Comment
North Coast news daily:
netdaily.net.au
G20 circus makes Abbott the monkey
Volume 29 #23
November 18, 2014
Wrestling the narratives Get a report done, then base your policy on it. It’s simple really. The NSW government’s attempts to allay public concerns about expanding the gas industry was released last week, and it’s called the ‘Gas Plan’. While the sparse 20-page document repeats itself somewhat, there is obligatory scaremongering about looming shortages. NSW only produces five per cent of its own gas, we are told. Interestingly it doesn’t mention deregulated markets as the cause of the expected shortage. The Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) is quoted – without qualification – by resource and energy minister Anthony Roberts (Liberal) as to why we should expect an impending shortage. But is this just politicking? AEMO’s ownership structure, according to its website, is ‘split between government and industry,’. It’s hardly independent, and looks suspiciously like an advocate for the fossil fuel industry. The Australian Energy Regulator (AER), however, is an ‘independent entity, comprising three members who are statutory appointments’. Anyway, AER’s State of the Energy Market 2012 says that domestic demand for the state is not increasing. Roberts says, ‘To put downward pressure on energy prices and secure supply, we need the growth of viable gas projects.’ Presumably the expected trickle-down from corporations will emit warm yellow pee in the form of economic growth. This is not about real energy security, and the government’s Gas Plan is careful to exclude mention of that. It appears to be aiming to establish a QLD-style overseas export market that benefits shareholders, and then, if we are lucky, possibly us. But shouldn’t we instead be starting the transition to renewables, where better jobs can also be created? And instead perhaps shouldn’t we address climate change, not exacerbate it? Around 97 per cent of climate scientists are saying this (www.climate.nasa.gov). But to humour the electorate, the state government says the expansion will be rolled out with environmental best practice. The Environment Protection Authority will be the ‘lead regulator for gas exploration and production’. Whoopdeedoo – we already know that they fined big miner Santos $1,500 for poisoning aquifers in the Pilliga forest last March. Roberts also says petroleum exploration titles will be removed from national parks. That’s actually sort of a win, but then again isn’t when you consider the gas will likely be shipped out via massive coal/gas ports on the Great Barrier Reef, which is of course under threat. And compensation will be offered for those affected by the industry, something the Wilderness Society says amounts to bribery. On the bright side, a ‘use it or lose it’ policy will require titleholders to ‘commit to developing the state’s resources or risk losing their title’. Hopefully that means the end to a blanket cover of northern rivers PELs. It appears real energy security can only be achieved by eliminating the fossil fuel industry’s financial influence over morally corrupt politicians. And advocacy groups such as the NSW Business Chamber should do better than to accept fossil fuel rhetoric. In doing so, emissions would be reduced, and rainbows may appear over a circle of people holding hands singing Kumbaya. Organic food bowls, not dirty coal holes! Hans Lovejoy, editor
L
et’s begin with the essential proposition: the G20 is a good thing – or at the very least an immeasurably better thing than any of its predecessors. The old G7 was an unashamed rich white men’s club: the United States, England, France, Germany, Italy, and Japan – the latter accorded honorary caucasian status as it was in apartheid South Africa. Canada was roped in at the last minute. And that was where it stopped – for 22 long years, the world changed but the G7 did not. The members were politically and culturally westerners, free-enterprise capitalists who saw their mission to preserve and enhance the economic status quo. But with the collapse of the Soviet Union, Russia was eventually brought into the fold and having opened the floodgates, the G7 finally accepted that there was a new reality. Pushed by Canada’s Stephen Martin and urged on from the sidelines by Australia’s Kevin Rudd, the G20 stumbled, blinking, into the daylight. The emerging giants of China and India could no longer be ignored and from Asia they were joined by South Korea and Indonesia. From South America came Argentina and Brazil and, from Central America, Mexico. The Middle East provided Turkey and Saudi Arabia, and South Africa and Australia brought up the numbers 19. To round things off, and to appease the old guard, the European Union as a whole was given a seat in its own right. Hence the G20, comprising 85 per cent of the world’s wealth, 75 per cent of its trade, and – more importantly – nearly two thirds of its population. Its leaders represent, in one way or another, a diversity which
mirrors a very large percentage of the planet on which we all live. It is worth celebrating, and so Tony Abbott, among many others, is prepared to celebrate. But alas, it did not go quite according to plan. To start with, we had the mega-macho threat of a shirtfront to Vladimir Putin. This was always going to be a letdown, and so it transpired. Our prime minister came down to a robust discussion, then to a demand for justice, and finally a request to an apology – not in the glare of sunny Brisbane,
