
J
h
q
h
q q
G i
aG
k
h
.+ h C ,-&.$
Y# :r2[ q
hC
G
F!\V$
q q
G
G e
h Qh
G
q
G
G
Y
K+
C
G dh
LG $
i
G
aG
G
q
q
G q
n o
k
C ,
G
cS :kLb ",k 3PEk 711 $ 71L?9
H.
G
q q
h Qh
G
TIERNEY, op. cit, p. 30. Perspective on Religious Liberty : A Comparative Frame Work, in
Religious Human Rights Global Perspective, Legal perspective,
q
f
J
?
DURHAM W., Cole,
G b
q
G
G
q
G
q
q q
J
Y
q
G
)64(
J1
G
q
G
G fE ,
aG
q q
G
q q
G
I
q
r q jC ,
q
n
q
)63(
,
G
edited by Johan D. van der Vyver, and John Wtte, Jr., Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, The Netherlands, 1996, p. 1.
G
)63( )64(
ÊU u L Ç ÓdN 5 5 8 9
11 13 14 15 15 17 18 18 21 25 27 27 29 35 41 41 41 42 44
7# .c
q
q
...................................................................................................
...........................................................................
q .,91?,(#h
G
7#Jr$
G
GQJ G Y.X.# 2k .,91.cUh 7O GQJ G a GJ+ C 2k 7O GQJ G %1Pr8
............................................................................
7O
................................................................................................
.........................................
ÑuñD Çè ÉQAM Ç w ºWOñM b Ç W ñdñ(Ç ºäèñ_Ç ÈU Ç ©W ÑUI WOñ u U WOñ ÑU2 ÉdE ¨
..............................................................................................................
J1,$8
q qq 71(0J G 70LE G m0Lc8 q qq 71(0J G 70LE G LU .(b
........................................................................................
.....................................................................................
M 0\U / Gh 7f! G 2k L1$Y G m0Lc8 iLG $ G 7#q .c G J .0q Lq E Gh 71q (0J G 70q Lq E G q qq . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The scope of religious liberty 71(0J G 70LE G d .?# )0J G F!\V$1 O.Vr$ G :/ h $ G ILrl G q71b .$9> G IL+ ._t )0J G m0Lc8 :71& .< G ILrl G
................................................................
..............................................................
...........................................................
....................................................
................................
7$0Jr
......................................
G J
7$0Jr
.c0LS9
G J
G
2k 71q (0J
.c$9?$
Gh
71(0J q
70LE q q
G
70LE q q
G
G
dq.#
q :dh
% Pr
$G
"Vl
G
H
2& .< G "Vl
G
H
q G :dh
$G
O .r9b / G 70q Lq D )# 7$0Jr G - 7 hJ G mq.# :/ h $ G ILrl G bLS G 2k 7$0Jr G J .0q Q.[ GL2#) Gh O .r9b / G 70q Lq D :71& .< G ILrl G q .f$ G %uE G 7l!9H$ G J .& .0J .1 -9q 0bh 2
.................................
.......................
..................................................
...................................
2q 1Lf G %
.c
G
2k 71q (0J
70LE q q
G
G Q
.P#
......................................................................................
.........................................................
...............................................................
.........................................................
:
kq q .1hQh C 2k : /h C q J GJr9c$ G OJc8h s0Le) G - C q q 71& .#hL G 70Q.[ GL2#) G - H q q .#hQ 2k dh $ G d.E9 G :/ h $ G ILrl G
425
G
. 9E$
J 0.
45
L k
G S ,
426
70Q.[ GL2#* .1$OQ .(0O 71E1P$ .
f $ Q 48
52
55
56
58
59
64
.R J,b
2k
7P1(u
q
.......................
.......
.1hQh C
71E1P$
Le
2k
H
7
3+ GK$
G
q
71E1P$
7 hJ
Jc8h
q
Jc91
.......................................
71(0J
G dh
J
= .<
Lf
G d.
G Q.
L9b / G
G O
1532 Z
C
J2#h
Z
2(0J G
...........................................................
F# .P9
G I
7< .<
G I
7tLD
:
7c1 GL
G I
:
b
d1 GL
.l8E
-
1
.l8E
-
2
J+ .c#
-
3
. 0b E
-
4
q
q q
b
L$c9P$
G %1
.....................................................................................................
@F .9(
c$
Gh /(
..........................................................................
74
......................................................................
q
2t
$G
80
...........................................................
83
..................................
85
...............................
85
................................................................................
85
...................................................................
87
q
71(0J
J,c
q
........
e
q
0O) Gh 71E1P$
21Lf G q
......................
2# 0O) Gh 21Lc G q
q
k
G 2
2(0J G O .r9b / G q
2(0J G O .r9b / G q
7!DL#
:
/h C
Jr9c$
Gh
G
J,b
k
k : 1&
. .; k
q
J9$8h q q
70LD
q
:
:
.< .; k
.c1 GQ
Gh 70q Lul G .+QhK> :71q (0J G 70q Lq E G :dhq $ G "Vl G H
...................................................
