Comment
North Coast news daily:
netdaily.net.au
A fistful of dollars without a plan to fund it
Volume 32 #25
November 29, 2017
Boycott this country The government has known for 18 months that Papua New Guinea was going to shut down the Manus Island detention centre, leaving the inmates trapped in a hostile environment with nowhere to go. It made no effort to resolve the crisis, rejected New Zealand’s offer of help and insisted that it is PNG’s problem and nothing to do with Australia. By using foreign aid as a carrot and stick it has indeed made PNG accept legal responsibility for the refugees. However, the rest of the world has no doubt where the moral responsibility lies. The abuse suffered by those already incarcerated for five years and more has been documented by groups such as Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and the United Nations. There is no doubt that a humanitarian crime has been perpetrated in the name of the Australian people, but despite widespread protests around the country the two major parties are too invested in their policy to do anything to help the victims of their ‘people smuggler’ narrative. Both sides are trapped by their extremist positions, adopted in the first place as each vied with their political opponents in an auction of brutality. Both sides also overestimate the influence of our predominantly right-wing media, which, as is becoming increasingly clear, represent only a minority of opinion. Hence, the detainees on Manus Island and Nauru can never under any circumstances be processed on the mainland, even though that would be the rational course of action. Nor can they go to New Zealand because that would be a ‘back-door’ way to Australia (it would be extremely easy to get round this with visa restrictions, but the point of course is to be maximally bloody-minded). So the refugees continue to suffer. What do we do when flagrant crimes against humanity are committed by a foreign government? We apply sanctions. This might be seen as an extreme option, only to be meted out to dictatorships and states with appalling records of human rights abuse, but if we were outside Australia looking in, instead of inside looking out, it might not seem a disproportionate response. At any rate it is the thinking behind the nascent campaign ‘Boycott Australia’. The writer Antony Loewenstein has suggested a sports boycott, and Crikey journalist Guy Rundle thinks crowdfunded ads against Australian tourism in overseas media might have an impact. Frankly, we have no idea if it would work. What is certain is that nothing else is shifting the cast-iron cage of cruelty the government has erected around the refugees incarcerated in offshore prisons. David Lovejoy News tips are welcome: editor@echo.net.au
W
hen all else fails, dangle the prospect of a tax cut and hope that the jaded eyes of the voters light up. Well, perhaps it’s not actually a prospect, more of a hint – or just a suggestion of a hint. But Malcolm Turnbull certainly mentioned the idea to an audience of the increasingly irrelevant Business Council, so presumably he intended it to settle in the headlines, which it duly did. At this stage we have no idea how much or when this bonanza is envisaged, let alone how it is to be paid for, and it is likely that Turnbull himself is equally ignorant. All that can be reported is that he says he is talking about it with ministers, which, given the sorry record of how his ‘conversations’ turn out, is not reassuring. But not to worry; there will be pie in the sky, or at least a fistful of dollars at the end of the rainbow. And let’s face it, nothing else seems to be working. But there is a problem; while the attempt to bribe a recalcitrant electorate into submission is an established political tradition, the efficacy is at least questionable. Many years ago the Labor prime minister Ben Chifley defined the hip-pocket nerve as the most sensitive part of a voter’s anatomy and ever since then (if not before) leaders have tried to scratch the itch. The most blatant example in modern times was in 1977, when the government of Malcolm Fraser produced advertisements which showed, literally, a fistful of dollars for the taking. The punters duly took it, but then it was snatched back in a few short months following Fraser’s election win; one headline summed up the episode as ‘Lies, Lies, Lies.’ In 1983, Bob Hawke was running against Fraser with the
slogan of reconciliation, recovery and restoration. The NSW premier Neville Wran brought the campaign meeting back to earth with the warning: ‘Delegates, it’s all very well to go on with this spiritual stuff, but if those greedy bastards out there wanted spiritualism, they’d join the fucking Hare Krishna.’ Immediately, tax cuts were inserted into the policy speech. Hawke’s successor as prime minister, Paul Keating, went further: tax cuts were to be included as L-A-W law, but in the end they weren’t, and Keating was dogged by what was seen as a
stupid; is an already sceptical public expected to believe that our legislators really have nothing to do until the senate has finished talking about the samesex marriage bill? With 53 items clearly listed on the notice paper of the House of Representatives, the proposition is too absurd to contemplate by a rational observer. The public may not be hanging out to watch every moment of the parliamentary sessions, but that does not mean they are happy about the idea of their wellpaid representatives skiving off whenever they feel like it.
