Page 8

8 News



Continued from page 1

focused, has limited impact and, most important, changes nothing about beach access as it exists today. “We don’t see any substantive impact on the town of Ocean Ridge,” said Town Manager Jamie Titcomb. “Our beach areas are defined and determined.” The same goes for coastal communities throughout the county, their officials say. Some law enforcement authorities, however, believe HB 631 could have the unintended benefit of making it easier for them to enforce the line between public and private beach. The law specifically cites the mean high-water line as a standard, reaffirming an ambiguous and shifting boundary that over the decades has been routinely misunderstood and contested. The Florida Constitution says the wet sand area below the mean high-water line is considered public and stateowned. The dry sand above it is private. Roughly 60 percent of Florida’s beaches are adjacent to private ownership. Manalapan has no public beaches and has struggled for years to keep interlopers from wandering off the wet sand onto private property. Police Chief Carmen Mattox says language in the new law affirms how his officers

People at the Lantana public beach see a new sign in the dry sand at Eau Palm Beach Resort & Spa. A new law addressing beach access takes effect July 1. Jerry Lower/The Coastal Star are patrolling the town’s beachfront. “I believe the new law delineates what part of the beach is public and what part is private property,” Mattox

said. “It confirms Manalapan’s beaches are private.” Law built on ‘customary use’ The thrust of the new law, which goes into effect July 1,

SOLD IN 2018

SOLD IN 2018

SOLD IN 2018

231 E. Lantana Road, Unit 601, Lantana Last asking price $179,500

12496 Aviles, Palm Beach Gardens Last asking price $849,000

3209 Karen, Delray Beach Last asking price $1,339,900

JUST LISTED 5801 N. Ocean Blvd., Unit 203

SOLD IN 2018

SOLD IN 2018

190 Camela Court, Jupiter Last asking price $1,160,000

405 S. Atlantic, Hypoluxo Island Last asking price $2,800,000

2 bedroom, 2 bath corner unit on 2nd floor in small, gated community of Oceanwalk. Direct ocean view with balcony off living room and master bedroom. Community has large pool area, tennis court and private oceanfront beach and cabana. Furnishings negotiable. $625,000

Capt. Curtis Brown

May 2018

prevents county and municipal governments from enacting “customary use” ordinances that allow public access to private beach property without first getting approval from the courts. The Florida Supreme Court has recognized the principle of “customary use” rights when the public has a tradition of use that “has been ancient, reasonable, without interruption, and free from dispute.” In other words, historical precedent can matter when it comes to determining access. There have been only a few customary use beach ordinances passed in the state’s history, according to the Florida League of Cities, and those have been in three northern counties: Volusia, St. Johns and Walton. No South Florida government has made a serious attempt at passing one, league officials say. Once the new statute goes into effect, it will require a judge’s sign-off on these relatively rare local laws that have sprung up along the Panhandle and the northeast coast. It was an ordinance in Walton that prompted the legislature to act this year. Some prominent Panhandle property owners, among them former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee and Republican political adviser Karl Rove, complained about a local customary use ordinance and filed suit. Rep. Katie EdwardsWalpole, D-Plantation, who sponsored HB 631, said the new law strikes a balance between public and private rights. “The legislation does not privatize public beaches nor does it impact the public’s ability to enjoy public beaches,” she told legislators. While the law abolishes Walton’s ordinance, it leaves intact all others, those passed

before 2016. The law mandates that, from now on, any city or county that wants to enact a customary use beach ordinance must first get a judge’s approval and make the case in court. Future sea level rise could muddle interpretation The Florida Wildlife Federation, the Florida Association of Counties and the Surfrider Foundation, a nonprofit group dedicated to beach preservation, vigorously opposed the bill, arguing it was an alarming precedent that was sure to cause confusion — which it surely did. Here’s how the Surfriders put it: “This bill is bad. It makes it harder for local governments to protect beach access for the public, it’s confusing and damaging for local tourism economies, and it sets a bad precedent. That said, unless you are in Walton County, it should not cause immediate changes in beach access or your ability to utilize the beach.” That last sentence is critical for towns such as Ocean Ridge, Manalapan and South Palm Beach, where beach access has been questioned. There are no immediate or foreseeable changes to any beach activity: From renourishment projects to sunbathing to morning walks, everything is as it was before HB 631. The law’s most significant impact in Palm Beach County could come years or decades from now, if rising seas shift the demarcation lines between wet sand and dry sand, and muddle public-private access. Future government councils and commissions will find it more difficult to invoke the customary use doctrine to sort out changing boundaries on the beaches, parties on all sides agree. The new law will shift some of the decision-making from municipal officials to judges. Ú

Second Time Around

Luxury Consignment Boutique Estates & Cash Buyouts

Consign and sell vintage jewelry, designer handbags and clothing

REALTOR, OCEAN & INTRACOASTAL PROPERTIES Cell :561 254 1509 Office:561 278 5104

Fax :561 278 5189 Email:

Hampton Real Estate Group, Inc. • 5108 N. Ocean Ridge, Florida 33435

801 George Bush Blvd., Delray Beach 561-278-0493 Open 7 Days

The Coastal Star May 2018  

Serving Coastal Delray Beach and north to Hypoluxo Island

The Coastal Star May 2018  

Serving Coastal Delray Beach and north to Hypoluxo Island