105
Jrb
Gh 70q L_( G .+QhK>h 71q (0J G 70q Lq E G :2& .< G %Pr G
q
...................................
113
2& .$<c G
q
100
105
hO
G
%uE G )#
...............................................
q
7
7 K
J1,$8
: #
)0JR GL G A .l!H G
75
71&.& .r
G
G
q
k 7# .b IL_&
7(0J$
q .!$$ G / E j.#
q
G
G 2
73
G
Pr8
71
....................................................
E9
G 70q Lq D := .< "Vl H
Jr9c$
71
G
. .;
...........................................
n
Lrl
k G : 1&
70LE
G
71
Gh
G
G d.
..................................
q
Lrl
q
65
71# 0O) G 7 hJ
G
q
71(0J
Gh
G JG
Lrl
q
G J &
71tL1# $ G 71L?9
3+K$! .rkh IJ0J?
q
7 .<
[ GL2#E(
JG
k
2(0J G
G :
L1M>h C
q
.........................................................
E9
L2#Q.&
70LDh .1 .l9Oh q
G : 1&
. J1
q q
G
E9
J 0G
aG
Cuius region, eius religio q
q
2(0J G M 0U) G
...............................................................
..........................
G :
q G d.
.<
q
G O
3+ GK$
G
G-
G :2&
)814-800 H
.................................................
q
52
k
3
q
.......................
q q
70LD
...............................................
e
Lul Lul
71qLR G 2 G 2
q q
G Qh
.lP!k
2k -
q
k 71(0J q
k 71(0J q
70LE1 7U .H
/ E ILU .c$ G
0O) G
J
70L_(
q
G
71E1P$
q q
70LE
G
q q
70LE
G q
71(0J G
2k 2(0J G O .r9b / G q
G :
H
G -
L
K?
G -
q q
70LD
-
q
/h C
C
G -
G Qh
70DL
k
K?
k G : 1&
. .;
C
H
fLr G / E LSb dO .9 G fLr G )# 71q (0J G 70q Lq E .1 2q &.& .r G a GL9b / G :2& .< G "Vl G H )0LSc G
123
............................................................................
123
................................................
q
71(0J
G
q q
70LE .1
2&.& .r G a GL9b / G q
70 GJ1
k
:
q
/h C
. 9E
J 0.
427
123
125
128
7 J 7 L E .1 ? J9 L9b / $ .P ) rD . 0b k 7 J 7 LE dq $ Lrl 7rD 0 7 [ .c LS9 k .P ) rD . 0b L; 7 .< Lrl 7 O .O $ .P ) rD .rD 7 J 7 LE . .; 7 J s .; k 7 J 7 LE 7 q) s .; k 7 J 7 LE LE 7 .D k 7 J 7 LE dq 7 J ,> 0 3 .> $ 7 LD q
.....
/ h
&
G f
G
q
1(
G b.
. G J
J &
0
G 2
q
2
q q
0
G
G b.
G
J &
0Q
G aG
1
&
G f
G I
G
C : 1&
G I
G
E
135
................................................
q
1 h
G
q
1$1!
..............................................
H
...........................................
G b.
G
1(0
q
1(0
1(0
G )1
0
G
k G : 1&
0
C
G -
H
.# -
L
0
q q
0
G
q q
G -
q q
G
&
Gh
q q
G
q q
G
0
G
q
q
2
G
q
1(0
1(0
. G 2
F
q
)#
. G 2
F
G
.# :/ h
3
q
.....................................
151
1(0
&
f
q q
0
G
q
E 2
135
150
1(0
......................................................
..
-
O
154
.................................................
157
............................................
159
.........................................
161
.......
161
.....................................................................................................
167
......................................
178
...................
q
71(0J
qq G 70LE G
1(0
G
J
)0
7 J 7PO& q
q
Gh
$ Gh
ILU .c$ G L18 .OJ G
.+L; Ch
2k
7 J 7 J
q
)0 J
Gh 7 hJ G
)1 1
G )0
G )1
71(0J
7q 0c
G J GP dh
qq q G 70LE G :dh $ G
q
2k
OL J J 1 Vl J2 1 KG #8 1 .c9 J2 1 KG #8
2$
G )1
h
h
Ã&#x2030;d UF*Ã&#x2021; W èb Ã&#x2021;è WOM b Ã&#x2021; W d(Ã&#x2021; ºw U Ã&#x2021; Ã&#x2C6;U Ã&#x2021; ñ ñ ñ
q G W .$& C :dh $ G
"Vl
G
.$
$ G
"
G
C
$
d hO : 1 &
G
.$
$ G
fh
G
C
$
d hO :
G
.$
$ G
189
.............................................