While the attempt to bribe a recalcitrant electorate into submission is an established political tradition, the efficacy is at least questionable.
by Mungo MacCallum betrayal. And remember: Fraser, Hawke and Keating were all regarded as far more effective and reliable than Malcolm Turnbull. So it is unlikely that what Bill Shorten unkindly but accurately dubbed the prime minister’s latest thought balloon will fly – certainly not without putting a lot more air into it. But in a sense it may not matter, because, as always, distractions have overwhelmed Turnbull’s desperate efforts to regain traction on the slippery slope on which he finds (or more likely loses) himself. Last week’s wizard wheeze was the decision to close down parliament for a few days, a clear signal from the leadership group (an oxymoron if there ever was one) to panic, run for cover and pull the blankets over their heads in the hope things will go away. This extraordinary desertion of duty has rightly been characterised not only as chickenhearted, lily-livered and utterly spineless, but also as incredibly
Stainless Steel Rainwater Tanks
It is not a question of whether Turnbull is scared shitless, but of what – a lost vote in the parliament, the right wing rump, a potential uprising in the party room, or most likely all three. With a couple of numbers already down and the possibility of more to go once his postponed reckoning on universal disclosure kicks in, the situation is not benign; but trying to duck it will, as always, only make things worse – as Tony Abbott triumphantly pointed out. Just as it may with the samesex marriage showdown, which, characteristically, Turnbull and his brains trust have attempted to avert with yet another committee, this one to examine the need for what is euphemistically called religious freedom. The personnel involved show the real aim: the chief inquisitor, Phillip Ruddock, is an old-fashioned committed Christian, and his deputy, Frank Brennan, is a Jesuit priest. The last of the trio is the new Human Rights com-
missioner Rosalind Croucher, who has adopted a very low profile following the exit of her predecessor, the redoubtable Gillian Trigg. The Christians obviously have the numbers, as was intended: there will be an apprehended bias (to put it delicately) that the idea is not religious freedom (already enshrined in the constitution and numerous laws both federal and state) but Christian privilege – further exemptions from secular law. And the idea that other religions, especially Islam, should have a similar advantage is, of course, out of the question: stamp out Sharia law! Ban the burqa! So the prevarication devised, we are told, by Peter Dutton is simply putting off the next inevitable stoush. Indeed, it may not even do that: Scott Morrison is apparently determined to force his version of religious protection through the same-sex legislation and Matthias Corman has already decided to plagiarise a human rights convention from the much loathed and derided United Nations to give it some authority. But the serious godbotherers in the party room are not appeased – although of course they never will be. Just to prove the point, one of their most enthusiastic backers, Andrew Bolt, reported that one of them is preparing to leave the coalition if Turnbull does not knuckle under – a rat is ready to desert the sinking ship. There have been empty threats from anonymous rebels (and even a couple of empty threats from identified insurgents such as George Christensen) so it might not give Turnbull too much cause to fret – not that he seems to show any, however dire the circumstances. After the past year, surely things can only get better. At least he can look forward to a tax cut…
Brunswick Heads Blinds & Awnings Throughout Byron Shire
The Byron Shire Echo Established 1986 • Purest,
safest drinking water
• Better Nicholas Shand 1948–1996 Founding Editor
General Manager Simon Haslam Editor Hans Lovejoy Photographer Jeff Dawson Advertising Manager Angela Cornell Production Manager Ziggi Browning ‘The job of a newspaper is to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable.’ – Finley Peter Dunne 1867–1936 © 2017 Echo Publications Pty Ltd – ABN 86 004 000 239 Mullumbimby: Village Way, Stuart St. Ph 02 6684 1777 Fax 02 6684 1719 Printer: Fairfax Media Brisbane Reg. by Aust. Post Pub. No. NBF9237
10 November 29, 2017 The Byron Shire Echo
value
• Longer
lasting and better built
• and
they look great!
(07) 5546 8571
www.stainlessrainwatertanks.com
GARAGE SALE 2ND DEC AT 8AM Assorted Blinds |Screens Doors | Awnings Bring your measurements! CLOSING DOWN 11TH DEC 14 Bonanza Drive, Billinudgel • 6680 4353
Byron Shire Echo archives: www.echo.net.au/byron-echo