The Jewish Weekly Issue 310 - January 25th by The Jewish Weekly

THE LARGEST CIRCULATED JEWISH NEWSPAPER IN THE UK! CONTACT US FOR ALL YOUR PROPERTY NEEDS SALES

WANT TO SELL? WANT TO LET?

LETTINGS INVESTMENTS PROPERTY MANAGEMENT

020 8203 2111 WWW.THEROUNDTREE.COM MAIL@THEROUNDTREE.COM 25 JANUARY 2024 / 15 SHEVAT 5784

@TheJewishWeekly 310

‫ַעל ֵאלֶה אֲ ִני בו ִכיָּה‬

FOR THESE I WEEP... (LAMENTATIONS 1:16)

PARASHAT BESHALACH BEGINS 16:24 16:24 16:17 16:24 16:26 17:03 16:30 16:12 16:31

Se e in for pa fo m g rm o e at re 7 io n

SHABBAT: London Manchester Leeds Liverpool Birmingham Antwerp Bournemouth Gateshead Jerusalem

20 of the fallen soldiers

ENDS 17:31 17:35 17:35 17:42 17:35 18:17 17:43 17:32 17:47

GREEN SUNDAY 2024

REMEMBERING ISRAEL’S VICTIMS OCTOBER

MEMORIAL FOREST

2 NEWS BY DAVID SAFFER

Israel suffered its highest daily death toll on Monday since the beginning of the IDF’s ground offensive across Gaza following Hamas’ brutal terror in October. The IDF, which has surrounded Khan Younis in complex operations, confirmed 21 reservists were killed in action close to the border in the central Gaza Strip. A number of troops were also injured. The IDF is conducting a full investigation. Three soldiers were also killed in southern Gaza. Thousands attended the 24 funerals. Since the October 7 terror attack, 555 IDF soldiers have been killed including 221 inside Gaza. IDF spokesperson, Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari confirmed on Tuesday that forces were operating near the community of Kissufim when the tragedy occured. The mission was providing security conditions for residents of southern Israel to return to homes. “Forces were removing structures and terrorist infrastructure in the area,” he said. “It appears that around 4 o’clock, an RPG missile was fired by terrorists toward a tank that was securing the force. Simultaneously, there was an explosion that resulted in the collapse of two two-story structures, while most of the force was inside them and nearby. “The explosion of the structures was most likely from explosives laid by our forces, which were about to be used for demolishing terror infrastructure and buildings in the area.” Hagari added: “This war has a very painful

TO ADVERTISE CALL 020 3906 8488 and heavy price, the devoted reservists who rallied to the flag sacrificed everything for the security of Israel so that we all can live here securely.” Israeli leaders offered condolences. Prime Minister Netanyahu, in an address to the nation, said the incident was “one of the most difficult days since the outbreak of the war”. “Together with the citizens of Israel, I grieve for each one of them,” he said. “I embrace the families, whose lives have changed forever. We send prayers for the well-being of our wounded. The IDF is carrying out a thorough inquiry into the tragedy; we must learn the lessons and do everything for the well-being of our soldiers.” Netanyahu added: “We are in the midst of a war, the justification of which is without parallel. In this war there have been great achievements, including today, in completing the encirclement of Khan Yunis, but there have also been very heavy costs. While we bow our heads in memory of our fallen, we are not relenting, even for a moment, in striving for the goal that has no alternative, achieving total victory.” President Isaac Herzog: “Every name represents a shattered family, whose world has been torn apart by loss. We hold these families close to our hearts, sharing their sorrow and pain, yet also feeling immense pride in the heroism displayed by this generation. They embraced their mission with unwavering determination, facing the forces of evil, and remained steadfast in their commitment to our shared goal and unwavering love for our people and homeland.” He added: “Even in the face of this sombre and challenging morning, we stand united

giggles concept love joyous

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu preparing soldiers before they go into Gaza

in strength, knowing that together we will emerge victorious.” Defense Minister Yoav Gallant: “We continue at this time with the spirit of the fallen, to complete our missions and do everything necessary. Our forces operate deep in the enemy’s territory. We are keeping an eye on everything that is happening in the north. Hezbollah continues to provoke us. We are prepared, we do not want war, but we are ready for any situation. We have one hand reaching to the south and a watchful eye towards the north.” War Cabinet Minister Benny Gantz: “These were reservists who left everything and turned out to defend the State of Israel and the Zionist vision. We remember all those who have fallen. We are all wholehearted in the important mission for which they fell and left for us to realise and ensure the peace of the State of Israel, our children and future in this region. I have no doubt that when they went out yesterday on their mission, they intended for us to continue, and this is what we will do.” Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich: “The news is utterly heart-wrenching. The nation of Israel stands by you, united in our sorrow and anguish. We are committed to ensuring that the sacrifice of these young men will not be in vain. They serve as a guiding light, illuminating the path for us to continue this just campaign of the Israeli people, until we triumph over the forces of evil.” National Security Minister Itamar BenGvir: “Now, more than ever, it is clear that we must not halt the war, we must not diminish our fight. We must relentlessly continue to subdue, crush, and defeat the Nazi-like enemy in Gaza with our full strength. The blood of our finest soldiers, our brave fighters,

The Jewish Weekly The Jewish Weekly

www.thejewishweekly.com www.thejewishweekly.com

We can’t wait to be a part of yours

office@thejewishweekly.com office@thejewishweekly.com editorial@thejewishweekly.com editorial@thejewishweekly.com letters@thejewishweekly.com letters@thejewishweekly.com advertising@thejewishweekly.com advertising@thejewishweekly.com

London tel. 0203 906 8488 London tel. 0203 906 8488 Manchester tel. 0161 804 1321 Manchester tel. 0161 804 1321

020 8203 2111

25 JANUARY 2024

was not shed in vain. I hope that we will be worthy of their sacrifice and fulfil their unwavering determination, written in their blood, to crush and dismantle Hamas, and to bring back all the hostages.” Netanyahu continued his visits to troops at the Elyakim IDF base where he met cadets on the company commanders training course. “My main expectation is nothing less than total victory,” he told them. “There is no substitute for victory. These monsters (Hamas) will be thoroughly defeated. There is no substitute for victory. This is my main expectation and I am certain that it is also yours.” Netanyahu added: “What is important is your spirit. It is the spirit of the people of Israel, of the citizens of Israel. “I rely and believe in you. It is not simple to be a commander because you laden yourselves with responsibility to carry out the mission and do so in the best way possible. But each one of you carries on your shoulders the destiny of the people of Israel and of the State of Israel. I wish you success. May you be excellent commanders.” Netanyahu was briefed by Training Centre Deputy Commander Col. Sharon Eltit. He heard about the training programme for future IDF officers who take up posts in a few months fighting at the front. Netanyahu spoke with course cadets and answered questions on the progress of fighting across Judea and Samaria. Chief of Staff, Tzachi Braverman, and his Military Secretary, Maj.-Gen. Avi Gil attended.