189
.....................................................................................................
q
qq q G 71(0J G 70LE G OhJD :2& .< G
70Q.9OJ
1(0
0
G
Q $# Oh
G
..................................................
195
.................................................................
195
..........................................................................
196
...................................................
197
................
G h C )0
G
!
)0
#
.....................................
)0
G
2
...............................................................
204
...............................................
-!F
q hh jQ GO
........................................................
207
......................................................
225
........
227
.
#
q jQ GO
q jQ GO
q G - f .(2 - LV# :711Lc G J .c0LS9 G
G f.&
G J
G
H
1,$
G /(
G
G
G aG
G
2k
!
G
q
G :
0
G
C
G QhO -
H
# -
L
h
k
G e
( G :
# 2
-
1
+C 2
-
2
Oh
-
3
qq G 70LE G :2& .< G
2k
71(0J
q
qq q G 70LE G :dh $ G
71(0J
q hC
k : 1&
0
G QhO -
q Gh e
G H GO
- IQ .9H# LP .$& - ILU .c$ G J .c0LS9 G
LF GM?
)0
1
G A
q
h f .&
G e., #
3 1&.&
jO
1#
204
)0
2
2
q
0
3 1&.&
0
G
0
n
206
"Vl
k
q q
190
. $
H
J 8 7 J 7 LE 7O . JD .r / . .q J l J JE8 . .; . .q J m Lc8 J m Lc8 k L 8 .OJ J F \V J JE8 k .c .r J m Lc8 tL $ .Yr / .E 7 .c ! .c ._ .< .; .O ) ]2Y c k ) ]2Y J k ) ]2Y 7\ O JD q
f 0O
G
1,$
$ 7b ? 7 .< 7b ? 7< .< 7b ?
....
% Pr G
J 8
G :/ h
183
201
Lk
$ G S ,
"Vl
% Pr
G
H
G
J .0.9E$ G SL,k 227 227 227 228 230 237 246 246 249 253 258 262 264 267 267 267 270 286 288 289 289 290 290 291
428
297 297 305
# 2 1q (0 k 7
0q q
G
J
q G :dh $ G
7 LE
$ F
=E2
G
k O .,9> / Gh d0LS9 G 2k O .r9b / G 70q Lq D : /hq C 72q .c9$ G 70q LV$ G L18 .OJ G 2k O .r9b / G 70q Lq D - C 71q &.& .r G-70q Q.9OJ G 70 .$E .1 /_E8 29 G J .& .0J G - H jqLV$ G d0LS9 G 3PE1 71q (0J G mF G.\ .1 a GL9b / G - L q 7lF .\ G h C 7!$ G h C )0J G L11f8 - O O .,9> / Gh d0LS9 G 2k 71q (0J G LF .cS G 7OQ .$# : .1k & .; IO .2c G QhO A .(2 .,8 .b GL# 3> G. G WhLS G q q q 2k 71# 0O) G L1e mF G.\! IO .2c G QhO A .(21 -9q 0bh 2&.0 .$, G ]H G - C
...................................................
................................
..........................
......................
...................................................
.......................................
...........................................
........................................................................................
.................
LV
#
.+QLq q 29 G +O .2$ G %q + Ch jqLV$ G 7 hJ G Q!?# mq.# - H )1$!P$ G L1f IO .2c G QhO A .(1 WhLR %11r8 - L .,$1#L8h QF .(u G A .(1 7 #P# 2k IJ0J> 7!DL# - O k gLF .cRh Jr9c$ G 70 .$D : .< .;
..................................
..............................
.....................................................................
...................................
7
1q & ( ! G 0q Q.,$ . 2
7
2 1q (0
G
?
k 7
0q q
G
J
G :2& .< G
7 LE
$GF
=E2
k f .(2 2k .,8 .r12\8h O .r9b / G 70q Lq D : /hq C 71q & .(2! G 7 hJ G .,1 aL9c8 29 G 3+ GK$ Gh f .0O $ G - C q Q.9OJ G )# 7cO .9 G IO .$ G f.$Y# 2k 71q !1!E8 IL_& - H f .(2 2k 71q (0J G LF .cS G 7OQ .$# : .1k & .; k gLF .cRh 2q (0J G Jr9c$ G 70 .$D : .< .;
.......................................................
..........................
......................
..........................................................
............................................................
...................................
q jLF GM? G
0
d LS9
...................................................
G
2 1q (0 k 7
0q q
G
J
7 LE
G :=
.<
G
$GF
=E2
k jqLF GM? G Q.9OJ G 2k O .r9b / G 70q Lq D : /hq C 71q (0J G LF .cS G 7OQ .$# %1_(8 : .1k & .;
..............................................................
...............................................................................
1q q hQh G J 0 G 2 1q (0 1& $ C - G ! &E - 1q GQ
......................................
$
.
.......................................
e .c G
/
q
9D 1917 e .c G
)#
.c LS9
.
