Page 1

34567 5 ) 6>56

˚ıı)  ı   ( ˚• (˛H


34567

S`*3B 86 5<6 >>> S/*2bnaq 5=8 Y\,*YS

MAY 1, 2012

 ˚ wı " x ]\Wq-*2 , b\YdE k\+ ]`\aW*,WqbS \-*  -\,d qV 1`f\,Z\-\ `*,Sb1Wq a1a,TbdD \/T+Z\ qV 4 ,*`b\,Sf +*jb d /*,ZSZd +dW\ /\+`1 ,S/Z\E k\ ,T/+d,*2bnaq ,/*W1hSZTE Z* ab\`TZV*f gn\-\ 3d`Z*Wd ]`\ab13d2bnaq `\4,Sb\V a,Tb\,Sf ]\/Ty d a,TbWT +T+WTyZSf ]`\`\gb,D w*`b\,* +*jb*x ]\bTj*2 Wp/1y /\+`\p Z\,SZ\p ]`\ b1E k\ \31 *`ab,\ P ,ab*Z\,W1ZSy d Z1+T d`q/ P Z14*+*`\Y ]\VW*/1 V`*y dan\Yd 4Wd T ]1`1YTZSbn 41YWp  Z* `*yD *a\]Sa 4YTgZp2 ,T`d , ıada* `Sab*E qVSy ]\Y1`E k\+ YS Y\-WS \b`SY*bS ,ThZ1 3SbbqE T qVSy b1]1` ab\^bn Z* h\WT \3\-\ *`ab,*D ,T/VS -\,S +14]1`1`,Z\ ,S/*pbn g1y 3d`Z*W 4 5<;= `\VdD TZ 2 ]\WTbShZ\ Z1yb`*WnZSY  T š`dZbd2bnaq Z* T+WT^D     1 /Wq ]`\/*3dD S/*ZZq gT2^ ]d+WTV*gT^ 2 h*abSZ\p ,a1a,TbZn\^ ]`\-`*YS +T+WTyZ\^ \a,TbSE qV* ]T/b`SYd2bnaq /\+`\,TWnZSYS ]\31`b,*YSD `S gSbd,*ZZT ,`1yanVSf Sa*Zn ,SV\`Sab\,d2bnaq ]1`1VW*/ -T2ZV* L,S/*ZZq 6>>6 `\VdE ZdY1`*gTq a*WYT, 4-T/Z\ 4 ,S/*ZZqY 5==> `\VdME * `1gnVSf Sa*Zn P w`SabSqZanVT `1gnVT Sa*ZZqD 1`1VW*/ Z\,\-\ a,TbdxD ıZjT /31`1W* gSb*bB dWDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ dWTj*C  P w1`1VW*/ Z\,\-\ a,Tbd ,qb\-\ SanY*x L4 ]`SYTbV*YSE *Z-WDMC \YDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ \Y1ZV*D

 ı ı 7 \-\ Z*,h*, ıadaH 9 )V ıada ab*,S,aq /\ ]\WTbSVSH : `SabSqZS T ]\WTbSV* < )V f`SabSqZanVT ,h1ZZq ,]WS,*pbn Z* ada]TWnab,\H 5> `*,/S,T f`SabSqZS T a,T/\YT -`\Y*/qZS

  56

  1V`1bS k*aWS,\^ aTYG^D )V ,T/Z\,SbS /\,T`Gq

5:

 \-\ ,hSbn \31 W\,\D )V1 Y*y+dbZ2 `1WT-T^H

5<

T+WTq 4YTZp2 3Sbbq

66

Sb*hT 4*]SbdpbnD S `*ZZT f`SabSqZS +`*WS dh*abn d ]\WTbShZSf a]`*,*fH

67

S ,S 4Z*2b1H  hdaq 4 T+WT^

68 75

*+WS3*yY\an /\ \-*D TZ ,SZ*-\`\/3d2 bSfE fb\ y\Yd aWd3Sbn

 ˝  ˚ı 6:

*j1 Y*y+dbZ2 d ,*jSf `dV*f

6<

˝Sbbq d +T+WTyZT h*aSD TWnZSgb,\

76 w b1`13S a,\2 a1`g1Ix


*-*b\ ,T`dphSf Wp/1y ,,*3*2E k\ `1WT-Tq Z1 ]\,SZZ* ab\qbS \ab\`\Zn ]\WTbShZSf a]`*, T k\ ,\Z* Y\31 ,T/T-`*,*bS ,*3WS,d `\Wn d `\4,Gq4*ZZT ]`\+W1Y Wp/ab,*D `\b1 TZjT ,T`dphT ]1`1V\Z*ZTE k\ `1WT-Tq T ]\WTbSV* Z1 Y*pbn 4YTjd,*bSaqD  qV ,S ,,*3*2b1E hS ]\,SZZ* `1WT-Tq T ]\WTbSV* bTaZ\ a]T,]`*gp,*bSH

\-\ Z*,h*,

ıadaH   Z*4,*Z\ wZ*y,]WSO ,\,Tj\p ]\ab*bbp , `1WT-TyZTy Tab\`T^ Wp/ab,*xD #\ ,T/]\,T, +S ıadaE qV+S y\-\ Y\3Z* +dW\ 4*O ]Sb*bSB w S `1WT-Tq Y*2 ,b`dh*O bSaq , ]\WTbSVdHx \WS ıada +d, Z* 41YWTE ,TZ aW\,*YS T ,hSZV*YS ,Sq,S, a,Ty ]\-Wq/ Z* g1 ]Sb*ZO ZqD *]`SVW*/E d ,T/\YTy *-T`ZTy ]`\]\,T/T ,TZ /*, a,\^Y ]\aWT/\,O ZSV*Y ,V*4T,VSE qV ,\ZS ]\,SZO ZT ab*,SbSaq /\ a]`*, ada]TWnab,*D \4-WqZnY\ /1qVT /dYVS 4 gT2^ ]`\O ]\,T/TD

ı

 " Ë&#x2122; 5 ) 6>56

3


`SabSqZS T ada]TWnab,\ ıada ]\qaZS,E qV y\-\ ]\aWT/\,ZSVS Y*pbn ab*,SbSan /\ a,TbdB wS P aTWn 41YWTD )Vk\ 3 aTWn ,b`*bSbn a,\^ ,W*abSO ,\abTE b\ qV 4`\+SbS ^^ 4Z\,d a\W\Z\pH \Z* ,31 ZT /\ h\-\ Z1 ]`S/*bZ*E b\Yd ^^ ,SVS/*pbn -1bn T b\]hdbnD S P a,TbW\ /Wq a,TbdD LDDDM *j1 a,TbW\ Z1f*y a,TbSbn

ıada ]\qaZS,E k\ Z1 f\h1E *+S y\-\ ]\aWT/\,ZSVS ,T/\V`1YWp,*WSaq ,T/ ada]TWnab,*

]1`1/ Wp/nYSE k\+ ,\ZS +*hSWS ,*jT /\+`T ,hSZVS T ]`\aW*,WqWS ,*j\-\ Z1O +1aZ\-\ *bnV*x L*b,Tq 9B57P5:MD \Yd ıada ]`S`T,Zq, a,\^f ]\aWT/\,ZSVT, /\ a\WT b* a,TbW*H ıada Y*, Z* d,*4TE k\ ,\ZS ]\,SZZT +dO bS Z*h1 aTWn Z1 bTWnVS /Wq qV\^an Y*O W1ZnV\^ -`d]S Wp/1yE * /Wq gTW\-\ a,TbdD *V\3 ,\ZS 2 Z*h1 a,TbW\ Z1 /Wq \+Y131O Z\-\ V\W* Wp/1yE *W1 /Wq ,aTfE fb\ \f\h1 ]`SyY*2 g1 a,TbW\D Ë&#x203A;* /\]\Y\-\p b*VSf \+`*4ZSf ,SaW\,T, ıada ]\qaZS,E k\ Z1 f\h1E *+S y\-\ ]\aWT/\,ZSVS ,T/\V`1YO Wp,*WSaq ,T/ ada]TWnab,*D #\+ aTWn 4*]\+T-*W* ]ad,*ZZp ^3TE ^^ b`1+* /\/*bS /\ b\^ ^3TD ,TbSWnZSV Z1 Y\31 \a,TbSbS VTYZ*bdE qVk\ y\-\ bd/S Z1 ]\ab*,SbSD \3 Z1 /S,Z\E h\Yd ıada ZTV\WS Z1 Z*V*4d,*, a,\^Y dhZqY ,T/O \V`1YWp,*bSan ,T/ ada]TWnab,* T ab,\O

34567 S ,S f\bTWS + \b`SY*bS +TWnj1 TZe\`Y*gT^ *+\ k\+ 4 ,*YS ]`\,\/SW\aq +14V\jb\,Z1 /\O Y*jZ2 +T+WTyZ1 ,S,h1ZZqH `\aSY\ Z*/TaW*bS a,\2 ]`\f*ZZq ,T/V*Y -\,S Z* \/Zd 4 ]\/*O ZSf bdb */`1aD \,ZSy ]1`1WTV */`1a /S,Tbnaq Z* a*ybT www.watchtower.org/addressD

4

`p,*bS T4\Wn\,*ZT ]\a1W1ZZq ,T`dphSfD ıada b*V\3 Z1 4*\f\hd,*, ^f 3SbS ,T/O Wp/ZSV*YS 4* Yd`*YS `1WT-TyZSf \`/1O ZT,D *,]*VSE f`SabSqZS Y*pbn a]`*,WqO bS ,]WS, Z* 3Sbbq TZjSfE ]\/T+Z\ qV aTWn ,]WS,*2 Z* ^3dE * a,TbW\ `\4aTp2 b1Y`q,dD w1 Z*W13*bn a,Tbdx `\b1 ıada\,T Z*ab*Z\,S k\/\ b\-\E qV y\-\ ]\aWT/\,ZSVS ]\,SZZT \+f\/SbSan 4 TZjSYS Wp/nYSE ]\`\/3dpbn ,*3WSO ,1 ]Sb*ZZqB qV f`SabSqZ*Y ab*,SbSan /\ ]\WTbShZSf a]`*,H 1`1/ aY1`bp ıada Y\WS,aq /\ \-* 4* a,\^f dhZT,B w 1 ]`\O jd b1+1 4*+`*bS ^f 4T a,TbdE * WSj1 ]`\O jd \+1`T-*bS ,T/ Ë&#x203A;W\-\D \ZSE qV T qE Z1 Z*W13*bn a,Tbdx Lı,*Z* 5;B59E 5:MD )V f`SabSqZS Y\3dbn \/Z\h*aZ\ Z1 Z*W13*O bS a,Tb\,T y 3SbS a1`1/ gn\-\ a,TbdH #\+ 4`\4dYTbS g1E `\4-WqZnY\ b`S 4*]Sb*ZZqB

Ë&#x2122; )V ıada ab*,S,aq /\ ]\WTbShZSf a]`*,H Ë&#x2122; #\ f`SabSqZS 4* Z*j\-\ h*ad Y*pbn `\+SbSH Ë&#x2122; )V b1E h\-\ Z*,h*pbn f`SabSqZSE ,]WS,*2 Z* ada]TWnab,\H

`-1ZbSZ*B Casilla 83 (Suc 27B), C1427WAB Cdad. Aut. de Buenos Aires. TW\`danB 66>>7>E SZaVE *Nq =D 1WSV\+`Sb*ZTqB The Ridgeway, London NW7 1RN. ı4`*^WnB PO Box 29345, ´ 61293 Tel Aviv. ıa]*ZTqB Apartado 132, 28850 Torrejon de Ardoz (Madrid). ıb*WTqB Via della Bufalotta 1281, I-00138 Rome RM. *Z*/*B PO Box 4100, Georgetown, ON L7G 4Y4. \W/\,*E Ë&#x2DC; 1a]d+WTV*B PO Box 472, MD-2005 Chi ¸sinau. TY1hhSZ*B 65617 Selters. \Wnk*B ulD Warszawska 58E >9O<7> NadarzynD

\`bd-*WTqB Apartado 91, P-2766-955 Estoril. \aTqB 5=;;7=E *ZVbO1b1`+d`-E ]D \WZ1hZ\1E dWD `1/ZqqE :D W\,*hhSZ*B PO Box 2, 830 04 Bratislava 34. "B 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. V`*^Z*B *Na =99E n,T,O `pf\,ShTE ;=8=5D `*ZgTqB BP 625, F-27406 Louviers Cedex.

Vol. 133, No. 9

The Watchtower (ISSN 0043-1087) is published semimonthly by Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc.; L. Weaver, Jr., President; G. F. Simonis, Secretary-Treasurer; 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. Druck und Verlag: Wachtturm Bibelund Traktat-Gesellschaft der Zeugen Jehovas, e. V.E Selters/Taunus. Verantwortliche Redaktion: Ramon Templeton, Selters/Taunus. Ë&#x2DC; 2012 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania. aT ]`*,* 4+1`T-*pbnaqD Printed in Germany.

Semimonthly

UKRAINIAN


)V Äąada ab*,S,aq /\ ]\WTbSVSH   Ë&#x161;Äą) `\4]\,T/*2bnaq ]`\ b1E qV Äąada* VTWnV* `*4T, Z*Y*-*WSaq ,bq-ZdbS , ]\WTbSVdD *]`SVW*/E Z1,/\,O 4T ]TaWq y\-\ f`1k1ZZq Ë&#x2122;Sq,\W 4*]`\O ]\Zd,*, y\Yd ab*bS ]`*,Sb1W1Y a,TbdD T4ZTj1 Z*b\,] f\bT, 4`\+SbS Äąada* g*O `1YD Ë&#x203A;-\/\Y Wp/S Z*Y*-*WSaq 4`\+SbS 4 Zn\-\ ]\WTbShZ\-\ /Tqh*D )V ]\,\/S,O aq Äąada 4* ,aTf gSf \+ab*,SZH



`*,Sb1Wn a,TbdD  ,*Z-1WTqf aV*4*Z\E k\ Ë&#x2122;Sq,\W 4*]`\]\Zd,*, Äąada\,T ]`*,SO bS Z*/ daTY* g*`ab,*YS a,TbdD VTWnO VS 3 /\+`* Äąada YT- +S 4`\+SbS /Wq WpO /1yE qV+S ]\-\/S,aq Z* gp ]`\]\4SgTpI

S qVSyan ]\WTbShZSy /TqhE V\b`Sy kSO `\ +*3*2 ]\W1-jSbS ab`*3/*ZZq Wp/1yE ,T/Y\,S,aq + ,T/ b*V\^ ]\a*/SH W1 Äąada ,T/Y\,S,aqE */31 Y*, Z* g1 ,*-\YT ]`SO hSZS L*b,Tq 8B<P55MD *`D *-*b\ Äąada\,Sf adh*aZSVT, +*3*WS Y*bS ]`*,Sb1WqE qVSy +S `\4,Gq4*, ^fZT

Ë&#x2122; & ) 5=8 B *41`+*y/3*ZanV*E *41`O +*y/3*ZanV* LVS`SWShZ1 ]SanY\ME *yY*`*7E *W+*ZanO V*E *Yf*`anV*E *Z-WTyanV*687 Lb*V\3 j`Seb\Y `*yWqME *`*+anV*E *e`SV*ZaE *h\WTE +*dW1E +1Y+*E +1Z-*WnanO V*E +TV\WnanV*E +T`Y*ZanV*E +TaW*Y*E +\W-*`anV*E ,*WWTO aTyanV*E ,*`*yO,*`*yE ,1Z/*E ,G2bZ*YanV*E ,T`Y1ZanV*E  ,T`Y1ZanV* L4*fT/Z*ME -*E -*^bqZanV* V`1\WnanV*E -*ZE -TW+1`banV*E -TZ/TE -`1ZW*Z/anV*E -`1gnV*E -`d4SZanV*E -d*`*ZT68E -d/3*`*bTE /*banV*7E 1,1E 1ab\ZanV*E 1eTVE 2,O `1yanV* LT,`SbME 4*Z/1E 4dWdE T+\E TW\V*ZanV*E TZ/\Z14TyO anV*E TaW*Z/anV*E Ta\V\E Ta]*ZanV*687E Tb*WTyanV*67E y\O â&#x20AC;š `d+*E V*4*fanV*E V*Z*/*E V*\Z/1E V*b*W*ZanV*E V1hd*E V1hd* LZV*jME V1hd* LqVdh\ME V1hd* L \WT,TqM7E V1O hd* L daV\ME VS`-S4nV*E VSb*yanV*7 L*d/T\4*]Sa bTWnVS

1V\Z\YThZT b* ]\WTbShZT ]`\+W1YSD pO /S +*hSWSE k\ Äąada a]`\Y\3ZSy Z1abS TZjSY /\+`\E b\Yd f\bTWS 4`\+SbS y\O -\ ]\WTbSV\YD )V ,TZ 4`1*-d,*,H wÄąadaE 4Z*phSE k\ y\-\ 4+S`*pbnaq af\]SbS T 4`\+SbS g*`1YE 4Z\,d ]Tj\, a*Y Z* -\`dx LÄą,*Z* :B5>P59MD b31E Äąada ,T/Y\,S,aq +`*bS dh*abn d ]\WTbShZSf a]`*,*fD

\WTbShZSy /TqhD an k\ ab*W\an 4* VTWnV* /ZT, /\ Äąada\,\^ aY1`bTD hZT e*`SO a1^,E qVT +\`\WSaq 4* 4,TWnZ1ZZq Äą4`*^Wp ,T/ `SYanV\-\ -ZTbdE `*4\Y 4 T`\/TqZ*O YSE V\b`T ]T/b`SYd,*WS SYE ]T/TyjWS /\ Äąada*D \ZS f\bTWS 4YdaSbS y\-\ 4*yZqbS qVdan ]\WTbShZd ]\4SgTpE b\Yd 4*]Sb*WS y\-\E hS b`1+* ]W*bSbS ]\/*b\V `SYWqO Z*YD Äąada ,T/]\,T,B wr \Yd Y1Z1 ,S]`\O +\,d2b1H \V*3Tbn Y1ZT /1Z*`TysD \O WS ,\ZS ]`SZ1aWSE ,TZ 4*]Sb*, ^fB r S2 g1 4\+`*31ZZq b* TYGqHs T ,T/]\,TWSB