WHAT’S INSIDE THIS WEEK WHAT’S INSIDE THIS WEEK 01 04 News News 15 Opinion 10 Letters 16 Games 16 18 Community Community 26 Opinion Feature 18

20 Games 28 Cookery 30 Judaism 24 Community 36 Kids 28 Judaism 38 Youth 34 Family Fun 38 Expert Advice

DISTRIBUTEDIN: IN: DISTRIBUTED UNITED BOURNEMOUTH, GATESHEAD, BIRMINGHAM, LIVERPOOL UNITEDKINGDOM: KINGDOM:LONDON, LONDON,MANCHESTER, MANCHESTER,LEEDS, LEEDS, BOURNEMOUTH, GATESHEAD, BIRMINGHAM, LIVERPOOL BELGIUM: BELGIUM:ANTWERP ANTWERP

THEJEWISHWEEKLY.COM

“I just hope to survive the winter” Hanna’s home was destroyed by a bomb. This winter, temperatures will reach -20°C in Ukraine. She needs your help. Will you repair Hanna’s home and keep her warm this winter? SCAN TO DONATE NOW

T: 020 8736 1250 E: info@worldjewishrelief.org

worldjewishrelief.org/winter

Get online, get informed, the Jewish Care way Now you can be part of our digital community, anywhere, anytime • Professional information and advice • Live and pre-recorded streaming entertainment • Singalongs and friendships • Service information • Exercise and wellness activities • Become a volunteer and get involved

All and more on-tap at

jewishcare.org Charity Reg. No. 802559

4 NEWS

TO ADVERTISE CALL 020 3906 8488

Hostage families meet Sunak Hamas to release our children.” Regarding the politicians, Eli, he Hostage families have called on the UK noted: “Each person told us they will do government to pressure Qatar to do more everything they can including talking to in the ongoing campaign to release loved Qatar and Egypt to release our families, ones from captivity in Gaza. 136 people. They understand the situaLiran Berman, brother of twins Ziv and tion. They need to know who is bad and Gali kidnapped in Kfar Aza, Eli Albag, good, who wants to live and who wants father of Liri Albag kidnapped near the to kill.” Gaza border and Ziv Abud, girlfriend of As for the atmosphere in Israel, Eli Eliya Cohen, kidnapped at the NOVA parnoted: “It’s very difficult in Israel when ty have attended a host of meetings with you don’t see your daughter and cannot parliamentarians and media this week. work. Sometimes I ask, who wants to live The three-day visit is of strategic imporin a country that sends missiles without tance due to Qatar assets in the UK. Key any reason. If someone kidnaps a son, audiences took place with Prime Minister daughter, mother or father how should a Rishi Sunak and Lord Cameron. government act against such people.” As to whether the Israeli government have done enough to get the hostages back, Eli gave a frank response. “I hope they have done their best,” he said. “We are here and in Israel day by day pushing that they will do their best. All the families are together, we are speaking and fighting together all over the world. Hamas on October 7 didn’t just kill Jewish people, they also kidnapped citizens of Britain. The whole world must know.” Eli had firm views about Hamas and their inhumane actions. He said: “With Hamas, there is evidence of what they did on October 7. Hamas have kidnapped the Palestinians in Gaza PHOTO: GETTY IMAGES too, they put them up as human Eli’s daughter Liri is 18. It is hard to shields. One day when Hamas are no comprehend the heartache he and his longer in power the world will hear the family has experienced since the October real stories from the Palestinian people. 7 terror attack by Hamas. When I hear people at demonstrations He told The Jewish Weekly, “We don’t defend Hamas and release Palestine, I know what has happened to Liri, I’ve not say, release Palestine from Hamas.” seen her for 109 days. We don’t know Eli was speaking on the day, 21 IDF if she has been able to eat, sleep, how reservists were killed in Gaza in a tragedy. they are treating her. We don’t know He said: “I was very sorry to hear the anything. Liri loves the world, people, news, over 500 soldiers have been killed likes to dance, sing, her dream is to visit already. For us each one is very imporJapan, she wants to help people and is tant, each one is not only a number, each a peace girl. We are very worried; all the family miss her. We cry every day and night for her. We are doing everything we can to get her back. “We want everyone to know what has happened. We want the UK government to pressure Qatar, they have supported Hamas with billions of dollars to build a nice Palestine. But Hamas have built underground tunnels with a lot of weapons and taught their children to kill people. Qatar needs to push

BY DAVID SAFFER

25 JANUARY 2024

one has a family, each one wants to live. Our neighbours, Hamas, they want to die. This is the difference between two people and organisations. Hamas want to die, we want to live but are dying because we are against this devil.” Appearing on BBC Newsnight on Monday night, Liran Berman said his mother

and 13 were murdered. Liri was one of seven abducted. Pictures were taken over 50 days ago but there are no sightings or knowledge about her condition or whereabouts. Eliya Cohen, 26, is an estate agent from Tel Aviv, who met his partner Ziv as teenagers. Eliya wasn’t keen on going to

felt the largest burden about his abducted brothers Ziv and Gali as his father has dementia. “It is tremendous stress,” he said. “The last hostages released saw them separately. They had minor injuries, but in tunnels for over 100 days minor injuries can turn into severe ones. But the relief of them being alive was tremendous.” Liran thanked Sunak for his efforts regarding the hostages. “He was one of the first Prime Ministers in the world to come and support the families since October 7,” Liran said. “We have asked him to do more, to keep fighting, to keep pressure on Qatar because we know Qatar has leverage on Hamas. They are hosting their senior leadership. And they are vastly involved in Europe.” Asked about families interrupting a Knesset session this week, Liron responded: “You can’t blame them. They’ve had more than 100 days of not knowing, of suffering, of no sleep.” Regarding a possible deal, he said: “I don’t want to be in the shoes of (politicians in) the decision making and they don’t want to be in my shoes. I’m thankful of not being involved. Right now, we will take whatever we can. We want our families back. We needed them yesterday. It’s been 108 days.” 26-year-old twins Ziv and Gali Berman lived in Kibbutz Kfar Aza. They were kidnapped from home. They are football fans, playing for a local team and fans of Maccabi Tel Aviv. They did everything together including flying, enjoying travelling and new experiences. Liri Albag lives in Moshav Yarhiv and hopes to be an interior designer. She has started her career in the military. Liri was among 28 girls in a bomb shelter near the border. Eight escaped

the NOVA party in Re’im, but the couple got tickets two hours beforehand. They were the first to leave when violence broke out but got a call from a cousin telling them not to continue as there was shooting up ahead. They took shelter with 30 others in front of the Re’im base and waited for the army. But two vans with 30 terrorists arrived and threw grenades into the shelter. Eliya was shot in the leg. Ziv’s nephew Amit and his partner Karin were murdered with 18 others. Four were kidnapped and six remained. They were discovered after six hours. A child was found murdered. Nothing is known about Eliya’s condition or whereabouts. Qatar business interests in the UK make it Britain’s 10th largest landowner with more assets than the Royal Family. The Board of Deputies has launched a scheme to encourage synagogues and communities to highlight a named hostage held in Gaza. Around 20 synagogues have joined the initiative The community will liaise with families to offer support and provide publicity for the ‘adopted’ hostage. Synagogues and organisations can remember hostages in prayers, social media post, reach out to local press and reserve a seat in the synagogue with a photograph of the hostage. BoD President Marie van der Zyl said: “Jewish communities all around the country have told us they want to do something to help in this awful situation. This is a way they can keep the names of hostages in the public consciousness and provide support to loved ones.” The Board is holding twice-weekly hostage vigils at Westminster while Parliament is in session. To join the campaign email sara.radivan@bod.org.uk

THEJEWISHWEEKLY.COM

Is Your Mum Sitting On a Stash of Cash?

Cash deposits are an easy target for 40% Inheritance Tax. Fortunately, there are some investment solutions which can swiftly shelter those savings from Inheritance Tax. What's more, the funds can stay in your mum's name giving her access when needed, including the ability to take monthly withdrawals for income.