1q GQ
7
Jl
G
1
hQ
. O
7
2 1q (0 k 7
71q 911k.P G 7!DL$ G
0q q 1
1
G
7 LE
Jl
G
. O
J
G
0q q
$!
$
J
k 7
L9 ?
P - C P G Lf - H )1$!
)1$!
.........................................................................
7 1
297
LV
......................................................
7 LE
G :2& .< G
q 1997 e .c G /9D 1990 e .c G
)#
Vl
G
H
hQ q G :dh $ G
$GF
=E2
kq q qq 2k 71(0J G 70LE G dXh : /h C 1989 q q q A GJ91 G 71(0J G 70LE G dXh : .1k & .;
...........................................................................................
..................
"
. 9E
J 0.
429
305
1990 e
...................................
1993 e
.c
.c k Jl .r 7 J 7 LE 9O 7 Jl . O k 7 J 7 LE q
G 2
G Q.
2 GQ
G f .&
q
1 GQ
Oh
1
G
q
1(0
Gh
q
hQ 2
q q
0
G
1(0
G
q q
0
G
G
308
...........................
325
...................................................
325
.....................................................................................................
GL9!?&E 2k 71q (0J G 70q Lq E G :2& .<
$ F J 8 .r 7 J L .cS Jr9c 7 LD .[ / .c k .P ) rD .q J 7 J mq . .; . L .cR 7O . .r 7 J .b ? dX .< .; .2c WVH 2 ?P8 L> . .Yr mq 7 J r9 L e . $ dX 7 J L 7 #P 7 J L .cS .c1 7 J L .cS 7O . k 7 J L k 7 J Jr9c .r 7 . D .P .G q
2 &. &
q
1(0
G
G
F
.........................................
325
..................................................
328
.....................................................................
329
.............................
329
............................................
q Q $#h 2&.&
+ F
IO
.....................................
336
..................................................
q
1(0
0
q
1(0
G )#
0 1!
1(0
.....................................
347
.....................................................................
349
...............................................................
350
.......................................................
h :
J GA G
E
G
h
F
G :
G
Q $# 2
G R.#
G 2
$ G f.&
G JG p
347
q
1(0
G
.....................................................................
1(0
k
.# : 1&
$ G
f 0O
#h
F
......................................................
q hC
E :
G
.$
1
G
G
344
1,$
k
q
q
G
f.&
h
G J
q
G
Q
G b.
$ G /( $ G " 1
G R.#
.........................................................
)0
q
.#h
G
&
f
1(0
G
q
!
,(# A
333
337
G 2
1998 e
=E2
G
k
q q
$ G
Gh
325
336
Lk
$ G S ,
-
C
-
H
0 $
G
:
k
k
GQ
#
1q GQ G 1& $ C 2 1q (0 G 0q q G : G $GF J 7 J mq / .r 7 J 7 LE .[ . .; 7 J 7 LE J r V k r 7 9OJ 7 uE mq 7 J L 7 #P 7 J .b ? dX 7 J 7 LE .. k 7 .q 7 . D 7 J L .cS 7 . D 7
Jl
.
.
k 7
J
7 LE
= .<
=E2
k
351
353
356
.........
8.
r n q 18h 9 )1 O $ G 2
IOQ G. G O.1
G )#
q
2 &. & n
q
1(0
)0
q q
0
G
G I
q
G )#
q
1(0
G
0Q.
G
q
1(0
......................................................................
q
..........................................
1(0
1& $ C 2
G J q
1&.&
.$
$ G
k
0 $
1(0
.# :
G
q q
0
G
( G -
$
.# -
$ G
G R.#
1(0
G
# -
G
q
q q
0
G
F
q hC
k E : 1&
G Q
8 1 $ G U.
hh
q
h
G -
0 $
G
-
360
...................................
363
...................................................................................................
366
..........................................................................................
#q G $ G J L f8 7 #P 7 J L 7 Yq )0
q
1(0
7 .c 11
G
.......................................................................................
373
..................................................................................................
q
1
G
G $G
d> L
1
!
G
373
...........................................................................
379
................................................................................
G
$ Gh J
J
q
380
..........................................................................................
380
..............................................................................
J
.
1 h
G
.$ G h %
$ G : GQ
F
G
. G
$ G
F
7E /
7 1Lc 7f .1 d> L / / .r .O J 7 J s .; .b O > .c q
8 .H #
G R .#
368
7
k
q hC
J .0.9E$ G SL,k
381
430
q
........................................................
71$OL
q
71&.& .r
G hC
G
q
71&hL9u ) G dq G.$
q
k G : .1& .;
712(> $ G 7f! .1 d> GL$
381
.........................................................................
383
.....................................................................
384
.............................................................
385
..........................................................................
387
........................................................
389
...................................
391
...............................................................................
405
.................................................................
410
...........................................................
423
...................................................................................................