Y*Z/*`SZanV\p Y\,\pME VSb*yanV* La]`\k1Z1 ]SanO Y\ME VTVdypE VTZnq`d*Z/*E VT`dZ/TE V\Z-\E V\Z-\ LV\WSjO Zq Y\Z\Vdbd+*ME V\`1yanV*67E V\a*E Vd*Z-*WTE Vd*ZnqO Y*E VfY1`anV*E W*bSanV*E WSb\,anV*E W\4TE Wd+*E Wd,*W1E Wd-*Z/*E WdZ/*E Wd\E Y*,`SVTyanV* V`1\WnanV*E Y*yqE Y*V1/\ZanV*E Y*W*-*aTyanV*E Y*W*qW*YE Y*WnbTyanV*E Y*`*bfTE Y*`j*WWnanV*E Y+dZ/dE YT4\E YTf1E Y\Z-\WnanO V*E Y\`1E Z-*+1`1E Z-*W*E Z/1+1W1E Z/\Z-*E Z1]*WnanV*E Z41Y*E ZT/1`W*Z/anV*67E ZTY1gnV*67E ZTd1E Z\`,14nV*7E ZnqZ1V*E \`\Y\E \b1b1W*E ]*W*dE ]*Z-*aSZ*ZanV*E ]*]GqO Y1Zbd L`d+*ME ]*]GqY1Zbd L p`*a*\ME ]1/TE ]1Z/3*+O anV*E ]1`anV* Le*`aTME ]T/3SZ \W\Y\Z\,Sf \ab`\,T,E ]\WnanV*67E ]\Z*]1E ]\`bd-*WnanV*687E `*`\b\Z-*E `\aTyO anV*67E `dYdZanV*E a*Y\*E a*Z-\E a*]\b1V L]1`1jSy\VME

a,*4TE a1+d*ZanV*E a1yj1WnanV* V`1\WnanV*E a1`+anV*E a1`+anV* LW*bSZanV1 ]SanY\ME a1adb\E aSZ-*WnanV*E aW\O ,*gnV*E aW\,1ZanV*E a`*Z*ZOb\Z-\E ad*fTWTE b*-*WnanO  V*7E b*^bqZanV*E b*yanV*E b*YTWnanV*E b*b*`anV*E b,TE b1O Wd-dE b1bdYE bS,E bS-`SZnqE b\VO]TaSZE b\Z-*E b\b\Z*VE b`dVE ba,*Z*E ba\Z-*E bd,*WdE bdY+dV*E bd`1gnV*E d-\`anO  V*67E d4+1gnV*E dV`*^ZanV*E dY+dZ/dE d`/dE d`ddZ/E eTO /3TyanV*E eTZanV*7E e`*Zgd4nV*687E f*da*E fTWT-*yZ\ZE fTO `TOY\bdE f\`,*banV*E g\gTWnE h1anV*7E hSh1,*E hTWd+*E hTb\Z-*E j,1/anV*7E j\Z*E q]E q]\ZanV*67D 6 *V\3 CDD 8 *V\3 MP3 CD-ROMD 7 d/T\4*]SaS b*V\3 /\abd]ZT Z* www.jw.org.


r 1a*`1,1sD \/T ıada aV*4*,B r\3 ,T/O /*,*yb1 V1a*`1,1 V1a*`pE * \31 P \O -\,Tsx L*`V* 56B57P5;MD `\ gp Tab\`Tp , \/ZTy VZS3gT ]\qaZp,*W\anB wıada ,T/O Y\,S,aq +dbS ]\WTbShZSY Y1aT2p T 4 ,1O WSV\p \+*hZTabp ]\qaZS,E /1 ]`\f\/Sbn ‹ Y13* YT3 bSYE k\ 2 V1a*`1,SYE T bSYE k\ 2 \3SYx LwChurch and State—The Story of Two KingdomsxMD ıada\,T Z1 +dWS +*y/d3T b*VT ]`\+W1O YSE qV +T/ZTabnE V\`d]gTq T Z1a]`*,1/WSO

,TabnD T+WTq ]\V*4d2E k\ ,TZ ]`\yY*,aq bSYE , qV\Yd 3*Wp-T/Z\Yd ab*Z\,SkT ]1`1+d,*WS Wp/S L*`V* :B77E 78MD ıada Z1 +`*,aq a*Y\bd3VS +\`\bSaq 4 Z1a]`*O ,1/WS,Tabp a,TbdE f\h* /1fb\ /d31 Z*O Y*-*,aq ,bq-ZdbS y\-\ d ,S`Tj1ZZq 4W\O +\/1ZZSf ]`\+W1Y b\-\ h*adD aT gT ]`SVW*/S ]\V*4dpbnE k\ ıada ,T/Y\,Wq,aq +`*bS dh*abn d ]\WTbShZSf a]`*,*f a,TbdD W1 hS ]\,SZZT 4*yY*bSO aq ]\WTbSV\p adh*aZT f`SabSqZSH

`SabSqZS T ]\WTbSV*  ˙ ı f`SabSqZS Z1 ,b`dh*pbnaq , ]\WTbSVdD \YdH \ ,\ZS Z*aWTO /dpbn ıada*E qVSy aV*4*,E k\ Z1 Z*W1O 3Sbn a,TbdD ,\^Y ]\aWT/\,ZSV*Y ,TZ ]\O qaZS,B w S Z1 Z*W13Sb1 a,Tbdx Lı,*Z* 59B5=C 5;B58MD \4-WqZnY\ VTWnV* ]T/ab*, b\-\E h\Yd f`SabSqZS Z1 ]\,SZZT +`*bS dh*abn d ]\WTbShZSf a]`*,*fD



T+WTq 4*ab1`T-*2 Z*a Z1 ]\VW*/*bSaq Z* Wp/SZd La*W\Y 58:B7MD

5D p/anVT Y\3WS,\abT \+Y131ZTD  T+WT^ aV*4*Z\E k\ Wp/S Z1 Y*pbn ZT 4/*bZ\abTE ZT ]`*,* V1`d,*bS a*YSYS a\O +\pB w 1 , aSWT Wp/SZSE V\WS ,\Z* f\O /SbnE V1`Yd,*bS a,\^Y V`\V\Yx L`1YT^ 5>B67MD p/S Z1 +dWS ab,\`1ZTE k\+ WTb*bSE Z*h1 ]b*fSD *V a*Y\ Wp/S Z1 +dWS ab,\`1ZTE k\+ da]TjZ\ ]`*,SbS a\+\pD +-\,\`pphS \+Y131ZZq d`q/T,E *Y1`SO V*ZanVSy Tab\`SV ˙1y,T/ `\YVTZ Z*]SO a*,B w`q/S aVW*/*pbnaq 4 Wp/1yE b\Yd ,\ZS afSWnZT ]\YSWqbSaq T ^fZ2 Y*yO +dbZ2 Z1ab*+TWnZ1D \ZS ,\W\/Tpbn ]1,O Z\pE \/Z*V \+Y131Z\p ,W*/\px LwThe Question of GovernmentxMD 1 /S,Z\E k\

6D * Wp/1y ,]WS,*pbn 4WT /df\,ZT aSWSD `S-*/*yY\ ,S]*/\VE V\WS *b*O Z* 4*]`\]\Zd,*, ıada\,T +dbS ]`*,Sb1O W1Y dan\-\ a,TbdD ıada Z1 4*]1`1hS,E k\ *b*Z* Y*2 4Y\-d 4*]`\]\Zd,*bS y\Yd ,aT g*`ab,* a,TbdD T4ZTj1 ıada Z*4,*, *b*Zd w]`*,Sb1W1Y gn\-\ a,TbdxD ˛-\O /\Y *]\ab\W *,W\ ]\qaZS,E k\ *b*Z* 2 w+\-\Y gT2^ aSab1YSx Lı,*Z* 58B7>C 6 \O `SZeqZ 8B8MD *,W\ Z*]Sa*, \/Z\,T`gqYB wS +\`1Y\aqDDD ]`\bS d`q/T,E ,W*/SE a,TO b\,Sf ]`*,Sb1WT, gT2^ b1Y`q,SE ]`\bS 4WSf /dfT, d Z1+1a*fx L˚e1aqZ :B56MD 1O ,S/SY\ /Wq Wp/anV\-\ \V* a,Tb\Y Z*O a]`*,/T V1`dpbn 4WT /df\,ZT aSWSD )V 4Z*ZZq gT2^ TabSZS ]\,SZZ1 ,]WS,*bS Z* Z*j1 ab*,W1ZZq /\ ]\WTbShZSf a]`*,H \/T+Z\ qV ]\bd3Z* abSfTq , \V1*ZT VS/*2 , `T4ZT +\VS Z1,1WSVSY ad/Z\YE 4WT /df\,ZT aSWS ]\b`qa*pbn Wp/anV\p ]\O WTbShZ\p aSab1Y\pD ıE b*V a*Y\ qV Y\`qO VS Z1 Y\3dbn ,]WSZdbS Z* Y\`anVd abSO

6  "

˙ 5 ) 6>56


,T/VS -\,S ]T/b`SYdpbn /TqWnZTabn

\3\-\ *`ab,*E * Z1 ]\WTbShZT `1e\`YS

fTpE ]\WTbSVS Z1 Y*pbn 4Y\-S ,]WS,*bS Z* Y\-dbZT /df\,ZT aSWSD T aSWS Z*Y*O -*pbnaq `\4+1kd,*bS Wp/1y T 4*,/*,*O bS w-\`q 41YWTx L+Gq,W1ZZq 56B56MD \O Yd a]`*,3ZT 4YTZS Y\31 4`\+SbS WSj1 \yE fb\ aSWnZTjSy ,T/ *b*ZS T y\-\ /1Y\ZT,EP \- -\,* L SfT/ 59B7C `1YT^ 5>B;E 5>MD

7D `*,/S,T f`SabSqZS gTWV\,Sb\ ,T/O /*ZT WSj1 \3\Yd *`ab,dD ıada T y\-\ dhZT 4Z*WSE k\ d ,S4Z*h1ZSy h*a \- ,ab*O Z\,Sbn d`q/ Z* Z1+TE qVSy ]`*,SbSY1 Z*/ daT2p 41YW1pD T+WTq Z*4S,*2 g1y d`q/ \3SY *`ab,\Y T ]\V*4d2E k\ ıada `SaO b\a ]`S4Z*h1ZSy d Zn\Yd *`1Y L+Gq,O W1ZZq 55B59MD aVTWnVS /TqWnZTabn *`abO ,* ]\4Z*h*2bnaq Z* 3SbbT ,aTf Wp/1yE ıada 4`\+S, w/\+`d Z\,SZd ]`\ \31 g*`abO ,\x -\W\,Z\p b1Y\p a,\^f dh1Zn LdVS 8B87MD TZ b*V\3 Z*,hS, a,\^f ]\aWT/\,ZSO VT, Y\WSbSaqB w 1f*y ]`Sy/1 b,\2 g*`abO ,\xD \YdH \Yd k\ ]T/ ]`*,WTZZqY *`O ab,* \3* ,\Wq +d/1 ,SV\Zd,*bSaq d Z1+T y Z* 41YWT L*b,Tq :B=E 5>MD

 k\ ab*Z1bnaq 4 Wp/anVSYS d`q/*YSH  T+WTq hTbV\ ]\V*4d2E k\ d`q/S wdaT2^ Z*O a1W1Z\^ 41YWTx +d/dbn 4ZSk1ZT L+Gq,O W1ZZq 5:B58C 5=B5=P65MD )Vk\ fb\an Z*O a]`*,/T ]1`1V\Z*ZSyE k\ \31 *`ab,\ Z1,/\,4T dadZ1 ,aT ab,\`1ZT Wp/SZ\p ]\O WTbShZT aSab1YSE b\ ,TZ *3 ZTqV Z1 4*f\h1 ]T/b`SYd,*bS gT aSab1YSD )V+S ,TZ Z*Y*O -*,aq ]T/b`SYd,*bS ]`S`1h1ZT Z* 4*-SO +1Wn Wp/anVT d`q/SE b\E e*VbShZ\E ab*, +S ]`\bS,ZSV\Y \-*D `*,/S,T f`SabSqZS Z1 +1`dbn dh*abT , ]\WTbShZSf a]`*,*fD S g1 \4Z*h*2E k\ ,\ZS Z1 gTV*,Wqbnaq ]\WT]j1ZZqY 3SbO bq Wp/1yE a1`1/ qVSf 3S,dbnH `\ g1 ]TO /1 Y\,* d Z*abd]ZTy ab*bbTD  " Ë&#x2122; 5 ) 6>56

7


)V f`SabSqZanVT ,h1ZZq ,]WS,*pbn Z* ada]TWnab,\H ˚˚˙ ı ab*bbqf `\4-Wq/*W\O aqE h\Yd a]`*,3ZT f`SabSqZS Z1 +1`dbn dh*abT , ]\WTbShZSf a]`*,*fD )V f`SabSqZS ]\V*4dpbnE k\ f\hdbnE *+S ^fZTY +WS3ZTY 3SW\aq WT]j1H \ZS ab*`*pbnaq ,SV\Zd,*bS ıadaT, Z*V*4B wı/Tbn b* `\+Tbn dhZqYS Wp/1y 4 daTf Z*O `\/T,E f`1abqhS ^f , TYGq *bnV*E T SZ*E T a,qb\-\ /dfdE Z*,h*phS ^f /\b`SYd,*O bSaq ,an\-\ b\-\E k\ q ,*Y Z*V*4*,x L*b,Tq 6<B5=E 6>MD ıaZd2 ]`qYSy 4,Gq4\V YT3 ıada\,SY Z*V*4\Y `\+SbS Wp/1y dhZqYS T ,SV\O Z*ZZqY y\-\ ,V*4T,VS +dbS aTWWp b* a,TbW\Y /Wq a,Tbd L*b,Tq 9B57E 58MD #\ g1 4* 4,Gq4\V T qV ,SV\Z*ZZq ıada\,\-\ Z*V*4d ,]WS,*2 Z* Wp/1yH

  qV\Yd `\4dYTZZT 4,TabV*E V\b`d Z1adbn ]`*,/S,T f`SabSqZSE 2 Z*h1 aTWnH

`\]\,T/d,*ZZq f`SabSqZ Z1a1 4Z*ZZq T ]\`qbdZ\V TWn Y*2 ,W*abS,\abT 4+1`T-*bS ]`\O /dVb ,T/ 4T]adbbqD *V a*Y\ T 4,TabO V*E qVd ıada Z*V*4*, a,\^Y ]\aWT/\,ZSO V*Y ]`\-\W\jd,*bSE Y*2 aSWd 4+1`T-*bS 3Sbbq Wp/1yD TE fb\ ]`SyY*2 T 4*ab\a\O ,d2 ıada\,T ,h1ZZqE 4*fSk*pbn a1+1 ,T/ Y\`*WnZ\-\ 4T]adbbqE qV1 /d31 ]\jS`1O Z1 4* Z*j\-\ h*adD p/S Z*,h*pbnaq dZSV*bS jVT/WS,Sf 4,Sh\VE Z*]`SVW*/E Vd`TZZqD \ZS `\4,S,*pbn b*VT `SaSE qV Wp+\,E YS`E /\,-\b1`]TZZqE /\+`\O b* T ,1WSV\/djZTabn L*W*bT, 9B66E 67MD ˛*,/qVS gSY `Sa*Y ]`*,/S,T f`SabSqO 8


ZS 2 gTZZSYS hW1Z*YS ada]TWnab,*D ,\O ^Y ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZqY ,\ZS Z1adbn /\+`\ +WS3ZTYD  qV `\4dYTbS b1E k\ f`SabSqZS 2 a,TbW\YH \/T+Z\ qV Taqgn ,T//41`V*O Wp2 a\ZqhZ1 a,TbW\E b*V T `Sab\,T ]\O aWT/\,ZSVS ,T//41`V*Wppbn a,TbW\ ,T/ \-* -\,SD \ZS Z1adbn a,TbW\ , b\Yd `\4dYTZZTE k\ ]`\]\,T/dpbn Z\,SZd ]`\ *`ab,\ T Y*pbn /\+`T ,hSZVS L5 1b`* 6B56MD Ë&#x2122;*WT ıada ]`\,T, ]*`*W1Wn YT3 a,TbO W\Y a,TbSWnZSV* T ]`*g1p a,\^f dhZT,D TZ aV*4*,B w \WS 4*]*Wppbn a,TbSWnO ZSVE b\ ab*,Wqbn y\-\ Z1 ]T/ YT`SWnZd ]\ad/SZdE * Z* ]T/O ab*,VdE T ,TZ a,TbSbn /Wq ,aTf d /\YTD \/T+Z\ y ,*j1 a,TbO W\ Z1f*y a,TbSbn ]1`1/ Wp/nO YSxD \WS a,TbSWnZSV ab\O ^bn Z* ]T/ab*,gTE y\-\ ,S/Z\ ,aTYD *V a*Y\ y ]`\]\,T/dO ,*ZZq b* TZjT /\+`T /TW* ]`*,O /S,Sf f`SabSqZ ]\,SZZT +dbS ,S/SYT /Wq TZjSfD ıada aV*O 4*,E k\ Wp/S +*hSbSYdbn /\+O `T /TW* ]`*,/S,Sf f`SabSqZ T 4*,/qVS gn\Yd ]`\aW*,WqbSYdbn \-* L*b,Tq 9B58P5:MD \W1VbS,Z* ,T/]\,T/*WnZTabn ıada\,T aW\,* w,S P a,TbW\ /Wq a,Tbdx T w,*j1 a,TbW\ Z1f*y a,TbSbnx ab\adO pbnaq ,aTf y\-\ dhZT,D TWnV* Wp/1y 4 `T4ZSf `1WT-Ty Z1 Y\-WS + ,SV\ZdO ,*bS /\`dh1ZZq Z1abS a,TbW\ ]`*,/SD aT `Sab\,T ]\aWT/\,ZSVS Y*pbn +dbS wa,TbW\YxD TY YTWny\ZT, ,T/VT, -\,S 4 ]\Z*/ 679 V`*^Z T b1`Sb\`Ty ,,*3*pbn a,\^Y \+\,Gq4V\Y TbS /\ Wp/1y b* ]`\]\O ,T/d,*bS ^Y b1E h\-\ Z*,h*, ıadaD #\ ]`\]\,T/dpbn ,T/VS -\,SH ıada /\`dhS, dhZqY ]`\]\,T/d,*bS Z1 qVTan a\gT*WnZT hS ]\WTbShZT `1e\`YSE T/1^