Get in touch to arrange a meeting and see how much inheritance tax you could save. Not ready just yet? Join our mailing list; newsletter@arnoldaaron.co.uk Specialist Inheritance Tax Planning & Investments 78 York Street, London W1H 1DP Tel: 020 7692 0884 e: advice@arnoldaaron.co.uk w: arnoldaaron.co.uk Inheritance tax planning is open to both males & females (not just mums)! HM Revenue and Customs practice and the law relating to taxation are complex and subject to individual circumstances and changes which cannot be foreseen. The value of investments and any income from them can go down as well as up and you may not get back the original amount invested. Arnold Aaron is a trade name of Arnold Joseph Aaron, who is an appointed representative of The Openwork Partnership, a trading style of Openwork Limited which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

(POTENTIAL TO TURN INTO A KOSHER ESTABLISHMENT)

he got the promotion

Uses credit card to get through the month Money issues are more common than you think. Even for higher earners. No matter what you earn, Mesila offers confidential, expert one to one coaching, using tried and tested steps to help maximise your income.

coaching@mesilauk.org www.mesilauk.org 0333 344 1711

YOUR PATH TO FINANCIAL PEACE OF MIND

GREEN SUNDAY 2024

Remember Israel’s October 7 Victims

MEMORIAL FOREST

JNF UK’s Memorial Forest will commemorate all those brutally murdered in the barbaric attacks in our beloved homeland. The Memorial Forest will serve as a living tribute, a symbol of resilience, and a sanctuary for reflection and solace for generations to come. This Green Sunday, with your generous support, we can make a long-lasting legacy for the Israeli victims who will never be forgotten.

HELP BRING THIS MEMORIAL FOREST TO LIFE

No donation is too small.

www.jnf.co.uk/gs2024 020 8732 6100

Donations from £100 will receive a special commemorative certificate.

Stay connected:

jnf.co.uk/subscribe

jnfuk

SCAN ME

@jnf uk

jnf uk

Registered Charity Number 225910

TO DONATE

8 NEWS

TO ADVERTISE CALL 020 3906 8488

1.4m march against AfD BY ADAM MOSES

An estimated 1.4million people marched against the far-right Alternative for Germany Party in nationwide protests last weekend. Organisers Campact and Fridays for Future said protests took place across 100 towns and cities to send a “signal against the AfD”. The backlash has seen reports this week of a possible political debate to ban the far-right AfD Party. Berlin saw 100,000 people in the city centre last Sunday. In Dresden, authorities changed the route of a march due to the “enormous number of participants”, police said on X. Some 70,000 people attended while in Bremen, police said 45,000 people participated. There were also large numbers in Cologne, Dresden, Leipzig, Bonn, Hamburg, Frankfurt, Hanover, Dortmund and Nuremberg. Signs sent a clear message including ‘Fascism isn’t an alternative’, ‘Voting AfD is 1933’, ‘no place for Nazis’ and ‘Nazis out’. The demonstrations followed a report from news outlet Correctiv revealing that AfD members met far-rigth extremists last November in Potsdam. Discussions included the possibility of expulsion of immigrants and non-assimilated citizens.

25 JANUARY 2024

AfD confirmed its presence noting its proposals for remigration did not involve ‘naturalised’ German citizens. According to reports, Austrian far-right member Martin Sellner, who is not an AfD member, was attributed to the comments at the meeting. But the meeting has caused outrage across German politics. Josef Schuster, Central Council of Jews in Germany, told broadcaster Welt TV the protests restored trust in “democratic

conduct” as Jews had felt “huge uncertainty” due to a surge in antisemitic incidents during the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza. Chancellor Olaf Scholz, attended a demonstration stating that plans to expel immigrants or citizens was an attack against democracy. Scholz called on protesters to take a stand for cohesion, tolerance and a democratic Germany. Interior Minister Nancy Faeser likened the situation to the “horrible Wannsee conference” where Nazis planned the extermination of European Jews in 1942. Politicians, church leaders and Bundesliga football managers called on people to stand Interior Minister Nancy Faeser PHOTO: WIKIPEDIA against the far right. Across Europe demonstrathe march sent the strongest message that tions continue. After London, where huge unity and understanding are our strongest numbers turned out last week, allies against prejudice. Manchester took centre stage on Sunday “Israel is not alone, the Jewish people are with around 6,000 attending a rally. not alone”, he said. The Jewish Representative Council of The Chief Rabbi thanked King Charles Greater Manchester organised and the and politicians for showing solidarity with rally. Politicians and community leaders the Jewish people. across different faiths attended. PHOTO: GETTY IMAGES Chief Rabbi Sir Ephraim Mirvis said

Chancellor Olaf Scholz

Aliyah: Building Dreams & Saving Tax ✓ Tax efficient investing before and after Aliyah ✓ 10 years tax free income ✓ 10 years tax free gains

✓ No inheritance tax ✓ Receive your entire pension pot tax free ✓ Specialist portfolio management for Olim

• The leading provider of Aliyah financial planning for 20 years • Helped thousands of UK Olim • To maximise the generous tax advantages and investment opportunities, contact our specialist team. 020 8202 1944 GoldersGreen@RaymondJames.com GoldersGreen.RaymondJames.UK.com

230 Golders Green Road London NW11 9AT

With investing, your capital is at risk. Raymond James Investment Services Ltd is a member of the London Stock Exchange and is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales number 3669657. Registered office: Ropemaker Place, 25 Ropemaker St, London EC2Y 9LY.

THEJEWISHWEEKLY.COM

10 NEWS

TO ADVERTISE CALL 020 3906 8488

25 JANUARY 2024

Goldschmidt scoops Charlemagne prize

BY DAVID SAFFER

Chief Rabbi Pinchas Goldschmidt and Jewish communities in Europe have been awarded the prestigious 65th International Charlemagne Prize in Aachen, Germany. The Conference of European Rabbis President received the accolade in recognition of his ‘outstanding efforts to promote peace, the right of all peoples to self-determination, European values, tolerance, pluralism and understanding and in acknowledgement of his significant commitment to interreligious and intercultural dialogue’, according to the citation. The Charlemagne Prize Board of Directors noted Jewish life is a “natural part of Europe” and there was “no place for antisemitism in Europe”. “Jewish life is an essential part of Europe’s past, its present and its future,” they observed in a statement. The Board recalled a quote from former Vice-President of the European Commission, Frans Timmermans, who stated: “Any attack on a Jew is an attack on everything that Europe prides itself in. The way we treat Jews and other minorities is like a litmus test for the state of health of our open European society.” The Board added: “Every form of antisemitism, every attack, every denigration and, above all, every act of violence, is an attack on us all. An attack on our liberal, democratic and pluralistic order, on our coexistence in a Europe that strives to attain its unity precisely by embracing, respecting and, as a matter of course, practising its diversity. A Europe that, wherever minorities are under threat, must visibly demonstrate its attitude, its responsibility and its solidarity.” The Board continued: “We live in a pluralistic, and increasingly secularised, society. But our united Europe is not value-neutral. It is only where the dignity and the diversity of individuals are respected that peaceful coexistence, one characterised by tolerance, understanding and humanity, is possible.”

The Board said Goldschmidt made three decisive points clear that ‘people of the most diverse religious and cultural backgrounds must find their place in Europe, intercultural dialogue is one of the great challenges of our time and European values are not negotiable.’ “The European way of life, characterised by democracy, freedom and the rule of law, is not up for discussion,” they added. In terms of Goldschmidt’s achievements, the citation noted he ‘provides reports on the state of the Jewish community, discusses the threats of antisemitism and cam-

to preserve religious freedom and religious peace, intensify dialogue and improve mutual understanding between Europe’s approximately 1.5 million Jews and over 40 million Muslims. “We work with Imams on combating threats to religious freedom,” Goldschmidt has stated. “Even on national levels, we support these talks even though it isn’t always easy. But we believe it’s extremely important. Because Jews are not only in danger from the far-right, but also from radical religious Muslims. So that makes dialogue with Muslim leaders really important.”

paigns against the restriction of religious life in Europe.’ They added: ‘As a representative of one of the oldest religious minorities in Europe, he has made it his goal to ‘help put an end to this burgeoning antagonism and conflict, which, in the years to come, could prove to be the greatest threat ever to the unity and security of Europe.’ Goldschmidt’s commitment to interreligious dialogue, the Board continued, is held in high esteem. He co-founded the European Muslim-Jewish Leadership Council and aims