425
..............................................................................................
q
q
q J .0QhO
712(> $ G 7f! .1 71&.& .q
:&L9&) G 7u2R
/!b
G
q
71&hL9u
E
dq G . #
71&.& .r 71H0 .9 s .;. sE!# q
Gh
q
Q
G
F
G
The Religious Peace of Augsburg, 1555 The Virginia Act For Establishing Religious Freedom 2& .< G 2& .u18 .l G
d$?$
G
CHILEAN LAW OF WORSHIP COLOMBIAN LAW OF WORSHIP
J
0b $ .0.9E$ e
G S G S
L,k L,k
ÊU u L Ç ÓdN 5 5 8 9
11 13 14 15 15 17 18 18 21 25 27 27 29 35 41 41 41 42 44
7# .c
q
q
...................................................................................................
...........................................................................
q .,91?,(#h
G
7#Jr$
G
GQJ G Y.X.# 2k .,91.cUh 7O GQJ G a GJ+ C 2k 7O GQJ G %1Pr8
............................................................................
7O
................................................................................................
.........................................
ÑuñD Çè ÉQAM Ç w ºWOñM b Ç W ñdñ(Ç ºäèñ_Ç ÈU Ç ©W ÑUI WOñ u U WOñ ÑU2 ÉdE ¨
..............................................................................................................
J1,$8
q qq 71(0J G 70LE G m0Lc8 q qq 71(0J G 70LE G LU .(b
........................................................................................
.....................................................................................
M 0\U / Gh 7f! G 2k L1$Y G m0Lc8 iLG $ G 7#q .c G J .0q Lq E Gh 71q (0J G 70q Lq E G q qq . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The scope of religious liberty 71(0J G 70LE G d .?# )0J G F!\V$1 O.Vr$ G :/ h $ G ILrl G q71b .$9> G IL+ ._t )0J G m0Lc8 :71& .< G ILrl G
................................................................
..............................................................
...........................................................
....................................................
................................
7$0Jr
......................................
G J
7$0Jr
.c0LS9
G J
G
2k 71q (0J
.c$9?$
Gh
71(0J q
70LE q q
G
70LE q q
G
G
dq.#
q :dh
% Pr
$G
"Vl
G
H
2& .< G "Vl
G
H
q G :dh
$G
O .r9b / G 70q Lq D )# 7$0Jr G - 7 hJ G mq.# :/ h $ G ILrl G bLS G 2k 7$0Jr G J .0q Q.[ GL2#) Gh O .r9b / G 70q Lq D :71& .< G ILrl G q .f$ G %uE G 7l!9H$ G J .& .0J .1 -9q 0bh 2
.................................
.......................
..................................................
...................................
2q 1Lf G %
.c
G
2k 71q (0J
70LE q q
G
G Q
.P#
......................................................................................
.........................................................
...............................................................
.........................................................
:
kq q .1hQh C 2k : /h C q J GJr9c$ G OJc8h s0Le) G - C q q 71& .#hL G 70Q.[ GL2#) G - H q q .#hQ 2k dh $ G d.E9 G :/ h $ G ILrl G
425
G
. 9E$
J 0.
45
L k
G S ,
426
70Q.[ GL2#* .1$OQ .(0O 71E1P$ .
f $ Q 48
52
55
56
58
59
64
.R J,b
2k
7P1(u
q
.......................
.......
.1hQh C
71E1P$
Le
2k
H
7
3+ GK$
G
q
71E1P$
7 hJ
Jc8h
q
Jc91
.......................................
71(0J
G dh
J
= .<
Lf
G d.
G Q.
L9b / G
G O
1532 Z
C
J2#h
Z
2(0J G
...........................................................
F# .P9
G I
7< .<
G I
7tLD
:
7c1 GL
G I
:
b
d1 GL
.l8E
-
1
.l8E
-
2
J+ .c#
-
3
. 0b E
-
4
q
q q
b
L$c9P$
G %1
.....................................................................................................
@F .9(
c$
Gh /(
..........................................................................
74
......................................................................
q
2t
$G
80
...........................................................
83
..................................
85
...............................
85
................................................................................
85
...................................................................
87
q
71(0J
J,c
q
........
e
q
0O) Gh 71E1P$
21Lf G q
......................
2# 0O) Gh 21Lc G q
q
k
G 2
2(0J G O .r9b / G q
2(0J G O .r9b / G q
7!DL#
:
/h C
Jr9c$
Gh
G
J,b
k
k : 1&
. .; k
q
J9$8h q q
70LD
q
:
:
.< .; k
.c1 GQ
Gh 70q Lul G .+QhK> :71q (0J G 70q Lq E G :dhq $ G "Vl G H
...................................................
105
Jrb
Gh 70q L_( G .+QhK>h 71q (0J G 70q Lq E G :2& .< G %Pr G
q
...................................
113
2& .$<c G
q
100
105
hO
G
%uE G )#
...............................................
q
7
7 K
J1,$8
: #
)0JR GL G A .l!H G
75
71&.& .r
G
G
q
k 7# .b IL_&
7(0J$
q .!$$ G / E j.#
q
G
G 2
73
G
Pr8
71
....................................................