]`\ 2/ZTabn /1`3*,S b* g1`V,SE hS k1 qVdan a,TbanVd T/1pD *b\YTabn ,TZ ]1O `1/`TVB wp /\+`d Z\,SZd ]`\ g*`abO ,\ +d/dbn ]`\]\,T/d,*bS ]\ gTWTy Z*a1O W1ZTy 41YWT Z* a,T/h1ZZq ,aTY Z*`\/*Yx L*b,Tq 68B58MD `*,/S,T f`SabSqZS aWdf*pbnaq ıada\,\-\ Z*V*4d T `\4]\,TO /*pbn +WS3ZTY ]`\ b1E k\ \31 *`aO b,\ P 2/SZSy d`q/E 4/*bZSy ]\VW*abS V`*y 4WTy aSab1YT *b*ZS T ,ab*Z\,SbS Z\,Sy ]`*,1/ZSy a,TbD ,*Z-1WTq \]SadpbnE Z* h\Yd 4\a1`1O /3d,*,aq ıada ]T/ h*a a,\-\ aWd3TZZqD `\ g1 ]T/1 Y\,* , Z*abd]ZTy ab*bbTD

\Yd `Sab\,* Z*dV* ]`S`T,Zp2bnaq /\ a,TbSWnZSV* , b1Y`q,TH 9


`*,/S,T f`SabSqZS T a,T/\YT -`\Y*/qZS ıË&#x2122;  aWd3TZZq Z* 41YWT ıada ]1O `1/daTY ]`*-Zd, 4YTZp,*bS a1`gq Wp/1yE * Z1 ]\WTbShZSy W*/D \/S,TO Y\anE Z* k\ 4,1`Zd, d,*-d ıada d a,\^y

*-T`ZTy ]`\]\,T/TD 1`1/ bSY qV aV*O 4*bS dhZqY w,S aTWn 41YWTx T wa,TbW\ /Wq a,TbdxE ,TZ ]\qaZS,E k\ ]\Oa]`*,3O Zn\Yd k*aWS,SY 2 b\yE fb\ wda,T/\YO Wp2 a,\p ]\b`1+d , /df\,Z\YdxD ıada /\/*,B w#*aWS,T W*-T/ZTE DDDhSabT a1`O g1YE DDDYS`\b,\`gTx L*b,Tq 9B5P55MD TZ Z*-\W\aS, Z* ,*3WS,\abT d4-\/3d,*bS YSaW1ZZq y ]\hdbbq 4 \3SYS Z\`Y*YS /\+`* T 4W* b* aWd3SbS ,\`g1,T 4 dan\O -\ a1`gqD `TY b\-\E V\WS ıada +*hS, Wp/anVT ab`*3/*ZZqE g1 a]\ZdVd,*W\ y\-\ ,SO q,WqbS YSW\a1`/q T Z1abS ]\W1-j1ZO ZqD  ,bTYE b*V* /\]\Y\-* Z1 +dW* -\O W\,Z\p Y1b\p y\-\ aWd3TZZq L*b,Tq 6>B7>P78MD TZ 4gTWq, f,\`SfE *W1 WpO /S y /*WT ]\b1`]*WS ,T/ f,\`\+ LdVS :B5;P5=MD TZ ]\bTj*, ]`S-ZTh1ZSfE *W1 Wp/S y /*WT ]\b1`]*WS ,T/ Z1a]`*,1/WSO ,\abTD ıada -\/d,*, -\W\/ZSfE *W1 -\W\/ ]`\/\,3d,*, /\jVdWqbS Wp/ab,d L*`O V* :B85P88MD

LdVS 8B87C <B5MD an h\YdE V\WS dhZT aV*4*WS ıada\,TE k\ 2 k1 +*-*b\ f,\`SfE qVT h1V*pbn 4gTW1ZZqE ,TZ ]\qaZS,B w\O /TY\ /*WTE /\ ]\+WS4nVSf a1WSkE *+S y b*Y ]`\]\,T/d,*bSE +\ /Wq gn\-\ q ]`SO yj\,x L*`V* 5B76P7<MD \h* ıada ]\O W1-jd,*, eT4ShZT ab`*3/*ZZq +*-*bn\fE ,TZ ,T//*,*, ]1`1,*-d ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZp T Z*,h*ZZp \3\-\ aW\,*D ,T/VS -\,S Z*Y*-*pbnaq Z*aWT/d,*O bS ıada* d a,\2Yd ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZTD \ZS

TZ 4YTZp,*, a1`gq T ]\W1-jd,*, ab`*3/*ZZq

\Yd ıada Z1 Z*Y*-*,aq 4YTZSbS ]\WTO bShZSy W*/ hS dadZdbS ]`ShSZS ab`*3O /*ZnE * 4\a1`1/3d,*,aq ]1`1/daTY Z* b\YdE k\+ 4YTZp,*bS a1`gq Wp/1y T ]\O W1-jd,*bS ab`*3/*ZZqH ıada 4Z*,E k\ , Y*y+dbZn\Yd \- 4* /\]\Y\-\p a,\-\ *`ab,* ]\VTZhSbn 4 daTY* Wp/anVSYS d`q/*YS y daTYE k\ ]`SZ\aSbn Z1k*abq

,T/\YT -`\Y*/qZS \/Z\h*a ,T/VS -\,S ,,*3*pbnE k\ ,\ZS qV f`SabSqZS ]\,SZZT +dO bS /\+`SYS -`\Y*/qZ*YSD \ZS j*ZdO pbn T ]\,*3*pbn d`q/\,d ,W*/dD ,\O ^YS ]d+WTV*gTqYS b* ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZqY ,\ZS 4*\f\hdpbn +WS3ZTf +dbS 4*V\Z\O aWdfZqZSYSD  ,bTYE V\WS ,SY\-S d`q/d ad]1`1h*bn \3SY Z*V*4*YE ,T/VS Z1 ,SV\Zdpbn b*VSf ,SY\-D \ZS w]T/V\`qO



10  "

Ë&#x2122; 5 ) 6>56

ıada ]`*-Zd, 4YTZp,*bS a1`gq Wp/1yE * Z1 ]\WTbShZSy W*/ ,T/ dan\-\ a1`gq +*3*pbn ]\W1-jd,*bS ab`*3/*ZZq Wp/1yE /*phS ^Y ]`*VbShZd /\]\Y\-dD W1 ,T/VS Z1 Z*Y*-*pbnaq ,S]`*,WqbS Z1a]`*,1/WS,TabnE qV* ]*O Zd2 d a,TbTD \ZS ]1`1V\Z*ZTE k\ WSO j1 \31 *`ab,\ dadZ1 ,aT ]`ShSZS Z1O k*abn L*b,Tq :B5>MD \/T+Z\ /\ ıada*E ,\ZS ab*`*pbnaq 4YTZp,*bS a1`gqE * Z1 ]\WTbShZSy W*/D *V* ]\4SgTq \+š`dZb\O ,*Z*E */31 -\W\,Z* ]`\+W1Y* Wp/ab,* V`S2bnaq Z1 , ]\WTbSgTE * , Y\`*WTD


,T/VS -\,S ,,*3*pbnE k\ ]\,SZZT +dbS /\+`SYS -`\Y*/qZ*YS pbnaq \-\,TE * Z1 Wp/SZTx LË&#x2122;T^ 9B6=C SYWqZ 57B5P;MD ,T/VS -\,S y/dbn /\ ,aTf Wp/1y T ]`\]\Zdpbn +14]W*bZ\ ,S,h*bS T+WTpD 1 Z*,h*ZZq /\]\Y\-W\ YTWny\Z*Y WpO /1y 4YTZSbS a,\2 a1`g1D Ë&#x203A;*,/qVS +T+WTyO ZTy ]`*,/T k\`\Vd a\bZT bSaqh Wp/1y ]\O 4+d,*pbnaq b*VSf 4-d+ZSf 4,Sh\VE qV Vd`TZZqE ]Sqgb,\E Z*`V\Y*ZTqE *4*`bZT T-`S T ab*b1,* Z1Y\`*WnZTabnD T Wp/S ab*WS h1aZSYS T ,T/]\,T/*WnZSYS -`\O Y*/qZ*YSE \aVTWnVS Z*,hSWSan 4*ab\O a\,d,*bS +T+WTyZT ]`SZgS]SD L Sb*yb1 ab*bbp wT+WTq 4YTZp2 3SbbqxE k\ Z* ab\`TZgT 5<MD `TY b\-\E +T+WTyZ1 Z*,h*ZZq /\]\Y*O -*2 +*-*bn\Y ]\-WS+Wp,*bS ]\,*-d \/Z1 /\ \/Z\-\ d a,\^f `\/SZ*f T ]\WT]jd2 ^fO ZT ab\adZVSD a1 g1 4YTgZq2 `\/SZZT d4SD  YTgZT `\/SZS P g1 YTgZ1 ada]TWnab,\D Ë&#x203A; \-Wq/d Z* ,a1 ,Sk1aV*4*Z1E qV ,S /dY*2b1E hS af,*Wp2 \- a\p4 ]\WTbSO VS b* `1WT-T^H T/]\,T/n 4`\4dYTW* P Z1 af,*Wp2D  hS ]\,SZZT ]`*,/S,T f`SabSO qZS +dbS ,T/]\,T/*WnZSYS -`\Y*/qZ*O YSH *VE +\ ,\ZS f\hdbn aWdf*bSaq ıadO a\,\-\ Z*V*4d +dbS Z*h1 aTWn T a,TbW\ /Wq a,TbdD \yE fb\ 4*ab\a\,d2 `Sab\,T ,h1ZO ZqE ]`SZ\aSbn +W*-\aW\,1ZZq a\+TE a,\O ^y aTYG^E * b*V\3 ada]TWnab,dE , qV\Yd 3S,1D ,T/VS -\,S 4*Wp+VS `\4V*3dbn ,*Y +TWnj1 ]`\ ]`\-`*Yd +T+WTyZ\-\ Z*O ,h*ZZqE qV1 ]`\,\/Sbnaq d ,*jTy YTag1O ,\abT1D 1 S b*V\3 Y\31b1 ,T/,T/*bS a*yb ,T/VT, -\O ,SPwww.watchtower.org/k

11


  ˚ ˚ #  ı ıGı

)V ,T/Z\,SbS /\,T`Gq b1]*Z1B wTV\WS Z1 /dY*,E k\ (Wq ,hSZSbn ]1`1Wp+D   ) ]1`1ab*, ^y /\,T`qbSD 1ZT +dW\ /d31 ,*3V\ ,S+*hSbS ^yxD (WqB w˛`\4dYTW\E h\Yd q ,b`*bSW* y\-\ /\,T`GqD `\yjW\ +*-*b\ `\VT,E ]1`j ZT3 ,TZ 4Z\,d ]\h*, Y1ZT /\,T`qbSxD

ı˙  4 T+WT2pE 4`*O /31ZSy Y*2 ]`*,\ ,SO +`*bSB `\4WdhSbSaq *+\ ]`\abSbS2 L*b,Tq 5=B=MD b1]*Z ,S`TjS, Z1 `\4WdO h*bSan 4 /`d3SZ\pD \ZS ]`*-ZdWS ,`qbd,*bS a,\2 ]\/`d33qD  ,bTYE ,\ZS 4`\4dYTWSE k\ /Wq gn\-\ ]\b`T+Z\ h\-\an +TWnj\-\E ZT3 ]`\ab\ 3SbS `*4\YD /31 (WTZ* 4`*/* 4`dyO Zd,*W* /\,T`d YT3 ZSYSD #\+ ]\/`d33q +dW\ k*aO WS,SYE h\W\,TV T /`d3SO Z* ]\,SZZT ]\,ZTabp /\,TO `qbS \/Z1 \/Z\YdD \Yd b1]*Z\,T b* (WT b`1+* +dW\ /\VW*abS hSY*W\ 4dO aSWnE k\+ ,T/Z\,SbS b*Vd /\,T`dD  k\E V\WS T d ,*j\Yd ]\/`d33T ab*O W*aq b*V* b`*-1/TqH 1`jT YTaqgT ]TaWq b\-\E qV ,S /T4Z*WSan ]`\ 4`*/dE Y\3dbn +dbS \a\+WS,\ ,*3VSYSD W1 Z1 4/*,*yO b1anI )V ,T/Z\,SbS /\,T`dH 1`dyb1aq Yd/`SYS ]\`*/*YS 4 T+WT^D an VTWnV* 4 ZSfD

˛

1 ıY1Z* 4YTZ1Z\D 2 \`*/SE V\b`T /\]\Y\3dbn ]`SyZqbS `Tj1ZZq , gTy a]`*,TE ,S 4Z*y/1b1 , w`\+d/SanIx 4* 66 V,TbZq 5=== `\VdE aD :E T 4* < a1`]Zq 5==9 `\VdE aD 5>E 55D

12  "

˙ 5 ) 6>56

5D d/nb1 h1aZSYS \/Z1 4 \/ZSYD ]\ab\W *,W\ ]Sa*,B w1]1`E V\WS ,S ,31 ,T/VSZdWS +`1fZpE daT -\,\`Tbn ]`*O ,/dx L˚e1aqZ 8B69MD `1fZqE Z*]T,]`*,/* T Z*,Tbn Y\,h*ZV* ]T/`S,*pbn /\,T`GqD \Yd +d/nb1 \/Z1 4 \/ZSY ,T/,1`bSYS T h1aZSYSD ]1`jd ,*YE Y*+dbnE +d/1 ,*3V\ -\,\O `SbS ]`\ Z1,T`ZTabnD W1 4`1jb\p ,*Y b*VS /\,1/1bnaq ,T/,1`b\ ]\`\4Y\,WqbS


]`\ b1E k\ ab*W\aqD \3WS,\E ,S Z1 +dO /1b1 4-*/d,*bS V\3Zd ]\/`\+SgpE 4*b1 Z1Yd/`\ ,4*-*WT dZSV*bS gT2^ `\4Y\,SD (Wq ]`S-*/d2B w]\h*bVd Y1ZT +dW\ /dO 31 ,*3V\ T Z1]`S2YZ\ \+-\,\`p,*bS gp b1YdD ) `\4V*p,*W*aq d ,hSZ1Z\Yd T f\O bTW* 4*+dbS g1E Z*h1 ab`*jZSy a\ZxD `\O b1 +`*V ,T/,1`b\-\ a]TWVd,*ZZq ]\-WS+O Wp,*, ]`\+W1YdD \YdH b1]*Z ]\qaZp2B waVTWnVS (Wq dZSV*W* `\4Y\, ]`\ Z1O ,T`ZTabnE Y1Z1 /*WT -`S4WS ]T/\4`SxD 4SO `*phSan d YSZdW1E (Wq ,S4Z*2B w1E k\ q Z1 f\bTW* \+-\,\`p,*bS g1 4T a,\^Y h\O W\,TV\YE bTWnVS ]1`1jV\/3*W\ 4*-\2ZZp `*ZxD ˛,Sh*yZ\E +d/nOqV* 4-*/V* ]`\ 4`*/d 4*,/*2 +\WpD ˙*Z*E qVd 4`*/S, h\W\,TVE V*31B w Y1Z1 +dW\ +*-*b\ 4*]Sb*ZnB qVH h\YdH ]`\ k\ ,\ZS -\,\`SWSH 1Z1 ]1O `1]\,Zp,*WS 1Y\gT^E q ]\abTyZ\ ]`\ g1 /dY*W*D SZ*WS bS3ZT y ,SZSV*W\ k1 +TWnj1 4*]Sb*ZnxD ˙*ZSZ h\W\,TVE *,O W\E ]`S-*/d2B w *a*YS `\4Y\,* 4 ˙*Z\p ]1`1`\ab*W* d a,*`VdD `\b1 YS 4*,3/S ]`\aSWS ,S+*h1ZZq \/Z1 , \/Z\-\D #S`T `\4Y\,S Z* gp b1Yd 4+WS4SWS Z*axD )V 4`\+SbS b*V1 \+-\,\`1ZZq Y1Zj Z*]`d31ZSYH *YGqb*yb1E k\ ,*j* -\O W\,Z* Y1b* P Z1 ]\V*`*bS a,\-\ ]\/`d3O Zn\-\ ]*`bZ1`*E * ,4qbS 4 b\-\E k\ b`*]SO W\anE d`\V T 4YTgZSbS ]\/`d3ZT d4SD an ]`SVW*/D dW d T y\-\ /`d3SZ* T )Z `1O b1WnZ\ \+-\,\`SWS a,\^ ab\adZVS ]TaWq ,hSZ1Z\^ ZSY Z1,T`Z\abTD w) 4`\4dYT,E k\ +d, Z*/b\ 4*yZqbSy \a\+SabSYS a]`*,*O YSEP V*31 ,TZDP 1ZT /d31 f\bTW\aq ]\O /\+*bSaq TZjSY T ,S]`*,/\,d,*bS ^fZT a]\/T,*ZZqD ) ,T//*,*, ^Y Y*y31 ,1an a,Ty h*a b* d,*-dD \Yd YS 4 /`d3SZ\p Y*W\ h*ad ]`\,\/SWS `*4\YxD a,T/\YO W1ZZq gn\-\ /\]\Y\-W\ ^Y \+\Y 4 h*a\Y 4`\+SbS ]1,ZT 4YTZSE qVT 4YTgZSWS ^fZ2 ]\/`d33qD