The Jewish-Christian dialogue has been given ‘impetus’, noted the Board from the CER. They observed: “The document ‘Between Jerusalem and Rome’ has been available since 2016 and is, so to speak, a Jewish response to the ‘Nostra Aetate’ declaration adopted by the Second Vatican Council in 1965, a milestone in Jewish-Christian relations. ‘We are presently experiencing a fruitful moment of dialogue,’ declared Pope Francis when he welcomed a delegation of European, American and Israeli rabbis

at the Vatican in August 2017. Chief Rabbi Goldschmidt said it was a “catalyst for increased cooperation in the future”. Following his meeting with the Pope, in November 2023, he noted: “We (the CER) are for peace. We believe in the right of all peoples to self-determination. We hope that the civilian population suffers as little as possible from this (Gaza) war. We pray for them and we hope that peace will return to the Middle East, to the Holy Land and to Europe.” He added: “Gaza will become a free democratic country that does not pose a threat to Israel, but guarantees security and a life in peace for its citizens. Or Gaza must be administered by a Palestinian leader who is supported by a community of Arab states.” Regarding Europe, Chief Rabbi Goldschmidt was asked by the newspaper Judische Allgemeine, whether Judaism had a future in Europe. He responded: “If we look at Russia, I have my doubts. The more authoritarian that country becomes, the fewer Jews will remain there. As far as Ukraine is concerned, if there is a Marshall Plan to rebuild everything after the end of the war, I definitely see a chance that Jewish life will flourish there again. And as far as the EU countries are concerned, a lot depends on whether extreme parties come to power and whether Europe will remain an area that can guarantee freedom, security and diversity for Jews, too.” The Board, in its conclusion, noted it was honouring an “outstanding representative of European Judaism and Jewish life in Europe”. Chief Rabbi Goldschmidt was Chief Rabbi of Moscow from 1993 until 2022, serving Moscow Choral Synagogue. He founded and has headed the Moscow Rabbinical Court of the Commonwealth of Independent States since 1989. Rabbi Goldschmidt has served as president of the CER since 2011.

EJC welcome Musicant comments BY HARRY SIMONS

The European Jewish Congress has welcomed the European Parliament conditioning a ceasefire agreement between Israel and Hamas on the unconditional release of all hostages held in Gaza. The resolution, which passed in a plenary session in Strasbourg last Thursday, conditions an end to hostilities with ‘full dismantlement’ of Hamas in the Gaza Strip. EJC President Ariel Musicant said the vote was a “resounding acceptance” the conflict emanated from the “brutal murders and abductions” committed by Hamas on Israel on October 7. Hamas’ dismantlement was an “obvious condition’” for future peace and security of people in the region, he noted, adding, “This is a strong and resolute statement

by the Parliament representing Europe’s democracies. It further asserts strong condemnation of those countries arming, financing and providing political support to terror and clearly recognises the inalienable right of Israel to defend its territory and its citizens.” The EJC also welcomed a Council of the European Union decision to place Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar on a list of ‘sanctioned’ individuals. Sinwar’s assets are frozen in European Union states. The list includes Hamas military leaders, Mohammed Deif and Marwan Issa. “The move is welcome, correct and logical,” Muzicant said. “Hamas is a terror organisation, there is no difference whatsoever between its so-called military and political wings and it should stand to reason

that all its leaders should automatically of Qatar and Turkey. Europe must show no appear on sanctions lists of the EU and its tolerance to terrorism anywhere.” member states. The tragedy is that it took the massacre of October 7 for this recognition of the need to sanction Sinwar. It should now be evident to all who Hamas is and who its leaders are. A terror organisation committed to the wiping out of Israel and the slaughter of Jews.” He added: “We call on the European Union to automatically extend this sanctions list to all senior political and military leaders of Hamas, whether those directly involved in the terror campaign in Gaza or those nestled up in the hotels Dr Ariel Muzicant

THEJEWISHWEEKLY.COM

Who else wants to save money on their health insurance?

After a couple of years of mediocre service from other brokers, I tried Lifepoint. They were extremely attentive and supportive of our company’s needs. They saved us over £60K! Their care didn’t end with the deal. The whole team continues to support the company and employees directive with quick, kind service. Can’t recommend more!

Call now for your free consultation!

020 3348 9868 www.lifepointhealthcare.co.uk

info@lifepointhealthcare.co.uk Please use the code 81 when you get in touch! Lifepoint Healthcare Ltd, is Authorised and Regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), under firm reference number 843831

THE UNTHINKABLE HAS HAPPENED AGAIN 1939

2023

NEVER AGAIN IS NOW! 36 HOURS

www.charityextra.com/yvuk

BELIEVE IN YOUR BUSINESS?

JTRADE 2024 LIKE IT’S NEVER BEEN BEFORE. Calling all B2B leaders and ambitious entrepreneurs, for a one-day-only business exhibition at our new, central location. Meet thousands of potential clients, network with industry leaders and break into new markets. Go to

www.jtrade.co.uk

Alexandra Palace, London

14 NEWS

TO ADVERTISE CALL 020 3906 8488

25 JANUARY 2024

Ancient Judean Hills coin discovered BY HARRY MOSES

Evidence of the earliest use of coins dating to the Persian period was recently discovered in an Israel Antiquities Authority excavation in the Judean Hills. A 2,550-year-old silver coin was among the finds with a sheqel weight from the First Temple Period exposed during infrastructure works by the Netivei Israel National Transport Infrastructure Company. The coin minted with a square stamp on one face was discovered by Semyon Gendler, Acting Judean District Archaeologist of the IAA.

D r. R o b e r t Kool, IAA Numismatic Department head said: “The coin is extremely rare, joining only half a dozen coins of its type that have been found in archaeological excavations in the country. The coin was minted in a period when the use of coins had just begun. The rare find contributes information concerning the way trade was carried out, and the process whereby global commerce moved from payment by weighing silver pieces, to the use of coins.” He added: “The coin belongs to a group of very early coins that were minted outside Israel, in the regions of ancient Greece, Cyprus and Turkey. In the 6th5th centuries BCE, such coins began to appear at sites in the land of Israel. Although the silver coin was minted as

a coin, it was found intentionally cut into two. This indicates that in the 4th century BCE, it was used as a weighed piece of silver, rather than as a coin, even though coins were current in this period.” Michal Mermelstein and Danny Benayoun, IAA excavation directors, said in a statement: “The site was situated in the rural area of the Kingdom of Judah, whose capital was in Jerusalem. It was first settled in the First Temple period, in the 7th century BCE (2,700 years ago), during the reigns of the kings of Judah, Hezekiah, Manasseh, Amon and Josiah, a peak

must accordingly respect the expert advice of those responsible for the safety of participants and spectators. In all the circumstances, CSA has decided that David should be relieved of the captaincy for the tournament. This is in the best interests of all the players, the SA U19 team, and David himself.” Reports followed of opposition political parties, Jewish community leaders and human rights commentators alleging political

interference. The furore has since grown with Jewish organisations around the world conveying its disdain. The Board of Deputies, Anti-Defamation League and Executive Council of Australian Jewry have called on the ICC to help reverse an unjust ruling against Teeger. The BoD’s CEO Michael Wegier, ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt and Executive Council of Australian Jewry CEO Peter

settlement period in the kingdom of Judah.” They added: A characteristic ‘four-room house’ was uncovered from this period, the sheqel weight, found on the floor of one of the rooms in the house, provides early evidence for trade. The dome-shaped stone weight would have been used for weighing metals, spices, and other expensive commodities. The sign on the weight was an ancient Egyptian (hieratic) abbreviation for the word sheqel, and the single incised stroke represents one sheqel. The weight weighs 11.07 g.” This was a standard weight in the in the markets according to archaeologists. Eli Escusido, IAA Director noted: “It is always surprising, how important findings are discovered in unexpected places. The tiny coins are a crucial source of information in archaeology. They provide us visual details, inscriptions, and dates. Through a tiny object like a coin, it becomes possible to trace human thought processes and observe that our economic habits have remained largely unchanged for thousands of years, only the technology has changed. In this context, it is interesting to consider future archaeological research in a world that has adopted electronic commerce.”

