NEWS DESK
Frustration, accusations, effective politicking By David Harrison Mornington Peninsula Shire community council meeting, Rosebud Memorial Hall, 25 May 2015. No personal account can be given of the meal, but it was up to the usual high standard, according to usually reliable sources.
Floral showpiece: Sculptural trees act as landmarks at Mornington Rose Gardens.
Art fulfills promise of rose garden DESIGNER Barry Johnson in 2002 gave Mornington Rose Gardens a series of well setout pathways to allow visitors to wander freely while exploring the wide variety of roses. His design allowed for sculptural elements where the paths intersected – and that’s now the site for three colourful sculptural “trees” that stand tall among their vibrant orange petals. This is how it all came about: Last year, Melbourne-based builder Atkinson Pontifex entered two gardens in the Melbourne International Flower and Garden Show. One, designed by Paul Bangay, was awarded the gold medal. The other, by architect Giovanni Veronesi and entitled “Emerge”, was dedicated to the charity Family Life. His tapered trees were sculptural elements, forming the centrepiece of his garden. The three tapered “trunks” of different heights create the form of trees with brightly coloured orange petals radiating outward. This garden, with the sculptural trees as its showpiece, was awarded the silver show garden award. With an eye to beauty and form, the Mornington Rose Gardens committee approached Atkinson Pontifex to discuss the idea of using the trees as a sculptural element in their gardens.
...Don’t miss securing that wanted prope property p rty Immediate access to Bond & Rent nt Move into that property now Fast prompt assistance Easy terms and conditions No upfront fees and charges Pre approval before finding a property We can assist with transfer off bonds between properties
WE CAN ASSIST YOU WITH S TO IMMEDIATE ACCESS T BOND AND RENT
1300 554 470 2-4 Chelsea Rd, Chelsea VIC 3196 Fax: 03 9776 2929 Email: info@bondassist.com.au
www.bondassist.com.au
PAGE 12
Mornington News 2 June 2015
With the help of a generous anonymous donor and the company, it was agreed and the trees have been installed. They now offer a colourful and creative landmark for visitors. Mornington Rose Gardens was the idea of the late Don Gordon, a former shire president of Mornington, and is in Civic Reserve, corner Dunns and Mornington-Tyabb roads. About 4000 roses are planted in 86 beds and surrounded by native trees and shrubs. The garden’s first sod was turned by Cr Anne Shaw in 2004 after volunteers had laboured over its construction during a long period of drought. Gardener and radio personality Jane Edmanson opened it in 2008. As a boutique residential builder, Atkinson Pontifex specialises in high-end homes and landscaped gardens. It has 31 years of experience in the building and landscape industry, winning the HIA 2009 Victorian House of the Year, HIA 2010 Australian House of the Year and about 20 other HIA awards. It also submitted entries to the 2007, 2009, 2010 and 2013 Chelsea Flower and Garden Show in London. Stephen Taylor
THIS is a Council Listen rather than a Council Watch, as your correspondent was absent from the meeting. But there’s always the shire’s recording, which is posted on its website a few days later. So let’s soak up the drama and atmosphere without actually having been there. Unsealed car parks appeared a straightforward agenda item until it was pointed out the shire had more than 250 across the peninsula. It is anticipated that one or two will be sealed each year. This means the task might be finished in 125 years (by 2140) and, at worst, it might take until the Year of Our Lord 2265 – 250 years hence – before the last one is sealed. Of course by then there may be no need for car parks, as the End of the World may have intervened. Is this a realistic report to bring forward, officers were asked. To which the reply was that two car park categories, A and B, will be (so to speak) first cabs off the rank and, yes, they will be dealt with over a mere 20 years or so. It might be possible to “leverage” funds to speed the process. After a number of items that covered topics such as Anzac Centenary books, CEO Carl Cowie’s monthly report, and third quarter budget review, it was Notice of Motion time, where the excitement can often start, especially if the NoM is authored by Cr Hugh Fraser. Indeed this one was. The first motion was to restrict community (meet your councillors) meetings to one annually for each of the six wards, a drop of four. Cr Tim