# ˝ ˛ D )Vk\ ,S ,hSZSO WS Z1,T`ZTabnE Z1 jdV*yb1 a\+T \]`*,/*Zn

T Z1 4,SZd,*hdyb1 a,\-\ ]\/`d3Zn\-\ ]*`bZ1`*D T4nYTbn Z* a1+1 ,T/]\,T/*WnO ZTabn 4* ,hSZ1Z1 T 4* 4*,/*Zd jV\/dD )Vk\ 3 ,S 2 31`b,\pE Z1 V`ShTbn Z* b\O -\E fb\ ,*a 4`*/S,E T Z1 \+`*3*yb1 y\-\ aW\,*YSD *V ,S 4*\f\bSb1 a,\-\ ]\/`d3O Zn\-\ ]*`bZ1`* +dbS 4 ,*YS ,T/,1`bTjSY L˚e1aqZ 8B76MD

6D ˙\VW*/*yb1 a]TWnZSf 4daSWnD T+O WTq V*31B w `*k1 /,\YE qV \/Z\YdE +\ Y*pbn f\`\jd 4*]W*bd 4* b`d/ a,TyE T qVO +S ,\ZS ,]*WSE ]T/TyY1 \/Z1 a,\-\ /`d-*x L˚VVW14Tqab* 8B=E 5>MD 1y ]`SZgS] \a\+O WS,\ ,*`b\ 4*ab\a\,d,*bSE V\WS ,S Z*Y*O -*2b1aq ,T/Z\,SbS ,b`*h1Zd /\,T`dD ]TWnZ\ ,T/VS/*yb1 /df Z1/\,T`SE qVSy `\4G^/*2 ,*jT ab\adZVSD qbd,*bS ,*j1 ]\/`d33q P \+\,Gq4\V T h\W\,TV*E T /`dO 3SZSD )Vk\ V\31Z 4 ,*a \V`1Y\ Z*Y*-*O 2bnaq g1 `\+SbSE b\ Y\3Z* ab,\`SbS k1 +TWnj1 ]`\+W1YD *Y b`1+* +*hSbS \/Z1 , \/Z\Yd ]\YThZSV*D 1 4`\4dYTWS b1]*Z T (WqD \Z* `\4O ]\,T/*2B w*, ]`\ybS qVSyan h*aE ]1`j ZT3 YS `*4\Y ,4qWSaq 4* ,T/Z\,W1ZZq Z*jSf ab\adZVT,D ) ]\ab*Z\,SW* ZTV\WS +TWnj1 Z1 4*,/*,*bS y\Yd b*V\-\ +\WpD ıE f\h* b1]*Z Y*, 4`*Z1ZT ]\hdbbqE ,TZ ,SO `TjS, 4+1`1-bS Z*j1 ]\/`d33qD #\/Zq q ab*`*pan 4*]1,ZSbS y\-\ d a,\^y ,T//*O Z\abTE T ,TZ /*WT ,Sq,Wq2 /\ Y1Z1 Wp+\,D ˛* g1 q 4*,3/S +d/d y\Yd ,/qhZ*xD # ˝ ˛ D *4\Y ]\ab*Z\O ,Tbn ]`*gp,*bS Z*/ ,T/Z\,W1ZZqY /\,T`S d a,\2Yd ]\/`d33TD

7D ˛*YTZTbn ab*`T 4,ShVS Z\,SYSD ıadaE 4*ab1`T-jS a,\^f aWdf*hT, ,T/ ]1`1Wp+dE aV*4*,B w)Vk\ b,\2 ]`*,1 \V\ /\,\/Sbn b1+1 /\ a]\bSV*ZZqE ,S`,S y\-\ y ,SO VSZnx L*b,Tq 9B6;P6=MD )Vk\ ,S ,hSO ZSWS Z1,T`ZTabnE ]\/dY*yb1E qVT 4,ShVS  " ˙ 5 ) 6>56

13


b`1+* w,S`,*bSx T w,SVSZdbSxE k\+ d`qO bd,*bS a,Ty jWp+D *YE +14]1`1hZ\E b`1+* ]\`,*bS ,aT 4,Gq4VS 4 \a\+\pE 4 qV\p ,hSZSWS ]1O `1Wp+1 L`S]\,Tab1y :B76C 5 \`SZeqZ 59B77MD *,W\E ]`\ qV\-\ 4-*/d,*W\aq `*O ZTj1E 4YTZS, a,Ty `\+\hSy -`*eTV T Z\O Y1` Y\+TWnZ\-\ b1W1e\ZdE *+S Z1 V\ZO b*Vbd,*bS 4 3TZV\pE 4 qV\p ,TZ aV\^, -`TfD  ,bTYE gn\-\ +dW\ 4*Y*W\D *,O W\ /d31 ]`*-Zd, ,T/Z\,SbS /\,T`Gq a,\O 2^ /`d3SZSE b\Yd Z*,Tbn `\4`*fd,*,aq 4 `\+\bSD TZ b*V\3 ]\4+d,aq a,\-\ Y\O +TWnZ\-\ b1W1e\ZdE * ab*, V\`Sabd,*bSan bTWnVS b1W1e\Z\Y /`d3SZSD S ,*`b\ +dO W\ ybS Z* b*VT 31`b,SH •\-\ /`d3SZ*E ˙*Z*E V*31B w31 ]`\yjW\ jTabn `\VT,E * q ,a1 k1 TZV\WS ]1`13S,*pE k\ b* 3TZO V* 4Z\,d 4*f\h1 aV\Zb*Vbd,*bSaq 4 ZSYD W1 q /\,T`qp *,W\,TE k\ ,TZ Z1 ]T/O /*abnaq a]\VdaTxD )Vk\ ]1`1Wp+ dhSZSWS ,SE Y\3WS,\E b`1+* 4YTZSbS a,Ty a]\aT+ YSaW1ZZqD `SO YT`\YE ,S afSWnZT /\ eWT`bd *+\ Wp+SO b1 e*Zb*4d,*bS Z* Wp+\,ZT b1YSD \/T waVSZnb1 T4 a1+1 ab*`d \a\+SabTabn `*4\Y 4 ^^ ]\,1/TZV\pxD ˛*YTZTbn ab*`T 4,ShVS Z\,SYSE *+S ]\/`d3ZTy ]*`bZ1` ,T/Z\,S, /\,T`Gq /\ ,*a L \W\aqZ 7B=E 5>MD  Y\O 31E h1`14 ,Sf\,*ZZq ,*Y ,*3V\ ,Sq,WqO bS a,\^ ]\hdbbqD *,Tbn qVk\ a]\h*bO Vd ,*Y +d/1 ZTqV\,\E k1/`\ ,Sq,Wqyb1 a,\p Wp+\, T ]T/b`SYVd a,\2Yd ]\/`d3O 3pD b1]*Z ]`S-*/d2B w(Wq h*ab\ ,Sq,O WqW* a,\p ]`SfSWnZTabn /\ Y1Z1 ZT3ZSY /\bSV\Y T aW\,*YS rq b1+1 V\f*psxD dW\ + /\+`1E *+S ]1,ZSy h*a ,S /1O b*WnZ\ `\4]\,T/*WS ]\/`d3Zn\Yd ]*`bO Z1`\,T ]`\ ,a1E k\ `\+SWS ]`\bq-\Y /ZqD ˛-*/*Z* `*ZTj1 T )Z V*31B w dW d ,SO `TjS, /\ Z*yY1ZjSf ]\/`\+Sgn `\4]\,TO 1 )Vk\ ,]`\/\,3 ]1,Z\-\ h*ad Z1 ,/*2bnaq dZSVZdO bS V\Zb*VbT, 4 b\p \a\+\p LaV*3TY\ Z* `\+\bTME ^f b`1+* \+Y13SbS WSj1 /\ Z*yZ1\+fT/ZTjSfD ]TWVdyO b1aq 4 Z1p bTWnVS , ]`SadbZ\abT TZjSfE T Z1f*y ]`\ g1 4Z*2 ,*j ]\/`d3ZTy ]*`bZ1`D

14  "

˙ 5 ) 6>56

/*bS Y1ZT ]`\ a,Ty /1ZnD *V ,TZ f\bT, ]\O V*4*bSE k\ ZTh\-\ ,T/ Y1Z1 Z1 ]`Sf\,d2xD

# ˝ ˛ D ˛*]Sb*yb1 \/Z1 ‹ \/Z\-\E k\ /\]\Y\31 ,*Y ,T/Z\,SbS ,4*O 2YZd /\,T`dD ˛*]SjTbn g1 T 4*ab\a\,dyb1 k\/ZqD *V\3 ]W*Zdyb1 `*4\Y ,SV\Zd,*O bS ]1,ZT +d/1ZZT a]`*,SD

8D 1f*y ]`\y/1 /\ab*bZn\ h*adD 1 ]\a]Tj*yb1 `\+SbS ,SaZ\,\VE ZT+S ,31 h*a 3SbS b*VE qV g1 +dW\ /\ 4`*/SD `SO ]\,Tab1y 65B9 /*2 ]\]1`1/31ZZqB w aqVSy V,*]WS,Sy P Z* 4+Sb\VxD #\+ ,T/Z\,SO bS /\,T`dE ]\b`T+1Z h*aE Y\3WS,\ Z*,Tbn `\VSD )Vk\ ,S ab*WS 31`b,\p 4`*/SE ]*YGqO b*yb1E k\ YdaSbn ]`\ybS /\ab*bZn\ h*adE *+S ,S 4Y\-WS ]\,ZTabp ]`\abSbSD T )Z ]`S-*/d2B w \WSan Y1ZT +dW\ ,*3V\ 4`\O 4dYTbSE h\Yd 3TZV* Z1 , ab*ZT ]`\abSbS a,\2Yd Z1,T`Z\Yd h\W\,TV\,T T h\Yd ,\Z* b*V /\,-\ \+`*3*2bnaqD `\b1E V\WS YTy h\W\,TV 4`*/S, Y1Z1E q 4`\4dYTW*E h\Yd b*V ,*3V\ ]`\abSbSxD `\abSbS y ,T/Z\O ,SbS /\,T`d 4*4,Sh*y Y\3Z* WSj1 ]\abdO ]\,\D ˚VVW14Tqab* 7B5P7 aV*4*Z\E k\ 2 wh*a WTVd,*bSxD ]1`jd Y\31 4/*,*bSaqE ZT+S Z*yV`*k1 P Z1 /TWSbSaq a,\^YS ]\hdbbqO YS 4 ]\/`d3ZTY ]*`bZ1`\YD `\b1E qVk\ g1 b`S,*bSY1 /\,-\E ,*Y Z1 ,/*abnaq ,T/O Z\,SbS /\,T`dD #\+ ,SWTVd,*bS 4*,/*ZT `*ZSE b`1+* ]`\+*hSbS ]`\abd]\V ,*j\-\ ]\/`d33q T /TWSbSaq 4 ZSY a,\^YS Z*yO -WS+jSYS /dYV*YS b* ]\hdbbqYSD *O V\3 4*\f\hdyb1 y\-\ `\4]\,T/*bS ,*Y ]`\ a,\^ `*/\abT y b`S,\-SD T/-*Zqyb1 Z1-*bS,ZT /dYVS ]`\ b1E k\ ab*W\aqE T Z1 4*b*pyb1 \+`*4S L˚e1aqZ 8B76MD \/dY*yb1E Z*]`SVW*/E ]`\ b1E h\-\ 4*4Z*, a*Y \-D \WS ab*`\/*,ZT T4`*^WnO bqZS ,T/,1`ZdWSan ,T/ Zn\-\E b\ 4*,/*WS y\Yd aSWnZ\-\ +\WpD \- -\,* Z*,Tbn ]`S`T,Zq, a1+1 /\ 4`*/31Z\-\ h\W\,TV*


L`1YT^ 7B<E =C =B5MD W1 \- aV*4*,B w 1 +d/d ]\,TV ab1`1-bS ,\-\ -ZT,dx L`1YT^ 7B56MD \WS y\-\ Z*`\/ kS`\ `\4V*p,*,aq T ]\,1`b*,aq /\ Zn\-\E ,TZ ]`\k*,D \WS ,S \+\2 4`\+SWS Z1\+fT/ZT 4YTO ZS d a,\^f ab\adZV*f T ]\+*hSWS /\+O `T `14dWnb*bSE b\ g1 /*abn ,*Y ,T/hdbbq ab*+TWnZ\abTD \/T ,S Z1 +d/1b1 ]`\ab\ /dY*bSE qV 4+1`1-bS ]\/`d33qE * 4Y\31O b1 a]TWnZ\ 4\a1`1/SbSan Z* TZjSf gTWqfD W*Zdyb1 `1-dWq`Z\ ,S/TWqbS h*a Z* b1E k\+ \+-\,\`p,*bS ]\abd] d a,\^f ab\adZO V*fD *V\3 Z1 ab*,*yb1 a*Y\,]1,Z1ZSYSD ]TWnZ\ /\W*yb1 /`T+ZT Z1,/*hT b* 4*]1,O Zqyb1 \/Z1 \/Z\-\ d Wp+\,T L*W*bT, :B=MD

# ˝ ˛ D 1 Z*Y*-*yb1an ,T/Z\,SbS b*VT 3 ab\adZVSE qVT +dWS d ,*a /\ 4`*/SE * `\4,S,*yb1 Z\,T y YTgZTjT ab\O adZVS \/Z1 4 \/ZSYD

*Y g1 ]T/ aSWd \WS ,*a \-\`b*pbn adYZT,SE ]*YGqb*yO b1B \- 2 ,\`g1Y ]\/`d3Zn\-\ dab`\p L*b,Tq 5=B8P:MD \3 ,TZ /\]\Y\31 ,*Y /\aq-ZdbS da]Tfd , ]\/`d3Zn\Yd 3SbO bTD Sk14-*/*ZT ]\/`d33q 4*ab\a\,d,*O

WS Yd/`T +T+WTyZT ]\`*/S y 4dYTWS ,`qbdO ,*bS a,Ty jWp+D 31 ]`\yjW\ ]\Z*/ 6> `\VT, ,T/b\/TE qV (Wq 4`*/SW* b1]*Z*D TZ ]`S-*/d2B w *y+TWnj1 Z*Y /\]\Y\-W\ b1E k\ 4 Z*O YS ]\h*WS ,S,h*bS T+WTp ,T/VS -\,SD *V YS ]\/\W*WS gp /d31 ,*3Vd ]`\+O W1YdxD (Wq V*31B w)VSY 31 +W*-\aW\O ,1ZZqY 2 b1E k\ YS ,Sb`SY*WS g1 Z1O W1-V1 ,S]`\+d,*ZZqD ˛*,/qVS a]TWnZ\Yd ,S,h1ZZp T+WT^ T Z*]\W1-WS,SY 4daSWO WqY b1]1` YS Y*2Y\ hd/\,1 ]\/`d33qxD

˛  • ˚ ˚˚B ˇ \YdE Z14,*3*phS Z* 4`*/dE q ,SO `TjS, 4+1`1-bS Z*j1 ]\/`d33qH ˇ )VT f\`\jT `SaS q +*hd d a,\2Yd ]\/`d3Zn\Yd ]*`bZ1`\,TH ˇ )V Z*,Tbn d Z14Z*hZSf a]`*,*f q ,Sq,Wq, Wp+\, /\ a,\-\ Y*y+dbO Zn\-\ ]\/`d3Zn\-\ ]*`bZ1`* T qV g1 Y\3Z* `\+SbS 4Z\,dH

 " ˙ 5 ) 6>56

15


  & ˝˚ 

)V1 Y*y+dbZ2 `1WT-T^H

 ab*bbT `\4-Wq/*pbnaq 4*]Sb*ZZqE qVT Y\3dbn ,*a gTV*,SbSD db b*V\3 Z*,\/qbnaq +T+WTyZT ,T`jTE V\b`T YTabqbn ,T/]\,T/T Z* gT 4*]Sb*ZZqD \/*ZT ,T`jT   ,S 4Z*y/1b1 d a,\^y T+WT^D ,T/VS  -\,S `*/\ \+-\,\`qbn ^f 4 ,*YSD

5D S ,aT `1WT-T^ ]`*,/S,TH

*-*b\ kS`Sf Wp/1yE V\b`T ]`*-Zdbn ]\/\+*bSan

\-\,TE Z*W13*bn /\ `T4ZSf `1WT-TyD TZ +*hSbn b*VSf Wp/1y T /+*2 ]`\ ZSfD * 3*WnE /1V\b`T ,SV\`Sab\O ,dpbn `1WT-Tp 4T 4WSYS Z*YT`*YSD  YSZdW\Yd `1WTO  -TyZT ]`\,T/ZSVS Z*,Tbn V*bd,*WS a,\^f \]\Z1ZbT, L6 \`SZeqZ 8B7E 8C 55B57P59MD ˛* ]\,T/\YW1ZZqO YS Y*aOY1/T*E ZSZT /1V\b`T `1WT-TyZT WT/1`S 4*\f\O hdpbn /\ b1`\`S4YdE ]T/b`SYdpbn ,TyZSE * b*V\3 4*yY*pbnaq ab*b1,SY `\4+1k1ZZqY Z1]\,Z\WTbZTfD L`\hSb*yb1 *b,Tq 68B7P9E 55E 56MD 