CSA blasted over Jewish cricketer BY DAVID SAFFER

Jewish organisations have called on the International Cricket Council to reverse a decision by the Cricket South Africa to take away the captaincy from U19 captain David Teeger ahead of the Cricket World Cup. The tournament, hosted by South Africa, started last Friday, and runs until February 11. The hosts played their opening game against England earlier this week. Teeger was removed as skipper the day Israel defended itself on a ‘genocide case’ at the International Court of Justice in the Hague earlier this month. CSA’s stance followed the annual Jewish Achievers Awards when Teeger dedicated his Rising Star Award to the State of Israel and its soldiers”. Following an investigation by CSA after a complaint a judge ruled Teeger had not brought the association into disrepute. The judge reportedly noted: “He was a young Jewish man speaking to his fellow Jews. It was clear from his comments that he did not purport to speak for cricket, cricketers generally, or indeed anybody else.” But CSA acted, stating the decision followed advice of possible protests about the Gaza War at venues, a focus on Teeger and a risk of violence between rival protestors. CSA noted in a statement Teeger would remain an important and active member of the squad. CSA added: “CSA has a primary duty to safeguard the interests and safety of all those involved in the World Cup and

THEJEWISHWEEKLY.COM

Wertheim have written to ICC CEO Geoff Allardice stating it is “highly likely” CSA’s action breaches the ICC Code of Conduct in anti-Jewish discrimination. They observed: ‘If CSA’s decision were based solely on security concerns, the manner in which CSA balanced security interests with non-discrimination interests demonstrates CSA’s complete indifference to discrimination against the Jewish U19 captain. CSA’s statement gives no indication that enhanced security measures were even considered in order to protect Mr. Teeger’s ability to participate in the tournament among potentially hostile fans. As you know, tournament hosts and local law enforcement have a variety of security measures to address demonstrations and potential violence. To get to the truth of this matter, we respectfully urge you to demand a copy of the CSA security advice and to review it against ICC’s Tournament Safety Planning Framework to assess whether CSA’s action was legitimate or illegitimate. We also ask that your assessment be made public through an ICC statement.’ The statement added: ‘CSA’s decision makes no sense from a security point of view. It makes perfect sense as an act of discrimination. Israel may be unpopular in South Africa, but the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance definition of antisemitism includes the example of holding non-Israeli Jews responsible for the actions of the State of Israel.’ The Teeger affair is set to continue against the backdrop of the competition.

16 COMMUNITY

JNF UK’s Green Sunday Campaign: A Poignant Tribute to October 7 Victims In a solemn response to the tragic events of October 7, JNF UK, is proud to unveil its Green Sunday campaign, historically launched around Tu B’Shvat. This initiative seeks to create a profound and enduring tribute by establishing a memorial forest to commemorate those who were tragically murdered on that fateful day. For decades, JNF UK has been a beacon of support for Israel’s development, particularly in the Negev. The organisation has played a vital role in building and strengthening new and existing communities, helping them to grow and thrive. Since October 7, JNF UK has stood side by side with the affected communities, offering unwavering support and swiftly delivering crucial assistance to those most impacted. JNF UK’s long-standing commitment to environmental projects inspired their Green Sunday campaign. This living tribute invites individuals to contribute in various ways—whether to the planting and maintenance of trees, the creation of walking trails, the construction of seating areas, or the building of a commemoration wall within the forest. The Memorial Forest is more than just a collection of trees; it is a heartfelt response to the thousands of lives lost in an attack

25 JANUARY 2024

TO ADVERTISE CALL 020 3906 8488

on our beloved homeland. It stands as a living testament to resilience, strength, and the unbreakable spirit of the Israeli people. The act of planting trees, deeply rooted in Jewish tradition, symbolises not only remembrance but a collective commitment to renewal and hope for a brighter future in Eretz Yisrael. Elan Gorji, JNF UK’s CEO, expressed, “This Green Sunday, we have an opportunity for everyone to unite and create a poignant living memorial. It will stand as a testament to the enduring strength and solidarity of the Israeli people, reminding us that even in the face of tragedy, hope can blossom anew. It sends a message that whilst our enemies seek to destroy us we are here to stay and this forest will be a legacy to those that were murdered for generations to come. “ Every contribution, regardless of its size, will be crucial in bringing this memorial forest to life. To find out more and contribute to the memorial forest, please visit www.jnf.co.uk/ gs2024.

COURT OF THE CHIEF RABBI BETH DIN, LONDON ‫בית דין צדק דק"ק לונדון והמדינה‬ Dayan M. Gelley, Rosh Beth Din Dayan I. Binstock Dayan S. Simons Dayan D.S. Englander Dayan E. Zobin

‫בס"ד‬

KASHRUT DIVISION – KLBD Rabbi E. Schoemann, Interim Director Rabbi J. D. Conway, Senior Adviser

KASHRUS NOTICE

This is to inform the public that as of Wednesday 24th January 2024, the restaurant La Fiesta, 235 Golders Green Road, will no longer be under the supervision of KLBD.

Kashrut Division, London Beth Din, 305 Ballards Lane, London N12 8GB, United Kingdom Tel: +44 (0)20 8343 6251 Email: info@kosher.org.uk Web: www.kosher.org.uk

Holocaust Memorial Day at Jewish Care Jewish Care is holding Holocaust Memorial Day commemorations across Jewish Care in our care homes, Retirement Living and community centres. At Jewish Care’s Holocaust Survivors’ Centre members lit memorial candles and held a Holocaust Memorial Day commemoration service followed by a lunch and heard words of comfort and hope from Rabbi Junik, Jewish Care’s Pastoral and Spiritual Lead. Members, accompanied by volunteers and Jewish Care staff also attended the HMD event in Central London and on Thursday held a tea with music to give the opportunity for the survivors, volunteers and staff to be together at the Centre. Holocaust survivor, Susan Pollack, MBE who was in a slave labour camp and then was liberated from Bergen-Belsen, later discovering that her brother Laci, was the only member of her family to have survived. After lighting a candle at the Holocaust Survivors’ Centre, she said, “I light a candle for my family and for those who have lost so many and for who we grieve. We have come a long way to survive the Holocaust and what we want peace and for people to talk to one another.” At Jewish Care’s Betty and Asher Loftus Centre in Friern Barnet, there was a screening of the Survivor’s Testimony of former resident Toby Biber z’l, who sadly passed away at Jewish Care’s Stella and Harry

Freedman House on 2nd December 2023. The film was made in 1995 when Toby was 70. The interviewer ( and narrator), Bernice Krantz joined the screening to present the film on behalf of the Stephen Spielberg “Stories of the Shoah Visual History” Foundation, which was set up with the proceeds from Spielberg’s film, “Schindler’s List” , and with the mission to record testimonies of all Holocaust survivors. Residents will be marking HMD across the homes with candles. Rabbi Junik, Jewish Care’s Pastoral & Spiritual Lead, said, “I want to pause and reflect about the effects of the Holocaust and the men, women and children who lost their lives and also to talk about the amazing men and women who survived, and are with us today.

“The Holocaust didn’t begin with violence. Hatred begins with speech. It’s a blessing that we can express our culture in this country, but that’s not something we can ever take for granted. We continue to say

never again, and while we see suffering, racism and bigotry we should not be silent. We remember and we should be encouraged to change the world around us and to change the future.”