E9
G 70q Lq D := .< "Vl H
Jr9c$
71
G
. .;
...........................................
n
Lrl
k G : 1&
70LE
G
71
Gh
G
G d.
..................................
q
Lrl
q
65
71# 0O) G 7 hJ
G
q
71(0J
Gh
G JG
Lrl
q
G J &
71tL1# $ G 71L?9
3+K$! .rkh IJ0J?
q
7 .<
[ GL2#E(
JG
k
2(0J G
G :
L1M>h C
q
.........................................................
E9
L2#Q.&
70LDh .1 .l9Oh q
G : 1&
. J1
q q
G
E9
J 0G
aG
Cuius region, eius religio q
q
2(0J G M 0U) G
...............................................................
..........................
G :
q G d.
.<
q
G O
3+ GK$
G
G-
G :2&
)814-800 H
.................................................
q
52
k
3
q
.......................
q q
70LD
...............................................
e
Lul Lul
71qLR G 2 G 2
q q
G Qh
.lP!k
2k -
q
k 71(0J q
k 71(0J q
70LE1 7U .H
/ E ILU .c$ G
0O) G
J
70L_(
q
G
71E1P$
q q
70LE
G
q q
70LE
G q
71(0J G
2k 2(0J G O .r9b / G q
G :
H
G -
L
K?
G -
q q
70LD
-
q
/h C
C
G -
G Qh
70DL
k
K?
k G : 1&
. .;
C
H
fLr G / E LSb dO .9 G fLr G )# 71q (0J G 70q Lq E .1 2q &.& .r G a GL9b / G :2& .< G "Vl G H )0LSc G
123
............................................................................
123
................................................
q
71(0J
G
q q
70LE .1
2&.& .r G a GL9b / G q
70 GJ1
k
:
q
/h C
. 9E
J 0.
427
123
125
128
7 J 7 L E .1 ? J9 L9b / $ .P ) rD . 0b k 7 J 7 LE dq $ Lrl 7rD 0 7 [ .c LS9 k .P ) rD . 0b L; 7 .< Lrl 7 O .O $ .P ) rD .rD 7 J 7 LE . .; 7 J s .; k 7 J 7 LE 7 q) s .; k 7 J 7 LE LE 7 .D k 7 J 7 LE dq 7 J ,> 0 3 .> $ 7 LD q
.....
/ h
&
G f
G
q
1(
G b.
. G J
J &
0
G 2
q
2
q q
0
G
G b.
G
J &
0Q
G aG
1
&
G f
G I
G
C : 1&
G I
G
E
135
................................................
q
1 h
G
q
1$1!
..............................................
H
...........................................
G b.
G
1(0
q
1(0
1(0
G )1
0
G
k G : 1&
0
C
G -
H
.# -
L
0
q q
0
G
q q
G -
q q
G
&
Gh
q q
G
q q
G
0
G
q
q
2
G
q
1(0
1(0
. G 2
F
q
)#
. G 2
F
G
.# :/ h
3
q
.....................................
151
1(0
&
f
q q
0
G
q
E 2
135
150
1(0
......................................................
..
-
O
154
.................................................
157
............................................
159
.........................................
161
.......
161
.....................................................................................................
167
......................................
178
...................
q
71(0J
qq G 70LE G
1(0
G
J
)0
7 J 7PO& q
q
Gh
$ Gh
ILU .c$ G L18 .OJ G
.+L; Ch
2k
7 J 7 J
q
)0 J
Gh 7 hJ G
)1 1
G )0
G )1
71(0J
7q 0c
G J GP dh
qq q G 70LE G :dh $ G
q
2k
OL J J 1 Vl J2 1 KG #8 1 .c9 J2 1 KG #8
2$
G )1
h
h
Ã&#x2030;d UF*Ã&#x2021; W èb Ã&#x2021;è WOM b Ã&#x2021; W d(Ã&#x2021; ºw U Ã&#x2021; Ã&#x2C6;U Ã&#x2021; ñ ñ ñ
q G W .$& C :dh $ G
"Vl
G
.$
$ G
"
G
C
$
d hO : 1 &
G
.$
$ G
fh
G
C
$
d hO :
G
.$
$ G
189
.............................................
189
.....................................................................................................
q
qq q G 71(0J G 70LE G OhJD :2& .< G
70Q.9OJ
1(0
0
G
Q $# Oh
G
..................................................
195
.................................................................
195
..........................................................................
196
...................................................
197
................
G h C )0
G
!
)0
#
.....................................
)0
G
2
...............................................................
204
...............................................
-!F
q hh jQ GO
........................................................
207
......................................................
225
........
227
.
#
q jQ GO
q jQ GO
q G - f .(2 - LV# :711Lc G J .c0LS9 G
G f.&
G J
G
H
1,$
G /(
G
G
G aG
G
2k
!