T+WTq -\,\`SbnE k\ TaZd2 /,* ,S/S `1WT-T^B ]`*,O /S,* T e*WnjS,*D *WnjS,* `1WT-Tq Z1 Z*,h*2 ]`*,/S ]`\ \-*D  ,bTYE \- -\,* f\h1E k\+ WpO /S 4Z*WS ]`*,/d ]`\ Zn\-\D L`\hSb*yb1 5 SY\eTq 6B7P9MD

The Complete Encyclopedia of Illustration/J. G. Heck

6D #\ h1V*2 Z* `1WT-Tp , Y*y+dbZn\YdH 

\- Z1 f\h1E *+S Wp/1y \+Y*Zp,*WS `1WT-T^E V\bO `T WSj1 4*q,WqpbnE k\ Wp+Wqbn y\-\E *W1 Z*a]`*,O /T 4Z1aW*,Wppbn y\-\D `SfSWnZSVS gSf `1WT-Ty ]`*-Zdbn +dbS /`d4qYS 4T a,Tb\YE qVSy ]1`1+d,*2 ]T/ ,W*/\p *b*ZS ˙Sq,\W* L)V\,* 8B8C 5 ı,*Z*  9B5=MD T+WTq Z*4S,*2 ]\,T2p daT `1WT-T^E V\b`T ,T/O /*ZT Wp/anVSY d`q/*YE * Z1 \-\,TD q aSY,\WThO Z* ]\,Tq Z*4,*Z* w*,SW\Z\Y 1WSVSYxD *V1 a*O Y1 TYGq Z\aSW\ ab*`\/*,Z2 YTab\E , qV\Yd ]TaWq a1a,TbZn\-\ ]\b\]d 4*`\/SW*an e*WnjS,* `1WT-TqD 1,/\,4T \- a]`\,*/Sbn `*]b\,1 4ZSk1ZZq Z* `1WT-TpE qV* \+Y*Zp2 T ]`S-Z\+Wp2 Wp/1yD L`\O hSb*yb1 +Gq,W1ZZq 5;B5E 6E 9E 5;C 5<B<E 67E 68MD 16  "

˙ 5 ) 6>56


7D )V \- ]\+W*-\aW\,Sbn daT Z*`\/SH 1,/\,4T \- dhSZSbn ad/ Z*/ e*WnjS,\p `1WTO  -T2pE T g1 ]`SZ1a1 ,aTY 4,TWnZ1ZZq ,T/ ^^ -ZTbdD  *WnjS,T `1WT-T^ ,31 ZTV\WS Z1 +d/dbn \+Y*Zp,*O bS y `\4/TWqbS Wp/ab,\D p/S +d/dbn \+G2/Z*Z\ aWd3SbS 2/SZ\Yd ]`*,/S,\Yd \-\,TD L`\hSb*yO  b1 覺a*^ 55B=C +Gq,W1ZZq 5<B6>E 65C 65B7E 8MD

8D #\ ]\,SZZT `\+SbS kS`T Wp/SH -\,* Z1 4*+d,*2 kS`Sf Wp/1yE qVT Z*W13*bn /\ e*WnjS,Sf `1WT-Ty a,TbdD 1]1` ,TZ 4+S`*2 b*VSf  Wp/1y b* \+G2/Zd2 , \/Zd \`-*ZT4*gTpE Z*,h*phS ^f ]`*,/SD L`\hSb*yb1 Sf1q 8B6E 9MD  -\,* ]`SyY*2 /\ a,\2^ `\/SZS ,aTfE fb\ f\h1 y\Yd aWd3SbSD \3WS,\E ,*jT /`d4T hS `\/ShT 4*O aYdh1ZT bSYE k\ ,S ]\h*WS aWd3SbS -\,TD `\b1 ,S \b`SYd2b1 +*-*b\ +W*-\aW\,1ZnB ,S 4/\+d,*2b1   /`d3+d 4 \-\YE ab*2b1 h*abSZ\p Z\,\^ /`d3Zn\^ `\/SZSD *V\3 ,S Y*2b1 Z*/Tp 3SbS ,ThZ\D L`\O hSb*yb1 *`V* 5>B6=E 7>C 6 \`SZeqZ :B5;E 5<MD



TWnj1 TZe\`Y*gT^ ,S 4Z*y/1b1  d 59OYd b* 5:OYd `\4/TW*f gT2^ VZS3VSD

ZS3V* \]d+WTV\,*Z* ,T/V*YS -\,SD



Z*a]`*,/T

& 覺 覺)H

17


ı ı) ˛ı( ˝ ) # ˙  j\bW*Z/1gn 4/\+d, V`*k\-\ 4* da]TjZd V*`G2`d +T4Z1aY1Z*H #\  /\]\Y\-W\ h\W\,TV\,T 4 `*4SWT^ ]\WSjSbS Z1Y\`*WnZSy a]\aT+ 3Sbbq T ]\`,*bS  4T 4,ShV\p Vd`SbS V\V*^Z wV`1VxH )V \/Z\Yd aW\,1Zg1,T ,/*W\aq VSZdbS  ]SqbSVdH `\hSb*yb1 ^fZT `\4]\,T/TD

w˝Sbbq ,S-Wq/*W\ hd/\,SYx

/,ThT \+G^f*, ,ab`*WTp Z* Y\b\gSVWT T 4/TyaZS, V`dO -\a,TbZp ]\/\`\3D ˝Sbbq ,S-Wq/*W\ hd/\,SYD

˙˝ ˚

ı ˙˝˚)B 5=9< ˙˚ ˙  )B "˙ı)   ˛ ˝ )B   ı" ı˛˚ ˚

 ˚D ) ,S`\ab*, d +*O -*bTy `\/SZTD *bnV\ +d, \eTg1O `\Y +`Sb*ZanV\^ *`YT^E b\Yd YS h*ab\ ]1`1^3/3*WS 4 YTagq Z* YTag1D `TY "\bW*Z/T^E YS 3SWS , Z-WT^E TY1hhSZTE 1ZT^E *W*y4T^E ı`W*Z/T^ T Z* T]`TD \WS Y1ZT +dW\ ,TaTY `\VT,E Y1Z1 ,T//*WS , jV\O WdOTZb1`Z*b d "\bW*Z/T^D ˛-\/\Y q 4*VTZO hS, 1Y+`S/3anVSy dZT,1`aSb1bD  6> `\VT, q ]\h*, 4*yY*bSaq +T4Z1a\YE ]\,Gq4*ZSY 4 Z*eb\pD ]1`jd ]`*gp,*, d T,/1ZZTy Y1`SgTE ]\bTY , e`SgT b* 4`1jb\p d ˛*fT/ZTy ,ab`*WT^D 1 b`S,*O W\ ,TaTY `\VT,D ,ab`*WT^ q 4*aZd,*, TZO ,1abSgTyZd V\Y]*ZTpE qVd 4-\/\Y ]`\/*,D ) Y*, abTWnVS -`\j1yE k\ ,31 , 8> `\O VT, 4YT- ,SybS Z* ]1ZaTpD ˛Gq,SW\an +*-*O b\ ,TWnZ\-\ h*adE b\3 q ab*, Y*Z/`d,*bSB 18  "

˙ 5 ) 6>56

) ıı) ˛ı  ˝ )D #1 ]1`1/ ,Sf\/\Y Z* ]1ZaTp q f\bT, qV\an ]\/qVd,*bS \-\,T 4* a,\2 3SbbqD \Yd ]\h*, f\/SbS /\ *Z-WTV*ZanV\^ g1`V,SE qV g1 +dW\ k1 , /SbSZab,TD W1 , g1`V,T Y*y31 Z1 Z*,h*O WS T+WT^D \bTY q Z*,h*,O aq d Y\`Y\ZT,E *W1 Y1Z1 ,T/O jb\,fZdW\ b1E k\ ,\ZS Y*W\ ]\VW*/*WSan Z* T+WTpD /Z\-\ `*4d /\ Y\^f /,1O `1y ]\abdV*WS ,T/VS -\,SD ) ,T/`*4d ]\+*hS,E k\ a,\^ ,h1ZZq ,\ZS +*4dpbn Z* T+WT^D ,T/VS ]\V*4*WS Y1ZT d`S,\V 4 5 SY\eTq 6B7E 8D  gSf ,T`j*f aV*4*Z\E k\ \3* ,\Wq ]\Wq-*2 , b\YdE *+S wdaTWqVT Wp/S a]*aWSaq T Z*+dWS b\hO Z\-\ 4Z*ZZq ]`*,/SxD 1ZT a]\/\+*W\an b1E k\ ,T/VS 4,1`b*WS d,*-d Z1 ]`\ab\ Z* ]\O b`1+d Y*bS 4Z*ZZq 4 T+WT^E * Z* ]\b`1+d Y*bS b\hZ1 4Z*ZZqD ˛*,/qVS ,S,h1ZZp T+WT^ 4T ,T/V*O YS q 4/\+d, b*V1 b\hZ1 4Z*ZZqD *]`SVO W*/E /\,T/*,aqE k\ \- b* ıada P g1 /,T \V`1YT \a\+SE * Z1 h*abSZ* b*2YZSh\^ `TygT Lı,*Z* 58B6<C 5 \`SZeqZ 55B7MD ) ]\+*hS,E k\ +T+WTyZ* ]`*,/* P W\-ThZ*


T ]`\ab*D dW\ jV\/*E k\ q 4Y*`Zd,*, abTWnVS h*ad T aSWE Z*Y*-*phSan 4`\4dYTO bS Z14`\4dYTW1D ˛ h*a\Y q ]\h*, ]`Sf\/SbS Z* 4T+`*ZZq ,T/VT, -\,SD 1Z1 4*f\]Wp,*W* /`dO 31Wp+ZTabn T ]\,1/TZV* V\3Z\-\ ,T/O V*E 4/*,*W\anE k\ ,\ZS a,qbTD *h*hS ^fO Zp kS`d Wp+\,E q 4`\4dYT,E k\ 4Z*yj\, ]`*,/S,d `1WT-Tp Lı,*Z* 57B79MD )• ˝  )  D 1,/\,O 4T ]TaWq a,\-\ f`1k1ZZq q 4dab`T, hd/\O ,d 3TZVdE Z* TYGq ˙T*Z*D \Z* ,S`\ab*W* , `\/SZT ,T/VT, -\,SE b\Yd Y*W* +*-*b\ ]`S,*+WS,Sf `SaD S \/`d3SWSanD ˙T*O Z* ab*W* /Wq Y1Z1 ,T`ZSY /`d-\Y T ]T/O b`SYV\p P g1 a]`*,3Z2 +W*-\aW\,1ZZq ,T/ -\,SD

˛-\/\Y d Z*a 4Gq,SW\aq +*3*ZZq ]1`1^O f*bS d b1`Sb\`TpE /1 2 +TWnj* ]\b`1+* , ]`\]\,T/ZSV*f /\+`\^ Z\,SZS 4 T+WT^D  6>5> `\gT YS ]1`1^f*WS /\ 1WT4dE k\ , 1Zb`*WnZTy Y1`SgTD db YS aWd3SY\ Wp/qYE qVT Wp+Wqbn \-* T ]`*-Zdbn +T+O WTyZSf 4Z*ZnD `*,/* ]`\ \-* T y\-\ W\,\E T+WTpE ]`SZ1aW* Y1ZT /dj1,ZSy YS`D TWnjTabn a,\-\ ,TWnZ\-\ h*ad q ]`Sa,qhdp b\YdE k\+ ]`\]\,T/d,*bS T Z*,h*bS +T+WTyZSf TabSZ +*-*bn\f Wp/1yD ˙d31 ]`S2YZ\ +*O hSbSE qV +T+WTyZ* ]`*,/* 4YTZp2 Z* V`*O k1 3Sbbq TZjSfE b*V qV g1 +dW\ 4T YZ\pD ) 4Z*yj\, Z*yV`*kSy a]\aT+ ,Sq,SbS a,\p ,/qhZTabn \-\,T 4* 3SbbqE qV1 ,TZ Y1ZT /*,D

2YD ˛ h*a\Y q ]\h*, 4*yY*O bSan a1Va\Y 4 h\W\,TV*YSD pZ*gnV\Yd ,TgT q h*aO b\ jdV*, a\+T a1Vad*WnO ZSf ]*`bZ1`T,E qV 3TZ\VE b*V T h\W\,TVT,E /1 bTWnO VS Y\3Z* +dW\EP d +*`*fE ZThZSf VWd+*f T Z*,Tbn d g1`V,*fD  ]1`T\/ V*`Z*O ,*Wd q \/q-*,aq qV 3TZO V* T b*Zgp,*, 4T jV\W*YS a*Y+SD ˙\ Y1Z1 ]`SyjW* ]\]dWq`ZTabnD 1`1/ Y\^f /`d4T, +dWS -1^E ]`\abSbdbVSE Z*`V\Y*O ZSD ˙1fb\ ]`S\f\bS, Y1Z1 /\ V\V*^Zd wV`1VxE b\3 /\O aSbn j,S/V\ q ab*, Z*`V\O Y*Z\YD ıZV\WS YS 4 /`d4qO YS Vd`SWS b`*,ShVd gTWd ZThE * TZV\WS q `\+S, g1 Z* a*Y\bT ,]`\/\,3 gTW\-\ /ZqD ) b*V 4Y*`ZT,E k\ ]TjW* ]\-\W\aO V*E ZT+S , Y1Z1  ı˙D

w\ZS +dWS /d31 /\+`T /\ Y1Z1x ı ı ˝

ı ˙˝˚)B 5=:; ˙˚ ˙  )B ˛ı)   ˛ ˝ )B ı ˛  ˚ ˝)

 ˚D ) ,S`\ab*, d `\+TbZSh\Yd YTabT ,*`1 Ljb*b *ZO*dWdMD *bnV\ ]\Y1`E V\WS Y*O Y* +dW* ,*-TbZ* YZ\pD ˙SbSZ\pE V\WS Y*YS Z1 +dW\ ,/\Y*E q Wp+S, \/q-*bS ^^ ]W*bbqD  Y1Z1 `\4,SZdWSan 3TZ\hT Y*Z1`SE T Wp/S ab*WS ,,*3*bS Y1Z1 -1O

 " ˙ 5 ) 6>56

19


) ıı) ˛ı  ˝ )D `SO +WS4Z\ , b\y h*a q ]\4Z*y\YS,aq 4T ,T/V*YS -\,SD \ZS +dWS /d31 /\+`T /\ Y1Z1D ,T/VS ]`\hSb*WS Y1ZT 4 T+WT^ SYWqZ 5>B57B w \31ZE fb\ VWSh1 TYGq -\,SE +d/1 a]*a1ZZSyxD ) 4`\4dYT,E qV ,*3WS,\ ,3S,*bS TYGq -\,SD ˙d31 h*aO b\E ]TaWq Z\hT 4 Z*`V\bSV*YSE q ,T/hSO Zq, ,TVZ\E /S,S,aq Z* Z1+\ T 4T aWn\4*O YS Z* \h*f +W*-*, d -\,S /\]\Y\-SD *Y* /d31 ]1`13S,*W*E k\ q `dyZdp a,\2 3SbbqD 1ZT +dW\ ^^ jV\/*E b\Yd q ,S`TjS, ]\`,*bS 4 Z*`V\Y*ZT2pD TaWq gn\-\ ]\-\/S,aq ,S,h*bS 4T ,T/V*YS T+WTpD \ZS 4*]1,ZSWSE k\ b*V1 ,SO ,h1ZZq /\]\Y\31 Y1ZT d +\`\bn+T 4 Y\O 2p 4*W13ZTabpD \ZS Y*WS `*gTpI S,h*phS T+WTpE q 4`\4dYT, P b`1+* 4YTZp,*bS a,Ty a]\aT+ 3SbbqD a\+WSO ,\ ,*3V\ +dW\ ]\`,*bS 4 -\Y\a1Vad*O WT4Y\YE \aVTWnVS g1 +dW\ Z1,T/G2YZ\p h*abSZ\p Y\-\ 3Sbbq 4 pZSf WTbD ˙Wq gn\-\ q 4YTZS, b\,*`Sab,\B ]1`1ab*, a]TWVd,*bSaq 4 w/`d4qYSx b* f\/SbS ]\ +*`*f T ZThZSf VWd+*fD

w) P +14/\ZZ* +\hV*x  "

ı ˙˝˚)B 5=;9 ˙˚ ˙  )B ˚ı)   ˛ ˝ )B )

20

˛`\+SbS b*VT 4YTZS +dW\ Z1W1-V\E *W1 q 4Z*,E k\ -\,* bd`+d2bnaq YZ\p b* `\4dYT2 Y1Z1E T g1 /\/*,*W\ aSW L5 ı,*O Z* 7B5=E 6>MD  6>>6 `\gT q ,31 Z1 Y*, 3\/ZSf -\Y\a1Vad*WnZSf 4,Gq4VT,D \O -\ 3 `\Vd q \f`1abS,aq T ab*, ,T/V\Y -\,SD )• ˝  )  D 1E k\ q Z*abTWnVS 4YTZS,aqE /d31 4,\`djSW\ Y*YdE T ,\Z* b13 ]\h*W* ,S,h*bS T+O WTpD * 3*WnE d Z1^ b`*]S,aq TZadWnbD * ,a1 3 ,\Z* y /*WT `\4,S,*W* Wp+\, /\ -\,S b* +T+WTyZ\^ ]`*,/SD 31 ,TaTY `\VT, q aWd3d -\,T ]\,Z\O h*aZ\E b\+b\ +TWnjTabn ,TWnZ\-\ h*ad ]`Sa,qhdp ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZp ]`*,/S TZO jSYD djd ,S4Z*bSE k\ TZV\WS /\,\O /Sbnaq +\`\bSaq 4 Z1]`*,SWnZSYS +*O 3*ZZqYSD W1 Y1Z1 4YTgZq2 /dYV* ]`\ b1E k\E Z1 ]T//*,jSan b*VSY +*3*ZZqYE q ]\bTj*p a1`g1 -\,SD ˛*,/qVS +WS4nVSY ab\adZV*Y 4 -\O ,\p T ]\+\3ZTy ]\,1/TZgT 4`\ab*2 Y\q a*Y\]\,*-*D SZT q k*aWS,* Wp/SZ*D