MANCHESTER COMMUNITY STANDS UNITED AROUND 6,500 TURNED OUT ON SUNDAY FOR THE MARCH AGAINST ANTISEMITISM STARTING OUTSIDE MANCHESTER CATHEDRAL, DOWN DEANSGATE TO CASTLEFIELD BOWL. SPEAKERS INCLUDED LORD JOHN MANN AND MARK ADDLESTONE.

PHOTO: LAWRENCE PURCELL

THEJEWISHWEEKLY.COM

PHOTO: LAWRENCE PURCELL

25 JANUARY 2024

TO ADVERTISE CALL 020 3906 8488

Beyond the Headlines A weekly glimpse into the Israel you won’t read about in the news

INVITATION TO THE KOTEL These days, when there is so much advice going around on how to cope, here’s another suggestion: Come to the Kotel. Just come. Last week, I witnessed the profound impact of visiting the “Wall.” Every week, I connect with hundreds of women via Zoom for a study session. Last week, though, we gathered in person at the Kotel. For many, it was their first visit since the onset of the war. One woman from Kiryat Shmona expressed her feelings: “How could it be that I haven’t come until now? I feel incredibly strengthened!” Shortly before we arrived, soldiers from the Golani Brigade, stationed at Har Dov on the northern border, came to pray and give thanks. They were joined by soldiers from the Shura army base and Zaka volunteers, who had endured harrowing days and nights identifying bodies of the fallen. A couple of weeks earlier, on the eve of Rosh Chodesh, a massive gathering of 50,000 people assembled here to pray for the safety and release of the hostages. Nearly every day, a new group arrives — survivors of the Nova festival, evacuees from the south and the north, wives of reservists, and just everyday Israelis. During our visit, a woman from Spain approached Racheli Hadad, the supervisor of tours at the Kotel, and myself. A Jewish woman, feeling a deep need to be at the Kotel during these times, had simply purchased a plane ticket and came. Soli Eliav, director of the Western Wall Heritage Foundation, shared a touching story. Recently, five youths who were suffering from trauma, accompanied by their mentor, found comfort for the first time in the presence of the Kotel’s ancient stones. “There’s something in Jerusalem that soothes and heals,” he observed. “It connects us to the essence of our current actions and all that is unfolding around us. It’s no coincidence that so many chapters of Tehilim describe the pilgrimage to Yerushalayim. Like the pilgrims of old, may we too ascend to Jerusalem with great joy.”

special occasions. The Yarchi family from Talmon found a unique way to celebrate their son Amitai’s bar mitzvah by sharing it with a displaced family from the Gaza periphery. Shira Yarchi, Amitai’s mother, shared her thoughts: “As Amitai approached his bar mitzvah, we wanted to imbue the event with a deeper sense of meaning, connection, and unity. We reached out to a family from the Gaza-border community of Kibbutz Magen, which had been evacuated to a Dead Sea hotel and who were also celebrating a bar mitzvah. This led to a joint celebration. “During a visit to the Dead Sea, we PHOTO: SIVANRAHAVMEIR.COM met the Levin family, including their son, Yuval. Our families instantly connected and formed a bond. The following Friday, both boys, Amitai and Yuval, attended my father’s shul in Ra’anana, where they donned tefillin together, marking a significant milestone in their lives.” Yuval’s mother, Maayan, added her perspective: “Ever since the war began, we’ve been displaced from our home. Organizing Yuval’s bar mitzvah was bittersweet. But when the Yarchis proposed a joint celebration, it was a gesture that touched our hearts. The boys have so much in common, and celebrating together, especially the moment they put on tefillin, brought an added layer of significance to the entire event.” Mazal tov, Amitai and Yuval. Your first mitzvah was performed together, in a special partnership. Welcome, as men, to Am Yisrael!

CELEBRATING IN TRYING TIMES In these uncertain and difficult times, many grapple with how to joyously mark

PHOTO: SIVANRAHAVMEIR.COM

VOICE OF COURAGE FROM THE REHAB WARD During a recent visit to the rehabilitation department at Sheba Medical Centre near Tel Aviv, I encountered profoundly inspiring individuals. Amichai Shindler, who lost both hands while rescuing Kibbutz Kerem Shalom from the terrorists, expressed his optimism with a smile: “I am waiting to get prosthetics for my hands so that I can hug my children.” Yehonatan Ben Hamo, who lost his leg to an RPG missile in Gaza, shared his philosophy: “You know the saying, ‘I came to give strength and left strengthened’? That’s my goal for everyone who visits me. I aim to empower them. My role extends to offering support and reassurance to all the newly injured people who arrive here.” These statements embody the remarkable spirit prevalent among the wounded and their families. Despite enduring significant challenges and pain, they radiate hope, a zest for life, and even humor.

FROM THE DUNGEONS OF THE KGB TO TUNNELS OF HAMAS I had the privilege this week of speaking with Natan Sharansky, a prominent figure who endured nine years in a Russian prison due to his opposition to the Soviet regime and his active advocacy for emigration rights, particularly for Jews seeking to make Aliyah. Earlier, Yaron Or, father of Avinatan Or, currently held hostage in Gaza, had shared his thoughts in a media interview, saying, “These days, my mind often turns to my son and to Sharansky, from whom I draw considerable strength.” Moved by those words, Sharansky reached out to Yaron, offering words of solidarity and resilience: “When I was in prison, I derived strength from many sources, first and foremost, my wife Avital. I felt her presence even though we never met during that period. Am Yisrael was also a source of great strength; knowing that people were praying for me helped me hold on. “I always kept with me a copy of Tehillim, written by David Hamelech, and that, too, gave me strength. I felt as if David Hamelech’s words were directed specifically to me and my distress. “After enduring many years in confinement, the realization dawned on me that it wasn’t just David Hamelech who empowered me; I was empowering him! The previous generations were observing my

THEJEWISHWEEKLY.COM

COMMUNITY 17

struggle and I was upholding their legacy. I couldn’t let them down. I was connected to our glorious past and to the promise of our even more glorious future; I was part of our magnificent story! This held true as a prisoner of Zion in Russia and it resonates just as strongly regarding the hostages currently held captive in tunnels in Gaza. We are all small yet significant parts of a grand and enduring story.”

GREETINGS FROM NEW JERSEY We recently spent Shabbat in Tenafly, New Jersey, together with the local Israeli community. Just minutes before Shabbat, we were joined by Ran and Orly Gilboa, parents of Daniela Gilboa, who is being held hostage by Hamas. They had just arrived from significant meetings in

PHOTO: SIVANRAHAVMEIR.COM

Washington. Suddenly, the name “Daniela bat Orly” – one of the Israeli hostages I’ve been praying for – took on a deeper, more immediate meaning. At the Shabbat meal, which drew hundreds of participants, Rabbi Yitzhak Gorshevitz, the Chabad shaliach of Tenafly, invited everyone to dedicate the “Eshet Chayil” zemer to Daniela, as a prayer for her swift return. “Eshet Chayil” or “A Woman of Valor,” is a chapter from Mishlei traditionally sung every Shabbat. It is an ode to the mother, the wife, and the women of the nation, verse by verse, in the order of the aleph-bet. On this occasion, the Rabbi urged us to direct this heartfelt song towards Daniela, sending these powerful words from New Jersey all the way to Gaza: “A woman of valor, who can find... Her candle burns throughout the night… Strength and dignity are her clothing… Let us praise her for her achievements…” This marked the start of a profoundly meaningful and stirring Shabbat. In a conversation with Orly, I asked her what was the source of her strength during these difficult times. She shared that it was precisely these acts of solidarity and mutual responsibility from around the globe, prayers and good deeds from people who are strangers, yet deeply connected on the soul level, that provided her with the fortitude to endure each day.

