ANALYTIC PERFORMANCE SCORING RUBRICS FOR STEEL BALUSTERS CRITERIA A. WORKMANSHIP 50% 1. ACCURACY 25% 1.1 Overall Height 1.2 Overall Width 2. PROCESS 25% 2.1 Measuring, Cutting, Bending and Assembling 15% 2.2 Uniformity and Smoothness of Weld Beads 10% B. PROPER USE OF TOOLS AND EQUIPMENT
PERFORMANCE LEVEL 95 • Accurate/exact height
90 • +- 1-3 mm discrepancy
85 • +- 4-6 mm discrepancy
80 • 7mm or more discrepancy
• Accurate/exact measurement • All parts were properly measured, cut, bended and assembled with joints fully welded. • Joints have uniform and smooth weld beads.
• +- 1-3 mm discrepancy • All parts were properly measured, cut, bended and assembled but were observed to have 1-3 joints not fully welded. • 1-3 joints have uneven or rough weld beads
• +- 4-6 mm discrepancy • Some parts were not accurately measured, cut, bended and assembled but was observed to have 4-6 joints not fully welded. • 4-6 joints have uneven or rough weld beads
• 7mm or more discrepancy • Some parts were accurately measured, cut, bended and assembled but with 7 or more joints not fully welded. • 7 or more joints have uneven or rough weld beads
• Appropriate tools and equipment were orderly and properly used at all times.
• Was observed not using appropriate tools and equipment once (scattered)
• Was observed not using appropriate tools and equipment twice (scattered)
• Was observed not using appropriate tools and equipment thrice or more
• Observed safety practices and used appropriate protective gears/ accessories all the time.
• Observed safety practices but were once noted not using appropriate protective gears/ accessories.
• Observed safety practices but were twice noted not using appropriate protective gears/ accessories.
• Was able to finish the output 10 minutes before the allotted time. • Able to discuss/explain with confidence all of the following: a. Process b. function of tools, materials and equipment c. cost of production d. employability e. business opportunity
• Was able to finish the output 5 minutes before the allotted time. • Able to discuss/explain with confidence 4 of the following: a. Process b. function of tools, materials and equipment c. cost of production d. employability e. business opportunity
• Was able to finish the output within the allotted time. • Able to discuss/explain with confidence 3 of the following: a. Process b. function of tools, materials and equipment c. cost of production d. employability e. business opportunity
• Observed safety practices but were thrice or more noted not using appropriate protective gears/ accessories. • Was not able to finish the output within the allotted time. • Able to discuss/explain with confidence 2 of the following: a. Process b. function of tools, materials and equipment c. cost of production d. employability e. business opportunity
20%
C.SAFETY WORK HABITS
15%
D. SPEED
10%
E.COMMUNICATION SKILLS (3-5 minutes only) 5%