 ˚D ) Z*`\/S,O aq , p+WqZTE ab\WSgT W\,1ZT ^D ˙\ h\bS`n\f `\VT, Y\2 /SbSZab,\ +dW\ +14bd`+\bZSYD ı b\/T ab*O W*aq b`*-1/Tq P +*bnV\ Z*VW*, Z* a1+1 `dVSD TaO Wq gn\-\ Y*Y* +dW* 4YdO j1Z* +*-*b\ ]`*gp,*bSE k\+ ]`\-\/d,*bS Y1Z1 4T ab*`jSY +`*b\YD  59 `\VT, q ]1`1^f*, /\ +*+daTD 1ZT ]\/\+*O W\an d Z1^E +\ ]\ adaT/abO


,d 3SW\ +*-*b\ Y\^f /`d4T,D ) b*V\3 Y*, +TWnj1 a,\+\/SE ZT3 d/\Y*D \WS ,S]\,ZSW\aq 5:E q 4,Gq4*,aq 4 fW\]O gqYSE qVT Z*]S,*WSaq d ,SfT/ZTD ) 4*]dabS, /\,-1 ,\W\aaqE ,/q-*,aq qV +dZb*` T ]\h*, Vd`SbSD ) ]1`1]`\+d,*, `T4ZT Z*`V\bSVSE *W1 Z*y+TWnj1 Wp+S, ,S]SbSD ]\O h*bVd ,S]S,*, VTWnV* V1WSfT, ,SZ*E *W1 4 h*a\Y ]\h*, ,S]S,*bS +TWnj1 ZT3 ]WqjVd Z* `*4D ) Z*,hS,aq ,YTW\ ]`Sf\,d,*bS a]GqZTZZqD 1`T/V\ WSO j1 4*]*f *WV\-\Wp ,S/*,*,E k\ q ]GqZSyE *W1 ZTfb\ Z*,Tbn Z1 4/\-*/dO ,*,aqE k\ q ,S]S, VTWnV* WTb`T, ,SO Z* hS ]S,*E 4YTj*,jS g1 4 -\`TWV\pD ˙d31 h*ab\E ]TaWq Z\hT Z* /SaV\b1O gTE q /\]\Y*-*, /`d4qY ab\qbS Z* Z\O -*fE f\h* a*Y ,S]S,*, d/,ThT +TWnj1 4* ZSfD )V\an \/SZ ]`Sqb1Wn aV*4*,E k\ q P +14/\ZZ* +\hV*D ˙Wq aW\,1ZO gq g1 4,dhSbn \+`*4WS,\E \aVTWnVS ab\ad2bnaq b\-\E fb\ a]`\Y\3ZSy ]1O `1]SbS TZjSfD •\-\ aW\,* 4*h1]SWS Y1Z1 4* 3S,1D ) ]\h*, 4*/dYd,*bSan Z*/ a,\^Y 3SbbqYD 1Z1 ]`\yY*W\ ]\hdbbq ZTVO h1YZ\abTE 4/*,*W\anE k\ 3Sbbq ZTh\O -\ Z1 ,*`b1D ) ıı) ˛ı  ˝ )D `SO +WS4Z\ b\-\ 3 h*ad q ]\YTbS,E k\ \/SZ YTy \/Z\VW*aZSV /d31 4YTZS,O aq P ab*, W*-T/ZTjSYD ) ,S`TjS, /\O ‹ ,T/*bSaqE k\ 4 ZSY b`*]SW\anE b\Yd 4*]`\aS, y\-\ , V*e1D TZ ]\qaO ZS,E k\ ,S,h*2 T+WTp 4T ,T/V*YS

-\,SE T `\4]\,T, b1E ]`\ k\ Z*,h*,O aqD a1 g1 +dW\ 4\,aTY Z\,SY /Wq Y1O Z1 P b*V\-\ /*W1V\-\ ,T/ `1WT-T^D ) ]\h*, ]`Sf\/SbS Z* 4T+`*ZZq ,T/VT, T ]\-\/S,aq ,S,h*bS T+WTpD S,h1ZZq T+WT^ ,T/V`SW\ Y1ZT \hTE T q 4+*-Zd, +*-*b\ TabSZE V\b`T a]\ZdO V*WS 4YTZSbS a,\2 3SbbqD *]`SVO W*/E q /\,T/*,aqE k\ YS 3S,1Y\ , w\ab*ZZT /ZTx L6 SY\eTq 7B5P9MD TO jSW\ b1E k\ \- Z1,/\,4T dadZ1 4 41YO WT 4WSf Wp/1yE * ]\VT`ZSY /*abn 4Y\O -d 3SbS ,ThZ\ , `*p La*W\Y 7;B6=MD ˙d31 4*f\bTW\aq 4YTZSbS a,\2 3SbO bqE k\+ +dbS a1`1/ ]\VT`ZSf Wp/1yD ) ]\h*, `\4]\,T/*bS /`d4qY ]`\ +T+WTyZT TabSZSE qVSf Z*,h*,aqD TWnO jTabn 4 ZSf aYTqW*aqE *W1 b*V* `1*VO gTq /\]\Y\-W* Y1ZT ]\+*hSbSE k\ ,\O ZS Z1 +dWS a]`*,3ZTYS /`d4qYSD ) 4`\4dYT,E k\ /\ ]Sqgb,* Y1Z1 afSWqO WS a*Y1 ,\ZSB gTWSy bS3/1Zn ,\ZS h1V*WS ,SfT/ZSfE k\+ 4Z\,d Z*]SO bSaqD ) `\4T`,*, daT ab\adZVS 4 /`d4qYS T 4Z*yj\, Z\,Sf a1`1/ ,T/VT, -\,SE qVT ab*WS /Wq Y1Z1 ,1WSVSY ]T/+*O /n\`1ZZqYD \ZS kS`\ Wp+SWS \-* y Z*Y*-*WSaq 3SbS 4* y\-\ Z\`Y*YSD \abd]\,\ q ]\4+d,aq 4,ShVS ]SqO hSbSD )• ˝  )  D ) ,/qhO ZSy -\,TE k\ +TWnj1 Z1 ]\b`1+dp *WO V\-\WpE *+S ]\hd,*bSaq k*aWS,SYD

1 4Z*pE k\ +dW\ + 4T YZ\pE qV+S ,h*aZ\ Z1 4d]SZS,aqD ) ]1`1V\Z*ZSyE k\ b1]1` Y\2 3Sbbq Y*2 4YTabD an d31 aTY `\VT, q aWd3d d eTWT*O WT ,T/VT, -\,S , W\,1ZT^D 1E k\ q ]T4Z*, -\,d T ,SV\Zdp y\-\ ,\WpE a]\,Zp2 3Sbbq a]`*,3ZTY a1Za\YD  " ˙ 5 ) 6>56

21


 ı ˛ (& S `*ZZT f`SabSqZS +`*WS dh*abn d ]\WTbShZSf a]`*,*fH  ˇ 1`1/ ,\4Z1aTZZqY d Z1+\ ıada /*, a,\^Y dhO ZqY hTbVT ,V*4T,VS k\/\ b\-\E qV ,SV\Zd,*bS  /\`dh1Z1 ^Y aWd3TZZqD `\b1 ,TZ ZTh\-\ Z1 4-*O /*, ]`\ dh*abn d ]\WTbShZSf a]`*,*f L*bO ,Tq 6<B5<P6>MD \Yd dhZT ıada* /\b`SYd,*O WSaq aWT,E aV*4*ZSf ZSY `*ZTj1B wT//*,*yb1 V1a*`1,1 V1a*`pE * \31 P \-\,Tx L*`V* 56B5;MD )V g1y ]`SZgS] /\]\Y*-*, ıada\,SY ]\aWTO /\,ZSV*Y 3SbS d a,TbTE *W1 Z1 +dbS y\-\ h*abSO ‹ Z\pH S ,\ZS Y\-WS `\4`T4ZqbSE k\ Z*W13Sbn ‹ /1`3*,TE b\+b\ V1a*`pE * k\ P \-\,TH ]\ab\W *,W\ ,,*3*,E k\ f`SabSqZSZ Z1 ]\O ,SZ1Z 4*yY*bSaq ]\WTbShZSYS a]`*,*YSD  \/O ZTy VZS3gT aV*4*Z\B w*,W\ +d, -\b\,Sy ,SV\O `Sab*bS a,\2 ]`*,\ `SYanV\-\ -`\Y*/qZSZ*E k\+ 4*fSk*bSaq , ad/TE *W1 ,TZ Z1 Z*Y*-*,aq ,]WS,*bS Z* a]`*,SE ]\,Gq4*ZT 4 /1`3*,Z\p ]\O WTbSV\px LwBeyond Good IntentionsPA Biblical View of PoliticsxMD #\ *,W\ ]\`*/S, \/Z\,T`gqYH  gTy 31 VZS3gT Z*]Sa*Z\B w•\-\ WSabS /\ ,T`dphSf d b*O VSf ,*3WS,Sf YTab*fE qV \`SZeE ˚e1a T Z*,Tbn SYE Z1 YTabSWS 3\/Z\-\ Z*bqVd Z* 4*gTV*,W1ZO Zq ]\WTbShZSYS ad]1`1hV*YS a,TbdDDD *,W\ Z*O  V*4d,*, V\`SbSaq d`q/\,TE *W1 d a,\^f WSab*f Z1 /*,*, ,V*4T,\V 3\/ZTy YTag1,Ty g1`V,T +\/*y

qV\an ,]WS,*bS Z* -`\Y*/anVT hS /1`3*,ZT daO b*Z\,Sx LSYWqZ 56B5<C 57B5E 9P;MD `SabSqZSE qVT 3SWS VTWnV* /1aqbS`Th ]TaWq aY1`bT *,W*E b*V a*Y\ hTbV\ `\4`T4ZqWS b1E k\ Z*W13Sbn \-\,TE ,T/ b\-\E k\ Z*W13Sbn /1`O  3*,TD \ZS ,Sq,WqWS ]\,*-d /\ ]\WTbShZ\^ ,W*O /SE *W1 Z1 +*3*WS +`*bS dh*abn d ]\WTbShZTy /TO qWnZ\abTD  ,Sk14-*/*ZTy VZS3gT 4*4Z*h*2bnaqB w\h* `*ZZT f`SabSqZS ,,*3*WSE k\ 4\+\,Gq4*O ZT ]\,*3*bS /1`3*,Zd ,W*/dE ,\ZS Z1 ]\-\O  /3d,*WSaq 4 bSYE *+S ^f 4*Wdh*WS , ]\WTbShZT a]`*,SxD  `S+WS4Z\ h1`14 7>> `\VT, ]TaWq ıada\,\^ aY1`bT d f`SabSqZab,T +*-*b\ k\ 4YTZSW\aqD  VZS3gT wT3 `Sab\Y T V1a*`1Yx \/SZ b1\W\Z*]Sa*,B w \WS 4* h*ad \Zab*ZbSZ* +d, 4YTZ1O ZSy ]\WTbShZSy W*/E +*-*b\ f`SabSqZ ]\h*W\ +`*bS dh*abn d gS,TWnZTy b* ,TyanV\,Ty aWd3+TE * b*V\3 4*yY*bS ]\WTbShZT ]\a*/SxD ˙\ h\-\ g1 ]`S4,1W\H T/ VTZ1gn IV ab\`Thhq b*V* adYTj  `1WT-T^ b* ]\WTbSVS ]\`\/SW* /1`3*,Zd `1WT-Tp   SYanV\^ TY]1`T^D SZT hSY*W\ `1WT-TyE qVT b,1`/qbnE k\ y/dbn  4* `Sab\YE 4*\f\hdpbn a,\^f ,T`ZSf 4*yY*bSO  aq ]\WTbShZSYS a]`*,*YSD W1 gT `1WT-T^ Z1 Z*O aWT/dpbn `Sab* T Z1 /\b`SYdpbnaq ]`SVW*/d f`SabSqZ ]1`j\-\ ab\`ThhqD


 ˛˚H #\ b*V1 wad/\,1 aS/TZZqxE /\ qV\-\ ]\,1WS *]\ab\W* *,W*H

ˇ  ˙T^ 5<B56E 57 `\4]\,T/*2bnaqE qV

 V\`SZeanVT p/1^ 4,SZd,*bSWS *,W*  , Z14*V\ZZ\Yd ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZT TZj\^ ,T`S T ]\,1WS y\-\ /\ wad/\,\-\ aSO /TZZqxE *+\ +1Y* L-`1gnV1 aW\,\E qV1 \4Z*h*2 w]T/,Sk1ZZqxMD  /*,Zn\O Yd \`SZeTE +TWq g1Zb`d *-\`S L`SZO VdME Y\3WS,\ Z1]\/*WTV aSZ*-\-SE +dO W\ ]T/,Sk1ZZq ]`\ab\ Z1+*D ˛*,/qVS b*V\Yd `\4b*jd,*ZZp 4 gn\-\ ]T/O ,Sk1ZZq Y\3Z* +dW\ 4,1`b*bSaq /\ ,1WSVSf Z*b\,]T, Z*`\/dD q ]W*bO e\`Y* 4 +W*VSbZ\-\ T +TW\-\ Y*`YdO `d +dW* `qaZ\ \4/\+W1Z* ,Sb\Zh1ZSY `T4n+W1ZZqYD `S ZTy +dWS /,T VTYZ*O  bS /Wq \hTVd,*ZZq 4 Y\4*^hZ\p ]T/W\O -\p b* Y*`Yd`\,SYS W*,V*YSD W*be\`Y*E \h1,S/Z\E y +dW* adO /\,SY aS/TZZqYE /1 *]\ab\W *,W\

ab\q, ]1`1/ ]`\V\ZadW\Y *WWT\Z\YE  `SYanVSY ]`*,Sb1W1Y f*^D ˛ gn\-\ ]T/,Sk1ZZq d`q/\,gT `\4-Wq/*WS adO /\,T a]`*,S T ]`SWp/Z\ ,SZ\aSWS ,SO `\VSD  -`1gnVSf YTab*fO/1`3*,*f Z*O `\/ZT 4+\`S 4*4,Sh*y ]`\,\/SWSaq ]1`1/ b*VSY ]T/,Sk1ZZqYE /1 ,S`TO jd,*WSaq ,aT YTanVT a]`*,SD  `\4]\O ,T/T ]`\ ad/ Z*/ ıada\Y d *b,Tq 6;B5= b* ı,*Z* 5=B57 Ld -`1gnV\Yd b1VabTM -\,\`SbnaqE k\ \ZbTy SW*b ]`\Y\,Wq, /\ Z*b\,]d 4T a,\-\ ]T/,SO  k1ZZq P +1YS L˙T^ 56B65MD

\Yd a]\aT+E , qVSy ab`*bSWS ıada*E ab*, /Wq /1V\b`Sf p/1^, V*Y1Z1Y a]\bSV*ZZqH

ˇ `\ `*ZZTf f`SabSqZ *]\ab\W *,O W\ Z*]Sa*,B wS ]`\]\,T/d2Y\ `SaO b*E qVSy +d, ]`S+SbSy /\ ab\,]*D ˙Wq  p/1^, ,TZ ab*, V*Y1Z1Y a]\bSV*ZZqE * /Wq Wp/1y 4 TZjSf Z*`\/T, P +14O -Wd4/qYx L5 \`SZeqZ 5B67MD \Yd a]\aT+E , qVSy ab`*bSWS ıada*E ab*, /Wq /1V\-\ V*Y1Z1Y a]\bSV*ZZqH \,\`qhS ]`\ a]\aT+ ab`*bS ıadO a* T ]`\ VdWnbd`d WS4nV\-\ f\/d  ]1`j\-\ ab\`ThhqE +T+W1^ab 1Z Tb1O `TZ-b\Z 4*4Z*h*2E k\ g1 +dW* wZ*yO -*Z1+ZTj* aY1`bn d b\y h*aD *O V* Ydh1ZSgnV* aY1`bn ,,*3*W*aq Z1aW*,\pxD Tb1`TZ-b\Z ]`\/\,3d2B

wp/S ,T`SWSE k\ b1E qV Wp/SZ* ]\O YS`*W*E ,Sq,WqW\E qV\p ,\Z* +dW*D \Yd ıada* Y\-WS ,,*3*bS Z1-T/ZSO V\YE 4`*/ZSV\Y /1`3*,SE h\W\,TV\YE qVSy 4*aWd-\,d2 ]\V*`*ZZqE ]`S4Z*O h1Z\-\ /Wq `*+T,O+dZbT,ZSVT,xD ˛ \-O Wq/d Z* g1 Z1`\4ad/WS,\ ]`S]daV*bSE ZT+S `*ZZT f`SabSqZS Y\-WS ,S-*/*bS \]\,T/n ]`\ ıada\,d aY1`bn T ,\aV`1O aTZZqD

 " ˙ 5 ) 6>56

23


 hdaq 4 T+WT^

4,T`qb

Sf daTf \- d`qbd,*,D

YdE

b\ 4 ZSf V*31 fb\ 4 ZSf V*31

-*,H


˚• ı ı ˙  )   ˙ 7 ˙

\y 4`\+S,

V\,h1/Wq 4,T`qb \gSfE

k\+S ZSZT YS

4Z*WS b13 ]`\ ZSfD dbbq ;B;P5>C <B59P5; ˛˙)