18 OPINION

TO ADVERTISE CALL 020 3906 8488

Never Again!!! OPINION PIECE BY RABBI DR SAMUEL D. LANDAU AND PROFESSOR LESLIE M. GUTMAN

The phrase, “Nie Wieder” or “Never Again” was a slogan first used by liberated prisoners from Buchenwald concentration camp. They wrote these words on handmade signs in numerous languages and displayed them on the barbed wire fences of the place that had just been their hell on earth. It was a call to the world to never again descend into such darkness. Jews are familiar with the cycle of destruction and rebuilding across the millennia. In ancient times, it began with slavery in Egypt followed a few centuries later with exile, first at the hands of the Babylonians and then the Romans. Across subsequent history, Jews were attacked by Greek assimilators, Catholic crusaders, York murderers, Spanish Inquisitors, Russian pogroms, Arab-land expulsions and the (seeming) “grand-finale”; the so-called final solution to the Jewish “problem” – the systematic annihilation of six million by the Nazis and their collaborators. Growing up in the shadow of the Holocaust, Jews believed that the cycles of collective trauma and the need for collective resilience were a thing of yesteryear. Perhaps we naively thought that such hatred could not be repeated. We were shockingly wrong. Whilst Oct 7th was nowhere near the scale of Nazi activity, it was aligned in purpose and execution. In the wake of Hamas’ brutal attacks, antisemitism has surged across the world, from university campuses to the streets of major cities. This year, Holocaust Memorial Day is no longer remembering the horrors of the past alone, it is reflecting a terror of today. Old wounds have been opened again. Oct 7th marks another cycle of collective trauma, which refers to the psychological distress that an entire group of people

experience in response to a shared tragedy. Just as individuals must process trauma in ways that foster their recovery, so too must groups work together to build collective resilience in the face of a collective trauma. Collective resilience is an iterative process. Over time, collective trauma becomes collective memory, involving an ongoing reconstruction of the event to understand its meaning for future generations. The meaning that is made from collective

Benny Newton’s badge from Buchenwald concentration camp, torn off his clothing and given to his grandson, Samuel Landau (co-author of this article).

trauma becomes a core identity marker for the group and thereby a processing tool for interpreting, contextualising and understanding future threats. In this way, the Holocaust is a lens that enables an understanding of the Jewish response to Oct 7th. Terrorism by design undermines a society’s structures and cohesion. In this sense, the brutal and barbaric acts of Oct 7th were intentionally committed to create strife and division. Horrific attacks were perpetuated against Jews, Muslims, Christians, Druze, Bedouin and Thais, all for merely living in Israel. Despite terrorism’s divisive intentions, when its victimisation is shared across group boundaries, it can reinforce the sense that “we are all in this

of the Oct 7th terrorist attacks and Israel-Hamas war. Moreover, the focus on victimhood as a dominant form of identity politics can foster a climate of competitive victimhood reinforcing and perpetuating conflict-defined divisions. The rejection of simplistic conflict narratives and one-sided blame and the promotion of proactive “we-thinking” can build bridges. Seeing the “other” as part of the “we” is an important process in collective resilience and a potential first step towards the pursuit of peace. The first ever Jewish national trauma was the enslavement and infanticide of the Israelites in ancient Egypt. Jews retell that story on an annual basis with symbols of

nothing they can do but I am certain the reality is that they just don’t want to do anything. Maybe it is because they think the hate marchers might turn violent, or because they don’t want to be seen to arresting people who are not white or maybe they just agree with the premise of the organisers; that Israel is a racist state and needs to be dismantled. Frankly I don’t believe for a moment it is the last of these. I do believe though that the police are the don’t want to do anything because they are frightened of the outcome. Imagine the response from the loud left if 250 of worst Jew-haters were arrested. The cries of racism would echo around the country leaving the Metropolitan Police Commissioner being forced to apologise for upholding the law. That assumes that the arrests would take place without any violence, which in turn would

lead to claims of police brutality. Much better then to put up the Jews complaining since when push comes to shove, Jews don’t riot or throw bricks at police officers. Much easier to fail to protect them, no real downside. Head north then, where the story is very different. Last Sunday, 21 January, 6,500 people turned out in solidarity with Israel. In what has been reported as the largest turnout in Manchester ever in support of Israel, communal leaders and politicians spoke in support of Israel and the Jewish community. The support from the Greater Manchester police was apparent to see and really welcome. The protection of a minority doesn’t just depend upon the appropriate legislation being in place. It also requires the authorities to exercise their powers to ensure that the protection is real. In London, sadly,

A tale of two cities OPINION PIECE BY ROBERT FESTENSTEIN

London and Manchester. For reasons which have already been explored, for Jews, central London is a no-go zone. When the anti-Israel/anti-Jew marches take place, pretending to support the Palestinians, London Jews stay at home. Where is the purpose in going into central London when there are hundreds of thousands of people calling for a ceasefire so as to let Hamas continue to exist and consequently kill Jews. None. It’s not as if the police cannot see what is happening. They can see this very clearly and they are just as clearly doing nothing to prevent, week after week, these hateful marches. The police claim that there is

together” and solidify collective empowerment. Indeed, some polling suggests there has been increased solidarity across diverse groups in Israel. How can we move forward from Oct 7th? In contrast to disaster myths of widespread panic and helplessness, collective violence can bring about cohesion, peace and ultimately reconciliation. This involves going beyond the “us versus them” narrative that constitutes much of the media reporting

THEJEWISHWEEKLY.COM

25 JANUARY 2024

collective memory to give new generations the strength to overcome adversity. Nevertheless, within this evening of Passover memory the demise of the Egyptians is not celebrated. On the contrary, Jews spill their wine in mourning at the loss of Egyptian life. Suffering is not a zero-sum game; there is only sadness. As the late Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks said, “I wonder if anyone who has known the depths of Jewish suffering through the ages can understand how deeply the desire for peace is etched in the heart of almost every Jew.” Whilst the narratives explored in this article are distinctly Jewish, they apply equally to all that suffer. Holocaust Memorial Day teaches universal lessons of the effects of collective trauma and the adaptive responses of collective memory and resilience. If both sides of the conflict in Israel and Gaza can recognise their shared collective processes, and in so doing see their shared humanity, perhaps this time, “Never Again” can really be never again. Samuel D. Landau is a clinical psychologist and community Rabbi. He is the founding director of Someone Else’s Eyes, an organisational culture change company that supports the British Army and UK Police Forces, amongst others. He is currently undertaking a PhD at UCL researching group-based interventions to improve organisational cultures. Leslie Morrison Gutman has a PhD from University of Michigan-Ann Arbor. She is Programme Director of the MSc Behaviour and Professor of Applied Developmental and Health Psychology at UCL. Her research examines mental health; risk and resilience; and intervention development, implementation and evaluation, with an interest in diversity and inclusion. Her book is entitled, ‘Resilience: A Jewish Guide to Facing Adversity, Fostering Strength and Living Your Best Life’ (Mosaica Press).

those powers are not being used and the result is there for all to see. It is reassuring though to know that where there is a will, in Manchester at least, the Jews can feel safe in the knowledge that the police are prepared to do their job. We need now to put as much pressure as possible ensure that the Metropolitan Police do the same.

Robert Festenstein is a practising solicitor and has been the principal of his Salford based firm for over 20 years. He has fought BDS motions to the Court of Appeal and is President of the Zionist Central Council in Manchester which serves to protect and defend the democratic State of Israel.