No amount of sophistry can conceal the inadequacy of the defence put up by Abbott by Mungo MacCallum but behind closed doors in Beijing. When the pair met at the G20, Abbott offered an effusive handshake. Even a captive koala seemed more aggressive. Team Russia one, Team Australia nil. In the end the seriously hard words came from David Cameron, Angela Merkel and Stephen Harper, prompting a reports that Putin was preparing to make his excuses and depart prematurely. In the end he didn’t, but it was another distraction which had already included far too many for Abbott’s time in the spotlight – the hysterical revelation that Russian warships could be seen in the distance among them. But the big one was of course Barack Obama’s stubborn insistence that climate change was the real issue. Having already pre-empted the headlines with his announcement with Xi Jinping at APEC, Obama upstaged everyone with his powerful and wide-ranging speech at Queensland Univer-
Quality dentistry has never been so affordable Combining our gentle, holistic approach with the latest in dental technologies and procedures means we provide you with the
The Byron Shire Echo Established 1986
Nicholas Shand 1948–1996 Founding Editor
‘The job of a newspaper is to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable.’ – Finley Peter Dunne 1867–1936 © 2014 Echo Publications Pty Ltd – ABN 86 004 000 239 Mullumbimby: Village Way, Stuart St. Ph 02 6684 1777 Fax 02 6684 1719 Byron Bay: Level 1, Byron Community Centre, 69 Jonson St. Ph 6685 5222 Printer: Horton Media Australia Ltd Reg. by Aust. Post Pub. No. NBF9237
10 November 18, 2014 The Byron Shire Echo
stopping the boats (which he said were illegal – they’re not) he moved on to complain that the voters and their parliamentarians did not want him to put up university fees and charge more for sick patients. No doubt his fellow leaders were bewildered. His own press called it a whinge. And of course he dismissed the Xi-Obama breakthrough as hypothetical. Well, yes: but no more so than his own action plan to increase two per cent of the world’s GDP. Pledges for the future are, by definition, pledges. But given the progress the United States and China have already made in working towards reducing their reliance on carbon, they must be seen as a lot more realistic than Tony Abbott’s own preelection promises. And they are serious. When Obama described Australia’s position as a healthy debate, he was obviously being tactful, but given the whole tone
of his speech, he was making it very clear that Abbott’s position was simply not acceptable. No amount of sophistry can conceal the inadequacy of the defence put up by him and his minsters: we really are doing something, it really will work and when we get around to it we may or may not do something more. And if you fudge the figures, we are doing as much as the United States. Of course it is not really an economic issue anyway, so it does not really exist. And above all, coal is good for humanity, remember? The arguments have always been self-serving and ignorant; in the context of Obama and the broad consensus of the gathering at Brisbane, they are contemptible. And this is the real strength and message of the G20 meeting: it shows us a hard look at our leaders and their peers, and when they are giving us hope and confidence, and when they are talking bullshit. And it seems that the punters can sense it: not just the audience at Obama’s speech, but those on the sidelines. The demonstrators who endured Brisbane’s heat to make their many points all had their particular grudges, and fair enough; but they wanted positive responses. Unlike too many of those who disrupted previous G20 meetings, they did not just want to tear the system down, they wanted to make improve it – to listen more to what they saw as the injustices and inequalities in society and to find remedies. Idealistic perhaps – even naïve. But how much better than fear and pessimism, gloom and doom. On that level alone, the G20 must be counted a success – even if Tony Abbott did not get the public acclaim he had wanted. Or perhaps because of it.
The Ironing Lady
best service at an affordable price
General Manager Simon Haslam Editor Hans Lovejoy Photographer Jeff Dawson Advertising Manager Angela Cornell Production Manager Ziggi Browning
sity, where he urged the masses to rise up and demand action – urgent and uncompromising action – from their politicians. The contrast from Abbott’s public adjuration to speak from the heart (as opposed to the brain, presumably) was devastating. After he reminisced through his 2013 election slogans, boasted about getting rid of the carbon tax – the most cost-effective weapon in the fight against climate change – building more roads for more emissions for more cars and
Call 0266 851 264 Shop 6/18 Mullumbimbi St, Brunswick Heads
Hate ironing? I love it! Really! Free up your time and let me iron it for you Free pick-up and delivery in Byron Bay Good old-fashioned door-to-door service Fast turn-around Friendly and reliable Convenient Smoke-free environment $25/hour (1 hour min)
0414 719 680 ~ Angela ~
w w w. b r u n s w i c k d e n t a l. n e t Byron Shire Echo archives: www.echo.net.au