\V*3S Z* Y*WpZVdB

\,h11/Y1/SV* W\ZSV* ˝S`*ed *,]\hVd \`\aqbV\ ˛1+`d 1a1WVd

1aSV* 1,* ,1hVd ˙1`1,\

)V -\,\`SbnB 1aSV 1, \`\aqbV\ ,1hV*

*,]\hV* 25


*j1 Y*y+dbZ2 d ,*jSf `dV*f ˙) a]`*,3Zn\-\ da]Tfd , 3SbbTH  gn\Yd /\]\Y\31 ,W*abS,* Wp/SZT 4/*bZTabn ]1`1/+*h*bS Y\3WS,T /*W1V\aq3ZT Z*aWT/VS a,\^f `Tj1ZnD ˛,Sh*yZ\E ]`SyY*bS `Tj1ZZqE V\b`T ]`SO Z1adbn /\+`T `14dWnb*bS , Y*y+dbZn\YdE Z1W1-V\E */31 ZSZT +TWnjTabn Wp/1y 3S,1 4* ]`SZgS]\YB ,a1 y \/`*4dD SE Z*]1,Z1E ]\-\/Sb1anE k\ +T+WTyZT ]\`*/S Y\3dbn /\]\Y\-bS ,*Y `\4,SZdbS bTaZT `\/SZZT ab\adZVS L˚e1aqZ 9B66P:B8MD W1 /Wq gn\O -\ ]\b`T+Z\ `1-dWq`Z\ ,S/TWqbS h*a /Wq `T/ZSf T Z1 /\4,\WqbSE k\+ ,*a ]\-WSZdO W* `\+\b*E ,T/]\hSZ\V hS `\4,*-SD #\O /\ `\/SZSE qV T , +*-*bn\f TZjSf ae1O `*f 3SbbqE ,*Y /\,\/Sbnaq ,S+S`*bS YT3 bSYh*a\,\p Z*a\W\/\p T /\,-\b`S,*WSY da]Tf\YD #\ /\]\Y\31 `\+SbS ]`*,SWnO ZSy ,S+T`H \4-WqZnY\ h\bS`S ]\`*/SD

)

5D q,Wqyb1 `14dWnb*bS a,\^f `Tj1Zn \WS b`1+* ]`SyY*bS `Tj1ZZqE dq,WqyO b1 qV\Y\-* `1*WTabShZTj1 y\-\ Z*aWT/VSD T+WTq -\,\`SbnB wd/`Sy +*hSbn WSf1 P T f\,*2bnaqx L`S]\,Tab1y 66B7MD )Vk\ ,S Z1d]1`1/31Z\ ]\/S,Sb1an Z* Y\3WS,T Z*aWT/VSE b\E Z*]1,Z1E +d/1b1 dZSV*bS ]\b1ZgTyZSf Z1+14]1VD ˛ TZj\-\ +\VdE dqO ,S,jS a\+T f\`\jT Z*aWT/VS Yd/`\-\ `TO j1ZZqE ,S +d/1b1 /TqbS +TWnj `Tjdh1D ˛*]Sb*yb1 a1+1B w)V g1 `TO j1ZZq ,]WS,*bSY1 Z* Y1Z1 h1O `14 `TVE 5> hS 6> `\VT,H )V ,\O Z\ ,]WSZ1 Z* YTy 1Y\gTyZSy b* eT4ShZSy ab*ZH )V YTy ,S+T` ]\4Z*hSbnaq Z* aTYG^ b* TZjSf +WS4nVSf Y1ZT Wp/qfHx W1 ]1`1/daTY 4*]Sb*yb1 a1+1B w S 26  "

˙ 5 ) 6>56

Y\2 `Tj1ZZq a]\/\+*2bnaq \-\,TH )V ,\O Z\ ,]WSZ1 Z* Y\^ ab\adZVS 4 ZSYHx aO VTWnVS T+WTq Z*bfZ1Z* \-\YE ,\Z* /\O ‹ ]\Y\31 ,*Y 4`\4dYTbSE k\ ]\/\+*2bnaq y\YdE T 4*ab1`131 ,T/ Y\3WS,Sf ]*ab\V L`S]\,Tab1y 58B56C 6 SY\eTq 7B5:MD

6D \+Tbn ,W*aZSy ,S+T`

SY*W\ Wp/1y d ]`SyZqbbT `Tj1Zn \`TO 2Zbdpbnaq Z* /dYVd TZjSfD W1 ]1,ZSy a]\aT+ 3Sbbq Z1 ]`SZ1a1 ,*Y k*abq ]`\aO b\ b\YdE k\ ,TZ 2 ]\]dWq`ZSYD \+Tbn ,W*aZSy ,S+T`D an ]`SVW*/ *b*WT1D \O Z* `\4]\,T/*2B w) Y`TqW* ]`\ k*aWS,1 ]\/`d3Z2 3SbbqD W1 4`\4dYTW*E k\ h1O `14 a,Ty a]\aT+ 3Sbbq d Y1Z1 ZTV\WS Z1 +d/1 Z\`Y*WnZ\-\ ]\/`d33qD  V\W1/3T ,aT Y\^ /`d4T +dWS /d31 `\4dYZSYSE \/O Z*V ]\abTyZ\ ]`SyY*WS Z1`\4ad/WS,T `TO j1ZZq , \a\+Sab\Yd 3SbbTD \ZS h*ab\ YTZqWS bSfE 4 VSY f\/SWS Z* ]\+*h1ZZqD  Y1Z1 b13 +dW\ VTWnV* fW\]gT,D *VSy a]\aT+ 3Sbbq 4*,/*, Y1ZT -WS+\VSf 1Y\O gTyZSf `*ZxD

*b*Wq ]\h*W* ,S,h*bS T+WTp 4T ,T/O V*YS -\,SD \Z* ]`S-*/d2B w1`1/ ,T/O VT, q +*hSW* k*aWS,Sf Y\W\/Sf Wp/1y T hd/\,T ]\/`d33qD ) ]\abd]\,\ 4YTZSO W* a,Ty ]\-Wq/ Z* 3Sbbq T ]1`1-WqZdW* a,\^ gTZZ\abTE f\h* g1 +dW\ Z1W1-V\xD #\ g1 ]`SZ1aW\ *b*WTH w) 4*,3/S ]`*-O ZdW* \/`d3SbSaq 4 Wp/SZ\pE qVd /d31 gTZd,*W* +EP `\4]\O ,T/*2 *b*WqDP ˛-\/\Y q ,SO yjW* 4*YT3 4* h\W\,TV*E qVSy ]\/TWq, Y\^ `1WT-TyZT ]1`1V\O Z*ZZqD \- ]\/*`d,*, Y1ZT b*O V1 aTY1yZ1 3SbbqE ]`\ qV1 q Z*O ,Tbn Z1 Y`TqW*xD 1 ıY1Z* , ab*bbT 4YTZ1Z\D


7D d/nb1 /*W1V\-Wq/ZSYS ZSV*yb1 Z1/*W1V\-Wq/Z\-\ YSaW1ZZqE * ab*`*yb1an hTbV\ `\4dYTbSE h\-\ ,S a]\O /T,*2b1an ,T/ Y*y+dbZn\-\E T ]W*Zd,*bS V`\VS /Wq y\-\ /\aq-Z1ZZq L`S]\,Tab1y 65B9MD 1 \+Y13dyb1an d a,\^f ]W*Z*f WSO j1 ;> hS <> `\V*YSE b\+b\ /\,3SZ\p Wp/O anV\-\ 3SbbqD q,Wqyb1 a1+1 , /*W1V\Yd Y*y+dbZn\YdE V\WSE qV \+Tgq2 \31 W\O ,\E Wp/S 3SbSYdbn ,ThZ\D T+WTq ]\qaZp2E k\ 4*,/qVS ,SVd]O ZTy 31`b,T ıada* `Sab* \- /*abn WpO /qY Y\3WS,Tabn \b`SY*bS ,ThZ1 3Sbbq L*b,Tq 6>B6<C SYWqZ :B67MD \- \+Tgq2E k\ Z1,/\,4T ,SV\Z*2bnaq y\-\ ]\h*bO V\,Sy Z*YT` ab\a\,Z\ Wp/ab,* y 41YWTD \yE fb\ Wp+Sbn \-*E Y*bSO Y1 Z*-\/d 3SbS ,ThZ\ Z* ,T/O Z\,W1ZTy `*yanVTy 41YWT La*O W\Y 7;B55C +Gq,W1ZZq 65B7P9MD S Y\31b1 +dbS b*YE qVk\ ,31 b1]1` ab*`*2b1an +dbS /*W1V\-O Wq/ZSYSD

8D *Y*-*yb1an /\aq-*bS ]\ab*,W1ZSf gTW1y #\ b`1+* `\+SbSE *+S /\aq-bS gn\O -\ \+TgqZ\-\ Y*y+dbZn\-\H 1`1/daTY Z1O \+fT/Z\ 4/\+d,*bS 4Z*ZZq ]`\ \-* Lı,*O Z* 5;B7MD \hZ1 +T+WTyZ1 4Z*ZZq /\/*abn ,*Y d]1,Z1Z\abT , b\YdE k\ \3T \+TbZSO gT k\/\ Y*y+dbZn\-\ \+\,Gq4V\,\ ,SV\O Z*pbnaqD *V* ,T`* Y\31 /\]\Y\-bS ,*Y 4`\+SbS ,aT Z1\+fT/ZT 4YTZSE *+S Y*bS \31 af,*W1ZZqD an ]`SVW*/ Sf*yW*D w 56 `\VT, q ]\h*, ,3S,*bS *WV\-\Wn T Z*`V\bSO VSEP `\4]\,T/*2 ,TZEP ab*, hW1Z\Y +*ZO /S y /dY*,E k\ ]`\3S,d Z1 +TWnj1 ZT3 7> `\VT,D 1`14 a,Ty -ZT, b* `\4h*`dO ,*ZZq q VTWnV* `*4T, ]`\+d,*, Z*VW*abS Z* a1+1 `dVSD ıE f\h* q b*VS a]\/T,*,O aq ,T/ 3Sbbq h\-\an WT]j\-\E ,a1 3 Z1

+*hS, d Zn\Yd 3\/Z\-\ a1ZO adxD \WS Sf*yW\ Z*,h*,aq d ab*`jSf VW*a*fE \/SZ fW\O ]1gn 4 y\-\ +*Z/S ]\h*, ,SO ,h*bS T+WTp 4T ,T/V*YS -\O ,SD Sf*yW\ b13 ]\-\/S,aq Z* b*V1 ,S,h1ZZqD 1E h\-\ ,TZ /\,T/d,*,aq 4 T+WT^E 4YTO ZSW\ y\-\ ]\-Wq/ Z* Y*y+dbZ2D Sf*yO W\ ]`S-*/d2B w) /\,T/*,aqE k\ , Y*yO +dbZn\Yd Z* 41YWT +d/1 ,T/Z\,W1Z\ `*y T Wp/S 3SbSYdbn d YS`T +14 b`S,\-D ) ]\h*, dq,WqbS a1+1 , b\Yd `*p T ]\ab*O ,S, ]1`1/ a\+\p Y1bdB `\4,SZdbS bTaZT ab\adZVS 4 -\,\pD `\b1 q 4`S,*,aqE b\+b\ VTWnV* `*4T, Z*]S,*,aqE T , Y1Z1 4Gq,SW*an /T,hSZ*xD #\ /\]\Y\-W\ Sf*yW\,T ]\`,*bS 4 YSZdWSY T 4`1jb\p 4YTZSbS a,\2 3SbbqH TZ ]\qaZp2B w\yE fb\ ,S,h*, 4T YZ\p T+WTpE 4*\f\hd,*, k\/1ZZ\ ^^ hSb*bS y a]TWVd,*bSaq WSj1 4 bSYS Wp/nYSE qVT ]`*-Zdbn ]\/\+*bSan \-\,TD ) 4`\4dYT,E k\ Y\^ /`d3VS 4 +*Z/S ,]WS,*pbn Z* Y1O Z1D ıE f\h* /Wq Y1Z1 ,\ZS +dWS Z*h1 `\/SO Z*E q `\4T`,*, 4 ZSYS 4,Gq4\VxD Sf*yW\ ab*,S, ]1`1/ a\+\p Z1,1WSVT â&#x20AC;¹ gTWT y ,S4Z*h*,E k\ 2 Z*y,*3WS,TjSYD 1 /\]\Y\-W\ y\Yd /\aq-ZdbS ,*3WSO ,\^ Y1bSB d4-\/SbS a,\2 3Sbbq 4 \3SO YS Z\`Y*YSD S b*V\3 Y\31b1 g1 4`\+SO bSD Ë&#x203A;*Z\bdyb1 a,\p /\,-\ab`\V\,d Y1bdE * b*V\3 b1E qVT V`\VS /\]\Y\3dbn ,*Y /\aq-ZdbS ^^D \4V*3Tbn ]`\ a,\^ gTWT bSYE fb\ Y\31 ,*a ]T/b`SY*bSE T ]\]`\O aTbn ^f ,T/,1`b\ -\,\`SbS ,*Y ]`\ ,*jT da]TfSD Ë&#x203A;/\+d,*yb1 4Z*ZZq ]`\ \-* y 4*ab\a\O ,dyb1 y\-\ ]\`*/SD 1 ,T/VW*/*yb1 g1 Z* ]\bTYD 31 b1]1` ]\ab*Z\,Tbn `\4,S,*bS a,\p Wp+\, /\ \-* T y\-\ W\,*E T+WT^D `\ b\-\E fb\ 4*ab\a\,d2 +T+WTyZT ]`SZO gS]SE aV*4*Z\B w a1E k\ ,TZ hSZSbnEP k*abSbnaq y\Ydx La*W\Y 5B5P7MD  " Ë&#x2122; 5 ) 6>56

27


˝ )  ı ı•ı 

TWnZSgb,\  wıada aV*4*, a,\^Y dhZqYB r˝ZS,\ /d31 ,1WSV1E * `\+TbZSVT, Y*W\D \3 +W*-*yb1  \a]\/*`q 3ZS,E k\+ ,TZ ,SaW*, `\+TbZSVT, Z* a,\^ 3ZS,*sx Lı) =B7;E 7<MD   Z*,h*ZZT ıada h*ab\ ,SV\`SaO b\,d,*, ]`SVW*/S 4 3Sbbq y ]`*gT `TWnZSVT, L*b,Tq 55B6<P7>C *`V* 8B7P=C dVS 57B:P=MD \YdH \Yd k\ ,TZ 3S, d aTWnanV\-\a]\/*`anV\Yd ada]TWnab,TD *O -*b\ y\-\ aWdf*hT, /\b`SYd,*WSan b`*/SO gTyZSf Y1b\/T, 41YW1`\+ab,*E qVT Z1 4YTZpO ,*WSan ab\`ThhqYSD ıY +dW\ ]`S2YZ\E k\ ıada Z1 `*4 4-*/d,*, b1E k\ ]\,Gq4*Z\ 4 `TWnO ZSgb,\YD 1 ]`S,*+Wp,*W\ Wp/1y /\ y\-\ Z*,h*ZZq L*b,Tq ;B6<MD S WT]j1 4`\4dYT2Y\ ıada\,T ]`SVW*/S b* TZjT +T+WTyZT \]\,T/TE V\WS +TWnj1 /\,TO /*2Y\an ]`\ ]`*gp `TWnZSVT, d ]1`j\Yd



ab\`ThhTB qVT VdWnbd`S ,\ZS ,S`\kd,*WSE qVSY 4Z*`q//qY V\`Sabd,*WSaq T 4 qVSYS ]`\+W1Y*YS abSV*WSanD q,Wqyb1 a\+TE qV ]`*gp2 `TWnZSVE b* ]`\hSbdyb1 Z*,1/1ZT , ab*bbT d`S,VS 4 T+O WT^D *V ,S /\,T/*2b1an +*-*b\ gTV*,\-\ y ]\,h*WnZ\-\D

T,+* ,Tb*2D TWnZSV ,Sf\/Sbn Z* ]\`T- a,\O -\ /\Yd TE Y`d3*hSan ,T/ ]1`jSf ]`\Y1O ZT, a\ZgqE Z* ]\,ZT -`d/S ,/Sf*2 Z*aSh1Z1 ,\W\-\p ]\,Tb`qD 1/*,Z\ 4*VTZhS,aq a1O 4\Z /\kT,E qVT 4YGqVjSWS ,Sadj1Zd a\Zg1Y 41YWpD *ab*, h*a \`*bSD TWnZSV VW*/1 Z* ]W1h1 W1-VSy /1`1,GqZSy ]Wd- T y/1 Z* a,\2 ]\W1D TZ ]`S,\/Sbn bd/S ]*`d ,\WT,E Z*/q-*2 Z* ZSf q`Y\ T ]\hSZ*2 ]\-*ZqbSD VdbSy

5

7

6

28


4*WT4\Y ]Wd- ,-`S4*2bnaq , V*YGqZSabSy š`dZbD TZ Z1 `\+Sbn aVS+E * WSj1 `\4]djd2 41YWpE ]`\,\/qhS , ZTy Z1-WS+\VT `T,VS P +\`\4ZS L5MD TWnZSV Z1 \-Wq/*2bnaq ]\4*/ a1+1E +\ ab*`*2bnaq `\+SbS `T,ZT +\`\4ZS LdVS =B:6MD TZ b13 ]SWnZd2E *+S Z1 ,SybS 4* Y13T a,\-\ Z1,1WSV\-\ ]\WqD ˛`1jb\p ,a1 ]\W1 ]`\\`*Z1 +\`\4Z*YS T -\b\,1 /\ aT,+SD TWnZSV b`SY*2 \/ZT2p `dV\p b\`+d 4 qhY1Z1YE * TZj\p `\4Y*jSaO b\ `\4VS/*2 ]\ ]\Wp Z*aTZZq L6MD TZ Z1 VSO /*2 Z*aTZZq b*YE /1 y\-\ Y\3dbn 4*b\]b*bS Wp/SE * ab*`*2bnaqE k\+ ,\Z\ ,]*W\ wZ* /\+`Sy š`dZbx LdVS <B9E <MD TaWq aTqZZq ]\W1 ]\b`T+Z\ +\`\Zd,*bSD TWnZSV 4Z\,d +1`1 ,\WT,E 4*YTabn ]Wd-* hT]Wq2 /\ ZSf V\WphT -TWVS T ]`\f\/Sbn 4 ZSYS ]\W1 ,]\]1`1V ]`\VW*/1ZSf `*ZTO j1 +\`\41ZD SYh*a\Y qV ,TZ g1 `\+SbnE 4-`*^ ]b*fT, Z*Y*-*pbnaq ]\,S/4n\+d,*bS k1 Z1]`SV`Sb1 Z*aTZZqD 1`14 qVSyan h*a `TWnZSV Y\bSV\p L7M `\4]djd2 41YWp T abSO Z*2 +d`GqZSE qVT Y\3dbn 4*-WdjSbS ]*`\abO VS L*b,Tq 57B;MD