25 JANUARY 2024

TO ADVERTISE CALL 020 3906 8488

OPINION 19

NJA Hails Commons’ Approval NJA Condemns Kings College of Legislation Against Public Terrorism Course for Biased Body Boycotts Content The National Jewish Assembly (NJA) celebrates a significant milestone in the fight against discrimination with the recent approval of legislation in the House of Commons. The proposed changes, outlined in the Economic Activity of Public Bodies (Overseas Matters) Bill, aim to prevent public bodies, including councils, from boycotting goods or services from any country, except those specifically exempted by ministers. In a vote last Wednesday evening, Members of Parliament voted 282 to 235 in favour of giving the Bill a third reading, demonstrating strong support for the measure. The NJA commends this decision as a crucial step in combating discriminatory practices and promoting fair and unbiased economic relations. One particularly commendable aspect of this legislation is the fact that ministers will not have the authority to exempt Israel, the occupied Palestinian territories, or the Golan Heights from its provisions. This ensures that the principles of non-discrimination apply equally to all nations. The NJA acknowledges that the road to passing this legislation was not without its challenges. The Government faced opposition from various quarters, including within

its own ranks. However, it is heartening to see that the importance of preventing public bodies from implementing their own boycotts against Israeli goods prevailed in the end. Communities Secretary Michael Gove rightly pointed out that the Bill provides a targeted and proportionate approach to address divisive and discriminatory campaigns like the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement. By preventing public bodies from taking decisions that conflict with UK Government foreign policy, the Bill ensures that a unified and consistent approach is maintained. The NJA extends its gratitude to all those who supported and voted for this legislation, recognising that it aligns with the values of fairness, non-discrimination, and equality. We believe that this legislative victory will contribute to fostering a more inclusive and just society, where economic decisions are made based on merit and not influenced by discriminatory biases. The NJA looks forward to the next stages of the legislative process and remain committed to advocating for policies that promote these values in the United Kingdom and beyond.

The National Jewish Assembly (NJA) expresses deep concern and disappointment over the revelations concerning the “Issues in Countering Terrorism” course offered at Kings College, London. According to a report published by the pro-Israel advocacy group Britain Israel Communications and Research Centre, the course content has raised serious questions about its objectivity and impartiality. The report, authored by Anna Stanley, a former civil servant who attended the course, sheds light on disturbing aspects of the curriculum. The NJA is alarmed that a prestigious institution like Kings College would offer a course that appears to promote biased perspectives and mischaracterisations. One of the most troubling aspects highlighted in the report is the repeated reference to Israel as a prime example in discussions about whether a state can commit acts of terrorism. The NJA firmly believes that using Israel in this context is both inappropriate and unbalanced. Such insinuations can contribute to a distorted view of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and unfairly label Israel as a “terrorist state.” Furthermore, the report suggests that some participants in the course questioned the

THEJEWISHWEEKLY.COM

focus on Islamist extremism within the UK’s counter-terrorism strategy, claiming it made Muslims feel uncomfortable. The NJA believes that addressing extremism and terrorism should not be hindered by misguided concerns about political correctness. It is concerning to see that the course materials imply that condemning terrorism is equivalent to endorsing the power of the strong over the weak. This perspective undermines the very essence of counter-terrorism efforts and fails to recognise the importance of addressing acts of violence and terror. The NJA calls on Kings College to review and address these issues promptly. It is essential that educational institutions maintain a commitment to impartiality, rigorous analysis, and balanced perspectives when teaching sensitive subjects like terrorism. The NJA believes that fostering an environment of open dialogue and critical thinking is vital for the academic community. The NJA urges Kings College to take these concerns seriously and take appropriate actions to ensure that future courses on counter-terrorism are fair, objective, and free from bias.

20 GAMES

25 JANUARY 2024

TO ADVERTISE CALL 020 3906 8488

Games

Bridge With Harold Schogger

www.haroldschogger.com 0208 905 3877

Dealer: North ♠8 6 ♥Q 9 5 2 ♦ A 10 8 ♣A Q 9 8 ♠ K Q 10 9 4 3 ♥7 W ♦K 9 ♣ J 10 6 3

N E S

♠J 7 5 2 ♥ 10 3 ♦Q J 7 5 4 3 ♣4

2♠ Pass End 1

1♣ 3♥ 5♠3

Pass 4♠ Pass

1♥ 4NT2 6♥

1. WEAK 6-10

♠A 2. ROMAN KEY CARD BLACKWOOD ♥A K J 8 6 4 3. 2 KEY CARDS PLUS QUEEN OF TRUMP ♦6 2 Lead ♠K ♣K 7 5 2 This deal arose in a team game. West’s weak-jump overcall was brushed aside at both tables and the slam was reached via the Key-Card enquiry of 4NT. The five spade reply at both tables promised two Key-Cards and the queen of hearts. The king of spades, asking for count from partner , was led at both tables. Both East players signalled that they held an even number of spades. After taking the king of spades with his ace, the first declarer drew trumps with ace and king then cashed the ace and king of clubs. When West proved to hold four clubs he was down one. The declarer at the other table also took the ace and king of trumps at tricks two and three. However, this declarer saw that there was no rush to tackle clubs. Instead, he decided to gather some information about how the diamond suit lay. His first move in that direction was to play a low diamond from both hands. After ruffing the spade continuation in his hand, declarer led his remaining diamond to dummy’s ace and

HAROLD SCHOGGER’S BRIDGE 18 HIGHVIEW GARDENS, EDGWARE, MIDDLESEX, HA8 9UE TELEPHONE: 0208 905 3877 EMAIL: SCHOGGER@HAROLDSCHOGGER.COM WWW.HAROLDSCHOGGER.COM

AFTERNOON FREE TASTER ON MONDAY 15TH JANUARY 2024 AFTERNOON BEGINNERS COURSE STARTS MON 22ND JANUARY 2024 AFTERNOON INTERMEDIATE COURSE STARTS TUE 23RD JANUARY 2024 GUARANTEED SUCCESS PHONE 0208 905 3877 FOR MORE DETAILS ruffed dummy’s ten of diamonds in hand. After West discarded a spade on the third diamond, declarer had that hand counted as an original 6:1:2:4 shape. So, after he cashed the king of clubs he led a low club towards dummy. When West followed with the six of clubs declarer covered it with dummy’s nine with complete confidence that it would win the trick. So, declarer had his contract when, as expected, East discarded a diamond. Of course it would not have helped if West had played one of his honours on the second round of clubs. Declarer would win the trick in dummy, then return to his hand with a trump to take the proven finesse against West’s remaining club honour. Finally, if West followed to the three diamonds then he could have at most three clubs and so declarer would play the ace and queen of clubs next. Then if clubs were 3-2 (or West proved to have begun with a singleton jack or ten of clubs) the suit would play for four tricks and the contract would come home.

MISSED GIFTING OVER CHANUKAH? IT'S NOT TOO LATE! GIFT ISRAEL BONDS.

During this holiday season, join us in standing with Israel by giving meaningful gifts. Together, let's make a lasting impact.

See More here

israelbondsintl.com/chanukah-en

infoEN@israelbondsintl.com 020 3936 2712 Development Company for Israel (International) Ltd.

Your capital may be at risk.

This advertisement has been issued by the Development Company for Israel (International) Ltd., which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and registered in England No. 01415853. This is not an offering, which could only be made by prospectus. Your capital is at risk, the rules under FSMA for the protection of retail clients do not apply. An investment in any of these bonds will not be covered by the provisions of the Financial Services Compensation scheme, nor by any similar scheme. Israel bonds are intended as a long-term investment as they are not listed or admitted to dealing on any recognised investment or stock exchange nor is there any established secondary market, as a consequence Israel bonds are not readily realisable before their maturity date. DCI (International) Ltd is not the issuer of these bonds, they are issued by the State of Israel. 12-23

THEJEWISHWEEKLY.COM

Looking to live or invest in Israel?!

We’ve got you covered

FEB 4 TH | FREE TO JOIN | 30 + SESSIONS | COME & GO THROUGHOUT THE DAY! TIME

TO P I C

PRESENTER