Page 1

The Role of E-Government in Selected Fire Services of Taiwan & the United States. A Comparative Analysis. John M. Moschella, EFO Annie Chou, M.S.

What is e-Government? • the use of technology to enhance the access to and delivery of government services to benefit citizens, business partners and employees.

Purpose • To evaluate selected fire department websites according to the six stages of e-government Lee (2010), West (2004), Moon (2002), Deloitte (2000), and Silcock (2001)

Stage 1: Information Publishing/Dissemination • departments and agencies establish individual websites. This step requires one-way communication that allows customers to download information from the site.

Stage 2: "Official" Two-Way Transactions • customers can engage in transactions such as paying bills or securing permits.

Stage 3: Multi-Purpose Portals • customers can, through a single point of entry, access several municipal departments, thereby saving time.

Stage 4: Portal Personalization • more frequent users could customize their own portals.

Stage 5: Clustering of Common Services • government would consolidate particular services along common lines to benefit the user.

Stage 6: Full Integration and Enterprise Transformation • At this stage old walls, as Silcock calls them, would be broken down and bridges constructed among departments ensuring smooth navigation throughout the municipality’s website. • Our survey: an avenue for feedback.

U.S. & Taiwanese Fire Departments • 50 fire (Metro) departments – city >1million (7) – city<1million (20) – county >1million (11) – county 500g to 1 million (8) – county <500g (4)

• 19 fire departments – city >1million (5) – city<1million (3) – county >1million (2) – county 500g to 1 million (6) – county <500g (3)

Taiwanese Fire Departments • Taiwan: 19 in total – 8 Metro sized fire departments • larger than 400 members • average population served: 2.2 million

– 11 county/city sized fire departments • average 267 members • average population served: 600 thousand

Demographics: 1. Name of fire department 2. Location of fire department 3. Size of fire department (personnel) 4. Population of community served 5. Career, volunteer, combination

Question # 1 • Is the fire department website one-way communication only? – YES—Aside from a comment page or ability to download something (forms, laws, etc.), there is no two-way communication via the website? For example, the user cannot submit a question – NO—The site allows the user to download material, or pose a question. There is interaction between the user and the FD site.

Question # 2 • Can the user engage in transactions such as paying bills or securing permits from the fire department? – YES—the user can, book an appointment, pay a fee, etc? – NO—the user cannot conduct any transactional business

Question # 3 • Can the user, through a single point of entry (fire department website), access other municipal departments? – YES—In this instance, for example, is there a drop down menu to access other municipal departments, like water, building, or electrical?) – NO—the user cannot access any other city department, fire related websites are not included, such as NFPA.

Question # 4 • Can users employ portal personalization? – YES—the user can have his/own name and password to gain access to the site, for example, logging into an airlines. – NO—there is no personal access to the site.

Question # 5 • Does the website have a clustering of common services? – YES—the user could access other departments needed for completing a job – NO—the user must individually contact each department

Question # 6 • Does the site offer user feedback? – YES—the user can submit comments, suggestions or feedback to the site – NO—there is no avenue for the user to submit comments, suggestions or feedback

Results • Question 1 – US:



• 6% neither

– Taiwan 100%-no

• Question 2 – US: 28%-yes – Taiwan 100%-no


• Question 3 – US: 80%yes – Taiwan 100%-no


Results • Question 4 – US: 10%-yes – Taiwan 100%-no


• Question 5 – US 22%-yes – Taiwan 100%-no


• Question 6 – US 26%-yes – Taiwan 100%-yes


100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0

US YES US NO Taiwan YES Taiwan NO







US/Taiwan Comparison

Conclusions—U.S./Taiwan • Almost 68% are one-way only sites (Taiwan 100%) – cannot download important documents

• Transactional business is only available in 28% of the FD sites (Taiwan 0 %) – cannot book an appointment, etc.

• 80% allow for easy navigation to other departments (Taiwan 0%)

Conclusions—U.S./Taiwan (cont.) • Only 10% have portal personalization (Taiwan 0%) – proven value to return customers

• Only 22% have clustered common tasks (Taiwan 0%) – something new and innovative

• Only 26% have any type of feedback/suggestion avenue (Taiwan 100%)

Recommendations • US & Taiwan fire department websites must allow visitors to download important documents – simple as email attachments

• US & Taiwan common services should be available – booking a ticket & choosing a seat

• Taiwan, common entry to other municipal departments is mandatory . . . saves time – easier to navigate

Recommendations (cont.)

• US & Taiwan personal sign-in (portals) saves time – much like other venues: airlines, Expedia, Amazon

• US & Taiwan, clustering of services should be based on a specific job – building a house: FD, Building, Electrical, Plumbing, etc.

• US & Taiwan, always allow for customer feedback – best way to evaluate performance – suggestions for improvement

â&#x20AC;˘ Let me know if you think we need any additional slides, especially for Taiwan. â&#x20AC;˘ What you have to do is be able to discuss why Taiwan is 0% for questions 1 to 5. Is it a question of the population not being computer literate? Not enough computers in the households? Residents do not need egovernment? Have answers to the questions why? ln

Read more
Read more
Similar to
Popular now
Just for you