˝ZS,* `\f\/Sbn VTWnV* YTaqgT,D S]*/*pbn /\kTE /\4`T,*2 ,`\3*yD \W\aVS qhY1Zp ,31 Z*WSWSan 41`Z\YE b\Yd \a,TbW1Z1 a\ZO g1Y ]\W1 ,S-Wq/*2 Y*y31 +TWSY P ,\Z\ -\O b\,1 /\ 3ZS, Lı,*Z* 8B79MD ˝ZS,* P -*`qh* ]\`* /Wq `TWnZSV* T y\O -\ `\/SZSD * ]\WT 3Z1gn 4*f\]Wp2 WTO ,\p `dV\p 3Ydb ab1+1WE * ]`*,\p ]T/`T4*2 ^f -\ab`SY 4*WT4ZSY a1`]\Y L8MD ıZjT hW1O ZS `\/SZS 4+S`*pbn 4+T33qE ,Gq3dbn y\-\ , aZ\]S L9M T VW*/dbn ^f Z* \aWT, *+\ ,\4* L:ME k\+ ,T/,14bS Z* aTWnanVSy bTVD

1YSW\a1`/Z\ jV,*`Sbn a\Zg1D \/SZ* f\,*2bnaq , bTZn eT-\,\-\ /1`1,* /Wq ]1`1O ]\hSZVdD aT aYTpbnaqE `\4Y\,Wqpbn T ]\O f*]g1Y a]\3S,*pbn aV`\YZd ]1`1VdaVdB fWT+E ]`*31Z1 41`Z\E \WS,VSE adj1ZT eT-S b* `\/4SZVSD TaWq gn\-\ ,\ZS ,b*Y\,dpbn a]`*-d /31`1WnZ\p ,\/\p L\,b\`1ZZq ˛*O V\Zd <B;MD

* adaT/Zn\Yd ]\WT Wp/S 4+S`*pbn ]\4\O ab*WT ]TaWq 3ZS, V\W\aVS L;MD SY 4*yY*O pbnaqE 4*4,Sh*yE +T/ZT y bTE fb\ Z1 Y*2 a,\O -\ ]\Wq L\,b\`1ZZq ˛*V\Zd 68B5=P65MD

9

; :

8


T4ZTj1E Z* aTWnanV\Yd b\VdE `TWnZSV `\4ab1Wq2 aZ\]S Z* a]1gT*WnZ\ ,b`*Y+\,*O Z\Yd ]T/,Sk1ZZTD \WS f\/qbn ]\ Zn\Yd V`d-*YSE bq-ZdhS 4* a\+\p k\an Z* ]\/\O +d ,*3VSf a*Z1y L<MD L\,b\`1ZZq Ë&#x203A;*V\O Zd 69B8MD \ab`1 V*YTZZq T VdaVS Y1b*WdE ,ab*,W1ZT , ]\W\4SE `\4h*,Wppbn ab1+W*D TWnZSV h1V*2 ,1h\`*E V\WS ]\,T2 ]`\f\O W\/ZSy ,Tb1`1gn Ldb 7B6MD \hSZ*2 adb1ZTO bSE T ,TZ +1`1 /1`1,GqZT ,SW*E b\+b\ w,TqWnO Zd W\]*bdx L=ME b* ]T/VS/*2 ZSYS , ]\,Tb`q \+Y\W\h1Z1 4+T33q L*b,Tq 7B56MD *3VT 41`Z* ]*/*pbn Z* 41YWpE * W1-Vd ]\W\,d

T4 4*WSjV*YS ab1+1W 4/d,*2 -1bn ,Tb1`1gnD TWnZSV ]\,b\`p2 g1 4Z\,d y 4Z\,dE *3 ]\O VS Z* 41YWT 4*WSj*2bnaq a*Y1 41`Z\D *Z\O,`*ZgT y\-\ /`d3SZ* T /\ZnVS +1O `dbn aSb* y ]`\aTppbn 41`Z\ L5>ME k\+ ,T/O /TWSbS y\-\ ,T/ ]TaVd b* TZj\-\ aYTbbqD )hYTZn 4aS]*pbn d V\jSVSE * aYTbbq ,SVSO /*pbnD n\-\ `\Vd ,`\3*y `qaZSyD `*gT,O ZSVS Z*]\,Zppbn 41`Z\Y -W1VS L55ME * `1jO bd 41`Z* 4aS]*pbn /\ qY /Wq 4+1`T-*ZZqD \+\bd Z* b\Vd 4*,1`j1Z\D *`1jbT `TWnO ZSV Y\31 ,S]`\ab*bS a]SZdE `\4aW*+SbSan T Z1V,*]\Y \-WqZdbS ]\WqE qVT ]`\abqO -*pbnaq /\,V\W* a1W*D TZ 4*/\,\W1ZSyE */31 ]\Wq ,31 +WT/\O3\,bT P Z* ZSf 4*O WSjSW*an WSj1 ab1`ZqD 1an d`\3*y P `1O 4dWnb*b ,*3V\^ ]`*gT P d V\Y\`*fD TWnO ZSV +*hSbnE qV `\+TbZSVS ]`qYdpbn /\ ,SZ\-`*/ZSVT, T /\ a*/VT, \WS,V\,SfE -`*O Z*b\,Sf b* eT-\,Sf /1`1,D \Y*f\Y `dVS 4 ZSY ,Tb*2bnaq adaT/E k\ aV\]d2 Z1,1WSO VSy VW*]bSV 41YWT d a,\2Yd a*/VdD *Y `\aO bSYdbn \-T`VSE a\h1,SgqE V,*a\WqE ]\`1yE Zdb T gS+dWqD TWnZSV Z* f,SWp 4*YSaO Wp2bnaqE 4,\/Sbn \hT /\ Z1+* T , V\`\bVTyE a1`/1hZTy Y\WSb,T /qO Vd2 \-\,T 4* â&#x20AC;¢\-\ hd/\,T /*`S La*W\Y :9B5>P56MD

<

=

5> 55


  ˝• & ˙ 

TZ ,SZ*-\`\/3d2 bSfE fb\ y\Yd aWd3Sbn ) (xD aTY ]`S2YZ\ hdbS g1 aW\,\ 4* /\+`1 ,SV\Z*Zd `\+\bd *+\ 4`\+W1ZSy ,T/ kS`\-\ a1`gq ]\/*`dZ\VD S f\h1Y\ +*O hSbSE k\ TZjTE \a\+WS,\ bTE V\-\ Wp+SY\E gTZdO pbn Z*jT 4daSWWqD ˛,Sh*yZ\E ]\Z*/ da1 YS Wp+SY\ Z*j\-\ \-*E -\,dD S ,TZ gTZd2 Z*O jT 4daSWWq , aWd3TZZT y\YdH \4-WqZnY\E qV ,TZ ,Sq,S, ,/qhZTabn ˚,1/O1W1fdE h\W\,TV\O ,TE qVSyE `S4SVdphS 3SbbqYE d`qbd,*, \/Z\O -\ 4 \3Sf ]`\`\VT,D L `\hSb*yb1 `1YT^ 7<B;P57 T 7=B5:P5<MD b\ b*VSy ˚,1/O1W1fH TZE \h1,S/Z\E +d, \/ZSY 4 ]`S/,\`ZSf p/1yanV\-\ g*`q 1/1O  VT^1D ˚,1/O1W1f 3S, b\/T 3E V\WS `1YTqE qV\-\ \- ]\aW*, ]\]1`1/3*bS Z1,T`ZSy Z*O `\/ (/S ]`\ Y*y+dbZ2 4ZSk1ZZqD ˚,1/O1O W1f* \b\hd,*WS +14+\3ZT g*`anVT 4,1`fZSVSE *W1 ,TZ Y*, ab`*f ]1`1/ \-\Y T ,1WSVd ]\O  j*Zd /\ `1YT^D T`* ˚,1/O1W1f* Y*W* 4*4Z*bS ,S]`\+d,*ZnE V\WS 4WTaZT ]`S/,\`ZT e*WnjS,\ 4,SZd,*bSWS `1YTp , +dZbTE VSZdO WS y\-\ /\ qYS 4 +*-Z\Y T 4*WSjSWS ]\YS`*O  bS L`1YT^ 7<B8P:MD )V ˚,1/O1W1f ]\,1O  /1bnaq d gTy aSbd*gT^H ˚,1/O1W1f /Tq, ,T/,*3Z\ T `Tjdh1E ]\+\O `\,jS ab`*f ]1`1/ `\4]`*,\p 4 +\Vd g*`anO VSf 4,1`fZSVT,D TZ ,T/V`Sb\ 4,1`Zd,aq /\  1/1VT^ b* ,SaW\,S, a,\p Z14-\/d 4 bSYE qV ]\,1WSaq 4 `1YT2pD \3WS,\E Z*,Tbn ,V*O 4dphS `dV\p Z* 4W\,YSaZSVT,E ˚,1/O1W1f aV*4*, g*`1,TB wT Wp/S ,hSZSWS 4W\DDD `1O   YT^x L`1YT^ 7<B=MD ˚,1/O1W1f ]1`1V\Z*, g*`qE T b\y /\4,\WS, y\Yd ,4qbS 7> h\W\,TVT,E k\+ d`qbd,*bS `1YTpD

 1 ˚,1/O1W1f* Z*4,*Z\ w1,Zdf\Yx L`1YT^ 7<B;MD \h* g1 aW\,\ +dV,*WnZ\ \4Z*h*2 wV*ab`\,*ZSy h\W\,TVxE ,\Z\ b*V\3 ,3S,*W\aq d jS`j\Yd 4Z*h1ZZT T ,V*4d,*W\ Z* \a\O +dE V\b`* 4*yY*W* ,Sa\Vd ]\a*/d ]`S g*`anV\Yd /,\`TD

TaWq gn\-\ ˚,1/O1W1f ,Sq,S, TZjd ]`SO ,*+WS,d `Sad P /\+`\bdD TZ d4q, w]\/1`O b\-\ jY*bbq b* Z1]\b`T+ZSf W*fT,E T a]daO   bS, ^f /\ `1YT^ /\ qYS jZd`*YSxD ˙Wq h\-\H #\+ ]`\`\V ]\VW*, g1 W*fYTbbq a\+T ]T/ ]*f,SE *+S jZd`SE qVSYS y\-\ Y*WS ,Sbq-*bSE  Z1 ]\`*ZSWS y\-\ L`1YT^ 7<B55P57MD -\,T a]\/\+*,aq g1y dhSZ\V ˚,1/O1W1f*D 1O `14 `1YTp \- aV*4*, y\O YdE k\ (/* +d/1 \+\,Gq4O V\,\ 4ZSk1Z*D TaWq gn\-\ -\,* ]\\+Tgq, ˚,1/O1O W1f\,TB w1+1 ,`qbdp gn\-\ /ZqDDD bS Z1 +d/1j ,T//*ZSy , `dVd gSf WpO /1yDDD V\Zh1 ,`qbdp b1+1E T ,T/ Y1h* Z1 ,]*O /1j bSE T +d/1 b\+T /dj* b,\q 4* 4/\+ShxD \O Yd -\,* ]\\+Tgq, ,`qbd,*bS gn\-\ h\W\,TV*H -\,* aV*4*, y\YdB w \ bS Z*/Tq,aq Z* 1Z1x  L`1YT^ 7=B5:P5<MD \- 4Z*,E k\ ˚,1/O1O  W1f /Tq, Z1 bTWnVS 4*`*/S `1YT^E *W1 y b\Yd k\ ]\VW*/*,aq Z* \-* T ,T`S, d n\-\D   ˛ gT2^ Tab\`T^ ,S/Z\B -\,* gTZd2 Z*jT 4daSWO Wq , aWd3TZZT y\YdD T+WTq 4*]1,Zq2E k\ \]*YGqb*2 Z*,Tbn Z*yY1ZjSy dhSZ\V d aWd3TZO ZT y\YdE qVSy YS `\+SY\ ,T/ kS`\-\ a1`gq L*`V* 56B85P88MD \y e*VbE k\ \- gTZd2 Z*j1 aWd3TZZqE ]\,SZ1Z a]\ZdVd,*bS Z*a Z*O +WS3*bSan /\ Zn\-\D d/nY\ ]1,ZTB -\,* w,SZ*-\`\/3d2 bSfE fb\ y\-\ Z*]\W1-WS,\ jdO  V*2x L,`1^, 55B:MD

 ı •˚ ı ı••  ˛ `1YT^ 76P9>

 " ˙ 5 ) 6>56

31


w Ë&#x161;Ë&#x161;Ë?  Ë&#x161;Ë&#x161;Ix    â&#x20AC;˘ Ë&#x161; ÄąË&#x2122; Äą 

Ë&#x161;   G)(

w\a]\/n /S,Sbnaq Z* a1`g1x  L5 Äą 5:B;MD

Ë&#x161;    

w SY ]1`1]\,Z1Z1 a1`g1E b1 -\,\`qbn dab*x LÄą) 56B78MD

Ë&#x161;   Ë&#x161;Ë&#x2122;Äą(

w Wd3S â&#x20AC;˘\Yd ,aTY a1`g1Yx L5 Äą 6<B=MD

5:B;MD b*Z Z*j\-\ a1`gqE b\+b\ b1E qVSYS \a\+*YS YS 2 Z*a]`*,/TE ,]WS,*2 Z* ab*,O W1ZZq \-* /\ Z*a L5 1b`* 7B8MD )V ab1`1-bS a,\2 a1`g1H T/]\,T/n Z* g1 4*]Sb*ZZq +d/1 ,a1+ThZ\ \+-\,\`p,*bSaq Z* V\Z-`1a*f ,T/VT, -\,SD \hSZ*phS 4 gn\-\ YTaqgqE gT V\Z-`1aS ,T/+d,*bSYdbnaq ]\ gTW\O Yd a,TbTD 1`/1hZ\ 4*]`\jd2Y\ ,*a ]`SybS Z* ,aT b`S /ZT V\Z-`1ad1D \hdb1 T ]\+*h1Z1 b*Y /\]\Y\31 ,*Y ]\,\/SbSaq b*VE k\+ ]\bTj*O bS a1`g1 \-* -\,S L`S]\,Tab1y 6;B55MD 1 Ë&#x2122;\,T/*bSan ]`\ YTag1 T h*a ]`\,1/1ZZq Z*y+WS3h\-\ /\ ,*a V\Z-`1ad Y\3Z* Z* a*ybT www.jw.orgD +\ 3 4*]Sb*yb1 ]`\ g1 , YTag1,Sf ,T/VT, -\,S hS Z*]SjTbn /\ ,S/*,gT, gn\-\ 3d`Z*WdD

S ,S f\bTWS +E k\+ ,*a ,T/,T/*WSH *,Tbn d gn\Yd Z1a]\VTyZ\Yd a,TbT ,S Y\31b1 ab*bS k*aWS,SYSE Z*+d,*phS b\hZ\-\ +T+WTyZ\-\ 4Z*ZZq ]`\ \-*E y\-\ *`ab,\ y hd/\,d Y1bd k\/\ Wp/ab,*D )Vk\ ,S +*3*2b1 \b`SY*bS +TWnO  j1 TZe\`Y*gT^ *+\ k\+ ,*a fb\an ,T/,T/d,*, T ]`\,\/S, 4 ,*YS +14]W*bZ1 +T+WTyZ1 ,S,h1ZZqE ]`\aSY\ ]Sa*bS /\ ,T/VT, -\,S Z* \/Zd 4 ,T/]\,T/ZSf */`1aE k\ Z* ab\`TZgT 8D

www.watchtower.org/k

wp12 05/01-K

 Photo on right: Aus dem Fundus der MUNCHNER  OLYMPIAPARK GMBH, Munchen

  T+WT^ aW\,\ wa1`g1x 4-*/d2bnaq Y*yO 31 bSaqhd `*4T,E T , +TWnj\abT ,S]*/VT, ,\Z\ ab\ad2bnaq Z1 +dV,*WnZ\-\ Wp/anV\-\ a1`gqE * aSY,\WThZ\-\D #\ b*V1 aSY,\WThZ1 a1`g1H \Z\ Y\31 ab\ad,*bSaq \a\+Sab\abT Wp/SO  ZS P ^^ /dY\VE ]\hdbbT, T +*3*ZnD \Yd ,*3WS,\ ab1`1-bS a,\2 aSY,\WThZ1 a1`g1H \- Z*/SfZd, g*`q \W\Y\Z* Z*]SO a*bSB w*/ da1E k\ WSj1 ab1`131bnaqE a1`g1 a,\2 ab1`13SE +\ 4 Zn\-\ ]\f\/Sbn 3Sbbqx L`S]\,Tab1y 8B67MD *j1 b1]1`TjZ2 3Sbbq T Z*/Tq Z* Y*y+dbZ2 4*W13*bn ,T/ b\-\E qVSY 2 Z*j1 aSY,\WThZ1 a1`g1D \YdH \Yd k\ â&#x20AC;š 

\- +*hSbnE k\ 2 , Z*j\Yd a1`gT L5 *Yd^W*

Watchtower 2012  

ukranian magazine, bible, watchtower

Read more
Read more
Similar to
Popular now
Just for you