G
q
G :
0
G
C
G QhO -
H
# -
L
h
k
G e
( G :
# 2
-
1
+C 2
-
2
Oh
-
3
qq G 70LE G :2& .< G
2k
71(0J
q
qq q G 70LE G :dh $ G
71(0J
q hC
k : 1&
0
G QhO -
q Gh e
G H GO
- IQ .9H# LP .$& - ILU .c$ G J .c0LS9 G
LF GM?
)0
1
G A
q
h f .&
G e., #
3 1&.&
jO
1#
204
)0
2
2
q
0
3 1&.&
0
G
0
n
206
"Vl
k
q q
190
. $
H
J 8 7 J 7 LE 7O . JD .r / . .q J l J JE8 . .; . .q J m Lc8 J m Lc8 k L 8 .OJ J F \V J JE8 k .c .r J m Lc8 tL $ .Yr / .E 7 .c ! .c ._ .< .; .O ) ]2Y c k ) ]2Y J k ) ]2Y 7\ O JD q
f 0O
G
1,$
$ 7b ? 7 .< 7b ? 7< .< 7b ?
....
% Pr G
J 8
G :/ h
183
201
Lk
$ G S ,
"Vl
% Pr
G
H
G
J .0.9E$ G SL,k 227 227 227 228 230 237 246 246 249 253 258 262 264 267 267 267 270 286 288 289 289 290 290 291
428
297 297 305
# 2 1q (0 k 7
0q q
G
J
q G :dh $ G
7 LE
$ F
=E2
G
k O .,9> / Gh d0LS9 G 2k O .r9b / G 70q Lq D : /hq C 72q .c9$ G 70q LV$ G L18 .OJ G 2k O .r9b / G 70q Lq D - C 71q &.& .r G-70q Q.9OJ G 70 .$E .1 /_E8 29 G J .& .0J G - H jqLV$ G d0LS9 G 3PE1 71q (0J G mF G.\ .1 a GL9b / G - L q 7lF .\ G h C 7!$ G h C )0J G L11f8 - O O .,9> / Gh d0LS9 G 2k 71q (0J G LF .cS G 7OQ .$# : .1k & .; IO .2c G QhO A .(2 .,8 .b GL# 3> G. G WhLS G q q q 2k 71# 0O) G L1e mF G.\! IO .2c G QhO A .(21 -9q 0bh 2&.0 .$, G ]H G - C
...................................................
................................
..........................
......................
...................................................
.......................................
...........................................
........................................................................................
.................
LV
#
.+QLq q 29 G +O .2$ G %q + Ch jqLV$ G 7 hJ G Q!?# mq.# - H )1$!P$ G L1f IO .2c G QhO A .(1 WhLR %11r8 - L .,$1#L8h QF .(u G A .(1 7 #P# 2k IJ0J> 7!DL# - O k gLF .cRh Jr9c$ G 70 .$D : .< .;
..................................
..............................
.....................................................................
...................................
7
1q & ( ! G 0q Q.,$ . 2
7
2 1q (0
G
?
k 7
0q q
G
J
G :2& .< G
7 LE
$GF
=E2
k f .(2 2k .,8 .r12\8h O .r9b / G 70q Lq D : /hq C 71q & .(2! G 7 hJ G .,1 aL9c8 29 G 3+ GK$ Gh f .0O $ G - C q Q.9OJ G )# 7cO .9 G IO .$ G f.$Y# 2k 71q !1!E8 IL_& - H f .(2 2k 71q (0J G LF .cS G 7OQ .$# : .1k & .; k gLF .cRh 2q (0J G Jr9c$ G 70 .$D : .< .;
.......................................................
..........................
......................
..........................................................
............................................................
...................................
q jLF GM? G
0
d LS9
...................................................
G
2 1q (0 k 7
0q q
G
J
7 LE
G :=
.<
G
$GF
=E2
k jqLF GM? G Q.9OJ G 2k O .r9b / G 70q Lq D : /hq C 71q (0J G LF .cS G 7OQ .$# %1_(8 : .1k & .;
..............................................................
...............................................................................
1q q hQh G J 0 G 2 1q (0 1& $ C - G ! &E - 1q GQ
......................................
$
.
.......................................
e .c G
/
q
9D 1917 e .c G
)#
.c LS9
.
1q GQ
7
Jl
G
1
hQ
. O
7
2 1q (0 k 7
71q 911k.P G 7!DL$ G
0q q 1
1
G
7 LE
Jl
G
. O
J
G
0q q
$!
$
J
k 7
L9 ?
P - C P G Lf - H )1$!
)1$!
.........................................................................
7 1
297
LV
......................................................
7 LE
G :2& .< G
q 1997 e .c G /9D 1990 e .c G
)#
Vl
G
H
hQ q G :dh $ G
$GF
=E2
kq q qq 2k 71(0J G 70LE G dXh : /h C 1989 q q q A GJ91 G 71(0J G 70LE G dXh : .1k & .;
...........................................................................................