Wood argued this was plenty. Cr Antonella Celi, speaking against the motion, said it was unfortunate that the issue was being discussed “on the fly-by”. There should first have been a respectful, collegiate discussion with colleagues. The fewer “meet, greet and eat meetings” view prevailed 7-3 and the road show moved on. The value of the agenda committee was put on the block. Cr Celi opposed its axing. She confessed to “experiencing some severe confusion” with the intent of the motion. But axed it was. We must now take flight above the fray to the denouement of the meeting – Cr Fraser’s move to abolish the development assessment committee (DAC) altogether and deal with planning requests at ordinary council meetings. The calm was over: now the storm. It started with a query on whether the amended motion could be heard. It got the OK. A fierce cold front, in the formidable form of Cr Celi, then swept through the chamber. Followed by Cr Anne Shaw, with a rhetorical question followed by her answer replete with expressions such as “undermining”, “shame on you” “disrespect, contempt for the community”, “a joke, and so is
To advertise in Mornington News call Bruce Stewart on 0409 428 171 or email bruce@mpnews.com.au
anyone who supports it”. But little logic. Cr Andrew Dixon started with a deep sigh, and then came a crescendo. He was lost for words. “It’s blowing my mind,” he said. “It’s just phenomenally ridiculous – it’s stupid.” There would be too little time to assess a development at a council meeting, he said. “We’ll give you 13 seconds each to put across your point of view … we’ll take it on board; mmm, yeah, no, yeah, no, eeny-meeny-mineymo, yeh, nuh, nuh, nuh, not going through...” Then, addressing those favouring abolition: “That’s transparency for you, guys. We take our job seriously; I hope you guys still do as well.” After this, a pause and a thumping noise, as if the councillor’s mic was somehow malfunctioning, or possibly had fallen off the desk. CW could only imagine the scene in the chamber. [Editor: It was Cr Dixon headbutting his microphone with frustration.] After him, Cr David Garnock, calmly: “This motion is in my opinion just another example of a kneejerk, poorly thought-out, ill-judged, personal crusade by one particular councillor who believes he has a mandate to make changes to this council’s operations without first discussing the implications or the justifications for proposed changes with his fellow councillors and shire officers.” The motion was brought when the mover knew the numbers would be in his favour. “I found this to be disgraceful in the past and I find the strategy disgraceful tonight,” he said. The vote was tied. Cr Graham Pittock used his casting vote to allow the matter to be debated. There ensued more debate about the actual motion with its five parts, much of it directed at Cr Fraser, but it was inevitable the abolition of DAC was in the tumbrel en route to the guillotine. But there was a powerful, underlying message in all this, expressed most robustly by Crs Shaw, Celi, Garnock and David Gibb – a huge collective frustration that they no longer exercise the almost untrammelled power they possessed before Cr Wood’s election last August. It was a spectacular upswelling, best expressed by Cr Garnock’s accusation that Cr Fraser brought the matter to council when he knew he would be able to get it passed. Disgraceful! Nothing of the sort. CW doubts this was part of Cr Fraser’s thought process. If it was, it was good politics, an exercise of the art of the possible. (The gallery emptied at about 10.30pm and councillors discussed in private a couple of tenders – $305,787 (plus GST) to replace firedamaged Warringine Park boardwalk between Hastings and Bittern, and $1,234,264 (plus GST) for a major drainage project at Mornington.)
WHAT’S ON AT NEPTOURS STRICTLY BALLROOM *CROWN CASINO – MONTHLY* Casino’s bus program with a Extended Season-Wed 1 July great BUFFET lunch (all) $35. Adults $125 P/s $110.00 Only persons over the age of ANYTHING GOES 18 permitted. Wed 15 July LAST THURSDAY EACH (a) $130 (p/s) $120 MONTH (numbers permitting) CRAFT & QUILT FAIR Fri 24 July QUEEN VICTORIA MARKET All $60 Tue 9 June ’15 - all $30. Shop for all the bargains we do not have down here. We even supply a couple of Eskys for some of your perishables. THE LION KING Wed 20 May Wed 29 July (matinee) (a) $120 (p/s) $110
LEGENDS Wed 9 Sept (a) $120 (p/s) $110 CATS - REGENT THEATRE Wed 13 Jan 2016 (a) $120 (p/s) $110 COMING IN MAY 2016 SINGIN’ IN THE RAIN
Neptours Phone: 5981 1277
www.neptours.com.au