..................
"
. 9E
J 0.
429
305
1990 e
...................................
1993 e
.c
.c k Jl .r 7 J 7 LE 9O 7 Jl . O k 7 J 7 LE q
G 2
G Q.
2 GQ
G f .&
q
1 GQ
Oh
1
G
q
1(0
Gh
q
hQ 2
q q
0
G
1(0
G
q q
0
G
G
308
...........................
325
...................................................
325
.....................................................................................................
GL9!?&E 2k 71q (0J G 70q Lq E G :2& .<
$ F J 8 .r 7 J L .cS Jr9c 7 LD .[ / .c k .P ) rD .q J 7 J mq . .; . L .cR 7O . .r 7 J .b ? dX .< .; .2c WVH 2 ?P8 L> . .Yr mq 7 J r9 L e . $ dX 7 J L 7 #P 7 J L .cS .c1 7 J L .cS 7O . k 7 J L k 7 J Jr9c .r 7 . D .P .G q
2 &. &
q
1(0
G
G
F
.........................................
325
..................................................
328
.....................................................................
329
.............................
329
............................................
q Q $#h 2&.&
+ F
IO
.....................................
336
..................................................
q
1(0
0
q
1(0
G )#
0 1!
1(0
.....................................
347
.....................................................................
349
...............................................................
350
.......................................................
h :
J GA G
E
G
h
F
G :
G
Q $# 2
G R.#
G 2
$ G f.&
G JG p
347
q
1(0
G
.....................................................................
1(0
k
.# : 1&
$ G
f 0O
#h
F
......................................................
q hC
E :
G
.$
1
G
G
344
1,$
k
q
q
G
f.&
h
G J
q
G
Q
G b.
$ G /( $ G " 1
G R.#
.........................................................
)0
q
.#h
G
&
f
1(0
G
q
!
,(# A
333
337
G 2
1998 e
=E2
G
k
q q
$ G
Gh
325
336
Lk
$ G S ,
-
C
-
H
0 $
G
:
k
k
GQ
#
1q GQ G 1& $ C 2 1q (0 G 0q q G : G $GF J 7 J mq / .r 7 J 7 LE .[ . .; 7 J 7 LE J r V k r 7 9OJ 7 uE mq 7 J L 7 #P 7 J .b ? dX 7 J 7 LE .. k 7 .q 7 . D 7 J L .cS 7 . D 7
Jl
.
.
k 7
J
7 LE
= .<
=E2
k
351
353
356
.........
8.
r n q 18h 9 )1 O $ G 2
IOQ G. G O.1
G )#
q
2 &. & n
q
1(0
)0
q q
0
G
G I
q
G )#
q
1(0
G
0Q.
G
q
1(0
......................................................................
q
..........................................
1(0
1& $ C 2
G J q
1&.&
.$
$ G
k
0 $
1(0
.# :
G
q q
0
G
( G -
$
.# -
$ G
G R.#
1(0
G
# -
G
q
q q
0
G
F
q hC
k E : 1&
G Q
8 1 $ G U.
hh
q
h
G -
0 $
G
-
360
...................................
363
...................................................................................................
366
..........................................................................................
#q G $ G J L f8 7 #P 7 J L 7 Yq )0
q
1(0
7 .c 11
G
.......................................................................................
373
..................................................................................................
q
1
G
G $G
d> L
1
!
G
373
...........................................................................
379
................................................................................
G
$ Gh J
J
q
380
..........................................................................................
380
..............................................................................
J
.
1 h
G
.$ G h %
$ G : GQ
F
G
. G
$ G
F
7E /
7 1Lc 7f .1 d> L / / .r .O J 7 J s .; .b O > .c q
8 .H #
G R .#
368
7
k
q hC
J .0.9E$ G SL,k
381
430
q
........................................................
71$OL
q
71&.& .r
G hC
G
q
71&hL9u ) G dq G.$
q
k G : .1& .;
712(> $ G 7f! .1 d> GL$
381
.........................................................................
383
.....................................................................
384
.............................................................
385
..........................................................................
387
........................................................
389
...................................
391
...............................................................................
405
.................................................................
410
...........................................................
423
...................................................................................................
425
..............................................................................................
q
q
q J .0QhO
712(> $ G 7f! .1 71&.& .q
:&L9&) G 7u2R
/!b
G
q
71&hL9u
E
dq G . #
71&.& .r 71H0 .9 s .;. sE!# q
Gh
q
Q
G
F
G
The Religious Peace of Augsburg, 1555 The Virginia Act For Establishing Religious Freedom 2& .< G 2& .u18 .l G
d$?$
G
CHILEAN LAW OF WORSHIP COLOMBIAN LAW OF WORSHIP
J
0b $ .0.9E$ e
G S G S
L,k L,k